12 ms·
Give nothing, expect nothing: Gitlab latest punching bag for entitled users
- greenthrow 4y agoThis take is bad. If you have been giving something away that your users rely on, then it is not unreasonable for them to get upset when that changes. Nobody needs a blog post defending Gitlab here. They are just suffering the expected outcome of their choices.
- overlisted 4y agoStuff like GitLab's or Docker's situation wouldn't happen if everyone self-hosted their own instances. This is yet another reason why centralization fails at scale: eventually some companies realize that they're giving free resources away to their users.
- 8fingerlouie 4y agoYou're assuming that self-hosting is free, which i can certainly guarantee you that it is not. The only situation where it may seem like it's free is if you host for your own personal use. For a business, somebody is getting paid to maintain self hosted servers on hardware (virtualized, on prem or in cloud) that are also not free, and besides the hardware cost you also have the cost of simply keeping them running. For personal use, it is only free in the sense that you don't value your free time. Initial setup is the smallest part of it. If you intend on exposing your services to the internet, you also need to be on top of patching, reviewing logs and much more. I've been self-hosting for decades, but these days i simply use whatever cloud offering fits my needs. It's usually cheaper, and/or much more resilient than what i had at home.
- yobbo 4y agoJust by having a phone, you are self-hosting software on a machine with 8 cores and several gigabytes of ram. Yes, it's not free, but the marginal cost of an app is effectively zero. Git on its own requires nothing in resources. I have an instance of gitea running in a container since many years. Its marginal cost now is less than $1?
- overlisted 4y agoYes. We need to develop easier ways of deploying self-hosted apps, which unfortunately isn't happening now because of a "I need demand to create demand" cycle that someone has to kick off. Panels like portainer are already a step in the right direction.
- WhyNotHugo 4y agoDunno why people insist on the "give nothing" part. The community has given a lot to GitLab. Every project that moved there had a network effect of bringing people over. So many have contributed to GitLab itself, both patches, bug reports, feedback, etc. And lots of devs have advocated at their place of work for a "let's move to something more open that GitHub" and moved entire organisations onto GitLab (I've seen this at multiple places of work). Not to mention that GitLab itself is built atop countless hours of work put into the libraries and foundations it uses. The open source ecosystem is a community where most parties are contributing and consuming what others contribute. It's ridiculous to portray GitLab as a "received nothing" entity.
- sparedwhistle 4y agoWe expect those free features to be free because THEY SAID SO.
- anothernewdude 4y agoIt was the paying customers of Redhat who complained the most to me. They had previously been able to use centos as a test for things, or for places where the more enterprise features were unnecessary. Dunno how that story ends, I jumped ship. I think they were looking into Rocky. Treating the free tiers as just a taste of the paid tiers is a misunderstanding of how this business works. It also reduces the worth of the paid tiers. Gitlab will be worth less as a business because of this, but perhaps they're focused on selling CICD and giving up on competing with basic github. And Docker simply gave up on their stranglehold of containers. Of course people complained and looked for free alternatives, and it will be Docker that suffers. They don't have much of a business model.
- frameset 4y agoYou make an excellent point. Where I work our company policy was that Linux VMs in Azure were either RHEL or CentOS. Since the scrapping of CentOS we've switched to Ubuntu LTS, with Premium support from Canonical where needed. I can't imagine we're unique in this.
- tetha 4y agoA lot of the complaints I have heard about CentOS also wasn't that CentOS was changing, or going away. Most people kind of expected something to happen sooner or later with IBM on board. It's much rather about how clumsy the change was: Bring out Centos8 first for a year or two as usual, and then slash the EOL and change how the distribution works massively post-fact.
- maxnoe 4y agoExactly, announcing that there won't be a CENTOS 9 would have been massively less controversial then changing EOL of CENTOS 8.
- EdwardDiego 4y ago... they still can use CentOS to test things now that it's upstream of RHEL. That's a weird complaint. Shit, they could even use Fedora.
- powersnail 4y agoIt’s a useless act to tell people to stop complaining about a free product just because they didn’t pay for it. First, free users still have the right to complain. Freedom of speech. I have grievances about Windows and MS, and I don’t even use it. Second, complaining is just words. It’s not like users of Gitlab are demanding financial compensations. They are just talking. It’s Gitlab’s right to choose to listen or not listen. “You didn’t pay for it so shut up you entitled free user” is one of those ideas that just don’t work in practice.
