16 ms·
Amsterdam looks incredibly realistic in the new Call of Duty
- mudrockbestgirl 4y agoIt's interesting we can create amazing graphics like this, but at the same time we can't model humans walking naturally. It looks quite realistic if you take out the humans.
- jowsie 4y agoWe can model humans walking naturally, they just don't bother for CoD.
- jk_ra_el 4y agoI’ve been in computer graphics 30 years. This satisfies me. If the young generation wants to take it further, more power to you as well. Maybe the uncanny valley is even bridge-able in my lifetime. PCVR support when?
- mromanuk 4y agoThis amazement is not one I share. Yes, it appears more polished than GTA type graphics. In particular, the NPC movements. To describe it as "incredibly realistic" is a stretch.
- jayflux 4y agoThis looks Amazing, but one thing I found jarring was the animations. It feels like game developers haven’t improved how NPCs walk since GTA 3. I don’t know if it’s because every NPC has the same gate or something but it’s odd.
- brap 4y agoI thought the exact same thing. Relatively to everything else, it almost feels like game developers aren't giving it any attention. Obviously they are, so what is it about NPC animation in particular that makes it so difficult? Even facial expressions seem pretty good nowadays...
- Pulcinella 4y agoIn this specific case I could imagine it’s just a very low priority. It’s a first person shooter where the vast, vast, vast majority of the time you are exchanging gunfire with enemy characters or other players. Except for small sequences like the one in the OP, you are very rarely ever interacting with NPCs in a non-violent manner outside of cutscene (makes for some easy talking points about the state of the AAA games industry) so I imagine those animations don’t receive many resources budgeted towards them. CoD Infinite Warfare (I.e. “the one in space”) had sequences in between every mission where you could talk and interact with the crew of your spaceship and the NPC animations were a lot better there. Also they had a lot of NPCs modeled after celebrities for some reason (e.g. F1 driver Lewis Hamilton) so there was likely pressure to animate the NPCs better.
- iknowstuff 4y agoGTA 4 was a breakthrough in ped animation due to their Euphoria engine. GTA 3, on the other hand, is memed to this day for the way they made women move their hips when walking. :)
- rafaelBG 4y agoWas it done using Unreal Engine 5?
- Narishma 4y agoNo, they have their own engine.
- ggm 4y agoI wish more games, any even, simply provided a "walk around as a tourist" mode. At this fidelity, it's enjoyable. I spent 6 months living in Amsterdam, it brought back memories. A short walk down from here is the back of the Hotel Grand Kraznopolsky. I can smell the weed from "the British bulldog" Cafe as I type.
- gonzo41 4y agoI liked The Division 2 for it's pretty close version of DC for this same reason. Obviously sans societal collapse etc.
- dijit 4y agoWoo! I worked on that game. We actually took GIS data from the real DC and modelled the world. So the map should be very close to accurate. The Division 1 was handcrafted, so we cut a lot of the world away that wasn’t interesting, small alley ways and such. I can’t tell you how happy it makes me to hear that you enjoyed the work that went in.
- ZeroCool2u 4y agoMy friends and I spent a good chunk of time playing that game right after we all finished college and moved away for jobs. One of us actually moved to DC and playing The Division 2 actually helped him learn the area! Really fun game, your work is much appreciated!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- solardev 4y agoReally enjoyed Division 2! Having visited DC during the Last Administration, your apocalypse was much nicer :) On the GIS side of things, didn't Ubi team up with some European nonprofit to make other real world locale into games for educational purposes? Can't remember the details, but I used to work for a museum and my boss wanted us to do something like that. And I was like that'd be nice, but we're not Ubi. It would be awesome to read about your production pipeline, like did you go from drone footage to photogrammetry to dozens of artists manually fixing things, or? Was there much ML involved?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- denysvitali 4y agoI've submitted the video yesterday here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33292230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33292230 Sadly it was ignored. The graphics are really impressive!
- endisneigh 4y agoThough it does look great, i wish more games focused on actually being fun to play instead of having long cut scenes and micro transactions. Ironically other than the fact that you have to pay per game and that you’re often forced to die, I prefer arcade games. They generally minimize friction to play edit: to clarify, I mean games with good graphics specifically. There are many great games (especially indie) out there.
- Semaphor 4y ago> I wish more games focused on actually being fun to play instead of having long cut scenes and micro transactions. IME games do. But then I also don’t play any shooters.
- lghh 4y agoHow many do you want? There are plying and tons of games like that on steam that release every day. Paying for lives was the first micro transaction!
- Tade0 4y agoIt appears that the easiest way to making micro transactions work and be cost-effective is some kind of vending machine with coupons.
- farias0 4y agoNowadays there are games for all tastes being released weekly, the biggest game of the year, Elden Ring, seems exactly what you're looking for. Also try indies like Slay the Spire, Into the Breach and Rollerdrome
- dreen 4y agoWell, this is Call of Duty, the Micheal Bay of video games.
- gonzo41 4y agoThat is an excellent way of characterizing COD. I play the campaigns pretty much because it's like participating in an action movie and you just kinda get to go along with the ride of it. It's not too tough or defeating (looking at you elden ring.) I don't really have time for really long games anymore and these are as entertaining as movies IMO.
