16 ms·
I’m going to ignore the security angle and post my big fear. Chrome has dominance similar to IE at the height of its popularity. Whatever you think of their d
by MBCook 4y ago
I’m going to ignore the security angle and post my big fear.
Chrome has dominance similar to IE at the height of its popularity.
Whatever you think of their decisions, Apple is the only thing stopping a 90%+ Chrome web. (Note: not why they’re doing it, just a side effect)
People keep arguing Apple is being anti-competitive. But no one seems to recon with the possible consequences of what they’re asking for. And I fear we may get a pyrrhic victory if these groups/governments keep pushing.
No, I don’t know a good solution. But I don’t think letting Chrome totally own the web is a good outcome.
- mtomweb 4y agoSafari still has around 60% on MacoS and all the normal users believe that there is browser competition now. At best it's speculation, but we can compare that to the very real harms of Apple's browser ban. We've written about the harms in detail here: https://open-web-advocacy.org/files/OWA%20-%20Bringing%20Competition%20to%20Walled%20Gardens%20-%20v1.2.pdf https://open-web-advocacy.org/files/OWA%20-%20Bringing%20Com...
- MBCook 4y agoIt may be 60% on MacOS but that’s a very tiny market. Overall Chrome is quite dominant. Numbers I found say on desktop Chrome is at 70%. Include the 7.75% for Edge (because it’s basically Chrome) and that’s almost 80%. FF at least exists and is similar to Safari. On mobile it’s at 65%. Safari is the only other browser above 5%. Chrome is dangerously close to total monopoly.
- mtomweb 4y agoMacOS is the only market Safari actually competes in and has the same advantage by being the default. I would actually expect the most likely outcome is Apple would fight hard to build a better browser to stem any losses to other browsers. They'll have at least 2 years to do it, so they can catch up in that time with enough investment.
- smoldesu 4y agoThey definitely have the capital to make it happen. Every time I boot up Safari after a MacOS update, I'm consistently wowed by how little of their revenue actually goes in to making a comfortable, feature-complete browser. It's almost like you're using a different, nerfed internet with Safari, but maybe that's just me being angry that uBlock Origin doesn't work anymore.
- robertoandred 4y agoThere are plenty of ad blockers for Safari, not sure what nerfed experience you're referring to.
- danShumway 4y agoThis has been debated to death, but there are no ad blockers on Safari that will work as well as uBlock Origin, because Safari doesn't have all of the APIs/hooks exposed that would be necessary to implement uBlock Origin's more advanced features. It's the same problem that developers were talking about with Chrome's Manifest V3 -- to the point where popular adblockers for Safari like Adguard actually run outside of the browser so that they're not quite as limited as they otherwise would be by Safari's apis.
- noisem4ker 4y agoThe nerfed experience of addons only specifying a significantly limited list of blocking rules, giving up being able to autonomously allow or deny each request with arbitrary parameters, surrogate scripts (replacing the original, tracking ones with privacy-friendly reimplementations) and cosmetically alter the webpage (e.g. fixing the layout with missing ads). Partial source: https://github.com/el1t/uBlock-Safari/issues/158 https://github.com/el1t/uBlock-Safari/issues/158
- smoldesu 4y agoAnd which of those ad blockers are Open Source?
- cma 4y agoMaybe Safari mobile would have to make a better UI with more competition, and could then keep more users.
- agust 4y agoThe size of macOS market is not relevant for the point being made here. What matters is that macOS is very similar to iOS in that it is owned by Apple, Safari is available on it, and comes pre-installed. The only difference is that on macOS browser competition is not banned by Apple. Yet, Safari still has around 60% market share on macOS. So there is a good chance that even if competition where allowed on iOS, Safari, which currently has more than 90% market share, would at the very least not fall down below 60%, preventing Chrome from becoming dominant. It is even more likely because most users on iOS actually believe they can install the real Chrome, so nothing will change in their eyes.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> The size of macOS market is not relevant for the point being made here. I disagree. There are already plenty of sites that are broken on macOS Safari because it's a niche platform. The only saving grace is that websites still have to support iOS Safari. If vendors were able to say "we only support Chrome" on iOS as well, I think that 60% macOS Safari marketshare would drop rapidly due to necessity.
