28 ms·
America’s favorite family outings are increasingly out of reach
- AlwaysRock 4y agoWhat movie theater are they going to that has $9 tickets? Even the non profit theater near my house cost more than that. The AMC is 11.20 per adult and 9.09 per kid.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoThe underlying causes are probably the ones underlying https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- nxm 4y agoForce of globalization was/is too strong to turn back time
- PaulHoule 4y agoFor these particular services I think https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease is more like it. That is, a Raspberry Pi is a much more powerful computer than the IBM 360/75 that planned the moon mission and costs orders of magnitude less but there has been no productivity improvement for baseball players. Movies are an entirely business than they were back in the day. I remember Ghostbusters being in the theater for more than a year, and back then there were not just the first-run theaters that charged full price but many second-run theaters that had cut-rate double features (I remember seeing one of Gremlins and The Dark Crystal) Today home video "competes" with theaters in some sense, a month of Netflix costs less than one movie ticket but the consequence isn't downward price pressures on theaters but exactly the opposite because home video demolished the second-run theaters leaving the first-run theaters to go on their own trajectory. (And as for TV sets and things to plug into TV sets... Today's TV offers better quality than was imaginable in the 1960s and is cheap in comparison. It's astonishing what people spent for old game consoles like the Atari 2600, what a VCR and tapes cost in 1980, ...)
- turns0ut 4y agoProblem with such theories is people are making the choices as to what laws and interpretation of them are, not magic. The people in charge have gotten much richer than average people. That’s not magic or unexplainable. It’s explainable in very easy terms; humans are taking advantage of other humans. Sorry; the magical thinking must stop. It’s people intentionally designing policy to empower them at others expense: https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-of-workers-is-a-big-factor-in-fed-policy.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-o... Economic theories are just another form of “god spoke to me, and said for every 10 widgets you produce, I own 9 to exploit for myself”. It’s just people being biased and manipulative for their own gain. Edit: asset valuations are often self reported and inflated to fake wealth. Fake social media accounts influence millions in spend, faking public interest. What economists are measuring is illusory.
- PaulHoule 4y agoIt's usually hard to say if people are better or worse off. Back in the 19th century Europeans weren't all that sure if they were better off or worse of than the Romans. Today's cars are better than cars were in the 1960s in every way. People live in bigger and better houses. Post-Starbucks you can find a good independent espresso bar even in small towns in the flyover states. I remember the demagogue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyndon_LaRouche https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyndon_LaRouche talking about the decline and fall of the US in terms of the decline in the number of hospital beds. But the truth is it's a good thing and not a bad thing: back in the day you would spend weeks in the hospital after getting heart surgery, now they know you're better off going home and being moderately active as soon as you can. The marxist argument that capitalism is a scam because somebody other than the worker makes a profit doesn't ring true with me because I've had jobs where I didn't produce enough value to earn my pay and it was always an enormously stressful situation that ended in tears.
- turns0ut 4y agoKings of old could not go buy Wagyu at the super market. We don’t need the patronizing and pontificating of the past to see some people do real work producing stuff and services and some use a pen to claim a portion for themselves. Ye olde English gibberish to make sense of that is unnecessary. Physical reality does not operate on human philosophy.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoImmigration from non-european countries exploded right around that time due to the immigration and nationality act. I don't know if that's co-orelation or causation. https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/ft_2020.08.20_immigrants_05.png https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/ft_20...
- retcon 4y agoIn the UK the 1980 banking act introduced formerly excluded commercial banks to housing loans and simultaneously increased the statutory maximum loan value from 3* single wage earners salary to 5* combined household income of married couples. Previously only mutual savings and loan member societies aka building societies could lend private housing loans. Not only now was the public forced into paying for profit margins, but access to capital enjoyed by commercial banks vastly outgunned the much more regulated thrifts who eg couldn't easily raise their offer rates above long term deposit bases. Disastrous in the up rate eighties. Louis Ranieri of Solomon Brothers fame opened The Mortgage Corporation in London and shipped in top trading talent but the thrifts not only knew nothing about their books but weren't persuaded to unload like the accidental priming of the US mortgage market. Although profit seeking it seemed only Ranieri ever gave a damn to do anything that might have saved UK S&Ls. Nothing contributed to the dissolution of the family more than this legislative enforcement of the necessity for one of any separating couple to forgo the ability to afford a home. P.S. Increasing the lending limit naturally turbocharged inflation. Adjusting your books to manage changing rates environment requires at least functional treasury and cash desks. Into this century several household name UK mutuals turned into banks didn't have their own CHAPS terminal. (Clearing House Automated Payments. Entry level facility for a even a token treasury function. Edit: for that matter even for a small company such as ours.) Edit: added about the rates market and the abysmal neglect of UK capital economic underpinnings. Things were so desperate and freewheeling the largest UK thrift only was persuaded to return the six billion it's actuaries deemed in excess of pension fund requirements at the time of demutualization in 2018. No carry paid. Edit2: only Ranieri.. have / gave a damn. Ed3 Louis' name correctly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Lendal 4y agoAnd yet pro events and Disney consistently sell out or are packed. So there must be additional complicating factors at work here.
- juve1996 4y agoIt's not really that surprising. There are a lot of rich people in America/the world that can afford these things, which is why prices raise, and the middle class/poor are further left out.
- hristov 4y agoThis is a great site except for the Hayek quote in the end. One of the bad things that happened in 1971 is that people started listening to scumbags like Hayek, instead of economists like Maynard Keynes who genuinely wanted the economy to help everyone and make the entire country richer and more powerful. The post word war economic order was Keynesian. It created the greatest economic boom known to mankind. Then people got greedy and the ideas of the kinds of Hayek got in vogue. Not only did the middle class get screwed but the philosophy of Hayek and the like made it seem like it was completely necessary and cosmically just that the middle class must get screwed.
- 999900000999 4y ago>But Martinez, a customer service specialist in Los Angeles, didn’t feel the magic when he saw the price tag. “Just for one day in the park and one night at the hotel, we were looking at over $1k and that didn’t even include food,” he says. “I had to explain to the kids that Mickey was out of Daddy’s budget.” WTF, if your from LA you just drive there? >Median household income was $67,521 in 2020, a decrease of 2.9 percent from the 2019 median of $69,560 (Figure 1 and Table A-1). This is the first statistically significant decline in median household income since 2011. https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2021/demo/p60-273.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2021/demo/p60-27... This article uses a figure of 84k per family. I agree with The article's premise, but it just feels a bit sloppy around the edges
- spywaregorilla 4y agoYour statistic is for households. Theirs is for "families", and may only include households with children.
- 999900000999 4y agoThey don't explain that though, usually the terms are used interchangeably when you're talking about a macroeconomic sense.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> They don't explain that though They don't use your term so why would they explain the difference? > usually the terms are used interchangeably when you're talking about a macroeconomic sense. This is the first time I'm looking into this but I'm pretty sure you're just making that up. Google shows many sources disagreeing with you, most of which cite definitions created by the US census bureau. https://www.economy.com/support/blog/buffet.aspx?did=932EBFA8-D905-4945-A5D5-D02D98113FA4 https://www.economy.com/support/blog/buffet.aspx?did=932EBFA...
- 999900000999 4y ago
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIMHO places like Disneyland getting very expensive is actually a sign of the large number, and growing, of well-off people. These places are one of a kind with extremely constrained supply-side while demand is huge so prices are relatively high to very high depending on the level of access/Hotel you choose. I am not convinced either that a trip to Disneyland with hotel stay was ever within reach of everyone, especially without a level of planning and saving for it. For many people who go there I suspect this is a once in a lifetime or once in a generation experience.
- roflyear 4y agoIncorrect. You can have an increasing segment of the population in count but the percentage of that population of the whole of the population is decreasing.
