29 ms·
I changed my mind about advertising
- soheil 5y agoJust because you find a crazy edge case that ads work for doesn’t make advertising as a whole any less evil.
- threshold 5y agoI hate advertising more than ever. I consider it a form of rape, no joke. I’ll not tolerate it at all, for any reason, ever again.
- quxpar 5y agoThe problem with attention as a form of currency is that people are, almost definitionally, not aware when it is being taken from them.
- mcherm 5y agoThat doesn't HAVE to be true. Consider a newspaper with articles and ads. The customer is absolutely aware of the attention currency when there are articles side-by-side with ads. And the customer may decide NOT to pick up the free local "paper" in the supermarket bin that's 80% ads with only a few articles. On the other hand, when there are ads that are formatted like articles, but with a little disclaimer ("This is a paid advertisement"). Those can be confusing. Better newspapers will do things like using a black border or requiring a different font to make it easier for customers to tell the difference. Finally, there are articles written by the newspaper's journalists about a topic chosen by an advertiser -- those are VERY subtle and confusing to the customer. I presume you can on your own extend this metaphor from newspapers to the Web.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago"I've changed my mind because my income depends on it and I don't want to feel like the bad guy"
- williamtrask 5y agoAnd he misses the point. Ask yourself what’s the difference between an ad engine and a recommender engine? In a recommender engine, the best recommendation for your quality of life is at the top. In an ad engine… that list gets resorted Advertising’s true cost is opportunity cost. It’s the lost opportunity of knowing the actual best option for your quality of life.
- quietbritishjim 5y agoI'm not trying to defend ads in general, but one problem that a recommender engine certainly suffers from is how to deal with a new entity. How do you make a new entrant gets into that list even though, while they may provide value, there's currently no evidence of that are far as the recommender is concerned?
- cf 5y agoWhile often ignored, item-to-item similarity recommenders work really well for new items and have been the basis for Amazon's and YouTube's early recommendation algorithms https://glinden.blogspot.com/2011/02/youtube-uses-amazons-recommendation.html?m=1 https://glinden.blogspot.com/2011/02/youtube-uses-amazons-re...
- lostcolony 5y agoI think you may be misunderstanding the parent (I may also be misunderstanding though) - they're saying that with a new user (not a new product), you have no information for providing recommendations to them; you have no idea what they're interested in.
- quietbritishjim 5y agoI was talking about new products/movies/whatever, not users. Sorry, "new entity" was too vague in retrospect. My point was around the utility of marketing, at least in theory. If I release a new brand of baked beans, how would a recommender based on past sales (and combinations of sales) know to recommend it to anyone. Marketing allows it to go up the list (unfairly, according to the post I was replying to).
- paiute 5y agoRemember when early Google ads were useful? And not annoying. If you can hook me up with a product or service I might want that's great. In contrast I switched from liberty mutual insurance because their ads annoy me.
- toiletfuneral 5y ago
- rambojazz 5y agoTLDR: ads are annoying, but now I'm making a living from it so it's fine
- _jplc 5y agoSo, your ability to have food every day depends on ads. You don't need mental gymnastics to justify surviving in a capitalist world using ads, it's okay, everyone understands it.
- b3lvedere 5y agoIndeed. And i don't care if they show ads or not. I will try to block it as much as possible, because i still hate watching those things.
- tupac_speedrap 5y agoIndeed. Why do people rationalise this stuff in such an odd way? Attention isn't currency and advertising isn't a foreign exchange. They mention about having a new "mental model" so mental gymnastics is probably an appropriate term in this case.
- zardo 5y agoStart constructing your views from a foundation of, "I'm a good person. The things I do are good."
- NateEag 5y agoOne of the things traditional Christianity has going for it is that any adherent is supposed to accept, at core, that they are not an inherently good person. Doesn't mean everything you do is automatically terrible, but in many Christians it does encourage self-reflection and self-awareness, because of the knowledge that any given impulse you have may actually be a selfish one that's terrible for other people. ...granted, it doesn't always work that way in conservative US evangelicalism. Even there it does sometimes, though. /rabbittrail
- hutzlibu 5y agoAh well, the people who burned at the stake, only burned, because the inquisitors wanted to save their soul, so doing something good to them.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoAuthor: Ads are annoying but money is nice and I like money more than my sworn principles. lmao
- mindcrime 5y agoWhere did he ever say anything about a "sworn principle" against ads? All I see is this: I believed that in addition to being annoying, it was unnecessary—that if for some reason advertising became infeasible, sure, some companies would go out of business, but they'd be replaced by better companies with other business models, and the rest of us would be better off for it. So basically "ads are annoying and unnecessary". Changing that opinion is not exactly some dramatic change in fundamental principles.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoRead his previous articles or comments on hackernews. Stop crying if you don't even look 2 inches further than your mouse pointer.
- mindcrime 5y agoI'm not engaging in some elaborate research project here. This isn't that important. If the guy has previous statements about a "sworn principle" against advertising then good for him I guess. But it's not in the article we're discussing now.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoI am not discussing the article. I made a comment about the Authors stance on advertising.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nyxtom 5y agoTargeted advertising isn't all that bad if it provides useful choice in an otherwise crowded market. Where I disagree with the premise is when advertising becomes predatory in a lot of ways is when it preys on psychology and emotion - particularly disgust, anger, distrust in some cases.
- assbuttbuttass 5y agoSo the author was anti-advertising as a consumer, but now is pro-advertising as an advertiser. Sounds about right.
- Spivak 5y agoI mean the less-cynical take is now that the author actually understands the reality of the business instead of the warped outsider's perception it doesn't seem half as evil as he was made to believe. I can respect that.
- tomp 5y agoThe best kind of businesses are those where the pipeline is distributed and each participant can keep telling themselves they’re definitely the good guys.
- danachow 5y agoThe outsider perspective of (especially online) advertising or for those that work with it is overtly rotten and “evil” - it’s doesn’t follow that somehow it’s better on the inside. It isn’t a sausage factory, it’s a sewage treatment plant.
- mananaysiempre 5y agoAnecdote unrelated to your point: I’ve grown up close to a sewage treatment plant and have been taken on a couple hours’ tour of it in middle school. And what do you know, while there is a faint odour in the air (much weaker than, say, near a barn or a stable, but it’s there), it’s one of the most sparkling-clean, meticulously organized workplaces I’ve seen before or since. I’ve been to chemistry labs with worse plumbing and more clutter than that, let alone industrial facilities. I mean, it’s not that surprising in hindsight—if it’s clean everything or drown in literal shit, you bet it’s going to be clean. But it’s definitely not what I expected. (Probably helps they didn’t get their funding or wages cut while the surrounding country was falling apart, chemistry labs and all, for the same reason.)
