25 ms·
Boards are dangerous to founder/CEOs
- andrewstuart 5y agoThat's one of the most useful, practical, open and realistic advice pieces I've read.
- vmception 5y agowhen you get thrown off of the board you still have your shares. so the trade is still successful by my rubric. I consider all things to be trades, whether I invested in a publicly traded equity, or whether I created a bunch of $0.00 par value shares to sell to a bunch of other people. the rule is the same: don't get married to a company. a board removing you doesn't need any fanfare. you still have the shares.
- bgroat 5y agoHeadline - I agree with you. Just retire, or do something else. You own the shares. Fine Print: There's still some screwy stuff they can do diluting your shares in particular.
- icedchai 5y ago"Just retire"... that may be difficult without liquidity, regardless of value of the shares.
- adventured 5y ago> There's still some screwy stuff they can do diluting your shares in particular. And they also may run the company you founded into the ground by selecting a mediocre replacement (who will surround theirself with mediocre managers), making your shares potentially worthless in the end.
- elliekelly 5y agoAnd often it’s not about a financial bruise so much as the ego/emotional bruise. Losing control is not a comfortable feeling for the CEO-type.
- vmception 5y agowhich is why my point carries weight: don't get married to the company/project/IP anything go in with a precision strike and leave. don't stay for 20 years and act surprised when the Taliban takes over the board again in 10 days. leave that to the disillusioned employees and sycophants. yourself and the external contractors extracted generational wealth for decades. and if you didn't nobody to blame but yourself.
- withinboredom 5y agoCan you have a single share that is always * X of the summed voting rights of other shares, so no matter how many shares they print, you just get more votes?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 5y agoSee also "cram-down round" :-)
- robocat 5y agoGood definition for it and similar terms: https://web.stanford.edu/class/e145/2007_fall/materials/CurtisMo.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/class/e145/2007_fall/materials/Curt...
- onion2k 5y agoa board removing you doesn't need any fanfare. you still have the shares. You do, but there isn't always a secondary market to sell them on, and if you leave under a really bad cloud the board will attempt to take the shares back, or issue a bunch more for themselves thus diluting your shares in to oblivion (see Eduardo Savauvin vs Facebook for details.) I don't think you should make light of leaving "with your shares" as if that's the end of the story. It might not be.
- School-Cotton 5y agoEduardo Saverin sued Facebook for doing that and is now worth $20 billion.
- onion2k 5y agoThat's brilliant, of course, but he owned 30% before being kicked out which would be a little over $300bn now.
- PeterCorless 5y agoThis is a very self-centered "I got mine" view. Think more broadly: What did you do to the valuation and perception of your company? What have you done to the value of everyone's shares, including your own? If you keep a role at the company, how will it be working with your team now that they see your position reduced? If you are walked out of the company without ceremony, what balls were in the air that aren't going to be caught? Who did you just leave in the lurch? So will those shares be worth anything if you were phoning it in rather than focusing on your CEO performance, or successfully trying to navigate the CEO-to-other-role transition? Will your competition smell blood in the water and try to cast FUD in the face of your current customers and all future prospects? What will your reputation be going forward? ("He was a difficult person to work with. We had to fire him.") So sure, you may have your short-term gains in your stocks. But what will it do to your career? And the careers of everyone who had followed you to that point? This article was very well-meaning. I just have a feeling that all-too-many short-term thinking people are going to follow your advice and say, "Well, to hell with it. At least I got mine."
- notreallyserio 5y agoIf I'm fired I'm not the one leaving anyone in the lurch. I don't understand.
- icedchai 5y agoSure, but it might not matter. Your company can be in such a bad state that the next round, if it happens, will massively dilute everyone, including you. You wind up owning less than 10% of a sinking ship. I've seen it happen. (And if you don't take that money, your company goes to zero.)
- boringg 5y agoYou still have shares but they may dilute you to nothing.
- Invictus0 5y agoGreat article, I really enjoyed everything about this piece. Nice insight into the realities of the boardroom.
- throwaway55421 5y agoIf you give up your 51% share, sure.
