10 ms·
Virgin Galactic flights grounded over Branson spaceflight 'mishap'
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- etc-hosts 5y agoI don't use Adblockers, I'm just a normal person... my browser Back button doesn't work! @#$)*@#$&#@
- belter 5y agohttps://archive.is/QlDQF https://archive.is/QlDQF
- sega_sai 5y agoI have mixed feelings about this. 1) It's nice that FAA reads newspapers and reacts in a sensible way 2) It's weird that they needed an article, rather than starting investigations after actual incidents.
- baggy_trough 5y agoIt's a sign of being in a low-competence regime. What matters is what makes the news, not what's actually happening.
- H8crilA 5y agoI have some experience with the aviation authorities, and they are generally competent. And I would say maybe even slightly too nitpicky, just like the general public is very nitpicky about every aircraft accident or incident. It is possible that they just didn't know about the issue it. Did you know, for example, that every bird collision, no matter how small the bird was, has to be registered as a flight incident and investigated? Or that every TCAS warning is a flight incident too, even if everyone knew exactly what was going on and there was no real danger? And I do not think it's wrong, you hit a bird every blue moon and you get extra hour or a few hours of paperwork, it's okay with me. The point is they're very detailed.
- scardycat 5y agoThey (aviation authorities) did not seem too nitpicky in clearing Boeing 737 Max and are culpable in the deaths of hundreds of people.
- selectodude 5y agoThey (the FAA) oversaw zero deaths caused by the 737 MAX.
- simonh 5y agoThat’s rather silly. The FAA allowed those planes to fly in the US, with the flaws that lead to those deaths. They also manipulated test results in order to facilitate recertification of the planes after the crashes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wonder_er 5y agoDoesn't count in their favor: "FAA safety engineer goes public to slam the agency’s oversight of Boeing’s 737 MAX" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376549
- trimbo 5y agoIndonesia has a bilateral agreement for airworthiness with the FAA[1]. [1] - https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/international/bilateral_agreements/baa_basa_listing/ https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/international/bilatera...
- detaro 5y agoIt oversaw and did their type certification, which per treaties is the basis on which they operate in many parts of the world.
- skynetv2 5y ago
- sp332 5y agoVG points out that FAA representatives were in the control room during the flight. https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/spaceship-carrying-richard-branson-flew-off-course-faa-is-investigating/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/spaceship-carrying-r...
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> FAA representatives were in the control room Control room doesn't see everything the cockpit sees. Particularly not in a pilot-centered vehicle design like Virgin Galactic's. Having a representative in the room, moreover, doesn't mean it's someone qualified to look for problems. Even if they are, it's a big room with lots going on.
- javajosh 5y agoRegarding 2, it makes sense to me. The FAA's purview is vast. They handle matters pertaining to all airspace in the USA. That includes commercial and private flights, drones, local government, and (of course) space flight. (And maybe even military flights, too, IDK). Is there such a thing as an "FAA detective" that preemptively goes on-sight to verify the reports they receive? Like most agencies, they function primarily on a self-reporting basis, relying heavily on the fear of retributive sanctions to ensure that they aren't being lied to in those reports. Can you imagine the cost of investigating everyone and everything the FAA is supposed to regulate?! My sense is that, unusually among government regulators, the FAA is generally competent and cares about the real consequences of their in/action - both because the subject is life-and-death table stakes, but also because when there's a disaster the FAA itself is, by default, one of the "usual suspects". And rightly so. Personally I see this as a very optimistic story about a regulator that actually does its job.
- refulgentis 5y agoYes, in the article it mentions specifically that FAA agents were in the control room and had access to the pilots warnings. So then it seems more like responding to an article than the facts they saw on the ground Edit: I'm being downvoted to -3 for reading the article and making an anodyne comment answering a question about it. Cool.
- bpodgursky 5y agoYeah, it definitely smells more like ass-covering for optics than anything they were concerned about at the time of launch.
- dougmwne 5y agoGood they were in the room at the time. I would absolutely want a public accounting for the gap between what the regulators in the room saw vs. why the grounding after the article. Abundance of caution over a nothing-burger? Ok, just say so. A bad call made by the regulators in the room? Ok, human error exists. An intentional effort to keep the regulators need-to-know or an intentional looking the other way? Big problem.