- markovbot 4y agothe author of this blog post appears to be disagreeing with some people's attitude and explaining another view of the situation. They are not imposing on anyone's freedom of speech or (as far as I can tell) intending to. They are also just offering words, perhaps in the hopes of changing some people's minds. I wonder, what makes this "useless" in your mind? > “You didn’t pay for it so shut up you entitled free user” is one of those ideas that just don’t work in practice. I agree with this, but not for any of the extremely dumb "reasons" you've provided.
- powersnail 4y agoI’m not saying that the author is imposing on people’s rights. I’m just saying that free users and frankly non-users have such a right, and are acting in accordance with what they are fully entitled to do. The act of complaining has nothing to do with payment. It’s you see something you disagree with, you can complain about it. Whether the target has a preexisting contract with you is irrelevant.
- Lutger 4y agoYou're absolutely right! And this is also exactly what the author does. Exercising the right to freedom of speech by complaining about the entitled freeloaders who complain (a tiny sliver of) their freebies got taken away from them. We sure love to complain. It's our freedom of speech.
- ricardo81 4y agoI make a point of donating to open source if I create an issue or speak to maintainers, just a token amount of a few Euros - or more if I've used their code consistently.
- throwaway290 4y agoI used to sponsor project maintainers on Github recurringly until MS blocked that feature for me because I have a Russian ID. It sucks that there is no common way of supporting OSS projects, but I guess that's nothing to complain about.
- rvieira 4y agoI don´t really agree with the Red Hat part of the examples. Red Hat has Fedora, CentOS and RHEL. The new approach makes sense to me, Fedora is the upstream to RHEL, RHEL is the upstream to CentOS. Additionally, users can use (up to a limit) RHEL for free now. Also, the nature of projects is very different. RHEL is available to be repackaged (e.g. Rocky) by the community with Red Hat´s blessing. A better analogy would be GitLab ending the freemium, but adding free enterprise GitLab for x accounts and giving the source of GitLab enterprise to the community to distribute as they want (but without official support)
- avhception 4y agoI (and by association, the company I work for) have been a CentOS user and was very unhappy when that was taken away, of course! But It's not necessarily about the money. We're no big enterprise, we're a bunch of small onlineshops and a few other operations. I'd be very happy for my employer to toss RedHat some coins. We're not stupid, I know that for RedHat to stay around they need money. I'm also a big open source advocate, so I'd be more than happy. But how do you even do that without involving a lot of overhead? DigitalOcean, our infrastructure provider, doesn't even offer any paid Linux. You pay for the VM and that's it. As far as I know, it's the same for AWS, Azure and what-have-you. RedHat needs to rethink their business model, maybe partner with these providers so they get a cut of the price from DigitalOcean. I'd be more than happy about that, heck, you could even include a small contingent of support tickets with the VM. Maybe a cheap CentOS VM w/o support and a slightly more expensive RedHat VM. I could definitely have used that at some points! So, RedHat, please - take our money!
- krageon 4y agoYou can pretty easily install whatever you want on whatever cloud provider you want if you have an actual VM you access. If that's outside of your capability, you shouldn't be using a VM. That said, there are providers that will sell you paid for OSes for a monthly extra fee. They're just not US technology giants :)
- avhception 4y agoWell, I didn't say I can't roll my own images. I said it's too much overhead. You loose a lot of the integration that the cloud provider has already baked into their images, you have to deal with RedHats subscription manager and sales department etc. What I want is an easy "20$/month CentOS, 24$/month RedHat" offer where all of that is taken care of.
- signal11 4y agoSome providers, eg, GCP, have this already. Red Hat Enterprise Linux[1] is available, as is Ubuntu Pro[2] and Rocky Linux[3]. Red Hat and DO need to speak to each other. [1] https://www.redhat.com/en/partners/google https://www.redhat.com/en/partners/google [2] https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/compute/ubuntu-pro-available-on-google-cloud https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/compute/ubuntu-pro-av... [3] https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/application-modernization/introducing-rocky-linux-optimized-for-google-cloud https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/application-moderniza...
