13 ms·
Amazon calls cops, fires workers in attempts to stop unionization nationwide
- GoodJokes 4y ago
- sershe 4y agoObligatory: I used to have some respect for them until I read about the union-mafia connections. Now I think mafia is completely irredeemable :) Unions are basically the embodiment of misaligned incentives - combining the worst of medieval guilds' exclusion (e.g. unions were openly exclusionary against Blacks during Great Migration), ineptitude of a government bureaucracies (too many examples to recount), monopolistic power (e.g. healthcare supply restrictions by AMA) kleptocratic "nepotism" (whatever is the equivalent of nepotism for an old boys club - that's where criminal connection come in), and actual incentive to be inefficient that probably has no parallel in history (see e.g. construction staffing in NYC vs. almost anywhere else, and many more examples including from some union members I know where necessary work is postponed forever so the union could benefit, in the safety of knowing it is illegal for non union workers to do it). They are literally the most harmful organizations invented by man outside of those dedicated to violence explicitly. Yes, they were a major factor in achieving something good, once, in very specific historical circumstances. So were nuclear strikes on cities...
- smeagull 4y agoYeah call in two groups known for having strong unions to stop unionization, that'll work.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoIt may, because it’s an intimidation technique. And because one of the two professions is specifically known for violence, and historically against other union organizers. The other is commonly categorized together with the former, and individual firefighters often internalize that.
- threatofrain 4y agoPolice unions are a different kind of animal; not the type to campaign in solidarity with what is typically a Democratic political value.
- smitty1e 4y agoPrivate sector unions are a simple matter of free association; if they kill the host, so be it. In the Navy, we called a public sector union a 'mutiny'.
- 0xy 4y agoThe NYPD union endorsed a Democratic mayoral candidate who campaigned on public housing, low-income support and more funding for schools. The LAPD unions have similar Democratic endorsements. You'll be hard pressed to find a large police union that isn't Democratic, much like most unions.
- jusssi 4y agoAre you sure they aren't just being practical? Seems like the changes they endorse could result in increased workplace safety for their members.
- dillondoyle 4y agoIn Democratic cities that makes sense. At least on campaigns I've worked on they tend to endorse what comes out as the more 'conservative' candidate because it's all realpolitik: the candidate which promises the most police friendly policies and who has the best relation (and thus would be friendliest in office to) police, fire, ems, whatever group leaders. Which are usually considered the more 'conservative' or policy friendly.
- jachee 4y agoFOP chapters often aren’t particularly democratic, progressive or labor-friendly; often endorsing Republican candidates. National FOP even endorsed Trump. Twice.
- GoodJokes 4y ago
- nwiswell 4y ago> two groups "fires" refers to termination of employment, not firemen.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoWhatever the name of their organization, the police are no friend to labor. Using arrests and police violence to intimidate union organizers is a classic unionbusting tactic with centuries of history behind it. Have you ever seen a cop on a picket line? In your memory, has a police union joined another local labor union in a strike or action? When workers have had to literally, physically fight and sometimes die for what we now consider to be workers rights, who were they fighting? who killed them? Often it was the police.
- vkou 4y agoThe police, and brutalizing labour unions have a long, and bloody history.
- dls2016 4y agoHere in Pennsylvania, the official state police history describes the origin of the force as a replacement for coal company police, who were a little too brutal in their union breaking.
- jonathankoren 4y agoPeople literally died for unions, both organizers and scabs. My grandfather was child laborer in the coal mines in Illinois and saw scabs get killed when he was barely a teenager. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herrin_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herrin_massacre
- kixiQu 4y agoUnder a hundred miles away, too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_massacre_(Washington) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_massacre_(Washington...
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoThe cops know their union is different, it is a pact with the elite to keep the rabble down, which is why they are virtually immune to the law. They feel no solidarity with any other union, and in fact know their union exists because others are not allowed to form.
