23 ms·
EU to make it mandatory to use customer-replaceable batteries in household items
- LinAGKar 5y agoTo save people some time: https://www-faz-net.translate.goog/aktuell/wirtschaft/eu-parlament-will-festverklebte-handy-akkus-verbieten-17867864.html?_x_tr_sl=de&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=sv&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-faz-net.translate.goog/aktuell/wirtschaft/eu-par...
- narrator 5y agoIf they wanted to cut down on e-waste, they'd let consumer electronics use lead solder again. With the whole tin whiskers issue, consumer electronics will regularly have to continue to be thrown out regularly.
- jmainh 5y agoprinter business, your end may be near
- netfl0 5y agoOverdue for sure. I wonder if there could be unintended side effects, I can’t think of any…
- judge2020 5y agoDepending on what it actually does, we can predict side effects by imagining it was in place 10 years ago. What if the Apple Watch required a user-replaceable battery? Would the design have changed demonstrably to accommodate this design restriction?
- netfl0 5y agoIn that case it would probably affect water resistance.
- lizardactivist 5y agoImportant to note here is that when it comes to household gadgets and personal electronics, not everything needs to be engineered to have water resistance like a diver's watch. Making sure something survives splashes or a minute at the bottom of the swimming pool will be enough to keep most of these things working.
- user_7832 5y agoWater resistance was my first thought as well, however I suspect a company with the R&D budget of Apple could likely find a way. The small dimensions of the watch might be a problem, but for phones I'm fairly certain it can be done. For a while companies like Motorola were selling nano-repellent (essentially hydrophobic) coating phones and calling them splash proof. You could easily design a gasket or something, existing waterproof phones already have parts that open for eg the sim card or microsd slot (which are gasketed).
- everdrive 5y agoI've got an IP-68 (or whatever is waterproof) phone with a user-replaceable batter. It effectively has weather stripping along the battery door, and uses a screw to keep it tight. It's cheap, simple, and effective. (and no, it's not a smart phone)
- choko 5y agoSo this would impact big players less, leaving startups in a more difficult position. That's regressive.
- Tams80 5y agoIf they want to design, manufacture, and sell rugged devices, then they should shoulder the costs. If they don't want to, then they can make something less rugged. No excuses for resource waste and pollution.
- endemic 5y agoHaven’t we had water resistant watches for quite a long time already?
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoMore expensive phones, more materials wasted, bulkier phones.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoBut on the flip side, phones can last twice as long (or longer, assuming the software and other hardware doesn't crap out instead) and the total materials in that time are one phone plus two batteries, not two phones and two batteries.
- choko 5y agoThe choice should be up to the consumer, not the EU. We had phones with removable batteries co-exist with phones with non-removable batteries. Most people preferred a slimmer, more attractive device and chose that over a removable battery. Ditto with keyboards. I would have preferred a phone with a hardware keyboard and a removable battery, but my tastes are niche. That doesn't mean I want a regulator to force the issue.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoExcept it's never a straight choice to a consumer. If a company asked me do I want 50% more battery life or 1mm thinner, I'm going for the battery. And lots of people would. How many people moan about their battery, and how many say "ooo, I with this phone was just a hair thinner"? But you don't get a choice, because it's all bundled up with other features to make it for you. Want NFC? Ok, you have to have the flagship model with the thinner case. Oh, you want the bigger battery, sorry we don't actually do one because we only had one model called the FailChungus 0.1 with a big battery and no one bought it (never mind that it came only in brown and had a 480x480 screen). Same for the 3.5mm jacks: no one has ever gone out and deliberately bought a phone without them. You just don't get a choice if you want everything else. I specifically got a non-flagship phone to keep that port, but I missed out on a lot of other stuff. While it's nice to think that consumers lead these choices, I don't think that's actually what's happening: the illusion of choice is given but the companies gradually do what they wanted to do anyway.
- wyager 5y agoA couple that come to mind: This will make various compact designs difficult/impossible (such as airpods or other small wireless earbuds). This will make waterproofing difficult/impossible/lower quality for many device classes (phones, earbuds, etc). Waterproofing on these devices requires adhesive (not easily replaceable) or ultrasonic welding (not user serviceable at all).
- ComradePhil 5y agoTo keep up the sales, they will have to find other methods of planned obsolescence.
- bluescrn 5y agoWhat about EVs? It seems a big problem that 50%+ of the cost/value of a vehicle is a battery pack that will inevitably degrade over time, and that usually needs replacing in it's entirity in the event of a fault or damage. We need some sort of standardised 'battery modules' that can be shared between vehicles, replaced/upgraded, salvaged from crash-damaged vehicles, etc. Instead of one single battery pack, there'd be a bank of maybe a dozen modules. They don't need to be user-replacable, but should be replacable by any competent mechanic. Some vehicles could come with unpopulated battery module slots, for optional range upgrades. Maybe others would be sold 'batteries not included', and you could buy or lease batteries from a choice of providers.