- bluedino 4y agoThe amount of money you could spend on your daughter on a Disney trip...they have an incredible amount of princess-related add-ons.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoAs a father to a daughter... you seem to have gone through the experience as well! ;)
- pjbeam 4y agoOh boy, this exactly. We just did Disney World for my oldest and a week of tickets + hotel (definitely not cheapest options) was about 10k. Food and drinks another 2k. Add ons almost 4k. You have to pay bribes to Lightning Lane if you don't want to spend hours in line. And then of course there's so much demand for everything that you basically have to regiment the visit entirely with reservations for everything. Overall it was a good trip but I should have taken time off afterwards to recover from my "vacation".
- bel_marinaio 4y ago
- treis 4y agoThis isn't really a good comparison. We have the same number of Disneylands and MLB teams that we did in 1960 with double the population. Not to mention increased international tourism to a place like Disneyland. And a box of candy, tub of popcorn, and sodas have gotten significantly bigger than 1960. A lot of places like LA are significantly worse than they used to be. But flyover country still has pretty cheap living. My local Six Flags + Water Park season pass including parking was $80 per head this year as an example. That's a lot cheaper than $1k for a single visit to Disneyland.
- loldk 4y ago
- dfmooreqqq 4y agoIn 1960, we had 16 MLB teams [1]. We currently have 30 [2]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1960_in_baseball https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1960_in_baseball 2. https://www.espn.com/mlb/standings https://www.espn.com/mlb/standings
- treis 4y agoWow I didn't realize so many teams were that new.
- hourago 4y ago
- oneoff786 4y agoThat feels like you’re identifying a cause, not invalidating the comparison?
- bombcar 4y agoEven Disneyland isn't insanely expensive for those who live locally - they have a "California Resident" pass to encourage locals to go during down times. What makes it expensive is airfare and hotel added on top of the tickets.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoEven camping is getting expensive too.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoIf you camp like they did in the 60s? I don’t. I have a modern backpack with a camel pack and lightweight tent and electric lantern et cetera. But those are one-time costs. And they’re totally optional. Car camping is still highly accessible and cheap as hell.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoNone of those things relate to being charged $15 per night per person for a spot with no facilities where you carry everything out 5km from the nearest transport.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> None of those things relate to being charged $15 per night per person for a spot with no facilities Back-country rangers have to be paid. And campers cause more damage than day hikers. That requires enforcement and mitigation. I believe NPS fees have tracked under inflation over the decades. Camping, based on fees alone, is cheaper than it once was. (And if you don’t want to pay the Park Service there are our National Forests.)
- dahart 4y ago> Camping, based on fees alone, is cheaper than it once was. This sounds right to me, a lot of my local parks seem to have rarely or never increased fees for decades. Several nearby canyon parks have had the same fees as long as I can remember. I keep expecting an increase, and am consistently surprised year after year that the prices stay fixed, making it relatively cheaper each year. Even the annual park fees are super low, making it incredibly easy to amortize the per-night cost of camping to be even cheaper, provided you want to do it more than once or twice in a year.
- 4y ago
- krsrhe 4y ago
- willturman 4y ago> But where fans are really getting taken for a ride is in the parking lot. Parking isn't necessary to see a baseball game at 90% of these venues, and shouldn't be included. Including parking in these comparisons at all demonstrates a lack of understanding of population density and transportation trends over the past 50 years in any city large enough to support a major league baseball franchise. We need to lose this expectation that you just drive your mini-van within 200 feet of any venue with something you want to see.
- rco8786 4y agoThis is totally out of touch with reality. Parking is absolutely necessary at 90% of these venues for a family. Transportation trends in the last 50 years have simply gotten more and more car dependent. Do you live in the US, or are you talking about somewhere else? Do you have children?
- jeffbee 4y agoJust anecdotally the nearby baseball parks are all well-served by trains in ways that they certainly were not 50 years ago. BART did not exist 50 years ago, now it serves (directly) the Oakland A's and within walking distance the SF Giants. Neither Amtrak Capitol Corridor nor Caltrain existed 50 years ago, now Capitol Corridor serves the Oakland A's directly and Caltrain serves the SF Giants directly. Increasing car dependence in the last 50 years is not a trend I am personally observing.
- bombcar 4y agoWith a family it's often much cheaper to drive the car even if you overpay for parking. Heckles, even in San Diego, where the trolley runs right into the stadium basically, you'd pay $5 per person round-trip, so you only need a family size of 3 to cost as much as the cheaper garages, 4 would match the "preferred" ones. Doesn't cost in gas, but you may be driving to the other end of the trolley anyway.
- 4y ago
- tonmoy 4y agoIsn’t this all driven by supply and demand? If people really were making less and willing to pay less for these activities, wouldn’t the companies automatically start cutting costs, make the products inferior and lower prices? Doesn’t this analysis only tell us that people today are more willing to (or able to) spend more compared to their income (maybe people save less or spend less taking care of their elderly or something)
- scottLobster 4y agoOr the industries are moving up-market. You have to go where the money is, and as the years go by there's less and less of it in the traditional "middle class". I also wonder if easy access to credit pays a roll. Credit cards were simply harder to get back in the day (partially tied to interest rates), which means a lot more enforced savings. Nowadays even someone with marginal credit can get a $1000 limit, blow out the card and pay 20+%/month on a baseball game they couldn't afford in the first place. But the ball park/team won't care, they got their money.
- f6v 4y agoOr maybe there’s unequal wealth distribution. Someone might be willing to pay but can’t make that much. One example is software engineer vs mailman.
- dfxm12 4y agoProbably not, especially when dealing with families. Notice how the tickets are relatively cheap and usually have gone up the least? You get marketed the cost of the ticket, which might look reasonable, but then the cost of add-ons, like beer, parking, etc., are hidden from you. That's where the biggest increases are. You, as an adult might have some foresight and self control to think, OK, I'm going to eat before I get there and I'll buy cheap merch at the store after the fact if I had a really good time, but they know that you probably won't say no to your kids who want a popcorn, a soda and to get the limited edition hat, all at outrageous markups...
- judge2020 4y agoThey would, the point of this article is that the upwards pricing without upwards wages means more and more people can't afford the vacations. Unless they just build in more capacity (which they do where they can[0-2], although DisneyLand is quite constrained in terms of real estate), the demand is increasing much faster than that capacity and thus the prices are increasing to match what the market will bear. 0: https://insidethemagic.net/2012/06/double-dumbo-debuts-at-the-magic-kingdom-offering-walt-disney-world-guests-twice-the-flying-elephant-fun/ https://insidethemagic.net/2012/06/double-dumbo-debuts-at-th... 1: https://thedisneyblog.com/2015/03/06/epcots-soarin-to-add-third-theater-and-upgrades/ https://thedisneyblog.com/2015/03/06/epcots-soarin-to-add-th... 2: https://www.themeparkinsider.com/flume/201605/5083/ https://www.themeparkinsider.com/flume/201605/5083/
- collegeburner 4y agonot just for families this makes it real hard to date as a 20something. all the stuff girls expect got way more expensive. i'm lucky i get paid well but not everybody got it this easy. and tbh i can't blame ppl who don't want to spend all this money on dating.
- f6v 4y ago> all the stuff girls expect The fact that someone is expecting someone else to be paying for dates in 2022 is just crazy.
- bombcar 4y agoI feel many things people call "dates" are very ... transactional these days. :(
- hombre_fatal 4y agoThis is just a self-limiting belief. Statements like " all the stuff girls expect" should be a red flag to you. Frankly, I hear this uttered by guys who are only making statements about how they think dating is like since they aren't actually doing much dating. Hint: Try branching out beyond dinner dates, anyways. There are cheap/free dates that are far more interesting, and you filter for cool women that want to do those things. "Wanna go to an expensive dinner?" isn't what women want in 2022 either. It's boring.
- fundad 4y agoPeople are scoffing at this but cutting out most of the dating pool because they don’t want to do cheap activities on dates is not easy advice to follow. Appreciating more substance is something people mature into. Over the course of years, not the length of an romcom. Anyone already mature enough in their 20s is likely take.
- dfxm12 4y agoParking is where they get you the most, then on top of that for out of town destinations, you would also have to rent a car. I was lucky enough to be able to walk to MLB games with my father when I was a kid. It just goes to show how valuable public transportation is, even when you're taking the bus to the movie theater, or popping on some light rail from the airport to wherever most of the hotels are.
