18 ms·
In 2019 40% of San Francisco traffic fatalities are from left turns
- chaostheory 5y agoA left turn traffic light would fix this problem.
- jalino23 5y agoI've been driving for five years now and left turn still stresses me out in downtown LA
- yongjik 5y agoRecently visited LA with wife, not the first time, but I had to joke, "This is a city where the weak can't drive - only the strong-willed will survive and make it to their destination!" FWIW I did make it to the hotel, though emotionally scarred.
- bombela 5y agoTo test your strength, try Paris, France. Especially around the massive roundabouts without lane markings and intermingled with various extra red lights. When you have graduated from this. You can afford a detour to Milan, Italy. Over there, traffic signals are superseeded by your skills at honking. I was told driving in India is many time worse!
- yongjik 5y agoHaha, I grew up in Seoul so I'm no stranger to traffic hell. (Though I also heard that India is at another level.) At least, in Seoul, I could avoid driving 99% of time. Harder to do it as tourist in LA ...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adam 5y agoAlso relevant: replacing 4-way's with roundabouts in Carmel, IN: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/20/climate/roundabouts-climate-emissions-driving.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/20/climate/roundabouts-clima...
- timidiceball 5y agoHave you seen roundabouts of this scale in person? They aren’t meant for people to be around at all
- martinald 5y agoHahaha. Are you joking? It's somewhat rare in Europe not to have a roundabout like this. They are clearly way better for pedestrians. You only have to cross half the road before you get to a safer place. Compare this intersection which seems to have been somewhat recently upgraded: From https://www.google.com/maps/@39.9679819,-86.1403832,3a,75y,273.04h,76.64t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sjStNUyOZFr8SQU0Us5VugQ!2e0!5s20160901T000000!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@39.9679819,-86.1403832,3a,75y,2... To https://www.google.com/maps/@39.9679454,-86.1403837,3a,75y,273.04h,76.64t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1stQ6wvE9qA77SwkFcqFefLQ!2e0!5s20190701T000000!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@39.9679454,-86.1403837,3a,75y,2... Notice that there is also now a bend in the road so a car physically has to slow down to navigate it, unlike miles of straight traffic light intersections.
- 1123581321 5y agoI'm a huge roundabout advocate but the user you replied to is correct. Despite the Carmel roundabout looking safer, when you're there, you don't feel like pedestrians are considered. I've driven through them. Smaller roundabouts in narrower streets feel safer for pedestrians even if the islands are smaller. It's really the street size that is doing the work and the smaller roundabout works in conjunction with the street size to make cars behave more like they're in a turn and not a road with curves in it.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI'm not sold, yet, on roundabouts improving safety over four-way stops. Pedestrians at regular intersections are pretty easy to spot. But when you come up to a typical roundabout, the road is twisting a little, you're looking to see what traffic is approaching the roundabout, and the crosswalk is usually right in the area where the road is twisting to line up for roundabout entry. I don't know that I have any suggestion, though, to make it better other than try to keep pedestrians far enough from the roundabout that drivers can easily focus on them and not be distracted by more moving parts. The argument that you are only crossing half the road at a time is fairly compelling, though. I guess there's a trade-off there.
- caminante 5y agoHN headline is misleading. Actual claim on site: > 40% of SF traffic fatalities in 2019 involved drivers making left turns who didn’t see the person in the crosswalk until it was too late.
- olivermarks 5y agoAlso of note: SF is a very pedestrian dense city with people wandering into the street looking at phones, not paying attention...and sadly a large number of substance abuse casualties endangering themselves and others. This reality has got increasingly worse since the iphone launch last decade, it's a huge problem.
- spamizbad 5y agoWhy are car drivers taking turns so quickly they cannot stop fast enough to not kill someone on a crosswalk?
- HPsquared 5y agoProbably focused on, and wanting to get out of the way of, other oncoming cars.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWithout going into unreasonable drivers (that surely are plenty), how many turns do one make in a trip there, what is the speed on the outgoing street, and what visibility do they have over the new street. Anything you do is an exercise of balancing risks. Breaking too hard is a risk, taking time slow at a fast street is a risk, and turning too fast is a risk.
- spamizbad 5y agoThe problem is, as a pedestrian, I have no way of knowing if vehicle intends to take a left turn across my crosswalk UNLESS they come to a complete stop and I can see their turn signal. So even if I am fully alert I ultimately have to trust that you will not run me over in the crosswalk if you are traveling fast.
