15 ms·
Americans duped into losing $10B by illegal Indian call centres in 2022: report
- qwertyuiop_ 4y ago“It may not be a national security concern yet, but the reputation (of a country) is involved, and we don’t want India to suffer on that count,” Daud told the publication. What about the victims?
- woodruffw 4y agoIt's an Indian news site. The framing makes sense for a domestic (and expat) audience.
- prottog 4y agoTo be fair, the person who made that statement is the FBI's legal attaché in New Delhi. One would expect a person in such a position to say something like that, to smooth relations with the host country. But yes, I hope the perpetrators are brought to justice and the victims receive some kind of recompense.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> To be fair, the person who made that statement is the FBI's legal attaché in New Delhi. One would expect a person in such a position to say something like that, to smooth relations with the host country. “It may not be a national security concern yet,” is actually a fairly ominous statement from an FBI official of any kind.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> It may not be a national security concern yet This translate to "we even conceive going into war because of this". > but the reputation (of a country) is involved And this translated to "and economic sanctions are very likely". So, don't think this is a bland statement.
- linhns 4y ago[flagged]
- autotune 4y agoIt's never an "Indian number," it always appears to originate locally or in the US. Either way, I just use good hygiene and ignore all outside calls unless on contact list. The only people who ever need to call me are family and PagerDuty.
- woodruffw 4y agoMy understanding is that most of these scams use spoofed numbers (or legitimate forwarding numbers), so there's no "just ignore it" remediation. SHAKEN/STIR[1] is meant to address this kind of spoofing, but it's not a stretch to imagine that these kinds of scams mostly target older people who are less likely to have (or understand) Caller ID anyways. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STIR/SHAKEN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STIR/SHAKEN
- ipython 4y agoShaken/stir isn’t a panacea however: https://transnexus.com/blog/2022/shaken-statistics-november/ https://transnexus.com/blog/2022/shaken-statistics-november/
- bilalnpe 4y agoYeah, they spoof local numbers. I haven't lived in the city my area code is from in a long time. Occasionally I'll answer calls from there when I'm bored and it's always a scammer. What's even more disturbing is that I'm now getting calls from people talking in Hindi. I answer in English but they ask me to switch to Hindi. (I'm from Pakistan and speak Urdu which is mutually intelligible with Hindi). I'm guessing it's to build familiarity/trust. They want to pay off my phone, electric and other bills and in return I pay them 50% of the amount. I give them fake info and try to keep them on as long as possible... asking them to repeat multiple times. Sometimes I'll tell how thankful I am that they came to me with this 50% off offer because I'm facing financial troubles. Not once did any of them fell bad about trying to scam a poor person. Their response is usually something like "This is exactly why we are offering this service, to help people like you". Eventually they get frustrated and hangup. This way I can hurt their ROI just a bit.
- mwint 4y ago[flagged]
- _Algernon_ 4y agoI know you're joking, but you might not want to try that with a nuclear power.
- balls187 4y agoTo temper the potential for anti-indian rhetoric, US authorities work side by side with local Indian authorities to shut these down. Mark Rober has a few videos dedicated to going after several of these scam call centers, and most recently 3 major ones were shut down and their owners arrested.
- typingmonkey 4y agoMark Rober also gets support from the LA police while they do not care about normal peoples theft.
- balls187 4y agoResource constraints are a problem across all industries. My recollection wrt Rober was the police aided him to help drive awareness. For the “normal peoples theft” what would you like to police to do?
- jen20 4y ago> For the “normal peoples theft” what would you like to police to do? - show up when called. - if they’re not going to show up, AT LEAST call back. - make at least a token effort to apprehend someone of whom there is a clear video. This does not seem to be outlandish expectations of the service provided by the largest line in city budget.
- balls187 4y agoMy guess is there are so many instances of “normal people theft” occurring that even calling back is a significant scale issue. Basically, our criminal justice system is not built to handle minor crimes, and criminal organizations are exploiting that at scale.
- sneak 4y agoSomehow they still manage to write people a lot of tickets, something that generates revenue for the police, and steal the money of legal marijuana businesses, something else that generates revenue for the police. There are no consequences to the police for ignoring the parts of the job that do not directly generate revenue for the police. This is not an overarching problem with "the criminal justice system" other than the fact that the police almost everywhere in the US have a culture of graft and rentseeking, and won't do anything if there isn't money or press involved.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI find that a majority of our incoming calls are scams. Surprised that Google/Apple haven’t fixed this at the behest of the government.
- civilized 4y agoI have a convenient heuristic which I imagine is quite common. I have a cell phone with an area code from where I purchased it, but I have since moved, so all my local calls come from a different area code. Calls from my area code of residence are almost never spam, while calls from any other area code, and especially my phone's area code, are almost always spam.
- woodruffw 4y agoI believe both Android and iOS support SHAKEN/STIR, as long as your carrier supports it. On my phone, at least, I see Caller IDs tagged with "likely spam" if a check fails.
- eikenberry 4y ago[flagged]
- ohCh6zos 4y agoWhile maybe an act of war is too harsh, we should be hitting them hard economically.
- weakfortress 4y agoThe police in India are paid off to allow this. Indeed, the best solution would be economic sanctions on India until it is resolved.
- ideavalodation 4y agoI don't support any kinda scam to begin with but what should other countries do to USA for exporting MLMs, ponzi scheme, crypto scams and other trash
- e_i_pi_2 4y agoI was looking for the perfect analogy and this is it - would India and other countries be justified for sanctioning the US government for something private companies did? Sanctions are something governments do to each other and this is an issue between private citizens. It just gets messy because it's international, but AFAIK we can't do anything from the US aside from investigating to get suspects then requesting extradition.
