27 ms·
Why can an ad break the Windows 11 desktop and taskbar?
- cm2187 5y agoThe biggest deal breaker I have seen with win11 so far is the following: https://chromeunboxed.com/windows-11-insider-preview-chrome-default-difficulties https://chromeunboxed.com/windows-11-insider-preview-chrome-... Microsoft was already overriding your default apps regularly. But now to change back the default browser it looks like it will require many manual steps if I understood correctly. Multiply that by multiple machines...
- Frenchgeek 5y agoWelp... Good thing Wine and Proton keep getting better... Because unless Microsoft pay for my computer, I won't allow them to act as if they own it.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI hear you. Don't get me wrong, I have plenty to complain about in Linux too which is why I'm still on Windows, but the day is coming where Microsoft has finally made Windows so shitty that it drives me away.
- seph-reed 5y agoI switched over to ElementaryOS for my movie/music/games/3d-modeling/video-editing/daw machine a bit ago. It's pretty, and it (mostly) "just works." I legitimately believe this project is on its way to eat Windows and Apples pies. Worth watching the progress of: https://elementary.io/ https://elementary.io/
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI don't particularly appreciate Linux distributions that try to pretend they're not Linux distributions by slapping "OS" in their name. Regardless, Elementary doesn't fix any of the issues I personally have with Linux Desktop that keep me from switching today.
- selfhoster11 5y agoEh, IDK. The Arch and Ubuntu experience are very far apart for me, especially as far as hardware support goes (beyond just kernel drivers, I mean - lots of devices need userland utilities to support their functionality, things like remote scanning for instance). They are different OSes that happen to share a kernel, but that's it. Even the userland close to the kernel can be very different.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThey share a kernel, shells, package management as an application distribution model, and many disparately developed complex systems. They all run the same software more or less. Once you've used a few dozen different Linux distros, which I have over the 20 years I've used Linux for things, you find that almost all of them are basically the same. Occasionally there's an outlier like Gobolinux or Rox that everyone ignores but even they still has most software in common.
- Tijdreiziger 5y agoWhich applications do you use for video editing and DAW? How does the experience measure up to the competition on Windows?
- Mikeb85 5y agoMeh, for all of Linux's minor inconveniences it works pretty damn well and the freedom to not deal with MS and Apple's bullshit is a pretty big win.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThat's subjective. There are deeply ingrained paradigms on Linux that infuriate me to the point that, thus far, I'm more willing to put up with MS's bullshit than I am with Linux Desktop's.
- ravar 5y agoDitch the Desktop, embrace i3.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoEven if I liked tiling wms and keyboard-only GUI that wouldn't actually fix many of the issues I have with Linux Desktop. The issues have to do with the multitude of disparately developed complex systems that are kludged together under the hood.
- jagger27 5y agoOr Sway, which is more or less i3-upon-Wayland.
- jmholla 5y agoI'm curious what those are. If they're around the UI, I've found Cinnamon is a really good approximation.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI'm already getting downvotes just for mentioning the things I've already mentioned. Unfortunately this is the common reaction whenever anyone brings up having problems with the way Linux Desktop does things. It's apparently ok to complain about lacking hardware support because that's a problem people can dismiss easily with "just buy different hardware", but if you say something like you don't want to use Linux because you think package management is a stupid way to manage applications then people just want you to shut up.
- Frenchgeek 5y agoWell, I did spend a few days finding a modern version of Linux that can run on a Mac mini PPC... Its OS X was outdated so I installed Yellowdog on it, then Debian and now that Debian don't support 32 bits G4 anymore all I found was Void Linux. Plus side: there's so little loading at boot, it start very fast. Downside: I had to install Linux like it's 1995. So I know well Linux is far from perfect... But it has become at least as good as the competition for my uses.
- pabs3 5y agoDebian still has an unofficial 32-bit powerpc port, just doesn't have security supported releases of the port.
- alerighi 5y agoI recently switched back to Linux after not using it as my main OS for a couple of years. I was surprised how better it got, one example, everything worked well out of the box, and I installed Arch Linux not Ubuntu, no problem at all, GNOME 40 is great, fonts are good out of the box, gestures that works, things like screen brightness works, Wayland is finally stable, printer installs without too much trouble.
- orf 5y agoYou're damning it with faint praise there rather than selling it.
- neogodless 5y agoBut why would you want to default to Chrome and not Firefox... ? OK OK the point is, it should be the user's choice to (easily) switch. Even if they are wrong!
- C19is20 5y agoThe user is never wrong, just sometimes incorrect.
- philipov 5y ago> Windows 11 Insider Preview makes it more difficult for users to default to Chrome Are they implying that it won't be more difficult to default to Firefox? I ditched Chrome already.
- chris37879 5y agoEh, give it a day or two, someone will make a tool that sets it and keeps it set just like they did for Windows 10, or, leave. That's what I'm doing, Windows 10 currently only gets booted for me to play a couple e-sports games with bad DRM that some of my friends and I play together, other than that, I'm in Linux full time on Pop_OS!
