11 ms·
It's sickening that this is always marketed as bad news, even though we've been in a bubble for the past 20 years. The bad news is that we decided that owning a
by pessimizer 4y ago
It's sickening that this is always marketed as bad news, even though we've been in a bubble for the past 20 years. The bad news is that we decided that owning a house is a retirement plan instead of giving people proper retirement plans. Somehow every non-homeowner has to be a policy slave to the passive income of some wealthy person. And we defend it by claiming that old people who are worth enough money not to work are not wealthy, as if we care about old people. We only care about old people as model "savers" who can be used to morally justify policies that directly and overwhelmingly benefit the very wealthy to the obscenely wealthy.
And also, there's a problem with revolving credit (i.e. a 2-year mortgage), such as Australia or Britain, or anything that is floating along with some interest rate. But these are a) intentional problems that the people making the loans hope will make them rich, and b) problems with pricing, because people are expected to take decades longer to pay off a house than it would take for them to build it alone with their own hands in their spare time.
- paulpauper 4y agoIt's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. It's good news for people who want to buy a home and have been waiting for prices to fall. People who read the Economist probably fall in the former category by demographics.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's bad news if you own a home and the market falls and you need to sell. Otherwise it's some opportunity cost (arguably) but you can continue paying your mortgage payments to stay in your house, and if you hold long enough it'll likely recover. This is different from the last major crash because that time house prices AND mortgage rates both dropped so you could easily feel "trapped" in your underwater house.
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> Otherwise it's some opportunity cost (arguably) but you can continue paying your mortgage payments to stay in your house, and if you hold long enough it'll likely recover. Most people cannot do this though, because the conditions that lead to housing market crashes also result in huge numbers of layoffs. What that means is that not only do people find themselves "underwater" but also unemployed, which means they either can no longer afford their mortgage payments, or sell at a (often huge) loss and start renting and/or relocate.
- neogodless 4y ago> It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. If you sell it (quickly). I happened to buy in 2007. House prices fell. But... I sold in 2020. Overall 38.5% price appreciation in 13 years. (Inflation over that time period was roughly 25%.)
- causi 4y agoI don't understand how high prices good news for anyone except people who own multiple houses. Your home is not a luxury. If you're selling it in an inflated market you're also buying in an inflated market, unless you want to throw your money away renting.
- 1123581321 4y agoIt’s good for people who want to sell and live in something smaller, since the market inflated the delta between differently valued houses on an absolute dollars basis. And in the age of increased nomadic living, emigration to low CoL countries and multi-generational households, there might not be much of a replacement to buy or begin to expense. Just explaining, not advocating for selling one’s home to retire.
- eweise 4y agoWell no. Its typical to sell in an inflated market and buy in a cheaper one. Market being a different location.
- syspec 4y agoBy definition that is NOT typical, otherwise the inflated market would have no buyers and the cheaper one would have no sellers
- lazide 4y agoNope - they’re talking about turnover between current ‘have’s’ and ‘have nots’, allowing the have’s to move to an area that someone who is poorer cannot afford to live due to lack of jobs or the like. There are more than enough actual houses in the US. We aren’t short on space. It’s location and current needs based on time in their life and available assets, etc.
- TuringNYC 4y agoIt is good if you want to change jobs and switch cities. If the market has fallen, you cannot sell w/o coughing up the difference in what you owe. (same in the case of owner death/divorce, where you need need to liquidate)
- ericmcer 4y agoGood news for people buying cash. For first time owners who need a loan the falling prices are more than offset by rising interest rates.
- TuringNYC 4y ago>> It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. >> It's good news for people who want to buy a home and have been waiting for prices to fall. It is bad news also if the market falls, you buy, and then it falls even more. The problem is the entire system where you are making a 30yr investment just so your family can get a good school district.
- nostrademons 4y agoIt's not that bad as long as you're planning to stay in your home and keep your job. Long-term owners are basically indifferent to housing prices, because they're not going to be making any transactions in the housing market. Same reason Warren Buffett is always marveling over why working-age people think news of stock market declines is bad. If you are a net saver, you want asset prices to be cheap and interest rates to be high, because you'll be a buyer of assets. Also, you're going to be investing in your children for a good 20 years, so it's not that irrational to make a 30yr investment in a house to get them into a good school district.