- aaronax 4y agoI think everything is just generally "nicer". Stadium seats are cushier, parking lots are paved instead of gravel, sidewalks are a lot wider, more air-conditioned spaces, better food availability, etc. And people expect more exciting and high quality things now, because they have seen a lot (comparably). Someone growing up in the 1930s wasn't able to hop on the interstate and go 300 miles away for the weekend. Those growing up in the 80s were more apt to do that sort of thing, and as mobility has increased, attractions (nicer ones) have been built out over the decades. Now that person who traveled to all sorts of attractions continues to seek out new things -> bigger and better of course. More $$$. The basic, economical attractions are still there if you look. Just think smaller scale. Instead of national parks, go to state parks. Instead of Disney, go to the state fair. Instead of Broadway, find the local theater troupe. Instead of MLB/NFL, check out summer or arena leagues. Just because you read about an attraction that seems cool, is 1,500 miles away, and is the best of breed nationwide, doesn't mean you need to or even get to experience it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bluedino 4y ago>> Someone growing up in the 1930s wasn't able to hop on the interstate and go 300 miles away for the weekend. Those growing up in the 80s were more apt to do that sort of thing You mean 1950's, not 80's
- tmaly 4y agoUS Highway system was not declared complete till 1992
- orangepurple 4y agoUS 59 north out of Houston may be upgraded to an Interstate soon. The overall plan is called the NAFTA Superhighway because it would be a great connection between the populated parts Mexico and Canada.
- DiffEq 4y agoWhile I understand the purpose, and the intrigue of the things discussed in this article, the title itself is inaccurate. My experience growing up in MT is that we did none of these things, nor did my peers. Most of the things we did were free and still are....like going for a walk, a hike, a bike ride, plinking, etc as a family.
- bombcar 4y agoI think they're talking about "yearly activities" - at least in the southwest it was relatively common for families to take a "vacation" each summer which was usually centered around something like going to Disneyland, or traveling somewhere, etc. Depending on how wealthy you were, there was a wide variation on what and how - poorer kids in my class would go to Magic mountain for a day (drive up early, drive home), richer kids would go to Disneyland for a few days and stay in the hotel. The nice thing was that you could have friends from class who were vastly different "wealth" go to the same park (the poorer kids would go for the day, but meet up with their friends who were staying at the hotel). From what I remember we never really cared one way or the other, we just had fun.
- prmoustache 4y agoThanksfully, the part that suffered the biggest increase are the parts (food, drinks) that you can bring to the venue or skip (parking) by doing things wisely.
- carbadtraingood 4y ago"Getting the same experience as earlier generations is more expensive" "Thankfully you can just not get the same experience!" You can only wring so much blood from a stone. The problem of declining working class comfort can't be solved by belt tightening forever. We, as working class folks need to start banding together and reclaiming our portion of profits.
- prmoustache 4y ago"You can only wring so much blood from a stone. The problem of declining working class comfort can't be solved by belt tightening forever. We, as working class folks need to start banding together and reclaiming our portion of profits. " Best way to do that is to create, participate and or support the non industrialized entertainment, not crying in the clouds. That are so many free/cheap sports to watch, more than often very locally, why sticking to the high dollar working class milking stuff? There are so many cheap yet interesting cultural stuff happening, why going to the big theaters to watch blockbusters? There are so much stuff to do in the woods, national parks, lakes, rivers, why going to entertainment parks when you could be doing fun stuff outside with a lot less money?
- burlesona 4y agoI am very skeptical of how they calculated the baseball numbers. Yes of course if you buy a whole bunch of stadium food it is expensive, but one of the entire gimmicks of the baseball stadium is that they make most of the money on beer and food. The thing is, food is optional! This is a form of progressive pricing that allows the team to charge people who are price insensitive more while still being affordable. Most baseball stadiums also have constant or frequent promotions for seating in the outfield berm, or standing room only, or last-minute walk ups, etc, which are very cheap. I recall walking up to the Astros stadium and getting $8 tickets just as the game was starting. So if you really want to go to a game but you don’t have very much money, there are usually ways that you can get in for very cheap. Parking is weird to include because it varies a LOT depending on the setting. Much like the airport, there are usually unofficial parking options just a bit further from the stadium that are much cheaper than the official parking - though this is less true for the suburban stadiums. One last thing is to note that the experience at the stadium has changed enormously. Stadiums in the 60s were basically a bigger version of high school bleachers. Now they’re luxury palaces. What has really happened is the stadium experience used to be much more equal, and now it reflects and capitalizes on increased economic inequality - offering wealthy fans a super-premium experience for a ridiculous price. I think that’s the actual problem. What used to be an extremely “democratic” past time is now an extremely unequal experience. And while I don’t think that is baseball’s fault, I think it’s a negative reflection of the broader economic changes since the 1950s.
- Spooky23 4y agoI agree, especially when looking at Mets and Yankees tickets. The price difference isn’t really there. We are a huge baseball family do a big extended family trip to the Yankees every year - usually $5-12 for 30 bleacher seats to a weekday game. I’m a Mets fan, and we usually do a few of games a year. One of the things about the baseball experience is there are lots of ways to enjoy it. Usually we do one “big” trip where we score a deal on a resale ticket behind the plate or first base, often including food for $100-150. Then we’ll do a couple of SRO or upper deck trips with a $5-12 ticket. And we’ll also do lower level outfield tickets for $30-80. I grew up I the 80s, and times weren’t all magic and marshmallows then either. My dad worked for the city and my mom was a nurse. We couldn’t afford fancy baseline seats at big city ballparks then either. Baseball is different in smaller markets though. If you’re in Pittsburgh or Cincinnati, your baseball ticket options are very different.
- hristov 4y agoTwo of these things -- baseball and disneyland are clear monopolies. The other thing -- movies is not really that expensive if you do not buy the food and you should not be teaching your kids to eat at the movies anyways. A lot of people are talking about the way the working class has been screwed over since the seventies. That is a good point. But another more practical point is that if you do not want to pay through the nose you have to keep your wits about you, know the price gouging monopolies and avoid them. Take your kids to a national park instead. Or to a soccer game. Or to a museum. One of the ways America is becoming a country for the rich is that monopolies are becoming more acceptable both in mass culture and politically and legally. As an ordinary person you can push against that. The easiest and first way you should push against is with your wallet and with your spending. Then you can do the more complex thing -- elect politicians that will not tolerate monopolies.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI will teach my children, if I ever have any, to eat at the movies. My girlfriend and I always try to support our local theater by getting as much concessions as possible. Movie theaters are a very important part of my life and I don’t want them to die. A movie ticket wouldn’t fund a thing, especially with inflation now.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoDoesn't seem that great to teach your kids to eat some of the worst food just to support a venue. It also sounds like self-deceit tbh. "Totally just eating this slurpee and vegetable oil 'butter' popcorn to support the local theater!"
- el_benhameen 4y agoYou can teach them that it’s a special, infrequent thing. My kids eat lots of fruits and vegetables and I don’t keep junk food around the house. But for me, shitty theater popcorn is part of the experience, and we go to the movies rarely enough that it’s easy to say “hey, this stuff isn’t good for you so we’re not going to have a lot, but let’s enjoy ourselves now and then”.
- yalogin 4y agoThis is something I have been lamenting for a while now. Taking the family to a basketball game is a really expensive proposition now. A family of 4 needs to spend more than 1000 to just lousy seats in the Bay Area. I don’t know who goes to these games and how they are able to justify the cost.
- rr888 4y agoA problem is everyone now goes to the big teams, theme parks, national parts etc, the second tier is unloved. Our local baseball team closed down because no one turned up, where everyone follows MLB. Similarly Yellowstone is overcrowded but the campground I used to go to as a kid is empty.
- MattGaiser 4y agoI have to wonder how much of it is this. My father and grandfather spoke of going camping at their favourite regional camping spots. When I went to university however, I had similar vacation experiences to people from all over the country as we all went to Disney and we all went to Vancouver and we all went Banff. The vacation/leisure experience is homogenizing for the middle class and decreasingly local.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's definitely an aspect - travel including air travel is so cheap now that people go to the "big spots" - people likely can't even name the closer small areas.