- innocenat 4y agoIf you want website to not be broken on Safari, the solution is to give developer without a Mac the ability to test on Safari. I wouldn't be able to fix my site if it's broken on Mac Safari if I don't have a Mac.
- AlexandrB 4y agoThat's a good point and probably a major strategic error on Apple's part. However in the IE era, even though Netscape/Firefox was free for everyone to test on, many large companies made their sites for "IE Only" because it's easier and cheaper. What I worry about is that, even if Safari kept up with web standards and was mostly compatible in terms of the basics, sites would start requiring APIs that only Chrome wants to support (e.g. FLoC). This would give Google a lot of leverage to push its own technologies on users (Amp also comes to mind).
- JamesSwift 4y agoUsing that logic of Edge being counted as Chrome, why dont we consider 100% of the iOS browser market to be Safari?
- MBCook 4y agoChrome was forked from WebKit but had been it’s own engine for a very long time at this point. They share ancestry but are pretty different. Edge is literally built off a relatively recent version of Chromium. It’s not a separate engine.
- JamesSwift 4y agoEvery iOS browser today runs on Apple Webkit. No exceptions. Thats an apple rule.
- MBCook 4y agoSorry. I didn’t notice you were talking about iOS only. I would hope mobile browser share numbers already take this into account, though I don’t know.
- JamesSwift 4y agoI think they pretty clearly dont since iOS is definitely more than 5% of the mobile market.
- thewileyone 4y ago> Safari still has around 60% on MacoS It's preinstalled on MacOS and you can't uninstall it, just choose not to use it.
- thayne 4y agoWell, if chrome did have 90%+ market share maybe we would finally see some antitrust regulation against Google's monopoly (ideally splitting chrome off from Google). Although there is no guarantee that would happen.
- toyg 4y agoThis. If Chrome reaches certifiable monopoly levels, it becomes easier to use anti-monopolistic instruments to force them to unbundle browser-making from other activities - which is really how things should be.
- MBCook 4y agoThat moves too slow. They could do a ton of damage in the time it takes for anti-trust measures to be placed on them. That’s kind of the point I was trying to make. You need to do that stuff before, or at the same time as, opening iOS. Otherwise we’ll just have a disaster.
- mturilin 4y agoI think this won’t work because Chrome doesn’t have independent business model. Also, if Chrome is removed from Google they could create another alternative based on Chromium since it’s open source.
- toyg 4y ago> Chrome doesn’t have independent business model. Wut? Independent browsers existed before Google, and still do. The browser is such a key element of the web experience that the possibilities for commercial exploitation are fundamentally endless; the number of players in the space is kept low only by the amount of resources required to really compete with the biggest IT companies on the planet. If you could forbid such players from being in the market, you'd see a plethora of new entrants. > if Chrome is removed from Google they could create another alternative based on Chromium The point is not to remove Chrome, the point is to forbid web-giants like Google from being in the browser market, because it enables monopolistic practices towards their web properties. So they would obviously be forbidden from restarting the project as "ReChrome" or whatever.
- JamesSwift 4y agoWhy would they hit 90%? I assume the way this would play out is that most people would stick with the stock browser because they don't even know/care about alternatives. The people that do care would likely install the same browser they use on desktop. I don't think Chrome owns 90% of desktop market share.
- MBCook 4y agoYou don’t think Google will push Chrome to iOS users with banners when they search, use YouTube, Gmail, etc? That’s what they did on desktop.
- liminvorous 4y agoThey already do this in their Apps, e.g. gmail at least at one piont prompted you to install chrome whenever you tried to open a link in a browser.
- colejohnson66 4y agoYouTube also. Clicking links in the comments and descriptions prompts me to choose between "default browser" and installing Chrome. Every time.
- JamesSwift 4y agoYes, but again why would that suddenly mean 90% of people use it vs the reality of desktop today where they don't own 90% of the market? Why are 9 out of 10 people suddenly jumping ship because Google pushed chrome on their phone vs on their desktop PC?
- swiftcoder 4y agoYou are ignoring that Chrome (+ Edge) already effectively controls > 85% of the the browser market, ignoring iOS. They only need a 25% uptake on iOS to push them over 90% globally
- 4y ago
- izacus 4y ago
- imwillofficial 4y agoYou’re accusing GP of shilling, then you distort the argument from the entire market that they were referring to, to only the iPhone. What kind of weird and aggressive behavior is this? You should be ashamed of your behavior.