- Barrin92 4y agoI think the take is partially right in that people are too entitled when it comes to these things, but there's a reason why that is and there's differences on the side of companies offering these benefits. A lot of companies do openly tout and incentivize people to move to their platforms loudly advertising their free features. And given that these are infrastructure platforms, they do that knowing very well that there is a certain kind of lock-in. If you create outsized expectations in your users in the name of spurring growth, you don't get to complain about them. I think Sourcehut does this in an ideal way. On the site it very clearly says that it's currently free, but as soon as it goes stable it expects users to pay, in fact they actually sent me an email reminding me of that fact. There's no shiny "we have all these shiny features, the first dose is free!" behaviour.
- dspillett 4y ago> I think Sourcehut does this in an ideal way. On the site it very clearly says that it's currently free And the honesty about alpha quality is refreshing. I usually find that someone being honest about that indicates that their idea of “alpha quality” is some distance better than what many claim to be “beta” or “release” quality! And not tracking (assuming this doesn't change in future) means that once you do pay you aren't paying twice (once with money, once with letting yourself be stalked by commercial interests). Self-hosted option too. Duly added to my ever-growing list of things I'd like to investigate but might never find time for…
- belorn 4y agoThe keyword here is infrastructure platforms. When those change, everything built on top has to change with it and this create work for people. I could imagine what happen if gmail would suddenly become a paid platform with no free tier. Users would have to change very single account they got in the world that is tied to that email, and I know in some cases you might need to contact support (through email) or use a recovery password. A lot of peoples identity is tied to a free service, a "freebie" given by a for-profit company. I fully agree that users have some outsized expectations on free infrastructure platforms, through I wouldn't blame that on the user. User's don't generally have much choice in what platform their bought products is built on top, but it is them that feel the effect first when the bottom layer is changed under their feet.
- tomedme 4y agoThe problem is that there's nothing between $0/month and $19/month. I would happily pay $20-50 a year for a "Solo" GitLab plan. I have a handful of small repos hosted by GitLab. I don't use CICD for those repos.
- djmips 4y agoWhere will you take your GitLab repos now?
- tomedme 4y agoThey're not inactive so there's no reason to move them. I also have Github and Bitbucket accounts if necessary.
- dspillett 4y ago> The problem is that there's nothing between $0/month and $19/month. A problem with having a smaller account is that once people are paying anything they expect, rightly so, more support than the free account, and the company has to account for this. It might be more trouble than it is worth to take the money for smaller accounts. You or I might never touch that support, maybe the majority won't, but some very much will. Our apps (in DayJob) service regulated financial industry companies (T&C and compliance side, not dealing with the money) and we have paying clients who are essentially paying costs because of how much time they drain (one of my regular tasks: proving that bad data has once again been sent in a nightly feed from a 3rd party system which is why we rejected the data). Free users are obviously costs too (they use resource) if you ignore the market-share and mind-share aspects, but it may be that low-cost users would be a worse prospect for the business. Also offering multiple pricing plans can cause confusion for some users who already don't 100% know what they actually want.
- Lutger 4y agoSo then the free tier has you covered right? It's still there, with 5gb storage, unlimited private repos and everything.
- 4y ago
- wokwokwok 4y agoYeah yeah, everyone is entitled and we should think of those brave corporations who need to make money. Seriously? Look, when you give something away for free, you’re either a charity or you’re marketing your non-free tier products and using your large user base to drive premium users. If a company has committed too much to their free tier and it is not sustainably driving premium users, I have little sympathy for them. You did a marketing thing. It didn’t work. Sucks to be you. You are still not getting my business. I do not feel sorry for you when people lash you on Twitter and promise to leave. There’s no reason to feel sorry for companys in this situation; it is a situation of their own engineering. If you don’t like the product, don’t use it. If enough people don’t use it, the conversion funnel will dry up and the company will change tunes (again). The only thing to take note of here is, yes: if you’re not paying for it, you are the product. Feel free to grumble about it and call out these companies, but don’t be surprised about it. > The common thread here: Lots of users expect to get things for free, forever, from for-profit companies that don’t answer to them. Those users contribute almost nothing1 to the bottom line for the for-profit companies, and actively drive up costs for them. Please, spare me. Those users are part of the conversion funnel to paid tier users. Gitlab would not exist without them. If they piss them all off and they leave, it will contribute, I’d wager, significantly the total evaporation of their bottom line.
