27 ms·
The End of Retirement (2014)
- nikanj 6y agoGenerally I feel like retirement used to mean "I'm too old and frail to work anymore", until that brief blip between 1950-2010, give or take a decade or two. It was a pretty cool idea that you could just stop working and enjoy life and its luxuries while still having a good few decades of quality life ahead of you. I believe this is really hitting Japan hard, as the age pyramid is inverted, and the relatively few working-age people need to support enormous numbers of people enjoying retirement.
- brubois 6y agoIsn't it going to hit all western countries hard? Seems to me Japan is just first in the list... As far I'm concerned, I'm living in Europe and I'm not confident at all that I'll get any retirement before my 70. Knowing that the lifespan increased a lot but not necessary the good-shape-span, it seems to me a better strategy is to enjoy more free time now by reducing work hours than to bet on an uncertain future.
- brundolf 6y ago> it seems to me a better strategy is to enjoy more free time now by reducing work hours than to bet on an uncertain future I've always thought this way, uncertainty or not. Why wait until you're old and frail to enjoy life? I've always put the matched contribution into my retirement accounts, because it's free money, but no more than that. The rest of my savings go into places where I don't have to wait until my life is nearly over to access them.
- brubois 6y agoIt's not about delaying enjoyment to old age but to be sure to have basic needs met and some comfort when old.
- nly 6y agoInvesting for retirement for me is a hedge against being old, infirm and still having to work just to survive and live with stress and anxiety. You should do the math on how much you'll likely actually have in retirement, and see how you feel about it, before it's too late to change your strategy. I put almost 20% of my net salary in to my pension, and my employer another 8%, and it's still unlikely that I'll be able to retire particularly early or will live a particularly comfortable life in retirement. For one thing, if I'm still renting when I retire I'll likely be barely scraping by. Doing the math can be a shock.
- brundolf 6y agoMaybe I should actually do the math; I guess I just assumed that with the full matching contributions on what should be decent 401k's, I should already be getting set up for that "basic comfort, not having to worry about working to survive" baseline. Not that I'm burning the rest of the money I make. My basic view is that I don't want to be rich when I'm old so that I can make "dream purchases" or live on a cruise ship for the rest of my days or whatever; I want to be living comfortably and fully for my whole life.
- nly 6y agoThe basic rule of thumb advocated is to assume a 3-4% safe withdrawal rate in retirement. So for example, if you want a $30,000/yr (inflation adjusted) income in retirement you need to save yourself a $1M (inflation adjusted) pot. Over a 30 year career with a 5% (real, above inflation) investment return that takes $1,200/month. Lots of people think saving a couple of hundred bucks per month will leave them super comfortable. The math tells the scary reality.
- SCNP 6y agoI have this "fun" slider on my retirement account's website that shows different values for different retirement ages. In order to hit my minimum, I had to slide it all the way to age 85. "FUN"
- bluGill 6y ago
- vagrantJin 6y ago> I'm living in Europe and... >... enjoy more free time now by reducing work hours than to bet on an uncertain future. Unknowingly or not, you've just echoed a chapter in Peter Thiel's book Zero to One with such perfect clarity, Mr Thiel may start to look like a savant.
- ayngg 6y agoIt will probably hit them (as well as other Asian countries like South Korea) harder because they have not had the same levels of immigration to buffer the demographic change like in the west. Overall things have just gotten increasingly uncertain and insecure throughout the developed world, retirement at 65 is probably a pipe dream for most millennials.
- ido 6y agoIsn't increasing automation supposed to fix that? Having machines do more and more of the work for us.
- n_ary 6y ago> Having machines do more and more of the work for us. Automation often does not reduce the requirement for labor, it only shifts the work and cost somewhere else.
