27 ms·
Elizabeth Holmes is sentenced to more than 11 years for fraud
- e40 4y agoThat recent picture of her looks like she is pregnant. Is that the case? What a way to start an 11 year sentence.
- ProAm 4y agotbf I think after 11 years she would be outside of the safe age range to have a baby in America, so now or never type of scenario.
- nemo44x 4y agoNot entirely true. She’s young enough where she can harvest a good deal of eggs reliably. They can be frozen until she’s out of prison. The uterus age isn’t as big a deal as the age of eggs when harvested.
- metadat 4y agoThis is a common misconception which is very much false. Frozen eggs don't last indefinitely and the viability degrades over time. After 5 or 6 years they become increasingly unlikely to be viable (it's not impossible, but statistically unlikely to be fruitful).
- shawabawa3 4y agoA friend of my mum had a baby at age ~55 using eggs frozen ~30 years earlier. Not sure if that was a crazy fluke or if some methods of freezing eggs are more reliable?
- metadat 4y agoThat's a crazy fluke, the max I've seen claimed to be done at all is 10-14 years. When I re-entered the dating scene a couple years ago I learned much more than I ever wanted to know about egg freezing. It's big business here in the Bay Area where there are a lot of ambitious career women.
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoI really think in another decade or two there is going to be a lot of lawsuits regarding egg freezing being pushed on women by tech companies to stay on the career fasttrack when they can't get a viable pregnancy. Most of the women I know that have gotten it done also seems to have almost a willful ignorance about the failure rate; especially later in life.
- 300bps 4y agoShe’s about 6 months pregnant now and the sentence won’t begin until April 27, 2023.
- tanseydavid 4y agoYou are correct.
- inerte 4y agoI heard on NPR that yes, she is.
- ceejayoz 4y agoShe had a child while the case was pending, and is pregnant again. Hell of a thing to do to a kid.
- LarsDu88 4y agoI'd have some compassion for her here. This is her last chance to have children, even if those kids might have a messed up life.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alvarezbjm-hn 4y agoThere are some of us who don't consider children a thing anybody has a "right" to have.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- iisan7 4y agoUN Declaration of Human Rights: Article 16 1. Men and women of full age, without any limitation due to race, nationality or religion, have the right to marry and to found a family. [...]
- notch656a 4y agoDo natural rights fully apply to those convicted of serious felonies between day found guilty and the end of serving their sentence? I'm not saying they don't, but in the US one of the natural rights is explicitly the right to bear arms.
- alvarezbjm-hn 4y agoNot all families have children. Some children are adopted. I am grateful for the love and care my parents gave me, but I don't consider myself something that belongs to them as birth right. It is my opinion people must be responsible of the children they breed.
- Arcuru 4y agoI know you're getting downvoted, but I must admit that I hadn't even considered that. She knew she'd likely go to jail for a pretty long time so if she wanted kids it _would_ actually be best if she had them beforehand. I mean, it definitely also garners sympathy with the judge, but it'd be totally reasonable for her to do it just because she wanted kids. Thanks for bringing up that perspective.
- metadat 4y agohttps://archive.today/00Uhs https://archive.today/00Uhs
- doener 4y agoThis user was faster: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33663191 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33663191
- dang 4y agoThe NYT article has the most information of the ones I've seen. Edit: https://twitter.com/scottbudman/status/1593729235818278912 https://twitter.com/scottbudman/status/1593729235818278912 also (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33663152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33663152). When all else is equal, we favor the earliest submitter of a story, but if one submission is more substantive than another (as yours was in this case), then it should win. A substantive article with more information has a better chance of forming a good thread.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- peter422 4y ago"Judge Edward J. Davila ... sentenced Ms. Holmes to 135 months in prison, which is slightly more than 11 years. Ms. Holmes, 38, who plans to appeal the verdict, must report to prison on April 27, 2023. Federal sentencing guidelines for wire fraud of the size that Ms. Holmes was convicted of recommend 20 years in prison. Ms. Holmes’s lawyers had asked for 18 months of house arrest, while prosecutors sought 15 years and $804 million in restitution for 29 investors."
- nimbius 4y agoholy cats. the only thing that might send you away longer is tax fraud and thats only because the us tax code was never demilitarized after we crushed the mafia. 18 months was never going to happen.
- lalopalota 4y agoaverage sentence length for drug related mandatory minimums is 139 months. (2021) pdf - https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-publications/quick-facts/Quick_Facts_Mand_Mins_FY21.pdf https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...
- from 4y agoMax sentence for tax evasion is 5 years. You can have multiple counts but almost no one is sentenced consecutively.
- vitaflo 4y agoIs it normal for there to be a sentencing and then be free for 5 months before going to prison? I always assumed after a sentencing you went straight to prison. What's the rationale for waiting? To listen to appeals?
- dannykwells 4y agoElizabeth is expecting and will give birth in early 2023. This is a mercy for the judge to allow her to not give birth in prison.
- FiberBundle 4y agoImagine how completely devoid of empathy you have to be to get pregnant twice, knowing that your children have an extremely high risk of growing up without their mother, just because you think that this will improve your chances of getting a lighter sentence. Absolutely despicable. She deserves every day she spends in prison.
- AustinDev 4y agoThis to me is the saddest part of the saga. It's obviously awful what she did to the patients but, seeing a mother do this to her own child somehow just hits different.
- HWR_14 4y agoI thought her thinking was "I will be unable to have a child when I get out of prison". Which makes some sense. Preventing my someone from procreating seems like a serious punishment not warranted in this case.
- lesuorac 4y agoThey don't yet cyrofreeze convicts, you can get pregnant while in prison although I suspect you must be on work-detail or some other revenue generating activity for the prison to approve your visitations.
- HWR_14 4y agoI mean, sure, technically. It seems far better to have a baby right before you go into prison then in prison though. The experience of being pregnant is probably horrible, and certainly giving birth unchained. Then when the baby comes you get to breastfeed if that's something you want to do and hold your baby for more than 10 minutes. And I guess in 11 years it means you missed like 5th grade graduation, but other than that it's not like 10 vs 11 is super relevant.
- dang 4y agoOk, but please don't fulminate on HN. Perhaps you don't owe fraudster mothers better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Waterluvian 4y agoSo that’s what… 9.5 years minimum? I can’t picture someone with such an inflated sense of self-worth finding that to be acceptable. How’s she not making this worse for herself by trying to flee or something?
