18 ms·
Dual 75“ 4K TV Floor Computing
- _8j50 5y agoGood luck sharing your screen on a remote call with that.
- frankwiles 5y agoHalf crazy, half awesome. 100% tempted!
- jaqalopes 5y agoI guess the idea behind this share is to get people's thoughts. To that end, I'm totally in favor of this honestly. Only reason I won't do something like this is that it's very space intensive and won't fit in my apartment. But if I could I would. Why not? My eyes aren't getting any better with age, and even my costly "good" office chair gets uncomfortable after a couple hours.
- rwc 5y agoLove it in theory, but the strain of moving your head to see the full dimensions of the screens would get old. Eyes are good at darting around a smaller screen up close, don’t know that the entire head and neck would appreciate that day in and day out.
- georgewsinger 5y agoThis is only an issue if the pixel density of the screens is small (forcing you to blow windows up larger, which forces you to crank your neck around more to see an entire screen). If the pixel density is high enough, you can compress tons of genuine screens together within your eye-gazing FOV, and even sit close to the screens.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoSure but then there's tons of screen area you're not using. If you're only going to look at a 32" FOV on a 75" screen, why not just get a 32" screen?
- georgewsinger 5y agoFrom the comments: > I’m curious as to how this affected your productivity Answer: > Productivity is through the roof. Even when noodling about on small side projects I find you so quickly end up with so much things open that you're constantly flipping between, so to have multiple terminals, text editors, reference documentation, version control, etc, immediately accessible is, honestly, life changing.
- tga 5y agoI definitely agree with that take when talking about running two 4k monitors at full resolution, but it doesn’t address the size at all. The more reasonable approach would be to use two ~38-42” monitors.
- that_guy_iain 5y agoOne 32 inch 4k monitor massively improves my ability to get stuff done. I'm tempted to get another one to see how it goes.
- bdcravens 5y agoI used to love "smaller" fonts and whatnot. Unfortunately my 45 year old eyes can't do it anymore. These days I stick with 2 32" at QHD. I've always used my laptop open for things like the terminal etc, but I find that's a bit too small unless I'm sitting directly in front of it (coffee shop etc)
- happimess 5y agoAlternate take: I achieve constant-time access (mod key + digit) to all those things with 10 workspaces in i3. I can't imagine having to see them all at once. Realistically, I'm only actually thinking about 1 or 2 of them at a time. If I need to check documentation, I'm no longer thinking about my build output. Slack, email, and calendar are disconnected from development tools. And if I need to do a quick context shift, I can switch over instantly.
- 5y ago
- CoastalCoder 5y agoHow is this different from having smaller monitors, closer to the user? Does it come down to the distances at which the user can comfortably focus their eyes?
- woleium 5y agofor many people (esp as you get older) the longer focal distance will be easier on the eyes.
- mgerdts 5y agoI have a 4k 28" monitor which I can't use at its highest resolution with 100% scaling and a 4k 40" TV that is a few inches further away which I can comfortably use at its highest resolution with 100% scaling. I'm a big fan of the setup I have and suspect I would be equally happy with a slightly larger display (maybe up to 55") a bit further away. Maybe the 28" screen would be more usable with computer glasses. With the 40" screen, I can see fine with my regular glasses. 75" seems a bit extreme, as it would require a few more feet of distance between me and the screen to make the screen fit into my field of view. I could see it as beneficial and quite usable in a situation where you need high resolution with many people viewing it.
- corysama 5y agoPretty much. That and how much your view changes when you move your head. I’ve played with virtual monitors in VR. Everyone loves the idea of having 80 foot virtual monitors. But, all that really does is make it so you can’t move your head in close to examine the low-rez text like you can with smaller virtual monitors up close.
- Fauntleroy 5y agoI use a single 65" 8k monitor about 4ft away (behind my actual desk). While this affords quite a bit of space, text rendering at small sizes (even with the ridiculous resolution), is simply not ideal. If I were only getting a screen for productivity / dev purposes, I would definitely seek a large monitor instead of a giant TV.
- hirundo 5y agoI use a 65" monitor at about 12 feet away for comms, and a 27" monitor close up for code. I'm looking forward to football stadium sized monitors in VR.