- FredPret 6y agoSometimes, “somewhere else” is upward on the value chain and is thus an improvement. Former plowshare-pullers become horse-steerers become tractor drivers. Each new invention does have it’s attendant complications, but they tend to be nicer than the basic, first job. Ie, I’d rather be a tractor mechanic than a plowshare puller. I’m glossing over generations of social upheaval and re-skilling here, but that’s the pattern so far.
- ayngg 6y agoMaybe, but machines also don't really pay taxes or into social security as well, at least not yet.
- orangepanda 6y agoAs automation increases, workforce transitions to more service-oriented professions that are more difficult to automate
- 6y ago
- n_ary 6y ago> I'm not confident at all that I'll get any retirement before my 70 Where I am(also EU), retirment is at 75 and already talks about raising it to 79, because lifespan increased, funds are in strains etc. I wonder if I will live up to that age to retire or it'll again shift several times, as the way world is changing with climate change and everything, life will probably be very different and expensive.
- nieksand 6y agoWhich country is this? I was not able to identify it via googling.
- Kbelicius 6y agoI do not know of any EU country with the retirement age over 70. Was it recently moved to those ages or did you mean 65 and 69?
- n_ary 6y agoIt is very strange, because I indeed remember it raised(there were news and criticism/opinion pieces everywhere) in 2015 to 75. However, now I checked wikipedia, it shows 65(+- few months). May be my memory is holding onto a proposal that didn't pass or something. I apologize for the misinformation.
- ldng 6y agoThat's the storytelling people keep repeating. That is not what is actually happening. Or at least, population is not getting older as fast as it's made to be and is not the biggest factor. For instance, France have, successfully, bet on immigration. But the public discourse being what it is, since the population was getting older supposedly, we are now lacking in schools and universities because we chose to not build or/and renovate infrastructures. So now we have a real education problem for instance. But the real problem with state pension fund in France is not that the population is getting older, the reality is that companies are simply not paying their due. With all sort of tax credit and exemption, various French government chose to artificially lower salaries for all employees. Most of them are not even aware as this is not treated on the case by case but globally at company level. The aim/excuse (depends on your political color) is to fight unemployment. The side effect, is that the state pension fund id depleting slowly but irremediably. On the other hand, to be fair, if you have massive unemployment, money is not entering the state pension fund either. But the population getting older is a trick politician love to use to not have explain complicated issues and arbitrations made in depth. The lazy way out IMO.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoPay as you go vs fully funded makes little difference - consumption goods such as nursing care cannot be carried over from one period to another. Unless France is going to use the depleted pension fund as an excuse to cut benefits, being underfunded only makes a difference in terms of whether the next generation of workers transfers goods to retirees in the form of taxes or pension fund contributions.
- ldng 5y ago> Unless France is going to use the depleted pension fund as an excuse to cut benefits That is exactly what has been happening several times during the last 3 decades.
- dcolkitt 6y ago> Generally I feel like retirement used to mean "I'm too old and frail to work anymore", until that brief blip between 1950-2010, give or take a decade or two. The question I'd have is why should the welfare state prioritize able-bodied workers just because they hit a fixed chronological age? I can definitely understand social security (which is essentially a welfare program) existing to support those who are too frail, infirm, or sick to work. Which would disproportionately fall upon the aged. But if somebody turns 65 and still capable healthy and capable of working (as many 65 year olds are in this day and age), why is the public budget subsidizing that person's leisure? I also understand the value of retirement as a time in later life to reflect and relax. And if this is valuable to someone they should take the personal initiative to save and invest to fund their retirement. But it doesn't seem like the purview of the welfare state to subsidize this lifestyle. The government doesn't subsidize vacations, gap years, and other types of "reflective leisure time". The purpose of the welfare state is to protect people in the most dire straits, not to make sure everybody's living the most fulfilling life possible. Heck, I can even understand advocating for UBI, which would give everyone a fallback option to not working. But it simply makes no sense that we essentially have UBI for able-bodied workers who are 65, but not those who are 35.