- Arisaka1 5y agoI'm sure someone will come up with a tool to fix a Windows feature yet again (like they did with Start shell). But we have to judge the intention of the original product designer and all I see is regress.
- criley2 5y agoI wonder if users who are unwilling to deal with increased hassle in browser changing will also give up things like iPhone/iOS which outright ban competing browser engines.
- colejohnson66 5y agoNitpick: they don’t ban competing engines. They disallow JITing JavaScript outside a WebView. Firefox or Chrome could include their own, but the wouldn’t be able to JIT the JavaScript. A distinction without a difference, but it’s a lie to say they ban other engines.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- code_duck 5y agoDo you think it would be accurate to say that functionally or effectively bans competing engines by forbidding a major component? I believe Mozilla or Google would prioritize including their own engine if it was reasonably possible.
- diamondo25 5y agoYes. But I don't think its allowed to run a virtual machine of any kind in the App Store, which the browser javascript engine is/has been.
- code_duck 5y agoApple is not a slave to or victim of their own policy. I feel like a browser is an important and unique enough piece of software that they could choose to make an exception, but obviously it doesn’t fit their business goals which appear to essentially the same as what Microsoft was thinking with Internet Explorer 6.
- csande17 5y agoYes they do: > 2.5.6 Apps that browse the web must use the appropriate WebKit framework and WebKit Javascript. https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/
- themulticaster 5y agoSomewhat related: I removed Edge a few years ago because I didn't use it and thought it's just a regular application. A recent Windows update however just wouldn't install: Every time it would abort and roll back the update installation just after the reboot, reporting one of those mysterious and very helpful Windows Update error codes. After a few days of scratching my head I found out that due to a bug, that specific update [1] can't be installed unless Edge is installed (prior to the update). IIRC the reason is that helpfully Windows installs the lastest Edge version for you during the OS update, so that "you can experience the fastest web browser, Microsoft Edge!" (or something like that, you know the drill. Nowadays it's not even supported to remove Edge since - according to certain Windows news outlets - Edge is somehow integrated into Windows 10 so by removing it you could break the OS. (Just why??) The aforementioned news outlets also ask why you would ever want to remove Edge - "Have you tried the new Edge browser? It's quite fast nowadays!" To clarify: I am not opposed to Edge itself in any way, but the whole "Why would you ever want to do that?" rubs me the wrong way. Another "Why would you ever want to do that?" story: IIRC, in Windows 8 there was a semi-official way to place your home directory on a different drive than your system directory. Back then I had a 128 GB SSD I wanted to use as a system drive for Windows, but because my downloads folder quickly accumulates a lot of baggage (> 50 GB) I wanted to place it on another drive. A few years down the road the upgrade to Windows 10 failed with a mysterious error code. Again, after a few days of scratching my head I found out that my setup (with the home directory on another drive) is not supported for the Windows 8.1 to 10 upgrade. Common Windows news outlets and forums also commented this issue along the lines of "Why would you ever place your home directory on another drive?" I guess I was too spoiled with the UNIX way (of separate mount points inside a unified hierarchy) to see the error in my ways... (/s) [1] Sorry, I don't remember the specific error code or update number anymore. Perhaps the 2004 update?
- LorenPechtel 5y agoThey got slammed by anti-trust over integrating Explorer before. They should be slammed 10x as hard over this.
- GuB-42 5y ago
- hpoe 5y agoJust saying I've been using Ubuntu for my primary work machine (in a massive company) for over a year now and things work great, haven't had to fiddle with anything strange haven't had any weird issues and the UI is much nicer than Windows. I'd recommend giving it a try.
- PaulHoule 5y agoBecause Microsoft sees the 1/10 of a penny it gets from the ad as more important than your Desktop and your Taskbar.
- Ballas 5y agoIt seems that in this case they would get 100% of the money. Of course that would be clear if you read the article, as the ad is for Microsoft Teams. Edit: I am dumb. Please disregard.
- misnome 5y agoI think OP meant that the 100% of the value of the ad does go to Microsoft, but that the value of a single ad would be very low, in fractional pennies. edit: <snark now unnecessary>
- Ballas 5y agoWhat you are saying makes even less sense.
- yial 5y agoI believe what they’re trying to say, is that for Microsoft the revenue that they’re “booking” per ad is 1/10th of$0 .01. Not that they’re only getting 1/10th of the ad revenue. And that they’d rather is $0.001 over your desktop experience as your desktop usage doesn’t generate them income.
