18 ms·
How Tech Loses Out
- tremon 6y agoActual title: How Tech Loses Out [..] What a difference those three letters make. But do read the article, it's a worthwhile read.
- mulmen 6y agoLoses out over what? Even with “how” it’s nonsensical.
- TiredGuy 6y agoI was initially confused about this too. The title of the corresponding video of the article replaces "over at" with "in", which is much clearer. In other words, it's not "over" anything it's "over (there) at" the specified places.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> How Tech Loses Out over at Companies, Countries and Continents > How technology loses out in companies, countries & continents > How Tech Loses Out None of these titles are understandable to me. How can it be so hard to give something a simple, intelligible, and coherent title? Or maybe I'm the idiot.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe missing implicit bits and technical conflations are probably what are throwing you. "Technology" really means technical understanding and resulting quality as opposed to use. Even the crappy ones still use tech that they outsource but poorly. Losing out means in the context of matters of popularity. It is losing out in the same way Semmelweiss did in his lifetime over "doctors should wash their hands".
- jbverschoor 6y agoTech is a cost center and not considered core business, even for telecommunications companies. But especially in the Netherlands. This is why it’s being outsourced. This is why they won’t pay engineers what they deserve. All ready to be swept away but any real tech or mega Corp.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> All ready to be swept away but any real tech or mega Corp. Regulations around the spectrum and the concept of auctions make it impossible for any new player to enter the market. Spectrum and radio equipment should be owned by the government and communication providers can just buy bandwidth/airtime on it at a fair price. That works successfully for things like the power grid, water/gas distribution infrastructure, etc.
- jsnell 6y agoWhile it's easy to nod along to the thesis of the article, I don't know that I agree with the examples. Is the suggestion is that European business has been hollowed out to being nothing except a sales channel for imports really true? As far as I can see, manufacturing has been steadily increasing in the EU for basically at least 30 years, with the exceptions of two one-off events (2008 financial crisis, Covid). Likewise for exports. And when it comes to telcos, why in the world would we want them writing their own tech? Very few of them have sufficient scale to make building their own basic infrastructure sensible. All they could plausibly be writing is value added services that nobody actually wants, rather than being dumb pipes. (I do think telcos shouldn't outsource their network operations as a whole. Outsourcing individual commodity functions like DNS seems kind of reasonable though.)
- ipython 6y agoTelcos have historically written some very successful technology. Unix from bell labs, Erlang from Ericsson to name two examples.
- makapuf 6y agoWell telcos did led the pack worldwide regarding networking and mobile coms (GSM started as a French acronym), as said Unix, c and c++, many mobile concepts and services before Apple and Google replaced those.
- jsnell 6y agoFirst, Unix and Erlang are not good examples here. They were more like tiny research projects that escaped the lab. No particular economies of scale needed. In comparison to that, te technical artifacts these companies were actually aiming to produce (e.g. networking equipment) had hundreds of times more people working on them. Second, Ericsson is not a telco, they're a supplier. Exactly the kind of entity that can achieve economics of scale on building say a mobile gateway router or a billing system, by building one that can be used by a hundred telcos, not just one. Vertical integration did make more sense for the AT&T of old. The market didn't yet exist, or wasn't standardized enough, for them to be able to depend on that.
- jasode 6y ago>If you separate the thinking about things from the doing of things, then innovation will suffer. I found the author's framework incomplete and not useful. For example, he didn't include any counterexamples. E.g. why is Intel with both in-house chip architecture design capability _and_ chip fabrication factories falling behind in innovation to competitors using the outsource model? - NVIDIA gpu + outsourcer TSMC is ahead of Intel at hardware for machine learning - Apple M1 chip + outsourcer TSMC beats x86 for laptop performance - AMD Neoverse chip + outsourcer TSMC bests Intel for many server workloads But that doesn't mean those companies outsource everything. E.g. Apple doesn't outsource the programming of iOS and macOS to outside consultants at Accenture or Thoughtworks. They do that in house. But Apple programmers don't write their own financial back office software. Instead, they use Germany's SAP ERP enterprise system. Likewise, none of SAP employees design and make smartphones for staff to use; they let Apple and Samsung manufacture the phones. Being strategic about outsourcing is a natural consequence of recognizing that other entities specializing in a competency can do it better/faster/cheaper. How did NASA "innovate" and send astronauts to the moon? They outsourced the work. E.g. The manufacture of space suits was contracted out to ladies bra manufacturer Playtex. The Apollo rockets were made by a combination of companies. NASA was the ultimate outsourcer.
