15 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg on Messenger (2013)
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoWhere are the messenger platforms ideas?? The next mails are missing :(
- sz4kerto 5y agoThey're in the following tweets. E.g. https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/1528063317041766400 https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/1528063317041766400
- SemanticStrengh 5y agotwitter is one of the worst thing that happened to humanity
- stereoradonc 5y agoUpvoted :-)
- frob 5y agoThis is eerie for me to read, especially this line: "If messenger came with Andrea for everyone, that would clearly be amazing for the world." Eleven months later, FB bought a little startup I was part of to try to build exact this. (Spolier: it flopped)
- avivo 5y agoI'm curious, why did it flop? Internal coordination issues? NLP tech not being ready yet?
- frob 5y agoNLP not being nearly ready. Some of the requests were powered by people on the backend and we hoped to use that as a training set. We could, but we only were able to automate the most basic things like reminders, weather, todo lists, daily transit, etc
- b112 5y agoIt's so weird. People have been using text menus, back through early SMS, all the way to dialup in the 70s. Probably before. But instead of proper menu items (1 for restaurants, 2 for blah blah), then submenus (1 for order, 2 for reservation), there is this strange fascination with natural langiage parsing via text. Meanwhile, typing '1', then '1' is far better than 'i want to order from a restaraunt'. Shorter, no mistakes, more precise, easy to use. Search, such as 'search restaurants' has been a thing too. I don't want to talk to a machine, which is designed to use as many glue words as possible, and seeks natural language as a reply. What a time waste! All that politeness is for humans, we don't need it from a bot.
- yashap 5y agoWit.ai?
- lwhi 5y agoI've been a victim of this in the past; it's very easy to excited about the flavour of your own Kool Aid. Mark getting excited about using a message to book a restaurant seems like a prime example of this.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoMany of the ideas he expressed (in terms of interacting with businesses) seem to be how WeChat runs, very successfully (never used it myself, just based on what I've heard).
- annadane 5y agoThe problem is it's never been his Kool Aid. He stole the Kool Aid from multiple other people and is pretending like he invented the concept (yes people will now argue you can't steal the 'concept' of Kool Aid, and it's about execution; but my point stands, other people can't borrow the concept if one person pulls the rug out from everyone else) of Kool Aid
- mrkramer 5y agoMicrosoft stole GUI concept from Apple and Apple stole it from Xerox. Good artists copy but great artists steal.
- mrkramer 5y ago>Mark getting excited about using a message to book a restaurant seems like a prime example of this. He was basically explaining chat bot/s without knowing it.
- azinman2 5y agoChat bots usually are built by the end service, not acting as a meta agent.
- bpodgursky 5y agoIf you read point (4) he clearly did know it, he just saw it as a more ambitious and challenging problem.
- xeromal 5y agoJust tried to paste the content of the tweets, but too long so I dropped it in pastebin for anyways who's interested. https://pastebin.com/e6af5MRv https://pastebin.com/e6af5MRv
- Jaruzel 5y agoThank you for that. Pasting a long document as multiple images via a Twitter thread needs to be some sort of punishable crime.
- xeromal 5y agoYeah, twitter is definitely not meant for long content!
- dredmorbius 5y agoCan haz moar weitspaze https://pastebin.com/raw/TJypYNGQ https://pastebin.com/raw/TJypYNGQ
- dilap 5y ago> For Messenger, I think differentiation is extremely important and something we haven't focused on yet. We've spent the past 6-12 months catching up to WhatsApp and competitors on table stakes like performance, reliability, pushability, etc. This work isn't done and we will continue to do it, including catching up in areas like groups. > But to get people to ditch WhatsApp and switch to Messenger, it will never be sufficient to be 10% better than them or add fun gimmicks on any existing attribute or feature. We will have to offer some new fundamental use case that becomes important to people's daily lives. They never did catch up on table stakes, nor did they discover that new fundamental use case. But they had a good fallback plan: Just buy WhatsUp. Bummer for the users, though. I find myself wishing something along the lines of antitrust was enforced more rigorously to help preserve competition.