- piyh 6y ago> welfare state prioritize able-bodied workers just because they hit a fixed chronological age? There exists a need to support the old and frail. Chronological age is an easier metric to use than to leave value judgements up to whoever is going to be determining if someone qualifies. It's also money that I as a taxpayer put into the system and will get ~70% of my contributions back. Your welfare state is my government forced retirement plan with negative returns.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoNation state social security systems are not financial investments with returns, they are insurance. What are the returns on your homeowners and auto insurance?
- Aunche 6y ago
- senko 6y ago(2014)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- op03 6y agoMost of the big traps society sets up is built on top of loss aversion. The chimp brain is unreasonably terrified of loosing status, cash, relationships, health, housing etc etc. That fear is used to setup all kinds of traps to keep the chimp in chains. So lot of people have got trapped in costly social/professional status arm races, multiple alimony/child support payments, multiple mortgages, endless credit card bills etc etc etc. If you want to retire. Know the traps. Avoid the traps - https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/loss-aversion/ https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/loss-aversion/ The world is not static. More people understand the weaknesses of their own brain the less things can stay the same.
- namelosw 6y agoHuman is weird. On one hand, they hate loss. On the other hand, they are so vulnerable to gamble-alike activities, which make the minority rich and majority poor, which always drastic decrease of the happiness in total (because those who gain money are slightly happier but those who lose money suffer).
- autosharp 6y agoPensions would be funded by everyone including me, "but I can gamble better than you"
- Barrin92 6y agoLoss aversion is perfectly reasonable. Being indifferent to losses makes sense in a world of risk, where costs are known and chances repeat, and where a cushion exists large enough to catch you. (this is the video game like world of the upper-middle class where everyone gets 10 shots) But most of us don't live in a world of risk, we live in a world of uncertainty, and people who make decisions under uncertainty have to consider that loss isn't that good if you lose so hard that you're dead (literally or metaphorically), or you don't get to see the payoff. The chimp brain is the way it is for a reason, if the tiger gets you that's it, doesn't matter how tasty the fruits on the tree are.
- bumby 6y ago
- courtf 6y agoCruelty without end. Billions are made off crashes, like the one in '08, that sink people into poverty exactly when they can't afford it. Billions more are made off their continued labor. But if one of these grandmas picked up a gun and shot someone on wall street, they'd be hauled away in an instant. Law and order.
- papito 6y agoThat's what Law and Order means. What you really want is the Rule of Law, but that's something the upper echelons don't like much.
- missedthecue 6y agoBillions are lost in crashes as well... There are a number of billionaires and hundred-millionaires who were undone in 2008. It's not like they all got richer and everyone else got poorer.
- courtf 6y agoSomething tells me they won't be spending their twilight years working the fields, but I suppose there's always a convenient counterexample or two out there to latch onto if you're looking for ways to ignore the broad trends.
- missedthecue 5y agoAll you're really saying is that the stock market is higher than it was in 2008. It's a true statement, but I don't feel that it's very insightful.
- courtf 5y agoHuh? No, I'm saying that a billionaire may have lost all their investments, but chances are they will never be so poor as to become one of the traveling poor when they are old. The crash in 2008 didn't just wipe out investments, tons of poor Americans had no investments anyway. The crash took out people's livelihoods, their jobs and homes. And without health insurance, they tend to ignore health problems that gradually become more expensive problems that can also wipe them out. They are too poor and too old to recover from these types of loss, and the government benefits they are entitled are not enough to keep them homed and healthy. The rich who lost money in the stock market will never in their lives have to consider these issues, and frankly I'm shocked at how often this stuff seems to fly over the heads of people on this website.
- kgantchev 6y agoSocial Security is a sham. That's making people live poorer after retirement. Many of them don't receive anything close to the money they earned while they were working. That's not the case if they had invested the same money in a 401K. It's absolutely terrible that old people are living worse than they would have had if the government hadn't forced them to dump their money in the dumpster fire that is Social Security. [1] https://taxfoundation.org/comparing-returns-tax-favored-retirement-plans-social-security-yields https://taxfoundation.org/comparing-returns-tax-favored-reti...
