34 ms·
Playstation Store removes Studiocanal movies, no refunds offered
- josephcsible 4y ago> Sony discontinued global sales of movie and TV content in August 2021, but at the time, it was promised that content already purchased would remain accessible in future. > As of August 31, 2022, due to our evolving licensing agreements with content providers, you will no longer be able to view your previously purchased Studiocanal content and it will be removed from your video library Sounds about right for Sony.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agowhy are we "expected" to honor their copyright for eternity when they do not honor their commitments ala "evolving licensing agreements". what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt.
- nikanj 4y agoBecause we have little money for lawyers, while they have much money for lawyers
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt. That is already how consumers behave. You're living the dream right now!
- alexeldeib 4y agoLegal repurcussions differ. IMO it comes down to: what’s the likelihood someone pursues me, and will I survive the expected cost of my defense. Nobody likes love letters anyway. Individuals may have a lower risk, but the cost is high if someone decides to come after you. Large corporations can take the legal costs far more easily.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThere's ways to reduce your risk in this sort of thing. The reason why people come after individuals is because BitTorrent is an insanely risky system. The achilles heel of P2P is that it has no privacy whatsoever, so whoever wants to extort[0] individual pirates can do so. However, direct-download sites generally do not confer risk onto their users in the same way. Even if the site gets taken down or sued, copyright owners generally don't care about following their logs to find individual downloaders. While they still probably can be sued[1], there's no reason for a legitimate party to do so. At that point the copyright holder got what they wanted, and marching down to everyone in the server logs' house to make sure they delete their infringing movies is absolutely stupid. For the same reason I've never liked the idea of "P2P YouTube alternatives". People rightfully complain about how they mishandle anything related to copyright, and they do, but the alternative is having every copyright holder with a chip on their shoulder financially cripple anyone who watched a video they didn't like. [0] Legal scholars will probably object to my use of the word "extort". Yes, if you have a legal claim for relief then threatening to sue for it is not extortion, it's just the law. However, the only way to actually make antipiracy enforcement at an individual level not financially crippling is to cross the line into actual extortion. The Prenda Law and Strike 3 Holdings incidents are good examples of how easy it is to do so. [1] The law is actually somewhat ambiguous on where the infringement actually is when you download something. I used to think "uploading equals infringement", but there's been some court opinions arguing that either both uploading and downloading are infringements, or that they infringe different parts of copyright. Nobody's bothered to prosecute a direct-download pirate to the point where this matters. Of course there's also Japan which has a law that explicitly makes mere downloading infringing. There be dragons.
- alexeldeib 4y agoI generally agree with you. I’d rather not play the odds on exposing my identifiers anyway, whether p2p or direct. Might as well go the extra mile and make sure whatever IP is non associated with me, so direct download over tor or whatever — you get the idea. Why give someone the chance?
- LeoNatan25 4y agoDue to my evolving licensing disagreement, I use torrents for all my movies and TV show watching needs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoYou're confusing the creator with the distributor platform You don't get to steal from a musician because Sony cheated you . > why are we "expected" to honor their copyright Because you don't want to be a thief . > they do not honor their commitments They do, in fact. It seems like you just assumed they committed to something they didn't, and are angry now that you've finally read the actual commitment. . > what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt. Then you'd be a thief who pointed fingers at other people to justify your own choices
- 2Gkashmiri 4y ago>You don't get to steal from a musician because Sony cheated you elsevier copyrights papers on their own name. should we fuck with them ? >It seems like you just assumed they committed to something they didn't, and are angry now that you've finally read the actual commitment. sony committed to keep those movies but now they are backtracking on that commitment. why?
- Mezzie 4y ago> elsevier copyrights papers on their own name. should we fuck with them ? Unironically yes. Fuck Elsevier and what they've done to academic publishing.
- effingwewt 4y agoRight, or they could offer refunds and it wouldn't be so bad. This days after Nintendo letting us know they 'are unable (read- unwilling) to offer refunds. We need consumer protection laws that do something, because since the 1990s businesses have made anti-consumer practices their bread and butter. They don't fear us, the laws, or government in general. Businesses fucking lie cheat and steal every single day.