- jjav 4y ago> The problem is the entire system where you are making a 30yr investment just so your family can get a good school district. A good school district can be nice (if you'll have kids and if you'll send them to that public school) but the primary reason to have a home is have a place to live where the costs are predictable over the long term, unlike renting.
- bombcar 4y agoEven if you have no children, the people you sell your house to may, so a good school district is a thing to keep an eye on. It’s also shorthand for a bunch of other things that boil down to “things are being managed decently well”. If you know you’re buying the house they’ll carry you out of to the last 6 feet you’ll own, then you can be much more flexible.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> And also, there's a problem with revolving credit (i.e. a 2-year mortgage), such as Australia or Britain, or anything that is floating along with some interest rate. But these are a) intentional problems that the people making the loans hope will make them rich, and The 30 year fixed US mortgage is responsible for a lot of the higher prices in US. Future taxpayers or users of the USD pick up a lot of the interest rate risk on behalf of present day borrowers. Evidently, given the continued resilience of the USD, market participants are very okay with this. > b) problems with pricing, because people are expected to take decades longer to pay off a house than it would take for them to build it alone with their own hands in their spare time. This is a highly dubious claim for which I would need to see proof. The actual building of a house in the US is down to 100 days by a well operated tract builder. The outsize portion of the cost is in the land.
- pessimizer 4y ago> The actual building of a house in the US is down to 100 days by a well operated tract builder. So I think one person should be able to manage it in less than 30 years, periodically calling in skilled help. If you're a Walter Segal fan, you can probably do it a lot faster. > The outsize portion of the cost is in the land. It is. I think that's a problem because land value is always speculative, so everything can be written off as land value. Why is that land worth that much? Because that's what was paid for it.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf you think the average person is capable of doing the things needed to build a modern house, or learning to do them at a level of expertise compared to any professional, we are living in different worlds. 90% of people will not get past laying a concrete foundation.
- crooked-v 4y agoI think of all the reddit DIY posts where there are immediately a hundred comments about how those notched beams will inevitably collapse and destroy the second story, or about how those pipes are laid out wrong and are guaranteed to clog, and then there's the nightmare that is bad wiring...
- kodah 4y ago> The bad news is that we decided that owning a house is a retirement plan instead of giving people proper retirement plans. I've pondered on this a lot. Houses have been treated as "nest-eggs", which is really a fancy term for a fallback plan, for quite some time. The housing market really only got out of control after the 80's which coincides with when mortgage packages started getting sold on the stock market. To me, that, city zoning, corporate SFH buying, and state governments that have economic policies that embrace/grow inflation seem to be the actual problem. I still think it's worth while to have house equity as a way to securely store money, but the government has to protect the housing market conservatively to make that work. Just like anything else the market is a system of incentives.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoPerhaps also single family zoning started to make its effects clear in the 80's. Personally I'd prefer to live in a nice townhouse in a dense neighborhood but that's hard to pull off (location wise not many options, and price wise there's just not enough available to make the nice ones comparable to a single family house)
- kodah 4y agoI suspect a successful city depends on diverse housing availability. Having too much high and medium density brings its own issues, same with too much low density. There's probably also something to how those are arranged within a city. I always wanted to grab something with lots of trees in near-proximity to the city, but I don't want to live near the active hustle and bustle. That usually comes with other trade-offs like a lack of greenery.
- rco8786 4y agoI agree with your overall point but > even though we've been in a bubble for the past 20 years what is a "bubble", to you? the last 20 years includes one of the greatest housing crashes of all time, and a period of some of the cheapest housing costs we've ever seen.
- orangecat 4y agoPrices did fall after the 2008 crash, but only back to where they were around 2003: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA. Of course there may have been more of a drop in particular locations.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoPeople bought with a mortgage though, and rates went down.
