23 ms·
Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives
- jimmydeans 4y ago
- Brendathomp9 4y agoI had this public records on my credit for close to 8 years now and I have always worried about it until I got to work with VIRTUALHACKNET @ GMAIL .COM , My Paul which was one of the hackers in the team was so nice to me , his listening ears to my issues gave me hope at first even before getting into work with their team , In just 5 weeks they were able to get the records erased and my credit score boosted to 815 as well .. I can actually say that I ever had such peace of mind that I have now in quite a long time and I’m thankful to these Incredible team of great credit specialists .
- Hutchins09 4y ago
- Ridgway09 4y agoI have known VIRTUALHACKNET @ GMAIL dot COM for over 3 years now and have been working with them in several issues I had in the past and currently which included my credit score issues , he is very attentive and promptly responds to his emails which makes him exceptional , he will make sure to keep to his words , I knew this after he told me that I will be a proud home owner once he is done with my credit and here I am today Living in my own house with my Lovely family , To be honest here , I recommend this team to get your credit issues fixed just like they did with mine .
- danuker 4y ago> It took two years for her old credit score to be reestablished. Two years of faxing in detailed documents—including Dave’s death certificate—only for the mistake to reappear. During that period, her life was effectively stalled. She considered moving, as it was painful to stay in the house she had shared with her late husband, but having a credit score stuck at zero meant she couldn’t get a new mortgage. Indeed, these glitches have the potential to ruin people's lives. Reminds me of Kafka's "The Trial".
- Tycho 4y agoI’m surprised that credit scores are even legal, to be honest. I wonder if there’s been any class action lawsuits.
- sokoloff 4y agoFor me, the pull quote about 40% of the way down the article is key. ("A credit score, at its most basic, is a predictive model of behaviour.") It seems fairly obvious that there's a lot of possible efficiency (read "cheaper and more accessible credit in aggregate" as the consumer benefit) to be had if implemented correctly. Lenders want to lend money to people who will pay it back as agreed. Lenders want to avoid lending money to people who will not (or want to charge an amount sufficient to cover their increased risk and costs). Borrowers want to borrow money at the cheapest possible terms. A system that correctly predicts who is likely to pay back borrowed funds as agreed serves both borrowers and lenders. That means it's unlikely that it should be made outright illegal. Regulations around data quality, challenging suspect data, removing erroneous data, how long correct-but-negative items can stay on the report, etc. are entirely appropriate of course.
- usrn 4y agoRacial stereotyping is, in it's most basic form, a predictive model of behavior. It's also illegal in nearly any financially meaningful situation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- p49k 4y ago> A system that correctly predicts who is likely to pay back borrowed funds as agreed serves both borrowers and lenders. Such a system can't be built without being unfairly biased against some people who don't fit a certain mold, and thus it should be illegal. Most of Europe has a much simpler system: Your ability to obtain credit is based on the past several years of income, with a penalty for instances over the past ~7 years in which you didn't pay back debts. That's it; no predictive modeling or scoring or other nonsense; everyone has an even chance at credit.
- lisper 4y agoThe solution to the particular problem reported in TFA is simple and obvious: allow people to sue credit reporting agencies for damages if they report false information. You will be amazed how fast these things will get resolved if that reform is adopted. Of course that won't happen because regulatory capture, but let's not wring our hands and pretend that this is a fundamentally difficult problem. It's not.
- refurb 4y agoWhy not just sue them in small claims court for some small monetary damages right now? You can do that, people rarely do.
- lisper 4y agoIt's complicated. The Fair Credit Reporting Act gives agencies very broad latitude to blame mistakes on the parties that furnished the information, and the resulting legal situation is a mess [1]. As a practical matter, you can bring such a suit, but your odds of prevailing on the merits are indistinguishable from zero. [1] https://www.courthousenews.com/high-court-wont-review-immunity-under-credit-reporting-law/ https://www.courthousenews.com/high-court-wont-review-immuni...
- refurb 4y agoUnderstood. But just like suing a large firm, when sending a $1000/hr corporate lawyer to small claims court, it makes more sense to just settle quickly.
- lisper 4y agoLawyers are not usually allowed in small claims court. But I'm pretty sure that all of the credit reporting agencies have a trained staff of non-lawyers who are nonetheless sufficiently well versed in this particular aspect of the law to destroy any prospective plaintiff.