- gogopuppygogo 5y agoIf you give up control. Weighted shares let a minority shareholder have more than controlling vote in a company. It is always important to understand the fabric of your company by reading, understanding, and following the terms of your Operating Agreement or Corporate ByLaws. Manager Managed LLC vs Member Managed LLC vs C or S Corporation are most common entity types. Use the right structure to best protect your interests.
- onion2k 5y ago51% isn't quite right. For a start, it's really "more than 50%", which is often 50% + 1 share, but in some structures there are different classes of shares with different voting rights. It's common to have a pool of voting shares that are issued to founders and preferred investors, and then non-voting shares that are issued to everyone else. There can also be shares that confer more than 1 vote to the owner. You really need > 50% of the votes rather than any particular amount of shares.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> 51% isn't quite right. For a start, it's really "more than 50%", which is often 50% + 1 share Most people describe "50% + 1" as 51% even though its not quite right, but everyone understands 51% as a shorthand for "greater than half, not inclusive of half". Eg. a 51% attack on a crypto network is the same way.
- Jugurtha 5y ago>It's common to have a pool of voting shares that are issued to founders and preferred investors, and then non-voting shares that are issued to everyone else. To your point about differences in classes, there may be a class with 10 votes per share, another class with 1 vote per share, and another class with 0 vote per share.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago
- ChuckMcM 5y agoThis is something you should really understand if you're starting a company. The board isn't your "friend" while individual board members may be, as an entity it probably isn't. The understanding that individuals can be "good" and the composite can be "bad" is usually encountered by most people when some government is doing something "bad" but the people who live where that government is in power are known to be "good." We see a lot of companies that have "good" employees but act in a "bad" way as a company. So with that in mind, you have to understand that none of your "friends" would fire you, but the "board of directors" (even if composed of people you consider friends) could easily decide to do that. Tom Lyon used to joke that it was only on your third startup that you funded yourself that you are really in control. The wisdom of that took a while to sink in for me.
- anthropodie 5y ago“A group experience takes place on a lower level of consciousness than the experience of an individual. This is due to the fact that, when many people gather together to share one common emotion, the total psyche emerging from the group is below the level of the individual psyche. If it is a very large group, the collective psyche will be more like the psyche of an animal, which is the reason why the ethical attitude of large organizations is always doubtful. The psychology of a large crowd inevitably sinks to the level of mob psychology. If, therefore, I have a so-called collective experience as a member of a group, it takes place on a lower level of consciousness than if I had the experience by myself alone.” - Carl Jung
- mattkevan 5y ago“The intelligence of the creature known as a crowd, is the square root of the number of people in it.” - Terry Pratchett
- lostcolony 5y agoAlso Pratchett, and mathematically probably more accurate (decreasing rather than increasing with the more people added) - "the IQ of a mob is the IQ of its most stupid member divided by the number of mobsters"
- kristoff_it 5y agoSimilar advice applies also to Open Source non-profit foundations, in my opinion :^)
- goldenkey 5y agoRelevant: [I refuse to let Amazon define Rust]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28513130 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28513130
- 0des 5y agoIt may be gauche to express this opinion on HN of all places and I hope it doesn't come off as tonedeaf disrespect, but does anybody notice VC is falling out of favor unless absolutely necessary? I am noticing a lot of bootstrappers that are emerging with the ethos that VC isn't what it used to be for some markets, and often a poor choice of the right VC can be a detriment to a project's longevity, with some teams choosing to avoid it at all costs.
- claytonjy 5y agoI've noticed the same though I don't know what the split is; still lots of VC companies, and more companies of all flavors being started right now. I've also seen some late stage cos raise a mix of equity and debt at favorable terms; is that becoming more common as part of the same phenomenon?
- lumost 5y agoRates are low, its preferable to raise debt than a dilutive round for existing investors. Companies that are locked into a prisoners dilemma for spending/market share need to get creative with how they finance their spending.
- dangrossman 5y agoI don't think that's a new sentiment around here. Anything published by 37Signals and its founders used to be mandatory reading on HN, and they were all about small teams eschewing outside investors. Their Getting Real book was published in 2006.