- snowwrestler 5y agoWell it says “after” the article, not “because of,” so it’s possible the FAA was planning to do this anyway. It’s even possible that the causality goes the other way: that the FAA’s movement toward a grounding was the spur for sources to reach out to a reporter.
- sp332 5y agoIt says "over". Well it does now anyway.
- wonder_er 5y agoAccording to at least one insider who is well qualified to speak on the issue, the FAA is not competent, should not be trusted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376549 "FAA safety engineer goes public to slam the agency’s oversight of Boeing’s 737 MAX"
- fotta 5y agoFrom the original New Yorker article [0]: > An F.A.A. spokesperson confirmed that Virgin Galactic “deviated from its Air Traffic Control clearance” and that an “investigation is ongoing." So this isn't a new investigation. [0] https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-red-warning-light-on-richard-bransons-space-flight https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-red-warning-lig...
- ascar 5y agoQuoting the article from yesterday: > An F.A.A. spokesperson confirmed that Virgin Galactic “deviated from its Air Traffic Control clearance” and that an “investigation is ongoing.” So I don't know where that whole narrative of the article causing the action is coming from. The investigation was already ongoing and it seems highly unlikely that bureaucrats rush something within 24 hours just because of an article in the newyorker.
- rrss 5y agoI think the originally submitted HN title was something like “flights grounded after New Yorker article” instead of the article’s title.
- beerandt 5y agoI also doubt that the FAA investigation would have much to do with the major narrative of the article. From their perspective, the flight went off course for 2 mins, and they're looking for the proximate cause. They're looking for a specific safety issue, not any underlying generalized sense of a rotten safety culture at the company. The acute problem might lead directly to a bigger general issue, if there's some direct evidence of fudged risk analysis or some specific, similar, overtly wrong behavior. But more likely, it'll just be: we misjudged how it would handle that specific wind and were blown off course. Or something similar. ETA: Has it even been established that the warning light/entry angle was the cause of or directly related to the airspace violation? Other than the new yorker author's assumption?
- nieve 5y agoEither they deviated by a large margin or the area they were cleared for was too small because you don't just get mildly blown off course enough to exit a decent clearance area.
- beerandt 5y agoMaybe. There are lots of explanations for not having a larger test area, or for miscalculating a manually piloted crafts mach 3+ trajectory. But you're missing the bigger point. It may have been completely unrelated to weather. By "something similar" I mean an innocent, isolated, non-cultural and non-conspiratorial explanation, that won't involve the FAA digging (or having to dig) any deeper than the superficial proximate cause. It was a test flight of a manually piloted craft. To some extent, things will not go as expected. Boeing and Russias last manned flights weren't manually controlled, and both had significant problems- early rocket shutdown and an unintentional, initially unstoppable thruster firing. Yeah it needs investigating, but it's hardly unexpected or uncommon, especially for a test flight.
- hinkley 5y agoI was just talking to an amateur pilot the other day and somehow this general topic came up. The FAA works on an honor system. If they chased people around looking for violations and fining people (which apparently they used to do) then people would try to circumvent detection, or avoid declaring an emergency and end up creating a bigger one. They need transparency for things to improve, so they expect you to self report and they bring the hammer down if you don’t by hitting you where it hurts: right in the flight certifications. From what I’m seeing it looks like Virgin didn’t self report before the news folks got wind and the FAA heard it through the grapevine, so they’ll get a big fat wake up call, and if that doesn’t get their attention then things will get much worse for them. Or, this is just SOP and an angle that sells ads and so it’s being hyped while nothing particularly egregious is happening from the FAA’s point of view.
