28 ms·
Something from the NYT mailing list yesterday: > The Covid vaccines are remarkably effective at preventing serious illness. If you’re vaccinated, your chances
by tzs 5y ago
Something from the NYT mailing list yesterday:
> The Covid vaccines are remarkably effective at preventing serious illness. If you’re vaccinated, your chances of getting severely sick are extremely low. Even among people 65 and older, the combination of the vaccines’ effectiveness and the Omicron variant’s relative mildness means that Covid now appears to present less danger than a normal flu.
> For the unvaccinated, however, Covid is worse than any other common virus. It has killed more than 865,000 Americans, the vast majority unvaccinated. In the weeks before vaccines became widely available, Covid was the country’s No. 1 cause of death, above even cancer and heart disease.
At this point if an adult in the US is unvaccinated it is (1) almost certainly by choice (there are some people who cannot get it for medical reasons but they make up only a very tiny fraction of the unvaccinated), and (2) it is very unlikely that any evidence or logical arguments will chance their minds.
With COVID becoming endemic everyone is going to get antibodies, with the only choice being whether you get your first antibodies by vaccination or by getting COVID.
The only question really then is how fast do we want the unvaccinated to do the getting antibodies by getting COVID thing. The faster they get it, the faster we can be as done with COVID as we are ever going to be.
I'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions.
- systemvoltage 5y agoCDC's new paper throws a wrench in all of these arguments from NYT: https://thepulse.one/2022/01/24/cdc-admits-the-obvious-natural-covid-immunity-is-extremely-powerful/ https://thepulse.one/2022/01/24/cdc-admits-the-obvious-natur...
- encryptluks2 5y ago> The faster they get it, the faster we can be as done with COVID as we are ever going to be. This reminds me of the arguments that unvaccinated were the cause of COVID-19 and were endangering those who are vaccinated. Vaccinated people get and spread COVID still. In fact, recent studies show natural immunity or vaxxed plus COVID causes much more antibodies than simply getting vaccinated, especially with a vaccine that targets an old mutation that has proven much less effective against Omicron and the likes. The vaccinated people will prob continue to get vaccinated a few times a year until they get a less dangerous variant.
- gibspaulding 5y ago>It has killed more than 865,000 Americans It looks like that's more Americans than have been killed in combat in all of the wars of the 20th century combined [1] Granted it's less than the UK lost in WW1 alone, so it's perhaps more a testament to how few the US managed to loose in the world wars (compared to Europe), but it's still wild to realize. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1009819/total-us-military-fatalities-in-american-wars-1775-present/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1009819/total-us-militar...
- walterbell 5y agoThese numbers can be further separated by "with Covid" and "from Covid" causality, as well as co-morbidities and expected lifetime. E.g. if someone was soon to die from illness A, but died 3 months earlier from complications induced by Covid, and the hospital received a financial payment for classifying this as Covid-related treatment, that should be broken out into a separate reporting category. Such deaths would not much change all-cause mortality for the year.
- xadhominemx 5y agoExcess mortality is higher than reported COVID deaths. Australia contained the virus in 2020 and saw negative excess mortality. Official COVID deaths understate the true toll.
- argvargc 5y ago...of lockdowns?
- xadhominemx 5y agoCOVID denialists often attribute excess deaths to lockdowns as opposed to undercounting of deaths from COVID. I was just preempting that line by pointing out Australia had severe lockdowns but negative excess deaths.
- 5y ago
- jrockway 5y agoI wanted to comment a little on the "choice" thing. I'm not sure that every person who is unvaccinated chose that. I had to try very hard to get my three doses. For the first series, I had to go to a faraway FEMA-run site. For the booster, I scheduled three appointments with CVS; the first two times, they canceled my appointment on the walk over (I made the first like 3 weeks in advance, and they canceled with 10 minutes notice -- "sorry, we ran out".) I did eventually get that third dose; but each signup took me about 15 minutes of typing in all of my medical information (`insert into form_responses (email, json_blob_that_is_passed_to_the_final_appointment_making_system) ...`?). I imagine some people just gave up after their first appointment was canceled. I never saw anyone talking about this; the government websites are like "go to CVS, you can just walk in!" but in reality no CVS locations were accepting walk-ins if you asked. And even appointments were tenuous. I feel like it's fair to place 90% of the blame on individuals, but I also think big companies are misrepresenting themselves to the government, or the government isn't asking if they actually have vaccines or not.
