13 ms·
Alphabet Earnings Report Q3 2022 [pdf]
- wally38389 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scyzoryk_xyz 4y agoabc.xyz - what an incredible URL
- daveevad 4y agomy favorite clever google url hostname will continue to be their cdn's 1e100.net
- ilovecaching 4y agoThe price hike on Youtube premium is insane. I guess it makes sense when every other product you try to bring to market ends in failure. If Google is the creme de la creme of software engineering companies, full of absolute geniuses, why can't they think of a product that people actually want besides charging more/putting out more ads for the products they have?
- pvarangot 4y agoGeniuses in their underwear at home resting and vesting no make you money.
- ThalesX 4y agoYou'd think the largest tracking machine humanity has ever built would be able to tell whether their 'underwear'-clad engineers are implementing the assigned tasks as expected.
- pvarangot 4y agoThe assigned task is not working for the competition
- shadowgovt 4y agoThis is different from pre-2020 when they were in their underwear in the office. (... I've heard stories. ;) )
- wutbrodo 4y ago> If Google is the creme de la creme of software engineering companies, full of absolute geniuses, why can't they think of a product This question seems to answer itself? Engineering skills are not product skills, and Google kinda sucks at product
- peppertree 4y agoGoogle engineering team is supreme but product team is subpar.
- melony 4y agoI thought they are famous for their "APM program"? Is it simply overrated?
- adam_arthur 4y ago“Signs point to yes” But for real… it’s prestigious because it’s hard to get into, not because Google is great at product development. In practice Google’s product muscle has proven to be pretty weak
- s3r3nity 4y agoThey've been riding off that "fame" for like 20 years, but it's a completely different situation today vs. when the program was at its peak.
- zoltar 4y agoThe house that Marissa built.
- smaug7 4y agoWhile I don't necessarily disagree, my understanding is that engineering tends to drive more of the product decisions. I question how much power the product team actually has.
- shadowgovt 4y agoThat has ceased to be true in vast tracts of the company. Cloud, for example, is chasing feature parity with its competitors and engineers are told to implement things because AWS or Azure have them, not because they organically grew out of the architecture of the existing system. In fact, quite a few features annealed poorly onto the existing architecture (which users of Google Cloud may have memory of).
- lumost 4y agoI spotted this in my account. I was originally under the impression youtube premium would be 15 bucks a month... some how it's now up to 30 bucks a month. 6x AppleTV and 2x Netflix.
- ilovecaching 4y agoIt's 30 bucks because you're paying via Apple. Google hates the Apple cut so they are now charging an extra 8 dollars a month for not giving them direct access to your credit card info.
- smoldesu 4y agoAre they wrong to do so? It makes no sense for them to make less money on a competitor's platform. There's also no real alternative to YouTube Premium on iOS (see: sideloading limitations) so they could arguably charge $50 a month and retain most of their iOS customers. This is your reward for locking yourself in a room with two hungry corporations.
- alimov 4y ago> so they could arguably charge $50 a month and retain most of their iOS customers. Source?
- smoldesu 4y agoIt's hyperbole, but people would still buy it. On iOS, Google is allowed to monopolize YouTube and it shows us a dark vision for the future of platforms that enable this kind of lockdown. Google can treat the platform like a second class citizen, buy up latent iOS advertising, force people to use an inferior app and still profit handsomely off it, all at the same time. This doesn't have to be the case. But Apple's lockdown enables Google's tyranny, so there's really no other choice. On other platforms, I can install apps like NewPipe on watch YouTube in the background without needing to download anything from Google besides the videos I want. Google is not the savior of this story by any means, but they're not afraid to play Apple's game of turning iOS users into hostages.
- alphabetting 4y agoI've always been surprised that YouTube has been that profitable to begin with. 40k hours of video uploaded every hour and all the watch time is pretty mind boggling.
- jorams 4y agoI don't think they've ever released how profitable YouTube is? Only revenues. I've always assumed it's unprofitable given what must be ridiculous operational costs.