- twoodfin 5y agoThe biggest challenge with a setup like this would seem to be mapping the user’s focus to the UI focus. Traditional pointing devices and window selection highlighting would be suboptimal. But I expect these problems will be solved via gesture or eye tracking + new modes of interaction for AR/VR. In particular, curious what Apple’s going to end up doing for their headset.
- soared 5y agoI don’t know if we’re talking about the same problem, but I previously solved something similar by binding a key that modified mouse speed. So if I need to go large distances with the mouse I hit the modifier and it zipped over super fast, let go of the key, and was back to normal speed. I replaced my desktop/keyboard/mouse with an Xbox controller/rpi for a while in college just for kicks. Worked great.
- rolobio 5y agoI’ve found that a 32” QHD monitor is the highest PPI my eyes can comfortably read. I tried to use a 4K TV as my monitor, but I needed something like 55” up close to read it comfortably. It was simply too large and I had to move my neck too much. Also, that was the day I learned some pixels are chevrons!
- turtlebits 5y ago32" QHD is ~ 92ppi. Are you saying that you can't differentiate any greater than that, or you get actual physical discomfort above that? If you are talking about UI size - that can be adjusted.
- legalcorrection 5y agoWindows supports fractional display scaling with perfect crisp text and graphics. MacOS doesn’t, but it can do integer scaling at least. (Edit: I’ve been corrected. Apparently macOS does do fractional scaling, but in a way that causes blur). Text size and resolution don’t need to be bound.
- tossoutijsbshsu 5y agoi use linux on a retina macbook @ 2880x1800 and fractional scaling works well in swaywm. they warn against it in the docs, but no problems so far (though it's only been a week)
- wlesieutre 5y agomacOS has scales between 1x and 2x. It doesn’t tell you what the scale factor actually is as a number, just a couple of options between “More space” and “Larger text”. IIRC the way it’s implemented is by rendering 2x and downscaling, so sometime’s it’s not as pixel perfect as Windows. But the simpler implementation for software developers meant they had like a 10 year head start compared to Windows where software takes a long time to support up new OS features.
- telesilla 5y agoThere are also 3rd party apps for finer control of resolutions and displays on macOS, such as SwitchResX
- prettyStandard 5y agoI use a 4k 49" tv on my desk as a monitor. Let's me snap 4 screens to the corners. The neck strain isn't great, though sometimes I will underscan the screen and that fixes the neck strain.
- tga 5y agoI use a 40” screen about 80 cm away, and it’s almost the perfect size. I think it would be even better with a curve, because text right on a corner (like a terminal prompt) is a bit of a stretch.
- smartbit 5y agoregretfully curved UHD 40” aren’t sold anymore. The MMD Philips BDM4037UW was available from dec '16 till summer '19.
- razvvan 5y agoI guess it depends on what you do with it but the cognitive load of the potential situation that would need all that realestate... unsettles me.
- mhh__ 5y agoI think recently I've been fiddling around with my monitor when my real issue is the angle of my arms and posture due to my chair, even if it manifests as being tense and unable to focus on the monitor.
- drewolbrich 5y agoAt this scale, I'm concerned about latency due to the speed of light travel time.
- QuikAccount 5y agoIf you aren't gaming then latency concerns are really overblown.
- cma 5y agoIt's just a joke, light only takes 3 nanoseconds to go a meter.
- uo21tp5hoyg 5y agocould be 2 nanoseconds if you built it in Rust.
- fb03 5y agoI propose a new movement: RRIR instead of RIIR Rewrite Reality In Rust!
- throwaway684936 5y agoThey were obviously joking talking about light speed, but I strongly disagree. Even ignoring how it improves the feel of typing, I'm a mouse-using heretic and it makes a huge difference with mice.
- computator 5y agoDo you think such a setup would be helpful for an elderly relative whose eyesight is getting worse? Even with glasses, the relative has trouble with a 27-inch desktop monitor with 2560 x 1440 pixels. Specifically, I was thinking of using an Ultra High Definition TV (49-inch with 3840 x 2160 pixels) but setting the resolution at 2560 x 1440. So it would be the same resolution but everything would be bigger. Would it help?
- layer8 5y agoIt depends on the distance they can best focus on. Then choose the display size accordingly. I.e. a huge display won’t work if they are near-sighted.