- lmkg 5y agoAccess is also a larger issue in under-served populations. I'm fortunate enough, as probably are many on this site, to be able to just swing by CVS during some downtime while WFH. A person who is paid hourly for an in-person job and reliant on public transportation will have a much harder time. I wish there were stats on "want to vaccinate, but haven't been able to."
- jrockway 5y agoVery true. I'm the best possible case, right? I get my full salary and benefits to wander over to CVS only to be told they're out of vaccine. I get my full salary and benefits while filling out all the paperwork. And if I do get COVID, guess what -- full salary and benefits while I recover. Most people are not that lucky, and unfortunately have to choose to roll the dice on COVID to avoid the certainty of being fired for missing work. I would love it if there was data on "want a vaccine but couldn't get it". The vaccine finder website could have you indicate "I'm interested" and then email you every month and ask you to confirm that you got a vaccine or that you gave up or that you're still looking. I fear that people don't ask questions they don't want to know the answer to; "300 million people are looking for a vaccine but only 200 million got it" would not look good. Sigh!!
- tynpeddler 5y agoThe vaxxed and unvaxxed populations both rely on the same medical infrastructure. So when the unvaxxed fill hospitals to recover or die, they are consuming scarce resources that are required by the population at large for other things like birth, cancer, surgery, etc. Sadly, we don't have an ethical way to let all the unvaxxed get covid without impacting the medical system negatively for the rest of us.
- akomtu 5y agoThe same reasoning can be applied to obesity.
- kritiko 5y agoI highly recommend reading this series if you think obesity is a personal failure: https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-part-i-mysteries/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-p... Obviously, yes, medical conditions do place burdens on health systems. That's why we tax cigarettes highly. However, in spite of considerable public health initiatives, the obesity rate continues to rise...
- GavinMcG 5y agoNot really. Various groups may disproportionately take up health resources, but the risk we're talking about is acutely overwhelming health systems.
- rory 5y agoThis is definitely the most pressing issue, but shouldn't we also, as a society, build the ability to e.g. double ICU capacity when needed? We're not talking about 100x here. As much as I support vaccination, it feels like gaps in vaccination are also used as an excuse to blow off repairing an extremely fragile public health system. We've had two years at this point.
- nicoburns 5y ago
- eli 5y agoGiven the topic of the post, it's funny you didn't mention one measure that does convince holdouts to get vaccinated: mandates. https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/01/22/do-vaccine-mandates-actually-work https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/01/22/do-vacci... (https://archive.fo/g2vHF https://archive.fo/g2vHF)
- 3glkjlkjlkg 5y ago
- skeptical3 5y ago
- twblalock 5y agoMandates work up to a point. Eventually you will be left with a portion of the population that cannot be convinced and will not obey mandates. Once you've reached that point, what purpose does the mandate serve? Nobody else is going to get the vaccines, so there is no public health justification for keeping the mandate around. However, what remains is the continual need to provide your vaccine status to your employer and in various other aspects of your daily life, which is a burden for vaccinated people too. The United States has probably already reached that point, or will soon.
- JPKab 5y agoI saw that email. David Leonhart I believe, who is one of my preferred NYT journalists. Something that was conspicuously absent from the paragraph regarding the unvaccinated vs. the vaccinated paragraph preceding it: Risk stratification by age. When talking about the vaccinated, he calls out the "even in people over age 65". There is zero question that vaccines reduce the relative risk for people under 65, however, it should be noted that the absolute risk for healthy people in this category is orders of magnitude lower purely by virtue of their age. Unhealthy people in this category should be vaccinated, of course. Just an example of narrative bias creeping in, even from the relatively top-flight Leonhart. Anyway, not disagreeing with you, just calling out a specific example of why the journalism on COVID has been, primarily unintentionally, misleading.
