24 ms·
Nvidia prepares to abandon $40B Arm bid
- theonlybutlet 5y agoInsider trading much?
- MangoCoffee 5y agoChina for one won't approve the deal. China is feeling the squeezes of tech cut off. only 3 companies is allowed to make x86. RISC-V is not there yet. the only option left is ARM. huawei's hisilicon was designing top notch ARM cpu for huawei's phone. ARM is just too important for China.
- scrubs 5y agoSince when do I care what China thinks? Frankly, it wouldn't kill for global trade (where the west is concerned) to swing back 15-20 deg to more autonomy. To zero? Madness; just a correction. The salad years of buying almost anything at Walmart, Tesco, Amazon for 15% less than what it'd cost from the west and taking that to the hoop as success are long gone. The low fruit is increasingly picked for them too. They can't do cheap labor 24/7/365 forever just like we can't do cheap prices for ever. Eventually we'll both need to rebalance price, jobs, security, and so on.
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>The salad years of buying almost anything at Walmart, Tesco, Amazon for 15% less than what it'd cost from the west and taking that to the hoop as success are long gone. Not according to the vast majority of consumers. Look what trouble far less than a 15% rise in costs due to inflation is doing to consumers. >They can't do cheap labor 24/7/365 forever The west cannot do expensive labor forever. It's dying faster than cheap labor.
- scrubs 5y ago>The salad years of buying almost anything at Walmart, Tesco, Amazon for 15% less than what it'd cost from the west and taking that to the hoop as success are long gone. Picking a current tangential issue and globbing it on to a needed global trade correction which has been in the making for the last 20 years is opportunistic. Inflation like this hasn't been seen in the US since the late 70s, for which there are many factors including Covid. >The west cannot do expensive labor forever. It's dying faster than cheap labor. US labor & regulation (where I am) is medium. Not stupidly high certainly not lowest. I think other places in the west find it harder here than us. Still I am not particularly pleased with US governmental institutional competence in the last 15 years. We are nowhere near our best, and sadly sucking in a few important areas. I would remind that outsourcing to China did not start the behest of a US politician taking a call from Joe Smoe manager who asked if he should outsource. The move east with consequent impact on labor and larger issues was done by US business people. Further examples are obvious, but let's not dismiss self interest either. Going back to my original point: I absolutely could not care less what the Chinese think on this particular issue. ARM isn't theirs anyway. China, whenever strategic dependency arises, wants their own lock-stock-and-barrel-stuff. MC/VISA will never be top there. And Intel/ARM/AMD/TSMC will never rule the roost there either. They will not be dependent on the west. So my question for the west: how much and how long are you gonna play a part in their goal? What are the limits? How do we know when enough is enough?
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>Picking a current tangential issue and globbing it on to a needed global trade correction which has been in the making for the last 20 years is opportunistic What you call opportunistic to make it less relevant I call illustrative of what a 15% rise in costs or prices means in reality. Can you show me a place where such a large class of items went up in price that was not catastrophic? Yet you think it will be some golden return to rose colored yesteryear. >US labor & regulation (where I am) is medium. Not stupidly high certainly not lowest. I'm in the US also. US wages are among the highest few countries out of around 200 countries over the world. They're among the highest in the OECD. I'd hardly call that medium. Those countries with a higher average or median wage are barely above the US, so I'd think it's safe to say US wages are just about the highest in the world. Why does an unskilled worker here make more than around 90% of the world population? Because he so amazing? Or because we have extraordinarily high labor costs? That unskilled work wage is not going to last, no matter how you slice it. Blaming China has pretty much zero to do with it - most low end jobs lost went to automation, and trying to make goods cost 15% more will only add pressure to automate more.
- Dah00n 5y ago>They can't do cheap labor 24/7/365 forever Yes and no. China can't, no, but history tells us exactly what will happen. Japan used to be the "cheap and crappy electronics maker". At some point the population has been lifted enough that some other poor country will take over the bottom jobs. Likely somewhere in Africa. It is not as if China at some point will start to fall back to where it once were and even if it did all it would do would be to hold the production in China instead of the next country. >Eventually we'll both need to rebalance price, jobs, security, and so on. That will never happen.
