33 ms·
Is nuclear power our best bet against climate change?
- newaccount2021 5y agoyou don't need to implement nuclear, just talk about it likewise, if you want to solve California's water problems, just say "desal" you don't have to actually build nuclear or desal, just type the words, get your upvotes, and shut off debate
- melling 5y agoImagine if the United States had gotten 80% of its electricity from nuclear over the past 4 decades. China might have adopted it instead of coal. We’d been talking about the danger of climate change in 2150.
- Hokusai 5y agoOil Buddhists will have have allowed that. The dangers of greenhouse gases was already there, and it did not matter. It has caused wars and the rise of authoritarian governments, and it did not matter. When money is the main motivator for a country it's impossible to do what is good for the long term.
- smell-my-bacon 5y agoSo what truly matters to the Oil Buddhists?
- gumby 5y agoTo become one with the atmosphere?
- smell-my-bacon 5y agoMy carbon to your carbon, my gas to your gas...
- Hokusai 5y agoBusiness, but I'm also curious now.
- dotancohen 5y ago> We’d been talking about the danger of climate change in 2150. More importantly, people would be terrified of fossil fuel production. Spills, mining accidents, radioactive pollution (yes, coal puts out more radioactive pollution than does a nuclear power plant), particulate-related respiratory diseases, and so forth. To think that people are afraid of nuclear energy is just crazy, I cannot comprehend how nuclear is perceived dangerous yet fossil fuels are somehow not.
- i_am_proteus 5y ago>I cannot comprehend how nuclear is perceived dangerous yet fossil fuels are somehow not [0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic
- jpalomaki 5y agoPeople are more afraid of clearly defined risks (local nuclear plant goes boom) than more abstract risks (slowly developing health issues due to air pollution). (Can’t find citation, this was likely mentioned in book Freakonomics) This is likely built into us through evolution. Natural selection has rewarded quick choices over analyzing and thinking probabilities.
- mattnewton 5y agoI think it has to do with how humans are wired; slow burning dangers don’t seem to be registered the same way that nuclear fallout and the dread of meltdowns as one big catastrophe are.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 5y agoTo me it's always about the lack of control. A nuclear plant failure, I'm faced with something I can do nothing about. Coal .. well unless our case of whole-plane-pollution .. you can mitigate. Same for cars vs planes. In a plane, I delegate my life to stats. Anything happens, I can do nothing about. My car.. I can always use slower, lighter roads, keep larger safety distance. Even if the odds of car crash are higher. (also if I were to drive alone in the midwest, my crash stats would probably be as high as planes.. density is a factor it seems)
- xyzzyz 5y agoChina did adopt nuclear. They are building 15 nuclear power plants right now, more than anyone else in the world, and almost a third of all the plants under construction. It's just their needs grow very, very fast, so they make it up with coal.
- systemvoltage 5y agoMeanwhile Californians will tell us to manage power and power cuts. I can’t get behind this agenda. It’s infuriating to see the west considering itself done. It’s in the name “Developed”, past tense. No need to develop anymore. We’ve thrown in the towel, large swaths of people are against population growth and against progress.
- adventured 5y ago> large swaths of people are against population growth and against progress Population growth is largely irrelevant unless you're really facing an extinction path (which we're very far from). The standard of living that can be delivered for people is what matters. Modestly fewer people with increased standards of living is a very nice outcome for most nations. Some nations are drastically overpopulated in terms of density for their available space and resources (eg India, China). If you're in a more affluent context, having four or more children is not a blessing for most people. Raising two children well is a quite difficult and life-consuming task, even if one parent stays home full-time. It makes perfect sense that affluent populations would choose to reproduce at a lower rate. It's rational. That said it's certainly disheartening to see the lack of spirit of seeking progress that used to widely exist in the West. It's still there, faintly, diminished.
- systemvoltage 5y agoMost economists think that population decline is tightly coupled with the economy. It may be rational in individual sense, but as a society, it is pretty much a bad idea. I suggest further reading: https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2021/03/27/the-economics-of-falling-populations https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2021/03/27/t... That said, overpopulation is also a problem. In a resource rich nation, it is never a problem.
