16 ms·
Gattaca is still pertinent 25 years later
- imperio59 4y agoMost works that touch upon core issues like Gattaca does tend to be relevant many years later. This is why we still read greek philosophers, works from the Renaissance, works from the time of the American Revolution (The Federalist Papers, for example), etc...
- blitzar 4y agoThe works that touch on these core issues are not often as well executed as Gattica - sometimes you wind up with Mean Girls ... ok that is a bad example as that is a timeless classic as well.
- IncRnd 4y agoThat's the first time I've seen someone compare Mean Girls with Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, the Sistine Chapel's ceiling, and The Federalist Papers.
- skeeter2020 4y agoBeing able to bring important academic thought to the masses in an entertaining way is important, hard and potentially lucrative though, and Mean Girls delivers!
- anderber 4y agoGattaca was so ahead of its time, reminds me I should re-watch it again.
- sourcecodeplz 4y agoDefinitely on my re-watch list, together with Idiocracy.
- DoctorDabadedoo 4y agoMike Judge with his Idiocracy and Office Space is almost like someone had a crystal ball for early 21st century.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoOffice Space is a documentary.
- mynegation 4y agoOffice Space is pure genius and I was flabbergasted not to see it more popular. I am glad Judge got much bigger break with Silicon Valley.
- fumar 4y agoMaybe I am dating myself but Office Space was always popular.
- acheron 4y ago“Paul McCartney was in a band before Wings?”
- mynegation 4y agoI am more of a "Dave Grohl was in band before Foo Fighters?" kind of generation but I see what you mean.
- ericmcer 4y agoHow did he get away with Idiocracy? I thought it was a good movie and somewhat prescient, but if you peel back the layers it is basically advocating some kind of population control or eugenics policy. Or it is just a comedy, but I hear it frequently cited as a dramatized version of a plausible future.
- recuter 4y ago
- agumonkey 4y agoRewatched it not long ago, was still a great watch, the pacing, the characters, the narration. Not as grandiose as it used to feel but still touching and worth every second.
- rzzzt 4y agoI understand this article appeared in Nature Genetics and so explores the genetics aspect of the movie (which is admittedly heavily emphasized, starting with the G-A-T-C letters highlighted in the title and opening credits), but I always thought it is about the practice of discrimination in general, regardless of what "quality" is chosen to put people in sets of "A" and "B". How literally should the audience take this cautionary tale?
- mynegation 4y agoIt is up to you. Like any good piece of art (literature, painting, sculpture, documentaries, movies, fiction etc), saying something specific to the audience is just the first order effect and sometimes not even the most important one. Inspiring you to get on a process of discovery, interpretation, asking more questions, is what any great art aspires to do.
- fallingknife 4y agoThe part that I could never get over is that the discrimination against the main character actually made sense. He's trying to hide his heart condition to go in an important space mission. edit: HN is rate limiting me so I can't reply, but to davesque's comment below: > no one wants to live in a world where their life and capabilities are pre-determined But we do live in that world. It was determined that I would never play in the NFL the day sperm met egg. (Probably earlier than that, actually, as I doubt there is a single genetic combination of my parents that makes an NFL player). On that same day it was determined that I would never have to study in school. I guess I'm just more comfortable with the fact that genetics plays such a decisive role in our lives than most people, and that's probably why I didn't see the movie as particularly interesting.
- acover 4y agoMisread
- fallingknife 4y agoThen it's not good writing, because it isn't a statistical probability in the movie. We actually see that he has a heart condition.
- anonporridge 4y agoThe great thing about Gattaca is that the cinematography ages incredibly well on top of the amazing plot. A lot of great sci-fi is marred by cheap effects that look incredibly dated only a decade later. Gattaca chose to focus on the story and create a minimalist future environment that still looks beautiful 25 years later.
- js2 4y agoDespite Gattaca being one of my favorite movies for years I only recently learned, right here on HN, that the cinematographer is Sławomir Idziak, frequent collaborator of Krzysztof Kieślowski, which explains why Gattaca looks so much like one of my other favorites, The Double Life of Veronique. > create a minimalist future environment that still looks beautiful 25 years later. See also: Dark City
- cstuder 4y agoAnd for the love of god, watch the directors cut of `Dark City`, not the cinema version.
- the_af 4y agoI watched the cinema version and found it outstanding. What are the changes in the director's cut?
- riffraff 4y agoI second this, I love dark city and never knew there was s director's cut.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoThe main reason director's cut is recommended for first-time viewers is theatrical version having an intro that reveals many elements. That said the list of all the differences is quite extensive: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118929/alternateversions/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118929/alternateversions/.
- narrator 4y agoWe can do editing of somatic cells of adults now. Gattaca assumed that was all static and unchangeable.
