27 ms·
Why the West is reluctant to deny Russian banks access to SWIFT
- jdrc 5y agoweak arguments though. It would be a swift action, a shock with immediate effect. the long-term points are not that relevant but evenso, the non-western allied world is comparatively small. a disconnection is not going to be forever.
- gyre007 5y agoThe difference b/w SWIFT and CIPS is the recently discussed "freedom to transact". In China you're beholden to CCP. If they get "tired" you can be cut off and there is nothing you can do about. In the west you have somewhat functional legal system you can follow up with.
- donarb 5y agoAlternate link to article: https://outline.com/GpZnXy https://outline.com/GpZnXy
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoIs there a situation where sanctions have done anything other than impoverish the general population?
- s_dev 5y agoYes, the sanctions aimed at the oligarchs impoverish the oligarchs.
- ancientworldnow 5y agoImpoverished or made slightly less obscenely wealthy. How many are truly penniless and only surviving through state welfare etc?
- knodi123 5y agoI don't know if you can call a slight reduction in an unimaginably massive fortune "impoverishment". Putin could lose tens of billions of dollars and still not be able to see poverty with a telescope.
- belorn 5y agoThe treaties on conflict resources and blood diamonds in particular seems to have worked fairly well in reducing the money flow to war lords. It seems about as effective as arm trade regulations. Naturally it is impossible to prove if either is effective since we can't run a control group with identical circumstances.
- gpsx 5y agoFor better or worse I think that is often the plan. First, presumably the government cares about the welfare of its people. Second it can make the people unhappy with the government.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThat sure seems to have worked out well in North Korea and Iran and Cuba and also the last time we tried it with Russia. The presence of external threats, in general, tend to strengthen support for dictators rather than to weaken them.
- phatfish 5y agoSurely it has? All those countries are crippled economically and only get attention on a global stage by saber rattling or when they decide to start looking to negotiate their way out. I hardly think Kim Jong Un has "strengthened support" from NK citizens, bar the top elite. They just get shot if they step out of line. Iran has a similar environment of fear, though not as totally controlling. I'm not sure what Cuba is like for political repression, but the people are hardly supportive of the government as i understand it. For what its worth, i don't believe imposing sanctions on Iran/Cuba is reasonable now. With the right diplomacy Iran looks to want to come to an agreement, and Cuba is no threat to anyone. Russia is in a better position while they have support from China. But there is still an affect. Also, i don't think it's possible to happily trade with Russia as if they were an ally while Putin grabs land from other eastern European countries.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, but it hasn't actually accomplished anything other than making their populations suffer. Every single one of these regimes are still around. The sanctions haven't succeeded in anything other than making the countries more miserable places to live in. If the premise was that the governments would care about their people and give in, or the people would turn on their governments, then no, that's just not happened.
- fulafel 5y agoThe oil embargo against the US improved car fuel economy.
- tzs 5y agoHow about the sanctions on Iran to try to get them to stop pursuing nuclear weapons? They made a deal to stop in exchange for removal of sanctions. That worked for a while but then a few years later the US reimposed sanctions claiming that the deal was not working (but was unable to cite any evidence to support this), so this time the sanctions provide no incentives.
- jdbernard 5y agoThe idea, as I understand, is that it's better to impoverish the population than to kill them (and us) in open warfare. It's not something we want to do.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoWhat is the alternative?
- at-fates-hands 5y agoThere's been a lot of talk if the West does this Putin would react by waging an ongoing cyber war against the US. There's been plenty of articles about how they've been hacking US infrastructure for years now. I think the fear of a cyber war is stopping them right now. https://www.wired.com/story/sandworm-cyclops-blink-hacking-tool/#intcid=_wired-bottom-recirc_7b2d5fb8-25f0-48c9-b1fd-fbb3aaeb4d3d_text2vec1-reranked-by-vidi https://www.wired.com/story/sandworm-cyclops-blink-hacking-t... ANY APPEARANCE OF a new tool used by Russia's notorious, disruptive Sandworm hackers will raise the eyebrows of cybersecurity professionals braced for high-impact cyberattacks. When US and UK agencies warn of one such tool spotted in the wild just as Russia prepares a potential mass-scale invasion of Ukraine, it's enough to raise alarms.
- oneoff786 5y agoThat seems unlikely to work. Russia will probably just attack because it can and will just deny it even in the face of undeniable evidence.
- s_dev 5y agoPaywall Removed: https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.economist.com%2Fthe-economist-explains%2F2022%2F02%2F25%2Fwhy-the-west-is-reluctant-to-deny-russian-banks-access-to-swift https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.economist.com%2Fth...
- andy_ppp 5y agoI actually pay for the economist, journalism costs money and it’s not that expensive to sign up. Great app that reads the stories to you if you’re doing something else.
- manquer 5y agoExpensive is relative to the person, there are plenty of people from developing world here. Even with economist discounts and student pricing it could be expensive for someone.
- andy_ppp 5y agoOh, people should be allowed to take it for free then?
- manquer 5y agoDon't judge someone just because you can afford it . Economist allows this type of bypass, it is not fully paywalled locked down by their choice, and have full control on how their content should be consumed and shared. They are fully aware of this kind of use and they are okay with it, don't know why any one should be concerned.
- Damogran6 5y agoThere's no shortage of good news sources...there is a shortage of personal budget. And a shortage of time to consume all of them.
- Toxical_Ickaruz 5y ago[flagged]
- Mikeb85 5y agoBasically Russia and China have alternatives and the west doesn't want to lose Swift's dominance.