- andrewzah 5y agoThere's a term for changing your opinion because you now realize you can profit from it. Unprincipled.
- randcraw 5y agoMercenary. Machiavellian. Exploitative. Thief. There are LOTS of terms for turning customers into victims.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- glitchc 5y ago"Hunger will do terrible things to a man's morals."
- guerrilla 5y agoBest we keep people fed then.
- omnicognate 5y agoYes, we should replace "free" ad supported business models, which are in fact anything but, with ones where the customer pays and are therefore the beneficiaries of the work being carried out. There are technical challenges to doing this as it requires sufficiently frictionless micropayments, but the biggest challenge is cultural. People are pretty addicted to "free" crap, so it's far from a given that most people will ever be willing to pay whatever arguments there are in favour of it. I think there's something of a pushback brewing though.
- guerrilla 5y agoNo, I meant it's literally in everyone's interest to keep everyone fed.
- omnicognate 5y agoThe relevance to the article or discussion being...?
- wizzwizz4 5y agoIf nobody was ever in a position where they had to compromise their principles in order to not die, it would be easier to look down on people who do compromise their principles for money.
- omnicognate 5y ago
- datavirtue 5y ago"My business makes $900 a month from ads." You don't have a business.
- wruza 5y agoYou don’t have to. Getting paid from something you disrespect is more or less okay and ubiquitous. It doesn’t even have to be symmetrical. I bet that ads are the way they are not because ads bigcorps are 99% stupid, but because it actually 99% works better than we fantasize here about how nice and discovery ads could be. It doesn’t work for you, but it probably does for average Joe, so put it on your site and use adblock.
- gwbas1c 5y agoI theory, I don't mind ads. For years I avoided ad-blockers. Then... Ads make pages load slower. Ads on mobile browsers make the text jump around while I'm trying to read it. Ads put giant pop-ups over the text that I'm trying to read. Ads start playing loud music, or flash. The problem isn't ads, it's a lack of bounds about what ads can and can not do. The web ran fine for years with ad-blockers as a niche; but ad-blockers only got popular when the ads themselves overstepped their bounds and became too intrusive. I'd be much happier if ads were reasonable and I didn't feel like I needed an ad-blocker just to view the %$#%@ website.
- pier25 5y agoExactly. I disable my ad blocker on certain sites like Reddit, Twitter,or forums I visit daily. I want to support those sites and I'm fine with ads as long as it's done respectfully.
- lostcolony 5y agoYep. I can remember the exact moment I decided to install an adblocker. I was on a comic site, and my entire browser got minimized, to show me a popup. That was it for me.
- notreallyserio 5y agoI'd be mostly fine with ads if they were: * first-party hosted: no needing to fetch content from 10 different servers * verified by the site publisher: all ads are relevant and are not obviously malicious * predictably sized: this goes with the other two, ads must conform to a size that fits in the content and does not push content around * oh and of course they must never, ever autoplay video or audio I don't particularly care if this is all too hard to do. If it's just too much, make your product a paid service. Or just don't make it at all, that's fine too. edited: formatting
- earthboundkid 5y agoYes! Ordinary people like ads. They put magazine ads up as posters in dorm rooms. They quote TV commercial catchphrases and jingles to one another. They watch the Super Bowl for the ads. People talk about podcast host read ads and do parody versions. And people love "influencers," who are just advertisers who say sassy things on Instagram or whatever. But no one likes web banner advertising. It's just a bad experience! At best people like it when you search and the thing they wanted is at the top of the list because of paid placement. They don't care if the placement was paid or not, but they like seeing the thing they wanted. Banner ads make the experience of using a web page worse, but unlike TV ads or magazine ads, they don't contribute anything good back. It's just "here is an ugly square that disrupts your browsing experience." Publishers should think about other ways of engaging reader attention.
- Konnstann 5y agoThe article even states at the end that it doesn't touch on the fact that advertising has shifted how content is displayed and even created, which I find hilarious. Adblockers have mitigated a lot of the "attention cost" associated with ads but not the fact that clickbait, "list" articles that require a page reload for every item, etc are now the norm.
- speedgoose 5y agoEveryone has a price.
- xxs 5y agobut $900/month - that's just cheap
- vcryan 5y agoI always come around to see the merits of a thing when it starts benefitting me.
- mgas 5y agoThis, and only this. He literally states "Fast forward two years and several pivots, and my slightly-less-early-stage business is doing $900 per month in revenue... from ads." I used to hate ads, until I started making money from ads. Now I am writing this fluff piece where I try to use rhetoric to re-frame the paradigm where I was once a disgruntled user, but now I am a profitable pusher. Particularly distasteful is the notion that "attention is a form of micropayment with low friction". If in the Library of Babel, all combinations of words are possible, I do not believe a more loathsome or self-serving bit of drivel could be found.
- danShumway 5y ago> When you use an ad-supported service, you're not "the product," you are the customer. You pay with attention, and the service trades some of that attention to an advertiser in exchange for regular currency But this is exactly what we meant when we said that you are the product. Your attention is being sold to advertisers, under the assumption that it will be converted into regular currency in the form of influencing your purchasing decisions. ---- I'm not going to jump on the hate wagon, if the author changed their mind, fine. There are more constructive ways to engage than calling them a traitor. But this sentence really confuses me, it's like saying, "you're not the product, your blood is." What did you used to mean when you said that the user was the product, if not that the user's own presence and mental state was being sold? It's also worth noting (and doesn't get brought up that often) that advertisers only care about consumer attention because it gets converted through roundabout processes into consumer spending. The whole of the advertising model relies on the idea that being able to get people's attention allows advertisers to change what consumers buy. Even the most innocent, ethical forms of advertising where people are genuinely being made aware of a product that they didn't know existed and that solves one of their needs still operates under this premise. What advertising does is it directly sells people's attention, and indirectly sells people's purchasing decisions. This is exactly why some people like me are so anti-advertising in its current online form. Sites need to maximize attention so that they can siphon some of that attention towards a product. This leads to some bad outcomes in what content gets produced, and I personally believe it leads to bad outcomes overall for society -- I think it leads to a situation where people are constantly having their concentration/focus/awareness drained from them. This is (in my mind) exacerbated by the fact that advertising is often omnipresent rather than the result of a conscious decision to "spend" attention. With money, you get a purchase screen. With ads, they just kind of show up in your regular life. The advertising model often takes the form of ads inserting themselves into other unrelated activities without explicit permission or any explicit contract with the consumer. Going back to the blood analogy, if a normal monetary model is kind of like getting blood drawn and selling it, advertising is more like mosquitoes. Advertisers show up where you want to be, and while you're doing other things they suck your blood; there's very rarely an explicit transactional step where you decide to give them your blood, and the only way to get rid of them is to either not go into certain places at all or to block them as best as you can. ---- Again, I don't want to just jump on the author and make them feel bad. It's good for someone to write a piece like this and try to think through why they're doing the things they do and to describe how they feel about advertising. It's better for this piece to be written then for the author to just ignore the disconnect. And I'll also push back on some of the blanket criticisms, because ads as micropayments is also a good way of looking at why the advertising industry has thrived online. I think that is a really good insight, I have often complained that one of the things holding back the web is the absence of a good, low-fee, (it feels weird to use word this in relation to ads, but we're talking comparatively here) "private" micropayments system (and no, cryptocurrency is not currently solving this problem). However, ultimately I find the arguments in this piece really uncompelling, and they don't capture why I oppose advertising in the first place. I'm not necessarily saying that paying via attention is always wrong, nor am I saying that consumers never want to know about new products. However, the way the advertising industry currently operates is (I believe) bad for society on an almost fundamental level, and making those ads less invasive or making them more private doesn't really solve the problem. Even if you look at a browser like Brave, Brave is trying to tackle privacy issues with advertising, but it's not tackling the more fundamental issue that an omnipresent monetization of attention is toxic for society. This article doesn't offer any strong reasoning as to why I should change my mind about that. I already knew ads monetize attention, that's one of the biggest parts about them that I don't like.