- crazygringo 4y agoHuh? For individual plans there's no hike ($12/mo.). Family plan went from $18 to $23, hardly insane. But now if you purchase via iOS instead of the web it's $30 because of the Apple 30% tax. So... don't do that. They are literally pushing you to subscribe via the web, so do that. The only thing insane is that Apple still takes a big cut of streaming/media subscriptions.
- browningstreet 4y ago$15 to $23. A bit insulting, TBH.
- crazygringo 4y agoNo, all news sources reporting the hike say it's been $18 previously, not $15. $18 to $23 is not insulting. It's still less than the price of two individual subscriptions.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoYou're both right. It was $15/mo, then the price went up to $18 but they didn't raise the price for existing subscribers, but this time they're raising the price for existing customers as well, so for the oldest customers, it's a 50%, $15->$23 hike, and for newer customers, it's a 27%, $18->$23 hike.
- indecisive_user 4y agoI have a family plan. I can confirm I pay $14.99 per month right now and received an email stating it will increase to $22.99. Perhaps I'm grandfathered into a cheaper plan, but that's my data point.
- shadowgovt 4y agoMost problems Google is trying to solve now outside their core competency and existing offerings are not, fundamentally, software engineering problems. Consider the saga of Stadia. The tech is rock-solid. That fact did nothing to address developers not wanting to risk a platform that might not have customers, customers not wanting to subscribe to a platform that may not have long-term support, game development itself being the world's biggest game of craps, entire swathes of the world lacking enough internet bandwidth for realtime streaming, and nobody trusting Google to lean into something at an operational loss for more than a few years anymore (with the exception-proving-the-rule of Cloud).
- _trampeltier 4y agoIn theorie, I was interested in Stadia, but a subscription but I still have to buy the game WTF. So of course I did not even try.
- UncleMeat 4y agoI think this is really interesting. Stadia didn't require a subscription. You could just buy games and play them. But loads of people came to the conclusion that you needed a subscription. My going hypothesis is that this was caused by the free trial of the subscription service (higher resolution, cheaper games) that everybody got when they launched. So since people couldn't access the games without getting the free trial they assumed that this meant that they couldn't access the games without a subscription.
- shadowgovt 4y agoYeah, that's high on the list of things that harmed the platform. Hypothetically, if they'd wanted to go a totally different direction, the could have courted game developers willing to create games for them that would have been offerable at a pure-subscription rate. But they chased AAA games and hit a major market issue: there was no way AAA publishers were going to under-cut their per-unit sales in other channels by offering with-subscription access to their product and trusting Google would pay them enough to make that worth their while.
- 4y ago
- Aleksdev 4y agoI think GCP, YouTube and Google maps are pretty good products. To answer your question. I don’t think it’s that easy to create a product that people love.
- explodingwaffle 4y agoI don’t understand why anyone would pay that much for YouTube premium- isn’t it just no ads, and background play? In what universe is that worth £16/$12 a month?? You could get two “real” streaming services for that if you pushed it a little.
- benjaminwootton 4y agoIt is quite punchy for an online service, but you would have to prise YouTube Premium from my cold dead hands. I visit YouTube multiple times per day for work, entertainment, research etc. Without Premiun there are so many ad units it’s painful.
- sidibe 4y agoNo ads and background play are great though. YouTube music also means you don't need a Spotify subscription which is $10 by itself. Altogether it is worth it to me
- krisroadruck 4y agoNo ads is worth quite a bit to me. I wish more platforms had this option to opt out of them legitimately. I would gladly pay another 25% on top of my YouTube Premium subscription if they would also enforce no in-content/native ads from the creators (just ask them to tag the beginning and end of the sponsored section, and auto-skip for premium subscribers). I basically lose my shit every time I have to hear "this episode brought to you by square space" lol.
- nitrixion 4y agoThis is yet another instance where piracy provides the better product. Installing uBlock Origin and SponsorBlock makes Youtube a much better product than simply paying for premium. If you haven't used it, SponsorBlock is a crowd sourced browser extension that identifies and skips sections of videos like "This content is brought to you by..." I used to pay for premium and use YT Music, but after getting fed up with YTM I cancelled. I'm noticing a much MUCH better experience using UBO and SponsorBlock. Unfortunately, this setup means the creators don't get any revenue from me. If only YouTube offered such an experience at a reasonable cost.