- kazen44 6y agosocial security goes far beyond just a pension system. things like housing, healthcare and social support for the less fortunate in society all fall under social security. the current pension system in most of the world is just not scalable because people getting older and the birth rate declining, but this does not mean that money couldn't be sourced from elsewhere. in most countries today, workers contribute the majority of the pension for the current retired generation. mind you the free market also does not have a solution for this problem, except to tell poor people or disabled people to be poor or keep working until they drop dead.
- q-big 6y ago> the current pension system in most of the world is just not scalable because people getting older and the birth rate declining, Is does scale in this situation: simply increase the retirement ages properly such that always at least roughly "inflow of money = outflow of money" holds. The problem rather is that there is no political will to do that.
- Ekaros 6y agoAnd somehow important thing that has been forgotten is that you can't pay out more than has been paid in. On average for generation. Too bad boomers are the entitled generation and ruined it for their children. They talk about their contributions, but I see no hard numbers if they have truly paid in as much is being paid out.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoThe real problem here is poverty and a lack of social security in the US. That's a solvable problem. It just requires the will to solve it and for whatever reason that is actually controversial in the US. I live in Europe. Retirement is very much on my mind but more in the sense that I need to secure a little more than just the state pension. You can live on that but only barely. A lot of European countries are lot poorer than the US. Yet retirement is a thing in those countries and not really under any threat. The need to work and the reality that a lot of work is just busy work that isn't really that critical because all the critical work is increasingly automated does not help with this. No offense but I work doing CTO work in startups and technically it's been a long time since I did anything close to producing critical goods or services. It's nice what I do and I live on it but I can't say with a straight face that it is all that critical or important. A lot of our jobs are like that. We keep ourselves busy doing things for each other or ourselves and try to monetize that. I can probably do that beyond retirement if I stay healthy. I might even enjoy that. Post scarcity society is not that different from where we are today (at least us privileged people working tech jobs). Poverty is increasingly having to do actual work to feed yourself. In most countries that at least gets you to retirement. The US is kind of unique in that it is very wealthy and yet does not take care of its people in the same way that much poorer countries have been doing for the last century.
- courtf 6y agoIt's broken for sure, though it's not really anything new. The US is still structurally a slave society, even if we now have the freedom to bounce between plantations (unless your visa is only sponsored by a specific one).
- Seattle3503 6y ago> The US is still structurally a slave society, even if we now have the freedom to bounce between plantations What makes you say that?
- courtf 6y agoThe country has never functioned without hordes of cheap, disposable labor that must work into their geriatric years or starve. There is no long-term stability, nor any expectation of it, unless you can become part of the owner class.
- wiredfool 6y agoThis opens with one of the the people featured in Nomadland, (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9770150/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9770150/) the Oscar winning film from last year.
- gabrielsroka 6y agoThe article was written by Jessica Bruder, who wrote the Nomadland novel.
- wiredfool 6y agoWell alrighty then, that would be it. Watched the movie a couple weeks back, and it's disturbing in the same way that other society falling apart movies are. There's an ambiguity over if the people are doing it by choice or if they're forced, or if they're just choosing to because the have to, and it's easier to not hate things that way.
- hoppyhoppy2 6y agoNomadland (the book) is nonfiction, not a novel.
- gabrielsroka 5y agoYou're right. The movie Nomadland is based on the book, but has been fictionalized.
- TrackerFF 6y agoI am lucky enough to live in a European country where I don't need to work after a certain age, because our social safety net ensures just that. I plan on retiring before that, but from our point of view, it seems absurd that the US can't / won't offer the same to their seniors.
- gryn 6y agoI too live in europe but I'm not so optimistic about it, given the societal trends it's likely my retirement age will be increased once or twice again before I reach it. this combined with inflation and the raise in price of specific things will probably means that the received amount won't be enough to live with.
