19 ms·
The ER charged him $6,589.77 for 6 stitches, cost that led his wife to avoid ER
- causi 5y agoSomehow everybody in this system claims they're not the ones making bank on this swindling. The doctors say they're underpaid. The hospital admin says they're underpaid. The insurance companies say they're barely covering their payouts. So who is lying?
- praptak 5y agoYou missed this part: "Both the physicians and the hospital are part of companies recently taken over by private-equity investors."
- blackhaz 5y agoSome people somewhere, with cigars, in $5,000 suits. "Look at all those schmucks! $400 per shot and $1,000 per stitch." The whole healthcare system needs to be regulated by the government end-to-end. All procurement must be transparent. Every cent traced. Pharma mafia dismantled - on a federal level.
- smabie 5y agoWho are these people? Where are they? Not really convinced they exist.
- donatj 5y agoThey don’t exist. They’re the imagined scapegoat for what is actually just a much harder to comprehend creeping bureaucracy cost. The human mind loves clear enemies but Hanlon’s Razor almost always applies. Almost no one ever actually has malicious intent, but our brain evolved to watch for enemies and loves seeing patterns where they aren’t.
- LightG 5y agoCool story. So what you're saying is there is an horrendous creeping bueaucracy cost here. Funny, because that's exactly what free market proponents argue is the cause of inefficiency in publicly managed healthcare systems, and the reason to move towards models based on the US system. Someone is lying.
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe costs are more diffuse than this. First, the U.S. system costs twice as much as other systems because we have more people employed delivering care and they make higher salaries. Doctors, nurses, they all make more in the U.S. than in Europe. So more people, getting paid higher wage, results in double the costs. But wait, the financing in the U.S. is quite predatory, so a lot of people pay nothing, and a few people are stuck with outrageous bills. It's like the infamous SF General Hospital that offered loads of free care to the poor and to immigrants and then refused to take any insurance so that normal people were regularly driven to bankruptcy if the ambulence took them there. The U.S. healthcare is one in which a half a million is spent on emergency care for an indigent person and 10 middle class families lose their life savings of 50K treating snakebites and broken arms. Once you wrap your head around this, you'll understand we have a very similar problem in higher education, and for very similar reasons.
- LightG 5y agoOk, I'll take all of that at face value and as given. It just sounds completely broken over there and I'm not sure I will manage to wrap my head around it. All I know is simpler systems around the world exist and work such that those 10 middle class families would never get stiffed like that, whilst also looking after the needy. I can't fathom it.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> It just sounds completely broken over there and I'm not sure I will manage to wrap my head around it. Agreed. But that's the way it is, and it's important to understand why it's this way. When Europe and Australia adopted national healthcare systems, the industry was ~3-5% of GDP. So at that point it wasn't politically strong enough to resist either nationalization or strict controls. Then healthcare mushroomed in size, being ~10% of GDP in Europe and 20% of GDP in the U.S. So now, when you try to do the politics that the europeans did, it doesn't work. The industry is too powerful. Merely blaming the US for not doing what Europe did misses this essential point. There are millions of nurses, lab techs, administrators, and doctors, and they have money and they vote. So the left keeps looking for some villain -- greedy insurance executives, Wall Street, Evil Billionaires, etc. And basically refuses to understand that these are not the ones standing in the way of reform. It's the 13% of our labor force that earns 20% of national income, and these are not the same easy targets that the left can attack, because they are a large portion of the US middle class, and are core Democratic constituencies. That's why healthcare reform in the U.S. always focuses on having the government pay some of the costs charged to consumers rather then reducing the costs of providing healthcare. E.g. more subsidies for this bloated industry, which only results in costs rising even more, and then calls for even more subsidies when people can't afford to pay the costs. When what we should do is fire 50% of the staff and cut the pay of those that remain by another 50%. That's the only way to get affordable healthcare. And you have a similar problem with higher ed.
- LightG 5y agoOwners, private equity firms, VC's ... whoever is the ultimate lever in this arena. It's not hard.
- tartoran 5y agoYep, wallstreet is heavily invested in this space. People fail to connect the dots.
- alistairSH 5y agoWhoever categorized the subject’s stitches as a Level 4 trauma, for starters. That was damn near fraudulent.
- praptak 5y ago"Both the physicians and the hospital are part of companies recently taken over by private-equity investors."
- blackhaz 5y agoThese people are rarely public, you don't even need to know they exist. They exist behind the figures we see on the TV. Where there is money and a chance of corruption, they definitely exist.
- yardie 5y agoThe hospital admins are lying. Doctors will go through a billing agency who can charge whatever they want. The doctor might not know, but would be naive to believe it’s not expensive.
- otagekki 5y agoThe hospital and the doctors. Almost $500 for a tetanus shot is simply not justifiable
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe doctors likely have nothing to do with how much procedures bill for. In private practice outside a hospital, they perhaps have more guilt here, but in an ER? They set the prices about as much as the janitors do.
- CalChris 5y agoDoctors are acutely aware of how much which procedures bill for.
- otagekki 5y agoYet they still charged roughly $2,000 for a single patient and that is something that did not take the whole day. If I was a physician I'd be happy if I could bill half that amount even if it took me the whole day to treat the patient
- legutierr 5y agoI've had doctors in the ER bill directly out of their own practice several times. Out of network, but I've had no choice in the matter except to receive treatment or refuse treatment for life-threatening conditions. The law here has changed since then to prohibit this kind of thing, though.
- learc83 5y agoIn the case where an ER doctor isn’t employed by the hospital, they are likely employed by a physicians’s group. These used to be ran by physicians, but now many of them have been bought up and consolidated by private equity. The doctors likely have very little say in the pricing.
- legutierr 5y ago
- throw8636363738 5y agoAll of them
- masklinn 5y ago> The hospital admin says they're underpaid. The insurance companies say they're barely covering their payouts. So who is lying? Insurance companies are definitely lying (their execs are paid tens of millions) though it should be noted that the US system greatly limits the ability to spread insurance payments on health populations, so it makes sense that the population using medical services is a larger share of the insured population, and thus has to pay more. Anyway more generally the administrative overhead of US healthcare is absolutely enormous e.g. as of 2017[0] it was almost 35% of medical expenses, versus 17% in Canada (up from respectively 31 and 16.7 in 2003). > [Administrative costs per capita in the US versus Canada are] $844 versus $146 on insurers' overhead; $933 versus $196 for hospital administration; $255 versus $123 for nursing home, home care, and hospice administration; and $465 versus $87 for physicians' insurance-related costs. So the admin overhead in the US (v Canada) is: - 5.78x on insurance - 4.76x on hospitals - 2.07x on nursing homes, home care, and hospices - 5.34x on physicians Importantly though you did not list drug companies in there. Drug costs are completely out of control in the US (some generic and out of patent drugs have seen price increases of 80x in a decade), and AFAIK modern treatment regimens tend to include a lot more different drugs. At the hospital level, aside from the administrative overhead above, as an other commenter notes there is also the issue that because it's not a single-payer public health system hospitals have to compensate for indigent ER clients by billing more to, well, people who can pay. Then of course there's the issue that because all the incentives are fucked under the US system it's being used the least efficient way possible e.g. medical costs are sky-high, so people can't have a GP, so they can't take care of their conditions until those go south, at which point they go to the ER which is the most expensive and least efficient medical service center. And then the ER's job is to stabilise them, but they still don't have any more money to pay for long-term treatment than they did before having to go to the ER (less, really), so they can't follow through, so they degrade again, and back to the ER. [0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31905376/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31905376/
- throwaway09223 5y agoMy understanding is that the ER system is especially expensive because paying customers are subsidizing non-paying customers (homeless) who use the ER as primary care. That said, I don't think this excludes the possibility that the insurance companies and the hospitals are also not telling the full truth.