- carlmr 6y agoHe did get into that, that sometimes it's smart to outsource, the example was the fuse on the toaster. But you need to build something, you need to have some core competence where you can innovate because you build.
- jasode 6y ago>He did get into that, that sometimes it's smart to outsource, the example was the fuse on the toaster. The counterexamples I was looking for were companies that didn't fit his thesis instead of a small part like a fuse being outsourced. The author Bert Hubert keeps emphasizing "making" in addition to the thinking. So a design(thinking) company like NVIDIA doesn't seem to follow his ideal of how an "innovative" company is structured. And another counterexample like Apple in the 1970s used to in-house assemble computers and box them for shipping. That was all outsourced decades ago to China and yet Apple got more innovative with the 2007 iPhone.
- mcguire 6y agoI started reading the article and immediately had a question... "This is a transcript of my presentation over at the European Microwave Week 2020, actually held in 2021." What's a European Microwave Week? Well, it's a conference put on by the European Microwave Association. "The European Microwave Association (EuMA) is an international non-profit association with a scientific, educational and technical purpose. The aim of the Association is to develop in an interdisciplinary way, education, training and research activities." Ok. "The European Microwave Association (EuMA) is an international non-profit association with a scientific, educational and technical purpose. The aim of the Association is to develop in an interdisciplinary way, education, training and research activities, including: "Promoting European microwaves "Networking and uniting microwave scientists and engineers in Europe "Providing a single voice for European microwave scientists and engineers in Europe "Promoting public awareness and appreciation of microwaves "Attaining full recognition of microwaves by the European Union..." So, uh, how far down this rabbit-hole do I have to go to find a meaningful term... "EuCoM 2020 Events: "GPR and Electromagnetics for Sensing Soil, Objects and Structures: Forward Modelling, Inversion Problems and Practical Aspects" - Lecce, Italy, January 29 - February 01, 2020 - Org.:R. Persico et al." Whew. [Edit] I wrote the comments above before I read the article. Now that I have read it, I came to an epiphany: *It's exactly what he is talking about!* EuMA doesn't do microwave things. It's an organization about microwave stuff, but what they do has nothing to do with microwaves. The schedule things, they write contracts for venues and catering, and they send press releases of various kinds. Wouldn't it have been slightly refreshing if EuMA's web site was written by someone who actually knew something about microwaves? Someone who could spice things up with meaningful examples? Even a little? Anyway, there are some issues with the article itself. "And we fight for all technology, even the stuff that is not core because we are attached to it, we love what we do." What is core, and what is not? And after you've eliminated everything that is clearly not core, what is clearly not core among the remaining things you have left? If you've outsourced the springs, knobs, cords, and cases then those start looking an awful lot like something else you should get from outside. Especially since your manufacturing facility is now just running one shift a day. Or a week. At the end of the article, he mentions, "JPL at Caltech in the US", which is an interesting (and appropriate) phrase. If you follow the Mars rovers or any of NASA's other unmanned exploration missions, you'll see JPL mentioned a lot. NASA is very proud of JPL. Which is a little strange since JPL and NASA are only loosely related. "JPL is a research and development lab federally funded by NASA and managed by Caltech", as their web site says. The launch vehicle, by the way, was a commercial United Launch Alliance Delta II. (Not that I'm bitter in any way.)
