29 ms·
US sentences crypto expert to 5 years after North Korea blockchain presentation
- paxys 5y agoThat's an unnecessary flamebait title. He wasn't sentenced for a presentation, but for evading sanctions.
- CamperBob2 5y agoHelp evil people, go to jail. I don't see a problem here.
- aaomidi 5y agoWe should imprison the entire US tax payer population then xd
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vernie 5y ago
- SkyBelow 5y agoCould someone explain why this wouldn't fall under freedom of speech? Sounds like there were not government secrets nor did the expert have a security clearance that would have held him to a higher standard. If Tor researchers gave a presentation at a security conference on how to install Tor, knowing full well that some would use it to engage in the proliferation of CSAM, would that also not fall under free speech?
- spacemanmatt 5y agofreedom of speech is not absolute. it's as simple as that. the guy violated a federal sanction.
- egberts1 5y agoexcept the charges is not on about freedom of speech, not at all, not even close.
- happytoexplain 5y agoThe first sentence in the article is "The US sentenced a blockchain researcher to more than five years in prison after he pleaded guilty to conspiring to help North Korea evade sanctions using cryptocurrency." Asked why what he did wouldn't be protected by freedom of speech, the parent replied "freedom of speech is not absolute ... the guy violated a federal sanction." I don't understand what you're implying about this thread of conversation - it seems fairly reasonable. The GP asked about freedom of speech - the parent didn't imply this is a freedom of speech issue. They explained why it isn't.
- CamperBob2 5y agoThe problem isn't so much the presentation or the content, as it is the transaction. Doing business with North Korea is highly restricted, as it should be, in order to maintain the integrity of US and international trade sanctions against the Kims. Russia now finds itself in much the same position thanks to Putin, so it's probably a good idea for everyone doing business there to familiarize themselves with economic actions being taken against that regime. Few people in the West ever attempted to do business with Pyongyang, but that's not true of Moscow. There's a lot more legal exposure, much of which will come as a surprise to those affected by it.
- meheleventyone 5y ago> Could someone explain why this wouldn't fall under freedom of speech? North Korea is under international sanctions and part of that means you can't aid them. Explaining how to launder money and evade sanctions to a general audience is probably fine. Explaining how to launder money and evade sanctions to North Korea is against the law.
- GauntletWizard 5y agoYou can almost certainly get away with "If I were North Korea, here's how I would launder money" as an academic article. Presenting it in Pyongyang seems like a pretty bright and clear "Aiding and abetting enemies of the US"
- vmception 5y agoIf the security conference was in a place sanctioned under the US International Emergency Economic Powers Act, then yes. He applied for a travel exemption, and was denied. He went anyway. He was charged with that, not the speech. That's how its enforced, for this specific reason. Regulate the intermediary to control the desired behavior. Don't regulate the individual with first amendment rights.
- orangepurple 5y agoThe USA junta will punish you if you go against them, constitution be damned, the judges are on their side.
- xadhominemx 5y agoFreedom of speech is meant to preserve democracy domestically, not be a free for all to aid enemies for profit. Any sane state, including free democracies, would prohibit residents from teaching rogue enemy nations how to avoid sanctions.
- ttybird2 5y agoI do not think that this is a widely held view. Regarding the US constitution for example, Part of Bernstein v. United States was the complaint that DJB was not able to legally talk to or teach about cryptography to cryptographers and students that are not US citizens. As for the "freedom of speech" as a general concept, I think that it is more of an individualist than a collectivist principle. It does not refer to countries or groups by itself, it is the right for entities to speak freely.
- vmception 5y agoErmmmm not here. When you can afford to tango with them, they don't take surprising constitutional views actually. That part is in your favor. Its more about affording to get that far, in other cases. This case isn't one of those? He wasn't charged for the speech, he was charged for violating a travel and business sanction after explicitly asking for an exemption and being denied. He went out of his way to hop over barriers placed by the government, and got charged for hopping over after telling the government he was interested in hopping over. They watched him hop over, they didn't charge him for the speech he gave after hopping over. Hopping over isn't a constitutional right.
- happytoexplain 5y agoThe issue is not the subjective "will this be used for evil", but the more objective "does this violate international sanctions", which it seems to. It has very little to do directly/exclusively with cryptocurrency or crypto in general.
