15 ms·
I want to lose every debate
- kuu 4y agoI would say that more importantly than winning or losing a debate is to know which debate you should participate.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoAbout 99% of the time IRL, debating is pointless and just annoying to everyone present.
- whstl 4y agoYeah, couldn't agree more. They also can be annoying online, so people just ignore. On Reddit you often see very long, deep, threads with 1-karma posts that nobody even bothers to vote for. On HN those long debates not only take a lot of space, and you often see moderators telling people to stop. Sometimes you gotta preemptively "lose" a debate, by not answering at all. At most a "Alright, I get your point but I disagree" which also doesn't really add much to the discussion.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoGreat point. A lot of people debate for debate's sake, because their opinion is out there. That's probably what I do on HN, I post and never look back or respond to any replies. Not a good trait, but anyway. Best thing to do, if you detect you're about to enter a debate, is to ask "What would it take for you to change your opinion?". If they reply with "nothing" or a vague answer or whatever, exit the debate. Likewise though, ask yourself the same question.
- artemonster 4y agoI wish debating skills were taught better in schools. A lot of people see debates as a personal attack on themselves and are set to win, no matter the cost. Then comes every dirty manipulation, trick and foul play. This is infuriating.
- nicbou 4y agoGreat perspective. This is why I love browsing HN. Despite its relatively homogeneous userbase, people manage to stay civil when they disagree Elsewhere it's harder, but it still happens.
- heleninboodler 4y agoDerek's right here. Being willing to be wrong is one of the best ways to grow. I have a lot of strong opinions and a lot of knowledge, and I used to think that meant I had to be an absolute warrior defending my side of an argument. Turns out you're stronger if you're willing to consider that you don't know everything. Yet another Derek Sivers post that makes me think he's a freaking genius.
- beebmam 4y agoEven better yet: don't presume (virtually) any of your beliefs are 100% right in the first place.
- paulpauper 4y agoUsually losing the debate means losing to the pig who has better experience. I prefer to just avoid debates. they tend to never be productive except maybe in academia. A common criticism you see online is people avoiding debate and blocking, but consider that usually this is from being tired of bad faith, obtuseness, etc. At some point, patience runs thin. You don't have time for the one or two good, productive debate out of dozens bad, pointless ones, so blocking or ignoring is easier. And no one changes their mind anyway.
- nicbou 4y agoIt's not a debate but a conversation. Treat it like an exchange of information, not something you can win or lose. If the other person doesn't follow, then you can stop replying.
- croes 4y agoSo the articles title is misleading
- nicbou 4y agoI didn't write the article, I'm just joining the discussion.
- croes 4y agoI'm just stating the obvious, wasn't targeted at you
- fluoridation 4y ago"Debate" doesn't have to mean just an organized discussion between two people in front of an audience. If two people are having an argument where they're trying to convince each other of their own position, that's also a debate.
- 4y ago
- paganel 4y ago> The sex worker explains why she loves her job. I'm not going to comment on the other stuff, but we should stop with the sociopathic neo-liberal glorification of "sex work", which in the majority of cases is just human trafficking. I come from a town in Eastern Europe where one of the local mob guys has been caught with trafficking hundreds of (I guess mostly local) girls in Spain. I'm pretty sure many of those girls, if asked, would have told a nice story of "I earn good money out of this! It's liberating!" to any Westerner techie client who would have bothered to ask, what else could have they said? They were still the victims of human trafficking.
- temptemptemp111 4y ago[dead]
- aflag 4y agoThe fact that some prodtitutes are victims of human trafficking doesn't mean that all are. In fact, there are countries where sex work is legal but not human trafficking. So it's possible to even have a legal distinction there. I don't know how things are in Spain, but in the US there's a huge stigma associated with being a sex worker besides it being illegal and actively enforced. In these conditions it would be very difficult to have sex workers who are not somehow a product of sex trafficking. However, in societies where it's not really a taboo, some people will pick that profession, at least for a while.
- glogla 4y agoI'd like to believe that the people who are against sex work are actually thinking of the good of the sex workers and because of human trafficking. Yet there is a lot of human trafficking in other areas, like farmwork or maids in the Western world, and the non-Western world is filled with sweatshops and literal slaves. And you never hear them mention it. Which makes me convinced these people are just anti-sex work for religious or moral reasons (because they have internalized that sex is sinful or bad), reasons they then lie about.
- 4y ago
- vlowrian 4y agoAh, the good old cognitive dissonance between striving to be right and the higher goal of learning and progressing as humanity. For those interested, I recommend this article from Psychology Today: https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/maybe-its-just-me/201103/why-did-we-evolve-the-ability-reason-argue?amp https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/maybe-its-just-me/...
- college_physics 4y agoIt requires energy to pay attention to others and walk in their shoes. Attaching a stereotypical label and switching off / ending the debate is the low cost option Ergo, we must reclaim quality time for engaging with others if we want to live in quality societies
- highland586 4y agoListening and taking someone's point of view has nothing to do with debating. When you're actually listening, you're not debating anymore. It's a life skill.
- zmxz 4y agoWhy post this comment? Asking out of curiosity, trying to listen to view your point.
- highland586 4y agoSome comments higher up conveyed it better than I did myself. I feel like losing a debate and understanding someone else's point of view/learning from them are separate things. In my own experience a debate is not the ideal means of communication if I want to empathize or understand someone better. But as groestl points out, this is a personal matter.
- groestl 4y agoThat might be your preferred way of learning. As for myself, I can't take someone's POV without understanding. And I can't understand without exposing my current model to be shaped by someone's counterarguments. For me there's no better way to learn (apart from explaining and being met with unexpected questions, which I enjoy even more).
- SilasX 4y agoClickbaity way to say it, but yes, I like to "lose debates" in the way Sivers describes here. For the same reason, I'm very tolerant of rudeness and disrespect if and when it comes with an insight that makes my understanding of something click. Also for the same reason I like to say, "Don't tell me I'm wrong; instead, improve my worldmodel to the point that you no longer have to, because the wrongness will be obvious." But I'm not sure that what Sivers describes here is coterminous with "losing a debate". Rather, it's just one way you might "lose a debate". In practice, losing a debate more often looks something more like: 1) The other side stubbornly refuses to engage with your point while effectively signaling you're a bad person despite endorsing the same tradeoffs you do. [B] 2) The other side points being so muddled that you can't untangle what they're disagreeing with or what makes your point wrong, but they speak with that confidence that everyone wants to agree with them. [A] I don't like losing a debate those ways. [A] Example of this kind of misdirection from Thank You For Smoking: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuaHRN7UhRo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuaHRN7UhRo [B] Recent example from HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33900804 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33900804
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoThe article's title is about debates, but all he gives are examples of conversations (except maybe one). I don't think you can really compare debates with discussions, thus drawing this conclusion from unrelated lived experiences does not make much sense to me
- temptemptemp111 4y ago[dead]
- somenameforme 4y agoI believe I feel this way. I think many, if not the vast majority of us do. Now for a little test. When was the last time you lost a debate on a topic you felt strongly about? And not a debate that further reaffirmed your own biases (I used to believe X was bad, but wow I was wrong - it's WAY worse than bad) but actually a meaningful swap from (X is bad) to (X is not bad). In my case, the answer is never. Now I'd like to imagine this is obviously because I'm the most intelligent, objective, and insightful individual to have ever lived. Of course I suspect the actual reason is because anything worth debating will always have reasonable arguments for both sides. And so long as your arguments are reasonably factually based, it's never really possible to lose a debate, unless you choose to. You can learn new things, expand your worldview, but losing will only happen if you want it to. Hence the reason I added that qualifier about swapping worldviews as opposed to enhancing a prior held one. Of course this doesn't preclude major worldview shifting change from happening, but it happens over long periods of times for reasons that I don't think any of us can really pin down. It's going to be a butterfly effect of a million little factors.