- lolinder 4y agoI think you make some good points, but you really need to tone it down. OP is sincerely voicing an opinion that is held by a lot of us here, and it's inappropriate to spew this much anger at them and accuse them of shilling and dishonesty. As in everything, someone can disagree with you without being evil.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bogwog 4y agoOn the other hand, if Apple's anti-competitive practices end and Chrome finally hits 90%+ market share, it would make it much harder for regulators to ignore Chrome's dominance and might lead to some actual change for once.
- Bud 4y agoLet me see if I have this straight. Apple has a tiny slice of the overall market, but you are terribly, terribly offended, and so your proposed solution is for Chrome to get more than 90% market share, because that would be a better situation? And "change" would result? How? You don't say. What change? You don't even hint. This just isn't a serious stance, I'm sorry.
- bogwog 4y agoLol @ the seething fanboyism in this comment. You did apologize though, so I forgive you.
- jpgvm 4y agoI don't think the IE comparison is apt. IE shipped on (almost) every machine, had a ton of lock in features like ActiveX, etc. MS actively abused their monopoly position to make it so preventing default installation of Netscape by OEMs, incentivising ISVs to ensure web based enterprise products shipped with "Works best in Internet Explorer" etc. Netscape lost market share to IE not because it lost users but because while the userbase was massively expanding they were buying Wintel boxes that shipped with IE on them so they never learnt that Netscape existed. Chrome is something users install because it's their preferred choice. We can argue as to why it's their preferred choice but the point remains that users actively download and install Chrome - usually as one of the first things they do when they purchase a new computer. That to me puts things on an entirely different level. To compete reasonably with Chrome you need to compete for users directly. You could argue that Google abuses it's monopoly position to market Chrome and that would probably be a valid argument but again, it doesn't change the active decision users are making. If anything Safari (especially on iOS) is more like IE. In that it serves Apple more than it serves users. Apple wants PWAs to remain gimped, by simply dragging their feet or refusing to implement certain web standards/proposals they effectively gimp PWAs. This forces apps to be written for their platform which in turn is where they generate the vast majority of their scalable growth/profit.
- Melatonic 4y agoLets face it - IE always just sucked. A lot. Whereas Chrome does not. Here on HN we might rail on it mainly for ideological reasons but the user experience is pretty solid. This is coming from a Firefox user.
- toast0 4y agoIE 4 and 6 were decent to good compared to competitors when released (although, IIRC, neither had ftp support?). What sucked was that they stagnated at that point in time while also becoming dominant. IE 5 for mac was well regarded, but I don't have personal memories. None of the future IEs were very good though, IMHO.
- 4y ago
- bad_good_guy 4y agoSo, you are happy to have Apple provide no user choice, because you fear a future where there is no user choice?
- nemothekid 4y agoNo; my problem is when people are using the "open web" as a bludgeon to get Apple to allow Chrome on iOS. If you want Chrome on iOS, just say that. To pretend that there is open future of browser diversity once Chrome is allowed on iOS is underhanded.
- idle_zealot 4y agoI want Firefox on iOS.
- cowtools 4y agoI want Firefox on iOS, and I want Tor Browser on iOS, and I want Lynx on iOS, and I want wget on iOS, and I want youtube-dl on iOS, and I want to run whatever the hell I damn well please on iOS. Underhanded? It's pretty clear that your stated goals don't align with your real goals here. Edit: I have a hard time putting into words why your arguments seem so deceptive to me. It is like whataboutism: the arguments you are making are technically functional but they just completely fall apart with any reasonable weighing of the pros/cons because it betrays the "intrinsic" goals (choice, browser competition, functionality, security) for "extrinsic" goals (browser diversity, but mostly the success of safari). This makes me think that you're secretly misaligned and that you actually hold those "extrinsic" goals as your intrinsic goals.
- spideymans 4y agoOften times idealic and well-intentioned measure have negative consequences. Just look at how the EU's cookie banners have eroded the UX of the open web as an example.
- simiones 4y agoIt's not the "EU's cookie banners", it is the advertisers' cookie banners. The EU doesn't mandate cookie banners at all. It's the website's choice whether to pester users about having them accept targetting cookies. The most natural implementation of the EU directive would be to have a place in User Settings where users can go and enable targeted advertising if they want it.