- yunohn 4y ago> those brave corporations who need to make money Have you considered that (and the article mentions this) the employees of said corporations, people like you and I, also want to be paid for their labor?
- mafriese 4y agoYou guys are getting paid?
- cesaref 4y agoI agree. It's a question of marketing, and if the company thinks that it can attract people with a free offer and expect to convert them to paying customers via non-free add ons, then that's their call. If it turns out they've massively over-estimated the value of their add-ons, and they don't get the conversions they have justified the free offer with, then that's again their mistake. I think we also have to discuss the elephant in the room, that these businesses are layered on top of free software, so they are effectively reselling (and attempting to profit from) something that is free, so it's unsurprising that people's expectations when considering using open source software is that they don't need to pay for it.
- Dave3of5 4y agoThe company chooses to use a freemium model if they want only paying customers to use their product then they are within their rights to change to that. Just because something is free doesn't mean you have no right to complain. If I give away free food that's spoiled and causes food poisoning am I immune from all damages? An example of this is Facebook. It's free for the users but it does track and sell a lot of your personal data. Without complaints from users we would never have seen things like the ios adpocalypse or GDPR. I'm sure the person who wrote this doesn't read HN but still wanted to give my 2 cents.
- frederikvs 4y agoTo me, the big lesson here is : if your company wants to offer a free service, be sure that you can keep offering that for free. Any limitation or restriction you put in place later will result in bad press. Offer the free service, but put limits in place right from the start. Only this many free repos, only this much free data, etc. Removing a limitation later on is easy to do. Putting a limitation in place is hard, and results in bad press. It's also fairer to users - they know what to expect, they know the limitations and the rules. They aren't caught by surprise when the rules change on them.
- thih9 4y agoWhat’s more important, bad press or paying users? Sure, not everyone will pay and some users will leave but those that stay might make up for it. My point is that launching with a free tier and applying limits later has been an effective monetization strategy for many successful startups. Gitlab might be a special case because of open source projects; providing a service and then asking for money from people that in many cases work for free does feel a bit pointless.
- Jensson 4y agoIf you make decisions that leads to you making money but causes problems for users then you will get bad press, simple as that. People would rather not use a free service at all instead of migrating and later be forced to migrate to another service again because it got too expensive, so any such strategy is user hostile. It is more user friendly to be upfront with what users needs to pay, of course the initial free is good for growth but still it is user hostile growth.
- blowski 4y agoStartups grow by giving users unlimited free access, only to start charging for that access once they've grown big enough. Such users should expect companies to revoke the free access. Such companies should expect bad press for doing so.
- bearmode 4y agoNot sure how much it is about entitlement, probably rather users angry at the bait & switch. Companies offering the world for free, getting users to expend the effort to move to their service, and then suddenly changing the entire structure and expecting users to pay. If you offer a service for free, you should be able to keep offering that for free (with paid upgrades instead of removing functionality from a free tier/removing the free tier entirely).
- zigzag312 4y agoThis. The problem is companies (ab)using a free tier in order to lure a huge amount of users into using their product and when they get enough of them, they change the free tier to be almost unusable, trying to force as many of free users as possible to convert to paying customers. It's not that users are entitled to free products, but companies using dishonest marketing of a free tier for their own gain. Free users may not be paying costumers, but they do invest their time into the product (that they probably wouldn't have otherwise), and more importantly, they spread the word about the product. Imagine the amount of advertising money the company would have to spend in order to reach as many customers as they have with the help of free users. If you can't afford to offer your free tier permanently, be upfront about it. As there are business models that can afford permanent free tier and users can't know which kind of free is your offer. Don't dishonestly use free users for marketing purposes and dump them when you don't need them anymore.
- Lutger 4y agoWhy? Why should a company do that?
- bearmode 4y agoTo avoid garnering a ton of bad press & ill will from users who now feel like you've deceived them, and that they've wasted their time on your service.