- watwut 5y agoI think it is more that prices are not transparent. Instead they are impredictable. And you can't shop around for cheaper treatment. Partly because you are not in position to do so and partly because no one will tell you full price in advance.
- throwaway09223 5y agoI agree that those are problems with American healthcare. I'm describing why ER prices are specifically so much higher than care in other areas of the hospital.
- Lifelarper 5y agoI find it hard to believe the small non-paying contingent is unique to the US or even a significant % of daily patients, plenty of other countries have homeless who end up in ED's. America somehow spends far more than any other country on healthcare and yet patients still have some of the highest out of pocket costs even when they have expensive private insurance schemes, something is clearly broken to anyone looking and it's not the homeless causing it.
- chongli 5y agoThe US's non-paying contingent doesn't need to be any different from any other countries in order to cause the problem. The issue is that the uninsured subsidize the non-payers alone. This is radically different from countries with universal health care where the costs are spread among the entire tax-paying population. As for why the US spends more than any other country: it's due to an overabundance of caution among the comfortably insured. It's much easier to get a variety of expensive (and often unnecessary) tests and scans (such as MRI scans) in the US. In countries with universal health care these tests and scans are restricted only to those with demonstrable need and they may be subject to long waiting lists.
- nine_zeros 5y agoThe American insurance system has inherent efficiency problems. Hospitals are for profit corporations. Doctors are reviewed on how much revenue they generate per patient - usually by asking for more diagnosis and treatments - which is what patients want too. Too much admin, too little doctors. Someone should get the admin to doctor ratios at hospitals, it is nuts. A lot of admin is there to handle the insane documentation requirements, software, machinery and dealing with insurance providers. Insurance providers have their own army of admins, talking everyday to hospital admins. On top of this, supplies providers know that insurance is going to foot any bill. So they charge more. Insurance tries to negotiate it down but there's only so much they can do - unless they buy stuff directly from China or somewhere else. To add, each of these institutions has their own management ladder with fatter paychecks than the doctors themselves. These folks are nothing but leeches who just need the corporate ladder to exist. Unfortunately, the only capitalist solution out of this is to allow massive production of doctors (blocked by AMA), allow doctors to unite and form their own hospitals willy nilly (harder than you think because legal requirements are burdensome) and for insurance providers to compete in open market - as they do for cars. No more open enrollment.
- masklinn 5y ago> Hospitals are for profit corporations. Doctors are reviewed on how much revenue they generate per patient - usually by asking for more diagnosis and treatments - which is what patients want too. FWIW lots of hospitals are non-profit (though I expect that changes are investors are moving more and more into the space). That doesn't mean they don't focus on doctor's revenue, it only means there are no owners skimming off the top, but there are still execs being paid (a lot), as well as suppliers, etc... I'm not saying NFP hostpitals are worse (or even as bad as) FP, but they're hardly good.
- refurb 5y agoMost hospitals in the US are non-profit entities.
- addicted 5y agoNo one is lying. The system is filled with massive inefficiencies. 1) Insurance companies don’t pay sticker prices. They pay negotiated rates. At the same time, hospitals have to pick up a lot of ER costs that are never covered. They might be making money but reasonable amounts at best (also that’s probably not true either considering how many hospitals are shutting down in the US). 2) The negotiated rates insurance companies pay are still very high. They are probably making a good profit, but their margin is still probably a fraction of the margin of many other industries, and it’s not like they have no competition, so they do have market pressure to reduce prices. 3) Doctors pay a ton in education and liability insurance and delayed earnings due to the extensive education required. They can spend over a decade, and be into their 40s before their net worth turns positive. So where is all the money going is an excellent question. No one is benefitting from this current system. 1 obvious destination for the money is the education system in the US. Higher Ed in the US is an increasingly growing money pit. Tuitions are exploding. Loans are exploding (and educational loans are unique in the US in that they cannot be canceled in a bankruptcy). Administrative salaries are blowing up. Ever fancier buildings are being built. Yet money for teachers, researchers and remasters/phds is plummeting. It’s a complete scam with the entire system paying ever more money to build fancy buildings, the vast majority of the cost of which is captured by corrupt contractors with connections to university presidents, etc. Then you have the pharma industry, which unlike any other civilized society, needs to advertise to consumers in the US. This means they have pressure to constantly grow their sales and once popular enough they have parents, and once generic, brand value, to force hospitals and patients to buy overpriced drugs. But the US can’t outlaw pharma ads like nearly every other civilized country has, because that will then destroy your Media and Tech industries, and where ads, and therefore pharma ads, make up a massive source of income. And I’m sure the same dynamic probably applies to medical tech as we’ll. So in honesty, the money is likely going to the places that are showing that they are receiving money. Not in the healthcare system, but rather to tech, media, and construction and real estate.
- gitfan86 5y agoAnother big inefficiency is the margin of error allowed due to malpractice lawsuits. If a patient is at a 1 in a 10,000 risk for a problem, the Doctor will order a test to rule that problem out. Because if the Doctor doesn't order the test and the person ends up having the problem, the Doctor could be sued for malpractice. In other countries the Doctor would say this is very unlikely so I'm not going to run the test.
- refurb 5y agoWell UCSF charged my brother in law $20,000 for an MRI a private standalone MRI clinic charges $3,000 for. Insurance paid UCSF $16,000 after discount. So I’d say the hospitals definitely are a part of the problem. You can imagine what he did with a fund raising letter he got from UCSF asking for a donation so they could continue to help the community…
- Aeolun 5y agoMeanwhile, the most expensive MRI I’ve ever gotten in Japan was $300 before insurance. Even the private clinic is making bank like there’s no tomorrow.
- refurb 5y agoIt was a complicated MRI that was actually 5-6 MRIs in one and involved radiocontrast. Their standard lower back MRI was $400. Price competition can be fierce in MRIs since the startup costs aren’t high and you can pull patients from everywhere.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- varelse 5y agoI had to go to the ER in Hong Kong and I got better service uninsured for $35 US than I've ever gotten in the United States fully insured. And no surprise bills afterwards whatsoever.
