64 ms·
Apple unveils contactless payments via Tap to Pay on iPhone
- throw7 5y agoCan it receive contactless payment from android phones (e.g. google pay)?
- babyshake 5y agoThis seems to not be an open API but instead only available to a whitelisted group of partners. Is this correct? Is it reasonable to expect this to have open availability by later this year?
- diebeforei485 5y agoGreat, now I need an RFID-blocking wallet because any yeehaw can place their iPhone to my pocket to charge my credit card.
- lxgr 5y agoThat's been possible ever since mobile POS services have started supporting contactless payments, without any catastrophic fallout.
- diebeforei485 5y agoIt's obviously different when everyone already has an iPhone. Most crime is opportunistic.
- lxgr 5y agoThe difficulty in pulling this off is not in owning the reading device (you can already buy a contactless payment terminal and cheap Android phone for much less than an entry level iPhone in every electronics store), but in opening a merchant account (this usually requires verification) and not getting it flagged for very obvious fraud before you can withdraw your "revenue".
- akakwwe 5y ago
- Grustaf 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- no_wizard 5y agoPerhaps I’m missing context here what do you mean by this one? Is there something about Stripe in this instance that’s “mob” like?
- exhilaration 5y agoHe's (jokingly) referring to these complaints of favoritism by the CEO of a Stripe competitor: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30066969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30066969
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samwillis 5y agoI'm so pleased to see this happen in a way where its not tied to Apples own payment processor. They could so easily have done that to capture more revenue but I suspect it would have opened up more chance of an anticompetitive lawsuit. Obviously they are going to vet which processors are allowed, but as a consumer you want that so you can be confident that the iPhone you are tapping your card against isn't skimming your account. I suspect there is a revenue agreement with the processors allowed on.
- jb1991 5y ago*allowed
- samwillis 5y agoThanks, fixed.
- thebean11 5y agoProtection against account skimming should happen on the customer's iPhone (it should only send data allowing a single transaction of a certain size) not the merchant's iPhone. If the customer's iPhone doesn't have that protection it's pretty easy for the merchant to hide a skimmer in their iPhone case / POS system / gas pump.
- samwillis 5y agoIt looks like it's not just Apple Pay, it's excepts any card payment, the protection has to be on the merchant's iPhone.
- thebean11 5y agoI don't think tap to pay can be skimmed in the same way you can with swiping. You'd have to actually clone the data on the NFC chip, which isn't possible through a tap from what I understand.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sabjut 5y agoClarification due to a somewhat confusing title: This is about the merchant using an iPhone to accept credit cards and other Tap to Pay devices. The customer was able to pay with Tap to Pay with their iPhone for a while now.
- melling 5y agoThe long slow road to contactless payments. Almost 2 decades along in the technology adoption curve. I was ready for this in 2005. https://money.howstuffworks.com/personal-finance/debt-management/blink.htm https://money.howstuffworks.com/personal-finance/debt-manage... If course as the article points out, it wasn’t even new technology back then: “ Not Exactly New Tech Mobile introduced the Speedpass in 1997. Speedpass is a small device on a keychain (called a fob) that users wave in front of the Speedpass logo on gas pumps. The cost of the gas is automatically deducted from the user's Speedpass account”
- Spivak 5y agoThat’s not at all comparable since you’re not really paying. By that logic we’ve had contactless payments for hundreds of years in the form of opening a tab at a merchant.
- lmz 5y agoThat's sounds like stored value or contactless debit. What do you mean "not really paying"?
- wizzwizz4 5y agoIt's more like a contactless gift card: since you can't use your change for purchasing something different, the payment is in the purchase of the gift card. It's still got the "contactless" part, though.
- MattRix 5y agoI can see their point. If you already paid in advance, you aren’t really paying again when it subtracts the value from your account.
- jeffbee 5y agoI wonder what role GS, the Apple Pay backend, has in this, if they are involved at all.
- minhazm 5y agoGS is the backend for Apple Card. Is it also the backend for Apple Pay? I don't think I've seen any evidence of that. I also don't see why Apple would need GS for that. Each bank needs to support Apple Pay, and Apple likely just integrates directly with Visa, Mastercard, Amex, etc.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoApple Pay is a Apple->payments-network; Apple Card is payments-network->GS/Apple. Apple Pay with Apple Card is the two tromboned together.
- MBCook 5y agoI’m guessing none. It sounds like software developers will have to bring their own CC processing for this, not that it will use some centralized Apple designated processor.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- knaik94 5y agoThat's a pretty awesome way of letting iphones start to replace POS terminals. It's been done before through add on and swiping, but the major cc companies are phasing out swiping. And the real play is introducing this into an iPad at some point. An iPhone is handy day to day and great for small run produce markets, but it's been a long while since I have gone to restaurants around my college campus that didn't have an ipad or tablet for paying.
- dhosek 5y agoI'm surprised that the iPad isn't being supported for this.
- jurmous 5y agoWhile iPads have NFC chips none of the released iPads have an NFC antenna. https://9to5mac.com/2014/10/24/nfc-ipad-air-2-secure-element/ https://9to5mac.com/2014/10/24/nfc-ipad-air-2-secure-element...