- EGreg 5y agoOur of curiosity, what was so hard for FB to have reliability, performance… and what exactly is pushability? Is it because the whatsapp dudes used Erlang?
- bryan_w 5y agoWhen you have 1000+ cooks in the kitchen, all being judged by how many new features they can pump out, just doing: import fbcorelibs; Creates a 250+mb ios/Android binary that bump against app store limits
- bcit-cst 5y agoyeah I was thinking the same thing? Maybe its something to do with CD/CI. being able to push changes to end users fast ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jgalt212 5y ago> Bummer for the users, though. The game's not over yet. Maybe Meta sells, or is forced sell, WhatsApp. Or maybe people move on to the new thing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- qqtt 5y agoAmazing how wrong Mark was about lots of things related to Messenger, and how just two months after this email FB ended up paying 20 billion to buy WhatsApp. You get the sense there was a real paranoia about WhatsApp being an existential threat but now almost a decade later and it's hard to see how FB got a return on that 20 billion investment for that particular acquisition. Also, I find it particularly interesting how Mark is so focused on pushing everything into the public "news feed" style sphere, and seems to have a kind of wishful thinking involving messaging in particular transitioning from a private activity you do with your friends to this public bombastic twitter-esque landscape of public figures "sending messages" to their followers and removing the barriers between those communications and "real" communications between your actual friends. He seems to intensely believe that this is really the only way to create a giant business - essentially destroying and corrupting personal private connections to fill your experience with "more engaging" public content to keep you addicted to the platform. Well, especially for chat, that didn't pan out. And now we are entering a period where private stories, private communication, and meaningful communication matters more - Instagram growth falling to single digits and rapidly losing ground to other platforms among younger users (a harbinger of things to come) - Mark's dogmatic commitment to the alter of public newsfeed paradigms has caused almost all his platforms to evolve towards a dying entity one by one - all except for, notably, WhatsApp. One gets the sense that Mark has one trick, and that trick is no longer effective at meaningfully growing and positioning FB for the future, especially compared to its historical growth rates (maybe those were unsustainable anyway).
- Firmwarrior 5y agoRe your first part, WhatsApp could've expanded out into a full social network the same way LINE and WeChat did in Asia. So I think Zuck was onto something Re: the rest: That's an interesting outlook. I wonder if younger audiences are more resilient to being tricked into trying to compete for "Likes" in a semi-public forum of their friends and family..
- annadane 5y agoUsing a spyware VPN called Onavo might not be the same thing as 'onto something'
- viksit 5y agoIt feels like the thrust here was to merge the concept of “community engagement” with “messaging”. Public conversations vs private conversations. The challenge I see is that users don’t want to mix the two - I imagine a version of “newsfeed meets google reader” (aka twitter) being very different from “messages to macys or my friends”. The incentive he’s creating for people to move to messenger seems to be “combine everything” vs “focus”, which ultimately failed. Instead it was instagram that propelled that to the detriment of messenger.
- blindseer 5y agoI think a lot of tech companies / products at tech companies, (e.g. Netflix, YouTube, Messenger) fundamentally get one thing wrong. They don't "value" the user's time and drive for *maximum* engagement. Maybe the problem is that there's a new sucker born everyday, but I despise using Netflix and YouTube, and I use them only because I have to. With Messenger specifically, I absolutely don't want to spend quality time with someone communicating over a digital device. I'd much rather just use it to make plans with the person I want to hang out with. And when I am making plans to spend time with a significant other, if I made a request to a service for "buying two tickets for hunger games at 9pm" and it returned a message saying "I can get you two tickets for shoreline at 9:10pm", I'd want to throw my phone into the ocean. I'd feel differently if I said "buy two tickets to any movie at 9pm", that'd be a completely different story. This is the same problem with YouTube. If you've recently subscribed to a user, or watched one of their videos for the first time, and then make a search for something completely different, one of a first few results will be a video of the user you initially interacted with. It is SUCH a bonkers user experience for me and I want to never give YouTube any information about myself for recommendations just because of that. These platforms / products should be just services. Give the user enough information to make the decision themselves, and help them make the best decision with the most accurate and pertinent information. I hate that these products shove content into your face. Anyone else feel like the golden age of internet services is behind us, and this shitty version is the only path ahead of us?
