20 ms·
Good. The website imore reported earlier this year that 96% of people in the US had opted out of tracking. It’s almost as if no one wants this “feature” Facebo
by MBCook 5y ago
Good. The website imore reported earlier this year that 96% of people in the US had opted out of tracking.
It’s almost as if no one wants this “feature” Facebook has been “providing” and given information about it and a choice have roundly rejected it.
I can’t wait to see what some of Apple’s other initiatives like the anti-tracking features in Mail on iOS 15 and the upcoming iCloud Private Relay do to the industry.
Hell, US intelligence agencies block ads at the network level because the ad industry is so infested with tracking/malware/spyware/exploits/etc. That’s a hell of an indictment.
Of course any time someone looks into it they find that that click-rate fraud is at outrageous levels. So maybe no one needs Apple. The fraud bots will keep the ecosystem running. /s
https://www.imore.com/96-iphone-users-have-opted-out-app-tracking-ios-145-launched https://www.imore.com/96-iphone-users-have-opted-out-app-tra...
https://www.vice.com/en/article/93ypke/the-nsa-and-cia-use-ad-blockers-because-online-advertising-is-so-dangerous https://www.vice.com/en/article/93ypke/the-nsa-and-cia-use-a...
- xivzgrev 5y agoIt’s also worth mentioning that apples prompt gives no benefit to tracking. It basically just asks “Facebook wants to track you. OPT OUT, or not”. Who is going to agree to that? If Apple gave developers a way to add a benefit or two, eg personalized experience or whatever, I bet we would see that % be much lower
- ceejayoz 5y agoMy "allow apps to ask to track" setting defaulted to off, too. Not sure what determines that, but in my case, I never even got the option to opt-in; the dialog never comes up because apps aren't even allowed to try asking me. I'm presumably in that 96%, but it wasn't an explicit choice. (I'd have opted-out, obviously.)
- vineyardmike 5y ago> My "allow apps to ask to track" setting defaulted to off, too. I have an employer profile on my phone for email/internal app/etc and one of the things this does is force this setting off.
- Terretta 5y agoThere’s [essentially] no contentful benefit to any major site’s tracking any more, [almost] nothing is ‘collaboratively filtered” and “personalized” around the content and your interests, [by and large] only around ad placement performance or conversion. The only remaining arguable benefit is that you will see “more relevant” ads, in other words, instead of seeing ads from whoever pays the most for your [well guessed] demographic, you’ll see endless “retargeted” begging for you to buy the thing you ordered last week.
- Jensson 5y agoDoes Apple use the same prompt for their own services tracking? If not, why don't they?
- dangerface 5y agoThe only problem with that is that tracking the end user only helps the developer not the end user.
- nielsbot 5y agoFB was toying with adding a screen before Apple's prompt: "Here's why tracking is good, actually." Wonder what happened to that.
- avalys 5y agoPeople “want” the free content and services that this advertising has been paying for. And the actual consequences of Apple’s decision for users and small businesses that rely on efficient advertising to connect with users will take time to become clear.
- donw 5y agoYou mean... they might need to charge money in exchange for goods and/or services? How capitalistically gauche!
- warkdarrior 5y agoGood. This will just accelerate the shift to crypto, where I can pay per page or per click, just tiny amount at a time.
- IAmLiterallyAB 5y ago"shift to crypto" mmm that seems unlikely
- jeffgreco 5y ago$0.15 for the page and $50.00 for the gas fee.
- keymone 5y agoTwitter has announced support for lightning. Why would anyone use eth when streamable money in isolated payment channels on top of the most secure monetary network in the world exists, is beyond me.
- yokem55 5y agoBecause rollups exist on Ethereum that are cheap and are far more suited to end user self-custody then lightning ever can be. At the moment zk-rollups are roughly 100x cheaper then mainnet, don't require the user to run a node to self custody, and the user can force a withdrawal to mainnet even if the roll-up operator completely dies.
- random292929 5y agoWhy does then Apple have a Ad service?. Should they not be tracking nothing?
- klodolph 5y agoDifferent ad services provide different levels of targeting, based on the data that different platforms collect about consumers and what those platforms are willing to let you use for targeting.
- jackson1442 5y agoWhat ad service? App Store ads? Those are based only on the actual search term.
- dialtone 5y agoNo they aren’t. Here https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/apple-advertising/ https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/apple-advertisin... have a nice read. But summary is they use a bunch of stuff about the device (past purchases, location, fingerprinting-like data such as carrier and so on) and your usage of a bunch of apps like apple news and stocks.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoIf you set brand image aside and just think about the huge amounts of money at stake, it becomes obvious that the whole app tracking transparency thing is just Apple taking over the ad market on iOS. They invented the term “cross app tracking” and defined it to not include their own conversion tracking through their various apps to purchases of their advertisers’ products via Apple Pay. Then they forced their ad-sales competitors to send all their conversion data to Apple, while providing separate APIs with richer data to their own advertisers.
