33 ms·
Dutch entrepreneurs avoiding negative interest by opening multiple bank accounts
- google234123 5y agoThey could also think about investing their excess money for some real returns.
- gjs278 5y agothey should not be forced to invest their money in a massively over-leveraged peak stock market that could crash any second. I think it’s fair to be able to cash in your chips at any point and not have to pay a fee for that every single year.
- blitzar 5y agoWhich is the behaviour the negative interest rate policy is intended to encourage. The article also fails to mention that bank deposits are only gauranteed up to 100k as well, so if you have a bunch of cash sitting around it is wise to spread it around different institutions anyway.
- monkeydust 5y agoMakes sense. In UK it's GBP 85k for single account, double if joint. Current best instant access rate is around 0.65%.
- iainmerrick 5y agoWhich is the behaviour the negative interest rate policy is intended to encourage. I’ve never quite understood -- can’t the bank do that for you? If the obstacle is that savings accounts are expected to have a guaranteed rate with zero risk, the banks ought to provide very easy access to investment accounts, with the ability to move money around frictionlessly. Is there just no demand for that kind of service, or regulatory problems, or something of that kind? Edit to add: I always felt that offset mortgages (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexible_mortgage#Offset_mortgages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexible_mortgage#Offset_mortg...) were a nice solution to this problem; it gives you a place to stash your savings and get a reasonable rate of return (basically matching your mortgage rate) while still being accessible if needed. But they seem to have gone out of fashion again, at least in the UK. Anyone know if there was some problem or disadvantage (either to consumers or to the banks)?
- blitzar 5y ago> I’ve never quite understood -- can’t the bank do that for you? You want them to tell you you have a fixed, gauranteed rate of return and use it to buy some apple stock or some bitcoin with it? The answer is they can do it for you, they do, do it for you, but you have to sign up for the gambling account not the instant access cash savings account.
- iainmerrick 5y agoWell... yes, sort of! Or at least, it’d be great if the bank let you choose how much money to put in a safe account with low but guaranteed interest, and how much in an investment account with higher but risky interest; and make it really easy to move money back and forth. I don’t know of any bank that offers anything like that. I guess there ought to be some safeguards, e.g. at least XX% of your money in a safe place. But there’s a point at which safeguards become friction that just stop you investing at all. For example, in the UK you have ISA accounts, which should work like that, but the restrictions are so annoying (yearly cap on deposits) and the benefits so weak (tax exempt, but on a pitiful interest rate so it makes no difference for most people) that they’re not very useful. Unless I’m missing something.
- blitzar 5y agoNatwest.com ... Products: Bank Accounts, Mortgages, Savings, Investments, Loans ... Your investment options are limited to actual investments basically, so essensially shares. Term deposits dont seem to be a big thing in the UK for whatever reason, and we dont have the US tax breaks to buy municipal bonds etc. ISA's are great, you can go buy some apple stock or some FTSE funds or depending on the provider one of 1000's of funds with it. 'Cash ISAs' while rare are still around are no better or worse than a savings account (IMO).
- iainmerrick 5y agoYes, I was thinking of cash ISAs, which do seem a bit pointless. This is a good nudge for me to look around for better/easier options to store petty cash in, so I’m going to do that. Thanks!
- ArnoVW 5y agoPerhaps they need the money liquid? Or the risk reward ratio is not good? Or they don't have a CFO that can do treasury and the opportunity cost / effort is not worth it?
- traceroute66 5y ago> Or they don't have a CFO that can do treasury and the opportunity cost / effort is not worth it? What's the CFO going to do when Eurobonds are negative too ? Converting it un-necessarily into another currency introduces exposure to forex risk. "Investing", aside from the risk, is not cash or cash-equivalent, so that's out of the question. Hence the best answer is generally just splitting out into multiple Euro bank accounts.
- blitzar 5y agoInvestors want their business growth and a 10 bagger (or bust) on their money, not paying a c-suite salary for 0.01% interest, or worse, a bunch of greek bonds that someone on the sales desk at Goldmans said was a great buy.
- emiliobumachar 5y agoSmall entrepreneurs typically have more much more risk exposure than average already.