- okramcivokram 4y agoLooks very realistic, here's the same location in Google Street View https://goo.gl/maps/q2qrUGSoFEouq3Kj6 https://goo.gl/maps/q2qrUGSoFEouq3Kj6
- gus_massa 4y agoDoes the game have too few bikes compared to Google Street View?
- moffkalast 4y agoIt honestly would pass for a recorded video at twitter's resolution... if it wasn't for the character animations looking decidedly average and robotic.
- matwood 4y agoIt does look great. The water, particularly with the boat going through it, is what I noticed first. I spend a lot of time in boats and around water, so it's always one of the first things I see in graphical simulations.
- rcarr 4y agoComparing the photo and the game the other thing I’d say is that the game actually looks too clean in comparison to reality.
- singularity2001 4y agoI thought it looked like some characters and animations superimposed on google street view
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoThe scale seems off.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoIt's more claustrophobic than Amsterdam generally appears to be IRL, and my guess is that this level of detail requires such environments, as it always has traditionally, since in large open spaces you have to compromise.
- pornel 4y agoI guess the next frontier for realism is character animation. To me their robotic movements and moonwalking feet break the illusion. There were very neat demos of ML-generated postures/movement, so it may be possible to nail it.
- Eduard 4y agoI agree. This game is in the cerebral palsy category of character animation (e.g. the NPC tourists on the canal's other side). GTA 3/4/5 are in the megalotesticle category (characters moving like wavering boats).
- fabian2k 4y agoThere are games with very realistic character animation like e.g. The Last of Us Part 2. But that is a lot of effort, requires a lot of expertise and is likely very expensive. Correct animations can also conflict with fast and responsive movement, and most games will prefer responsiveness to realistic animations. Having both requires advanced approaches that can blend different animations well, which seems to be rather difficult.
- antegamisou 4y agoIt's funny, I remember reading somewhere that research on Computer Graphics, rendering specifically, is 'solved' because photorealism had been accomplished. What had been omitted though was that efficient photorealistic rendering, as well as the visual elements that human perception instantly picks up on such as material(s) translucency, lighting/shadows, and as you've already mentioned animations (and the bigger challenge of facial expressions!) is what everyone's after. And what we have at the OP is indeed impressive work, which still looks artificial. Contrary to the critique of the comments so far, and outside the graphics research interpretation, this isn't something necessarily negative imo. I like video games that preserve a few elements of non-photorealism.
- fooker 4y agoHuman perception does not pick up bad lighting or shadows, this is a fairly well known fact in the computer graphics world. Sure, you can compare two and tell which one is better but unless it is really bad humans won’t be bothered by it or even explain what’s wrong.
- rcarr 4y agoThe main things I noticed as being off: - The wave breaks/spray from the boat doesn’t look right - NPC motion is still janky and robotic. - Lack of wind. All vegetation is motionless as is the hanging sign. Even on windless days vegetation still tends to sway minutely. - Lack of squelch. The ground is wet and has leaves and puddles all over it but everyone sounds like they’re walking on dry ground. Some NPCs don’t seem to have audible footsteps at all.
- notart666 4y agoYeah, I noticed that too. I think it's tied to the frame rate of the animations. Kinda weird
- billythemaniam 4y agoAnimation is the hardest and will be the long pole of visual realism in games. I've seen better water than that, but it's still hard to make Pixar-quality water in video games. Paradoxically, the more realistic the graphics, the easier it is to notice flaws. Regardless, still impressive video.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sgt 4y agoI think they should rather fix those things before trying to make everything so photo-realistic. But maybe that's just my taste.
- replygirl 4y agoremember... no dutch
- k__ 4y agoI was there in April and this video really throws me back. I can't count how often I had to go over one of these tiny bridges.
- tkiolp4 4y agoMeh. I don’t care much about how realistic it looks like. I care about how realistic the interactions are, this is: can I break a car in two? Can enter any building? Can I make a hole in the ground? Can I cut trees? Can I kiss NPCs? Can I demolish any building? Sadly, games are not optimizing for these kind of interactions.
- aerovistae 4y agoIt's not really practical or sensible to task your developers with making sure that Spiderman can start digging a hole if he wants to. In the long run probably frameworks will start to handle these things - soil mechanics, building infrastructure, metal deformation, and so on, and then all games will start to include them by default by gradual degrees. But hoping the game developers themselves make working hedge trimmers instead of focusing on actual gameplay is silly.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoIf you can't rip a car in half or see the insides of a building then battle damage will look like it's painted on. If Spiderman can't move a bit of rubble (he doesn't really do dirt) then he can't pull something into or out of place to free a friend or trap an enemy. It's (all) the little things that are in the way of a game feeling immersive and appealing to people who aren't just into the main mechanic (ie shooter on rails).
- FredPret 4y agoOn that note, can you shoot through anything? In real life, you can punch holes in and through buildings and trees, given enough bullets and a high enough caliber
- Rimintil 4y agoOnly certain wood materials and glass.
- rtlfe 4y ago> Can enter any building? Can I make a hole in the ground? Can I cut trees? Can I kiss NPCs? Can I demolish any building? I'd really prefer for the developer to focus on the gameplay and plot rather than make a perfect simulation of earth. What you describe sounds like a cool sandbox, like Flight Simulator, but isn't appropriate for most games.