- boplicity 5y ago> Insurance paid UCSF $16,000 after discount. There you go. The insurance company is actually incentivized to not negotiate a lower price. What if they refuse a ludicrous price? Their customers will complain -- what, what? go without MRIs? Worse -- the insurance company gets to keep 20% of the costs as profit. For a $16,000 bill, that's $3,200. For a $3,000 bill, that's just $600. So why, again, would they fight for a lower bill? No reason. Competition from other companies? Unfortunately, they're all playing the same game, and lower premiums are simply not happening.
- pydry 5y agoProbably a lot of actors. You know that the hospitals who claimed that their prices were trade secrets when being forced to reveal them were telling porkies.
- throwthere 5y agoLol what? Insurers are hugely profitable— many are public companies and don’t hide that. And you can underpay plenty of people if you give them difficult to do bullshit jobs that don’t provide value. That doesn’t make “administrators” liars. Doctor salaries have declined over time with inflation— is hard to blame them for higher healthcare expenditures. My main point is outright calling people liars and playing a blame game isn’t going to get anywhere. The system is fubard.
- Folcon 5y agoI'm curious, are there just more staff? How many admins / doctors does the US system employ compared to other health systems? I'm willing to believe addicted's[0] rationale, but maybe most people are getting paid poorly, there's just more of them in the system? - [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29287371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29287371
- heavyset_go 5y agoIf you're looking for somebody that's walking away with fat bags of cash, you aren't going to find them on payrolls.
- pietrovismara 5y agoIt's not secret knowledge at all. Just invested 2 minutes in searching: > US health insurers report billions in first quarter as small providers face stress > UnitedHealth Group, reported $4.9bn in profits in the first quarter of 2021 while CVS Health reported $2.2bn - https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/may/08/us-health-insurance-companies-2021-first-quarter https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/may/08/us-health-i... > Major U.S. Health Insurers Report Big Profits, Benefiting From the Pandemic - https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/05/health/covid-insurance-profits.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/05/health/covid-insurance-pr... > The health insurance industry continued its tremendous growth trend as it experienced a significant increase in net earnings to $31 billion and an increase in the profit margin to 3.8% in 2020 compared to net earnings of $22 billion and a profit margin of 3% in 2019. - https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/2020-Annual-Health-Insurance-Industry-Analysis-Report.pdf https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/20...
- fgonzag 5y agoThough in this case it is quite obvious that there are some parties making an obscene amount amount of money in healthcare, there are businesses where employees feel underpaid, owners lose money / break even, and customers believe they are overpaying, so no one is happy. Childcare is first example I can think of.
- thrower123 5y agoThis is why you want to go to ConvenientMD or similar urgent care centers for anything not acutely life-threatening. It's usually faster than being seen at an ER, and costs an order of magnitude or more less - my insurance has a baseline fee of only $50 vs $600 for the ER.
- lucidguppy 5y agoMy anectdata shows that urgent care centers do very little and get to charge whatever they want. There's a reason they've popped up like weeds.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThis doesn't make the ER scams acceptable. It's like saying "Be more careful to avoid being mugged or raped."
- jmclnx 5y agoEliminate all political donations from non-humans. That is the biggest issue, thanks to Citizens United Ruling by Republican Supreme Court Appointees, people in the US votes have no power any more. As soon as someone gets elected the do not give a crap about the public. That is when money starts flowing to them in large amounts to push corporate agendas. Republicans are very good at this game, notice how they are able to block even tiniest efforts are political reform.
- DFHippie 5y ago> As soon as someone gets elected the do not give a crap about the public. This goes too far. Believing it is impossible for politicians to do the right thing is a counsel of despair that harms those who are trying to do the right thing and gives advantage to those that aren't. If you believe it is impossible for democratic action to provide good governance, what is your alternative?
- jmclnx 5y agoI wish I knew, but one thing that should be fixed in the US is the Electoral College. The limit of 435 Reps skews the numbers. House of Representatives is suppose to be 1 Rep per a fixed number of people. But Congress put a hard limit of 435, that means Small States have more people per Rep than Large States. For example, Wyoming has 1 Rep for 480900 people. California has 1 rep per 736000 people. To be fair and agree with the original intent of the US Constitution, California should have about 82 Reps instead of 53. Texas for that matter should really have 52 Reps instead of 36 has it as now. The way it is now it has one rep per 700279 people. This will even out things a bit and hopefully get come changes through.
- mysterydip 5y agoMaybe I missed it in the article, but if he was injured on the job, shouldn't the construction company pay the bill?
- jermaustin1 5y agoFrom personal experience, many states dont require workers compensation for independent contractors. Now there are protections still, but it isn't as robust as employee protections, and even then in some states (like Texas), the company doesn't have to have workers compensation insurance at all, but instead can use mediation and arbitration to "take care of" injured workers. My sister is an orderly at a nursing home in Texas, and was attacked by a patient, she was was scraped up and had to get stitches, but they wouldn't allow her to fill out a work place injury form or reimburse her for medical expenses, and instead the onsite RN stitched her up at the request of management. The company (pretty large nursing home management company) does not carry workers compensation insurance and instead uses 3rd party arbitration to handle injury "disputes"... so if you are TRULY injured, you have no real recourse than to wait days and days without treatment waiting for this third party to say they will reimburse you.
- onphonenow 5y agoThis is not that bad because he ended with a negotiated rate and paid 1,000 or so. I’ve seen much worse One cause is political. One place I worked govt would only pay a % of the billable rate - this was so politically they could say program was saving money. So the ‘rack’ rate went through the roof. The irony? We’d have preferred to charge less to cash payors (this was a nonprofit) because they were much less painful to deal with if they paid when service delivered - but instead it was so costly no one could afford cash payments
- ZanyProgrammer 5y agoHaving to go through the process of negotiating it down is proof that the system is a failure, because that’s very obviously difficult for the majority of people to do. You simply shouldn’t have to do that in the first place.
- alienchow 5y agoYes you can negotiate the prices with insurance, but that means there's always a risk that insurance doesn't cover as much as you hoped for. This means every emergency becomes a risk assessment of estimated cost / probability of negotiation / network coverage / hassle. This is so broken. When I'm headed to the ER, I'm looking for immediate medical attention. I don't want to be shopping around for hidden hospital price estimates, verifying network coverage and deciding if I should Uber, ambulance or drive while I'm half dead. After all that we still got slapped with a $30k bill for half an hour. Cleared the HDHP deductible real fast. Thanks WEC Hospital for the wonderful hours long wait to pay you jacked up prices. When we had our first kid, we had to repeatedly call the hospital and insurance to make sure it's within network and that the midwives were going to be covered. Then we got slapped with a $15k bill because one of the nurses is outsourced and not within network. After 5 separate hour long conversations on the phone with Aetna we finally managed to get the clinic to lower the bill to $3000 which Aetna then covered. And then 10 days later I received a $15k bill payment reminder. I think the whole healthcare discussion in the US seems way too distracted with figuring out how to refactor a code base written by clowns, instead of just building a new system ground up. With 50 different states to pander to, I guess that's the logical result. Pretty glad I left the US, my mind is now cleared of lots of unnecessary baggage.
