19 ms·
Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising
- glandium 5y agoIn related news: https://fortune.com/2022/01/05/kazakhstan-internet-bitcoin-mining-mystery-crypto/ https://fortune.com/2022/01/05/kazakhstan-internet-bitcoin-m...
- LordJohn 5y agoI'm from Kazakhstan. Russia only protect military bases in KZ. I really don't understand why Olzhas Auyezov write this bullshit. Sorry for my English.
- sAbakumoff 5y agoI was born in Kazakhstan. In the 90s, after the USSR fell apart, we witnessed an incredible rise of nationalism that resulted in anti-Russian sentiment. So, like many other families, we escaped Kazakhstan in the late 90s. Now..The Russian army is sent to quell deadly unrest. If the Kazakhstan army joins protesters, it could end up with a full-scale war between Russian "invaders" and "patriots" driven by the same nationalism. PS. 2022 is gonna be fun(not).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- peakaboo 5y agoAfter covid I just accept we are living in hell. Everything about the systems we exist in is a joke. At the end of the day, just embrace the madness I guess.
- throwaway4good 5y agoNah. It is going to be fine.
- throwaway4good 5y agoSo what drives this conflict? As I understand the ousted government was nationalist yet it asked Russia for help?
- progre 5y agoLikely losing power means loss of fortunes, privilages and for some people even life, so they will do anything to stay in power.
- thejackgoode 5y agoTheir collective security treaty is… interesting. I wonder how Russian people would react if situation was opposite and Kazakh paratroopers landed in Kazan, for example. Calling civil unrest “foreign terrorism” is not new in history for sure, but not in the age of internet. What to say, no “end of history” in sight
- ilaksh 5y agoMaybe you can help me here. My reading of the situation is that it was an attempted revolution against a dictator after he made a devastating unilateral decision to raise prices for a critical fuel. Am I missing something?
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoTHe prices were still very low. And the decision was almost immediately reversed. Any economical problem can't justify violent uprising with takeover of an airport and decapitating of police officers, etc. etc. Never.
- janeroe 5y agoOur only source for "decapitation of police officers" are Russian telegram accounts which, there is no question, are 100% trustworthy (they are not; what happened to that poor "little boy in underwear crucified in Ukraine" that never existed). On the other hand, we've got plenty of evidence of police shooting protesters, including in the head. I'm somehow sure relatives of the murdered are not OK with that. I wouldn't even be surprised if they demanded revenge and acted on it (family means more in that part of the world and it's way bigger, too).
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoNo, it is the official Kazakhstan source, not Russian telegram accounts. The uprising is very vioulent without any doubts. There are a lot of sources to confirm captures of government buildings and posession of arms. Speaking of Ukraine, do you remember a "burned AC unit" in Lugansk? That was not media, that was official Ukrainian statement.
- janeroe 5y ago> No, it is the official Kazakhstan source Which source? The one that requested Russian intervention? Why there are lots of videos of protests, shootings, killings by the Kazakh army, and looting by unidentified people but only words of the interested party for this one? I don't remember the "AC unit" but I do remember Russian media's "100% sure version of 2 Ukraine planes downing the Netherlands' jet" a few years ago (with interviews of "experts" all over the place). That was their position for a long time (maybe half a year, until they shamelessly changed it to "Ukraine BUKs did it"). The "beheading story" seems like a fairy tale from the same authors.
- brnt 5y agoIt's very weird to see the President argue 'foreign interests' spark the unrest, and then promptly invites a foreign army to quell it. Who's falling for that?
- HatchedLake721 5y agoForeign army in this context is just using a treaty you signed with an ally to request assistance. It’s as “foreign” as any NATO country’s army to another.
- brnt 5y agoIt'd be very strange if the French government asks Germany or Nato to quell the gilet-jaunes demo, wouldn't it?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ReptileMan 5y agoAnd yet intelligence agencies routinely spy for one another to get around those pesky warrant and probable cause requirements.
- jevgeni 5y agoIt's almost like intelligence work and active military operations aren't the same thing...
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoAren't most people from Kazakhstan pretty anti Russia? Wouldn't this be more like Taiwan asking China to send in the army to help with a protest? Or Iraq asking Iran?
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoExcept that NATO countries are not run by tzars in their 70-ies whose only hope is to die quietly in bed, surrounded by elite killers.
- anonair 5y agoSo much anti-russian sentiment that 30% of population is still russian and russian is the second (if not first) most spoken language in Kazakhstan
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jokoon 5y agoThis country is so large...