- chickenpotpie 5y agoSame reason you can't yell fire in a crowded theater. There are limits to freedom of speech, especially when it interferes with national defense. Schenck v. United States is an interesting case where the supreme court ruled that passing out fliers to encourage resistance to the draft is not protected by the first amendment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States
- ttybird2 5y agoFunnily enough passing out said fliers is exactly what I believe "freedom of speech" is meant to protect.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt’s Time to Stop Using the ‘Fire in a Crowded Theater’ Quote: https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-time-to-stop-using-the-fire-in-a-crowded-theater-quote/264449/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim... Three Generations of a Hackneyed Apologia for Censorship Are Enough: https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackneyed-apologia-for-censorship-are-enough/ https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-ha...
- chickenpotpie 5y agoI read the Atlantic article, but I don't think they made a strong enough argument to justify retiring the quote. Regardless of the circumstances that it was first used, it's meaning is still very true. It is still illegal to yell fire in a crowded theater and there are many exceptions to the first amendment. An american citizen cannot verbally harass someone, they cannot share child pornography, and they cannot go around telling everyone how to make a nuclear bomb.
- simoncion 5y agoYou should read the Popehat essay. The guy is a former Federal prosecutor. He knows what he's talking about. Moreover, you forgot to read this part of what you linked to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States#Subsequent_jurisprudence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States#Subse... > A unanimous Court in a brief per curiam opinion in Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), abandoned the disfavored language while seemingly applying the reasoning of Schenck to reverse the conviction of a Ku Klux Klan member prosecuted for giving an inflammatory speech. The Court said that speech could be prosecuted only when it posed a danger of "imminent lawless action," a formulation which is sometimes said to reflect Holmes reasoning as more fully explicated in his Abrams dissent, rather than the common law of attempts explained in Schenck. > An american citizen cannot verbally harass someone... They can, actually. See the quote from the wikipedia article above. > ...they cannot go around telling everyone how to make a nuclear bomb. _Pretty_ sure that they can. It's widely said that any physics graduate student can work out how to make a useful but basic nuke. The issue is _actually building one_, or sending the materials to construct one to a sanctioned nation. First Amendment protections are _broad_ and exceptions to them have been (historically) carved out with _great_ reluctance. This is a feature, not a bug.
- TheGigaChad 5y ago
- spacemanmatt 5y agoi wonder if he thought he had a 1st amendment defense
- ALittleLight 5y agoProbably the kind of thing you should go over with your lawyer first.
- outworlder 5y agoHe would have been better served by the 5th amendment.
- flerchin 5y agoI would love to hear from Mr Griffith's perspective on this. 5 years in prison is a BFD. I wonder how the arrest went down, why he took a plea, what the details of his presentation were, so many things.
- vmception 5y ago> I wonder how the arrest went down At the airport upon return > Why he took a plea Because the prosecutor would ask for way more prison time otherwise, the US International Emergency Economic Powers Act charge was pretty solid > what the details of his presentation were Information the North Koreans could have found already, even with their limited internet
- flerchin 5y agoYou have any links for those answers? I appreciate them.
- radicaldreamer 5y agoHe wasn't arrested at the airport when he returned, he was questioned and cooperated, then was arrested later with evidence partially being what he himself told investigators.
- vmception 5y agoThanks. I think they want links because they hadn't seen this case before even though the rest of us have been watching this slow motion trainwreck for some time.
- radicaldreamer 5y agoPretty good rundown here: https://www.thedailybeast.com/crypto-enthusiast-virgil-griffith-sentenced-to-5-years-for-north-korea-trip https://www.thedailybeast.com/crypto-enthusiast-virgil-griff... --- According to his lawyers, after his North Korean speaking engagement, Griffith actually went straight to the U.S. embassy in Singapore, where he was residing at the time, to tell them all about the experience. He also chose to meet with the FBI in Puerto Rico and San Francisco. But after extensive talks, the feds instead surprised the technologist by arresting him at Los Angeles International Airport on Thanksgiving Day 2019, while Griffith was boarding a flight to Baltimore to spend the holiday with his parents and sister. He was indicted months later on a single count of violating presidential executive orders aimed at blocking North Korea from the international banking system as punishment for its repeated threats to nuke the United States. The arrest immediately generated criticism, as the exceedingly eccentric and devoted community of cryptocurrency enthusiasts cast the prosecution as a crackdown on free speech. Meanwhile, the federal government played right into that by shrouding the case in secrecy. So many court files were kept sealed that journalist Matthew Russell Lee, who runs the publication Inner City Press, asked the judge to reconsider in a letter that noted, “The sealings and withholding here are unacceptable, and go beyond those requested even in the Central Intelligence Agency trial” of accused Wikileaks leaker Joshua Adam Schulte. As the case proceeded, Griffith’s attorneys maintained that his travel was “a goodwill speaking trip.” During his chats with FBI agents, Griffith came clean and offered to help the feds explore his North Korean contacts and activities, according to a source close to Griffith. This source described at length Griffith’s willingness to cooperate with the American intelligence agencies and the potential to become something of a spy asset. Those hopes were dashed when the Justice Department came down hard on him.