- kweingar 4y ago> every other product you try to bring to market ends in failure Pretty difficult to square >$250B of annual revenue with “all of your products are failures” and “can’t think of a product that people actually want”
- kyleplum 4y ago> Our third quarter revenues were $69.1 billion, up 6% versus last year or up 11% on a constant currency basis "Constant Currency Basis" seems to be the latest innovation in the non-GAAP methods of reporting revenue. The creativity of the financial industry never ceases to impress. Thankfully we do have a set of "Generally Accepted Accounting Principles" that helps see through the bull.
- ISL 4y agoFor those who have never heard the term (like me), here's a link: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/constantcurrencies.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/constantcurrencies.asp
- MichaelZuo 4y agoAlong with EBITDA and other funky accounting measures, they likely are warning signs. i.e. presenting fluffed up numbers prominently is indicative of something.
- qeternity 4y agoEBITDA is not funky, it's a core financial metric (which has limitations like every other). Things get funky when you start seeing "community adjusted EBITDA" and its cousins.
- prottog 4y agoHa, I had just forgotten about "community adjusted EBITDA"! What a laugh that was.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWhy do you believe it's impossible for a 'core accounting metric' to be funky? Just because something is widely used doesn't mean it's guaranteed to be actually correct or reflect reality. For example: It never makes sense to exclude depreciation for anything physical without adding back on some cost of wear-and-tear, since everything physical suffers wear and tear. I've never seen this happen in reports with EBITDA figures, nor in this report. i.e. They're effectively presenting 'profit' figures that exclude some amount of real, tangible, losses. So it's really only a pseudo-profit, which is why there's a separate 'Net Profit' figure in every SEC compliant report.
- lwneal 4y agoRevenue is down for YouTube, compared to last year. Maybe this explains recent increases in ad placement [1] and the choice to gate 4K quality behind the YouTube Premium subscription [2]. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2022/10/4/23386782/youtube-premium-subscription-4k-quality-resolution-restriction-google https://www.theverge.com/2022/10/4/23386782/youtube-premium-... [2] https://9to5google.com/2022/09/16/youtube-ads-unskippable/ https://9to5google.com/2022/09/16/youtube-ads-unskippable/
- nightski 4y agoFrankly YT Premium pricing is ridiculous. It's not worth $23/mo for my family. That's way more than Netflix and Google doesn't even produce its own content... If it was cheaper I'd subscribe.
- samyok 4y agoThey seem to have walked back both of those and instead have just lifted the price of YouTube Premium as a whole [1] [1] https://techcrunch.com/2022/10/21/youtube-premiums-family-plan-gets-a-price-hike-in-several-countries/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/10/21/youtube-premiums-family-pl...
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>Revenue is down for YouTube, compared to last year. Maybe this has something to do with becoming the defacto censorship arm of the government and banning/blocking/demonetizing/driving away many customers and viewers.
- CabSauce 4y agoMaybe it has to do with extraterrestrial viewership being down. (If we're just making stuff up.)
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoYou sure they seem to be up by my metrics?
- alphabetting 4y agoGCP revenue growth accelerating at 38% though still not profitable. Probably see the first quarter above water in Q4.
- gorbachev 4y ago~$14B profit in one quarter. I now totally understand why they have to lay off people. /s
- alberth 4y agoOperating margin went from 32% to 25%. That's a massive swing. They are considerably less profitable this quarter than last year same quarter ($19B)
- gorbachev 4y agoThere are companies on this planet that can only dream about 25% operating profit.