- vkou 4y agoI doubt her passport still works, and I likewise doubt that she still has (or ever had) the right friends to disappear without one.
- Waterluvian 4y agoHmmmm yeah I guess she was never actually part of the elite billionaire club of people with seemingly limitless power.
- googlryas 4y ago24 months and then "house arrest"
- deathgripsss 4y agoIf it's a federal sentence I don't think they will be that lenient
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt’s federal. So an absolute minimum of 85% of the sentence.
- googlryas 4y agoIf one of the guys who was selling children into prison (cash for kids) was able to get on to house arrest before 85%, I'm sure she will be able to find a way.
- Waterluvian 4y ago
- dang 4y agoAll: we had a flurry of threads about this all at once, which isn't surprising, but the comments they got were almost all bad (for HN)—cheap and reflexive rather than thoughtful and reflective. We want the latter, not the former*, so please take a moment to reflect before commenting, and if you'd make sure you're up on https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html we'd appreciate that too. * https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=reflective%20reflex%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- AustinDev 4y agoDo any of the patients she defrauded have civil suits against her / Thernos?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThey would have to be able to show some damages, which would be quite hard.
- moistly 4y agoDo the families of patients who died have any recourse? It’s an affront to justice that she seems to have gotten away with what’s effectively murder or manslaughter.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoWho died? They failed to demonstrate patient harm in court. The best they prosecution could find was one person who got a false positive for HIV and was retested and found negative.
- moistly 4y agoAh. I haven’t followed this case, and have seen claims of misdiagnosis and patient harm. I assumed this had led to tragic outcomes.
- donedeals 4y agoShe was found not guilty on the patient related matters.
- munk-a 4y agoIf we're talking about financial damage done this sentencing still feels exceedingly light. We have a real double standard - there are people in jail for longer for possession. Edit to clarify: My statement is more intended to emphasize how overly punishing possession charges rather than to advocate for draconian charges for all offenses.
- tptacek 4y agoA federal 10 year sentence is a very severe punishment. There's virtually no parole federally; once you're in, you're in.
- the-printer 4y agoIf her stay in “the Feds” is anything like the experiences I’ve heard of from people who are not her gender nor her race, it’s quite possible that she’ll be giving lectures in the Metaverse by 2026.
- KerrAvon 4y agoI'm a native English speaker and I'm having trouble parsing this. Could you clarify?
- martinald 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoNo.
- fuckstick 4y ago
- the-printer 4y ago
- codex_irl 4y agoOut of curiosity, does anyone know what happened to all of the Theranos hardware / technology after the company was shut down? e.g. the edison testing machines
- arthurcolle 4y agoWhat is the value of IP that doesn't work? Edison machine IP seems about as useful as those time travel or perpetual motion machine patents that come up.
- jen20 4y agoI'd imagine those machines in particular would be useful as museum pieces.
- codex_irl 4y agoThat is what I am thinking.
- jliptzin 4y agoCollectibles…definitely a market there
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoI would very much like a Theranos Edison for my office, next to a Juicero.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI feel really bad for her children, I can't believe she had the gall to have them given this inevitability. I'm also of the mind that people shouldn't go to prison for non-violent crime (some extreme form of probation seems more effective to me), but that's an entirely different story.
- trentnix 4y agoShe had children specifically hoping it would help her avoid harsh punishment. She’s a manipulative sociopath…having children was more of the same.
- whyenot 4y agoI am not aware of any statement from her or those close to her that confirms your assertion. She is 38 years old. If she wants children, it's now or never. She might be a terrible person, but that doesn't change the realities of female biology.
- trentnix 4y agoI’m not sure that analysis is any more flattering. She had children knowing she was at serious risk of significant incarceration. Pretty awful situation she’s created for innocent children.
- micromacrofoot 4y agonot the kids fault though
- prepend 4y agoI find it odd that she found love and married. It seems like a pretty big negative that someone would have to get over to meet and love someone who defrauded billions of dollars.
- finexplained 4y agoI mean, she's attractive, smart, pretty good genetics, clearly well connected. I don't find it that surprising.
- mothsonasloth 4y agoThis is not the first and won't be the last case of its kind. The interesting thing politically is if this will be enforced or not, as I am sure there are a lot of Silicon valley founders worrying now. At best they will get some deserved extra scrutiny, at worse will be getting investigated. I've seen talk about Holmes' political connections, but she surely is too toxic for them to get her a "free pass". She might get relief from somewhere else though?
- jeffbee 4y agoWhy would anyone be "worried about this" unless they, too, were running a big scam? Theranos did not fail it was just crime from start to finish.
- dheera 4y agoHonestly, I couldn't care less about the sentences for Holmes and Bankman-Friend. You know who I want locked up? - The guy who pushed someone into the tracks on the NYC subway - The guy who poured sulfuric acid on a woman in NYC - The guy who attacked elderly Asian women in SF - The guy who attacked elderly Asian women in Oakland - The guy who spit on a friend in San Francisco 2 weeks ago - The guy who raped Chanel Miller - The guy who raped another unnamed victim at Stanford recently - The ones running around South Bay smashing small businesses, smashing cars, sometimes while people are in them Unfortunately the government doesn't give a flying f about locking the people who are ACTUAL threats to the safety of me and my friends, and busy dealing with locking up some startup founders, who admittedly are disgusting, but not nearly as disgusting as the above.
- zzleeper 4y agoYou know, they could easily go after both groups no? We often feel we are in a XOR situation, but it's often easier for the govt to try to consistently enforce rules independently of the faces attached to the accused.
- bilekas 4y agoThis. It's almost sad to see that people equate completely different crimes with each other. To be honest it's actually a bit refreshing to see someone actually receive a significant charge for financial crimes such as investment fraud. So often it seems white collar crime goes largely unpunished.
- asveikau 4y agoI think Holmes did actual damage that equals or surpasses some of these violent acts you enumerate. Medical tests that don't work is a serious crime. There are serious consequences to, say, an HIV test that doesn't work right. And she sold that with full knowledge that it didn't work. Of course, she's being prosecuted for financial crimes and not this... I guess they got Al Capone on taxes.
- dheera 4y ago
- kkielhofner 4y agoYou know what REALLY bothers me about this? She (possibly) gets pregnant during the first trial to garner sympathy. Even if you have a charitable interpretation of this only the worst of the worst narcissistic sociopaths decide to "start a family" when they're potentially facing 15 years in Federal Prison. She's currently pregnant with her second child. Now those kids get to grown up without a mother and live the rest of their lives with the knowledge or at least suspicion they're in this world because their con-artist mother was trying to manipulate the justice system. Even IF you take the approach that she thought big and failed, doing no real wrong the situation with her pregnancies (in my mind) isn't up for debate. On this issue alone I find her completely reprehensible.