- throw_away23823 4y agoSeems like they should have agreed on better licensing agreements. I see the point for subscription based services, but in this case they should have an agreement to continue streaming for those who have purchased it. The content provider has been paid for it too, right? I am not a lawyer, but I don't think licensing agreements like this is not enough in a consumer court. When you purchase something, the consumer expects to be able to access it for as long as the distributor exists. The services use the term "Purchase" or "Buy". If that is not actually the case, they should call it something else. Otherwise it is misleading the consumers, no matter where they hide the small print in the license agreement. At a minimum I would expect a refund, as they are no longer providing the service that was paid for.
- ge0rg 4y agoIf complaining and asking for a refund doesn't yield a result, you will have a very hard time finding a lawyer to get this through the courts, given the rather marginal value of the content that you "purchased".
- mnw21cam 4y agoIf you have "purchased" a decent collection of these films, it'd probably be worth your time going to the small claims court.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agoI believe some European countries employ government officials who prosecute attacks on consumers that violate consumer protection laws
- ratww 4y agoI really hate Sony. I had a Sony Bravia TV for several years, and bought it because it came with a "Netflix compatible" sticker. Netflix however wasn't really compatible from the get-go, and they promised it would work in the next upgrade. I wasn't in US/EU so simply returning it wasn't possible. They kept promising it would work in the next upgrade, and I would upgrade, even though each time it was making the TV incredibly sluggish. Eventually five or six years passed and the TV stopped receiving upgrades and it never had Netflix.
- sofixa 4y agoDoesn't your country have laws against false advertisement? Such bullshit would have gotten them a (not huge, but still, it's a Matt of principle) fine in the EU.
- JohnHaugeland 4y ago> Such bullshit would have gotten them a (not huge, but still, it's a Matt of principle) fine in the EU. This was brought to the EU and the EU didn't do anything
- ratww 4y agoThey did but since I believed their promises for too long I was the sucker stuck with a shitty TV.
- a4a4a4a4 4y agoI mean, it was probably Netflix compatible via HDMI? I don't see the problem here. \s
- ratww 4y agoYou're joking but at some point they really used this argument.
- kwith 4y agoOlder Sony Bravia TVs that just barely met the specs for streaming applications had to go through such roundabout ways to actually stream the content. They did not support the latest streaming standards (DASH/HLS) and basically had to stream raw MP4 files. They were a very exceptional case device at least at Prime Video. Newer devices obviously supported the regular streaming standards. At this point (and even 5 years ago), getting a little streaming HDMI stick will provide an infinitely better customer experience for a ~$35 investment. Most smart TVs just don't have a great user experience compared to the devices designed around that.
- PebblesHD 4y agoIf this sort of activity continues, I can only see it decreasing the effective value of good ‘purchased’ through these online stores. People will only pay similar prices to physical goods for digital goods if they behave similarly, if they do not, the price must surely come down to reflect this.
- izacus 4y agoThis can be easily fixed by exclusivity deals, cancellation of "unsecure" physical copies and the fact that none of modern media display devices even feature physical media drives. You can't vote with your wallet if they kill all the alternatives with the help of IP law ;)
- paganel 4y agoMost probably that will force most of the people to stick to using more TikTok (or whatever video platform will be popular at a future time) and less feature movies. Which I find a real shame, because I personally love movies, but imo that's the direction things are going.
- caramelcustard 4y agoThere are videogame streamers and YouTubers who easily provide over 4 hours of content on a regular basis, mostly for free. It's going to be either making subscriptions as content rich and cheap as possible or hoping to get a renaissance of movie nuts culture.
- consp 4y agoI really would like to know how they will get around article 10 of EU directive 2019/770 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32019L0770#d1e1321-1-1 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL... Edit: As far as I heard it is valid for anything delivered after Jan 1st 2022, which includes continuation of exiting indefinite contracts from before that date and the continuation of them. Correct me if I'm wrong/misinformed though.
- jfoster 4y agoIsn't it silly that there needs to be laws written to ensure consumers simply get what they paid for?
- stingraycharles 4y agoFundamentally businesses have no morals, and everything is just an equation based on profits. If it makes economical sense to do this, many a business would be inclined to do it. Not saying that it’s right, but it’s definitely completely understandable why we need laws to protect consumers.
- nly 4y agoI mean a company like this can always deny you the things you've paid for by going out of business and closing the platform. You should just assume that if you buy a digital license to something that it's never really yours
- ratww 4y agoTrue. We probably need a law for that too. The movie still exists. The license should just be transferred to another platform, or DRM should be removed so you don't need the platform to see it anymore. If companies fail to comply with this, maybe we'll need laws forbidding "selling" with DRM or something like that.