- 4y ago
- adenozine 4y agoHow can we cooperate to get rid of them?
- sokoloff 4y agoStarve them of their income stream by committing to never take credit, saving and paying cash ahead of time for every purchase? Get everyone else to agree to do the same. Demand for credit scoring will plummet (and with it, the income stream to the scoring agencies). Open a lending institution that will lend money to anyone with no credit checking? Hope that you don’t get adverse selected out of business, but if you don’t and can compete without it, demand for credit scoring will plummet. Or petition your representatives to make this particular type of service illegal.
- RHSeeger 4y ago> Open a lending institution that will lend money to anyone with no credit checking? Hope that you don’t get adverse selected out of business, but if you don’t and can compete without it, demand for credit scoring will plummet. This seems unlikely to succeed. You'd wind up having to give the same rates to everyone, because you have no real way to assess risk individually. As such, you wouldn't be able to compete on rates for people with good credit.
- throw8383833jj 4y agoAnd, also need to get rid of all regulations that prevent shopkeepers from charging credit card fees (or discounts for cash buyers). If you're paying for everything with cash/debit, you're paying those credit card fees unless merchants can charge different prices.
- sokoloff 4y agoIn the US, cash discounts have been explicitly allowed since around 2010 (via the Durbin amendment to the Dodd-Frank law). Merchant agreements were updated to reflect these possibilities. (Visa's is under 1.5.4.14 Discount Offer – US Region and US Territories, 5.6.2.1 Convenience Fees – AP, CEMEA, and US Regions, 1.5.5.2 Surcharges [and possibly others].) Accepting, handling, counting, accounting for, and securing cash (against insider and outsider threats) is not without cost either.
- bsenftner 4y agoCredit scores can only affect your life if you live on credit. I spent 20 years without a credit card, and the only impact was being a hassle to rent a car. but as far as cars go, I do the unthinkable: I save and buy with cash. I simply do not use credit. Beyond my house payment, I purchase everything up front, including the nice and hefty discount when paying insurance in full for the year. It is a pain in the ass to get used to not using credit, but it is so, so worth it.
- adrr 4y agoHow did you get home loan if you didn't have any debt to build up your score and credit history?
- bsenftner 4y agoIt's called putting down $150K in cash, and having a stable job. Also, my credit "score" is "N/A".
- adrr 4y agoPutting $150k down is like standard since you need to put down 20% anyway. Are you paying like significantly higher interest rate like a jumbo loan? If you don't have a credit score, the government won't back it so its more risk on the bank and you're paying a much higher interest rate. Banks also don't keep the loans and package them up and sell them. If you don't have a credit score, not sure how they would do that. No score would qualify as subprime.
- bsenftner 4y agoMost people's 20% down is also a loan. Plus, in addition to that $150K down payment, I can point to my savings account with more than the loan debt inside. The only reason I have a loan is for the tax relief, if not for that I'd have purchased the home completely. My home loan is under 2%.
- 4y ago
- kome 4y agoCredit Scores in the USA is basically developed into a social score. No European countries (with the possible exception of the UK) use a similar system. I wonder why Americans just keep going for it.
- mcntsh 4y ago> No European countries (with the possible exception of the UK) use a similar system There's SCHUFA here in Germany
- csunbird 4y agoYup, and you are not able to even rent a house without a positive score.
- nisegami 4y agoThe credit score system benefits the ones who have the most power to change it. That's why there's no real motivation to remove it.
- ramesh31 4y ago>I wonder why Americans just keep going for it. We trade one for another; there's no social caste, royalty, or nobility here. Your worth as a human being is determined entirely by the sum of your assets.
- jimmaswell 4y agoYou don't need a vault of gold to have a good credit score. All you have to do is have some credit and use it responsibly. Too much for some people to handle so they decry it as unfair.
- mcntsh 4y agoI've been working since I was 16 years old and I've had sparkling credit my entire life. I pay my cards in full every month; never missed a payment for 10+ years, paid off my car early. I moved abroad and forgot about a $30 dollar balance with AT&T which brought my FICO score to 600. One 30 dollar bill means I can no longer qualify for a mortgage or a car payment or anything.
- goatherders 4y agoPay it off. Wait a month. You'll be fine.
- mcntsh 4y agoIt went to collections. That stays on your credit for 3-5 years.
- goatherders 4y agoIncorrect. Pay it off in full. They will report that to the credit folks and it will be removed.