- ahepp 5y agoI used to live in Michigan, where we have a thing we call the "Michigan left". To turn right at an intersection, you continue straight through the intersection, then take a left turn at gap in the median to return to the intersection from the other side of the boulevard and proceed to make a right turn. I'd be interested in what the trade-offs are. I imagine space usage is a big one.
- tyingq 5y agoIf that's hard to visualize: https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/tctimes.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/f/f3/ff3e874c-27db-11e4-b3b5-0019bb2963f4/53f3adcf0d9a9.image.png https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/tctimes.com/con...
- red_hare 5y agoThat's very helpful. Thanks!
- jldugger 5y ago> To turn right at an intersection Pretty sure you mean 'to turn left'
- cornstalks 5y ago> To turn right at an intersection... You mean to turn left, correct? I've seen this technique used by people as an optimization. Some lights have very long wait times for left turns, so people will do what you describe rather than waiting in the left turn lane.
- deanCommie 5y agoLooking at the diagram [0], I'm dubious if this is a good "authoritative" solution. The problem with left turns is collision with oncoming traffic moving straight through. Especially at yellow lights where the turning vehicle is trying to make it out of the intersection before the light turns red and they feel like they are blocking 90-degree traffic [1], and end up colliding with oncoming vehicles running the yellow. This design seems to shift that problem 100 meters down the road, but the challenge of crossing oncoming traffic remains (I guess without the pressure of trying to get out of a turning Yellow Light situation). So it's definitely an improvement, but isn't there a simpler one called "Dedicated Left Turn Signals"? If both directions had an "advance left" light where both could turn safely, and there was a dedicated light for turning (i.e. no entering the intersection to turn except in a dedicated Left turn sign), this solves the problem, no? Dedicated Turn lanes and signals need space, so they're not always possible in dense urban environments, but the Michigan setup doesn't suffer from a lack of space. So i feel like the Michigan solution is useless for San Francisco, and also not as good as the alternative for Michigan [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left#/media/File:Michigan_Left.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left#/media/File:Mich... [1] Which, incidentally, FEELS unsafe, and inexperienced drivers panic trying to get out as soon as possible, but isn't actually - these vehicles are starting from 0 and accelerating - they are unlikely to accelerate INTO you. In rushing to get out before the light turns red, they are more likely to collide with an oncoming vehicle trying to run the yellow.
- hprotagonist 5y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/SMIDSY https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/SMIDSY
- marcosdumay 5y agoDoes anybody know why bike paths are always on the left of the street? Looks to me that most problems come from that.
- hprotagonist 5y agoin the US, they’re always on the right. ie, in the direction of traffic
- aresant 5y agoWhy don't we have an X prize for incremental self driving around collision mitigation & safety? So much interesting research on the advent of "Automatic Braking Systems" and its introduction -> - eg in China researchers demonstrate the potential of saving thousands of lives per annum - "fatalities could be reduced by 13.2%, and injuries could be reduced by 9.1%." (1) - and when using data from insurance claims - ". . front-facing automatic emergency braking systems can cut the frequency of bodily injury liability claims by nearly 25%. A similar study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) involving police-reported crashes — typically the most severe type of collision — found front automatic emergency braking reduced "front-to-rear" crashes by 50%. Often referred to as rear-ending another vehicle, these crashes can be deadly, particularly when the car responsible for the collision is moving at high speed. " (2) - Or when outfitting large tractor trailers with the tech - "Equipping large trucks with forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking (AEB) systems could eliminate more than 2 out of 5 crashes in which a large truck rear-ends another vehicle, a new study from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety suggests." (3) I recognize that we'll see "trickle down" safety improvements from the self driving groups, but how do we just ensure every 2025 model or what have you has some basic automatic braking system in place that includes pedestrian recognition? (1) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/ (2) https://www.jdpower.com/automotive-news/report-automatic-emergency-braking-systems-save-lives-save-money https://www.jdpower.com/automotive-news/report-automatic-eme... (3) https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/study-shows-front-crash-prevention-works-for-large-trucks-too https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/study-shows-front-crash-pre...
- dheera 5y agoOr you know, don't have left turns and pedestrian crossings at the same time. A simple software fix of the traffic light pattern would eliminate almost all of these fatalities. Sequence should be - Pedestrians in all directions including diagonal - Traffic in horizontal direction, no pedestrians - Traffic in vertical direction, no pedestrians Repeat
- jeffbee 5y agoYou just doubled the expected wait time for pedestrians at every crossing.