- radicalbyte 5y agoOne of the big Chinese brands - Neo - have removable battery packs. Check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTsrDpsYHrw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTsrDpsYHrw
- sokoloff 5y agoMy LEAF had an individual battery module replaced (under warranty) and I’ve heard anecdotes of several other EV owners online with a similar repair story. They’re not “all or nothing” already. More details: https://www.mynissanleaf.com/viewtopic.php?t=30380 https://www.mynissanleaf.com/viewtopic.php?t=30380
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIt's not standard, but this basically already exists. It just makes sense for the car makers themselves to build batteries from modular components at various levels. e.g. VW group uses one MEB 'platform' across it's different brand's EVs cars/vans, and the different models with different battery sizes, have different amounts of modules like these in them: https://www.secondlife-evbatteries.com/products/vw-id3-battery-module https://www.secondlife-evbatteries.com/products/vw-id3-batte... And it's almost guaranteed, though I haven't checked, that this module contains a bunch of smaller batteries. https://www.volkswagen-newsroom.com/en/modular-electric-drive-matrix-meb-3677 https://www.volkswagen-newsroom.com/en/modular-electric-driv...
- 5y ago
- judge2020 5y agoI understand the lure to link to forums, but this one is particularly light on details; the only hard info about the law(s) is a link to the text itself. This is pretty important since the carve-outs will make or break this bill, because I doubt user replaceable batteries will be mandated for a pacemaker, electric vehicle, or high-volume home energy storage equipment like RESU battery.
- archi42 5y agoI don't like the link either. But a quick Google search didn't bring up a good English speaking source (yesterday), so I can understand tomte linking to the eevblog forums. This was published yesterday by Golem [1] (German tech news) and two days ago by the FAZ [2] (respectable German news outlet). While both might be better links, they're in German. You can try Google Translate or DeepL, which usually work pretty well. Since this is happening on the EU level there will eventually be official translations of their plans; as well as international coverage. [1] https://www.golem.de/news/nachhaltigkeit-eu-parlament-beschliesst-verbot-fest-verbauter-akkus-2203-163803.html https://www.golem.de/news/nachhaltigkeit-eu-parlament-beschl... [2] https://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/eu-parlament-will-festverklebte-handy-akkus-verbieten-17867864.html https://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/eu-parlament-will-fes...
- toyg 5y agoEU directives can be relatively light on details, at times, because they are meant to be made more explicit at the national level; the ECJ will eventually rule on the spirit of the law anyway, as soon as somebody appeals a judgement to them. Obviously a degree of common sense will be applied (i.e. peacemakers), but EV should definitely be a target - you can replace a car battery today, why should it not be possible tomorrow?
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoI don't even see the link to the text itself. I watched the EP parliament press release on Wednesday and the actual proposal is nowhere near what these headlines are saying. It has more to do about tracking components during battery manufacturing to ensure that the ecological cost is appropriately reported, that they do not come from conflict regions, promote alternatives to rare earths, etc.
- kasabali 5y agoComments in the linked thread are spot on. Manufacturers would do anything to avoid abiding spirit of that law to keep their bottom line. What's more depressing is "tech enthusiast" circle (eg. in reddit or hardware forums) will be more than eager to rationalize, defend and disseminate any weak technical excuse made up by manufacturers for keeping their anti consumer practices.
- vanderZwan 5y agoTrue, but the alternative of not pushing back leads to an even more dystopian future so I'll take picking a fight with them
- amelius 5y agoYeah, but tech enthusiasts typically prefer to stay in their comfy chairs, and in their favorite echo chambers, so they don't have any real world impact.
- hackernewds 5y agoSays the tech enthusiast on his armchair?
- avs733 5y agospeaking for myself, not the OP - I am sitting on the ground, my armchair manufacturer went out of business and the padding turned into a brick when their license server went offline.
- naoqj 5y agoI like my phone thin and sturdy and I have no interest in replacing batteries myself.
- bobbean 5y agoThere's some pretty smart people in the field, don't you think if they are forced to come up with a solution that they will?
- Duralias 5y agoI really hope a law like this actually affects something. I know it isn't a thing most people think about, but after loosing so many things to just passive battery degradation because I forgot to keep them charged, I would just really want batteries to be easier to swap. And I really cannot understand the people that want their device to be unusable if they forget to charge it. The dumbest one being VR controllers, since you quite simply cannot comfortably/usably charge them with a wire while playing, but people want integrated batteries still.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoSocialist planning economy, that is all that is. It sounds good on paper, but will just make things more wasteful and expensive. I personally haven't had top change batteries in phones for over a decade.