- chordalkeyboard 4y agolower rates mean higher prices, ceteris paribus
- pessimizer 4y ago> the last 20 years includes one of the greatest housing crashes of all time, We can call it a housing pause at this point, because all of that money was put back into houses. I think it is unbelievably important to remember as a baseline that world housing prices tracked inflation for 400 years. In the US they tracked inflation, there was a bump up with government housing subsidy right after WWII, then it continued to track inflation until the dot com bubble burst After which there was hockey stick price growth, a crash, massive government intervention and transfer payments to the wealthy, mass evictions of people who couldn't pay after their ARMs moved, massive buy-ups of that property by large investors and funds, and the restoration of hockey stick price growth. > a period of some of the cheapest housing costs we've ever seen. Where? Are there any places that fell back to the 380 year trend line, or are there places that are reasonable compared to their price in 2006 considering inflation. We're still in a period of the most expensive housing costs ever. They've grown to precisely what they need to be to take away any disposable income, along with education and healthcare. They're completely detached from physical considerations, they're simple financial instruments. And property owners have tricked people into thinking that it's a supply problem.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt's bad news if: - we stop building more houses. That's what happened in 2008, and is one of the major causes of the current crisis - it discourages turnover. IOW, people who should move for work/personal reasons don't because they're underwater or because selling would mean they lose the really nice rate they're currently locked in to. And without turnover, it becomes hard / expensive for people to buy. The latter issue is a stupid technical reason. The second issue could be solved by transferrable mortgages.
- JustSomeNobody 4y ago> - we stop building more houses. That's what happened in 2008, and is one of the major causes of the current crisis This will most assuredly happen. Too many people have a financial interest in keeping housing prices inflated.
- biomcgary 4y agoI am a huge proponent of normalizing work from home / remote work for this reason. Arbitrary, economically forced turnover (i.e., location requirements from corporations) is very disruptive for human life and childhood development. As a kid, I averaged one move per year due to job availability being tied to location of said job. If housing turnover was primarily a matter of personal preference, not economic necessity, the world would be a more stable, healthier place.
- nine_k 4y agoFactory work cannot be done from home. With re-industrialization trying to take off, there will be more factory work, with many positions requiring highly educated / trained professionals.
- bluGill 4y agoReindustrualization is coming with automation. The people building the factory will go to the next one when this is done so they can live anywhere. Many of the machines need a specialist to repair, so that person just needs good access to an airport and can live anywhere. Some people will go in daily, but the days of thousands of Union workers in a factory are gone. It will be hundreds.
- sosodev 4y agoI find the bad news angle weird too. If our home were to lose half of it's value it wouldn't really change anything except our ability to move in the near future. That's assuming I keep my job during this time of course.
- choeger 4y agoWell, it depends on how you financed. If you paid a large part of your mortgage already, or needed a small one to begin with, you can still move, bacause all houses will get cheaper. If you sit on a large mortgage, though, you better don't move and have a long-running fixed interest rate.
- gipp 4y ago> That's assuming I keep my job during this time of course. Sure, but that's the other jaw of the trap we've built for ourselves. The knock-on effects of large-scale drops in home values are highly likely to induce major economic disruption on a national scale, which makes losing that job all too likely.
- anm89 4y agoDoes everything in world have to be sickening, or appalling or catastrophic. Is it really so sickening that someone in the world had the audacity to frame something in a way you disagree with? Can't you just say "I disagree with this"? I say this as someone who thinks it is very much a good thing that house prices are coming down, and the more the better.
- pessimizer 4y agoI only say sickening because it makes me nauseous. You may have another physical reaction, and you're entitled to it. > Is it really so sickening that someone in the world had the audacity to frame something in a way you disagree with? It's sickening because it's a manipulation intended to bolster house price growth. When housing is too expensive, some children literally don't eat. Is that sickening? > Can't you just say "I disagree with this"? I feel like I got that across. If you're complaining about getting a little extra, it's low on the list of things that bother me.
- anm89 4y agoGetting physically nauseated by every opinion you encounter you disagree with sounds like more of a bad outcome for you then anything else. I'd want to fix that if I were you but of course feel free to continue if you enjoy it. I'll be honest, I don't believe you. I guess go ahead with it if that's what you want. It definitely lowers the quality of the discussion
- bombcar 4y agoPeople have started abusing hyperbolic language more and more since text gives little ability to emphasize how strongly they feel. And soon everything is literally life and death and everything gets maxed to 11.