- nostromo 5y agoOther facts about pedestrian deaths: 80% are at night. 33% involve a drunk pedestrian. 20% are elderly. Contrary to these data about SF, most pedestrian deaths (73%) are not at intersections, but at non-crossings. I try to tell friends to be more careful walking at night, and to not walk drunk (take an uber, it's safer). https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/pedestrian_safety/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/pedestrian_safety/i... https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/road-users/pedestrians/ https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/road-users/pedestr...
- pharmakom 5y agoIt’s time for pedestrian infrastructure that is safe by design. Most of these fatalities could be prevented by lowering the speed limit.
- riffic 5y agosigns and fines have minimal impact on driver behavior. Apply treatments to the road that alter driver behavior - the perception of danger is quite a motivator in reducing speeds (tullock's spike for instance).
- jwagenet 5y agoLowering the speed limit doesn’t make sense if there are wide streets with wide lanes (more comfortable to drive in) and no enforcement. In SF it would be preferable to reduce street width in reality or artificially with protected bike lanes, bus/muni right of way, etc on wide streets like Geary or Van Ness .
- colpabar 5y ago> In SF it would be preferable to reduce street width Absolutely. It seems like the best way to reduce speeds in cities is to make it uncomfortable to drive fast in them. Big wide streets make it feel like you're going "slow" at 25mph, so people go faster. Of course, we could also slowly carve out areas of cities where cars are not allowed, but how will businesses survive if people can't park directly in front of them? /s
- cdolan 5y agoTesla FSD 10.X will increase this number. The left turns I have seen the system try to take on Youtube are downright terrifying.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- madars 5y agoClearly need to correct for selection bias: we don't watch YouTube videos of non-eventful Tesla turns.
- sedatk 5y agoI'm very anxious about left turns for that reason alone and move my head around the left column to see if I'm missing someone like trying to watch a movie with a taller person sitting in the front. It's amazing that we think we can take on self-driving before we can take on not killing pedestrians on left turns.
- jjk166 5y agoWell it is a lot easier to put a camera in a blind spot than an eyeball. Human hardware isn't going to get better any time soon; my money is on safe self driving long before safe human driving.
- Animats 5y agoThere's something called "left turn hardening". This involves minor barriers to channel drivers into making wider left turns. New York City does a lot of this.[1] [1] https://www1.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/turn-calming.shtml https://www1.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/turn-calming....
- jimbob45 5y agoI never knew that's what those were for. Thanks for sharing. I know you see a lot of concrete (+ grass) road medians in the South. Do those have a similar effect or do the cones need to extend out to really work?
- selimthegrim 5y agoMobile, AL has some pretty big left turn channels they dug out the median for. New Orleans tends to make U turns past the intersection.
- azundo 5y agoThe linked page describes exactly that - "Left Turn Calming" projects. > At SFMTA, we’re working hard to help drivers make left turns the right way. We’ve installed Left Turn Guide Bumps at designated intersections around the City, with painted safety zones and raised bumps to remind drivers to slow down and make squarer left turns. We’ll test how well these treatments make left turns safer, with a long-term goal of installing calming project at other intersections where they are needed most.
- mlex 5y agoThere’s one of these at 10th Street turning left onto Folsom.
- baybal2 5y agoWhy US can't simply install left turn signals onto traffic lights more widely? I noticed how few of them are there in North America.
- 5y ago
- chmod775 5y agoThat's information that anyone with a driver's license should have learned and been tested on, both theoretically and practically. Besides making roads safer, I wonder how long society can go on without re-testing people's competence for moving tons of steel at 60 miles per hour on a regular basis. There's very few dangerous activities that don't require regular re-certification and training, and driving really shouldn't be an exception. Some main contributing factors to road fatalities are going too fast for conditions, exceeding the speed limit, failing to look properly (left turns!), reckless driving, and various forms of inexperience.[1] That means it's mostly people who don't know/forgot how to drive safely and mouth breathers who don't realize most traffic laws exist for a reason and are written in blood. Can't hurt to remind people occasionally and make sure they can actually be trusted on roads. [1]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001457518300873 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000145751...
- lucasmullens 5y agoIn California you only need an 80% on the written test to pass. And if I remember right you can retake it the same day. To phrase that another way, you can be wrong about 20% of the driving laws and still drive. They should raise the bar.
- jdavis703 5y agoOr if peoples can’t remember all the rules, they should reduce the number of rules while stiffening the consequences for causing a crash. For example, if you’re at fault you loose a drivers license for life (or perhaps are restricted to operating only motorcycle-class vehicles and lighter). As it stands we have all these rules that drivers forget or ignore. Then when a crash happens, they receive no consequences. I’d rather have people using intuition to driver safer for fear of punishment vs a set of rules that only increases safety in theory (see the unenforced three foot bike passing law).