- PaulHoule 5y agoActually I think they are being penny wise and pound foolish. Alternately, they are distracted by the new shiny. Early sources, such as this classic book https://www.amazon.com/Image-Guide-Pseudo-Events-America/dp/0679741801 https://www.amazon.com/Image-Guide-Pseudo-Events-America/dp/... frame public relations and marketing folk as cynical manipulators who don't fall for the illusions they create. The post-modern environment has had about 60 years to develop since that book was written and I think the culture has deteriorated and I believe that, today, the image makers really do live in the "the matrix" they've created and have trouble distinguishing it from reality. (I think of how Valmont in Dangerous Liaisons really fell for his victim Madame de Tourvel.) My contacts with local business people and people who sell ads for radio and newspapers have convinced me that prices for advertising were too high for a long time because the people who buy advertising get gratification from hearing their name on the radio and the people who advertise won an auction because they get more gratification from hearing their name on the radio more than anyone else. Years ago somebody who was an "influencer" would try to appear authentic (not an "influencer") but today authentic people will try to look inauthentic ("i pretend to be an influencer even though I don't get paid") to get credibility. People under this spell will run ads in situations when they clearly shouldn't and they'll be astonishingly resistant to anyone who tries to talk sense into them. (Your desktop usage does make income for Microsoft since your OEM bought Windows for you. If they annoy you enough you might switch to Linux, MacOS, etc. Unfortunately your OEM probably wants to wreck the value of a $2000 computer they sold you by selling $2 worth of annoying ads.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> However, that doesn’t answer why the Windows shell was so poorly architect in the first place. It's simple really: Microsoft doesn't have any competent developers working on the Windows user interfaces. My guess is that if you display any competence you wind up being moved to somewhere they care about like Azure, PowerShell, or the licensing team. At this point I'm wondering if it is worth trying to build my own desktop on top of Windows Server Core.
- markus_zhang 5y agoI'm wondering what's the average programming skill MSFT takes in. I mean they definitely have a lot of competitive people who work in kernels and system programming fields, but I'm not sure about the other departments. Maybe the less important fields are for new hires to get into the game and that's why they suck.
- mathattack 5y agoThis is also why they never bother getting cut and paste to work between apps from companies they buy. It’s compounded by clueless salespeople who don’t know their products well enough to push the improvements that their customers want.
- thrower123 5y agoThe inconsistency in the way copy/paste works just inside of Outlook is maddening. Copy text and an image from an email? Images paste in all broken. Copy just the image from the email? Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Copy the image from the email, paste it into Paint, crop the canvas, then copy from Paint into whatever? Works every time.
- RubberbandSoul 5y agoI have the habit of "washing" everything with Notepad to get rid of inconsistencies: Copy text, data, etc from wherever Paste it into Notepad Copy it again Paste it where you want it and then apply any formatting according to the destination app's formatting rules Not a great workaround but at least it works.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jseigj43 5y agoWindows sucks, what's new.
- syncbehind 5y agoThanks for your insightful comment.
- phaemon 5y agoIndeed, not an insightful comment at all. Everyone knows that.
- cortexio 5y agoThere's some trouble in afghanistan (that's kinda new)
- jacquesm 5y agoWell, it's a surface so therefore sooner or later it will be plastered with ads and functionality is secondary to eyeballs. So this is more or less by design. Every time you see a surface that does not have advertising on it you have to wonder how long it will remain that way.
- adamdusty 5y agoThis happened to my girlfriend's laptop that she uses for school. By the time they released this fix I had already backed up what she needed, wiped the SSD, and installed a clean version of windows 10. After that, we'll both be on windows 10 as long as possible.
- MBCook 5y agoShe was running a pre-release OS?
- bitwize 5y agoWell, she is dating a Hackernews.
- lostlogin 5y agoWhich is why it’s mystifying. If she was running an obscure distro, compiled from source after checking each line for nefarious code like everyone should do, and after having prepared the hardware (carefully consulting the compatibility list), that would be normal.
- post-it 5y agoBest not to use a beta OS on your main workstation anyway.
- syncbehind 5y agoWhy would you ever run a beta/ pre-release on your main machine? That seems like asking for trouble.
- adamdusty 5y agoShe can do whatever she wants with her stuff. I told her I could run it back for her if she wanted when I saw she was on 11 but she said she liked it.
- selfhoster11 5y ago
- emn13 5y agoSigh, now I pressed Win+C because the article mentioned it... of course that opens cortana, the app that insists on being unclosable and sticking around in your alt-tab order, no matter whatever you do. Lovely.
- aspaceman 5y agoReally wish I could meet the idiot who closed that bug as WNF. Just know they have some dumb as rocks reason for keeping that behavior. "The user may want to return to Cortana. WNF"
- emn13 5y agoIt's also just plain weird and inconsistent - like so many windows apps by MS. The default OS behavior is fine, and works. Why are they going to the extra effort to break it? Other apps sometimes decide to minimize to the tray, but even those don't stick around in your alt-tab order o_O. You'd think first party apps would adhere more strictly to OS norms, but no...
- Piskvorrr 5y ago($_$) Why indeed...?
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoDark patterns make money. MS likes making money. If you don't want to be a pawn in their social experiment use something else.