- ryandrake 4y agoThe Indian government is pretty clearly complicit. At a large enough scale, there is no difference between permitting something and encouraging that thing. And other countries are free to impose economic sanctions on the USA for the shitty things it allows/encourages US companies to do. If there is a market incentive for companies to do something bad, and the government can, but does not act to correct/neutralize that incentive, then the government should be blamed. India is a democracy, so that blame also falls on the electorate. As a US voter I grudgingly accept my ~4e-9 proportion of the blame for the shitty things the US allows.
- ridicter 4y agoIt's gotten bad enough that if someone with an Indian accent is calling me and it sounds like it's from a call center, I hang up immediately.
- GalenErso 4y agoI solely answer phone calls from anyone other than friends and family, work, and scheduled appointments.
- Timon3 4y agoDo you happen to work in a scam call center? If so that seems like a reasonable approach!
- harrisonjackson 4y agoAnother giveaway is an extra pause before they start talking. This is call software that lets them dial a bunch of numbers at once until someone answers and it switches the person that answered over to an available headset. If you answer and say hello and there's an extra second just hang up. They'll call back if it is important.
- ipython 4y agoThere’s also a very distinct “bloop” sound from their phone system, I assume it’s the sound of “connecting” you to their conference. Honestly, that is a 100% signal of a scam call that would be trivial to detect en masse in an automated system.
- DrearyWoods 4y agoThis is my advice to my parents now, who sometimes get anxious over the disgracefully manipulative bait these scammers deploy. "If it's an Indian, hang up." If there's a legitimate need to get in touch, they will find another way. My (naive) hope is that this might also discourage offshoring and/or reward companies employing Americans, if enough people do likewise.
- hijinks 4y agomy wife almost fell for one because she needed to do an amazon return. She Googled "Amazon support phone number" on her phone and the 2nd link had a 800 number but it was a site either legit or setup by scammers to review the phone number. She called it and figured someone was funny when they asked her to install an app on her phone.
- 29083011397778 4y agoI don't shop at Amazon if I can at all help it, so as someone unfamiliar with the return flow: this actually sounds expected. Telling the person you're trying to scam "It's a new feature not built into the main app yet" sounds totally believable, and almost expected for a digital-first company like Amazon. And if a legacy retailer said the same thing, I would consider them mildly slow and fragmented, not necessarily scamming me. "Scammer" wouldn't be the first thing to pop into my head. Combined with how easy it is to get "support" from scammers instead of actual companies and high-pressure act-now tactics scammers use, and your wife was probably one of the few that caught on.
- Nextgrid 4y agoLet me guess, was that search result an ad? Yet another reason to block them.
- sys32768 4y agoI always wait on the line until I get an actual person and then I give them a satisfyingly long raspberry. I think it would be more effective if I learned a Hindi curse.
- temp20221227 4y agoI have to preface this with saying that most Indians are decent people, and do not work at call centers scamming Americans. Within India, they deal with this type of phone crap on a level beyond what we do. There are some shady loan companies there that require you to upload your contacts list and harass every one of your contacts if you miss a payment. Anyways, I'm all for insulting a call center scammer, and a rude comment about their mom, especially comparing them to a dog or something, will probably piss them off. Then if they overreact back, threaten to email their boss the call recording.
- AussieWog93 4y ago>I think it would be more effective if I learned a Hindi curse. When asked, just tell them your name is "Ben Chod". Gets em every time.
- HamSession 4y agoA lot is caused by the forwarding services that mask the numbers. Really each should be held liable for any damages.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoI think for that to be meaningful, there would need to be some mechanism to prevent fly-by-night operations formed to isolate the liability. Maybe requiring them to post a large bond (proportional to the liability) and/or have insurance?
- calimac 4y ago[dead]
- CoastalCoder 4y agoCould someone explain why the reply from @calimac was killed? I'm guessing it has something to do with the snowshoe-spamming reference, but I'm totally in the dark.
- probably_wrong 4y agoThe user is probably blacklisted due to bad past behavior. You can vouch for individual comments, though.
- rootusrootus 4y agoBanned by sctb on Oct 16, 2016 for political ranting.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoWouldn't being banned prevent them from posting? Or does it just insta-kill all their posts?
- rootusrootus 4y ago
- evo_9 4y agoSet your phone to silence unknown callers. Completely eliminated the issue for me, along with any other random goofball trying to call me.
- zippergz 4y agoAlso caused me to completely miss an appliance delivery because the driver called me from his personal cell, I forgot I had "unknown callers" filtered, and he gave up when he couldn't reach me. Even though I get way more spam calls than legitimate calls, I realized that fully half of the legitimate calls I get are from numbers not in my contacts: delivery drivers, doctors offices, restaurants confirming reservations, etc. The collateral damage of this setting was worse than the scam calls for me.
- wetpaws 4y agoThere is a solution for this and it's called SMS
- notahacker 4y agoI'm not convinced the solution to the problem "I'm not able to deliver this item because you're not answering the door or phone" is to expect delivery drivers to use asynchronous communication methods and plan their day around making deliveries when people that can't or won't respond immediately get around to replying. I receive more spam SMS than scam calls too. Some of them are even asking me to provide information for the benefit of fake deliveries...
- deadbunny 4y agoIt's a delivery. Couldn't he have knocked on your door?
- alistairSH 4y agoThey often call at dispatch time to ensure you’re there to accept delivery. They don’t want to drive out, only to have to return the appliance because nobody was home.
- marze 4y agoRather than "caused by illegal Indian call centres in 2022", wouldn't it be more accurate to say "Indian industrial-scale criminal scam operations"?
- photochemsyn 4y agoOperating in collusion with American carriers who don't try to identify and block these operations because they get paid on a per-call basis?