- helloguillecl 5y agoThis is absurd. Even in a country with liberal economics and "free choice" health system (however with universal care, and state regulation), the same stitches in a world-class private clinic in Santiago, Chile would cost 400 USD, before insurance. The clinics there are not the ones Americans imagine from a middle-income country, most of them have better infrastructure and doctors than the ones I know in Europe. And I don't even need to start talking about health services in Europe, where I live. This is the kind of things that show how inviable is a market-led economy without proper regulation. Let the powerful profit from the weak and you'll see this kind of thing every time. If you compare life expectancy in Chile and some other Latin-American countries with universal care[1], they are higher than in the US, despite being a more unequal and/or poorer. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/life-expectancy?tab=chart&time=1999..latest&country=CHL~URY~CRI~ARG~USA~DEU https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/life-expectancy?tab=chart... Edit: Many commenters miss the point. The US leads the way in too many areas and at least I expect them to be an example of the benefits of free market economy. Some have mentioned that regulation is indeed the problem. I would say, that we need the right regulation so the right incentives are put in place, in benefit of the market and competition. So at best it would be better not to have the industry dictate the regulation.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe stitches are expensive mostly because of many regulatory factors that restrict the supply of medical services and drive costs up, with the "free market" component being in how much they can charge the patients. It's the worst of both worlds in the US.
- helloguillecl 5y agoI can tell you that you cannot freely open a clinic in Chile, and Doctors have the monopoly on many treatments that are delivered by nurses or other workers in Europe. Becoming a Doctor is not easy, and foreign Doctors must go through difficult tests before working for the public system. Additionally, I remember that many supplies come from... the United States? So what regulations are you talking about? Maybe you meant monopolies?
- nyamada 5y agoMy daughter here in France had a bike accident two months ago which requires 14 stitches in her foot. We received 3 follow-up visits from nurses to clean and redress her wounds -- We pay about 100€ a month for supplemental private insurance on top of the public health insurance here -- Total cost for us? about 40€. We would have had to pay about 100€ more for the nurses' visits, but the mutuelle covered it. These are some of the reasons why my wife and I moved from the US to France -- she's French, I'm American; but I can't imagine returning to the nightmare complexity of billings and profiteering that the US system has become...
- ryannevius 5y agoExorbitant health insurance premiums and healthcare bills was the primary reason our family of 3 (now 4) left the USA (we're all American citizens). It's such a relief knowing that we all have the option to go to the ER without emptying our bank accounts. My tax rate is higher here in Europe, but I'm actually saving significant money compared to the USA, when factoring in healthcare costs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThese are some of the reasons why my wife and I moved from the US to France -- she's French, I'm American; but I can't imagine returning to the nightmare complexity of billings and profiteering that the US system has become... I'm American and live in Norway. I feel the same. My out of pocket here is around $300, after which a lot of things simply become free. I don't have to consider whether or not I can afford to take care of something, and I have trouble explaining how much lower my stress levels are because of it. My taxes aren't higher than in the US: IN fact, they might be lower than taxes plus insurance premiums - and that doesn't even touch on the deductibles.
- pietrovismara 5y ago> My taxes aren't higher than in the US: IN fact, they might be lower than taxes plus insurance premiums - and that doesn't even touch on the deductibles. I start to think that some people aren't really concerned by the amount they are paying. What they deplore is the idea that some "freeloader" could benefit from their taxes. Even if the net result is that they're spending less.
- aerodog 5y agoWashington Hospital in the Bay Area charged me $2,010 for a COVID test when I went to their ER. Later I was told I was stupid for having gone to the ER to do the test there. I just never suspected they would charge that much.
- lelandfe 5y agoThat the CARES Act put no restrictions on pricing for tests is, in hindsight, pretty shameful.
- edgyquant 5y agoIn this case it seems like the steep price is to prevent frivolously using the emergency room. You can get covid tests dirt cheap (or free) if you schedule and appointment at a hospital or one of the testing sites. Emergency room has to have capacity to take on actual life threatening emergencies.
- alisonkisk 5y agoIf the ER was rewlly so busy, they'd hand out brochures for non-ER clinics instead of fleecing minor patients, because they'd be too busy for minor case patients.
- sjogress 5y agoIt seems like you've done the research here: how do you know how you are supposed(?) to do the test in the US? Here in my municipality in Norway the media keeps repeating how/where/when to get tested, and if anything important changes the municipality will literally send a SMS to all its citizens to ensure as many as possible are up to date. From my admittedly limited experience with the US (NYC/tri-state area) I get the impression that information is often hard to find and hard to understand. This could of course be caused by cultural or lingual differences since I'm neither American nor a native English speaker.
- minhazm 5y agoIt’s very easy to find where to get a Covid test. First result on google will tell you exactly where to go. Almost every drug store also offers them.
- smcleod 5y agoI'm in my mid 30s and have left fixing up some damaged teeth and my large wisdom teeth impacted for 17 years too long, this Monday I'm going to get them removed under general anaesthetic at a private hospital. The Australian government covers hardly any dental unless your teeth have completely rotted through and are chasing other issues. So far my costs are: - $4500 in fillings and general dental. - $1800 for a crown (gold). - $350 consultation with surgeon (via zoom). - $1100 for 30-40 minutes (max) of a theatre room for the initial operation. - $4000 for the surgeon for 30-40 minutes. - $450 for the anaesthetist. - $0 for X-rays (covered under Medicare). - $150 transport. - $YTD medication post surgery. - $YTD follow up dental work. - $YTD additional surgery to cavities from the top teeth into the sinuses - this is only a maybe, it's a risk. Total so far in the last 3 months has been over $12,000 What stand out for me is how can the surgeon charge $4000 for 30-40mins of active work, and I'm assuming a little paperwork. Having said all that, I admitted myself to the ER earlier this year and spent the day there having a bunch of tests, didn't cost anything at all and no insurance required. While healthcare in Australia is generally pretty decent,dental is significantly lagging behind and expensive.
- sen 5y agoI have no idea on the reasons or specifics but I needed pretty serious dental work here (AU), dental quotes were around $7-8k (“maybe more” they said), went to my GP and he wrote the referrals etc and it cost me $200 out of pocket, mostly for the prescriptions. Sure you wait a while for our public health stuff if it’s not life threatening, and if you’ve got the cash available then private is faster/fancier, but the public system does work.
- smcleod 5y agoDid you have to get major surgery under general anaesthetic? This was after I had referrals from my dentist and a second opinion. I do have some complications with a major nerve running about 1mm from one of the largest tooth's roots and I was told when there's some risk of damage to facial nerves you should make sure you get a good surgeon.
- jiggawatts 5y ago
- sorokod 5y agoCan someone make a coherent case for public healthcare to be a for-profit endeavour?