- lostlogin 5y agoSiri on the Mac isn’t this bad but it is also horrible. Getting it too never appear and never try to help is an irritating step which is required on a new install.
- d2wa 5y agoIt’s C for Chat in Win11.
- marcodiego 5y agoIf the OS has ads out of the box, it is already broken.
- inetknght 5y agoSo... also Ubuntu then
- Mikeb85 5y agoWhere are the Ubuntu ads? I remember the Amazon ads back in the day, but there haven't been any in quite some time.
- e3bc54b2 5y agoUbuntu has weird ads in the apt upgrade or something like that promoting their other services. They also sneak in their Snap package for Chromium even if user asks apt to do it. In general the Snap push feels like making proprietary apps normal on Linux desktop.
- daxelrod 5y agoThey promote other technologies of theirs via the MOTD, which some consider an ad. See https://news.softpedia.com/news/canonical-under-fire-for-putting-ads-in-the-ubuntu-motd-530372.shtml https://news.softpedia.com/news/canonical-under-fire-for-put... . Here's the current MOTD: https://motd.ubuntu.com/ https://motd.ubuntu.com/
- officeplant 5y agoYes? Ubuntu has its fair share of problems over time as well. Luckily there are hundreds of other distros.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bastawhiz 5y agoOperating systems in beta are buggy, usually up until the eleventh hour. Yet, we continue to be surprised when the latest macOS preview or Windows beta eats our homework. Just a couple months ago we were bemoaning the issues in macOS Monterey, including VPN apps just not working. If you don't want bugs, don't run the beta. Edit: why the downvotes? A bug in a beta is the only news here. Ads in Windows are not new. Critical bugs in Windows are not new. Windows updates and services breaking Windows is not new. Literally the whole point of the beta program is to find bugs like this.
- neogodless 5y agoMy history is rusty, but the first ads in Windows were probably in Windows 8 live tiles in the Start Menu. (Not including Internet Explorer being forced upon everyone.) But it expanded from there - there are ads in Settings encouraging browser choice and discouraging changes to default applications. Ads all over your first-run experience. Ads in the taskbar encouraging you to use Edge and Teams. The ad system is heavily integrated into Explorer / taskbar. Which is how poorly constructed ads can break such vital operating machinery.
- ByteWelder 5y agoEven ads on the lock screen (for Microsoft Edge) and through MS-certified drivers (e.g. Corsair iCue, Dolby Atmos).
- drcongo 5y agoAnd they charge you to use this?
- neogodless 5y agoSort of? I've been building PCs for about 20 years, and when doing it for others, I'd have them buy a license. For myself, the only time I can recall buying a Windows license was for Windows Home Server and WHS 2011. I got a free Windows 7 Ultimate license, which I have now upgraded through 8/8.1 to 10 Pro. But yes, a mainstream Windows user pays for a Windows license, either through a direct license purchase, or through the baked in price of a machine. Most users did not pay to upgrade machines from 7/8/8.1 to 10, but that was a bargain with the devil, as it made it easier on the decision-makers at Microsoft to find other ways to make money off of Windows 10 users.
- drcongo 5y agoWhat a horror story, thanks for the comprehensive answer.
- sharken 5y agoPart of setting up a Win 10 machine should include disabling telemetry, even though it's not easy. https://winaero.com/how-to-disable-telemetry-and-data-collection-in-windows-10/ https://winaero.com/how-to-disable-telemetry-and-data-collec... It probably won't be long before the Windows 11 version is here.
- HumblyTossed 5y ago> How come that it would stop responding just because of one failed cloud service? Because the network the developers are on ALWAYS connects to the cloud service so nobody ever ran into an issue.
- grishka 5y agoUnless the main purpose of your software is to be a client for an online service, you should always assume that the normal state of the user's network connection is offline, and being online is an exception.
- Piskvorrr 5y agoWindows (a product that you need to buy a license for) has builtin ads. Well, good for MS, I guess...as for me, I'm quite happy that MS has pushed me away from its stack already with Vista: it sure isn't getting any better.
- mschuster91 5y agoWindows 7 was a perfectly decent OS. In my opinion, the best one they ever made. Rock solid in the end, able to run on anything from ultra low cost embedded stuff to high performance workstations, no ads... Only thing that bugs me to no end is that they never released a "final" version that has all available security and quality updates included, so one does not need to run Windows Update for hours after a fresh SP1 install (after wasting hours getting WU to run in the first place, it broke thanks to some signature hashing update).
- wintermutestwin 5y ago? In your 1st paragraph, you praise Win7 as "rock solid," and in the 2nd, you point out the incredibly lame and showstopping bugs in their SHIT updater which show just how jello solid their OS is. I have the same types of updater issues on Win10 boxes I have to support. I assume that the new clusterfuck will be more of the same.
- unanswered 5y agoExpect more of the same. My impression from my years in the Windows org is that the only team with any devs remaining working on the desktop version of Windows is the shell team, and that is being staffed more and more by webdevs.
