21 ms·
Ten years after the Higgs, physicists face the nightmare of finding nothing else
- uwagar 4y agothe whole of western civilization built on materialism is in trouble.
- annyeonghada 4y agoOn what are built others civilizations? I've yet to see a civilization that is not built on money and power.
- dynjo 4y agoI sometimes ponder whether we fundamentally just went in the wrong direction from the very start with quantum physics, but we ended up so far down the road it was impossible to start again. Disclaimer: I'm not a physicist and my understanding is superficial at best.
- Victerius 4y agoJames Clerk Maxwell united electricity and magnetism with a pen and paper. Einstein discovered special and general relativity in the same way. Has theoretical physics advanced enough now that such pen and paper discoveries are all but over, and the only way to continue making progress is to dedicate an ever larger share of the global economy's productive capacity to building larger and more expensive experiments? What if we build a $200 billion collider that finds nothing? What if a $1 trillion collider is needed to continue making progress? That could be a line out of Asimov. "And so eventually the entire economy was exclusively focused on the construction of larger and larger particle accelerators. There was no room for anything else. Medical research was stopped. Movies stopped being made.Improving the lot of mortals was abandoned as a policy. The only thing that mattered to the 30 billion humans alive was to build and pay for the next accelerator." Obviously an extreme extrapolation. But what if? Should we just ... give up on particle physics?
- throw93232 4y ago
- burmanm 4y agoWell, we also blow up billions in missiles that achieve nothing. So, why not smash some particles instead?
- Victerius 4y agoMissiles advance rocketry, electronics, composite materials, fuel chemistry, and precision guidance, all technologies we'll need more of in the future.
- Beltiras 4y agoWe probably wouldn't have the LHC now if the results hadn't been applicable to blowing stuff up for previous incarnations of it.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoI would absolutely prefer smashing particles over smashing missiles.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoIf building and paying for bigger and bigger accelerators would be the only things that matters for humanity, it wouldn't be that bad. First, servicing the accelerator is a major source of employment to the economy. I think it is a much better way to spend money than maintaining all the militaries in the world. Second, such a project will require a lot of highly educated personnel to run it, so it'll require a considerable investment in education.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SassyGrapefruit 4y agoI think "nightmare" is a bit sensational. The LHC's purpose is not to "find X" it is to take measurements over a novel range of conditions. The new data is what we're after.
- Certhas 4y ago"Nightmare" was how physicists themselves characterize the situation we are in, and have done for at least 15 years. Look at the 2007 article linked in the article above: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.315.5819.1657 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.315.5819.1657 Jonathan Ellis is on the record there describing the scenario we find ourselves in now as "the real five-star disaster". (you can get the full article by putting the link into scholar.google.com). And I recall hearing and reading the "nightmare scenario" phrase before that 2007 article.
- aeturnum 4y agoI think people here should imagine it like an infrastructure investment with an extremely bad ROI. People are using it and it's well-made, but the return on our investment would never have justified the cost in time or effort. The whole history of high energy physics is a back-and-forth between models and experiment. We get to a new energy level, try some things that the models are ambiguous about, and previously we've gotten new and interesting results that lead people to reshape models and make new predictions. That has not, generally, happened with the LHC. The frustrating limitations and inconsistencies of the standard model are the same as when we built it. The problem is we spent a lot of money and time and focus on building a tool that has not actually moved us forward much. This happens from time to time - but it's bad! We have not made our series of scientific advances by getting lucky on a bunch of coin flips - we've been able to use previous experiments to design the next set of tools in ways that productively open up parts of the science we could not observe before. The fact that we seem to have failed to accomplish this with one of the largest, most expensive tools ever built calls into question the methods that led us to choose to build this tool instead of other possible ones.
- 4y ago
- adtac 4y agoI only have an amateur interest in physics, so I'm sorry if this sounds dumb, but I often think about what if we've reached as far as we can go within the current framework of physics? This is more meta-science than actual science, but what if we made some decisions very early in the development of physics and mathematics and we need to revisit those?
- mhh__ 4y agoThere is still huge amounts of work to do in the less fundamental aspects of physics.
- tejohnso 4y agoPerhaps one such decision is that matter is fundamental. There are increasingly substantial cases being made that this is now holding us back in physics, and that we need to consider that consciousness is fundamental, and matter is only a consequence of it. See, for example Hoffman's The Case Against Reality.
- onionisafruit 4y agoWhat does fundamental mean in this case?