- jliptzin 4y agoIt is terrible if that was the reason, but as for the kids, plenty of kids grow up with one parent or raised by grandparents, aunts/uncles, or adoptive parents.
- kkielhofner 4y agoEven if it wasn't the reason I don't think it's a stretch to say the seed of doubt that this situation plants in the minds of these children will likely cause a lot of completely unnecessary psychological damage.
- bigmattystyles 4y agoOr she's 38 and her fertility window is closing. I'll hold many things against her, she deserves prison time, but I won't hold having a child against her or judge her for it. She may be doing it for the reasons you mentioned, but so many women go to prison with far fewer resources to care for their children while they're in. I doubt she thought any seasoned judge would take it into consideration.
- loeg 4y agoAnd she will be out before she's 50 and be able to have some relationship with her kids. I agree with you (and not the grandparent comment) -- I can't hold this against her.
- tptacek 4y agoIn a previous thread, I had this at "more than 10 years, less than 60" (yeah, that's an easy bet to make!). The core driver of the sentence is probably the guidelines 2B1.1 table, which scales sentencing levels by economic losses. She was convicted for something like $140MM in fraudulent losses, which by themselves ask for a 24-level escalation (the table maxes out in the mid-40s). By the numbers, the court was probably quite lenient here. Not to say that's an unjust outcome; the "lenient" option for sentencing on serious federal felonies is still quite harsh. Edit I tracked down the prosecutor's sentencing memorandum; they asked for 15 years. So I guess maybe not that lenient. Later edit The PSR (the court's own sentencing memorandum, which the prosecution and defense respond to) had Holmes at level 43. I hereby claim that I called this. :P But the PSR looks at the guidelines level table, which suggests 960 months for level 43, and instead recommends 108 months. So the court imposed a sentence higher than the PSR, lower than the prosecution asked, and all parties asked for much lower than the guideline maximum for the level. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29790880 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29790880 Later later edit I'm doing the math wrong; the guidelines range at that level is 240 months per charge (usually served consecutively). Still much higher than the ultimate sentence.
- ryoshu 4y agoFTX is over $1 billion and the table maxes out at $550 million, so that should be fun. Lawmakers should revisit that.
- tptacek 4y agoThat's true, and it does mean that once you hit $550MM, you might as well keep going, but on the flip side, the full sentence accelerator for 2b1.1 at $550MM gets you above 20 years by itself.
- geraldwhen 4y agoI’d wager bankman-fried is going to disappear, or mysteriously die in India. Gerry Cotton had far less money on the table and he supposedly died abroad.
- Qtips87 4y ago
- jasonhansel 4y agoInteresting to compare this with the ongoing FTX disaster. I think these two cases are sort of parallels: people assumed that someone was a genius to such an extent that they disregarded any signs of fraud and sought little proof of the assertions being made.
- wpride 4y agoAlso, accumulating powerful backers and friends to signal "this is a successful company" instead of building an actual company.
- throw422223 4y ago[flagged]
- sesm 4y agoThe primate behavior part doesn’t make sense to me. As a primate, I don’t want females in my tribe to mate with low value males.
- 0xy 4y agoSBF will get a lower sentence or might even dodge jail altogether considering how many political palms he's greased, including throughout the current administration.
- jasonhansel 4y agoI'd give it a couple months.
- shapefrog 4y agoI would happily suggest that Elizabeth Holmes was orders of magnitude BETTER connected than SBF.
- DuckFeathers 4y agoBut Holmes did not donate hundreds of millions to various groups and definitely did not help launder large amounts of money from war torn country. You have to be connected closer to the swamp to be protected by them.
- wilsonnb3 4y agoI hope everyone learns their lesson from this - only lie to poor people. Someday we will have to reckon with the fact that SV founder culture encourages this kind of behaviour.
- khazhoux 4y agoNo, it does not encourage this behavior. And that’s why Elizabeth Holmes sucks. SV thrives on trust, not on deceipt. There’s a big difference between a founder saying “I’m going to change the world!”, which is optimism mixed with naïveté, versus a founder saying “my technology works!” when they know it does not.
- walrus01 4y agoI mean this in the nicest way possible, but are you old enough to have been around for the "dotcom 1.0" boom money, VC funding, startups and irrational exuberance of investment in anything tech related from 1995-2000? It's always been like this.
- khazhoux 4y agoYyup, I’ve been here a long time. I’m not saying there hasn’t been fraud, but the SV Way is not to outright lie about the core technology, as EH did. Dotcom 1.0 was full of hucksters and it rightly crashed. The hasn’t been the norm in this newer era of YC, A16Z, First Round, etc. Integrity is valued and expected.
- xiphias2 4y agoHow much can she decrease it with good behaviour? (which she will probably have, as I'm not expecting her to do anything bad there). Maybe she gets out after 5 years, which is hopefully enough for her to not start something similar again.
- nixgeek 4y agoYou can only get 54 days per year of good time credit and there is no parole in the Federal system, she is nearly guaranteed to serve ~9 years.
- Qtips87 4y agoIn his sentencing statement, Judge Edward Davila said the case was "troubling on so many levels." "What went wrong? This is sad because Ms. Holmes is brilliant.” Brilliant of what? Of dressing in black turtleneck and imitating Steve Jobs? Able to lower her voice one octave down?
- vagrantJin 4y ago> What went wrong? This is sad because Ms. Holmes is brilliant. This statement right here. The fact that a supposedly impartial judge is having a crisis of reasoning... The joke being "all equal before the law", the punchline being that aristocrat/peasant social structure is doing better than ever inside a self-proclaimed "republic"
- Laforet 4y agoThe laws of the republic are only as impartial as the people enforcing them. Unfortunately charisma works in mysterious ways.
- leobg 4y agoIsn’t the argument, “This is especially bad because she had the foundation to use her intelligence in ways not useful to society. She took to crime not because she was raised in the wrong milieu or saw no other chance to survive with what she had. She took to crime by choice. Not only did she caused damage by what she did. She also caused society damage by withholding her talents, for which society, too, had paid, from real tasks facing us.”