- MBCook 5y agoDo they have the NFC hardware iPhones do? Maybe because of this they will add it to new iPads going forward.
- axg11 5y agoThree interesting implications from this press release: - Stripe as the first user of the SDK vs Square: For any small business starting this spring, I can't think of a reason why they wouldn't use and iPhone+Stripe to start off. Zero hardware cost (assuming they have an iPhone), no need to wait for hardware delivery. - NFC will be coming to the iPad. - The ability to keep the same hardware but switch payment network lowers switching cost for small businesses. Payment platforms will have to differentiate on ecosystem as well as cost.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoPresumably companies like Square and Clover are selling their own POS hardware and probably are less than happy that every iPad and iPhone running latest OS with NFC is now a competitor to their hardware. Stripe does not make hardware (as far as I’m aware) so this initial partnership makes sense.
- mojzu 5y agoI'd imagine for these companies the hardware is a necessity to get customers into their payment processing business, could even be a loss leader rather then a profit centre. If a lot more people now have a potential POS device in their pocket it could expand their markets quite a bit, although other payment processors who formerly didn't want to or couldn't make hardware may now become competitors
- ritwikr 5y agoStripe does have a physical terminal too (https://stripe.com/terminal https://stripe.com/terminal) but I've never seen it at a merchant.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoHuh, I did not know that, I’ve also never seen one out in the wild.
- bduerst 5y ago
- reffaelwallen 5y agoImpactful to Square?
- iamacyborg 5y agoMaybe, depending on how much of their revenue comes from hardware sales. Eventually they'll just be an app that runs on the phone, making it significantly easier for a business to signup to use their service.
- 0des 5y agoSquare is a different market segment, more of the first year, trendy-but-still-playskool retail merchant setup.
- ra7 5y agoCould you expand how Square is different market segment? I thought POS terminal was one of their primary products.
- 0des 5y agoSquare is for small or entry level merchants who may be in their first year and can't afford an actual production grade POS or web integration, stripe is for those who've realized they've reached that point or have encountered Square's limits, and by them moving into the entry level market by supporting this method of transacting with iDevices, I'd say square should be considering their next move.
- benreesman 5y agoIn what way would you consider merchants to be scale-bifurcated along the card-present/e-commerce line?
- verst 5y agoAt my local farmers market every vendor uses Square to accept payments, but also seems to have iPhones themselves. With this announcement I can very much see Square being removed from the equation in this small business without fixed store front scenario.
- lucioperca 5y agoLet me guess, 30% goes to apple when you do that?
- paradite 5y agoThe technical term for the cut is called Merchant Discount Rate (MDR). It's usually 1-3%. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/merchant-discount-rate.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/merchant-discount-rate.... I'm not sure what's the exact revenue share model / contractual agreements between Apple and its partner payment platforms(Stripe, etc).
- ab_testing 5y agoSo, is Apple -> Stripe now ?
- duxup 5y agoKinda weird. If a rando retail person pulls out their iPhone and asks me to tap... that's kinda strange in my mind. Something about "how do I know that isn't their personal phone?" would pop in my head. But things that seem awkward can become commonplace.
- llampx 5y agoEven now, they can use a Square wireless terminal and you wouldn't know if its hooked up to their personal iPhone or what.
- duxup 5y agoAbsolutely true.... just seems like a mounted device like they usually are seem more 'official'.
- djrogers 5y agoSquare and similar terminals aren’t mounted anymore - the vast majority I see these days are wireless wedges that use Bluetooth or some other wireless protocol.
- iamacyborg 5y agoThere's a big difference between something that looks like a payment terminal and what appears to just be a personal mobile phone though.
- aloe_falsa 5y agoWhen I pay with cash, I don't usually worry that the salesperson will put it in their own pocket. If they choose to be dishonest, that's between them and their employer.
- parkingrift 5y agoPeople use their personal phones with Stripe, Square, and Venmo. The only difference here is the lack of a terminal. It’s ultimately processed the same way.
- gandalfian 5y agoWhinge: but the term "Tap to Pay" winds me up. "Hover to Pay" maybe, or "Contactless" makes sense. But tap the card reader with your card and you disturb the touchscreen and cancel the payment. Don't tap it's a trick.
- hunter2_ 5y agoYeah, I never understood why "tap" and "contactless" became synonymous in this context, given that "tap" is an onomatopoeia for the sound of two objects making contact. Is it possible that "contactless" actually refers to lack of electrical contacts (i.e., not using the gold pads)? We already have plenty of words for this idea: radio, wireless, inductive. Or is the intent to mean no physical contact whatsoever such that a tap would only be accidental?
- bluk 5y agoFor most people, I bet it's more of a marketing term. When people hear "contactless", they might think that someone can steal your credit card number or charge you just by being in the same area.
- numpad0 5y agoIt’s not of both; significance of contactless technology that are used in Tap to [__] is that they require neither electrical nor physical connections. There are other RF-based technologies that require no conductive surfaces but some sort of mechanical touches. The reason why the users are instructed to slam the card or device is because users fail to perform required actions if simply told to hold the card or phones just right. Spatial cognition isn’t a forte for many. The reason why tap is used in VISA contactless over touch is probably because Suica system used by JR East uses the phrase “Suica is touch 1-second”.