- spideymans 4y ago>The most natural implementation of the EU directive would be to have a place in User Settings where users can go and enable targeted advertising if they want it. And why would we assume that these companies would follow the "most natural implementation"? The very predictable response of the industry to the EU directive was to make the cookie banners as annoying as invasive as possible, such that users would consent to tracking out of apathy. No, it's not what the EU intended to happen, but it was a consequence. Which brings me back to my original point: often times idealic and well-intentioned measure have negative consequences. In hindsight, perhaps the EU should've legislated that the UX for the tracking content cannot be unreasonably annoying. I don't know how I'd go about codifying that into law though.
- JCWasmx86 4y ago> I don't know how I'd go about codifying that into law though. Simply make the DNT-Header a legally binding thing. If the user sends it, it means that only technically necessary cookies can be used. This would require no UX from the side of the website, thus defeating all dark patterns at once
- spideymans 4y ago
- jacooper 4y agoMeh, at best Safari is the New IE it doesnt support many feature in purpise to serve Apple priorties and hinder the web. https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/23/opinion_column/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/23/opinion_column/
- Narretz 4y agoOn the other hand, actual browser choice for iOS will force Apple into improving Safari at a faster rate. This is good competition.
- mvid 4y agoIf quality of competition truly mattered, then IE wouldn't have had to be stopped with legislation
- idle_zealot 4y agoIE wasn’t stopped with legislation. It continued to be bundled with Windows. It was eventually dethroned by Chrome.
- AlexandrB 4y agoOne could argue the successful legal action against IE bundling stopped Microsoft from further entrenching it in Windows. With Edge in Windows 10/11 you can see the kind of nudges that Microsoft probably wanted to add all along.
- izacus 4y agoAnd now this topic is full of people defending this exact entrenchment by dictat from Apple.
- veilrap 4y agoIt's not the same, because Safari is already a minority in the market compared to the Chrome behemoth.
- simondotau 4y agoSeriously, I kind of wonder whether or not grass roots anti-Safari sentiment is dominated by web developers who resent having to test their sites in more than one web browser.
- lucasyvas 4y agoIt's not Apple's choice to make on whether or not Chrome becomes a browser monopoly - fighting anti-competitiveness with anti-competitiveness is not a solution. The chips will fall as they will and we will all be left to deal with the aftermath. That's the way it has to be.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> That's the way it has to be. What? Why? I assure you that's not how Google thought of it when they were facing off against Firefox and IE. They were putting Chrome installers in every SourceForge download and telling you to install Chrome when you searched Google. Why should their competitors lie down and let Chrome roll over them?
- theturtletalks 4y agoFor one, people still had the decision to download Chrome even if it was advertised heavily. Apple forces Safari on all their iOS users since all the browsers have to use WebKit.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Apple forces Safari on all their iOS users… Lots of people use non-Safari browsers on iOS (Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Opera, Brave, DuckDuckGo), and iOS lets you choose your default browser. I know you know Safari <> WebKit, but 99.99% of users don't know or care about the plumbing.
- mtomweb 4y agoAll the real browsers have been banned. Ask any browser vendor. The rest are basically Safari skins.
- Spivak 4y agoAgain, users don’t really care about the plumbing. Chrome went from WebKit to Blink. Safari spiritually went from KHTML to WebKit. IE went from Trident to EdgeHTML to Blink. Opera went from Presto to Blink. The identity of the browser is the chrome, ba dum tiss.
- xfalcox 4y agoApple could be asked to provide a single alternative browser, like allowing a real Gecko-powered Firefox to solve both issues?
- ahartmetz 4y agoI also think that Apple is doing a good thing here. Since I don't use any Apple devices, I also don't have any trouble with it personally :) (I'm doing my part by using Firefox.)
- Arnavion 4y agoSame. As another Firefox user and Apple non-user, I'm grateful to Safari for keeping web devs in check so that their shit runs on Firefox.
- ascagnel_ 4y agoIt reminds me of what Apple did with iBooks: they weren't trying to do the right thing, they did it the wrong way, but if they had been successful, it would have been better for the market as a whole. The DoJ correctly went after Apple and eventually won, but they also should have looked at Amazon for using what were basically dumping-level prices to secure the market for themselves. Apple is in the wrong to tie Safari to iOS and block the installation of other browsers. They're wrong to do it for the sake of keeping control of the OS. They're right to do it, because that's the only thing that's keeping Chrome from a near-monopoly of the browser space.