- alex_sf 4y agoNothing. It’s pseudoscientific nonsense.
- denton-scratch 4y agoI'm not a physicist; but the GP mentioned consciousness as an alternative to matter as the fundamental "substance". Well, I've come across that idea before; in certain kinds of Buddhism, consciousness is considered fundamental, the senses are created by consciousness, and the material world is projected by consciousness through the senses. Well, this was explained to me in the context of a particular type of tantric Buddhism; but actually the basic idea is common across most mainstream Buddhism. Most schools teach that the universe is cyclical, and is completely destroyed at the end of an era, before being recreated ex-nihilo. The creation process is started with the appearance of Brahma, who then hallucinates the rest of the universe into existence. So in that model, it is consciousness, not matter that is fundamental, because the material world cannot come into existence without consciousness.
- trentnix 4y agoWasn’t there an article a week ago about a new particle found “on a tabletop”? Feels like I'm being hustled.
- Hellion 4y agoStop reading pop science articles
- quickthrower2 4y agoProbably a food particle
- gus_massa 4y agoI remember that report, it was a very confusing press article. They used a tabletop device to make a "simulation" of a Higgs boson inside a semiconductor. It was not a new elementary particle like an electron or a photon. Is solid state physics they don't call those thing a "simulation", they call a quasiparticle. They are not a single entity, but they behave almost like a single entity, so if yu are working in the are it's easier to make the calculation as if they are a single entity. Moreover, most of the time they just call the particles, but everyone in the area and physicist in other areas understand that they are talking about quasiparticles. The problem is when the new reach the press and that implicit understanding is lost.
- bamboozled 4y agoWhy would this be a nightmare, isn't this good? They know they're going down the wrong path and can probably correct?
- nemo44x 4y agoTrue but you’d hate to be the physicist that spent their career going down the wrong path only to see tomorrows physicists discover the big breakthroughs and the realization that your contribution will be sent to the dustbin of history.
- denton-scratch 4y agoYah. Well, for most of us, the prospect of making a significant contribution to the sum of human knowledge is a faint prospect. They say all political careers end in failure. Very few politicians die in the saddle, or simply retire. Most of them are destroyed. My guess is that most careers in science research end similarly; lots of career-length research projects fail to achieve their goals, and very few scientists get Nobels for world-changing discoveries.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> for most of us, the prospect of making a significant contribution to the sum of human knowledge is a faint prospect Physicists are bright people with other options. They forewent those other options to have an increased chance at contributing to human understanding. I can empathize with the greater tragedy of their failure than that of e.g. a millionaire adtech founder.
- lmm 4y agoThe prospect of actually "finishing" physics could be a nightmare for those working in it. I had a friend who was a brilliant pure mathematician, his teachers and friends agreed he fully deserved to do a PhD in complex analysis - but complex analysis was essentially done in the 19th century, there's just not a lot of research opportunities there.
- dlsa 4y agoAt least they are finding nothing and confirming they are finding nothing. Less scrupulous operators might be always finding something even if its not there. So that's a sign of good science. Maybe there's something they haven't found because there's so much data? Mix things up and look again? Change assumptions? Or as someone I know likes to say to various smaller humans: have you looked around the couch? Really? Are you sure? Have you had a good look? this is how the tv remote usually subsequently reappears as there is a difference between just looking and having a good look. The best science also happens when you've looked, not found it but now know where not to look. Even better science happens when you know exactly why it shouldn't have been there at all. Surprising science happens when you find the errors in your assumptions and discover it can sometimes be where it previously was not expected to be.
- highwaylights 4y agoThey haven't found nothing. They've found something, which is nothing. They've looked, been able to rule out some hypotheses of what they might find, and have established some evidence against others. Progress achieved, and the search continues.
- jordanpg 4y agoThis. This author, who should know better, is suggesting that the only "success" is a new discovery. This is patent nonsense. Every time a hypothesis is ruled out, and every time a hypothesis is ruled out with greater confidence, the experiment has succeeded. What is true is that discoveries drive public excitement and public support for additional funding. That is a political problem and it is solvable. If Western governments can find the public support for trillions in military expenditures, I am confident that it can be found for the comparably meager budgets of the scientific establishment.
- anticristi 4y ago> If Western governments can find the public support for trillions in military expenditures, I am confident that it can be found for the comparably meager budgets of the scientific establishment. Sadly, that achievement -- public support for trillions in military expenditures -- belongs to a not-so-Western government invading a wanna-be-Western government.