- wheelerof4te 5y ago
- ralmidani 5y agoISIS (and Al-Qaeda) are predictable, convenient excuses for keeping dictatorships in the Muslim world. Before ISIS took over Raqqah and other territory in Syria and Iraq, it was the FSA (Free Syrian Army), not Assad, who kicked ISIS out of Aleppo and the Damascus countryside. When Putin intervened in 2015, the overwhelming majority of airstrikes targeted the FSA and civilian areas outside the control of both Assad and ISIS (https://www.newsweek.com/more-90-percent-russian-airstrikes-havent-targeted-isis-u-s-334290 https://www.newsweek.com/more-90-percent-russian-airstrikes-...). For Putin and Pals, ISIS is the gift that keeps on giving.
- wheelerof4te 5y agoHere's a hint: Stop causing color revolutions in other coutries, that in turn create a power vacuum, which leads to chaos and anarchy. Seriously, that is not hard. What makes you think FSA are "moderate" headchopers and how are they any better than Assad? Just because they have "Free" in the name? Such naive thinking.
- ralmidani 5y agoAside from the ISIS excuse, the other tired cliche is that it’s all a US conspiracy. Addressed in another comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29822573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29822573
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoIt is a conspiracy theory to imply that US does not change regimes, indeed.
- yread 5y agoJust a few months ago it looked different, there were articles like this https://globalcomment.com/is-russia-losing-or-tightening-its-grip-on-kazakhstan/ https://globalcomment.com/is-russia-losing-or-tightening-its... about US looking into getting an airbase and Tokayev trying to play it both sides. That probably won't happen anymore
- rainworld 5y agoThe Armenians, too, and even Lukashenko tried to play both sides, get cozy with the West. They are probably/definitely not going to do that again.
- q1w2 5y agoIt's pretty telling that several western leaning nations/political groups in Asia have been defeated by non-Western adversaries. We've now seen this in Armenia, Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and now Kazakhstan. I think the geopolitical message is pretty clear - EU/US will not protect you. Alliances with them cost little, but have little protective value. Russia/Iran/China/Turkey might force you to pay a higher price for their protection, but at the end of the day, they will actually protect you.
- keewee7 5y agoLook what happened to Armenia that tried to appease both Russia and the West. It's more important to have few close allies than appeasing everyone.
- Guessnotgauss 5y agoWorked out pretty well for India, they still court Russia and the US
- aqsalose 5y agoIndia is much larger country than the others mentioned in this thread.
- radmuzom 5y ago
- brnt 5y agoWhataboutism anyone? You should've received your updated propaganda field guide by now, currently it is no longer advised to so blatantly point somewhere else.
- HatchedLake721 5y agoSorry, but it sounds like a cheap attempt to accuse the other party of propaganda and use the "whataboutism" card. I don't see anything whataboutism'y where one accuses a foreign state interfering in another state. (and I personally find Kazahstan's idea that rioters received foreign military training funny, since it's the cheapest excuse ex-USSR governments use when people are tired of the same people ruling the country for 20-30 years and start protesting) For it to be whataboutism, it should include something along the lines of "What about... ?" that discredits an opponent with their own hypocrisy.
- Const-me 5y ago> accuse the other party of propaganda Click the first link, it writes that Americans attempted a regime change in Belarus, and instigated a war between Azerbaijan and Armenia.
- mlindner 5y agoRussia's sending paratroopers and it's somehow the US interfering? Lol? Khazakistan is under Russia's wing. Russia props up the dictatorship to help Russia. This uprising is a popular uprising.
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoRussia does that by a completely legitimate request of country's government. What kind of issue is there about it?
- snickerer 5y agoI traveled many post-Soviet countries in the past years with my old camping car. My personal impressions in Kazakhstan were frightening. A deeply corrupt state, much worse than Russia. Aggressive armed bandits in police uniform tried to rob me several times. Kazakhstan is true mafia state where every part of the regime tries to enrich itself at the expanse of the people. In contrast to the rich oil elite there are the normal people who often not even have tap water in the villages. And who live often in constant fear of being robbed by the armed forces. But why is such a dysfunctional dictatorship so stable? Why did it last for three decades? The situation is very similar to Azerbaijan. I believe the answer is: it is backed by the West because a stable dictator in Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan guarantees the oil flow.