- edrxty 5y agoCan second this. A couple decades ago the FAA was pretty tyrannical in their approach to compliance. Among other things they'd commonly stick inspectors at random airports and run through everyone's paperwork as they came in, handing out incredibly harsh punishments to anyone out of compliance. This garnered a lot of distrust from the community and lead to people devising ways of avoiding them as well as a general sentiment of hiding errors so they wouldn't get aggressively sanctioned. Unusually for federal agencies, the FAA actually reversed course on this behavior and generally just tries to come down on egregious cases. People are encouraged to report on safety slips and near-misses using NASA as an unbiased intermediary. They've been known to be lenient towards minor negligence (ie. unintentional mistakes, airspace/runway incursions, etc) if the pilot recognized it and reported on it for the sake of providing stats for policy decisions. All that said, more recently where the FAA has stopped, insurance has picked up. Insurance companies have been quick to jump on the availability of more sophisticated flight recording/tracking and the prevalence of social media to enforce their own views on aviation safety. Rates have been skyrocketing and it's becoming much harder to insure anything that isn't a simple fixed tricycle gear utility category certified 2-4 seater.
- NetOpWibby 5y ago
- didntknowya 5y agoonly really have to look at the Boeing fiasco to realize the FAA has lost it's tooth. Many companies will take the risk for profit or glory while the FAA take a reactive rather than preventative approach.
- lmilcin 5y agoI am convinced that at the moment fierce competition in this area causes competitors to try to use any excuse possible to do anything they can to stall opponents. Getting any small problem to have as much publicity as possible? Yeah, sounds about right. Pretty sure an anomaly like this would not be happening if space didn't get commercial attention.
- kiba 5y agoThank god it got grounded before someone got killed. Elon Musk ordered a flight. Imagine that he got killed in an accident aboard the Virgin Galactic. It might kill the Starship program, which I viewed as one of the most important endeavor humanity is undertaking, regardless of people's dislike or like for the man.
- mlindner 5y agoThe FAA grounded it because it flew outside the flight corridor, which could cause risk to the general public. The FAA grounding has nothing to do with whether there was risk to the occupants or not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Johnny555 5y agoElon Musk ordered a flight. Imagine that he got killed in an accident aboard the Virgin Galactic As risky as Virgin Galactic is (and it's certainly risky), Musk probably faces a greater danger of dying in a car accident while driving to the office since he drives or rides in a car much more often than he flies in a spacecraft.
- warning26 5y agoMy question is, would it have been grounded without the article? The article was based on testimony from one of the pilots, right? Perhaps the FAA would have grounded it based on the same info, article or not.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe New Yorker article came out yesterday. I seriously doubt the FAA would have made a rapid-fire action to ground the fleet and get all of the associated legal work finished within 24 hours of publication. The FAA was involved with the launch and has presumably been investigating from the start. The fact that an article on the topic was published yesterday is coincidence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoRecent and related: The red warning light on Richard Branson’s space flight - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28385024 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28385024 - Sept 2021 (237 comments)
- hashkb 5y agoBranson is entering eccentric-pathetic territory. All the other billionaires, evil or otherwise, tend to demonstrate a high level of confidence. Sir Richard is spending his money to s*k his own d*k and he's going to kill people to (ultimately fail to) do it. Additionally, he's throwing up roadblocks for SpaceX, which has demonstrated extreme competence and productivity.
- mlindner 5y agoTo clarify, the FAA is grounding it because it flew outside the flight corridor, which could cause risk to the general public. The FAA grounding has nothing to do with whether there was risk to the occupants or not.
- Dylan16807 5y agoLeaving your flight corridor twenty miles up cannot cause risk to the general public. Also are there better explanations of the flight corridor shape somewhere? I'm confused about how cutting the engines would have helped stay inside it.
- nickhalfasleep 5y agoIf they cannot properly plot their route, then what else did they get wrong? This could easily cause them to rain dead billionaires all over someone's house.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIf it's a grounding because of the failure, and they would also be grounded if they had aborted just before leaving the flight corridor, I think that logic works. But that's not a great explanation if the grounding is specifically for leaving the flight corridor.
- nraynaud 5y agoThey could declare an emergency if they abort. Then nobody will look at the zoning during the investigation, and they get to ask whatever they want from the ATC who will simultaneously keep all the other aircrafts clear of the zone (also it New Mexico, so the uncontrolled zoning is weird)
- Denvercoder9 5y ago> Leaving your flight corridor twenty miles up cannot cause risk to the general public. As long as they're able to get back into their flight corridor before they're at an altitude where others fly.