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThis is an excellent read. Because it was written as a presentation, it’s quite readable. I like the toaster example. It reminds me of this: http://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/TheParableOfTheToaster.html http://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/TheParableOfTheToaster.html He mentions the Dreamliner. That project is kind of a poster child for how not to do stuff, but I suspect that many of the problems came about as a result of cultural hysteresis. The engineers and managers were good, but inexperienced in development of such a loosely-coupled project. I agree with the premise of the talk. In the US, we are facing the same issue with manufacturing. It’s actually impossible to do some types of manufacturing in the US. We’ve crossed the Rubicon. Alea jacta est.
- 1cvmask 6y agoMinor correction. It is a “i” and not a “j”. Julius Caesar said “Alea iacta est” when crossing the Rubicon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alea_iacta_est https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alea_iacta_est Although there is the WarCry album with the “j”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alea_Jacta_Est https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alea_Jacta_Est
- chriscool 6y agoOn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_alphabet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_alphabet you can see: "It was not until the Middle Ages that the letter ⟨W⟩ (originally a ligature of two ⟨V⟩s) was added to the Latin alphabet, to represent sounds from the Germanic languages which did not exist in medieval Latin, and only after the Renaissance did the convention of treating ⟨I⟩ and ⟨U⟩ as vowels, and ⟨J⟩ and ⟨V⟩ as consonants, become established. Prior to that, the former had been merely allographs of the latter." So at Julius Caesar's time, I and J were the same letter that you could write either way.
- Radim 6y ago> It is a “i” and not a “j”. **J**ulius Caesar said … Why not "Iulius Caesar", for consistency? :-) In any case, English may not be the right language to bicker about spelling and pronunciation in. It sports one of the most idiosyncratic orthographic systems in existence. English also has a long history of butchering names, words and sounds, including its own (e.g. the Great Vowel Shift [0]). Iulius vs Julius is the least of its worries. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift
- Scene_Cast2 6y agoI agree with the observation of how things are (high on outsourcing, low on tech & talent). I do disagree with how things got there. In a competitive market, when you outsource, you get immediate costs savings. If your competitor outsourced more things than you have, you'll be at a financial disadvantage for some amount of time before the "innovation debt" catches up. That can be decades - the quality of the outsourced parts can remain equivalent or superior for quite a while (or even perpetually, in case of fuses). A similar thing happens with companies that do actually want to innovate. All of them are spending all available resources competing with each other, that the R&D for big tech projects simply cannot happen without external intervention or external funding. Historically, none of the well-staffed and well-funded research labs have been funded by companies whose products are a commodity.
- kingsuper20 6y ago>In a competitive market, when you outsource, you get immediate costs savings. That's a good point. In addition, there's the (mostly) inevitable tendency for economies of scale to push for outsourcing. Several companies I've worked for shut down their board shops while I was there, there's just no way to practically keep up with that. Fabs got bigger. Specialty sheet metal shops can pound out the work faster than you can. One related thing I've noticed is that older companies (dunno about places that make exclusively software) are never well equipped to deal with perpetually cheaper products with smaller margins. As a side note, I suspect that the real magic in making toasters, if all done in-house and using simple inputs, is to design the manufacturing facility. The toaster itself is relatively simple. The Rouge must really have been something.
- genericone 6y agoWell for those reasons and more, every consumer hardware is about design for manufacturability these days. If you cant get the manufacturing right, scaling doesn't happen. Redesign will be costly or impossible without having those design methodologies front and center at the start. If your design is only possible with CNC, then say goodbye to the larger market.
- choxi 6y agoThis explains the stagnation in the airline industry pretty well. They don't make the planes so there isn't a lot they can change about the in-flight experience, and they don't run the airports so there isn't much they can do about the onboarding experience. There's a Planet Money episode where they talk about an airline that made more money selling oil futures than flying planes.[1] Maybe any sufficiently outsourced company becomes indistinguishable from a finance company. 1. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/140954343 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/140954343
- novok 6y agoThe stagnation of experience is totally a choice made by humans. We could let it be like boarding a shinkansen in japan, where your mom can hug you at the fare gate, you can bring bottled water and you don't have to take off your shoes or anything out of your bags, but we chose not to. We could do CGP grey style boarding, but we do not: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3e5Jn2gG8Eg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3e5Jn2gG8Eg
- Clubber 6y agoOur process does 3 things: 1. Fools enough people to think the government has their shit together and is protecting people. 2. Surveillance. 3. Make work jobs program. The whole shoe thing is because of Richard Reid, the shoe bomber. There was a later foiled "underwear bomber," I'm glad the government didn't have the same reaction to him as they did Richard Reid. Actually now that I think about it, they have full body scanners. I haven't been on a plane since probably 2006.