- jacobolus 5y agoIn the case of Azerbaijan, my understanding is that western European companies have just blanket bribed more or less every official they interact with up and down the Azeri government for the past few decades, to help them set up contracts that are grossly unfair to the Azeri public. Oil money that does go to Azerbaijan gets embezzled away, with those companies’ knowledge and implicit support. I haven’t heard of anyone from e.g. BP getting punished for this, though I believe the British government asked it to investigate itself a few times.
- cblconfederate 5y agoAnd vice-versa. Azerbaijan is known to bribe politicians in european and EU organizations, aka the "Azerbaijani laundromat" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azerbaijani_laundromat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azerbaijani_laundromat https://www.dw.com/en/how-german-politicians-have-aided-the-aliyev-regime/av-59036114 https://www.dw.com/en/how-german-politicians-have-aided-the-...
- mlindner 5y ago"Backed by the west" is a common conspiracy theory pushed by Russian government. You should be asking yourself who's benefiting. The west does not benefit from anything related to those states, all oil they produce first flows through Russia. Russia benefits by having these states as basically feudal subservient states that they can extort for profit. (I will note that most western oil comes from the middle east with Europe also getting a decent amount from Russia.)
- codebolt 5y agoIt seems noteworthy that Kazakhstan represents ~22% of Bitcoins hashrate (~45 TWh/year of electricity), at the same time as people are out in the streets rioting over the price of heating their homes.
- adolph 5y agoI’ve read this note about Kazakhstan and BTC a couple of times now but I havnt seen any documentation for the claim. For a crypto novice, what would be a method for validating this claim? BTC and other crypto seem to gravitate toward less expensive energy sources, yet require a substantial capital investment. Is crypto an emerging method for dictators to expropriate wealth? Are there going to be “blood bits” similar to “blood diamonds” or other commodities tainted by their provenance?
- MagnumOpus 5y ago> Is crypto an emerging method for dictators to expropriate wealth Yes, same for local mafiosi/siloviki who can force the electricity company guy to look the other way (at gunpoint). > Are there going to be “blood bits” similar to “blood diamonds” Given the recirculation and tumbling, probably a majority of BTC/Ether went through shady people's hands (just like most $100 bills have coke residue on them...). Bitcoin advocates usually tout this as a feature not a bug.
- adolph 5y agoIsn't there a difference between using a medium of exchange versus creating it? To stretch the analogy, instead of using $100 bills, printing them a la NK superbills? If dictators/mafiosi contribute a significant amount to the overall hash rate, are they not decreasing transaction costs for whichever blockchain they use?
- pjc50 5y agoPart of the stupidity of bitcoin's proof-of-waste algorithm is that increasing the hashrate increases transaction costs. The difficulty level adjusts automatically to maintain N blocks per hour, while the number of transactions in a block is fixed. So adding hashrate just increases the energy cost of blocks. (The actual transaction cost to the user is driven by congestion and is set unilaterally by the user based on their tolerance for queueing, so it can be zero.)
- cmod 5y agoMy own experience in Kazakhstan a few years ago was amazing — kind, generous people. I had the most surreal (but standard) Russian Bath experience: sitting with a bunch of naked folks as they self-flog with branches in rooms so hot you needed wool caps to keep the top of your head from singeing. When I was getting dressed a huge guy next to me said something in Russian, I was certain I had committed some bath faux pas, but then he repeated in heavily accented English: "Those boots, suitable in winter?" Almaty was surprisingly cosmopolitan, walkable, felt eminently livable. Took the train to Baikonur. Walked on the launch pad, visited the old control rooms. [0] The whole way: Kindness and gentleness were the two words that kept bouncing around my head. In the middle of nowhere folks were driving sensibly (as opposed to, say, in Morocco where I felt like every car ride was a dice roll). I saw two cars have an accident in Almaty — the drivers calmly stepped out, shook hands, and discussed the situation. Nur-Sultan was, however, miserable — built for cars, human antagonistic, artificial layout, depressing architecture. I'd love to get back to Almaty. Hoping for swift and peaceful resolution on all this. [0]: https://craigmod.com/ridgeline/036/ https://craigmod.com/ridgeline/036/
- thejackgoode 5y agoBeing Eastern European, I can attest to the fact that this kindness and generosity (poorly abstracted as being passionate about things) has a flip side, and you don’t want to be on the opposite side of this treatment.
- nmfisher 5y agoCan you elaborate?