- speedgoose 4y agoThe video is full or reflection artefacts because it uses screen space reflections, in 2022. It would be so much better to use raytraced reflections like RTX games. It also has transparency bugs. You see the boat through the reflection on the windshield of the car right at the beginning. Walking animations are a bit clumsy with the path finding that is a bit unrealistic. The water effects around the boat look bad. This isn’t very much better in terms of technology than a AAA from about ten years ago. The artists did a great work.
- R0flcopt3r 4y agoIt’s also a blurry mess with tons of tearing at low frame rate. Might be down to the encoding that twitter does.
- franciscop 4y agoLooking at the original youtube video, tearing seems to be from Twitter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA
- badpun 4y agoLol, so as usual, game devs perform technical miracles, rendering an incredibly rich virtual world at smooth 60 FPS, while a bloated and barely-competent Silicon Valley company cannot even display a freaking video clip of it without tearing.
- fmajid 4y agoTwitter is barely even incompetent.
- franciscop 4y agoAs a usual twitter user, I've been dreading watching any videos there and I'm used to find them on youtube because of this. I thought it was because I was using linux, but now that I've moved to a macbook m1 with the power of a supercomputer 10 years ago, the quality of the videos is too ridiculous to take twitter videos seriously.
- sylware 4y agodoes it have a vulkan backend?
- mkl95 4y agoIt looks like they invested a ton of money on texture optimization and lighting algorithms. However the animations look like the basic skeletal animation / skinning you can learn from an OpenGL/DirectX tutorial. That imbalance is kind of weird.
- greenthrow 4y ago"Brand new AAA game looks incrediby realistic" has been a very banal observation for the last 20 years. If this were a link to a discussion of some special technique that the creators of the last CoD used maybe that would be interesting. But this is lacking in any kind of substance.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoDid you watch it? I really think this is very next-level. It's not perfect yet, definitely not but it's a major step IMO. Perhaps it helps that I know the city.
- kingkawn 4y agoThe next tier of mediocrity
- GekkePrutser 4y agoWhat game looks much better than this?
- dymk 4y agoTLOU2, Red Dead Redemption 2, Horizon Zero Dawn 2 RDR2 in particular looks much more realistic. More detailed terrain, better lighting, leagues better character animations.
- anthk 4y agoNo. Not even close to the raytraced images from 2003 with PovRay. This is nothing close. Even an RTX GPU in not enough to what we've seen as photorealistic.
- nnopepe 4y agokinda weird to see US demographics superimposed over amsterdam. Couldn't spot a single blonde/redhead
- GekkePrutser 4y agoThe area in question is super touristy so that's not too weird :) The lack of cyclists passing through is weirder IMO.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mysterydip 4y ago"Well boss, looks like the team will need another couple weeks vaca-- er, research in Amsterdam. We don't have everything quite realistic enough yet."
- GekkePrutser 4y agoConsidering they picked the red light district I assume they are not done with their 'research' :)
- fit2rule 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Keyframe 4y agoMaybe I'm jaded being around graphics for too long, but every few years we have a bit of an advancement and proclamations of "wow, this looks real!". Probably since early 90's. Only theb, a couple of years down the road, same material suddenly looks funky compared to new material.
- tester756 4y agoStill I hate that games like call of duty are expensive, are somewhat decent but short as fuck. Just playing it randomly, without some tryharding you can complete it in something like less than 10 hours, it sucks.
- Rimintil 4y agoI’d guess most of the player base is there for MP. Some of the more well known content creators on YT said they never played the CoD campaign as they jumped straight to MP. With the week of time between the SP release and MP release, along with MP rewards, there’s a reason to actually complete SP this time.
- Bakary 4y agoI've always been surprised by this metric. True, if the game is only a couple of hours it can be a bad investment. However, I can think of at least half a dozen ten hour games that have left me with a more memorable impression than some games I've played for ten times as long. To my teenage self it would make sense, though. Enough time but not enough money, which makes long (sometimes artificially long) games a necessity.
- tester756 4y agoThe problem is that the story is short. Compare those CoDs to e.g Cyberpunk which I needed like 40 hours to complete it was way better
- Bakary 4y agoPersonally, I see it as an equation of Story/atmosphere quality x mechanical pleasure x length where story is the trump card. A game like SOMA has low mechanical pleasure (it's a walking simulator, essentially) and a short length, but the story and atmosphere are so high that I will forever remember the experience. Cyberpunk has decent length, decent story/atmosphere (obviously this is subjective) and decent mechanical pleasure so it's a great game. CoD has a short length, decent to high mechanical pleasure (well at least I hope so for their sake since it's supposed to be about the multiplayer shooter replayability) and low story/atmosphere because it's just a string of action movie clichés. I think that's what makes it sound very mediocre compared to Cyberpunk. Other gamers might see mechanical pleasure as the trump card, and I can definitely understand their POV (Portal 1 for instance). I'd venture a guess that length is rarely a trump card except if you are stuck with the games you do have. Usually for length to be the most important factor, you need at least a decent degree of the two other factors to go with it. For example, what people love about Skyrim is that the basic gameplay of walking around and doing things is fun and you can just pick up the game everyday for months and still have things to do. The story is nothing special, but the atmosphere is comfy enough. You know the game is there for you when you come back from work.
- breck 4y agoAnd yet it's not even close.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI know that area, it is very accurate. Wow. Really a major step forward. Sure there's some things 'off' but there is so much right. Wowwww
- acapybara 4y agoNeeds more people riding bicycles.
