31 ms·
Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong?
- chaostheory 5y agoThe people who tend win from increased inflation are debtors. Imo the demographic with the most amount of debt are not “young people” as the article states.
- baragiola 5y agoTrust me, you don't want inflation. Source: Argentinian
- TremendousJudge 5y agoHah, but this time _they_ have the dollar printer. They can actually take the convertibility of 1 dollar = 1 dollar all the way to the stratosphere if they want. Greetings from a fellow neighbor
- guiye 5y agoyeah, today with 1 dollar you can buy a beer, then next year will cost you 2 dollars ;)
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoArgentina’s problem is it owes debt in dollars, so inflating the peso doesn’t reduce the debt.
- yazantapuz 5y agoNo. Our problem -I live in Argentina- is that we spend like there is no tomorrow and no consequences.
- imtringued 5y agoYes every permanent money system suffers from this problem. You can permanently take money out of circulation thereby forcing the government to replenish the supposedly lost money.
- cpr 5y agoSure, let's whitewash the current administration's total failure and rebrand as a success.
- titzer 5y agoI think there are decades of bad policy stacked on top of each other that are responsible for the current mess.
- aaa_aaa 5y agoCurrent administration created gazillions of dollars out of thin air, far more than previous ones. They deserve the credit.
- gilbetron 5y agoHmm - this stimulus check seems odd, then: https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/106514776-1588262659494gettyimages-1221870060.jpeg?v=1605545731 https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/106514776-158826265949...
- efdee 5y ago[citation needed]
- GeekyBear 5y agoThe enormous increase in money creation is very real, but it started in the last year of the Trump administration. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL
- brandmeyer 5y agoRelevant to interpreting M1 and its sudden jump in 2020: https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/05/savings-are-now-more-liquid-and-part-of-m1-money/?utm_source=series_page&utm_medium=related_content&utm_term=related_resources&utm_campaign=fredblog https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/05/savings-are-now-more...
- whakim 5y agoThe basic assumption here is that inflation reduces inequality. That's plausible (it certainly was a strong contributing factor to the great reductions in inequality that occurred between 1920 and 1950). But inflation is also an extremely blunt-force instrument: lots of people who aren't very wealthy also get hurt. I'm not sure why we'd want that in a world where fiscal policy (i.e., taxation) exists, unless we've just thrown up our hands and abdicated all responsibility about what kind of society we want to live in to unelected Central Banks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jhawk28 5y agoIf anything it increases inequality. It hurts the poor the most. The wealthy are more immune because they will have their wealth in things that go up with inflation. When it is caused by the government spending more than it takes in, it is effectively a hidden tax. NONE of these things are new concepts. Even the belief that the inflation won't hurt is new. Many other societies have blindly thought they were immune until they were not.
- efdee 5y agoWhen you say the wealthy are immune because their wealth is in things that go up with inflation, what exactly are you thinking about? Not stocks for sure. Maybe those who have money invested in property for hire, but even then whether your income goes up with inflation strongly depends on where you are location. Interesting to know: in some countries (eg. Belgium) wages are automatically adapted to inflation, so "the poor" aren't hurt at all.
- usefulcat 5y agoWhy would you not expect stocks to increase with inflation? Most of the time, stocks have far outpaced inflation for several decades now.
- 5y ago
- Johnny555 5y agoHave We Been Thinking about Inflation All Wrong? The answer is almost certainly "yes" because the economy is complex and you can't really distill it into a single number that gives a clear signal for "good" or "bad". Skew in the price of individual goods (like luxury cars, or food staples) can make the inflation number out of sync with the impact on average people.
- titzer 5y agoDon't tell the 80s that!
- djrogers 5y agoIt's telling that the vast majority of the pushback on the 'inflation is bad' viewpoint comes from well-off academics, tech folks, and just generally people who are hurt the least by inflation.
- Avshalom 5y agoI unload trucks and stock shelves at Target. You think my viewpoint about inflation is gonna get published in a way that anyone sees?
- BitwiseFool 5y agoThere's a viral video going around of a Target employee placing a new price tag on Jimmy Dean breakfast biscuits. Sure it's not getting treated as seriously as an article in the New York Times written by Paul Krugman, but it's arguably having a greater impact than one of his milquetoast columns on the subject. So please, do share what you're seeing.
- Avshalom 5y agoI mean that's not really the point. The thing is that if a journalist writes an article about inflation they might ask me if inflation is affecting me but of course the majority of the article will be from "experts" because otherwise they get called out for giving equal weight to Random J. Asshole as they do to economists or whatever. So every article pro/con/neutral about complex economic phenomena is going to be majority academics or bank CEOs or fed-reserve spox. That's the nature of journalism.