- rightbyte 4y ago
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agoyou will own nothing and you will be happy
- caramelcustard 4y agoI wonder what quote people brought up during the licensing bickerings of way before that "what if we were all to just like rent things lmao" article.
- bluescrn 4y agoEven when the billionaires and gigacorporations own every physical asset on the planet, surely they can still let the little people ‘own’ some digital assets? Isn’t the ideal to have us all continue our excessive mindless consumption within virtual spaces, maximum profit for minimum environmental cost?
- ecmascript 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrEUzKTt7j0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrEUzKTt7j0
- b3lvedere 4y agoThe Old Man : Anyone can buy OCP's stock and own a piece of our city. What could be more democratic than that?
- ratww 4y agoI own nothing [1] and I'm quite happy, and I have a lot of leftover cash each month. [1] Except for a few 2TB external hard drives to store the media I don't "own".
- bambax 4y agoYou can pirate everything, pay nothing and be quite happy too. Edit: allegedly.
- rvz 4y agoExactly like I said a few days ago; funny enough: [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31970488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31970488
- CamperBob2 4y agoIf the answer involves giving money to Sony, you asked the wrong question.
- le_isms 4y agoAs much as HN hates NFTs, they could really help solve this problem. Decentralized online digital ownership is a great use case.
- Gigachad 4y agoHow does that help when the google drive link on your NFT goes offline?
- politelemon 4y agoHN hates NFTs because of 'self evident' statements like this, it's seen as little more than micro-hype statements to up the value of something seen as useless. NFTs do not solve this problem, the content has been removed. If you feel they do, feel free to explain how it would have helped in this situation.
- ageitgey 4y agoNFTs don't let you include the movie itself as a payload, so they are just a token that gives the owner to a claim to a movie via some external system. In this case, there is no disagreement that the consumer purchased the movie, just a refusal to honor that purchase. An NFT that said you bought a movie is meaningless if the system streaming the movie to you to stops honoring it. It's no different than what is happening here.
- grumbel 4y ago> so they are just a token that gives the owner to a claim to a movie via some external system. Yes, but that's exactly what you don't get with a central database. There is no way to use your Sony-database-entry to access the movie from whoever holds the rights right now. Companies also go out of business or change plans, so that central database will cease to exist in the future anyway. With an NFTs you have a proof of ownership. You still would need a service to honor your NFT token, but NFT usage would be the very thing that makes those services possible to exist in the first place. We have seen with MP3 that this can work, just in that case the MP3 itself was used as the ownership token to move content to other services. With movies that doesn't work, as companies don't even give you a raw file of a movie, but they might be willing giving you NFTs, as those don't circumvent the DRM measures they have in place. Either way, NFT are of course only a small piece of the puzzle here, there is a lot of supporting infrastructure that would need to be build and that nobody is building right now. And given the energy usage and cost of blockchains, it's not really usable for your $3 movie anyway. So it's not a workable solution at the moment. But even with all it's faults, it's still the closest thing to a possible solution for digital ownership that we have.
- _hao 4y agoHarr harr mateys...
- freitasm 4y agoAnd corporations still complain about piracy but they do not help themselves.
- robonerd 4y agoHow do otherwise intelligent people come to believe things this stupid? An NFT is a glorified receipt, the most it can possibly do is prove you purchased something but you can already do that with regular fucking receipts and credit card statements. Seriously, I want to know. How did this happen to you? Was your common sense dazzled by math?
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoI can't believe I'm going to defend NFTs, but ... _if_ copyright law were satisfied that you aren't infringing if you purchased perpetual access to a copy--digital or otherwise--then "a glorified receipt" could be all that was needed _if_ the system honoured users with a right to access, on any system on which it was available, for cost, a work that has been legally purchased. In USA, I can't see why proof of purchase and TPB wouldn't be enough. Platform issues don't negate the rights you purchased.