- Kostchei 4y agomaybe in the US, but this is not universal and Amazon is a global behemoth. For sure, right-wing conservative politicians are birthed within police services (exhibit 1 peter dutton), and support for conservative gov feels natural for police (pact with the rich and all that), but there is a lot of groundswell left-wing within the active union members- support for communal good etc. I've been the guy in uniform who turned up to negotiate a peaceful settlement to a transport dispute. I'm not sure why the inspector picked me to go inside the picket with him, but once there we both ended up dealing with the union. My starting points were "you want an outcome, some of this is private property, some is a road under the traffic act, but irrespective, nobody wants an injury" (trucks driving over people in the picket seemed distinctly possible) and "I'm a union guy"- which an inspector is not really (they have a separate commissioned officer union which .. is. .not like a union ) We didn't move anybody in the picket. Management acknowledged the petition. Business resumed later that day and no-one got runover. Over the next 18 months there were investigations, in various states including ours, that identified breaches of transport acts, OHS etc, by some of the contracting companies- and a couple of directors got fined. And going on, general issues with trucking law enforcement , fatigue management etc had an impact on normalising the laws across the states. (ie the transport unions had a valid point about problems in the industry) So I'd say, don't expect police to go heavy against unions, you may be disappointed. 15 years exp. YMMD outside Australia
- oh_sigh 4y agoIt seems like they called the cops because they thought there were uninvited individuals on their property. To go from that to the idea that they did it "to stop unionization" is a leap. Would they have done the same thing if animal rights protesters, or the Proud Boys, or whoever came and someone thought they were on Amazon property illegally? I think so.
- dundarious 4y agoMistaking employees for trespassers, and mistaking your own property boundaries, combine to make a fairly large mistake. You would think the union-busting agents they’ve hired would have better intel on this type of thing...
- wolverine876 4y agoWhy is it a mistake? They sent an intimidating message, which their targets have helpfully amplified by telling the world: Take on Amazon and they may have you arrested.
- tsimionescu 4y agoGP was being facetious, showing how ridiculous the OP's claim that this is just Amazon calling the cops to stop trespassers is.
- dundarious 4y agoYes, exactly. Without any further info, and given the context of union-busting and intel collection especially at this facility, I think it’s unlikely this was a just a dumb mistake, and quite likely it was intimidation, seeking a pretext to fire the employee/organizer.
- googlryas 4y ago"A fairly large mistake" - What do you think the consequences should be for the person who called 911 in this situation?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jp0d 4y ago
- blamazon 4y agohttps://archive.ph/bNmbX https://archive.ph/bNmbX
- stevewatson301 4y agohttps://archive.ph/bNmbX https://archive.ph/bNmbX
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nafix 4y agoInteresting the Washington Post ran this story considering it’s owned by Jeff Bezos.
- pfarrell 4y agoJust the way it should be.
- nradov 4y agoWashington Post journalists are unionized since before Jeff Bezos acquired the business. https://postguild.org/about-us/ https://postguild.org/about-us/
- Barrin92 4y agothe optimistic interpretation is that people like Bezos aren't quite as Machiavellian as people make them out to be, the negative one is that it's a 'the king tolerates the jester because he's powerless' situation. Reality is probably somewhere in the middle. Bezos doesn't strike me as the petty type but Amazon's probably also not that afraid of reporting.
- bpodgursky 4y agoBezos is 100% checked out right now. He doesn't even bother checking in on his vanity projects like Blue Origin more than once a week or so. He's living his best life with his new girlfriend and fancy boat, he's absolutely not going to go slumming at the WaPo headquarters to beat down a couple annoying reporters.
- MandieD 4y agoThe Post has run plenty of unflattering stories about Amazon in the time he’s owned it.
- throwk8s 4y agoA news organization needs to attack its owners more often, not less, if it wants to maintain credibility.
- 4y ago
- rvense 4y agoThey are just trying to protect their employees from being forced to join a union, which is ineffective and a waste of money and bad for workers. Company has your best interests at heart, don't listen to those rabble-rousing pinkos. Unions don't work, that's why Company don't want them here and had to call the police.
- dogman123 4y agoHell yea, lick that boot !
- missedthecue 4y agoLow grade comment. I don't think this abides by HN rules.
- the_only_law 4y agoGuessing this is satire, believable though, until the "company has your best interest at heart".