- wzdd 5y ago> You pay with attention, and the service trades some of that attention to an advertiser in exchange for regular currency. This is a very superficial take. You obviously don't just pay with attention. You also pay with actual money -- you do, or the friends or family you talk about the product with do. And you don't necessarily do it completely consciously, because one of the effects of "raise awareness" advertising is to make things that are familiar to you seem more attractive. Given three equivalent options, one of which you vaguely remember from somewhere, you're more likely to pick that option. One could of course argue about whether this payment (using actual money) is good or not, and whether using advertising in this way is ethical, but extracting money from you or your social network is the end goal. Somewhat-unbelievable arguments about advertising as a whole being a con aside, if people weren't responding to advertising by increasing advertisers' revenues, then nobody would advertise.
- alecbz 5y agoThis is a really good point. The only reason your attention is valuable is because it is (on average) going to cause you to spend enough money to actually pay for the product, but in a sneaky way you won't quite notice and won't associate with the product itself.
- the8472 5y ago> if people weren't responding to advertising by increasing advertisers' revenues, then nobody would advertise. Not necessarily, it could also be a red queen's race. But that also is a net-negative since money gets spent on advertising instead of passing the savings through to the consumer.
- amalcon 5y agoRight, the attention is only valuable as a way to get to your money. If we somehow eliminate all of the cognitive biases, it would seem to be better[0] to just pay with the same amount of money. That would free up a bunch of attention that was being destroyed to redirect the flow of money. That attention could be used to do self-directed research into products and services that you might value ("pull advertising"). On net, this would be far less predatory and more pleasant. Of course, we can't somehow eliminate all of the cognitive biases involved. Pretending we can leads to ludicrous conclusions like mine here: obviously the world is never actually going to work in this way. I think the closest we might get would be to clean up certain types of predatory advertising, maybe starting with anything aimed at young children. Which is of course what most of the world has been trying (and, to a limited extent, succeeding at) for decades. [0]- There is a credible argument here that the advertising model allows people with more money to subsidize people with less money, but since we have a magic bias-removal wand in this hypothetical, it's still more efficient to just do that directly.
- throwaway98797 5y agodie a hero, or live long enough to become a villain.
- delegate 5y agoAdvertising is not a 'foreign exchange for attention currency' (metaphor used by author). On average, it's manipulation, brainwashing and commodification of well told lies. But that isn't the real problem - the real problem with advertising is that it works. Why is that a problem ? Because advertising is manufactured demand. Last time I looked at the 'Law of Supply and Demand' on Wikipedia some time ago, the word 'advertising' appeared 0 times in there. I've just checked, the word is there 1 time as the 6th item in a list. I think it deserves way more attention (pun intended) in the economic theory. Just look at that simple chart. A positive shift in demand results in an increase in price and quantity sold of the product. In other words, you can make people consume considerably more stuff they don't want by constantly nagging them with ads. Given that 'stuff' are nature converted into object we temporarily use and discard, the result of this macroeconomic ideology - destruction of nature and change of climate in half a century. We all know the names of the big tech companies who are exceedingly efficient at pushing up the global demand curve. This business model really needs to stop.
- WalterBright 5y agoLinux got its start from advertising. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Linux#The_creation_of_Linux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Linux#The_creation_...
- pjerem 5y agoThank you.
- vatican_banker 5y ago> Because advertising is manufactured demand. I see advertising radically different. People exhibit an spectrum of interest in products in the market, from “zero interest in buying” to “shut up and take my money”. Advertising works by convincing people close to the “shut up and take my money” part of the spectrum to actually buy. Disclaimer: I’m not a marketeer.
- tomaskafka 5y agoYes. And sometimes it even connects people with 'I have this thorny problem to which I would love to buy a solution instead of relying on manual workarounds' with people selling the actual solution, leading to win-win for everyone.
- tomp 5y agoWell what can I say… thank god for AdBlock! Keep your ads ;)
- shawabawa3 5y ago> Along the way I've also adopted a new mental model for advertising AKA a coping mechanism
- kordlessagain 5y agoMaybe their model just treats attention as a neutral thing to be taken by whatever takes the most of it?
- npteljes 5y agoCoping recently have taken on a negative meaning that was previously served by "apologist" among others. In this case, OP just became an apologist for the advertisement industry, because he found that it can make him money that he couldn't previously achieve.
- onion2k 5y agoI don't really mind ads. I do mind; - being tracked around the internet without a very good reason - being lied to by advertisers that make spurious claims - adverts that use flashing/moving things to draw my attention - anything that makes my computer make a sound when I might be somewhere quiet - anything that grossly wastes electricity or bandwidth - anything that's not related to the context of the page I'm looking at (see point 1) Ad platforms like Google AdSense's text adverts, or Carbon Ads, would be kind of OK if they didn't track the heck out of me. It's the ever-escalating attention war between content and ads that's the main problem. It started with "punch the monkey" ads that tricked people into clicking, and it's continuing with full-page-take-over-the-browser-video-ads now. Advertising is fine. Taking my full attention away from what I want to focus on without my permission is not.
- jackson1442 5y agoUgh honestly the text adverts are more annoying than banners and the like. It makes it feel like the _content of the site itself_ is being optimized for revenue, rather than being useful content. And god forbid you hover the wrong word and bring up a 400x400 popover telling you how great some product is. Maybe these aren't AdSense text adverts, but this was my general experience with text adverts as a whole.