- Gigachad 4y agoWhen you buy stuff on these digital stores, you agree to pay for an indefinite license to the content. So it can be pulled at any time. Why would these stores use NFTs attached to ownership licenses when they could just reword their ToS to include ownership. They don’t want to sell ownership to begin with so they would never use NFTs either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agothe discussion is about the benefits of a solution (prescriptivism) rather than the process of implementing it, and getting stakeholders to agree it's not very insightful to say that people like money and will seek it or avoid losing it (descriptivism)
- Gigachad 4y ago
- bob1029 4y agoInevitable. If you truly want to own your content, you either need to purchase physical media or visit TPB. Having expectations that a corporation is going to uphold some prior agreement is a fun joke. Especially, when you’ve already given them your money. The only way to fix the behavior is to fix the consumer, but most people don’t have the patience to manage terabytes of on-site media in such a way that it can be reliably accessed by mobile devices.
- MrPatan 4y agoOr they could put the license you purchase in a public distributed database.
- rekoil 4y agoAnd the encrypted data (decrypted by said license) shared in a distributed public swarm, crowdsourcing the responsibility to keep it in existence and accessible. That protocol can be exercised by you to take personal responsibility for your own content, or you can yolo that responsibility onto the network and hope enough other people share your particular interests.
- sneak 4y agoSmart contracts cannot hold secrets, as they are executed by hundreds or thousands of nodes. If your license holds the key and it is on a blockchain, the decryption key is public, alongside the ciphertext.
- daenz 4y agoFinally a use for blockchain!
- jjeaff 4y agoI think we will get there sooner than later. Solid state storage is progressing in capacity pretty swiftly. 100 and 200tb SSDs already exist. They are just super pricey. Home file servers/media servers would likely become more popular if you could just plug a small low power device into the wall.
- harha 4y agoIt’s time for a law that gives you the right to keep pirated copies if you own (as in press the buy button, even if it’s an indefinite rental) the original.
- pharmakom 4y agoIn practice there are no penalties for pirate content, although sounds like a good change.
- SSLy 4y agoIn Germany? No, they really fear their enforcement authority.
- meltedcapacitor 4y agoThere is no enforcement authority, all the blackmailing is done by private rogue lawyers.
- Adrox 4y agoDo you know what you are talking about? The blackmail done by a "private rogue lawyers", has a judge signature to authorize the ISP to give my personal information based on the IP that they supposedly got doing the infringement. This is always done in courts in Bavaria that are very copyright-owners friendly. Furthermore, around 1 year after I "Lawyered up", I still got a official Court order to show up in court, that's when I decided to fold and pay the 1000€.
- pph 4y agocopyright infringement: 10€ (their) lawyer fees: 990€
- lakomen 4y agoI received those letters 2 times. I have never responded to them. There was a "Gerichtlicher Mahnbescheid" once which is just [x] denied. The rogue lawyer continued to harrass me asking why I denied their claim. I didn't respond to that either. In the end nothing happened. They use scare tactics. That was before the mess the EU created 2-3 years ago with the reforms. So idk what the status is like now. But ignorance is bliss. The big players do it all the same. They ignore you until they really have to deal with you.
- whatisweb3 4y agoAnother commenter mentioned “NFT” and got downvoted to oblivion but I do think there is merit in considering new economic models that disrupt current platforms. Not a new model where access to the media is restricted only to the purchaser - and corporations fight to maintain DRM and inevitably become gatekeepers of popular culture. Instead, a model where creator revenue is not tied to media access. See [1] and [2]. [1] https://www.billboard.com/pro/camp-chaos-songcamp-nfts-50-person-band/ https://www.billboard.com/pro/camp-chaos-songcamp-nfts-50-pe... [2] https://mirror.xyz/herndondryhurst.eth/S-W2ZXRbrcy8bVGrKwMXSou63gWir7RJ9xs6wUn_h-0 https://mirror.xyz/herndondryhurst.eth/S-W2ZXRbrcy8bVGrKwMXS...
- londons_explore 4y agoContent producers get to decide the economic model. They effectively have a monopoly on content people want to watch. And they've decided that Widevine/PlayReady/FairPlay DRM is what's required. And all of those require by design an online server to enable access to the media. All of those services will one day deprecate/retire their servers, and all paid content downloaded to your devices today will become unplayable. Your granddaughter won't be able to watch any films she finds on your old iPad she finds in the attic 100 years from now. Unless you can convince studio execs that they will earn more money with your new economic model, it's going nowhere.
- whatisweb3 4y ago> Content producers get to decide the economic model. Only insofar as we keep paying them, and ceding control of our media to them. The Camp Chaos example has no content producers dictating an economic model - because consumers and fans are paying the artists directly.
