22 ms·
Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 2022 goes from 90% to 26%
- disambiguation 5y ago* Community prediction.. This is basically a survey.
- ncr100 5y agoNot so basic. Survey with the predictors (humans) being ranked in their impact on the conclusion based on their historical prediction success.
- disambiguation 5y agoInteresting twist. Will be more interesting if its tied to an index fund.
- polishdude20 5y agoAh so the better you do in previous surveys, the more weight it puts into your prediction?
- jessriedel 5y agoYes.
- amriksohata 5y agoThe Taliban took 2 weeks to take over Afghanistan with little resistance in comparison. Both Ukraine and Afghanistan have similar land in sqm and population sizes. Why does anyone expect Ukraine to be taken over in a few weeks when there is bound to be more resistance? You would think atleast double or treble that time.
- deutschew 5y agolack of natural barriers, the Ukraine, Belarus lands are flat which means very little places to hide for the insurgency. in Afghanistan the Taliban could hide out in network of caves and there is just no flatten mountains, the Vietcongs could utilize underground networks and dense forests to operate. One hope for Ukraine is urban warfare, Putin launched two miserable wars against Chechnya and they were decimated from insurgents hiding out in various apartment buildings, it is likely what is stalling the advance in Kyiv.
- nwiswell 5y agoYes. The terrain for Ukranian insurgents will simply be civilians. How can you tell who is going to shoot you in the back when you turn around? Unfortunately, we live in a new age and China has perfected facial recognition software, which they will probably have no scruples about providing to Russia. I'm not sure a crowd provides the same kind of anonymity that it once did.
- deutschew 5y agoThe uncomfortable truth is that civilians will be used as shields by insurgency as it always has. We are starting to see some of this right now (and I'm not 100% certain) but for instance the alleged Azov battalion operating near DNR/LNR area is said to be not allowing citizens to leave the city. There are footages going around them turning (you can tell from the patches they wear) citizens away from checkpoints as they try to leave. Like Hamas in Palestine who regularly launch rockets at Israel from top of apartment buildings, it's only a matter of time before insurgency turns to this tactic as they are determined to keep fighting.
- riku_iki 5y ago> There are footages going around them turning (you can tell from the patches they wear) citizens away from checkpoints as they try to leave. Another side of the story is that Ukrainians claim they couldn't reach agreement of ceasing fire and humanitarian corridors with Russians. I believe people are leaving Kharkov and Kiev relatively freely.
- deutschew 5y agohow much of this was contributed to banning all reporting from the Russian side of things? right now the atmosphere is like if you even remotely suggest that Russia is actually making slow progress despite losses you are viewed as supporting Russia! Yet what the fixation on Kyiv is doing is it's pulling resources away from the south and Donentsk/Lukansk area where the Ukraine army is in real danger of being completely surrounded. There is heavy propaganda and disinformation from both Russia and Ukraine but what we've done in the West is effectively ban impartiality. Never before have we seen this level of zealous emotions since WW2. @JominiW on twitter does a very good explanation of various political and military objectives and the strategic movement of the Russian forces and he's repeatedly called out the dangers of believing the enemy is a paper tiger. We've seen all sorts of incompetence from the Russian side and Ukrainian forces have done a good job of defending Kyiv but we forget that Ukraine is not just Kyiv, it is slowly being swallowed up from all directions. This is called target fixation and it's going to shock a lot of people who only follows one side. Best thing to do in an unpredictable and volatile situation is to not fixate on one view. We will shortly know in the coming weeks what will happen, if Putin makes significant grounds, he has more chips to gamble/make demands. If Putin fails here, he has no choice to escalate in ways that was previously thought unimaginable. It doesn't help that US/NATO alliance is adamant on not escalating to WW3 yet they sanction every Russian, despite their objections to war and Putin, in some extremely liberal naivete that the Russians will rise up against an authoritarian government who is ready to use small scale nukes if need be.
- CRConrad 5y ago> what we've done in the West is effectively ban impartiality. WTF is there to be "impartial" about?
- jatone 5y agoyeah fog of war makes understanding the situation as a 3rd party cumbersome. I've essentially given up and just going to wait and see what falls out.
- yladiz 5y ago> we forget that Ukraine is not just Kyiv, it is slowly being swallowed up from all directions Except we haven’t forgotten, news orgs are reporting on things happening outside of Kyiv. Russia seems to have really overplayed their hand because they were barely able to take Kherson after like a week, and can’t even take bigger cities like Kharkiv, even with intense shelling. Russia may not be a paper tiger, but they sure can’t do much against an enemy many times smaller than them.