- nitwit005 4y agoAlso a bit less exciting to travel a small distance because of places getting more similar over time. It used to be you could travel a short distance and hit a new accent, and slightly different food.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoWhere are you where you have empty camp grounds? The local/state ones here in the PNW are booked out months in advance nearly everywhere. I suspect bots are being used.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoIsn’t this just “Baumol’s cost disease”? All of these are services and services have had their price go up faster than inflation (while goods have had their problems go up slower). It’s kind of meaningless because money is fungible, so if Disneyland costs 2x what it did in 1960 (in real terms but your clothes cost 1/2 as much then you could be saving money overall. In fact that’s why they have CPI in the first place!
- robg 4y agoWhereas movie theaters seem to be a dying industry, and doing what they can to survive, Disney and baseball could afford to charge less. But why would they when demand <> supply can be tightly controlled by increasingly higher prices?
- bazzert 4y agoA beach parking pass for a popular beach near Boston is now $45 for a weekend day.
- jeffbee 4y agoThis is really a riff on the fact that if you don't drive a car and eat meat the inflation is not a thing. The NYT personal inflation calculator makes this pretty clear. There is a sharp inflection around perceived inflation related to cars, airplanes, and animal products. If you walk to the ball game this story looks very different.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoThe plain Quaker oatmeal I buy in 42 oz canisters is 50% more expensive than it was 10 months ago. I can come up with more examples that have nothing to do with meat or animal protein if you'd like. One thing you're ignoring is that even if you don't drive a car like myself as well, tangible stuff still has to be transported around. And for food, the war on fossil fuels is also a war on farms using Diesel powered equipment for which there is no replacement and nitrogen fertilizers made with natural gas. We've only just begun to see the effects of these two issues. OK, there is one replacement for there and a lot more people in the world will be experiencing it: starvation.
- jeffbee 4y agoAh yes, the "war on fossil fuels" in which oil prices today are lower than they were 10 years ago. Nice try.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoVehicle users don't give a damn about the price of crude oil except to the extent it makes the fuels they use like Diesel more expensive. Our biggest problem is refinery capacity, it's down 1 million barrels per day or 5% from before COVID which has now abated causing demand to go up. Distillate imports from Russia which were making up part of the gap have been embargoed because of the invasion. Worldwide refinery capacity is said to be down 3 million barrels per day. Natural gas prices were getting bad due to bad policies in China, Europe and the US before the invasion, and CF Industries as one example shut down both of its nitrogen fixing plants in the U.K. last year (the government there arranged for one to reopen so the byproduct of CO2 would be available for other food industry uses). For that matter, 10 years ago is a curious beginning point to choose because another anti-fossil fuel President was in office at the time. Rhetoric is not going to fill empty bellies in the coming months or make my breakfasts cheaper.
- elif 4y agoThey didn't include the costs of COVID testing, masks, or probabilistically amortized costs for lost work, paxlovid, etc. The costs of these activities has truly never been higher.
- mgas 4y agoMy personal take on this is that the idea of adjusting for inflation over time based on macroeconomic rates of inflation is useless (apart from showing that even though we make more money now, we can afford less). National inflation does not correlate with cost of living on a 1:1 scale. The lesson is similar to the adage "the stock market is not the economy". Typical things that are presented to us as the proverbial market forces (jobs creation, stock market indices, currency valuations, national debt) are more often used as excuses by price-setters to increase costs for consumers, whether or not manufacturers and service providers (at any level) actually incur increased costs. We as consumers are typically blind to this, and just accept that things get more expensive. Remember the oil issues in the early 2000s after the Deep Horizon leak and Hurricane Katrina? Gas prices went from ~$1/gal to over $3/gal for a while, then settled back in at around $2.50. And everyone was relieved and just ate that crap because they could finally fill up their suburban tanks without waiting in line. It's going to happen again here soon, when gas comes back down to around ~$4/gal (or $5.50 in CA). Also, in what world does a stadium beer at a Padres game cost $5? Even a disgusting Bud Lite will run you north of $10. The reality of MLB is that you can probably get tickets for next to nothing, not need to pay to park (if your stadium is in an urban area and you are willing to walk a bit), but you will absolutely get gouged on food and drink. The movie theater model is in full effect.
- throwaway4220 4y agoWhy did Disney get $500M in govt subsidies?
- stomczyk09 4y agoI mainly want to address the baseball portion, as I do agree with the theme park prices getting to crazy high levels, and big expenses: -While it is frustrating that the prices are rising, there are ways around this. The type of game is an important factor to include. Obviously rivalries are going to be expensive, but if you go to maybe a Wednesday night when your team plays someone out of market, you can grab same day tickets for a deal on broker sites(although fees are annoying). I believe there are ways to be creative about this, and doesn't necessarily have to break the bank(I paid 6 dollars to see the yankees play the marlins like 3 years ago as an example). -The food portion I do agree with, as that is getting out of control. I tend to eat before I go and stick to waters(maybe a beer or 2) to not spend too much while there. -Given the subway system in New York, I've never had to park a car to get to a game and pay round trip 5 bucks to get to the game, so I'm uneducated on this one. I am sure this is probably the hardest cost to avoid in most cities. Last thing I will say, as I know my prior thoughts don't necessarily address the obvious problem of major league games becoming out of reach for groups/families. When I was a kid, one of my favorite games I've ever been to was a Minor League game in Newark, NJ. For a low price, you can get GREAT seats and the same environment of a baseball game. From what I remember, it was a fantastic family environment, that tends to offer cheaper amenities(i.e food, drinks, etc.) that still provides a great ballgame environment. Know this is not the same as seeing your favorite big league team play, but still a great option! Would love to hear what people think
- neutronicus 4y agoThe Orioles are for sure dirt-cheap. They run promotions where you can get in for four bucks. When I was in Pittsburgh for a minute the Pirates were a crazy bargain too. If the MTA ever gets its shit together I'll be able to get there and back on the Light Rail, too.
- stomczyk09 4y agoGood insight! That being said, the only baseball stadiums I've been to are the 2 in NY, Philly, and San Diego so don't have the national insight. The Yankees do Pinstripe passes where you get a beer and a seat for X dollars which tends to be a good deal
- sloan 4y agoCourtesy a rentier investor class intent on not sharing the growth of the economy with workers.
- intrasight 4y agoOut of reach AND tickets sell out. So what's Disney to do? Why would they lower prices? Ballgames don't generally sell out. And they have several available price-points. Movies have ways to get discounts. And their issue is just getting people in since their competition is watching at home. Like offices, they need to make the experience very compelling. Not so easy.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThis is being reflected in the kind of startups that get large funding rounds these days. Its either products made for people who have too much money (NFT marketplaces, superfast delivery, expensive consumer goods), or for people who have too little (BNPL, medical debt payments, etc) America - and American entrepreneurs - need to ask themselves some tough questions.
- fundad 4y agoI think one problem is Americans aren’t the target market for major attractions and events as much as international tourists and of course high income Americans. The real whales have the sky boxes or rent out the whole venue.
- jrwoodruff 4y agoThe other piece of this that isn't accounted for is the demand on family budgets that didn't previously exist - cable, internet, cell phones, streaming services, higher grocery prices, higher insurance costs. The family budget is getting squeezed hard before any of these pleasant weekend outings or vacations. And then when you do get to the park, concessions, upgrades and other upsells make the entry-level experience feel subpar.
- bushbaba 4y agoinsurance costs. Heck it's ~4k/year even if your primary employer pays the majority of the cost. And then you've got a deductible to hit...etc.
- eatsyourtacos 4y agoSelf employed I'm at about $1800/month in PREMIUMS for a family of 4 for medical+dental... not to mention the 10k+ deductible.
- stripline 4y agoWell you no longer have to pay the lamplighter, milkman, weekly blockbuster rentals, etc.
