11 ms·
Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media
- uptownfunk 4y agoGrowing up in early 90s we had a computer lab where we would go as part of kindergarten and first grade to play logo draw and Oregon trail. That feels way different to the type of tech exposure kids are getting these days with social media. There is something fundamentally different about making things “social” than just doing something harmless offline, like playing a game with the family, writing a story, using MS paint, math blaster. When things became social, it’s like we were all given sledgehammers and told to go smash the candy store and raid it for whatever we wanted. Maybe I’m being nostalgic for the early / mid 90s when we didn’t have these devices glued to us and little red notification icons hijacking our dopaminergic circuitry.
- reeckoh 4y ago+1 to offline computer labs. Our primary school had one in the '90s, but they only let us in for an hour or two each week. The teachers didn't know how to use the computers, and the parents mostly felt that it was a waste of time which would rot our child brains. Still, the school had paid a bunch of money for it as part of an initiative to get rid of the library's card catalog system, so it had to be used. The teachers tried to convince everyone to play math and typing games, but most kids played with a sort of photoshop-lite program, stuck magnets onto the CRT screens, or played Oregon Trail. It wasn't an efficient process, but just about everybody in our district was a proficient typist by middle school. When I got to college, I was surprised by how many people typed on their laptops like they type on their phones, with rapid index finger pecks.
- MattDemers 4y agoWe figured out pretty quick how to use Windows' internal network messenger, and that was pretty cool (in terms of being able to chat with peers without the teachers knowing). It still blows my mind that kids are using Chromebooks and Ipads daily on an elementary level.
- Aeolun 4y ago> It still blows my mind that kids are using Chromebooks and Ipads daily on an elementary level. I saw this recently on an equipment list for first graders. “One iPad and Macbook with specifications in line required by the school”. Wtf is my first grader going to do with an iPad other than watch Youtube?
- the_only_law 4y ago> , I was surprised by how many people typed on their laptops like they type on their phones, with rapid index finger pecks. What kind of people do you hang around. I don’t know anyone who commonly uses their index fingers to type on their phone. It’s mostly thumbs.
- reeckoh 4y agoGood question - I'm even typing this with thumbs now! Thinking back, it was during a time when most phones were small enough to fit comfortably in one small hand. People would hold it with one hand, and use the other to tap. Modern phones are too heavy and bulky for that, so I think we use both hands to hold and use them. Or maybe the finger-pecking was unrelated to phone use, who knows.
- gsatic 4y agoFundamental difference is there is click/like/upvote/view/follower count next to everything. These counts never existed on the old Internet. Kids were never getting judged with the whole planet scoring their thoughts like today. And people werent programmed to think collecting Likes and Followers is the point of the whole story.
- amadeuspagel 4y agoThankfully, there's still 4chan. At least one place to talk without a click/like/upvote/view/follower count.
- noobermin 4y agoAnd probably the worst place for a child to go.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Fundamental difference is there is click/like/upvote/view/follower count next to everything. These counts never existed on the old Internet. Public view counts on individual pages were extremely common on the “old internet”, if by that you mean the WWW pre the rise of the terms “social media” and “social network”.
- api 4y agoThe problem with social media isn’t the social part. It’s the media part. Media comes from the root of mediate. Social media is a huge system sitting between people and mediating their communication. The main goal function for most of it is to maximize engagement, which means amplifying and prioritizing the most toxic interactions. It’s like having someone sitting between you and your friends steering the conversation toward whatever is the most negative, hateful, or ridiculous.
- unglaublich 4y agoGrowing up in 00s, we had internet porn, scams and gambling _everywhere_... still we turned out fine.
- jgavris 4y agoOh how I miss the computer labs with Kidpix, Oregon trail, Mavis Beacon, and maybe later Marathon LAN parties (when the instructor left the room for an hour)...
- baremetal 4y agoIn middle school we had quake 1 too. But only during recess or before school.