- tehjoker 5y agoThis totally discounts reinfections and long covid. A lot of people are going to die and get disabled. Antibodies seem to not last very long at levels that prevent infection. This is a very severe crisis that doesn't end because people get tired. It's like being tired of a war and laying down your weapons and then getting surprised when you get overrun.
- skillpass 5y agoI agree - I am worried about taking hospital capacity claims at face value though. From what I've seen, it was common for hospitals to report being overwhelmed even during flu seasons pre-covid. I wouldn't classify that level of 'overwhelmed' worthy of mandates upon society. I don't doubt that during these periods of time hospital resources are strained in some way, but there's a difference between this routine level of being overwhelmed and a level where freedoms should be restricted from the general public. I don't have a good model for where the line should be drawn, but I lean towards not imposing restrictions unless massive benefit can be shown beyond a reasonable doubt.
- walterbell 5y agoThere are operations research PhD's who use decades of aggregate demand data in dynamic pricing algorithms for the purpose of revenue and queue management in perishable services, e.g. software for pricing of airline seats, rental cars and hotel rooms. In countries with universal healthcare, price cannot be used for queue management, but the US isn't one of those countries. Did any hospital use queue management software to adjust pricing as a mechanism for demand throttling, due to limited capacity in 2020-2021? In any case, if supply-vs-demand is both a policy driver and metric of intervention performance, we need public, detailed hospital capacity data for analysis and optimization of net societal costs vs benefits. Utilization of space and skills is eminently quantifiable and software already exists for demand mgmt.
- zrail 5y ago> Did any hospital use queue management software to adjust pricing as a mechanism for demand throttling, due to limited capacity in 2020-2021 No one shops for healthcare in the US based on price, for three reasons. First, prices are unknowable in advance. Second, if you have insurance the insurance will fulfill their end of the bargain if you need to be admitted (i.e. they will pay as agreed upon in the insurance contract). Third, emergency rooms in the US are required by law to stabilize any emergent patient that walks in the door, which means anyone can go to any ER anywhere and get treatment.
- varelse 5y agoNew variants are now emerging every 30 days. Good luck with that plan. Why is the concept that life finds a way so hard to accept? We're getting our asses kicked by this thing. But I would agree with you if the variants would just stop creating themselves. But it doesn't seem like any immunity really lasts. So this leads to repeatedly infecting yourself with variants as they emerge (1 in 6 chance of a bad outcome of long covid or worse), become a bit of a test rat for the latest vaccine, or some combination therein. I'm hoping we eventually get a vaccine that transcends the evolutionary range of this thing. And then we could do exactly what you're suggesting. But that's a science project and you never know how those will go. The main concern I have is will we be a nation crippled with PTSD and long-term healthcare concerns when this is finally over with?
- theandrewbailey 5y ago> I'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions. Having anyone's freedoms dependent on available hospital capacity is a terrible way to run a society. Note that these freedoms were debated and won in an era where medicine was terrible.
- Nbox9 5y agoI’d like to know that if I have a heart attack or get hit by a bus then I’ll have access to top quality healthcare —- not burnt out understaffed hospitals. Sharing limited resources is a major role of the government, and managing hospital capacity seems to fall under “promote general welfare” to me. My $0.02
- enchiridion 5y agoIt definitely is, but they’re addressing it from the wrong end. If the pandemic could be fixed by the government managing individual behavior we’d be done with it by now. Instead the government should be focused on expanding highly covid specific care capacity. That is by far a better way to spend the covid relief money than distributing it to sustain a nebulous lockdown. As far as I understand from talking with doctors, at no time within the last year have hospitals been at maximum emergency covid capacity, as in hospital beds in the hall ways, cafeteria, etc. This tells me that we are close to the amount of beds we need, and it would be feasible to build out additional capacity quickly, relieve the strain, and get back to normal.