- joshvm 5y agoIt's physically easier to touch the reader than to hover over it? Especially if the reader is a bit janky/older and takes time to complete the transaction. If you look at Oyster (TFL) for example, most people physically touch their cards to the turnstile/bus readers. The official advertising also uses the phrase "tap in, tap out" for stations where there are no barriers. "Contactless" is also fairly widely used in the UK - e.g. "do you take contactless?". Contactless is because in theory you don't need to touch your card to the reader. My new phone seems to have a good enough antenna (active?) that it triggers the POS terminal much further away than my debit card, but usually the activation distance is small enough that tapping is easier.
- numbsafari 5y agoIt'll be fascinating to see if/when/how this rolls out internationally, which isn't mentioned at all in the article.
- losvedir 5y agoIs this only for merchants? I feel like here in the US we still don't have a great way to send money back and forth with friends and family. Zelle is decent if both parties' banks support it, but otherwise I've tried Google Pay, Paypal, Venmo, and they all have some problem or another. A lot of them (I'm looking at you PayPal) require you to give them your bank username and password!
- eightysixfour 5y agoYou can send money using Apple Pay, but most of these free money transfer applications are free because they’re using ACH, so they “need” access to the bank account to see if the underlying funds are there. If they transact like a credit card processor, there are fees. This is setup so that you can run an existing merchant app (launching with Stripe) and collect money with all of the same fee requirements as using stripe normally.
- twobitshifter 5y agoThe press release includes mention of solopreneurs but nothing about friends and family, so i think there must be some business angle to it.
- floatingatoll 5y agoThere’s many debit card “send to friend” apps that fill this space, including Apple Cash and Square Cash and etc. but your most likely compatibility app is Venmo. I’ve had zero issues with any of the Cash apps I’ve used to date, though.
- kencausey 5y agoRegarding your allegation about Paypal, are you outside of the US? I ask simply because I am in the US and have never had to provide a username or password to my bank account to Paypal. I do have a bank account linked but it was done simply by Paypal making two small deposits to my account and then withdrawing them and asking me to tell them the amounts of the transactions. Given, this was many years ago, but I would be surprised to learn that this has changed. edit: typo
- rvz 5y agoI guess it was a good thing that Square had to move quickly, Since Stripe threw the gauntlet at them for just the reader [0] (If you don't have an iPhone). Now they are directly allowing payments from the phone. No need for readers at all. Next will be the iPad as the integrated terminal with NFC and no external equipment. But there remains the next one. Cryptocurrency payments which both of them are still in. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27534927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27534927
- TIPSIO 5y agoI would really like to see it become normal for tipping people this way (that isn't at a cash register / tap) but with AirDrop. For example, I recently had movers. I went out of my way to get a cash tip for them earlier. It would have been nice to skip that and just ping it at them somehow without awkwardly saying "Hey friend do you have Venmo? Apple Pay? CashApp? I'd like to tip you. What's your phone number?! Let me get that, thanks, bye, delete.". This is NFC and a bit different but just my thoughts.
- hn_throwaway_69 5y agoEh, I hope it doesn't. Tipping needs to die out. I'd prefer to have the moving company pay the movers a living wage such that a tip would be unnecessary and politely refused.
- ludamad 5y agoI'd rather an industry standard payout, but the workers getting pay proportional to revenue is actually not a bad model. I just hate the analysis paralysis
- TIPSIO 5y agoThis is obviously a bit flame-y / unrelated / political. Regardless of how you personally feel about US wages and the 20% I already prepaid for tip through the company to them, to be able to send money to others would be useful. There could be other cases besides tipping.
- exikyut 5y agoI'd be really interested to know what to properly call it, but IMHO this is the kind of thing that the market will never solve top-down because the structure of the relationship would never support it. I think an on-the-ground solution that caters to the long tail would be the only thing that would basically survive. Everything else would succumb to social forces and basically just fizzle out. AirDropping Apple credit could be an interesting pilot study, but I doubt Apple would do something like that sadly :/
- skeeter2020 5y ago
- twobitshifter 5y agoIt notes that it’s supported iPhone XS or later - what feature was added to the XS that is not in the X? When Apple names the “pro” model like this does it mean that the XR from the same generation is not supported?
- CharlesW 5y agoPossibly this? https://9to5mac.com/2018/09/12/iphone-xs-and-iphone-xr-can-read-nfc-tags-without-having-to-launch-an-app/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/09/12/iphone-xs-and-iphone-xr-can-r...
- numpad0 5y ago8 Global/7 JP and later has FeliCa secure element; checkm8 exploit works up to X. It’s a fine thinking to not accept secure transaction originating a potentially jailbroken device; perhaps that’s why?
- exikyut 5y agoI was wondering about that too. I wonder how much SecureROM extraction pays nowadays? It used to be $200k circa 2015: https://ramtin-amin.fr/#nvmedma https://ramtin-amin.fr/#nvmedma (Interim while the above URL currently doesn't work: https://web.archive.org/web/20200217151824/http://ramtin-amin.fr/nvmedma.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200217151824/http://ramtin-ami...)
- umanghere 5y agoThere are publicly available SecureROM dumps online, see http://securerom.fun http://securerom.fun The author(s) maintain the site out of personal interest.