- The_Colonel 4y ago> but actually a meaningful swap from (X is bad) to (X is not bad). In my case, the answer is never. I think you did, otherwise you would never change your opinions, which I doubt. But I think it works more subtly. I've noticed that when I lose a debate, my immediate emotional response is rejection - the person is wrong, my opinion is right, even though I couldn't effectively justify it. But once the emotional hurt of loss wears off, it will sometimes (not always) move my position, sometimes a little bit, sometimes completely. It can take days, months, sometimes years.
- Cthulhu_ 4y ago> But once the emotional hurt of loss wears off, it will sometimes (not always) move my position, sometimes a little bit, sometimes completely. It can take days, months, sometimes years. That's exactly it; I'm convinced people's opinions can and will change over time, but they take time. This is used in subtle ways too with modern-day internet and social media (and before that, newspaper headlines); people will scan the internet's headlines and depending on what they see, form an opinion. If all you see is headlines about police brutality, you will be convinced that the police is corrupt and violent and shit. If all you see is headlines about a demographic being involved in crime, you'll form prejudices about them.
- tsuujin 4y agoI’d like to offer an alternative framing: don’t debate at all, just listen. While high school debate did teach me many positive lessons and I am thankful that I spent four years of my life doing it, many years later I have come to understand that it also taught me something truly negative: that the point of a conversation is to win. I have put a lot of time in my adult life unlearning that trait, and reflecting on the harm it did to my relationships with other people. If you want to grow like OP here suggests—which I think is a valuable, worthwhile goal—you will do yourself a great service in learning to listen. I know we all think that we do this, but I don’t think many of us actually do. When you talk to others, take note of how much of the time you spend formulating a response. I know that for me, I find that frequently I’m already generating my rebuttal before they finish speaking. I am effectively listening to respond, not to hear what they have to say. I’m much much better at listening to hear today than I was a decade ago, but I still have to correct myself on this routinely. It’s important to note that you can listen to hear and still be free to respond; if you want to have an interesting conversation you will definitely need to put in some effort too. Just make sure that you’re internalizing what they’ve said before you form a response to it. It will almost certainly slow down the pace of a conversation but stands a decent chance of making each exchange a lot more interesting for both of you. I really believe that the most profound realizations of my life have come when I shut up and put in the effort to internalize what other people around me were doing and saying.
- sokoloff 4y agoI recently read a similar point phrased in a way that really resonated: “if you’re right, you’ll still be right in five minutes” (so you might as well listen carefully in case you’re wrong).
- atoav 4y agoWhile this is good advice, it is still in a debate-mindset where, ultimately, it is about "winning" a conversation. But if you argue with someone who holds factually wrong opinions is it truly winning "if you showed them" and they think "what an asshole" and move on? That type of person is practised at brushing off a debate loss. That means if you enjoy winning such a debate it tells more about you than about the person opposite. The best conversations I had with the worst people stemmed from me not even telling them my opinion at all. I just asked them to explain theirs to me and asked the questions that occured to me in a respectful manner. Leaving them in healthy confusion and doubt afterwards (and learning a thing or two about them on the way) is more rewarding than winning a debate with them. Sometimes those people really surprise you as well, because they hold a combination of opinions that seem incompatible to you.
- jez 4y agoEvery debate you lose is one where someone else won (and by the author’s logic, was deprived of the chance to lose). Some debates I want to win, for the simple joy of teaching someone something new. While it would be an optimal use of my time (from an information-theory point of view) for me to lose every debate I participate in, some debates are worth taking up for the chance to share.
- paulpauper 4y agoI am wrong constantly. yet somehow I and others, who are also wrong, function and get by in life. It's kinda amazing how society works when so many people are wrong. If I had to guess it's the correcting mechanism from the exchange and discussion of ideas. Bad ideas tend to be weeded out or turn into better ones.
- _cenw 4y agoUnderstanding perspectives is a useful skill. But it's not where having an educated opinion ends. I understand the desire of US fossil fuel companies to do fracking. They're not stupid or comically evil. But they can be greedy, misguided, selfish and too focused on short term gains (if you want to be extra accustory, "within their lifetime"). If you then move over to how much astroturfing is involved in pushing through a viewpoint you may even call it evil. Though not comically, because everything here is still just following the forces and inventives of our economic system - profit at every non-monetary expense. If you want change, your solution needs to address systemic issues (not neccessarily abolishing capitalism, but focusing on different inventives and making other alternatives viable/profitable though taxes) (I hope the point I picked is uncontroversial enough, but you can probably apply it to your least favorite policies of your least favorite flavor of political party, organization, movement or institution)
- doctor_eval 4y agoIn Manufacturing Consent, Herman and Chomsky write that (I’m paraphrasing) “nobody wakes up and thinks, ‘how will I ruin the world today?’”. Our world is full of perverse incentives which are embedded into society itself. It’s been one of the most important lessons I’ve ever learned. Truly evil people are rare. Selfish people not so much. But selfish people nevertheless will generally follow the law and social convention. Unfortunately it’s hard to change either of these things.
- mandmandam 4y agoFracking is textbook comic evil. Say there's a comic book where fossil fuel co's worked to permanently ruin the groundwater and increase earthquakes in a region - bribing lawmakers and fucking over the people who lived there, gagging scientists, etc - all just for a resource that is literally burning the planet... So they can upgrade their megayacht/private jet... I'd find it hard to believe that others could allow it to happen. "Following the incentives of our economic system", so your actions are indistinguishable or worse than those of a comic book villain, *is* comically evil. Literally. The fact that so much of our economic system defends this behavior says a lot.
- 4y ago
- o_m 4y agoI agree with this, and I hate when people say "debating is pointless because no one ever change their mind".
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoOne great advice I've heard is that, before even going into a debate, you ask someone "What would it take for you to change your mind on this subject?" People won't change their mind if they don't have an open mind to begin with, or if they're not open to debate on a subject matter in the first place. A lot of people - online and off - will engage in debate for debate's sake, even though all parties involved are not willing to change their opinion. They just want to be heard. I mean who here would have an open mind about e.g. flat earth or whether the Holocaust actually happened (to invoke Poe's law)? I sure don't, and I don't feel guilty about it either; I don't need to consider anyone's point of view if I find their opinion morally reprehensible, and if they strongly hold those beliefs and are unwilling to accept alternatives, they're not worth the effort or time. They can go back to their echo chambers.