- gwnywg 4y agoWell, looks like I'm going back to old good Mantis and Jenkins on my own server. Good old times are back :)
- hyperbovine 4y ago> When CentOS moved from a direct clone of RHEL 8 to the CentOS Stream model, hordes of people raised virtual torches and pitchforks because they were no longer able to run a freebie RHEL clone. Many noted that this was bad for their business because of the uncertainty and having to either pay up or move to another RHEL clone. Few seemed to note that it’s bad for Red Hat’s business when people don’t pay for its flagship product, which in turn continues to fund development of RHEL. “Freebie RHEL” is an odd choice of words. It’s been literally decades since I meddled with RHEL, but CentOS as I recall it was the community response to RedHat essentially trying to cordon off a whole distribution’s worth of FOSS, and charge money for it. I am surprised to learn from Wikipedia that RH succeeded in capturing governance if CentOS sometime in the teens, and not surprised at all to see that another project, Rocky Linux, arose to take its place.
- afiori 4y agoThe founder of both Rocky Linux and CentOS tells the tale it his own word in a podcast https://changelog.com/podcast/427 https://changelog.com/podcast/427 My understanding is that over time RH became the main maintainer of CentOS organically, so they were fronting both the direct costs (dev time) and indirect costs (people using CentOS as a cheaper RHEL).
- PaywallBuster 4y agoI think the most painful point is that they removed the 5$ plan and require their _anual_ subscription to be paid upfront. Lots of people use only the basic features (git, issues, merge requests, maybe the CI with Gitlab runners or self hosted runners) The premium package may be too much, for people who are not interested in the 100s of premium/enterprise features they Gitlab is building or where paying per seat quickly becomes uneconomical. Shameless plug: I'm building a managed Gitlab hosting at https://hosted-git.com/ https://hosted-git.com/. I'm still happy with the Gitlab product but I think there's a gap in their offering for SMEs/small teams who may otherwise jump ship and migrate to a competing offer given the very competitive landscape! Hopefully paying per server will be a good alternative and give customers more control.
- Lutger 4y agoRemoving a cheap tier is not a nice, though I still think that if the premium price is too much then you're better off on the free tier. And if that's really not enough you really were lucky all these years profiting from gitlabs growth hack. The premium tier still provides a ridiculous amount of value for it's price. For truly open source projects, they have a really generous program giving seats that normally cost 100 dollars a month away for free.
- molf 4y agoIf you have more than 5 users, the free tier is not an option. We liked and paid for Gitlab, but the price hike from $4 to $19 per user is absurd. Forcing an annual subscription on us was the motivation we needed to migrate away.
- Aeolun 4y agoTo get just one single thing we need would be $100/month. It’s for some 100’ish people, so it’s $10k per month, and since they don’t do monthly, it’d be $120k in one go. I just… I can’t present that to management as a good deal. There is no way whatsoever that that’s worth it. We can get all of the things Gitlab does separately, better and at a lower price…
- sph 4y agoDocker, GitLab and Red Hat are punching bags? I do not have any horse on this race, but am I supposed to feel bad for corporations? Why should one care about a company's feelings? Dealing with entitled users is one cost of doing business and it is already included in the price. > Lots of users expect to get things for free, forever, from for-profit companies that don’t answer to them. Those users contribute almost nothing to the bottom line for the for-profit companies, and actively drive up costs for them. Are you serious? Give me shares and I will contribute to the company's bottom line. What a lousy proposition.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoI hope this article is satire. Users are absolutely right to be upset at Gitlab, Docker, etc. who pull a bait-and-switch on the community. Users adopt the product because of the infra foundation is free, and then comes the rug pull when the product reaches market saturation. This almost always happens right after a capital raise...
- sparedwhistle 4y agoIt's hard to tell if something is genuine or satire these days isn't it...
- c0mptonFP 4y agoIs there a word for this type of business model? Offering a service for free until they become the de-facto standard, and then start squeezing people?
- popcorncowboy 4y agoMonopoly
- christophilus 4y agoGitlab is far from a monopoly by any definition. The name for it is VC-backed capitalism. Burn through money to buy a market— run at a loss longer than your competitors can, then flip and start hiking prices once you are dominant. That was never a good strategy for Gitlab, though, so I’m surprised they took that road.