- smcleod 4y agoIt looks really fake to me. Flat looking textures, poor lighting, awkward looking characters?
- m348e912 4y agoSeems like game developers have gotten car racing and general environmental rendering figured out. There has been times where I truly couldn't tell whether game play footage it was real video or rendered. That all ends when characters enter the picture. Anything "living" just seems off, whether it's a human or even a dog. Why can't video game use actors to model movement and looks and then extrapolate from there? Maybe they do already, it's just not very convincing.
- kingkawn 4y agoBecause it’s cheaper to make bad dolls than do motion capture for everything
- beezlewax 4y agoA least some of this is the characters movements have no context. They're making gestures that might look more natural if they were talking to another character but they're standing alone on a bridge. There's also no realistic gravity between their feet/body and the ground or objects around them. They pop up and down if there's a step and appear to be floating.
- kingkawn 4y agoThese games get more and more detailed yet still feel utterly lifeless.
- noufalibrahim 4y agoAn environment this rich with detail will affect senses other than sight. The smells, temperature, ambient sounds and things all contribute to making it real. Peripheral vision and the combination of all these other senses make the experience. Seeing the whole thing on 2D screen, i feel, makes it less realistic as the graphics improve. The difference between reality and the screen becomes more stark. If it were liken cartoon, i think I'd suspend reality better just to be in it. This leaps away from artificial into reality and doesn't get there thereby raising my expectations and then disappointing me. Great technological achievements though.
- strogonoff 4y agoHuman mind doesn’t (can’t) process the entirety of perceivable space-time in all of its detail, far from that. Rather we treat it more as a symbolic interface, superfluous accidental detail is simplified away whenever possible (sometimes excessively so: the Invisible Gorilla effect, optical illusions, and so on). This is why I don’t see inherent value in increasing realism of film and videogame visuals (I do think contrasting degrees of realism could be used to achieve an artistic effect, but am yet to see this technique employed) and incidentally why I start to find unstaged photography frustrating and consider learning to draw (the technique employed by many illustrators, where a photo of an actual scene is taken as a reference and then traced over to leave out unnecessary detail and focus on shapes and colors of interest, is appealing).
- noufalibrahim 4y agoI agree. I consider games as a modern form of art and simply trying to get them photorealistic doesn't seem to be the most interesting thing that can be done with the medium.
- thih9 4y agoNo cyclists though?
- he0001 4y agoI don’t understand all the nitpicking done here. I’d say it’s extremely fun to what how tech progresses! Great work all involved!
- pprotas 4y agoLet me go off topic a bit here. I've never seen a scene in a game as realistic as the footage provided in this tweet, and I say this as someone who has been gaming all my life. I am not even a fan of CoD, don't even play those types of games. As a Dutch citizen I was simply happy about the fact that they were able to recreate Amsterdam in such a beautiful way. Full of excitement I've opened the comment section for this post and what do I see? The top comments are full of negativity about how the waves in the water don't look right, the sounds of the footsteps are not squelchy and there are artefacts in the rendering. Why is HN so negative about amazing things? I get that we like to provide constructive criticism, since we are so passionate about technology. But come on guys, this is just spewing hate at the level of some cesspool internet forums I will not name. Be better HN!
- geraldyo 4y ago
- jesuscript 4y agoYou are talking to generations of people that grew up with video games. This isn’t some shit they saw for the first time, they’ve been watching the progress since childhood at this point. Basically, they lost perspective on how amazed an average person would be. Similar to how porn addicts don’t flinch at triple penetration videos, or … you get it. Wish I could come (ooof) up with better analogies. Yes, even I went “nope, that’s not real enough”.
- Sebb767 4y agoAlso, we've been able to generate pretty realistic images for quite some time now. For some expertly crafted ray-traced stills, it's nearly impossible to tell whether the picture was computer-generated. This looks pretty amazing, I'll give that, but you can still clearly see it's a computer game. A bit better than the last one maybe, but not "can't tell if rendered"-realistic.
- pprotas 4y agoAre you comparing 1 frame of a still that hasn't been rendered in real-time to a video game that is being dynamically rendered at at least (I hope) 30 frames per second? > you can still clearly see it's a computer game I'll give you that, but we are comparing this footage to footage of other video games from the past. Can you name a video game that looks more realistic than this? Maybe some of those realistic racing games I guess, but that is a different type of video game. My point is: currently, this is as close as we get to real-life, no? Sure, it can be better (and it probably will be in the future), but I'd say this ranks pretty high.
- lm28469 4y agoDo people not know what real life looks like anymore ? Not even a second in the video you can see some weird artefact through the car windshield, the lighting looks completely off too What fools us is the low res + motion blur, pause the high res video at any point and it looks like a video game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA
- nothis 4y agoJust had the video play without sound and my girlfriend said she thought it was real before she noticed the overlay text being weird. We just went to Amsterdam, too I agree that we'll be shaving off these last 3% of visual artifacts for a while (honestly, on a good setup, games have been looking like this for 5+ years, the main thing this video has is photogrammetry and lighting). But this does look realistic.