- nordsieck 4y agoThere's a sort of hidden weakness to "losing": it's extremely difficult for people to correctly filter out BS at scale. I'm not talking about on an individual encounter level - BS almost always loses to truth. But the percentage isn't so high that smart and/or successful people never fall for BS in their lifetime. Especially since BS is under evolutionary pressure to be extremely believable. That's a big part of the benefit of being part of the mainstream of knowledge. It's almost certain that large swaths of the mainstream are BS. But the mainstream is also exposed to the most criticism (at least the parts where criticism is acceptable), which means that BS tends to get filtered out more quickly as well. In contrast, looking at "alternative" knowledge communities, they all generally have that whiff of being scammy. There's probably some truth in there, at least in some of those communities, but there's also a lot more BS. So, I'm not saying to never lose. Losing is generally good. Just take care to make sure that you're actually losing.
- The_Colonel 4y ago> But the mainstream is also exposed to the most criticism (at least the parts where criticism is acceptable), which means that BS tends to get filtered out more quickly as well. This is what I worry in relation to ChatGPT. Producing quality, believable BS is currently expensive, and the price of exposing it is relatively manageable. But with ChatGPT, it will be possible to produce huge amounts of BS which will be extremely believable and simply uneconomical to critique and expose. BS can be tailored to the audience, imagine a Wikipedia written by ChatGPT specifically for your which takes into account your own biases. It doesn't even have to be factually wrong, it can just modify the writing style, a word here and there to evoke a different sentiment, play on your personal preconceptions to move slightly your political position in a certain direction. People will claim they are immune to such subtle manipulations, but I don't believe that.
- concordDance 4y agoIt's also worth noting that ChatGPT is a BS generator that's only allowed to generate BS for one side of a number of modern arguments.
- 4y ago
- pdpi 4y agoI don't like the position of "losing is good". I want to win every debate, because I define winning a debate as coming out of it knowing more that I did going in. Debating isn't a zero-sum game, me winning doesn't make you the loser.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoYeah but what if you're wrong and you "won" by attrition? This is the problem with a lot of debates; they don't end with one party being convinced of the other party's point of view, they often end because one party just gives up. I mean your point does apply if you actually acknowledge your lack of knowledge on a subject and do your research before bringing in an argument, but a lot of people don't, they have a standpoint and will stick to it. Losing isn't good, but neither is winning if that was your goal going into a debate; the goal should be to learn and come to a consensus.
- pdpi 4y agoI think you misunderstood me. The point I'm making is that you should redefine "winning a debate". Learning (and hopefully coming to a consensus) is exactly what winning should mean in your head. Just altogether abandon the notion that you win by convincing the other party you're right.
- personjerry 4y agoRemember, if you're winning, if you're correct, if you're talking, then you're not learning. Only when you're wrong and you recognize you don't have the full picture can you grow. I think our education systems and parents often frame being wrong as bad, but it's precisely the opposite.
- psychphysic 4y agoIt bothers me that people argue so poorly. That's why debate exists. And why some people excel at podcasts Joe Rogan being an examplar. His best debates have very similar formats. "Tell me about"/"why do you think" "What about X" "So you're saying Y?" "Wouldn't that mean Z" People are bothered because he rarely ever seems to shoot others down just gets them to lay out their points and fleshout reasoning. The only time he shoots you down is if he thinks you don't have an explanation around some aspects of your point. But his job is done the audience can make up its own mind.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoThat's the mark of a good host (or debater), instead of arguing directly (confrontational), they encourage the other party to think. You don't win a debate with arguments and counter-arguments, you win it by letting the other person come to and change their own conclusions.
- badcppdev 4y agoYou seem to be stating that Joe Rogan's 'best debates' aren't debates so much as interviews. I'm bothered that you describe that as a debate.
- psychphysic 4y agoYou're nicely applying the JRE method here. The problem is that the other definition of 'debate' is competitive and people have interests to appear correct more than to be correct.
- badcppdev 4y agoTo follow the spirit of the original linked article I will choose to accept that a debate can be defined as a conversation where one person presents their ideas and another person listens and asks clarifying questions in a generally non-argumentative manner. With the JRE you seem to be saying that the guest is arguing that their ideas are correct and JR is arguing the negative but only through the use of questions and occasional direct counters to the guests argument. Seems like a debate to me although also fits the definition of an interview.
- entropyneur 4y agoAll of these "debates" are about how someone else's way of life makes sense for them. The world would be a better place if we assumed this is the case most of the time instead of having to be convinced of it.
- wnkrshm 4y agoYou can understand people and where they come from, information about why they believe what they believe. But it's naive to think this can always foster common ground - some beliefs are entirely incompatible with the existence of the listener.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI've heard a good one about that; there's opinions and there's morals. You can debate about whether, idk, donuts are good or not; that's a personal opinion, the stakes are pretty low with that. But other disagreements are on a moral level; things like racism, some people are morally bankrupt and have Strong Beliefs about what should happen with people not like them. I don't believe you can (or should) debate with people like that. And I think that the anti-science 'debates' can also hit people on a moral level; how DARE you hold these strong beliefs that do hold up to scientific scruteny? (think flat earthers etc).
- fluoridation 4y agoI completely disagree. Silence is implicit agreement in some (and I would argue most, at one time or another) people's minds. A fringe mentality that doesn't encounter any push-back will tend to exacerbate itself further and further. If an idea is not factually wrong anyone can be convinced of it. Anyone can be made racist or tolerant given the right argument.
- t344344 4y ago[flagged]
- KingLancelot 4y ago[dead]
- eggie5 4y agoYears later, still puzzling over Thomas Jefferson's passivity at Philadelphia, John Adams would claim that "during the whole time I sat with him in Congress, I never heard him utter three sentence together" Jefferson, himself would one day advise a grandson, "when I hear another express an opinion which is not mine, I say to myself, he has a right to his opinion, as I to mine." And "Why should I question it. His error does me no injury, and shall I become a Don Quixote, to bring all men by force of argument to one opinion?... Be a listener only, keep within yourself, and endeavor to establish with yourself the habit of silence, especially in politics."
- pjerem 4y ago> Why should I question it. His error does me no injury Isn't that an incredibly dangerous behavior especially in political debates ? I mean, wrong political opinions do injure people. Maybe not the other people in the room but the people who elected them. Do I miss something ?
- eggie5 4y agoAs Adams agreed, it was quite the perplexing philosophy. However, who won in the end? The firebrand Adams or stoic Jefferson???
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThomas Jefferson was as privileged as they come. Of course he'd have that opinion. He was at the top of the pyramid. Opinions held by his fellow man would have no impact on him personally.
- trynewideas 4y ago> Do I miss something ? Yes, the part of governmental politics that involves creating and enforcing policy. Jefferson would listen to people's arguments in legislature but infrequently debated them because his strength (in his own estimation, at least) was in writing responses, especially as policy proposals. Someone speaking a disagreement does him no harm, even if what's being described would be harmful. But someone implementing something he viewed harmful in enforced policy is different, and he treated it very differently. Governmental politics tends to emphasize, even glamorize, the former, but the latter is what actually affects people and Jefferson often focused his attention on it. One could strongly suggest that Jefferson's preference for written arguments and policy over political debate and lobbying is why Hamilton had more effective Federalist influence over early policies of the United States, and manifests even more strongly in Jefferson's prescriptions for the republic — the Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights, wanting to rewrite the Constitution every 20 years, his opposition to slavery and promotion of universal free education, freedom both of and from religion in government, strongly held national liberties and local self-government — many of which were at the time, or have always been, ignored in practice.