- TomVDB 5y agoHow do you want a savings bank to invest? Government bonds? Corporate bonds? Stocks? Crypto? Are you willing to cover their potential losses with government guarantees? Savings accounts are supposed to be a safe storage of money. They have certain insurance guarantees because of that. Encouraging banks to use that money to speculate is exactly what you don’t want them to do. Savings banks are not known to employ the most brilliant investment minds.
- jbverschoor 5y agoNot only that, but it's also a method of protecting your assets. You're protected for €100k per entity per bank.
- hackeraccount 5y agoyeah but realistically will any person ever lose assets in a bank? I know in the 2008 crisis they made (or maybe it was just they said they would make) any personal accounts good; if it was over the limit (I think that's FICA) or not.
- stingraycharles 5y agoYes, it actually happened in The Netherlands a bit over a decade ago, after the financial crisis. If you had more than 100k in savings in there (and they were known for their attractive savings rate), you would be in trouble. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSB_Bank https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSB_Bank
- ascar 5y agoDoes (or did) the US have laws that protect a certain amount of savings? I would assume since the 100k are guaranteed by law that the state does not further step in on losses above that. When there is no law like that in place the situation is entirely different.
- 5y ago
- cascom 5y agoIsn’t this just brokered deposits - which are nothing new?
- fifticon 5y agoThis does not work in Denmark. Banks know officially whether your bank account is your "living wage" bank account or not. If you have a bank account that is not the 'wage deposit' account, banks have started charging a premium for HAVING an account with them. I used to have several accounts, but since they've started with this extra-fee crap, I have closed all except my main account, because the fees would eat the deposited money. There may be ways around it, but I haven't found it.
- user568439 5y agoWhat about N26, Revolut and all these new online banks? They don't charge anything where I live in the EU. I don't have 100k though.
- agurk 5y agoRevolut does work nicely for this - and has the side benefit of allowing SWIFT transfers to DK accounts. This is something bizarrely that some traditional banks (looking at you Danske) don't allow. Also in DK, the limit for being charged negative interest is generally 100,000 DKK ~ €13,500. With IT salaries it can become a monthly hassle dealing with it.
- im3w1l 5y agoConsider automatically investing a big portion of it.
- petre 5y ago> This is something bizarrely that some traditional banks (looking at you Danske) don't allow. Probably why their Estonian branch was used to launder money. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danske_Bank_money_laundering_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danske_Bank_money_laundering...
- hobo_mark 5y agoN26 charges 0.5% on accounts over 50k, curiously Revolut does not appear to do that (yet).
- nikkinana 5y agoJust keep cash. If everybody did that you'd fix it. Or move.
- technicolorwhat 5y agoDarn it, I feel excluded, I am dutch and haven't opened any multiple back accounts yet. I probably should.
- torcete 5y agoDo it! Also, why not program periodic circular transfers across a month, of let's say 100€, just for fun! For extra fun, include words in the description like Iran, Kabul, and North Korea :D
- traceroute66 5y agoAnd this is news why exactly ? Negative rates have been around since 2014. And this "trick" of opening multiple bank accounts has been exploited across the EU for pretty much the same period of time. For example, I've frequently done business with German companies. They don't even hide it. It is not in the slightest bit uncommon to receive an invoice with four or five EUR bank accounts printed on it. You can randomly pick your "preferred" account to pay to and the company's accountant will rebalance the accounts at the end of the quarter (or wahtever).
- luckylion 5y agoHaving multiple bank accounts isn't usually a thing to avoid negative interests in Germany. It's that payments between banks took three days to settle (I think they're down to 1 day now), while payments between accounts at the same bank usually settled immediately. It's much easier to have multiple accounts with the largest banks so most of your customers can use bank-internal transfers. Also, it's usually a good idea to have a backup just in case something goes wrong with your primary bank account. Dealing with bureaucracy is bad enough, dealing with it while you're also unable to send or receive payments is way worse.
- traceroute66 5y ago> It's that payments between banks took three days to settle (I think they're down to 1 day now) Isn't Germany subject to SEPA time constraints like everyone else ?