- skybrian 4y agoYou don’t have to eat out. Packing a picnic lunch can be done cheaply, and that’s a traditional family outing too.
- cortesoft 4y agoFor something like Disneyland, the total annual attendance is way higher today than it was in the 60s, so demand is clearly still there and they are increasing their capacity. It isn’t like they have a ton of excess capacity that they are pricing out of attending. Imagine Disneyland simply cut prices by 50% tomorrow. Now, instead of Disneyland being out of reach because it is too expensive, it would be out of reach because all the tickets were sold out. I would rather the cost of something increase than make it impossible to get at all.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's also nice (in a way) because they're much more cognizant of this, and if you are willing to flex you can get in much cheaper than a normal "high time face-value" price. Last time I went we brought 12 people for about a grand.
- zaptrem 4y agoSeems like they should just build more Disneylands.
- bombcar 4y agoI feel Disney is more gun-shy than they should be with new parks, they could easily support a midwest Disneyland and probably a Texas one, too. As it is the midwest has a rollercoaster in a giant mall.
- allturtles 4y agoI'm seeing a bunch of comments along the lines of "it's not that expensive to go to the movies/baseball game if you just don't buy any food or drinks." I feel like what we're seeing across a wide range of industries is a business model where the 'bare bones' experience can be had for a somewhat reasonable price, but a variety of things that used to be considered a standard part of the experience (popcorn at the movies, a soda or beer and hot dog at the baseball game, an assigned seat and a carry on bag on the airplane) are now 'extras' with highly inflated prices and fantastic profit margins.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agosee also: the entire airline industry
- EricDeb 4y agoWere middle class people really flying around that much in the 60s and 70s? I have no idea but I feel like they weren't
- MandieD 4y agoPretty sure that middle class Americans rarely flew before deregulation in the late 70s. My mom's middle class parents packed the kids up in the car and took a few epic road trips to visit family in other parts of the country in the 60s - flying would have been unimaginable.
- jeromegv 4y agoFlying got 50% cheaper after deregulation. Before that, it was definitely more of a upper middle class thing. Going to Europe for a couple weeks was definitely not common. https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2022/06/economic-regulation-of-the-commercial-aviation-sector-and-the-1978-airline-deregulation-act/ https://blogs.loc.gov/law/2022/06/economic-regulation-of-the... But somehow people think that "things were so much better before"
- VictorPath 4y agoThere is that, and there is also the fact that the average wage has fallen in the past century. Odd that the graph shows how much better the average family is off than in 1960, 60 years ago. As the graph shows, 1960 to 1970 was the largest boost. And most of the family income boost from 1970 to now was due to the wife having to work, not higher wages. Not the case for Google L6s, but the economics of the majority of US workers.
- bushbaba 4y agoHousing is expensive because it's what people can afford. I often wonder how much damage was done by encouraging dual income families. It provided temporary relief, at the expense of raising costs and bringing everyone back to a previous single-earner lifestyle long-term. With dual income you have to pay for daycare (2-3k/month), and that's not pre-tax. This lead to less births, requiring more immigration. The government used illegal immigration to fill the gap, which has put strain on our social services such-as schools. I wonder if we were better off economically with the single earning household norm.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoOn the other hand, women gained economic (true) freedom. Daycare is also $2k per month per child at the higher end, for infants, in high cost of living areas. SF/LA/SD/SEA/NYC might be a little higher, but the vast majority of the US will be at $1.5k/month or lower. What probably happened is women having opportunity other than having kids and being a housewife brought out the costs of having kids that women were previously eating on behalf of society. Now the costs are more explicitly and society needs to pony up to make it more attractive.
- bitwize 4y agoParents are just gonna have to improvise: feeder team instead of the Yankees, second run theaters, Lake Compounce instead of Disneyland. The U.S. population has grown while the number of Disneylands and major league teams has remained about the same. Plus, the internet and mass media have amplified fandom. Disney theme parks used to be thought of as interesting and fun for the kids. Today, untold legions of Disney adults make the hajj to Mickey Mecca every year. The same with going to your favorite team's stadium to watch them play. The result is the venues are more crowded, the lines are longer, and due to the laws of supply and demand, prices go up. So Mickey Mecca is out of reach for a typical family outing. But it can be planned and saved for as a special event; and more local, less famous, less expensive destinations will more than do for a typical summer trip.
- jmpman 4y agoThe Arizona Diamondbacks have sucked the fun out of going to the ballpark. Even with the cheapest seats in the league, it’s unpleasant. The cheapest seat gets you a nose bleed look at one of the worst teams in baseball. You overlook the rest of the empty stadium, while your kid, unable to concentrate on the ants, find more pleasure in just about anything. They’re not cultivating the next generation of fans. Have a once a week/month/year special, ideally not on a school night (if during the school year), where the seats are sold same day for $5 - for any seat left in the stadium. Get the kids into the crowds, up close, with some excitement. Maybe a $20/seat combo that includes your seat, a hotdog, drink and a box of cracker jacks.
- missedthecue 4y agoIf you get the cheapest anything, you'll have an imperfect experience. But I just pulled up mlb.com and checked prices for a random DB game (Friday night game, Aug 5). Outfield seats at field level are 25 bucks. Or you can get tickets right by the bullpen in foul ball territory for $25. Not bad for 3+ hours of friday night entertainment.
- anon291 4y agoThe root cause behind this is childlessness. Families were bigger in the 60s so things had to be cheaper for families to afford it. Now, there is sufficient demand for these 'family' activities amongst childless adults, who have more income per individual, and a higher willingness to spend on these entertainment activities (whereas families with kids often spend income on kid's education and activities). This has the effect of making things even worse for children.
- cptskippy 4y ago> The root cause behind this is childlessness. That is the current narrative being pushed by conservatives. All our problems are due to selfish individuals not having children. I suppose we can blame inflation too on all those child less dual income families as well? I mean if they had less money they wouldn't be able to buy up all the things and prices would be lower for everyone right?
- anon291 4y agoI'm actually not making any value judgement. It's an observation. One of the effects of fewer children is that companies that previously marketed towards children, now market mostly towards adults that are still able to live out their childhood fantasies. onestly, when it comes to families, I actually think this is a good thing, because Disney, MLB, etc, are terrible organizations that don't deserve much support. Disney happily kowtows to China's every whim, and its new content is ultimately not that great (save for a select few films). Professional sports has ruined our education system in this country (school-to-pro-sports pipeline), that disproportionately affects minority males, who are encouraged to spend more time attempting to achieve a dream that they are unlikely to (making a sports team) and little time doing those things that will almost certainly help them in life.
- cptskippy 4y ago> One of the effects of fewer children is that companies that previously marketed towards children, now market mostly towards adults that are still able to live out their childhood fantasies. Companies aren't shifting focus away from Children so much as they're expanding their focus beyond them. While the birth rate in the US has been in decline since the early 70s, the population and the number of children has largely grown. It's really only in the last 5-10 years that we've seen a decline in the number of children. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr70/nvsr70-17.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr70/nvsr70-17.pdf The reason you see companies like Disney expanding into China and abroad is because they're chasing growth, not due to decline. The market always demands growth.
- cptskippy 4y ago> Before we get into the numbers, let’s compare how much families earned in 1960 to what they earn today. > Today’s median family earns considerably more, at $84k per year, or $40.38/hr. ... But when it comes to traditional family outings, the purchasing power of that income has declined. I'm not sure this is a fair comparison because it doesn't distinguish between single and dual income families. https://www.pewresearch.org/ft_dual-income-households-1960-2012-2/ https://www.pewresearch.org/ft_dual-income-households-1960-2... According to Pew Research, only 25% of families in the 1960s were dual income vs 60% today. Not only have wages not kept up with inflation, but, even with dual incomes, families have less purchasing power. On top of that, they have less free time because the work of maintaining a household didn't go away.
- sriku 4y agoThis reminded me of how in Tamil Nadu (a southern state in India), move ticket prices have a cap (and movie going is HUGE) so it stays affordable for the masses despite really good and well maintained theatres. So companies that run movie theatres charge a bomb for the food (popcorn etc). If houxan afford the food, that's ok, but if you cant, you can just go watch a movie for <$2 per seat.
