20 ms·
Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork?
- fungiblecog 6y agoWell I don't so I guess that "we" isn't counting me at least
- imheretolearn 6y agoNobody who is somebody became someone through work-life balance - Anonymous
- philmcp 6y agoI agree with this for those trying to create their own business. I disagree for most salaried positions though - soft skills, politics and luck play a huge role
- kar5pt 6y agoThis saying embodies all the pretentions of the cult of overwork. Only the people who are "successful" (measured by monetary wealth and/or fame) are "somebodies". The rest are nobodies. They're invisible.
- barbazoo 6y agoI don't know if you're being sarcastic, but you don't need to work endless hours to "be somebody", maybe to be a successful entrepreneur but then you have a very specific idea about what defines someone's value.
- austinjp 6y agoThe definition of being "somebody" is missing here. Anyways, it's not exclusively true that work-life balance has to be sacrificed. I met a very successful business owner (millionaire, to quantify) a while ago who didn't do meetings before midday. Hated it, and would prefer to meet late afternoon. If being "somebody" includes financial success, they illustrated that it's not necessarily incompatible with a happy work-life balance.
- all2 6y agoWealth, power, fame == "somebody" Tbh, I'm not interested in being that kind of somebody. I'd rather be a good friend, good at my job, and doing the work my God has set out for me to do. If I can nail those I think I'm doing pretty well. Dare I say I might even be satisfied.
- drewcoo 6y agoDoes no one else see the humor in that?
- borodi 6y agoI would say that the opposite. Most people that are "somebody" in the history of the world were that as soon as they were born.
- philmcp 6y agoDuring lockdown I was feeling pretty burnt out myself which got me thinking: why are basically all jobs 9-5, 5 days per week? Why is there no variation on this model? It annoyed me so much that I decided to create https://4dayweek.io/ https://4dayweek.io/ - Software Engineering jobs with a better work / life balance
- nceasy 6y agoman I just heard about your site few days ago and find it dope. I hope it to have some more data scientist/ML jobs any time soon!
- philmcp 6y agoCheers mate - really appreciate it! More jobs (e.g ML) getting added soon, just need to convince more companies to consider applications for a 4 day week
- kar5pt 6y agoHow do these companies scale down the workload for 4 day a week employees? Estimates in the software field are based on intuition. I could easily see this becoming, "get 5 days of work done in 4 days and get paid less for it" if the people involved aren't used to estimating based on 4 day work weeks.
- tharkun__ 6y agoCan you elaborate on your context maybe? Asking because to me this intuitively doesn't make sense but my context is agile software development with sprint and story points. Since story points are a relative complexity measure they don't care about how long the work week is. The velocity measured over each sprint in these points also doesn't. Velocity is just an average number of observed story points delivered per time period. How many days were 'work days' and which, doesn't really matter.
- nceasy 6y ago
- Tabular-Iceberg 6y agoHow much do these ultra successful types actually over-work and how much is just posturing to trick the underlings to over-work? In American Psycho Patrick Bateman has it pretty chill, spending all his working hours on watching TV, reading magazines and talking trash with his peers. I used to think it was just another example of how unhinged he was, but maybe it’s a comment on some kind of double standard on workload vs. compensation in the corporate life.
- brutal_chaos_ 6y agoThat is a great take on it! My take was the higher up you go, the more meaningless the work is. As in paper pusher vs innovator. Though I imagine near to and at C level it may be different.
- maxqin1 6y agoIt's all posturing. Why wouldn't it be? Leadership is all about "leveraging great people" right? So it makes sense to keep up the appearance if it means an extra X% output. And that's not even considering the management of expectations to prevent complaints about income inequality. I mean, you didn't work 80+ hour weeks, so, who are you to complain?
- throwagrayson 6y agoNo, they're just smarter, faster, bolder, and harder working, and they have social circles that mirror those qualities.
- drunkpotato 6y agoI honestly can't tell if this is sincere or sarcasm.
- weasel_words 6y agoSarcasm or not, this is how life is. Hang with people who are one trait and you tend to become that trait. Hang with people who are not, and you'll tend not to be either. If you want to "chill", hang with those people. If you want to "work hard", hang with those people. I'm not judging, I'm just saying. Choose your circle of friends wisely.
- aritmo 6y agoIt's just posturing. The same people who complain all the time, for sympathy.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"The roots of this phenomenon can be traced back to the 'Protestant work ethic' in the 16th Century - a worldview held by white Protestants in Europe that made hard work and the quest for profit seem virtuous. Sally Maitlis, professor of organisational behaviour and leadership at the University of Oxford, says that "later, the drive for efficiency that arose out of the Industrial Revolution", as well as the way we prize productivity, have "further embedded the value of consistent hard work, often at the cost of personal wellbeing". The roots of the valorization of work may well have been religious, and maybe Christian (though I very much doubt it's exclusively Christian in its origin), but it's definitely spread throughout much of the world, even among the non-religious and even atheist population. I can't count the number of times I've heard people praise others as "hard working"... in all sorts of contexts, in many different parts of the world, native or immigrant, hard work is praised to the heavens and one of the best things you can say about a person is that they're hard working. I almost never hear the value of working hard being questioned, except when the subject turns to burnout. Then everybody nods sagely and agrees that overwork is bad.. the next day they go back to praising hard workers.
- crispyambulance 6y agoThe Protestant/Calvinist work-ethic is definitely a factor especially, IMHO, in technology work. It stretches over to Asian non-Christian cultures too, but I suspect that's because it's an export which they've accepted as their own because it happens to jive with the strict authoritarian hierarchies which are common in Asian countries. You can see it in Stackoverflow as well. The gamification encourages people to prove they are "worthy" of even deigning to ask a question by showing they've done "the work". Those who haven't are subject to humiliation and dismissal, regardless of need or authenticity.
- halflings 6y ago> You can see it in Stackoverflow as well. The gamification encourages people to prove they are "worthy" of even deigning to ask a question by showing they've done "the work". Those who haven't are subject to humiliation and dismissal, regardless of need or authenticity. I don't see how stackexchange's policy is related to the article, or "Protestant/Calvinist work-ethic". They are banning low-effort questions (e.g "File couldn't be opened" when the person just has a typo in a file path) because they devalue the platform, waste time that could have instead been spent on useful questions. > I suspect that's because it's an export which they've accepted as their own because it happens to jive with the strict authoritarian hierarchies which are common in Asian countries. Or they independently developed a glorification of hard-work from other sources. It's nothing new. All the Abrahamic religions do, and the same is true for secular ideologies such as communism.