- ascar 5y agoSEPA is more relaxed than you might think. N26 has a nice explanation [1]: > ...[A]ll standard SEPA transfers should arrive within a maximum of 2 working days. Keep in mind that if a transfer is made just before a weekend or holiday, the time frame will be extended to a maximum of 3 working days. > You’ve probably heard that all SEPA transfers have to be completed within one “banking day,” so let’s clarify what that means—one banking day is equivalent to two working days due to the opening hours of the banks involved. Any weekday that is not a holiday is considered a working day. [1] https://support.n26.com/en-eu/payments-transfers-and-withdrawals/transfers/how-long-do-transfers-take https://support.n26.com/en-eu/payments-transfers-and-withdra...
- raxxorrax 5y agoNegative interest is an abomination considering how wealth enables further gain of capital. This is why cash should stay, otherwise people would be subjected to a lot of money grabbing. Entrepreneurs are acting correctly here.
- trgn 5y agoNegative interest is a return to the origins of banking. You would pay a bank to hold your assets. What you got in return was the convenience of not worrying of getting robbed, or being able to transfer large sums across large distances with bank notes. imho - that was the proper way to think about savings. If bank patrons want to see interest on their savings, they should convert theirs to capital and actually invest it, with all the responsibilities and risks that entails.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThat isn't applicable since the bank invests my savings already and doesn't just keep it in a safe. It could also mean that any amount you borrow would result in you paying back less. It would be a negative interest rate...
- SonicScrub 5y agoIt's completely applicable if the returns the bank can make are less than the operational costs associated with storing your money. The offered interest rate is going to be some function of the bank's operational cost subtracted from the bank's investment return. When interest rates set by fiscal policy are so low that the bank can't make enough through investing deposits to offset the operational costs, negative interest rates must occur.
- selfhoster11 5y agoWe don't chisel bank balances on stone/clay tablets anymore, or guard it with spears. Securing and transferring money should be much cheaper than it used to be millennia ago.
- 5y ago
- streamofdigits 5y agoBank fee income will definitely go up as they are typically set at flat level and not linked to the deposit amount. Could it be that increased fee payments effectively undo the strategy of avoiding the negative rate? Remember, you can beat the system, but you can't beat the house...
- sumedh 5y agoHow does the housing market work in countries with negative interest rates, I am assuming the home loan rates are very very low so does that lead to a boom in house prices?
- hetspookjee 5y agoThe housing market in the Netherlands is a complete train-wreck for almost a decade. The climate crisis pressing down on the ability to build new houses, the negative interests rate and a flailing government makes matter consistently worse. In Q1 2021 the prices rose with almost 12% compared to previous year, and the prices are rising almost quicker and quicker by each month, with no clear end in sight. Yes, the loan rates are on a historical low, but have been already for a few years now.
- Aeolun 5y agoTrying to move back to the Netherlands, but I despair of ever trying to buy a house there. Half a million is not uncommon for the area I’m looking :/ and that’s in a tiny suburb half an hour from Amsterdam. Like, salaries do not seem to have similarly risen, so who the hell is buying these houses?
- Ekaros 5y agoSalaries don't need to raise when interest rates drop. For same payment with lower interest rates you can service much higher principal. For example at 1000€ month 5% rate you could loan 151 525€ but with 1% rate you could loan 217 441€...
- Aeolun 5y agoTrue. The problem is that housing prices have risen by several hundred percent.
- Shaddox 5y ago>Like, salaries do not seem to have similarly risen, so who the hell is buying these houses? People and institutions looking for a way to 'park' their funds in a safe investment.
- nashashmi 5y agoIsn’t now a good time to forbid the usury?
- Spacemolte 5y ago100 thousand euros? The limit in denmark is 13442 euros..... "What we do is simply share the bill with our customers", but funny how they don't really seem to want to share the surplus...
- Aeolun 5y agoI find this weird. How can you possibly have negative interest on a savings account? That means it’s quite literally better to withdraw all of your excess cash and stuff it in an old sock…
- geewee 5y agoVery common in the EU. Every danish bank has negative interest over a certain amount of money
- andi999 5y agoOne day you come home and your sock is gone...