- assbuttbuttass 5y agoHow will this make things more wasteful? If anything it should cut down on waste by allowing people to replace just a battery rather than throwing the whole phone away
- DocTomoe 5y agoI can easily see more replaceable systems being less waterproof, leading to more water-damaged units, which means more trash and higher replacement rates. Also, nooks and crannies on stuff tends to get broken and lost (just remember how your TV remote looks after a few years), something a monoblock-style phone doesn't have. Sure, we know you can build consumer electronics to be virtually indestructible - but few people wantt to walk around with a Nokia 3310 these days. To add insult to injury, this ruling will be quoted to justify price increases. Replaceability exists on the market already, but it does not seem to be competitive outside of very niche (very ecologically-conscious folks for the fairphone, outdoor enthusiasts for ruggedized phones) customer groups.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoYou need more materials to construct the phone with a replaceable battery. You need connectors, latches for opening, screws...
- Kbelicius 5y agoYou need more resources to construct one phone with a replaceable battery than 2,3,4 or however many phones without a replaceable battery? I'm not well versed in hardware but that sounds like bullshit.
- 5y ago
- Macha 5y agoIn regards to this comment: > Guess there will be some more lawmaking involved, to define these expected lifetimes. There are expected lifetimes established as part of the track record of consumer cases about laws implementing EU directive 1999/44/EC. While some countries go further (e.g. the UK's 6 years for manufacturer defects was in place even while they were in the EU), for electronics that's usually held at 2 years for the EU minimum.
- ComradePhil 5y agoThis is a very good start. If they did the same for screens, I wouldn't be surprised if the phone sales dropped to half or even less. There is no way companies like Apple and Samsung will be OK with this. I expect big pushback from them. If these steps go through, it will be interesting to see what other planned obsolescence [1] methods will these companies go for. The one big tool Apple has is the full control of the software ecosystem. They can simply make newer apps unavailable for old phones for example. That will need to be tackled at some point. [1] Veritasium video on planned obsolescence which is interesting: https://youtu.be/j5v8D-alAKE https://youtu.be/j5v8D-alAKE
- aardvarkr 5y agoYou’re picking on apple but they’re the best when it comes to this… I don’t know a single android phone that’s still usable after five years and still gets software updates. At a certain point the old hardware just can’t handle the new OS as new features get added. Planned obsolescence is certainly a thing but you’d be wise to lobby Samsung to add updates past two years before focusing your wrath on apple. Edit: looks like Samsung bumped it up to 4 years of updates in 2019
- toyg 5y agoApple gets the stick because they effectively invented the model and pushed hard for it. Nokia-era batteries were replaceable, the the iPhone showed up and it all went to hell.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoExactly, and it wasn't just phones. It was pretty standard to be able to upgrade a ton of parts (memory, disk, boards) in a desktop PC until Apple taught the industry how to solder everything in place.
- kaladin-jasnah 5y agoYou can still upgrade a number of parts on desktop PCs (including the disks and memory). Do you mean laptops or am I unaware that desktop PCs could be upgraded even more in the past?
- causality0 5y agoSeems to be putting the cart before the horse as long as batteries are allowed to have DRM that hinders third-party replacements, but a good step nevertheless.
- im3w1l 5y agoPhones are becoming ever more expensive and at the same time the pace of improvement is slowing down. It's making more and more sense to buy a top-end phone and keep it a long time. Repair and maintainability of phones is thus going to become more important. But I don't know if it's necessary that the an ordinary user can do it themselves.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoBattery and/or display replacement has become almost as expensive as a new device starting around 2019. In the iPhone 6 times, you could have your display replaced for about 50-60 EUR, and your battery for as low as 30 EUR. Not so with newer devices, whether Apple or Android ones.
- alisonkisk 5y ago
- bencollier49 5y agoThe next thing I'd like to see is a rule on maintaining security updates for devices beyond 3-4 years. I'm going to have to give up my perfectly operating 4/5 year old Samsung phone shortly because it'll be falling into the "no support" bracket.
- walterbell 5y agoMicrosoft Linux on Azure Sphere devices come with 10 years of security updates. If an Azure Sphere network router gains traction, it could influence the policy of competitors.
- fastball 5y agoWould you be happy to pay a subscription fee for this?