- feoren 5y agoI'll see it, if you type it out right now in this comment. I think shelf-stockers have more power than ever to get their views heard.
- imtringued 5y agoYou benefit by keeping your job. In the current system deflation means you become useless to society. Yes capitalism is a ponzi scheme.
- miki_tyler 5y agoInflation washes out debt. Who think inflation is good? People, companies or institutions that are buried in debt to the tits. For the rest of us it is just an extra hand inside our pockets.
- causi 5y agoInflation washes out debt as long as wages are rising with inflation. If they're not it's just crushing us all.
- odonnellryan 5y agoNot true. Likely with high inflation the real return on your debt is positive. My mortgage returned +4.5% last year. That is a great investment!
- odonnellryan 5y agoIt's also probably fine if you do not have large amounts of cash savings. Lots of people have debt. I think most or almost everyone has debt.
- theritis87 5y ago
- mdavis6890 5y agoThe thing to keep in mind is that what really matters is stuff: The goods and services that add economic value to our lives, like shoes, houses, food, sports games, accounting services, haircuts, etc. Also called the metaphorical "pie." Inflation is bad to the extent that it causes the total stuff we produce to go down or to become more poorly distributed, and good to the extent that it does the opposite. And a shrinking of the pie - a reduction in stuff produced - can/will cause inflation assuming people have the same or greater amount of money with which they can purchase that stuff. The more we stay focused on the production of stuff, and less on the quantity of money or inflation, the better off we will be, and inflation will take care of itself.
- pdonis 5y ago> Inflation is bad to the extent that it causes the total stuff we produce to go down or to become more poorly distributed, and good to the extent that it does the opposite. Even doing the opposite can be bad if it's the wrong stuff. It's not just the total amount of stuff that matters; it's how much of the stuff is stuff people actually need or want, as opposed to stuff that gets produced but never actually used because it wasn't produced to meet a customer need, it was produced because of misallocation of resources. > The more we stay focused on the production of stuff, and less on the quantity of money or inflation, the better off we will be, and inflation will take care of itself. I agree with being focused on production, as long as it's production driven by actual customer needs. But that also means not just not focusing on the quantity of money, but taking away the government's ability to manipulate the quantity of money. Otherwise you will get misallocation of resources and you'll be producing the wrong things.
- ren_engineer 5y ago>I agree with being focused on production, as long as it's production driven by actual customer needs this has always been an interesting question to me, because in theory companies like Facebook are worth hundreds of billions despite making many people miserable and actually lowering productivity by wasting time. Basically part of the sin economy, things like gambling and drugs. All bring in lots of money but we'd arguably be better off without them. Facebook makes money by getting people addicted to their app by design. Customers and markets aren't rational if the people are driven by addiction, in which case it would make sense for the government to intervene. China is doing this by incentivizing people to go into hard sciences like semiconductors instead of consumer software
- gtsop 5y agoAn analogy of what I hear: A surgeon having a nearly dismantled body in front of them, thinking "hmm maybe I should have put a hanzaplast on that poor fella, maybe would have saved him" Surgeon being the "economists", body being the economy.
- kkoncevicius 5y agoThe best one-sentence description of inflation I've heard is: inflation is a hidden tax on savings. People who save money are hurt the most. It's as if the newly printed money is generated by taking a bit from anyone according to how much cash he/she has stored away.
- matzab 5y agoinflation is a hidden tax on savings That's basically Germany's state motto.
- forgetfulness 5y agoThe people hurt in most tangible ways are the ones who don't have the capacity to save; if you were spending all your salary each month, living hand to mouth, inflation now means fewer and less quality goods and services. And that can be eating less nutritious food, having to use more worn down clothes, having to postpone medical/veterinary expenses further, etc. Now, it happens that in the US the people working the least paid jobs have seen a wage increase, but that won't be necessarily the case and they aren't the only ones on a tight budget.
- kkoncevicius 5y agoThe things is that markets adapt but lag behind. For a while the old prices are still in place while the money is being printed. Then, slowly, the market "notices" that the amount of money increased so the prices readjust. While the prices readjust - everything becomes more expensive. Your haircut is more expensive - so the hair stylists salary catches up. Your bread becomes more expensive so the farmers that produce flour also have their salaries catch up. Everything eventually catches up, except for the amounts of money that were allocated to savings.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoThat’s not true at all. Salaries aren’t increasing at the same rate that food, goods, and services. Stuff gets more expensive at a greater rate than wages increase.