- girvo 4y ago> math blaster https://www-old--games-ru.translate.goog/game/11519.html?_x_tr_sl=ru&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=sc https://www-old--games-ru.translate.goog/game/11519.html?_x_... This is the game that taught me maths when I was 4-5 years old, and part of why I was excellent at maths for the rest of my schooling. Gosh it was fun! That plus exploring Encarta 95 for hours on end. But I also sunk a lot of time into SimCity 2000 and MechWarrior 2, to be fair.
- bigger_cheese 4y agoI grew up in the mid to late 90's, so probably about 5 years later than you. My first real exposure to the internet was through my year 7 English class. My English teacher was I guess you'd call an early adopter he was one of those people convinced technology was going to be revolutionary he somehow signed our class up to be a part of an email pen pal program with a school in Japan. One lesson a week we would go to the school library (where there was a computer with dial up internet) we would tell the teacher what we wanted to say and he would type 2 or 3 sentences from each student in our class and then send it using a program called "Eudora" (pretty sure we were using the teacher's personal address) and maybe a week later the teacher would show up to class with a stack of printouts. He would hand each of us the printout from our respective pen pal full of broken English. We did this for maybe a semester. That was my first exposure to online "social" use of computers. A few years Later people started to get internet at home ICQ (a chat program became pretty popular) this was around the time of Napster so there was a lot of downloading songs sharing them with people on ICQ etc. A little after that Online gaming was starting to be possible, I remember playing Quake, Starcraft and Diablo 2 with my friends online. I think around year 11/12 Counterstrike came out, it was a mod for the game Half Life and was very popular. The latency was normally pretty bad but it slowly got better. In the early days bandwidth was so limited it really restricted what kinds of social activities you could do on line.
- vfclists 4y ago[flagged]
- rightbyte 4y agoI don't get your angle here. I guess that the biggest share of produced anti-worm meds is used on animals? What was he trying to say.
- vfclists 4y agohttps://edition.cnn.com/videos/health/2021/08/22/ivermectin-mississippi-poison-control-calls-surgeon-general-murthy-reaction-keilar-sotu-vpx.cnn https://edition.cnn.com/videos/health/2021/08/22/ivermectin-...
- bigbillheck 4y agoThat clip doesn't want to play for me, but ivermectin's great if you or your pets (or livestock, I guess) have nematode trouble. Doesn't do a whole lot for the famous virus tho.
- vfclists 4y agoNope. The Surgeon General should have corrected her by saying that Ivermectin was a drug approved for human use but he went along with the horse dewormer bullshit. I guess you could say all the Africans who used Ivermectin were consumers of horse-dewormer. The issue is his integrity and honesty as a state medical official. If he can't be relied upon to speak the truth in one area, how can he in another?
- gus_massa 4y agoIt depends on the country you live. In some countries it's used (almost) only for animals, because the health conditions of humans is so good that you don't need dewormers. In other countries there are national plans to give most of the population dewormers because it's an endemic problem. Many of the papers claiming that ivermectin was good against covid-19 were produced by hospitals running these national programs. You are already giving ivermectin to a lot of people, so you it's almost free to count the deads in the people getting ivermectin and compare it to the death of the general population. (In my opinion they use bad statistics to get the results, there are a lot of bias that they can't fix. Double blind randomized controlled trial or it didn't happen.)
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoIncidentally 31 may also still be too young.
- coding123 4y ago43 soon, and I still don't think it's a good idea.
- cmsonger 4y agoIn my case "50s is 'too early to join social media'". So right there with you. :) (Though to be honest, joined back in the 00's then left in the early 2010s.)
- LarryMullins 4y agoWhat's the best age to get addicted to heroin?
- rpmw 4y agoHe also claimed that water is indeed wet.
- zahma 4y agoNot only wet but soaked with forever chemicals and hormones. Where to begin to save the children?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 4y agoAre parents going to deny their kids access to social media? Among the parents I know, none of them do this even if they admit it's probably bad for their kids. The social pressure from the kids' peers is the number one reason they give: their kids will be left out, and social alienation is viewed as worse than social media. Perhaps a coordinated effort would make a difference, I don't know. I'm skeptical. Despite saying lawmakers are "paying attention", there's no talk of regulation in this article, so presumably a voluntary effort on the part of parents is the only actionable plan they are ready to discuss. As the article notes, social products are not de facto designed to keep kids out, and have not done a good job of it so far, so I am also skeptical they will improve in the future without any legal pressure.