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe fact that you take issue with people being wrong about the law speaks volumes. The test questions tend to be fairly simple, which sign is an octagon, how far before a turn should you signal, at a four way stop what happens, basic operational rules of the road stuff that has little to do with the law. The law questions tend to be stuff about penalties that will rarely if ever have any bearing on you if you drive reasonably. Go check the state's practice test questions if you don't believe me.
- jeffbee 5y agoOf course far better than just begging drivers to square up their lines would be to simply ensure that anyone who tries to cut off their turn destroys their car in the process. It's quite simple to put a rigid object at the point of the centerline to protect pedestrians. https://www.google.com/maps/@47.3625432,8.5339337,3a,75y,196.28h,86.61t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1stYIe1BAL5RbfTYi7xD836Q!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DtYIe1BAL5RbfTYi7xD836Q%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D175.45322%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en https://www.google.com/maps/@47.3625432,8.5339337,3a,75y,196...
- dorianmariefr 5y agoMaybe making the streets narrower would help
- rootusrootus 5y agoThe closest calls I've ever had with pedestrians were on left turns. IMO the problem with modern cars is the airbags in the A-pillar. The pillars have gotten so wide that you have to consciously bob your head around back and forth (like a fighter pilot, of course...) to look around both sides of it. Otherwise people can easily vanish into that blind spot. I think a lot of people just forget that there's a big blind spot there because they're used to just looking on either side and inferring what's not visible -- which is usually fine with something as big as a car. But on a left turn, a pedestrian walking the same direction you are driving can be completely hidden as you turn because their motion will be synchronized with the blind spot.
- wonnage 5y agoThis was one of the worst adjustments for me coming from an old car. I think driver testing should be updated to account for it - looking around the pillar should be as mandatory as the shoulder blind spot check when changing lanes/turning.
- ozgune 5y agoI've been driving in the US for 16 years. The "left turn on green" is still the most non-intuitive part about driving here. As a driver, when you have a green light, you need to pay attention to giving priority to incoming traffic and pedestrians crossing the street, while also maintaining your calm with cars lining up behind you. It's way more intuitive that when you have a green, you can go.
- worker767424 5y agoAdding a blinking yellow left arrow could help.
- Skunkleton 5y ago"blinking yellow left arrow" is the same thing as not having a protected turn at all.
- digianarchist 5y agoBrit living in Canada. I hate left turns in North America. Often you can't clearly see oncoming traffic, pedestrians have right of way which can leave you unable to complete a manuever and a lot of judgment is put on drivers to turn at the correct time. There's a technical solution to this problem. Dedicated left turn lights which appear to run in some places only during peak hours.
- unstatusthequo 5y agoWhat is also dangerous are pedestrians who see a car turning or proceeding, look right at the car/driver, and then walk into the crosswalk, assuming car will slam breaks on. Or the pedestrian can’t be bothered to look up from their smartphone or stop their podcast to hear what’s going on around them. Pedestrians have some responsibility to co-exist as well.
- pmulard 5y agoI'm honestly surprised there aren't more traffic fatalities in San Francisco, especially with how many pedestrians, ride sharing drivers, and narrow streets there are. Coming from the mid-west, there are status quo norms (laws?) that baffle me: - Cars can park all down the street, even right up on the crosswalks at either end. It is incredibly hard to see people trying to use the cross walks, when they are behind the cars. Cars parking that close is illegal in many streets where I'm from. - The amount of cross walks in the middle of high traffic streets (not intersections) that rely solely on visibility between the driver and pedestrian. Again, these streets are usually lined with cars on either side, so it's even harder to see. They could use the electronic, push button signs that light up and beep when a pedestrian wants to cross; which to be fair I've seen around, but not nearly as many as there should be. I understand the city isn't going to reduce street parking, but at least implement better communication between drivers and pedestrians. The light up cross walks are a good start.
- estebank 5y ago> Cars parking that close is illegal in many streets where I'm from. That's called daylighting and SFMTA knows it exists. That they aren't using it everywhere is baffling[1]. > I understand the city isn't going to reduce street parking It should, but given how much push back there is for every change to cities that make them better cities (increased density, prioritizing local movement of people by improving things for transit, cyclists and pedestrians, implementing safer streets) I'm not holding my breath. [1]: https://www.sfmta.com/blog/daylighting-makes-san-francisco-crosswalks-safer https://www.sfmta.com/blog/daylighting-makes-san-francisco-c...