- vagrantJin 4y agoI am merely pointing out something we can all see, but pretend not to. Can you imagine the judge in a serial killers murder case going on about how talented the killer was in cutting up body parts and could have contributed to society by being a specialist amputator. Poor thing just made a bad choice. Now we put away such a talented amputator in prison and the world is darker for it. Oh woe!
- 4y ago
- tacker2000 4y agoGood. She was a fraud and misled everyone in a big way: investors, patients, etc… White collar crime needs to be punished. Or “held accountable for”
- shapefrog 4y ago> She was a fraud and misled everyone in a big way: investors, patients, etc… ONLY guilty of defrauding investors - not guilty of defrauding patients. "Holmes was acquitted on three charges relating to patients who received inaccurate test results but found guilty on four charges, including one count of conspiracy to defraud investors and three counts of wire fraud against investors." Which makes me wonder - if your product is not defrauding customers, then how is it that you are defrauding investors ...
- bnjms 4y ago> Which makes me wonder - if your product is not defrauding customers, then how is it that you are defrauding investors ... I believe a distinction is being made where Theranos the company is understood to have defrauded customers but it cannot be proven that Holmes directly defrauded all customers. Where it can be proven that she directly defrauded investors given she was aware of the fraud against customers.
- shapefrog 4y agoShe fully embraced the startup grindset, faked it till she made it (she didnt get there) and moved fast and broke things - emulating the heros around her. In the end she goes to jail for being a bad investment for investors and not for the "crime" of fucking around with peoples health.
- LarsDu88 4y agoKill regular folks -- totally fine, barely an inconvenience Make rich people lose some money -- off to jail with ye!
- drstewart 4y agoWho got killed?
- joe463369 4y agoThat's hard to determine and presumably why she wasn't prosecuted for it. It's certainly believable that people received false assurances about their health from Theranos that ultimately led to a preventable death.
- eberkund 4y agoPeople who made health choices based on faulty test results.
- josho 4y agoThere's 2 signs of intelligence that I've seen. First, coming up with something new and novel, e.g. being the first to decide that we can move fast & break things. The second is knowing when to apply patterns, e.g. applying the lessons learned from other startups. Holmes showed her lack of intelligence by applying those startup patterns to a highly regulated industry. To get her product into some of those settings required committing fraud. So, the whole move fast and break things works great for startups, it fails miserably in healthcare. She didn't know better, and even worse didn't know when to apply a different pattern.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoA light sentence that just encourages fraud. You can become a billionaire in exchange for 10 years of your life napping. Why work for 40 years?
- l33tc0de 4y agoDon't think she became a billionaire at the end
- dhfbshfbu4u3 4y ago
- maximus-decimus 4y agoYou think that if he were sent to a private prison, he could just buy it?
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoIs it spelled out clearly what exactly Elizabeth Holmes was convicted of committing investor fraud for? Was it this? > Holmes admitted on the stand that Theranos was running blood tests on modified third-party machines without telling its business partners and that she added the logos of two pharmaceutical companies to studies that the company sent to investors. This seems like everyday, standard startup procedure. Was there a lot more?
- tptacek 4y agoYes. There was a lot more.
- mrkramer 4y agoTheranos used Siemens machines to perform blood tests instead of their "miracle" machines. German engineers know how to get the job done!
- soperj 4y agoThey didn't work with the amount of blood that they were providing.
- oldgradstudent 4y agoThey were using smaller amounts of blood and diluting them outside the machines' spec. Not much even German engineers can do about that.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWhy can't she claim they made some dumb modification - and combined with using the Siemans machine out of spec - that it was the "Theranos Machine"? This seems like startup 101. On one hand, I can see why it's fraud. On the other hand, I can't - because it seems indistinguishable from a lot of businesses.
- voisin 4y ago
- celestialcheese 4y ago135 months, for defrauding and conspiring to defraud 3 of the largest investors of $140MM. If we follow this sentencing as a guide for future cases brought against SBF & co, should we expect 1 mo per $MM defrauded, so 8,000 months, or 666 years(!) ? Or should we look at it like 45mo per investor defrauded, so 45,000,000 months? Either way, I think this is probably a fair sentence and more than I expected. 11.25 years isn't trivial, and as long as there isn't some early release or she wins a more lenient sentence on appeal, it's going to be a painful 11 years, especially since she's about to be a new mother. Feel bad for the kid..
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThere no way all of that will be served in a prison.
- celestialcheese 4y agoAre you guessing here or is there something I missed in the article? Her sentence starts in April '23 and it's not house arrest.
- gopled 4y agoThis guy called it back in 2013: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6349808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6349808 The whole thread is an interesting read in retrospect, quite a mix of effusiveness and skepticism: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6349349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6349349
- holyharvey 4y ago
- xwdv 4y agoAgreed. I hope they learned that sometimes the devil comes dressed as everything you ever wanted.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoWhat the GP said never happened.
- xwdv 4y agoWhat is this revisionist history? It certainly happened, I saw it for myself with my own eyes.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoNot in the link that was given.
- system2 4y agoThanks for sharing this. It was a trip to read all those comments with what we know right now.
- nunez 4y agoone of the most legendary posts on Hacker News, for sure. this is the only thing that person posted, and it was 100% spot on YEARS before the fall. this person HAD to be an insider, no question.
- dfraser992 4y agoBetween this and FTX, I am really starting to think the death penalty ought to be applicable for financial crimes beyond a certain magnitude. The intangible cost to society / peoples' lives is incalculable, but given the fundamental hypocrisy of the West anymore, the only thing that truly matters is money, especially rich people's money and thus grifters and con artists like SBF and Trump are allowed to skate by with a slap on the wrist. 11 years (no way is she serving that) is a slap on the wrist.
- mrkramer 4y agoDeath penalty would perhaps be suitable if customers died because of Theranos' faulty products. I'm not familiar with this case in detail but I know she scammed patients with her blood tests. Imagine your doctor scamming you with your health records?! That reminds me of a horror movie Jigsaw where main antagonist gets his cancer X-ray record mixed up with other patient's record. I agree 11 years is a light sentence. If I was judge I would give her 20 years.
- from 4y agoWould society be any better off if she got 20 years vs 11 years (also accounting for the $300000 those 9 years would cost the government)? I guess read https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/elizabeth-holmes-sentence-11-years-theranos-fraud-much-rcna57742 https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/elizabeth-holmes-sente... and see if it changes your mind. Her life is basically ruined with the only consolation being the fact that her husband is rich and I doubt any would be fraudster would repeat what she did if they knew they could get 11 years for it. I think there is a case to be made for penalizing some of the more calculated frauds, like there is a huge Medicare fraud problem and there'll be cases with loss amounts in the millions where people get 2-3 years which in my opinion is too low to have a deterrent effect. But giving her any more just seems cruel and would ultimately just hinder whatever restitution she is supposed to make.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI have the inverse opinion. I think the cost to society for these types of financial crimes is minimal, and close to zero. She wasted some specific investors money, which is bad. However, the financial crime has basically no impact on the average person.