- scrubs 5y ago>It is not as if China at some point will start to fall back I never said they were. Also babysitting Chinese outcomes is another not-my-problem. There's a whole invasive inflexible CCP state control thing going on there who, by the way, claim it as their problem. It's also not a feature for China to fall back to some pre-Deng era. Knowing what I care and don't care about it is not equivalent to hoping China fails. Certainly not. Maybe China will rock and roll. Maybe they fall in disinflation like Japan did starting somewhere around the 1990s, from which I'm not sure they recovered. I am saying the west has got to do a better job at realizing what the end game is for China in some important areas. And know what our concerns are, and do a better job at holding the line. Here, in the US, "show me the discount! show me the cheap!" cannot be the last thing heard. >Eventually we'll both need to rebalance price, jobs, security, and so on. Good! I love it when people lay down a hard line. Hard lines are easy to bust.
- monocasa 5y ago> They can't do cheap labor 24/7/365 forever They're already adjusting their economy. The cheap labor is now found in the rest of SE Asia with east Africa viewed as growth potential for cheap labor by the Chinese.
- fomine3 5y agoThere are also original HPC chips. https://www.hpcwire.com/2021/11/24/three-chinese-exascale-systems-detailed-at-sc21-two-operational-and-one-delayed/ https://www.hpcwire.com/2021/11/24/three-chinese-exascale-sy...
- vassilevsky 5y agoShit, I was hoping so hard on a gaming SoC that would put Intel out of PC gaming already ;(((
- tester756 5y agois this state slowing technological advancement or actually state protecting it?
- no_time 5y agoadvancement for the sake of advancement is not something to celebrate. I can't imagine a situation where more consolidation in this space is something beneficial for anyone except the company doing the acquisition.
- tester756 5y agothat's good point, naive of me.
- dogma1138 5y agoProbably a mixture of both, I think NVIDIA had a chance to push ARM to new heights it would also have forced them to be far more open. Longer term the market might be in a better position with a public ARM. I think a lot of the concerns around NVIDIA were driven by hyperbolic statements and memes. ARM is a good example of a monumental success and relative failure as in their cores and their architecture is in everything but they never have been able to capitalize on their success at the same scale at least as far as it goes for converting it into revenue which sits only at around $2B per year. NVIDIA on the other hand has mastered capitalizing on every success no matter how small it is. Overall as acquisitions go on paper it was a good match. It would’ve given ARM access to a lot of capital, engineering resources and a driven management with a strategic vision. NVIDIA would’ve gotten the ability to set the path for one of the most commonly used CPU architecture and being able to offer a completely vertically integrated solution to both enterprise and end consumers. Arguably NVIDIA could achieve the latter on its own too at least by licensing ARM I do think it’s a shame that they don’t have an x86 license too. ARM on the other hand would need to undergo a massive change to get into the position they arguably deserve to be in.
- trasz 5y ago>they never have been able to capitalize on their success As in, they failed to destroy the company for short term gains, like companies usually do.
- pseudolus 5y agoLink to the Bloomberg source story with more details: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-25/nvidia-is-said-to-quietly-prepare-to-abandon-takeover-of-arm https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-25/nvidia-is...
- justinclift 5y agoWonder if this means Nvidia will jump on the RISC-V bandwagon instead?
- dannyw 5y agoNo chance. Nvidia will invent their own proprietary standard.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- msk-lywenn 5y agoLooks like they are already using RISC-V: https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Tue1345pm-NVIDIA-Sijstermans.pdf https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Tue1345pm-NVIDI...
- amelius 5y agoInteresting to see that slide (8) about embracing open source. Would it go both ways?
- kelnos 5y agoI would doubt it. They already use both ARM and RISC-V in their products, why would they invent a new ISA? That's not a trivial thing to do, and it doesn't seem worth their time.
- stabbles 5y agoWhat will this mean for NVIDIA's Arm based Grace CPU?
- jonwinstanley 5y agoThe licensing deal is most likely completely separate, but agree that it adds some uncertainty to the relationship
- d3mon 5y agoNothing. They will continue developing their own CPUs. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/330671-nvidia-announces-new-cpu-rd-effort-in-israel https://www.extremetech.com/computing/330671-nvidia-announce...
- JiNCMG 5y agoNothing. NVidia still has it's ARM license and as long as they are kept out of the x86 chip business (thanks to Intel and AMD) they are happy to renew the license with ARM.