- thejackgoode 5y agoFor example, ex-nomadic and Caucasian “honor culture” is linked to necessity of trust in regions with predominant animal husbandry. If your cattle gets stolen before winter, you die of hunger. That’s why honor killings and hospitality are the flip sides of the same coin — you can’t afford losing trust. Robert Sapolsky gave a lecture about it.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThe wealthiest European countries have problems with rising energy prices (remember the French yellow vests?) so I'm interested to see how Kazakhstan thinks they can placate their citizens. My own government is giving me €400 this winter which is nice.
- switch007 5y agoIs that 400 for everyone? Our government (UK) is not changing the existing single payment of £140 (means tested). On top of that, the PM “misspoke” and told Parliament it was £140 a week…
- MagnumOpus 5y agoThey already reinstated the subsidies that halve the LPG prices and made a song and dance about firing some ministers. But at this point, the discontent is bigger than that...
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoNo they SAY they will reinstate the subsidies. When a Dutch finance minister goes on TV to give everyone money you believe him because he has an unlimited creditcard. It's a "look under your seat" moment. Why did Kazakhstan make this decision in the first place? Because they are in dire financial straits.
- q1w2 5y ago...and with that €400, you will likely buy heat, at least partially, supplied by Russia.
- mlindner 5y agoLots of weird extremely Russian-patriot sounding comments in this thread. Russia is sending paratroopers because they don't want another Ukraine situation. They don't want Kazakhstan to break away from Russia because of a popular uprising like Ukraine did. And it's a lot easier for them to prevent it than it was for Ukraine because Ukraine doesn't border Europe so the west won't protest it as much. I expect a whole lot of bloodshed is about to happen and I'm not looking forward to it. Best of luck to the Khazak populace.
- ttybird2 5y agoOn the other hand I see a lot of weird intelligence officer comments around. At the end of the day the regular people will be the ones paying the price for the war between the giants.
- matt_the_bass 5y ago“When two elephants fight, it’s the grass that does suffer”
- radmuzom 5y ago> Lots of weird extremely Russian-patriot sounding comments in this thread. This kind of nonsense comments appear whenever there are people with positive comments on China or Russia. I guess my top level comment on this thread will be one of the "Russia-patriot" ones. For the record, I am an Indian living in Malaysia - I simply choose to read proper sources and be informed of geopolitical events rather than parrot US propaganda. I learned to do so after reading a book by an American, often mentioned in HN (the book is Manufacturing Consent by Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman).
- r721 5y ago>I simply choose to read proper sources and be informed of geopolitical events rather than parrot US propaganda And yet in your other comment you linked to "Moon of Alabama", anonymous blogger which always takes a pro-Kremlin position. How is that a "proper source"?
- danjac 5y agoThe old "fraternal assistance" card. Much like Yanukovych gave Russia the pretext to invade Ukraine in 2014.
- VictorPath 5y agoThe Russian military have been in the Crimea since back when there were British red coats stationed in New York City. If remaining where they have been for centuries is an invasion. Can't imagine Americans ever saying the US invaded South Vietnam when it's various puppet Saigon governments asked for fraternal assistance.
- fjhfhgf 5y agoOnly Russian nationalists do not know us invaded Vietnam and Russia invaded Ukraine. Everyone else history book are up to date
- Paradigma11 5y agoWhat vietnam did the US invade and when?
- timeon 5y agoMilitary base and whole peninsula are two different things.
- danjac 5y ago> The Russian military have been in the Crimea since back when there were British red coats stationed in New York City By that logic, next time there's a protest or riot in NYC the British should send in some Royal Marines. Russia signed a treaty with Ukraine respecting Ukrainian sovereignty and borders in 1997. It broke that treaty - and international law - in 2014 with the occupation of Crimea. You could argue Crimea should never have been ceded to Ukraine back when both nations were part of the USSR and you may well be right. But if we start allowing military invasions to correct an injustice because part of a country was made part of another country, we'd have eternal conflict. Ask the Serbians about Kosovo, the Irish about Ulster, the Germans about East Prussia, on and on.
- pulse7 5y agoThis looks similar to troops without any signs on their uniforms in Kiev, Ukraine a few years back... So now we can guess which country is using "no-name" troops...
- tryauuum 5y agoThe only similar part is "Russian military in foreign country". No-one hides the fact that they are Russian
- scotty79 5y ago"unrest" word doesn't sit well with me in a country with 30-years-in-office president.