- TheMagicHorsey 5y agoInflation is bad in the sense it punishes people that made the right decisions and saved money for their retirement. Inflation eats away at the savings they made in their working life and makes them a pauper in old age. The argument that they should have been invested fully into the market is fine for educated people. But many uneducated people save cash because they do not have access to all the financial tools that educated people do. Inflation also empowers elites who have had access to debt. Inflation reduces the value of that debt in real terms and cements their wealth ... because they use debt to acquire real assets: real estate, companies, stock, etc. Inflation rewards the elites and punishes the working savers. It is a tool that is used to transfer wealth from the many to the few. So I oppose these periodic debasements of currency. Look at the examples of Venezuela and Argentina to understand the true dynamics of inflation.
- imtringued 5y agoYes, we should abolish inflation by implementing negative interest rates on cash and adopting price level targeting. Long term interest rates will be 0% on certificates of deposit. This is consistent with saving for retirement.
- TheMagicHorsey 5y agoYou seem to misunderstand how interest works in a society that uses capital in production and in the purchase of income producing assets. I also don't suggest price level targeting.
- softwarebeware 5y agoBetteridge's Law of Headlines says: "No."
- sneeze-slayer 5y agoRampant inflation is a problem. The inflation seen now in many places is not quite there. 7% is higher than we would like, but if the alternative is to have shrinking GDP and massive unemployment, I would rather have some inflation. In the US at least, a lot of the raise in the US CPI is due to rising energy costs (predicted months ago due to cold winter in Asia), used and new cars (the infamous chip shortages), and food. Rising food costs is a problem, but it is not a catastrophic problem. The US federal government could subsidize farmers that grow real vegetables, not just corn and soybeans. This would bring down the cost of real food and probably allow people to eat healthier.
- xyzzyz 5y ago> The US federal government could subsidize farmers that grow real vegetables, not just corn and soybeans. You can’t subsist on “real vegetables”. Vegetables form important supplement to the diet, but they are not basis of it, nor they ever been (people used to eat much more grain and much less meat and vegetables than they do now). Governments are subsidizing staples, because it is by far most effective way to ensure food security.
- sirspacey 5y agoHaving been a recipient of those programs “staples” are not what is being subsidized. The largest “food” producers are, like General Mills and Coca Cola. I could get soda but not fresh fruits or vegetables for my kids. We somehow have to keep discussing what real nutrition for children looks like and the impact it has on their ability to become productive citizens. It’s really not that much of a mystery anymore, plenty of reproducible studies have been done, but our systems are still not designed to achieve it. Yes, it makes a massive difference what the goals of food security are.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y ago>The US federal government could subsidize farmers that grow real vegetables, not just corn and soybeans. I mean they could also just stop subsidizing corn production quite so much; that would probably be preferable to providing a larger subsidy to grow other things.
- mise_en_place 5y agoInflation favors the debtor, while deflation favors the saver. Obviously the world's largest debtor (US govt) will consider inflation to be desirable and necessary. Otherwise it would lead to a sovereign debt crisis if there are positive real interest rates leading to a US govt default. Keep an eye on the Fed, especially before the midterm elections. The Biden administration will put an extreme amount of pressure to continue quantitative easing, even if the Fed is signaling that rate hikes are coming soon.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Inflation favors the debtor, while deflation favors the saver No, deflation favors currency hoarders and lenders; the primary mechanism of saving is investment in productive assets, which deflation disfavors. > Obviously the world's largest debtor (US govt) will consider inflation to be desirable and necessary. Except it doesn't, except at a very low level; inflation in general (and energy inflation, in particular, which is one of the main factors in the current overall inflation) is one of the most well-established objective factors adverse to reelection of incumbent politicians in the US. > Keep an eye on the Fed, especially before the midterm elections. The Biden administration will put an extreme amount of pressure to continue quantitative easing, even if the Fed is signaling that rate hikes are coming soon. If? The Fed is already tapering QE, scheduled to end it mid-March, and signalling a mid-March rate hike.
- imtringued 5y agoI wish we could finally end the inflation farce. A demurrage fee has only to be paid on liquidity i.e cash and demand deposits. If people lend their money at 0% interest they can save money. Since financing is much cheaper companies can afford to pay workers more. Inflation can be controlled via price level trageting all the way to zero.
- xyzzyz 5y agoInflation only favors the debtor if he doesn’t have to take on more debt. USG has a lot of short term debt it needs to continuously roll over. If inflation persists, the yields will go up, so USG will roll over the current low interest rate debt to new high interest rate debt. Given how much debt it has, the service payments will skyrocket: at 130% debt to GDP ratio, and at 27% tax to GDP ratio, each 1 percentage point increase in yields translates to additional 1.3% worth of GDP going to debt service payments, which is around 5% of total government spending. That means that if current inflation persists, and the bond investors will expect 7% inflation instead of 2% inflation, they’ll demand bond yields to be at least 5 percentage points higher. This will make the debt service payments go from current 6% of the budget to nearly 1/3rd of it, a tremendous increase. This will only increase fiscal pressure on the government, making it less credit worthy, which will push yields even higher. No, if you’re indebted above your head with mostly short term debt, inflation does not make you happy.