- lm28469 4y agoIt look like an architecture renders from 2010. The last 3% will never be shaved off because we're not using the right techniques. CGI in star wars are realistic, as in you they can fool 99% of people even when paying close attention. Video games are realistic if you glance at a video of them from 3 meters away while being busy doing something else I guess it depends on your definition of realistic, I'm a photographer, everything screams "fake" in these supposedly "realistic" games. Some of them are artistically pleasing (rdr2, tlou2, &c.) I'll give you that, but everything is off, the lightning, the camera movement, shadows, reflections, depth of field, motion blur, textures, ...
- hypersoar 4y agoI'm reminded of this blog post[0] from 2017 about bad tone mapping in video games. A game can put all the work it wants into realistic puddle reflections, but it'll still scream "video game" to your eyes if the color grading is so out of whack that it couldn't possibly be a real scene. That post is focused on how it was done wrong so often in the early days of HDR. This clip has lots of things that stick out to me as video gamey, but the color is on-point. I suspect that's a huge part of the realism. [0] https://80.lv/articles/games-look-bad-hdr-and-tone-mapping/ https://80.lv/articles/games-look-bad-hdr-and-tone-mapping/
- Timja 4y agoHow much freedom does the player have in this type of game? From watching these videos it seems like the player does not influence the story at all? What if you jump into the river for example? Would you be able to swim around in it? Would bystanders be worried about you, call the police, the police would come and get you out of the water etc? Or would a magic hand keep you from jumping into the water and you have to stay very closely on track to the scripted story?
- capableweb 4y agoThe campaign in Call of Duty is not a open world campaign where you get to do whatever you want and the environment reacts appropriately in most situations. It's basically a interactive movie where you get to practice sneaking and shooting sometimes, in the style of a Michael Bay movie. Expecting what you write about in the third paragraph is a misunderstanding of what the game is trying to be.
- zarzavat 4y agoIt’s Call of Duty so there is a linear singleplayer that is like an interactive movie, and then an online multiplayer which is the part that people actually play.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoabout zero in CoD
- rogual 4y agoThis is exactly as realistic as I remember Half-Life 2 looking when it was first shown. There definitely seems to be a "hedonic treadmill"-style effect for realism. Also, I gather Call of Duty is a shootyman game so players will presumably be murdering these realistic people in great detail?
- haxorito 4y agoI don’t see anything super impressive that could be attributed to CoD developers. I think most of this really advances in hardware that allows more lighting, higher quality textures and more polygons. But even with all of that, this isn’t looking incredibly realistic. There are games and engines that done it little more convincing
- denysvitali 4y agoCompare it with Zuckerberg's Metaverse: https://i0.wp.com/mustanid.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Mark-Zuckerberg-himself-spits-on-his-own-metaverse%E2%80%A6.png?w=768&ssl=1 https://i0.wp.com/mustanid.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Ma...
- synu 4y agoThis looks like a 2002 Nintendo GameCube release called like “World Baby” (Credit https://twitter.com/cd_hooks/status/1559665074868031490 https://twitter.com/cd_hooks/status/1559665074868031490)
- charcircuit 4y agoWhat is the point of comparing it with Horizon Worlds? The games have a different art style, have access to a different amount of compute power, and are targeting different frame rates and resolutions.
- TheAngush 4y ago> I don’t see anything super impressive that could be attributed to CoD developers. I think most of this really advances in hardware that allows more lighting, higher quality textures and more polygons. Who do you think is making the lighting, textures, and polygons? Who do you think is coding the engine for it?
- FpUser 4y ago1) Graphics is totally amazing 2) Yet I can see that it is fake the second I look at it. No need to analyze. I am not trying to diminish the work done in any way as it shines.
- krangfu 4y agonope chars to slow
- krangfu 4y agoThe place is but the characters respond slow and grand theft auto
- smusamashah 4y agoIt's the lighting which is amazingly realistic. The contrast between shadows and sunlit area. There are so many details which are off. It's the lighting which is so crazy good that it looks real on the first sight. Games don't have that very often.
- riffraff 4y agowhat bothers me in this, even in a still frame, is cars and scooters/mopeds. There is something of with them and very noticeable, I think because of the uniformity and "polish" of the surface/texture/materials. The rest of the city does look pretty great tho.
- krangfu 4y agoGame and movie too different thing.
- layer8 4y agoWhat stood out to me in the second video is that the walla (background noise/chatter) didn’t match the relatively low number of visible people, and also didn’t change when moving around (until the player entered the side alley). Realism isn’t just visual.
- Bakary 4y agoI find this amazing, but I wouldn't want to play a game with graphics that are too realistic because reality has an ugly tinge
- abraxas 4y agoYes, those games with realistic graphics mostly resemble American gang violence movies. Not sure who enjoys this kind of ambiance. I'm glad the indie game scene is as vibrant as ever because in the early 2000s the urban ghetto simulators was all that there was.
- Bakary 4y agoOne analogy I could make is photorealistic pencil drawings of the Joker or other pop culture characters. It takes astounding skill, and you sound like a dick for being critical of the author, but the end result seems... pointless, somehow?
- mastax 4y agoI feel for all those game devs, making something realistic is a lot of work but it's hard to be impressed. Something has to be hyper-real to compete with reality; it's why over-saturated images are so common, a more realistic rendition just doesn't capture it. I just finished Horizon: Forbidden West, and the more fantastical setting let the devs stretch their legs. (Coincidentally, Guerilla Games are from Amsterdam). Few moments of that game aren't jaw-droppingly beautiful. I frequently heard my companions "can we go now" dialog lines because I was crouched down staring at the moss. And I played half the game at 720p30 MPEG compressed with PS Remote Play because I didn't want to take over the TV. When I moved the ps5 to my desk it was like seeing it again for the first time.