- exikyut 5y agoOooh, TIL. That's really cool. It's very amusing that as you get to the bottom the "Vulnerable to" starts to disappear :) and yet you can download the bootrom anyway~ hmmmmm :D
- edf13 5y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30259251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30259251
- tiffanyh 5y agoThis is the outcome of Apple's 2020 acquisition of Mobeewave. https://www.pymnts.com/apple/2020/apple-buys-mobeewave-for-100m/ https://www.pymnts.com/apple/2020/apple-buys-mobeewave-for-1... It essentially turns an iOS device into a POS system. Apple already gets 15 bps for all Apple Pay transactions. I'm curious to hear the additional monetization Apple plans to get for this.
- pilsetnieks 5y ago> Apple already gets 15 bps for all Apple Pay transactions Bits per second? Beets per sale? Blackened pieces-of-eight per scurvy-rat?
- thesimon 5y agoBasis points
- atlbeer 5y agoBasis points
- mlyle 5y agoBasis points-- hundredths of a percent. so 0.15%.
- ghayes 5y agoI always remember "100 basis points = 1%". It's a little confusing since percentages are scalars, so really 1 bps is just the scalar 1/10000.
- runeks 5y agoBeets per sale
- mwint 5y agoSchrute Farms mode.
- staplung 5y agoI was using my phone for contactless pay but stopped during the pandemic because I realized it was more cumbersome than using a credit card to do the same thing. The phone tries to scan my face, fails because of the mask, then just waits for a hot second to see if my face might change shape, then prompts for a password. With the credit card, I just swipe it over the reader and I'm done.
- bobbylarrybobby 5y agoThankfully in iOS 15.4 (currently in beta), Face ID works with a mask on by scanning the shit out of your orbital bones
- ketzo 5y agoWoah, really? That's super exciting.
- macintux 5y agoI use my Watch, which is almost always simpler even without a mask. However, you should be able to hurry it along to prompt for a password. Apple doesn’t make it easily discoverable, but if you tap on the status message when it’s trying to decide whether it recognizes you, it will prompt you for a password instead (while logging in, and I imagine during Apple Pay as well).
- verst 5y agoYou can configure your iPhone not to use FaceID for Apple Pay only. That's what I did for the same reason as you. I just quickly enter my PIN to use Apple Pay.
- pornel 5y agoYou can use a contactless physical card too. No need to use an outdated insecure mag strip. Apple-style solution to this is to buy Apple Watch which authorizes payments without face scanning.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- johnwalkr 5y agoThis seems pretty nice for small retailers. Apple pay is not a big improvement on normal tap to pay, although it still feels cool 5 years later to pay for stuff using my watch. The gamechanger exceptions are: - Transit. I can use my watch/apple pay for transit in many cities. From experience, I have only used it in 2 cities. Slow and annoying in Vancouver, but much less annoying than the alternatives. In Japan, instant and more convenient than using my suica card or suica function of my phone. Back in 2016 I bought an Apple watch within hours of learning that it supported suica. The only slight inconvenience is that I prefer to wear my watch on my left hand, and the card reader at gates is always on the right. - Online commerce. Only twice have I had the good fortune of finding something I wanted to buy online available using apple pay. But wow, was it a good experience. No login[1], no entering my address or details. Just approve apple pay by fingerprint or faceid, confirm my address, and wait for the goods to arrive. [1] I have a common name, and an email address several dozen people think they own. Making a new account on any site/service is a nightmare. If I can even make an account, Logging in 1 year later is usually impossible because someone has tried to reset "their" password 50 times. Fixing an account on any service that profits from its users (eg venmo) is usually impossible. They won't cancel an account misusing my email so long as the transactions go through.
- pl0x 5y ago
- tannedNerd 5y agoEh, the apple article explicitly says other platforms soon. With all of apples recent anti trust issues I expect that to be less than a month or two or they could be accused harming smaller companies again by favoring stripe.
- kache_ 5y agoOut of the loop: the comment you're replying to is referring to the Bolt CEO claiming that Stripe is in cahoots with other organizations, particularly ycombinator & hnews to manipulate the perception of stripe. The reference to the mob is a play on the fact that the cofounders are Irish.
- akprasad 5y agon=1, but I don't have any mental association between "mob" and being Irish, and I don't feel comfortable reading that intent into the original tweets without stronger evidence.
- snemvalts 5y agoContext https://twitter.com/theryanking/status/1485784823641755648 https://twitter.com/theryanking/status/1485784823641755648
- jve 5y agoSome more context: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30066969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30066969
- ucha 5y agoEDIT: thanks everyone for quickly correcting my mistake, I missed the part that explained that more forms of contactless payments would be accepted I don't really understand why a merchant would use this feature. If you already use a PoS, why would you replace it with another one that only supports customers who own an Apple device? If you accepted only cash, maybe it's a small improvement because you can use your existing iPhone if you had one to accept cashless payments from Apple customers... Does Tap to Pay only make sense in the second case or am I missing something?