- jlelse 5y agoBut nuclear meltdowns would have killed a lot of people and made a lot of land uninhabitable.
- beeboop 5y agoThere is no evidence for this and it's baseless speculation at best.
- jedimastert 5y agoMore than coal has? Honestly, I kinda doubt it.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoCoal burning literally releases more radiation into the environment than nuclear power would.
- dredmorbius 5y agoTrue, but utterly irrelevant. Quantities of radiation released by coal plants under normal operations are not a health concern. Coal has plenty of other health, and environmental, concerns. Quanities of radiation released by a coal plant are unlikely to vary much at all, no matter how critically mismanaged the plant might be. Quantities of radiation emitted by a badly-mismanaged, sabotaged, or attacked nuclear power plant, on the other hand, become a health concern for people across continents and beyond, as with Chernobyl and Fukushima. (Note that "concern" need not mean "realised risk", but given that one of the characteristics of nuclear incidents to date has been inaccurate or misleading information on precisely the levels of risk presented, prudence and caution strongly recommends presuming a worst case until otherwise conclusively demonstrated.)
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoI was just pointing out that nuclear power plants don't pollute the planet with radiation. Coal plants do.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoAren't the biggest greenhouse gas polluters concrete manufacturing and container ships though?
- rsj_hn 5y agoWouldn't that be the people who buy products shipped from overseas and those who buy buildings made with concrete instead of wood and brick? That's the problem with an economy in which there is a circular flow of commodities.
- dehrmann 5y ago> people who buy products shipped from overseas Container shipping is pretty efficient. I found this quote: > A big ship will emit about 0.4 ounces of carbon dioxide to transport 2 tons of cargo 1 mile. That’s roughly half as much as a train, one-fifth as much as a truck and nearly a fiftieth of what an airplane would emit to accomplish the same task. For CO2 emissions, container shipping from Shenzhen to Long Beach by ship is about the same as Bloomington, IL to Long Beach by truck.
- rsj_hn 5y agoGood point! Just because there is a concentration of some activity in one part of the flow of commodities doesn't mean that the activity is inefficient.
- dehrmann 5y agoContainer shipping accounts for ~2.2% of CO2 emissions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_effects_of_shipping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_effects_of_shipp... You're probably thinking of other emissions. They burn heavy fuel oil, so they emit a lot of sulfur.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y ago>greenhouse gas
- jeffrallen 5y agoOh, thank God, finally a counterfactual to Betteridge's law of headlines.
- iamgopal 5y agoLast I calculated all USA energy need can be fullfilled by about ~800 ( + 150% to cover all kind of storage and transmission ) Billion USD investment in solar. On the other hand, do we have any idea about how long Nuclear power will last, If we produce lets say, 50 percent of all our energy needs from it ?
- macspoofing 5y ago>Last I calculated all USA energy need can be fullfilled by about ~800 ( + 150% to cover all kind of storage and transmission ) Billion USD investment in solar. And what do you do at night, or on a cloudy day? There is no grid-scale storage solution.
- andrekandre 5y ago> And what do you do at night, or on a cloudy day? with photovoltaic generation that is true, but not with molten salt https://insideclimatenews.org/news/16012018/csp-concentrated-solar-molten-salt-storage-24-hour-renewable-energy-crescent-dunes-nevada/ https://insideclimatenews.org/news/16012018/csp-concentrated...
- pg_bot 5y agoI've been doing some research into cryogenic energy storage and it seems like a universal solution to the grid scale energy storage problem. It uses off the shelf industrial components, can be located almost anywhere, doesn't use any rare or expensive elements, and there is no pollution in the cycle. The general idea is you cool air until it liquifies and store that in large storage tanks when you have an excess supply of energy. Then when you need to discharge the battery you boil the air and run the resulting gas through a turbine. It's also fairly cost competitive with a LCOS of $140/MWh, which is less than the cost of generating a MWh with new nuclear power plants.
- jdavis703 5y agoThat means we only get electricity, when the sun is shining. Yes, solar can be good. But it’s got to be mixed with other tech such as battery, and perhaps even nuclear.