- deutschewelle 5y agoA bit of this but mostly as others pointed out, EU nations reliant on Russian gas also happen to hold large sway over other members is what is causing reluctance to destroy their own economy to serve the interests of US security umbrella. One EU country went as far as to remove ALL nuclear source of energy to increase dependence on Rosneft. In this same country many DO NOT WANT another Greece mooching off them and WANT putin to take Ukraine out of the picture before other EU smaller member states with US backing will demand them in. Likely some talk took place between Xi and Putin to create a barter system, to trade Grain for Oil and vice versa. This explains why Putin is totally unphased by threats of Western sanctions because he realizes the EU's interest is not aligned with NATO/US security goals. Think about this by supplying cheap Russian gas, they could overnight dictate where the next industrial region in Europe would form. They could sell to Berlin at several times the markup it used to receive while supplying its industrial outsourcing in other European countries with cheaper gas to force to spread out Germany's production chain. There's just so many ways to manipulate Europe, its no longer clear who holds the ultimate veto power in Europe. Is it the nuclear armed and hesitant Western Europe nations or is it the nuclear armed and hostile Russia? Financial sanctions just do not make an impact if a country is determined to take its national security concerns known to its enemies. Putin is not only cunning, he is proving to be far more capable and adventurous than any other leader in the region. Like in a game of poker, fortune favors the bold, or whoever risks more stands to gain/lose more. Kiev will fall in a few weeks and Russia has barely used its full capacity, most likely to avoid collateral damage that would impact its political objectives: decapitation of the central Ukranian authority
- ksec 5y agoIt is definitely the last one. >Last, using swift as a weapon against Russia could hurt long-term American interests. America holds sway over international finance thanks to the dollar’s dominance and its pre-eminent role in global settlement systems. Further politicising swift would give China an incentive to bolster cips, its rival to swift for cross-border payments in yuan. It would also help China court any country with uneasy relations with America looking for alternatives. I would imagine there are additional politics in play with disabling SWIFT. I dont how many countries will need to agree before shutting down SWIFT access, if it is at the will of US it would be more like a semi-nuclear option. Although I am already surprised by CIPS, one eighth of transaction volume of SWIFT is not "well behind". From many POV this already seems like a battle the west are clearly losing.
- liminal 5y agoWill sanctions need to broaden to include China or other countries supporting Russia?
- lisper 5y agoSanctions only work when imposed by a stronger country on a weaker one. Ecuador, for example, cannot impose sanctions on the U.S. For this reason, it is quickly becoming unfeasible to impose sanctions on China. Imposing effective sanctions on Russia is already hard enough, and Russia's economy is much smaller than China's.
- pydry 5y agoChina has hinted before at imposing sanctions on the US. It's the first country that has been able to make that threat credibly in.... ohhh, a long long time.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThey've imposed sanctions on US weapon companies recently. Soon once their domestic airplanes are semi-competitive with Airbus, they may even sanction Boeing.
- nine_zeros 5y agoMore than the alternative system, the immediate problem appears to be that Europe is so badly dependent on Russian gas that cutting off swift will be a suicide for Europe. Europe needs to move to renewables for residential and industrial use ASAP.
- Scoundreller 5y agoOr be more like France: about 70% nuclear generation of electricity. Still dependent on gas pipelines to North Africa, but also building out its LNG infrastructure so it can buy from more sources. They’re heavily promoting heat pumps for heating, but that also comes along with increased A/C use in a country that seems to culturally avoid it (in my depressing experience).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jborichevskiy 5y agoCurious to hear about how A/C use is culturally avoided. Is it seen as a negative social status signal to have the convenience? Or is the environmental impact a consideration?
- Scoundreller 5y agoiunno, more people than I could imagine there think air conditioning makes you sick. To the point of opening windows on the highway instead of turning on the a/c that’s there. My sample is limited, but it’s thinking I’ve never encountered in North America. Having said that, construction usually has excellent shutters on windows, so you can block the sun effectively. Covered outdoor parking is common at malls in the south. Being and staying cool are encouraged, but a/c often isn’t.
- mhitza 5y agoEU reportedly has 40% of it gas imports from Russia. However, the European Commission President has already stated that EU is prepared for partial disruption of gas flow https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-says-it-is-prepared-partial-disruption-russian-gas-flows-2022-02-15/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-says-it-is-prepared-... Solidarity towards Ukraine by EU, would be to step up and proceed with blocking Russia from the SWIFT system. The thing is, such a decision would impact EU citizens negatively in the short-medium term. And I think that level of solidarity is a hard sell, and hard to quickly measure support for, within each country's electorate. The other issue, for Germany, is that removing them from SWIFT would be like clearing Russia's billions of debt obligations. If there was any moment for EU to swallow a hard pill, would be now, and cut of gas import, rather than try to get consensus on blocking SWIFT access. It's the perfect time to apply that form of economical pressure, especially now that we're having a bit of early spring weather (though uncertain how long that will last). Not sure about Cyprus, and others opposing the measure, what negative implications it would have for them and why they decided the way they did.
- baybal2 5y agoCounterpoints to the article: "SWIFT ban will push Russia into China's hands" — Russia is already fully submitting to any Chinese economic terms. The swathe of Russian land the size of France was already leased to China effectively in perpetuity https://www.asianews.it/news-en/Vast-swathes-of-land-beyond-the-Volga-leased-to-Chinese-companies-52947.html https://www.asianews.it/news-en/Vast-swathes-of-land-beyond-... . Russia sells its natural resources to China at unbelievable discount. "SWIFT ban will make Russia, and China to develop an alternative to SWIFT" — Russia, and China already don't use SWIFT for trade in between government companies of each other. "SWIFT ban will provoke Russia into all out war" — Russia is already waging an all out war. "SWIFT ban will make Russia to switch to Chinese Yuan, and end the dominance of US dollar" - Russia already uses Yuan for trade with China, and bunch of other countries. "SWIFT ban will make Russia to rely on China economically instead of EU" — This is the silliest claim I hear. If EU wants to trade with Russia, then don't sanction them. Sanctions are a bar on trade, and ability to extract profits.