- valeness 4y agoThis is patently false. They will remove it if they are feeling particularly jolly when you call and ask. But they are under no obligation to do so and they have denied this action to me before.
- gaadd33 4y agoThey do have to mark it as paid at least under the FCRA if you are in the US.
- parkingrift 4y agoI’ve been in this situation and you can make repayment contingent upon deleting the negative remarks. As in you send me a letter certifying you’ll delete the remark, and I will remit payment. If they refuse then you can just refuse to pay until they relent. Their only alternative is to take you to court or sell to the next collection agency down the line. Creditors and collection agencies won’t take that action except as an absolute last resort.
- TrackerFF 4y agoHere in Norway, we don't have any credit score in that sense. Rather, we have sort of a "credit history" system, which shows the following: -When there's been registered wage garnishment (by court) against you. -When there's been registered a lien against your property. -When you've entered a court-ordered debt payment program. -When you've been registered as bankrupt. And by law, these things have to be deleted when you've settled your debt. In any case, it's difficult to get those things by accident. Usually you're at the end of the process, and have been through civil court. With that said - it should be mentioned that Norway is a INCREDIBLY creditor friendly country, as far as the law goes. If a creditor really want their money back, they can / will take you to court, and eventually get a garnishment on your wage or welfare money. Or property/vehicles/personal belongings lien if you don't have any income. I like the system as it is. I really don't like the idea of constantly having to do things with respect to a credit score - and I'm not talking about gaming the system or being a deadbeat, but trying to maximize my credit score for the sake of keeping it high.
- sgjohnson 4y ago> trying to maximize my credit score for the sake of keeping it high. Just being a deadbeat will do exactly that. It takes 0 effort. Put your purchases on a credit card, and settle it in full every month.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> Put your purchases on a credit card, and settle it in full every month. If you don't need credit then taking on credit is an extra thing to manage. I personally like all my spending being on my debit card and coming out of my account so I have a single balance that reflects how much money I have. I don't want to deal with an extra company especially when their business model ultimately relies on trying to get me to miss a payment so they can charge fees/interest.
- maxerickson 4y agoTheir business model is a 1 to 3 percent fee on every transaction they are involved in. My credit card company sends me a notification when a statement is ready and another friendly reminder a week before the bill is due. They make money on interest also, but they would rather have someone that spends and pays off a lot than someone that carries a modest balance.
- throwoutway 4y agoThis is exactly why China implemented a “social credit” system, which is an authoritarian version of this kind of power.
- ProfXponent 4y agoThe US credit system is plenty authoritarian in its own right.
- jimmaswell 4y agoBanks, private entities, deciding who to do business with based on a number they calculate is absolutely not authoritarian. It comes nowhere close to the concept of authoritarianism unless you think a dress code at a club is also authoritarian.
- ProfXponent 4y ago
- pessimizer 4y agoIf "authoritarian" here means virtually identical, except that they also include crimes and misdemeanors. I bet we could do that in the US if the oil on the slope was inclusion of "hate speech/crime." Hiring someone with a history of that is a liability, and lending to those people could lead to losses if they are fired.
- TuringNYC 4y agoThe US system is also authoritarian: - There is almost no easy way to fix bad problems. The fixes require huge bureaucracy that only highly motivated people can solve - We like to pretend it works. It does, except for 5% of a population and it really sucks if you aren't in the 95%. People in the 95% dont realize how bad it is for the 5%. By the 5% i'm talking about legitimately credit-worthy individuals being unfairly denied by the system (not un-credit-worthy legitimately denied.) - We like to pretend it is private market driven, but the private orgs driving it have almost government-level power to control your life by cutting off funding
- bryans 4y agoThere are actually very few regulations regarding the credit score "system" -- if it can even be called that -- and it shows. The system is grossly abused by everyone involved, and typically the only people experiencing the effects of that abuse are already in the most vulnerable positions. It's quite reprehensible what humans are willing to do to each other over an unpaid bill, almost universally representing a completely non-relevant amount of revenue for the companies. How many lives have been disrupted or ruined over sending $15 to collections?
- bluedino 4y agoYou never opened a single account other than that? You in essence have no credit, then.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 4y agoBecause it's just math applied to the highly regulated credit history system. The way that the score is calculated is inconsequential, as long as the underlying credit history is correct.