- paulcole 5y ago> With Messenger specifically, I absolutely don't want to… The big issues with a proclamation like this are: 1. You’re 1 person and you have to recognize you don’t speak for anyone other than yourself. 2. The things people say they don’t want to do and what they actually don’t do are often surprisingly different.
- bozhark 5y agoFound the FB dev edit: take your own advice
- 5y ago
- chinchilla2020 5y agoMy takeaway from this entire post is that Twitter is not appropriate for long essays and people need to stop acting like it is.
- Lammy 5y agoThe WhatsApp situation was a huge driver behind Facebook's 2013 acquisition of Onavo. FB first positioned Onavo as an "Opera Mini"-like data-compressing VPN for people with mobile data caps, later as "Onavo Protect" so they could scare people into installing it with the threat of the big bad open Internet, and lastly as "Facebook Research". It gave FB five years of passive market research data so they could identify and acquire (or clone) popular new apps before they could grow into WhatsApp-sized competitors. Think of all the Snapchat-like features that appeared in Instagram around this time, for example, after they failed to directly clone Snapchat as "Slingshot". The data from Onavo was so strategically-important that FB were willing to pay teenagers to install it and burned their Enterprise iOS cert doing so: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onavo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onavo https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-acquires-onavo-for-up-to-200-million-2013-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-acquires-onavo-for-... https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/21/facebook-removes-onavo/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/21/facebook-removes-onavo/
- upbeat_general 5y agoI’m curious about this. Is it not possible to buy usage data from other network operators without owning them? As much as I hate it, I’d expect this is sold much like location data is. Sure, you may not get the raw traffic but that seems not very useful for FB.
- Lammy 5y agoA lot of that data probably is for sale, but think how much more powerful the VPN is when the metadata is more valuable than the probably-encrypted-anyway raw traffic: - you can directly correlate an Onavo user's traffic to their Facebook profile for demographic and interest data which telecoms won't even know. - if two Onavo users are both Facebook users, you can identify up-and-coming apps which pose a threat to Facebook's most valuable asset: the social network itself (the links between people, not any FB software). That includes both explicit links ("Friend" requests) as well as implicit links like mutual group memberships, mutual participation in comment threads, mutual "private" sharing of the same content, etc. - you get a more complete picture of a person's phone habits across the entire day, not just when the Facebook app is front and center. Remember that this happened immediately after the failure of the "Facebook Home" product which provided application usage tracking by acting as an Android "Launcher" replacement. - you get a more complete picture of up-and-coming apps' "stickiness", i.e. if a person opens the competitor app immediately when a notification comes in versus if they leave it for a while and get back to it later. - you get a more complete picture in markets where dual-SIM phones are popular (e.g. when people might have voice/SMS service on one and pre-paid data on the other). - you get a more complete picture in markets where people seek out Wi-Fi for high-bandwidth activities due to the expense or unavailability of unlimited mobile data. - you can use Facebook's ad targeting system to directly push Onavo on people in markets you want to enter and dominate.
- snowwrestler 5y agoIt’s funny to read this now; I remember a big surge of excitement about Facebook chat bots among organizations. It was going to be a cool new way to engage followers on Facebook: they could message your org as if it were a person, and a bot would immediately handle the most common requests. FB even started putting a little score near the message button on pages for how fast replies happened. (Still there, last I checked.) The excitement faded pretty quickly once folks realized that it was just a FB chat version of an automated phone menu. We know how popular those are. I don’t think it ever caught on with users, at least among the orgs I’m aware of.
- pull_my_finger 5y agoThey may be more popular outside the US. Where I am a lot of big businesses still use facebook for their online presence, and use those very annoying chat bots as their support gateways. Really frustrating as a user, but that's the state of things where I am.