- popcorncowboy 4y ago> The name for it is VC-backed capitalism The goal of which is to seek monopoly or at worst stable oligopoly. Anyway, GP was asking what you call it when you saturate/dominate a market, become the standard and then raise prices on your captured audience. This is definitional monopoly. VC-backed capitalism is a predictable symptom emerging from the possbility of such outcomes.
- wink 4y agoDisregarding the contents of the article, if you looked at the thread of the "we're giving you less space" announcement, I saw a handful of people just here who were like "wait, why do we have all these artifacts? why is there no automated (and documented) retention policy for this crap?" - so I think Gitlab have to blame themselves for this part. They don't deleted old stuff and don't even make it easy for the users to delete their old stuff - hard disk usage goes up. surprised pikachu face But yes, I know this is not the full story and I'm not even sure I have a Gitlab account, so I'm at least not an entitled user of their service in any noticeable manner ;)
- popcorncowboy 4y agoPure corporate apologist bollocks. Shame on the author. When a business offers something for free there's always and everywhere a commercial imperative behind it that is calculated to be to the beneift of the business (any consumer benefit is incidental). Fundamentally the problem with this move is that it's anti-consumer. A corp wears some cost up-front to feed some benefit, and then when the cost to the consumer to switch is high enough, they pull the original deal (and yeah, as someone else said, this often happens sometime after institutional money gets involved). At least drug dealers have the temerity to TELL you that only the first one's free. Corps that bait and switch like this without grandfathering in the people they made the original deal with are straight up exploitative. Put whatever lipstick you want on that pig Joe, you're not a make-up artist, you're a shill.
- tailspin2019 4y agoOne thing that this sort of analysis sometimes misses, is the users who may well have multiple accounts (or influence over such), some on paid tiers and some on free. Then the "entitlement" can become a bit more of a grey area. I have both free and (multiple) paid accounts with GitHub for example. If I complain about limitations in their free tier, I am still also a paying customer of GitHub at the same time which is important context. That's not to say that the "entitlement bias" being talked about here for free services is appropriate, but it's just extra context to keep in mind. By the same token, I use a lot of Cloudflare's free services, but I've also brought them a lot of business, have multiple accounts and external customers on paid tiers etc. So I am a revenue generating customer for them. As a customer, I evaluate these companies' services on the sum total of my experience across my paid and unpaid accounts. As a side note, this can also backfire when it comes to support. I feel that I get pretty bad support from Cloudflare at times, because they seem to treat me as one of their many freeloaders [0], when in fact I've had multiple Pro and Business plans with them and until recently have introduced new customers to them too (which they won't necessarily be able to track). When they respond to me, they don't really have a clear picture of my value to them as a customer, and I think it shows. So when analysing how a company treats its "freeloader" users, its worth bearing in mind that a significant proportion of those users may also be revenue-generating for them, some in ways that won't be obvious. [0] I use "freeloader" here as a purely descriptive term about the commercial relationship and not as a judgement.
- zigzag312 4y agoDon't dishonestly use free users for marketing purposes and dump them when you don't need them anymore.
- netzego 4y agoIt is simply not true that non paying users "giving nothing" and therefore can't "expect nothing". I always wonder, where were these tech companies now if they started with that castrated service in the first place? Would you consider paying for git web service, no one ever heard about it? All these "cheap" users were making it possible to be greedy now. These companies just exploiting their network effect, well knowing their are now "to big to fail". "As of August 2022 GitLab has a market cap of $10.09 Billion." [https://companiesmarketcap.com/gitlab/marketcap/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/gitlab/marketcap/]. GitLab you'll get your cake so cry gentle.
- durnygbur 4y agoI would gladly pay for a Linux distribution outside of <Number> Eyes jurisdictions or at least with a transparent relation with them. Americans you can pay or not, doesn't matter. They'll munch all available data either way.
- lizardactivist 4y agoWell, even after these changes I think the free offer is generous, and that GitLab as a whole is god-sent. I can't complain.
- Aeolun 4y agoThe problem is not that the you don’t get something for nothing. The problem is when something that you used to get is suddenly taken away (regardless of the cost).