- renewiltord 5y agoThe shrill exhortation of the crowds from journalists is really exasperating. I certainly have decided to stop paying attention to any more “how dare they”. If the FAA reacted to the story instead of proactively then that is embarrassing.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoThis is the same company that killed a test pilot by playing fast and loose with safety measures. It absolutely does not surprise me they haven’t learned from it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/VSS_Enterprise_crash https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/VSS_Enterprise_crash
- dougSF70 5y agoExactly, VG is trying to go too fast to market.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- morpheos137 5y agoSeeing as virgin galactic is currently a private experimental endeavour not open to the general public I don't see what the big deal is about this inside baseball. The ship may have strayed from its flight plan but the chance of collision with something else is pretty close to nil since 3d space is big and white sands test range is in a very remote area. It also does not smell right to me for a reporter to be taking sides in internal HR issues and siding with terminated employees. All that said commercial space tourism will never work out in our life times and it is basically just a vannity project for billionaires like self-driving cars. Nothing fundamental has changed since the 1970s. Space is big. It is empty. It is dangerous. And last it is very expensive. If Virgin can bring the cost of human space tourism flight down to $100,000 for example, that is still just a way to separate rich fools from their money. $100k for 15 minutes of flight and nifty view. Humans belong on Earth. There is nothing out there besides a nice view and a whole lot of empty space. Wait until the competition perfectly simulates space flight using an isolation tank and a VR headset. Woah same experience on the ground but with no risk of burning up on re-entry and much cheaper too.
- arcticfox 5y ago> Humans belong on Earth. There is nothing out there besides a nice view and a whole lot of empty space. Well, disagree. There's a lot out there, almost everything in fact.
- morpheos137 5y agoAlmost nothing relevant to humans who live about 80 years and evolved on Earth. If humans lived millions of years and there were other life supporting planets then space travel might be interesting...assuming one could even navigate between star systems. Again and again I see the pattern of real world tech aspirations being driven by science fiction fantasy. The thing is though that real world tech is constrained by reality while fiction is not. No, you will not be riding in driverless cars on mars in 2100.
- m4rtink 5y agoWe have the tech now for interstellar travel and we had it since the 1960s in the form of Project Orion - the only issue is that it needs a couple thousands thermonuclear warheads to work. And I'm sure better options will show up over time, as space infrastructure develops. As for habitable planets - we already quite heavily modify the one we live one to suit us better (eq. I would freeze to death where I live without heating in the winter) so large habitats built from in space resources might be a better option anyway long term.
- bob229 5y agoHAHHAHAHA
- worik 5y agoPity it is too late to not let him back
- feintruled 5y agoSaw a funny joke about this - "We shot Richard Branson into space but unfortunately he managed to find his way back"
- dougSF70 5y agoBranson is the Royal Crown Cola of the commercial space flight world. He is the ultimate in show-boating bell-ends. I am glad he has had his wings clipped. Unlike his other stunts, the stunt was never core the the virgin business. This stunt (first buffoon in space) is core to the business and he has royally $%@ed it.
- dougSF70 5y agoDownvote at your leisure. The fact is , Branson and his business empire is pure marketing gloss on average products. Virgin Galactic shouldn't exist.
- ljm 5y agoThis is just a bullshit puff-piece to show that Branson is still in the billionaire space game with Bezos and Musk. Why do we give the slightest fuck about these people?
- anaganisk 5y agoHow else we are gonna get space ads.
- dwd 5y agoFor anyone living on Earth the result would be mindfizzlingly spectacular. One hundred and twenty-eight stars would appear to go supernova simultaneously, burning with such ferocity they would be visible even in daylight. And the hundred and twenty-eight supernovae would spell out a message. And this would be the message: ‘COKE ADDS LIFE!’ For five whole weeks, wherever you were on Earth, the huge tattoo would be branded across the day and night skies. Honeymooners in Hawaii would stand on the peak of Mauna Kca, gazing at sunsets stamped with the slogan. Commuters in London, stuck in traffic jams, would peer through the grey drizzle and gape at the Cola constellation. The few primitive tribes still untouched by civilization in the jungles of South America would look up at the heavens, and certainly not think about drinking Pepsi. The coat of this single, three-word ad in star writing across the universe would amount to the entire military budget of the USA for the whole of history. So, ridiculous though it was, it was still a marginally more sensible way of blowing trillions of Dollarpounds. And, the Coke executives were assured by the advertising executives at Saachi, Saachi, Saachi, Saachi, Saachi and Saachi, it would put an end to the Cola war forever. Guaranteed. Pepsi would be buried.