- joshuamorton 5y ago> Instead the government should be focused on expanding highly covid specific care capacity. That is by far a better way to spend the covid relief money than distributing it to sustain a nebulous lockdown. This is not something the government can do. It's not something anyone can do. What you're asking for (though you may not know it) is for their to suddenly be more nurses and medical practitioners. That's not a thing that can just suddenly happen, or even happen with 2-3 years of prep. You need a decade to actually functionally increase the supply of nurses and specialists. Now there are lots of short term fixes the government has done, such as activating the national guard in locations (to reduce non-medical load on nurses) and hospitals can pause elective services to free up space and time, but that has huge downsides since it means people get life saving nonemergency surgeries like cancer removal.
- vkou 5y ago> The only question really then is how fast do we want the unvaccinated to do the getting antibodies by getting COVID thing. The faster they get it, the faster we can be as done with COVID as we are ever going to be. No, there's one other question - how much of our limited health resources do we want to allocate to people still refusing to get vaccinated. In all fairness, I think they should be allocated proportionately. If 20% of a region's population is unvaccinated, and there's a bed shortage, they should get ~20% of hospital beds.
- rsynnott 5y ago> If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions. This is basically the reasoning used in Ireland; the hospitals weren't overwhelmed as Omicron peaked in the first week or so of January, so overnight we went from really quite restricted to all restrictions except mask requirements gone. Over 95% of Irish adults are vaccinated, so this isn't a trick that will work everywhere, but... for now it seems to be going okay.
- legitster 5y agoThis seems to be the near consensus opinion of reasonable people I know. People are really downplaying how effective the vaccines have been. My one unvaccinated friend has stated several times that they would rather sign a waver denying themselves access to an ICU bed than get vaccinated. I don't know what we are waiting on as a society to reopen other than enough people to get it.
- mint2 5y ago>” At this point if an adult in the US is unvaccinated it is (1) almost certainly by choice (there are some people who cannot get it for medical reasons but they make up only a very tiny fraction of the unvaccinated), and (2) it is very unlikely that any evidence or logical arguments will chance their minds.” This typical line of thought ignores a huge issue. Vaccine mandates don’t help per se, but it’s an issue that is pretty bad to just gloss over. Articles like this really need to describe some sort of policy or plan for the 7 million or so immunocompromised people in America. Like at least mention them and advocate something. Don’t just gloss over 7 million people. Propose something like Priority access to the new Pfizer pills and additional assistance with other things to avoid high risk activities.
- mywittyname 5y ago> Articles like this really need to describe some sort of policy or plan for the 7 million or so immunocompromised people in America. Wear good masks, social distance, etc. Basically do everything that's recommended to prevent the spread of covid, besides getting a vaccine. As a bonus, doing these things will help keep them safe from a large number of other airborne illnesses that put them at risk. Plus, there has been an increased awareness about preventing the spread of airborne diseases in general. Lots of stores and businesses have installed filtration systems that help keep everyone safer. Contactless delivery / checkout is much more mainstream, and it's now socially acceptable & legal to wear a mask, which is something certain people are going to continue to do. So while it has certainly been a nightmare for immunocompromised people, some positive changes have also resulted.
- twblalock 5y agoThere always have been, and always will be, vulnerable immunocompromised people. We didn't reorganize society around that fact before the pandemic, and we shouldn't do so now. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but we can't keep using things that will never change as reasons to persist with a state of emergency -- otherwise that state of emergency will never end.
- mint2 5y agoYou may want to reread my comment and think about what I’m saying, you didn’t need to come out and advocate abandoning immunocompromised people to Covid.
- truted2 5y ago“ It has killed more than 865,000 Americans, the vast majority unvaccinated.” Could someone please put a number on “vast majority”? I keep hearing this adage but a majority is 51% and there’s a big range between 51 and 100% that a word like “vast” doesn’t precisely capture..