- Kalanos 4y agothe country is fuller and the world is flatter
- syrrim 4y ago>But when it comes to traditional family outings, the purchasing power of that income has declined There's an obvious way to dispute this claim: at the time, these were not traditional family outings. They were modern family outings, and would have been alternatives to what were considered traditional family outings back then. As they became traditional, markets found a way to cash in on their status in that regard by raising prices. Cheaper alternatives also arose, but people who want the "real" experience typically won't settle for the cheap version. Thus, the price increases.
- fundad 4y agoThis is probably true, think of when more rural areas had thriving popluations. They aren't near a stadium or amusement park, a family's social life involved their church and "family outings" were organized by church groups. Populations grew around urban areas which have tons of churches in the US but also the opportunity to interact with many more types of people and an explosion of new types of activities. I think Big Outing also made sure sitcom characters went to major league sports stadiums and amusement parks which people aspire to attain.
- JamesSwift 4y agoThe Disney calculations dont take into account fastpass pricing, which is the new favorite gouge of theme parks these days. I'm not sure if capacity limits were loosened over time or what, but its almost a necessity to get a fastpass to enjoy your (very expensive) day at the parks these days. It used to be that only a couple of the popular rides would be a long wait, but its almost all of them any more.
- medvezhenok 4y agoI think that part of the effect is headline cost inflation. All sorts of businesses are incentivized to price discriminate (since people now have vastly different purchasing power), and they usually do it by setting a high default price and then giving all sorts of discounts to groups that they want to incentivize. This happens in medicine (headline rate vs insurance negotiated rate), it happens in education (sticker price vs average price paid), it happens on Amazon (see the preponderance of coupon clipping / sales to get around price tracker sites like camelcamelcamel). For a few more examples: tinder discriminates directly (older people charged more), onlyfans runs promotions for new members (just like cable companies). Traveling escorts will change their rates depending on the cities that they're touring, based on what the market will bear... etc. In the 1940s and 50s you could get big problems for trying to generate big profits - and there was a 90% excess profits tax in the 40s to drain all of the excess fiscal stimulus back out of the economy. As the after-effects of those policies wore off, price discrimination came back. Price discrimination is the name of the game in today's world.
- octokatt 4y agoPrice discrimination is the name of the game in today's world, and is taught in every economics class. At some point, we need to ask folk to price goods for a meaningful cost, not the maximum allowable, for better access and a more open market. Money cannot be the only measurement of a meaningful marketplace.
- dougmwne 4y agoIn this thread: rich people explain why poor people have nothing to complain about.
- robotburrito 4y agoI would say just go take your kids on a nice hike in a state park or something. Go ride bikes. Much cheaper!
- olivermarks 4y agoHealth and safety bureaucrats arguably prevent affordable leisure activities - in most western countries it is very hard to provide unique small business run experiential places and activities due to endless expense meeting ever more legal requirements. The result is identical generic theme parks, stadiums etc all over the world run by large global companies. The theme park companies will milk a family for everything they have once they're in the park with kids wanting to wait for evening fireworks aligned with slightly less expensive pizza and sugary drink offers.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoBoth health and safety and accessibility/ADA requirements. I was playing mini golf the other day and realized you couldn’t even build that course anymore, it’s not wheelchair friendly. The cost of starting or running any business open to the public has gone up astronomically with the growth of overwhelming bureaucracy at all levels of government.
- harambae 4y ago>Health and safety bureaucrats arguably prevent affordable leisure activities I've seen 100+ places in America that rent ATV's and about 4 that rent dirtbikes. I haven't fully investigated why, but I have to imagine it's some type of liability/lawsuit situation.
- egypturnash 4y agoMy husband looked over my shoulder and made the interesting point that it's worth comparing the population of America in 1960 to now: 179,323,175 people in 1960 has grown to 331,449,281 in 2020. That's about 180% as many people competing for the same entertainment resources. (source on those numbers: wikipedia's pages for the 1960/2020 census) Movies have also kind of stopped being a thing you have to go to the local Temple of the Cinematic Arts to see. You can sit at home and stream everything on a pretty big screen. So their revenue's dropped off a lot, even without the fact that they have to give almost the entire price of the ticket to the film studio and are trying to survive by marking up the popcorn.
- TulliusCicero 4y ago> That's about 180% as many people competing for the same entertainment resources. That makes sense for Disneyland and maybe baseball teams, but less so to explain movie theaters, since they're not supply constrained in the same way.
- hotdogrelish 4y agoInterestingly, in 1960 there were 16 MLB teams that played 154 regular season games for a total of 1232 games that year, compared to 30 MLB teams playing 162 games for 2430 total games (almost double!) a year today. I imagine other sports have seen a similar trend as well.
- bombcar 4y agoThe Houston Texans are the most recent NFL team, but I feel baseball has been more willing to add teams than the NFL has (and baseball games happen almost every day, whereas football is once a week). I've always thought you have baseball team fans and football sport fans; baseball fans want to watch their team, football fans like watching their team but want to watch all the teams, too.
- pmarreck 4y agoAll of these things have a fixed supply, while the demand for them has only increased; this is why costs have increased. US population alone has at least doubled since then. the one exception possibly being the theater experience, since you can build more theaters, but real estate has also gone up (due, again, to fixed supply and increasing demand) and that cost is passed along to the consumer, so the effect is the same. Plus, pandemic losses need to be recoup'd, etc.
- fzeroracer 4y agoHas demand actually increased, or has it been bought out by people with more money than your average person? I feel like this point is often missed. There's a fair amount of Disney superfans for example that have the wealth and ability to make frequent and often trips to Disneyland. If you have enough of those wealthy individuals, they can push out everyone else. In this scenario the price of the attraction(s) is almost irrelevant and incentivizes Disney to only cater to a very specific and wealthy crowd. Real estate functions the same way as land is consolidated under wealthy individuals. These individuals then make a lot of their money by actively harming people's ability to rent or own property (though things like AirBnB) and then repeat the cycle. The problem isn't fixed supply/demand, it's the consolidation of wealth and power in fewer individuals that then disproportinately affect the dynamics.
- pmarreck 4y agoHow does AirBnB "actively harm people's ability to rent or own property"?
- emptybits 4y agoArticle says the three components of going to a ballgame that have increased the most since 1960 are: parking (66x), soda (27x), and beer (19x). Pretty wild. So a suggestion: The American family parks somewhere cheap, takes public transit to their favorite family outing, then consumes less soda and beer. Enjoy the ballgame in a better-than-1960 stadium, while also chipping away at an environmental and obesity situation that 1960 never knew!
- chrismarlow9 4y agoI think it's a matter of alternatives. Sure I can do all that, or I can drive down the road to a sports bar and pay a normal price for everything and watch the game and be back home in 15 minutes. You have to get with the times and eliminate all that. Sell a VR package where I can watch the game as though I am sitting behind first base. Bonus if my buddy across the country can sit next to me and we can chat. They're trying to continue to make money in a world with locality rules and limited space, and we are increasingly entering one where your location doesn't matter. Covid just pushed this agenda a little harder than it was naturally playing out.
- emptybits 4y agoAbsolutely, but sports bars and VR chats aren't (yet?) "America's Favorite Family Outings", per TFA.
- neutronicus 4y agoYou can't really count on the Light Rail here (Baltimore). Might have a great experience, might be stuck at the station for an hour waiting for a train. We used to do what you suggest when I was a kid (park at the light rail terminus, ride in to Orioles games), but ... that was back when it used to run more-or-less reliably.
- throw8383833jj 4y ago"in order to afford them, today’s American families have to work up to 2x as many hours as they did 60 years ago." This is the type of thing I've been talking about. There's been a massive drop in living standards over the last 50 years. and if you think not seeing mickey mouse is a problem, geez, just take a look at shelter and transportation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- parkingrift 4y agoExtremely skeptical of the MLB estimates. You can see the Yankees play the Pirates this fall in NYC for $24 for four (4) people. $22 in round trip subway fare to anywhere in NYC. $54 on food and drink. $100 total. If you feel entitled to seeing Red Sox vs Yankees in prime time in October for the same relative price your grandparents paid… well I don’t know what to tell you.