- Barrin92 6y agoThe article paints a picture of this as a universal but it's not really true I think. From my experience, in the German Mittelstand, overwork is not seen as a positive. There are a lot of very productive firms, and there's a huge focus on working 9-5, doing your work well, not being distracted, and then going home and having a life. Staying at work till midnight would be seen as not managing time correctly, neglecting family, being overworked, not in good shape, making mistakes and so on. I don't even think it's necessarily that popular in American culture any more after the sort of financial excesses of the late aughts. The stereotypical banker who is coked up and accidentally destroys the economy isn't really as cool anymore as he was in the 80s
- austinjp 6y ago> Staying at work till midnight would be seen as not managing time correctly, neglecting family, being overworked, not in good shape, making mistakes and so on. How is it seen if someone is at work by 7am? Or even 6am? Genuine question.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn my anecdotal experience, seemingly not noticed, as people assume that you came in just a few minutes before. For a couple of reasons, I spent a period of time going into work at 6AM. Most came at 8 or 9. Far more people commented when I stayed until 6PM one day. A former co-worker of mine used to do this as well. I didn’t notice for weeks and only because I logged in very early one day.
- kar5pt 6y agoAt my old job I was routinely praised for being a hard worker because people kept seeing me stay to 7pm. I usually heard comments like, "don't work too hard" and "make sure you don't stay too late". What no one seemed to notice was I was coming in at 11. I never felt the need to correct anyone.
- yuppie_scum 6y ago
- ConceptJunkie 6y agoI don't. And none of the companies I've ever worked for do either. I guess I'm fortunate. Sure, I've needed to work a little overtime, but I've never had any problem maintaining my work/life balance, and have a pretty good career.
- tharkun__ 6y agoWith you there. I don't mind doing more on one day over another. It's actually great because you can finish something while in context instead of arbitrarily dropping the pencil at 5. I make very sure to balance it out though and if my company doesn't do or require time tracking, I will do it myself. What I do though is to be 100% there during work hours. Meaning in the office it's work not play or personal time. Reading HN is not for work hours for example. Same now with the WFH. Work time is work time and I get everything I want to done in the regular hours and fingers crossed so far nobody has ever complained to me about it. I am very allergic to deadlines dropped on me because someone else didn't plan ahead properly as well. HR, C-level and marketing come to mind.
- Swizec 6y agoWhen somebody brags to you about how much they work, answer with “Maybe if you were better at it, you wouldn’t need to work so much” Watch their jaw drop edit: use responsibly, social intelligence required (like don’t say it to your boss, but as a jab at a good friend)
- stagger87 6y ago"How to lose friends and alienate people."
- tharkun__ 6y agoNot the OP here and I agree with you (that's why I never say that) but can you honestly say that you never _thought_ it when they complain? I know I do most of the time. There are the workoholic exceptions that just can't help themselves.
- koyote 6y agoI agree with other commenters that it might not be the best thing to say if you want to keep your friendships. It's a very true sentiment though. Another one that often comes to my mind when people brag about amount of hours work is something along the lines of: "Do you know that you're effectively being paid at near minimum wage?" (obviously not true for everyone, but some people's salary goes from 'decent' to 'minimum wage' per hour worked) But it's even worse than just being paid less per hour worked: For each hour you work, you lose an hour of 'life'. Working 10 hour days instead of 8 hour days means that you lose 10 hours of 'life' a week.
- TchoBeer 6y agoThat's an awful thing to say. I think a better response would be "why are you proud of having less free time than me?" I remember in school people would often brag about how little sleep they got and when they said that to me I'd say "why are you proud of how unhealthy your life is?" I would NOT say "sucks for you that you're too dumb to study enough and get to bed by 11". That would be a dick move.
- 6y ago
- booleandilemma 6y agoFear that if we don’t work hard we’ll be replaced by the next guy who will, and maybe for cheaper. Somehow everyone’s always busy with things to work on, even the guy I see watching YouTube videos after standup.
- MattGaiser 6y agoHow about those of us that just enjoy our jobs? My company is really good about work life balance. But there are plenty of people, myself included, who log in on the weekends or at 2AM and write code or review stuff. Coding is fun! There are people out there who do for pay something very similar to what they would do if they had millions of dollars.
- eggsmediumrare 6y agoStop setting standards for free that those of us with other priorities can't meet. If you must code, work on something other than work.
- bpodgursky 6y agoCounterpoint: don't tell me what to do.
- eggsmediumrare 6y agoYou're free to do what you want, but working for free doesn't just hurt you. It hurts your coworkers and the industry as a whole.
- bpodgursky 6y agoActually working long hours as a developer in my 20s got me a ton of extra equity and skills which set me up very comfortably professionally and financially. I'm not recommending flipping burgers for free overtime, but it's ludicrous to claim that working hard doesn't pay dividends in professional high-skill fields for fair employers.
- eggsmediumrare 6y agoThat's fine, but again... Why do work that makes money for someone else for free? You can achieve the same thing by working on your own stuff. I'm also a well paid software developer, but I spent my 20s recording albums, learning to garden, staying fit, and generally not spending my time making money for someone else for free.
- lovetocode 6y agoI was on the Tesla hiring webinar last Friday for the application development vertical and on more than one occasion they alluded to their overwork culture. I asked some hardball questions that they either did not see or refused to answer. Most of the webinar was non-engineering related discussion and more of just a “woke culture” advertisement. Like they say, never meet your heroes. It was really quite a bummer because I have been stoked about being a Tesla customer and potential employee candidate. We own two Tesla’s in my household so I am all in at this point. Because I am a father of two and moderately conservative I feel like I wouldn’t be a good culture fit. I’ll do my 8 hours a day and some occasional unpaid overtime is fair but I got the vibe that they work more than 40 hours a week fairly regularly. I would love to be wrong about this so someone please prove me wrong.