- cletus 5y agoAccording to the EPA [1], electricity accounts for 25% of greenhouse gas emissions. While that's significant, replacing all fossil fuel usage for power production is significant. The standard concerns apply: 1. We have no long term solution for the storage and disposal of enrichment byproducts. There is reprocessing but the results are simply less toxic (eg UF6 -> UF4) and are, to date, expensive; 2. We have no long term solution on the storage and disposal of fission waste products; 3. The failure modes are huge. Most notably, the Cheernobyl Absolute Exclusion Zone stands at 1000 square miles 35 years after the fact; and 4. This it he big one for me: I just don't trust governments or corporations to maintain, inspect, manage and operate nuclear power plants at scale. > Researchers have estimated that about 1 in 5 deaths globally can be attributed to fossil fuels through air pollution alone From the linked post [2]: Also worth noting: > The study shows that more than 8 million people around the globe die each year as a result of breathing in air containing particles from burning fuels like coal, petrol and diesel, ... So it's including vehicles. You could be 100% nuclear power generation and that part wouldn't change. The counterpoint is electric vehicles. While these are generally a positive, they have more limited utility, higher cost (a significant issue in much of the world) and you have to factor in the externalities of the power used to charge them. [1]: https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis... [2]: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2021/feb/fossil-fuel-air-pollution-responsible-1-5-deaths-worldwide https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2021/feb/fossil-fuel-air-pollutio...
- closeparen 5y agoWhat is the long term solution for "the last few weeks have been cloudy"?
- tuatoru 5y agoDiversity. Long distance (1000 km) transmission, wind AND solar, short term storage, load shedding agreements, and long duration storage. Iron-air looks economically viable already for timescales of two days to two weeks. Hot rock storage, the same. It's rare to get cloudy calm periods lasting longer than two weeks over 1000 km distances, but there are readily available seasonal storage choices. Electrolysed hydrogen, either stored directly or as ammonia. Just need PV prices to fall a bit, which is expected, and the cost of electrolysis to fall, which is happening. I have only hit the universals here. Depending on geography and mining history, there are a bunch of other storage options available in many places. Mechanical (gravity) storag other than pumped hydro is another possible technology. So is methane synthesised from CO2. Edit. I'm in favour of nuclear, if the numbers work. The LNT theory should be exposed as the bull** that it is and ALARA abandoned in favour of specified limits. Then let nuclear compete with renewables.
- Beldin 5y agoSignificantly reducing population (to, say, 3 billion or less) is probably our best bet against climate change. However, to do so in any remotely ethical way takes a lot of time. The next step is energy use: both reduction of consumption and reduction of wasted energy, ie. less energy, more effectively used. Things like insulation fall under this category. Because we're simply using too many resources for the world to remain unchanged in the medium term. We need to change. Changing the energy mix without addressing this just postpones the consequences of our actions - and not even that much. Basically: massive, world-wide societal changes are our best bet against climate change. Nuclear energy is our best bet to push the hot potato to (at best) the next generation.
- csisnett 5y agoFunny how people who think the earth overpopulated always think is other people who are overpopulating it, and not themselves. Wealth can be created. There's no limit to how much wealth can be created. Focusing on deleting the population is immoral.
- rahen 5y agoNobody asked to delete population. The challenge is to allow people to access familial planning, make contraception and abortions more widespread in developing countries, and stop or at least reduce pro-natal fiscal policies in the West. Besides, morality is highly subjective.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's no limit to how much wealth can be created. Citation requested. That, and other statements of your comment, are articles of ideology and belief, not scientific statements. You're attempting to moralise what is a factual matter. That is as effective as a moral theory of disease, which is to say, not at all.
- csisnett 5y agoTell me what the limiting factor in creating wealth is then? I said it is immoral and that we have moral options that work. Or you think wealth can not be created?
- NoblePublius 5y agoJust gonna be that guy on this thread who is not convinced anthropogenic climate change is a thing, or that if it is a thing that it is more significant than natural variations of climate. The economic and political consequences of the proposed solutions to this alleged crisis (enrich these corporations and these nations at the expense of these corporations and these nations) are too glaringly one sided to suggest empirical impartiality. It also continues to astound me that proponents of the “climate crisis” narrative never make any mention whatsoever of the fact that the most valuable energy company/car company in the world makes solar panels, batteries, and electric cars. Instead climate crisis actors demonize Tesla for not being unionized (eg, Tesla excluded from the White House American Electric Car Summit) and are lining up at the piggie trough for exclusive Biden bucks that will fund infrastructure investments that will help Ford and GM catch up to Tesla. To wit: our best bet to speed the transition to sustainable energy is to get out of the way of the capitalists who have already solved this problem with superior transportation and energy products.