- mdavis6890 4y agoThings, including economic things, always change over time. The mix of goods and services that we produce will change, and prices with them. Many things will get more expensive or become unavailable, while other things will get cheaper and more plentiful. And new things will be invented. Televisions and microwaves are cheaper now. Intuitively I would have thought cars are cheaper too - but a moment of research indicated they're actually more expensive. Food and energy have become much cheaper as well. (Talking about over decades) It's very easy to cherry-pick any one thing to focus on and say "Look how bad/good it is now." - but that doesn't make it meaningful or right to do so.
- strix_varius 4y ago> Intuitively I would have thought cars are cheaper too - but a moment of research indicated they're actually more expensive. This surprised me so I looked into it - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_longevity#Statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_longevity#Statistics - in 1960 a car's lifetime was about 100k miles, while today it's about 200k. https://www.thepeoplehistory.com/60scars.html https://www.thepeoplehistory.com/60scars.html https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38748092/new-car-average-sale-prices-47100/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38748092/new-car-average-... - in 1960 the average new car cost $2,752 ($26,100 in 2022 dollars) - in 2022 the average new car costs $47,000 So in 1960 you'd pay about 26100/100000 = $0.26 / mile, whereas in 2022 you'd pay about $0.24 / mile. There'd also be qualitative differences in the experience like performance, comfort, safety, entertainment, etc. On the whole it's not a lot cheaper (somewhere around 8%), but it turns out our intuitions were correct.
- reddog 4y agoWhen did a family trip to Disney World become the American middle class Hajj? My kids have been to every national park west of the Mississippi but are alone among their friends in having never have visited Orlando to venerate the rodent. When people find this out they act like we should be reported to child protective services.
- bel_marinaio 4y agoThe sheeple have been corporatized. They sit in front of the idiot box for 21+ hours weekly soaking up the advertisements telling them what to buy and where to vacation. Most people are boring and unoriginal. They just want do the same things as all the other sheeple
- jerrybender 4y agoI assume that you only count the contiguous western United States. Some Alaska national parks are very inaccessible.
- kasey_junk 4y agoAnecdotal but right now you can buy s “family four pack” at the Chicago White Sox for $75 inclusive of fees. That’s tickets, hot dog, soda & chips for four people. That’s nearly half the price of the articles cheapest listed ballgame.
- easton 4y agoBeing a Disney aficionado, I have to note: the price in the 60s was only to get in the park. You had to buy separate tickets for each attraction once you were in (either ala-carte or in a book that came with several categories for $3-4). They moved to the current model (one ticket all attractions as long as you are willing to wait in line) in the 80s when EPCOT opened in Florida. With inflation it's still higher today (especially if you stay at a hotel), but not as much as the article makes it out to be. https://clickamericana.com/topics/family-parenting/life-for-kids/disneyland-attraction-tickets-a-b-c-d-e https://clickamericana.com/topics/family-parenting/life-for-...
- hguant 4y ago>Being a Disney aficionado, I have to note: the price in the 60s was only to get in the park. You had to buy separate tickets for each attraction once you were in The article literally covers this, both in their infographic for Disney, and in the paragraph preceding. >(One important clarifying note: Back in 1960, you paid for the park admission ticket and the rides separately. We’ve combined those costs below.) Maybe read the article before you comment about its faults...
- easton 4y agoWas the amount per person then? The books (per my link, I'm guessing they changed pricing seasonally so the article is also probably right) were ~$4.50 per adult and included admission. If the number in the article was per person then the situation has gotten worse than it claimed, if it wasn't then it's better. (In any case, I missed that comment when I read the article the first time, you're right. Sorry!)
- travellingprog 4y agoThey explicitly mention that they accounted for that in their calculation
- EricE 4y agoYou could get day tickets at Disneyland before EPCOT opened. I still have some that are hand stamped and signed from the late 70's. The parks are out of control. You pay more for longer wait times. On the other hand if they lowered prices/let more people in, the wait times and crowding would be even worse and there would be complaining about that. The real problem is they just need more parks - some in the midwest wouldn't kill them so people wouldn't have to travel as far. Spread the load out. It might have just been bias growing up with Disneyland but I much preferred it to the magic kingdom - it seemed like they watered the individual parks down to encourage people to park hop. The real issue is I think a lot of companies just assumed they couldn't compete at the same level as Disney so they didn't even bother trying. I think Universal with Harry Potter found out that yes, you can steal attendees from the house of mouse and providing a themed experience is also doable - they are far from invulnerable. I'm eagerly looking forward to Universal's Epic Universe; hopefully it will light a fire under others (hey Cedar Fair - there's more to parks than just coasters!) that it is worth it to up their game too.
- runako 4y agoOnce you've figured out how to pay for childcare, food, and college savings, you are obviously rich and can afford to take your family to a movie. /s
- mkl95 4y ago> Just for one day in the park and one night at the hotel, we were looking at over $1k and that didn’t even include food That's doesn't look like a competitive tag anywhere on Earth. Do you REALLY have to take your kids to Disneyland though? There are tons of significantly entertaining, cheaper things you can do.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoHighest MLB salary in 1960: $80,000 ($800,000 in 2022 dollars) Highest MLB salary in 2022: $43,000,000
- neilknowsbest 4y agoRegarding the relevance of the example expenses for Disney: Disney's 2019 Annual Report [0] shows total revenues of $26B for their Parks, Experiences and Products segment. Within that, revenues for admissions are $7.5B, merchandise/food/beverage $6B, resorts/vacations $6B, and some miscellaneous licensing $6.5B. An industry or market research company reports [1] visitation in 2019 of 155MM. I'm assuming this is somewhat accurate. Admissions revenues per visitor are around $50, compared to a cost of $150 or so quoted in the article; TFA might be overpaying for tickets. The resorts/vacations (I assume this means hotels) revenue is $40 per visitor or $160 for a family of 4 for 1 night. This, combined with the prevalence of <$200/night hotels near Disneyland [2] suggests to me that not all visitors are staying in the Disney hotels, and the ones who aren't may be paying less than the $450 from TFA. All this to say that the current costs for Disney are likely lower than what TFA suggests, unclear by how much. [0] - https://thewaltdisneycompany.com/app/uploads/2020/01/2019-Annual-Report.pdf https://thewaltdisneycompany.com/app/uploads/2020/01/2019-An... [1] - https://www.teaconnect.org/images/files/TEA_369_258927_200716.pdf https://www.teaconnect.org/images/files/TEA_369_258927_20071... [2] - https://www.google.com/maps/search/Hotels/@33.8029354,-117.9252399,14.5z https://www.google.com/maps/search/Hotels/@33.8029354,-117.9...
- DoreenMichele 4y agoIn the 1950s and ’60s — the so-called Golden Age of American capitalism — family outings were within the realm of affordability for most median income earners. Many blue-collar workers could afford new homes and cars and still take their kids to Disneyland. WW2 marks the end of The Great Depression. Due to high unemployment during The Great Depression, America was able to increase supply of both "guns and butter" -- the shorthand they used for military production and consumer products. During the war, there was rationing, there were Victory Gardens where people grew their own food so farm production could feed the soldiers overseas, women went to work at very high rates to fill essential jobs left vacant by so many men shipping out as soldiers. They stopped production of cars and converted car factories to jeep factories. You couldn't buy silk stockings, so women bought makeup and drew a seam down the back of their leg to look like thry were in silk stockings. You couldn't buy sugar, so birthday cakes were sometimes a sawdust mockup for show, just to blow out the candles. Cigarettes were rationed. You had low birth rates because as Lucille Ball once said, you can't phone that in and the men were mostly overseas. You had many two income couples with no kids being born and nothing to spend the money on due to wartime rationing and restrictions. The result: Savings rates exceeded 50 percent during parts of the war. "The Boys" came home and as veterans were entitled to both help going to college and help buying a house. Prior to that time, both homeownership and college were generally viewed as more upperclass trappings. The so-called middle class of the 1950s and 60s had upperclass assets, working class sensibilities and a substantial nest egg to start their family with. If we made the entire US buckle down, work, stop having kids, denied them spending opportunities and forced them to save half their income etc for the next five years, then issued them help with mortgage payments and free college tuition, the 2030s might look a lot like the 1950s. But we can't, so we won't. Yet that's the invisible elephant in the room behind what created the wealth of the 1950s and how that legacy still haunts us in myriad ways.