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoThe cost of supporting a product for it's lifecycle should be baked into the original cost.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoIn practice it often is -- even in the case of many bad Android phones. It's just that the lifecycle they work to is the two year phone contract replacement lifecycle, not the longer one you might imagine. It's Darwinian: as long as the phone is not abandonware by the time the user's contract runs out, it doesn't matter. And the only Darwinian pressure to resolve this would be longer plan terms.
- hughrr 5y agoI think they should actually forcibly separate buying a phone from the carrier.
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoI wish companies would be forced to do that same for everything, and at a reasonable cost. It's infuriating how if I buy, say, a dishwasher, and the heater pump goes, it's around £100 for a new one, but the whole machine costs maybe £400. Are you telling me that all that steel and plastic and motors and controllers and labor and profit and shipping and everything is actually 75% of the cost, and 25% of the entire value of my dishwasher is tied up in the value of that one part, the one that happened to need replacement? And don't get me started on cars! If we as species cared about sustainability (we don't), companies would have to sell their parts for little enough that you could buy all the parts for a whole new machine for no more than the cost of the new machine. That would focus their minds on using interchangeable, standard, COTS parts to avoid having to maintain SKUs and also avoid having the parts fail in the first place. Rather, now, it's highly profitable to make parts fail: you either get to ding the customer for a replacement part at 500% markup, or they give in and buy a whole new machine, and the old one goes to scrap.
- superjan 5y ago> companies would have to sell their parts for little enough that you could buy all the parts for a whole new machine Something like that could be a law. We could allow them a little markup to cover distribution cost, but one could argue it could be that simple.
- a-priori 5y agoWhat this could be saying is that it’s very inefficient to buy the parts in units. If you were to buy a thousand of these parts, as a manufacturer might, I doubt they’d each cost £100.
- imglorp 5y agoYeah motors are expensive, but I have saved so many large appliances needing a minor component from the trash with a little basic troubleshooting and a site like appliancepartspros. So often, it's a sensor, a pawl, heating element, belt, or roller that's 1% of the machine's price. This is in reach of anyone with a few hand tools and the internet. A repair company (always 3rd party now) will charge %50 of the machine's price for a trip charge, marked up parts, and labor.
- AJRF 5y agoI suspect replacement batteries are going to become very expensive in the EU. The laws that the EU try to bring in always sound so good in practice - but they are very surface level and the implementation never accounts for second order effects. See; cookie banner laws, GDPR.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoLost faith in this whole idea of EU trying to force companies to do better after the cookie law. Now every single website I have to dismiss a pop up before I visit. Yet once dismissed the site functions completely fine so really the law should have just made whatever happens when I click accept illegal because you clearly don’t need it for any of these services to function. But no, now I have to dismiss a pop up every time instead.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoAs annoying as dismissing the popup is: > Yet once dismissed the site functions completely fine This is one of the intended outcomes of the law, because it prevents companies denying service to those who do not wish to be tracked on an all-or-nothing basis. Which is something that was beginning to happen. It may seem like there was no outcome from the legislation, but this is partly because it outlaws some outcomes. It's like the Y2K thing, when people tell you that it was all a fuss over nothing.
- feanaro 5y agoWhat cookie law? The cookie banner was never mandated, except in cases where you're trying to set cookies which are not legitimately necessary for your business but are for surveillance purposes. The trouble is businesses either don't understand this or pretend not to.
- tgv 5y agoMy company doesn't understand it, and shows a banner because you never know. However, I've turned it into a simple thing that tells you we're not tracking you (it's only a session cookie, after all), and after clicking goes away for a year (plus a cookie to track consent, of course).
- sytelus 5y agoI have a contrarian view on this. I really don’t think governments should be making technical decisions for the product design unless it directly impacts health issues. If fixed batteries makes product smaller or better then it’s choice of creator, maker and hacker. Consumer should be voting with their wallets and they should have a choice. This kind of constant interference from EU burocrates without understanding technical details is what led to completely pointless “accept cookie” disaster all over the Internet that has already cost billions of dollars collectively while not benefiting anyone.
- nemo44x 5y agoThe cookie disaster is a constant reminder that these government agencies need to be reeled in and limited. It’s also embarrassing that when I browse the web it’s more or less the EU’s single contribution. Good job!
- Shadonototra 5y agocookie popup is not a disaster, it forced companies to tell their users they are tracking them user replaceable battery is important because what's most likely to die 1st in your electronics is the battery, if it is soldered, high chance you'll have to replace your whole thing, producing useless e-waste i had to replace my electric toothbrush recently because the battery died, but the whole thing was still in perfect condition, such a waste
- slig 5y ago>cookie popup is not a disaster, it forced companies to tell their users they are tracking them Now people know that they're being tracked. Great. They are still being tracked and now are being annoyed with the modals everywhere. Those of us that get bothered enough can install some extension to hide them, but the for most people it's just another annoying thing they have to click away in order to continue what they were intended to do.