- pessimizer 4y agoIt was a prelude to the modern private surveillance industry. Virtually any legislation affecting that would effect the credit rating agencies.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoPeople always told me growing up that I should get a credit card, to start building credit for when I eventually wanted to buy a house. I didn't bother, because buying things on credit always seemed sill to me. Come time to buy a house and those people were still all "oh boy, you're going to have a hard time!", but you know what? Having no credit history wasn't a problem at all. I had to arrange for bank representatives to talk to some bill collectors and authorize them to talk about my payment history, that's it. Sure, maybe I didn't get the best rate in the world, but it was a pretty fair one. I feel like stories like this are intentionally played up for the benefit of the credit industry.
- kkielhofner 4y agoThere's yet another credit score type system that has significant effects on the ability to participate in the financial system that's much less known: https://www.investopedia.com/what-to-know-and-do-if-you-re-listed-in-chexsystems-5179535 https://www.investopedia.com/what-to-know-and-do-if-you-re-l... It's known (quite infamously) to essentially keep unbanked populations unbanked. Long story short if you've had overdraft fees, bounced checks, etc opening new accounts at banks that utilize ChexSystems becomes nearly impossible. On one hand there have clearly been people that have taken advantage of banks being siloed and abuse overdraft protection, etc to essentially get loans they can knowingly abscond with. Just move on to another bank. Repeat. On the other hand, ChexSystems is much less well known and a bit more "shadowy". The old story of "I use my debit card, mismanage my activity against direct deposit/balance, get hit with overdraft, then overdraft again once the fee hits, etc and next thing I know I'm $500 in the hole because of a $2.50 debit at a convenience store and now I'm essentially banned from every bank." In the case of the debit card example (or credit cards) banks could do what they used to and actually decline the charge. However they've clearly figured out it's much more profitable to allow the charge and just hit people with (often excessive) overdraft and over credit limit fees.
- metacritic12 4y agoI wonder if this is statistical discrimination. Like in theory, someone who closes an account $2.50 in the negative does very little damage to the bank directly. The $2.50 is a small fraction of the annual overhead of the bank account. Yet these behaviors are highly correlative of unprofitable checking customers. The entire checking account model seems to be based on whales that return the bulk of the profits. If you sneeze wrong, your statistically 10x less likely to ever become that whale. From a profit maximizing POV, it totally makes sense for banks to do this. But from a "banks are a basic utility" point of view, it doesn't seem to make sense.
- Retric 4y agoMany banks actually make most of their profits from fees not whales. A X$ overdraft fee quickly enters payday loan territory in terms of profit vs capital at risk.
- ProfXponent 4y agoI locked my credit when I left the US, and I have no intention of ever unlocking it. Free yourself from a broken system and experience the world that doesn't treat you like a wage slave.
- 0daystock 4y agoCredit Scores are bad, but "The Work Number" and other creepy derivative products are getting so much worse. There is a literal ledger of our salaries being shared by companies to presumably coordinate wages - how is this ok?
- tediousdemise 4y agoIt's okay because we're just servants tied to our bank mortgages with little to no say in what the elite shareholder-run private sector dictates behind closed doors (and in which the legislative elites are also privvy/permissive). Year over year, your freedoms and finances will slowly dwindle. A law is passed that destroys your privacy... local/state/federal taxes are increased... the cost of groceries and housing keeps creeping up... but your employer need not cut you any slack, because you're just a number in one of their spreadsheets, serving a means to an end. There are no laws that dictate companies must pay a livable wage; instead we are brutalized and battered by the free market, with nothing left but a steadily decreasing quality of life.
- stuu99 4y ago[dead]
- banannaise 4y agoAnd then we have "tenant screening services" which give major negative marks for things like being taken to court for eviction, even if it was years ago and even if the judgment was in your favor. These are, of course, not covered by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, so nobody is required to tell you what's on your report or allow you to dispute it, nor do they even have to tell you they used the report in denying you an apartment.
- the_svd_doctor 4y agoThey are covered by the FCRA https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consumer-reports-what-landlords-need-know https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consum...
- thecleaner 4y agoI am utterly flabbergasted regarding how and why am open source credit rating model doesn't exist. These people rely on third party providers whose data is "ok" if I am being generous. They do ridiculous data science and its basically critical software engineering being done by morons behind closed doors.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIs it true that one reason the US has such a strong credit score system is the lack of reliable data on who people are? In the UK we have credit scores, but they're pretty irrelevant. What matters here is being able to show who you are (a matter of looking you up on things like voter lists) and you never having been taken to court for your debts (County Court Judgements). In fairness we also have a lot less unsecured debt and a much more punitive bankruptcy system...