- 88840-8855 5y agoJust my 2 cents. I live and work in Germany and am insured in one of the many public insurances. My monthly contribution is 350 Euro, my employer has to pay 350 Euro per month, too. Hence, I am paying approx. 7500 Euro for my insurance per year. Assuming I work 35 years plus some inflation, then I will pay over 300.000 Euro for my insurance. This excludes contribution before 25 (where my parents paid for me) and my contribution after I retire. What I want to say: public insurance is NOT free, but also comes with high cost.
- ksec 5y agoIt is listed / breaker out as such or is it a percentage coming from Total Tax?
- akvadrako 5y agoYou think that's all it costs? According to wikipedia, German health care is 77% government-funded.
- 88840-8855 5y agoI also should add that dental treatment is only covered when you get the most basic things. When you have bad teeth, you are f"""ed as you will have to pay the lion-share for your dentures. But dont worry, there are insurances for that, too. The good ones cost you another 300-400 Euro per year. This makes another 30.000-50.000 Euro on top of what I already pay.
- detaro 5y agoI'm fairly certain the indicator they cite there is Current expenditure on health by general government and compulsory schemes, i.e. includes the public health insurances, but it appears it's not in the current WHO database anymore and thus can't 100% verify that.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoMy mother is on Enbrel for her rheumatoid arthritis. The price? $6,500 per month.
- danlugo92 5y agoYou can probably import that from somewhere. Dm me if you want help
- eterm 5y agoIf I'm reading the NICE site correctly, the NHS appears to pay a around 20% of that: https://bnf.nice.org.uk/medicinal-forms/etanercept.html https://bnf.nice.org.uk/medicinal-forms/etanercept.html £715 (approximately $950) for 4 doses, almost a month's worth with 1 dose per week coming out around $1k/month. Even ignoring the fact that patients here don't pay, just having NICE and a system which will fight drug companies over costs appears to massively bring down the costs of these medications.
- Borrible 5y ago[flagged]
- orf 5y ago> The next day, she visited a doctor who said her condition was bad enough to go to the ER — but she regarded that option as financially perilous. > So even though she was deliriously ill, she hit the road in search of cheaper treatment. USA #1! Freedom!
- jonplackett 5y agoWhy is the discussion in America always private VS nationalised healthcare instead of just making private healthcare value for money / less insane. Here in the UK we have the NHS which is great. But we ALSO have private insurance / hospitals / healthcare that is reasonably priced.
- sheerdried13 5y agoAustralia is the same, and if you decide to get private insurance you get the 2% medicare tax levy taken off your taxable income.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoFor one thing, healthcare is such a mess in the US that it actually might be easier to just nationalize it rather than trying to fix the private insurance system. Also, in a country with both, the private system can't be any worse than the public system because it has to compete with it, so the fact that the UK has good private healthcare doesn't necessarily mean that it will be easy to fix the private system in the US without the existence of a nationalized system as well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zahllos 5y agoIn Switzerland the insurance system has various deductibles you can choose from per year, and then a monthly premium that varies per deductible. If you can't afford to pay this for genuine reasons, then the cantons will step in as part of the social insurance system. Once you have paid out of your deductible, insurance covers 90% up to a certain value and then everything. Costs for treatments are standardized and agreed on nationally: you can go and look them up. Your bill has codes on it that match this list. It is called TARMED: https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/fr/home/versicherungen/krankenversicherung/krankenversicherung-leistungen-tarife/Aerztliche-Leistungen-in-der-Krankenversicherung/Tarifsystem-Tarmed.html https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/fr/home/versicherungen/krankenv... Insurers under the LAMal system are restricted in what they charge for premiums too, and must negotiate this with the confederation. There's still a lot of scope for private companies to make money here. LAMal covers what are deemed essential treatments, which is most things you need a doctor for. If you want 'alternative' medicine there are insurers you can pay more money to for that. Likewise, if when you go to hospital you want a guaranteed private room every time, then you can pay extra for that. And so on. Even on the basic system, you have a choice between telephone doctor for all appointments except emergencies, family doctor for the same or the unrestricted system where you can ring up a specialist yourself without referral. Needless to say, the one where you ring the insurer first is cheaper, followed by the family doctor (similar to the UK: referrals are controlled via your GP). I don't see any poor doctors here, or poor insurers either (insurance, behind banking, is a massive business here). So it is entirely possible to design a system that includes a large amount of private insurance that also doesn't randomly try to bankrupt people for getting stitches.
- iso1210 5y agoI had a gout flareup while in Washington DC for work. It's happened before, last time (in the UK) I phoned up the freephone national number for advice, my wife drove me to the local hospital, I walked (hobbled) in, had a couple of tests, was given some tablets and a presecription, and left in 15 minutes. That cost about $1.50 in gas parking would have cost another $5, but it was the weekend and parking was free. The prescription was $12 (standard price in the UK for any prescription drug or drugs, no matter what it is) In the US I phoned my insurance company, got an Uber down the road to the hospital, and walked in passed the (armed?) guards to sit in a crowded waiting room. Receptionists took my blood pressure twice, was unimpressed with my (international) insurance. 2 hours later I went into some form of casualty area and sat in a chair, had blood pressure taken a couple more times. Eventually someone came and gave me a tablet, then they wheeled in some computer trolley to take my credit card (about $900), and gave me a prescription. There was no informing me of prices up front, no choices (not that you have much of a choice when you're in hospital - for me it was a really minor thing so I actually would have had the choice to either pay or not pay). A few weeks later at home I received another bill for $2k from the hospital. I believe the bill charged for each of the times they took my blood pressure, I was never asked "would you like your blood pressure taken for $200", I wasn't asked if I wanted to sit in the comfy chair rather than the plastic chair for an extra two slips of latinum, the price wasn't up for negotiation, it just was. The difference between the two cases is night and day, the UK treatment is fast and free, the US will make you wait for hours and then charge you a fortune.
- _puk 5y ago"The prescription was $12 (standard price in the UK for any prescription drug or drugs, no matter what it is)" Just to note, in Wales all prescriptions are free. Can't speak for Scotland / NI.
- peterdn 5y agoPrescriptions are free in Scotland and NI too. Only England charges.
- OJFord 5y agoWhile we're noting, they are pretty good about telling you/charging you less if it's something that's available off prescription (and was prescribed just to record the advice, or particularly because non-standard dosage advised, etc.) so £12 too much. Like paracetamol say, you'd need a pretty hefty prescription to be able to buy enough all at once that £12 was a good deal. (A standard box is I think 24x500mg, good for three days (4h spacing, but 4x1g max is advised, not 6x) at max standard dosage, can buy two off the shelf for about £1, so you'd need a prescription for almost three months' worth, or a correspondingly higher dose...) Also, £12 is the one-off price, there are better subscription type rates for people with medium/long-term recurring prescriptions.