- haunter 5y agoIt can help for sure. The longer focal length itself is a huge difference but I'd test it out somehow (renting, borrowing etc.) before investing into something like this >I was thinking of using an Ultra High Definition TV (49-inch with 3840 x 2160 pixels) but setting the resolution at 2560 x 1440. So it would be the same resolution but everything would be bigger. I'd rather use OS level UI scaling you will have sharper and better picture
- computator 5y ago> I'd rather use OS level UI scaling you will have sharper and better picture I tried various OS scaling methods. The problem with "magnify or zoom in on the whole screen" is that it's very cumbersome for an elderly person, easily getting lost on where you are on the screen. The problem with an OS configuration to make all text and icons bigger is that it doesn't do it for everything — many text labels, buttons, menus, etc., remain at a small font. That's why I'm hoping a hardware-level solution (a much bigger display) is the answer.
- ______-_-______ 5y agoCouldn't you get an equivalent focal length by wearing reading glasses?
- FlyingAvatar 5y agoI use 3x 27" 4K monitors in portrait mode side by side with my Macbook Pro screen at the end. This gives me about 10 normal screen sized areas. I usually have the following things open in specific spots: - General Browser (mostly for email and weather) - Calendar - Terminal - Text Editor - Desktop Mode Browser for App in Development - Detached Debug Console for the above - Mobile View Browser for App in Development with attached Debug Console - Browser for documentation / reference - To Do List - Slack
- jwr 5y agoI'll present a different data point. I also used to like multiple monitor setups, using up to three monitors. And then I realized that I'd much rather have a single good quality screen, because there is less fussing around with things. A 27" iMac 5k screen got me enough screen real estate to be happy. These days I am looking for single-monitor solutions, at 27" — anything larger and you need to turn your head. (incidentally, 5K vs 4K makes a huge practical difference for me: in my full-screen Emacs I can comfortably fit three columns of code on a 5K screen, but on 4K this is problematic)
- caffeine 5y agoHave you tried 2x 27” screens vertically, ideally models with minimal bezel? I’ve found that it doesn’t increase head turning because it’s not much wider than a single screen, but I can fit twice as much stuff. Also I can read a much longer file of code at once, which is more useful than you’d expect..
- boulos 5y agoThat's been my setup for the last decade (currently a pair of U2720Q monitors). macOS unfortunately does a worse job with "font smoothing" when using the monitors vertically, but it's fine. The main downside is that since most people (obviously) use their displays in landscape mode, lots of websites and applications are pretty antagonistic to a tall and thin display. (Spreadsheets are often quite bad, but there are lots of places where people eat up horizontal space for padding or side bars that are suddenly super annoying). There's a bit of a push to larger, ultrawide 5k2k monitors (e.g., Dell's U4021Q or the delayed-by-a-year-not-actually-available LG 40WP95C) but a pair of high resolution 27s is still a lot more pixel density. These bigger ones also tend to have lower brightness, presumably do to power and thermal targets per display.
- legalcorrection 5y agoThe guy claims he uses the keyboard by hunching over the side table[1]. That is so comically anti-ergonomic (most people would get back pain within an hour or two, and be bedridden within a couple of days) that I think this is fake and posted on Reddit for karma/trolling purposes. Consider also that to focus on another window requires the user to substantially turn his head. This would very quickly cause neck strain. Our inclination is to believe things are real, but people do just go on the internet and lie. A lot. [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/battlestations/comments/toecyt/dual_75_4k_tv_floor_computing/i25yqv6/ https://old.reddit.com/r/battlestations/comments/toecyt/dual...
- seattle_spring 5y agoMy thoughts as well. This looks like an ergonomic nightmare.
- fleaaa 5y agoAttaching split keyboard on the armrest with a trackball or trackpoint would be a sweet spot.
- globular-toast 5y agoThere's no way anyone is doing any serious typing with such setup. I can imagine it if keyboard use is minimal. Not sure what job that would be but I'm sure there are some.
- peterhajas 5y agoI’ve used 4K 39”/40” televisions (originally 3, now 1) for the past 8 years. I find that the panels look great, and they give me a huge working area. They’re also really reasonable - $250 - $350 for a good TV. They last a while. Smaller 4K/5K panels (with more pixels per inch) are nice, but I never understood the push for density. I’d rather have more workspace with lower density.