- kanzure 4y agoWe can do some editing of some of the somatic cells in adults, and those edits have some effect. Reaching all of the somatic cells is actually quite difficult. We have had significantly better results with germline genetic engineering in animal models. If you really need to reach all the cells, that's how you'll do it. For example, if your trait is developmental in nature. Try it at home: https://diyhpl.us/wiki/genetic-modifications/ https://diyhpl.us/wiki/genetic-modifications/
- kanzure 4y agoGattaca set the field of biotech back by decades. Countless hours have been wasted pointing to the movie for why we should not go down the slippery slope of genetic choice. Cool movie though, that's part of the problem. "If the audience is supposed to accept that genetic determinism is true in Gattaca, then no amount of Vincent's hard work should make Vincent a hero. He's just a fraud. If the audience is not supposed to believe that in the world of Gattaca genetic determinism is true (that is, it's false), then it should be interpreted as a story of discrimination, and a story of the underdog's heroic hard work overcoming the negative effects of a corrupt, wrong, erroneously-discriminating society." from http://www.ln.edu.hk/philoso/staff/sesardic/Gattaca.pdf http://www.ln.edu.hk/philoso/staff/sesardic/Gattaca.pdf & https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32386006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32386006 Besides, Vincent could just purchase a ticket for a rocket ride instead....
- brmgb 4y agoOr as I like to put it Gattaca put the spotlight on research which had been treading the line of ethics for a decade with a dangerous lack of supervision and helped convince people that putting the brakes on it was welcome. That’s fiction playing its role.
- kanzure 4y agoyeah let's hope parents don't get to choose a better life for their kids, watch out?
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoWell, the problem we deal with today is that parents--actually medical professionals--choose death for children rather than allow them to live out their lives. Zero children with Down Syndrome are born in Iceland. Why? Because physicians would rather end their lives as soon as they find out that they "suffer" from the condition. I placed "suffer" in quotes, because many of us are quite aware that people with Down Syndrome don't suffer any more or less than the rest of us with a medical condition, and many of them lead happy and productive lives for a relatively long time. But if the physicians, or the parents, can just head off that predicted suffering within a 9-month time frame, nobody has to suffer at all (beyond one little procedure.) Sometimes I wonder who would suffer more, a child born with Down, or overly-entitled parents who will always wish their baby wasn't so... imperfect.
- apples_oranges 4y agoI believe advances in AI will make the core plot idea of the film obsolete. It is a good movie, but even the most genetically perfect human will probably not have a fraction of the intelligence of AI. He will be, relatively speaking, a mere dummy like the rest of us. Thus the future as shown in this film will not happen. However, good sci-fi is actually always about the present. And the movie has a lot of interesting things to say about the human condition in the late 1990s and now.
- mb7733 4y agoFrom what I remember the film didn't focus on intelligence. The main character suffers from genetic disorders that affect his health and lifespan, plus discrimination based on his 'invalid' status. All of that is still very relevant regardless of any progress with AGI.
- whatshisface 4y agoIQ was mentioned a couple times in the film, and the main character was shown studying very hard to keep up with his job. The fact that it wasn't the sole focus of the selection program was a consequence of the whole society wanting to do it. It wasn't a bunch of super-nerds doing something weird, the idea was that every part of our society's conception of achievement and "human quality" had been folded in to the nightmare, which made it inescapable.
- mb7733 4y agoFair enough, but health and fitness are not just for sport and culture. It's practical; you don't want your astronauts to have medical emergencies in space. Similarly, if you put resources into training them you'd rather they didn't die at 30 due to poor genetics. If any new tech threatens to render the premise obsolete, it's robotics. Not sending humans to space in the first place avoids the issue of selecting astronauts at all.
- whatshisface 4y ago
- beebmam 4y agoI found it really hard to relate to any of the characters in the film, to the point where they were barely recognizable as humans. Does it make sense, in a world like the one in Gattaca, for a person that is part of a discriminated class, to go into space, instead of trying to change the society around him to be less discriminatory? It seemed to me like the whole effort was a self-motivated, flaccid revenge fantasy that wouldn't make any material difference to the others suffering from discrimination on earth. All of that effort, for what? Anyway, I didn't hate the film, I just found it bizarre, alien-like.
- refuse 4y ago> Does it make sense, in a world like the one in Gattaca, for a person that is part of a discriminated class, to go into space, instead of trying to change the society around him to be less discriminatory? Most people in discriminated classes in the real world don't go out trying to change society.
- sangnoir 4y ago...and the few that attempt to change society almost always fail, or don't live to see the change they fight for in their lifetime.