- anaganisk 5y agoYou know what, in years this might be true. We never know, what cutting edge tech we would invent next to show ads.
- dwd 5y agoPepsi Russia apparently considered using a Cubesat constellation, but the idea was shot down by head office. Drone swarms displaying logos and messages would be a more feasible option.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ssijak 5y agoTechnically Branson was not the first, his pilot is sitting in the front. Lucky pilot.
- ssijak 5y agoWhy are do so many people have hard/bad people about billioners going to space? At least they are doing something which pushes some tech forward.
- amelius 5y agoBecause they are paving the way for space tourism.
- dspillett 5y agoA large part of it is thinking what else the investment could do, like asking every medical scientist that isn't trying to cure cancer/AIDS/C19/... why they are wasting time on whatever else they are doing. Another chunk is probably common or garden variety jealousy flavoured with the source of a little us-v-them! With Tricky Dicky (sorry, sir Tricky Dicky) particularly there is the matter that he was asking for government (and thereby tax payer) handouts to help his bits of the air industry only last year. There are similar complains for others wringing the pennies out of the 99.9% to fund their plaything projects, by pushing their workers to the point of not having decent toilet breaks and provision for other essentials for instance.
- mmustapic 5y agoBecause the tech is useless for anything else besides billionaires going to space.
- GordonS 5y agoI'm not sure if your comment is missing a '/s'?
- probably_wrong 5y agoI think it's a sign of the different way of thinking about problems between SV types and "regular" people. SV: this investment will revolutionize technology, and will give us an amazing ROI over the next 50 years. This could pave the road to whatever comes after the cell phone and change our entire world! Regular people, in the meantime, are scrapping by to gather enough to feed their children, drowning in debt, and/or working in terrible jobs (sorry, "gigs") to make those same billionaires richer. "Whatever the next iPhone in 50 years will be, maybe" is not really high on their priorities.
- raffraffraff 5y agoGood. Would love to see emissions laws that basically outlaw these bullshit vanity trips to "the edge of space". Get a fucking skateboard, Sir Dick, if you want an adrenaline rush. Or go downhill on a bicycle.
- gambiting 5y agoUhm....ok, but would you ban the flight even if Sir Branson wasn't on it? Because if yes, then you've effectively banned any kind of space research and private development. Also....not sure about the emissions impact as those rockets don't burn normal carbon based fuel. Space Ship Two burns HTPB specifically. Someone else would need to comment what the emissions impact of that is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroxyl-terminated_polybutadiene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroxyl-terminated_polybutadi...
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's very well possible to support space research and private development while at the same time wanting flights of this kind stopped. All Branson will achieve is shutting down of space research and private development with his ill conceived contraption. This has gone too far already, and there is zero output here from an applicable technology point of view other than in the 'things we shouldn't be doing' department. Blue Origin is on more solid footing and they in turn are toddlers compared to SpaceX.
- raffraffraff 5y agoWould I ban them if Branson wasn't there? Absolutely. Unless it's a one way trip. What does the human race get out of Branson's vanity project? He wants to be able to send bunch of rich folks to the edge of space for a fee. All for kicks. Are helicopter rides not cool enough anymore? Fuck all of them. Forgetting about fuel in the rocket for just a second, what about the vessel that them to launch altitude? But anyway, I'm willing to bet that no matter what magic dust is used to propel the rocket, there's a co2 cost. If not in the burn, then in the production of the fuel.
- darkrai0707 5y ago"Although the flight's ultimate trajectory deviated from our initial plan, it was a controlled and intentional flight path that allowed Unity to successfully reach space and land safely at our spaceport in New Mexico," Obviously! Getting off course was intentional. Going rouge on a space mission will be next cool thing in space travel and Sir Richard was just setting an example
- christophilus 5y agoIs rouge an intentional pun referring to the red light? If so, kudos! Or did you mean rogue?
- Railsify 5y agoI'm still bullish on Virgin Galactic and Virgin Orbit.