- epistasis 5y agoJust going to be the guy that says that not only is human caused climate change a massive threat to humanity's economic future, but also that even if it were not, it would be far cheaper to switch to carbon-free tech than continue on our current path. Carbon free electricity is cheaper than fossil fuel, and as we electrify things like home heating and transport, we typically see efficiency increases of 200%-600%, meaning we need far less primary power to begin with. Any objection to the scientific basis of anthropogenic climate change is based on political ideology and false propaganda. We need to stop having allegiances to politicians and bad news sources, and maintain allegiance to truth and the unbiased pursuit of it. Far too many in our country are tools of fossil fuel interests. So while I agree that some environmentalists are tools of weird political ideologies, they are staying closer to the truth than those who oppose climate change. Unless most of your wealth is tied up directly in fossil fuel assets that you can't sell, you are also shortchanging your own economic future by not embracing newer and better technology.
- NoblePublius 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- carapace 5y agoIt's a bit cheeky but I like to point out that the Sun is nuclear power. It's a maintenance-free fusion reactor so powerful that it can blind you from 150 million km away. - - - - Anyway, Robert Bussard believed that he was on to something with his polywell fusion plant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FhL5VO2NStU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FhL5VO2NStU He claimed that it would only take about $200M of engineering development to become viable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell
- LatteLazy 5y agoIt's too late to fight emissions. It's time to build flood defenses and irrigation systems and move cities north...
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYou're being downvoted, but I think there is some truth to what you are saying: 1. Humans have shown time and again that they simply aren't capable of the global wide self-sacrifice that would be required now to prevent the worst effects of climate change. Just look at a chart for global greenhouse gas emissions over time. The only time you even see a slight reduction is when there is a massive global recession or pandemic. We basically need about "2 or 3 pandemics-worth" of reductions annually to hit our goals. This just isn't going to happen. 2. That said, I think it will be possible to transition over to primarily renewables, but the main driver for this will be economic (solar and batteries are continuing to plummet in price). It will just take a long time (or, at least, longer than we really have) before this increase in renewables really starts to dent CO2 emissions. Thus, I think maintaining a focus on emissions is a good thing, because it will still help that transition to renewables happen faster. 3. Your second sentence is absolutely true though. I think at least a 3 meter sea level rise by 2100 is pretty unavoidable by now, and that will have a massive impact on coastal cities. Significant impacts from climate change are unavoidable at this point, so we should start planning for this.
- redisman 5y agoWhy not both
- LatteLazy 5y agoWell for the last 50 years we haven't had the budget/motivation to do meaningful emissions cuts. So the idea that now it's urgent that we do mitigation, we can split that budget/motivation seems... Hopeful.
- himinlomax 5y agoRegarding reserves, the article makes the usual mistake of taking currently known and cheap sources as definite. But consider how Mad Max came out in the late 1970s, when the fear of completely running out of oil was evident to everyone. And yet, we have now found so much more oil that we have to force ourselves to stop using it. We haven't been looking for more uranium simply because there is no need for it. The known _cheap_ reserves are barely tapped. And there are many known sites that are simply not tapped yet because the aforementioned ones are just so cheap. If there was a need for more, prospecting would be profitable and would be done. (As an aside, taking uranium out of sea water is almost certainly never going to be worth it.) And the same applies to thorium or fast breeder reactors. They're just not worth the effort at this time. But again, if the demand was there, it would take just 10 years to build them.
- envengineer 5y agoSee above comment about radioactive mining waste. More mining, more waste. Forever. Of course, it's not in all the proponents back yards.
- himinlomax 5y agoCoal mining waste is also radioactive. It also damages thousands of times larger areas.
- antattack 5y agoHistory of accidents, design flaws, shortcuts taken during construction show that we are not ready for Nuclear Power.