- tharkun__ 6y agoUnpaid overtime is never OK if you ask me. That said I favour flexible time arrangements instead of what I gather is mostly understood by 'overtime'. Thus averaging out to 8h (preferably 7h) per day. They definitely work more and things like parental are also not really a thing. Source: a friend of mine works there now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rconti 6y agoYou're not "all in". You can sell a car and replace it at any time. It's just a possession. I don't get how that's related to whether or not you want to work there? Everything I know about Tesla would lead me to believe that it would be a high pressure/high output environment; seems like there's more than enough publicity about this out there.
- barbazoo 6y agoI know very few people in salaried positions whose overtime isn't at least somewhat related to their inability to a) manage their time properly or b) stand up for themselves.
- rubicks 6y agoBecause the alternative, namely the conscientious abstention from overwork, will often earn you a reputation as a "bare-minimum worker", a "clock-watcher", and "not a team-player".
- rhizome 6y agoThis is basic accepted business principles as far as this dropout can see. First, reduce labor costs. One way to lower wages is to get salaried people to work as many hours for their check as you can convince them to do. This is one place where sociopaths shine. Second, the ideal labor cost is $0, aka the ideal state of capitalism. When humans are involved, this means slavery. "Ideal" means the same as above: reduce labor costs wherever possible. Convincing people to overwork is a sales job, and bending everybody around you to your preferred activities is practice for when you're going for funding or acquisition. Is there any MBA who wants to help build a company that doesn't get acquired? Gonna need those persuasion skills. Working 80hrs a week? Congratulations, you've cut your own salary in half.
- sneak 6y ago> Second, the ideal labor cost is $0, aka the ideal state of capitalism. The labor participants are engaging in capitalism as well; earning $0/hour is not an ideal state for me as a service provider.
- cherrycherry98 6y agoAdam Smith argued that free workers are superior to slaves because they have greater incentive to want to better themselves for their own benefit and to innovate their processes to show they are worth more wages. Slaves, by contrast, he argues will perform the bare minimum work to avoid repercussions. They are also far from free, they cost money to purchase and there is a cost to providing them with necessities of life as they don't have the means of providing for themselves.
- pnutjam 6y agoJust like there are rule for overtime pay, there should be well documented rules for comp-time and on-call. Companies handle these all sorts of ways, but people should not be expected to give away tons of time.
- xpe 6y agoTheory: overwork culture is a 'race to the bottom' when workers feel more pressure to (1) compete against each other instead of (2) organizing together to promote mutual interests. Put this way, 'overwork culture' would be a collective action problem in the context of an economic system where owners have more leverage than workers. So what about tech, where workers seem to have high leverage? Why do they still overwork? One factor that may be overlooked is this: workers are not only competing against their contemporaries but also future workers (which may be more numerous and perceived as less expensive).
- thomastjeffery 6y ago> So what about tech, where workers seem to have high leverage? Do they? In my experience, most software engineers do experience a better work/life balance, especially at startups where they have more leverage. Even so, we can do better.
- 1270018080 6y agoThere's also no tech union. And even though many tech workers are at the top of the working class bubble, it's still working class. You have more in common with someone working minimum wage than the executive who writes himself a bonus and hoards equity.
- yuppie_scum 6y agoThis is a very privileged viewpoint
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoCombination of two factors: 1. Efficiency wages. Highly motivated and skilled programmers are so much better at their jobs than unmotivated and unskilled replacements that it's best to "overpay" above the market-clearing price, giving employers meaningful choice in applicants and regain some of the negotiating power in the relationship. 2. Tournament theory of compensation. Quantifying performance of engineers is difficult, but rank-ordering them (especially without an explicit stack-ranking) is relatively easy. So an efficient solution is to overpay the best-performing "winners" and underpay the rest, getting the same incentive effects as piece work without the cost of quantifying work output.
- hard_penis_2 6y agoThat’s a really hard penis to solve.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoContrarian view: we have never worked less, but our work has less meaning, so the psychosomatic pain per hour is higher: https://ourworldindata.org/exports/annual-working-hours-per-worker_v88_850x600.svg https://ourworldindata.org/exports/annual-working-hours-per-... In the past most work was directly tied to feeding your family.
- thomastjeffery 6y agoWe're have never worked less on average, but that average is heavily skewed by a small percentage of workers.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoI've been working for 30 years, at a dozen companies. There is a difference in the intensity of the workers that roughly correlates to the size of the company. The larger the company, the lower the intensity overall. But in all cases, I seldom if ever saw employees who weren't actually working a full day's work or more. These were all technology companies, ranging from 5 - 3,000 employees, and it was a fact that if people didn't pull their weight overall, the company wouldn't last long. I am certain the apocryphal slacker is out there, otherwise we'd not have the parody. From my perspective at least, people had to produce, regardless of what they were expected to deliver. If they didn't, they eventually got moved out.
- prawn 6y agoMy brother tells a story of a rail maintenance company where the margins were fat enough that lazy employees could survive. One lazy guy, having been busted sleeping at his desk, went looking for somewhere he could get away with it. In a basement, he found a large laundry hamper of some sort, which worked well for a few days until one day he went to get in for a nap and discovered someone else was already sleeping in there!
- theshrike79 6y agoI've worked in factories when I was younger. Just grab an empty box and say you're delivering it to the other end of the factory when someone asks. Works every time if you're confident enough.
- giantg2 6y agoBecause it's an arms race and we have to perform to survive.
- unchocked 6y agoA simple answer with strong explanatory power: because we are competing for status (increasing subjective marginal returns) instead of working for money (decreasing subjective marginal returns).
- didibus 6y agoI think it's easy to buy in the idea of "hard work pays off", because believing in "luck" instead for a measure of success isn't as satisfying. We like to think our effort pays off, that we've got agency, and that those who made it better than us must have done so because they worked harder and so deserve it, and can be an inspiration and model for us to do the same one day. As opposed to thinking they just lucked out more.
- callamdelaney 6y agoLook at the people who believe that the people who achieved more than them got 'lucky'. Usually they spend their time complaining about how they're not lucky, as apposed to applying themselves and getting what they want. edit: My point is that believing hard work pays off is a much more effective framework for achieving literally anything.