- irrational 4y agoI think so. We don’t buy our kids smartphones. We tell them that they can have one when they can buy it themselves. That tends to happen around 16-17. At home we block social media at the router level. They have Chromebooks from school, but social media is blocked on those by the school district. We’ve never had any of the kids complain about social alienation.
- yumraj 4y agoDitto. My old got cellphone in 9th grade, and all usual ones are blocked via pihole at home. Now in 12th, he does use Discord to communicate with a limited set of friends. But that’s it. I’ve said it before, the difference is that we don’t use any of the social media ourselves, so kids are OK. If parents use them but ask kids to refrain, obviously it’s not going to work.
- dmitryminkovsky 4y ago> Ditto. My old got cellphone in 9th grade, and all usual ones are blocked via pihole at home. Can’t they get around this by turning off Wi-Fi?
- 4y ago
- amadeuspagel 4y ago> the skewed and often distorted environment of social media Where is the unskewed and undistorted social environment that is implicit here?
- klyrs 4y agoTalking to peers in the cafeteria or playground is not subject to a corporation boosting attention to the kids that it finds most profitable. More generally, taking your "no true scotsman" approach to kids safety would suggest that it's fine to let kids play in a lead-dust sandpit because you can't eliminate 100% of environmental lead.
- Tade0 4y agoGone with the advent of the internet. We're just still getting used to this new reality after over 20 years.
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago[flagged]
- Tade0 4y ago> “If parents can band together and say you know, as a group, we’re not going to allow our kids to use social media until 16 or 17 or 18 or whatever age they choose, that’s a much more effective strategy in making sure your kids don’t get exposed to harm early," I'm surprised by this statement considering he's a parent. You can't really prevent a teenager from doing something if they set their mind on it. All we can really do is educate. My take is that every social media outlet starts a death spiral once its first generation of users starts being parents of teenagers.
- layer8 4y ago> You can't really prevent a teenager from doing something if they set their mind on it. All we can really do is educate. So also give them access to tobacco and booze?
- m4tthumphrey 4y agoMore like educate them about the issues of tobacco and booze.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>So also give them access to tobacco and booze? Depends where you live, but in some EU countries, teens start drinking and smoking and already give up on cigs and beer before American teens even start. It's pretty common to see 14 year olds smoking and drinking beer outside in public despite these being officially allowed when you're 18. Teens will always try to do what adults tell them is forbidden and bad for them, because doing forbidden things is enticing and makes you look cool and rebellious.
- stackbutterflow 4y agoYour first sentence contradicts your last. I think every year that a teenager doesn't start drinking alcohol is a net benefit. They black out at college parties at 20 so what? By that time their brain is more developed. I think Europeans have a very unhealthy attitude towards alcohol and their kids pay the price of it. And they do not give up alcohol at all. On the contrary, they don't know how to party without alcohol for the rest of their life.
- ergonaught 4y agoWe occasionally "grounded" our teenaged daughters from their devices for various reasons. This primarily cut them off from social media. After a week away from it, even they acknowledged how much healthier and happier they were (mentally/emotionally). A few days after device usage resumed, those things tanked. We pointed it out a few times. They saw it, too, even brought it up themselves. But of course they continued using the stuff. It reminds me of the vast hordes of young people vaping who wouldn't be caught dead hitting a cigarette, apparently aware that this is idiotic but doing it anyway. It's fun times to be a human.
- lordnacho 4y agoSocial media is basically internet era alcohol. Except alcohol has been around for a heck of a long time and the internet has been a culturally important thing for maybe a quarter century. Just like in previous times when we discovered alcohol, various cultures also found ways over time to deal with the fallout. Some cultures don't do so well with it. The same happened with various other chemicals like opium, tobacco, and crack, which all have had societal reactions over time. The contraceptive pill is another one, and I'd argue so are processed foods.