- rdtwo 5y agoDo people put money on this because 4:1 odds are pretty good. If definition of fall is a mission accomplished type photo op I’d take those odds. If it’s prolonged stable holding then I probably would not
- garyrob 5y ago26% is closer to 3-to-1 odds. :)
- frogger8 5y ago
- babyshake 5y agoPrediction markets for real money that relate to violent outcomes are a very dangerous territory ethically. You could bet the Kyiv will fall and then provide support or resources to the Russian forces, for example. A more practical example would be something like an assassination prediction.
- somedude895 5y agoIf you have the sort of influence or resources to make something like an assassination or war happen, then it's really easy to make money on those things already, for example by shorting certain stocks. And I'm sure that's already been happening for a while to some extent.
- DennisP 5y agoIt'd have to be a very liquid market, to make it profitable to provide enough support to make a material difference. I'm not convinced assassination markets are practical. If you make a prediction that a person will be assassinated on a particular day, and put money on it, you'll make the odds for that day spike up, thus warning the target to take new and unpredictable precautions. If you try to counter this effect with less specific predictions, then more people will take your side of the bet so you'll get worse odds.
- ryeights 5y ago
- jcadam 5y agoZelensky is starting to sound like he's open to considering some of Russia's stated terms (no pursuit of NATO membership and cession of eastern Ukraine). That doesn't sound like things are going especially well for him.
- ch4s3 5y agoIt's a lot better than the regime change that Russia was initially aiming for. Fighting a large neighboring power to a standstill and suing for peace is quite the success.
- otherme123 5y agoBasically what Finland achieved in the heroic Winter War. True, Finland lost some terrain, but I don't think anyone would find the aftermath as a soviet victory, when the original desire was to anexate the whole country.
- tada131 5y agoBut Soviet losses were incomparably bigger than Finland. Is this war the case?
- otherme123 5y agoIMHO war isn't a scale of bodies. Each side has a strategic objective(s), and winning/losing should be measured against that. Case in point: Vietnam. uSA and allies lost between 1/3 and 1/2 lifes than the North. And the USA loses were small (60.000 in a total of 1.5 million deaths). But it was a total defeat of the USA because none of the strategic objectives were achieved. Ukraine: strategic objectives are being an independent country with a fairly working democracy. Russia: conquer and create a puppet state in Ukraine and keep pressing west againt NATO countries. In the end we should measure against that, not by body count. I don't like it either.
- tada131 5y ago
- CodeGlitch 5y agoHere's my prediction: Russia will take control of all or most nuclear power plants and other infrastructure. At which point it's only a matter of time until the people of Ukraine will surrender with no water or electricity. As it stands the West can do nothing. In the case that NATO starts shooting, the sarcophagus over Chernobyl can be bombed (Putin can blame Ukrainians here). It seems to be that there's no way out for the Ukrainians :(
- khazhoux 5y agoI agree. I fear Ukraine will “win” when Russia retreats from the scorched, destroyed-to-rubble ruins of their nation.
- pvaldes 5y agoGetting rid of the Russian interference forever would be still pay back. We must remember that Germany was fully destroyed to rubble also and now is the largest economy in the EU. Under the correct environment things can recover surprisingly fast.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoRussia can't do that. They have no way of moving supplies from Russia into Ukraine. That means Russia's operational capabilities are limited to five days, at which point their troops are stranded.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Russia will take control of all or most nuclear power plants and other infrastructure. At which point it's only a matter of time until the people of Ukraine will surrender with no water or electricity. I doubt Ukraine will surrender as long as it can supply its forces with food, drinking water, and ammo. > As it stands the West can do nothing. The West can do a lot of things that it chooses not to do out of fear. IMHO one of the biggest mistakes it has made has been to be very, very clear about what it won't do, while letting the Russians be very, very unclear about what it won't do. The result has been the Russian leadership is not afraid, and has taken advantage of the freedom that affords to bomb the shit out of Ukraine. If NATO had massed soldiers in Poland in January and been deliberately ambiguous about its intentions, it's quite possible that Russia might not have invaded Ukraine at all (and then mocked the NATO by saying "LOL guys, we were really just doing exercises").