- mjr00 5y agoChat bots are definitely still a big thing, but the value proposition has completely flipped. Zuckerberg (and others) were pushing an experience for the user, where they'd be delighted by interacting with a humanlike support bot that could interpret their human request. The value would come from additional user engagement with the platform, and therefore ad revenue. In reality, chat bots are a cost optimization technique for businesses, where they save money by paying support bot services in exchange for reduced support staff. Still making money for someone, but they're nearly universally a worse experience for the end user, and certainly not a reason why users would engage with the FB platform.
- xmprt 5y agoOn the contrary, I've had much better experiences with chat bots than I have had speaking with customer support on the phone. With a chat bot, I can wait for a response and be notified immediately. I wouldn't even mind if they took multiple hours to fulfill my request. Staying on hold on the phone for even 5 minutes feels like hell.
- triyambakam 5y agoI find it strange that Facebook communicates across the company... using Facebook. It doesn't seem like a medium well suited for that.
- mFixman 5y agoFacebook-in-Facebook later got renamed to Workplace and launched as a separate product, which IMO is fantastic for engineering organisations with >1000 people. Slack doesn't really work at those sizes.
- triyambakam 5y agoCan you explain why you think it's a great product?
- rnotaro 4y agoI believe the equivalent on Office 365 / Microsoft for business is Yammer.
- AceJohnny2 5y ago> "[...] if we had gotten the quality balance right and not repeatedly thrashed our ecosystem [...]" I'm choosing to believe even in 2013 this was referring to Google's messaging strategy.
- woojoo666 5y agoIt's interesting that Mark Zuckerberg saw the transition to privacy / private channels back in 2013. From what I remember, sharing to your feed, posting to other people's walls, tagging each other in images, were all still very popular back then. But as Mark Zuckerberg predicted, usage of these features has dropped dramatically (at least from what I've seen).
- noodleman 5y agoHe himself was burned by Facebook's privacy settings when private photos of him and his then girlfriend were leaked. In other photos his laptop has tape over the webcam and microphone. He knows why people are privacy advocates. Probably moreso than anyone else, given the data he has access to. Personally, I think it was always a matter of time until this sentiement found it's way to the general public.
- akyu 5y agoInteresting to get an more raw insight into Mark's thinking. In some ways its insightful and prescient, but also feels like there is desperation and a kind of throwing spaghetti at the wall and seeing what sticks. I suppose Facebook has/had the resources to do plenty of spaghetti throwing though. Another observation is that this would have been the moment for Facebook to lean into short video content a la TikTok. But it seems like the video content is just an after thought for Zuck. Hindsight is 20/20 I suppose, but its interesting that they almost got there. Vine already existed at this point and I guess Zuck did not view it as a threat. Perhaps that's one downside of the "defensibility" mindset that seems to pervade this writing and most of the ideas. I get the sense that this is Zuck responding to competitors, and not really crafting a unique vision for Facebook as its own entity.
- DLay 5y agoHe didn’t launch a competitor, but Zuckerberg approved the blocking of Vine’s API access to find Facebook friends a few days after it launched. TikTok must have paid a pretty penny to have access to it today.
- pentagrama 5y agoI'm wondering if now people like Zuckerberg, for communications like this, instead of email will be using something with auto-delete features to avoid get this messages on the internet in 10 years. Do you think that on the time of writing he knows that this can be public someday? This is public because some law force Facebook to give this messages to the government and they publish it? Some recipients leaked it? FB was hacked? I get some negative feeling on reading this messages that seems to be written as private.
- xmprt 5y agoCompanies aren't allowed to auto delete messages for legal reasons. At any point communications can be subpoenaed for a lawsuit and companies will have to show them in court and if they are caught deleting messages, they could be in even bigger trouble if they don't have a legitimate reason for deleting them.
- mlom 5y agoinnovation and differentiation are not things i need or want in my messaging app, holy cow, i just want to send messages. use a standard protocol or write a new one, i don't care, but the problem you are solving is SENDING MESSAGES TO A KNOWN USER. write a protocol, document it, and let the client handle the rest. omg. grow up
- didip 5y agoThese are all great ideas. Why didn’t they implement many of these inside Messenger or WhatsApp? I also wonder why Meta suddenly lost their competitive spirit in Messaging space. WA is so behind compared to WeChat/Line/Kakao.