- turtlebits 5y agoHigher PPI makes things clearer and easier to read for me.
- hyakosm 5y agoHi-DPI panels gives you more choice for UI density.
- mnkmnk 5y agoI am tempted to do this, at least as a FU to the monitor industry. There is so little innovation in monitor tech! Why are monitors so expensive and old tech compared to TVs? I just want an affordable large monitor with 120Hz refresh rate and USB-C for coding, but options are quite limited. All monitor innovation is into HDR and super high refresh rate which I don’t care about. And prices seem artificially high.
- Nbox9 5y agoI really enjoy the 49” ultrawide 1000R format Samsung has been pioneering. It’s the size/resolution of two 27” 1440p monitors next to each other, has a buttery smooth refresh rate, and a curve that makes viewing more comfortable and natural. The new quantum dot displays are also very innovative.
- metadat 5y agoWhat do you like about the qDots vs "regular" pixels?
- thfuran 5y agoSamsung's newest qd displays are qdoled so you get extremely fast response time and very high contrast ratio and the dots give high color saturation so the color volume is very large. Brightness is also high (for an oled).
- Nbox9 5y agoThey are just an improvement on the OLED technology, with reduced burnin risk and brighter pixels being the largest improvement.
- lordnacho 5y agoI've seen trading firms do this. Why have 8 monitors when you can just have one giant screen? All you do with it is show some app, doesn't need to be special.
- Arubis 5y ago
- bombcar 5y agoI have four monitors connected to my Mac. The two centrals are ultrawides (34UB88-P) on top of each other - the lower one is the main window where the action happens - the one above is the secondary where terminals and other monitoring processes happen). The main is large enough for work and references to be next to each other. The 4K on the right (run at hi-dpi) is for various non-work chat programs, reference images, etc. the 4K on the left is for work chat and Finder windows, and the laptop display itself holds email. It works well. The main advantage is being able to glance at chats without switching windows.
- tailspin2019 5y agoAs a fellow multi-monitor geek, I’d love to see a photo of this setup!
- Synaesthesia 5y agoHow big is your desk?
- bombcar 5y agoIt’s a normal size desk. The key is lots of vesa mount arms.
- temp8964 5y agoThe reason this can be superior to desk computing is that it gives you more vertical space. Desk computing removes the lower half of your vertical space because of the desk. Imagine in the future, the desk surface is also a screen, we can put some supporting apps like calendar, notebook, todo list, etc. on the desk. That will be really nice. In his setup, he can literally add another screen by laying another TV on the floor.
- throw0101a 5y agoThe Dashews, a couple who design offshore boats (sail and power), after a few years of experimentation, ended up coming to a similar design for their navigation station their FPB line of powerboats: * https://setsail.com/rethinking_modern_nav-2-2/ https://setsail.com/rethinking_modern_nav-2-2/ May not be able to do this on the deck of a traditional sailboat where things are exposed to the elements, but in an enclosed wheelhouse it adds a lot of flexibility, especially with modern the NMEA 2000 data bus and various vendor 'black boxes' (or leverage a Raspberry Pi), e.g.: * https://mvdirona.com/2016/09/maretron-n2kview-on-dirona/ https://mvdirona.com/2016/09/maretron-n2kview-on-dirona/ Aside: the owner of the above linked Dirona is James Hamilton, VP & Distinguished Engineer at Amazon.
- blamazon 5y agoWow. I am blown away by the photos in that FPB link. I'm not a boat person but it's unlike any boat pilot house I have seen before. A great room indeed.
- throw0101a 5y agoThe Dashews seems to regularly think 'out of the box'. They took their decades of experience in sailboat design, especially to hull shapes, and applied them to a power boat (so they could continue to travel in old/er age): * https://setsail.com/the-concept-explained/ https://setsail.com/the-concept-explained/ * https://setsail.com/intro-to-fpb-program/ https://setsail.com/intro-to-fpb-program/ * https://setsail.com/category/fpb-78/ https://setsail.com/category/fpb-78/ YT channel: * https://www.youtube.com/user/DashewOffshore https://www.youtube.com/user/DashewOffshore A tour of one of their earlier sailboat designs that is/was for sale recently: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrDxYkSI710 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrDxYkSI710
- throwra620 5y ago
- walrus01 5y agoI'm skeptical how well that display on the left side of the nav-2-2 URL holds up for visibility under direct powerful sunlight. Even if it's a very expensive model.