- sshine 4y ago> Another commenter mentioned “NFT” and got downvoted to oblivion It’s rather extreme; mention anything cryptocurrency related in a not negative way, and it gets downvoted. Making a neutral observation tends to be neutral.
- snorremd 4y agoThis is the reason I've given up on "owning" digital content on online platforms. At this point I will not purchase movies or tv-shows, only stream them on streaming platforms. Studios are shooting themselves in both feet by making it impossible to truly own content. By implementing customer hostile licensing models for digital purchases people will move towards streaming instead which generate far less income than selling the content à la carte.
- mike_hock 4y agoIt's been the same idiocy for more than 2 decades now. It always has to be some convoluted contribution model designed to frustrate the customer. Just fucking sell the movie in a free, standardized format with no strings attached. So then it'll be possible to copy it but copying is illegal. Well guess what ... The only difference now is that the pirate is better off and the customer is a chump.
- snorremd 4y agoI agree. I think Bandcamp is a shining example of how digital sales could be handled. They provide DRM free open format files that you can re-download whenever you want to. No-one is going to take away the files you've already downloaded and saved on some disk. Bandcamp might go out of business and in such a case you'd lose access to any content you have not saved. But that is a fair trade-off. But the movie industry believes DRM free formats would undercut their region based business model and allow rampant piracy. Like people haven't been cracking DRM-locked content for ages already. And they might be right about increased copyright infringement, but dismantling the whole notion of ownership is not the solution.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoThe problem is the bait-and-switch. All the really good stuff is behind a second paywall. The movies you really want to watch cost extra money to rent and "more" extra money to "buy." I'm paying for the cake, but then getting charged extra for the icing. It's really starting to irritate me.
- JohnHaugeland 4y ago
- rob_c 4y agoStop buying a digital product on a locked ecosystem. Frankly this is the same as 1984 on the Kindle. Those who have the common sense to steer clear are laughing whilst these companies engage in borderline illegal activities.
- drunkenmagician 4y agoFor those people that wonder why consumers still torrent movies and TV series, here's your reason. And while media companies continue this behaviour, piracy will continue unabated.
- b3lvedere 4y agoYou do not own most forms of content/entertainment you consume. Maybe the only exception is what you created yourself and haven't sold the rights of. This applies to all forms of content/entertainment consumers would like to enjoy in perpetuity. It's a tale as old as money. People will try to find new ways to generate money from creating things (example: NFT) and other people will try to find new ways to circumvent paying for it (bad example: take a screenshot of said NFT). Most consumers might pay for 'fair' agreements, but don't like it when the agreement is altered. And when the consumer complains about that, the creator/company quotes Darth Vader that they should pray they won't alter it any further. I do not disagree with both sides. I understand making money is important. I can also understand that stripping away those initial rights of the license is not fair.
- grishka 4y agoThe problem with copyright is that it's enforced by governments — who have monopoly on the use of force. NFTs are not enforced by governments, so they're just this funny cringy thing some people engage in, and that some other people, like me, make fun of.
- marak830 4y agoShit half the time inpirate is so I can get English subtitles. Netflix Japan is horrible for those.
- eproxus 4y agoThings like subtitles and even audio tracks has to be the laziest mistakes by these companies. How hard can it be to copy all subtitle files to all folder in the CDN? (I know, it's probably a bit more complicated than that, but it can't be much). If an movie doesn't even have the original audio track, it'll just lead me to unsubscribe faster.
- nottorp 4y agoThat's why I only buy games from Sony and only on disc.
- thombat 4y agoAnd you make sure the player never, ever, has access to the internet, in case it downloads a licence update for the game that revokes your use of it.
- trinovantes 4y agoYou need to make sure the disk doesn't physically degrade or get destroyed I still have a working PS2 but most of my game disks are no longer playable due to scratches or got lost/damaged from moving
- nottorp 4y agoI have nothing against installing firmware cracks/torrenting replacements. I'm just stating that games on physical media are the only thing that it's relatively safe to pay Sony for.
- dschuetz 4y agoIn case somebody forgot: you never purchase a digital copy, you only purchase a license to exclusively watch a movie anytime you like using the vendors consumer platform. Anyone ever read the license agreements when "purchasing a movie" online? This is the reason I do not buy movies any longer; 1 streaming account on Netflix is enough for me, I do not care about anything else anymore. May they rot in consumer hell.