- spamizbad 5y agoNot surprised: it seems a common theme with crypto evangelists is the application of the blockchain to avoid sanctions. I don't think its deeply ideological (as in anti-America/Pro-NK) - it's more like they view US financial hegemony as a "competitor" to blockchain technology and a hinderance to global cryptocurrency adoption. Why he would throw his life away like this seems silly. I don't see the point in taking payment for a presentation you could record and upload on youtube which can be readily viewed by North Korea's leadership.
- ethbr0 5y agoIt's the ultimate place any honest monetary cipherpunk ends up at. Either you have government controlled financial systems, or you have decentralized financial systems. Getting to any middleground is pretty tortured, both technically and morally. Sort of like "Strong encryption permits a world in which child pornography cannot be tracked" with respect to encryption. It's ugly, but true. (Said as someone who doesn't care about cryptocurrency enough to have a strong opinion either way)
- wolverine876 5y ago> Either you have government controlled financial systems, or you have decentralized financial systems. Some parties control the latter; don't be fooled. The question is, who?
- woah 5y agoNo, I think this is a misconception. Sanctions can work without government controlled money. Prosecuting terrorism or organized crime can be done without government controlled money. Catching tax evaders can be done without government controlled money. Everything can work without government controlled money, it just requires more on the ground police work. All of these things were done without government controlled money not very long ago. Similar to how the job of police would be a lot easier if every citizen was required to carry a surveillance microphone, their job is easier if all transactions are can be censored and surveilled. But it is not necessary. For example, sanctions: Find people who are trading with a sanctioned regime by looking at if they are importing goods from there. Very easy. If they are paying for labor (remote IT work or something), you can also catch that. Informants, etc.
- unethical_ban 5y agoYou almost have to wonder if there is more we don't know. I can't imagine anyone person being able to fundamentally alter NK's understanding of Blockchain. Laugh at that country, but there must be a few doctorate level brains that can watch proxied-Youtube. He knew what he was doing and he took a principled stand on sharing information with a very unsympathetic party. It would be like teaching mobsters how to clean an AK-47 when there is a specific law against it - sure, the law may sound bogus, but you broke it, and you aren't being exactly noble about it.
- erdos4d 5y agoNo, there isn't more, the US would certainly detail it in the indictment if there was. This is obviously a political prosecution against a guy they just didn't like hanging out with guys they don't, and lending those guys a certain legitimacy in the process. He provided NK with nothing of value, as you say, they certainly know about cryptocurrency and have been using it for quite some time now.
- ricochet11 5y agoThis is so sad, how does locking him up for 5 years really helps anyone? or keep anyone safer? He did something stupid maybe, but his work was exploring how digital systems can help bring peace to the world, and he thought a good place for that to happen is NK, so who doesn't agree with that? None of the information he presented was secret, it was all publicly available. For comparison here is a company that actually facilitated NK building Nuclear Weapons, 145 violations of the law , they got fined $15k more than Virgil and had no jail time. https://www.complianceweek.com/regulatory-enforcement/td-bank-fined-105k-for-north-korea-sanctions-violations/31208.article#:~:text=TD%20Bank%2C%20N.A.%20agreed%20to,of%20North%20Korean%20sanctions%20regulations https://www.complianceweek.com/regulatory-enforcement/td-ban... What a stupid and harmful legal system.
- orangepurple 5y agoIt is obvious that the US penal system is designed for retribution not rehabilitation. Furthermore, you are not allowed to do anything important unless you are affiliated with the Party.
- beebmam 5y agoNorth Korea actively threatens the use of nuclear weapons, offensively, against its neighbors and enemies. There should be no sympathy for this regime or anyone who collaborates with it.