- clairity 6y agowe’ve collectively chosen to let financialization ruin societies by allowing money to be the only viable yardstick of worth and value. unconstrained capitalism reduces this way through its natural instabilities, and not without unintended (and intended) consequences. it can only foster better society if we level the playing field and rigorously ensure competition.
- 6y ago
- Fordec 6y agoAt the core of it, the very core of it, tech is waged work. Just like in manufacturing, which was outsourced quite prolifically. Tech isn't special in this regard. The thing that hasn't come about yet though is, sales, marketing, accounting can also be outsourced. Dare I say automated. It is at the end of the day, still waged work. Marketing is not an asset class. Accounting isn't capital ownership. Fabrication is a tool, tech is a tool, social media is a tool. The moment that this sort of stuff gets automated there will be a reckoning on how businesses are built in western society. I don't mean a saleforce competitor with a slicker UI, I mean completely abstracting away payroll and the like. Imagine for a moment: You could say to anyone, "I like the work you do want to work for me?" either in person, online, even here. They say yes. Now suddenly a pipeline process kicks off, like a CICD for recruitment. You have your budget metrics all in place, the receiver has their negotiation asks, etc. And AI hashes out a negotiation, in browser or on your phones etc. comes up with a negotiation contract, highlights the important bits or deal breakers that need a higher level sign off. "Click 'Yes' to work." Done. Hired. Here's your onboarding package and account credentials, your paycheck comes in at the end of the month. All the while, the two people at the table or on twitter have just been continuing on with their lives. Nobody talked to HR. Nobody had to manually do filings with the IRS. The business owner never opened a dashboard or logged in to their negotiation.ai account. It is not this easy at the moment. But no rule of physics says it can't be in the future. Entire classes of work could crumble while people could create in a much more competitive manner.
- novok 6y agoSo you mean, how work was done before the modern nation state, income tax, passports, visas and mass literacy? All of the work you describe was created by human bureaucracies for human bureaucracies. Beforehand you didn't need the paperwork.
- Fordec 6y agoThe difference being, before there was no paperwork, at all. In such an automated system, the checks, balances and oversight all still exist. They're just invisible to the human eye rather than libertarian style just gone.
- DavidVoid 6y ago> We barely develop any software here anymore. So even very European companies like like Nokia and Ericsson, that are now trying to tell us that they are building our European telecommunication infrastructure. They’re actually not, they’re getting that built by other people in other countries far away. Anything having to do with server and PC development and manufacturing, there’s nothing left of that in Europe anymore. This is quite an exaggeration, if not actually an outright lie. Ericsson's main hub for radio software development is in Kista, and there are some 3000 developers in Croatia as well. Some of Ericsson's radios do have their software developed exclusively in China (to my knowledge at least), and there are also a decent amount of developers in Ottawa, but to claim that all of Ericsson's software is "built in countries far away" is highly misleading imo. The 13,000+ Ericsson employees here in Sweden aren't just sitting around doing nothing.
- mncharity 6y ago> This is quite an exaggeration, if not actually an outright lie Or alternately, poor editing? Without the "So", the "software" sentence binds to the previous paragraph, becoming about apps and enterprise software. And the Ericsson sentence binds to the hardware sentence, becoming about telecom hardware manufacturing. Both unremarkable.