- freecodyx 4y agoEverything is perfect even better than real life. But still humans are still far from being looking natural, they always look like a balloon to me. Something is always off when it comes to simulating humans, the eyes movements, body
- seydor 4y agoPity that most games are not available as open social worlds that you can use in VR
- Loveaway 4y agoCall of Duty and realistic should not be allowed in the same sentence. Utter non sense narrative glorifying war and conflict. Many kids these days are stupid enough to get themselves recruited, after growing up with these games and having been fed a twisted picture of reality. Shows you how our moral compass is based on nothing but thin air, when society thinks shit like that is fun and cool, while games depicting a naked human for example is completely unacceptable.
- whoooooo123 4y ago
- adesanmi 4y agoBro there are anime skins on the guns that shoot purple tracer rounds…
- joshspankit 4y agoI wish there was more budget available for virtual tourism. I may just buy this CoD so I can (eventually) mod it and walk around Amsterdam in VR.
- andrewallbright 4y agoAs a hobbyist game dev one thing I've (recently) learned is that optimizing performance is paramount in video games. Running at 60 FPS you have a budget of 16 ms per frame (VR requires 90 FPS minimum else risk VR sickness; ~11ms per frame). Any scripts and anything you want on screen needs to fit in that amount of time. It's a big exercise in smoke and mirrors. I'd love to know what optimization techniques are used so that those precious CPU/GPU cycles can go to those good looking things. Side note: being absolutely forced to optimize the heck out of games as an essential practice gives me a much greater sense of performance characteristics in my "real" job and also in leetcode.
- jessermeyer 4y agoModern renderers: Use the GPU to decide what to render, and in a growing number of cases, will cull triangles in compute (software) instead of letting the fixed pipeline do it. The vertex shader feeds parameters to the fragment shader even if the triangle is culled (depth or backfacing), so with vertex counts climbing, there is a lot of dead time spent feeding fragment shaders that are never ran. Render at a lower resolution and temporally upsample to a higher resolution. Using low overhead apis that optimize command recording performance (DX12, Vulkan) and transfer / memory access. Multithread all the things. Obsess over data locality and compression.
- dclowd9901 4y agoCulling triangles seems to be going away though, especially with the rise of ray tracing. The expectation is that even aspects of the scene we can’t see influence lighting. How are they managing that?
- jessermeyer 4y agoWhat makes you think culling triangles is going away? Ray tracing is usually done with a highly approximated volume or planar representation of the scene, which is then applied to surface triangles. Rendering objects that 'we can't see' has been done for as long as shadow caster light sources have been around. Even though we cannot see the mesh directly, the light can, and the viewer can see the shadow. These indirections all play their role in the greater "rendering equation", and the specific solution depends on the constraints of the application and resources of the development team. Some renderers have abandoned triangles altogether for signed distance fields, but this involves re-creating from scratch the entire art pipeline.
- rcarr 4y agoWhy are any comments listing criticisms of the realism of this video being flagged? This is not what I would expect from Hacker News and is very worrying.
- Bakary 4y agoThe unrealistic flaws of the video are fairly obvious and don't really need pointing out, and sometimes the endless nasal pedantry takes its toll on the mind
- rcarr 4y agoSome of the flaws are obvious. Some of them aren’t. Either way they can lead to very interesting conversations and get the mind thinking. You should be flagging blind hatred not observations and criticism. You’re literally shutting down free speech. Metaphorically you’re creating a walled compound where all the “happy” people can pretend everything is fine and dandy meanwhile on the opposite side of the wall is a bunch of unhappy homeless people who literally had their house taken away by the people in the compound just because they happened to disagree with something one of the powerful people said at a dinner party.
- Bakary 4y agoYou can vouch for comments to unflag them by clicking on the timestamp. I have done so multiple times when it was clear the author had made an interesting point but did so in an unduly hostile manner. However, the ratio of flagged comments that didn't deserve their fate is incredibly low. The free speech martyrdom angle makes sense on paper, and it's true that there are users that act as commissars, but the practical reality is that no interesting discussion actually flows from the flagged content. This is something every online community eventually learns through experience. Most of the time, the abstract idea of free speech is the only merit these comments have, and from that we can also ask if flagging is not an expression of speech in and of itself.
- rcarr 4y ago
- z9znz 4y agoIt looks incredible. Although this beautiful recreation is missing the endless tourists aimlessly walking on bike paths and the very loud conversations between Dutch people (their talking volume is what many of us consider yelling, but that's just normal). Once we get VR headsets that are maybe twice as good as the best now, and we have high quality simulations, the scifi stories of people choosing living in unreality seem more plausible.
- dmytrish 4y ago> Dutch people (their talking volume is what many of us consider yelling, but that's just normal). It's funny, I thought it was Americans who are so loud compared to the Dutch.