- ricochet11 5y agoHow do we go about improving relations? How do we improve the lives of the people living under that awful regime? How do we give people ways to exit and escape, and have access to the freedoms we have?
- mdanger007 5y agoSanctions are one of the few tools the world has against nuclear armed despots. If you're really interested in the questions you ask, I would start here: https://nymag.com/strategist/2018/03/the-10-best-books-about-north-korea.html https://nymag.com/strategist/2018/03/the-10-best-books-about...
- pen2l 5y agoDid his PhD at Caltech under Christof Koch in computation and neural systems, was a super talented mathematician... and then he gets involved in crypto. I remember conversations with friends only a few years ago in which we would lament how young brilliant minds were eventually going on to work on adtech, and we would sigh and hope that the tide would turn. Boy, we were not prepared for this tide. Anyway, the NYSD release gives some interesting details: (https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/manhattan-us-attorney-announces-arrest-united-states-citizen-assisting-north-korea https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/manhattan-us-attorney-a...) GRIFFITH identified several DPRK Cryptocurrency Conference attendees who appeared to work for the North Korean government, and who, during his presentation, asked GRIFFITH specific questions about blockchain and cryptocurrency and prompted discussions on technical aspects of those technologies. After the DPRK Cryptocurrency Conference, GRIFFITH began formulating plans to facilitate the exchange of cryptocurrency between the DPRK and South Korea, despite knowing that assisting with such an exchange would violate sanctions against the DPRK. GRIFFITH also encouraged other U.S. citizens to travel to North Korea, including to attend the same DPRK Cryptocurrency Conference the following year. Smart enough as he was, I'm sure he knew of the terrible human rights track record NK had. That he chose to start helping the NK government evade sanctions, I am not able to muster a lot of sympathy for the guy at this point.
- tmpz22 5y agoAll that education and they still didn’t have the common sense to maybe not go to North Korea
- radicaldreamer 5y agoI think there's a kind of naïveté at work here. He cooperated when questioned after returning from North Korea, only to have his own words used against him when he was charged. He didn't take sanctions violations seriously enough and when he asked the State Dept for permission beforehand to go, they said no, and he went anyway.
- egberts1 5y ago
- nmwnmw 5y agoThis is the same Virgil of: - Ethereum Proof of Stake [1] - King of the Nerds TV Show - Wikiscanner [2] Source [3] [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.09437 https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.09437 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiScanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiScanner [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgil_Griffith https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgil_Griffith
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throw8383833jj 5y agoI really wonder if he knew he could go to jail for this. did he know the risks?
- chatmasta 5y agoI met Virgil at an academic workshop back in 2014. We went out in Amsterdam. He was a weird guy, to say the least (he’d probably be the first to agree). He was generally quite affable and obviously highly intelligent. He’s an idiot for this fiasco. But it’s also sad to see him in jail; I don’t see how this benefits society in any way. Five years in prison seems like a disproportionate punishment for an arguably victimless crime. None of us is safer today because Virgil is in prison.
- ethbr0 5y agoAgreed. This feels like early-90s computer crime sentencing. Making it easy for someone to bludgeon you over the head with a legal charge is your own fault. But the net impact of the charge can also be useless.
- Daishiman 5y agoIf you were to advice a sanctioned country on how to launder money or evade currency controls you would also be penalized in the same manner.
- ethbr0 5y agoExplaining how cryptocurrency works is itself advising a sanctioned country on how to launder money and evade currency controls. Is Wikipedia liable?
- unnouinceput 5y agoThis is about sending a message, especially to brilliant minds. No prosecution was involved when Rodman was visiting NK and definitely helped NK with having a highly visible star being personal friend with Kim, but hey Rodman is not a brainiac.
- otterley 5y agoDennis Rodman didn't break the law by the mere act of visiting North Korea and being friendly with Kim. As far as I can tell, the only time he may have acted questionably was a suspicion of bringing in some luxury goods (https://www.si.com/si-wire/2014/01/24/dennis-rodman-sanctions-north-korea https://www.si.com/si-wire/2014/01/24/dennis-rodman-sanction...), but it doesn't seem like that case was pursued.
- stuntkite 5y agoThis is a weird event that it's going to take me a long while to form an opinion on. I just... don't know what to say or think about this. That isn't a thinly veiled condemnation. I genuinely don't know what to think about this but it's clearly something that needs to be evaluated very critically and involves so many things that are so... of their time and place.