- lbwtaylor 5y agoCompletely agree - why daylighting isn't more comprehensive in SF boggles the mind. Someone above blamed the A-pillar. I think parked cars are a significantly worse problem in SF for turning visibility and daylighting is very limited.
- worker767424 5y ago> It is incredibly hard to see people trying to use the cross walks This is only an issue for right turns (on two-way streets, anyway). Recently, walk signs have started illuminating a few seconds before the green light, and I assume it's for more pedestrian visibility. I wouldn't be surprised if the most dangerous thing in this scenario is a right on red while jaywalking. The driver knows they have a red, they look left for oncoming traffic, but not right for jaywalking pedestrians.
- jedberg 5y agoInstead of installing bumps and doing a marketing campaign, why not actually fix the problem and install roundabouts? They're safer, cheaper than lights, and more environmental because they keep traffic moving.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoWe have roundabouts everywhere in France, but in the US, they seem not very popular. They do removes the need for traffic lights, make priority checking a non issue and avoid left turns among other benefits. Although they prevent you from going to fast locally, they tend to make traffic more fluid on average. Why are they not used that much in the US ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 5y agoUnpopular locally. The Seattle area has quite a few and people adapted pretty well to it, but the few in SF are stop-sign controlled as well, which makes them prettification projects.
- AnotherGoodName 5y agoThere's roundabouts where I live in the USA with stop signs. People didn't know who has right of way and it led to road rage confrontations so the government had to add stop signs to them. People in the area now complain that roundabouts suck. Which they do when you have to stop before entering. So now we get more four way stop signs and traffic lights instead which cause traffic to stop and start, wasting fuel and increasing congestion. Sigh. On the other hand at least you can turn right on red which is something my home country needs to allow by default since I haven't once seen an issue with it in my years in the USA.
- estebank 5y ago> On the other hand at least you can turn right on red which is something my home country needs to allow by default since I haven't once seen an issue with it in my years in the USA. > Right-Turn-on-Red (RTOR), in its “Western” version allows motorists to turn right on a red signal after stopping and yielding, unless specifically prohibited by a sign. The objective of this study was to determine the effect of Western RTOR on pedestrian and bicycle accidents in selected jurisdictions adopting the rule in the mid-1970s. The results showed significant increases in pedestrian and bicyclist accidents involving right-turning vehicles at signalized locations following the introduction of Western RTOR. These increases were: 40 % for pedestrians and 82 % for bicycles in New York State; 107 % for pedestrians and 72 % for bicycles in Wisconsin; 57 % for pedestrians and 80 % for bicycles in Ohio; and 82 % for pedestrians in New Orleans. Analysis of police accident reports suggested that drivers stopped for a red light are looking left for a gap in traffic and do not see pedestrians and bicyclists coming from their right. Countermeasure research and development was recommended to deal with this well defined problem which involves between 1 % and 3 % of all pedestrian and bicycle accidents. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0022437582900019 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/002243...
- underdeserver 5y agoHi. Left turns where the pedestrians have a green light, or oncoming traffic does, are batshit crazy. Kill them before they kill more people.
- cjensen 5y agoIt's odd to me that such a significant source of fatalities is being addressed in a very unambitious way. Left turns are clearly difficult maneuvers in many parts of SF. Why not turn them into protected left turns? This "just blame the drivers" attitude is really odd. Their response is to tell drivers that they need to take more care and then enforce the care with an obstacle course. Why not do something harder that would be more effective? Protected lefts. Separating walk signals from green lights. Tickets to penalize poor driving. Tickets to penalize anyone walking out of turn. Tickets for anything that makes the left turn more complicated so drivers can focus on the job.
- pm90 5y agoThe obvious answer is that it’s easier to blame drivers than enact meaningful change, which requires time and effort. You’re absolutely right though, this is a systemic problem fand needs a systems-based approach to solving it. Speed limits, limiting hours for motorized traffic… there are many ways in which this problem can be alleviated.
- aqme28 5y agoYou got me a bit confused by this. You say we shouldn't "just blame the drivers," but then advocate for increased ticketing. That's a contradiction.
- pm90 5y agoJust blame the drivers is shorthand for asking drivers to do better, without any other changes. Rules and laws to penalize drivers are a more effective strategy since people respond better when there are real costs associated with driving poorly (or so I hope; it seems logical but maybe it doesn’t, maybe the laws will be selectively enforced, not sure).