- lettergram 5y agoThe obvious answer is no, because we likely cannot stop climate change. We’re exiting an ice age (the natural state of the world is no massive ice sheets), we don’t know the actual causes of climate change, and even if we believe we know what causes climate change (say, carbon), most of the green house gas emissions aren’t from energy production. That said, nuclear is likely better for the environment. I’m very bullish on nuclear.
- gorgoiler 5y agoPlease correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t it a truism that, in the 20th century st least, civilian nuclear power plants were simply a wheeze for the actual grand plan: weapons manufacturing? The two are coupled in a way that doesn’t feel comfortable. Imagine a different timeline in which something called an Apricot bomb became the ultimate must-have weapon of mass destruction to ensure a seat at the big boys diplomatic table. E.g. you smash apricot stones together to produce annihilation. Suddenly we have government programmes researching the health benefits of apricot juice, a system of distribution of apricot juice to all elementary schools, university departments funded specifically to produce generation after generation or stone fruit experts, oh and sure, a bomb or two, but trust our top men: that’s not the main focus, silly citizen!
- bjourne 5y agoTrue, and this is the reason why no one believes the Iranian government's claim that they are enriching uranium only for civilian purposes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pomian 5y agoImagine all the left over arsenic waste.
- gorgoiler 5y agoCome friendly bombs. Sweet almond flavoured release.
- sien 5y agoThis isn't true. There are many countries that have had nuclear reactors for decades and have no nuclear weapons. Sweden, the Netherlands, Belgium, Australia, Germany, Canada and more. List of countries with nuclear power : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_power_stations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_power_stations
- doikor 5y agoNothing really is the "best bet" in this. The correct solution is to hedge your bets by betting on just about every possible solution. The local resources available dictate just too much what is the "best" solution but even then one should not put all the eggs in one basket. But solving the electricity problem is just solving one part (~25%) of the equation. There is still a lot of greenhouse gasses being released from cars, construction (concrete), farming and various industrial processes. But the electricity seems to be the easiest problem to solve and once we have that on track to being fixed we can move more resources into the other issues.
- jabl 5y ago> Nothing really is the "best bet" in this. The correct solution is to hedge your bets by betting on just about every possible solution. The local resources available dictate just too much what is the "best" solution but even then one should not put all the eggs in one basket. It aggravates me to no end that people are fighting this pointless nuclear vs. renewables war, all the while fossil fuels are laughing all the way to the bank. Should be invest in building nuclear? YES! Should we invest in wind and solar? YES! Should we invest in grid-scale storage? YES! Should we invest in transmission capacity? YES! > But solving the electricity problem is just solving one part (~25%) of the equation. There is still a lot of greenhouse gasses being released from cars, construction (concrete), farming and various industrial processes. But the electricity seems to be the easiest problem to solve and once we have that on track to being fixed we can move more resources into the other issues. Electricity is in some ways the easiest problem, yes, but also once we have clean electricity we can use that to decarbonize many other sectors. Transportation, to a large extent. Heating, yes. Many important industrial processes can use hydrogen, like steel production. Etc.
- ncmncm 5y agoNot true: solar is the clear winner. Thus far, storage hasn't been important, but will become so soon. Very cheap iron-air batteries will roll out in 2023. Wind will remain important, as will long-distance power transmission. Spending on other methods is not just wasted; it means not spending those dollars on solar. But replacing Portland cement with one of the numerous carbon-neutral alternatives is urgent, as is building out all-electric ammonia and hydrogen synthesis: hydrogen for steel production, and ammonia to fuel retrofitted container ships.
- deeviant 5y agoNo, by virtue of Betteridge's law of headlines. Also by virtue that nuclear plants are too expensive, take far too long to plan, authorize and build, only make sense in stable developed countries where the dirtiest and fastest growing carbon emissions are generally in more unstable third-world countries. Oh and they aren't fairing well against solar and wind plus storage in terms of price: It will probably be less than a decade before wind and solar + storage are cheaper than nuclear.