- bigcat123 5y ago
- DizzyDoo 5y ago> America has blacklisted big Russian financial institutions, preventing its own banks from dealing with them, and imposed strict export controls. These measures are much narrower in scope than disconnecting Russia from SWIFT, but they cut more deeply. Is that true? It sounds counter-intuitive to me, someone who uses SWIFT payments a lot but isn't at all an economist or super into foreign policy, that the US blacklisting a few big Russian banking institutions would cut deeper than the immediate and total removal from the larger payment network. But if that is indeed the case, why not both? The answer the article gives for that is "it would hurt the West's investments/position with respect to China" which, yes, makes sense, but is that pain worth it? A few decades of land wars across the European continent would do that too, right?
- actuator 5y agoMaybe because of the same reason, "West" can't even not sell Gucci bags to oligarchs. https://mobile.twitter.com/barnes_joe/status/1497194009038626842 https://mobile.twitter.com/barnes_joe/status/149719400903862... If this is true, it is quite shameful on Italy's part
- estaseuropano 5y agoThis was some story from before the agreement, and it seems the story lived on. The legal text is not yet out, but you will find it on consilium.europa.eu probably later tonight and can check then.
- sjsvsnd 5y agoWhy is it any more shameful than German BMWs or securing Germany’s gas? So far the Germans haven't given up anything meaningful that they don't already have. Not a cubic cm of gas has turned away. All they’ve done is delay future flows from NS2.
- orangecat 5y agoThis is a bunch of words around "it would be inconvenient for us because we allowed ourselves to become economically dependent on a criminal state". In particular Germany gets a gold (red?) star for shutting down their nuclear plants. Meanwhile the Chinese Communist Party has to be enjoying this. If we can't agree to take the relatively minor hit of financially cutting Russia off from the civilized world, we'll obviously be unwilling to do anything significant when they invade Taiwan.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoTSMC probably already has all their facilities mined. It doesn't take much, to turn a fab into a junk heap. You just need to break the clean room containment, and you have a billion dollars' worth of permanently useless garbage. Heck, just turning off power would probably do it, but they'd want to be sure. I actually have a story, from the company I worked for, that supplied lithography stuff (big, expensive steppers). They need to maintain clean room standards from the first framing, to the final delivery (special airplanes and trains). They delivered a set of them to a company that then went belly-up. The power was turned off, and the equipment became junk.
- ebruchez 5y agoTSMS is not the reason China wants Taiwan, and there is more to Taiwan than TSMC: a wonderful people, a thriving liberal democracy, and great local culture, for example. I understand why there is so much focus on HN on TSMC, but it's disheartening to observe the lack of realization that we are not just talking about a fab on a rock, but about human beings.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThat’s a very good point. People, in general (not just HN geeks), tend to have difficulty looking at other folks as “human.” This applies to our next-door neighbors; let alone, people in a distant nation. I appreciate your making that point. But TSMC is a very big fab on a rock…
- dsl 5y agoThe actual reason is because SWIFT gives the US/EU visibility into all inter-bank transfers, which provides us intelligence to build sanctions on top of. It's the financial equivalent of kicking Russia diplomats out of a building where we have every conference room bugged. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist_Finance_Tracking_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist_Finance_Tracking_Pro...
- s_dev 5y ago>The actual reason is because SWIFT gives the US/EU visibility into all inter-bank transfers But like clearly it doesn't if Russia and China have their own systems. How would Swift reveal Russian/Chinese internal transactions?
- dogman144 5y agoDoesn't have to reveal all transactions to be of extreme value on the whole.
- s_dev 5y agoGiven the the EU did remove all of Russian from SWIFT. A lot of these replies are looking very speculative and a bit silly -- simply imagining convoluted explanations where are none like "kicking Russia out of Swift will hurt Europe more".
- gonzo 5y agoLack of traffic is also g2.
- throwhauser 5y agoThat makes no sense. If Russia had an effective way to conduct its business without SWIFT in the event of sanctions, it would also have a way to conduct its business outside of SWIFT any time it has something to hide. To follow your analogy, if they had a separate office in a separate building that they could use in the event that they get kicked out of the bugged office, they would already be using it whenever they wanted additional privacy. The only way SWIFT actually forces Russia to be visible is if it's their only option, so no visibility can be lost if they're cut off.
- zabzonk 5y ago> Why the West is reluctant to deny Russian banks access to SWIFT Possibly because the banks using it don't really understand it. After succesfuly delivering one project at Credit Suisse I was charged with implementing a SWIFT interface, but no-one, and I really mean no-one, could tell me what such an interface should look like, or how it should be used. After a lot of mucking around at and around Canary Wharf (which did at least get me to the top of the Canada Square building a couple of times - remarkably shoddy indoors, at least on the CS floors) I came to the conclusion that this was a project that never could work, and left.