- brmgb 4y agoI find this article amusing. I think it puts forward something interesting but frame it completely incorrectly. The author doesn't actually want to lose debates even if it doesn't seem to realise it. He doesn't want to have debates at all. He just wants to have conversations with people and less preconceptions. That's something I'm completely in line with. I believe we suffer as a society from a collective excess of opinions. The funny thing is that even when he tries to describe is prejudice in an unprejudiced way, he horribly fails at it.
- noduerme 4y agoAstral Codex he ain't
- chengiz 4y agoI agree he frames it incorrectly, but he has not failed in terms of results. If he framed it as "I want to talk to people", it would not be posted on HN, and no one would be visiting his site or discussing his shower thought.
- noduerme 4y agoIt's not really healthy to view such a thing as success, unless your goal is to become good at bullshitting people (as opposed to creating lasting things of value that you can be proud of). Lots of great projects show up in HN and receive no views. On the other hand lots of self promoters who say nothing imortant get tons of views. Ideally you'd want to be in the middle, where you made something awesome and were good at promoting it.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoTo each their own, but I prefer argumentative and opinionated people and have nothing against discussions even when they become heated. In my experience, there is much more to learn from others by discussing a topic than by "listening" to them. Good discussions take a certain emotional detachment from the topic, though, and when that is lost it can become unpleasant. But in my opinion "pleasant" isn't a major criterion for good conversations.
- renewiltord 4y agoI actually want to win every debate. Winning is hitting delta less than something small. The whole point is for each utterance to increase information gain. Aumann's Agreement Theorem always applies so if you get IG = 0 at any stage it is worth considering if the discussion is worth it. Additionally, verbal and textual conversations lack the depth to transmit the full state of the probabilities in your model. Consequently, it is often useful, as a participant, to break off a miniclone of oneself to perform the information interchange and then integrate it into the rest afterwards. You can't tabula rasa the miniclone easily because of the bootstrap time but you can't retain elasticity of your true mind. A more plastic form of yourself can work well. The problem is that this approach is susceptible to information contagion.
- bjarneh 4y ago> Now I want to hear everything about how clothing is like the SMTP protocol If email is from the wrong "brand" (i.e. server); it is instantly seen as garbage and discarded by most mail hosts. If clothes are from the wrong "brand" (i.e. manufacturer); they are instantly seen as garbage and discarded by most people. /s
- devnullbrain 4y agoThis is very self-congratulatory and fails to account for the many times where winning a debate can have greater implications than navel gazing. If the author has never encountered these, he's either very lucky or has no meaningful views against the mainstream anyway.
- dtx1 4y ago[flagged]
- mihaic 4y agoI got the same impression, as coming from the modern style of "open-mindedness", which seems to be interpreted not as judging an idea by its merits alone, but by giving more weight to non-establishment ideas.
- ajfwe 4y agoI have no idea how someone could not convincingly accept that. In modern western society, adultery, one of the worse possible civilization destroying crimes, is hardly even regarded as truly evil and is glorified in media. Especially when women do it.
- messe 4y agoCan you share some examples of media glorifying it? That hardly seems to be a common thing.
- dtx1 4y ago[flagged]
- fluoridation 4y ago>I have no idea how someone could not convincingly accept that. So you mean that to you it's so obvious that shariah leads to peace that you have trouble understanding how someone might disagree? Then I assume that you completely agree with all aspects of shariah, right? Then why would achieving peace require killing homosexuals and apostates? Are those two specific groups particularly violent? It seems to me that killing is quite a violent act, so homosexuals and apostates would have to be really violent to justify outright killing them.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoConvincing is in the eye of the beholder. It doesn't surprise me anymore because at this point I've seen more than enough of this sort naivety/idiocy that's massively trending again in the West. It's not a new phenomenon: https://www.timesofisrael.com/museum-acquires-bertrand-russell-letter-on-hitler https://www.timesofisrael.com/museum-acquires-bertrand-russe...
- mihaic 4y agoThe first time I saw US-style collegiate debate, it seemed like a great mind-game. Over time I've come to consider it though as the sign of a bullshitting culture, where the truth is irrelevant, and winning the argument is all that matters. Professional debating and the article both feel wrong since they're missing the key element to me: synthesis of opposing ideas into something more than each individual side. It might happen that at times this synthesis means that one side is completely discarded, but the goal of any debate to me should be to achieve the sum of all truths that are held by all parties. Most places from from schools to success stories seem to fail in describing the purpose of debating to me because of that.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoIt's the difference between being right and winning. Not the same thing. The best way to be right is to change your mind, since the odds that your model of reality matching with reality are stacked against you. If you don't plan for failure, you plan to fail. If you don't plan for being wrong, you plan to be wrong.
- nhooyr 4y agoWhat do you mean US-style? As far as I'm aware, such debate clubs exist all throughout the world. The most famous of which are probably the Cambridge Union and the Oxford Union both in the UK.
- mihaic 4y agoIt might be anglo-saxon style. I've never seen them in mainland Europe in this format.
- sebzim4500 4y agoI don't know about the Oxford Union, but the people arguing in the Cambridge Union generally believe the arguments they are making. This makes it quite different from debate clubs in school.
- onos 4y agoI agree. The fun thing for me in “debate” is understanding the arguments for and against something. Most often, arguments differ through either (1) the axioms used, or (2) there is a subjective preference at play. In these cases, there is no right side. Of course, there are cases with an answer, often scientific type questions.
- TrackerFF 4y agoI’be learned to keep an open mind. Whenever I see something which I don’t understand, or something that screams “that’s just stupid” I try to wait with being the judge - because by experience, there’s usually some rationality behind that. It might not make sense to me, but could make sense - even be very important to others. Probably the people I enjoy the least to interact with, are the highly opinionated and cocksure people that simply refuse to expand their minds. Listen more, would be my best advice. Wait until you see a bigger picture, and don’t try to infer everything from the go.
- depot5 4y agoI remember an interview with a smart man at some medical device company. His most memorable thing started with the pretty boring, "what do you like least about work?" So, I replied, "arguing about plans for projects. Many co-workers get emotional there and resist bringing in facts." And his reply to that is what made me think he's pretty smart. Arguing and debating about what to do is one of the biggest ways that managerial types can add value to a workplace. And it's even right to get a bit emotional, because the things decided in the meeting is probably going to decide stress, money, and life quality for everyone there. It's hard to change plans after deciding what to do in a big meeting. Bad managers will use debate tricks, but so will good ones. Everyone must be aware of these things, otherwise it's out of control. The expectation for senior employees is to be responsible and contribute important arguments in debate.