- blibble 5y agoI for one can't wait for explorer.exe to be entirely replaced by Electron
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoThe fact that we're no longer shocked and aghast at the idea of Microsoft pushing advertisements to the desktop - but rather that those ads have bugs in them - shows how far the Overton window has shifted. Boiling the frog.
- zdragnar 5y agoWe have had ads in windows since st least the release of 8 many years ago (many in tech time at least). On top of that, manufacturers have been pushing ads onto windows for even longer in the form of preinstalled crapware. The bug is really the only thing that is new here.
- city41 5y agoA good time to thank Stallman for seeing all this coming and preparing way back in 1983. As far as I know he was the first person to kick off the open source OS effort, and of course quite a few people have helped over the decades.
- sneak 5y agoNone of the OSes that Stallman suggests are acceptable are actually acceptable, though. No real way to build a skyscraper or produce a state of the art feature film on free software. Stallman was as wrong about just as much stuff as he was right. It turns out that a few hundred billion dollars of paid software engineering effort can't simply be waved away as "nonfree, so irrelevant". The whole world moved on to devices where not only is the software nonfree, there is not even an option of choosing free software, and, even if there were, there is no comparable free software to choose. Why? Because they work better and allow you to get more things done in less time.
- y4mi 5y agoMost of the apps on my phone are from f-droid so your premise is void. It's true that it's unreasonably hard to get a decent mobile device that's also free by his definition, but there definitely are free app choices which are often superior to their closed equivalent if you step outside of the apple ecosphere.
- kwonkicker 5y agoWait, why are we ok with the fact that windows has ads in them?
- fron 5y agoThe choices are to accept Windows w/ ads, or reject Windows altogether It's not about being ok with it, it's about only having the nuclear option, switching OS entirely, as the alternative
- selfhoster11 5y agoOr rip and tear into Windows to remove the ad-bearing components. Granted, this may not be a choice for long, but worked for a while.
- glecedric 5y agoDoes anyone know if the Windows 11 pro version will have the ads and privacy shenanigans ?. Or you require the enterprise version, which is not easy to get for the average joe.
- CTOSian 5y agolast week I tried the w10 enterprise (latest iso) and -holy crap- on the start menu search , there was an ad "for minecraft", I did run those removeappx scripts but even then... yes I am back to linux (not everything is fantastic there, I am talking about theming) but when I remove the m$-edge and the darn thing is being reinstalled AGAIN after an update, that is absurd -not to mention I had to play with the policy to cut off the telemetry - at least on linux I have the friggin control.
- yoyohello13 5y agoEveryone blames Microsoft for this shit, but the real blame should go to everyone who STILL chooses to use their user hostile, buggy, platform. If you want to see stuff like this change then use an OS that actually views its users as more than ad revenue.
- redleggedfrog 5y agoC'mon man, throw a try/catch around that sh*t!
- DrBazza 5y ago> Microsoft pushed a promotional message which is why "I'm out" after 20 years or so on Windows. I don't want an OS that sends me messages like that, supports adverts, or (initially at least) demands to be always connected to the internet to store my "stuff" in their cloud. I haven't booted into Windows for (checks `uptime`) about 4 weeks now.
- Rd6n6 5y agoI use windows for affinity suite and unreal 4 and I think that’s it. About half my gaming needs windows too. Everything else is Ubuntu. Ubuntu is a great OS, it’s just missing a few apps (mostly graphics related) that certain people need for their work
- Arisaka1 5y agoI worked in IT for 10 years, and most of the time I had to work with Windows even in the server. I was also a gamer who played 3-4 hours a day. I switched to Arch Linux and, outside of the few pain points which weren't a big deal for anyone who's used to "google, read docs, apply" workflow everything went great! I would be hopeful for the future of gaming on Linux, and then you see things like kernel-level anti-cheating and Valorant adapting their anti-cheat to support TPM 2.0. I'm not a gamer anymore (at least not as much as I used to play) but stuff like that make me shrug my shoulders. 1 step forward, 2 steps back.
- tomxor 5y agoThat Windows has ads in it sounds completely insane to me... you buy an OS.. and you still get ads? Makes my memories of win95 seem fonder.
- Mindwipe 5y agoWell, ultimately because the new taskbar is a half finished mess, and the idea that it is ready to push out a month from now to mass users is completely bonkers.
- 0xcde4c3db 5y agoOn this note, is anyone familiar with the state of alternative Windows shells? The last time I played with them was ca. 20 years ago when the cool kids were running LiteStep on Windows XP. The LiteStep web site and forums still seem to be up, but I don't think it's been under active development for quite a while. I've also seen some scattered praise for Classic Shell / Open Shell (although I'm not sure whether that's a full shell replacement) and heard of a handful of people running the ReactOS shell on Windows. Is this still at all viable, or has MS made an intractable mess of the relevant APIs over the years?