- StriverGuy 5y agoInteresting you avoided calling them basecamp given the recent media fallout. Not saying you did it intentionally, but just rare anyone refers to them as 37Signals much anymore.
- dangrossman 5y ago
- staunch 5y agoSelling equity is one thing. Selling control is another. When the founders have control, they're the leaders and directors have to follow. When the directors have control, they lead and the founders have to follow. Generally, founders are more successful leaders of their own companies.
- bluGill 5y ago> Generally, founders are more successful leaders of their own companies. Is that just because bad companies remove their founders in a last ditch effort to survive? Is that because bad founders can screw the company before they are removed?
- staunch 5y agoFounders are the ones with the experience, skills, and knowledge to lead the companies they create. Generally, VCs are equity portfolio managers and not qualified to lead a company. Even when they are successful founders themselves, they're almost never the right people to lead another founder's startup.
- loudthing 5y agoReading this title gave me a headache.
- daenz 5y agoI'm happy and appreciative that this advice exists, but as a tech person who just wants to build new things, it makes running a company sound like a massive drain on the psyche.
- nickff 5y agoRunning a company is a massive drain, and is not the best way to 'build new things'. Starting and running a company is one of the best ways to 'build a new organization'.
- dqpb 5y agoYou can always choose not to take on investments that relinquish your control.
- bluGill 5y agoThere is a reason I "work for the man" instead of run my own company. I could make money, but I wouldn't be a programmer. It took me almost 20 years of a CS degree before I was earning more money programming than I could have earned if I had dropped out of school and stayed at McDonald's (they offered me a management job and the career path in the direction was obvious - and also why most people even on that track decide to self limit before they reach the highest I could see from there.) To make it clear, if you found a company you MUST be a management type person. You can maybe program 25% of the time, but the rest of your time is sales and management duties. You can hire out the sales but that means more management. Soon you are best off hiring out the programming as well and being all management.
- repomies69 5y agoThere's tons of different companies, VC-funded high-growth startups are just a small subset of all companies. If you want to do programming in your own company you can set up some boutique working on some niche. Absolutely no need to be "a management type person" in my opinion. It certainly is possible to run company where you do up to 80% programming IMO. But, if you want the big bucks it typicalle makes sense to hire and grow. If you want to stay small and do stuff yourself, it means less money.
- 4monthsaway 5y agoI like this article, nice to see this type of advice without all the usual fluff
- rsweeney21 5y agoI always thought stuff like this happened to OTHER founders, but would never happen to me. But my board fired me six months after closing our series A. The advice in this article is 100% spot on. I didn't know any of this. I was totally focused on building my company. But if you raise money you can't do that anymore. 50% of your time will always be occupied with working on your next round of funding or managing your board of directors. I noticed super early that VCs were not "helpful" at all like they had claimed during the fundraising process. So I got fired, and I thought, "well, at least I still have my founders stock!" Then a year after I got fired the series A investor led the next round of funding and decided to value the company at $0, so I got diluted by 99.99%. Sounds illegal, right? Well, it probably was, but what am I going to do about it? They have billions of dollars and I had no money. I just let it go and started something new - bootstrapping of course. On the bright side, the new CEO ran the company into the ground. Meanwhile my new company is doing well and I love my job. Anyway, do what this guy says to manage your board and just plan on being fired at some point if you raise VC money.
- gonehome 5y agoCan’t you structure things like Zuckerberg or Palantir and just have the founder retain unilateral company control?
- pfarrell 5y agoSure... If your company is so attractive that the investors will go along with it. IMHO, Facebook's history is an outlier. Most startups aren't positioned with the leverage they had when raising money. I don't know enough about Palantir's history to comment.
- hinkley 5y agoWhen the orders of magnitude change, so does the correct solution. In other words: Stop comparing your startup to FAANG. You are not FAANG. If you were, everyone else would know it. Since you aren't, their strategies don't work for you.