- InTheArena 5y agoArmies have momentum. Germany almost lost in 1941 when Barbarossa failed. Hitler managed to keep his armies from disintegrating, but it was a near thing. Japan's armies went far further then they had any right too in the same period, because of the perception of invincibility, higher morale, and everyone underestimating them for racial reasons. It's very clear that the Russians badly screwed up their logistics chain - see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4wRdoWpw0w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4wRdoWpw0w for a good obvious breakdown. But they also dramatically underestimated the morale of Ukrainians and also badly miscalculated NATO's response. NATO is flooding UKR now with drones, anti-tank misles and surface to air missles. They also have failed to have clear armor and air supremacy. They have fed some of their most "elite" VDV units into a meat grinder by sending them directly into Kyiv without any support, under the thesis that the Ukrainians would leave them uncontested, or where not able to maintain a reasonable response. Nevermind that Ukraine is mobilizing quickly (pre-war calculations where 30 days to build a effective force), while 75% of Russia's strike forces are in theater, and 95% are committed to battle. Because of all this - Russia is in a no-win scenario. To hit their goals will result in sanctions staying in place - and eventually destroying the Russian economy or alternatively leaving them as a vassal state of China. If they retreat, they may save their army, avoid a vietnam scenario, but Putin will loose face, and Demcoratic forces will be revitalized inside of Russia. Or they just stay where they are at. Inching ever close to Kyiv, but never winning any strategic victory. Forces are pushing towards stasis right now. I'd never bet on it - it's disrespectful to the dead and those fighting for their futures, and there are armies in the south that are a big problem - but I don't see a path for Russia to get what it wants. The question is how long will the sunk cost fallacy rule?
- twblalock 5y agoThe Russian government knew there would be sanctions no matter what happened. They had already decided to accept those even in the event of victory. They aren't in a no-win scenario either. Kyiv cannot hold out forever. The Russians have an overwhelming numeric advantage and they can simply wait out the defenders, using that time to fix their supply lines. It's tempting to exaggerate a Russian setback into a total collapse or a defeat. That's wishful thinking.
- antihero 5y agoReminds me of the time Trump won and I'd "hedged my emotions" - chucked £50 on him winning when he had 1/10 odds, so figured my friends and I could spend the £500 (that I eventually won) drink our sadness away in the pub that evening. Worked an absolute charm.
- harambae 5y agoI also bet on the politician I don't want to win, with the thinking that I'll be happy either way. But in this case there's no actually money on the line, that's not how the linked website works. (PredictIt and others won't take bets on the issue, it appears.)
- akomtu 5y agoPutin is dumb or desperate (maybe trying to score a quick victory because of some more pressing matters). All he needed to do is to assemble a big enough chunk of his army at the borders, do some maneuvers from time to time, pepper it with threatening rhetoric to keep everyone stressed, but never attack. This "psychological siege" would tank the economy of Ukraine and he could demand progressively bigger concessions. The west would've only expressed a "strong disapproval", but ignored the situation otherwise.
- jacquesm 5y agoHindsight is ...
- paxys 5y agoWhat you described is exactly what Putin has been doing over the last decade, and the result was simply pushing Ukraine more towards the west and NATO, exactly the opposite of what he had intended.
- throwaway_4ever 5y agoYou have little idea how impossible it is to keep a large force deployed along the border like that full time. Huge untenable monetary cost and morale drops precipitously where intelligence communities know it's not a threat if they've been sitting there a year+.
- beepbooptheory 5y agoI just have no confidence that we can really know anything for sure one way or another. The media so far (in the West) ranges from tangibly self-conscious to overt propaganda, much of which is proven false a day later. There is no harm in this in itself, propaganda is as much part of the war as any other part, I get that, but I at this point I wouldn't be surprised that Russia is doing much better than what is being reported, or the opposite. I don't know, this is not a bet I would take.
- bostonsre 5y agoWhat are some examples of "propaganda" that proved to be false a day later?
- imwillofficial 5y agoGhost of Kiev Snake Island Soldiers Dying Heroically Nuclear Reactor Shelled, Radiation Rising
- sillysaurusx 5y agoThe nuclear reactor was shelled. I saw it live. Doubt it had anything to do with radiation though.
- raverbashing 5y agoThe increased radiation is from kicking up dust around Chernobyl Regardless of that it is incredibly stupid to do any kind of fighting around a nuclear plant.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago> Regardless of that it is incredibly stupid to do any kind of fighting around a nuclear plant. That goes both ways. I saw the video from the start of the fighting and that was UA forces who started to fire upon oncoming forces from the building to the right on the video. If you mount defenses for something vital for the civilians of your country you should always question how exactly to do that to minimize the damage from the fighting. Given they took positions in the building, started the fight first, had a prerecorded video for Twitter of how they are under attack[0]... Sure, I'm just an arm-chair general, but for me it looks what the Ukrainian force decided to fight on the NPP territory and buildings. [0] go find it you if you didn't saw it. I doubt the first thing what would come to my mind as an operator of a NPP is to fire up a video for a social network.