- sdfhdhjdw3 4y agoOh jesus christ, the constant whining! This is science. This is how it works. Maybe there's nothing else to discover, maybe it will take us 100 years, we don't know, that's why it's called research.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> Maybe there's nothing else to discover AFAICS that is not one of the options; there are mysteries and contradictions whose explanations remain to be discovered. But maybe we can't discover more using the LHC (which I doubt).
- prionassembly 4y agoThere's the mythology of the heavens being held up by the titan Atlas, who rests on top of a cow, which rests on top of a turtle... the kiddy version continues on top of another turtle, on top of... I once had a vision -- yes, a vision, something deep came to me as I laid half-awake -- that after a few dozen turtles the actual ground was made of jackstraw[1]. It rested on a firm tangle. I've always felt since then that the world and the universe themselves are made of contradictions. That some contradictions are fundamental, and this is why since Socrates we've always been so focused on finding contradictions. Because maybe we can find the ones we can't pick apart. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pick-up_sticks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pick-up_sticks
- denton-scratch 4y ago> the world and the universe themselves are made of contradictions. In logic, it's said that from a contradiction you can validly deduce any proposition. The idea that contradictions are fundamental is horrifying; it implies that any attempt to reason about the world is doomed. I don't know how it would affect me if I believed that. I hope you have a good therapist!
- Grimburger 4y ago> Maybe there's nothing else to discover, maybe it will take us 100 years, we don't know, that's why it's called research. At what price?
- fithisux 4y agoThey could open projects in a git hosting site, publish their code in a polished form. They can even contribute to various projects related to their work. Or create a data hosting service for others to examine them.
- Barrera 4y agoStagnation of scientific fields is normal and can last many years. In that time, little anomalies pile up, are swept under the rug, and largely forgotten. To admit anomalies can ruin careers, after all. Eventually someone (often very young/inexperienced) comes along and upends the field by proposing a different model or doing the experiment whose weight breaks the camels back. What's new here is the scale of the work. It's not clear how you upend a field where the price of entry is measured in billions of dollars.
- XorNot 4y agoWell that's not the case though: you can upend the field with data from the LHC - after all Einstein didn't do the Michelson-Mauley (how I spelt that right) experiment himself, but Special Relativity was developed out of that result existing.
- chopin 4y agoMichelson-Morley experiment: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_experiment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exp....
- adamsmith143 4y ago>Stagnation of scientific fields is normal and can last many years. In that time, little anomalies pile up, are swept under the rug, and largely forgotten. To admit anomalies can ruin careers, after all. Could not be more wrong for Particle Physics. An Anomaly could define your career and herald a Nobel Prize. That's exactly what we're looking for. We desperately want to find anomalies, not hide them.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoReally? Because the article seems to say the complete opposite in multiple instances. "Oh hey this thing doesn't match what is expected according to the standard model but yeah the standard model is tots fine bro." > For example, in 2017, physicists working with LHCb, one of four large particle detectors fed by the LHC, found that B mesons, particles that contain a heavy bottom quark, decay more often to an electron and a positron than to a particle called a muon and an antimuon. The standard model says the two rates should be the same, and the difference might be a hint of supersymmetric partners, Ellis says. So why is the standard model not in the trashcan?
- otikik 4y agoPhysicists are facing the nightmare that tomorrow is Thursday and nothing else.
- piokoch 4y agoThis is bollocks. Typical clickbait title. There is still a lot of unsolved problems in physics, both experimental and theoretical. Particle physics is just one branch of science (and rather boring, if you ask me), popularized by CERN marketing, so people think new physics equals finding some new particle. There is a lot of interesting problems waiting for exploration. I will not even try to list them "unsolved physics problems" googling shows enough.
- Certhas 4y agoThat's a very uncharitable reading of the headline. I think it's pretty clear that it's talking about particle physics, not physics as a whole. At any rate the article makes this clear in the first line: > Unless Europe’s Large Hadron Collider coughs up a surprise, the field of particle physics may wheeze to its end
- ssorallen 4y agoThis is clickbait to someone in particle physics? It describes the standard model, what the LHC was able to find, what it hasn’t been able to find, and why there is skepticism about further discoveries. This is some high quality clickbait.
- alienozi 4y ago
- Terry_Roll 4y agoIt was easy picking the low hanging fruit in the physics world decades if not hundreds of years ago, in some case's you merely had to pick up the fruit that had fallen off the tree!