- lxgr 5y ago> why would you replace it with another one that only supports customers who own an Apple device? It's not only Apple Pay: > US merchants will be able to accept Apple Pay _and other contactless payments_
- darrenf 5y ago> If you already use a PoS, why would you replace it with another one that only supports customers who own an Apple device? What makes you think it only supports payment from Apple devices? The press release is pretty clear: At checkout, the merchant will simply prompt the customer to hold their iPhone or Apple Watch to pay with Apple Pay, their contactless credit or debit card, or other digital wallet near the merchant’s iPhone
- microtonal 5y agoIf you already use a PoS, why would you replace it with another one that only supports customers who own an Apple device? Did you read the article? At checkout, the merchant will simply prompt the customer to hold their iPhone or Apple Watch to pay with Apple Pay, their contactless credit or debit card, or other digital wallet near the merchant’s iPhone, and the payment will be securely completed using NFC technology. This will accept contactless cards, Google Pay, etc. as well.
- riskable 5y agoSure would be nice if Apple and Google got together to accept each other's systems. Or even better: If there was a standard that let any device send money with any other device (using compatible hardware). Imagine if there was a regulation that required interoperability. Or if the banks were forced to allow (authenticated) payments between systems without transaction fees. We're 20 years overdue for this.
- gigatexal 5y agoSo ... Square/Block is not dead?
- aquark 5y agoQuestion for anyone in the know at Stripe ... does this make a iPhone work like the existing BBPOS WisePOS terminals and able to interact with a web app _without_ any code running on the phone itself (other than Stripe's) Or is it more akin to the BBPOS Chipper readers and still needs a custom mobile app to interact with? ie: can a platform built on Stripe use this for their customers without needing to supply a mobile app?
- edwinwee 5y agoIt's designed to work through a mobile app via the iOS SDK: https://stripe.com/docs/terminal/payments/setup-sdk?terminal-sdk-platform=ios https://stripe.com/docs/terminal/payments/setup-sdk?terminal....
- aquark 5y agoThanks -- appreciate the reply. As a future product option I'd love to be able to treat these as standalone terminals, so we can offer a web based POS app (running on a different device) and the phone as a payment terminal without having to deploy our own mobile app.
- motohagiography 5y agoCorrect me if I'm way off, but when Apple launched it, iPhones had a separate secure element with applets that use keys stored in slots, very similar to chip/pin cards. The protocols for payments (EMV standards) all used symmetric keys, and so any issuer who wants to be a part of Apple Pay needs Apple to get a key into their SE. It's possible to do this through a process called "personalization," where in general, a secure element has "initialization" keys that are installed at manufacture, but then the keys get updated (personalized) once the user gets it. I'd speculate that Stripe could get integrated using a personalization protocol, with new keys over the existing protocols, and not require its own intitialization keys in the SE. A further speculation would be that Apple's pay partnership with GS may have facilitated a different protocol that uses more manageable asymmetric keys for doing reconciliations, and all the complexity is in integrating with generic payment terminals, whereas for anything that doesn't depend on that, you can use more sensible protocols that aren't freighted with backward compatability to chip/pin cards. Square would probably be the easier integration, but Stripe may have some secret sauce for this. Anyway, wildly speculative, and would be interested what's way off in that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- frb 5y ago> Apple will work closely with leading payment platforms and app developers across the payments and commerce industry to offer Tap to Pay on iPhone to millions of merchants in the US. Is it just me feeling that Apple is again playing gatekeeper to iPhone APIs and hindering true competition by "working with leading platforms" aka. the big players, like Stripe or PayPal, essentially leaving startups and smaller players disadvantaged. Why not just finally open the NFC API?
- dagmx 5y agoThey do that when they're concerned about bad actors or want to prove out the API first with a controlled set of people who are willing to experience breakage
- frb 5y agoIsn't that what the AppStore review process is for? Or why not provide an extra approval process for the NFC API? On the other hand they were not so concerned with bad actors when releasing AirTags. Feels more that it's about control than safety and like that kind of decision that got them into all the antitrust probes in the first place.
- dagmx 5y agoApp store review can only catch so much, and isn't able to analyze the actual code. It's one way for them to gate malicious code. And providing extra approval process for the NFC API is exactly what they're doing here. AirTags actually have a lot of design in them to thwart bad actors so your comment there is incorrect or ignoring all the anti stalker measures in there.
- fomine3 5y agoNFC API itself don't enable user to steal from contactless credit card. See Android.
- alwillis 5y agoThey do that when they're concerned about bad actors or want to prove out the API first with a controlled set of people who are willing to experience breakage Not only must you be reviewed by the App Store, but your app will require security entitlements to act as a payment processor. And you'll have to be a registered Apple developer in good standing. If a malicious actor went through all this trouble to grab some transactions, they'd be shutdown within hours of the scam and Apple would refund the money. Also, who's going to trust or want to use "Bob's rando payment processor"? No merchant is going to do that.
- gernb 5y agoWhen do they announce they want 30% of all payments made with this system?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAdd society goes cashless we need to support infrastructure that doesn’t leave the poor behind.
- exikyut 5y agoWhat I wish could happen but probably never will: that this takes off sufficiently much that it's commercially viable for Apple to spinoff a personal payments business that lets me yeet small amounts of money directly out of people's bank cards for personal payments. Perhaps with an eg $50-100 limit or so. PayPal allows free C2C transactions that are much higher in any case.