- dmitriid 5y ago
- Arnt 5y agoThe original source doesn't seem to say "not replaceable", but describes batteries that are glued or fixed in place. So making a watertight phone (or other device) with the battery inside the seal seems to still be allowed by the current proposal, so long as the seal is the only thing that complicates replacing the battery. Bug or feature? You be the judge.
- p1mrx 5y agoIf this happens, we're probably going to need more "standard" battery sizes. I've noticed Chinese manufacturers using the Nokia BL-5C as a de facto standard for portable electronics (bluetooth speakers, radios, game consoles, etc.), but that's a bit small for a modern smartphone.
- kawsper 5y agoThe BL-5C is a great standard for internally mounted batteries, for externally mounted ones I really like the Sony NP-F550.
- avar 5y agoFor even sturdier externally mounted ones something like the Makita battery format becoming a standard would be fantastic: https://www.worldofpower.co.uk/blog/makita-one-battery-fits-all/ https://www.worldofpower.co.uk/blog/makita-one-battery-fits-...
- userbinator 5y agoPerhaps one of the widely cloned Samsung Galaxy models which still had a removable battery? Seems to be around the right dimensions and intended application, in any case.
- tarr11 5y agoWhy not just tax products extra that don’t comply? Seems far less invasive.
- DonHopkins 5y agoBut I love my MacBook Pro swelling up really thick! It's like getting a free upgrade to a bigger computer!
- CRConrad 5y agoOh no, please don't! The thickness of a ~square-foot slab of metal growing from 0.5 inch to 0.6 would be suuuch a horrible imposition! Isn't this thing supposed to be portable?!?
- aldebran 5y agoThis (https://toothbrushbattery.com/guides/braun-oral-b-professional-care-1000-battery-replacement/ https://toothbrushbattery.com/guides/braun-oral-b-profession...) is why we need laws such as this one.
- skipnup 5y agoDo you know of any toothbrush with an easily replaceable battery? I'm in the need for a new one as my battery slowly dies and I don't want to solder my toothbrush.
- Tams80 5y agohttps://www.amazon.co.jp/-/en/Omron-Healthcare-HT-B210-G-Electric-Toothbrush/dp/B01GZEL47M/ref=sr_1_6?crid=HLLWVTYSOL6N&keywords=%E3%82%AA%E3%83%A0%E3%83%AD%E3%83%B3+%E3%81%AF%E3%81%B6%E3%82%89%E3%81%97&qid=1647189369&sprefix=omron+t%2Caps%2C632&sr=8-6 https://www.amazon.co.jp/-/en/Omron-Healthcare-HT-B210-G-Ele...
- aldebran 5y agoUnfortunately no. ^That’s the one I have. OralB and Phillips are the good ones and both do this battery not replaceable nonsense. My 10+ year old OralB had a replaceable battery and it worked fine and had no issues with water safety even though I washed the entire unit under water. We need a podswap like thing for electric tooth brushes.
- lotu 5y agoquip uses a AAA battery that is easy to replace. They use multiple gaskets to keep it safe from water.
- windex 5y agoHaving to throw out completely usable devices because of batteries conking out should be a crime and should be classified as littering by the manufacturer. I still miss my old Nokia.
- MrYellowP 5y agoAh, so batteries will be getting more expensive. (ignoring the already roaring inflation)
- motters 5y agoI hope that this will also apply to mobile phones.
- leroman 5y agoThis is a great first step but this needs to go further.. Case in point- I just replaced a 2018 Macbook pro 15 (i9/32g/1t - top model) with a new Macbook pro 16, the reason? it just died (apparently due to connecting a bad USB-C cable), this is the second time this happened to this laptop, the first time was under warranty and they had the motherboard replaced. Actually, when I say "motherboard replaced" I mean motherboard+memory+CPU+HDD !!!! because it's all soldered on-top of the motherboard, so I have to pay as much as a new laptop to replace it if either one of these component dies.....