- phkahler 5y agoI see this more and more. When software infrastructure become mature and stable, the people who built it eventually leave or retire. You end up with systems that people use and occasionally modify, but the real understanding is gone. The ability to make big changes is reduced. Knowing what secondary effects a change may have is nearly impossible. But you can keep right on using it just fine.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoIt boggles my mind the endemic shortsigtedness regarding deep knowledge of systems that is shown by software owners. Case in point, higher salaries for new hires without deep knowledge, and lack of retention salaries for those who have years of history with systems. Another example, getting contracted consulting developers to build business critical systems, without locking in retainer arrangements to ensure continuity of deep support knowledge.
- duped 5y agoI mean it doesn't help that the developer class has a giant incentive not to make things that last
- no_wizard 5y agoincentives tend to follow other incentives. As noted above, the best way in the industry most of the time is to move companies to get better compensation, and sometimes better workplace conditions as well. Companies don't incentivize people staying around. At bigger companies sometimes - not always though - you can make progress in these areas by getting promoted, however that only works for N percent of a workforce at any given place. If companies incentivized retention with realistic paths to better compensation and growing your career, they'd see lower turn over with these systems. There's a reason that in recent times there were newsworthy stories about companies giving out retention bonuses and salary increases when some sticks started to plateau / lose value (and therefore RSUs not retaining value), because its relatively rare
- kungpao42 5y agoWe should de-peer the russian ISPs from the internet.
- cellis 5y agoThat would just further isolate working class Russians. A dictatorship doesn’t need consent of the governed to start a war so many Russian people may not approve and now you can’t even communicate with them. I think this would be incredibly short sighted.
- mdaniel 5y agoOr take the AT&T approach: throttle their link to 14.4k > it seems you have exceeded your allotted foreign invasions this century; we're reducing your bandwidth until your next billing cycle
- rcpt 5y agoTelegram would do ok at 14.4
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoThis will just lead to a further balkanization of the internet. China and Russia aren't going to sit by and be beholden to western tech and financial stacks when they can be cut off at any time.
- marcosdumay 5y agoNowadays dictatorships take that decision themselves. No need to impose it on them.
- maccolgan 5y agoWho's "we"? The Internet was supposed to be decentralized from the start, to prevent actions like this.
- belorn 5y agoThe article discuss the benefits and drawback of SWIFT being the dominating banking system in the world, and the risk that cutting of Russian banks from it would encourage the other banking systems to take over. What I find missing from the article is that primary intention of wanting to cut off Russian banks from SWIFT, ie stopping trade between Russia and other countries. In particular, stopping Germany and Italy, the two countries most dependent on Russian oil and natural gas. If the world want to stop countries from trading with Russia, have a trade agreement that imposes sanctions to anyone trading with Russia and goods that comes from Russia. Right now the oil and gas from Russia is just as bloody as blood diamonds.
- dundarious 5y agoOil from Saudi Arabia is no less bloody. The Yemen war is dragging on for another year, and the civilian toll is unbelievable. I don't think the concept of justice is the primary motivator here, or at the very least, it's an utterly compromised sense of justice.
- maccolgan 5y ago
- sunflowerdeath 5y agoFor me it looks like all of those banking / swift sanctions will mostly affect regular russian people and small businesses, who will not be able to work with foreign markets. Russian goverment will continue to trade oil and gas like nothing happenned, and will find way to trade other goods through non-Western countries like China. And sanctions regarding high-tech export will take many many months to have an effect. Honestly, it looks like western countries try to decieve people, that they are actively helping to solve this situation, but actually want to leave everything as it is.
- mmastrac 5y agoPart of the power of sanctions are to weaken a leader's power over their people. If they lose the mandate to lead, the people may revolt and decapitate the leadership causing the issue.
- sunflowerdeath 5y agoPeople fear being jailed, tortured and having their lives ruined by its own government much more than any consequences of economic sanctions.
- waffle_maniac 5y agoIt hasn't worked before with Putin but people still believe that if the pressure is strong enough he will change. He clearly doesn't care and no one is going to take power from him.
- dundarious 5y agoIt is true that that is the logic, but there are so many modern examples to show it is a flawed logic (Cuba, Iraq before the 2nd war, Venezuela, etc.). I do wish that policy makers were as open about this as they were in the early years of the Cold War, that their goal is to inflict massive pain on the population and pray for unrest. Instead, nowadays it is framed as a direct punishment on the leaders or an abstract notion like the enemy nation or their supposed ideology.
- oi2j3oi32 5y ago
- yyyk 5y ago"Why the West is reluctant to deny Russian banks access to SWIFT" Because Europe is dependent on Russian gas (thanks to an ill thought out denuclearization drive), and both Europe and US governments prefer their economic and electoral interests over Ukraine or the international order. The rest of the article are really silly excuses (Russia is a relatively small economy and can't meaningfully hurt the dollar etc.).
- dillondoyle 5y agoJust another reason green energy & climate change can't be ignored. I'm more of a hawk on CCP and Russia But I'm a mega super hawk when it comes to spending painfully NOW to stand a chance against the worst of the worst of climate change.
- yrgulation 5y agoNot the whole of europe tho. Its mainly germany.
- riskneutral 5y agoIt is the whole of Europe: http://edition.cnn.com/2014/06/16/business/eu-gas-russia/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2014/06/16/business/eu-gas-russia/ind...
- yrgulation 5y agoYes and the largest is germany, hence “mainly”.
- freshthought 5y agoWhat is SWIFT, behind the scenes?
- chasd00 5y agoprobably a TCP socket and an old, well established, EDI format.
- bsd44 5y agoProbably for the same reason they didn't exclude Five Eyes from SWIFT when they invaded Yugoslavia, Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria and killed over 1,500,000 people in just over twenty years...lol nah it's about money. They'd shoot themselves in the foot if they did it.