- siva7 5y agoTruly bizarre to ask as the head of state for foreign military intervention in your own country to dump down civil protest. Almost like it’s just a russian puppet state
- culebron21 5y agoKazakhstan asked CSTO contries (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_Security_Treaty_Organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_Security_Treaty_Org...) to do that, whether we like this or not (I don't). So that's nothing bizzare, and 3000 Russian paratroopers (plus 1000 from other conutries) don't make such a huge country a puppet state. P.S. So funny, you complain you don't get the logic, and I get downvoted for explaining it, rather than calling names.
- siva7 5y agoIt absolutely is bizarre, even if they are military allies. Can you imagine Canada asking for US military on their own grounds to fight civilian protests? Me neither. That’s a definition of puppet state.
- culebron21 5y agoNo, it's not the definition of puppet state. Wikipedia: > A puppet state is a state that is de jure independent but de facto completely dependent upon an outside power and subject to its orders. Even though Kazakh president does become dependent on Russian forces to some degree, I don't see how 3000 soldiers can control a country with an army of 100,000, National guard of 32,000 and 86,000 policemen. It may give an upper hand, but against whom? There's even no organized opposition. If you make paragons Czechoslovakia uprisings in 1968, then USSR sent 500,000 soldiers and 5,000 tanks in a 10 times smaller country. So it was 3 orders of magnitude larger intervention than this. Using a military treaty in case of a popular unrest may be illegitimate, but it's nowhere near a puppet state.
- janeroe 5y ago
- gnull 5y agohttps://novayagazeta-ru.translate.goog/articles/2022/01/05/vkhod-konem?_x_tr_sl=ru&_x_tr_tl=en https://novayagazeta-ru.translate.goog/articles/2022/01/05/v... I found the explanation of this article quite convincing. The key takes is: Tokayev, the Kazakhstan's president, does not completely trust his own forces and is afraid they might be more loyal to the old president, or the elites might see him as weak and try to plot against him. Therefore, he asks Putin for his armed forces to assist in stabilizing the situation. This is good for both of them: Tokayev stabilizes his position and gets some time to fire or prosecute the officials he doesn't trust, and Putin gains more influence over Tokayev in the future — Tokayev becomes dependent on Putin's support. Over the last two days, Tokayev has made some big changes in the government structure. For example, he fired the old president Nazarbayev from his current position of The Chairman of the Security Council (which he technically wasn't authorized to do). The old president hasn't made any public response to that, and is rumored to have escaped to Europe with his whole family (flightradar has shown a few private jets leaving the country as the riots got violent). Tokayev has also removed some of the Nazarbayev's people (people who served under Nazarbayev for a long time) from their positions yesterday; one big example is Massimov, the head of Kazakhstan's National Security Committee, the country's main intelligence service. Watching the local news closely these last days, I'm getting convinced that someone is orchestrating the violence and shooting on the streets. There's a footage of people handing out firearms to the protestors (it looks more like hunting rifles and shotguns, so it must be the loot from the firearm stores; but some of them have combat AKs they captured from the police, one video shows them having an RPG grenade). And those armed people with no uniforms are too organized: they give actual armed fights to the police and army forces — not something you could expect from a spontaneously gathered crowd. The organization and determination are shocking: they move from one government building to another, seizing things, burning cars and buildings, focusing on important ones (firearm stores, police offices, city administration) in the situation where mobile broadband is off. Yesterday, the government has withdrawn its forces from the city (friends of my friends who are in the police say they were ordered not to wear uniforms) and evacuated the main buildings. Today they are entering back and fighting the bandits, they report that a few groups were already eliminated. Having said this, obviously not everyone who's out on the streets now is one of those organized bandits. There are many people who genuinely came for a peaceful protest before it was hijacked into what it is now, and there's also people who are seizing the opportunity to loot and wreak havoc unpunished and drunk (what comes to mind is the video of a guy trying to set a traffic light on fire using a gas burner). Disclaimer: I'm not in Kazakhstan right now, but I'm watching the situation closely through media and my friends there EDIT: Removed the news of TV broadcast tower being stormed, it turned out to be fake
- awb 5y agoHow are articles like this relevant on HN? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. This is all over TV news. I get that it’s newsworthy, but it’s Reddit newsworthy not HN newsworthy. What am I missing?
- q1w2 5y agoI wonder if there's a political version of HN that with actual experts in geopolitical analysis. Social media is just everyone pushing their own agenda and guessing without providing any evidence or meaningful analysis, and when it comes to HN - it's pretty much the same. It's nothing but anti-Russian sentiment and conspiracy theories in this thread. Nothing of substance, because no one here is an expert in this field.