- Jerry2 4y agoI guess we finally know what the price for "Fake it till you make it" is: 11 years.
- jongjong 4y agoMore like the price of "Fake it till you break it." I don't think there is any price if you end up making it.
- Alex3917 4y agoNot that I don't think Elizabeth Holmes deserves this sentence, but when was the last time you heard about an investor get sentenced to a decade in prison for saying they'd make valuable introductions (or whatever) as part of the investment process and then not following through?
- realgeniushere 4y agoThat’s not how sentencing works in this country. The specific crime you were convicted of determines the possible range of sentences. Then judge considers a multitude of factors to determine exact sentence. This includes prior offenses and also all “relevant conduct”, i.e. the totality of your wrongdoing, not just what you were specifically convicted of. Also, not sure what you’re on about re: failing to make introduction. She claimed to have revolutionary blood tests that worked, but they were useless and she knew it. It was blatant lying and fraud to the tune of millions of dollars. Not to mention all the doctors and patients who thought they got accurate test results and relied on them.
- robswc 4y agoI'll have to watch a doc or something but two quick questions if anyone knows: Was this even in the realm of possibility? What lead her to start this company? Was it 90% scam, 10% "trying" or just 100% scam? Thanks!
- rawgabbit 4y agoComplete scam. Her Stanford professor gave several interviews where the prof said she told Holmes her technology is not scientifically possible. All the execs at Theranos knew it didn’t work. That was why they secretly outsourced work to traditional laboratories. Then there was the whistle blower Tyler Schultz. He got roughed up by Theranos lawyers at his own grandfathers house. His grandfather was George Schultz former US Sec of State and Theranos board member. The lawyers wanted him to admit he gave away “trade secrets”. The trade secret is Holmes and everyone at Theranos belong in prison. https://www.fraud-magazine.com/cover-article.aspx?id=4295006794 https://www.fraud-magazine.com/cover-article.aspx?id=4295006...
- wilsonnb3 4y agoI still can't get over the fact that so many rich people invested in this thing and joined the board despite anyone with the scientific knowledge to understand what Theranos said they were doing knew it was a scam. How to you invest millions in a medical/science company and not ask some impartial third parties if they think it is legit?
- rawgabbit 4y agoHolmes also scammed Harvard Medical School. HMS invited her to join their Board of Fellows despite Phyllis Gardner's loud protests, the very same Stanford professor who met Holmes years earlier. Phyllis Gardner was on the same Board of Fellows and told everyone else that Holmes was a fraud. Harvard ignored Phyllis Gardner as all they could see was $$$. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/11/3/elizabeth-holmes-hms-fellows/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/11/3/elizabeth-holme...
- yesenadam 4y ago
- transfire 4y agoWhatever. The real downside here is that research funding in the field of blood testing will be decimated for them next 20 years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themihai 4y agoTo be honest I thought she will get away with no prison time like the Sacklers but I guess her powerful friends were not that powerful after all. Not enough $ in the game.
- Ptchd 4y agoI would rather see her see no prison and the Sacklers get life....
- batch12 4y agoI know that people are mostly happy about this this-- and I'm definitely in the minority, but I feel that watching someone lose 11 years of her life in slow motion is not something to be celebrated. It's sad. Secondly, I know it's a pipe dream, but I'd rather see her contribute something back to society (if this is society's retribution) than drain money from us so we can keep her caged.
- batch12 4y agoI feel pretty strongly about this, so please use this opportunity to hit me twice instead of telling me why I'm wrong.
- ddoolin 4y agoI just think it's possible to be both. Happy that the justice system functions as intended (which many see as increasingly rare) but also sad for her as a person to lose so much of her life behind bars.
- bitexploder 4y agoYou are using empathy for her, which is great. Losing a decade of your life sucks. You don’t get that many years to begin with. Committing fraud sucks though. You can’t just do that and then say you are sorry and “contribute to society” to make up for it. There are so very many terrible things about our justice system, however lying and committing fraud at this scale absolutely must have consequences, especially to deter others from attempting the same sort of fraud.
- sbassi 4y agoso how do you disincentivize prospective criminals to do this in the future?
- batch12 4y agoGood question. Maybe take what they took, garnish future wages, have them make some kind of restitution, or something similar. I think if prison sentences were applied reasonably, reliably, and objectively they'd be a better deterrent. For instance, if it wasn't a gamble worth taking, if the consequences were guaranteed and applied evenly, I think people wouldn't risk this kind of fraud. Overcompensating by applying rare and lengthy prison sentences as a warning just makes this akin to a ghost story that rich people tell each other.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoAs I predicted, @mikeyouse https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=mikeyouse https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=mikeyouse and I both owe $10 to charity, per our bet (more than 3 for me, less than 15 for him). I shall pay, of course. For you, sir, you can either give directly to Lighthouse Ministries (lfrad.org), or if you want to be sure it's tax-deductible, you can give to Martha's Kitchen in San Jose with a note that it's intended for Lighthouse. (They're a tax-exempt in California but their IRS 501(c)(3) hasn't come through yet.) Martha's acts as financial sponsor for them, which has some legal significance I don't quite understand.
- mikeyouse 4y agoSounds good - I'll donate right now. Lighthouse is good with me. In a way, I'm glad we both lost that bet. Side note, I previously worked with nonprofit fiscal sponsors - basically Martha's uses their (c)(3) to incubate specific initiatives like Lighthouse and handle all of their compliance / HR / legal for a small fee on the donations.
- Cupertino95014 4y agohi, yeah, I don't mind losing the bet at all. I see the gleaner from Lighthouse all the time while walking the dog, so that's how I know them. Founded by a three-strikes guy!