- naasking 5y ago> How can you possibly have negative interest on a savings account? If a bank is forbidden from investing your money, and thus putting your savings at risk, then it costs them money to safely manage it.
- shard972 5y agobut we have fractional reserve banking? so this isn't the case
- space_rock 5y agoI'm learning today that most people on hn don't know how central banks work and how interest rates are set
- naasking 5y agoI wasn't saying that's what's happening here, the OP just asked how banks "could possibly" charge negative interest on savings. In a world where a bank couldn't use the money you deposited, they would have to charge you in some way. Negative interest rates could be one way to do it. Simple answer to a simple question.
- enaaem 5y ago
- jokoon 5y agoIt's crazy how lack of transparency and secrecy can allow a minority to use scheme to evade laws. I once met a woman for some short class on business plans on zoom, and she was actually taught how to create a holding and the whole loophole package to optimize taxes. I asked about the morality of such thing, and I was shocked to realize she did not seem to care at all. The banality of evil allows some people to just get access to an easier life by not caring.
- Rucadi 5y agoWhat it's inmoral is to pay taxes. In fact, evading paying taxes in a legal way should not be an excepction, but the norm. Stop romanticizing taxes.
- naasking 5y agoStop romanticizing stable societies? That's a weird take, but you do you I guess.
- HideousKojima 5y agoStable societies existed long before anything and everything was taxed.
- naasking 5y agoYou mean "tribes". Those aren't societies.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoI mean that you are a soyboy faggot, go and give 100% of your salary to the state.
- lbarrow 5y agoThe behavior of the people with multiple bank accounts in the article is both legal and perfectly ethical. Are you saying we have an ethical responsibility to pay as high bank fees as possible?
- wdb 5y agoChips totally forgot about this
- dcolkitt 5y agoThis is going to probably not be received well given HN’s famously visceral hostility to crypto… But you can get 5%+ yields on Euro stablecoins in DeFi. And I’m not talking fly by night ponzi pools. This is like on battle tested bluechip protocols like Curve on Uniswap. Is the risk zero? No. Should you put all your funds there? No. But parking a small segment to balance out the negative bank yields is pretty attractive from a risk reward standpoint. If you’re getting negative 0.5% at the bank, you can protect your capital from decaying by moving 10% or less of your cash savings into DeFi.
- ArtTimeInvestor 5y agoPeople will do that when there are more normal onramps to crypto. Currently to get crypto on Coinbase or wherever, one needs to go through a crazy signup process where you deliver photos of documents that enables anyone who gets ahold of these photos to identify as you and use these to sign up as you on other places. It is a catch 22. There should be a crypto way of doing KYC. Not signing up by delivering a photo of you passport, but by signing a message cryptographically.
- hanniabu 5y agoThis is no different than traditional platforms
- ArtTimeInvestor 5y agoThere are differences. 1: You can walk into a bank and sign up for an account. You cannot walk into Coinbase and sign up for an account. 2: Most people already have a bank account. Most people do not have a Coinbase account.
- radu_floricica 5y ago> Currently to get crypto on Coinbase or wherever, one needs to go through a crazy signup process where you deliver photos of documents that enables anyone who gets ahold of these photos to identify as you and use these to sign up as you on other places. Really? I'd like to see a civil suit where an institution says I owe them money and shows a picture of my ID as proof of contract. There are ways of signing legally binding things online (DocuSign for example, which AFAIK was actually tested in a trial in EU), but they have more sophistication than that.
- ArtTimeInvestor 5y agoIs that because banks are allowed to print money as they wish? I mean, what became of the business where entrepreneurs go to a bank and loan money to finance building new ventures? For that the bank needs money, right? So I guess that they don't want money from customers anymore means they get it from elsewhere. Probably from the government in the form of permission to print money? Let me know if I am wrong here.