- dylan604 5y agoThis is a godsend for all of the people that love to read what's on their co-workers' screens.
- Trasmatta 5y agoSpeaking of monitors, I got one of those absurd 49" ultra widescreen displays a few months ago. The resolution is 5120x1440, so it's functionally equivalent to two 27" 1440p monitors placed side by side. The text is naturally not as crisp as a 4K monitor, but the amount of screen real estate is great for development. Paired with a tiling window manager it gives so many options. I did the dual 27" 1440p thing for years, and I find this setup superior. With the dual monitor strategy you have to either deal with a huge bezel right in the center of your vision, or push the secondary monitor off to the side, requiring more neck movement to see what's on it. With this monitor, everything remains much more clearly in my field of view.
- matsemann 5y agoBiggest gripe for me with the curved displays is that 1440px in height is not really that much. Kinda blurry when one's used to a 4k display with 2160px over the same vertical distance.
- Trasmatta 5y agoYeah, if you're used to 4K, the resolution will definitely feel like a step down. For my personal usage, I've found the horizontal space to be really beneficial for development. YMMV.
- unethical_ban 5y agoI would be less scared of one of those monitors, if I could use them as two virtual monitors - that is, the OS would split it down the middle and treat them with separate wallpapers (if desired), along with the keypresses and mouse shortcuts associated with tiling/managing dual monitors.
- tuvan 5y agoI believe all of them have a "picture by picture" mode where left half shows one input and right half shows another input. You could achieve what you want with 2 cables. But I haven't felt the need for such use. I use Microsoft Powertoys to tile a 16:9 area in the center and two half width areas on the sides and I am very happy with that setup. I am sure linux window tilers have even better capability.
- whartung 5y agoSo, I look at this and it reminds me of a trivial experiment I did in a hotel room, which is sort of the opposite of what these people are doing. Simply, I took my phone and held it up in front of me, a comfortable distance from my face, and covered the hotel TV with it. At that point, it's easy to realize that the phone screen isn't necessarily too small, at least for "TV" watching, because, net, the screens are the "same size" in terms of consumed field of view. In the end it was the same if you could watch it comfortably (which is a different problem).
- wasmitnetzen 5y agoIt does make a difference on eye strain, since they need to focus to a point much closer.
- sometimeshuman 5y agoA constant focal point is not good for eye health either. I had considered converting my two monitor setup to one traditional monitor and one project that is > 10ft away. But projectors have too many disadvantages atm (e.g., high power consumption, brightness, etc.).
- noja 5y agoPerhaps an alternative would be to suspend a screen from a drone that is constantly moving around the room. It would combine eye muscle exercise with neck exercise. For extra points, the screen could be configured for me to chase after it, providing ever more opportunities for exercise.
- cma 5y agoYou can also shift to more postures the farther back the display is and it will still take up roughly the same field of view no matter how you move, whereas with small monitors you can't both sit up straight and lean back without drastically changing pixels per degree of vision.
- cma 5y ago
- amelius 5y agoGuy should have better spent some money on nice furniture, imho.
- karmakaze 5y agoThis reminds me of a vivid dream I had in university, where the room I programmed in had source code displayed on the floor and I could scroll or walk around and browse it. The listing on the floor had that wide green-and-white band printer 'paper' look. Don't remember if it went all skeuomorphic with rendered perforated edges and holes. It also had other printer type things that were just sitting there not printing at the time. And for a reason I never understood there was a large pixelated volumetric figure of my housemate Bill also in the room like a 3/4 life-size Lego figure. As I interpreted it at the time, I didn't think the figure was generated in real-time as to be able to instantly into something else. It didn't feel virtual, and augmented reality wasn't a concept at the time. I suppose in theory it could be fully rendered in roomscale VR if my hands and arms looked and moved accurately enough.