- drunkpotato 4y agoDefinitely a situation that calls for an </s> tag.
- ztgasdf 4y agoI figured it was sarcasm since they had the word "Company" capitalised.
- poisonborz 4y agoWouln't have expected this article from this source. Worth noting that Washington Post is owned by Amazon founder Bezos. It was usually said that billionaires owning mass media is used by them to push their free market agenda (and there were certainly a number of occassions where it denounced upper class taxation or stayed mum on the Bezos/UAE phone leak scandal) but also some counter-examples like reporting on toxicity in Blue Origin (also owned by Bezos). Glad to see more of such pieces, this shows that the media landscape is not as black and white as some make it out to be.
- Thorentis 4y agoUnless this article was intentionally allowed to be released as a way to counter the recent accusations that WaPo is just a Bezos mouthpiece.
- cmeacham98 4y agoIntentionally allowing anti-Bezos viewpoints would make the WaPo more than "just a Bezos mouthpiece" regardless of why they were allowed, no?
- raxxorraxor 4y agoNot necessarily, it could just build plausible deniability for the paper not being independent. I don't at all believe that is the case here, but it could be that Amazon expects unionization to be inevitable and later articles undermine certain key position as unreasonable. The lie would get a mantle of truth. Or integrity in this case. The is why real independence for news rooms is important because you can never know.
- tnzk 4y agoNo as long as they would selectively pass only articles which look anti-Bezos at quick glance but are actually supportive with full read.
- CyanBird 4y ago
- rayiner 4y agoAmazon and Starbucks: https://www.salon.com/2022/06/12/starbucks-ceo-pushes-harder-against-unions_partner https://www.salon.com/2022/06/12/starbucks-ceo-pushes-harder.... What's with Seattle?
- MBCook 4y agoExtremely high cost of living likely makes union benefits much more appealing relative to low CoL areas.
- jjulius 4y ago>What's with Seattle? Seattle has had a really strong progressive slant for a long time, this isn't at all surprising.
- rayiner 4y agoI mean, what’s with ostensibly “progressive” companies engaging in union busting? I assume neither Bezos nor Howard Schultz voted for Donald Trump, so what gives?
- loeg 4y agoThe very simple explanation is that these companies aren't "progressive." Or at least, not their C-suite. Seems pretty obvious?
- barsonme 4y agoMost companies are only "progressive" inasmuch it lets them make more money. They'll be whatever you want so long as it lets them sell more stuff. The fact that this is apparently such a shock to people is exactly why they do it.
- systemvoltage 4y ago> Most companies are only "progressive" inasmuch it lets them make more money. What are they supposed to do then?
- drewcoo 4y agoThe company is acting completely unethically and illegally. It needs some execs in handcuffs already. And the HN lede is "Bezos paper says anti-AMZN things!" Go figure.
- 0xy 4y agoAmazon accused the union of illegal intimidation of voters, why would you immediately trust one side in the matter? Unions and corruption/illegal conduct, after all, go hand-in-hand. Consider the fact the RWDSU was caught illegally intimidating workers into signing up to them in order to extract fees, earning them a rebuke from the NLRB. [1] So, if the retail unions targeting Amazon have such a history of illegal intimidation, and Amazon is alleging it's happening yet again, why shouldn't they be believed? These unions have shown they'll intimidate and operate illegally to achieve their goals. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retail,_Wholesale_and_Department_Store_Union#Merger_with_UFCW_(1990s_to_present) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retail,_Wholesale_and_Departme...
- GoodJokes 4y ago
- effingwewt 4y agoThe union may turn out bad/corrupt, but we already know that Amazon already is. The previous behavior of the company is all the reason one should need to scrutinize anything they say/do with a magnifying glass and to never give Amazon the benefit of the doubt. That was forfeited by them long ago.
- jseban 4y agoThe difference is that amazon is driving innovation which enables you to stay competitive. Unions cause stagnation which will lead to being outcompeted in the long term, even if you could argue a more peaceful existence in the short/medium term, you are just putting on blinders.