- lemursage 4y agoThis feels like that Futurama episode where Farnsworth discovers the last particle and descends into panic, realising he has nothing else to do. However, in my opinion, asking why there's nothing else is also a valid question to consider, even if we suspect there's something more to what we've seen so far. Also, perhaps it'd be a tad bit more accurate to rephrase it `particle physicists`, not `physicists` -- even though it's totally exaggerated anyways.
- colinmhayes 4y agoAt some point that becomes philosophy more than physics.
- somenameforme 4y agoScience has had countless cycles of believing we had discovered, more or less, all that was to be discovered and the remainder would come in sorting out things to another decimal place. Then a revolution, sometimes in short order, sometimes centuries later, comes around and emphasizes our ignorance and arrogance. So at any given point you have two options: that we've finally reached "the end" - this is it and we can go no further. Or that we're at yet the latest cliff-face searching for that ever-elusive path through. I would always bet, hard, on the latter. At least if I could live forever, because even if I am right there's every possibility, if not probability, that none of us living today will be around to see it shown. The notion of being able to discern all the fundamental laws of the universe while living on a single isolated grain of sand in a beach of ever more bizarre discoveries stretching out endlessly in all directions just seems improbable to me, at best.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoI believe they got a lot of good data about the proton, it helped with that...it's just a good instrument in general. There's other virtues. And you think a particle isn't good enough? Realize how important the electron was to you eg reading this? There's still time for more work. But like the age of discovering new continents is passed, now it's subtler things. Like the time when the center of Africa was unknown, but the Americas and Australia and Antartica were known.
- anticristi 4y agoFascinating! The victims of their own success. I would love for Sabine to cover this (https://www.youtube.com/c/SabineHossenfelder https://www.youtube.com/c/SabineHossenfelder).
- Brometheus 4y agoShe surely will…
- jcroll 4y agoThis nytimes article has a very different take. The field is excited at the prospect of new physics: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/13/science/cern-hadron-collider-muon-leptoquark.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/13/science/cern-hadron-colli...
- NoGravitas 4y agoAll I'm hoping for from the LHC is that they collapse the false vacuum.
- clerk_occam 4y agoI’d prefer if they didn’t
- tiborsaas 4y agoCollapse your own false vacuum and please do it very far from Earth, I'd like to enjoy our particles a bit more.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoMaybe we need a bigger collider. Earth would look cool with a ring around it.
- qwerty456127 4y agoWhat else do they want to find?
- danrocks 4y agoA use for cryptocurrencies? /s
- jakey_bakey 4y agoIt says they were looking for particles with supersymmetry - I know on The Big Bang Theory they discovered Super Asymmetry - do you think the boffins at CERN have tried looking for that?
- jmyeet 4y agoI really thought I'd see meaningful progress on harmonizing quantum mechanics and relativity or some of these other "big" problems in fundamental physics but now I'm not so sure. This by the way is a good reason not to dump tens of billions into a successor to the LHC. We simply don't know what we're looking for. Despite a number of significant upgrades we still haven't found anything that breaks the Standard Model. I mean we've disproven a lot and that means something but we should still have an idea what we're looking for. I'd love to know what making new space (ie what makes the universe expand) actually means. At one point I thought space might be discreet (eg at the Planck length) but that's not how that works. What is time? What is space? What really is mass? What is a force? These are things we can describe the effects of but not really what they are. It would be deeply disappointing if there was a fundamental limit to our understanding that would prohibit a deeper explanation, which actually seems like a possibility.
- red_trumpet 4y ago> What is time? What is space? What really is mass? What is a force? These are things we can describe the effects of but not really what they are. That's how models work. Even a unifying theory would not satisfyingly answer those questions.
- dav_Oz 4y ago"Science" doesn't care about individual careers or generations (in that case of physicists) who are left with "nothing else" to discover (fundamentally) and are simply "condemned" to pass the torch (determining values and uncertainties as best as possible). It's a brutal selection process if viewed from an individual lens which can consciously participate for say at best only 3 generations. The institutionalized systems - which themselves carry an often underappreciated (in the field itself) or overexaggareted (outside the field) intertia - we now have in place to best approximate "science" are still left with a lot of headroom for optimization. One of the many corners overlooked handwavingly imhv are for example the attempts to raise scientific literacy (critical thinking, formulating (theoretical) and testing (practical) hypotheses) in the societies overall, the fertile humus, so to speak. Because of the massive shifts/societal changes actually the reverse seems to be happening in the last decades in an accelerating speed. Decentralizing science could help here and is a legitimate concern in the case of the LHC as an example of a highly centralized research model. I find the struggle for a sweet spot appropriate, here. That being said, it is still possible that we just find ourselves at a local low (at the current level of the LHC) with some arising anomalies but by just pushing the energies a little farther this let's us get out of the hole, again. So, nobody is arguing to shut the LHC altogether, but depending on what we find, the next "Future Circular Collider" to be built on top of it might simply not be "worth" it in the foreseeable future.