- starwind 5y agoFrom Coindesk: > Judge Castel read a series of text messages and emails from Griffith in which the defendant admits to sharing information with North Korea for the express purpose of helping the repressive Kim regime evade sanctions. https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/04/12/former-ethereum-developer-virgil-griffith-sentenced-to-5-years-in-prison-for-north-korea-trip/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/04/12/former-ethereum...
- aaomidi 5y agoIf the national security of the country is going to be in trouble because of a presentation then uh, lol.
- danielvf 5y agoAccording to the original complaint, a few months after being interviewed by an FBI agent on returning from his trip to North Korea, Griffith had the following conversation over text messages: Griffith: I need to send 1 [REDACTED UNIT OF CRYPTOCURRENCY] between North and South Korea. Other Guy: "Isn't that in violations of sanctions?" Griffith: It is. A few day later, also in text messages to someone else: Someone: What interest does North Korea have in cryptocurrency? Griffith: Probably avoiding sanctions... who knows." It looks like it wasn't just speaking at a conference after being denied permission from the US that got him in trouble, it looks like both before and after the trip he was working on a variety of ways to get the North Korean government more onboard with cryptocurrency, including discussions about mining ventures, moving funds in and out of the country, and offering connections with other cryptocurrency people.
- wnevets 5y agoSo the title is incredibly misleading?
- tommek4077 5y agoI've read it as a time reference. He got trialed after the conference.
- wnevets 5y agothere are certainly others commenting on this post who didn't read that way. They're posting as if he was literally sent to prison for just talking about crypto.
- toomanyrichies 5y agoYeah, the author of the article could have just as easily titled it "US sentences crypto expert to 5 years after multiple conversations on evading sanctions". You can draw your own conclusions as to why they went with the title they did.
- 5y ago
- nickysielicki 5y agoThe founders of this country are rolling in their graves. Every part of this story. All he did was go to another country and spread truthful information. > "The most important feature of blockchains is that they are open. And the DPRK can't be kept out no matter what the USA or the UN says," This is conspiracy? Is telling someone that a gun can kill now considered conspiracy to murder, too? Is it really the stance of the US government that North Korea knew enough about cryptocurrency to hold a cryptocurrency conference, but that they wouldn’t have been capable of evading sanctions if not for this man speaking this sentence? And while I’m at it, free citizens should not have to ask permission from the government for where they are allowed to go. In free societies, if the other country lets you in you can go. We are not a free country. Half of a decade! Over 5% of his life, gone. Unbelievable.
- jp57 5y agoSome of the founders of this country were responsible for the Alien and Sedition Acts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alien_and_Sedition_Acts
- JohnWhigham 5y agoSeriously, the weird veneration we have for the founders is very bizarre mainly because once they got in power, they largely acted like any other ruler.
- jvanderbot 5y agoI don't think their intent was ever to act unlike a government. But then again who can really divine intent? All we can do is live by laws. But even a self-limiting government has to play politics internationally, and that requires a specific set of tools. I don't see anything here that trips alarms to me.
- Zamicol 5y agoTheir practical actions clarified and tempered their espoused dogma. Wise individuals are frequently misunderstood thanks to the ambiguity of language, and listeners reasonably prefer assumption over nuance.
- gmuslera 5y agoWhat if he did the exact same presentation in youtube, and in NK they saw that presentation? What if someone in NK downloaded the open source implementation of that blockchain, participated on it, or even mined quite a few coins? Could be argued the same about any open source program (and their developers) dealing with encrypted information in any way? What was the problem? Going in person? Answering questions in the same way that he would do to any other person? Giving a "forbidden hint" that is basically spam all over internet by now? I don't care about crypto, but I do care about what this precedent implies.