- kodah 4y agoIs that the case? When I worked in telefony abuse, like this, was pretty hard to track because of all the middlemen involved. They'd have phone banks with multiple phone numbers that they'd lease from providers in India who worked with them to rotate through outbound numbers. India doesn't allow Americans telefony companies, much less voip (in order to provide these telefony companies business), so looking at India from a telefony perspective is much like looking at several black boxes. Tldr; because of India's policies the country of India has to do something about it. Much like Chinese knockoffs and IP theft.
- bradleyjg 4y agoWe handled this in the days of email spam by blacklisting providers that refused to police their customers.
- saghm 4y agoWhat would happen if the American companies just started playing hardball? For example, what if they required that contracts with foreign telephone companies had a fee based on scams detected as coming through and just refused to work with any company that wouldn't agree to those terms? I have no idea if that exact idea would make sense or even be possible to implement, but my thinking is that in many cases the American companies might be able to afford to lose the business more than their international partners, so playing a game of chicken might be worthwhile. In other words, just because American telecoms might not be able to do anything from a technical perspective doesn't mean that they don't have social or business pressure they could apply if they actually wanted to solve the problem. Ultimately, it seems like the American companies haven't done anything because they don't really have any business incentive to; as long as they aren't held culpable legally and don't lose sales due to the PR hit, trying to use their influence to solve this is purely a risk from a financial perspective. I don't at all subscribe to the Friedman perspective that businesses are ethically obligated to maximize profits at the expense of literally everything else, but I do think that it's a reasonable description of the way businesses trend toward acting; an entity structurally designed for making profits will inevitably end up acting in a way that only considers that measure unless the incentives are changed, which is precisely why we _do_ need to regulate things to curtail business behavior that's a net bad for society as a whole by making it unprofitable, whether that's through direct fines or making business liable either civilly or criminally for their actions.
- iamshs 4y agoCanadian public broadcaster, CBC, reported this as "financial terrorism" back in 2019. Now it seems the references have been scrubbed out. $10B drained from old and financial vulnerable is absolutely ridiculous and should be called financial terrorism.
- jws 4y agoTerrorism requires a political goal. Simply wanting more money and stealing it isn't a political goal.
- pseingatl 4y agoStopping the use of gift cards sold by Target or restricting their use would go a long way towards stopping this. Cracking down on the money mules who forward the cash would help as well. Reporting the bank accounts the scammers use and shutting them down is also key.
- cute_boi 4y agoThese days whenever I hear Indian voice, I just reject call. They way they target grandparents is surreal. One day they told my my friends parents that their children is in accident and they have to pay in gift cards. It is so distressing to elderly people. US must take strict actions and call out India publicly. Elderly people are weak, education isn't going to solve the scam problem. Scammers must be punished harsly. They erode the trust in system. Also, Indian government is not doing anything. In many places like Kolkata, scammers can get away easily by bribing police. Our phone are being redirected to India, and they can abuse our phone number. I wish, the US government passes strict rules and regulations to keep these scammers in check.
- jacquesm 4y agoTelco's could put a stop to this if they really wanted to. Start with disabling number spoofing for international calls, if the number presented isn't in the country of origin then reject the connection request. Another choke point is the gift card system.
- code_runner 4y agoEdit: I was thinking of a totally different gift card scam. Whoops Gift cards should require some amount of destruction in order to get to the actual barcode… something to make tampering obvious. The same way clothes have a little ink exploder the clerk removes… just a quick easy step that is destructive to the packaging… but still presentable when you give it to someone
- arcturus17 4y agoWait, how would this stop phone scams?
- Fnoord 4y agoNothing can stop that. The goal is lowering the victims / profit. How to do that, that's the question. It comes to no surprise to me poor countries (with bribed police force) try to scam rich ones.
- Ekaros 4y agoMaybe there should be some educational program about these. Or license to have a phone and bank account...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- snshn 4y agoI'm sure those scammers will redeem themselves one day.
- teatree 4y agoIs there any way to coerce the Indian government to take action on this? Looking at YouTube videos where these scammers literally run corporate offices to steal from old and financially vulnerable people is heartbreaking.
- robofanatic 4y agoCheckout Jamtara on Netflix. a great series about this.
- faxmeyourcode 4y agoThese operations have to be sponsored by the state at this scale. At the bare minimum they're at least looking the other way. My grandparents are the targets for this kind of scam, and when they call their bank they get an Indian customer service rep to discuss the situation with. Absolutely disgusting that the situation has been tolerated for so long.
- CoastalCoder 4y ago> These operations have to be sponsored by the state at this scale. I'd argue that one such state is the U.S. Congress could pretty trivially order that carriers give each customer a choice about what kinds of spoofed / unreliable-origin calls to let through. E.g.: For calls originating (inside | outside) the U.S.: (allow-all | allow-whitelist-only | allow-only-when-presenting-callee-issued-passcode | etc.) But Congress doesn't do this. This isn't exactly Congress sponsoring this behavior, but I suspect there's some bribery and/or unsavory lobbying going on.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> But Congress doesn't do this. My own thesis, is because politicians, and PACs, use robocalls extensively. They don't want you blocking their junk calls.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> My own thesis, is because politicians, and PACs, use robocalls extensively. I doubt it, its easy enough for them to just exempt their own calls (which, incidentally, they do from existing Do-Not-Call rules.)
- factorialboy 4y ago> These operations have to be sponsored by the state at this scale. How so?
- nigerianbrince 4y agoI doubt it. It's < 0.003% of indian gdp.
- zarriak 4y agoJust get a job where you have to pick up every call you get and some of them won’t be spam!
- mrsuprawsm 4y agoIt's mind-boggling that the United States allows this kind of thing to happen. In the EU I get maybe one spam call every couple of months. From the stories you hear from Americans on HN, Americans get multiple spam/scam calls a day, and the vast majority of their inbound calls are spam/scams. What is going wrong in the US that isn't going wrong in the EU? Language barrier? Regulatory capture?