- Tempest1981 4y agoBut more insidious
- lordnacho 4y agoI'd say the fact that the internet is clearly useful in certain ways is a thing that allows some of the downsides to travel along. With something like recreational drugs, the upsides are just pure hedonism, you do them because they make you feel a certain way and the downsides aren't inextricably connected. Plus the downsides are pretty awful, whereas with internet stuff it's awful but in a way that doesn't require an ambulance. Basically social media addiction is a flu that millions of people catch and mostly live with, whereas drug addiction is a thing fewer people catch but some of them die from it, like Ebola.
- 4y ago
- LatteLazy 4y agoBe careful my friends: it would be terrible for us embrace medical advice that agrees with our prejudices but ignore similar advice on subjects we don't like like sex ed and sleep and stress and bullying...
- klabb3 4y agoWe need more granular language to talk about these issues. Anyone with moderate proficiency in online communities know that there are major differences between eg instagram and a private discord chat to play Minecraft with your friends. Perhaps we should look at online media as games, with different rules and incentives, and find out which rules are good for us and which ones aren’t. Public people oriented social media (instagram & Twitter being canonical examples) clearly stand out to me as the most problematic. Worse, the content promotion algorithms are opaque and not customizable, which makes it very difficult to research their influence. Upstream, >99% of these companies’ revenue come from advertisers, it’s likely that they constitute the largest stakeholder in our children’s online experiences (and our own, of course).
- thomastjeffery 4y agoI agree that looking at "social media" in the context of game theory would be incredibly useful. Talking about "social media" as if it is one cohesive thing is lazy and unhelpful. The same goes for "teenagers".
- bdw5204 4y agoI think the "you must claim to be at least 13 to be able to participate in an online discussion site" law makes sense as it functions as an IQ test of sorts to keep under-13s who are not ready to be on the internet off the internet. But I'm not in favor of increasing the age as I think its reasonable for teens to be able to openly admit that they're teens. The problem with most of the social media platforms is their hostility to anonymity. A teen with a Twitter account or a Reddit account should absolutely be an anon so that their posts while they're still figuring life out aren't tied to their real name and it would be good if social media companies and search engines would help people destroy the evidence of any embarrassing stuff they posted under their real identity as a teen for the same reason that we as a society typically expunge the criminal records of teenagers who commit crimes. But social media companies have been making it harder and harder to be anonymous. For example, Twitter started locking new accounts and forcing them to provide a phone number a few years ago ostensibly as an "anti-bot" measure. This is actively harmful and should be discontinued. Likewise, Google needs to allow users who wish to remain anonymous to turn off all of their account security measures other than a password. Security measures such as tying accounts to phones are helpful for adults who have their identity and their finances tied to these accounts but it makes these services unsafe for minors as it allows the platform to know the identities of their underage users which is a possible security risk. Minors should also be educated in terms of basic measures to protect their anonymous accounts from deanonymization attacks and on the dangers of meeting their "internet friends" in real life. All of this used to be standard advice for "heavily online" youth in the 90s and 00s. I don't see any reason why it shouldn't be in the 20s other than the preference of some social media outlets that users use their real identity for ad targeting purposes and the insistence of certain powerful people who can't handle criticism that anonymity is bad because they get criticized by anons who otherwise wouldn't feel safe challenging them (i.e. online anonymity is also good because it allows adults who'd otherwise feel unsafe speaking truth to power to feel safe enough to do so).
- BlueTemplar 4y agoSeems like Twitch has been pushing lately for some channels to only allow chat if the typist gives Twitch their phone number ? Thankfully, there's still 4chan ! (/s ... or is it ?)
- olliej 4y agoBased on my dad 60ish is also not a good age
- thenerdhead 4y agoIsn't the surgeon general in a position where they can amplify the best scientific information on social media / technology addiction and help parents / kids understand the risk of engaging? Perhaps that type of voice could help create the next D.A.R.E. program, but for this issue given the efficacy of prevention programs.