- etripe 6y agoIt's not entirely so black and white, and it's definitely no XOR. You can work hard and fail due to being unlucky - as far as I understand it, that's most people who start their first business. You can be lucky and fail upwards, see Trump, who botched more projects than he didn't. And you can be lucky and apply yourself, see Elon Musk or Bill Gates. It's important to realise that both play a role, because you don't want to self sabotage when your business fails due to extraneous circumstance. Perhaps you should try again, preparing better for things you can't control. Perhaps it really just was a bad time to get promoted and you should stick with the company longer. It's also important to realise that someone who got a couple mill as an inheritance or "boost" for their business will always have a leg up - if you're measuring success in monetary terms. The same goes for challenging entrenched competition in your sector. Perhaps you should re-target to businesses that will be amenable to your agility and tailor-made solutions, because that kind of service might not be offered by well-established competitors. Equally important is realising that there is a basic truth to the biblical parable of the talents: no matter what you get, you won't get anywhere without applying yourself, whatever that means to you.
- Enginerrrd 6y ago
- okareaman 6y agoWorkaholism is only one of the many addictions people trap themselves into. The pursuit of a reward is part of the mammalian makeup. Then there is the need to escape due to the "fight or flight" response. There are many good techniques to address these core issues in our makeup.
- markus_zhang 6y ago>But millions of us overwork because somehow we think it’s exciting – a status symbol that puts us on the path to success, whether we define that by wealth or an Instagram post that makes it seem like we're living a dream life with a dream job. Work _IS_ exciting if it fits with one's target. I think the key takeaway is that one _CAN_ love his work, or at least part of it, which results in overwork, which is normal and even should be encouraged. But none should be forced to overwork in the ideal world. >"We glorify the lifestyle, and the lifestyle is: you breathe something, you sleep with something, you wake up and work on it all day long, then you go to sleep," says Anat Lechner, clinical associate professor of management at New York University. "Again and again and again." IMO this is actually indeed the ideal way to live. You burn your life for something you love. You live with it, expose your soul to it and you bet all your awaken time on it. Gekko, regardless whether his actions were legal or not, indeed worked the job he loved and as a fund manager he had his way in the fund. This is perfect for anyone. On my side, let's just say that work, albeit that 80% of it is boring, is still a lot more interesting than non-work, that includes changing diapers, cooking meals and others. Plus it pays the bills.
- browningstreet 6y agoBecause: it’s sold to those for whom untold fortunes may arise. It’s re-sold to every two-bit manager and unfortunate employee inside the rest of the economy.
- Proven 6y agoWhy would I? I like it. Nudging people to works less is a socialist plot to make everyone more dependent on the State.
- throwaway481048 6y agoWhy? Because we are frequently utilizing any and every method to increase our self worth, to not only justify fleeting happiness, but give reason to our ever-fading presence on this cold rock we call home. The latter is particularly difficult to encapsulate.
- minikites 6y agoWe are not remembered as individuals, we are remembered as a collective: Alexander the Great found the philosopher looking attentively at a pile of human bones. Diogenes explained, "I am searching for the bones of your father but cannot distinguish them from those of a slave."
- gandalfgeek 6y agoAn important factor is not long hours or overwork, but how much control one has over one's work. Can't quite find it now, but there was a study which found that senior ranking people had better health outcomes than junior folks, even though both sets put in the same number of (high) hours, because the senior people had more agency over their work. I doubt Musk saw 100 hr weeks as soul-draining drudgery where he needed to run out the clock.
- tomrod 6y agoMoney.
- watertom 6y agoHardworking and reliable people are valuable assists to a community, and I suspect some aspect of this is wired into our brains. So it’s natural. Working so that others may get rich at our own expense is relatively new, and it’s largely a marketing message, done by those who are getting rich, and they are tapping into what’s wired into our brains.
- fabianhjr 6y agoI highly suggest the book "The Last Night: Anti-Work, Atheism, Adventure" by Federico Campagna. One of my favourite quotes: > "Finally, we now have at our disposal a set of technologies that would be able to make most of human labour redundant. Instead of profiting from the ease allowed by a production devolved to machines, humans find themselves competing against technology and are thus forced to reduce their demands and expectations to the level of the machine. We try to work as much and as tirelessly as machines do, and by doing so we turn ourselves into second-rate production machines, never as efficient as the real ones." ~ Federico Campagna
- sneak 6y agoI'm fairly certain that most of the work done by humans working long hours today is beyond the technology of the machines, for the moment. There's no machine that can do my job, for example, and I suspect that that is true for most extremely career-oriented people.
- antoniuschan99 6y agoIt’s definitely dependant on the motivation whether it’s glamour, status, paying off debts, or wanting to change the world. But the thing is, work (ethic) is essentially the only thing that one can control. Other people may be more talented, or have more intelligence but work ethic comes from within. Just like being disciplined and working out and exercising (which is also similar as the motivations to train vary widely). I remembered this from Will Smith talking about it. His movie pursuit of Happyness is relevant to the topic https://youtu.be/05nOroFYIF8 https://youtu.be/05nOroFYIF8
- irjustin 6y agoWe teach it to our kids for crying out loud. It's imbedded into us from ~3rd grade. School starts at 7:30 am, ends at 2:30-3. After school club, then there's homework. Kids who use the 4pm to 10pm kids who study/grind hard get better grades are praised - look at Billy or Suzy here! Taking a step back - this is what happens when there's a limited resource. Any competition for a limited resource will naturally create a 'workaholic' culture since that's the way to get more of whatever limited resource there is. That's why I'm 1000% for the StarTrek replicator. We tried communism - it doesn't work.
- wonderwonder 6y agoI have found that the more money I make the more hours I have to work. I am a software engineer, non manager. I had a job making 60k a year and I worked 40 hours a week, it was awesome. Then I got a job making 120k a year and I worked 65 - 75 hours a week. I did not want to do this but to keep up with the workload I had too. It was not just me it was all of the engineers so I am confident it was not a lack of skill. Now I make 200k a year and I find myself working 75 - 90 hours a week and it is terrible. Again, my co workers who have been there longer than me work the same hours so I know it is not a lack of skill on my part. It is just expected, refusing would likely lead to me losing my job. I have no idea if this is the same at all companies as I can only speak from personal experience. It just seems in software that they just require more and more of your life hours. I would love to find a balance of good salary and ~45 hours a week.