- cloudking 5y agoHaving tried multiple sizes and resolutions, personally I've found 27" 2560x1440 (2K) to be the sweet spot for desktop computing and gaming. Very happy with https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B08LCNWQWL https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B08LCNWQWL
- emacs28 5y agoI find curved displays much nicer to look at on the edges. I hope spherically curved monitors come out some day too. I use a 32" 2160p 4K curved display (1500R). It's harder to find than the 1440p curved displays but they're out there. Also, I find I prefer looking straight in front of me best and don't really use anything more than a single 4k display. I try to improve my app switching skills & tools before using more monitors.
- didip 5y agoIf I have the budget and the space and wife’s approval, I think the scorpion desk is better and a lot more ergonomics. https://www.amazon.com/Imperator-Scorpion-Gaming-Computer-Office/dp/B08HYRNJCH https://www.amazon.com/Imperator-Scorpion-Gaming-Computer-Of...
- passivate 5y agoHah, just looking at this gives me a headache. When I last tried such experiments (5+ yrs), I found that none of the display panels I had access to played nice with sub-pixel font rendering. Also now that I'm used to smaller 120hz panels, I can never go back to 60/75hz.
- prosaic-hacker 5y agoThis is a scaled up version of my setup for my adult son, who is legally blind. We setup 2 of these as our "zoom" stations at the beginning of the pandemic. A good chair/sofa up close the TV, 55" UHD TV connected to a Lenovo laptop with a wireless keyboard and trackpad combo. My son's TV is also connected to the cable box, WII, DVD players (Reg & BR) These are not some sort of high performance workstation just a cheap and dirty solution. Everything was in the house , Laptops from 2016, TVs and keyboards from the last couple of years of Black Friday sales and a few HDMI Cables. I saw someone else's setup with a dual recliner that had integrated Fold away TV tables that the keyboard and mouse sat on. It was a gaming setup.
- zrail 5y agoI use a 43" 4K LG monitor (not TV) as my every day work screen, positioned about five feet from my face. I have macOS set to scale it up about 25". I can't really say I'm more productive on it than just using my laptop, but I definitely notice less eye strain when I'm using the big monitor.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- etchalon 5y agoNo. Just. No.
- russellbeattie 5y agoI recently turned 50 and though I've had to wear glasses for long distance vision my entire life, my arm-length distance has only just succumbed to age. I just got a new prescription, but for the past year I've been bobbing my head back and forth to my screens like a chicken. The solution is now bifocals, or multi-vision contacts which leave everything - both close and distant - slightly blurry. I can't say I'm in love with either solution, but that's life. But hey! I like this idea! I could dial in my contacts prescription for 20/20 distance vision and just sit back in my La-Z-Boy. It might be a bit awkward going back to the office...
- jiveturkey 5y agoThat's a really tiny chair and keyboard.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoAnd 8k is coming.... I'll probably get a big 50-55" 8k for the main and try to put my 1-2 40" 4ks on the flanks. If you're not twitch gaming, TVs are such a better bang for the buck.
- Kiro 5y agoReadable link on mobile: https://www.reddit.com/r/battlestations/comments/toecyt/dual_75_4k_tv_floor_computing/ https://www.reddit.com/r/battlestations/comments/toecyt/dual...
- DesiLurker 5y agoThis abomination is what happens when you let peasants WFH for way too long. seriously though I have thought about doing a projector to ceiling so I could code lying down on bed with zero stress on back.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoI tried comparing using a 75" 4K TV to a 32" 4K monitor and the biggest issue is that you have to sit just a bit closer to the 75" TV then typical living room use would dictate which means moving furniture, etc. A much easier trick is getting nice monitor arms that let you position your 32" 4K monitors better, it's often the monitor stand that prevents proper positioning. In my case one monitor is hovering a whole 1" back from my keyboard which would be impossible with the stock stand.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoLooks cool, but I found that too many monitors is more light radiation blaring into my eye sockets, and I found if causing inability to sleep normally as well as possibly affecting my vision. I had a 75" TV but the amount of light that thing emitted hurt my eyes if I watched it too much. I went back from 4 monitors to just two, a 32" 4k one and a 1920p one for screen sharing in meetings with people with normal size monitors. And a smaller TV :)
- dave333 5y agoWonder how many years before every wall is a screen that will be installed like wallpaper.