- steve76 5y ago
- jaywalk 5y agoIt was much more than just the Five Eyes countries involved in those invasions, so there really wasn't anybody of any significance left that could have removed them from SWIFT.
- bsd44 5y agoThat is exactly my point; you don't dig your own grave. Sanctions are only affective when it hurts someone else, not you. That however proves to be a difficult task in a globalised world.
- boplicity 5y agoOne reason, and one reason only: Cheap oil. We're willing to destroy the future of the entire world for cheap oil. What's one relatively small country in comparison to that? The West wants Russia's cheap oil. There's no other explanation.
- mtmail 5y agoThe article lists several other explanations.
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago> There's no other explanation. ...that you can think of.
- anamax 5y agoCanadian and in-US oil/gas is less expensive (from a US perspective) than Russia's. Taking the US off the market also makes Russia's oil/gas cheaper for other countries. However, we're shutting that down.
- rank0 5y agoOil isn’t optional. It’s the most important commodity in the world. Nobodies lifestyle on HN would be possible without it. It’s the natural gas too. Europe needs natural gas for power. Is Europe’s supposed to deprive its citizens of electricity?
- brodouevencode 5y agohttps://archive.is/CHiiI https://archive.is/CHiiI
- newaccount2021 5y ago[dead]
- yrgulation 5y agoThe west? I thought it was a handful of countries that russia has quite cozy relations with.
- ck2 5y agoSEIZE THE YACHTS AND REAL-ESTATE It's not rocket science. Physical assets. All of them. Every country, especially USA, if there is Russian owned property, it's not theirs anymore. Every holding company or if some oligarch is dumb enough to have something in their name. Lots of penthouses in NYC and Florida. Seize them all. Sell them and pay for the funerals of all the innocent people that are about to needlessly, pointlessly, brutally die in fear.
- orbifold 5y agoThat is what happened with German assets during World War 1. One of the reasons why there are two Merck companies today for example.
- ck2 5y agoI was thinking last night about how the USA delayed getting into a war with the Nazis for two whole years while entire countries were taken over. But they even continued to do commerce with them. I don't expect "boots on the ground" because I wouldn't want to send anyone to their death even if they are young and ignorant so willing to do so. But hell, the least we can do is make Russia disappear from everything else and close down their world. No travel, no assets outside of Russia to any other country. They aren't China, we can do that to Russia. China would be a nightmare but not Russia. They aren't leaving Ukraine ever. Are all the events and cancellations just waiting for things to "shake out"? It's basically forever. Or at least Putin's lifetime but who know who is waiting in the wings.
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoIf you do that, the issue is: The other side will treat the property of every US citizen, company, or state as a fair game for appropriation, and if not possible for destruction. Would you risk seizing private property of a Russian citizen, if Russia decides to retaliate by destroying property of a US citizen, wherever in the world it may be located? Let's please not further escalate, it's time for diplomacy. Diplomacy means agreement, agreement means compromise. We may not be fully satisfied, the other side may also not be satisfied, but we'll both claim a diplomatic win for our side and go on with life. If the alternative is war and mutual destruction, it's the only reasonable way to go.
- dundarious 5y agoOne of the reasons that JFK's military advisers were initially against the naval blockade of Cuba and in favor of a full invasion, is that a blockade is essentially an act of war anyway. It is a relatively modern concept to do more than use the threat of "blockade" level sanctions without a declaration of war (declarations are out of fashion, but a meaningful mutual understanding that the parties are at war). Just like Syria, Yemen, and several other conflicts, the situation is horrendous, but from all rational perspectives, I don't think Ukraine should precipitate a war between nuclear powers. An economic blockade like the SWIFT proposal would possibly cross over into war.
- barbazoo 5y agoThanks for the context. Indeed it is easy to demand the most drastic measures, but, while that may feel like revenge in the short term, it might not be the best step in diplomatic terms. Diplomacy must be so frustrating at times to work in.
- dundarious 5y agoYes, it's amazing how some of the people I know who are the most embedded in the field (working 10 hours a day, 6 days a week, reading updates on movements on the ground in all parts of the world, casualty lists, diplomatic messages, policy/planning papers) are outside of their work, some of the most cheerful people. It seems extremely demanding. Especially if you're good -- having to disregard most of the information and especially commentary designed for public consumption. I think the most stark, but in a way obvious, lesson is that we should hold ourselves responsible for the predictable outcomes of our actions. It is no good to say "our enemy is evil" and do something that we can reasonably predict will lead to an "evil" action by "our enemy". (Of course you can't always minimize in this way, but it's an important point, because there are numerous recent examples where predictable outcomes were very bad, but ideology won out).
- sjsvsnd 5y agoIt is an act of war, but there is a huge material difference between invading and blockading.
- ecf 5y agoIt’s almost like Putin knows the West is incapable of any meaningful action.
- hajkrem 5y agoWhy not limit the funds a Russian citizen can place at EU banks? It's a signal to all the wealthy that they do not have an easy "plan b" once shit hits the fan, and incentives them to create a more stable environment. Also, why not sanction well-known Russia-paid European spies like Gerhard Schröder and limit their finances within the EU. The Hungarian national TV just aired a pro-russian programme, where an "expert" named Georg Spöttle put Zelensky and Hitler in parallel. Why not sanction these guys first?
- vdsk 5y agoRussians living in London and Paris are already the most anti-Putin/United Russia electorate. We would be hitting at the pro-West and westernized Russians, not to mention that we would have to carve exceptions all the time for political dissidents fleeing Russia. The second main reason is that it would remove the need for Putin to impose capital controls since the main place these funds would go are western banks. I understand the sentiment and why this might sound a good idea, but it would be very counterproductive.