- jagrsw 4y agoThere are debates which are illuminating (esp. when you first time hear some ideas), you get new POVs and see excitement in the speaker's eyes, and even numbers/data might add up to a point, but the overall ideas might be harmful/dangerous/impractical/too-nuanced/in-theory-sure-but Examples: - People should believe in god(s) b/c people believing in god(s) are more stress-resistant and are overall happier -> improvement of life quality - Everyone should pay the same amount of taxes - since they get from the state on avg the same amount of services -> fairness - Everyone should be paid the same for any kind of job if they put the same amount of effort/time -> fairness - Geopolitics can be described in a few catchy phrases (esp. in hindsight) - zero-sum games, rimland/heartland etc. - Richer and more achieved should have more kids (by law or consensus) than poorer ones -> it'll improve human gene-pool wrt cognitive capabilities People formulating and believing (and sometimes acting on) such and similar ideas are not rare. Having them as family, friends, colleagues, random interlocutors at a party and entertaining their train of thought, sure. But considering them as a partner in a company, advisor, someone you elect for public office... not so much.
- avaika 4y agoThis is all fun until you talk to someone who is absolutely brainwashed or alien to a peaceful behavior. Do you really want to lose the debate to flat earth advocate? Do you want to lose a debate to a war aggressor supporter? Do you want to lose a debate to a serial killer? I bet you don't. PS. Maybe I didn't get something right, but I suffered a lot in conversations with close relatives who are denying that killing other people is bad in the light of ongoing war in Ukraine :(
- FlyingSnake 4y agoOf course the will be outliers and edge cases for most of the advice you receive. This observation from Derek is more or less a guideline, not an iron rule. He's not advocating to forgo common sense when dealing with people.
- jnsaff2 4y agoI think that the fact that Derek found this interesting enough to write about and people find it controversial to discuss about here kinda proves that his wish is the outlier and the norm is arguing with bad faith actors or people who have made up their mind and want to convince you, not really learn anything. Maybe this is an internet thing but genuine enlightening discussion is kinda hard to be found on internet.
- iinnPP 4y ago>close relatives who are denying that killing other people is bad Nobody, except people with legitimate mental health issues, thinks killing is a "good" thing. Your close relatives believe Russia is on defense. Kind of like how the US was on defense in Iraq. So, from their perspective, the way to save lives is to negotiate an end to the war where Russia takes that tiny bit of land, and Ukraine stops being considered for the UN. Come to the discussion using human life as the topic. Figure out where solutions exist that save the most lives. Talk about how many die and what is gained or lost as a result. Moving the conversation from nations to humans will not only help the argument make more sense, it will have you coming away with far superior respect for your incredibly important family unit.
- amelius 4y agoGiven the current level of political polarization in the US, we can conclude that Americans are very bad at this.
- dalanmiller 4y agoBe curious, not judgemental.
- zxcvbnm 4y agoInsu
- zxcvbnm 4y agoAgree if no consequence. But imagine, what if there is. And the debate's winner gets to implement his BS.
- tsylba 4y agoDialectic is where things happens, it's where people meet. Dialectic is the dancing space between two perspectives. We all know the saying "It's not about the nails", where one person try to solve an appearing problem for another one who secretly just need an ear to be listen to. Yes, listening is important as a human skill to relate & connect, but ultimately living together is dancing between perspective. We hardly all be passive or let others strongly shape our shared narratives. We know we're not right, how can we be ? we share a narrative about the world and try to make sense of it. Like the Tao symbol Yin & Yang interlacing, everything we do, we tell contains a part of truth and a part of wrong. The issue is when one identifies too strongly to one's perspective. We're always at least partly wrong but living is deciding which path to take at any moment, and accepting it's not right. Politic is how we organize ourselves & Democracy aims to listen to everyone, the only way to do that is to share our perspective and enable true dialectic. Sure, sometimes positions are strongly held, but there is no true freedom without a bit of a fight isn't it ? how can we all relate all the time ? share the same taste, share the same vision ? it's boring and borderline dangerous. That what anarchism tell us, not as a dogma to political utopia but as a way to relate politically : we differ so we need to talk, we need to dance everytime to build a better shared perspective, with as many vision there is. Anarchism is a dialectic of every moment, inhaling and exhaling, sharing and dancing, but we cannot dance alone, and we cannot just all listen (and say nothing), and we cannot all talk (and be deaf to others perspectives). And this is what we are all doing just now, what the authors of the post did too. He speaks his truth and wait for people to dance with it. (But as anything goes, what I just typed is neither completely true or false, and that's ok)
- jojobas 4y ago> The Muslim explains why Islamic law is a perfect recipe for peace. Let me rephrase it for a second. > The Communist explains why global USSR is a perfect recipe for peace. > The Nazi explains why Reich is a perfect recipe for peace. Sometimes you have to wish for an idea to die, too bad if some of its carriers have to go with it.
- janjones 4y agoA book on this topic: Think Again [1] [1] https://adamgrant.net/book/think-again/ https://adamgrant.net/book/think-again/
- robalni 4y agoI feel like there are two different things that are often talked about as the same thing: 1. Wanting to understand and learn. Here you use the help of another person to figure out what the best solution or the right answer to something is, or just to understand how something works or in other ways improve your knowledge. There is no winner or loser; the only outcome is whether the discussion was successful or not. 2. Wanting to prove how much you already know or that your idea is the correct one. This is just about showing everyone that you (or your idea and therefore you) are better than the other person, not about what you learn from it. Here there is a winner and loser; you win if you appear to know the right answer from the start. These are two very different things; you could even say that they are opposites. In number 1, the goal is to learn. In number 2, the goal is not to learn but to stay with your current idea. Why don't we have different words for these two things? It seems like in this article, what he is talking about is doing number 1 but talking about it as if it were number 2. Could the reason that we talk about these two things as the same thing be that people often do both at the same time? In that case maybe they want to appear as already knowing but secretly still trying to learn something. Or maybe they only try to learn but others are judging them as if they should already know everything from the start, and that way misunderstanding what they are doing.
- fluoridation 4y agoConsider this: You have an idea about how things are and this other person has another idea in direct contradiction with yours, such that at most one of the two can be right. If you want to treat their idea as if it has merit then you have to argue with them to understand why they think what they think and how well their idea fits in with other facts you already know. If you care about the truth then you will need to subject their idea to the same harsh trials your own idea (presumably) passed, and if there's any possible flaws or inconsistencies you'll want to dig in to thoroughly understand everything. You might that in fact you were wrong all along and this idea is actually better than yours. Do you see how and why one might want to learn something new while outwardly appearing to want to prove themselves right (or, more accurately, to prove the other person wrong)? An idea that one can't prove wrong is certainly worth considering seriously.
- hp6 4y agoIMO the author underestimates the positive effects of non combative debates between adults. For a long time before we could just google, debating was one of the main ways we used to check our ideas. Do you believe the sky is red? Try to debate someone and see if you can convince them. And while we now can just google most of the simpler things, that's not the case for complex ideas. As the author notes by simply listening you will have a better view of the other persons arguments. But at the same time you deprive them from the opportunity of validating their ideas. Which is not a simple tradeoff. Even worse most people will take silence as a form of agreement, which for a debate about C++ vs Rust is no big loss but is not true for a lot of other issues. And strangely enough the examples provided by the author are complex non trivial ideas no one should take for face value or agree by silence.