- acdha 5y agoYou'd have to adjust for the period of time where vaccination wasn't available but currently the difference is best characterized as vast — the weekly rate is 10 per 100k versus 0.71 for fully vaccinated without a booster and 0.10 for boosted individuals: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/united-states-rates-of-covid-19-deaths-by-vaccination-status?country=~All+ages https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/united-states-rates-of-co...
- omgwtfbyobbq 5y agoI would guess something like 5-25%, but it's a subjective term, so who knows. Table 1 on page 3 has unvaccinated covid deaths at ~20% of the total. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/pdfs/mm7104e2-h.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/pdfs/mm7104e2-h.pdf
- thatfrenchguy 5y ago> I'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions. You forget the second order effect here: the more unvaccinated people hospitals have to treat, the more likely their nurses and doctors are to quit, even if "the hospital is not overloaded". The more likely they are to quit, the more likely people are to die of other preventable causes in the future (because once they're burned and quit, they're not coming back).
- CWuestefeld 5y agoThe exact operation of this effect isn't clear, I think. If we could wave a magic wand and make it all immediately end, that would be preferable. But that's not going to happen. That leaves us with two choices. We can let it drag on and on, or we can tear off the bandaid quicker. It's not clear to me which of those two is worse for the healthcare professionals you're talking about.
- loceng 5y ago"... has killed more than 865,000 Americans, ..." Can we start holding people and publications to differentiating for past variant vs. Omicron, etc? It deserves and necessitates such nuance.
- histriosum 5y agoI don't see how we could ask that of either people or publications - the data simply doesn't exist. Only a tiny fraction of Covid cases get genetically sequenced.
- spookthesunset 5y agoSo perhaps we should add huge qualifiers to all these scary sounding numbers, eh? Because the lack of context throughout this pandemic has created vast amounts of ungrounded, unchecked fear and hysteria.
- deegles 5y ago> With COVID becoming endemic everyone is going to get antibodies Vaccines provide better protection than infection, just to be clear. It's not true that you're safe because of a previous infection. See: https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-protection.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr...
- reducesuffering 5y agoI see your Aug. '21 CDC paper, and raise you 1 more recent Jan. '22 CDC paper: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm "By the week beginning October 3, compared with COVID-19 cases rates among unvaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis, case rates among vaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis were 6.2-fold (California) and 4.5-fold (New York) lower; rates were substantially lower among both groups with previous COVID-19 diagnoses, including 29.0-fold (California) and 14.7-fold lower (New York) among unvaccinated persons with a previous diagnosis, and 32.5-fold (California) and 19.8-fold lower (New York) among vaccinated persons with a previous diagnosis of COVID-19. During the same period, compared with hospitalization rates among unvaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis, hospitalization rates in California followed a similar pattern. These results demonstrate that vaccination protects against COVID-19 and related hospitalization, and that surviving a previous infection protects against a reinfection and related hospitalization. Importantly, infection-derived protection was higher after the Delta variant became predominant, a time when vaccine-induced immunity for many persons declined because of immune evasion and immunologic waning (2,5,6)." TL;DR only vaccine did not provide better protection than only previous infection
- lliamander 5y agoNot necessarily: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262415v1.full https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262415v...
- systemvoltage 5y agoNo they don't, indisputably now. See the massive 15 million people study from CDC Jan'2022 paper and here is an article that summarizes it: https://thepulse.one/2022/01/24/cdc-admits-the-obvious-natural-covid-immunity-is-extremely-powerful/ https://thepulse.one/2022/01/24/cdc-admits-the-obvious-natur...
- throwaway554349 5y ago[flagged]
- maskil 5y agoDone with Covid? Are you aware that vaccines are failing spectacularly with regards to Omicron infection? Hospitalizations are another story, but this notion of the vaccines ending Covid is just not holding up with new variants.
- jwagenet 5y agoWhat? I thought it has been pretty clear that even with Omicron, the vaccine dramatically reduces risk. In WA, the unvaccinated are 2-4x more likely to get covid and 5-11x more likely to be hospitalized. https://www.doh.wa.gov/Portals/1/Documents/1600/coronavirus/data-tables/421-010-CasesInNotFullyVaccinated.pdf https://www.doh.wa.gov/Portals/1/Documents/1600/coronavirus/...