- azinman2 5y agoThey did try the agent approach, called M. It failed. It wasn’t a meta-agent, however. My guess is people didn’t like the idea of only sometimes being used if Facebook thought they should route to them, no ability to control end user experience or brand loyalty, every random service would need to be world class at NLP, and other miscellaneous reasons associated with being just confined to a simple textual transaction. There are also probably less examples of this than you’d think — restaurants and movies are 101, but where else does this go? Even getting the next obvious thing — concert tickets - all of the sudden requires picking seats, looking at photos of the venue, constraining different options, understanding how many seats are together, etc. Even with crappy UI of Ticketmaster you want the breadth of options and probably to comparison shop. Things quickly get out of hand, and unless you trust the agent to make decisions for you and explain it’s rationale, there are better interfaces than just text.
- user3939382 5y agoI was confused for a second, I thought this was the time he said everyone who gives Facebook their data were "dumb fucks" That was a different story https://www.esquire.com/uk/latest-news/a19490586/mark-zuckerberg-called-people-who-handed-over-their-data-dumb-f/# https://www.esquire.com/uk/latest-news/a19490586/mark-zucker...
- landryraccoon 5y agoReading this fascinating thread makes me finally understand why I left Facebook as a platform - and that's because Facebook ISN'T a platform. Zuckerberg thinks of Facebook in terms of technology - it's an application platform with certain features like messaging, a news feed, an API and so forth. That isn't what Facebook was to me. In the beginning, Facebook was a community. As An Application, the problem it solved, that of staying in sync with your community, had many other solutions: Meeting IRL, talking on the phone, going to reunions, and so forth. Facebook was just a convenient virtual place to put those conversations and meetings instead. It felt neat, it felt good to have your community in a digital space. The reason I left has nothing to do with the features. Facebook is a perfectly FINE application. I cannot point to a single technological flaw with it. The flaw is in the community. Every year since 2016, I have felt that much of the communities that I interacted with are no longer relevant to me, and somehow the old ways of finding community : Reunions, talking on the phone, meeting IRL for events - just feels like a better community somehow. I am sure Zuck and Team over at Facebook will continue to add new and amazing features to Facebook that make it a better and better platform, application and API every day. But I don't think I will ever go back, because the community that I found and loved there in 2011 died in 2016, and I cannot imagine it ever coming back. When I go online and see some of the ways in which friends have changed - I just cannot imagine wanting to be close to them again. I have a criticism of Zuckerberg which may seem unfair, but it is what it is. Zuckerberg is very intelligent, and he's a technologist. But he's not a community organizer. He isn't someone who inspires people to come together; he's not a "bringer" as an organizer might say. I don't think Facebook needs more technology. It needs reconciliation and healing of deep and painful divides that were formed over the past decade that mirror a tear in the fabric of our very society - the deep and brewing divisions in values in western society are NOT going to be papered over by an algorithm. If anything, profit maximizing algorithms that create cliques and insular societies that only see what they want to see make the problem WORSE. Facebook needs a Martin Luther King Jr, not a Thomas Edison or Steve Jobs. This description by Zuck of Messenger and News Feed in technological terms only reinforces by opinion that I'm never going back.
- civilized 5y ago> Facebook needs a Martin Luther King Jr, not a Thomas Edison or Steve Jobs. Every part of society needs an MLK Jr. We pay so much attention to elites who are as trivial and uninspiring as they are rich and powerful. It's been so long since a public figure was someone to believe in. Other than perhaps briefly Obama, I don't think it has happened in my lifetime (I'm under 40).
- siskiyou 5y agoI loved it when Facebook released the Messenger app, because I could occasionally install Facebook to post vacation pics without ever installing Messenger. I've still never used Messenger.