- rkk3 5y agoIt's a systemic issue drivers are one stakeholder and many are responsible. Vehicle designers & manufactures, Urban Planners etc. > people respond better when there are real costs associated with driving poorly The real cost is that driving kills 40,000 people a year in the US.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is hard for me to take percent statistics like this seriously. How does the overall fatality rate compare to other cities? What are the total death counts? Where would we rather have 40% of the pedestrian fatalities occur?
- black_13 5y agoIn Austin and DFW motorists on a cell phone will kill you if you are on a bike and the worst is Plano and the worst for that is at 5pm. They are one their cell phones. I stopped riding in that area and in Austin i confined myself to trails.
- williw 5y agoIt doesn't say if it includes left turns from one way street to a one way street on red light. Which is legal in California.
- 999900000999 5y agoThis is why I live in a public transit friendly city. I hate driving, I think most people are bad drivers. Even completely sober, you might just be tired. In places like LA driving is so essential people ignore license suspensions. Police often don't care, a friend of mine from nonchalantly talked about driving without a license or insurance. I happily haven't had a car in about 2 years. No tickets, no insurance, no clown kissing my bumper. I'd love for more cities to invest in public transit. I refuse to live in a city where I need a car! If I ever have to RTO, I'd rather ride a train. I can goof off on my phone, play video games, etc.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I hate driving, I think most people are bad drivers. Even completely sober, you might just be tired. It's not just the other drivers. Driving is rarely enjoyable, for me.
- mbg721 5y agoThere's a big difference between driving in stop-and-go traffic at rush hour and driving on a scenic road with no particular deadline. I guess some of that is "hell is other people", but I really enjoyed a national park auto tour (with audio guide) fairly recently.
- wolverine876 5y agoGood points and whatever suits you is of course fine. A suggestion: Try a tour on a bicycle. It's a very different experience: rather of watching from an isolated box, with somewhat limited view, and a bit distracted by the priority of driving, instead you are in it, with a 360 x 360 view, breathing the air, smelling the smells, hearing the sounds (with no engine noise). Also, it's much easier to stop and look, get up close, or go off-track.
- mbg721 5y agoI'd probably enjoy that as an individual, but it's trickier with a family.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hmmmhmmmhmmm 5y agoAs with COVID-related outcomes, focusing only on fatalities ignores other meaningful negative outcomes. Based on personal experience after living SF/Oakland ~ 10 years, I'd also take measurements like "in pedestrian cross-walk" with a grain of salt. Anecdotally, 1st-degree friends have been involved in: * Pedestrian killed by a MUNI bus, intoxicated and just out of the cross-walk, the bus driver deemed not at fault. * Cyclist killed by a delivery truck, while biking in a bike line on Folsom. * Cyclist in bike lane on Valencia hit by a truck, dealing with TBI and anxiety years later but with no visible damage. * My Uber driver, turning left onto Valencia, hit a pedestrian holding a red cup. A police officer happened to witness the incident, saw the red cup, and sent the driver on their way in under a minute.
- lxe 5y agoMaybe we should turn some of these left turns into a protected "arrow" signal? Or separate the pedestrian right-of-way with the "red human" signal? insert boardroom meeting getting thrown out the window meme
- higgins 5y agoNot everyone is an ambiturner
- worker767424 5y agoI wonder how many accidents and fatalities are due to poor layouts (that are hard to fix), inadequate signage, and unique designs that are "safer," but add enough mental overhead that you're paying more attention to where you should be so you're not in a bus-only lane rather than looking out for pedestrians. Driving in SF can be complicated when you're not familiar with the streets. Intersections feel like multiple clever solutions stacked together.
- brailsafe 5y agoThe amount of left turns that exist in Canada & the U.S where you're yielding to 3 or 4 oncoming lanes of traffic, 1 or 2 of which could also be waiting to turn left, is absurd. Now try doing it while you're learning to drive manual. People should be afraid of cars.
- temptemptemp111 5y ago... "San Francisco outlaws turning left"
- piinbinary 5y agoI wonder how much of this is because SF rarely uses left-turn signals. This forces drivers on streets like Guerrero or Valencia St who need to make left turns to do so against oncoming traffic. When that oncoming traffic doesn't give you a good opportunity to make that left turn, you are forced to take bad opportunities. This usually involves dashing across the oncoming lane quickly at the last second. I can't imagine that this is safe for pedestrians.
- piinbinary 5y agoMaybe a more interesting question: How does this compare to other US cities, and what do those cities do differently?
- ghaff 5y agoBetween the density/congestion, the street layout in much of the city, the hills, etc., I'd say SF is generally more difficult to drive in on average than most US cities.