- moret1979 6y agoI hope it doesn’t come too hard, but you’re part of the problem by what you describe. You took the bait of more money to trade off focused hours with busy hours productivity. This sets expectations to employers and others around you, and wall off a lot of people who can’t - and shouldn’t - take the same deal. Plus, this mode of heavy workload in hours is usually a signal of low return of value for what is produced in this time, meaning deep work to deliver more value is crowded out.
- wonderwonder 6y agoI don't take it hard at all, but in all fairness its not like they advertised the required hours on the job application. You start a job, its more money than you ever made, you have finally made it and then the hours start to just pour on. I have a family its not like I can just quit so I work and then finally land another job making more money but then somehow the cycle repeats. Sounds like I just have terrible luck to land 2 of these in a row.
- aaronchall 6y agoSome managers will push you to do more until you push back. Perhaps you have to learn to say "No" to things you don't have time for in a regular workday. As Stephen Covey put it in 7 Habits, when asked to do more, pull out your prioritized, filled-out calendar and ask which item they'd like you to deprioritize to take on the new task. Then you'll discover their real priorities.
- rkagerer 6y agoI've always put in whatever it takes to get the job done. I enjoy my work, and take a lot of pride in doing it well and delighting users. The attitude tends to attract more responsibility (which can sometimes mean more work) and leadership opportunities. Both in career settings, and organizations where I volunteer. And I've noticed it can be contagious. e.g. If I'm willing to sit "in the trenches" with a developer on my team to help them solve a nasty bug, they'll often take advantage of the opportunity even if it's after hours once the regular workday has quieted down. I do consulting now, and usually charge by the hour. It's a good arrangement - for my clients because they get as much (or little) of my attention as they need, and for me because I know at least when things get demanding my compensation scales accordingly. Once a CEO dragged me into his office and complained I was the highest "paid" person at the company, including himself. I explained why he was getting incredible value, asked him to point out anyone who put in the same hours and suggested hiring more staff so they didn't need to lean on me as hard. On the other hand, there were times I under-quoted fixed contracts, and ended up effectively netting less than minimum wage. But my work ethic stayed the same throughout. I've noticed backlash on HN lately against people who work long hours. I'm not sure where it comes from. If there are devs here who bought into the vision at a startup which didn't pan out and came away feeling cheated, or if it's plain old laziness or entitlement. I get that people have other priorities in life, and that's just fine. I've worked with 9-5ers who diligently stick to the clock. They're focused on family, other interests, etc. Nothing wrong with that. I know people for whom the job is "just a job", not a passion. That's OK too - although sometimes it makes me sad when I get the sense it's not so much a question of work/life balance as it is they just don't enjoy it and might feel more inspired doing something else. Whatever the impetus, it's no reason to beat up on hard workers who've chosen to make their career a priority.
- drivebycomment 6y ago> I've noticed backlash on HN lately against people who work long hours. I'm not sure where it comes from. My pet theory is that with higher wages and popularity, the fraction of engineers who build stuff for fun have gone down and there's more people who are doing it purely for money. They care less about the "craft", the joy of problem solving and building, and don't see their work as their "calling". Rather, it's purely a means to an end, and they only care about minimal efforts and maximal monetary returns.
- nsonha 6y agowhat is easier: committing to (over) work and let others give us a mission, OR think hard about the meaning of life, work, everything, redefine impacts and productivity to align with your values, while appear to be doing not much? A lot of people also have this thing in which work has actually become their comfort zone and they make no effort to learn hobbies or take more responsibilities out of work. Not saying it's right or wrong, just to them "not working" isn't that easy nor enjoyable.
- Animats 6y agoWhy do people buy into it? Because it's marketed heavily. The US needs to get back to the 8 hour day, the 40 hour work, time and a half for overtime, a living minimum wage, and a union rep to push back when the boss wants to violate that. Unions. The people who brought you the weekend.
- golemiprague 6y agoThe bible brought you the weekend in the form of the Sabbath, the day were people were not allowed to work.
- missedthecue 6y agoAs it happens, Religion brought us the five day work week. Not unions. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/08/where-the-five-day-workweek-came-from/378870/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/08/where-t...
- atlgator 6y agoIf you give an animal random rewords for a task, they will do that task until they die. B.F. Skinner was the unwitting father of modern management.
- anovikov 6y agoFor all the bad things about it, for many jobs, overwork is beneficial because it increases productivity. A programming working on a project 70 hours a week will likely get done 10x more than working 20 hours per week, because he doesn't waste time remembering what he was doing (ofc as long as he's actually coding, not reacting to endless distractors on Slack).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- atlgator 6y agoInflation basically. In the 1950s you could afford a nice middle class lifestyle, own a home, raise multiple children, all on a single income and no college education. When women entered the workforce en masse, everything seemingly doubled in price. Both spouses working to maintain the same lifestyle. When everyone got college degrees, they became required even for jobs like bartending. When everyone got mobile phones and high speed internet, suddenly you're expected to work around the clock and on weekends. All to maintain more or less the same lifestyle, albeit more technologically advanced.
- YZF 6y agoThat wasn't true everywhere though, in the USA in the 1950's it might have been true but in the rest of the world? Whenever I try to think about these large scale systems I end up realizing how difficult it is to predict the outcome. Everything people are buying has to be produced. Everything produced needs people (or automation) producing it. Somewhere there is an equilibrium. What's happening globally has an impact (e.g. we possibly had a better standard of living by taking advantage of places that had a lower standard of living). Competition (and inequality) has an impact because not getting ahead of the game can put you in the bottom rungs where you're really doing badly. In a game where only the top 20% are doing well there is fierce never ending competition to be in that 20%. In a game where everyone has some guaranteed basic standard of living you would expect the competition to be less fierce. Another note is that people used to work crazy hours during the industrial revolution. Similar story there, you had to get some work if you didn't want to be poor, and it was easy for employers to take advantage of employees.
- doktorhladnjak 6y agoThe 1950s were a unique time in the American economy. The rest of the developed world had just come out of WW2 with large portions of its cities, industrial production, and overall economies severely disrupted or outright destroyed. Meanwhile, the US was unscathed and had spent the war further building up its industrial capacity. It was never sustainable, only something possible for a point in time.