- beebmam 4y ago> Most people in discriminated classes in the real world don't go out trying to change society. What is your evidence for this claim? I'm not as certain as you that a majority of people in discriminated classes don't try to change their society for the better. Maybe it depends on exactly what you mean by "change society", but at least for me, I see even small discussions like the one we're having here as potentially changing society. By the way, I'm curious, and please correct me if I'm wrong (as I'm not trying to misrepresent your beliefs): Are you making a normative claim here too, like "Discriminated classes shouldn't try to change their societies"?
- bequanna 4y ago> Does it make sense, in a world like the one in Gattaca, for a person that is part of a discriminated class, to go into space, instead of trying to change the society around him to be less discriminatory? I think this is a little naive. Why should every member of an underclass have to fight the good fight vs improve their own personal position? IMO, the latter is much more likely.
- OnionBlender 4y agoThis is my favorite movie but I always wondered if Vincent ends up dying in space.
- bni 4y agoI always interpreted it this way: He is going to space wearing a business suite, so space flight is quite routine and safe in the Gattaca universe.
- snissn 4y agothis line lives so deep in my brain: "You want to know how I did it? I never saved anything for the swim back"
- losvedir 4y agoI never understood that. I don't think the movie is clear exactly what happens, but he... does swim back, right? Or does he just flounder and rely on his brother bringing him back?
- skeeter2020 4y agoThe movie leaves it a little vague, but his brother disappearing would wrap up the plot nicely, as would his brother finally seeing the Vincent's perspective and keeping his mouth shut. On a broader level it's the "burn the ships" strategy; nothing motivates like having no alternative.
- evan_ 4y agoHe didn’t limit himself planning for the future, rather he found that when the time came he had strength he didn’t realize he had.
- InspiredIdiot 4y agoAlso, he quite likely _does_ die in space. Which figuratively but very directly represents not leaving anything for the swim back. There is room to square the main message of the movie about transcending limits with Gore Vidal's line (something like) "No one exceeds his potential... It would simply mean we had failed to accurately assess it in the first place." Maybe he makes it back, maybe he doesn't, but he goes, does what he sets out to do with no consideration of whether he will be able to return and then tries to return. It's exactly equivalent to people who say they would go to Mars even without knowing whether it is a one-way trip at the outset.
- goatlover 4y agoOne message of the movie could be that there is no fixed measure of potential. There are too many variables. One of them being how badly someone wants to achieve something. Thus it’s massively unfair to measure someone’s potential at birth.
- klyrs 4y agoYour keyboard is still nasty, 25 years later.
- Frummy 4y agoNo joke, this film helped me get over really bad mental stuff. That the human spirit can sort of compensate for pretty much anything is what I find beautiful. But the bad side is the faustian bargain, the sacrifice.
- preommr 4y agoSame for me. I often think about this movie along with your point about how some people have to pay more for their dreams. The way that I think about things now I think reflects the protagonist in the movie: In many ways it doesn't matter. The goal and the obsession that some people have is so all-consumming that they'd pay any price to achieve it. There's a scene where ethan hawke's character has to go through a painful bone procedure to adjust his height and he comforts himself by thinking he's a few inches closer to the stars. Everything is just about coming one step closer to the goal regardless of if it can be reached or if someone else can get there faster.
- Frummy 4y agoCompletely true. I found myself last year waking up every day saying fuck it, 5 caffeine pills to read the next book and same thing tomorrow, suffering is relative and sort of fake, it's just an experience like any other. There's only one life so it doesn't matter how easy someone else has it, that's inaccessible. Anyway I was fucked up over my brain and balls being fucked up from birth and losing 50% of my net worth but now that I am like two months away from owning a house and have the job that I want I've forgotten what used to bother me it's not even on the map anymore, call it nonattachment or call it positive nihilism you just grow past things. Im healed after surgery and walk normally, I blend in so and so and that's good enough
- fallingknife 4y agoI guess I never thought it was much more than a good movie. I mean what is the message supposed to be? For one thing the main character has a heart condition and absolutely should be weeded out of the space mission he is trying to get on. As a larger point about a dystopian future with discrimination based on genetic characteristics I don't think it works either. We discriminate like that based on genetics now. It's just that it comes from random chance at birth rather than human modification, but really what's the difference?
- chordalkeyboard 4y ago> We discriminate like that based on genetics now. It's just that it comes from random chance at birth rather than human modification, but really what's the difference? What are you alluding to here?
- fallingknife 4y agoWe explicitly discriminate by intelligence, which is mostly genetic. How is that different than Gattaca? One must assume that the genetically enhanced in the movie are actually enhanced after all. And we implicitly discriminate by height, which shows a strong correlation with income. That one doesn't even have utility like discrimination based on intelligence does.