- Cupertino95014 4y agoDone. (I first looked for L & L Foundation, which pointed me to something in Singapore https://www.llf.org.sg/how-to-help/donations https://www.llf.org.sg/how-to-help/donations) but I got suspicious and found your original link.) ================= Thank You for Your Donation! Thank you for your gift to The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society (LLS). Your kindness is bringing new hope to blood cancer patients across the country. Thank you for your gift to The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society (LLS). Your kindness is bringing new hope to blood cancer patients across the country. Thanks to you, we will: - Invest in innovative research and help deliver safer, more effective treatments - Connect patients and caregivers with free education and support services - Advocate at the state and national level to advance healthcare access
- sigstoat 4y agothe "she'll never be convicted" crowd has moved on to "she'll never serve much of the sentence", despite a dozen folks here explaining how the federal system works. i look forward to returning to HN in september 2032 and seeing what what sort of cope is on display when she's released after 9.5 years. will we have holmes-prison truthers? "she was never in prison, it was a body double the whole time!". it'll be fascinating.
- hnarayanan 4y agoI am literally a member of this crowd. Let’s see how this plays out.
- breck 4y agoContrarian opinion: the real villians in this story are the morons who told a young bright college student that patents and building in secret were good strategies. #BuildInPublic #LiberateIdeas
- tonymet 4y agoKenneth Lay got 45 years for enron. When will we finally bridge the female equality gap . Equal crimes equal times.
- voisin 4y agoEnron was publicly traded and the fraud affected a huge number of people, retirement plans, etc. Holmes defrauded a few dozen investors that quite honestly should’ve known better.
- specialist 4y agoEnron orchestrated power blackouts. IIRC, some people were harmed.
- chadlavi 4y agoShe deserves much harsher than this for the harm she did to real people, which she sadly got off without a scratch for. As far as defrauding rich people, that's basically a public service. It's not surprising that the one she got got for was the one where she hurt rich people.
- throwaway5959 4y agoThis woman likely killed people (directly via suicide, indirectly via false tests). This sentence is light IMO.
- 627467 4y agoHey, maybe years ago when Theranos was first accused of fraud this sort of speculation (crappy test resulta leading to deaths) would have made sense. But years of airing dirty laundry in public on this case have not brought forth any such claims, from family members etc. If we are to place bets and speculate, I would bet no one was actually killed by this. But I'm not trying to argue this is a fair sentence. Just saying that we don't need to keep throwing random speculative argument with hypothetical crimes years later.
- throwaway5959 4y agoYou’re right, the crimes she was convicted of in the court of law allow for a tougher sentence.
- wilsonnb3 4y agoThis is probably pedantic but since she is still alive, I highly doubt that she killed anyone directly via suicide
- holyharvey 4y agoBased.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoOuch! She got married, has a kid and is pregnant. The cynical side of me says that she did all that to get some leniency. It did not work.
- swyx 4y agotwo comments upthread from you: "this sentencing still feels exceedingly light."
- impulser_ 4y agoSo if Martin Shkreli got 7 years for fraud, Elizabeth Holmes got 11 years for fraud. Does this mean SBF is looking at life in prison? Hard to see why stealing billions of your customers money to spend gambling and buying personal items then lying about it multiple time isn't a bigger crime than what those two were sentenced for.
- themagician 4y agoSBF will probably get off with no sentence or a very light sentence. Hell, he might not even get charged. Martin basically ASKED for prison. Instead of apologizing, or claiming ignorance, he sort of doubled down on arrogance. Homles did largely the same thing. She doubled down. SBF is apologizing left and right, claiming ignorance, and admitting that he made a mistake (even if it was 100% intentional). That goes a long way. Longer than you'd think. Most of the people he defrauded have little power over him. SBF knows how to play the game. He's been playing it since Day 1. When in doubt, lie. But keep your lies consistent. A good lie is easier to believe than the truth. Because if you believe it, they believe it.
- from 4y ago"Acceptance of responsibility" is like -3 points on the guidelines. That won't change the fact that he's still at like +40 points for the enormous loss amount, the huge number of victims, and the number of victims who suffered hardship. Even if they depart downward (they probably will because he will likely have the one of the best legal teams ever assembled and the most persuasive sentencing memorandum ever drafted) they are unlikely to depart by as much as you're talking about. SBF will probably get at least the sentence of Holmes unless he gets the most naive judge in the world.
- propogandist 4y agoSBF will be out fund raising again soon, he won’t see any time behind bars. -20 thanks to political bribes & connections, -5 helping with Ukraine’s money laundering, -12, based on the points Kanye has made.
- 4y ago
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoI mean what she did was very wrong, but murderers get out in less time
- black_13 4y ago
- pipeline_peak 4y agoSuch bullshit, I might as well do shady shit too if all it means is 11 years… Let me guess, Sunny gets 20
- syspec 4y agoShe has to surrender by April 27th. How does that work? Usually I thought after your trial, at sentencing... that's it, you go away in handcuffs
- from 4y agoNot unless you're considered a flight risk or a danger to the community. People usually sell their house, car, cancel utilities, say goodbyes, etc. It's pretty sad to be honest (not saying that most of it isn't deserved).
- andirk 4y ago> long sentence for Ms. Holmes was important to “deter future start-up fraud schemes” That is not how justice works. Each case must be taken by itself. So gross how people throw around this "sends a message!" bullshit so flippantly when it clearly means "the punishment will not fit the crime as we have added a bunch on to scare other people".
- s1artibartfast 4y agoDeterrence is a long accepted part of sentencing in the US. You might not like it, clearly how punishment works. Get a fine for speeding or littering and it will have no relation to the damage you did.
- andirk 4y agoDeterrence is seeing justice in action. All sentencing, like speeding and littering fines, are supposed to hurt _just enough_ to deter one from doing it, but not in excess. 8th Amendment "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted." uses the word "excessive" twice. All of this is opinionated since quantifying justice is often pretty difficult. https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-8 https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-8
- s1artibartfast 4y agoSounds entirely compatible with sending a message. Message =/= excessive
- jen20 4y agoYou mean “long-established” not “long-accepted”.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI agree that they are different but would argue that both apply
- fortran77 4y agoI suppose it wouldn't be feasible to bring charges against the board members, too? Even though they are also culpable. (I'm not saying that Holmes didn't get what she deserved.)
- seventytwo 4y agoThis needs to happen far more often.
- synergy20 4y agoOK, so what about Sam Bankman-Fried, will he be sued and sentenced too? when you mess up billions of dollars can you get out untouched in the end?