- h2odragon 4y agothese platforms wanted what their "free tier" customers were publishing, so they could become a source worth paying for. Now that they have gotten reputation and interest they've forgotten what brought it / no longer care to pay the price for the meat of their attraction. This was all predictable: Remember SourceForge?
- danielovichdk 4y agoNo such thing as a free lunch. Grow up
- strken 4y agoThe problem with what GitLab did (but not with Docker or CentOS) is the potential data loss. The bait and switch is fine if it just causes a migration to some other service or an upgrade to a paid plan. Deleting users' old data is different, though. Even if it's not morally wrong, it's the kind of decision that makes me lose faith in a service.
- myszon 4y agoProgrammers expect to get paid handsomely for writing software and get software for free. <sarcasm> Sure. That makes sense... </sarcasm>
- dangerface 4y ago> it’s bad for Red Hat’s business when people don’t pay for its flagship product There was never any chance of me paying for rhel if they had been upfront about the support lifetime of centos I would have just used Debian and every one would be happy. The only problem was them binning it over night. If your business does a rug pull like this what else are people going to think? - Edit - If a business says one thing it's not entitled for people to expect them to keep to their word, if they don't keep to their word you can expect backlash, thats not entitlement. The whole thing reads as "Consumers need to think about the feelings of corporations"
- oytis 4y agoThe companies are (rightfully) punched for first offering services that cost money for free, thus discouraging the open source community from developing and promoting decentralised alternatives and then taking advantage of the adoption and lock-in. In the good old days it would be called dumping and maybe even got the attention of antitrust bodies.
- yowlingcat 4y agoI'm surprised no one has mentioned the elephant in the room -- Gitlab's new pricing per user per month ($19/mo) is steep compared to the incumbent, Github's ($4/mo). I like the ability to self-host, but I'm not sure what I really get from the premium.
- satellite2 4y agoIt's interesting that none of those businesses tried the megaupload business model: free and slow by default, paid and fast otherwise.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoIf your pricing plans include an unbounded amount of anything, then the unbounded dimension will be abused by some proportion of your users. You will then be accused of a bait-and-switch when you try to correct your initial error. You either need to charge for everything according to usage, place reasonable-and-transparent acceptable use limits on everything, or accept this dynamic.
- jrochkind1 4y ago> As they say, if you’re not paying for something, you’re the product. If you didn’t pay for RHEL, you have no stake to complain about changes to CentOS. Why doesn't being "the product" give you stake to complain?
- darepublic 4y agoI do wonder about this sometimes. When free services make their service worse in the interest of monetizing. Is it entitled for people to feel upset by that? Well I wouldn't say it's entitled to feel a certain way. It may be that psychologically it's natural for people to react this way and maybe companies like Gitlab would do well to remember this going forward. But it can also lead to situations where users are bullying a service that is fundamentally reasonable.
- balentio 4y agoWhat you are "Giving" Gitlab is partial custody over your coding "children". You are having to trust that Gitlab isn't going to screw you in some way or another, which history shows is a "Bad idea". I think until we can get a situation where code is hosted on our own hard drives and accessible on the web at the flip of a switch, we are always going to have this "but you guys didn't pay for x" feature convo. The solution then is to not use Gitlab, but to invest in decentralized services that make Gitlab extinct. Problem solved.
- wikitopian 4y agoOpen source is a monetization strategy for corporations operated by and for mature adults who are attempting to profit. While there surely remain some humble hobbyists involved in the process, tech executives should stop hiding behind cultural norms of gratitude within the open source community that were meant for the true volunteers, not them. It's like if I dressed up like a referee, went downtown to where some kids were playing basketball recreationally, screwed up a bunch of calls because I don't know what I'm doing, then got offended by the kids because they jeered my bad calls. I would be especially unsympathetic if I were only volunteering to referee the games for free as part of a for-profit scheme where I charge people to bet on the games.