- neop1x 5y agoThis is getting pretty common with new Macbooks. Stop buying this proprietary piece of junk. It can stop working randomly for no reason (literaly; one day it won't start and won't charge, not a single beep). There are lots of proprietary chips with their custom firmware and any of those can go bad or decide to dislike your usb-c charger and only apple or those with years of experience with behaviour of each model and access to stolen schematics and spare chips desoldered from doner boards can diagnose and fix it. The display flex cable can break by just opening and closing the lid every day and you lose video or backlight, fixing just the flex is so tedious that they often replace the whole display assembly which is custom made by apple and costs half the price of the laptop. Same if LCD cracks. If keyboard wears down you need to replace the whole keyboard assembly. And the battery is glued and difficult to replace. If you compare that with a HP Elitebook laptop, it is a completely different universe. It is not uglier or bulkier and yet the keyboard is replaceable in minutes, held by screws, flash is in the slot, power rails are nicely visible, chips often with publicly available datasheets, battery easy to replace or measure, LCD panel has a standard size and eDP connector and you can even pick a different brand and it will work just fine.
- plandis 5y agoI’m okay with this as long as it doesn’t impede engineering efforts from making smaller devices.
- jokoon 5y agoI remember that upright vacuum cleaner (it's a vacuum cleaner without a long flexible pipe, it's just a long arm with wheels). I did not buy this. The head was pivoting and had a small part of a flexible pipe. After 6 months or so, that flexible pipe broke, it was impossible to fix it properly even with a strong duct tape. They asked about 100 euros to remplace the ENTIRE head part. The seller said "normal wear". It's impossible to find a solution for this, unless you create some "durable design" label, which would essentially be an independent company testing every devices and items out there, and certifying those object as being "durable enough". The brand would just use those certifications. Same thing for right to repair. There are durable brands (Miele for example), but they are so much of a niche that they overprice their articles. Consumers are never aware because it's difficult to know what part will break and when. Oddly, there are almost no brand that advertise the durability of their product. It's very easy to suspect all those brands agree with each other to not make durable items. Such anti competitive practices are often quite difficult to prove. Look at how Louis Rossman spent YEARS making video for people to hear about just Apple. The electrical appliance is also a huge market, and electrical appliances will break more often, so without doubt it makes it much much harder to fight.
- black_puppydog 5y agoMiele is niche?! Having grown up in 90s & 00s Germany, it's one of the household names for me...
- Lio 5y agoMiele are ace. Lovely designs. We bought a built-in fridge freezer from them recently. i.e. hidden behind a cupboard door. The sales guy couldn't understand why we would pay extra for an appliance that no one would see the name on. He was all about impressing any visitors to the house. It was the most energy efficient unit I could find according to Which magazine. Should recover the difference in price to the no-name unit they were offering with 2 years. (Actually probably quicker now given changes in the energy market). I expect to keep it for at least 10 years and as well as better performance it has other useful features not on a bottom of the range unit. E.g. It's really quiet and if you go away on holiday you can switch the fridge part separately to the freezer to save more energy.
- taf2 5y agoThis seems good on the surface… but imagine you are designing a new piece of hardware… add this to the list of many “good things” that maybe won’t be great in 20 years from now when a new technology doesn’t fit the mold… I’m all for being able to repair. I enjoy finding a short and fixing by replacing a blown capacitor… I’m just not a fan being forced to build things in a specific way that prevents innovation. Maybe in 20 years we have amazing new batteries that last 100 years… maybe a device doesn’t need a battery just a capacitor and exposed to the sun is this now not a possibility? Because the capacitor need to be replaceable or is this a loop hole in the regulation… time will tell but IMO more rules about what and how I can design new hardware is bad
- technobabbler 5y agoEh, if battery tech ever gets there, they can just update the law. Big deal? In the meantime it'd prevent needlessly thin phones and laptops designed around planned obsolescence.
- AlchemistCamp 5y agoWhat incentive is there for battery tech to "get there" when progress is essentially banned in the name of standard parts? It's hard not to see this sort of regulation at the very least slowing down innovation and causing worse environmental outcomes as a side effect over a decades long scale. It won't be apparent to most people though, since they won't be able to see the counterfactual world where technology improved slightly faster.
- technobabbler 5y agoI'm not sure what you're talking about. Why would allowing battery replacement hinder development of battery tech? If anything it should spur a battery aftermarket using different charge controllers, chemistries, etc. that are user-swappable for the OEM ones. It just sounds like a generic antiregulatory complaint ungrounded in reality? It's not like li-ion tech has advanced dramatically absent such regulations. The bottleneck seems to be chemical, a matter of energy density, not a regulatory chokehold on innovation. It's just part of a bigger right-to-repair war, whether it's batteries or cars or operating systems. Manufacturers are increasingly moving to rent-seeking behaviors and X as a subscription, which is great for their profits but not so good for consumers or societies. Big tech is already on the verge of supplanting governments across the world, the last thing they need is more freedom to "innovate". They don't do it for the social good, just for their profits, and regulation is always playing catch-up to try to limit the social and environmental damage from their actions. At least the regulations have some measure of democratic buy-in, vs the what, 2-4 big tech companies that alone determine the future of tech? They don't have your interests at heart, at all.