- fartsucker69 4y agoThere are more fundamental considerations to be made. For example, the small scale structures of the universe might just be too small to be observable by experimental means. As in, not just practically too small (too difficult to build experiments for it), but fundamentally not possible to observe due to their mathematical structure. There are already a lot of things in quantum physics particularly that we can't observe directly. For example, there's no such thing as observing separate quarks - if you separate two quarks too much the binding energy between them pops another set of quarks into existence. But you can infer their existence indirectly "via math" basically. However it's easily possible that the more fundamental structures of the universe are bound in such a way that you can't even observe them indirectly, even if you had access to machines that could produce the energies required.
- krinchan 4y agoThis is such a CERN thing to say, lol. "Bluh bluh the ILC and muon colliders aren't real! Neutrinos are fake!! Low energy particle physics is a lie!" Also this article is weird because phase 2 for the LHC is under way. Currently run 3 is happening and just started but this article talks like the beam upgrade isn't happening. Also particle physics has gone far more than 10 years between major discoveries. I'm gonna guess this author is yet another person who needs to stop whining about supersymmetry not happening. Like the only point the article makes (but makes it obliquely) is that supersymmetry is no longer a good motivator of higher energy beams. However, all our theories still break down at that level. So there's still a crap ton of things to explore. I'm somewhat concerned that Science would go this click-bait with an article. The mood is hardly a nightmare.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lokimedes 4y agoThese articles will be gold in 100 years. We found the bottom of reality, guys, no need to look further!
- typon 4y agoThis comment itself might be the "real" gold, if in a 100 years, we actually make no material advances in experimental physics and the state of the art remains. I would bet that it's quite likely, unless somehow we achieve communist utopia and the world economies combine to fund a solar system size accelerator.
- danaris 4y agoThat's not really what's being said. We know there's more to find; we know there's problems with our current understanding; we know we haven't found "the bottom". The problem is, we've found what looks like a bottom, and all the looking we do for cracks in it, or knocking on it to find hollow spots, or hitting it really hard to try and bust through, just keeps coming back with everything being unbroken, solid, and unyielding. It's not self-congratulation; it's frustration.
- anigbrowl 4y agoNo. The nightmare here is physicists knowing the Standard Model can't possibly be the bottom, but lacking clues about where to find stairs.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoThere is an existential angst amongst particle physicists because they all understand that they are the thoroughbred pets of the scientific world. Even if they find something, it doesn't matter, because they are working in energy regimes that are not reachable in the ordinary physics of the universe as it exists today. Even the discovery that the Higgs Boson as a lighter mass than predicted, while intellectually intriguing doesn't matter outside the very small circle of high energy and theoretical physicists. In many ways, their field is already dead - they just haven't acknowledged it yet.
- dav_Oz 4y ago>because they are working in energy regimes that are not reachable in the ordinary physics of the universe as it exists today. This isn't accurate. Actually because of the higher energies (> 10 orders of magnitude) naturally found throughout the universe one could argue to concentrate more on collecting data of those relatively ubiquitous events in the observable universe instead of going through the route in obtaining some little fractions of that energy on earth. Current "records" [0] >Fastest Fermilab proton: 980 GeV; 99.999954% the speed of light; 299,792,320 m/s. Fastest LHC proton: 7 TeV; 99.999990% the speed of light; 299,792,455 m/s. Fastest LEP electron (fastest terrestrial accelerator particle): 105 GeV; 99.9999999988% the speed of light; 299,792,457.9964 m/s. Fastest cosmic ray proton: 5 × 10^10 GeV [!!!]; 99.999999999999999999973% the speed of light; 299,792,457.99999999999992 m/s. [0]https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/08/23/cosmic-rays-are-more-energetic-than-lhc-particles-and-this-faster-than-light-trick-reveals-them/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/08/23/cosm...