- throwaway22032 5y agoHacker News is such a bizarre place. On the one hand, we have threads about how browsers are fingerprintable and some app is using telemetry and endless discussions on theoretical zero-knowledge protocols and the importance of cryptography and Snowden saying this and that that get voted up to the top. On the other hand, something like this comes up which is basically another step along the "no-one accepts cash" funnel and so now everything you ever buy with metadata is part of the borg. Like, you've literally deliberately introduced an MiTM. I don't get this blind spot. Paying with cash is literally the easiest thing I do to reduce my data trail.
- AlexanderTheGr8 5y agoHow long before some stores don't accept cash? How long before banks do a background check (taking weeks) before giving you cash?
- wmeredith 5y ago> How long before some stores don't accept cash? This already happens. My closest NFL and MLB stadiums do not accept cash for anything inside the park.
- djhn 5y agoAlready happens. My local bike shop stopped accepting cash.
- dharmab 5y agoCashless businesses were appearing in NYC pre-pandemic until the city passed a law against them to preserve access for unbanked consumers. This law was criticized as it greatly increased the cost of starting a small business. Then the pandemic happened and cash usage declined further. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/23/nyregion/nyc-cashless-ban.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/23/nyregion/nyc-cashless-ban... - Note the date
- pomian 5y agoMost Airlines quit accepting cash for on board purchases. "For our convenience"
- websap 5y agoDid they just completely destroy Square's POS device business?
- joshstrange 5y agoNo support for Swipe or Dip but this is pretty awesome. I still need swipe/dip so I'm stuck with my BTLE device for that stuff but this is pretty awesome for contactless.
- websap 5y agoYeah, but this seems like a pretty e2e solution to me now. Most people get an iPhone before their first credit card. They can not get an Apple Card directly on their iPhone with a few touches that instantly gets added to their wallet (the physical card takes days to ship), the card in the iPhone Wallet can now directly be used.
- 0xy 5y agoThis is a clear shot across the bow of Dorsey's empire. Given Square's huge portion of their revenue coming from readers, things have to be looking bleak over there. Square is down 61% since October.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoI think until this goes out of the "NFC only" card capture space there's going to be room to compete. I don't think you can realistically run a point-of-scale business that doesn't allow mag stripe / chip payment yet. Maybe I'm wrong though.
- jon889 5y agoWeird that this is US first when in the UK it’s extremely rare not to be able to use contactless. (I only say UK as I live there, but definitely there are other countries that are heavily focused on contactless)
- adventured 5y agoApple might perceive a large advantage to moving quickly in the US market right now, that there is something to gain by grabbing land there sooner rather than later (as opposed to rolling it out in various smaller markets with higher % contactless rates first).
- curiousllama 5y agoSquare stock lives and dies with bitcoin - wouldn't use the stock as an indicator of this
- edwinwee 5y ago(I work at Stripe.) Square and Stripe Terminal are designed for pretty different use-cases: Square is an instant POS that small business owners can use to accept payments for their shops. Stripe Terminal allows platforms and tech-forward companies to integrate with the Stripe API—to deploy and customize in-person payments for bespoke checkout flows (think Shopify, Lightspeed, or HouseCall Pro).
- joshstrange 5y agoThis is really freaking cool and a long time coming. It's sad that iPads are left out since those are the primary POS device that stores use (off the shelf device at least) but I look forward to testing this out when they release it. I need to support swipe/dip so I'll have to stick with my BTLE device for that but this would be cool addition to have contactless-only checkout stations manned by people with iPhones.
- aplummer 5y agoAs an aside, if anyone knows why Australia has 100% contactless payment penetration I’d be interested to know
- LeicaLatte 5y agoVery cool! Looking forward to POS demos at the March event.
- tsycho 5y agoSo is this iPhone to iPhone only, or can the customer use any NFC enabled credit card directly, or (shudder) their Android phone?
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoYep, Android and tap-to-pay cards will work too.
- prepend 5y agoThis will be nice. A few months ago a street vendor was selling a book he had written. He seemed like a nice guy and I wanted to support his initiative. The book was only $10. He didn’t take cash, nor Venmo, nor PayPal. He took cash app, Apple Pay and a bunch of other things I had never heard of. I don’t use cash app and wouldn’t sign up just for him. We tried to use Apple Pay but couldn’t figure out how to add his contact info and send money. I’m sure we could have eventually figured it out, but we gave up. He also had an android phone with some apps there but couldn’t work with my iPhone. This sounds like it would have been really useful. I’ll settle with “just give $10 to this person who has an iPhone, I don’t care about anything else” as a step closer to “just give $10 to this person who has anything”
- Pxtl 5y agoTangentially related, I'm still surprised how few low-end Android phones have NFC. Like, the Moto G line is everywhere and they still don't have that?
- eole666 5y agoOutside of USA, where most people don't have an iPhone, I don't really see the point.. It would be more usefull with ipads or any less personal device : If the shop's owner haves an iPhone accepting paiement but it's an employee doing the paiements, the shop opwner has to give his personal phone to the employee to accept paiement ? Or he needs to buy an other iPhone with no personal data and accepting paiement (is it even possible ? ) to give the employee ? .. and now it's already more expensive than a simple contactless paiement machine.