- ericholscher 5y agoLots of people talking about how advertising is terrible in the comments here. Unfortunately, much of the internet is dependent on ads for revenue. I am personally working to improve the technology behind the ad ecosystem, so we can not worry so much about privacy and page performance, along with malware and other issues. I’d love to have more people working with us to improve things, rather than just commenting on how they are terrible. Unfortunately, advertising is never going to go away, unless you want to start paying for every newspaper or service online. So let’s work to make it better. https://github.com/readthedocs/ethical-ad-server https://github.com/readthedocs/ethical-ad-server & https://www.ethicalads.io/ https://www.ethicalads.io/
- InCityDreams 5y ago>So let’s work to make it better. No.
- etempleton 5y agoPeople hate bad advertising, but they also hate paying for things. There is a happy medium where good advertising can subsidize things people only kind of want to pay for. People are largely indifferent or sometimes like good advertising. Super Bowl ads, for example, often draw as much of a crowd as the game itself because the ads are well produced and entertaining. The problem is there is always pressure to make more and more money and eventually that leads to bad practices in advertising. Examples of Bad Advertising: - Popups or other types of digital ads that compromise the user experience - Privacy compromising tracking - Misleading / false advertising - Over-saturation of advertising - Outdoor ads that block a beautiful view The whole digital advertising landscape, unfortunately, is filled with some of the worst advertising we have seen in the modern era. The ads are sold too cheaply and at too high of a volume causing over saturation.
- mschuster91 5y ago> People hate bad advertising, but they also hate paying for things. People hate having to put effort or risk into paying for things. Online payment was ridiculously blasted with friction even before PSD2 hit thanks to all the fraud going on, now it's even worse. Not to mention you can't just go and pay 10-50 cents to view a single online news article behind a paywall - the papers all want your personal data to upsell you, don't offer non-subscription models, and make bailing out of subscriptions ridiculously hard. And the credit card industry wants their cut on top, too, which makes micropayments even more expensive to offer. How did iTunes, Spotify and Netflix get so big and essentially killed piracy in their respective markets? They offered an easy, risk-free way for consumers to access content they want. Everyone else - particularly news media - hasn't gotten the hint yet. How to fix it? I think the situation needs to be fixed from two sides: First is obviously banking. There should absolutely be an international (!) instant banking network - I'm thinking about something like expanding SEPA Instant payments, but specialized on nano-transactions, and correspondingly low fees. Then, a bank issues auth tokens that allow a set budget of micropayments to users; their browsers then upon authentication (e.g. fingerprint or user's password) automatically emit a micropayment transaction - basically, the user visits a paywall site, an OS/browser dialog pops up that asks for confirmation to pay e.g. 10 cents to the New York Times, the user presses their finger on Touch ID, and a second later the NYT has their ten cents and I can read the article. The other side is content authors themselves. They absolutely need to get rid of the need to know everything about their customer and to lock them in. Provide good content and the people will come.
- egypturnash 5y agoWell, good luck not going down the slippery slope of slowly changing your services to whatever will maximize engagement and deliver the most ads to the most eyeballs, regardless of how healthy this user engagement is, dude.
- rewq4321 5y agoYou're assuming there will never be competition in his niche or that he will somehow discover a way to maintain a monopoly.
- egypturnash 5y agoI'm assuming that he is running an ad-supported business on the Internet, and will be subject to the same temptations that everyone who runs an ad-supported business on the Internet are subject to. Perhaps he will manage to avoid these temptations, especially if his thing makes enough to give him a comfortable profit without courting VC and its demands to pivot into whatever model results in the most unicorns flying through the air on jets of cash expelled out of their buttholes. Perhaps he will not.
- rewq4321 5y agoUsers care about UX. Ads affect UX. If there is healthy competition, then things can't get as out of control as you're implying.
- yalogin 5y agoAdvertising is not micropayment with low friction. That’s like saying war is just the other country buying weapons for free. Advertising is an attempt at making the customer pay for stuff. Attention is free and so you cannot stop or prevent advertisements, they are a form of free speech if you will. However we are talking about the extent you go to profile users and tailor the ads to them. Google personalizes on a per user basis and everything they do is to get that data.
- alecbz 5y agoWhat? > Advertising is an attempt at making the customer pay for stuff. Yeah that's who's supposed to be paying for things? It sounds like you're maybe alluding to a kind of advertising that's unavoidable by just existing in the world, like billboards or bus ads or something, but I don't think that's what we're talking about here. Or I guess a product that you don't know is going to have an ad, you use it, then bam an ad. Sure, in some way that's kind of like taking money without your consent. But once you know a product uses ads, you can just not use it because you don't like the way they charge you for it.
- fumar 5y agoThere is little to distinguish paid advertising to content marketing or PR. Which both easily bleed into the larger media ecosystem. If you take a step back most of our experiences, even on HN, are from press releases or news articles driven largely by marketing. It works. I’ve spent over a 18 years understanding and working in the sector. You can’t escape it. There is no centralized view on its ethical responsibilities. But there is no doubt that advertising and marketing and the media at large influence people and alter their behaviors.
- asciimov 5y agoAs someone who lost a day of work because a clever ad prompted my partner to install malware (it looked like an official Adobe Flash update), I'll continue blocking most ads for the foreseeable future. The only ads that I don't block are banner ads posted by small time websites. For example, a sports blog for my almamater hosts their own local ads. I don't block those because all their ads are image banners with a link to local to the university businesses.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoFlowers are also advertising. Flowers are usually considered beautiful and a good thing. It follows that advertising is not categorically bad.
- hutzlibu 5y agoIt depends. Flowers blossom to attract insects in exchange for nectar. You might call this good advertisement. But there are plants who "advertise" like flowers who have nectar, but really don't. So they trick the insects into visiting them to spread their pollen, but they do notngive nectqr in return.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoThose evil flowers often still look beautiful to humans, though.
- tomashubelbauer 5y agoI also changed my mind about advertising, a few years ago. I used to not want to use an ad blocker, due to my love of defaults (one extra thing to install, messes with the page possibly breaking it etc.) but also so that I could effortlessly support the content I was consuming. But the online advertising industry has gone too far and for me at least, I don't think there is coming back. Too much manipulation, too much tracking, too many obnoxious ads, auto-playing videos, outright scams and so on. I will block any ad I can. If too many people do it and the outlet I am reading / watching videos of can't no longer afford to produce content, they can open up donations. If they still can't support the effort on donos, then I think it's time to close shop. I feel like the reality is, someone else will step in. There are a lot of passionate people willing to put content up online just for the feeling of helping others and getting their work recognized. I am happy for every one of those people who can make it their business and scale their operation up, truly. But I do not feel obliged to keep supporting them being able to produce online works as a business by giving away my privacy and sanity through being subjected by awful ads run by ad networks who think my online data is theirs and that it hasn't made its way to their database yet is a bug they need to fix.