- tejohnso 5y agoHow could it be our best bet? I hope not. It does nothing to reduce the consumption frenzy, and it does nothing to remove CO2 / CH4 from the atmosphere, and it does nothing to reduce insolation. Something like the MEER:ReflEction project[1] seems to be more appropriate to me. [1]: https://www.meerreflection.com/home https://www.meerreflection.com/home
- defterGoose 5y agoIt can cleanly (zero excess carbon) provide vast amounts of energy for direct air capture of CO2 (energy is the biggest barrier for that). The efforts proposed in the site you linked require huge geological-scale engineering efforts never before attempted. Nuclear is really here and it works well the overwhelmingly vast majority of the time. Don't get me wrong, changing mindsets and reducing consumptive behavior are at the root of the problem as well, just remember that 'perfect' is the enemy of 'good'.
- newbamboo 5y agoI guess there are two types: 1) those who oppose nuclear because they fear science and don’t grasp the logistics involved in solar, 2) those who might have been able to prevent climate change if they had more political sway many decades ago. I think the first group will win, because it will always be the larger group. It will always be a smaller group that have greater intelligence and foresight. For this reason I think discussion and public debate about climate change is counter productive. Trying to involve more people in a solution will just bring more mediocre minds to the discussion and hinder our best attempts to solve the problem with their innumeracy, ego and lack of scientific understanding.
- RobertRoberts 5y agoThis is maybe an oversimplification. My biggest concern comes from waste storage, of which my information came from a congressman who had to directly manage the waste in a particular state. To store this waste you must trust many moving parts, including greedy politicians, greedy corporations and more. None of which have ever proven to be trustworthy indefinitely. I'd rather have less electricity and peace of mind than nuclear and be forced to trust the untrustworthy to protect our lands forever.
- 46756e 5y agoI feel like saying "discussion is bad because it brings mediocre minds" to a discussion is a bit gatekeep-y. That applies to every discussion. That being said though, I do agree somewhat with the premise that "democracy is great because anyone can vote, but it is terrible because anyone can vote." It sucks when some field becomes political, because the attitude around it changes from "lets listen to the experts" to "it is my God-given right to have an opinion on it regardless if I understand the issue."
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe problem with "listening to the experts" is that at some point people figure out that the experts are very easy to bribe/intimidate/silence. So if we hand over the reigns of the nation to experts, then that's basically ceding our decision making to whoever can best organize to control the most experts. Don't think that academia and the tenure process aren't rife with groupthink, forbidden thoughts and positions, etc. And it's hard to find a group of people with less integrity than researchers chasing grants or academics trying to get tenure. Today, universities are the places where freedom of thought and expression are most suppressed, and groupthink runs rampant. Academics are under the thumbs of administrators and terrified of angry student groups. Researchers are sometimes afraid of being physically attacked if they espouse the wrong opinion. This is not who you want to hand control of society over to. So there is really no substitute for wisdom and intelligence. A foolish population is going to make foolish choices and a wise population will make wise choices. Both science and politics are downstream of culture.
- jacquesm 5y agoThere is an endless stream of pro-nuclear articles ever since the nuclear lobby figured out that their best bet to get re-instated as a viable source of power is to hitch their wagon to climate change. But it doesn't change a thing about the underlying issues: non-proliferation, radio active waste, potential for accidents, very bad economy over the total operational life-span.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoWhereas solar panels and wind energy of course have no lobby whatsoever and are only being promoted by idealistic, well meaning activists that can be trusted 100%.
- jacquesm 5y agoThis is attempting to put the solar and wind lobby on equal footing with the nuclear lobby: it isn't even close.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoWhy not? I mean, maybe not, but what makes you so sure? The solar and wind lobby stands to make trillions of dollars from government spending, but we are supposed to think they don't do any lobbying? Only the nuclear industry is in it for the money?
- jacquesm 5y ago> I mean, maybe not, but what makes you so sure? Maybe it is the decade-and-a-half that I've been studying the energy situation in some detail? The nuclear industry has a typical installed unit cost of $25B or thereabouts (that's usually not the original estimate or even close to that). A typical windpark is a fraction of that and solar deployments are much smaller as well. Besides that the market for solar and windpower is much more fragmented, with nuclear there are only very few parties on the supply side.
- NotChina 5y agoFor 35 years the green movement told us to use Fossil Fuels, and forced a moratorium on new nuclear plants. Fast forward to now and ponder how they thought they were right all along.