- alecco 6y ago> The average EU country would need to have more than four times (434 percent) its current annual gross domestic product (GDP) in the bank today, earning interest at the government’s borrowing rate, in order to fund current policies indefinitely. (2009) https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/articles/gokhale-NCPA-319.pdf https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/articles/gokhale-N...
- Hitton 6y agoFriend (tenured economics professor) once only half-jokingly told me, that having children who will take care of you when you are old is the most dependable retirement scheme.
- geomark 6y agoChildless friends tell me they won't have kids because they are too expensive. I tell them they are thinking about it wrong. They own a house and talk about it as their best investment. Well, kids are an investment. A high risk/high reward investment for sure. But possibly the greatest investment they will ever make, due at least in part to the reason your friend mentioned.
- incompleteCode 6y agoMy counterpoint to this is: it's worth it to regret the last few years than to regret it an entire lifetime. I know I'll regret kids. Edit: Goes without saying that you'll need to plan for your retirement. I fully anticipate assisted suicide being a legal option during my old age.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhat if the childless friends are planning to kill themselves once they need assistance? Then their calculations make sense. I have kids, but I still do not want them to spend their time caring for me on a constant basis. I hope I have the ability and physical will to take myself out before that happens. I saw what my parents gave up taking care of one set of my grandparents, I do not wish that on anyone. They “lived” into the upper 90s (over a span of 30 years since the grandparents were 15 years apart in age) and I consider my parents to have wasted many of their best years.
- geomark 5y agoIt seems very sad to me to think of it as wasting your best years taking care of your aging parents. I considered it a privilege to take care of my parents to the end. To each his own.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kingsuper20 6y agoSocial security doesn't seem to work too badly (although the $500 listed in the article implies that the lady featured didn't put together a full career of anything). It's certainly more sustainable than Medicare (US old-age health system for you furriners). You could argue that a guaranteed income program consists purely of increasing the subsidies for SS and taking money from 'the rich', but that'll require more political will than exists. An interesting situation that I see a lot of is folks who spent an entire worklife doing largely cash work (construction, waitresses, bartenders, business owners who never took a reported salary) who find themselves getting older with little money on the horizon. This is probably 50% of the people I know.
- alecco 6y ago> The report pointed to $52.72 trillion in unfunded Medicare benefits and $37.60 trillion in unfunded Social Security benefits https://www.accountingtoday.com/news/u-s-governments-financial-condition-worsened-by-8-16t-in-2019 https://www.accountingtoday.com/news/u-s-governments-financi...
- kingsuper20 6y agoI was just musing about how perfectly constructed this article is to appeal to a tech cubicle employee. 1) Doom porn for those worried about their later years (Hint: it's unlikely that you can pull a full career out of programming, hw engineering, tech marketing). 2) Amazon. 3) Van living. ..a) Sounds good to a single engineer who would rather mountain bike than construct one more product that rhymes with the last 5. ..b) Van design and construction is an interesting problem, especially the unsolved issues of sanitation. 4) Quartzsite, BLM land, other big get-togethers. Burning Man for introverts. Maybe there's room for a new Woody Guthrie. 5) Bob Wells and the whole van living youtube biz. Teaching people how to shit in a bucket can actually pay the bills in our brave new world. Go figure. 6) Often discussed never solved social issues (guaranteed income, public health care). Grave concern can be shown by everyone. It's got it all.
- yesBoot 6y ago“Retirement” is a recent invention. Before the last generation or so, the elderly moved into family support roles. Given that we’re bending over backwards to inflate the wealth of older investors, deflating the buying power of the younger generation in exchange, is enabling retirement a great idea? It sounds amazing, right? But why must the youth honor the elder generations contracts at their expense? Why must we “wait” until we can live a free adult life? Just kidding; it’s to prop up the choices of the past as I said. There are embedded social norms that need a fundamental rethink.