- naasking 4y ago> We explicitly discriminate by intelligence, which is mostly genetic. How is that different than Gattaca? We discriminate on intelligence when it's important for the job at hand. The bad kind of discrimination is the kind that considers irrelevant factors. I agree implicit discrimination based on height and attractiveness exists in our culture. This movie is a searing criticism of exactly that kind of discrimination.
- fallingknife 4y agoWe do our college admissions by SAT score. If we did them by genetic test for intelligence (Gattaca style), the classes would be mostly the same minus some dumb rich kids. And since social class and income is heavily determined by where you go to school, it's a similar situation to Gattaca. In the movie, if the genetic enhancements work, then it's basically meritocracy, and not that different than what we have today. If they don't work, like you seem to imply in your comment, then it's arbitrary discrimination, which isn't a particularly interesting or unique concept for a movie.
- jonplackett 4y agoGattaca trivia you may already know - the name is made out of the letters of the genetic code G, A, T and C
- TacticalCoder 4y agoOh I know: I loved the movie so much (and still do) and found it so cool that the movie was named that way on purpose that I gave my daughter four given names and they start respectively with G, A, T and C...
- Vecr 4y agoOne thing I don't understand about the movie, even after reading the screenplay etc. is why does Vincent claim the doctors knew the exact time of his death just seconds after he was born? They clearly don't and can't, given the entire rest of the movie. Are the doctors just reading out the exact middle of the probability distribution (or the time with the absolute highest probability), to way more precision than actually makes sense? On another note, I'm not sure the probability curve would actually only have one peak in Vincent's case, one peak from his heart condition and another from old age would make sense. The doctors/his parents should have explained the nature of the probability distribution in much more detail.
- akira2501 4y agoIsn't that the entire point of the movie? They /don't/ actually know even though they think they do, the entire society is built on hubris.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoGood thing we would never fall for such an obvious thing.
- maxerickson 4y agoYou can read it as a criticism of the society that he was born into.
- skeeter2020 4y ago>> The doctors/his parents should have explained the nature of the probability distribution in much more detail. It may be a movie based in science and still relevant, but it is still first and primarily a movie for entertainment. Add in the fact that "doctors knew the exact time of his death just seconds after he was born" can be interpreted as how long his body will last, not predicting the future, and I'm not sure your request for explaining the math behind this statement would contribute much to the movie.
- Vecr 4y ago
- seized 4y agoWith Crispr and related technologies it seems even more pertinent today than 25 years ago.
- andruby 4y agoGattaca is my favorite movie. Brotherly feud, science, genetics, space. I enjoy movies when there’s one theme I can relate to, this movie has four. The style, human spirit and perseverance are a bonus. I rewatch it when I need to put things and life in perspective.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoAm I the only one who just realised GATTACA is spelt using just the DNA bases?
- darksfall 4y agoNo, I feel this has been very recently asked in another HN post.
- parenthesis 4y agoI thought it was super fun to see Gore Vidal acting in a movie. I haven't seen it in a long time, just looking up the cast, and Dean Norris plays — you guessed it — a cop.
- college_physics 4y agoThere is a bit of survivorship bias. Sci-fi has imagined every possible universe, some of the predictions feel very close to what is transpiring. And if we focus entirely on the human stories behind technological facades or other cultural variability, some people claim that all possible stories have been written already.
- naasking 4y agoI doubt that very much. People can always be wilder than fiction. I'm not aware of any sci-fi that predated gender fluidity, for instance.
- IngoBlechschmid 4y agoGreg Egan's _Diaspora_ (1997) and _Oceanic_ (1998) come to my mind. Of course not really predating, with what we now recognize as gender fluidity existing for thousands of years, but in any case early texts long before the notion rose to be widely known in our culture.
- Vecr 4y agoThose are probably written too late, I'd say they would need to be written in 1990 or before to really count as predicting anything. Though actually, if they predict it with more accuracy and say how common it is (so it's not just the one weird character being weird, but also not being anywhere close to everyone) that might be something as well.
- IngoBlechschmid 4y agoFair. (In _Diaspora_ many people are; in _Oceanic_, all.)
- sangnoir 4y ago> I'm not aware of any sci-fi that predated gender fluidity, for instance. Ursula Le Guin's The Left Hand of Darkness (1964) had gender fluidity, before it was called that. It was central to the story.
- abtinf 4y agoDeath by thesaurus: switching “relevant” to “pertinent” is incoherent in this context. If you are going to use a cliche or idiom, then use it without modification.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoNot everyone has idioms memorized by word. Some of us have them memorized by gist, and our misunderstanding of words can cause us to get it gist wrong.
- senthilnayagam 4y agoat current levels space travels is risky, high cost and prestige. except for couple of private space tourists in last couple of years, everyone else was chosen by governments, predominantly fighter pilots. billionaires will be going to space more often than commoners in this and possibly next decade. I liked Gattaca but believe more in The Expanse kind of future colonisation of solar system.