- hartator 5y agoKeeping readjusting pricing and no knowing what a dollar is truly worth is a net loss for the people. It’s literally economics 101.
- imtringued 5y agoYes and this is why we should add negative interest rates to money and land value taxes to land so we can finally concentrate on more meaningful things than to engage in an endless over employment and under employment spiral.
- jbay808 5y agoWhen it starts to get really burdensome to keep your promises, the idea of breaking them gets really attractive. But that doesn't come for free. It costs credibility. The cost of central banks breaking their inflation-control commitment when inflation starts running hot, is that the market starts pricing in their unwillingness to raise interest rates. This fuels a whole bunch of other inflation feedback loops, and then before you know it, the central bank wants to get inflation back under control again. But now nobody believes that they'll do what they say they're going to do, so they end up having to work twice as hard. If your goal is stability, it's better to just keep your promises to begin with.
- jonnycomputer 5y agoStability is a notion that depends on scale. You might have a long slow decline that feels relatively stable, but leaves you in a bad place. It seems to me that was the trajectory we were on.
- zozbot234 5y agoYup. The kernel of truth behind Austrian theories of macroeconomics/the business cycle is that interest-rate based policy setting is inherently an unstable system. If the central bank makes policy errors that fail to stabilize the underlying target (whether inflation, nominal income, exchange rates, whatever) the whole system starts spiraling away from that unstable equilibrium point, and the subsequently needed correction grows even larger. It's important that errors be promptly corrected, and expectations about future policy remain properly "anchored" to the right target.
- wolpoli 5y ago> It's important that errors be promptly corrected, and expectations about future policy remain properly "anchored" to the right target. It would be interesting to know if inflation expectation has become unanchored in the mind of the general public, because, ultimately, inflation expectation causes inflation.
- 5y ago
- ccuqui 5y agoInflation is the direct result of governments printing money like crazy to hide why they spend money like crazy and continue to be extremely inefficient and corrupt instead of cutting expenses and becoming more efficient and leaner. And it mainly affects the poorest in society. How can that be good?! Don't take my word for it: see what is happening in Argentina, Venezuela, Brazil, etc and then decide for yourself how "good" it is to live in a country with high inflation rates...
- TremendousJudge 5y agoBrazil has had its inflation under control (for Latin American standards, anyway) since the 90s, after the Plan Real. Also, Latin American runaway inflation is something that has been happening since the 60s, every measure under the sun has been tried to fix it, with only limited success in some cases. Anyway, it's a bit more complicated than "spending money like crazy and being corrupt".
- valcron1000 5y agoIn Argentina the cause is plain and simply "spending money like crazy and being corrupt". Source: I've been living here for my whole life.
- imtringued 5y agoRead Silvio Gesell's book or watch the silvio gesell institute on youtube. His economic theory is based on his experience of inflation and deflation crises in argentina. His son founded villa gesell.
- digisign 5y agoIn the last few years the Real has dropped about 50% compared to gold and the dollar.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoInflation != value compared to the dollar Unlike other Latin American countries, Brazil's economy is mostly decoupled from the dollar -- people don't save in dollars, they save in reales. Prices are all in reales (including housing and cars, something that is usually in dollars in other countries), and most importantly, the national debt is in reales, and mostly internal. A rise in the price of the dollar is not necessarily harmful to the people living there if the prices don't rise the same way, and it can even be beneficial by making the exports more competitive in the world market.
- ojbyrne 5y agoThis goes back in history to mention the 2008 financial crisis, but doesn't go far enough. Those who were around in the 70s remember stagflation - high inflation and high unemployment - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stagflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stagflation
- WillPostForFood 5y agoIf inflation were allowed to run a bit higher, it could deliver a long-overdue win for young people who have had to face a combination of stagnant wages and rising housing costs. Inciting inflation to fix rising houses costs and stagnant wages is kinda crazy. It definitely won't help housing prices, and wages increases are almost always lag behind price increases.
- redisman 5y agoI don’t understand hire this helps. Personally I got a 4% raise against 7.5% inflation so..