- hajkrem 5y agoLiving in London/Paris, earning well (~being affected by the sanction), having "anti-Putin opinion" yet doing nothing lacks any merit. Who else would do the actual work of changing the regime if not the locals?
- vdsk 5y agoWhat do you want them to do? Just go rot in Moscow's prisons? You clearly over-estimate the level of leverage the citizenship has over its government, even in democracies. This is not a democracy. On that note, do you also want to sanction the Syrian refugees? They're not personally storming the presidential palace over Damascus.
- sAbakumoff 5y agoFrget about SWIFT. Why does the West not seize the assets of Putin's friends and family members? Why don't they cancel the citizenship or residence permit for anyone who has something to do with Putin and his gang? All these kids, grandkids, nephews, etc. of the Russian elite.
- DevKoala 5y agoBecause the west is dependent on Russian oil.
- hiavraham 5y agoI apologise if I am too direct, but cannot help it, but say, that these are extremist ideas. Why should relatives or friends be held responsible for actions that are not theirs. In my former communist nation, if one person went against party line their entire family would be prosecuted. The statements you made are unfortunately not hard to find being drawn in the minds of many, however, they are a bitter memory for those who have lived in times when this kind of thought prevailed. The past should serve as a teacher. Unless there is actual proof of their wrong-doing they are innocent until proven guilty, and as such merit the same treatment as anyone else.
- sAbakumoff 5y agoI am sorry if I am being too direct, but the very inability to impose strict measures on Putin's gang is the reason he doesn't hesitate to do what he does. If anything, if we seize the Russian elite money, then they might be willing to overthrow Putin's regime in exchange for getting their resources back. These are not extremist ideas, this is a pretty reasonable MO. Unfortunately, no one in the West has the stamina to do that.
- an9n 5y agoIf the West could swallow it's pride for a while, it could go all out for fracking, reopen coal mines and build enormous gas to fuel plants etc., and buy itself time to go full carbon neutral. But it won't. Why not? Because the eco-zealotry overrides Ukrainian lives.
- FpUser 5y ago>"Because the eco-zealotry overrides Ukrainian lives." Do not be so dramatic. West never had problems with "overriding" human lives. It had killed millions without any repercussions.
- pettusftw 5y agoThe following is US centric because that is the only resource extraction I'm personally familiar with. Coal should stay dead. It has no redeeming qualities except that the cost is largely in externalizations. Oil and LNG output is constrained by price. More and more shuttered/untapped wells will go online as prices rise and they become economically viable. This is already in progress at current prices. I'm not sure what you meant by pride, but we don't need to drill/frack protected areas because they're cheaper to get resources out of. If protected areas are not what you meant, rest assured that unprotected areas will be "gone all out" on based on the economic calculus of extraction and there are plenty of untapped areas[0]. Price is the better incentive because it's elastic in response to demand like that created by embargoes on Russian resources, and also incentivizes a move away from fossil fuels by nature of its high price. It will be costly to average consumers at an already precarious time, but at least it aligns incentives with a more sustainable future instead of sacrificing unreplaceable ecologies by "going all out" as you describe. [0] https://www.usgs.gov/centers/central-energy-resources-science-center/science/united-states-assessments-undiscovered-oil https://www.usgs.gov/centers/central-energy-resources-scienc...
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoIf Russia is cut out of SWIFT they will just use their own system, minor inconvenience at first but long term works out well for them. A few years ago the US said they were going to forbid oil speculation and force people to accept delivery of all trades. They backtracked on that immediately when they found out Dubai was rushing to fill the gap by opening their own commodity exchange that would allow speculation. Likewise I think the US and even the EU might talk tough about ejecting Russia from SWIFT, but won't follow through out of fear of losing control to a Russia and/or China controlled system. A lot of western countries use SWIFT to spy on each other. The US would supposedly monitor SWIFT traffic looking for transfers to Airbus and feed that info to Boeing so they could try to undercut them on price.
- DevKoala 5y agoWhat’s more interesting to me is why the whole world is so energy deficient that they cannot stop using Russian oil. IMHO that was the first mistake.
- lazide 5y agoIt isn't that the whole world is energy deficient (in any real sense), it's that key modern economies have become reliant on specific sources, and interruptions in those sources make them very vulnerable to very expensive impacts. So they're blackmailable. And lots of cheap energy and global trade is almost like heroin for dealing with internal problems and social ills - no need to confront inefficiencies, figure out sane monetary policies, have hard conversations on hard topics, etc. So a lot of countries have pent up BS that will tear them apart when the heroin (I mean oil) stops flowing. International strongarm politics 101.
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoFrom any adversary’s perspective, the ability to shut them out is as good as shutting them out. They need to prepare an alternative solution. The moment the SWIFT system became political, it was already doomed, and the petrodollar along with it.
- ukraineally 5y agoMy understanding Germany made a huge mistake in connecting with Russia. Swift and or petroleum product sanctions would just crush germany. This is going to be a key reason. Given the context, no real major war had ever happened in a long time. Perhaps Germany was connecting in order to build relationships. Which may actually be a long term benefit for everyone. In the long run maybe preventing further conflict. Germany did halt Nordstream 2, which wasnt doing anything yet, but I dont believe they did anything else yesterday? Most likely they fear retribution.