- Jleagle 4y agoHow is Netflix better? You still don't own it and they are probably more likely to remove it than a movie store.
- rexf 4y agoStreaming services have no pretense of ownership. You can watch whatever they happen to have as long as you keep paying. When you buy a title on Amazon, Apple, etc., the digital services are selling you on "ownership". In theory, this will be in your account forever (without any money changing hands after the initial transaction). The reality is obviously not so simple.
- black3r 4y agoWhen Steam stops selling a game because of licensing issues and you bought it before, you still have it in your library and can download it from their servers. How and why is selling movies more complicated?
- somat 4y agoOne reason I think steam has done as well as they have is that they have not fucked up(yet). Every once in a while I think a little too much about how most of my games only run due to the benevolence of a company, and I start researching what it would take to run without steam. but in the end, steam is is such a quality of life improvement that I accept their solid track record of not fucking up and keep buying games there. I think the proper paranoid way to buy games on steam would be to use a separate account for each one. then you could treat them as a sellable item.... which would be such a huge pain in the neck their would be no point of using steam in the first point(except, perhaps that it is the only place the game is sold.)
- pharmakom 4y agoIt feels increasingly like paying for media is for chumps. If you pirate then you get the format you want, the edition you want on the device you want… indefinitely.
- ainiriand 4y agoI tend to feel the same. Something like I understand their legal hurdles licensing things across different country laws and such but in reality that is not my damn problem. Silly things like why can't I watch HBO max in Germany?
- capableweb 4y agoEven sillier, why are there subtitles for languages available in some countries, but not in others, even on the same service? If I'm in Brazil watching a Netflix show (even some Netflix originals), I don't see the same amount of subtitle options if I was in India. Absolutely bonkers.
- norman784 4y agoAFAIK this happens when the subtitles are not made by the same company, for example old Disney movies are translated in each region, but not by Disney itself, so they don't own the subtitles. For Netflix originals I have no explanation, I though they do it all themselves.
- usrusr 4y agoChances are the cut you get in India isn't the same as the one you get in Brazil. Wouldn't be surprised if the subtitle translation were made on region cut level, and not on source level so that they could be simply passed on with whatever subset of the audio track viewers get to see (hear)
- account42 4y ago> Chances are the cut you get in India isn't the same as the one you get in Brazil Which is in itself already yet another reason why pirates get the better service.
- anshumankmr 4y agoGood old DVDs and Piracy
- anshumankmr 4y agoSeriously, what happens if the games I bought on Steam are no longer valid due to some potential disagreement between the game publisher and Valve?
- danpalmer 4y agoI suspect this won't happen, and that Valve have contingencies in contracts to ensure this never happens. You might no longer get updates to a game, but that would likely be it. Why? How is this different to films? Games are what Steam does. Films are not really what the Playstation Store does. Sure you can buy them, but who does? Not enough to cause irreparable reputational damage would be my guess. Also, the Playstation Store has far less negotiating power with film distributors than Valve/Steam does with game publishers, so the contract terms aren't likely to include contingencies for this sort of situation.
- Mindwipe 4y ago> I suspect this won't happen, and that Valve have contingencies in contracts to ensure this never happens. They don't, and they literally can't.
- danpalmer 4y agoIs there something in contract law that prevents this?
- Mindwipe 4y agoIt's more that no supplier can credibly claim that they can deliver it. If there's a rights dispute about a piece of underlying code for example, the terms can say what they like but they can't override it not being that entity's code to licence. Valve certainly try and insert a presumption they can leave the title up, but it's not a given, and there's also not much to stop a developer from "updating" the title to a barely working basic binary.
- 4y ago
- bambax 4y ago> you will no longer be able to view your previously purchased Studiocanal content This can't be real. It reads like a joke. Something users purchased can no longer be accessed? I think that's the definition of stealing. Good thing we still have torrents. FYI: Some torrent search engines are blocked by ISPs in Europe, at the DNS level; this is easily circumvented with a VPN, but it's also easy to bypass using DNS-over-HTTPS in Firefox [0]. [0] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-dns-over-https https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-dns-over-https
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- killingtime74 4y agoIt’s not stealing, it’s in the contract. That’s why I only Torrent
- wongarsu 4y agoSure, they always argue that you are only "renting" them for a one-time-fee, and that the rent agreement could end at any time for any reason. But them using the word "purchased" in this very announcement (not a mistranslation btw) gives weight to the argument that this is intentional deception of the customer. An even easier case in Germany, where courts acknowledge that customers don't read the terms of service, so any "surprising" terms hidden in the TOS aren't legally binding.