- anm89 6y agoSimple, because to some people it is worth it. Everyone else can complain about the situation this imposes but those people have a right to over work themselves. And of course, ON AVERAGE, they are going to make more money and be more successful. So other people try to follow suit because they want the same results. No one is forcing you to overwork. I can promise you there are many many people living on communes all over the world who spend all day doing aerobatic yoga and eating organic quinoa and getting one over on "the man". If you don't like it go and join them.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoBecause people conflate "doing time" with "doing tasks". Largely because listing ALLLL the things, large and small, that gets done in a work day is a hard problem, especially for managers to track. And employees don't really want that level of invasion into their day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- atoav 6y agoFor me it is something else. Most of my career I was working as a feeelancer. And as such my main goal was always to deliver work to a certain (usually comparatively high) standard. That's just the way I like doing things. However as a freelancer I had more or less total control over the amount and kind of jobs I would take on — now that I work in a fixed position this control is somewhat gone (or I have to learn deal with it in a different way). My goal to do work up to my standard stayed, which means there is an inbalance between the amount of work I got to do and the time I have. This also has to do with the quality of my work: Doing things well does take longer, but more importantly if people know you are doing things well a lot of things will get pushed your way.Now I could lower my standard, but in fact I'd rather quit than lower that standard. I probably need to say no more often within the job.
- intellix 6y agoI have a standard 9-6 with an hour break between and then I work on a second company between 6 and midnight every night. Also work all weekends all day long but trying to have a more healthy lifestyle and go out whenever I want. If the work is interesting I'm really excited to solve problems but I definitely don't want to do it all my life. I'm 33yo and just trying to feather my nest. I think I'll always work and never retire but would love to only work maybe 2-4 hours a day on my own terms
- SavantIdiot 6y agoI stayed in a small town outside Chablis, France, many years ago. I rented a room above the only restaurant in town. There were a few businesses, mostly food-related and clothing repair. Everything just seemed slowed down. I watched a man in waders unload a dead boar he had just shot to the butcher at 9am. I watched two other men repairing brickwork on a foundation. I watched another woman tending a large garden, then go to work at a bar/restaurant. The stores were open for just a few hours. The shelves were free of random plastic trinkets and gadgets. It just seemed like it was 1/10th the normal speed, somewhat Luddite... and every task seemed oddly fundamental. I've also encountered towns like this in Spain, Greece, Austria, Mexico, Guatemala, Chile, Uruguay, Thailand and Cambodia. After reading these comments, I would never have believed that so many small towns exist that seem untouched by 24-hour stores and everything cheap and on-demand. It sounds inevitable that everyone is eventually pushed into hyperinflationary always-working mode. But yet, these places persist. I might even chalk it up to depressed economies and "third-world" nature, but my samples include all sorts of economies. I think we choose what kind of lifestyle we want, but it needs to be done at the community level. Without going all "we should all be farmers hippie dippy portland nature fetishist", it does seem like decisions have consequences and it is possible to steer away from hyperactivity.
- runarberg 6y agoIt is funny that you mention Portland there. In my experience Portland is precisely this fast moving town, everything 24/7, with stressed out workers where everything has to be done fast and for profits. Don’t get me wrong, Portland is a nice town and worth the visit. To an extent it is more chill then say Seattle or San Fransisco. If you want a chill town in the West I think Boise, Idaho or Santa Fe, New Mexico, are a better fit. Although I do admit that people don’t generally think of the hippie dippy type when they think of Boise.
- SavantIdiot 6y agoYeah, there is a vibrant tech scene in portland that fits what you say. I like it more than San Fran because I feel like I can fit the whole town in my head, whereas San Fran is a bit overwhelming (too many meetups up there in San Fran!!) But PDX really does have a bubble-headed progressive wing. They voted NOT to put fluoride in the water! Boise is simply too far right. I don't want to live in a light purple zone surrounded by bright-red crazies. I'll prefer the type of crazy that protests for social justice over protesting to keep facism and white supremacy. Yet Portland has great examples of progressives who have their heart in the right place but forget to think critically. New Mexico is collapsing. Outside of ABQ and Santa Fe, it is full of ghost towns. Quite literally boarded up towns between Las Cruces and Roswell. It's a state in decline.
- J253 6y agoI’ve never subscribed to the cult of overwork. In fact, I subscribe to the cult of maximizing my hourly rate. If I receive an salaried offer, the first thing I do is take into account company culture and the amount of guaranteed PTO (can’t stand the whole “flexible” PTO thing—always felt like a great way to peer pressure people into not taking PTO) to try and accurately calculate how many hours I’ll work in a year and then divide my base yearly salary by that. E.g. Job 1: average 40 hrs/week, 30 days PTO, yearly salary $100k Job 2: average 50 hrs/week, “flexible” PTO, yearly salary $130k The maths: Job 1 40(hr/wk) * 52(wk/yr) = 2080(hr/yr) 2080(hr/yr) - 240 hours PTO = 1840 hours worked per year $100k/1840 = $54.35/hr Job 2 “Flexible” PTO is a tough thing to estimate, obviously, but I’ll be generous and assume one takes 20 days. 50(hr/wk) * 52(wk/yr) = 2600(hr/yr) 2600(hr/yr) - 160 hours PTO = 2440 hours worked per year $130k/2440 = $53.28/hr So there ya go. Even with a 30% pay “increase”, overworking yourself as a salaried employee at Job2 ends up earning you less per hour than the salaried position at Job1. Obviously, there are all sorts of fair arguments for what _potential_ benefits you might reap from putting in those extra hours, so it’s entirely personal whether it’s worth it or not to you. Depends on how valuable 600 extra hours per year of free time is to you. For me, it’s Job1 999 times out of 1000.
- edem 6y agoIt is very simple. There is no easier way of getting ahead of other employees than staying longer in the office. It requires no effort. Unfortunately it is a race to the bottom so I employ another strategy. I am the last to enter the office and the first to leave but I try to maximize my effectiveness while I'm there and solve problems a few can so they'll remember me as the guy who comes in solves the problems and goes away making the life of everybody easier.