- mtoner23 5y agoRead the article, he knowingly broke sanctions rules sending money across borders
- starwind 5y ago> What if he did the exact same presentation in youtube, and in NK they saw that presentation? If it was general information about how Blockchain can be used to evade sanctions, it would probably be fine as long as he was reporting how it could be done and not encouraging it. > What if someone in NK downloaded the open source implementation of that blockchain, participated on it, or even mined quite a few coins? Almost certainly not a problem. His tool is legal and he can't control other people taking it and using it to commit crimes. > What was the problem? His intention was the problem. The point of his talk was to help the North Koreans use crypto to evade sanctions. In law, intentions matter. There's a massive legal difference between hitting a pedestrian with your car and running down a pedestrian with your car, even if the outcome is exactly the same. The first is an accident, the second is assault. > Judge Castel read a series of text messages and emails from Griffith in which the defendant admits to sharing information with North Korea for the express purpose of helping the repressive Kim regime evade sanctions. > What the judge found most damning, perhaps, was a photo of Griffith presenting at the conference, wearing a traditional North Korean suit and standing in front of a blackboard on which it read “No sanctions!” with a smiley face. https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/04/12/former-ethereum-developer-virgil-griffith-sentenced-to-5-years-in-prison-for-north-korea-trip/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/04/12/former-ethereum... > I don't care about crypto, but I do care about what this precedent implies. That the intentions of the defendant matter? I have bad news for you, you find this Hammurabi's code and the Old Testament
- tomphoolery 5y agoHe should be in jail for longer. What a traitor.
- behringer 5y agoImagine knowing literally anything about north Korea and wanting to help that government. He should be put away for life for aiding crimes against humanity.
- RobertRoberts 5y agoWhat if the news about NK is not entirely unbiased? (I have no proof either way, just asking the question) Edit: People are taking my comment wrong. I am asking this because there are a lot of assumptions people have, I know almost nothing about NK, and the comment I replied to seemed somewhat irrational, a little reactionary and certainly vindictive.
- jcrash 5y agoThere are many different sources of information about what goes on in NK, including people who have escaped from there.
- xtian 5y agoTrue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BkUMZS-ZegM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BkUMZS-ZegM
- outworlder 5y agoNo news sources are entirely unbiased, even when they make an effort to be. Regardless, we know a lot from NK from multiple sources. The main reason we don't know more is because of how closed that dictatorship is.
- rat9988 5y agoOr how closed we are to them? There is no media unbiased about them in the west. But I do know you can travel to NK and see for yourself. That said, it is easier to know things about Portugal than NK. They are definitely doing something to hide information. I'm just trying to say that any image based on the media from non friendly country is bound to be wrong. No matter how much different sources you have.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoMods: Better link: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/united-states-citizen-pleads-guilty-conspiring-assist-north-korea-evading-sanctions https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/united-states-citizen-p... Better title: "United States Citizen Pleads Guilty To Conspiring To Assist North Korea In Evading Sanctions"
- mzs 5y agoor this for the sentencing itself: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/us-citizen-who-conspired-assist-north-korea-evading-sanctions-sentenced-over-five-years-and https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/us-citizen-who-conspired-assi...
- cormacrelf 5y agoYes, the pleading is from September last year.
- wolverine876 5y agoBusiness Insider isn't a great source, but I don't like primary sources: They will be very biased in their own interest. A good secondary source can provide context, information from sources that disagree or have other perspectives or concerns, etc. That's one reason Wikipedia requires secondary sources.
- flatearth22 5y ago
- otterley 5y agoHN guidelines require primary sources. People can post those alternate views and links to supporting articles in the comments.
- cormacrelf 5y agoThis is like... the weirdest post to bring that up on. DoJ announcements are some of the driest, most precisely worded press releases from any organisation on the planet. You could not hope for a better primary source. When you read "co-conspirators", did you think oh, DoJ is biased, they're using heavily charged terms to make us feel a certain way? They aren't! He was charged with a conspiracy offence. That's what the people he conspired with are called.
- insulfrable 5y agoCome on! The man already got a PhD! Doesn't that count as time served?
- erdos4d 5y agoI was under he impression that NK already had a rather sophisticated cryptocurrency capability and was already using it to evade sanctions, as well as for criminal operations. I mean, anyone who can install software can send/receive cryptocurrency, it's trivial. This seems more like a political prosecution than about any material harm the guy did.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoNot that I'm particularly fond of one mafia gang or the other (yes, the USA government is less damaging to its citizens compared to North Korea - but they are both evil aggressors), but this is a weird hill to die on for Griffith. Why do something so blatantly illegal? I understand disrespecting the made up laws some idiot bureaucrats come up with, but I don't understand allowing their hired guns to lock you up for 5 years.
- tptacek 5y agoCalled it. :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21666694 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21666694 Doing the guidelines sentence exercise is sort of fun, in a nerd-snipey way, and is a way to understand a bit of how federal criminal law works for us non-lawyers.
- tinybrotosaurus 5y agoAnd what exactly one exercises by doing that?
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not sure I understand the question, but the exercise I'm talking about is pulling up the federal sentencing guidelines and working out a guideline sentence.