- alberth 4y agoMy initial takeaways: - Alphabet is experience massive decline in revenue growth. (Only 6% YoY growth vs 41% YoY growth in 2021) - Internal costs are sharply increasing (Only a 25% Operating Margin vs 32% last year). A 7-point swing is massive. To put this into perspective, outside of tech, most companies only have ~10-point Operating Margin. So this swing of 7 points in margin, for most companies, could be the difference between being profitable vs not. - Even though they are generating more total revenue than last year (same quarter) - they are considerable less profitable overall ($14B this year in Net Income vs $19B last year same quarter). This is related to the previous bullet. Alphabets stock is -6% in after hour trading.
- alphabetting 4y agoI think it's dofficult to compare 22 to 21 and 21 to 20 given COVID.
- gigatexal 4y agoTrue, but earnings are earnings. And a substantial drop in organic earnings is nothing to ignore.
- marcyb5st 4y agoDisclaimer: Googler here but opinions are my own. I think what happened was a the perfect storm: remote working made people be more at home and so more time spent online. Additionally, stimulus checks were juicy targets for advertisers that tried to sell people stuff to spend time. Now, we are having inflation due to all those stimulus checks that forced central banks to hike interest rates. Moreover, energy prices and supply chains disruptions exacerbated the situation by driving more inflation and the cost of doing business. Advertisers understandably prefer spending less money. Under these circumstances such a drop in unsurprising IMHO. Similar to the drop in Q1/Q2 2020. EDIT: I wrongly used stimulus checks as an umbrella term. I really meant all the actions that pumped a lot of money into the economies.
- 4y ago
- endisneigh 4y agoOof. Curious to see Microsoft and Apple. I guess if you’re a Google investor you’ll be happy with cloud continuing to grow. Profitability is inevitable.
- khazhoux 4y ago> Profitability is inevitable. This comment is worth saving ;-)
- endisneigh 4y agoHeh, I got that reference.
- oars 4y agoRemindMe! 1 year
- gsanderson 4y agoMicrosoft was a small beat but the stock's currently down, presumably on the slower growth in Azure.
- teepo 4y agoThe read I have is more around PC sales declining. Cloud still has good margins across the big 5. GCP is a quarter or so away from profitability after the massive build outs and Azure has probably the largest GP right now of the hyperscalers.
- anonporridge 4y ago> Profitability is inevitable. Unless the rise of many viable competitors drives cloud computing down to a commodity service with razor thin margins. There's no guarantee that the AWS gravy chain is going to materialize for other companies.
- paxys 4y agoCommodities can still be expensive and profitable. Yes it is easier than ever for a company to get into cloud computing, but despite the increased competition retail prices are going up the entire sector is making more money than ever.
- diceduckmonk 4y agoIt's worth pointing out that Google Cloud here is not just GCP but also includes Google Workspace (Gmail, Docs), maps API, and probably also enterprise Chromebook sales. The growth rate is not necessarily indicative of GCP adoption.
- alphabetting 4y agoWouldn't this suggest GCP growth is higher than the 38% growth number for Google Cloud? Well engrained services like Google Workspace probably aren't seeing growth like that.
- carlycue 4y agoThis is a friendly reminder that the only well run companies are led by Satya Nadella and Tim Cook. Alphabet and Meta are like two spoiled children that got rich quick and don't know what it's like to go through an existential crisis.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoThere are only two well run companies?
- insanitybit 4y agoExistential crisis here means >10 billion dollars coming in? Must be nice.