- bluedino 4y agoIt's mind boggling that such a high amount of people are willing to pay up whenever they get a call or email
- rootusrootus 4y agoThe fraction is quite low, but when you're pulling from a pool of people measured in billions, even a really low percentage is good enough.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoLucky you. I usually get one or two spam calls a day in Europe (France/Germany) but they are marked as spam. Bless the people keeping that red list up to date. This thread makes me wonder if Americans have such info (whether a call is a likely spam) automatically pop up when receiving text or calls.
- jjtheblunt 4y agowe do have that info (perhaps presentation of such depends on phone software of course). almost all my inbound calls are spam, in the united states. when i've listened to voicemails left, they even have native north american accented people reading the prerecorded scripts, so there's deep roots to the depravity that cross country borders.
- ghaff 4y ago>if Americans have such info (whether a call is a likely spam) automatically pop up Sometimes but not consistently. Though honestly in the US I get maybe one SPAM call or text a week these days.
- pico303 4y agoTo everyone suggesting to silence unknown callers, most of these scams come through email or text messages, and the victim is tricked into calling the scammer. Best defense: don’t ever call a phone number you receive in a text or email message. Delete the message and look up your bank’s, Amazon’s, or PayPal’s phone number yourself through the company’s official web site. Also, don’t get scared by messages about your finances…stay calm. The scammers count on you getting freaked out and doing something stupid.
- grammers 4y agoI once had an issue with Microsoft at work and had to get MS support to help me. They literally called me on the landline and asked for remote control of my computer. It was totally legit. Still I felt uncomfortable and asked for a Teams session with screensharing instead (and not remote access), but this 'was not possible'. So, how are people to distinguish between 'fake' calls and real ones if companies still use such shitty techniques?
- tester457 4y agoMaybe their email domains, I don't think scammers can get a hold of domains like "microsoftsupport.com"
- jfk13 4y agoWhy not? OK, looks like "microsoftsupport.com" is taken, but GoDaddy is happy to offer me alternatives like microsoftsupport.app, microsoftsupport.site, microsoftsupport.tv, or microsoftsupport.uk that should work equally well for scam purposes. Or microsoftpcsupport.com is available, if a ".com" is particularly desirable.
- pca 4y agoDoesn't Microsoft use a thousand different domains, most of which look sketchy? What if you receive an email from microsofts-support@live.com? Could you immediately tell that it is not legitimate compared to, e.g. contact@microsoftsupport.com?
- cdolan 4y agoMy favorite: aka.ms Or “cudaserv.com”, which is auto enabled link scanning for Office365
- grammers 4y agoThey couldn't get it to work on Linux anyway. So I just stopped and never got the issue resolved...
- Xeoncross 4y agoI like that the same page shows a video of an "illegal school" being torn down by the government. Is this a joke? Like, what kind of dastardly evil people are constructing schools without permits in a country desperate trying to feed and education the large population? Is the municipality head just upset they didn't get an under-the-table payment like usual?
- chakkepolja 4y agoSchools are a money making business like everything else. Illegal school means they didnt follow rules and regulations.
- temp20221227 4y agoNot a joke. Your concepts of building codes and property ownership are western. There's no such thing in India. Rather, there's a patchwork of policies that contradict each other and no consistent sense of which one has precedence. And land ownership is complicated by qualifications over who can sell it and claims from family members who maybe had a descendent there hundreds of years ago. And of course, various policies benefitting squatters. And whoever could forge the ownership papers nicely enough to claim it's theirs. These things are all features and not bugs. It gives pathways for the government to dispose of any buildings that are annoying it for whatever reason. They find the law on the books that allows them to bulldoze the school the quickest, have the tractors out there within hours, and complete the process before any lawyer can get through the patchwork of laws to stop it. > Like, what kind of dastardly evil people are constructing schools without permits in a country desperate trying to feed and education the large population? Don't blame whomever built the school, they were trying to help! Blame the ones who tore it down.
- weakfortress 4y agoThe problem is these scams are cheap to run and the risk is very low for the people running them. The police rarely do anything except a token show to arrest a few call centers full of low-level scammers. Rarely are the kingpins ever arrested and as such they just pop new centers up as often as they go down. A multi-factoral approach may be the best: 1. Sanction India to encourage the government to clean up it's police force and go after these scammers with prejudice. Not the call centers, the kingpins that run them. 2. Education. Run commercials on every TV stations, news stations, etc to educate people on this. Perhaps even including example calls. Run TV shows talking about the scammers and examples of them successfully bullying people into paying to build deep distrust of these people and allow people's pattern-matching brains to do the rest of the work. 3. Punishing call forwarding services for every scam call. Force them to implement deep KYC under threat of severe company-ending fines. 4. Find a way to "encourage" carriers to improve their services to terminate these calls before they even make it to the customer. I get so many telemarketing and scam calls to my phone anymore I have to pay $100/year for a service to stop about 80% of them. This is unacceptable. I'm not alone, I would guess in a survey of the average American their cell phone is basically useless as a calling device these days.
- allisdust 4y agoProblem is the ring leaders of the scam call centres that actually finance the operations and move the stolen funds are usually not Indian residents. Once one call center is busted, they move to recruit another. The employees themselves aren't blameless either and need to be caught but the problem will simply rotate between countries if the brains are not caught. The reason there are so many scam call centres are there in India is the same reason there are so many customer support call centres: cheap English speaking labour.