- tikhonj 6y agoI originally wrote this as a response to some comment, but it applied to multiple different threads, so I figured I'd post it top-level instead: I found a job where I worked remotely and people legitimately cared about what I accomplished over weeks and months without even seeing how long I worked each day. I took full advantage and worked weird but not particularly long hours. Counterintuitively, this helped me do more: I wrote maintainable code with fewer bugs, so, once I had a solid foundation, I could do experiments and add new business logic fast. Based on code I've seen on other projects, it's not hard to imagine a different codebase doing the same thing where a one-day feature in my world would have been a two-week feature instead. Now I'm sure you're thinking to yourself that I'm exaggerating, but I've absolutely seen teams and projects with this kind of productivity delta. It's always hard to convince people about counterfactuals, but in software "slow is smooth and smooth is fast" is absolutely true. If you take your time and avoid unnecessary deadline pressure up-front, you will average substantially less time on new logic and debugging. The difficulty, of course, is that when you do this right it looks like you're solving easy problems while the team that coded themselves into a corner and constantly have to fight fires look like heroes burning the midnight oil. (There's the cult of overwork again!) It helped that I ended up contrasted with somebody who took on a lot of responsibility only to strew overcomplicated garbage across multiple parts of our codebase. The rest of the team took a depressingly long time to recognize the problem, but it eventually wasted too much of everyone's time to ignore. I am not sure that anything short of a painfully tangible demonstration in this vein would convince people without direct experience that the dynamic I'm talking about is real and important! Anyway, working reasonable hours actively helped me do better work and I am convinced this is true for most software work and most people. As a bonus, it worked out pretty well for me, I got promoted. I still have reasonable hours but the work is now far more people-oriented which means my impact, if anything, is even less related to my hours! What I'm realizing is that if you're a manager and you want to build a resilient and productive team, you actively do not want your ≈staff engineers and data scientists working anything that even resembles long hours! But that's a post for another day... The moral of the story is that it's possible to find teams which legitimately care about output rather than input, which will let you have a solid salary with great hours. Unfortunately I still have no idea how to evaluate teams on this axis as a job candidate; I just got really lucky stumbling into this particular job. I'm not sure how to reproduce that for future roles (always looking for suggestions!), but at least it's nice to know that such teams do exist.
- papito 6y agoSix-day work week was standard like, what, 100 years ago? Now it just seems savage. And so will the five-day work week. I had the luck of getting a four month severance when a company closed, full salary, full benefits. I lined up a new job and just said I will start later. Let me tell you, going back into a tech job, 10 to 6-ish PM every day was no joke, after three months of not giving a fuck. It was torture. I could not understand how I did it until then. And there was that painful realization of "what am I doing here for eight hours a day? I am clearly not using all of it. Give me four hours and I will do the same amount of work and go live my life". And that's when I knew that I am not going to be the guy on his deathbed, realizing that he worked too hard and didn't live, after winning the cosmic lottery of being born on such a rare place as planet Earth.
- californical 6y agoTaking a month off of work (in between jobs) to travel and explore is what got me into the whole FIRE thing — similar ideas to you
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI wanted to take a month off work between jobs last time, but the new employer was desperate for someone to pick up some maintenance work so it ended up being a 1 day/week thing. Not quite the same. Plus it was December and I have a family now so traveling or doing something silly wasn't an option unfortunately. Did finish a big lego piece though.
- johncozen 6y agoTell me you live in a van without telling me you live in a van…but seriously congratulations or finding your passion.
- porker 6y ago> Let me tell you, going back into a tech job, 10 to 6-ish PM every day was no joke, after three months of not giving a fuck. It was torture. As a consultant, after a _very_ quiet year due to covid (I had travel and entertainment clients - yay me), I am finding the same. I have zero drive to go out and win business. I don't want to spend days building software to enrich the bosses and "streamline operations" so they don't have to re-hire the staff they laid off. Or work long days. Or have to kiss ass. It can't last because the money won't, but a break from work has challenged me.
- stunt 6y agoPerhaps partly because we use marketing tactics to make people feel desperate for having all things that they actually don't need in their life. People have so much to give to have them.
- teekert 6y agoWho is "we"? I don't know anybody that buys into this. In fact, I applied for a job at ASML once and they give me a case: Suppose you notice you can't finish all your work by the deadline next week, what do you do? I say: "Well, I don't mind spending some nights working if stuff really needs to be done." Wrong! Go to your project leader and tell him the things you could finish and which ones he wants you to focus on. We don't want burnt-out employees. The large healthcare company I work for now has the same attitude. I get weekly emails telling me to go for a walk daily, or about how management employees separate work and life during these challenging times. I don't know anyone glorifying this lifestyle.
- rocgf 6y agoI have learned about the perils of overworking the hard way - burnout after about 2 years of working too much. I've since learned to be more tempered. However, maybe I am missing something in most of the comments in here. Everybody seems to agree with the article and against working longer hours. However, how are you supposed to 'get ahead' if not by working longer and/or harder than your peers? There is obviously a balance here, but knowledge and, implicitly, higher income doesn't just happen. If you don't push harder, you won't get more. And I honestly don't think I can ever be satisfied with any given salary in perpetuity.
- adamhp 6y agoAnd this is really the heart of why capitalism is truly evil. You're stuck on a treadmill that adjusts as soon as you get comfortable. There are rows and rows of your peers next to you, and you see them running a bit faster, so you press the button to go faster so you don't look "slower" than them. It is built-in from the primate days of fighting for literal survival. You can't let them win or you'll starve and die. If you're a well-paid SWE, you're probably in the top 1% of the world: eating anything you want, living happily, likely without debt (or could easily pay it off). And here you are thinking you still need more, and thinking you'll never be happy with it.
- nickd2001 6y agoSo, don't play the game! My formula = (1) live in slightly cheaper neighbourhood. Your kids will be at school with a healthy diversity of people. (2) If you drive, something uncool / old-but-reliable. That's 2 big costs reduced. Then, develop and nurture a long-shelf-life vendor-independent skillset e:g Linux, command-line, python which'll always be in demand. If your employer then demands crazy hours, easier to walk away. Less well-paid university or gov't jobs may be the answer. BTW there's a conflict in the treadmill argument. Companies that push harder and harder will eventually fail if important people burn out. I worked in the USA for a bit. Sometimes I blatantly left earlier than my colleagues. Cos the mountains beckoned. Possibly annoyed some management. Didn't get fired though. Cos had good skills! Good luck don't let The Man win. ;)
- herbst 6y agoLast time I had a regular job the 32 hours per week already felt way to much. It may comes from my burnout in the past but I really do not understand why so many people who would have the choice opt for working more than less. I don't think enjoying life when old (fire or rich pension plans) is a good plan either as it's not that likely to even get there without serious health issues (statistics, not because I'm unhealthy) and my today's money is worth nothing then when I would need it. Working little but smart, don't be wasteful with your money and invest smart is kinda what I try doing.