- d3mon 5y agoPlenty of headwinds for Nvidia have emerged recently: -Declining crypto -Dead arm acquisition -Increasingly competitive amd /Intel GPUs (both integrated and discrete) -Rising tsmc wafer prices
- trollied 5y agoI couldn't help but read your -D and -I things as compiler flags....
- sgerenser 5y ago-DACQUIRE_ARM=0
- throw_m239339 5y agoLOL me too, maven CLI arguments...
- marcosdumay 5y agoYeah, and the unescaped spaces really destroyed it.
- terafo 5y agoAMD is increasingly competitive, but still doesn't have good software compatibility outside of gaming. GPUs are not the priority for them. They basically make 10 times less cards and aren't going to make more. Which is sad since we need more competition. Rising TSMC prices aren't as big of a deal for them since they are mostly on samsung right now. I wouldn't say that things are so bad for Nvidia. They are selling more cards than ever, their "Ultimate Play" to rise the prices across the board will, most likely, be successful in the long run. Sub 200 dollars segment is dead, like sub 100 before it. Since they are going to make monstrous MCM GPUs, the price for an absolute high end is going to rise to unseen heights(performance will rise with them). I hope Intel will stop this madness eventually, but they won't be able to do it fast, even if they try as hard as they can.
- ColinWright 5y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30070289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30070289 Comments both there and here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- d3mon 5y agoRelated : NVIDIA setting up cpu R&D team in Israel https://www.extremetech.com/computing/330671-nvidia-announces-new-cpu-rd-effort-in-israel https://www.extremetech.com/computing/330671-nvidia-announce...
- eatbitseveryday 5y agoJust like Intel has it
- irthomasthomas 5y agoMay be related to Arm China going rogue? [0] It is starting to look like Britain's sale of Arm was a good deal after all. Foisted! [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28329731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28329731
- zinekeller 5y agoNo, that didn't deter Nvidia, it's mainly with EU, UK and American regulatory pressures (which might formally stop the acquisition). Additionally, some civil servants within the UK government have said that the ministers are considering to declare Arm as a critical company (and considering the "partygate" has made the Johnson government more populist, it's becoming more likely that pro-Britain moves will be made, at least as perceived by voters).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nivenkos 5y agoBut ARM was already sold to SoftBank (Japanese). It's not like it's still Acorn producing British microcomputers...
- Traster 5y agoYes, this was the insanity, they waved through selling it to Softbank, but then cottoned on to how important it was once they realised it was going to be acquired by Nvidia. They shouldn't have let it sell in the first place, but atleast they're fixing that now, and if they can guide it towards an IPO that would be a very good result.
- chasil 5y agoAs a public company, shareholders with enough stock can offer competing slates of directors. Even with an acquisition blocked, if Nvidia is in that position, they can dictate ARM's policies. Perhaps the UK would force them to divest, but a coalition of shareholders might be more difficult to stop.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoI don't think it's a neither a good nor bad news, actual owner -Softbank- is not the best for ARM, but also ARM-AMD could make almost a monopoly in the GPU market.
- Dah00n 5y agoIn the GPU market? I doubt Nvidia sees it that way with its current share of 83%
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cpncrunch 5y agoNon paywall version?
- yrro 5y agoRelevant parts: > Nvidia Corp. is quietly preparing to abandon its purchase of Arm Ltd. from SoftBank Group Corp. after making little to no progress in winning approval for the $40 billion chip deal, according to people familiar with the matter. > Nvidia has told partners that it doesn’t expect the transaction to close, according to one person, who asked not to be identified because the discussions are private. SoftBank, meanwhile, is stepping up preparations for an Arm initial public offering as an alternative to the Nvidia takeover, another person said. > The U.S. Federal Trade Commission sued to stop the transaction in December, arguing that Nvidia would become too powerful if it gained control over Arm’s chip designs. > The acquisition also faces resistance in China, where authorities are inclined to block the takeover if it wins approvals elsewhere, according to one person. But they don’t expect it to get that far. > Both Nvidia and Arm’s leadership are still pleading their case to regulators, according to the people, and no final decisions have been made.