- Kiro 5y agoThis comment thread is much better and more interesting than the usual hateful and toxic discussions HN is known for.
- stevespang 5y ago
- sinyug 5y agoIt is always a surreal experience to see the sheer scale at which western media outlets deploy propaganda and rewrite history. Attempts to overthrow governments in Belarus, Russia and Kazakhstan are "protests." So are attacks on the residence of the President of Kazakhstan with rifles and grenades, and burning down the office of the mayor of Almaty.[1] The same outlets described the mild violence by a congregation of Trump supporters near the Capitol last year as a "coup," "attack" and "riot." [1] Russia-led alliance sending peacekeepers to Kazakhstan (https://apnews.com/article/business-kazakhstan-almaty-9da42330ca51c36fe9fd88f9ef35ff4e https://apnews.com/article/business-kazakhstan-almaty-9da423...)
- SassyThrowaway 5y agoIn another tab I have a Meduza article open listing how the rhetorics of President of Kazakhstan has shifted from using words like "a demonstration" to "an international terrorist group". Assuming that Meduza's compilation is accurate, and if Kazakhstan keeps redefining the narrative, what is so strange about many foreign media outlets not keeping up with that?
- sinyug 5y ago> Kazakhstan keeps redefining the narrative, what is so strange about many foreign media outlets not keeping up with that? What Kazakh politicians say is not very relevant here. The media outlets themselves are reporting that presidential residences and mayoral offices have been attacked and set on fire by "protesters."
- anticodon 5y agoMeduza is a rusophobic media with 100% foreign funding that was created with one sole purpose: disseminate Western propaganda in Russian population. It's in every their article. It's a trashcan of the worst and dumbest pro-West propaganda, I don't know how any sane person would refer to it. It's not a journalism, they don't even have journalists. They're producing anti-Russian fake news. BTW, even that they do poorly, I know people that unsubscribed from Meduza because they're tired from it's paranoid rusophobic hatred.
- Rd6n6 5y agoWhat actually happened? Is it so hard to give an overview of the situation near the start before jumping into the newest, most dramatic aspects?
- PeterisP 5y agoMy very rough interpretation of the last few days is as follows: Economic events (including increase of gas prices) triggered local social unrest, which the government attempted to suppress and failed as it escalated and resulted in at least some breakdown of government power (some police refusing to suppress protesters and joining them, protesters seizing government buildings and setting them on fire, looting of weapons from police stations, etc). The local military seems largely not involved (but there are some cases) and apparently it's not expected to be fully loyal to the leadership if asked to suppress revolts. After that ruler offered a back down on the changes and a rotation of the government, but the protesters apparently want a full change of leadership. This was not acceptable to the leadership, who invited neighbouring militaries to support them against the revolt, which can be used more freely/reliably than local army.
- anonair 5y agoThere are also theories, like the current president’s orders were sabotaged by those loyal to (or afraid of) the older one, so that he had no choice other than disbanding whole cabinet of ministers and asking for military support from Russia and other allies
- Ergo19 5y agoEleven years ago, Saudi Arabia sent troops into Bahrain to help quell Arab Spring protests there: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2011/3/15/saudi-soldiers-sent-into-bahrain https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2011/3/15/saudi-soldiers-sent...
- dfsegoat 5y agoAnecdote: My martial arts gym hosted a Kazakh olympic wrestler for a few months. He was won of the nicest and friendliest people I have ever met, even though we had a serious language barrier. Reading this, I will definitely reach out to him.
- amai 5y agoI'm sure the troops are there only for their vacation. Jokes aside, this is as if the NATO (especially the USA) would send troops to France against the yellow west protests. Or as if the NATO would be sending troops against the Catalonian separation movement. The NATO also didn't send troops to Turkey during the Turkish coup d'état attempt. What the CSTO is doing here can only be compared with the Warsaw Pact sending troops to suppress the Prague Spring. It shows that the CSTO is basically the successor of the Warsaw pact.
- moneywoes 5y agoA diversion from Ukraine?
- postnik0706 5y agoAll this happening in Kazakhstan is so scary. Our family - my wife and myself - lived in Almaty till we were in our thirties, then moved to Canada and then US. Our relatives still live there. Everything you'd call normal life went fubar in a just a few days. The town is in ruins, or at least its center, there is no law or police presence in there. Banks, grocery and other stores are looted and there is literally nothing left in there. Who did all this - nobody knows. Nobody of the locals know anything, in fact. No internet, no TV, no news. I truly wish nobody ever has this kind of experience in their life.