- salford 5y ago> There are a lot of passionate people willing to put content up online just for the feeling of helping others and getting their work recognized I had the same thought. Ads enable people who previously put up their content out of passion to do the same thing to commercial gain. Is this good or bad? On the plus side, it incentivizes the creation of more quality content. On the other hand, "labor of love" content is homier, less corporatized, and the extent to which they will help you on a given problem is not biased by their ability to earn money from said problem. It's a similar situation between mom and pop restaurants and chains. Now it's hard to say that one or the other is definitively better -- depends on what you're looking for. I wish there were resources out there to help understand the nature of this tradeoff and how it has played out in different areas of the economy.
- epolanski 5y ago> There are a lot of passionate people willing to put content up online just for the feeling of helping others and getting their work recognized. They already are, but since they think about content rather than seo you can't even find them.
- gotostatement 5y agoHilarious article. "Why I changed my mind about advertising: I decided I wanted to make money off ads"
- quacked 5y ago"Why This Nerd Changed His Mind About Nonviolent Resistance After Learning How to Fight"
- NoGravitas 5y agoSomeone changes their opinion in order to match their source of income. Film at 11.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI see, you changed your mind because you're now profiting by stealing our attention and hacking our minds. Good thing ad blockers exist and keep getting better and better, hopefully one day they will completely nullify your profits and you'll be able to change your mind again.
- jbuhbjlnjbn 5y agoIt's really as simple as that. The author tries hard to frame it as a learning experience of some sort, but what stuck for me was he could not argumentatively distance himself from the most obvious ulterior motives, making money, the gain from it. This self-reflection is too shallow and comes across as an excuse imo. But still I appreciate a lot that he actually talks about it to create a discussion.
- jacobobryant 5y ago> but what stuck for me was he could not argumentatively distance himself from the most obvious ulterior motives, making money, the gain from it. Sure, that could be influencing my reasoning, but it goes the other way too. It's easy to criticize ads as a business model when you don't have skin in the game (ducks). That's why I decided not to bring up either of those points: I'd rather write for people who are willing to focus on the argument instead of assuming bad faith.
- jbuhbjlnjbn 5y agoOf course, same goes for me, for everyone. I just hope I will stand by my principles even when confronted with frivolous amounts of money, but it didn't happen yet, time will tell. But I have it easier in this case - because I view subliminal manipulation in advertisements as something horrible. Freud's legacy is one of deception for profit, something immoral right at the core. Creating useless needs, producing useless goods, deception has become the norm. The playing on the weakness of the human mind is something horrible. It makes a mockery of our intellect.
- ryanmcbride 5y ago
- alecbz 5y agoSo people are mostly talking about ads in general or hypocrisy, but I do think the author's point has some merit here. Frictionless payments and eliminating transaction overhead is a real benefit of ads, and I think one way to reduce reliance on ads would be to explore other avenues of addressing this problem. Like, riffing: you could maybe have some kind of automatic implicit patreon type thing. You sign up for "auto-patreon" and put $5/month in your account, you allow any site to charge up to $.10 a day, then you just browse the internet and sites will automatically charge you for usage.
- tomcam 5y ago> In particular, attention is a form of micropayment with low friction. No. Modern targeting includes at least dozens, maybe hundreds of ways to surveil you without your knowledge or consent. A micropayment would transaction would include your full knowledge of what you were giving up in exchange for a commodity you consciously chose to pay for.
- franciscop 5y agoThe mental loops the author jumps to justify/accept ads themselves is interesting. We agree any of these is bad: - I used to treat my employees well, but my agency was not sustainable with it so now I crank the whip every time someone wastes few minutes. - I used to sell fresh food, but my restaurant was not profitable so now I sell low quality food while claiming it's organic. Both of these are also clearly immoral, but in these fields it's clear that they don't become moral because of the profit factor. However the author seems to be saying because the business is not profitable that makes ads morally correct*? That doesn't seem good reasoning, I'm all for changing your own morality over time and each person having a custom set of rules but "profitability" is/should def not be what makes something moral or immoral. Maybe the author unknowingly had a more complex set of rules to define ads as moral under certain circumstances, maybe they just changed them, or maybe they are doing something they themselves consider immoral, but I find it strange to say profitability is part of moral. *Edit: actually the author doesn't talk about morality so these are more my rumblings/ideas based on the article than a correct review of the article. Probably because right now I have a somewhat strong moral belief, fairly weakly held, about ads and I'm thinking about similar questions as the author :)
- fleddr 5y agoAs you self-admitted, there's important nuances. When you say: "you can read all the content on my website for one year for $2". ...nobody will give you $2. Because they're conditioned that content is free. Because payment is a hassle. Because they may not know one year ahead what the value is. Same thing with games in the app store. A game you love and play a lot, clearly would be fairly priced at 5$. And still game developers are forced to make them free to play with in-game purchases to make up for it. People really do not want to pay for anything in the digital space. They won't pay a fixed fee, hate subscriptions too, and don't really donate at scale. As still people eagerly consume all this stuff anyway, I think the ethical point is incredibly one-sided if not hypocritical. You claim that the economic value is zero yet consume it anyway. Ads are the only model widely usable to overcome this. No other successful model has emerged. Nobody wants to run ads, they have to, because the "customers" are in fact the immoral ones. With no immediate successor on the horizon, I think ads should be redesigned to be less invasive. No excessive tracking, no absurd resource usage, and security protection.
- jqcoffey 5y agoMy small input to this debate: I know I certainly bought—-actually paid for—-magazines like Computer Shopper just to browse the ads. I think many folks on HN of my generation likely did the same.
- lol1lol 5y agoexcept I've no control over what I am attending
- scandox 5y ago"Why Richard, it profit a man nothing to give his soul for the whole world. . . but for 900 MRR!”
- rglullis 5y ago$900/month seems a really low price to sell your soul.
- rewq4321 5y agoAds aren't a problem if there are multiple competing services to choose from. If customers care about the ad-related UX then they'll switch to a better competitor. The problem is monopoly (as usual). I recently switched to a new tech publication because the old one had a "page jumping" problem (related to ads) that they didn't fix for a while even after I sent them a message. No big deal - this is how a good market works. Another problem is bad discovery mechanisms. Google search should de-rank pages with to many spammy ads, but that's not in their interests due to their control of the ads ecosystem. This does kind of come back to being a monopoly problem. A cool feature of ads that's not mentioned in the blog post is that they automatically price discriminate. Rich people effectively pay more and subsidise the content for those from developing countries. This probably angers rich people more because they (somewhat subconsciously) value their attention at a rate which makes the content seem expensive. Of course, there are still problems to solve with malware, excessive tracking, etc. but these don't seem intractable.