- mempko 5y agoBanks never lend other people's money. They create it. When you give your money to a bank, they add it to their reserves and your bank balance becomes a liability to them. They hold that liability because they need reserves for inter-bank transactions. When a Bank makes a loan to you, they don't take money from reserves. They simply create a balance in your bank account with them marking how much they owe you. They just create the money there. Reserves come into play when you want to transfer those funds to another bank. But if two people have a bank account with the same bank, then the bank doesn't need reserves to do that transfer. So no, banks don't lend other people's money. Not a single bank in the modern world lends other people's money. Bank lending in fact CREATES deposits. All the money you have in your bank account came from either A) Government spending B) Someone took out a loan. Either public spending or private debt. See: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/money-in-the-modern-economy-an-introduction https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/m...
- ArtTimeInvestor 5y agoInter-bank transactions need to be done with real money (the "reserves")? So a bank run could be done online? If enough customers of bank A send money to bank B, then bank A has to file for bancruptcy?
- mempko 5y agoYes, this is a risk banks need to manage. They typically do this by not having all the reserves tied to instant access accounts. So deposit accounts where the person cannot take everything out at once like savings and CDO.
- seaourfreed 5y agoBanks should NEVER give a negative interest rate. They make money on loans, time-value-of-money and other sound economic principles. There is something very very wrong when banks give negative interest rates. The things that are very wrong that are causing it, have come into existence. It started in EU country central bank lending to banks. Now end consumers are seeing that in their personal banking. Imaging a world where the Dutch now have a "bank" that is over the internet in another country. Their money is stored in USD stable coin, or another countries stable coin. Citizens could flee there, in mass. First, the country (Netherlands), would try to stop the on-ramps. But sooner or later, there will be other entrepreneurs who make easy ACHes/wires that re-route to a crypto account and buy-into crypto (like a USD stable coin). Then the country in mass, could move their bank accounts out of the Netherlands. Then banks in the Netherlands could collapse... ....or be replaced by a healthy alternative (foreign USD Stable coin backed accounts). Then the massive fundamental problems going on in macroeconomics that cause the negative interest rates will become visible. These problems remain hidden from the citizen-base because of how technical they are. It would require they be fixed, instead of draining money from citizens to put-their-finger-in-the-dike patching the problem.
- arez 5y agothat's the thing, banks don't make enough money with loans if the interest rate is that low for such a long time. It's nothing very very wrong if banks do that it's just an effect of keeping interest rates low. I don't fully understand your dutch over the internet bank stablecoin comparison, but if you mean that people could flee into different currencies than this is not new at all, some years ago this happened already with the swiss franc. It's also not hidden because there're well enough economists talking about the implications, it's not as complex as you think and yes people with money in the bank are going to be expropriated but this happens anyway if you print more money.
- prestigecity 5y agoWow are you exited to visit The Prestige City for better life style please visit - https://www.prestigecity.gen.in/ https://www.prestigecity.gen.in/ Refer - https://www.twarak.com/ad/bangalore/real_estate/real_estate_agents/913325/the-prestige-city-apartments-plots-villas-off-sarjapur-road-bangalore/ https://www.twarak.com/ad/bangalore/real_estate/real_estate_... https://www.findinall.com/profile/prestigecitygen https://www.findinall.com/profile/prestigecitygen https://in.pinterest.com/prestigecitygenin/prestige-city-wwwprestigecitygenin/ https://in.pinterest.com/prestigecitygenin/prestige-city-www... https://www.scoop.it/topic/prestige-city-bangalore-project https://www.scoop.it/topic/prestige-city-bangalore-project https://bangalore.in.locan.to/ID_5176975343/The-Prestige-City-Bangalore-Apartments-For-Sale.html https://bangalore.in.locan.to/ID_5176975343/The-Prestige-Cit...
- choeger 5y agoIt's not entirely true that this is caused by the ECB. In fact, only 10% of a typical German bank account (Sichteinlagen) are required to be held with the ECB. For other countries it might be even less (minimal reserve is 1%). Out of these 10% the bank gets charged no interests on the first 6% (six times minimal reserve). So if you have 100k€ in the bank in Germany, that bank has to pay for 4k€ - that's just 20€ per annum and charges you 250€ (assuming a typical 50k€ exemption). At the same time they can lebd out 90k€ at a market rate of 1.5% to finance some housing. That's 1350€ revenue per annum. So in this simplified, idealized case, the bank just asks you to increase their revenue by 17% out of your own pocket. The only case when the bank has to pay more is when they don't hand out enough credits and whose fault is that, frankly? Who should carry that risk?