- MarkusWandel 4y agoNot a gamer, and I've never been impressed beyond the "whoa, cool tech" thing in game videos. But this is good enough that I'd watch a feature movie rendered like this, no problem. It draws me in. Someone once said that virtual reality will never look right "until you put some dirt in it". And that's just it. They've recreated the irrelevant clutter that goes along with real life and that's what makes it look right.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoAmazing. I wonder if the textures come from photographs. Here there's a higher quality video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_LlSR6-ibA
- etempleton 4y agoCall of Duty is interesting because, despite how you might feel about the gameplay at this point, it is one of the few games really pushing things forward graphically. Games that operate at this budget level have just become incredibly rare. Sony first-party games, CoD, CD Projekt, Rockstar, and honestly not much else. The visual fidelity here is really incredible. Some elements, such as animations and water look bad by comparison, but it is still impressive.
- cloudking 4y agoYou think that's cool? Try the Matrix UE5 demo on PS5 https://youtu.be/WU0gvPcc3jQ https://youtu.be/WU0gvPcc3jQ
- ricardobayes 4y agoThat's insane
- tgv 4y agoThat's really levels beyond that CoD trailer. The characters are much more realistic, too. Neo's face has a bit of a photoshoppy look, and the black girl's gait looks a bit stiff, but the rest is phenomenal.
- vl 4y agoThe most interesting part is at the end, where they show engine features, but at the same time they character is walking through the streets and you can see character animation and lighting is off. My guess faces/motion in the middle of the demo are pre-animated.
- wrycoder 4y agoI think we are all getting there.
- trgn 4y agoLooks fantastic. Dumb question, but this is an intro it seems. It's not going to have gamers shoot machine guns FPS-style through these street right? Right?
- hazebooth 4y ago[spoilers ahead] Thankfully, this is not like the "No Russian" mission in the original Modern Warfare 2. Instead, you're tasked with intercepting a known terrorist, and have to protect yourself against the cartel. You will be punished for harming anyone that isn't part of the cartel.
- trgn 4y agoThank you, that's a relief indeed :)
- nlstitch 4y agoNo cycling people and no people riding scooters... hmm
- akaike 4y agoExcept the human models, this looks really amazing. At first glance I really thought it’s just some edited after effects video :) Amsterdam looks very pretty!
- yboris 4y agoFor another ultra-realistic feel in a computer game: https://twitter.com/esankiy/status/1580225720361832448 https://twitter.com/esankiy/status/1580225720361832448 The trick here is you have a very POV camera-mounted-on-head effect with lens distortions (in I think VR) and the environment is very deteriorated, making me doubt it was a game in the first place!
- Axsuul 4y agoJust missing the window girls
- jmyeet 4y agoMy first thought is this is really getting into the uncanny valley. Some things look incredibly realistic that it highlights how other things don't and overall creates a bit of a jarring effect. Some random thoughts: 1. You see the sidewalk on the bridge is wet like it's been freshly rained on. Other things don't look like this. The bridge is higher than the road on the far side so should be drier but the road looks drier; 2. The boat just looks off to me. It's like it's too "clean"; 3. Of course the movement of people is off. Games just haven't conquered this yet. 4. The water also looks off given the lighting and the conditions. It should be murkier rather than dark with an almost oily finish; 5. It looks like the near side of the canal is in shade but I don't really see the line from whatever is obstructing this (assumedly it's buildings to the "left"). The Sun is low in the sky to the left; 6. The sky just doesn't seem to match the expected position and lighting from the Sun. Don't get me wrong: it is amazing, particularly rendered in real time. But there are uncanny valley artifacts.
- ekianjo 4y agoNot really if you look at people walking around for more than 1 second. Character animation has always been the weakest point of video games.
- TillE 4y agoOf CGI in general. I like Rogue One a lot, but they were way too proud of their awful rendition of Grand Moff Tarkin, giving repeated closeups to an incredibly fake face. The biggest budgets in Hollywood still can't escape the uncanny valley.
- saint_angels 4y agoI think the main problem here is with transitions between animation states and matching each animation to the context. If ML motion matching[1] becomes popular in the industry, I think it would smooth out these issues a lot. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16CHDQK4W5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16CHDQK4W5k
- ricardobeat 4y agoI remember this being solved over ten years ago, without ML, there was this software that seamlessly blended between poses and activities (morphine or something like that?). I wonder what happened to them. Unreal 5 also has similar tech.
- saint_angels 4y agocan't find anything on "morphine", but animation blending is something that Unity/Unreal/etc had for a while. Although, I don't think any publicly available engine solves this like Ubisoft ML models do. Usually it requires at lot of work to look seamless
- ricardobeat 4y agoThe demo was a blender-like environment, with opaque white human models. You could shoot arrows at them, bullets, switch between poses and animations or set up obstacles to watch them react realistically and tumble around. This was sometime before 2010.
- mmzeeman 4y agoIt looks incredible. But there is one really big omission. Where are the cyclists? Where they to difficult to model?
- vinkelhake 4y agoI love it. These set pieces are like wonderful dioramas you can walk into. CoD Black Ops Cold War (2020) had a bunch of these and my favorite was where you infiltrate the KGB headquarters. So much detail and so much to look at. Take it for what it is people. It's not the next GTA, nor is it minecraft. These levels are basically highly scripted walking simulators.
- holoduke 4y agoThe graphics are stunning, but the animations are not. I would prefer a game with less polished graphics, but super realistic animations/physics of everything. NPC's , cars, boats, fluids etc. But still an amazing next generation graphics scene.