- temptemptemp111 5y agoTime to quarantine all cars for an unknown amount of time!
- ozzydave 5y agoHas any city tried combining those HAWK Signals (flashing amber on crosswalk) triggered by a camera looking for pedestrians (/ cyclists etc)? I think that would be a cost-effective combination by making the pedestrians much more obvious.
- ffggvv 5y agothis seems to put all the onus on drivers. in my experience driving in SF, i'll be in the middle of the intersection waiting to turn left (its unprotected) and light will be yellow turning red. And i have a shot to go left but then an idiotic biker or pedestrian will walk even though it says "dont walk". leaving me to be stuck in the intersection. people often ignore those pedestrian lights completely and dare you to hit them. dont get me started on bikers who ignore all lights and zip out in half a second
- csours 5y agoWatching dashcam footage I started saying "Left Turns Are Always A Mistake". If a left turn is possible in a dashcam video, it almost always the source of the incident.
- phkahler 5y agoI've thought a bit about roads and it seems to me that having 2-way streets is a poor choice at the highest level. When you're driving north, the LAST direction you'd want to go is south. Yet the closest thing to you at all times is the southbound lanes. To go west - which you want to do more than go south - you have to cross those lanes. As soon as you decide to make all the roads one-way, a whole set of other issues come up, but having to stop and wait for half of your turns goes away. The EPA drive cycle for city driving has an average speed of ~20mph and that turns out to be close to what I experience even when posted speed limits are 45mph. Traffic lights are a plague, and IMHO traffic circles are not much better. All I can say with certainty is that it's complicated.
- frankus 5y agoThe tradeoff with that is that you end up with more than one lane per direction, which works fine with signalized intersections, but is unsafe at non-signal-controlled crosswalks. Without a traffic light, a car in one lane will stop for a someone waiting to cross, and a driver in the other lane (or who pulls around to pass the first car) might not realize that there is a reason for the car stopping, and hit the person crossing as they enter the other lane.
- trgn 5y agoTragic to read. The biggest thing imho is that drivers are making left-turns at speed. They should come to a full stop. Drivers are extremely extremely inconsiderate and selfish. When turning left, drivers are generally looking into the opposite lane where the cars are coming, looking for that gap, and then _gun_ it, so they can make the turn. Scanning for that gap in traffic is the only thing they care about, iso of _also_ looking for pedestrians or cyclists at the actual street they're turning into.
- tomohawk 5y agoNew Jersey has eliminated most left turns, especially on major roads. What happens when you add NJ and SF together? More flight to other states?
- agilob 5y agoIn a lot of delivery companies drivers are forbidden (or discouraged) to turn through oncoming traffic, I knew that about RoyalMail and DHL, but here is an article about UPS: >UPS have moved away from trying to find the shortest route and now look at other criteria to optimise the journey. One of their methods is to try and avoid turning through oncoming traffic at a junction. Although this might be going in the opposite direction of the final destination, it reduces the chances of an accident and cuts delays caused by waiting for a gap in the traffic, which would also waste fuel. https://theconversation.com/why-ups-drivers-dont-turn-left-and-you-probably-shouldnt-either-71432 https://theconversation.com/why-ups-drivers-dont-turn-left-a...
- pindab0ter 5y agoI don’t understand why oncoming traffic and pedestrians all have a green light the same time as when you’re green for a left hand turn. Here in the Netherlands almost all traffic light intersections are set up so that when you’ve got green you’re good to go unless specifically indicated otherwise by signs. Not to mention roundabouts completely bypass this problem, though those might not have the traffic throughput needed in a city centre.
- mig39 5y agoThis is a solved problem. Roundabouts. Even when accidents happen in Roundabouts, they're generally not "T-bones" or hitting vehicles at 90º or head-on. They're more glancing-typing collisions. Much safer.
- SkeuomorphicBee 5y agoOr even better, just ban left turns. Forcing drivers to take 3 right turns is such a simple solution, I don't understand why Americans don't adopt it everywhere.
- StillBored 5y agoAnd Michigan lefts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left
- mig39 5y agoVery cool! Almost like a mini clover-leaf?
- mazugrin2 5y agoRoundabouts are great for roads between towns and cities and other population centers. But urban streets where lots of people are walking should be designed for pedestrians first, not cars. Roundabouts are actually quite complicated for pedestrians to traverse safely.
- filereaper 5y agoTo any Product Manager or developer working on Android Auto, CarPlay or Waze. Please add a "Avoid left turns, unless they're protected" option! It'll save lives and reduce overall stress for drivers!