- ggy5567 5y agoI certainly hope so, but the numbers (how great the benefit is) keep getting lower. And your stats are just per population. Maybe the people who refuse to get vaccinated are also 2-3x as likely to refuse to wear masks or avoid crowds. We need real stats somehow by randomly testing populations then seeing how they fare.
- maskil 5y agoData from Australia, Israel, Denmark, all highly vaccinated countries, show a very different picture, and yes, even on a per Capita basis
- kmonad 5y agoI think the hospital capacity is a key argument indeed. But there is another aspect to consider. Each viral replication is a potential event where a new variant can arise, thus the fewer viral replications the better since each new variant has unknown risks. An unvaccinated person will on average be host to many more viral replications after exposure to the virus than a vaccinated person after exposure. Thus, if a large part of the population remains unvaccinated, the virus has more room room to evolve than necessary given we have easy access to effective and safe vaccines. Therefore, this should also factor into a debate around vaccination policies and personal choice vs societal risk.
- mikem170 5y ago> Thus, if a large part of the population remains unvaccinated, the virus has more room room to evolve than necessary given we have easy access to effective and safe vaccines. Word was that Omicron diverged from an earlier version of covid in mice, over the course of about a year, then jumped into humans [0]. I think this detracts quite a bit from the point you were trying to make above, since we are not vaccinating mice, nor all the other animals that harbor covid such as bats, cats, dogs, primates, and deer [1]. Since we can't vaccinate or destroy all of the non-human hosts for this coronavirus, and the virus already has evolved in animals and made the jump to humans a couple of times, I don't agree that the point you made above is relevant. [0] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/covid-19-did-omicron-evolve-in-mice https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/covid-19-did-omicr... [1] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/animals.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/...
- kmonad 5y agoInteresting. Indeed animal hosts could be problem. I would counter two points: 1) Assuming animals were a major source of variants, it quantitatively but not qualitatively changes the problem. Until we know the quantities, I do not see how you can assert relevance. 2) The references you provide say Omicron came most likely from a human with prolonged infection. The paper proposing a intermediate variant in mice is interesting, but considered unlikely (your reference: "Evolutionary biologist Mike Worobey, Ph.D., of the University of Arizona in Tucson, said the most plausible theory remained that Omicron evolved in an immune-compromised patient with a protracted [SARS-CoV-2] infection.") Viral replications are the only scenario where variants can emerge naturally. Duration of disease and severity of disease are correlated with load and total viral replications. Vaccination reduces both at the population level. A vaccinated person therefore will on average be a less likely source of a variant. How much this weighs against other factors when deciding on policy is impossible for me say, but I would insist it is not irrelevant based upon current knowledge.
- cletus 5y agoI agree. My sense is the government has silently taken this stance and that hospitals aren't at risk of collapse like they were a year or more ago. I also get the feeling the vaccinated have given up on the unvaccinated too just based on how rarely I now see posts on social media. It's like a tacit acceptance that if people are going to choose to die, so be it. I actually wonder if this not caring is what will actually defuse this particular anti-vaxx movement. Or it'll just be the next vaccine and the Covid vaccine issues will be completely forgotten. I mean when was the last time you heard about vaccines causing autism? what's interesting here is the underlying psychology that makes people susceptible to manipulation by thinking they're in the know on some Big Lie. This seems to be nothing new however and I can't help but think of this quote from Goebbels of all people [1]: > “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.” [1]: https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/joseph-goebbels-on-the-quot-big-lie-quot https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/joseph-goebbels-on-the-...