- abracadaniel 5y agoAttention as a currency is an interesting mental model to approach it from, but I think it makes advertising look even more unethical. There’s no contract for my attention, no agreement for me to pay. It makes ad supported sites less like a museum with a suggested donation box, and more like a museum with a pickpocket. Their business model may rely on that stolen money, but that doesn’t mean it’s okay. This also has me thinking about the monetary cost of ads to the viewer. Ads consume my time, my electricity, and wear and tear on computer components. It may be a faction of a penny, but ads only bring in a fraction of a penny. All without my permission.
- rizkeyz 5y agoJust for a moment imagine a world without any ads. I for one do not have to imagine that, but just have to remember back, when I grew up in the eastern block. What you wanted to buy was available in the stores and you could always ask someone, if you needed something very special. If an ad were merely a statement of existence - but that not what ads have become: "brand refresh", "pivot", "awareness", "emotion", or any other subtle or not so subtle message that wants to influence you. I see so many people driven to "buy" things they do not need and then "buy" again books on how to clean the mess up. From where I'm standing, this is all just very ridiculous at this point. Note that I am not saying there is a free will, not at all, but hey, do I want to this endless mostly senseless stream of unneeded stuff let influence me or something a little more grounded?
- m-i-l 5y agoThe whole article could have been replaced with the line "I changed my mind about advertising because I now make money from advertising". The fact that the author feels compelled to spin it out to a 480 word article suggests some deep-rooted unease with this, and also illustrates one of the (many) issues with an advertising-based revenue model - you have to learn to waste users time (aka "maximise for engagement") to maximise revenue. Digging a little deeper, the fact that 10% of forwarded emails are sponsored[0] highlights another major issue with advertising - the conflict of interest between user needs and site operator's profit. How do I know which emails I can trust as having useful unbiased information (i.e. satisfying my needs), and which are potentially misleading junk adverts (i.e. satisfying the site operator's desire for profit)? And what is to stop the signal to noise ratio becoming completely untenable over time in the desire to maximise profit? I'm not completely anti-advertising BTW - there is a time and place for it. Just not when you are trying to use informational sites on the web. The analogy I've used is that you don't want annoying salespeople in a library getting between you and your books, but you don't mind them so much when you are down the high street shopping. [0] https://silken-cafe-474.notion.site/About-The-Sample-a989b5bd39054b37a51432d6999beac3#897e7ab4bba742ba9a5830097ac33eb8 https://silken-cafe-474.notion.site/About-The-Sample-a989b5b...
- jacobobryant 5y ago> The whole article could have been replaced with the line "I changed my mind about advertising because I now make money from advertising". I responded to this sentiment in another comment, but I'll just quote from the HN guidelines here: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."[1] > How do I know which emails I can trust as having useful unbiased information (i.e. satisfying my needs), and which are potentially misleading junk adverts (i.e. satisfying the site operator's desire for profit)? Because ads are clearly marked with a "sponsored" label. > And what is to stop the signal to noise ratio becoming completely untenable over time in the desire to maximise profit? Because if we send people newsletters they don't like, they'll be more likely to stop using the service. > the conflict of interest between user needs and site operator's profit. Interesting anecdote: I haven't measured this in a while, but at least when we first introduced ads, the sponsored newsletters tended to be rated more highly than the "organic" newsletters. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- zackmorris 5y agoWhat would everyone think about trying to increase ad payouts? My feeling is that Google took 50% of the ad revenue 20 years ago and Facebook took perhaps 40% after that, so the remaining ad networks are trying to operate on 1/10 the revenue they enjoyed in the 1990s and that's why ad income is no longer viable for most of us. My numbers are probably way off but my sentiment isn't. It seems like we could fix that through various privacy/legal channels (breaking up big ad agencies?) and organizing against monopolies and duopolies. I don't expect that to be successful, but it could open a broader conversation about where the web went wrong doubling down on in its ever-escalating wealth inequality instead of engineering stuff like UBI that would have brought shared prosperity for everyone.
- mvkel 5y agoSo I guess this guy is saying his moral code is worth $900/m? I'm personally not against ad/user data companies, but for someone who is to be convinced otherwise for $10K/year is ...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ianferrel 5y agoWe should commend the author for the transparency with which he describes the philosophical progression from "against advertising" to "in favor of advertising, now that I'm making money from it".
- amoorthy 5y agoMy startup eschews ads and has a low cost subscription news service. However, both models work for different market segments. 1. The segment of users that doesn't really care about the quality of news and is happy to skim headlines is best served by ads. (This is the largest segment) 2. The segment of users who wants to be fully informed, as quickly as possible, is better served by a subscription.
- tpoacher 5y agoIf you're happy to define "working in exchange for wages" as "slavery", then yes, I've also changed my mind about slavery too. Trouble is, very few people would accept that strawman definition as the extant one.
- benlivengood 5y agoHumans are not very rational, to our detriment. Most advertisements make use of logical fallacies to convince people they need a product. Most advertisements are therefore mentally unhealthy both because they actively deceive people and because they lower the sanity line in public discourse by getting people used to believing bullshit unquestioningly which makes them more vulnerable to propaganda.
- AlwaysRock 5y agoThis is just a long way to say, "I decided I like money more than I dislike ads"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chaostheory 5y agoWhat people in the HN bubble don't often think about is that not every user can pay without advertising. Many people in the world cannot afford to pay for a service with money. Donations only go so far in supporting these types of services.
- vmception 5y ago"I use to be against sharecropping until I started making money from it"
- croes 5y ago>When you use an ad-supported service, you're not "the product," you are the customer. It's not the ads that make you the product but the tracking for the ads.
- arepublicadoceu 5y agoI have this theory that without ads 90% of the web as we know it would end immediately. And nothing of value would be lost. Without all the noise created by the web supported by ads it would be way easier to find what really interests me on the web: hobbyists and people that love to share information for the value of sharing alone. Not SEO optimized crapware with uncountable 5 best this, 10 best that.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. Who really cares if these shitty websites go away? I'd very much enjoy it if the web went back to its roots where people made a website because they actually had something to say instead of inflammatory clickbait bullshit designed to optimize "engagement". I don't even surf the web anymore, this is one of the few sites I still visit.
- epolanski 5y ago> I have this theory that without ads 90% of the web as we know it would end immediately. And nothing of value would be lost. I'm gonna reuse this quote for sure in the future.
- bigbillheck 5y agoI personally would like to think I wouldn't compromise my principles for $10.8k/yr, but would prefer not to have to find out.
- scotty79 5y agoAdvertising is a tax on the economy. Economy is like the forest. Companies are the trees and advertising they buy are the tree trunks. If they somehow cooperatively agreed to grow shorter trunks they would save so much nutrients. But since they compete with each other they need to grow as tall as it is physically possible, to avoid being overshadowed by others. Whole advertising industry should be nationalized and scaled back to non-profit that would mainly keep online and up to date a catalog of goods and services with dry data and test results.