- noduerme 4y agoI'm sorry, but I just can't read this. Ever since I put out an album on CDBaby in like 2004, which was Mr Sivers project at the time, I have been subjected to an endless stream of daily self promotion from this man. Somehow he evades all spam blocks and all attempts to remove myself from his lists. I have never seen another human being so self absorbed who consistently just had to have their meandering thoughts manually junked from my inbox for so many years. Not even my father who forwards shit from fox news every morning. My pure level of irritation at seeing Sivers name must be a great credit to his ability to evade every spam block on earth; it's almost like every attempt to block him just makes him stronger.
- romanovcode 4y agoYou don't have to read anything. One does not have to be a genius to guess EXACTLY what the blog post is about.
- noduerme 4y ago[dead]
- stingraycharles 4y agoCan't you just block his emails?
- noduerme 4y agoI've tried. I've even contacted him personally. I run my own mail server so you think it should be trivial. A year or two later, he's gotten past my filters again. We're talking about 20 years here. I don't understand it but he's got some form of email jujitsu.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qrng 4y agoAs a matter of fact, this logic is expedient for those who want to brainwash someone. Sure, you may have to listen to the weak people you think are "stupid," and that gives you a new perspective. But not in the case of some huge media. They just want to sensitize people with convenient political and commercial propaganda. Punch the strong and sympathize with the weak.
- UhUhUhUh 4y agoLet's not forget the Prime Directive.
- kypro 4y agoThese days I try to actively confuse myself as to what positions I hold in the aim to be more objective with my reasoning. As best I can I try to block out thinking in terms of labels completely. When I was younger I cared a lot about having very clear, well defined opinions. I adopted labels to describe my positions and would wear these labels with pride as I believed them to be correct and well-reasoned. Eg, I am a liberal. I am pro-choice. I am anti-war. But truth was I wasn't 100% liberal, pro-choice, or anti-war. There were circumstances where I could hold more nuanced opinions depending on the context. But because I adopted these labels I was always really reluctant to acknowledge when nuances existed. This was especially true the more gray the right answer was. For example, a lot of people who are anti-war believe the US was right to join the fight against the Nazis. But what about the American civil war? What about supporting Ukraine against Russia. Are these justified positions too? Suddenly it's difficult to claim to be anti-war while also be a supporter of many major conflicts. How can someone who claims to be anti-war be in favour of so many wars? You know rationally you can't be anti-war and also pro-war when it suites you so you might be tempted to try to rationalise why actually the American civil war shouldn't have been fought or why Ukraine should just let Russia win to preserve peace. Equally assigning labels to others is also bad. What if you were arguing with someone you consider a racist and they make a good point? No matter how correct they are to acknowledge that point is difficult because suddenly that risks agreeing with a racist. I'm from the UK and I've seen this with the EDL here. While a lot of their opinions are awful, they also occasionally can make good points about issues like grooming gangs and Islamic extremism here in the UK. The problem as no one wanted to agree with them about anything so Islamic extremism and grooming gangs got labelled a far-right conspiracy. I suppose a more recent example of this was with Covid. In 2021 agree with any argument against mass government mandated vaccination programs was often considered being anti-vax. My head is far more muddled these days. I believe I'm more objective and flexible in my thinking though. I'm saying this because while being happy to lose a debate and change your mind is great, no one goes into a debate to lose - especially not to someone you view as an ideological enemy in some form. As soon as you assign labels to yourself and think in terms of "winning" and "losing" it's very difficult to think rationally about anything.
- varispeed 4y agoWhen "debating" I often was presenting a point of view I disagree with as if it was mine and trying to defend it as best as I could based on the information I have to see what other people have against it, whether it makes sense and if it is similar to what I actually think about it. It was helpful to me, as often the point I disagreed with, was actually "the right way" and I was able to keep being out of my bubble. That being said, people often believed that what I say is what I actually believe in and so many won't even speak to me because they think I am a twt. I guess I was good at this.
- thenerdhead 4y agoThe stoics would say two ears, one mouth and the Buddhists would say the ears have no lids but all else do. Everyone is right in their own perspective. That’s why it is called a point of view.
- baxuz 4y ago> The Muslim explains why Islamic law is a perfect recipe for peace. And I'm done with this article.
- cutler 4y agos/peace/oppression/
- hendry 4y ago"The Singaporean in the three-piece-suit explains why clothing is like the SMTP protocol.", that must be Meng Wong of RFC4408
- a_c 4y agoI come to ask this. Why is it like SMTP?
- noam_compsci 4y agoHow self congratulatory. So many people, most people hope and assume they are this way. We all think we are super progressive and smart and just want “growth”. It’s a bit redundant to spell it out. So what? Big clap. You have a growth mindset. You want to embrace “regret”. How intellectual of you.
- t43562 4y agoIn my family we like arguing about things. Our way of doing so is quite animated and enthusiastic. We're trying to get our point heard of course but the real pleasure is perhaps that it is a fight in the sense of a water pistol fight or a game of rugby or something like that. It's mental exercise with excitement and humor. It doesn't suit everyone and might seem alarming. Also we sort of play the game with the underlying attitude that it is all unimportant and that we admire and like each other. The mind changing never happens then but sometimes it happens a few days later. I HATE changing my mind but usually after I have I'm glad I did it. It's very uncomfortable but to say that nothing can change what I think would be to admit that I wasn't thinking anymore. It would be awful to be like that.
- harel 4y agoI chime well with the gist of this post. However, I think there is no win or lose in a debate. There is the sharing of perspective. The terminology of win/lose is a symptom of Side-ism which I believe humanity suffers from. People feel like they need to be on a side of something, which leads to people who feel like they belong to the "other side" feel left out and ignored, and then the wheel turns and then the other side feels the same. Each side tells themselves the other side is stupid/evil/ignorant/etc. Instead they could have listened, compromised, come out of the assumption that neither side is wrong, and there should be a middle ground that works for all. But instead we're stuck with side-ism and an everlasting shift from one extreme to the other, while the majority in the middle get car sick from all that violent movements.
- log101 4y ago> They lend me their shoes and glasses, so I can walk a mile with their viewpoint and experience it for myself. I love this qoute and completely agree with it, it's always enlightening to "really" try to understand other people, without evaluating whether they're right or wrong. But the problem arises when you both start acting and your ideas clash. And you need to decide which is the "best" way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bluedino 4y agoThis is some Seth Godin, LinkedIn level stuff right here.
- pattisapu 4y agoVigorous debate is a good thing. It's about learning to turn it off afterwards. Debate at its best is where the issues are at stake -- not the relationship. Getting clear on that is an important communicative and emotional skill. The problem with "wanting to lose" in this post is how fake and sentimental that attitude can become, against our best intentions. If both sides can put their cards on the table, that's a more productive conversation, rather than one side shutting up and keeping theirs close to the vest. Confrontation is not an evil to be avoided. Hurting others is the harm to be avoided. Those are two very different things. Sometimes avoiding confrontation hurts oneself and others the very most. Furthermore, there is no logical reason why one should default to thinking that only others will bring value to the conversation, and that one's own experience and judgment are not as important to share. By sharing one's thoughts, the other side may hear, learn, or rethink something that could change their lives. To the extent that "wanting to lose" consciously or unconsciously results in one bringing less of a certain energy to a debate, that's an opportunity lost for everyone. Discernment and diplomacy are the valuable skills here. Again, rather than check out (whether smugly or earnestly), instead, let's make efforts to figure out when, where, why, and with whom to turn on the heat, -- and then turn it off. Sportsmanship among athletes and collegiality among lawyers are good examples of this in practice. "And do as adversaries do in law, Strive mightily, but eat and drink as friends." --Shakespeare, The Taming of the Shrew, Act I, sc. 2.