- sleepingadmin 5y agoThe walrus being a far-left MMT proposing place wrote this when inflation was at 3.5% or so. It's now much higher and very evidently out of control. The article quotes Mark Carney, as if he were on their side. BoE under Carney have raised interest rates twice: https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/interest-rate https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/interest-rate and that hasn't even dented inflation. https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/inflation-cpi I believe Carney has a speech tonight which most likely will touch on inflation and interest rates. Guess we'll see. MMT and UBI as political subjects have been utterly dead since the time this article was written. What a disaster of an article.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> It's now much higher and very evidently out of control. Monthly inflation is slowing, and is at an annualized 4.8%. We had a big spike in the summer/fall that's still showing up in our annual figures, but inflation itself is coming under control. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30289147 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30289147
- overtonwhy 5y agoYeah but they're a brand new user who is claiming that everything is terrible!
- nostrademons 5y ago0.6% monthly inflation annualized isn't 4.8%. Not really sure how you got 4.8%, but the computation you want is 1.006^12 = 1.0744, about 7.4% (which also happens to match the annualized figures).
- bryanlarsen 5y agoA year has 8 months, doesn't it?
- e4e78a06 5y agoCoincidentally government transfer payments funded by deficit spending reached a new low for the year [1]. I'd also add CPI underestimates true inflation because it uses hedonic adjustments, but in real life consumers don't keep buying crappier and crappier products. If you use 1980 methodology for computing CPI it's around 15% annualized now [2]. [1]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-government-recorded-119-billion-budget-surplus-its-first-since-before-pandemic-11644519768 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-government-recorded-119-bil... [2]: http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/inflation-charts http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/inflation-charts
- licnep 5y agoIt always seems weird to me how people think of inflation as a single number, when it is made of made of many different components, some prices might be going down or constant, while others are rising. Energy prices rising are definitely the most impactful ones cause they affect every sector.
- rglover 5y agoWhen you have to write propaganda about a thing that's long-term been identified as "bad," (with ample historical examples) actually being a good thing, you're being willfully dishonest and in denial. Many here will fight and bicker and kick and scream but Bitcoin is the only solution to the absolute ruin being dangled over the millenial and younger generations (primarily because it disconnects state/human control of the currency and programmatically enforces a cap on issuance while ensuring transparency and consensus on a global level).
- chasd00 5y agoi don't know about bitcoin but you do have a point about the current spin being put on high inflation. High inflation is universally known as bad for an economy.. until now for some reason.
- rglover 5y ago> High inflation is universally known as bad for an economy.. until now for some reason. Because, presumably, the shoe is about to drop and they want citizens to willfully accept their savings/investments going to zero and replaced with a digital surveillance currency (CBDC or Central Bank Digital Currency). If they can convince the general population that "inflation is good," they're less likely to take flight to alternatives like metals, Bitcoin, land, etc or try to behead the bankers who stole their wealth. IMO, MMT is just Stockholm Syndrome rebranded for finance.
- standardUser 5y agoI don't think anyone is arguing in favor of sustained high inflation, and we also don't currently have sustained high inflation. But some inflation is good for the economy, and current inflation currently hasn't gone much past "some" after being extremely low for a very long time despite obvious inflationary pressure.
- DethNinja 5y agoHigh inflation rates just after a supply shock will wipe-out the middle class and push most to poverty. Honestly, I can't believe more people aren't buying Bitcoin at this stage.
- 01100011 5y agoI am beginning to think that the fed will try to engineer a situation where wage gains are leading prices in a wage price spiral. Why? Because inflation solves a world of problems(i.e. unsustainable debt). It avoids cancelling the 'wealth effect' currently deluding half the population into thinking they're rich. Inflation sucks when your wages aren't rising as fast as prices. Inflation isn't so bad, I think, when you are getting paid more but then subsequently prices rise. If a demographic and cultural shift causes a permanent shortage of workers, one could envision a scenario where wages have to rise to compete for talent and in that environment inflation could be tolerated. Inflation means the fed doesn't have to pop the asset, real estate and commodities bubbles. Those bubbles softly deflate as their prices only drop in real dollars as the USD loses value. A hundred million voters don't wake up feeling poorer, unless they're the suckers who own the fixed rate debt. As a moron who is currently holding lots of cash, I'm hoping the fed will have the fortitude to fight inflation. History shows they do not, however.
- bittercynic 5y agoIt's a tricky situation to be in. I try to believe that I cannot time the market, time in the market beats timing the market... but just can't bring myself to buy into it right now. It's been so long since we've had a recession, and it seems like we've forgotten the lessons of 2008. It may not be subprime mortgages this time, but lots of people seem to believe asset prices only go up, much like they did in 2007. Maybe this time really is different, but I don't believe it.