- selfhoster11 5y agoI'm one of those people that quite heavily customised their Windows 10 experience to run away from the actual Windows 10 as far as possible. I can confirm that Classic Shell (now Open-Shell) is 100% the one piece of software that makes Windows 10 usable. Having to use an unfamiliar Windows 10 machine with its Start Menu is jarring and unpleasant. The replacement Start Menu is just better. Windows 10 Explorer has a couple of mods that change its functionality, but I guess that it could be replaced by a third party application entirely. There are both Explorer-style and Norton Commander-style (dual pane) file managers that would do the job just as well if not better than the stock application. Notepad and Task Manager also seem very easy to replace with freeware alternatives. I haven't tried such measures recently, but I can see no reason why they should fail. If you want to mod away the Windows 10 taskbar (which is the one thing I actually like about Windows 10), you may want to check out RetroBar. It's a C#(?) replica of the classical-style Windows taskbar from 95 to XP eras. It even has the same icons and hides the original Windows 10 taskbar. It actually feels uncanny, running something so close to the real thing on such a new OS. It's very nice. Other than that, I don't know of anything that would e. g. get rid of the new Control Panel or other mandatory parts. In practice, if you replace the things I listed above, it's really unlikely that you'll come across the stock Windows UI in the course of normal daily use.
- dimgl 5y agoI'm trying to break away from Windows but Linux OSes are in such poor shape as replacements for workstations... In particular I'm talking about desktop environments, not so much the OSes themselves, although the kernel and the OSes at times have their own problems too. I decided to try GNOME 40, everything was sort of okay until I couldn't even even pin custom applications to the dock... I had to write .desktop files or something and I just gave up. I also tried ElementaryOS but still ran into tons of usability issues. Granted, a lot of those issues are because some apps are missing Linux specific functionality and developers aren't really focused on supporting Linux, but honestly there are power users waiting to get away from Windows right now. Every other week my friends are talking about how once there's a good Linux alternative they're switching and never looking back. Now with Valve's Proton things are looking better than ever for gaming, but it still feels like Linux has a long way to go.
- walteweiss 5y agoBefore I switched to Linux (from macOS) I believed such commenters as they gave me the plausible excuse. This is wrong. Linux is very good for an average person. Well, if that average person wants to do something unusual and doesn’t want to invest even a fraction of their time into learning the system… well, blame on them. Making a desktop file is no rocket science, and something you can learn how to do within half an hour at most. Don’t listen to someone who makes such a bold statement as ‘Linux in such a bad state’ and then immediately shows their lack of competence with showing they are unable to make a desktop file. It is not Linux, it is you and all those guys who upvoted you to become the top voted comment on this thread. ElementaryOS is trash, just get yourself Fedora Workstation or even Ubuntu, if you have no idea of how to deal with Linux, changes are it will be much easier for you with those distros.
- walteweiss 5y agoForgot to add about the distros: I didn't mean Ubuntu and Fedora are bad in any way, but the opposite. I think they are very good for an average person who looks to escape Windows. Personally I think Fedora Workstation is much better than Ubuntu, but very similar in that very departments: being very popular and yet working out of the box.
- intrasight 5y agoI'll stick to using Windows Server as my desktop.
- dimgl 5y agoI've been thinking about this more and more. Is it worth it?
- nicholashead 5y agoI had a weird issue the other day (two days ago?) too where trying to load Microsoft Store/check for updates would just completely freeze the program. And also my start menu would not execute apps - I could search for them and hit enter to run them - but nothing would happen. I'm wondering if it was related to some of this. You're absolutely right that an OS should never "soft-lock" on cloud/networking issues. It's insane to me that we still deal with this as programmers in the year 2021. Write asynchronous code. Expect network slowness or weirdness.
- d2wa 5y agoIf I remember correctly, then your specific issue was supposedly fixed in one of the recent Insider builds. Windows Search is heavily cloud-dependent, and yes it’s performance suffers under poor network conditions.
- nihilmu 5y agohow can you people live like this?
- nihilmu 5y agohow can you ppl live like this?
- stefan_ 5y agoRemember when 70% of iOS apps stopped working because the Facebook SDK crashed on launch after Facebook servers started sending slightly differently formatted JSON crap? And then, it happened again? Looks like this innovation has finally landed in Windows!
- chadlavi 5y agoThat was third party apps. This is the OS itself.
- lpcvoid 5y agoIt saddens me that a developer decided to stuff json into the registry, when it's perfectly possible to instead store nice and compact binary data structures. But this is 2021, can't have efficient data representation anymore.
- rdiddly 5y agoI was, not quite saddened, but surprised, to see JSON in the registry recently. I forget where it was though or what I was doing.
- yabones 5y agoI've seen XML hex encoded before. That was from a Toshiba printer driver on win 7. This seems like the logical next step...