- jeromegv 5y agoBeside AppStore ads, how can I buy ads from Apple for the Apple ecosystem to replace Facebook ads?
- tangjurine 5y ago> Of course any time someone looks into it they find that that click-rate fraud is at outrageous levels. So maybe no one needs Apple. The fraud bots will keep the ecosystem running. Could this be why ad recommendations are so bad? Recommendation engines being trained on (mostly fraudulent) click-through rates instead of ROI? Edit: It seems like it would be just a little more work to check both, but often incentives aren't aligned to doing the best work...
- _nalply 5y agoGood. And bad. I am not sure that Apple deserves this power. What if Apple is the next evil megacorp? For me this sounds like science fiction. Megacorps waging subtle war against each other. What's next?
- ben_w 5y agoAs far as I can tell, what Apple is doing with their privacy settings is merely what is required of data controllers (e.g. Facebook) by GDPR anyway, and as an EU resident by choice, I don’t personally see it as a huge issue for them to say “all apps must be compliant with EU law” (but then, if I did have a problem, I would not have migrated to here).
- simonh 5y agoI'm sure corporations have been waging war against each other for as long as corporations have existed.
- caskstrength 5y ago> I am not sure that Apple deserves this power. What if Apple is the next evil megacorp? Power to... present user with dialog asking whether they consent to be tracked? The horror!
- SXX 5y agoUh. Imagine presenting user with dialog asking if they want to pay 30% apple tax or they want an option to use 3rd-party app stores. Oops, users are too dumb for that, but Apple will protect them!
- breakfastduck 5y agoThey are presented with that. Just in real life. When they choose to buy the iPhone or something else.
- throwinawaysoon 5y ago
- BiteCode_dev 5y ago> The fraud bots will keep the ecosystem running It's like that everywhere. Yesterday a friend of mind was revealing to me that crypto currency exchanges were pressuring them to create bots so that their coin trading volume would go up or they would be delisted. There are bots to write comments on trip advisor and to star on amazon. Bots to follow on twitter. Bot to click on referal links and bot to farm in games. I'm pretty sure if we all suddenly went offline, half the internet would seem to keep going as usual.
- SuchAnonMuchWow 5y ago> I'm pretty sure if we all suddenly went offline, half the internet would seem to keep going as usual. Seems like a reasonable estimate if half the internet is porn.
- bongoman37 5y agoThere are massive bot farms that watch videos, click on ads, sometimes even do a download of the app after clicking and open the app. I've sometimes thought Google could cut out the middleman and just allow creators to outright buy 'views' on YouTube. You could pay like $100 to get 10,000 additional views which would translate to some additional ad revenue, which ad companies would know is inflated so they would discount the rates appropriately and no money would need to be sent to bot farms. This would also be far greener and need less servers and bandwidth and would be an overall win-win.
- thow-58d4e8b 5y agoIt's one thing to read about the click farms, but nothing can prepare one to actually see the videos of them in action - just visceral. It has an eerie Matrix-like feeling to it. 13 sec video of a Chinese click farm (quite loud): https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1072114511212109824 https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1072114511212109824 10 sec - thousands of phones (not loud): https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1148447866366464000 https://twitter.com/mbrennanchina/status/1148447866366464000
- 5y ago
- chrisBob 5y ago> Hell, US intelligence agencies block ads at the network level because the ad industry is so infested with tracking/malware/spyware/exploits/etc. That’s a hell of an indictment. I think this just means that they have a different threat profile than I do, and they take it seriously. There is a chance that an ad could attempt to attack me, but I am not likely to be targeted. If I thought state level attacks were going to target me specifically I would do a bunch of things differently, but it is not currently worth the effort.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI think its not about attacks as much as its about information gathering. There is value in knowing what the US Gov is searching for, visiting, from where, and when. The potential for attacks is just an added bonus. The problem is the tracking.
- dangerface 5y agoThe two times I ever got a virus was both from an advert exploiting flash, the threat is real.
- randcraw 5y agoI suspect US Intel staff who browse fear being identified, tracked, and their interests monitored more than they fear being attacked. The host from which they browse should be free of any sensitive data and easily disposable if hacked.
- nielsbot 5y agoAnd the other 4% tapped the wrong button by mistake...
- theshadowknows 5y agoI can tell you marketers are freaking out. And it’s delicious to watch.
- Lamad123 5y agoappol will seve you its own ads and spyware now!!