- ncmncm 5y agoThe most enduring product of any nuclear power project is not radioactive waste, but corruption. Nuclear power construction projects, at least in the western world, invariably become conduits for wholly legal, long-term corruption, making nukes about the most expensive kind of power (ignoring externalities from coal). This is a common feature of big-ticket public-works projects, particularly also including tunnel projects and military procurement. Nukes take so long to build not because it is so hard to do -- it is mostly just concrete and plumbing -- but because nobody actually involved wants the construction money ever to stop flowing. No output is even promised for years, which is easily stretched out, often beyond a decade. Sunk-cost fallacy helps this process: once a few $B are burned, it is easy to unlock more against the prospect of admitting what was already spent bought nothing. As bad as is the corruption around fission, fusion has been and must be much worse. A fission plant is expected to produce power eventually, or the plug will finally be pulled. One recent fission failure has cost $30B, so far, which seems like a lot, but fusion has burned more already without even breaking ground on a plant. ITER, even if 100% successful, will generate zero watts: no turbines are in the site plan. A plant built after it would cost, conservatively, >$50B and take decades to finish. (The most likely outcome would be that it is never finished.) Meanwhile, the costs of solar, wind, and storage are still plummeting, with no hint of a lower limit. Thus far wind and solar have mostly avoided becoming conduits for corruption, probably because it is easy to see how the money is spent, and maybe because of the high fraction of idealists involved. (The exception is solar thermal.) Power can begin flowing almost immediately, after a small fraction of the whole installation is done, which can then fund further construction. Thus, the up-front capital needed is small, and costs are constrained by immediate revenue. Thus, every penny diverted to fission and fusion (not to mention feeding and maintaining coal) from solar and wind brings climate catastrophe ever nearer.
- joe_the_user 5y agoThis is a key point. The US especially needs to solve the construction generates corruption problem before it can have sane nuclear power. It needs to do this for public transit as well. But the thing with solar is you can ramp it up and then worry about how to store the cyclical excess and this means you can make the storage mechanism competitive.
- 5y ago
- ThinkBeat 5y agoNuclear power not renewable. There is a very finite supply of uranium. The same as with coal, natural gas, oil etc. If we build a substantial number of nuclear power plants all across the world, that resource may run out within 200 years. We have then left our future generations with several hundred new sites that cant be used for anything productive for 100s of years or a lot more. A ton of nuclear waste nobody knows what to do with. Transporting highly dangerous uranium from where they dig it up, to the power plants and then from there to somewhere safe is risky. It would be the top mission of terrorist groups to capture. They dont have to make a bomb, or anything very advanced. Just spreading it over a city like NYC would be bad. Some say we reached peak uranium in the 80s, some say in 30 years ahead. All agree that it is going to happen. The usual retort from nuclear lobbyists is that we will have nuclear power that is new and advanced so there won't be any nuclear waste left that we must worry about. And that new nuclear powerplants will not have the errors the hold ones did, so Fukushima, Chernobyl could never happen. These new advanced nuclear reactors do not exist in any numbers and a lot of them do not exist period. They are ideas on a drawing board. Thorium reactors would have access to fuel that is a lot more plentiful and easier to extract. Nobody has yet built a proper Thorium reactor that is reproducible and affordable. Waste would also be less dangerous. Yet some of the transitions the thorium reactor process would have would be extremely dangerous. Hopefully, they would not stay in that state awfully long. Breeder reactors would extend the uranium supply for an extremely long time. There are two reactors that are in part based on this concept. If we were to start investing in nuclear power, then we need to finance building one these new reactors and observe it over 10 to 30 years. That should be enough time to learn about most bugs, dangers, faults, and problems. If it looks good, we build a few more and see what happens. Over several hundred years we could have enough new reactors running. Planning to construct a lot of untested reactors in parallel around the world is to me an exceptionally bad idea. We need to test learn, fail and learn in an iterative process IMHO Focus of financing and building sources for electricity should be focused on renewable energy that can keep going for a long time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_uranium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_uranium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium_fuel_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium_fuel_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium-based_nuclear_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium-based_nuclear_power
- 5y ago
- mem0r1 5y agoYes, it is.