- babypuncher 5y agoI prefer data be serialized into something human readable wherever there is any chance a person might want to edit it manually. Storage is dirt cheap and de-serializing JSON is very fast. The registry isn't the place to do it, and I'm surprised anyone still bothers with it in 2021. All my software relies on config files, and this is the pattern Microsoft themselves have promoted for years with .NET
- LorenPechtel 5y agoThe registry is a good idea for anything *other* programs need to know. Putting the information for any given program into the registry is a bad idea and I think far more an anti-piracy measure than good programming.
- superdisk 5y agoThis is really emblematic of how I think Windows (and Microsoft) lost its way. Maybe the registry wasn't ultimately the best implementation, but I don't dislike the idea behind it-- a centralized repository of information and configuration for programs. Flawed as it may be, it was an attempt at something more sophisticated than storing things in files. I feel like this is the case for a lot of legacy MS technologies-- they attempted to really innovate, and maybe they fell short but at least they were trying. OLE, COM, .NET, JET engine, WinFS, Longhorn, all attempts at making an advancement in the OS space. Seems like recently though that they've just succumbed to the "Unix philosophy" of doing everything in a simple yet primitive/crude way. It greatly disappoints me that now NOBODY is trying to make an operating system for the future, not based on the local maximum of Unix, except maybe Google and Fuchsia. Shoving JSON into the registry is like a caveman using a hoverboard as a club or something. Sad!
- hbn 5y agoIt's hard to even make the "this is what you signed up as an Insider" argument when they're supposedly releasing this thing next month. This launch is gonna be a mess.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- phreack 5y agoThey coupled the OS to cloud stuff so tightly they break together? That's so absolutely bonkers, even if it's a boiled frog situation, I'm speechless. I'll start dual booting Linux to get used to it because this is finally unacceptable.
- pas 5y agoWell, considering that real frogs jump out when the water gets too hot, maybe people will too. (If there's an alternative, and they really feel the inconvenience.)
- Jalad 5y agoReminds me of this Leslie Lamport quote: A distributed system is one in which the failure of a computer you didn't even know existed can render your own computer unusable Although I wasn't expecting a Windows 11 desktop machine to be a distributed system!
- alkonaut 5y agoThe Windows Shell works the way it does because it worked that way before. If I wrote an extension for explorer 15 years ago and it used a bug or even an undocumented api it probably still works. That’s the good thing. The other side of the coin is that things can never fundamentally be fixed. It appears that explorer must block the UI thread while waiting for a network share operation (for example) due to some fundamental eternal compatibility promise.
- banana_giraffe 5y agoNot any more. I mean, they'll still work, but shell extensions are now hidden behind another layer in the right click menu on Windows 11.
- eplanit 5y agoHow can people trust a company with a product like this, and a product history like it has, with their code on Github, or with their personal/career info on LinkedIn? I've always considered Microsoft as the "McDonalds of Software" -- they sell billions of copies, but the product isn't of quality or healthy.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThere is not much of an alternative. LinkedIn and GitHub are basically Facebooks of their respective niches, and they actually matter for career advancement.
- alexeiz 5y agoMicrosoft Teams was installed on my test Windows 11 box without asking. When the Teams notification appeared, I was like "WTF is this shit?" I had to go, search for Teams in the start menu and then uninstall it. After this incident upgrading to Windows 11 I'm not.
- a13n 5y agoI'm pretty sure Teams came with installing office for me, not installing Windows 11. I could be wrong though.
- nicce 5y agoTeams is intended to be part of the Win 11. They have had even ads about that; no need to install it anymore! https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/24/22548738/microsoft-teams-windows-11-integration-announcement-features https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/24/22548738/microsoft-teams-...
- at_a_remove 5y agoI wonder if the LTSC version will have this nonsense in it.
- dano5 5y agobecause it's beta? ^^
- dano5 5y agobecause it's beta? ^^ but joke aside, I don't get ads in the taskbar or start menu
- jrockway 5y agoAs I always say in these threads, I would be happy to pay Microsoft for a Windows license that doesn't have Cortana, Teams, telemetry uploads, the app store, etc. I just want to run applications that through past probably-illegal monopolistic actions, require APIs that only exist on Windows machines. Accept that you are just boring plumbing, and don't have any "value added services", and you earn my money. (Oh, and ship the damn patch for Hyper-V that adds nested virtualization on AMD processors. It's been in preview builds for like 2 years!) Computers are about the applications you run and what you make with them. Nobody wants to know the name of their OS vendor, or buy anything else from them. Sorry, Microsoft. If something is good, I'll find out about it. (Happy to pay for Github, for example!)
- n8cpdx 5y agoI'd like to see windows be part of office 365. Windows users get 'free' Windows on the desktop and Mac users can get licenses for parallels. Maybe they could set it up so that Windows is free with ads, but subscribers can turn everything off and get full control.
- bombcar 5y agoOffice 365 E5 includes this. Or at least a Windows 10 Professional license. Not sure if you have to have Windows 10 normal first.