- superfrank 4y agoI hear what you're saying and agree, but D.A.R.E. probably isn't the best example since a lot of studies have found that it was ineffective in preventing drug use. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1448384/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1448384/
- thenerdhead 4y agoSure that's fair. I don't know the modern equivalent. I guess it is called "Keepin' it REAL". Which is what I was thinking in terms of efficacy from previous literature by the surgeon general. https://cdc.thehcn.net/promisepractice/index/view?pid=4186 https://cdc.thehcn.net/promisepractice/index/view?pid=4186 https://real-prevention.com/keepin-it-real/ https://real-prevention.com/keepin-it-real/ I mostly found this guidance in here: https://addiction.surgeongeneral.gov/sites/default/files/surgeon-generals-report.pdf https://addiction.surgeongeneral.gov/sites/default/files/sur... > Well-supported scientific evidence demonstrates that a variety of prevention programs and alcohol policies that address these predictors prevent substance initiation, harmful use, and substance use related problems, and many have been found to be cost-effective. These programs and policies are effective at different stages of the lifespan, from infancy to adulthood, suggesting that it is never too early and never too late to prevent substance misuse and related problems
- ergocoder 4y agoThe last surgeon general also said masks didn't reduce covid spread. He reversed his words a month later. Prop to him for reversing his words. But still. Maybe we should wait until more research is out.
- rdl 4y agoI don't have children, but I think if I did, I'd ease them into social media by paying them run a social media profile for a cat -- from the perspective of the cat, with no humans or PII visible, solely the cat. This would accomplish a few goals: familiarity with the tools, exposure to the annoyances of the process in a relatively safe environment, and probably dislike of the whole thing due to it being "a job" before it's a hobby or personal interest.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- joshuaheard 4y agoAn as empty-nester who gave their child a phone at 10 years old, I would say make the minimum age for social media 16, just like driving. We gave our child a phone to give her a competitive technology edge and to keep track of her movements for safety. However, social media is like crack cocaine for kids. We found out when we would take her phone away as punishment, and she became a monster. She constantly had FOMO. It's also nearly impossible to limit their screen time while in the possession of the phone. There should definitely be some sort of age restriction, whatever it is.
- IshKebab 4y agoHave you tried that with adults though?
- watwut 4y agoTo be fair, adults are isolating themselves. Loneliness epidemic and all, adults dont have all that many relationships that would matter to them that exist outside of institutions they are in - work. Adults dont use social media to keep communication with friends - they dont have friends. Adults use social medias as newspaper.
- mixmastamyk 4y ago> It's also nearly impossible to limit their screen time while in the possession of the phone Was this a few years ago before Screen Time on iOS? Or was Android? We have a very locked down ipod touch and it works well most of the time.
- gardenhedge 4y agoThe same thing happens when you take a playstation away from a gamer kid
- robryan 4y agoMaybe you can restrict social media in terms of connecting to everyone, but I don't think you can or should stop 13 year olds from being able to talk to their friends with the various group messangers.
- charlieyu1 4y agoMy generation grew up with everyone having ICQ accounts at 12-13.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoUh oh! I had ICQ but it was at a time I didn't know a single other "normal" person on the internet besides colleagues at aerospace jobs. Late 90s? Probably folks at universities too. Significant number of pre-teens? Unlikely. Also ICQ didn't use dark addictive patterns to my memory, it was just fun.
- granshaw 4y ago11 here
- anthonyskipper 4y agoSame could be said about religion. Probably more true in that case.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoEvery part of this recommendation is too broad. "teenagers aged 13 to 16-18" is way too broad a category. What developmental characteristics are shared among that entire group? Which of those characteristics make an individual "too vulnerable" to benefit "safely" from "social media"? Are those traits really unique to children, and not adults? Is the use of "social media" itself entirely separate from learning how to "safely" interact with "social media" later? The same goes for "social media" itself. Are we talking about public forums, direct messaging, group chats, content creation, media consumption, or something else? What moderation techniques and goals are involved? What subjects do the spaces in question focus on? If we can't get specific here, our only choice is to ban everything from 4chan, to Tinder, to Snapchat, to SMS, to IRC, to landlines, to physical letters, all the way down to chatting unsupervised in a public park! And what is the "risk" posed? That a child will feel disproportionately leveraged judgement from their peers, and fall into depression? That a child will view traumatic content and get PTSD? That a child will start an unhealthy or dangerous relationship with an adult? That a child will build political or religious beliefs that contradict their parents' ideology? That a child will build an addictive relationship to the media itself, and avoid healthier activity? That a child will learn how to use technical computing skills to circumvent parental, school, or government censorship? Every one of these concerns is considered valid by a significant group of adults, and considered invalid by another. We all know that leaving people alone to leverage something as powerful as computer networks is dangerous. That leverage goes both ways, and the metaphorical fulcrum is most often positioned nearest to the individual user, and farthest from the network itself. Even though this subject is vitality important, we must recognize that the only way to interact with it at all is through context. The more context we have, the more control we have over the leverage that these tools provide, and the better equipped we become to maximize safety and utility.