- eru 5y agoYou are free to move your money and business to a different bank, if you don't like it.
- choeger 5y agoYeah right. Because banksters would never all run the same scheme, right? They are so "competitive", you would never find the same conditions on every bank account nation-wide.
- eru 5y agoHow would you figure out whether the conditions are because of 'banksters' colluding or because of something else?
- IkmoIkmo 5y agoIndeed, in addition the central banks don't just charge negative rates, they also allow borrowing at negative rates (-1%) via the TLTRO which means banks are making money borrowing from the ECB, they currently receive more money from TLTRO loans alone than the ECB charges them. In short, low interest rates are obviously a factor, but banks didn't have to do this. They're charging you because they can and because most banks are following suit.
- secondcoming 5y agoDoes anyone _not_ have multiple bank accounts? It makes sense, not just because of negative interest rates, but for when things like a bank's IT systems going down. At least in the UK, you're typically not charged for having a basic bank account; fancier ones do have monthly charges.
- tiku 5y agoThe interest is already negative because you pay for those accounts.
- tharne 5y ago"Negative interest rate" is such an Orwellian term. Let's just call it what it is, the government penalizing you for not spending your own money as fast as they think you ought to.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoShould your capital increase over time without it being put to productive purpose?
- logicchains 5y agoBanks don't just sit on piles of cash, they lend it out. That's literally what banks do with the money people deposit in them, it's the whole point of banks!
- paulluuk 5y agoI'd argue that the main point of banks is that they protect your money from theft. Given that most people who use banks are poor and don't actually receive any significant interest.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThey don't receive significant interest because banks choose not to share any interest with the end customer. Easy access savings rates have been sub-1% for so long in the UK that customers have instead turned to exploiting introductory offers on current accounts.
- lucian1900 5y agoThat’s not at all how banks work. BoE helpfully explain https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/how-is-money-created https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/how-is-money-c...
- Armisael16 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ewg4345h43 5y agoOfficial inflation is 4% (!!!) now in Germany, but the real inflation is usually 2.5 times higher than the official, so it is probably 10%. Gas prices increased by 4% in just last 3 months: https://www.mwv.de/statistiken/verbraucherpreise/ https://www.mwv.de/statistiken/verbraucherpreise/ The most food prices increased by 5% - 20% in the last year: https://www.az.com.na/nachrichten/nahrungsmittelpreise-gestiegen2021-08-18 https://www.az.com.na/nachrichten/nahrungsmittelpreise-gesti...
- soldehierro 5y agoThe food prices link seems to be for Namibia, not Germany.
- hawk_ 5y agoyou shouldn't let facts get in the way of a good story.
- eru 5y ago> but the real inflation is usually 2.5 times higher than the official, so it is probably 10%. Citation needed.
- erikswn 5y agoHe probably meant, for a certain demographics the inflation is higher since they they have a different consumption "basket" than the average citizen. E.g. young people are more likely to rent than owning an appartement. But the general inflation reflects only the average spending on housing. So if 50% of the population owns a home, rising rents are only reflected half as strong for the general population. However I could not find any reliable numbers how strong the contrast for each demographic group is...
- ketzu 5y agoGermany reduced its VAT last year in july by 3% and reinstated it this year. This masks inflation quite a bit. Inflation last august was 0% (rest of the year was negative). So inflation compared to 2019 is also 4% for august. source: https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/1045/umfrage/inflationsrate-in-deutschland-veraenderung-des-verbraucherpreisindexes-zum-vorjahresmonat/ https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/1045/umfrage/... gas prices in germany are highly volatile in general. It is currently as expensive as it was 2012. source: https://www.adac.de/verkehr/tanken-kraftstoff-antrieb/deutschland/kraftstoffpreisentwicklung/ https://www.adac.de/verkehr/tanken-kraftstoff-antrieb/deutsc...