- jpttsn 6y agoI guess I don’t get it. What is it you want to do instead of working? Suppose I can produce the required output in less time (say 20h per week) because I’m just so smart. Then why would I spend the other 20h just watching TV? Why not produce up to twice the output by working 40h? If your answer is “I get paid the same regardless of my output,”then that’s the wrong terms for so smart a person. Employment is for those who (unlike you) aren’t confident about their output capacity and have to resort to selling their input capacity. If your answer is “I don’t need that much money” then I guess the counter is “I don’t need that much recreation”.
- langitbiru 6y agoEntrepreneurship, taking care your parents, raising kids, passion (writing novels), working out, and so on.
- soneca 6y agoYou lack a lot of imagination if you think that the only thing someone would do with an extra 20 hours a week is watching TV.
- jpttsn 6y agoI don’t judge, but I rarely met anyone who spends their extra 20h on anything good. It’s mostly: - TV/video games/Facebook - drinking/drugs/gluttony whether as thrill-seeking or sedatives - a creative “hobby” (i.e. another job that they’re not good at) - “traveling” (larping to farm for Instagram validation) I just find it more interesting to pursue my actual trade. Of course we all need some amount of rest to stay sharp, but excesses of leisure never seem to produce much, not even happiness. YMMV.
- soneca 6y agoWhen you say that hobby is ”another job they’re not good at” you are obviously judging them. Most of your examples are dripping with judgment. I am not sure why you even bothered to start your comment with ”I don’t judge, but...” When you say ”I don’t get it...”, my interpretation is that you lack empathy toward people that face life differently from you. Not that is any sort of puzzling behavior, it’s just you failing to make an effort to understand other people.
- vallas 6y agoNo retirement was the standard 100 years ago I think.
- vallas 6y agoRetirement was not even a thing 100 years ago, I think.
- ElectricMind 6y agoReminds of the great Thanos quote by seeing very opposing views in the comments below “As long as there are those that remember what was, there will always be those that are unable to accept what can be.” (Avengers: Endgame, 2019) Solution? Same need to reduce everything till last atom and start again..
- danielam 6y agoWhy? The answer is ultimately spiritual and cultural (note the shared etymology of "culture"[0], "cult"[1] and "cultivate"[2]). The article does point to the consumerist ethos as a factor. This is true. Consumerism is a vicious and degrading religion. But what drives consumerism is a fundamental restlessness and malaise characteristic of modernity that stands behind both work-for-work's-sake—the world of "total work"—and the pursuit of the myriad empty recreations on offer. Both are forms of escape and marks of a diseased soul. You can't fix the problem simply by reforming workplace practices alone, though that could, of course, help because it would at least create the space needed to pursue leisure. But by simply bandaging the symptoms, we avoid trying to determine the root cause. We persist in the same pathological condition. Truncate work in the absence of leisure and that space will be filled with either some other work or more recreation. (N.b. I recommend Josef Pieper's "Leisure: The Basis of Culture"[3] if you want to understand what leisure is and how it differs from recreation.) [0] https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=culture https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=culture [1] https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=cult https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=cult [2] https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=cult https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=cult [3] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/767958.Leisure https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/767958.Leisure
- 734129837261 6y agoI work 4 hours a day, 4 days a week, and I worked as a senior software engineer for Apple doing exactly this, successfully so. Most companies I've worked for (and I select them based on this) don't hold people to 8-hour work days and 5 day work weeks. Those kind of hours are ridiculous and everybody knows it; nobody (in my field) can be productive 8 hours a day. Ever since I switched from 8h/day 5d/week to 4h/day 4d/week I'm far more productive than I've ever been. Hard focus for 4 hours is way more efficient than fucking around for 8 hours a day. In software engineering that's also where the worst bugs appear, out of annoyed/tired/overworked brains. Now I work freelance and I let my clients know that I'll work my own hours, but I get shit done. So far, so good.
- ladyattis 6y agoI don't know if people are working that much more or are just being forced to sit at their desk or in meetings just to satisfy the myth of productivity. Like for my current job, I work 8-4 since my lunch is a paid benefit. Even then I don't have that much on my plate mostly because I'm waiting on others to answer my messages on Teams for business edge cases with code or database changes. Aside from that, there will be times where even in new development I'm just puzzling over an edge case before tapping someone on it to ensure I have the problem fully understood to me (no point in nagging people who wouldn't know much better). I think it's a bit of a and b (a being some people are definitely overworked, and b being some of us are just pretending to work to just make the numbers look good to our employers even when we've already got the work done and just could do something else like skill training or take a short day).
- steelframe 6y agoI had a (relatively) brief stint as an engineering manager a couple of years ago. I prioritized individual well-being and sustainability above pretty much everything else. I never pushed the team into "crunch time." I repeatedly emphasized balance and stride in work patterns. I thought, "We're in an obscenely wealthy industry. We can comfortably trade off some money for time and be just fine." Boy did I misjudge the general insanity of MORE MORE MORE FASTER FASTER FASTER all around me. If my team didn't deliver 'X' by 'Y' (for some 'Y' that wasn't obtainable without overworking my team) the entire management chain above me was flipping their shit. There were sales and PM shooting daggers at me out of their eyes as I explained that our plan requires 6 months to execute with excellence, including thorough testing and having the right metrics in place. I had one PM flat-out say that his own promotion was on the line if we didn't go balls-to-the-wall on the project and cut whatever corners we could, but there was absolutely no external force that required us to shave 45 days off the schedule. These were enterprise contracts in a huge industry with mountains of leeway on what we delivered and when. My team did deliver, and we did a fine job of it, but the entire thing helped convince me that engineering management just isn't for me if I am not allowed to work at my own pace and prioritize the things that are important to me, such as delighting customers and building reliable systems. I left that job to be an IC again, and I'm back to working reasonable hours and really taking the time to do the sort of "deep work" with a refreshed mind that I need to do in order to come up with good ideas and durable systems. I'm not going to make as much money as quickly as I would have if I were willing to overwork myself and my team, but in the end, I take Joseph Campbell's philosophy on career ambitions. "It's not worth it."