- canuckintime 4y ago> It reminds me of what Apple did with iBooks: they weren't trying to do the right thing, they did it the wrong way, but if they had been successful, it would have been better for the market as a whole... Amazon for using what were basically dumping-level prices Apple was successful in that regard though; the contracts they made with Big 5 remained intact and Apple didn't have to compete with Amazon on price. Apple's strategy was not better for the market as a whole because Apple never cared about the market as a whole. Due to Apple's anti-competitive behaviour we are still stuck with a Publishing industry decades behind on digital
- m-p-3 4y agoOn the other hand, this denies me from using an actual Mozilla Firefox web browser on iOS. Imposing an artificial limit on iOS isn't how the web will move forward. > Whatever you think of their decisions, Apple is the only thing stopping a 90%+ Chrome web. I don't see Apple making any effort to diversify the browser ecosystem by making their browser available on other operating systems, so their inaction on other fronts isn't going to reverse the trend either.
- CharlesW 4y ago> On the other hand, this denies me from using an actual Mozilla Firefox web browser on iOS. It denies you from using Gecko. You can use an actual Mozilla Firefox web browser on iOS.
- jedberg 4y agoA semantic nitpick that is totally irrelevant. Most people on this website usually mean Gecko when they say they want to use Firefox.
- rPlayer6554 4y agoLet's not pretend all of HN is a hive mind. I for one thought that Firefox the browser had chosen not to be on IOS because to they couldn't use Gecko. This is new information to me. So no, using the proper names for things is not a semantic nitpick. The commentator didn't not try to invalidate the parent's point, just show the language issue.
- judge2020 4y agoReally? You mean people don't use Firefox because: - it protects what's important - you can "Personalize your experience with new colorways." - has Facebook Container - syncs across your devices Mozilla knows the actual engine isn't the deciding factor when trying to get people to change browsers. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/new/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/new/
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> I’m going to ignore the security angle That's the whole purpose of this post. Instead you want to fear monger and deflect from a sore subject for Apple.
- MBCook 4y agoTheir argument (which others have pointed out flaws with) is Safari is a security issue so Apple needs to open up. I’m saying even if they’re right about security (which I doubt) the fallout will be so much worse we shouldn’t do it. This is not something you can look at in a vacuum. There are serious ramifications to their suggestion and they need to be realized.
- glitchc 4y agoActually that’s how the system is supposed to work: Let Chrome become a monopoly so that we can finally regulate it. The same thing happened with IE and we crossed that bridge when the time came. Apple needs to open up their ecosystem to other browsers. This is not a suitable excuse.
- MBCook 4y agoI would argue Chrome is already a de facto monopoly. So why do we need to make things worse to make them better? Let’s make them better (fix the Chrome issue) and then make them better again (the Safari issue) instead of the other way around.
- danShumway 4y agoI completely sympathize with this worry, but are we certain that allowing multiple browsers on iOS would mean Chrome dominance? Part of the reason Chrome dominates on Android is because it's the default browser. How many people on iPhone are we expecting will change their default browser? As far as I know, most users don't change their messenger clients on iOS.
- MBCook 4y agoThe one number I can find is that 25% of iOS users already use Chrome on iOS. So that’s 5% of all surfing. You know that would immediately become real Chrome. Once it’s possible to have real Chrome my fear is Google would start breaking things on Safari (or just refusing to fix things) to drive people to it.
- danShumway 4y agoIt's a somewhat legit concern given that people have alleged they basically did that already with Firefox. And the stats make me curious -- given that Chrome on iOS is just a wrapper around Safari, are people just switching because Google Docs tells them to, and that's enough? I'm having a hard time of thinking of a functionality reason to switch to Chrome in iOS (maybe browser/bookmark sync, I guess). I'm surprised to see a number that high.
- MBCook 4y agoI have always highly suspected that normal people don’t know/care about how Chrome on iOS works. It’s only the developer community that is so outspoken about it. Of course I have no way to prove that at all.