- taurusnoises 5y agoWhat's interesting about this to me, is how many times he refers to the user wanting to go one way, namely private and uninterrupted, and him continuing to drag the user back into the public, data-mining open. He and the lot are creeps. These platforms pretend like they're social services first that mine usage to keep the lights on, when in fact they're data-mining services first, baiting users into engaging in a public forum so they have more data to mine. It's lame and super average, vanilla, capitalist bs.
- swivelmaster 5y agoSeems like few people remember that for a brief period, messenger bots were all the rage in the tech press and a lot of investment money was lit on fire to support them. I suspect most or all of that fervor can be traced back to this email. Concise, visionary... and wrong. It's a classic example of confusing what's good for business with what's good for consumers, and then getting wrapped up in a story that rationalizes the use case. Messaging is a convenient interface in theory, but in practice it's not. Zuck talks about opening a specific app to perform a specific action as if it's some terribly onerous process, but consider that most common use cases are the first or second button on an app's home interface. Tap to open, tap to do the action. Even if it technically takes longer because of load times, it feels shorter because you're doing less work. Two or three taps to complete a task vs. opening messenger (tap), then TYPING what you want and hoping it's parsed correctly. Sounds awful. Zooming out, this is a microcosm of how we get the labyrinthine user experience of so many popular apps and web sites: Executives suppose they know where the future of their business is, then insist the UX be built around that (instead of how or why people actually engage). Note that Zuck's analysis here isn't based on any data whatsoever - it's purely "here's what I think the future of this business is," and then the entire company pivots around it. Is it all bad? No, having some kind of vision isn't bad. But... This is one of those areas where we can point to someone like Steve Jobs and say, at least he generally focused on the end-user experience and worked towards building the right product; FB/Meta's business-first consumer-later approach is backwards. It might seem at first like it's framed as being about the consumer experience, but if you pay close attention the primary questions answered are: What can we do to increase engagement on the platform? And: What might others do to drive engagement that we can do first? Wait a minute, what might others do that we can do first? That sounds like... playing defense. Except, the others haven't done it yet, so it's speculative proactive defense, which is something just about any startup advisor would caution against. But FB/Meta is at the point where they're focused on market share above all else, so decisions are being made from this backwards second-guessing defensive position. And because so many of us are already locked into the ecosystem, we're experiencing the consequences.
- mmmmmbop 5y ago> it's speculative proactive defense, which is something just about any startup advisor would caution against True, but at that point, Facebook was not a startup anymore. Playing defense as a startup might be silly, but as a large tech company, it's arguably essential.
- fumblebee 5y ago>"Just like News feed started out as friends content only but eventually expanded to included more content that is now critical to everyday engagement..." Aged like milk, and not only in the context of the 2016 election. Friends' generated content was the main reason why I started using Facebook back in '08. Content that showed up on my newsfeed not created directly by friends triggered my - and perhaps many other folks' - leaving the platform.
- bigcat12345678 5y agoGiven tiktok's growth, these old words are barely meaningful...
- jeffparsons 5y agoIdeas number 3 and 4 together sound to me like the foundations of a generalised "intent economy": a buyer expresses what they want, and the platform dynamically builds the graph of agents required to fulfill that intent, including quotes, bidding, idea/pitch refinement etc. as necessary. Maybe you just want a burger. Maybe you want a gift for Mother's Day but you have no idea what. Maybe you want a new house designed and built. I don't think I actually _want_ this (I view Uber-for-everthing as kinda dystopian) but I'm amazed that nobody has made a serious attempt to build this. Uber has one part of the puzzle in their driver-customer connection and order fulfillment platform. Facebook has another in its social graph. Amazon has another in its marketplace and Mechanical Turk. And a thousand other companies have one highly specialised subset of this, like finding and scheduling a couple of tradespeople required to do a job on your home. I must be missing something that makes it a lot harder than it seems, or that means there's a lot less value there than it looks like on the surface, because why else have none of these huge players decided to go for it?
- bcherny 5y agoWhat are some examples of what your friend's mom would use this service for?
- rsanek 5y agoIt's wild how much of this long post is just about addressing potential concerns about spam. I remember how annoying early Facebook News Feed was with Farmville, but it sounds like this was a recurring problem for them that they had to constantly pay attention to.