- the_af 4y ago> The problem with "wanting to lose" in this post is how fake and sentimental that attitude can become, against our best intentions. Yes. Plus it can seem condescending. I wouldn't want to debate anything with someone adopting some sort of "philosophical master" stance that "through losing" will achieve enlightening. I prefer the other person gets angry if need be, which at least is honest, rather than trying to play some Socratic bullshit on me. It comes across as "I'm better than you, let me show you that to lose is actually to win".
- pattisapu 4y agoGood point. People smell condescension, and then check out. The whole thing cools. They'll say just enough to get to the next topic gracefully. The dispute is patched up with something like "we'll agree to disagree" or something like that, in the interest of polite conversation, rather than square-on debate. In that scenario one does not receive the full force of an opponent's argument. It never got ventilated. An opponent only brings that energy to a debate between earnest people who see themselves -- not their arguments -- as equals.
- Kukumber 4y agoyou only loose if you refuse to debate OP got it wrong
- Giorgi 4y ago>The Muslim explains why Islamic law is a perfect recipe for peace. That would be so funny to listen to. Mental gymnastics would be trough roof.
- pessimizer 4y agoI feel the same way. I'm going to try to defend my position as well as I can (sans dishonesty and rhetorical tricks), but actually winning an argument means it was probably a waste of my time. My goal is to be right about everything, so I wish that in every argument I have I'm on the wrong side because when somebody who is right convinces me that I am wrong, I become smarter than I was before the argument. I think it's pretty common to feel indebted to people who convinced you that you were wrong. Really what happened is that they put in the work before you got into it with them, and aggressively shared the benefits with you. Losing an argument is like someone beating the crap out of you, strolling into your home and ransacking it until they find your debts, then paying them off against your will. I walk into every argument hoping to lose, and hoping I don't embarrass myself too badly on the way to that loss. The worst is when you figure out that you were confidently, smugly wrong. But if you laugh with your opponent about how cocky you were, it makes it all better. edit: it's only worth my time to win in an argument if I'm trying to help someone I care about, or if I'm trying to argue against behavior that affects me or someone I care about negatively. Not an abstract effect, like when you pretend your tweets are social work, but concretely, like with a coworker that you depend on, or a neighbor.
- foxbee 4y agoI try to aim for education with empathy.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoLoose every debate. When you are on your deathbed you won't be reviewing these debates. You'll be either reliving those great experiences you had, or regretting the experiences you didn't have. Key word: "Experiences" Words don't count for anything. They're just sounds we make....
- wesleywt 4y agoNot every opinion is worth your time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kitd 4y agoThis reminds of "Argue well by losing" [1]. The purpose of debate shouldn't be to win or lose, but to reach consensus. In addition, the ancients of the classical world regarded "Rhetoric" (ie the ability to debate) as being the highest form of intelligence. It required not only a deep understanding of the reasoning behind your own opinion but also an equally deep understanding of that of your collocutors. Ie, you should be able to argue in favour of his/her point as well as your own, and as well as he/she can. That takes wisdom and humility that most today seem to lack. [1] - https://haacked.com/archive/2013/10/21/argue-well-by-losing.aspx/ https://haacked.com/archive/2013/10/21/argue-well-by-losing....
- semireg 4y agoThis TED talk “on being wrong” has stuck with me over the years. https://www.ted.com/talks/kathryn_schulz_on_being_wrong https://www.ted.com/talks/kathryn_schulz_on_being_wrong Especially the part about the coyote in loony tunes running off the edge and not falling until they realize they are wrong. That’s what feeling right feels like… until you realize you’re wrong.
- bsuvc 4y agoOP assumes everyone debating him is doing so in good faith. These "learnings" he is taking to heart could very well be built on lies and ill intentions of those he is debating. Sure, it is good to be open to new information, but it's not wrong to develop a worldview based on your own objective observations, experience, and research, that is firm and not open to sway by agenda-holding groups and individuals who seek to "enlighten you".
- Malky 4y ago> don’t debate at all, just listen. Just loved this.
- baryphonic 4y agoHow peculiar that every "debate" this person has lost is in the same ideological direction. How would this person respond to: - the Christian explaining that the resurrection of Jesus is a historical fact? - the prosecutor describing the heinous crimes of the people she's put behind bars? - the sibling of an addict denouncing opiates & opioids, meth, crack and the drug trade? Where's the limit for this person when encountering: - the pederast who describes his perversion as "love?" - the practitioner of FGM who praises it as a "tradition?" - the religious fanatic who believes God has told him to kill? I hope the person would be at least open to the first set of people, and would be willing to "win" against the second set. Overall, I think the framing is a bit wrong. Having an open mind doesn't mean you have to stick your finger in the wind, and having firmly held beliefs without experience, knowledge or wisdom doesn't mean you need to preach them vociferously. Certain things are true, and certain perspectives are not so valuable.
- fleddr 4y agoAgree, in the same ideological direction and all of them inconsequential. It's very easy to have an "open mind" when no stakes are involved.
- ben30 4y agoIm reminded of the book “Getting to yes” by Roger Fisher. “ In any negotiation, he wrote—even with terrorists—it was vital to separate the people from the problem; to focus on the underlying interests of both sides, rather than stake out unwavering positions; and to explore all possible options before making a decision.” https://www.economist.com/obituary/2012/09/15/roger-fisher https://www.economist.com/obituary/2012/09/15/roger-fisher
- mythrwy 4y agoThere's a time and a place for vigorous debate in support of your position, and a time and a place for listening non-judgmentally with an open mind. Most things don't matter all that much and aren't worth fighting about. Some things are. Some people just like to fight at every opportunity, and others are too cowardly to fight when they should.
- curiousllama 4y agoI used to think this too, but found it was mostly a manifestation of my intellectual cowardice, not a coherent position itself. An open-minded willingness to change one’s mind is admirable. But if you change your mind too often, you end up thinking less yourself - you’re outsourcing learning. It should get incrementally more difficult to change your mind the more you learn. Otherwise, you’re just collecting facts, not actually understanding anything. Besides, you don’t really hope you’re wrong, and it’s a bit arrogant to say so. Have you ascended above these petty emotions of the flesh? Being wrong is A Bad Thing, and “I believe I’m wrong” is an oxymoron. I think a better approach is “I’m always willing to change my mind, and hope I never have to.” I’m often wrong, about things of which I’m unaware, and I always pursue the opportunity to be less wrong. But it’s a worse title.
- JohnFen 4y agoBut discovering that you're wrong is a great thing. It means you've become just a little bit less ignorant -- and we're all ignorant of more things than not.
- JohnFen 4y agoThis is a special case of one of my life mottos: I've never learned anything by being right.