- fallingfrog 4y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the official inflation statistics are total hogwash. If rent has risen faster than inflation, and food has risen faster than inflation, and medical care, education, gas, and trips to Disneyland have risen faster than inflation... I mean, what do we call that? Inflation inflation? By definition we're supposed to be looking at the value of money such that the cost of all those things stay constant. The numbers are cooked. Maybe certain kinds of consumer goods which were manufactured overseas have gotten cheaper in real terms, but that doesn't cancel out the currency getting debased.
- dangus 4y agoI would say that professional sports costs aren’t a great representative of cost increases. The amount of ballparks hasn’t expanded to match the number of fans, and that’s really the role of minor league teams. Major League Baseball is doing what is logical here: price segmenting their product in ways that wasn’t possible in the past. The television experience also wasn’t so great in the mid-century. Why would you invite people with not a lot of spending money to an in-person experience when you can fill the bleachers with the wealthiest 10% of the country? In other words, every seat you fill with someone willing to spend $50 at the park is an opportunity cost compared to the person you could have sitting there willing to pay $100. Increasing the supply of seats might actually lose you money compared to only inviting the wealthy and maintaining scarcity. Same deal with Disneyland and Disney World. There aren’t proportionally more Disney parks and capacity to meet demand, there are still just two destinations in the whole country that have expanded relatively modestly in terms of capacity increase, but there are lots of other theme parks and attractions that have opened or expanded since Disney opened his. It’s entirely logical for Disney to only cater to the top tier of spenders, because they run the most desirable and expensive to operate per-capita parks. A point about parking: regardless of inflation, car infrastructure doesn’t scale. We know this already but most of America is in denial and will get into arguments with me about how they need their truck to survive. Car-based infrastructure works fine when your town is a certain modest size and not every individual owns one, but our population size and car ownership rates have ballooned since the mid-century, and now traffic and parking is a squeeze in moderate-sized cities that don’t have good enough mass transit. So, in conclusion, I think movie tickets are perhaps a the best representation in this article of our relative loss of wealth compared to the other items on this list. Only movie ticket demographics and economics have truly stayed the same compared to these other examples. Movies are still more expensive, because it’s absolutely true that the typical American family has become poorer in many ways.
- alistairSH 4y agoThe crazy thing about the Disney cost... it doesn't include airfare or food, both of which can be EXPENSIVE. You could just about do a European vacation for a similar daily cost (albeit, you'd need to do a week+ to make the airfare cost work out).
- bredren 4y agoI wonder how much of this difference is due to rampant compensation inequalities of the 1960s. Where the services supply chains that make these experiences happen should have cost a lot more than they did.
- scotuswroteus 4y agoI just went to the best Giants game of the season for $25
- jdkee 4y agoNo mention of the fact that it takes two earners in the median household to see the raise in inflation adjusted outcome. In fact, inflation adjusted wages for the middle class has been flat since the 1970s. So it is even worse for the middle-class than portrayed in this article. See https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoDisneyland has 3 times more visitors now than before, in large part because of the globalization. Even at current prices, ride queues are unbearable.
- uptownfunk 4y agoSpeaking for myself, and I make a decent wage, all the headlines / media have made me re-evaluate how I am spending every penny. We no longer eat out as much, spend on flights, try to do more things at home, just to be prepared for [more inflation | potential lay-off | some other macroeconomic event]
- jeromegv 4y agoMakes you wonder how much of your behaviour and fears are driven by headlines instead of reality. Sure things go up and down with the economy, but they also went very up for a lot of people (ie: demographic of people on hackernews) during COVID. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/02/23/savings-bank-accounts-covid/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/02/23/savings-b... Flights are expensive because demand is through the roof while labor is not available to fulfill the demand. Same for eating out. Not negating that inflation is up within the last year, but did you realize how good were the last few years (even before COVID) but didn't quite realize as there was no headlines telling you that good news?
- uptownfunk 4y agoAbsolutely, it's why for the most part I try not to read the news.
- fundad 4y agoThey're trying super hard to speak a recession into existence because we know why.
- jhbadger 4y agoAs for a baseball game, try going to a minor league game -- it's far cheaper and everybody including the players seems to be having more fun than at a major league game.
- betwixthewires 4y agoI personally don't mind it. Maybe people should be taking their kids to the park, to the woods, camping, to actually play baseball. Real, substantial experience is cheaper and more fun, and it's better for their upbringing than fake hollow culture defined by corporations for your consumption. Fuck Disneyland, go to Yellowstone instead.
- ppierald 4y agoThe going to a ball game is an interesting example. I think there are financial disincentives at play, most notably, the price of beer. There are likely forces at play that will maximize the dollar intake while minimizing the amount consumed. This is not popcorn (still expensive) we are talking about. If beer were 1/2 as expensive, then people would drink 2x more and spend the same amount, but the effect on society would be much worse. We would have more fights in the stands, more drunk driving, and other negative effects. So by jacking up the price of a beer, fans can enjoy one or two, then realize they don't have the budget for a 3rd or 4th and cut it off there. They cut off sales in the 7th inning to prevent most of those effects I mentioned. But that's just a theory ... a beer theory.
- russdpale 4y agono point in catering to the poors in a world of haves and have nots. That is what America is now.
- tnorthcutt 4y agodrivers are willing to shell out more than what is reasonable for a slice of asphalt. If drivers are willing to pay, isn't it reasonable? Isn't that a core tenet of supply and demand?
- greedo 4y agoI remember as a young man in San Diego, being able to go see a day game or doubleheader. It wasn't cheap if you wanted good seats, but you could often find someone scalping their tickets for a decent price. Once, in 1984 I was able to get a pair in the first row right off first base. The memory still sticks with me today. Jack Murphy Stadium didn't charge for parking, so it was just gas, tickets and beer/hotdogs. I think the day cost me and my buddy like $30 each in 1984, and seeing Tony Gwynn was priceless. According to the Internet, that's about $85 in today's simoleons. Now these were like the best seats in the house and I got lucky with the scalper.
- bombcar 4y agoPrices weren't even that bad once they moved to Petco, as long as you were willing to roll up on the Trolley for a weekday game.
- greedo 4y agoI only went to Disneyland once in my life. My uncle took me, and this was probably in the early 70's. You bought a book of tickets for the rides, and of course the best was the "E ticket." I was probably around 7 or 8 and once we got in the park I was amazed. Then I somehow lost my book of tickets. My uncle was not happy...
- DEveritt 4y agoCan people not enjoy a movie without soda and popcorn?
- rootsudo 4y agoEveryone is comparing about Disney, and I find that $1000 figure low - I honestly think you can find better value, or could, when you could travel to Japan or Hong Kong and do Disney there. Growing up around Disney World, and heading back there nowadays, it is a shame, and it's not the park or the employees but the people and the absolute density. It is a fully mature commercialized money extraction machine, not that the ones in Japan or HK aren't - but I've managed to snag tickets round trip to HK and JP that were $600'ish, hotel accommodation is average at $50 a night for 5 star in both places but not in actual disney accomodations, there's public transit/rail so easy to get around and food costs were a fraction, we're talking $15 a day, with entry tickets at $40-60. Of course Tokyo Disney Sea. Tokyo Disney Land and Hong Kong Disneyland aren't for everyone, but I wouldn't go near the one in Orlando ever again - that was a treat growing up and each subsequent time was an experience that was hell, not to mention International Drive in Orlando, needing a car and the whole sake of it. It's really ironic - Orlando is built around cars, while JP/HK you need nothing but to show up on your two feet. And the people are 100% better mannered too.