- Jsharm 5y agoI'm no fan of ads either but one undeniable benefit is equality; if Google cost money to use then those in poverty would simply be unable to use it. The service is paid for by the wealthiest (as these are the most valuable eyeballs to advertisers anyway).
- nononononon1425 5y ago
- kazinator 5y agoWhy did I change my mind about advertising? "[M]y slightly-less-early-stage business is doing $900 per month in revenue." In other words, we can take Upton Sinclair's familiar witticism: It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it. ... and add a corollary: Even if he had once understood it prior to that salary.
- superfrogged 5y agoWhy does every cereal commercial have to begin with some kind of industrial accident?
- harryvederci 5y agoThis reads to me as: "I couldn't make money from my business without ads, so now I think ads are okay." I've been living advertisement-free since 2010. My mother thinks she's immune to advertisments. Her reasoning is that ads are so annoying, they'll have the opposite effect on her. I respect her line of thinking, but a while back when we discussed ads, I asked her the following question: "How often do you think about buying something?" She thought about multiple times per week, probably even multiple times per day. She asked me the same question, and I had to dig really deep to finally answer: "I haven't thought about buying something other than groceries for months."
- charonn0 5y ago> When you use an ad-supported service, you're not "the product," you are the customer. You pay with attention, and the service trades some of that attention to an advertiser in exchange for regular currency. The problem with this view point is that it's not just our attention that's being taken. If it were then the notion that "you are the product" wouldn't have gained such currency in the first place.
- ryanmcbride 5y ago> When you use an ad-supported service, you're not "the product," you are the customer. That isn't really true though. The company that uses an ad-supported model can't pay its bill with a user's attention, it pays its bill with the revenue it gets from funneling those users into clicking on ads. The author can try to redefine what a customer and a product is, but the bottom line is that they are receiving money in exchange for ad clicks, which means their customers are the ad company, and the product are the clicks. This whole article reads like the author is trying to cope with the fact that they are willing to do the thing that actively makes their product worse, if it means they get more money. I haven't changed my mind about advertising, even if it means my project will always operate at a loss, I'm prepared for that. People that want to support it can subscribe to the Patreon, and they get some extra stuff, but I'm not going to try and monetize bot traffic by stuffing my pages full of ads.
- mdoms 5y agoWell you see it benefits me now.
- hedora 5y agoCattle aren't the product. They pay for their feed with delicious cheeseburgers.
- kelnos 5y ago> Fast forward two years and several pivots, and my slightly-less-early-stage business is doing $900 per month in revenue... from ads. This entire piece just feels like someone trying to rationalize their choice to do something they previously considered yucky, because that thing turns out to be lucrative. > In particular, attention is a form of micropayment with low friction. This is an interesting way of framing it, one I am surprised I actually like. When framed this way, it's easier for me to coherently say "I don't agree to use this payment method". I say that by using an ad blocker. And if you still give me the content of your site, despite the presence of the ad blocker, that's on you. This framing does have flaws. A traditional payment goes through some kind of order and confirmation flow. "Taking my payment" -- i.e. foisting ads upon me -- before confirming I am ok paying that way, is not ok. I'd be fine with a page that popped up a modal saying "This site requires payment in the form of attention (advertisements). Click 'Accept' if you agree to these terms." I would be happy to see sites being up-front with that, so I can choose to close the browser tab rather than waste my attention. (Sites with ad-blocker blockers more or less do this, and I'm fine not consuming their content.) I get that cash micropayments have all sorts of problems, but I do wish that was at least a viable option. > This doesn't address more salient concerns with advertising, like sharing data with 3rd parties or the question of if it pushes companies to maximize for engagement more than they otherwise would. While I agree those are big problems, for me, the problem is that I see advertising as a form of mental and emotional manipulation. I don't want to be treated like someone who must be manipulated into purchasing something, even if it is something that I need or would find genuinely useful. Having said that, I'm not sure how our economic system would look if all advertising (not just online) were banned. Our economic system depends on consumerism, and no advertising would severely damage sellers' ability to get consumers to open their wallets. Not saying that would be a bad thing, but it would certainly cause a huge upheaval, which could be painful for a lot of people, at least for a time.
- vortext 5y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
- lm28469 5y ago> I used to hate X until X made me money The human tragedy in a nutshell
- laurex 5y agoWe as humans are quite excellent in judging our own behavior as correct. We are not so good at imagining the downstream effects of our actions. The author is no doubt correct that there are not catastrophic effects from his choice of business model, but then to conclude that it means that advertising is really fine as long as some constraints are net seems to ignore that combined with corporate directives to (by law) maximize profit, large-scale ad-based businesses will find more and more justification for releasing those constraints. I’m a fan of brownies but it doesn’t mean I’m going to argue that sugar is not harmful and the sugar industry not a driver of poor health outcomes.
- dr_awkward 5y agoOne of my main issues with the idea of advertising as the attention economy that pays for the internet is that with the VC structures that fund startups, most services don't demand profitability until they're well into (or past) the scale-up phase. So, the typical growth curve for a "free" online product seems to be: -free to use at the beginning, no ads, "we are a startup! we do this cool thing that you will love" -as a critical mass of users is built and the demands for profit begin, it turns into "we are a scale-up. we're sorry to do this, but we need to monetize in some token and nonintrusive way" -eventually, the tool/service/offering becomes a critical gatekeeper (login with FB/Google/Apple; you need an email address to apply for any professional job today; event organizing gets walled behind FB accounts; can't read twitter/reddit/fb--places where legtimate--though possibly ill-informed or intentionally manipulated--discourse actually takes place), "hey, the shareholders demand growth and dividends. enjoy the ads we sold your eyeballs for." Who ever asked for their smart TV to show ads as part of the software? No one? Why does the stock weather app on my Samsung phone have ads--it didn't always. I didn't sign up for this. I signed up for a non-intrusive experience. The service got made into something that should you choose not to participate, you will suffer economically. And the advertising got inserted--accept the EULA and the ads, or suffer the consequences. BTW: ads don't work nearly as well as the ad publishers want you to think they do. The measurement is manipulated by the companies who do ad measurement (I work for one of these), because if the measurement makes the ads look bad, then Google (or whoever) will just find a different ad measurement company (very 2008 bond-rating-agency dynamic going on here). The publishers, of course don't mind inflated estimates of ad effectiveness, because the more successful advertising is on their platform, the more they can sell ad space for, and the more ad space they can sell. The marketers at the advertiser don't want accurate measurement--they want to look like last year's ad campaign did well because that's how the marketers get their annual bonuses. (We report results to the publishers, and the marketers at the advertisers. We should really be reporting to the CFO, because if you're a shareholder YOU ARE LOSING VALUE BECAUSE OF THE WASTE AND FRAUD IN THE AD ECOYSTEM. Want to learn more? Freakonomics Radio has a couple good shows on how advertising doesn't really work. Professor Kinshuk Jerath (Columbia University) has written recently about the misalignment of incentives in the advertising ecosystem (i.e., pubs don't care about inflated results; marketers don't either, and it's in the best interest of the ad measurer to look good). Professor Anna Tuchman (Northwestern University), et. al. have recently done a huge analysis of TV advertising, suggesting that its effects are an order of magnitude lower than the ad industry would have you believe.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoI wonder how much I would change my mind about if I were making $900/month from it. Maybe I'd decide that gas leafblowers weren't all that bad.