- roenxi 5y agoI've never heard a convincing argument about why the COVID restrictions weren't literal violations of human rights. Often I got a variant of "I'm scared we're just going to do it". Most (all?) of the arguments for it turned out to be wrong - eg, vaccination has not slowed the spread, even marginally, according to the experience in Australia where COVID tore through a highly vaccinated population. In my state (~95% adults 12+ vaccinated) we have had more than a million cases (population 8 million) in 1.5 months. And the testing systems collapsed, probably quite a bit more in reality. This is now taking it one step further - this argument is as an assumption - suggesting people have to give up their freedoms because people paying for their own hospital capacity is unacceptable to you. I say that because the sort of person who is pro-freedom to the point of not wanting a vaccine might well overlap with the population of people pro-freedom enough that they want individuals to pay for their own healthcare. This is not a sustainable position against 2019 business-as-usual. I agree with the headline.
- i386 5y agoI’m Australian. Vaccination and restrictions were why we never saw refrigerated containers of dead people on street corners, like NYC did in the first wave. Many people would have died or needed to be hospitalized.
- nsxwolf 5y agoYou are proportionately about as bad as the United States is in deaths right now.
- bsder 5y agoCite your data. Start here: https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/ https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/ Showing new deaths per day with 1 week averaging normalized by population, the US is about 2-3x Australia right now. As for new confirmed cases per day normalized by population, everybody is about the same because Omicron is so infectious. I suspect the US number is a bit undercounted because the number of cases spiked so fast that confirmed cases simply couldn't keep up.
- nu11ptr 5y agoApologies in advance for getting on my soapbox, but this has been on my mind for a while. The way in which the media has gotten everyone to say "the unvaccinated" is a 'disease' against basic science (not even getting into the divisive nature of this). I would go as far as saying if you read any paper, study, or other that refers to the "unvaccinated" as a single cohort, you are reading vaccine propaganda, not science, or certainly not good science. This must stop. Prior infection immunity is basic science that we've known for eons, and ignoring it is so blatantly glaring an omission, it should make the most staunch pro-vaccine person pause and say: "why are they so adamant to vaccinate those with prior infection?". One would expect prior infection to be robust, and multiple studies, including even the CDC's most recent shows it to be easily as good if not better and longer lasting than the vaccine. This should not come as a surprise to anyone. If you think any of the above is "anti-vax" then I would suggest the media has won and science is dead. I'm not suggesting the vaccine doesn't work. I'm not suggesting it doesn't provide protection against severe disease and death. I'm not suggesting anyone go out and intentionally try to get COVID, but a HUGE # of people have already had it and ignoring them is downright unscientific. If you are a rational person who wants to see good science and are unemotional and detached from outcomes, then you will want to see proper study cohorts, and combining prior infection in with the "unvaccinated" cohort, is just bad science. This bad science fuels the anti-vaxx movement even more, and honestly, it is hard blame them.
- maxerickson 5y agoIt's a lot harder to accurately determine if someone has convalescent immunity than it is to just give them a couple shots. And then immunity is not a binary or linear response. Vaccination can still boost immunity in the case that someone has recovered from infection.
- ChrisClark 5y agoBecause the vaccine protects so much better than just a previous infection. We've been over this, over, and over. But you just won't accept the numbers now will you?
- ravar 5y ago
- throwaway098567 5y agoEthically I think it’s the people who cannot get vaccinated through no choice of their own that need to guide policy. If we can protect these people, and there was a fair amount of hospital capacity, I’d be all in on letting the anti-vaxxers just get it. I live in a country with health care. So I’d even be in favour of charging the anti-vaxxers the cost of care. Give the nurses the extra money.
- ezoe 5y agoBy the same logic, just leave the thief and murderer as is because it is very unlikely any education will change their mind.
- nradov 5y agoAntibodies are only one aspect of immunity and they tend to decline over time. Over the long run cellular immunity is more important. https://peterattiamd.com/covid-part2/ https://peterattiamd.com/covid-part2/
- Consultant32452 5y agoHospitals are overwhelmed by people who are vaccinated, have mild or even asymptomatic covid, and are certain they are going to die. https://www.wcax.com/2021/12/22/covid-positive-vermonters-with-no-symptoms-clog-up-ers/ https://www.wcax.com/2021/12/22/covid-positive-vermonters-wi... I'm sure there's plenty of actual sick people too. But we need a serious change to our messaging.