- kube-system 4y agoYou have to know who someone is to look up their credit in the US, so that's not the reason. I'm guessing the biggest reason is your latter point -- it is very easy to get a lot of credit in the US and relatively easy to have it forgiven.
- waynesonfire 4y agoto play devils advocate, it can also do the opposite as it lowers rates for responsible folk, especially for responsible struggling folks.
- banannaise 4y agoCredit scores for people who are responsible and struggling will be much closer to the scores of those who are irresponsible, rather than those who are responsible and not struggling. For the most part, the credit system expects perfection, so if you're out of work for several months and need to keep yourself fed, you're going to earn a black mark that will be a lot of work to counteract. Even if you manage to keep it spotless, credit scores still give a lot of weight to "having access to a lot of credit, and not using it", or "having a mortgage that you've been paying consistently for years", both of which mostly require you to already have good credit to get.
- sharker8 4y agoCredit scores are part of the marketing scheme to make people think they need mortgages. Slight exaggeration but not far from the truth.
- partiallypro 4y agoI don't understand your point, you can have over an 800 credit score without ever having a mortgage.
- alar44 4y agoHow else do you pay for a house?
- martin_bech 4y agoAs a European, the credit score system seems completely bonkers..
- teddyh 4y agohttp://www.threepanelsoul.com/comic/credit-rating-agencies http://www.threepanelsoul.com/comic/credit-rating-agencies
- caethan 4y agoRelevant article from patio11 on how to fix this problem if you have it: https://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-reports/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-r...
- bondolo 4y agoDo credit scores and the costs of borrowing associated with specific scores correlate to the actuarial risk of default or is it just a huge scam to justify usury? What is to stop them from charging twice as much for 2% additional risk? "It is not our fault you have less than perfect credit"
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoI think in the US credit score system rose as a way to work around racial discrimination laws.
- fleddr 4y agoHere in the Netherlands we have a simpler system. Any non-trivial credit such as your mortgage, car loans and student loans are registered centrally at an institute called the BKR. When you regularly fail to make payments on these loans, you may be marked with a negative rating. So it's fairly binary information: good or bad. Over here, day to day payments are done with debit, so no detailed "small credit" history is recorded at all. In my case, this BKR institute has a single entry, my mortgage, and soon none at all. So I'd then have no registered credit at all, and thus also no score. ...which is celebrated by creditors. A complete lack of data is interpreted as you being the most financially sound person possible. This high trust culture doesn't come out of nowhere. Culturally, payment discipline overall is very solid as we have somewhat of an anti-loan culture (don't live beyond your means). Further, you're not going to get away with defaulting on loans, there's no mercy for it here.
- wang_li 4y agoIn the US a credit report has things like you haven’t paid on this bill for 30 days, for 60 days, for 90 days. Or your account was sent to collections. And monthly balances on your debts. And how much revolving credit you have. Not sure exactly what you mean by small credit, but your daily purchases or spending is not on your credit report. It’s largely similar to what you describe but the information, good and bad is kept for 7 years.
- fleddr 4y agoI was under the assumption that in the US, a lot of people pay with credit instead of debit. If they pay with credit, I would assume this adds to their credit history and score? Is that not true?
- astura 4y agoIt shows up as a revolving line of credit on your credit report. It shows your credit limit and the balance on your last bill.
- simonswords82 4y agoI find it abhorrent that organisations (Experian/Equifax) who I have never directly done business with have a license to collect, use and sell my very personal information for financial gain. I had hoped with the implementation of GDPR I would be able to write to these con artists and ask them to remove my information but alas apparently my personal right to object does not automatically mean they have to stop processing my data see more here: https://help.equifax.co.uk/EquifaxOnlineHelp/s/article/HowdoIaskyoutodeletethedatayouholdaboutme https://help.equifax.co.uk/EquifaxOnlineHelp/s/article/Howdo... The whole arrangement is a total scam.
- r00tanon 4y agoThere is also new "recession resiliency" score that is trumping even high credit scores now. Another money grab on the part of CBs that credit card companies are using to justify raising rates even on good standing accounts.
- Soderberg09 4y ago