- muhammadusman 4y agoI was in Amseterdam last week and seeing this in the game really impressed me!
- spoonjim 4y agoEventually people are going to just disappear into these amazing worlds and spend as little time in meatspace as possible.
- 4oo4 4y agoCoD has a history of being very selective about what parts of their games are realistic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttjSaW-lSNQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttjSaW-lSNQ
- nojvek 4y agoBoth Nvidia and Intel have some amazing papers on real time ray tracing by using neural nets to filter noise and upsample. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VxbTiuabW0k https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VxbTiuabW0k I wonder if those techniques were used. If metaverse looked like this instead of crappy new horizons app, i’d be a lot more interested. This reminded me of the lara croft demo unity had a while back. Amazing to witness evolution of realism in games. I visited Amsterdam a while back and couldn’t tell from first few seconds whether it was real or not. The jerky human movement gave it away though.
- 8note 4y agoI'd really want to see the not just bikes described infrastructure in action. Lots of bikes, sidewalks that stay at sidewalk level when they cross streets, roads vs streets with transitions between them etc
- m3kw9 4y agoI give props for also detailing the interiors of shops. Most games will just close the door and put a piece of opaque piece of glass
- Gregam3 4y agoI used to like 20 seconds from this exact spot, even though I believe it. I'm in some disbelief that this is real, it's just so accurate.
- 3qz 4y agoIt looks very good but in 10 years everyone will think it looks awful. Remember when people thought Skyrim on Xbox 360 was good looking? lmao
- Tiktaalik 4y agoUnfortunately this level of fidelity relies on the user having effectively zero agency or ability to do anything or move anywhere outside of the tight boundaries of this area. Still impressive! But probably not terribly compelling for anything other than pure looks.
- tsol 4y agoYep. Making this environment fully interactive would be an entirely new task to accomplish. The game only allows you to stick to the script, which for CoD is appropriate. But developing a MMORPG like a Skyrim, where the environment is meant to be fully interactive, would be exponentially more complex. I'm sure it's just a matter of time though
- squarefoot 4y agoAgreed. While it is truly impressive, I'd rather give up a bit in photo realism to have a true open world experience with believable NPCs.
- vl 4y agoIs there a good single player mission in this new CoD, or is it all optimized for online grinding, as it used to be?
- mdswanson 4y agoI enjoyed the single player campaign. Yes, it's more of an interactive movie at times, but there are some fun scenarios...and the graphics are insane. Took perhaps 6 hours to play through.
- rizz0 4y agoAmsterdam local here — in fact, I live in exactly this street. Where the first cartel guy gets subdued is where I get my coffee, and the people that live in the canal houses are my neighbors. (My house may or may not be in the map, would have to play the game to check.) Fun facts: (1) A year or two ago several guys spent days using some sort of device to scan all buildings in our street. They got complaints from several bar owners and tenants as they appeared to be taking photographs inside the buildings, and they wouldn’t explain why. I wouldn’t be be surprised if it was for this map. (2) The footage is hyperrealistic not just graphically, they got the details right with surprising accuracy. Even the garbage bins are in exactly the right place. (It’s also not unlikely that a guy could be subdued like this without people being too surprised, as tourists like to use this district to get wasted 24/7.)
- stuaxo 4y agoThey seem to have missed the absolute shedload of bikes.
- ricardobeat 4y agoThis area has few bikes compared to the rest of the city, due to the sheer amount of foot traffic. Truckloads of british tourists are unloaded here every day.
- echlebek 4y agoComments like this are why I love the internet, cheers!
- BonoboIO 4y agoIf there would be several guys photographing my building or bar, and would not explain why, I would call the cops, because that is extremely invasive, probably illegal and suspicious. You can photograph the „public“ but not private spaces like bars, inside of buildings and so on. And the „we don’t tell you“ would not fly with the police.
- hugh-avherald 4y ago
- grogenaut 4y agothe water decals from the boat are totally out of place for a boat moving at that speed and are obviously decals landing on the water texture... the people look soft focus and rounder than normal folks. The skin texture is really flat/matte. And that's from watching for 10 seconds and typing. It looks really good from the postage stamp sized video on the twitter feed. It looked like a game when I went full screen. Still not bad. Is the story still terrible and just mini-game after mini-game with endless waves of baddies till you push a volume trigger like their last well every single game?
- password321 4y agoSeems like their world models are outpacing the development of their NPCs because they immediately ruined the immersion.
- amelius 4y agoIt looks incredibly realistic in Google Streetview too. A technology from, what, 10 years ago?
- dash2 4y agoVery realistic. Unfortunately Price's English accent is not so realistic, being more from chim-chim-churree/Big Vern territory [1]. Not shoer people talk lahk vat in Sarf Lahndahn any mawwah, squire bruv guvnah. [1] https://twitter.com/byramb/status/1326098732501381120?lang=zh-Hant https://twitter.com/byramb/status/1326098732501381120?lang=z...
- fattless 4y agoIf this photorealism/accuracy is interesting to you, you might find the game "Chernobyite" interesting. Smaller indie studio scanned huge parts of Chernobyl and perfectly recreated it for thier game. I havent played it, but interesting stuff.
- raspyberr 4y agoLooks amazing. Unfortunately, doesn't look very interactable. So why not just be a film? Would look even better then.