- dionidium 5y agoTech nerds (like myself) tend to think in terms of software and protocols. "If the server responds with a 200 OK to your request, then that means by definition that it gave you permission!" But this is a reminder that that's basically absurd. The government can actually just lock you up for violating the law and it doesn't matter what the stupid protocol says.
- wolverine876 5y agoHere's a NY Times from the time of the arrest which has many relevant details: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/02/nyregion/north-korea-virgil-griffin-cyptocurrency-arrest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/02/nyregion/north-korea-virg...
- timcavel 5y ago
- kache_ 5y agowhy people mess with the government, I do not know pay your damn taxes! And don't defect sanctioned research to unfriendly enemy states!
- tofuahdude 5y agoIt seems like such a low bar! "Don't break federal law by expressly teaching sanctioned nations how to bypass YOUR OWN COUNTRY'S rules" seems like table stakes on passable intelligence. I cannot believe how many people in these comments are defending this guy.
- csours 5y agoFrom yesterday's Money Stuff (not about this incident): "Yeah. There is a vein of crypto libertarianism that imagines that you can have money that is immune from the claims of society, but that’s only really true if the rest of your life is immune from the claims of society. If you live alone on a faraway island and have a lot of weapons then sure right maybe the authorities can’t seize your Bitcoins. (Though you also can’t use your Bitcoins to, like, order pizza delivery.) But if they can toss you in jail until you cough up your Bitcoins, then the Bitcoins aren’t doing that much for you." https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-12/will-elon-musk-buy-more-twitter https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-12/will-e...
- flatearth22 5y ago
- jl2718 5y agoAn interview with a DPRK defector about this: https://unchainedpodcast.com/yeonmi-park-on-why-doing-business-with-north-korea-is-like-buying-a-ticket-to-a-concentration-camp/ https://unchainedpodcast.com/yeonmi-park-on-why-doing-busine...
- siruncledrew 5y agoThe main lesson of the story is not that he was using crypto, but that he was conscientiously trying to enrich himself by conducting illegal activities with a sanctioned dictatorship. Personally, if he’s being this blunt about his intentions, then it shouldn’t be a surprise that his actions landed him consequences.
- ttybird2 5y agoReposting it from the previous thread: He is the creator of WikiScanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiScanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiScanner https://www.reuters.com/article/us-security-wikipedia-idUSN1642896020070816 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-security-wikipedia-idUSN1... He also created Tor2web with Aaron Swartz and used to work for the tor team. Seems like an interesting guy. It's a shame that this happened. The situation is kinda similar to the one with Bobby Fischer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Fischer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Fischer "In 1992, he reemerged to win an unofficial rematch against Spassky. It was held in Yugoslavia, which was under a United Nations embargo at the time. His participation led to a conflict with the US government, which warned Fischer that his participation in the match would violate an executive order imposing US sanctions on Yugoslavia. The US government ultimately issued a warrant for his arrest. After that, Fischer lived as an émigré. In 2004, he was arrested in Japan and held for several months for using a passport that the US government had revoked. Eventually, he was granted an Icelandic passport and citizenship by a special act of the Icelandic Althing, allowing him to live there until his death in 2008."
- tofuahdude 5y agoIt's a shame that he took these actions or that he was punished for them?
- ttybird2 5y agoFor me personally the second. But I am sure that regardless of what we think regarding what he did, we can all agree that it's a shame that someone like that won't be around to work on cool tech due to his sentencing, kinda like with Hans Reiser.
- paxys 5y agoHe always had the option to work on cool tech. What he instead chose to do was go to North Korea and educate them on how to use Ethereum.
- 5y ago
- locallost 5y agoIf North Korea did this, it would be further proof that they're a dictatorship. But alas, where they have their ruthless dictator, we have our* rule of law. *I am not American. I wish I get to see in my lifetime that this vicious misuse of moral values by the US finally ends, but I am not optimistic. By misuse I mean pretending that certain actions are done on moral grounds, while looking the other way when they or their allies do the same things.
- m3kw9 5y agoSure, but NK not already using crypto would be news to anyone.
- lizardactivist 5y agoThis is wrong on so many levels. The U.S. doesn't get to decide who gets to use blockchain, or whatever technology.
- tofuahdude 5y agoThe U.S. did not decide who gets to use it. The U.S. punished a U.S. citizen for violating national law. That's very different from deciding who gets to use a technology.