- crubier 5y agoPut simply: Yes. Nuclear Power is (part of) our Best Bet Against Climate Change. I don't even think this requires further arguments, in 2021. This fact has been known for like 20 years, by anyone having a clue about orders of magnitude and energy.
- poormystic 5y agoIs the practise of Love our best defense against our own carelessness?
- rbrbr 5y agoEvery time there is an article about nuclear energy it has hundreds of comments here, many of which are pro nuclear. And every time I write the same, nuclear energy only is cheap energy if you ignore the entire decommission costs, which is what the big atomic industry always does. And that big lie is the core of the problem.
- avidphantasm 5y agoI think we are past the point of being so picky that we think we can afford to ignore all non “perfect” solutions. We have to recognize that to engineer our way out of climate disaster we will have to employ solutions that create new problems (e.g., nuclear waste) that we will have to solve in the future. As long as these problems can be solved later (which to an extent is true with nuclear waste), then we must proceed.
- edem 5y agoWhat about fusion? Is it still a pipe dream?
- mac01021 5y agoThis forbes article from 2 years ago (https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerpielke/2019/09/30/net-zero-carbon-dioxide-emissions-by-2050-requires-a-new-nuclear-power-plant-every-day/?sh=3b43285235f7 https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerpielke/2019/09/30/net-zero...) explains that, to replace the world's fossil fuel consumption with nuclear power consumption by 2050, a new nuclear power station would have to be brought online every day between now and then. I intuit (perhaps wrongly) that even one per 10 days is extremely far fetched. So, if 2050 is the deadline by which we must become carbon neutral in order to prevent catastrophic levels of climate change, I guess nuclear power cannot amount to as much as 10% of the solution.
- sesuximo 5y agoNuclear power already produces about 10% of world electricity https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-future-generation/nuclear-power-in-the-world-today.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-fu...
- mac01021 5y agoThat's true, but does not contradict any of the above. First, because much of our energy use is currently not electric. Second, because we're concerned with the energy consumption that is currently _not_ accounted for by nuclear power, not the portion that already is.
- natmaka 5y agoThe first part of this piece seems weird because this is not anymore about developing "nuclear vs fossil" but about developing "renewable sources or/xor nuclear".
- entropicgravity 5y agoNo.
- noetic_techy 5y agoNuclear in the short term, Fusion or Thorium reactors long term should be the goal. Get MIT's Spark reactor funded and built and lets hurry up and finish ITER, while we prototype Thorium in some medium sized cities. High density power generation is the key. Look at all the problems that come with wind and solar: land usage, transmission lines, loss of energy when weather becomes unfavorable, the amount of battery storage you need to manufacture.
- simonebrunozzi 5y agoLet me arrogantly simplify the problem a bit and offer a solution: 1) bet everything on renewables - solar and wind. more scale means lower and lower production/maintenance costs over time. 2) bet on the cheapest, most effective, least polluting energy storage solution, and add huge scale to it, hence vastly reducing costs over time. Cheap and clean energy storage makes the intermittent production problem of most renewables go away. No nuclear meltdowns. No waste disposal. And no coal, no gas, no pollution from burning that stuff. Ok, end of arrogant rant.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoNo waste disposal is wrong. For both solar cells and wind power. The panels are hazardous waste, and the carbon fiber blades are so far not economically recycleable, thus land fill material. Both last no longer than about 10 years, after that they are degraded too much, blades of wind turbines sometimes degrade even faster. Furthermore you can't put a wind turbine into the ground like a toothpick, especially not one about 200 meters high. They need massive concrete foundations, and if in a forest, broad ways to deliver and maintain the stuff. Guess what producing all that shit at scale means? More emission of the stuff you want to counteract the atmospheric effects of. Never mind, shit happens. Also stuff at sea degrades faster, and usually needs a shitload of continous maintenance to counteract that degrading. There is no cheap and clean storage at the scale needed, at least if you don't play stupid externalization games. The needed stuff does not grow on trees and needs to be produced in energy-, material- and transport-intensive ways, emitting even more of the stuff whose atmospheric effects it is supposed to counteract. Where were we?