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYeah there's a lower limit to the interest, otherwise every consumer will take their money out and save it in cash (or gold or even crypto) the moment they are hit with this negative interest (I know I would!). But I bet eventually it'll come through to consumer accounts, once they've locked down crypto enough and enforced card payments everywhere. The EU is heavily doing both right now. I'm not an entrepreneur and don't have that much money in the bank but this really worries me because I want to buy a house at some point. This is becoming crazily difficult. I think it's pretty insane that the ECB still does this negative interest thing. Even at zero interest we're already losing savings all the time due to inflation. It's really undermining my trust in the banking system, basically I'm leaving my money in a tank that's slowly draining.. Totally counter to the concept of a bank which should be trusted and safe. I can understand they need to be paid too, but they already charge a fee for the account. But actually taking money away is ridiculous.. Meanwhile house prices are increasing dramatically yet banks need ever more personal investment to provide a mortgage. How can I ever get this if I can't even save money anymore? They should really stop trying to appease multinationals who benefit from this for cheap exports, and gain consumer trust back. These multinationals are also the ones avoiding taxes on a wide scale (e.g. Apple not paying any tax in Ireland on all their European profits) and not even contributing to our system.
- aazaa 5y agoIt's worth pointing out that never in all of world history has such a large percentage of sovereign debt yielded a nominally negative rate. Where this ends is anybody's guess. But when the situation finally does resolve itself, it seems reasonable to expect economic and social dislocation both qualitatively and quantitatively beyond anything ever seen before. The incremental manner in which the GFC continues to play out has numbed most people to the danger they are in.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eru 5y agoNah, the situation isn't that new. Yes, negative nominal interest rates are fairly new. But we had negative real interest rates on sovereign debt every now and then. Especially during the Great Inflation.
- germinalphrase 5y agoOur entire political systems is hyperbolic and actively seeks to undermine trust in institutions that could push back against the political system’s interests. Even if the danger were eminent, the average person on the street 1) probably couldn’t understand the threat and 2) wouldn’t have a single idea about how to mitigate their personal exposure to that threat (if it were even possible for them to do so).
- IkmoIkmo 5y agoIf you look at it in terms of purchasing power rather than on a nominal level, we've been there many times. Honestly some commenters in the Netherlands were surprised over the past six months that people suddenly took action when their savings account went from 0% to -0.1% interest, but were entirely passive when their 0% interest account was exposed to 2% inflation for years, which has a much larger impact on purchasing power and was essentially subjecting people to negative annual returns on their purchasing power (i.e., the metric that matters).
- csomar 5y ago
- intothev01d 5y agoThink about how ridiculous this is for a moment. It's an easy loophole, and just more red tape and a bother. That's also not really the issue though. The problem is rates in general. Trying to spur growth into a system where there is none. Forcing speculative investing because of poor central banking policies and tough economic conditions. Ultimately the backlash from this will be worse than if central banks had avoided interfering in the first place. However, the interference has allowed a free-for-all in inflation and asset repricing to attempt to shift the debt they created away from themselves and increase wealth for those with assets. So in a sense, it's working. Robbing Peter to pay Paul. No one should be under the assumption anything else is happening here with these policies.
- eru 5y agoHow can the central bank _not_ interfere? For a central bank there's no such thing as no policy. Even inaction is a policy. (Of course, there are systems that work without a central bank. And can work very well in fact. But that's not what the Dutch as part of the Euro zone have.)
- intothev01d 5y agoYes, they ultimately act at some point and not at others, and that is their policy or stance (action or inaction). The problem is the actions they've been taking that are leading to the results I'm referencing.
- GDC7 5y ago> Even inaction is a policy Inaction is the only policy. All the other actions are stuff that these people do to justify their existence . With all due respect for Jerome Powell, Bernanke etc. these people are kind of frauds. They are the only academic which are globally known and get all the respect and bows as well as recognition. But their craft is a pseudoscience. The Nobel committee knows this, in fact the Nobel Prize for Economics is commonly referred as such but in reality it's: "The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel" Worlds apart. If they were real men they'd pick a real science and face real irrelevance like real men if they are wrong or fail to make important contributions. Only in economics people are still around after getting it wrong so many times. It seems like the more wrong you are , the more recognition you get, as people anticipate that economists who shoot frequently will get it right more than those who shoot infrequently given the randomness of their predictions
- dhosek 5y agoThis is not unlike the practice in the US of opening accounts at multiple banks to keep the balance below the FDIC insurance limit (currently $250,000).