- KronisLV 4y ago> When Docker had the temerity to introduce limits for free users pulling containers from DockerHub, or requiring a subscription for large business users, lots of people started complaining and/or looking for a free alternative. To me, this feels almost inevitable for any service that might need to provide lots of storage to its users. It's actually kind of surprising how expensive most cloud storage is. Personally, I just migrated over to having my own Nexus instance for all of my container images, with custom cleanup policies (e.g. dev repository is purged every week, prod one has a different policy), as well as there's the obligatory proxy repository that acts as a cache for pulling things from Docker Hub or elsewhere. Currently it's hosted in a VPS with a HDD, though if I need even more storage, I'll just move over to my homelab with more HDDs, which are way more cost effective than renting lots of space, even with smaller local providers. Of course, for many it will be infinitely more cost effective (e.g. when they don't want a learning experience) to just pay Docker Hub or another provider to use their managed container registry. That might not always be viable when planning things for an enterprise setting, though, which is when this knowledge about self-hosting and on-prem deployments might come in handy. > Now, GitLab is making changes to its free tier and may zap inactive repositories or repos that are too large. In my eyes, that's probably the same problem and honestly the idea of purging data that nobody has accessed for a while seems like the logical outcome. Let's take this argument to the extreme, just for fun - what would happen if GitLab would store this data in perpetuity (assuming the company survives)? Would we end up with 100 year old repositories by people whose descendants will manage them? Or, you know, a bit of a graveyard? > When CentOS moved from a direct clone of RHEL 8 to the CentOS Stream model, hordes of people raised virtual torches and pitchforks because they were no longer able to run a freebie RHEL clone. Here, I think there is more nuance. I think the thing that upset the community was not that CentOS was killed off (in its previous free-RHEL-alternative sense), but rather that the EOL was changed. Instead of announcing that CentOS 8 will be supported until its approximate EOL of 2034 (since most other releases were supported for ~10 years), instead they changed it to 2021, just 2 years after release. Even CentOS 7 will outlive it, its life span being 2014-2024. So many enterprise deployments went wrong because of this choice and people were understandably upset. Moreso, there weren't really that many alternatives to it with a similar reputation: Rocky Linux took time to get up to speed, Alma Linux isn't quite as widely trusted and many would prefer not to use Oracle Linux for certain reasons. Alas, it was a bit of a mess, especially when you are in circumstances where nobody will feasibly pay for RHEL but want something like it.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoI really don't understand the perspective of most people here. Providing a service like Gitlab does costs money. The more people use it, the more it costs them. The bigger the projects they host, the more it costs them. Maybe at one point X feature was practical for them to provide for no cost. Now that they're larger, X feature is now too costly to provide for free. I don't think it's reasonable for everyone to use whatever pricing scheme would work at the huge scale when they haven't made it there yet. That's a recipe for killing the product fast. So - start with what works to get yourself off the ground and adapt as inflow and outflow of cash change. If you don't like it, there are plenty of alternatives.
- todd8 4y agoWhile there is lock in to using a service like Gitlab, I wouldn't expect the "free" tier to provide every feature I might need. Sophisticated software like, say, Adobe's products are expensive to develop and maintain. Eventually, Adobe's bundling and required subscription fees made me leave their suite of high-quality products because I'm not a media professional in any sense. On the other hand, despite being a long time Emacs user, I don't mind paying for JetBrain's products. They are high quality and are definitely worth what I pay for them. Expect to pay for what you use and be grateful for anything that is given for you.
- gardenfelder 4y agoAs if it's even remotely possible to reduce a really complex (borderline wicked) situation to some core thing, consider this: How do you plan to pay for your free lunch?
- theknocker 4y ago
- siproprio 4y agoMaybe it’s for the better, if in the future there’s no service perceived as the default one. Perhaps then we’ll get something better than git.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThe open-source model works by applying shaming tactics to bad actors. It's always interesting to see people try to apply this to profit-driven companies, who are essentially immune to these tactics. "Oh you were using a free service, and it became paid? And you're not going to pay? Then nothing of value was lost. Move aside and make room for someone who will pay." - The companies, probably.
- addicted 4y agoGitlab keeps misleading its users. That’s why people criticize them. This has been the case since day 1, when Gitlab was supposed to be O/S with money made off consulting and later Gitlab.com hosting. They host a free tier and they keep moving stuff out of it without much warning. But quite simply this article is invalid because it’s not even accurate about its facts. Gitlab also removes features for paying users. They frequently move features that were present in a certain tier to more expensive tiers.