- Kukumber 4y agoWhat do you mean? Microsoft's profit dropped by 14% Azure stays afloat because they managed to secure ties with governmental agencies thanks to their strong and suspicious lobby, it's not an organic growth (AWS and Google is an example of organic growth and industry leadership and innovation), what area Microsoft innovated? in Europe for example, Microsoft is a monopoly - education - public administrations They all use Microsoft services, office, windows and now azure And it's not just with Europe, they managed to secure multiple times billions of cash (questionable Hololens contract with the military) And lets not forget they have a track record of bribery cases https://www.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-settlement-idUSKCN1UH1P3 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-settlement-idUS... https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/07/22/microsoft-pay-million-settle-probe-into-hungarian-kickback-scheme/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/07/22/microso... https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/25/microsoft_accused_of_corrupt_business/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/03/25/microsoft_accused_of_... http://techrights.org/2014/05/28/microsoft-brazil/ http://techrights.org/2014/05/28/microsoft-brazil/ Xbox, Windows, HW revenue down too
- chevman 4y agoYou think AWS and Google do not employ the same sort of growth tactics as MS and others? Where do you think all the AWS and Goog sales folks hail from? Hint - the same places as MS sales folks and every other company! In enterprise land, AWS and Goog are frequently dismissed as they are still relatively immature in how they engage and navigate large orgs, if they even try. MS (and Oracle and even IBM still to some extent) walk around and laugh all the way to the bank signing 9 and 10 figure deals.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hamiltonians 4y agonot enough ad revenue. need even more youtube ads. never mind too many ads ruin expierience
- skohan 4y agoKind of an aside, but I recently signed up for YouTube Premium and find it a very good value. I often use YouTube as a tool, for instance for quickly learning how to do something by watching, and ad-free makes this a significantly better experience. Also YouTube music comes with it, and I find it better than Spotify, so it replaced that account completely.
- time_to_smile 4y agoNot to mention that nobody stops to ask where this magical ad-revenue is coming from. Ad revenue is always taking a slice out of somebody else's profit, and at the end of the day the profit is always taking the slice out some consumers wallet. But if inflation is high, and consumer debt is rising (which it is), then eventually the consumers wallet is going to get much tighter, which will shrink those companies making things profit margins, which in turn has to hit ad revenue. And yet every companies solution right now seems to be "we'll increase the advertising!" As if ad revenue was manna from heaven.
- paxys 4y agoTech stocks are broadly down 1-2% after hours because of MSFT and GOOG earnings.
- qorrect 4y agoYeah look at the hit QQQ took on those two drops.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSince their revenue is driven by advertising doesn't that mean they're indirectly driven by the health of the economy? When the market tanks so does their revenue. People buy fewer things and ads are less effective.
- paxys 4y agoYou can generally say that about most companies. The economy is one big feedback loop, and every disruption reverberates to everyone participating in it.
- wutbrodo 4y agoThe degree of correlation varies; for some cos it even runs the other direction. Web ads are such a critical part of commerce that the correlation for a co like Google is extremely strong.
- swellguy 4y agoWhy have all of these remote-unfriendly tech companies hired so many employees during remote-only Covid? Is it incompetence or something else? Surely it would affect their culture, product, etc. if they have those things.
- peteyPete 4y agoSince everyone was home and spending more time online, online companies got more business, therefore needed to hire more, and since everyone could work remotely, it allowed people to apply for tons other jobs since location no longer mattered, creating a crazy boom and poaching war, where some companies would just hire whoever they could put their hand on.
- bushbaba 4y agoDoubtful. Suspect Google departments get headcount proportional to the department's revenue. Google over-hired, simple as that. Pausing hiring in a booming economy gives warning signs to current employees. Over-hiring allows leadership to layoff without actually causing workforce impact. It's always better to over-hire than under-hire when you are a F500.
- wutbrodo 4y agoBecause tech went through an enormous boom during Covid, and everyone was bottlenexked by headcount
- swellguy 4y agoNope. Tech companies don't scale like that, especially Google Search or Youtube. Adding more people just makes things worse.
- VirusNewbie 4y agoIt depends. At a certain scale, strategically adding headcount can absolutely increase profit. It doesn't seem outrageous to think if a team of 20 engineers can improve efficiency by marginal percentage points for one component it can have enormous financial repercussions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- modshatereality 4y agoYoutube staff needs to be completely gutted, and the site should undergo a complete overhaul. It's damn-near inoperable on non-chrome browser and that does tend to create a monopoly... edit: I can't even use the site without overriding my useragent with a blank one... WHY IS THAT I WONDER?
- iKevinShah 4y agoI am using Youtube on Firefox containers and I find it works OK (personal experience). What are the problems you are seeing? In any case, IF youtube is making sites near-inoperable on non-chrome browsers, I'd imagine that would be one of the requirements from higher ups than anything else. That statement is my guess.
- keepquestioning 4y agoLooking like great news for Google