- metahost 5y agoHere you go: https://archive.fo/NEg6u https://archive.fo/NEg6u
- lewisjoe 5y agoQuick summary on why it matters that Nvidia abandons ARM takeover: 1. ARM doesn't own any factories. Its entire workforce publishes blueprints for making chips (like a software company where the entire asset is intellectual) 2. Buying this type of intellectual asset, means owning and controlling a technology. 3. This also means, all the other customers who depend on this tech (Apple, Samsung, Amazon, pretty much all big tech companies) are now at a disadvantage with NVIDIA as a competitor. 4. China heavily depends on ARM (Huawei, the company's biggest tech manufacturer rely on ARM) 5. This means, the after ARM gets owned by a US company, the US can possibly just cut-off ARM supply to China 6. Since ARM is basically like a software company, it's better to not be owned by a hardware maker. That way, it can prioritize demand from several hardware makers instead of being directed to cater to one market) So, all-in-all this is a good thing :)
- UncleOxidant 5y agoWhy don't the ARM users form a consortium to own ARM?
- ginko 5y agoQualcomm did suggest that: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/14/qualcomm-offers-to-invest-in-arm-as-regulators-threaten-nvidia-deal.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/14/qualcomm-offers-to-invest-in...
- londons_explore 5y ago> This means, the after ARM gets owned by a US company, the US can possibly just cut-off ARM supply to China But IP is very hard to control the supply of, especially one like this where hundreds of companies have a copy of the IP. If the US won't license it on fair terms, China will just stop enforcing IP laws and allow anyone to copy it for free.
- criley2 5y agoWith all due respect to China, licensing on fair terms has never been a requirement for state-sponsored intellectual property theft.
- londons_explore 5y agoWith an increasing number of countries worldwide using their powers to prevent the sale or merger of companies, will we see a devaluation of these companies? After all, owning something is only of value if you can sell it, and if you can only sell with permission from 10+ country governments, all of whom can say no for strategic reasons, then it isn't such a great purchase.
- neolefty 5y agoGood point from a global view. I'd like to see a little more international cooperation, leading towards a global standard, but we have many hurdles between here and there, especially involving trust between nations.
- anotherman554 5y agoOwning a company is traditionally thought to be of value because you get a stream of dividend income from the profits the company earns, not because you can sell the company.
- paulmd 5y agowhat? no. assets/IP have always been highly valued and certainly not on the sole basis of their cost-to-replicate. (and if you can't sell assets, that's the only valid metric for valuation - "I need that thing and would have built it anyway". Even if it's complimentary to your existing business - the BATNA is "build it myself".) extremely controversial (if not outright incorrect) statement to be labeling as "traditional wisdom". Says who?Probably not any economics textbook written in the last century.
- anotherman554 5y agoYou are confused or may not have been paying attention to the context of the post you replied to. We're talking about the value of a publicly traded company, Nvidia. We aren't talking about the value of the Mona Lisa, or an NFT of a dancing monkey or even a Bitcoin. I didn't write anything controversial and you don't need to consult an economics textbook, a basic Investopedia article will do: From Investopedia: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/fundamental-analysis/11/choosing-valuation-methods.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/fundamental-analysis/1... "The dividend discount model (DDM) is one of the most basic of the absolute valuation models. The dividend discount model calculates the "true" value of a firm based on the dividends the company pays its shareholders." An alternative model if there is no dividends: "the Discounted Cash Flow model uses a firm's discounted future cash flows to value the business. " The ability of a firm to sell itself to a foreign firm is not a factor is valuing the firm. I wouldn't use these models to value a Pikachu trading card, but this is stock market 101 type stuff.
- klelatti 5y agoOnly two weeks ago SoftBank / Arm / Nvidia made a submission to the UK competition authorities with a singularly pessimistic view of Arm’s prospects as a stand-alone company [1]. I wonder if this was wise given the where the deal seems to be now. Whilst this is a bit overdone, it does highlight the challenges that Arm faces. If the Nvidia deal is dead - which seems likely - then floating clearly seems unlikely to offer the prospect of the return that SoftBank was expecting when it paid a premium for Arm. The key question from an Arm user / customer’s perspective seems to be ‘Can Arm as a stand-alone company finance the investment it meets to stay competitive?’ [1] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/61d81a458fa8f505953f4ed7/NVIDIA-Arm_-_CMA_Initial_Submission_-_NCV_for_publication__Revised_23_December_2021_.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/61d81a458fa8f...