- heartbreak 4y agoI think it’s specifically purchasing a license to view the content.
- car_analogy 4y agoIs the "content" described as "Movie Title" or "License to view Movie Title for a limited time arbitrarily determined by us"?
- bencollier49 4y agoThis happened to me on Amazon, I think it was. They shouldn't be allowed to use the word "buy".
- _trackno5 4y agoWell, guess this is a good reminder to everyone that anything you purchase on these online stores generally are not really yours. Same applies to Steam, Playstation games, etc. More reason to support DRM-free solutions or just buy physical media you can backup.
- kurupt213 4y agoThis is not acceptable
- lakomen 4y agoCroatian Telekom recently removed certain Cinemax channels from the premium package and are now asking for additional compensation if you'd still like to view them, in the literal middle of the 2 year binding contract. Imagine someone changing the contract's contents one sided. They argue they sent an SMS so it's all fine. Well I don't think so. That leads me to another case, Daybreak Games Company and Everquest 2. They run those TLEs aka nostalgia servers every few years. In the past incarnations you could earn certain vouchers by completing "heritage quests", long winded quests which take some group effort to complete and lots of running around and whatnot. With those vouchers you could "buy" weaker version of those heritage items, on live servers (aka non-nostalgia). They have recently removed the vendors where you can buy those items from, an awful breach of trust and something you have worked hard for simply removed because they felt like it.
- avian 4y ago> in the literal middle of the 2 year binding contract. I don't know about Croatia, but usually such a change in service allows you to break the contract on your end without any penalty (as in, end subscription right there and not pay the rest of the 2 years). It might be hidden in the fine print though and they probably don't want you to know that option exists legally.
- rasz 4y agoDepends on the contract. My cable changed ~10 years ago to stipulate ">200 channels, changing depending on licensing and availability" after first round of national regulator forcing them to allow early cancellation.
- pfortuny 4y agoYes, but in the meantime you risk losing your phone line for at least some days (“if you do not pay…”) and that is a risk that nobody wants to assume nowadays (for good reasons).
- yrro 4y ago> due to our evolving licensing agreements with content providers An impressively high weasel quotient in these words. > you will no longer be able to view your previously purchased Studiocanal content and it will be removed from your video library I expect this policy decision will not survive contact with the courts of Germany and Austria.
- ratww 4y ago> An impressively high weasel quotient in these words. If they changed "evolving" to "devolving" it would be quite honest, since this is clearly a regression.
- globular-toast 4y agoYeah, we said stuff like this would happen. Why are people surprised?
- basicplus2 4y agoAllways buy the tape, record, CD, DVD, Etc make a backup
- uptown 4y ago"Most people don't even know what a rootkit is, so why should they care about it?" - Thomas Hesse That was the end of Sony purchases for me.
- marcodiego 4y agoThanks! Another very good example of why DRM is bad for my list.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoBuying digital licences is for suckers. Piracy is forever, plus you learn practical skills like redundant data storage and offsite backup methodologies. Seriously, the 'value' related criticisms of cryptocurrencies have come true, but for digital licensing.
- namelessoracle 4y agoWith the Playstation Plus changes they have made, they are making Microsoft Game Pass look better and better. They keep acting like they have a massively dominant position instead of having a competitor with deeper pockets who is willing to take losses to undercut them in close proximity
- liampulles 4y agoMoves like this are why I still have DVDs. Its trivial to bypass any region locking, reverse any PAL speedup, and upscale during playback - and the sound quality is already generally excellent. Unlike several generations of hard drives which I've lost completely, all of the DVDs I've ever owned still work just fine. If space is a concern, buy some file binders and some paper disc sleeves and store your discs and covers in them. If convenience is a concern, fair enough - but I find the experience of going to thrift shops and markets to find gems to be a fun and cheap hobby.
- frankzander 4y agoThis ladies and gentleman is DRM ... they do what you want with your payed content ... in your face
- Robotbeat 4y agoIf you "buy" a digital asset, you should be given legal cover to "pirate" it as a backup to protect against this possibility.
- robotburrito 4y agoI remember Richard Stallman warned us of this sort of thing for many years.