- Digory 5y agoNever stand between people and a pile of money. Your Board doesn't fire you when you're the best guide to a pile of money. Your Board will fire you if they think you're slowing their progress toward a pile of money. If you think your skills as a guide to piles of money are imperfect, don't put your life in the hands of people who need you to rapidly increase their pile of money.
- repomies69 5y agoActually, the board has to believe that the replacement CEO they find from the market, will generate better returns than the current CEO. So, it is not that the CEO has to be "the best", it has to be good enough so that if he is fired, the likelihood of the new one succeeding should be lower than with him. Note that there should be quite many advantages for the current CEO to do the job well compared to some external guy. Typically it might take 2 years from a new CEO to learn the business, etc. Boards don't fire on a whim, they genuinely have to believe that a replacement will do clearly better job - they don't want to go through all the hassle of finding a replacement just for fun.
- robocat 5y agoThe VC cares about their portfolio, so if removing the CEO gives gains elsewhere in their portfolio, then their financial incentive can be against the startup. Edit: also the financial incentives of the most influential board member might not be aligned with the company valuation. Or the “nobody gets fired for buying IBM” theory where it is better to put in a known respected CEO (John Sculley), because fault can be blamed on the founder and LPs will believe the future VC spin. Usually the startup is one of the failing investments to consider changing CEOs, and I suspect that there are a lot of other human motivations that come into it.
- repomies69 5y agoThat is true, but I don't see how firing the CEO typically would give gains somewhere else in the portfolio. For example VC's very rarely invest in competing companies. However what affects the situation is that VC's want a lot of risk, and the risk preferences of the CEO could be considerably lower - eg. the CEO would be fine with moderately profitable company, while the VC wants all or nothing. I don't think it is common to change CEO's for truly successful companies which actually show good numbers. No one wants to change the CEO, they do it because they think that it clearly increases their possible returns so they basically have to do it because otherwise they would look incompetent as board members.
- extr 5y agoWhat an article. It's rare you find something that has such practical and straightforward advice for managing people (even if those people are your board members).
- flenserboy 5y ago1. Avoid going public if at all possible. 2. Avoid outside investors if at all possible. 3. Avoid having a board if at all possible. 4. Control the shares or the shares will control you.
- szundi 5y agoStep one on this road: and you suddenly found a pendrive with 100kpcs of BTC.
- _qzu4 5y ago> 1. Avoid going public if at all possible. This is basically what Bloomberg has done. Despite selling financial terminals to bank traders, the company still hasn't gone public after all these years.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoValve as well. I believe they also have the highest profitability/employee ratio of American companies.
- bluGill 5y agoThat isn't always good advice. Often the money from going public is required to make it. You either go public, or someone else will take your idea, go public and use the money from it to eat your lunch and then you get nothing. Good ideas are easy. Unique good ideas are so rare as to be non-existent. Nearly all good ideas are obvious to anyone who knows the field and what can be done.
- streetcat1 5y agoThe market today is so big that many competitors can live side by side . At least in B2B. I mean there are hundreds of CRM companies. You can have other companies eat your lunch. All you need is to get into a default alive state. I.e. have 5-10K MRR. The rest is nice to have. It should be possible in any billion dollar market.
- w0mbat 5y agoSurely the author meant, "Your Board of Directors Will Probably Fire You', or some other statement that makes sense in English. I know the horrible grammar comes from the original article.
- Kaizeras 5y agoThis brings memories. I also got „asked to leave“ after raising our first round. I was young (25) and naive, with no experience in business within the family. But what was really crucial back then was that I lacked a mentor who’d make me aware of the risks before letting the sharks in. It took me three years to bounce back and start something new. On the positive side, I learned a lot.
- cutemonster 5y ago> It took me three years to bounce back What happened with the first company? I wonder if you made any money from it in the end, if maybe they sold it and you hadn't been diluted to much > I also got „asked to leave“ Could they force you, by having more votes? Or were they just very persuasive and convincing
- qaq 5y agoSo with crowdfunding cap now at 5 mil. in US sounds like a good way to avoid this whole thing?