- matthewmorgan 4y agoMy grandfather stopped answering his landline telephone because of these scumbags. Kitboga is a youtuber who winds scammers up and wastes their time, and is pretty righteous https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HNziOoXDBeg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HNziOoXDBeg
- iosjunkie 4y agoCame here to mention Kitboga. Watch a few of his videos to get a sense to what lengths the scammers go to defraud the elderly. Utterly heartless.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoThere's a whole cottage industry of scam baiters. Harvey Dentt, Rinona Poison, Scambait Central, Lenny the robot (much less active of late), and quite a few others. Many of them use voice filters to sound elderly, or to change genders. It seems like a lot of the scammers are getting frustrated, constantly trying to figure out if you're Kitboga, etc. A vital service that is educating the public while providing rich entertainment.
- Apocryphon 4y ago@Scambaiter on YouTube is excellent, as he uses technical knowledge to actually hack and disrupt call centers.
- debarshri 4y agoIt is not just Americans who affected by these scams. It is also Indian elderly population too who are affected by these scams. I think Indian authorities are very slow to react to these issues because police dont really understand the impact these calls make. Also they are paid off and are often of part of the mafia that runs them. My parent's friends have also been scammed. The Netflix series "Jamtara" really shows how intertwined these scams are with political system. The intent of these mafia and political groups is purely money and there is anti American sentiment that drives them.
- LegitShady 4y agoThe police in India understand. They are corrupt and paid off, so it continues.
- rockyj 4y agoExactly. At one level, the Indian political system is a politician-criminal nexus. The politicians are supported by money flowing in from shady systems, the politicians allow shady systems to run and use the money to win elections. Rinse and repeat. Then there are some variations of these - e.g. the politician and criminal is the same person or in the same family, the criminal also does some legit work, the criminal does mostly legit work and lot of it is goverment projects or projects running on tax money (which are done badly or subcontracted and money flows back partly as kick-backs). This cycle is hard to break unless some serious reforms are brought it, but then why would the politicians break the very system which brings them so much power and money.
- jesuscript 4y agoThey wouldn’t break the system because it’s one of the few systems that works in that country (I’m taking a amoral stance here). Even the “good” systems don’t work, like water, electricity, or traffic/transportation. So whatever, I can see why they are okay with a “bad” but working system. Nonetheless, it’s quite dysfunctional.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoSo many of these scam call center operators masquerade as honest businessmen, even winning local awards. Sickening.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoAnd even more money has been lost through the horde of outsourcing firms such as Infosys and Wipro with low quality developers.
- willhinsa 4y agoCongress is asleep at the wheel. The spice must flow The coffers leaking doesn't matter when lobbyists fill them back up every night
- sdfds1231231 4y agoThese scammers have become bolder. Recently the targets have been elderly indians as well.
- sdfds1231231 4y agoThese scammers have become bolder. Recently the targets have been elderly Indians. My friends dad was scammed a few lakhs. Obviously no police complaint gonna work, they just gonna keep it on record. Hopefully the international outrage would push the authorities to do something about it.
- devinprater 4y agoI love watching Scammer Payback and Kitboga on Youtube.
- 2143 4y agoI fully agree that these scammers must be prosecuted. Just a couple of things: 1. I don't think there's any official conspiracy by Indians in general to screw over Americans. So kindly don't put out poorly thought out responses calling for blanket ban on Indians or things like that. 2. Indians themselves get scammed by these scammers. That's all. Carry on.
- miohtama 4y agoThe title is incorrect. If you read the original article it is clear that $10B is all US online fraud together, not Indian call centers as Deccandherald.com writes > The trend is persisting, with total money lost by Americans in all internet/call centre-related frauds in the last 11 months having been estimated at $10.2 billion, an increase of 47% against last year’s $6.9 billion.
- 1SFOD-D 4y ago[flagged]
- Qtips87 4y ago[flagged]
- jeezzbo 4y ago[dead]
- HollywoodZero 4y agoIt's not just India. The rise in the random texts (which end up pushing investment scams) also originates in off shore call centers in Southeast Asia. Often times they get migrant workers with promises of jobs, but then take their passport and force them into years of repaying for their relocation fees. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-62792875 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-62792875
- PaybackTony 4y agoI built telecommunications systems / software for some time. The unfortunate truth here is that telecom carriers absolutely already have everything they need to largely put a stop to it but they knowingly ignore it. It's the biggest problem in the US because because of pricing. It's expensive to run outbound campaigns in almost any other country, and very cheap in the US (fractions of a penny per minute compared to 5-10c per minute in some EU locations). Scammers need volume to make money. The reason carriers -- from the local exchange carriers and up -- ignore it is because just a single scam operation can mean 10s of thousands of dollars in volume a month, and sometimes more. Since they have to self-report for the most part they're not very incentivized to stop it. There are a few easy to implement regulatory / technical mechanisms that could nearly axe all of it, but carriers push back hard on those regulations and they never stick. I know from experience dealing with this that it's absolutely not ignorance that's at play on the regulatory and commercial side. It's disgusting, and as fueled with greed and red tape as you'd fear.
- jesuscript 4y agoThat’s kind of sad that they won’t just fix it if they can. I over hear my elderly parents give each other tips like “don’t open that email, it’s fake” and things like that.
- javajosh 4y agoSo, I realize this is a big ask - but can you please write this up as a story and sent it to a major news outlet? My cynicism is already high, but I would not have suspected this of all things, that telcos would allow the elderly to be victimized to the tune of $10B to make a few pennies. Also, fuck gift cards. Make them illegal
- _-david-_ 4y ago>Also, fuck gift cards. Make them illegal And when scammers go back to using Western Union are you going to ban that as well? When they ask a person to send them cash are you going to ban cash as well? Hell let's just ban all money to prevent this.
- ramesh31 4y agoThis has nothing to do with Indians, and is entirely a failure of the FCC to regulate the legacy phone system. The tech industry solved e-mail spam, why can't they be allowed to do the same for phones?