- belgesel 6y agoThe guy has an article discussing 5G Telco business. 5G: The outsourced elephant in the room - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/5g-elephant-in-the-room/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/5g-elephant-in-the-room/ And also HN Discussion - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26843068 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26843068
- DavidVoid 6y agoThat was a fairly interesting article, thank you for linking it. The parts about vendors having a great deal of insight into the networks is certainly true from my experience. For example: I -- an outsourced software developer working for Ericsson here in Europe -- have insight into what software/hardware is deployed in Verizon and AT&T's networks in North America, as well as which of their nodes/radio units are having issues due to software/hardware problems. Now Ericsson doesn't run and operate Verizon and AT&T's infrastructure, but Ericsson does have a great deal of insight into it via proactive log collection and similar initiatives. If one of Verizon's radio units in Texas is having a lot of problems, then a software developer in Croatia might end up analyzing some log/crash dumps from it to see what's wrong with it, and then tell someone at Ericsson in Canada to tell Verizon that the unit should probably be replaced.
- spiritplumber 6y agoI enjoy selling people things that I've written the firmware for and that I've done at least a bit of the manufacturing on. It helps me to think of my customers as real people, even if it's just someone who bought my thing on Amazon. I don't get how people who don't feel that way work. I'm sure they do, and good for them, but I can't really grok how they work.
- sudopluto 6y agothis author also has a really good series on how to use a subset of C++ as a "better c"
- lioeters 6y agoThe series: Modern C++ for C Programmers Introduction - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-intro/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-intro/ Part 1 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/c++-1/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/c++-1/ Part 2 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-2/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-2/ Part 3 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-3/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-3/ Part 4 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-4/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-4/ Part 5 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-5/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-5/ Part 6 - https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-6/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/cpp-6/
- imgabe 6y agoThere's a part in the Foundation series by Asimov where the Galactic civilization has forgotten how their technology works. They have all this amazing technology, things that generate free energy and terraform planets or whatever, and all that's left are technicians who kind of know that if you push this button that thing is supposed to happen, but they have no idea what the machine is actually doing internally or the physical principles on which it operates. When the machines break, no one is able to fix them. I think about this a lot and the world seems more and more like this every day.
- TrackerFF 6y agoThere are certainly places in the world, today, where machines from the 60s-70s-80s are running critical processes, and all the original people involved in design and implementation are either dead or retired - so you're stuck with technicians that only have repair manuals, along with spare parts of everything. Bespoke, one-of-a-kind circuits / machines / etc.
- solipsism 6y agoEven if that's true, those are exceptional examples. They're rare. So why should we care?
- cinntaile 6y agoOld IBM mainframes in banks and government institutions aren't that rare I think. But I don't have any numbers to back this up.
- inter_netuser 6y agonot rare at all. COBOL still runs the world, despite what many on this board think.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoCOBOL is rare outside the USA and Western Europe, I'm pretty sure.
- wrnr 6y agoSad as it may be, I think it is foolish to resist the commodification of technology. I've disassembled my broken washing machine and found I can find a replacement for most constituant parts. How would you event improve on such a thing, why would you want to do that? I think we better embrace this evolution and move ahead with the right-to-repair legislation.
- andrewflnr 6y agoThey're not kidding about that Boeing document they linked. It's a pretty short, clear read. You should read it.
- pas 6y agoCould you provide a tl;dr? What does its title mean?
- mathattack 6y agoIf as a company you have outsourced too much. No good engineer will still want to work for your company. This is the root of the article. The bell companies got so bad at technology (in part due to outsourcing to every consultant on the planet) that they can’t hire smart engineers. There are lessons to broader companies too. How many large non-tech corporates learned this the hard way? And in an ironic twist, it appears that IBM (the outsourcer) can’t hire engineers on their own either, so they have to buy the RedHats and Turbonomics of the world.