- cyberlurker 6y agoHaving an industry take care of our elderly does free younger generations from elder care responsibilities. It’s not a total loss for the younger generations. Elder care is really hard work. But I do agree we shouldn’t be subsidizing early retirement so the wealthy elders can go on vacations.
- yesBoot 6y agoAnecdotal, but all my elders who committed to supporting their grand kids; taking them to soccer and such, lived on their own into their 90s. The ones that died before 80 had turned into hermits, spending their last few months in industrialized care homes. Being obliged to contribute to communal work may come along with cognitive health benefit. I don’t have an issue with caretakers being relied on for difficult health reasons. But are we creating health problems through social norms?
- bradlys 6y agoSometimes you don’t want the grandparents around. There’s a reason many people move out, ya know? The amount of shitty parents that don’t deserve a single thing from their children is massive. And for that reason, we do need an industry built up around elderly care and facilitating independence from elders.
- yesBoot 6y ago
- at_a_remove 6y agoI cannot claim to speak for the entirety of Gen X, but most of us find this unsurprising. Killer bees, acid rain, sex that kills, nuclear war, we have been waiting for the other shoe to drop for decades. We will finally have our Road Warrior future, it's just that we didn't expect to be grey-haired for it.
- siliconunit 6y agoZooming out: I think lots of comments suffer from a combination of workcentric view of life and old school puritan values where work is holy and good no matter what. In a true 'smart' society first thing you would do along with your skilled and big headed friends would be to figure out a way to fully automate everything and NOT work... Yes fix the odd broken stuff and help out when is needed, improve and innovate for the sake of optimization/discovery and scientific curiosity, but nothing mandatory to the actual single in order to have basic needs covered, food, housing etc. Money and all the financial system is a lame excuse to keep the status quo and everyone else under its control, with enough computational power you can forecast and implement very nice lifestyle for everyone, the ability to measure and compute nearly everything to a very good degree is something that only recently we achieved and we are not taking full advantage of. Simple example: Japan... too many old people too few to support them, yes we could automate most of the food chain and provide free housing for all of them, but we don't have -fantasy resource x (money)- to accomplish it, this is frankly ridiculous. If you can measure resources and make sure you use them in a reasoned manner you can cover most basic needs for everyone, the reason why it doesn't happen is the heritage of a feudal society who prized violence and subjugation of others and believed in invisible entities that would punish who was against them and/or the established power, and power needed slaves/workers. This was a blink of an eye ago historically.
- bradlys 6y agoNo joke. Where are the teenagers on HN? This place seems to be full of angst-ridden middle-aged people who decry the lack of backbone and work ethic of the modern man - who cannot imagine not working because they’ve finally hit the peak of their career and are doing so well in middle management!! I mean, I just got a damn raise for shipping that product! I worked hard and so should you god damn it!
- UncleOxidant 6y agoThose middle management jobs tend to be the first to go in a downturn.
- logicslave 6y ago
- kwertyoowiyop 6y agoHow do you suppose all the people in the article are doing now, seven years later?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- atlgator 6y agoI don't understand why able-bodied/minded people remain in minimum wage jobs their entire life. And I made minimum wage myself working at a grocery store and video rental shop. The lady in the article was 60 in 2014. Why didn't she ever consider learning skills along the way that would offer salary growth or just flat out apply for higher paying jobs? I managed to raise my hourly wage from $5.15 to $27 over 6 years with only a high school diploma. And I was morbidly obese at the time too so it wasn't for my looks. We could at least push young minimum wage earners today toward learning a trade or other areas experiencing labor shortage like truckers, etc.
- 3GuardLineups 6y ago>he and his wife, Barbara, saw his nest egg — $210,000 in investments — vaporize in the stock market what kind of investment literally vaporizes to $0? Not to be insensitive, but it seems like this shouldn't happen. The markets recovered to all time highs pretty darn quick