- noneeeed 5y agoLots of people other than shops take money. There are lots of one-man businesses or tradespeople who take credit card through services like SumUp which require a seperate device paired to their phone. For people like that this will be very useful. Both my plumber and the guy who fixed our washing machine used SumUp, as did most of the market-stall holders at the Christmas market this year. All of them were using the phone-linked version (rather than the one with its own SIM). Sure, it's not right for everyone, but it will be perfect for a lot of people.
- clintonb 5y ago> Later this year, US merchants will be able to accept Apple Pay and other contactless payments simply by using iPhone and a partner-enabled iOS app The target user is a US-based merchant. Most likely, it's a small business, perhaps a sole proprietorship, that uses a small Square reader today. This gives that business one more way to accept payments, but without the extra hardware. A business with multiple employees/points of sale has alternatives. This is probably not the solution for them.
- uptownfunk 5y agoMy local bakery doesn't even accept cash anymore. Probably a lot of places. I was explaining to my 3 year old that "a long time ago people used to pay with these green pieces of paper called money, now we use this thing called Apple Pay on our phones"
- brtknr 5y agoContactless but you have to tap and most will make slight contact :) exciting nevertheless!
- sydthrowaway 5y agoHow does Square feel about this?
- YoungWeb 5y agoContactless payments are great but there are many intermediaries in 1 simple purchase in the current payment processing system. I would like to see digital payments evolve into true p2p transactions. Let me pass you my bits. I don't want to pass them to bob, jessica, then larry and then have larry pass you the bits.
- matthewaveryusa 5y agoDoes anyone have a doc with the specifics of how tap-to-pay works? Specifically, what happens when mulitple individuals are in proximity? I imagine there's a payment request broadcast followed by a payment allow response, followed by the broadcaster sending a subsequent request message to a selected payment response? I'm curious about the specifics and what kind of clever things the protocol has to maximize security and minimize DoS, and what kind of information is transmitted on each leg of the protocol
- 0xTJ 5y agoThis title is awful, there's really no way for me to read it as accepting payment, instead of the ubiquitous paying that way.
- billylo 5y agoI hope this would mean CoreNFC will no longer block payment application id tags. https://developer.apple.com/documentation/corenfc https://developer.apple.com/documentation/corenfc
- steadyready 5y agoMan, I swear sometimes I feel like I’m on a forum full of wanted criminals, state actors, and/or felons. I’m not saying I’m against privacy. I am all for not being tracked, but we are approaching absurdity. I really want to see all of you who praise “privacy” go fully offline and use only cash. No cards. No bank account. Nothing. Salary? Cash, because earnings could also be sold and used for advertising. Groceries? Cash. Gas? Cash. No checks also, as they can be tracked /s Also, while we are at it, no Android, no iOS, no Windows or Macs. Only Linux, because we can’t trust UE vendors. Really, maybe we should start spending our energy in convincing legislators that PII should not be sold along with transaction data/histories. Matter a fact, let’s rally for universal privacy laws. How about that? Let’s not go 50 back in evolution just because “visa bad”. I’m happy not to lose cash or reach for my wallet anymore.
- glial 5y agoAgreed. I'm all for privacy too. But trying to solve social problems with technical solutions seems optimistic at best. Even if everyone on this website uses cash only, the issue of data privacy still exists for the other 99.999% of society - and we should try to solve it for them too.
- Santosh83 5y agoCash decentralises power to the extent possible. E-currency centralises it to an absurd degree. That's the point. The slope of convenience though is gradual and slippery indeed. Institutions we've had for centuries crumbling in a matter of decades is a matter of concern. They worked more or less. There is no guarantee what is replacing them will work but we seem to have blind faith they will, since we're throwing the baby & the bathwater very gleefully out the window.
- steadyready 5y agoI never said “remove cash”. It should continue to exist nevertheless, because it’s a level of system redundancy and backup. I just said that I shouldn’t have to sacrifice quality of life improvements and STILL have my PII data sold from other channels.
- 5y ago
- npollock 5y ago"use their iPhone to seamlessly and securely accept Apple Pay, contactless credit and debit cards, and other digital wallets through a simple tap" other digital wallets = crypto?
- hrdwdmrbl 5y agoYes, could I accept DAI? Use State Channels?
- lxgr 5y agoGoogle Pay, Samsung Pay etc.
- alwillis 5y agoother digital wallets = crypto? Yes! WWDC should be pretty interesting this year: https://9to5mac.com/2021/12/28/comment-tim-cook-said-apple-is-looking-at-cryptocurrency-heres-what-theyre-like-to-do/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/12/28/comment-tim-cook-said-apple-i...
- manzu 5y agoWhy is this US only?
- holoduke 5y agoHow secure is this? For example in the Netherlands creditcards are showing a secret number on the backside of the card. Let's say the app on the phone is altered and making pictures of the card once it swiped over. The phone can then collect all information to make a purchase. I would not trust somebodies phone to swipe my card over.
- pliuchkin 5y agoThat's a good question, the first thing that came to my mind was someone cloning cards.
- dustinmoris 5y agoOh no, now Epic will get upset because they won't be able to plug in an external USB 2.0 CC reader into an iPhone.