- nodesocket 5y agoCongratulations EU you just managed to raise the price of all household items due to regulation.
- alexklark 5y agoBut you still need to call a 95 euro/hour certified battery changer professional licensed by the EC battery changing association or pay fines and all your appliances battery licenses will be revoked and issued for a mandatory inspection of certified battery EC inspection professional (169 euro/ hour).
- m101 5y agoWhilst the EU's war on waste and reparability legislation may be looked at through rose tinted glasses I think it has a number of negative side effects. 1) cost: The reason goods are cheap is that companies can rely on you needing to replace them ever [3] years. If you start to make it such that they only need to be replaced every [9] years then a manufacturer may only be able to rely on one third of the revenue. This has two effects - less money to go around for innovation / development (resulting in less good technology), and higher cost of goods (impacting the poorest the most). 2) livelihoods: The higher level thing going on here is that consumption of goods has raised living standards for many people around the world. On the other side of every good purchased are the livelihoods of people working in whole supply chains to produce that good. Reducing consumption will mean that those making all the things we consume will have less take home income for themselves (again, probably impacting the poor the most). It is a bit of a sad fact that the best way we have of organising society where people may gain a sense of dignity and meaning in their lives is through pushing consumption. 3) cost of business: all these rules and regulations are expensive to comply with. The EU will legislate itself to a bureaucratic death. My view in general of regulation is that it is designed to protect the interests of the wealthy, or those most willing to make a cost versus quality of life / fuzzy feel goods trade off. If replacing the battery was really that big a deal to consumers then people would buy a phone that had a hot-swappable battery - i.e. no need for regulation! Having said all that, I find the EU legislation mandating vampire power drain from not-in-use chargers is probably something i'd be on board with. This has the somewhat unique property that literally no one cares about something costs 0.1EUR a year, but it adds up at a country scale. I'm not entirely sure why i'm on board with this though.
- diffeomorphism 5y agoLet me summarize: not damaging the enviornment might cost money. Yes, and it is worth it.
- m101 5y agoWell, that's where it comes down to who you are. It is worth it to some, but not to everyone. The problem is that blanket rules are applied to everyone, without compensation. Even those that claim the are doing it to prevent environmental damage are damaging the environment in some way unless they live off the land in a hut. So it's just a matter of where the line is drawn, and almost all cases it's unfair in some way.
- Phenomenit 5y agoGreat, Now could you please do the same with the chargers, should be easier. In The last five years Ive bought maybe 5 different electric trimmers/shavers from Philips and they all have different charger-connectors. Even the two small green blade ONE are only two years appart and I specifically asked in the store if it was the same charger but it's not. They make ever so small changes in the plastic and voltages to make every new trimmer charger incompatible with another model. So if you the charger brakes or you loose it somehow you might as well buy a new. Terrible!
- oceanplexian 5y agoIt’s unfortunate because while I want replaceable batteries I don’t think it is the government’s place to mandate it. I want a lot of things but it would be wrong to mandate them. I’d like iPhones to have headphone ports, I want my laptop to support Linux, and all USB-C cables to be interoperable. But the problem is that the government shouldn’t be picking winning and losing technology. What if a company comes out with a battery that lasts 15-20 years (Which is already the case with some newer chemistries)? Maybe I, as a consumer, don’t want the government making my phone thicker or increasing the cost of a product because of an obsolete regulation.
- Rygian 5y agoThe point of the law is not to please those who would like to exchange batteries, but to have 90% of the batteries actually recycled, and reduce dependency on raw materials. The government isn't picking winners or losers, it's regulating the waste of scarce raw materials (those present in the battery, and to a lesser degree, those present in the rest of the device). The first company to come up with a battery that lasts 15–20 years will of course have to wait for regulations to adapt, like every other advance in technology in the history of mankind. Your position seems to be that you'd like the government to keep turning a blind eye on companies' wasteful strategies, just in case someone in the future might do something less wasteful.
- titzer 5y agoThe whole trend toward custom Lithium-ion battery packs seems to be driven by making devices thinner--not just phones, tablets, and laptops, but everything. They then integrate a USB, micro-USB, or even USB-C charger. Rechargeable is nice...replaceable is nice. But rechargeable and replaceable? I hope that we get back on a trend to use standard batteries, like AAAs, which have many excellent rechargeable Lithium-ion options now. I have plenty of AA/AAA-powered devices and about a dozen or so rechargeable AAA's cycling in and out. For some reason rechargeable 9-volt batteries haven't really caught on. They seem to have weak capacity and are expensive.