- dmitriid 4y ago> are we certain that allowing multiple browsers on iOS would mean Chrome dominance? Yes. From Google's apps already asking you to open links in Chrome to Google actively sabotaging competition https://twitter.com/johnath/status/1116871231792455686 https://twitter.com/johnath/status/1116871231792455686
- lenkite 4y ago"Whatever you think of their decisions, Apple is the only thing stopping a 90%+ Chrome web." Sorry what ? Can you point me to the place where I can download Safari for Linux and Windows and Android ? If they actually had those builds, I would believe what you say. But no - All they are doing is protecting their turf by hitting every other browser with sticks so folks prefer native apps over web apps.
- MBCook 4y agoI think you misunderstand. Yes, Safari is only on Apple platforms. I’m saying Chrome is already dominant on Windows, Linux, Android, and Chromebook. The only one where it’s not is iOS (Mac is kinda close, but small in terms of users). If real Chrome can go on iOS my supposition is Chrome will become dominant there too. Leaving no platform not dominated by Chrome.
- dekhn 4y agoChrome runs on all 3 major platforms. Safari does not. I think I'll side with Chrome and its dominance, because I don't want to be stuck on Mac.
- snowwrestler 4y agoPeople do not seem to understand how important it is to Google they they achieve full control of the browser end of the WWW. The blog post at the top of this thread talks about CVEs and other measures of resistance to 3rd party bad actors. It does not engage with the concept of Google themselves as a bad actor. With full control of the rendering engine on all platforms, Google can stop engaging with standards bodies. Web rendering standards will become simply what Google says they are, even if it is to their benefit. Imagine AMP but on steroids. When Safari stops rendering mobile sites correctly, there will be lots of helpful friends and family (and ads) telling folks to "just switch to Chrome, it's a better browser anyway." Google could also ship their own root certificate list and take control of Web PKI. Imagine Symantec but entirely at Google's option. Play ball or get security warnings. This would allow an end run around the democratization afforded by Let's Encrypt, for example. Controlling 90% of the client end of TLS confers just as much power as controlling the CA end. Google also has no incentive to make Chrome secure or performant on iOS devices; they run the competing mobile OS platform. If Chrome/Blink is forced into iOS, it won't be long before complaints crop up and we start seeing "Android runs Chrome better than iPhone" ads. The fundamental fight is not about browsers, it is about defining the platform: "commoditizing your complement." Google wants Chrome to be the platform, and commoditize the computer. This will let Google centralize profits to itself. This is why Android is free (as long as you ship Google's services too). They will spend as much as they must to achieve this. It is existential. Lots of folks in this thread talking about Firefox. In this context, Firefox is a strategic front-end for Google. Google is essentially paying for Firefox to continue existing, so that people will use Firefox as an ideological cudgel against Apple. Also seeing some comments about antitrust. So the plan is to get the government to step in to quash the competition that exists, wait for all the predictable bad things to happen, and then get the government to step in again to re-establish competition. Does anyone actually think this is a good idea? Or is "antitrust" just a convenient way to dismiss legitimate fears and objections.
- liveoneggs 4y agoYeah I have a really hard time believing https://open-web-advocacy.org/ https://open-web-advocacy.org/ is not actually google but it is certainly aiming towards Google's benefit and, ironically, the end of any chance of an "open" web
- _8j50 4y agoIt isn't in Chrome's interest to dominate 90%+ anyways. It already is being treated as the default browser when devs create frontends. It will almost certainly see regulation, at least in the EU to have some sort of standards compliance else Google is fined.
- MBCook 4y ago> It isn't in Chrome's interest to dominate 90%+ anyways. Why is that? I’ve never heard anyone argue that point before so I’m curious what you think the downsides would be to Google.
- _8j50 4y agoBecause anti-trust. Companies answer to countries who don't like anti-competitive companies that aren't controlled by the state. People won't care but politicians will take notice of any company controlling almost all of their market which effectively gives them political leverage and dissatisfied voters. They also make for a great punching bag when politicians want to act like they are for the people because 100 million fine against Google means relatively little to google but a lot for getting voters to vote for you.
- j0hnyl 4y agoThe difference between Chrome and IE is that IE sucked, but Chrome is currently the best user experience. What's the problem? If you have privacy concerns there are enough alternatives. Opera, Brave, Tor browser, etc. perform pretty well.