- varelse 5y agoLikely Qualcomm bales them out as they have offered to do so and eventually takes them over quietly by osmosis so no one notices until the deal is done. https://www.barrons.com/articles/qualcomm-offers-to-rescue-arm-if-regulators-block-nvidias-40-billion-bid-51623704676 https://www.barrons.com/articles/qualcomm-offers-to-rescue-a...
- 310260 5y agoFrom that document: > As Arm’s CEO, Simon Segars, explained: “We contemplated an IPO but determined > that the pressure to deliver short-term revenue growth and profitability would > suffocate our ability to invest, expand, move fast and innovate.” It sounds like Arm needs a change in leadership to me. Find the capital for long-term investment somewhere and follow a path to improvement like AMD did. Yes, there is pressure to deliver short term profit as there always is today. However, that's not a strategy that works for a company like Arm. Everyone around the world can see the value in what Arm produces. Find someone to invest who isn't a hedge fund manager and still sees that value.
- michelb 5y agoDoesn't Softbank need their money back? ARM most likely has to IPO whether they like it or not, right?
- syadegari 5y agoDoes anyone know why they decided to go for buying Arm in the first place? If they needed tight integration with their GPUs and wanted to move away from x-86, can't they come up with Arm-based solutions like Apple did?
- bayindirh 5y agonVidia is trying to become a full-stack company. They have GPUs. Got network capabilities with Mellanox. Add ARM knowledge on top and you have a complete platform building capability. TL;DR: nVidia just wants to dominate the whole stack. Like Apple, but for data center / scientific / AI / HPC, etc.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI am an NVIDIA employee in a niche of the HPC business. This is not an NVIDIA official opinion. HPC is nice, but when you hear Jensen getting really excited, it’s not about dominating some niche like that, it’s about a vision of the shiny sci-fi high tech future, and actually delivering the tech to make it real. So don’t just look at HPC to understand the NVIDIA ambition. Start at edge computing; imagine a world with ubiquitous autonomous robots (cars and drones and otherwise). Think of the onboard chips driving their vision and speech recognition models: That’s a great place for ARM and NVIDIA chips together, whether as one company or two. Watch a recent keynote and see how all the rest of the tech fits into place as part of that: 5G signal processing chips, for instance, something you might gloss over if you’re not in telecom. You don’t need a roadmap to see how it is all connected in support of this world of the future. (I certainly don’t have the roadmap, either, I just watch the keynotes and help shuffle bits.)
- Atreiden 5y ago> Start at edge computing; It seems pretty clear that this what they're thinking of. They want to be able to license an integrated architecture that includes power-efficient computing and a powerful ML engine. They've been so heavily investing in this space for a reason. What I can't figure out is why this is such a big deal to regulators. Nvidia doesn't manufacturer these things (aside from Jetson I believe? Not 100% clear on this). They license IP. And this is IP that I think the world would really like to have. Currently the only player in this space is Apple. They've built their own integrated silicon with their perpetual ARM license that is now giving them a huge market advantage, and will continue to do so until there is another competitor. The R&D required to compete with a cash-liquid >2.5 Trillion dollar company is just not feasible for any of the other major players at present. Nvidia/ARM opens doors for tons of other companies. I also think it's foolish to think that Apple won't try to expand this tech offering well beyond personal computers and tablets. They will expand to IoT/Edge devices and services. But the difference is they won't be licensing their IP to other manufacturers, they will be building it themselves (or contracting Foxconn to) and keeping everything in their walled garden. Guess I'm just frustrated that of all ridiculous acquisitions and anticompetitive nonsense I've seen in the past decade, THIS is the one getting smothered.
- gigatexal 5y agoHuzzah! Good. Keep ARM free to sell its IP to all.
- bibinou 5y agoDoes Apple still rely on ARM?
- fredoralive 5y agoApple's chips implement ARM ISAs, although Apple creates their own implementations rather than licence ARM's own core designs. How much this affects them depends on the licensing agreements between ARM and Apple, which only they know about, although Apple apparently have a favourable deal. They didn't publicly seem phased by the idea of Nvidia owning ARM, anyway.