- hamilyon2 5y agoMost of the time I restrict myself from this kind of comments, but here is what experience is typically like in Russia. You are sick or even probably sick, like biten by tick and worry about it is infectious. You go to the neatest hospital, local ER, register yourself (no documents needed). Any time of day. You get triaged immediately, if your situation is not life-threatening, there is a queue. Waiting times are anywhere between nothing and two hours. Doctor sees you, you get medication, procedures, tests as needed. Everything is typically done in professional manner, quick and no bullshit. There are sometimes signs hospital is understaffed, like single nurse doing everything. In Moscow, treatment is world-class. In rest of Russia, your milage may vary. You typically leave diagnosed, fixed, with documents. Nobody ever asks you about payments or bills. What bills? The state-provided health care is free
- OJFord 5y agoSame in the UK (except the hospital probably is understaffed!) - it's weird for me to think of a hospital as somewhere you might go to pay for a service, like Tight muscles? Go there, pay the masseuse; Bone sticking out? Go there, pay the doctor.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>In Moscow, treatment is world-class. Is this true in the public system as well? I'm asking since in Romania the public hospitals are still more miss than hit, even in big cities. Hospital managers are politically appointed leading to terrible corruption and inefficiencies, meaning waiting times can be pretty long so the doctors who work there refer you to their private practices, and while conditions on the surface look good and everything is covered by the public insurance in theory, sometimes hospitals are short on supplies, asking you or your relatives to bring stuff from home, the food can be terrible, and you never know what corners some staff might have cut and you end up picking some dangerous hospital transmitted bacteria leaving you worse off than when you came in. And sometimes, if you're unlucky, you can end up in healthcare hell where you get bounced around between different hospitals if each judges you're not their problem to deal with. Outside of big cities, you don't even want to go near any public hospital unless your situation is serious. When my mom was admitted to the local hospital for infectious diseases around 2008ish, there were roaches and rats everywhere and this was in a big medical university city of the country. Pretty sure the roaches and rats are gone nowadays, but still that was unacceptable.
- meerita 5y agoThere's no free market in healthcare. Same thing in Singapore (highest free market in the world) would cost 0 due the cheapest healthcare plan is around 16 dollars.
- afranchuk 5y agoAnecdata: I just had a very mild infection a month ago, but it went to my heart so I went to the ER (thinking they'd give me antibiotics and send me on my way). They wanted to monitor me for 2 days so admitted me. I know I have the right to refuse (and very nearly did), but wanted to make sure my heart was all right. Long story short, they gave me nothing more than aspirin for that stint, did an echo and an EKG, and the billed amount is $130k. Completely ridiculous. I don't care if that's not the amount you pay, that's not right. The baby aspirin were $10 each!! Meanwhile they sent me home with an aspirin prescription for 120 (adult) pills that was about $5.
- tartoran 5y agoThis is absolutely ridiculous. Lots of people who would need to be monitored will simply refuse to do so, afraid of the astronomical bills. Even 5k would be a lot but 130k?
- KboPAacDA3 5y agoHow much did you pay in the end?
- afranchuk 5y agoWell, I haven't paid yet ;) but the adjusted amount charged to my insurance was about $12.5k. I have a highish deductible plan but I have an HSA so after meeting deductible and maxing out my out of pocket limit the HSA is going to cover much of what remains (it's been accruing for 5 years and I never have medical expenses). But I think it's completely insane we have to play these games with healthcare. Why does it have to feel like gambling and bartering!?
- Ekaros 5y agoWhat I find most insane in the USA system is the initial price and then some "adjusted" amount that can be nearly 90% discount... Why isn't there only one single price for everyone? Why isn't it mandated that you can only charge single price for everyone and you can't give discounts?
- squarefoot 5y agoI suffered a really bad motorcycle accident on Dec 2020 with fractures on both wrists, one arm, one shoulder and L4 vertebrae. Had to get arm and backbone stabilization surgeries and almost two months hospitalization plus rehabilitation. Total cost: zero. I later paid just a few dozen € to get the full medical documentation, tests results, etc. plus all the DVDs with the imaging, but that was my choice. I have neither insurance nor a job; if it wasn't for our healthcare, I really don't know what would have happened to me. Actually I paid for it in advance with my taxes during my past jobs, and that's the whole point of universal healthcare: it's an investment for those who one day will need it, and a form of contribution for everyone else. Frankly I have never understood those who oppose it; are they so anally retentive wrt their money that they can't renounce to a fraction of their income to help others, and potentially themselves too?
- jdub 5y agoOne day, probably not very soon, Americans will learn that universal healthcare is freedom.
- DangitBobby 5y agoI'm not going to hold my breath. We seem to feel very clever for believing that any system will be made worse by government involvement. People are unironically worried that Biden will usher in an era of socialism. It's too stupid to make up.
- sheerdried13 5y agoNot american, so it's kind of insane when I hear talking them wanting to quit there job, but can't because of the health insurance. Basically being held hostage, either stay at your crappy job, or risk massive debt and bankrupty becaue of medical bills. It's insane this is what's considered "freedom".
- fareesh 5y agoHow does the hospital arrive at the cost? From what I can see there is a cost breakdown in the article, but a deeper breakdown would help make sense of these things. If the hospital has to pay for administrative staff, nurses, doctors, maintenance, electricity, etc. and then deliver a profit to the owner. Is this profiteering or just costs that are passed on to the patient? If it's the latter, then why are those costs high, and so on until something looks disproportionately expensive. Is it that hospitals are pricing treatment because of having to comply with some expensive regulatory requirement? Or is it that doctors are paid an incredibly high wage compared to doctors in other parts of the world? Or is it that insurance paperwork requires a large administrative staff? I suspect there is no single answer to these questions, and that there is some complex set of reasons why costs are high. If it's just profiteering, then the solution is to get stitches from elsewhere. A vet or a nurse or EMT can probably do it freelance too.
- trixie_ 5y agoPrices in medical care like anything else is a function of the maximum amount of money that can be extracted. With the socialized Medicare/Medicaid already in place, hospitals charge as much as they can knowing the government has deep pockets, will pay, and will give minimal resistance. Those high prices are then charged to insurance companies as well through closed door, complex negotiations on a case by case basis - super inefficient and expensive. Also without consumers in the loop even caring what their insurance company is paying, and no price transparency in general, there is no pressure to decrease prices, improve quality or compete in general which are the cornerstones of free market economics. Luckily price transparency laws were passed last year and are still working their way through the system so hopefully people will start to get a taste of what’s possible soon and decide to take those laws even further.
- medEvilz 5y agoAt what point will we start talking about breaking up the cartels? The American Medical Association is an Anti Consumer lobbying group that literally 400M on bribes. Physicians should be punished. The other various medical cartels should be punished too. The easy solution is to legalize science based medicine. But the Authority based medicine establishment would never let that happen.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Hakashiro 5y agoI always find interesting to read these stories because nowhere else but the US can you make over 300k USD a year as a senior engineer of some kind. In Europe, 200k EUR is already ridiculous, and most countries take away half your salary in taxes anyway so... Would you rather make 300k and pay 4k for the occasional ER visit or make 50k after tax and pay 100 for the occasional ER visit? I suppose this comment will get buried in downvotes, but do not ever forget that American engineers are the best paid workers in the entire world.