- baq 5y ago> it is very unlikely that any evidence or logical arguments will chance their minds Disagree. Anecdotally a relative dying of Covid traumatizes some (not all) just enough to start questioning their beliefs and get the jab.
- rcpt 5y ago> With COVID becoming endemic everyone is going to get antibodies, with the only choice being whether you get your first antibodies by vaccination or by getting COVID. That's not what endemic means.
- innocentoldguy 5y agoYou're not going to get COVID antibodies via the vaccines. You would with other vaccines (e.g., polio, measles, etc.), where they inject the actual disease into your body in order to trigger your body's natural immune response, but the mRNA vaccines don't work that way. The only way to get COVID-19 antibodies currently is to get the disease. I'm not vaccinated and it is by choice because I've already had COVID. Getting a vaccine for a disease you've already had is like wearing two pairs of pants. Sure, you can do it, but why?
- reaperducer 5y agoI'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions. I don't think you're breaking any new ground here. In the two regions where I've lived since the outbreak, hospital capacity was already a factor in what precautions were mandated. But the spread of disease is a lot more complicated than sick/not sick. It has an affect on society much farther and wider than hospital capacity, and that should not be the sold yardstick by which we measure our reaction.
- john_moscow 5y agoExcept, the hospital capacity per 1000 population has been steadily declining in the West for ages [0] and is at half the capacity in China for comparison. So rather than blaming the unvaccinated, we should maybe review the policies that lead to it. [0] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.MED.BEDS.ZS?locations=CA-US-CN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.MED.BEDS.ZS?location...
- jupp0r 5y agoMy guess is you don't have children under 5 who can't be vaccinated right now. Yes, there is a low chance of complications, but it's still the most deadly infectious disease for that age group [1] and I'd rather have my kids obtain antibodies through vaccination than disease. [1] https://twitter.com/GYamey/status/1455708642297188354 https://twitter.com/GYamey/status/1455708642297188354
- ls15 5y ago> The only question really then is how fast do we want the unvaccinated to do the getting antibodies by getting COVID thing. I think the question that so many people forget is how fast the unvaccinated themselves want to get antibodies, not how fast someone else wants to get them antibodies. > I'd say the answer to that should be determined by the hospital capacity. If a region has sufficient hospital capacity that it would not be overwhelmed by the increase in COVID cases among the unvaccinated go ahead and lift most restrictions. Im my country, Germany, that currently is debating mandatory vaccinations for everyone, the maximum average share of Covid patients was 5% at the top of the most deadly Covid wave. 95% of patients were in for other reasons. https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/fileadmin/Dateien/3_Downloads/C/Coronavirus/Analyse_Leistungen_Ausgleichszahlungen_2020_Corona-Krise.pdf https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/fileadmin/Dateie... > Gemessen an der vorhandenen Bettenkapazität ergibt sich eine durchschnittliche Belegungsquote von 1,3% durch COVID-19. Die höchsten tagesbezogenen Belegungsquoten gab es in der zweiten Dezemberhälfte mit knapp 5% aller Betten. I don't want to have to undergo medical procedures, just for optimizing a statistic by a very small percentage (for two weeks in a year) that could have been optimized in other ways. Some pointless covid intervations at national level have burned so much money that nations could have built thousands of new hospitals instead.
- HWR_14 5y ago> (2) it is very unlikely that any evidence or logical arguments will chance their minds. While this is true, we've seen that employer mandates actually do change their minds. Yes, something like 1-2% of people don't get vaccinated even in that case, but that's far less than the 20% that claim they will lose their jobs to not get vaccinated.
- fithisux 5y agoNice fairytale but you should see more television. People who decided to not get the jab have been hunted like animals. And people that got the jab got really sick or died and infected others. Also there were effective medications for covid but people were misled to believe that they did not work, people died and were terrorized to get vaccinated. This is a crime. Unless you enjoy it.