- ryanSrich 5y agoIf you can crowdfund to $5m then yes. I’m guessing that’s orders of magnitude harder for something like a B2B SaaS business than raising traditional VC though.
- qaq 5y agoThats actually a good question given the paper overhead non-accredited investors prob. don't get access to any decent opportunities.
- ilamont 5y agoBoards are necessary too Are they? I've run my own company without a board for 9 years (bootstrapped) and several friends who were CEOs of funded companies had board-driven horror stories ranging from getting the boot to forcing dissolution of the company.
- bluGill 5y agoIn many cases the law requires it. Check with your lawyer to see if this applies to you. Even if it doesn't apply, it is useful to get outside advice. The hard part is getting good advice. Boards should do this, but as the article points out, they rarely do.
- ilamont 5y agoI've been on nonprofit boards in the past, and we really did play important roles on advice and some tactical activities related to committees. But the incentives were completely different.
- kelnos 5y agoThey're necessary if you want to take on funding. It's hard to imagine VCs agreeing to give you money without you agreeing to have a board. I'm sure there are rare exceptions, but they're just that: rare exceptions.
- ghc 5y agoThat's not really true until an equity round these days. Companies who raise seed rounds on SAFEs and notes often avoid having a board. In the portfolio of my firm, that situation accounts for just over half of the initial seed investments we've made in the past five years. Forming a board is an investment from both sides. It takes a lot of work to be a director or even an observer. At the earliest stages (pre-A) VCs are much more willing to keep it informal and avoid the distraction.
- ksdale 5y agoOnce upon a time, I helped a group of friends start a company, and as we were going over the parts of the LLC agreement that outlined what would happen if the company dissolved as part of a fight, the entire group treated me like I was ridiculous for suggesting that they would get in a fight. I told them that if they were planning on staying friends forever, they didn't even need the LLC agreement, they could just promise to treat each other fairly. The company imploded amidst a massive falling out something like a year later...
- mooreds 5y agoPlan for the divorce during the honeymoon. Then put the agreement in the safe. Two outcomes: * everything goes swimmingly: you've wasted a bit of time and paper * everything does not go well: hard decisions are already made Before I co-founded a startup, I read the Nolo books on partnerships, especially the parts about dissolving them fairly. The details differ slightly if you have an LLC, C corp etc (as long as it is private) but the overarching themes are the same and so so important to consider.
- system16 5y agoReading things like this and how common it is for investors to take over, I just wonder how it is possible that a young - and presumably naive - Mark Zuckerberg avoided the typical VC pitfalls and board guillotine / "CEO replaces themselves to help transition company to the next level" path? Was it just because Facebook's growth was so unprecedented they had no need to replace him? Or did he have a very good mentor or early investors that believed in him or helped guide him without taking advantage of the situation? Or was he actually just extremely shrewd at navigating board politics?
- fezzez 5y agoHe had leverage. Facebook's massive growth meant that he could command the terms of the investment, and he ensured that he would always continue to control the board even as he was being diluted with later rounds.
- thethimble 5y agoSee the “dual class” structure he managed to set up early on to preserve control. https://www.vox.com/technology/2018/11/19/18099011/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-stock-nyt-wsj https://www.vox.com/technology/2018/11/19/18099011/mark-zuck... This was made popular by Larry and Sergey in 2012: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312512160666/d333341dex993.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312512... It’s really only possible if the company/investment is so compelling that investors will invest with virtually no control.
- repomies69 5y agoIf the company makes money, there is very little reason to fire the CEO. In fact pretty much the opposite, there are probably CEOs that would deserve to be fired for multiple reasons, but because the company makes good money, the board won't care. The board is responsible towards the owners, if they actually fire a CEO of a performant company, they really have to show why it was in the best interest of the owner. All these stories where the CEOs were fired are from companies that weren't profitable, needed constant funding rounds etc. In the situation where the company is just sucking money from investors the CEO gets changed easily.
- cm2012 5y agoWhat an incredible essay. Top 5 I've ever read in insight.