- Ericson2314 5y agoI look forward to UBI making it more profitable to sell people the shit they already want, than try to farm up some new demand when there is already plenty.
- Atlas667 5y agoIn an economic system where generating capital did not lead production ads would not exist, but information would. Information on products. Not emotional manipulation for consumption, but technical knowledge of tools.
- jarbus 5y agoI'd be curious if the author uses ad-blocker
- freediver 5y agoNothing wrong with ads if the user opts-in. Most ads online are opt-out (where "opt" usually means installing an ad-blocker). This is terrifyingly invasive.
- jonas_kgomo 5y agoThe early internet was preposed to have so called micro-paywalls by Ted Nelson, somehow the pioneers didn't really push for this paradigm. It would have created a generally sanity preserving web.
- btdmaster 5y agoAdvertising is fundamentally waste -- if everyone spends the same amount of resources on advertising, no gains are made but a lot of resources are spent. How can this be justified?
- pdimitar 5y agoWell of course once something starts making you money you will stop looking down on it. This dude clearly demonstrated post-hoc rationalization in action. This is what stood out to me though: > In particular, attention is a form of micropayment with low friction. It's anything BUT low friction. The attention-based economy is a race to the bottom where every vendor SCREAMS THEIR LUNGS OUT just for a few minutes of your time and even if you indulge only 20 of them you'll still emerge not very informed on the other side, with your time wasted, and with your brain's ability to focus gradually eroded. That last part is -- and should be officially labeled as -- a criminal act. I don't mind if this or that website has some unobtrusive ads (Troy Hunt's website is a very good example; StackExchange is also fine). The problem is that EVERYONE wants a piece of the sweet ad money so the users get bombarded with them from all directions. No, it's not low friction at all. Not for the users / consumers anyway. To them it's a minefield. --- I even want ads in some areas. But the line between being informative / optional and obnoxious / prevalent-and-mandatory has been crossed at least 15 years ago, both in TV and the Internet. Tone them down and even us the techies might start enabling them -- because every now and then they are in fact useful. The reason I am disabling ads and I'm fighting them is because I know that by default they'll not give me anything I want, will take precious screen estate (25% of the screen ON A PHONE, REALLY?!), will get in the way and will do their absolute best to make me mis-click / mis-tap so they can get their $0.0001 because I "interacted with the ad". You ever tried to open an erotic video posted on Reddit without your content blockers? Good luck with that. Hint: moving elements on the screen. As if we're playing Asteroids and Brick Breaker at the same time. Of course I'll block ads. Advertisers must become good citizens of the net and we can then re-negotiate. Until then they will be treated like scum -- because they act like such, all the time. --- Sadly none of that even touches on the outright malware that comes attached with a lot of modern advertising, to the point that Samsung actually issued a warning to not utter certain words IN THE COMFORT OF YOUR OWN HOME because their TV is listening. <facepalms> Just let that sink in for a minute. ...So OK, the guy made some money and now his perception is warped. Nothing particularly illuminating about his article however.
- orange_puff 5y agoI don't like ads either, but I also couldn't possibly expect content on the internet to be free, so am happy with the exchange we have currently.
- epolanski 5y agoI remember a healthy internet without ads and I would go on and say that safe for some topics there is less content than there used to be, e.g. 15 years ago.
- t0bia_s 5y agoA good product does not need advertisements.
- a_bonobo 5y agoThat's a lot of words for 'whose bread I eat, their song I sing'. Author didn't like ads for good reasons, now likes ads because he's making money of them, followed by mental gymnastics as to why they're good. If you like money, just say so.
- BLKNSLVR 5y ago> Along the way I've also adopted a new mental model for advertising. Basically I think of attention as a currency and advertising as a foreign exchange. When you use an ad-supported service, you're not "the product," you are the customer. You pay with attention, and the service trades some of that attention to an advertiser in exchange for regular currency. This is missing what I think is the most important value proposition of online advertising these days: your profile, your data, what you like, so that you, personally, can be psychologically squeezed for money. "Your attention" is a small percentage of the value proposition compared to the tracking and all the things that tracking enables (profile creation, targeted advertising, etc.).
- bardan 5y ago"I changed my mind about advertising after I started making money through advertising."
- weq 5y ago> This business model really needs to stop. and the worlds economy would collapse. FOMO is the sugar of the mind. it drives everything from the conception of a child, to its schooling, to marrage and death.
- SebastianKra 5y agoThe worst argument I hear all the time, is that ads help pay for the content you consume. That's not true. The money still comes from you. It's just charged extra the next time you buy a product, given to a marketing team, who give it to Google, who then give it to your content creator. And you better believe, that every party takes a sizeable cut. [1] And for what? What's the value added by advertisements that couldn't also come from independent reviewers, journalists or comparison sites? It's obfuscation. Make a product appear more popular than it is, close out the competition, stay in peoples minds, _lie without repercussion_ [2]. The author argues that ads are low-friction. It may seem that way when all the infrastructure is already set up: The automatic auctions, the marketing teams scripting, drawing and filming the ads, the confused and annoyed consumers, the additional bandwidth... But surely, we can come up with less frictional system, right? - [1]: The only way that's not true, is if adversing is a bubble. There are some arguments that it is: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/does-advertising-actually-work-part-2-digital-ep-441/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/does-advertising-actually-w... [2]: BP carbon footprint
- ksec 5y agoOnly a few days I posted this [1] >I cant upvote you enough. This single comment contains many of the contrarian view against HN. It is nice we have these real world stories on HN to balance the ideological fight against ads, where All Ads are evil. And of course there are people who disagree ( but the upvote suggest otherwise ). I am not sure if this submission was a response to that or a coincidence. But a lot of the replies here pretty much make my point. A lot of people on HN either have an idealistic view point of Ads, or a near zero understand of Ads as a business. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30205606 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30205606
- xg15 5y agoEntrepreneur who makes money from advertising changed his mind about advertising.