- hef19898 5y agoWell, Germany got gas, very reliably, from the USSR before Russia all the way back to the Cold War. Hickups only happened when Ukraine and Russia couldn't agree on transit fees. Hence Nordstream 2. If NS2 wouod already be live, Russia could also just turm of Ukraines gas. Now they can't without directly hitting one of their biggest markets. In a sense, not certifying NS2 limits Russias options. Not that I am convinced someone in the Gean government, old or new, ever thought this through so.
- ukraineally 5y ago>In a sense, not certifying NS2 limits Russias options. Not that I am convinced someone in the Gean government, old or new, ever thought this through so. The way I see it and one of my political opinions. 1. Big business runs governments around the world. 2. Big business decides the shots and war is bad for business(unless you're in that business) 3. Those big businesses are who prevent wars from happening. Then again, this is what forced putin's hands. A ton of big business went to ukraine over US investment treaties and the EU stuff.
- ramshanker 5y agoIf the west goes ahead, east will have more systems similar to Swift!
- steve76 5y ago
- TameAntelope 5y agoI dunno much about this, but I saw a tweet from someone I trust that described SWIFT in HVAC terms as the thermostat, and the new sanctions like blocking off the ductwork for a specific room; more targeted, still painful, and pulling the thermostat wouldn't do much more. [0] [0] https://twitter.com/daniel_mcdowell/status/1496985031205703683 https://twitter.com/daniel_mcdowell/status/14969850312057036...
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoRussia has been pushing BTC on RT for a while now. Seems related. That would push the price up. Counter-move: Will this precipitate the banning of Bitcoin by/in the US? That would push the price down. (Simultaneously, possible rate increases also tend to push the price down.)
- derbOac 5y agoI was asking in some forums a few days before the invasion whether Russia would start pumping money into crypto, especially things like Monero. The response I got (aside from accusing me of selling crypto, even though I don't own any), was that it's seen as too unstable and too unpredictable an asset for oligarchs and so forth to put their money into. Switzerland also indicated they weren't doing anything about sanctions. There's other tax havens out there as well. That seemed like a good point to me; why put your money in bitcoin or Monero when you could put it into gold, or keep your money in a Swiss account? I'm sure these oligarchs have very solid ways of laundering money. On the other hand, maybe this will be just the sort of thing that kicks of practical reasons for use of crypto. Today there's articles about huge donations to Ukraine in the form of BTC, so who knows.
- mahkeiro 5y agoSwitzerland is imposing their own sanctions, and will make sure that Switzerland cannot be used to circumvent EU & US sanctions. https://twitter.com/BorisBusslinger/status/1497205399229022213?s=20&t=6lU2GbfOTR9p5EtC2p2KGQ https://twitter.com/BorisBusslinger/status/14972053992290222...
- hanniabu 5y ago> maybe this will be just the sort of thing that kicks of practical reasons for use of crypto There's already practical uses for crypto for exactly the same reasons you think there will be. All those uses currently exist and people are using them for that, no SWIFT lockout needed.
- politician 5y agoSWIFT is WhatsApp for payments. It doesn't move money, it moves messages concerning the movement of money. The alternative to SWIFT for banks is picking up the phone and calling the other bank to setup a transfer, or setting up a private API between banks.
- tlogan 5y agoI wonder what will be excuse after Putin invades Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania …
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoBecause the US is no longer the dominant economic force, nor the dominant military force (perhaps larger but spread too thin). We watched the USSR waste itself in Afghanistan, and then the US did the same thing. And just as public opinion was the lowest on the war, after a botched exit, Putin attacks Europe. The US should not have been in Afghanistan or Iraq, but oil companies said yes. It should be on the ground in Ukraine, but it can't because it is spent. On the subject of military power, Arther C Clarke's Superiority [1] is a great short story. "It shows the side which is more technologically advanced being defeated, despite its apparent superiority, because of its willingness to discard old technology without having fully perfected the new. Meanwhile, the enemy steadily built up a far larger arsenal of weapons that while more primitive were also more reliable." Ironically, the "advanced" technology isn't advanced anymore: the weapons are out of date. But they still manage to be expensive. The US knows this, and they can do nothing. All the screaming and howling in the media is just propaganda. They have already agreed to cede Ukraine. Putin already won the war electronically. The US is hopelessly divided. The nation that once put a man on the moon, that dominated science, now has radicalized citizens call in bomb threats to hospitals because they wont treat a patient with ivermectin. 50% of the population believe that the election was rigged. No surprise that Trump supports Putin. The US can't agree on whether covid is real, how can it keep promises it made to Ukraine? The US is a failed power. It is like the UK after it lost its empire: delusional. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superiority_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superiority_(short_story)
- pettusftw 5y ago> It should be on the ground in Ukraine, but it can't because it is spent. Should it? That's not a foregone conclusion. Your justification for why it "can't" is also quite debatable. > Meanwhile, the enemy steadily built up a far larger arsenal of weapons that while more primitive were also more reliable." Ironically, the "advanced" technology isn't advanced anymore: the weapons are out of date. How so, can you expand on justification for this line of thinking? > 50% of the population believe that the election was rigged. Not true, but I agree with your overall idea about the extreme levels of division. > how can it keep promises it made to Ukraine? What promises? If you're referencing denuclearization in the Budapest Memorandum, my understanding that it was not an assurance of protection from third parties, only an assurance of non-aggression from each signatory. Meaning the US made no guarantee to protect Ukraine from Russia if Russia broke the pact, which they have. Do you have any reason for disagreeing with that assessment?