- gumby 5y ago> founder often gets to write a press release about how they replaced themselves with someone better suited to take the company to the next level or something like that. This is so common that when I have replaced myself I’ve had friends “comfort” me thinking I really was fired. In my life I’ve been fired once, though I should not have been. I have also not been fired in two cases where I should have been (early in my career).
- thrower123 5y agoAfter all these years I still don't understand the rules about replacing the real titles of articles with an editorialized version
- Waterluvian 5y ago“ They will each feel like your special confidant. They will also see the other board members reacting calmly to the news and start to think that perhaps you actually have it under control. This will calm them down in the future.” This seems like obviously good advice. But also begins bordering on what feels like manipulation. And that makes me uncomfortable. In fact, this whole thing feels like manipulation. If nothing happens in a board meeting because it’s scripted, why do they exist? It seems like the solution to not getting fired as CEO is to control the whole thing and manipulate everyone.
- gilbetron 5y agoFrom the article: "All this may sound cynical or manipulative. It probably also sounds like a lot of work. It is all of these." It's literally the point of the article.
- jyscao 5y ago>If nothing happens in a board meeting because it’s scripted, why do they exist? He actually answers that later on. >Of course, you have already told them all this on the phone, one by one, so you know how they will react. They will want to talk anyway, because part of the meeting is them performing for each other, but, again, no surprises. Except instead of only "part of the meeting", perhaps it might even be more fitting to say "most of the meeting". Edit: and also this "Board members show up at meetings to monitor their investment and decide if they still want you to be CEO."
- shard 5y agoFor anyone not aware, this method of discussing individually with stakeholders ahead of time before any decision or approval meetings is a common way to make the meetings go smoothly. Stakeholders won't be surprised by any items you bring up, you won't be surprised by anything they bring up and can address issues ahead of time, nobody will be embarrassed at the meeting (you really don't want to surprise a VP with some fact which might be construed as his team not performing well, especially in front of other VPs), and everyone will be able to see that everyone else agrees with the conclusions of the meeting.
- 0des 5y agoThe article itself is titled "Your Board of Directors is Probably Going to Fire You", why has the title of the post just now changed?
- wpietri 5y agoOoh, this is spot on. > The fact that early-stage founders continue to take their money has to be some sort of delusional grandiosity, in my humble opinion. “Well yes, they fire half the CEOs they back, but surely not me.” Having started companies, delusional grandiosity is almost a requirement, especially if you're going to take venture capital. I mean, just look at the odds. So it makes perfect sense to me that the VCs happily take advantage of it.
- ryanSrich 5y agoI think you have to weigh the options though. On one hand, you have a 50% chance of being fired. On the other hand, you’re raising from Sequoia. Is raising from Sequoia going to change the direction of your company so much (in a positive) direction that it’s worth taking on the 50% chance you’ll be fired?
- GoatOfAplomb 5y agoThe meeting management tactics in this post are highly applicable in other situations as well, whenever you are presenting to a group of approvers/overseers. For me, that's launch reviews or program reviews. It takes a lot of time, but a smooth review pays it back many times over.
- Davidbrcz 5y agoIt felt like reading a tutorial for handling vassals in crusader kings.
- itronitron 5y agoI worked for a startup for several years, as the fifth hired software developer and got to see our CEO fired within the first eighteen months. They were not the founder, but they had hired the VP of Sales and the entire sales team who were also all let go on the same day. Luckily the core product wasn't impacted and our primary clients probably didn't care. The company hired two more CEOs over the next three years, each of which lasted less than six months. I'm not convinced that the new CEOs ever actually did anything, although that is possibly due to the board running interference. My two takeaways from this experience are that if you are a founder you don't want to be CEO, and CEOs are basically useless.
- sombremesa 5y agoMaybe the reason these CEOs were all let go was because they were useless?
- stanislavb 5y agoBootstrap or get fired...
- wkimeria 5y agoThis article is absolutely terrific. I think this advice can be used for any type of high stakes meeting at work.