- frontman1988 4y agoIs it bad that I don't feel sorry for the Americans getting scammed given the obscene wealth inequality that exists between the two countries? Some wealth shifting to a poor country with millions of malnourished people might actually be a net positive to the world? Morality is complicated for sure.
- prhn 4y ago> Is it bad that I don't feel sorry for the Americans getting scammed yes
- frontman1988 4y agoHave you been to India and seen the absolute squalour and poverty that exists? I guess the net happiness in the world increases everytime some poor indian scams an american. The american is momentarily pissed off and wiser about scams, while the Indian has got a lot of money that will improve his living standards considerably.
- modriano 4y agoNot every American is wealthy, and none of the Indian scammers are the Indians living in absolute poverty. Have a look at this scammer and his resume [0] and tell me how this college educated criminal defrauding Americans who aren't very tech savvy "increases the net happiness of the world"? [0] https://youtu.be/EapyNrHp9xo?t=400 https://youtu.be/EapyNrHp9xo?t=400
- potamic 4y agoIt's not bad, it's reprehensible. Notwithstanding the fact that there are about a dozen moral qualms about this line of thinking, the economic conditions of the countries have little bearing on the economic situations of individuals in this interaction. I'd wager that the scammers here are more wealthy than most of the people they are scamming. And given their criminal backgrounds, they are likely to do more harm than unintended good to the people around them. Remember Gandhi who once said, "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind".
- redsummer 4y ago[dead]
- newsclues 4y agoFines for the Telcos that enable these scams could resolve this issue, but the Telcos make money off this and don't care.
- shockeychap 4y agoMy uncle almost drove two states away to give a stranger $10,000 because he was duped into believing his grandson had gotten into an accident and killed a pregnant woman. The only thing that stopped it was that he first needed to borrow the money, which led to my involvement. We made some calls and were quickly able to confirm that the grandson in question was at home and nowhere near the "accident" in question. My parents have had to cancel their main debit card twice in the past year because they've given out the number to someone they thought was with their bank. My neighbor (in her 80s) almost gave her SSN to somebody who claimed to be with Social Security. I knew a guy who lost his entire retirement to scammers and had to give up his dream of retiring to Florida. I'm sad to say it, but it's more dangerous than ever to be old or naive. In the old days, the scammers had to come to you. The internet has made it trivial to carry out scam operations from the other side of the world, and everyone who COULD do something (especially the FCC and telcos) seems to be indifferent and apathetic.
- grimgrin 4y agosimilar story for me a year ago. grandpa got a call that i was in jail for hitting a car and the driver was pregnant. lost her baby. they even had “me” talk to them briefly which really got em believing. he went to bank and mailed $9500 in cash, to what ultimately appeared to be an airbnb was v sad because he felt supreme humiliation over the matter.
- shockeychap 4y agoI'm sorry to hear that. It was almost the exact same thing with my uncle. When I first started asking questions, he tried to assure me it was legit because he had heard his grandson talking in the background. My guess is that they had somebody sobbing hysterically while talking so as to make it hard to recognize that the voice is "off". When you're stressed, it's easy to miss that kind of thing, and they exploit it.
- codezero 4y agoAirbnb must be a hotbed for these sort of things. I had a friend in the 90s who would squat at unfinished or unoccupied homes while he ran fraud scams, renting an Airbnb seems much easier, since these scammers almost certainly rented it with a stolen identity.
- baby 4y agoI don’t respond to phone calls anymore. I receive spam calls and texts every day. At this point I’m thinking about just blocking everything, the problem is that I still need to use this for: - 2FA - restaurants waitlist That’s it. I just scrolled through a bunch of texts and calls and anything meaningful nowadays seem to come from whatsapp
- dxbydt 4y agoUntil last year, I was completely unaware of this problem. I made a stupid, stupid mistake - registered a .us TLD using “Google Domains” - within minutes of registration, the calls started. Some Indian voice offering website construction, ios app, android app, tech support, on & on…over 100 calls in a single week! Used call block but they kept coming. They switch numbers and send 1000s of text messages - neverending spam. I wrote to Google support and they pointed to the fineprint - cannot enable privacy on .us tld ! So the phone number will remain public. Calls kept coming. Over 1000 calls! Finally bit the bullet and changed my phone number. Will never ever buy anything from google domains. I sure hope the FTC goes after these spammers and the telcos who enable this sort of behavior.
- binkHN 4y ago> cannot enable privacy on .us tld Interesting! Never knew this!
- bcrosby95 4y agoIt's not Google's fault. This is the rule for .us domains. Blame the US government.
- ipqk 4y agoBut that's not a Google Domains issue, it's a .us issue. All registrars cannot enable privacy on .us domains.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoI learned this the hard way too. Not with Google domains, but another registrar. I was getting dozens of calls a day from Indian voices proposing to create a website for me. Switched the WHOIS data to private and that slowed it down but didn't stop it. This was two years ago and I'm still getting about one call a day. I've since learned there are caching services for WHOIS data that will sell you historical contact data. Obviously the Indian fraudsters are using these services. The days of friendly WHOIS are over. Never register a domain without setting the privacy flag.
- kevmarsden 4y agoThat sounds like a nightmare, but I wouldn't let that experience sour your opinion of Google Domains. I actively avoid Google products, but Google Domains is an exception. They make limited upsell appeals, their pricing is straight forward, and if it's available, they include privacy protection with the annual cost. And they are clear about the lack of privacy protection for .us domains. This text appears when checking out: "Privacy protection is not supported for .US domains."
- user3939382 4y agoI apologize for the controversial and maybe inflammatory opinion, but it’s my reaction and thought on the issue. How much more were the American people just fleeced by Congress for this money that was sent to Ukraine? 10x more money. No one can scam the American people like our own government.