- sparker72678 4y agoIE gained market share most when it was a great user experience. IE 4 was frickin amazing compared to other browsers at the time. 5 and 6, _when they were released_, were also excellent browsers. It wasn't until after they had dominance that IE really withered.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoThis is the absolute reality of what Open Web Advocacy is pushing for. A complete Chrome monopoly. It's really frustrating a couple lazy web devs with really incorrect understanding of the space keep getting so much attention.
- adamius 4y agoWhy does Apple get to choose how its competitor gets to compete? We give microsoft plenty of flak for anti-competitive behavior. It deserves it too. Its not hard to see why. But so does Apple. Now why can't I install my silly joke app? Oh that's right Apple won't let me install my joke app on my devices or friends for more than a week or so for reasons. Even though it can be easily tracked to me, its signed etc. Why is that? Control. Why can't I have a linux vm chugging away on ipados? Apple says no. Why? Control. If Apple wants to exert this much control then it really needs to accept liability. So those security defects? Where's the service level agreement to time limit those glaring holes? Its therefore unacceptable for Apple to be slow to fix an issue when its competitor could have already fixed it. Oh wait, there are no competitors on ios since no one is allowed to compete. You must use webkit. How is that not anti-competitive?
- veilrap 4y agoNo one is forced to use Apple products at all. Choosing an Apple product over non-apple products is a choice. There is extensive competition with Apple products. Choosing to buy an iPad, and being upset that they can't install linux on it, failed to do any product research before buying the product. Many people, myself included, choose to use Apple products in part BECAUSE of how those products work and function, today. I don't want to install additional browsers, app stores, or other crap on my phone, I just want it to work well, out of the box with reasonably high security. For my needs Apple products provide that today. If Apple's products don't fit your needs, the solution is trivial - don't buy Apple products.
- stale2002 4y ago> Apple's products don't fit your needs, the solution is trivial - don't buy Apple products. If you don't want to install alternative app stores or browsers, then you should simply choose to not install them. With the new digital markets act being passed in the EU, everyone will be able to install whatever app store or browser that they want. And you can't complain because you should listen to your own advice by not installing those other app stores or browsers.
- adfjalkfja 4y agoLove that I can't use chromecast on any other browser. And how they make youtube ads much much tougher to get away from when you do use it
- albatross13 4y agoMy computer, my choice.
- jmyeet 4y agoI've seen this claim a lot lately that Chrome is the new IE. I don't think it holds water. First, IE was bundled onto virtually every computer at the time and Microsoft went out of their way to stop you from replacing it (eg system actions would use IE). Second, Microsoft's anticompetitive IE behaviour was aimed at protecting its Window monopoly. Microsoft was worried that the Web would become a device-indepndent platform and that would obviate the need for Windows at all. Third, is Chrome actually bundled to any large degree? There's enterprise bundling but how significant is it? There are Chromebooks but I feel like they're not a huge factor. I guess there's Android. Chrome's desktop share seems to be 68% [1]. That's impressive for an action people have to take to change the default. Fourth, Google doesn't have the same motivations as Microsoft (in regards to protecting another platform). There are other much more real issues (eg favoring their other properties like Youtube) but crippling Chrome doesn't seem to be something that aligns with any of their interests. It seems way more likely that Youtube (etc) will work better in Chrome. While that's bad for other browsers, it doesn't have the same negative effects as what Microsoft tried. Fifth, the core of Chrome (ie Webkit but also V8) is both open source and the core of other browsers (notably Safari and Edge) so it's less likely Web developers will end up in a situation where they effectively have to implement something twice, once for Chrome and once for the rest. That was pretty much the situation with IE. Will it be a big deal in the future? Maybe. I don't really see this being a big problem anytime soon however. [1]: https://backlinko.com/browser-market-share https://backlinko.com/browser-market-share
- summerlight 4y agoApple could also tackle Chrome's dominance in a different direction. Just invest much more aggressively in Safari and web apps, 10~20x OpEx. Release Safari on Android and all other major platforms. Make most of it fully open source. Make all of its first party apps available on the web. Obviously this means that they need to give up on their iron grip on app developers so they didn't do that even if that was the exact path Steve envisioned. But that's not a good excuse either.
- cyanydeez 4y ago"we can't have competition be because apple will lose"
- account42 4y ago> No, I don’t know a good solution. I know one: Anti-trust enforcement.