- WalterBright 5y ago> To prevent this, entrepreneurs are now spreading their money over different accounts at different banks. Did anyone think this wouldn't happen?
- taneq 5y ago> For someone with 200 thousand euros in the bank, this could mean paying 500 euros in interest at the end of the year. If 200k euros of working capital is worth less to you than 500 euros/year then you're really, really bad at capitalism.
- nostromo 5y agoBusiness idea: take in cash deposits. Hold the cash as paper currency in a vault. Avoid negative interest rates. After you build up enough deposits, start making loans to make money. Maybe if you make good loans you could even pay some interest to your depositors. I’ll call it “Bank.”
- bserge 5y agoBanq (Bunq is taken already)
- Naga 5y agoI know you're being funny, but for most of history real (as opposed to nominal) rates of return on cash have been negative. Sure, you wouldn't be paying the bank interest, but you'd be paying for storage, security if you have enough, losses on rodents eating your cash, etc. Positive rates of return are actually quite a new phenomenon.
- ketzu 5y agoYou'll still have to fulfil minimal required deposits with the central bank (but my understanding was that they are free of charge). After that, what will you do if you can't make enough money from loans for your employees (including yourself) and your other expenses?
- SonicScrub 5y agoOk, so how are you making money to sustain your operation? Presumably you are a business, not a charity. Your vault isn't free, neither is the land it sits in, and as you gain more customers your security costs are going to increase. Also your customers are going to want convenient withdrawal and deposit options, so you will need multiple vaults in different locations (plus security measures). Not to mention the overhead you'll need to run this business (accountants, HR, IT, asset managers, etc). Thus there is a degree of scaling to your costs. This is fine though, just subtract these costs from the revenue generated by your investments. Your simplified business model looks something like this: Profit = Investment Returns - Operational Costs - Interest Paid to customers Only you have to have sufficiently liquidity such that your customers can get withdrawals whenever they want. This means your investment pool is going to be conservative, thus limiting your returns. Now what happens when your nation's central bank craters interest rates, thus driving your investment returns down? Oh shit, now the revenue source is drying up. What gives? Profit, or your interest rates? Well profits have to be at minimum high enough to justify all this effort, so looks like the interest rates are going to drop and drop and drop as the cost of money goes down.... Congratulations, you are now in the same place as all those other institutions. Who would have guessed that an identical business model subjected to all the same economic push and pulls would end up at the same destination.
- fmakunbound 5y agoClueless here. What’s the point of a negative interest savings account? It seems about as good keeping cash under the mattress and burning some at the end of the year.
- coolspot 5y agoMatress is not as safe as a bank. Under current economic policy, banks basically don’t want your money. They have plenty of money they can’t get return on. Processing your dirty cash, maintainibg secure ATMs and servers is not worth it. They can borrow money from central banks at 0% or negative (return back less than borrowed) with less trouble.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- drummer 5y agoSwitch over to private crypto currencies like monero or pirate chain. Many problems instantly solved.
- jacquesm 5y agoOne great way to monitor how currencies are really doing is by comparing them to real estate, there isn't much that you can hide there. In NL houses increased between 10 to 20% in value (depending on where in the country you look) over the last year alone. That's almost the same as saying the Euro has devalued to the same degree, but of course when you track the official inflation numbers they come out all roses and sunshine.
- wayanon 5y agoWhy don’t they put these sums into crypto ?
- remir 5y agoMight as well buy some crypto stable coins and store them on a lending platform and earn 5%+ interest.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI've been doing the same since forever for a different reason: bank deposits are protected up to 85k£/100k€.
- unixhero 5y agoIsn't having a loan better?
- TobySKT 5y agoThe guide below will explain what ERP software can do, discuss the advantages of choosing the right ERP for your business and explain what to look for in an ERP system for optimal benefits or maybe it help you realize that it's time to think about custom ERP development https://steelkiwi.com/blog/best-erp-systems/ https://steelkiwi.com/blog/best-erp-systems/