- nugget 5y agoMy partners and I have a couple hundred employees in Dnipro, Ukraine. Most of the employees have relocated to Poland or western Ukraine, some are sheltering in place, some are fighting. We started to source supplies last week, especially for those who are sheltering in place or fighting. During discussions with various parties across the supply chain it became clear that an enormous effort was underway by hundreds/thousands of organizations (Governments, NGOs, companies, individuals) to flood Ukraine with every conceivable item they might need to support combat operations. Almost all of the commercially available weapons systems, ammunition, and body armor that we could find was already headed to Ukraine. We decided to focus on battlefield/first responder medical kits and supplies since those items were needed, but hadn't been mobilized as much. "Soldiers win battles, logistics wins wars." I heard that last week and it stuck with me.
- tada131 5y agoWhat about food?
- bobowzki 5y agoAn army marches on its stomach.
- Choco31415 5y agoI think the question is - is food being mobilized to Ukraine?
- trhway 5y agoanecdotally - yes. We bought and brought some stuff following that https://www.facebook.com/lnyuz/posts/5490539337642083 https://www.facebook.com/lnyuz/posts/5490539337642083 (drop-off in San Jose, some people order stuff from Amazon with delivery right to there), and while i don't see food among the list of requested item, boxes packed with donated food were pretty prominent there (and even though food wasn't mentioned we actually brought food too - long term packaged high calories low weight, we thought that probably that may be needed too and it happened so, seems like many people do that).
- cozzyd 5y agoI wonder if some corrupt Russian general stands to make a lot of money from this type of bet
- helpseeker 5y agoInformation from either side is to be taken with a grain of salt, although Ukraine is winning the social media ops-game hands down. I think since after the 1st week of troop movements it's pretty clear: - Russia aims at encircling cities, draining the resistance there, forcing them into negotiations and so that enemy combatants can evacuate into western Ukraine (like they did in Syria) - Ukraine aims at short-term luring them into cities (e.g. preventing humanitarian corridors, creating negative pr) and long-term building up an insurgency (turning Ukraine into Russia's 2nd Afghanistan). A recipe for humanitarian disaster. The upside: Russia doesn't seem intent to even set foot in western Ukraine.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The upside: Russia doesn't seem intent to even set foot in western Ukraine. That seems to have changed since you wrote this five days ago.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>Information from either side is to be taken with a grain of salt, although Ukraine is winning the social media ops-game hands down. At lest in the west where our information is censored to provide a Pro-Ukrainian perspective. I can only guess at how the social media ops-game is playing out in Russia and China within their own propaganda bubble.
- oezi 5y agoCan you clarify how are our information censored in the west? Like specifically what kind of information is actively suppressed by a government actor?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't have any evidence of government action so I assume it is voluntary. A simple example is I tried to Google search Ukrainian troop locations last weekend and got zero hits. A number of Wikipedia articles for historic events are also actively being revised
- legulere 5y agoWhy would you put such a low prediction on that website when you can predict a percentage in the range of [41%, 59%] and have guaranteed points?
- Imnimo 5y agoBecause your goal is not to maximize your chances of getting at least one point, it's to maximize the expected number of points you get.
- shuntress 5y agoUnder news stories like this, it's worth remembering that actions have consequences and high level political decisions matter. Remember that Trump was impeached for threatening to cut off military aid to Ukraine in exchange for a personal favor. The very same military aid that has likely prevented the outright capture Ukraine by Russia.
- tim333 5y agoIt's certainly been going better for the Ukrainians than I thought at the start - I thought the tanks would roll straight into Kyiv. Now they seem stuck and Russia lost 30 helicopters last night and today Poland agreed to give all their MIG29s. I guess this isn't really just Russia vs Ukraine but to an extent Russia vs the free world.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThis is a pretty wild swing, indicating that "Fog of War" is a very real thing.
- jansen555 5y ago[dead]
- env123 5y agoI'll tell you straight-up: this was written to increase morale for Ukraine. Whether Kyiv fall or walled up to Russian forces has yet to happen. It's still too early in the siege to make up these predictions I could imagine Russian propaganda pulling up statistics saying Kyiv will fall soon Also, too many people here do not understand geopolitics - the aim of invading Ukraine is to speed up the process of Russia's demands: - Ukraine never joining NATO - Donbas and Crimea ceding to Russia w/ Ukraine losing claim to them It's not about fully invading Ukraine and ceding the whole state, because that would be a bigger problem for Russia if it does so