- mdasen 5y agoThe ARM deal would have impacted all other ARM licensees a lot more than Apple. As you note, Apple is making custom cores so they don't need ARM's reference designs. For example, Google's Tensor processor in the Pixel 6 uses ARM Cortex-X1, Cortex-A76, and Cortex-A55 cores and ARM's Mali GPU. They add some ML cores to the design, but the CPU/GPU is really designed by ARM. Apple, on the other hand, makes its own internally designed cores for its processors rather than using ARM's designs. While you're right that the general public doesn't know ARM/Apple's deal, we do know that ARM offers a perpetual ISA license. Even if Nvidia bought ARM, Apple could still make current ISA processors forever (it seems unrealistic to think they don't have a perpetual license). While Nvidia might not want to help Apple, it would be in Nvidia's interest to offer new ISAs to Apple at reasonable rates because a) one probably doesn't need updates to the ARM ISA at this point b) Apple not getting on board with a new ISA could impact the rest of the industry getting on board with it given that Apple is so large (and respected) c) Apple puts a lot of time and money into LLVM and having them against an update to the ARM ISA would (at the very least) mean that there wasn't free labor (from Nvidia's perspective) adding compiler support for the ISA update. It's true that we don't know all the details about deals between Apple and ARM, but at this point it seems like Apple doesn't really need ARM. Samsung, Google, Amazon, and others use ARM's reference designs. If ARM disappeared, they wouldn't get updated cores and would have to build up in-house design teams. If ARM disappeared, Apple would just keep on making new designs. I think Qualcomm is looking to go more custom in the future as they bought Nuvia and are looking to make inroads into things like laptops over the next few years. In some ways, it seems like ARM getting bought by Nvidia would be good for Apple. If Nvidia becomes really harsh for third-party licensees, it could mean a few years where the costs skyrocket in the Android ecosystem while their costs remain the same. Even after that, it might lower the number of manufacturers for ARM processors. Would MediaTek spin up a custom-design shop? Would Samsung? Maybe, but it would add a lot of cost over re-using reference designs. Apple isn't really reliant on ARM for anything at this point. The rest of the industry is pretty reliant on ARM's reference designs. If Nvidia ownership meant that those reference designs went up in cost or if Nvidia wanted its best work to go into Nvidia processors and put out weak updates, that would benefit Apple with Android manufacturers scrambling to figure out what to do: buy expensive Nvidia processors, ship weaker updates, invest in the custom-core route?
- TradingPlaces 5y agoThis was never going to happen. US, UK, China and EU all have regulatory leverage, and they were about to go 0-4
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt’s a bigger story for SoftBank than it is for NVIDIA. NVIDIA can do OK without ARM, but for SoftBank it was a way to be able to pay redemptions for the failing Vision Fund. Back in the day a Japanese businessman who screwed up the way Son did would find a knife in their room and know what they were supposed to do with it. The ARM deal took the pressure off but it is back on again.
- sealeck 5y agoI really don't think suggesting that Son should commit ritual suicide is an appropriate comment to make.
- nixass 5y agoNow Microsoft and Activision-Blizzard
- johnebgd 5y agoDoing what they always do, stealing without repercussions from innovators around the world.
- Nokinside 5y agoYou are correct, but I dislike the tone that what they do is "typically Chinese" or what Chinese do. * When Chinese were ahead, European stole and smuggled manufacturing technologies from China. * Industrial revolution in the United States was started by ruthlessly stealing the British innovations. Samuel Slater -- the "Father of the American Industrial Revolution" -- is known as "Slater the Traitor" in Britain. * Japanese stole and copied every design and technology from the US and Europe they could from the start of Meiji era 1868- to 1960s. Piracy is not a theft in a sense that it's just illegal, not fundamentally immoral. I think it's actually cool historical constant that moves the world ahead.
- rscho 5y agoChina never was ahead.
- patrickk 5y agoChinese price dumping from state-sponsored companies also largely wiped out the German solar PV industry[1,2]. Germany was an early innovator in solar, especially in regards to inventing the concept of a feed in tariff when solar PV was still hideously expensive, thereby driving wider adoption. Planet Money did a nice podcast on the history of it [3]. [1] https://www.dw.com/en/chinese-exports-crushing-german-solar-industry/a-16031596 https://www.dw.com/en/chinese-exports-crushing-german-solar-... [2] https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/last-major-german-solar-cell-maker-surrenders-chinese-competition https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/last-major-german-solar... [3] https://www.npr.org/2020/01/17/797322305/episode-965-das-green-old-deal https://www.npr.org/2020/01/17/797322305/episode-965-das-gre...