- eric__cartman 5y agoWindows should have a "minimal install" option were it only installs the base operating sysyem and not much else. That's why Windows XP/7 will always be the pinnacle of Windows releases in my opinion.
- derefr 5y agoIt does, but Microsoft doesn't consider that level of minimalism to be an "end user" use-case, so it's not an option available to end users to install. Instead, in Microsoft's minds, this is a use-case exclusively of interest to embedded-device system integrators (i.e. the people building the world's ATMs, billboards, gas pumps, slot machines, ticket kiosks, etc.) So that's how they market it: https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot/ https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/iot/ Make no mistake, though, you can just download and install Windows IoT Core onto any random PC; and (mostly) arbitrary Windows apps can be installed and run on top of Windows IoT Core. The only proviso being, that IoT Core is maybe a bit too minimal for your use-case: IoT Core assumes you don't need a desktop (because you're likely remotely managing the device, and deploying a full-screen kiosk-style app that isn't meant to be broken out of.) It still has a graphical "control plane" shell sort of thing, but it's entirely built on the Metro/UWP UX, with no ability to launch programs in windowed mode. (Essentially, there's no window manager running.) I believe this means that Win32 apps that try to spawn multiple windows (e.g. old versions of Photoshop that make the palettes their own windows), won't work on IoT Core. Most modern stuff avoids that, though. I would note that this "remote-deploy and boot apps in fullscreen, with access to Win32 but not GDI, graphics only though UWP" paradigm, closely mirrors the experience of using an Xbox One in developer mode. I bet the "distro" of Windows used between IoT Core and the modern Xbox are near-identical.
- lobocinza 5y agoUntil it's a 'commercial offense' I will counter/refuse everything that contain ads.
- jumelles 5y agoI'm not crazy! I had to reinstall Windows last night, extremely frustrating.
- Shadonototro 5y agotheir native stack is so bad that they though the web tech would be a much better and solid alternative this is very sad on many levels windows needs a full reboot, and even that i'm not sure it's gonna be saved, it's poorly managed they can't even agree on what this version is, internals says windows 10, marketing team says windows 11 billion dollar company, they said
- smusamashah 5y agoIf a Linux OS becomes a good at gaming as Windows and get an office suit as good as Windows, we can't move away general public from Windows. These are the two things left which most people use it for.
- luxuryballs 5y agoThey can’t make it too good they still have to sell us Windows 12.
- cooljacob204 5y agoI think it might be time to change to Linux. I really hope Valve can get EAC and Battleye running soon (Gaming anti-cheat services).
- michaelmrose 5y agoSo what is the chance of an ad by a third party exploiting systems or accidentally breaking them. Is there a good reason to believe that that ad space will be treated differently in the long term from any other space?
- fuzzfactor 5y agoAccording to the author: >I’m not saying Microsoft needs to remove its account, cloud gaming, entertainment, software delivery, and other cloud services. No need. Millions of people have been saying it for a while.
- cgtyoder 5y agoGet this guy a couch - someone has a case of the vapours. PRERELEASED SOFTWARE HAS A BUG IN IT OMG! Yes, there are still going to be problems. No, it's not the end of the world and there's still time to fix it. This is a tempest in a teapot and utterly not worth the screen space on HN.
- mdoms 5y ago> There’s an enormous elephant in the room, though: how Microsoft could have let this happen? Yes, this is a beta build for early adopters. Yes, rough edges and productivity losses are expected. Why pay lip service to the fact that you're intentionally running beta software if that won't affect your view? Yes, your beta software broke. That happens.
- sundvor 5y agoUsed to be part of the Win 95 beta and such. It was greatly exciting back then. Now I'm in no rush to install Win11 whatsover, even though my main PC that I built last year actually has the Asus TPM module (added later) as I needed Bitlocker. My high end Asus motherboard at over AUD$500 didn't include this $50 module, which is a Win 11 requirement. (Well it cost me that much when including postage). A pet gripe with Win10: Entering your name as part of a normal setup creates a screwed up username, which is very annoying when using command line paths. Doing an "offline" installation lets you pick your own, but still inundates you with stupid "are you sure" questions and forces you to give 3 kinds of "what's your favourite colour" answers when setting up a password. The above is so annoying, when almost everything else has gotten so good. (Very notable exception: The fact that I even have to see the words "candy crush" in my start menu when done, and that Store tries to force you to log in every time you get something from it eg Terminal or Ubuntu for WSL2). I'm sure Win11 will make keeping in control even harder. I predict this is going to be another failure. Tic-toc, never fails for them.
- bladefire 5y agoThe core process that gives you the snallest sense of stability and control, the taskbar and startmenu, are still aspects of the operation system that Microsoft refuses or is too inept to update. My bet, they lost all of their assembler programmers and are left with an inept team of skin programmers.
- canadianfella 5y ago> installation of an unrelated software. A software?
- phendrenad2 5y agoCorrection: Why can an ad break the windows 11 beta desktop and taskbar