- yk 5y agoThe article appears to confuse several different mechanism, that all would manifest in inflation. On one hand there is the expansion of the monetary base after the financial crisis, that never ended up as price increases because the money got stuck in the stock market and businesses increase prices when they believe their customers can pay more, that is when wages rise. On the other hand, what we are seeing right now is the market adjusting to a covid economy, people suddenly need webcams, better laptops and office chairs and consequently these products rise in price because there are not enough of them. Now, in the second case the central bank can't do much about the inflation, because it is a production problem, not a monetary problem.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoNo. Just because your model of something isn't predicting as well as before doesn't mean it is 'all wrong'.
- yoyar 5y agoInflation of the money supply leads to prices that end up higher than they otherwise would have been. This does not necessarily mean nominally higher prices. This is a distinction that leads people to say things like: Obama did it and prices didn't go up. With the implication that it might be ok to inflate to infinity.
- uticus 5y ago> If inflation were allowed to run a bit higher, it could deliver a long-overdue win for young people who have had to face a combination of stagnant wages and rising housing costs. My understanding is that inflation hurts fixed income, especially the elderly who don't have the advantage of young people where they can change jobs or absorb risk as readily. If that's true, then the "wrongness" of inflation has been pinpointed - it's ethically wrong to financially hurt our elderly.
- namdnay 5y ago> it's ethically wrong to financially hurt our elderly. Why would it be more wrong to hurt the elderly than the young? The elderly are far wealthier
- cableshaft 5y agoYouth don't have as much (or any) savings to lose and can switch jobs / demand a raise to make a higher wage. Anything they do have saved is probably invested and increasing in value along with inflation. Elderly just have less money to eke a living on, and can no longer get a job (most likely). Everyone gets hurt by inflation (well, maybe not if you have a ton of debt), but the elderly are stuck and can't do anything about it.
- uticus 5y ago> The elderly are far wealthier Ignoring the stats, please think long term about your implications. Let's imagine you are a young person. Your wage increase means you have $20 to save for retirement, vs $10. However, if inflation remains average overall, by the time you get to retirement, your $10 buys $5 worth of stuff. On top of that, you are now old. A young person decides you are able to pay more because you've saved more (having had more time to save). Your $10 in retirement is reduced to $8, to buy $5 worth of stuff.
- dnautics 5y ago> If inflation were allowed to run a bit higher, it could deliver a long-overdue win for young people who have had to face a combination of stagnant wages and rising housing costs what the hell? Inflation exists as a policy to stiff wage-earners. This is arguably more likely to go exactly the other way than the author expects. Take it from a nobel laureate: https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-higher-inflation/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-hi... > it’s really, really hard to cut nominal wages. Yet when you have very low inflation, getting relative wages right would require that a significant number of workers take wage cuts [...but when you have inflation, their wages get cut without anyone being the wiser!!].
- fennecfoxen 5y agoDon't worry, it'll be great! You'll get a 10% raise, and prices will only be up 15%.
- dnautics 5y agoTo be frank, for a small sliver of wage:mortgage ratios this could be fucking fantastic... for "young wage-earners" who already have a house (like me! but I'm not really that young anymore). For other wage-earners, not so much, sad trombone.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoYeah, if you're at all on the fence, or close to the fence, it's a fine time to get a mortgage, even if house prices have gone up somewhat. An excellent inflation hedge!
- Nbox9 5y agoRising interest rates is likely to have a significant downward pressure on home prices. Think carefully before entering a very leveraged position (like the 3.5% down FHA loan) in the current market.
- CyberRabbi 5y agoThroughout this entire “stimulus” fiasco, my faith in the ability of nominally smart people to independently reason about simple concepts like supply, demand, and inflation has been humbled. First there was a denial that inflation was occurring now there is an excessive panic that it signals the end of the economy. Can I get off this clown car? Periods of unusually high inflation happens. This happened in the 70s. It will happen again. The fundamentals of the American economy are changing but not in any dramatic way since at least the 90s. Everything is still made in China, we are still a service economy.
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoThis nihlism about currency depreciation and deficit spending will end badly. Two plus two does equal four, no matter how much more profitable or convenient it would be for it to equal four trillion.
- meerita 5y agoHow can be good to let inflation soar? Didn't the author of the article never stepped in Venezuela or Argentina?
- wolpoli 5y agoThere used to be a simulator called Chair the Fed [1] that shows the effects of various economic shock and the interest rate movements that's required to stablize the inflation rate and maintain full employment. In a negative demand shock similar to what we just experienced, it requires quite a bit of high real interest rate (Interest rate - Inflation rate) to slowly get inflation back down. Sadly, they removed the game early in the pandemic and I can't get it to work on archive.org. [1]: https://www.sffed-education.org/chairthefed/WebGamePlay https://www.sffed-education.org/chairthefed/WebGamePlay
- jonnycomputer 5y agoIt'd be one thing if we weren't seeing high economic growth at the same time as inflation. But we are. So maybe this is the thing we need to get labor back in a place where their salaries match their productivity.