- Dah00n 5y ago>state-sponsored companies Your comment reads as if there's something wrong with state-sponsored companies but there really aren't and everyone does this including the US and Germany. How they do it might differ but the end result is the same. Directly, tax cuts, giving foreign aid that have strings attached like the US does with almost all its "aid" ("we give you $XXX million and you agree to use it to buy from US defense contractors A, B and C" isn't aid - it is state-sponsoring of companies). It is only seen as a problem in the West when done by a country like PRC and it hurts a company in a country like the US or Germany - never the other way around. I don't know what to call it but it smells like a mix of nationalism and racism.
- paulus_magnus2 5y agoThe regulators should never approve such a takeover or should state that this takeover will inevitably result in a forcaful split of NVIDIA. There will be a conflicf of interest between Nvidia a consumer of ARM and Nvidia provider of IP to competitors (Samsung, Qualcom, Apple, AMD). Nvidia should play ball (or somehow the regulators should nudge them to play ball ) and invite all big ARM customers to form a co-op.
- captainbland 5y agoNvidia would be amongst the worst possible custodians of ARM. Their business models are quite strongly opposing: ARM's is to create a fair, competitive playing field between CPU producing companies and reap licensing fees for the pleasure, Nvidia's is to nakedly leverage all of its technologies for Nvidia's products' benefit and Nvidia's products' benefit only.
- tombert 5y agoWhile I too was against the NVidia+Arm merger, and am glad it's being abandoned, a large part of me feels like they wouldn't do it just because it could be an antitrust nightmare, with Apple and Qualcomm and LG all suing because of anti-competitive practices, and probably winning. I'm not a lawyer, but that seems like a likely scenario from the very little I understand about US law. I don't think NVidia would be quite that stupid; I think if they were smart they would keep ARM business as usual just to avoid that, and just reap the licensing fees from the above companies.
- WheatM 5y ago
- naruvimama 5y agoMicrosoft used to be in the same place, they started growing once they opened up. Instead of rent seeking. VLSI is hard, but with massive investments in fabs and design across the board, Nvidia will be forced to go the MS way. Nvidia licensing their GPU to ARMs customers will itself be a big start.
- froggertoaster 5y agoI love that this would make Nvidia too powerful. Uh, exactly what have Google and Microsoft been up to? I'd say they're "too powerful" at this point...
- mrtri 5y ago
- realmsalah 5y agoNice
- 01100011 5y agoI wonder how the average ARM employee feels about this. Are they losing out on a windfall from their labors because the deal fell through? I wonder if that will affect retention?
- interator7 5y agoIt always blew my mind that Arm is worth that much solely licensing intellectual property. Wouldn't it be more cost efficient for some of their biggest customers to simply hire engineers who can produce similar output? Can someone give me insight into their design team?(size, history, experience, etc.)
- Aissen 5y agoDesigning a CPU is easy. Very easy, any grad student can do it. So why is Arm worth so much ? Because it's only part of the problem. If Arm is so successful, it's (IMHO) because of software. Sure, they have world-class CPU designers. But in order to launch a new CPU, you need a full software ecosystem, as RISC V startups are discovering. One other advantage of Arm is that it has strong anti-fragmentation measures in place. With enough money you can design your own cores, but in order to deviate from standard Arm architecture, you need Arm's signoff. This serves the first advantage: it keeps the software ecosystem value intact.
- smoldesu 5y ago> But in order to launch a new CPU, you need a full software ecosystem, as RISC V startups are discovering. You should have seen the state Raspberry Pis were in circa-2011. Everyone online was treating it like the RISC-V of today, criticizing it for a complete lack of software and calling it a novelty board. Lo and behold, come 2018 everyone and their mother wanted a Raspberry Pi for some purpose. Sure, 70% of the software people wanted to use wasn't available, but the things it had were power efficient and performed just about on-par with it's x86 counterparts. RISC-V is between both of those stages right now, the biggest limiting factor is getting hardware into the hands of developers, which is starting to dissolve as manufacturers are catching on. > This serves the first advantage: it keeps the software ecosystem value intact. Why do people assume that adding an extension to your RISC-V processor throws the software ecosystem out the window? It's the exact same scenario as ARM, except you're not beholden to arbitrary version updates (eg. v6, v7, v8) that break compatibility. If you want to upgrade your ISA, you just... do. Your base instructions will still run fine, and software compiled for RISC-V will just run. The only way you could fragment like that is if your chip failed compliance tests, which... why would you even ship it then?