- ketanmaheshwari 4y agoDisclaimer: I am a person of Indian origin. I personally do not think reprimanding India will solve this. If somehow India stops this the void will be filled by scammers from some other country. This calls for reforms in telecommunications systems / regulations / norms / protocols.
- tigeroil 4y agoThing is, there's other nationalities who quite frankly would probably be a lot more effective at coming off as convincing to potential victims, especially given the unfortunate effect this has had on the Indian people's reputation. The fact that we haven't really seen anything near the level of Indian call centres tells me that this is unlikely. I'm not saying that scammers don't exist in other countries, but that it's very rare to see anything with the level of sophistication and organisation that we see in India.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> If somehow India stops this the void will be filled by scammers from some other country. As if those would-be scammers in other countries presently don't scam.. because Indians do? How do Indians presently scamming stop would-be scammers in other countries from doing the same? That's nonsensical. Face the facts, this is an India problem. Harsh economic sanctions against India are necessary to solve this problem, and if that fails, null routing India and the whole of South Asia if necessary. And if diplomacy fails, escalation to military strikes against Indian telecom infrastructure would be in order.
- coding123 4y agoBest advice: don't have an area code that matches where you are. when you start getting calls from Houston (for example) you know it's spam/scam. But when you get calls from the area code you are actually in, it's legit.
- yalogin 4y agoThe telcos have all my info, name, ssn, address everything. They can easily prevent all of this. These spammers generate revenue for the telcos and so for them spoofing calls is a service they are providing and don’t want to remove that “feature”
- aravindgp 4y agoAll telcos in don't allow number spoofing. No matter what is your requirement. Indian telcos don't allow for number spoofing. The same rules must be implemented in every country, it's just ridiculous that in this day and age open robbery using telephone is still being allowed. Nobody should have that facility period. You must one number per customer no matter how many lines you take. The ability to change number should be next to impossible. Everything stops with this one change. Number spoofing must be stopped from all countries.
- dalbasal 4y agoDiplomats have been MIA on this issue for far too long. This is exactly what diplomacy should be good for. The victims of these crimes aren't in India. It makes sense that it would take external pressure to prioritize them.
- pjdemers 4y agoWasn't there a guy who was running an IRS scam who was caught, tried and convicted and will spend the rest of his life in a US supermax prison? And his children, who lived in the US, were stripped of their citizenship and deported. The universities where his children attended were threatened with receiving stolen property and forced to pay all tuition and fees back to the IRS. And of course their degrees were revoked.
- mderazon 4y agoIronically, India have solved the problem domestically via regulation https://www.ledgerinsights.com/how-it-works-india-anti-spam-telecoms-blockchain/ https://www.ledgerinsights.com/how-it-works-india-anti-spam-...
- heikkilevanto 4y agoIt is too easy to fake the originating number. The actual line number where the phone call comes from is probably in the protocol already. A lot could be solved if the phones started to display that as well. Even better, allow the users to block on both official and actual numbers. Could probably be done without involving the telcos, only a change in the handset software.
- bjourne 4y agoI've also had a run-in with "the Indian tech support". Weird thing is that when the guy on the other end realized I was running Linux and just messing with him, he became incredibly rude and cursed at me. Told me to "put fingers up my butt" and that I was a horrible person for wasting his time... Surreal almost.
- jt2190 4y agoCan we change the link to the original sources? > Romance-related frauds and ‘tech support’ pop ups, originating largely from illegal call centres and phishing gangs in India, have caused losses of more than USD 3 billion... in the last two years alone. [1] > Daud said the FBI’s website for reporting internet crimes (ic3.gov) have registered about 8.5 lakh complaints in 2021 with estimated losses of $6.9 billion, and over 7.8 lakh complaints in the 11 months of 2022, accounting for $10.2 billion in losses. The biggest losses are on account of investment ($3 billion), business email compromise ($2.4 billion), personal data breach ($1.2 billion), romance ($1 billion) and tech support ($781 million). [1] [1] "Illegal Desi Call Centres Behind 10 billion loss to Americans in 2022", Times of India, Dec 27, 2022: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/illegal-desi-call-centres-behind-10-billion-loss-to-americans-in-2022/articleshow/96501320.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/illegal-desi-call-... [2] "Elder Fraud Report 2021", FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center https://www.ic3.gov/Home/EF https://www.ic3.gov/Home/EF https://www.ic3.gov/Media/PDF/AnnualReport/2021_IC3ElderFraudReport.pdf https://www.ic3.gov/Media/PDF/AnnualReport/2021_IC3ElderFrau...
- temp20221227 4y agoA lot of comments here suggest the Indian government is complacent in these types of operations, but I don't really believe that's the case. The Indian central government is a pretty small and unpowerful entity. Beyond securing the countries borders, and keeping the currency spinning, the government doesn't have the ability or power to do much more. They are not especially well funded (taxes are seen as especially unwelcome culturally) and staffed by tenured officials who cannot be fired and have no incentive to perform beyond the bare minimum. The relative unity and peace holding the country together is not the lousy government, but really more Indian culture sticking together. Police are also seen as having some level of authority in the country, but realistically there's only 1 police for every 1,000 citizens (source: https://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/03/business/worldbusiness/03security.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/03/business/worldbusiness/03...) and the country is heavily heavily reliant on private security who are generally just villagers who are given a badge and rules to enforce. Outside the big cities, government control is very limited. How else could the crop burning choking Delhi every winter continue? So do these call centers operate with the blessing of the government? Probably not. Do they have to bribe police to operate? probably not. The government is probably unaware of scale of the problem, the police have their hands full taking care of their own people, and the American government wouldn't dare try a diplomatic solve as India's agreement with many foreign policy situations is mission critical. Maybe it'd be better if in America we could try to get support off of the POTS and try to better connect to official brand sites or apps? Or we have phone plans/email plans for the elderly that don't allow stranger contact?