- dnbdave 5y agoHow long until I can mug people via NFC and without the pesky mandatory minimums that come with weapons charges? Soon?
- syspec 5y agoYou can do that today, https://squareup.com/us/en/point-of-sale/restaurants https://squareup.com/us/en/point-of-sale/restaurants
- morpheuskafka 5y agoSo between this and the free Square magstripe reader for Lighting port, you've got everything covered. The only issue would be liability shift for a card that has EMV but doesn't have contactless and thus has to be processed as magstripe, but those cards are getting rarer as most issuers are replacing with NFC-enabled ones.
- aetherspawn 5y agoThis is such a big deal because for small merchants, these terminals are generally really expensive and take high cuts. Now small cafes, tradies, etc getting on their feet can use the hardware they already have to start processing straight away.
- barkerja 5y agoDoes the use of a terminal tack on more fees in addition to the fees the processor already takes?
- aetherspawn 5y agoIn a lot of cases the processor is not the bank (SmartPay, Square, etc), so usually, yes, they'll want a cut. And then you'll also get charged for the paper rolls (for receipts), and renting of the EFTPOS equipment if you rent it. I ripped this off some marketing material that I found for a popular EFTPOS terminal in Australia: A merchant service fee is a fee you pay to your EFTPOS provider to process your transaction payments. This fee is calculated as a percentage (or fixed fee) of every transaction where a customer swipes, inserts, or taps their card at your terminal. For every transaction, your bank pays fees which include: a fee to the issuing bank (e.g. the bank that issued the card), the scheme fee (e.g. Visa, Mastercard, EFTPOS), and the switch fee (who processes the transaction).
- tannhaeuser 5y agoI think governments should wake up to defend monetary sovereignty/independence before it's too late, like with the web/the ad market.
- IvanK_net 5y agoI wish people were more aware of fees. You pay around 1% of the amount as a fee. Without these fees, everytihng could be 1% cheaper. Imagine every person in the world making 1% more overnight. 1% of your money is a lot. That is why you will never be able to give money to a friend this way. You give $100, but they receive $99. They give it back after a week, and you receive $98.
- stepanhruda 5y agoNot that easy, most people get more than 1% back on their cards. It’s a reallocation mechanism where poor people who can’t pay their credit card bills end up sponsoring everyone else
- bouzouk 5y agoOn Android, this has been a project in Europe for a few years, called SoftPOS, that should be coming live in coming weeks/month (ie. be able to acquire a contactless card payment using only your phone- no other hardware). Apple declined to be part of it and thus it was expected that they release there own version soon.
- jonobird1 5y agoIt'll be interesting to see how Square reacts to this, and how much traction and market share this builds over the next 12 months, if any.
- mariojv 5y agoWould I be able to use this to process payments at a garage sale without going through a bunch of hoops? That would be great. I know you could theoretically use Zelle/Paypal/Venmo, but it seems much easier to just be able to accept a card payment. Plus, I wouldn't have to give strangers my email, phone number, or username, which would be needed for those payment methods.
- est 5y agoThis will be a huge hit in China if works out. With UnionPay merchants can receive money directly into their deposit cards, hopefully without fees. It will eat Alibaba and Tencent's lunch.
- jaimex2 5y agoIt's a trap!
- thasaleni 5y agothis is dope, and also something I have been working on on android (yes I am gonna be that guy, Android has supported this for a long time)... it's great for informal merchants, and maybe waiters that run around a bar collecting bills from customers... but actual POS devices aren't going anywhere, there is always gonna be a need for them, this function has been there and even has a name (softPos) many companies can give you this functionality TODAY on your android phone, so yes apple devices can now participate but it won't shake the market as everyone thinks.
- breakpointalpha 5y agoFun fact, I was out late last night at a local upscale gas station. Think clean, well lit, and modern touchscreen sandwich ordering. NOT a dirty, broken down place. You'd expect the tech to work flawlessly in a place like this. I was second in line behind a younger guy who asked to use his iPhone tap to pay, the clerk shrugged and pointed to the card scanner. Guy taps his phone and the scanner bricks, hard. The young man was somewhat embarrassed for holding up the line and sheepishly dug some old school greenbacks out of his pockets to pay before slinking out the door. The clerk confusedly tried without luck to recover the register, before giving up and asking me and the other 6 people in line to move to another register. I had a little mini panic because all I had was a card, no cash, and about $20 worth of snacks. What do we do when electronics fail?
- rswail 5y agoThe way google/apple/samsung pay work is that there is a secure element that is running its own OS that contains applications. For contactless payment (the consumer side), there are apps that implement the EMV NFC standards and also interface with the tokenization services that are run by the card issuers. In this case, it's a different sort of application that provides the merchant side of the EMV transaction, provisioned as part of the PCI SPoC standard (https://www.pcisecuritystandards.org/assessors_and_solutions/spoc_solutions?agree=true https://www.pcisecuritystandards.org/assessors_and_solutions...). SPoC relaxes some of the physical security requirements while enhancing online monitoring (of the application and security of keys etc) and approval of an end-to-end implementation. So the SPoC standard will allow merchant side payment processing without needing specific PA-DSS compliant readers etc, because the end-to-end between the secure PIN reader (SCR-P standard) and the SPoC monitoring replaces that.