- jedimastert 5y agoI'm reminded of CGPGrey's video: the Rules for Rulers https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs
- snowwrestler 5y agoI’ve got an opinion that may not be a majority here. And I can see how it could go wrong sometimes, especially from the perspective of a founder CEO. But, IMO boards should be dangerous to CEOs. In the long run it is good, and in some cases necessary, for a company’s long-term health. There are tons of examples where a CEO change was necessary to resolve distractions, right the corporate ship, and allow a company to pass through a crisis into a new period of growth. And whether the CEO resigns or is literally fired, the locus of pressure is almost always the board’s power to fire them. Imagine being CEO without that—you’re in charge of everything, with no accountability or consequences for anything. There is no way to maintain perspective and focus over time. Everyone wants to please you or at least avoid your displeasure. The company gets distorted over time by your personal preferences and preoccupations. I would argue this is the core of the problem at Facebook. That company would be much better off if there was a way to change leadership there, or at least threaten to.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoGreat read & certainly seems like sound advice. Also, the author seems like a fun individual
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Alexander25 5y agoThanks to this article I can learn more. Expand my knowledge and abilities. Actually the article is very real. https://www.toysruscreditcard.org/ https://www.toysruscreditcard.org/
- ubermonkey 5y agoWhat's interesting is this, which speaks to a level of entitlement that's kind of bonkers: "I imagine you believe that the decision to stop being CEO of the company you started should be your decision, not someone else’s. But the fact is, it often isn’t. Often, it is the board of directors’ decision." The CEO serves at the pleasure of the shareholders. If the founder wishes to maintain control until he or she decides to walk away, there is a very simple choice that will absolutely ensure this: maintain control of 51% of the voting shares. The interests of the owners of a firm trump the interests of an employee of the firm. A minority-shareholder founder-CEO is an employee with equity, and can absolutely be fired. The tl;dr is that if you dilute your ownership, you're not in control anymore. This is often part of the deal. But don't act like it's some huge injustice. It's literally the deal the you made.
- neycoda 5y agoThe world's all about greed now, and the higher up and abstracted out the people are from the passion of the company's founder, the more the more they're going to fuck everyone over for a shark bite. We're just brilliant animals at this point.
- mst 5y ago> The advice here is pretty basic: nothing happens in your board meeting. Your board meeting is scripted. The board members should have seen the information presented before the meeting (and not just because you sent the deck—half of them won’t read it beforehand—you must talk to them.) And you should know beforehand how each board member will react to the information presented. If there are decisions to be made, you already know how each board member will decide, because you told them about the decision to be made and they told you what they will decide. No surprises This is, honestly, how one should aim for pretty much any -formal- meeting to run - as a high trust means to make a pre-existing consensus common knowledge to all the participants. (things like design brainstorms are a completely different category, hence the 'formal' qualifier to try and make that clear)
- cutemonster 5y agoHmm it'd be interesting with a list of all meeting types, and their intended outcomes, and if scripted or not
- cannabis_sam 5y agoBoards themselves have conclusively proven to be extremely dangerous to all of society, not just founders, since it’s dominated by CEOs deciding the salary of other CEOs… Adam Smith literally warned against this two fucking centuries ago: > People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices. We are all paying a double price, first for insanely inflated executive salaries and second since us normal workers actually have to face the consequences of a business going down, while the CEO, who’s actually responsible for the destruction of the company, drifts of on their golden parachute to a new executive position.
- sirspacey 5y agoStellar advice and completely agree. My Series A was freshly inked and six months later I was removed. The company’s fundamentals never improved and the company was later acquired-hired. Here’s the question to ask yourself as a founder: What am I doing all this work for? There is only one job an investor board member has - to enable you to raise the next round. All their advice boils down to that. Yet the most common case is that an unknown investor will lead your next round, not your current. So all this massive overhead on your time & attention is just the cost of capital. Your team needs you. Your customers need you. Your mission needs you. Your investors do not need you. They just need an outcome. Even this article is tame. I routinely hear that board members do not read prep materials, fail to understand how the business is evolving, and pontificate. It’s a living nightmare when time is of the essence. Read Blueprint to a Billion. Companies with too many investor seats die.