- whydid 4y agoThe Indian government is complacent because they allow such extreme poverty to exist where people need to seek out scams like this in order to survive. Extreme inequities rationalized by an abusive caste system, mixed with a culture that praises creative work avoidance.
- known 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bdr 4y agoCrazy idea: a red team for hire that tries to scam your relatives (but doesn’t actually go through with it). Seems like the most effective way to teach people what to look out for.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thepasswordis 4y agoAt this point I don't consider email, text, or phone calls to be a legitimate way to contact me. If you want to contact me, message me on signal. It's sad, but marketers and scammers have effectively ruined the idea of people reaching out to me on the phone. It's sad, but it is what it is.
- jliptzin 4y agoCheck out kitboga on YouTube for some hilarious scamming the scammer videos. The guy tries to waste as much of the scammer’s time as possible and he’s quite good at it. Of course there’s only so much one person can do, but he does seem to be doing more than the entire US law enforcement apparatus combined.
- dang 4y agoUrl changed from https://www.deccanherald.com/national/americans-duped-into-losing-10-billion-by-illegal-indian-call-centres-in-2022-report-1175156.html https://www.deccanherald.com/national/americans-duped-into-l..., which points to this.
- nikanj 4y agoDid the economy benefit over $10B from allowing voip calls to spoof numbers? I feel like dropping that ability would be a net win - would be much harder to spoof the elderly with a scam coming from a clearly foreign number
- spyder 4y agoIt will get worse with the advancement of AI and could scam the less vulnerable people too for example by voice cloning from few minutes of a voice sample of your friends or relatives. There was a CEO of a company who already got scammed in a similar way: https://www.identityiq.com/scams-and-fraud/scammers-use-ai-generated-voice-deepfake-to-steal-almost-250000-from-ceo/ https://www.identityiq.com/scams-and-fraud/scammers-use-ai-g... And the even more scary thing will be when they will be able to use a ChatGPT like AI to automate the whole thing in the future.
- gigatexal 4y agoHorrible. There’s folks on YouTube who try to prevent victims from getting fleeced but many many many get scammed.
- GnarfGnarf 4y agoJust to put things in perspective: for ~350 years (1600-1949), the West dominated and exploited India. The British taught the Indians that it was OK to steal from another nation. And they taught them English too. What goes around comes around.
- golemiprague 4y ago[dead]
- ramadan_steve 4y ago[dead]
- psnehanshu 4y agoThere's this guy called Karl Rock who busts such scam call centres. You can find the playlist here: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMhislZnB_6e0G4Qo1pcZD0QbQ-BSDw7n https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMhislZnB_6e0G4Qo1pcZD0Qb...
- rockzapper 4y agoMy wife worked in one such company several years ago. The interesting thing is that while hiring her, she couldn't even anticipate that the company was a scam. The company described itself as a certified technical support service. They showed her such a rosy picture of the work they did. It was only after a couple of weeks, when they had explained the processes, that she realized it was a scam. She left soon thereafter. By the way, they were ready to pay whatever she asked for (up to a reasonable limit of course). The tragedy is that people in countries like India need to survive, and values take the back seat. Two more such companies offered her the same kind of job but she declined.
- charles_f 4y agoIn BC we regularly get scams like missed delivery, order confirmation for something expensive, or your social insurance number will get cancelled. These are such an annoyance that I started making it into a game instead. They mostly target the Chinese population, which in bc is quite large, and I'm assuming are ran from China. Each of the calls end with a "press 1 for English and 2 for Chinese". If you choose 1 the line hangs. If you choose 2 you get a Chinese person on the line. Sometimes the message is directly in Chinese and you need to guess the right key. I programmed some diatribe in Chinese in Google translate from my bookmarks toolbar. Once in a while I get an Indian call center, mostly pretending to be Amazon with an order for an iPhone, which then veers into "someone stole your identity". If you reply with a younger voice, they hang. If I make an old person's voice, they stay with me. The more lost I sound, the harder the catch. I'm playing at keeping them on the line the longest time possible. It's fun cause they employ a few traps like asking for your birthdate then your age, or asking for some piece of information like your SIN a few times to validate you don't BS them. My backstory is getting better and better. It's kind of like beating a boss everytime you pass one. Nowadays I'm excited when I receive one, because I get to play. But it's only a matter of time before my parents get trapped
- dartharva 4y agoI'm just gonna be that guy - just install Truecaller. It has been the singular line of defense against all scammers and spammers for most (almost all) people in India and it works wonderfully. Scammers/spammers get routinely identified and blacklisted using crowdsourced information, and with terrific speed and prejudice. I do believe the reason most scammers have started focusing on foreign victims instead is because Truecaller has made it nigh impossible for them to dupe Indians at scale. Yes, they have the bad habit of scooping off your contact lists to index people without consent, and, on hindsight, is indeed an affront to telephone privacy, but its benefits outweigh those compromises enough.
- cuteboy19 4y agoIn America, the number you see on the call is not guaranteed to be the actual number that's calling you. In fact sometimes it doesn't show any number at all, just "Private number". It is a situation easily fixed by attestation but for whatever reason American carriers don't do that
- yati 4y agoI was thinking we could run what is being said in a call from an unknown number through a scam detector. The detector, upon noticing an established fingerprint of scam activity, would alert the caller. There is Call Screen in the native Android Phone app that does this, but even better: it can take the call on your behalf, and warn you based on what the other party says. It is available in the US, but it seems only for Pixel devices? https://support.google.com/phoneapp/answer/9118387?hl=en&ref_topic=10078984# https://support.google.com/phoneapp/answer/9118387?hl=en&ref...