- kkfx 5y agoIMVHO the main point is "circularity vs linearity" of anything: if something can be recycled ad infinitum like a glass bottle there is no much need for "repair", we can keep rebuilding at best quality, for things can't be that "circular" instead repairing is a must. Batteries themselves are kind-of modular, in the sense that most tools batteries so far are made of standard elements soldered together, they tend to be easy to replace, that's not the case for mobile phones, laptop etc but for that electronic there are many more problems, starting from the design for planned obsolescence, IMVHO the real solution is making mandatory open hardware and free software, this way certain bad design can't simply survive because someone who know denounce defects, some propose corrections and OEM who refuse them get a bed reputation so quickly they can't recovery. The actual norms have failed to be effective, for instance recently the EU mandate the availability of spare parts for various home appliance, BUT they mandate only for "official repair center", so OEMs decide that to be an "official repair center" someone need to pay a non marginal annual fee for training, updates etc and the resulting costs are so high that's still convenient drop a damaged appliance instead of repairing it. Being open in hw terms by design and free in software terms prevent that effectively: if you try to circumvent norms that clearly appear and you end up quickly under fire. Even competitors are pushed to act one against another. Again to make that work we need public research, made for the sake of humanity not for profit, doing so ensure a real constant innovation that the market can't ignore and can't hijack for business reasons. And again that's not that hard to accomplish, we have had more or less in the past, at least in EU countries, with public universities and big research labs not entirely public, unfortunately, but publicly founded enough that the private part have to obey, can't lead the public one.
- giantg2 5y agoAre there any exceptions? I generally agree that users should be able to fix stuff. The one scenario I have in mind is that smoke detectors are supposed to be replaced every ten years and they now make some with a 10 year sealed battery. So it's a lifetime battery.
- iliketrains 5y agoYes! I wish this was mandatory world-wide! Just recently my shaver battery got to the point it lasts ~2 seconds on "full charge" and it is not replaceable. The charging adapter does not provide enough power to make it run. So I am forced to trash a perfectly working shaver just due to old battery. And this is how majority of battery-powered shavers work. My next shaver is corded.
- mrtweetyhack 5y ago
- ab_testing 5y agoWhen will the iPhone or the iPad (which can be used by the whole family) be considered a household item ?
- thepangolino 5y ago
- spyc 5y agoYes! Smart phones and notebooks should never have been allowed to go fixed internal battery. I hope they are included with this, or right next.
- Terry_Roll 5y ago> Industry is not too happy about this. The global tech giants are not happy as it currently helps to consolidate their monopolies in various country's. There is also a security & privacy benefit with removeable batteries as you can be sure a device hasnt just gone into a sleep mode whilst still logging meta data, except where its not.
- rasz 5y agoModern electric tools are the new Ink printers. Parkside, Makita, Milwaukee, DeWalt, Ryobi - they all build huge ecosystems around selling cheap tools with ridiculously expensive proprietary batteries. This needs to die.
- Beltalowda 5y agoI think batteries should be replaceable, but not necessarily customer replaceable. When I got a new battery for my iPhone SE I spent €30 on it (in total: battery + labour costs). I think that's a reasonable amount for a repair/replacement. It's not even super-hard to do and could have done it myself, but I don't have the right tools and didn't feel like buying them as I'm unlikely to use them for other things. There are real advantages to "battery packs" like this too: it makes the devices smaller, cheaper, sturdier, and overall just better, with the downside that replacing the battery is more difficult. But as long as it can be done in ~20 minutes by a technician it seems an acceptable trade-off to me.
- arendtio 5y agoJust two weeks ago I found out, that the Sennheiser headphones (RS180) I believed to be dead, just didn't work anymore, because the rechargeable batteries were broken. After replacing the batteries, I went on and replaced the ear cushions and now they are as good as new, despite being 10 years old or so. I am so happy to have bought a product that allowed me to easily replace both parts.
- neop1x 5y agoI agree with that and welcome it but still I think they should make distinction between device types! For example smartphones are often very tiny, technology advances a not and we often also want waterproofness to some degree. It is a bit sensible that there may be a glue desired and it is not that problematic. But the current state of macbook and mac repairability is pretty bad! Macbook is not a 2-year smartphone consumable, yet it is quite common that LCD breaks or LCD flex breaks from just daily use, or keyboard wears out, battery used to be glued. And only apple can fix a broken display flex and they do that but replacing the whole assembly which costs half of the device cost. And that is an example of the issue which this bill should fix and which we need! This probably applies for other bugger devices with planned longer-term use. Without any distinction, it may not work very well. We don't really need ALL smartphones to have easily replaceable batteries and be bulky, non-waterproof, heavy, etc.