- mncharity 6y agoFrom DoD "2020 Industrial Capabilities Report to Congress"[1] page 9: > issues confronting our defense industrial base [...] first has been the steady deindustrialization of the United States over the past five decades, including workforce and manufacturing innovation [...] While total manufacturing output has grown during this period, [...] the workforce on which a defense industrial renaissance would depend has become [...] an endangered species. > Together, a U.S. business climate that has favored short-term shareholder earnings (versus long-term capital investment), deindustrialization, and an abstract, radical vision of “free trade,” without fair trade enforcement, have severely damaged America’s ability to arm itself today and in the future. Our national responses – off-shoring and out-sourcing – have been inadequate and ultimately self-defeating, especially with respect to the defense industrial base. > These trends have had particular impact on the core element of a successful manufacturing economy: the machine tool industry. Of the world’s top twenty-one machine-tool makers, only two today are American: Gleason and Haas Automation. By contrast, eight are based in Japan, and six in Germany. [...] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26219118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26219118
- throwawaygh 6y ago> DoD report to Congress Reader beware. Reports to Congress are highly politicized -- both the Department itself and various bureaucrats within are kissing the ring in hopes of protecting/increasing funding. You can safely expect these reports to mention climate change, green energy, diversity, etc. much more often for the next four years. And guess what? The best office politicians serving life terms in the DoD will make sure those reports direct funds in ways that benefit their priorities. POTUS in 2020 was protectionist, so DoD tells a story about how they and their private sector allies need money and tell it in a way that aligns with that protectionism. The main thesis about why money is needed matches the biases of the person with the pulpit, and then the report helpfully suggests exactly how to achieve that goal that we all of course agree should be the goal. In 2020, onshoring manufacturing. In 2021, maybe still onshoring but maybe play up the whole climate thing a lot more. "Caveat Emptor" is merely a warning, not necessarily an indict of the product. Reader beware.
- 6y ago
- mik09 6y agoi think it's hegel that said 'through work, the slave becomes the master'. shocked to find this true in the modern corporate world. nice article.
- bawolff 6y agoI feel like this misses the elephant in the room. Telecommunication is a pretty mature field. Phones aren't changing very much. I think its obvious that a company in an immature field will innovate a lot, there's a lot of low hanging fruit. In a mature field its a waste of $$$. Everything the author said could still be true, i just think the cause is a lot more intentional and non mysterious. Of course the company that sells tech that has been commiditized will be noninnovative. Why wouldn't they be?
- Nextgrid 6y agoThere are other commoditized products out there that provide much better customer experience and reliability. The other day my internet connection went down and I needed to use 4G as a backup. In 2021, in the age of Amazon, Uber and cloud computing, where you can pay to get pretty much any product/service delivered on the same day, I couldn't get uninterrupted mobile internet from any of the carriers here no matter how much I was willing to pay. I had to work around some stupid billing systems and artificial constraints, and sit through minutes of pre-recorded marketing bullshit just to be able to pay them money. They seemed to be more interested in marketing irrelevant crap to me than actually taking my money and giving me the one thing I wanted and was happy to pay big bucks for: internet access. In the end I couldn't find anything better than topping up 30 bucks at a time and resetting the "bundle" every couple days when the data runs out. There was no way to just tell their system "here's 300 bucks, give me data until this runs out". Telecommunications is fucked.
- ImPostingOnHN 6y agoA field becomes "mature" when the innovation begins to stop, versus vice versa.