- reducesuffering 4y agoIsn't Gattaca already here? Another commenter mentioned 0 down syndrome children born in Iceland. Aren't we already doing embryo selection as prospective parents in "1st world" countries?
- jart 4y agoIceland just has a high abortion rate. Selectively terminating births isn't quite the same thing as the genetic engineering and embryo manipulation that was going on in the Gattaca movie. There's even a quote from the movie that specifically addresses this, where that guy says, "you could conceive a million times naturally and never get such a result."
- reducesuffering 4y agoI don't mean Gattaca's full tech involving choosing traits for a child are here, but that the age of embryo and trait selection is here. Aren't some parents doing embryo selection filtering out undesirable traits?
- canucker2016 4y agoYes. In India and China, selecting embryos based on sex (preferring males) has supposedly led to a lower number of baby girls. see https://www.newscientist.com/article/2199874-sex-selective-abortions-may-have-stopped-the-birth-of-23-million-girls/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2199874-sex-selective-a... But South Korea has been able to reverse the trend, from https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-38362474 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-38362474 ==== In an effort to reduce the incidence of selective abortions, South Korea enacted a law in 1988 making it illegal for a doctor to reveal the gender of a foetus to expectant parents. At the same time women were also becoming more educated, with many more starting to join the workforce, challenging the convention that it was the job of a man to provide for his family. It worked, but it was not for one reason alone. Rather, a combination of these factors led to the eventual gender rebalancing. South Korea was acknowledged as the "first Asian country to reverse the trend in rising sex ratios at birth", in a report by the World Bank. ====
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoGood movie, but according to these plots, it was better to be handicapped in 1023 than it is 2023. Let's say genetic engineering assisted human evolution became a reality and enhanced humans pretty much dominated exciting things like space exploration. To be more ethical, participation could be selected by neutral merit tests, but in practice enhancement would still end up as a dominating factor. So what? I would still rather go on vacation to Mars on a spaceship built by enhanced folks than not go at all. Just like I am not realistically smart enough to make a new vaccine in a year, but I still enjoy not dying of the diseases. If genetic engineering is available to all parents and has no adverse side effects, why treat it differently from prenatal vitamins or hiring tutors in school? Some people will choose to go without genetic engineering, or vitamins, or vaccines and that's fine - they can find their own unique role in society and we all benefit of having a control group for our various experiments. Tons of valuable science only exists because of Amish, and the later seem to be perfectly happy to live their own way, and if someone are unhappy we don't stop them from leaving.
- optimalsolver 4y agoJerome, Jerome, the metronome. You can play the piano by that heartbeat of his.
- cm2187 4y agoEugenism is inevitable. You can't stop parents trying to get the best life for their children, that's pretty much their top priority. We don't like to frame it that way but we are already there with pre-natal tests. Even the selection of mating partner is a form of eugenics. College graduates only marrying college graduates, repeat that for many generations and it is bound to have an effect.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrown_43 4y agoEugenics is a comforting story the middle classes tell themselves feel better about being ruled by liars and swindlers. If you want the best life for your children teach them to be selectively sociopathic without a shred of decency. One day they can be the next Obama or Trump. Or Gates. Or Musk.
- imachine1980_ 4y agoThree of the four people(I think Obama wanst) are white sons of millioneirs, I don't think smart is the important part of the equation.
- thrown_43 4y ago[dead]
- flavius29663 4y agoI keep thinking about eugenics, how can we have eugenics without resorting to genocide or ending up with a dystopia, like in Gattaca? Should we even strive to get eugenics, why bother? Where does diversity become detrimental to success for an individual? The clone of a perfect individual will always perform better than the peers, except when we need adaptation and flexibility. Will we get to a society where just some parents agree to alter the genes of their offspring like in Gattaca, for some very niche job opportunities? What happens when it goes wrong, can the child sue the parent?
- mhb 4y agoDiscussion about the Gattaca draft script: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34134565 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34134565
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wonderwonder 4y agoGattaca is one of my favorite movies, mainly because of how believable the concept is. Lets say tomorrow they create a commercially available means of ensuring a child is physically and intellectually superior. Once people start availing themselves of this service anyone with the means almost has to do it as well simply as a kindness to their unborn child to ensure they don't end up as a subspecies to the new genetic ubermensch. Society would quickly split into a genetic upper and lower class exactly as displayed in the movie. It would be very hard to consciously condemn your child to the lower class for the entirety of their life if you had the means to do otherwise. I'm not advocating for this, just describing what I see as the most likely scenario.