- spaetzleesser 5y ago“So maybe this is the thing we need to get labor back in a place where their salaries match their productivity.” Otherwise all the economical growth is just BS for most people.
- readthenotes1 5y agoInflation is great for people and companies with fixed rate debt. I'm sure that the prospect of increasing personal and corporate wealth has nothing to do with the motivations for wanting more inflation though.
- oonerspism 5y agoWe will always be thinking about inflation wrong, if we consider it in isolation. (a rule true of most things, but I digress...) Intrinsic to inflation is it's relationship with Interest Rates. The global pendulum swings to inflation for a phase, and then it swings back to high(er) interest rates for a phase. "The squeeze" (or "the expansion"!, depending upon which side of the equation one falls) is put on in one direction, and then, some years later, the tables are turned and the squeeze is eventually applied in the opposite direction. So to consider inflation as though it were an isolated system able to be managed in it's own right will always be problematic, in the way of trying to change one cog of a clock mechanism (without considering the whole).
- steve76 5y ago[dead]
- ankaAr 5y agoInflation=bad Repeat with me: if the inflation is going up, I will run away. Laughs in Argentinian inflation (50% or more for last years) Put your money to work when inflation is running loose, look or save on another currency, stock stuff or buy something that is not loosing value. 1001 ways to survive in Latin America
- rmason 5y agoMost folks on HN aren't old enough to remember inflation as an adult and it's effects but I am. Nothing in my life hurt more people than inflation. If you were older and on a fixed income you were screwed, folks had to sell their possessions to survive. I remember farmers paying 20% interest to get loans for fertilizer, fuel and seed to plant their crop. The average person overnight had less buying power. The only people who benefited were the rich. If they owned land or buildings the prices shot up. If they were highly leveraged they could pay off their loans with cheaper dollars. If they were in business they could raise prices on what they sold and pass along the cost to someone else.
- xapata 5y ago40 years ago, there were many fewer stock market participants, and many more retirees on fixed income. Now it's relatively rare to retire with a fixed-income pension. More of us are shareholders now, with IRAs and 401ks.
- ledauphin 5y agomost of _us_, I can easily believe. But most _people_ in the Western world? I'd like to see some references.
- xapata 5y agoI don't know about the "Western world" but in the US stock ownership is dramatically more prevalent. At the same time, pension plans have nearly disappeared in the private sector. The ownership rates are trivially searchable. The 2nd link I found was a Gallup survey that estimated around 60% of US residents, which is roughly 1.5x the portion that have a college degree. If you're thinking of the poor, Social Security payments increase with inflation, so they're not quite fixed-income.
- FrameworkFred 5y agoWell, I guess the question is what will happen when Not-Canada manages to achieve stable prices while Canada lets theirs "run hot." It seems to me the rest of the world would make sure to hang on to Not-Canadian currency while being very willing to swap Canadian currency for everything else, which would increase the supply of Canadian currency, causing further Canadian inflation. Or is the author suggesting we should somehow convince the entire world to let their currencies "run hot"? What if a few holdouts went rogue and (gasp) maintained a relatively low rate of inflation for their currency? I can reason out why a low and steady rate of inflation might cause folks to keep money moving around in an economy, but a do-nothing approach seems silly and unworkable over the long term on a global scale.
- lend000 5y agoNote that the only times in the last few decades (and possibly throughout modern history) that wealth inequality decreased were during economic recessions [0]. Sometimes, you just need to let the market reallocate capital. Short term versus long term thinking. Governments should be primarily in the business of long term thinking, because they are the only organizations positioned to do so. [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBST01134 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBST01134
- cat_plus_plus 5y agoPersonally, I love the idea of not having to pay back what I borrowed to buy my house. But I also can't be so anti-social as to advocate screwing over everyone who doesn't have money for a downpayment and can't afford the risk of keeping their savings in the market. They really ought to be able to put some money in a savings account, or in a jar if they don't have access to banking, and have an idea of what their savings will be worth in a decade. Better educate people that they sometimes have to take a pay cut to stay employed than hoodwink them and leave them destitute down the road.
- Melatonic 5y agoThe good side of inflation is that if your massively in debt then your debt just became less valuable. Your earnings probably did too but you can always try to get a raise or get a better job.
- x3sphere 5y ago> If inflation were allowed to run a bit higher, it could deliver a long-overdue win for young people who have had to face a combination of stagnant wages and rising housing costs. “ Yeah this doesn't make any sense. Housing price increases have far outpaced any increase in wages. If inflation continues to run hot, I expect housing will just get even more expensive especially as investors will be frantic to park their money in something that beats inflation.