- happytoexplain 5y ago>Would you rather make 300k and pay 4k for the occasional ER visit or make 50k after tax and pay 100 for the occasional ER visit? The trend you're describing is true, but this is an extremely unrealistic average comparison designed only to support a point of view.
- roland35 5y agoMost tech companies offer great insurance on top of higher salaries, so this doesn't really effect highly paid employees. For example, my insurance premium is around $200/month for my family and I have a maximum out of pocket cost of $3k a year. So the system works well for me at least, but I know it is much much worse for others
- FearlessNebula 5y ago$300k salaries are top tier engineers, not the norm. The vast majority of people regardless of job are making closer to $50k.
- Hakashiro 5y ago50k is what you make in Europe as a top tier engineer.
- wffurr 5y agoThat's a great deal for the programmers. Not so much everyone else. Median household income for 2021* in the United States is $80k; which is a far cry from $300k. Even the $300k doesn't go as far as you'd think given the costs of housing in the areas that pay that kind of salary. *https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il21/Medians2021.pdf https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il21/Medians2021....
- kayxspre 5y agoThis reminds me of the ESS surgery I took last Sunday. The bill came at approximately $4,900, and approximately 60% goes to the physician. I didn't have insurance, so I have to pay them in full. Although I enrolled in the universal healthcare scheme (which allowed me to pay up to $1 for treatment), my sinusitis is more serious such that I don't think UHS will properly cure me, causing me to pursue special clinic at public hospitals (where more experienced physicians are available).
- scrose 5y agoEven with my $0 deductible insurance that I paid several hundred a month for, I just got through a months long battle with my insurance over a $10,000 ER bill and additional $2,000 bill they deemed ‘not medically necessary’ — my partner was bleeding from their mouth and unable to eat or drink for more than 2 days after a surgery. It took multiple calls to the doctor and insurance and haggling with the billing department to get the final charges reduced to $0 and $100 respectively. Even as a well paid software engineer, I’m strongly eying other countries where your life and death isn’t seen as a massive profit center for investors.
- saevarom 5y agoThis is insane. I live in Iceland. I recently fell off my bike, got a bad cut on my forearm and needed stitches and extensive cleaning of the wound. I visited my local clinic where a nurse cleaned the wound and a doctor applied 5 stitches. The whole process took about 90 minutes with wait. For this visit I paid 500 Icelandic Kronas, about $3.75. Afterwards the wound got infected which required another $3.75 visit and antibiotics treatment costing about 10.000 ISK,rougly $75.
- ludston 5y agoA colleagues son was in a motorcycle accident, and needed some emergency surgery to fix his leg. He was talking about how he was really dreading the hospital bill. I got to go through the joy of explaining to him that because we're in Australia, it's free. The American healthcare system seems completely nuts from here.
- spodek 5y agoI've heard positive reviews of Never Pay the First Bill: And Other Ways to Fight the Health Care System and Win https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/635536/never-pay-the-first-bill-by-marshall-allen https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/635536/never-pay-th.... I've only read as far as the free preview allows, but it looks good. It teaches the system and how to fight back by a Propublica investigative journalist who had to fight the system himself.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYour library may have a copy: https://www.worldcat.org/title/never-pay-the-first-bill-and-other-ways-to-fight-the-health-care-system-and-win/oclc/1237651976 https://www.worldcat.org/title/never-pay-the-first-bill-and-...
- bilekas 5y ago> But many facilities will require those who have insurance to use it — knowing they can bill higher prices that way. And therein lies the problem.. It's been said over and over but there is still no getting around the fact that most people in the US literally can't afford to get sick or have an accident.
- echlipse 5y agoDamn this is costly. I am an outsider from a developing nation in the east looking into this. Here that treatment wouldn't have costed more than 10$ in a very good hospital maybe. I have two questions for US citizens: 1. How are the prices so high(ELI5)? 2. What happens if someone doesn't pay the entire amount of the their medical bills? Edit: Another question I want to ask after reading some of the other comments. 3. Doesn't big companies in the US keep medical staff for basic medical emergencies like this? That would be free of cost for the employees if things are similar to how it is here.
- hyperstar 5y agoQuestion from a welfare country and complete ignorance: what exactly are the steps necessary to change this and why is it so difficult for the USA to take them?
- DangitBobby 5y agoYou have to abolish the private healthcare system, which is hard because the people who make money off of it have bought the government. > "160 million people like their private insurance," Biden said during the November Democratic presidential primary debate. Democrats are hellbent on keeping the insurance system through any cost saving measure. Republicans haven't actually proposed any plans. 1. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/nov/21/joe-biden/do-160-million-americans-like-their-health-insur/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/nov/21/joe-biden/...
- lmilcin 5y agoHi USA. You are sick. It is called "health care" and you are doing neither. I live in a second world country called Poland and even here with all our failings and problems we are not afraid to go to ER when we need stitches. Organizing medical help should be basic responsibility of a government the same way it should be to get its children to be educated and have good start for life. Nation is a collection of people that work together so that they can prosper but, most importantly, fulfill their basic needs including a need for safety. I can think of no large group of people that would say "Let's work together. But maybe let's decide we are not going to to deal with our life threatening problems that can hurt as sometimes completely at random. When people talk about helping a third world country what are the first thing that are being mentioned? It is usually building schools and hospitals. Because educated and healthy people can take care of themselves. Why would USA decide to not provide free education and free healthcare is completely beyond me.
- authed 5y agoShould have got the suture kit on Amazon for $20 /s https://www.amazon.com/Suture-Practice-Kit-Medical-Students/dp/B08HM82GNT/ https://www.amazon.com/Suture-Practice-Kit-Medical-Students/...
- lucidguppy 5y agoAmericans have to watch their health more these days. Companies are now ONLY offering high deductible plans. You HAVE to invest in your HSA for things to be sane. You cannot afford to be overweight or t2 diabetic in America, not anymore. The biggest money makers are cardiovascular surgery. These are bankruptcy makers. Get your teeth checked out and clean. Get physicals - keep your cholesterol low. Get the vaccines and booster. Try to get as healthy a weight as possible. Watch your higher risk behaviors. Avoid cigarettes and alcohol. Even then its a roll of the dice.
- ModernMech 5y agoMy wife’s last ambulance ride was $1200 to take her to the hospital 4 miles away. They didn’t even do anything for her, just drover her there. I wish she had called an Uber — something like this makes me not want to call an ambulance ever again.