- pikelet 4y agoNo one said anything about 'every opinion you encounter', so if anyone is exaggerating it's you (and personally it feels more like you're lowering the quality of the discussion at this point). In this specific case I'm also incredibly frustrated by the negative language used in these articles. I see the same thing all the time here in New Zealand, despite house prices being completely out of reach of nearly everyone and most young people wondering if they will ever own a house. I guess it's just natural for those who only see housing as a 'market' to be exploited.
- danans 4y ago> people are expected to take decades longer to pay off a house than it would take for them to build it alone with their own hands in their spare time. Somehow every non-homeowner has to be a policy slave to the passive income of some wealthy person. I agree that we have made houses too central to net-worth, but most homeowners are not wealthy. They are typically paying a significant amount of "rent" in the form of interest on the borrowed capital used to purchase their houses. I'm not saying it's the same as the non-tax-deductible rent paid by renters, but it's a very different situation than an inherited house in a very expensive area that is owned outright. > people are expected to take decades longer to pay off a house than it would take for them to build it alone with their own hands in their spare time. As someone who built significant portions of my house with my own hands in my spare time, I can assure you that individuals artisanally and incrementally building their homes is not a scalable approach to housing. We should instead be building houses like we build modular flat-pack furniture, with major components built in controlled factory settings, and final assembly on site. The way I did it (GC doing the heavy structural work, my doing the finishing work) itself isn't scalable. Yes it saved me money, but the amount of knowledge I had to build in order to effectively complete it isn't realistic for most people, who very reasonably aren't interested in the understanding all the different ways to do flooring underlayments.
- dendrite9 4y agoYou might be interested in Walter Segal's ideas of building houses as assemblies from materials in their available dimensions so the parts are easy to reuse or modify. I find his ideas both compelling and a bit too idealistic or from another era. In the winter I have an architect friend who I talk to and hope to get his views on the pros and cons this year. https://theprepared.org/features-feed/segal-method https://theprepared.org/features-feed/segal-method
- pessimizer 4y agoHe's kind of amazing and I'm obsessed with him, but the problem with his original concept is how hard they are to insulate. He has a lot of living followers that have put a lot of time into designs that can be insulated well, but they lose the off-the-shelf quality of the original Segal concept. The Architects' Journal Special Issue: The Segal Method: http://www.ianwhite.info/THE_SEGAL_METHOD.pdf http://www.ianwhite.info/THE_SEGAL_METHOD.pdf http://www.segalbuildings.me.uk/ http://www.segalbuildings.me.uk/ ----- edit: It took me a little while to find Segal's followers' books, so I might as well list the ones I own here if anybody else is interested. They contain updated, insulated interpretations of Segal's process, and experimentation with alternative materials. The Self-Build Book: How to Enjoy Designing and Building Your Own Home by Jon Broome and Brian Richardson Out of the Woods by Pat Borer and Cindy Harris The Whole House Book: Ecological Building Design & Materials by Pat Borer and Cindy Harris The Green Self-Build Book: How to Design and Build Your Own Eco Home by Jon Broome
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- conanbatt 4y agoWell you want prices to go down because supply is going up. If the supply is the same and prices go down it doesnt mean it is more affordable - it is precisely because it is LESS affordable!
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y ago> because people are expected to take decades longer to pay off a house than it would take for them to build it alone with their own hands in their spare time. The problem isn't the building costs - it's the land costs. Construction workers are relatively low paid, and profits on home building aren't outrageous. DIY housing doesn't really solve any problems - and is a ridiculous proposal to the average person.
- bombcar 4y agoLots around here go for $10-15k and house prices are still what I would consider “highish”.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoProbably because people are only building McMansions - mostly because the way the market works - buyers are only buying new McMansions. Between site prep, utility hookup, permits, and plans - there's probably close to a $30k fixed cost to build a 600 sqft house. If the lot also costs $15k (usually $60k+) - you're looking at a $45k - $90k fixed cost. Every house has at least one kitchen - you can build these for much cheaper - but the types of kitchens buyers of new houses expect cost at least $60k. Same for a bathroom - but you're looking at $20k. Assuming the rest of the house costs $100 sqft - a new 500 sqft house is going to cost $50k + $60k + $20k + $45-90k = $175-225k. You want a ~20% margin - so this becomes $210k-$270k. At this point - why are you building a 500 sqft home? You bump it up to a 2bd + 2ba 1400 sqft home, and you run into the same problem. There's no buyers at the price you can build - so you build a McMansion instead.