- dasudasu 6y agoAs an "expert" in telecom, he should really know better. Nobody is under the illusion that regional telecom companies are some sort of tech hubs. Of course they're not. They don't have the economies of scale -- unless they become a gigantic monopoly such as AT&T and then get broken up anyway. Or, in the case of AT&T again, if they just helped create an entirely new industry so that they have to build everything themselves because there is nobody else to do it anyway. But this is just a historical curiosity. The telecom industry is obviously not in this state today. What incentives does a small, geographically limited service provider has to spend so much on R&D? So that they can get try to make awkward licensing deals for their awesome tech if they strike gold and get to be the first to develop 5G? This makes very little sense. Telecom equipment vendors are an actual thing. They're just not that well known to public. For the optical backbone, you have the likes of Ciena, Juniper, Infinera, ADVA, etc. (More well-known Nokia and Cisco are also heavy players there.) These companies are all system integrators themselves, and have their own degree of vertical integration. There are component vendors which specialize even more, although they are increasingly getting gobbled up through consolidation in the sector. This is partly because people figured that it makes little sense to develop the same transceivers or modems at 10 different companies when you can instead merge them and combine the R&D budgets, patents, and manufacturing know-how. This is the same reason we don't have 20 CPU manufacturers. This is advanced stuff with high R&D costs. His argument seems to be that it'd be nice to just have more people work in this field at regional telecom companies, because then some areas like parts of Europe wouldn't be deprived of a tech sector. The reality is that we don't need a very large workforce to develop the most high-end stuff, and tech, especially the high-end non-consumer grade variety, really is a winner-takes-all market when it comes down to it. There is nothing preventing a big telecom service providers from buying any of these system vendors. That would also be very expensive and subject to heavy regulatory scrutiny to ensure proper competition in the market (buying a system vendor and then blocking the sales or price gouging your competitors being a big no-no). But there again people figured out in the 80s and 90s that conglomerates are actually less, not more efficient. Everyone is better off specializing in their own thing. The tech inclined people end up joining those companies instead, and that's really for the best. Is he really arguing that innovation and tech doesn't exist in the field? Where does he think it comes from? Some unnamed office in Shenzhen? Besides Huawei or ZTE, not really.
- dusted 6y agoAbout that toaster.. The one without the microchip is the better one, if only for not needing a god.damn microchip. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1OfxlSG6q5Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1OfxlSG6q5Y
- mkl 6y agoI dunno, that one seems like it would be quite fussy about the type of bread, and you don't have much control. It also toasts the two sides unevenly, and gets very hot on the outside. I prefer my modern one: - At any point you can lift it up to see how done it is, and drop it back down. - If you're toasting frozen bread, you push the lever down and press the "Frozen" button. - If it pops up too soon for you, you push the lever down and press the "A little bit more" button. - If you're toasting fruit loaf, you press that button. - The outside stays touchably cool. A combination of the bread-temperature-sensing (assuming that's not what my one does) and the more modern features might be even better.
- 01100011 6y agoI remain unconvinced that a company who outsources production does not add value or perform useful engineering and quality control. Sure, I wish the west had retained some of its manufacturing and design capabilities. But I don't think his examples make a very compelling point. We're mostly SW folks here, I think, so we generally understand that interfacing components requires a well written contract and appropriate testing at the boundaries. Why is it not the same in manufacturing? If I'm outsourcing the manufacturing of my toaster to various parties, I still have a hand in specifying the pieces, assuring they meet my requirements, and verifying they are put together in a way that upholds my brand value and meets customer expectations. That very much requires engineering talent. It also benefits from comparative advantage and provides my company with more profit which could, theoretically(although seemingly rarely in practice) allow me to provide a superior product at a better price point. Any decline in quality would be the result of (poor?) business decisions and not inherently a result of outsourcing.
- legulere 6y ago> We're mostly SW folks here, I think, so we generally understand that interfacing components requires a well written contract and appropriate testing at the boundaries. It also means that we understand the overhead in doing so, compared to doing things inside of a team.
- varjag 6y ago> If I'm outsourcing the manufacturing of my toaster to various parties, I still have a hand in specifying the pieces, assuring they meet my requirements, and verifying they are put together in a way that upholds my brand value and meets customer expectations. Except eventually you can't, other than in very vague, handwavy sense. Engineering specification is a skill, and it dies when manufacturing base moves overseas. You get maybe a decade of transitional time when you both have an oversupply of now unemployed engineer force AND cost savings from doing the actual work elsewhere, but then people change careers and new college students know better.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"I launched a telecommunications company called PowerDNS." Is writing an authoritative and recursive nameserver with flex and bison and licensing the software to some telecoms in Europe the the same as "launching a telecommunications company". Would he say that the companies that some European telecoms are outsourcing to have "launched telecommunications companies". Why not call it what it is. A software company. That now provides SaaS. A company that is taking on outsurcing work from telecoms that are internet providers. It is itself an illustration of the problem he purports to identify in the presentation.