- garaetjjte 5y agoBack in times of WinCE navigation devices, there were many route settings like Easy/Short/Fast which presumably modified pathfinder weights. It seems they disappeared with GMaps and other smartphone apps.
- tzs 5y agoWhat percent are on right turns?
- azinman2 5y agoIt's been well recorded that something like 70% of motorcycle fatalities are left-hand turns. I don't think this is somehow endemic to SF versus other cities.
- frankus 5y agoEven when they have a dedicated signal and plenty of time, I'm surprised at how terrible most drivers are at turning left (US/Canada perspective here). The standard approach seems to be, as soon as they enter the intersection, to point their car at the lane they're heading into, and then at the last second attempt to correct the fact that they're entering that lane diagonally. That usually means either cutting the corner of the oncoming lane or swerving into the adjacent lane/bike lane/shoulder (or both). This is easily remedied by proceeding straight into the intersection for roughly a car length before starting the turn. This lets you maintain a roughly constant turning radius and sets you up to enter the destination lane more or less straight-on. A bonus is that it's safer (it's easier to see people in the crosswalk) and more comfortable (than the sudden-jerk-at-the-end-of-the-turn that the typical maneuver requires).
- TheMagicHorsey 5y agoAs bad as the traffic fatalities are in SF, I hope the city also puts a similar amount of thought and care into crime prevention. That and outdoor defecation are the two most visible things effecting quality of life in SOMA.
- forthwall 5y agoI recall many years ago that I had almost been run over by a police officer in the bay area making a left turn too short (and drove into the left lane of oncoming traffic). My bicycle was destroyed but fortunately I had survived unscathed. I've noticed unless there's a car in a left lane, drivers often will cut into the oncoming left lane to prevent going too far right. I think it would be beneficial to add some sort of bollard between lanes so cars do not overcorrect, and could save lives from that implicit blindspot.
- talideon 5y agoMy first time in SF was... interesting. Where I'm from (Ireland), a red means stop, not "only stop if you might be driving into traffic", which is what it seems to boil down to in the US. Let's just say I got a _nasty_ surprise when I discovered turns on red were a thing. It's without a doubt one of the most pedestrian unfriendly bits of law I've come across.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- invisible 5y agoGiven that there is a light and camera at many intersections where this would occur, would it be feasible for us to have some indicator if a human is in the crosswalk? We have cars that are able to detect many different types of objects in far more complex environments.
- perl4ever 5y agoSo why can't Google Maps eliminate stupid left turns from its vehicle directions? If they have information on traffic lights, then they could stop telling people to make a left out of a side street where there's no light. But if that's too difficult, they could just have an option for making routes with only right turns, like it's rumored delivery companies do. I was so hopeful that somewhere in the depths of their Maps API there was a way to customize the routing logic, but it appears not. Google knows best.
- jamesmontalvo3 5y agoWhat percentage come from right turns? Is it less than a third of ledt turns, and thus three right turns is safer than one left? Probably more efficient: should map software offer a “limit left turns” option?
- Someone 5y agoFTA: “40% of SF traffic fatalities in 2019 involved drivers making left turns who didn’t see the person in the crosswalk until it was too late.” If there are traffic lights, there should not be anybody on those crosswalks. Neither should there be “incoming traffic, including bicyclists”. Good junction/traffic light design avoids having streams of traffic crossing each other (“conflict free intersections”). See https://beyondtheautomobile.com/2020/08/11/signals-for-change/ https://beyondtheautomobile.com/2020/08/11/signals-for-chang... and the (linked from there) video https://youtube.com/watch?v=knbVWXzL4-4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=knbVWXzL4-4
- guerrilla 5y agoI wonder if you could replace most of these with roundabouts...
- dnautics 5y agoWouldn't we expect, say, 40% left turn, 40% right turn, 20% head on?
- forix 5y agoNot surprising. Anecdotal, but I was once hit by a cab while crossing the street. They were making a left turn. Yes, it was 2AM and I was wearing dark clothes but still, there was plenty of light at that intersection and it's not like I jumped out of nowhere (I had already walked more than halfway across the street before I was suddenly on the car's hood and then of course on the asphalt). Luckily for me I didn't suffer any injuries (that I know of).
- apexalpha 5y agoI don't really understand the video on the site. Why would pedestrians have a green light when left turning cars also have a green light? surely the entire concept of traffic lights exists so that you DON'T cross each other?
- ksec 5y agoWould the studies have the same results in Right hand drive countries?
- derekpankaew 5y agoThis website makes me really dizzy. It scrolls horizontally and diagonally as you scroll down?