- goatlover 4y agoProblem is genetics is messy as the article states, and we have a long way to go to unentangle the role the environment plays, plus there are always unpredictable environmental factors. There’s also the possibility of negative side effects to certain genetic advantages. You might predispose your child to being a genius and mentally ill. I don’t think the movie’s caste system is realistic, because the role of genes isn’t that deterministic. There would be too many exceptions like Ethan Hawke and Jude Law’s characters.
- wonderwonder 4y agoWhile I don't disagree with you based on today's genetic mastery I think things could look very different in 25 years. Also all of human history is essentially different castes deciding they are better and society adapting to it.
- goatlover 4y agoAnd what if in 25 years we're able to show that environmental factors are more important than genetic for a majority of things?
- wonderwonder 4y ago
- pixelmonkey 4y agoThis movie holds up. I recently rewatched and really, really enjoyed it. (Some spoilers embedded in the below.) One thing I love about the script is how the 4 main characters give us all the different angles on the genetic dystopia problem. Vincent is genetically "inferior", but psychologically "determined" to overcome physical limitations. He has to use his mind and body to overcome his genetics. Jerome is genetically "superior", but psychologically defeated due to his accident causing permanent physical limitations. He has to use his mind to compensate for his body, and he "lends" his genetics to Vincent, to make Vincent as capable in their society as he once was. Vincent helps Jerome finally achieve his own potential by the end, thus the final scene. Anton is genetically "superior", but mentally and physically weak. His willpower atrophied as he was constantly told about his genetic superiority. In a way, he allowed his genetics to act almost like an inheritance that made him soft and unambitious. Through the flashbacks, we get the sense that he was always a little cocky about his genetic superiority. He was "born into success". But through adult Anton, we learn that all he has done with his genetics is to become a conformist in this dystopian society. A rule enforcer of the genetic state itself, not someone striving for any higher purpose. When Anton loses the swim match to Vincent, he lets him go on with his plan (not shown in the script or movie), presumably because Vincent has proven that genetics alone do not determine ability, shattering one of his core beliefs. Finally, Irene. She is genetically "upper class", but not "superior". She illustrates the degree to which genetics had become a class marker, like wealth in our current society. She is genetically strong enough to join the space exploration program, but not strong enough to be an astronaut, perhaps only a scientist. (Her last name is Cassini.) She is just as driven by passion for humanity's potential as Vincent, and just as angry about the genetic lottery. That is why they connect as they do. But, in her case, she discovers -- through Vincent's display of willpower -- that her heart condition does not have to limit the life she can lead today. Irene represents society at large, discovering that living your life under the determinism of genetics (or any other limiting class & rule system) will cause you to live a smaller life than you otherwise could. Vincent shows us what we can aspire to despite our imperfections, and Irene shows us how to come to terms with living a happy life despite our imperfections. "Irene" has its origin in the Greek word for "peace" (coming to terms with life as it is). Whereas "Vincent" has its origin in the Latin word for "conquer" (fighting against life's limitations and winning).
- lapama 4y agoInterestingly enough, the article ends up in what I understand is a circular loop: a concern about the best in society. I'd prefer a concern about the average neighbour and person, instead.
- wonderwonder 4y agoThrow away comment but to anybody that likes this movie and it's ideas, I highly recommend the Red Rising series by Pierce Brown. It's the concepts of this film allowed to run their course for a few hundred years.
- giberson 4y agoI though about this movie a lot going through IVF with my wife. Particularly when selecting the embryo to implant. For those that don’t know: With IVF, the doctor harvests as many eggs from the woman as possible. Then after taking the make sample and cleaning, selecting the semen with best modality , fertilize each embryo. Then let the embryo grow for a couple of days then freeze the embryo until it’s ready to be implanted (likely during the woman’s next cycle). If you choose, and generally for a fee, you can have each embryo tested for chromosome mutations. After the process your doctor will call you and let you know how many eggs were harvested and how many were fertilized. They can then give you a report card for the embryos that represent likelihood of live birth, chromosome evaluation, male/female etc. You then make a selection of which embryo (s) to insert. Obviously, given the expense of IVF it’s hard to imagine a scenario of not telling the doctor to pick the highest rated (male or female) embryo just for best chance of success. Felt very reminiscent of gattaca. And that was just selecting the best that we produced. I can easily see myself saying yes to “The best embryo you have had a chromosome defect that will likely result in condition X, but we can fix the defect with a small gene modification, and give the child the best chance for a healthy life, should we modify the embryo?” And then the slippery slope, “we can also improve the odds of higher intellect, being taller , thinner, etc”.
- abledon 4y agowho are the biggest IVF players in the space right now?