- native_samples 4y ago
- radu_floricica 4y agoA couple of karma burning facts: - Amazon has better wages and conditions than the industry average. Warehouse work is tough in general, Amazon isn't making it particularly hard and pays relatively well. - Unions aren't universally good. The reason we got to "defund police" is because cops are practically unfireable due to a strong union; and unions were at least part of the reason why GM lost so hard in front of Toyota and other competition. In general, societies create wealth through freer markets, then vote to spend that wealth on social policies and income redistribution. Which is perfectly fine, btw. However, this gives a framework for answering the question of timing: do you want more social policies now? If you think it's a good time, then yes, unions are one way forward. If you think the economic/geopolitic situation is still fragile, you may want to vote for more slack in the system.
- legulere 4y agoGood relations to the unions is one of the reasons for the success of German car brands.
- radu_floricica 4y agoI'd be wary of such comparisons. Germany has a completely different system, which is already old and functioning. Just to give an example, the poster above you strongly suggested that the main point is to hurt Bezos. That's a cultural difference which is pretty significant: you can't hurt Bezos this way without also hurting the company, and so large categories of stakeholders: clients, suppliers, employees. Going into unions with this mindset won't create the kind of partnerships you see in Germany.
- justinzollars 4y agoI was a member of a Union and in my opinion it contributed to a negative work environment where management develops an adversarial role against employees and vice versa. I'd say the employees and the company are better off without one.
- pm90 4y agoIf the management wasn’t adversarial towards you they definitely were towards others in the non unionized workplace, you probably just happened to be in the blue team.
- justinzollars 4y agoThis isn't true. You don't need a mob to negotiate on an individuals behalf. Also why are unions silent about the United States policy towards exporting labor/manufacturing capacity to China and a huge influx of very low wage workers from Mexico? Both really really really hurt labor.
- pm90 4y agoUnion is not a “mob”. Whataboutism is the dumbest way to make a point.
- justinzollars 4y agoWell, then you should go for the Unionization of whatever tech company you are an employee of. And you could experience the joys for yourself.
- gtsop 4y agoI was a member of the management and in my opinion the union contributed to a positive direction for the employees, but against me and that's why I called the cops
- justinzollars 4y ago
- Proven 4y ago
- gigatexal 4y agoIsn’t this paper owned by Bezos? Pretty cool such an article made it to the paper.
- rdevsrex 4y agoAt this point in history, if anyone honestly thinks that maximizing shareholder value is a good highest goal for a corporation, they are just blind. It's clear in situations like this to see that the only reason Amazon is doing this is for power and money, and probably just money. If we want to survive another 100 years, corporations have be brought to heel somehow, and if that means legislation to curtail stock buy backs instead of re-investment, or altering what fiduciary responsibility means to include the wellbeing of employees, not just shareholders, I'm fine with that. But this current system is taking us nowhere good.
- giardini 4y agoTrying to tweak capitalism per se is a losing cause b/c we have no idea how to. Better to keep the current framework: corporations + unions + laws, which work and have been shaken out by previous generations. Until we see a social system that is better and is time-proven, capitalism is a good "first-order approximation" of what we want in a workplace. It is only an approximation b/c it so often creates/aggravates externalities, but that doesn't mean it isn't useful.
- qubex 4y agoThe combination that seems to have struck the best balance so far is Ordoliberalism as enshrined in Germany.
- mercer 4y agoBut how does any other approach, entirely novel or otherwise, become time-proven without testing and tweaking on a society-level scale? Much of the social change we've seen, happened despite enormous pushback from the status quo, and was in no way 'time-tested'.
- rakoo 4y agoThe _only_ goal of a corporation is to maximize revenue for their owners, all else be damned. It's a tool designed to do that. It's what capitalism wants, and no tool that was built for capitalism will change that, even with all the regulations you put in it. If we want work places to care for employees, care for the environement, care for the neighborhood, then corporations are just not the correct tool so we have to use another one. Workers-owned coops are good, voluntary associations are another one. > But this current system is taking us nowhere good. Indeed, but it's specifically by knowing what the "system" is, what are its tools, its methods, its proponents, and what to do instead that we can go forward.
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoIt’s so tiring to see news like this always devolve into a barrage of “profits considered evil” comments.