- Cupertino95014 4y agobtw, I'm listening to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFFxLwvGLhU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFFxLwvGLhU right now, so I don't know if he covers this later. He's right that she will soon give an interview where she admits guilt, no matter what she says now. It's a ploy to get a commutation. But: There is such a thing as a prison consultant. You pay for them before you go in. These are people with some background in the bureau of prisons, or some pull, or something. They can steer you to a "good" prison, if the one you're designated for is not what you want. My friend was supposed to go to one near his house, and he preferred a different one. He got it. It was not a country club, contrary to the stereotype. (Should be unnecessary to say this, but I'm not going to provide any more details.) The guy in that video said that they could be pissed off at her, and ship her across the country to West Virginia, instead of Dublin, CA. The thing about that you wouldn't think of is, those trips are hell. It's a special flight, It might stop eight times on the way, and every step of the way you're cuffed or chained, waiting a long time for the next flight.
- kilroy123 4y agoThat was a great video actually. Very eye opening.
- vadym909 4y agoUnfortunately, I think the sentence is appropriate and hope it serves as a lesson. We have too many startup founders today that think lying, cheating and defrauding investors, customers, employees are table stakes or worse "hacking it" or faking it till you make it- is OK and justified. Look at how casual SBF seems even after being caught as a fraud. There's no remorse. Its disgusting to many Americans who work hard, follow the rules and make low wages doing an honest job.
- bmitc 4y agoIt is pretty frustrating to me that Holmes was only ever convicted of defrauding investors and not patients.
- ktln2 4y agoNot familiar with legal issues - can someone explain why Adam Neumann is free but Holmes is in jail? Isn't both committing fraud from investor POV? And is SBF committing the same crime?
- kumarvvr 4y agoAdam Neumann had a failed business model. He explained his business model. Investors believed in the business model. They invested. But the business model, and his PR image dents caused them to lose money. Holmes had a vision of a business model. She explained her business model and brought on a board of directors of leering old farts. Investors also believed in the vision and invested in her to achieve the vision. She tried to achieve her vision, but failed miserably. Instead of telling investors and regulators and business partners about the failure, she hid the failure, covered up by using industry standard practices for medical testing, passing them off as testing from her products. As a cherry on the top, she also used her comically in-accurate products to give actual test results to patients. As a cherry on top of the cherry, all the while this was happening, she had an affair with another investor, went on a PR blitz of fame whoring and the like. When the chickens came to roost, she pitched up her voice, started wearing feminine colorful dresses, got pregnant for sad puppy new mom face points. She is a psychopath and a danger to society.
- ergocoder 4y agoYou forgot that she also hired people to harass her own employees. One committed suicide. Comparing Holmes to Neumann is an insult to even Neumann.
- foxhill 4y agodoes this not describe - modulo some specifics - elon musk? where is full self driving? solar roof tiles? the manned mars landing? holmes deserves punishment on some level, certainly, although honestly i feel 10+ years might be a bit much. where is this zeal for her male analogues? they’re all playing the same game.
- 4y ago
- snotrockets 4y agoJust imagine how much less she's had to serve if she was a man.
- zeruch 4y agoGood. She got off easy.
- meltyness 4y agoHow is a company supposed to fail gracefully? There's always a touch of dishonesty in these ventures -- it's so-called risk -- but when a company no longer is worth anything, how is that supposed to fail blamelessly? It's a wonder that "Computer (occupation)"[0] never became a corporation with unions so that we'd have a case study of something that clearly should have gone by the wayside with the advent of technology. Maybe there are some guidelines for business models that even make sense. Apparently Theranos illustrates that "accusing everyone else of being a lazy liar with stagnant investment" isn't workable either. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_(occupation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_(occupation)
- anshumankmr 4y agoBased.
- wycliffb 4y agoNot bad for that kind of money. Not bad...
- anon291 4y agoThis is going to be the unpopular take, but this woman committed a crime that is very easy to prevent. Blacklist her from taking any further investments or being CEO or any executive officer. There's really no reason to feed and house her. She should work for her money and we don't need to ruin a child's life. The primary purpose of imprisonment is to keep dangerous (i.e, violent) offenders off the street. Violence is especially bad because it is difficult for the government to prevent all violence, so drastic measures like prison make sense. It is fairly straightforward to stop holmes from doing what she did again using other means. I dunno, just my take. And yes, I feel this way about most white collar crime. Like it or not, white collar crime is not violent; thus prison seems pointless and like a waste of money.
- leobg 4y agoAgreeing with what you say. But the criminal system’s purpose is not just prevention. Actually, nobody is really sure what its purpose is. Why do parents, when they get really angry, sometimes hit a child? Psychology has proven that doing so is a really terrible way of preventing further infractions. So the impulse to punish is not necessarily rational. A whole religion has been built on the idea of consciously letting go of the urge to judge and punish - and it hasn’t worked out for 2000 years. So one reason why the government punishes criminals is to take the wind out of the sails of all the private parties that otherwise would cry for punishment of that person, or take it into that own hands. In that sense, it is essentially a power move by the state in order to remain in control and “keep the peace”.
- faangiq 4y agoShe did something bad but 11 years feels like too long …
- nsxwolf 4y agoThese crimes were bad. But on the bright side, we got Alan Ruck’s finest performance on that Hulu show.
- faangiq 4y agoWhere is the jail time for Zuck? He nuked $750b in shareholder wealth. I eagerly await the sentencing.
- Ekaros 4y agoExtremely light sentence if you think money involved. There really should not be this sort of discount and some clear and simple math on prison time per amount of damages.
- emmelaich 4y ago> "I am devastated by my failings,” she said. “I have felt deep pain.." I am. I have. Still me me me. Narcissist.
- fmx 4y agoEven now she does not admit any responsibility. "I failed", not "I maliciously, knowingly, willingly committed crimes". Not surprising give that she plans to appeal, though. She is trying (as usual) to have her cake and eat it to: get credit for remorse during sentencing and still be able to claim she's not guilty at the appeal. Hence this cringeworthy non-apology apology.
- timwaagh 4y agoFor one thing let me say I'm glad she was sentenced. She took too much risk with the most precious things we have: our lives. However, I think there are a lot more in silicon valley et cetera who would be guilty of similar things she did. Elon Musk is known for having lied about his degree, for instance. Now I don't know whether that's enough. I really think it's not but it's a question to consider. Didn't someone at Twitter lie about bots as well? At least according to Elon. Holmes did go too far so she was nabbed. But it does beg the question whether this will set a precedent for anyone in the fast-talking fast-failing startup circles trying to 'fake it until you make it' or whether any precedent set will be limited to certain sectors, certain types of individuals et cetera. I guess silicon valley lawyers and startup accelerators will have to do their homework and figure out whether anything should change.