- KMag 4y agoDid you find a very skewed sex ratio in your embryos? My dad has a sister, but has only two sons. My brother has 3 sons and one daughter, all natural pregnancies. My wife and I have 1 son via IVF, and the other 4 embryos we had checked for chromosomal abnormalities happened to all be male. I am aware that some IVF processes can inadvertently introduce a sex bias by exacerbating the tiny speed advantage the lighter Y chromosome gives sperm. I'm curious (and will never know) how much of the skewed sex ratio of my embryos is due to randomness, how much is due to IVF processes, and how much might be due to some familial abnormality.
- abledon 4y agoAnd today we're getting headlines like this: https://www.businessinsider.com/pronatalism-elon-musk-simone-malcolm-collins-underpopulation-breeding-tech-2022-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/pronatalism-elon-musk-simone...
- paulwilsondev 4y agoLooking forwards to genetic discrimination lawsuits.
- linuxhansl 4y agoGattaca is hands down my favorite movie of all time. From a dystopian future, where a determination ("not saving anything for the way back") can still make a difference against all odds. A love story, a friendship, and finally an unexpected act of goodwill and an ending that is both relieving and sad. And all this on top of the great acting and cinematography!
- lenocinor 4y agoI’m glad many of you enjoyed the movie. I watched it for the first time last month and did not enjoy it personally. I think the thing that kept making me not believe the narrative was the assumption that you could somehow control how your DNA was left behind. Your body leaves behind hair and skin cells and eyelashes and whatever constantly. No amount of scrubbing like he does in the movie will help that. Also the idea that we would have really advanced genetics but not better genetic detection and tracking technology was not believable for me either. It’s a shame because I think the core idea of the movie was interesting. I just wish the implementation was more believable for me.
- joshuahedlund 4y agoSci-fi has always accidentally reflected the limited imagination of the era it was written in. My favorite example is Isaac Asimov’s I, Robot, written before digital displays were a thing. In the story technology has advanced so far that humans have landed on Mercury for mining, but they have to track their lost robots by manually drawing a pencil graph of their radar pings.
- Vecr 4y agoI'm not sure about that, possibly he put some sort of special make-up/glue-ish stuff on his face to try to seal it in, and his clothes caught the rest of it? He's seen putting stuff in his hair, probably for that purpose. Anyway, how sensitive are detectors in real life? Remember, you need enough intact genetic material to figure out who it is, it's not like detecting anthrax or something where you can just look for a few short conserved snippets. I imagine it's not something PCR works especially well on, so you might not be able to amplify it at all.
- LoveMortuus 4y agopertinent: relevant or applicable to a particular matter; apposite.
- b1c1jones 4y agoI like watching it for the Avantis.
- kerkeslager 4y agoI'm perhaps in the minority of people here, but I didn't like Gattaca, because I thought it actually didn't approach any of the nuance of the genetics discussion, instead opting for a pretty inane oversimplification. Perhaps it makes for an entertaining movie, but it's not a deep philosophical piece. In the movie, the "bad guys" believed that your potential is limited by your genetics. Which is trivially true. But, weirdly, the movie decides this is the thing that needs to be disproven, and goes on to show the main character "overcoming his potential", which is, by the definition of the word "potential", not possible. Showing a fictional character swimming faster than he's supposed to be able to doesn't persuade me that people can overcome their potential. As someone with a disorder which has a genetic component, I don't feel that anyone is doing me any favors by this naive polyanna-ism. There are things I cannot do as a result of my genetics, and it would be good for no one, including me, to assume otherwise. In fact, not understanding my own limitations has been one of the most destructive forces in my life, and identifying and acknowledging those limitations has had immense positive results for me. And very few people, even among literal eugenicists, believe that genetics are the only thing that determines our potential. Most people understand that both nature and nurture are components of one's potential. So basically, Gattaca is a movie that disprove something that is true, and that even the bad guys don't believe is the whole picture. Where the bad guys in the movie go wrong isn't that genetics determine what your potential is (they do), but what to do about it. In the movie, a person's genetics are used to determine all sorts of far-reaching effects about their life. But if we understand that both nature (genetics) and nurture play a part, then it becomes obvious that just because a person has optimal genetics for a certain trait, doesn't mean they'll actually reach the full potential of that trait. Someone with suboptimal genes for that trait might more fully realize the potential of those genes, and surpass the person with better genes for that trait. And further, we might some day be able to associate genes with traits to the point where we know what genes are optimal for certain traits, but it would be extreme hubris to think we really understand what traits are optimal for a job or task. At my college the math requirements for a CS degree exceeded the math requirements for a math minor: and I barely ever use above 8th grade math in my almost two decades as a programmer. If we could test genetic predisposition for math ability, testing programmers for those genes would be counterproductive: not because programmers might overcome their potential for math ability, but because math isn't really all that relevant to programming. It's a losing game trying to align these traits better: the needs of jobs change over time, so the genetically-ideal candidate for a job today won't be the genetically-ideal candidate when the job changes tomorrow. The movie is noticeably sparse in its explanations of how they define "intelligence", for example. And defining "intelligence" is a pretty difficult task. The real-life bad guys (eugenicists) get this wrong too: certain races have traits that others don't (white people are most susceptible to skin cancer, for example!) but we have no way of weighing the traits of each race against another race to determine that any one race is superior. And if we get down to my personal belief on this, it's that everyone is worthy of love, full stop (unconditionally). Conditioning your care for another human being on their genetics is the antithesis of that. That doesn't mean, however, that we should pretend that genetic advantages don't exist. As I shared before, I have some less-than-ideal genes, and that's a real thing I have to consider in my day-to-day, and a real consideration for me should I ever choose to have children. Of course I'm still a valid human with all the rights that come with that. But that doesn't mean I can somehow overcome those genes.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoI don't share the prevailing opinion of Gattaca. I recall the main character as lying and cheating to to hide their genetic predisposition to heart failure. So they can take a place on a space mission, endangering a billion-dollar craft and the lives of the other crewman, all for hubris.