- intrasight 5y agoAs I never thought there was synergy here, I think Nvidia will do better without ARM. There is plenty of growth in their core domain.
- Symmetry 5y agoAs a NVidia shareholder I'm relieved at this. ARM is clearly less valuable as part of NVidia with all the conflicts of interest that entails than as an independent company. NVidia talked about synergies but they could pursue all of those with an architectural license for far less money. It's actually something of a pattern that most mergers fail to provide synergy and destroy value, it's just that they enlarge the empire of the CEO and so seem attractive from that standpoint.
- overview 5y agoCitrix and Wrike in a nutshell.
- skinnymuch 5y agoHaha what a funny acquisition. There’s no synergy there besides I assume weak attempts at bundling things.
- snvzz 5y agoARM gets the short end of the stick here. NVIDIA being a well known hostile company, the industry did not miss the news about its ARM purchase intent. And thus they looked for alternatives. That's RISC-V. Today, pretty much every company designing microcontrollers or SoCs is involved with RISC-V. They won't cancel those efforts to embrace ARM again.
- sho_hn 5y agoSad memories of Nokia. The N9 debuted to great reviews and was built on a promising tech stack that continues to outlive it today (Qt, etc.). Repeated takeover attempts and intent by Microsoft, and finally installing an ex-MS VP who cancelled the platform internally before an actual sale to Microsoft, was too much of a distraction. It's hard to survive a bodged takeover attempt, much less an actual takeover.
- raxxorrax 5y ago
- thedigitalone 5y agoPaywall, archive link here: https://archive.fo/vl5Or https://archive.fo/vl5Or
- phendrenad2 5y agoI never understood this deal. Nvidia can hire some CPU designers and make a RISC-V core and join a much more vibrant ecosystem. Why settle for ARM?
- Blammar 5y agoBird in the hand versus two in the bush, perhaps. ARM is proven, RISC-V isn't (do you know of a RISC-V chip that is competitive with Apple's M1 ARM-based chip?)
- awill 5y agoIt seems crazy to me that Blizzard/Activision is worth more than Arm. I get BA has tons of world-famous games, but almost every phone on earth is Arm. Arm is taking over laptops and servers too.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> almost every phone on earth is Arm. Arm is taking over laptops too. Is there a RISC-V analog to Blizzard/Activision?
- jdhawk 5y agoSiFive?
- Cyph0n 5y agoUbisoft?
- throwaway946513 5y agoIndie developers?
- mhh__ 5y agoIs there a RISC-V analog to ARM? They're simply not in the same league (yet).
- __s 5y agoI imagine Blizzard would be worth less if all their IP was licensed out to other large game studios with very liberal terms
- stefan_ 5y agoAnd everyone actually making competitive products was doing so because of their own extensions, not whatever Blizzard did.
- mrandish 5y agoYes, that's a big reason why the valuations are different. ARM's designs being so central to the products of so many companies has occurred only because of ARM's licensing terms being so liberal, including things like forward pricing caps, MFN clauses, etc. They basically chose to trade away pricing power (hence margin) for ubiquity and longer-term relationships.
- greatjack613 5y agoFor all those that need to get around the paywall. https://webreader.app/?url=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-25/nvidia-is-said-to-quietly-prepare-to-abandon-takeover-of-arm https://webreader.app/?url=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/ar...
- kunai 5y agoGod bless Lina Khan.
- indigodaddy 5y agoWould it be way too cynical to suggest that the reason that this deal was/is not likely to close, is because Intel is influentially and aggressively/successfully lobbying against this? How would smoothing out the current Intel/AMD machine not be healthy overall?
- dafty4 5y agoDid anyone expect a different outcome?
- sytelus 5y agoThese days, I don’t know if it makes sense at all to get sold out to anyone. Why not IPO? It’s a free never ending river of money that you can dip again and again. With proper voting structure, you retain full control and never fear dilution. Additionally, no dividends ever which means no worries about returning investor money or any real ROI. Over time, get included in one of the ETF index and you are set to unimaginable market caps. Selling out is for the losers, IMO.