- j7ake 5y agoThis is wrong because inflation will eat into the size of monthly payments you can contribute to your mortgage, and thus lower the total dollars of house you can buy. Imagine if groceries and gas take more and more of your income. If/when interest rates go up, it will also decrease price of houses because the cost of borrowing will go up, and thus lower the total dollars of house you can buy. If you’ve already bought your house then great, but expect to sell the home at a huge loss when interest rates hit 20 percent.
- rr808 5y agoThis seems backwards. Yes central banks have had a low inflation target but the biggest fight of the last 14 years since 2008 has been against deflation. Central banks have kept dropping rates because prices have stayed so low and were in danger of falling. Inflation has suddenly spiked up - everyone should be happy that at last the deflationary spiral has stopped. As long as doesn't continue central banks are happy.
- m348e912 5y agoThis isn't talked about much but it has to be considered. There is a relationship between interest rates and the repayment rate of the 30 Trillion in US debt that's owed. Even a moderate increase in rates, to 5-6% (way short of almost 20% we saw under Volker), would be catastrophic in terms of being able to service the debt which would affect bond and treasury interest payments. Perhaps the Fed is stuck between a rock and a hard place. Continued inflation is the do-nothing outcome, which to me means it's more likely to happen.
- baryphonic 5y agoI've had a similar thought for a few years. It began to doubt it when it looked like we might actually correct for this with decent growth, including real increases in productivity-improving technologies. But the pandemic has now disabused me of any trust. We seem to be in some sort of regulatory-debt trap. The government needs growth to sustain itself, but it can't do that because it has no control over the administrative state. So therefore it inflates, which harms growth (and has horrible distributional effects) but helps with debt, at least until lenders stop showing up to the bond auctions.
- rhacker 5y agoNo, just read here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Target/comments/sllin5/inflation_in_real_time/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Target/comments/sllin5/inflation_in... And then post a new article that says you were an idiot for writing that.
- mostertoaster 5y agoInflation is a great tool if the sign of being prosperous is how much you consume. You will definitely cause the net amount of things that are consumed to increase. For the sake of the environment some deflation might actually be good.
- rmason 5y ago"Inflation is as violent as a mugger, as frightening as an armed robber and as deadly as a hit man.” — President Ronald Reagan
- infologics 5y ago[dead]
- jhoechtl 5y agoInflation really is all about transferring money from those who create to those who produce. Those who create are called workers and those who produce entrepreneurs. Once the creators buy something they are consumers. As a side note: Ironically those who consume are the ones who created it before, therefore Marx thought it would be natural that the working class should be in control. You want to create positive inflation so the creators have a an incentive to consume because prices in next year a higher than today. You want to create positive inflation which is not to high as otherwise prices for life-essential goods (energy, water, basic food) increase and a higher proportion of the available income has to be spent on this goods instead on consumables. The right amount of inflation is dependent on many, many, many factors, for one the availability of cheap energy. Many factors in the model to economic growth are feed-back therefore small changes to one factor can create large effects up to point where the system becomes erratic (chaotic) See the IS-LM model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IS%E2%80%93LM_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IS%E2%80%93LM_model , assuming that interest rate and inflation are directly dependent.
- Einstant 5y agoInflation is an important topic to discuss when looking at the hackernews algorithm. Central banks breaking their inflation-control commitment can lead to a lot of negative consequences, like market distrust and higher rates. It's therefore important to be honest and keep your promises if you want to maintain stability in the economy. For example, Reagan's tight monetary policy helped to tame inflation in the 1980s. Nixon's decision to break the gold standard in 1971, on the other hand, caused a lot of instability in the economy. The Gold standard and inflation are complex topics, and further reading is recommended for those interested in learning more. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/121015/what-gold-standard.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/121015/what-... https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/inflation.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/inflation.asp https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/inflation_target.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/inflation_targ...
- smsm42 5y agoI would be more inclined to seriously consider the premise if the US weren't in the middle of the worst inflation bout in decades, and that wouldn't be critically inconvenient to certain politicians, facing an election quite soon, and I hadn't read many articles in the press affiliated with those politicians claiming that first the inflation doesn't exist and next that the inflation is actually very good. Given all that, I am having a hard time now taking any arguments towards it seriously. Also, > For decades, governments have done all they can to keep inflation down Did they really? I mean, like the inflation is something that pops out of nowhere by a quirk of cruel nature, having nothing to do with government actions - or it's an entirely predictable - and repeatedly predicted - result of such actions? If the latter, can we seriously clam they done all they can to avoid it, if they actually done all they can to cause it?