- tinybrotosaurus 5y agoAnd what was the purpose of said law again? If i increase the price of cars by a 1000x, am i not deciding who gets to buy and then use one? I'm making it harder to buy cars with the intention of less people using it, just like carbon taxes and the like.
- erie 5y agoBut some may hint at 'pay back' for old grievances : June 3, 2009. SFI researcher, Virgil Griffith, created a program called WikiScanner, which tracks computers used to make changes and edits to Wikipedia entries. WikiScanner revealed CIA and FBI computers were used to edit topics on the Iraq War and the Guantanamo prison. https://www.santafe.edu/news-center/news/media-channel-cia-and-fbi-computers-used-for-wikipedia-edits https://www.santafe.edu/news-center/news/media-channel-cia-a...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 29athrowaway 5y agoAre crypto currencies affected by export regulations on cryptography?
- daenz 5y agoHow to make a supervillain, step 1 Jokes aside, after 5 years, I'm not sure how he will not hold a serious grudge (if he didn't have one already) against the USA.
- hvs 5y agoI think he pretty clearly already didn't agree with the USA since he ignored the fact that they told him he couldn't go and violated sanctions. I'm pretty sure they aren't worried about him "holding a grudge".
- daenz 5y agoI think it would be smart to keep an eye on people who hate the USA, especially when they demonstrate capability and intent.
- mort96 5y agoWait the title calls this guy a cryptography expert but nowhere in the article is that mentioned again? He just seems to be a cryptocurrency researcher?
- some_random 5y agoGood. Sanction busting for one of the most evil regimes in the world is reprehensible.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 5y agoUnless NK operatives are totally ineffective when it comes to searching the internet, I have a hard time figuring out how he helped them do something they would have no trouble figuring out for themselves.
- nathias 5y agoIt's really astounding the lengths people will go to in order to rationalize their dealings with tyrannical regimes, but yea North Korea is obviously also bad.
- imchillyb 5y agoThe warrior sliced off yet another head. The Hydra wailed and spat its venom, taking scarce notice of the loss. Another head was already growing in its place. Punishment avails only when the lucrative prospect of crime is diminished by said punishment. The US government is attempting to slay Hydras with a spoon.
- usr1106 5y agoI thought free speech is a holy thing for US citizens. So speaking abroad about something that is not classified secret is a crime?
- teleforce 5y agoIt's interesting to note that this guy is a graduate of Caltech, the same university as Hal Finney that many people believe to be the founder of Bitcoin[1]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_bitcoin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_bitcoin
- jll29 5y agoVirgil is at it again. I met him at a summer school a couple of years ago, a remarkable character. He developed WikiScanner, which exposed the "beautification" of U.S. politician's Wikipedia pages, conducted from the White House and other government building's IP addresses, which was creative and in the public interest. I'm surprised that giving a talk about blockchain and crypto-currencies would be considered that sensitive, as the whole Web is full of (open source) software and instructions how to use Ethereum, the ETH currency and related stuff. > Griffith: I need to send 1 [REDACTED UNIT OF CRYPTOCURRENCY] between North and South Korea. Other Guy: "Isn't that in violations of sanctions?" Griffith: It is. Strange: The Virgil Griffith that I met was very smart, not sure if he would have had such an exchange in an unencrypted medium. He came across as an ultra-tech savvy prankster that had also hacked his high school's payment system (he did not say that because he was prevented under court order, so he just quipped "google me"). Here's an EdTech talks he gave 2019: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymGl84RORLQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymGl84RORLQ Edit: I was wondering about that strange redaction of "[UNIT OF CRYPTOCURRENCY]". Clearly, as he is working on Ethereum, that one has the ETH currency, so likely it was that. Could the unredacted just say "1 ETH" (not a secret)? Then the transfer would have just been symbolic, not actually evading sanctions at scale. On the other hand if he was (allegedly) talking about 1 million ETH or BTC then it would smell more like a serious crime, assuming for a moment that exchange really happened. [BTW, 1 ETH = ~$3,000 versus 1 BTC = $40,000 at the moment, so the unit makes an order of magnitude difference.]
- Eavolution 5y agoIf he was trying to help the DPRK government, I have no sympathy for him. But if he was trying to help innocent people get around sanctions I kind of feel different. I've always felt uncomfortable with sanctions affecting individuals who had nothing to do with the reason the countries being sanctioned.