- post_break 4y agoYeah he is the karate kid version of a hero.
- chii 4y ago> endangering a billion-dollar craft and the lives of the other crewman which is the an outcome that was produced by the societal bias towards imperfect people. For example, instead of denying the role to him purely based on genetics tests, they could measure the actual performance against a standard (a standard which you'd need to perform at to do the job). Then, if he is predisposed to heart failure, there could be provisions made to ensure it doesn't interrupt the mission or endanger people on board. Even perfectly healthy people could get a heart attack due to something unpredictable, so having the facility and knowledge to handle such a situation is good regardless. Instead, the society is choosing to eliminate heart failure (or failure modes) - and i think they're blinded by the idea that they must've succeeded by using genetics.
- conscion 4y agoExcept he then cheats on the cardio test, thus reinforcing that the genetic test was valid and he shouldn't be allowed on the trip.
- JoeAltmaier 4y ago'Imperfect people' cannot become Astronauts today. For good reason. You can't wish that away - heart failure. It's like I said, asking others to risk their lives for an avoidable risk, so that one guy can have 'their dream'.
- glued 4y agoWhat incentive does someone born perfect have to strive for perfection?
- paulpauper 4y agoNever saw this movie. now i want to
- anigbrowl 4y agoAndrew Niccol's other sci-fi films, In Time and Anon are also very worth watching. In Time has the distinction of being the only film to make Harlan Ellison shut up.
- jasmer 4y agoIt's odd that everyone talks about 'genetic enhancements' as a measure of success or opportunity because I never even thought about the film as being about that. I thought the film was far more about eugenic fascism, and that kind of thing being wrong in the first place? It's not a story about a kid who 'beat the system in which he wasn't supposed to belong'. It's a story about a system of 'stupid requirements'. It wasn't 'amazing' that he was able to keep up with the 'genetically perfect' rather the notion that 'genetic perfectionism' is a bit absurd. It's like if society only handed jobs to those with 'perfect SAT scores', well yes, it's a measure of 'perfection' of some kind correlated with positive things, but it's not that big of a deal. The Nazis were very big on genetic perfection, and this is a classically Hollywood dig at their ideology. Now they should update it for 2023 and have it about students meeting 'genetic criteria' for Ivy League admissions, which is a weirder game than trying to get to space ...
- chii 4y ago> have it about students meeting 'genetic criteria' for Ivy League admissions the film's premise was that space exploration is still relatively new frontier, and selection into the program is both a prestige affair, as well as expensive (with potential failures costly). Pre-screening candidates with high statistical rates of success makes sense for such a program imho. Not everyone in society has to have the opportunity to be at the frontiers of human affairs. Now, having genetic criteria for admission into education, on the other hand, is pure discrimination. There's no need, unless the resources put into education is high, such that the failure of the student puts heavy cost burdens into the system.
- jasmer 4y agoYea I'm pretty sure 'space' is a metaphor in the story and that it's not even specifically relevant. He's living in a 'genetically selective orthodoxy' where 'diversity is abhorrent' kind of thing.
- qualudeheart 4y agoIs it really? Changes to biological intelligence are irrelevant in a world with one decade timelines until human level artificial general intelligence. If you genetically engineer your kids they still need to slowly grow up. By the time they turn 18 years old the world may already be dominated by machines.
- hi41 4y agoWhere do you rent dvd with director’s cut? I used to listen to why the director created the scene a certain way so I could learn the art of film making.
- stewx 4y agoInteresting tidbit about the movie: Andrew Niccol, the director, wanted to make The Truman Show, but he couldn't get funding for it without enough of a track record. So instead, he made Gattaca which had a low budget. Its success allowed him to fund The Truman Show.