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoYes, what you say is true. My argument was very poorly made.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Even if they find something, it doesn't matter Yeah, that's a general attitude. I highly doubt that it's true, but most people seem to believe it. Just because you found the problem on a very high energy setting, it doesn't mean that the changes in theory you will get only impact very high energies. It may also impact low energy events that are naturally rare or events that have some consequence you can take out of the accelerator. All that you know is that the immediate consequence of the finding won't matter. But new findings often have more consequences than the immediate ones. If a new accelerator had a good chance of determining something unknown, it could be a worthwhile investment.
- ww520 4y agoHaven't all the particles in the Standard Model been found? LHC is not strong enough to look into gravity or dark matter. What else can be found?
- tablespoon 4y agoIt wouldn't surprise me or sadden me if particle physicists don't make any new fundamental discoveries or real theoretical breakthroughs for the next millennium. They also probably only have 20-30 years to show something if they ever want to build another, bigger and more expensive particle accelerator.
- pfdietz 4y agoIt would surprise me greatly, because I'd go "hey! I'm over 1000 years old!"
- yt-sdb 4y agoA few years ago, I went to a public interview/chat with Rainer Weiss in NYC. He described years of work in which the LIGO team found inventive ways to make their systems more precise. They just kept knocking down orders-of-magnitude. Still, after taking new measurements, they found nothing. No gravitational waves. Then the interviewer asked him if he was discouraged at this point in his career. I loved his response. He said, "No, it was a more meaningful zero."
- 1970-01-01 4y ago0.000 > 0.00 Love it.
- evanb 4y agoYou have the inequality backwards!
- w-j-w 4y agoIf he is comparing meaningfulness as the parent comment would imply, then he has it right.
- timdiggerm 4y agoMathematically, yes. But in terms of value, no.
- nerdponx 4y agoAn economist might notate this as "0.000 ≻ 0.00". Curly comparison operators like "≻" (U+227B SUCCEEDS) are often used specifically to avoid ambiguity with traditional comparison operators like ">". See: https://www.oeconomist.com/blogs/daniel/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/pref_symbols.pdf https://www.oeconomist.com/blogs/daniel/wp-content/uploads/2...
- hombre_fatal 4y agoHeh, I think a barely different glyph introduces more ambiguity than it solves. On my screen it’s effectively the same glyph but now with “oh, well it’s actually different.”
- bannedbybros 4y ago
- Lapsa 4y agocan they find socks? they just disappear!
- whatever1 4y agoExperiments need good hypotheses to be useful. Sometimes hypotheses can be generated incrementally and this is what 99.9% of the scientists are capable of doing. It seems that probably we have hit that wall in particle physics and we need a Giant to smash it and take us to the next level.
- PaulHoule 4y agoThis NYT article from 2 days ago https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/13/science/cern-hadron-collider-muon-leptoquark.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/13/science/cern-hadron-colli... spins it the other way. Personally I am amused by this old scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light_neutrino_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light_neutrino_ano... because there is some precedent for superluminal neutrinos (I saw an experiment at Los Alamos National Labs that was trying to measure the neutrino mass by observing tritium decay and their best fit estimate for the mass was imaginary, although consistent with zero.) Also if "SERN" was like it is in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate_(TV_series) superluminal neutrinos would be something they'd definitely cover up.