- qwertox 4y agoI don't get it. There are many sex workers which are forced to do this job, some even under threat. I also don't see an issue using analogies to explain things. Was the Hindu person poor itself? If so, how has this person dealt with sickness in the family? Any religion is a perfect recipe for peace, it just depends on the fairness and good will of those practicing it. Why should partying not be a good thing as long as it is done in a good balance, and why would an ugly tattoo require an explanation, unless a good story can be told about it? What does any of the above have to do with stupidity? I certainly wouldn't want to lose a debate about why murdering someone can be considered a good thing. I just don't understand the spirit in which that article has been written. But then again, "TED speaker" kind of explains it a bit.
- aeturnum 4y agoThis does have enormous TED energy. I think the idea is to quickly touch on profiles of people whose world views (apparently?) contradict the authors and then to promote the idea of listening, with an open heart, to people who you believe at the outset are misguided. I think this is because it's common for us to find powerful new insights into how people see the world or feel about things when temporarily we set aside our judgements and understand the internal logic of people we disagree with? That people make more sense once you see things with their eyes, and then also the world makes more sense because those people want things in the world too? I dunno, it's pretty fluffy.
- BeetleB 4y ago> I certainly wouldn't want to lose a debate about why murdering someone can be considered a good thing. Serious question: What is the benefit of winning this debate?
- dgfitz 4y agoI sure wouldn’t be upset if someone murdered Putin, ideally 11 months ago.
- qwertox 4y agoIt would be someone presenting me this argument, like one can assume other people were presenting the author their arguments "pro sex work" which the author apparently never considered. Someone presenting me an argument that "murdering someone can be considered a good thing" and them wanting me to lose this argument is something which I would not want to happen. I think the issue in that sentence was the double negative in addition to the lack of definition of who is proposing that argument. But assuming you did not get confused: I would prefer to live in a society where it's considered a good thing to not murder others and if this were up for debate, I sure hope I would not get convinced of the opposite, which would mean "losing the debate" in the way the author means it.
- Existenceblinks 4y agoIn english this seems to be called "debate bro culture"? In my language it's called like "debate horny". The gist of this thing is oppose to loseless context, so there's always part of context that is lost. Debate is close to talking in analogy. It will leads you to something but not the thing as a whole.
- rocknor 4y ago> The Hindu explains why poverty doesn’t upset her. So according to the author me and my community are not upset by poverty and hence are not doing anything to fix it. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/india-lifted-415-million-out-of-poverty-in-15-years-says-un/articleshow/94926338.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/india-lifted... https://gdc.unicef.org/resource/report-india-lifted-271-million-people-out-poverty-decade https://gdc.unicef.org/resource/report-india-lifted-271-mill... Who is this author again and why are people listening to a charlatan like him?
- russelldjimmy 4y agoIt seems to me that the author spoke about one particular Hindu they met who was not upset by their state of poverty. It’s not clear to me that they claimed that your community is not upset by it, and is not doing anything to fix it. Help me with clarity.
- manquer 4y agoIf it has nothing do with her being hindu or beliefs generated from religion then why is that fact she is hindu relevant ?. It is like saying a short or bald person came to me and said poverty doesn't bother them. If I was short or bald then I am going to be offended by that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 4y ago> her I think you're extrapolating. Author is very clearly just talking about an individual, not a group. No need to get outraged.
- manquer 4y agoBut he is, he characterized that person as a Hindu,he didn't say a friend or a neighbour or whatever else he could have described her by. The implication in labelling her hindu is that this a common or known position amongst Hindus?.
- owenfi 4y agoA corollary that helped me take criticism less personally: a friend once said “I ONLY like negative feedback”. They went on to explain that positive feedback/compliments weren’t helpful to them because they couldn’t grow from it. The starkness of the statement was what I needed to recognize it.
- diffxx 4y agoInteresting perspective. This requires a level of inner strength that many of us do not always have. Increasingly though I realize that I don't need a lot of verbal feedback. You can tell a lot just by people's physical reactions to you. And the corollary is that I notice that there are some people that I try and shut down with body language to get them to leave me alone.
- canada2us 4y agoNow here is a new problem: The other side wins. The examples are that there are no consequences of the debate, which is great. But in reality, there are consequences (some of them are negative) if you lose the debate, e.g., job interview.
- JAlexoid 4y agoI have read multiple times, that debates cannot be won or lost. People don't change their minds as a result of debates, thus it's impossible to win or lose a debate. What the author talks about isn't a debate, but rather learning.
- Octokiddie 4y ago> ... I don’t want to convince anyone of my existing perspective. I would rather be convinced of theirs. It’s more interesting to assume that they are right. There's no need to assume anything. Ask good questions instead. It might not seem like it, but asking questions is one of the most important skills there is. This skill is not taught in K-12. If anything, you're taught to assume that what you read/see is right. In many degree programs, you also won't be taught how to ask questions but rather repeat what you've read or heard, with some level of analysis. The difference between good questions and bad questions often comes down to leading. The subtext of a leading question is that the asker is trying to push the askee in a particular direction. Those question tend to yield bad answers of the kind that won't convince you of much. Better questions are interrogative-led. They start with words like "who", "where", "what" and "why", not words like "do" or "are". It takes practice to ask these kinds of questions and the follow-ups that are needed to actually be convinced by someone else's argument.
- mikotodomo 4y agoThe way I always lose debates on social media is when a pedophile (or pedophile defender) argues with me. They have an answer for everything. I don't have that much time to be on screen to argue with them.
- lazyeye 4y agoI think the completely radical idea being rediscovered here is called humility.
- pictur 4y agoYou can't understand people with empty arguments. on the contrary, you get prejudices or wrong impressions about them. I think it makes more sense to listen to people to understand. If you want to understand.
- AlbertCory 4y agoGreat analysis. I'd extend it to "interview." I had a chance to do some interviews on a podcast (for a change, I'll dispense with the shameless self-promotion and not link to it), and I had a chance to practice this. I tried to remember, "the listener is not here to listen to ME; they're here to listen to the interviewee." Also sometimes watching the old Dick Cavett show on OTA. It's a miracle that they ever let a guy like him on television. He actually talked to his guests, rather than reading off some cue cards his producers gave him.
- zh3 4y agoThis reminds me Bertrand Russells's "The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt". Though in my experience a lot of very intelligent people are pretty cocksure [0] and could do with a dose of humility. [0] Ref. the word 'cocksure', not that HN will ban me, but twitter might - cf. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-norfolk-64451977 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-norfolk-64451977
- fedeb95 4y agoSadly sometimes our desires aren't met
- saeranv 4y agoBut what about the person who argues that you should want to win every debate!?!?
- collyw 4y agoGet yourself over to reddit, the best debaters ion the world. Appeal to authority almost every time.
- zestyping 4y agoWhen your goal is simply to learn, then you can listen instead of debating. Sometimes the outcome matters, though. Sometimes there is justice, well-being, or kindness at stake.
- Connor_Creegan 4y agoObviously not every convo needs to be a duh-bate. but "works for me/them" is a pretty low bar for veracity or moral permissibility.
- branko_d 4y agoThere are three kinds of debate: - Debate where the goal is to learn. - Debate where the goal is to persuade your opponent. - Debate where the goal is to persuade the audience. The first is good for your soul, the second for you ego and the third for your political career.