- bjt2n3904 4y agoI fully agree. But should the surgeon general also make comments about how code reviews need to be empathetic? I mean. If the surgeon general is gonna make statements about what is "healthy" for other social issues, where does he stop?
- slavboj 4y agoGiven how the office of the surgeon general has been so obviously politicized and their recommendations based on political considerations, I am reluctant to take their advice in and of itself as evidence of anything health related. It's likelier based on the administration's desire to put pressure on their political opponents at social media companies than any actual health considerations.
- LanceH 4y agoI read this as an excuse to take further control of the internet and ignore the 1st amendment.
- xlii 4y agoThis is something that’s on my mind lately. My kids nag me constantly for Facebook/WhatsApp/TikTok etc. Main argument is that peers are using those media and they feel excluded. The thing is that all parties involved is way below required 13yo. I do have arguments which are heard but it is not like reality stops being it especially when there is no alternative outside of school-owned Teams account that has most social activities disabled. It feels like there’s no win in this fight, except for maybe suing FB for not checking carefully enough and allowing young minors to use their platform.
- wslh 4y agoPhysical activity, physical activity, and physical activity. It does not need to be a sport.
- charcircuit 4y agoAt that point why don't we ban teenagers from having friends in general? Just lock them in a room alone with no other human contact. If connecting with people via the internet is not allowed neither should connecting with people via any other medium.
- hestefisk 4y agoAny tips from parents of pre teens / teenagers on how to manage this? My son is turning 11 soon and his peers already have their own mobile phones, YouTube accounts etc. I want to protect him and only have this when he is old enough. I expect the next few years to be challenging times :(
- cloudking 4y agoYou can give them phones without giving them full permissions to any app/website. Apple and Google have pretty good parental controls, where you can decide which apps/websites are allowed, screen time for specific apps etc.
- hestefisk 4y agoI know, but peer pressure I expect will persist. My youngest son is already frustrated he can’t watch YouTube because all his friends can, and he’s 7. I guess it’s more about tips on how to talk to them about it.
- rsyring 4y agoWe simply said "no" to social media and also led by example by not using social media[1]. Also talked about social media perils occasionally and shared articles from HN regarding. 1: I don't consider HN social media for the purpose of this discussion. I do use Facebook very occasionally for marketplace and groups that only exist in FB (utility only).
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoGive him an absolutely crap phone (maybe like a Light Phone II). If he wants a better one he can get a job and buy it himself, which will take some amount of time and at minimum he'll learn something.
- ck2 4y agoGood luck with that even if true. All you parents posting here how your kids are regulated, ha no there is always a friend with a workaround, you have no idea what they are doing elsewhere. I remember when small cellphone came out (not smartphones, original cellphones) and wealthier parents started giving them to kids, people were freaking out how inappropriate. Then smartphones for kids. I cannot even fathom what kids are exposed to these days before they are even in high school.
- pbj1968 4y agoSurgeon Generals tend to be kind of nuts.
- diordiderot 4y agoSurgeons General* Edit: Was that the joke?
- LoganDark 4y agoHonestly, yes. I grew up using the Internet from about the age of 5... but that was back then. This is now, where apps like Snapchat and TikTok exist. The internet is no longer safe to explore in that way.