- zackmorris 4y agoI have so many problems with the physics status quo that it's hard to know where to begin. But here are a few code smells: * The strong force probably doesn't exist. It's an empirical description of what happens in the nucleus around 10^-15 meters. But due to stuff like gluon self-interaction, it's difficult to analyze. I suspect that it's related to the curvature of space around mass and is probably connected to neutron star and black hole math. But as long as it's portrayed as unified with the electromagnetic and weak forces, I just don't see us gaining a better understanding of it anytime soon. Also the description of the force between quarks increasing with distance, enough to concentrate enough energy to create more quarks (like how a high-energy photon can split into a particle and antiparticle), feels more like epicycles than deep understanding. * Physics right now seems more obsessed with mathematical elegance than application. Normally I prefer theory and abstraction over implementation, but what's the point of discovering a Higgs boson if we can't modulate it? It's nice to know it's there, but what are the chances of using energy to manipulate an object's inertia? I suspect that it's more of a clever mathematical construct than a force we will ever manipulate in our daily lives. Actually, re-reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_mechanism#Simple_explanation_of_the_theory,_from_its_origins_in_superconductivity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_mechanism#Simple_explana... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_generation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_generation it sounds like the Higgs mechanism is more about explaining the masses of particles than how to manipulate mass. The problem might be in how long range and short range forces (carried by massless gauge bosons and massive gauge bosons respectively) are treated differently. That's almost certainly not the final model of reality, and writing this out, I bet it's one of the main reasons that string theory tries to add so many dimensions that maybe aren't there. But since I'm not literate in this, I can't dig into the code. * Physics education is just.. bad. Understandably so, because so much of this is so fringe and so new that only a handful of people in the world actually understand it at a deep level. Which is why I think videos like this are so important: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b05IeSlMMDw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b05IeSlMMDw . Notice how she skips over notation pedantry and calls the bracket notation vectors. She also isolates entanglement as the key mechanism of quantum computers (at the 4:21 mark). I've read countless articles on that for YEARS that never stated what's going on with such clarity. So if we can't simulate entanglement inside a classical computer, then we can't simulate reality in them, because we wouldn't be able to build a quantum computer within The Matrix. So are we living in a simulation? Probably not. I bring this stuff up because the problem is probably in my own lack of understanding, not physics itself. So more budget needs to go to education and refactoring the existing physics "codebase" to use better notation and terms. Maybe you all have insights that invalidate my concerns. Those insights should be at the forefront of every Wikipedia article, not buried inside somewhere.
- fifticon 4y agoThen get to work figuring out dark matter..
- mkl95 4y agoA nightmare as in "my job will likely be boring until the day I retire". A nightmare many dream of.
- lamontcg 4y agoKind of happy right now that I didn't decide to dedicate my life to this when I was in my 20s and went off and did something else. I would have been awfully frustrating to spend 30 years in a quest to find nothing new. Hopefully at some point someone cracks open the desert, but I'm somewhat skeptical that it'll happen through the high energy frontier. My bet is that quantum computation and decoherence is where it'll be.
- syngrog66 4y agounfortunate they included the word "nightmare" in the title. hardly a nightware in the overall scale of nightmare-worthy things
- maxclark 4y agoI hate this headline
- anm89 4y agoWhy is having a better understanding of the laws of physics a nightmare for physicists?
- dodobirdlord 4y agoTwo points are important to consider. 1) It’s clear that the standard model is an incomplete model, due to some small discrepancies between theory and observation. 2) Large-scale particle physics experiments are very expensive and depend on government funding, and politicians must be persuaded to allocate funds. The nightmare scenario for particle physicists is that funding bodies get bored of the lack of exciting new results before the known discrepancies in the standard model are resolved, cease funding particle physics experiments, and the discrepancies are never resolved.
- labrador 4y agoGood. Now maybe physicists can start solving the riddle of consciousness.
- Koshkin 4y agoThe problem of consciousness is outside the subject area of physics. Chemistry - maybe, but more likely cell biology and information theory. Even more likely it will remain an issue of philosophy rather than (positive) science.
- labrador 4y agoUnless consciousness is a field we haven't figured out how to measure
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MichaelMoser123 4y agoIs astrophysics is now seeing more action than particle physics?
- ezekiel68 4y agoThis attitude ("nightmare") is backwards. What is this clinging to sunk costs of money and career time? The point is not for scientists to figure out how to extend the life of their big toy; the point is to delve into the many, many unexplained mysteries such as a the true nature of what we call "gravity", harmless methods to observe intercellular activity during diet or substance interventions (not with markers after biopsy or necropsy), how to convert ocean water to drinking water without getting the project cancelled by those who cannot bear to countenance the death of a single marine life form, and on and on. Truly Max Plank wrote well, when he penned, "A great scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."[0] [0] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/08/190829150642.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/08/190829150642.h...
- calsy 4y agoIsn't it funny that the single particle that they 'found' happened to be the one governments and investors gave them billions in hopes of finding. Nothing else, just the single particle to validate the entire existence of the LHC. I wonder what it would do for future investments if they didn't find it? But hey, I probably don't understand the science like 99.999999% of people. It's so technical that you just have to take their word for it. I do understand humans though.
- eterevsky 4y agoWhat exactly are you implying? That if they were given money to discover supersymmetry, they would've discovered it instead of Higgs? Well, discovery of supersymmetrical particles _was_ one of the main goals alongside discovering Higgs, and none were discovered so far. Or maybe you think that Higgs discovery was a hoax?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrtri 4y ago