- Ptchd 4y ago
- negamax 4y agoOhh.. literal property buying for secured retirement funds exists. All those chickens are coming home to roost
- ajross 4y ago> It's sickening that this is always marketed as bad news, even though we've been in a bubble for the past 20 years. Everything is marketed as bad news. Bad news sells. The bubble was itself a favorite target. And FWIW, we're seeing the same thing happen currently with the freakout about inflation. Understood correctly, inflation is just a gauge transform; it doesn't "do" anything on balance. Sure, it moves money around a little because some signals are delayed more than others. But to the extent it does it works to the benefit of almost everyone complaining about it. Everyone with significant debt (mortgages for the folks here, credit cards for the proles, corporate loans for the people folks here want to be) experiences inflation as a reduction in net money owed. It's a good thing for us, on balance. Yet... freakout anyway. Because bad news sells.
- WalterBright 4y ago> giving people proper retirement plans 1. social security 2. 401ks 3. IRAs of various types 4. simply buy & hold stocks These are already in place.
- the_sleaze9 4y ago1. Social Security This may not be a functioning program in the next 30-50 years, or will have extended the minimum ages for payout that they won't be viable. 2,3,4. All examples of the replacements for traditional Pension programs, which are what we should have. Putting the onus to not only save hard, but to invest wisely in the time horizons necessary for something like retirement in the market is, in my opinion, not workable and combined with the complete lack of education around money management in public schools makes it, again imho, just down right cruel. I'd like to see the return of heavily regulated pension programs and unions for many, if not most professions.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe traditional pension systems (defined benefit programs) have turned out to be very vulnerable to insolvency. Hence the transition to defined contribution programs, like 401ks and IRAs. SS is a defined benefit program. Its insolvency is a problem with all such systems, including the ones you advocate for.
- phkahler 4y agoTraditional pension plans should work better than individual retirement investments because they pool participants. Individuals have to invest enough to get the payout for their longest reasonable life expectancy. A pension fund can rely on statistics and not be funded enough for every participant to live the longest time. Emphasis on the word should. Humans are bad at managing huge amounts of money.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Traditional pension plans should work better than individual retirement investments because they pool participants I don't see any particular reason why they would. Lots of individuals do much better with their investments than bureaucrats do. Also, there are many "fire and forget" index funds available for those with little investment skill.
- ghaff 4y agoWhat are proper retirement plans? In the US, there is Social Security which one could argue could be higher but it's there. And lot of people were happy with the shift away from defined benefit pension plans that were essentially a transparent way to get a retirement supplement for having worked for GM for 30 years. A lot of people wanted to have greater control of their retirement savings in a way that wasn't tied to long tenure with an employer.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoMaybe because the long tenure with an employer went away in the 70's when we started off-shoring everything? I don't think people want control of their retirement savings, they just want a retirement savings. (And you're lucky if Social Security even covers health insurance costs - forget about covering your property taxes, grocery bill, utilities, etc.)
- SideQuark 4y ago>Maybe because the long tenure with an employer went away in the 70's when we started off-shoring everything? Maybe because people started moving around in their careers a lot more than in the 1970s when you had one job for life? We employ far more people, at higher wages (especially for women and minorities, and certainly with higher benefits (BLS tracks total cost to employ - check the historical data) than the 1970s. So maybe that offshoring really did not move many jobs overseas. Most jobs moved to automation (the US only lost top producer of goods rank somewhat recently - except most of that production is automated now). Also, pensions never covered many people. Far more people retiring have 401ks now than had pensions at their peak. https://eh.net/encyclopedia/economic-history-of-retirement-in-the-united-states/ https://eh.net/encyclopedia/economic-history-of-retirement-i...
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI guess I just see the causality in reverse. People "moving around in their careers" reads like a euphemism for laid off, downsized, given the pink slip.