- tibbydudeza 4y ago5 years with good behavior or with political connections she can get a pardon say after 2 years.
- homeland221 4y agoOnly 11? Gosh she literally faking medical results with death consequence. At least Madoff only con "investment money" of the rich. Holmes literally play millions of poors their lives. Says a lot about gender equality and every American lives equality....guess George said it best....some are more equal than others.
- perlgeek 4y ago> Only 11? Gosh she literally faking medical results with death consequence I agree that her actions were egregious, but those weren't what the trial was about. The trial was about defrauding investors, not about defrauding customers. I don't know if there is a separate trial about that, or if it's too hard to proof harm in an individual case, or if nobody ever bothered. Hard to get money out of a failed company.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y ago> The trial was about defrauding investors, not about defrauding customers. Yeah, f@ck the customers. In the Capitalistic utopia of the USA, you cannot be allowed to embarrass the oligarchy, whether they work in private equity, the Fortune 100, or the military-industrial complex. They really are between a rock and a hard place with Holmes. She's obviously psychopathic enough to raise ungodly amounts of money, whatever the cost, but she embarrassed the wrong kind of people. So we wind up with a moderate sentence that means she will do hard time (to scare people away from outright fraud), but not too much (so she will be able to get back into the game after).
- rainbowzootsuit 4y agoPerhaps from a pragmatic perspective you could think that this was the easiest case to get a conviction on. The prosecution would be mindful to get that one first so they don't cause a double jeopardy acquittal if they miss on the case that is harder to prove, but more correct in a moral sense. They could now bring that case without worrying that she'll get away without repercussion.
- CrypticShift 4y agofake it until you make it...to prison.
- 0x4542 4y agoHey @dang, I’ll reply to your comment here, considering you seem to have blocked replying on your sticking comment… You can have as many rules and guidelines as you like, but you can’t go around stamping on people’s right to free speech, just because you don’t like them, especially when their comments aren’t offensive. Also, referring to other people’s comments as “cheap”, as if you somehow feel your opinion of others and the way they express themselves is somehow more authoritative than say, UN charter on Human Rights (the right to freedom of expression) gives me the impression you have little respect for others. “We want the later, not the former”. Ever heard the expression “‘I want’, never gets”? You appear to suffer from what I refer to as a “deluded sense of entitlement”. You have no right to try to censor people, or bully them, just because that’s what “we want”. I’ve been HN reader for quite a while. I enjoy the community, and the debate, it’s not a stinking cesspit like Reddit, but your comments are a step too far.
- yreg 4y ago>people’s right to free speech There is no "right to free speech on hn". This is a moderated forum with rules and guidelines. >it’s not a stinking cesspit like Reddit In no small part thanks to the guidelines and moderation.
- ak_111 4y agoI don't know who managed to blow their life more. With her intelligence, good looks, connections and charisma she could have easily been a Marissa Mayer 2.0 by hustling 10 times less than she did, if only she played it safe in any of the big tech companies. She could have easily had an 8 digit net worth by time she is 40. Instead she will be spending 11 years in prison. On the other hand her CFO made 50m by the time he was 30. Now he is going to be penniless spending most of his rest of his life in jail.
- jwmoz 4y agoSBF next.
- RadixDLT 4y agoand she got pregnant just in time
- firefoxkekw 4y ago11 years for literally putting lives at risk due to medical fraud, forget the money part for a moment. Someone may have lost a love one because of her, maybe it was a few? Hundreds? Who knows. But we are over 8 billion people in this world, do we really need people like this ever having a second chance to life? Medical fraud should be life sentence, at most, give her the opportunity to work from prison for the rest of her life. This type of people prey on the ingenuous and naive, nothing wrong with being ingenuous but for the rest of us, we should also call out the predators like Holmes and try to keep this predators out of society.
- tayistay 4y agoShe wasn’t convicted of defrauding patients, only investors.
- andix 4y agoSounds about right to me. Poor child though, but I don’t think it would be less poor growing up with such a person as their mum.
- jongjong 4y agoOnly government organizations and reserve banks are allowed to commit fraud.
- tayistay 4y agoMany comments here calling for harsh sentencing for these sorts of crimes. I can’t find much empirical evidence that long prison time is a good deterrent for this. Perhaps I’m not using the right keywords. Please reply if you know good references. I don’t think the dollar amounts matter much here, because those defrauded were rich and didn’t suffer significantly, AFAICT. (She wasn’t convicted of defrauding patients)
- dudeinjapan 4y ago8 years for fraud 2 years for theft of Steve Job's wardrobe 1 year for that ridiculous baritone voice
- cbeach 4y agoIt's odd that HN criticises Elizabeth Holmes less than it does Elon Musk. * One is a privileged charlatan who pretended to innovate, dicing with the health of innocent customers, and defrauding investors out of hundreds of millions of dollars. * The other is an African American who arrived in the USA with $2K dollars in his pocket and became wealthy by innovating on the Web, kick-starting electric transportation WORLDWIDE and making America a space-pioneering superpower again. I always hoped HN was a community of critical thinkers who orient towards innovation, science and truth. How did we get so caught up in tribal political BS? The media too - they hate Elon Musk more than they ever hated Epstein or Weinstein. We can, at least, be better than the media, can't we?
- dudul 4y agoWhat data do you have/use to claim that HN criticizes one more than the other?
- cbeach 4y agoI've followed HN over the last few weeks and there are literally hundreds of comments and posts from people being negative about Musk and Twitter (since it got taken over by Musk). Barely anything about Holmes. Amazon lays off 10,000 workers. Not a peep from HN. Musk's Twitter lays off less than 10,000 workers. Massive angst on HN.
- dudul 4y agoPlenty of negative comments on this thread. Basically it's just your feeling. No hard data.
- jen20 4y ago> followed HN over the last few weeks Holmes has not really been in the _news_ (the "N" of "HN") in the last few weeks, until this event which has attracted hundreds of posts. Musk, by contrast, has done lots of newsworthy things in the last few weeks. Such an attitude is like being surprised that people talk about Joe Biden more than George W Bush at the moment - the fact is there is simply more to talk about with the former than the latter.
- chaosbolt 4y agoMeanwhile SBF is free, and the people investigating him have all received donations from him in the past. 11 years is too much for Holmes, people have done much worse and gotten a lot less than that. My guess is the sets of people who lost money on Theranos and those who lost money on FTX don't intersect at all, the former is made of rich people and the latter of everyday people, so it makes more sense...