- forty 5y agoMy understanding is that the US is okay doing it. The ones that are blocking this are Germany and Italy. Even France (where I am) said okay, even though our economic interests in Russia are quite big (I read that France companies are in total one of the largest foreign employer in Russia, la Société Générale owns a big Russian bank, and some of our energy companies have interest in Russia).True we don't depends as much on the gas. Germany, I'm so disappointed in you :(
- ape4 5y agoWhat if they add a service charge ;)
- godmode2019 5y agoEurope gives Russia 700 million a day for petrochemicals. They are financing the war in Ukraine, and will continue to do so, Europe makes their war donations via the swift payment system because they rely on Russian oil and gas. The Syrian war was largely about stopping a gas pipeline planned to go through Syria from Qatar to Europe which would have challenged the Russian gas monopoly. The Russian pipeline travels through Ukraine.
- HstryrsrBttn 5y agoIf there are still more than 300bn in Russia: maybe time to deinvest? Do it. Let them feel the pain. Either the Russian people start to realise what they support with Putin or they don't deserve any more mercy than Nazi-Germany.
- WastingMyTime89 5y agoDespite the article being clear as most commenters don’t read them anyway and considering the amount of non sense I have been reading on HN concerning SWIFT including in this very thread, I think some precisions are needed: - SWIFT is not American. It’s a cooperative headquartered and was funded in Belgium. - SWIFT is lead by a 25 members board of directors. No country can have more than two members on the board. - SWIFT is messaging system. It’s used to pass orders and it archives them. It is not involved in own these orders are settled. SWIFT is a telex replacement. - SWIFT is useful because banks have automation in place to directly process SWIFT formatted messages. It is important because banking institutions are slow moving and conservative. From a strictly technical point of view, doing what SWIFT does outside of SWIFT is extremely easy. It’s all IP based and the messaging format is standardised. - If you read articles about the impact of being disconnected from SWIFT, you will often see the case of Iran being used as an exemple. That’s garbage. Iran was hit by US sanctions threatening repercussions on anyone doing business with them using dollars. The figure quoted is not really due to them being cast out of the SWIFT network. - CIPS actually uses the same exchange format as SWIFT but on a different network. It’s a good showcase of how easy to do it is.
- useFAR 5y ago
- seniorivn 5y agofor some reason mainstream media and politicians don't talk about it, but there is an option to maximize chances to stop Putin detain families of all the people who have any connections to him, and freeze/seize their western assets and accounts. Until further notice. Everyone in Russia will know what it means, and some of Putin's establishment might be able to stop him to save their families and fortunes. It's absurd that families of most of Russian elites live in the west, all their money is stored in western banks and yet the only sanctions on the table are the ones that hurt the most regular people
- cheriot 5y ago> So, instead, we have an hour-long technical discussion where I ask them questions about web vitals, accessibility, the browser wars, and other similar topics about the web. I'd dramatically prefer a good programmer that needs to learn something new over a poor programmer applying the knowledge they already have. I've never come across a perfect interview question, but the goal should be to focus more on problem solving than knowledge. I've been out of web development for a while so the article was an interesting review/update, though.
- blunte 5y agoI have absolutely no expertise on this subject, but I think an effective approach would be to isolate and financially cripple the wealthy people who surround him. Make them hurt finally; basically make their "wealth" irrelevant outside of Russia. Lock down all their assets and ban them from entering the country (UK/US/many EU states). If a large group of powerful, very wealthy people suddenly find their luxury life threatened because of the small-man complex of one person, they will turn on that person - directly or more likely secretly. There must be enough people with enough money to collectively carry out a leadership replacement action. Add the "will of the people" who also don't want this war, and it should be easier to remove the source of the problem than to fight head on. To clarify, cutting the entire country off from SWIFT would be a clumsy approach when targeted measures could be taken as I suspect above.
- swframe2 5y agoTo paraphrase Hanlon's razor "Don't confuse reluctance with incompetence". The US is a rat's nest of different interests; it is too internally divided to fix hard problems. There are always wealthy political donors who control enough politicians to prevent a good solution. At this point, the US can only put lipstick on its incompetence. I do feel sorry for Ukraine but the GOP represents 40+% of the US electorate and they are now a cult rooted in disinformation (and supported by Russia). A nation this divided can't save itself; how can it save anyone else?
- avgcorrection 5y agoThe funny thing about the America-divided narrative is that the majority of liberal-leaning American opiners fall back on that same explanation (and then sprinkle on some paranoia about the vast reach of Russian disinformation for good measure). Maybe a rat’s nest of different interests but still suprisingly united ideologically.
- swframe2 5y agoYou posit that "the majority of liberals-leaning American"s hold the same beliefs in the "America-divided narrative" and yet conclude that everyone is "surprisingly united ideologically". That seems like a contradiction but it's possible we just disagree on what is ideologically important. For example, I think it is important that 74m Trump supporters think Trump is honest and an equal number of Trump haters think he is dishonest. How do you think liberals-leaning and conservative-leaning Americans are united ideologically?
- avgcorrection 5y agoYou’re right. I didn’t communicate that well.
- simonblack 5y agoRussia is channelling Dirty Harry: "Go ahead. Make my day."
- rurban 5y agoNot the west, just 3 countries vetoed it. The ones which are 100% dependent on cheap Russian gas in the winter. Or with Germany 60%.
- voidr 5y agoThe West is doing a great job at ignoring the fact that the Ukrainians are bullies themselves: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_policy_in_Ukraine#Ukraine's_2017_Education_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_policy_in_Ukraine#Ukr... Non Europeans also have trouble understanding that without Russian gas a lot of people would be without heating and Ukrainians don't care about that(their politician said so), but expect Europeans to care about them. The US is also quite allergic to armed neighbours, see Cuban Missile Crisis.