- busyant 5y agoSimilar-ish story I'm in the US. * I paid $20 K out of pocket for a surgery that my insurance would not cover. * A few weeks after surgery, I developed a complication that left me in HORRIFIC pain several hours / day. * Almost immediately after development of complication, I got ANOTHER $20 K bill from the hospital. * I read the fine print on my contract, "HOLY SHIT. THEY CAN DO THIS????" * Meanwhile, horrific pain persists, day after day. * Wife says, "You need to go to ER." * Me: "NO WAY. You wanna get hit with ANOTHER $20K bill because I developed a complication due to a procedure that the insurance refused to cover from the get-go? I'll ride this out." * Horrific pain persists. I cancel a lot of my work. * A few weeks later, I have a follow-up visit with surgical group. * I tell surgical group, "I got this $20 K bill ON TOP of the $20K I already paid." * Surgical group: "Oh. That's a billing error." * I explain very s-l-o-w-l-y that I did not deal with my horrific pain for WEEKS as a direct result of receiving an erroneous bill and that there may be a lawsuit coming someone's way. * 15 minutes after leaving my follow-up visit, I got 3 phone calls from hospital admins and surgeon expressing profound regret for the error and assurances that the bill was "gone." If I could leave the US, I would for this simple reason.
- SkipperCat 5y agoAmerican emergency care is the exact opposite of a "free market". In a free market, you get to shop around, compare prices and most importantly, there is a supply and demand curve where if prices rise too much, you can choose not to consume the product. Works great with potato chips, not so much with bleeding wounds. If I'm 'forced' to go to the nearest hospital because I may die if I don't, then that hospital should be 'forced' to bill me a fair rate. You can't have free market billing but captured service demand. They do the same with utility pricing - the power company can't decide to 10x the cost of a KW (sorry Texas), so the same should be for medical bills (especially emergency care). We've 'socialized' firefighting, policing and the defense of our country. Why haven't we done the same with health care? I dunno, maybe not enough Americans have visited Europe or Canada and seen the liberating power of free health care.
- althaffe 5y agoI don't get this. I live in Kerala, India. And for most things that doesn't involve a surgery, I can visit a government hospital nearby and it would cost me absolutely nothing. The medicines are free. Vaccines, TT shots and injections are free. And yeah, stiches are definitely free.
- adnmcq999 5y agoI was charged 10,000 for rabies shots administered in the ER despite calling and getting pre-authed. Their billing dept fat-fingered my insurance companies address. Yes, that was the unique identifier - a physical address. I had to fix it myself. Unrelated but I was also audited a similar amount due to clerical error by robinhood + irs. Unnecessarily complicated laws designed to screw 99% of us are working.
- xtracto 5y agoFor Americans that question why some other country has certain polinices or government that seem extremely crappy (say, Mexico crime struggle, Venezuela failed economic policy), healthcare is a good local example of a country's broken system which most citizens hate but that just cannot be reformed. For a lot of these abuses, shit needs to hit the fan in some way like what happened in Egypt during the Arab risings. Otherwise it's a gradual decades process to move away from the status quo.
- taxyz23 5y agoThis is definitely a problem but the problem is not high deductible plans, its price transparency which distorts supply and demand and steers people to high cost emergency room medical care while unfairly shifting costs to those who choose more price transparent plans. And the article's charge calculation is dishonest, ignoring premium savings and insurance discounts in order to get a bigger headline grabbing number. I had a high deductible plan and got snagged with a similar charge but not as large. Same deal, a walk-in by a family member to an emergency room cost over $2, 000, no treatment, simple 15 minute consult. They classified it as a level 4. I understand this is intended to offset overhead and also to discourage unnecessary walk-ins but really ? I argued with the hospital on the level 4 classification and the fact they never informed my family member how much it would cost them prior to (or even after) treatment. They would not budge and I held out until they threatened to send to collection at which point I gave in because it was easier to pay.Also I figured I saved as much on my high deductible plan and it was a lesson learned both to me and my family. The article is not being up front with the cost calculation. First, the family in the article likely saved thousands of dollars from their high deductible plan ( for example at the time I was saving at least $300 a month on my plan v lower deductible plan, a savings of $3600 a year in premium). I didn't see anywhere in the article where the premium savings was calculated and it certainly was not deducted from the headline number. Second, included in the headline number is the unnegotiated undiscounted retail cost. No insured person pays that number. Buried in the article they note the true discounted cost, the "you pay" number which was negotiated by the insurance company as part of their deal with the hospital and passed on to the insured. Granted the discounted price is still outrageous, but it's much lower than the headline. Third I believe the article fails to mention those with high deductible plans are able to put away the thousands they save on premiums (and more if they choose) in a health savings plan (similar tax advantages to a 529 for education or a 401k roth and similar investment choices of mutual funds, stocks, bonds, cash, etc. ) which is only available for those with high deductible plans and which can grow over a lifetime (this NOT forfeited each year like the medical savings accounts most people are familiar with). In addition, most areas, and I would bet even in this rural area, there are private stand alone clinics that would have treated him for around $200 . The mistake is to walk in to a hospital emergency room for non-life or death situations, a problem that most people who are on low deductible plans do all the time, driving up artificial demand and real costs for everyone. Hospital emergency rooms are equipped with the most expensive personnel and equipment, they should not be used for non-life threatening problems. One of the main problems with the American system ( other than government intervention which has royally misallocated resources, screwed with normal market driven supply and demand, and micromanaged health care production, supply, and delivery) is that no one knows how much it will cost given the complexity of the insurance. Hospital emergency rooms need a simple menu-like sign at the door giving the out-of-pocket cost for common treatments and encouraging people to call their insurance company first and/or go to other clinics for non life threatening issues. The price transparency law that was passed a few years ago did little as it resulted in long lists of obscurely named procedures, usually in a pdf buried in the website. And/or they should give a reasonable estimate to high deductibles and charge them a r$1000 or so in order to walk through the door, refunding any difference when they walk out. In addition the low co-pay plans for emergency visits are obscuring the true cost to the hospital, encouraging unnecessary emergency room visits, and pushing these costs onto cash only and high deductible plans. High deductible plans should be encouraged legislatively, rather than demonized. Also, instead of fighting the tendency of people to run to hospital emergency rooms, hospitals should run lower overhead, lower cost 24 hour clinics adjacent to the emergency rooms and informing people of cost/benefits of each. While I appreciate this article pointing out the problem of emergency room costs, high deductible plans, are not the problem but one of the solutions to high medical costs. They can regularize supply and demand and increase price transparency.
- simonblack 5y agoWhy is it that poor, third-world countries can afford a single-payer health system that treats all patients equally and economically, and the so-called richest country on Earth makes sure its citizens get bankrupted for the most minor medical issues? I had triple-bypass in 2005. Cost to me? Zilch! If I lived in the US, I'd be dead for the last 16 years.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe market for healthcare needs to be completely unregulated and open to competition. The licensure barriers to providing drugs, medical devices, and medical services leads to far less innovation toward more efficient ways of producing medical products/services than there otherwise would be.
- spants 5y agoI am in the UK. My father-in-law has just been treated for almost cutting a finger off with a chainsaw (the safety gear was sitting on the floor next to him). He went to the emergency dept (saturday) for initial checks and xray and then to a plastic surgeon today (sunday) who operated on his finger. Total cost to him was £0.
- kcartlidge 5y agoThere's loads of interesting comments and opinions in this thread, many of which are true. What it boils down to though is simple - corporate greed and regulatory capture.