- mkl 6y agoHe didn't hide that, he stated it explicitly a little later: "I used to sell software, and now I sell services". "Telecommunications company" seems more specific than "software company" to me. Taking on outsourcing work is how he came to be in the position of understanding the topic of the talk/article the way he presented it, and understanding how little the "actual" telecommunications companies were doing.
- spicyramen 6y agoWorking on Cloud that is exactly what happened. Many countries have federal regulations to host services in data centers inside their geographical boundaries. Instead of having a Cloud provider, these larger corporation asks Google, Microsoft and AWS to build and deploy services in these zones. A very dangerous path for European companies. Excellent article
- a-dub 6y agoandy grove (of intel fame) has written quite a bit about the dangers of over-outsourcing over the last 20 years. one of his more interesting points was that running a manufacturing operation made intel better at designing chips in unexpected ways. unfortunately, every link i find is either dead or behind a paywall. oof.
- erwincoumans 6y ago"Losing out without the tech" would be a better title. Also, Europe may start to realize that it has to develop some tech, such as Cloud services, itself. As @jbverschoor mentions, the European attitude needs to change to consider tech as a core business, instead of a cost center, and pay engineers accordingly. https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-pledges-e10-billion-to-power-up-industrial-cloud-sector/amp/ https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-pledges-e10-billion-to-po...
- pas 6y ago... but Europe is not just some dude making decisions all by itself. So who should do exactly what? Sure, maybe the corporate culture needs to change. Maybe CEOs, boards, investors/shareholders, regulators (and managers, and employees, and education, and ...) have to change to change corp culture. So how? Also why do exactly Europe has to do this? Is Cloud the new gunpowder? Should the EU Commission just run a big OpenStack cluster? (So these big alliances are completely useless. Just like OpenStack itself. Instead of this 10B EUR for some pet projects of random big and old industrial companies, the Commission should work on making it easier to start a company, hire/employ folks anywhere, sell stuff, make contracts, develop standards, report problems [ie. corruption], and it should create X-prize like grants/competitions, it should give incentives to build and maintain direct to end-user technology. Anyway, this is just like the F35 in the USA, members states want to spend the money at home.)
- erwincoumans 6y agoTech is the new gunpowder. USA and China government understand how to prioritize and plan this. The European Union needs a 5 to 10 year tech plan like this older Chinese one: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11684 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11684
- pas 6y agoYes, gunpowder is literally tech too after all, and there's no shortage of tech in the EU. The EU Horizon2020 was a great initiative for example. The EU thinks in 7 year budget cycles. I too recommend more spending on tech and science. That said the direct EU budget is not particularly huge (just 1% of the GNI of all of the member states), but members should spend on tech more anyway. And the NGEU (next gen EU) COVID relief fund is "just" 750B EUR. (Though again, member states themselves will also spend a lot of money on boosting the recovery.) Naturally there are obvious strategically important areas where the EU as whole should do direct investment into R&D. (Food, energy security and health for example.) There's about 20B EUR / year earmarked for "single market, innovation and digital" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiannual_Financial_Framework#Expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiannual_Financial_Framewor... ) China does understand that the best way to build up a particular industrial capability is to do it. "Just do it". Especially using tech transfer agreements. Hence their amazing railway network. (But their 5year plan is not particularly interesting.) ---- I'd argue that the EU should just do more (a lot more!) of what it usually does anyway. (Which is participating in various projects, from ITER, ESA (+ Galileo), to funding a lot of initiatives like NGI.) Also it'd be great to capitalize on GDPR and other differentiating directives. (So partially funding projects that offer GDPR-compliant alternatives.) ... and healthcare, the EU populace is aging, fast .. if that's not great "market" opportunity I don't know what is. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ But, still, the core issue is that there's not enough direct capital sloshing around in the EU. If the Commission would partially fund targeted VC funds it could make very big waves in various tech sectors.
- QuadrupleA 6y agoThis article / talk seems entirely focused on company boundaries - what's in-sourced and outsourced - but isn't that sort of secondary? If you have a group of 500 people contributing to the making of a toaster, whether they all call themselves Company A (with many divisions) or are split into many companies, it's kind of the same when the rubber meets the road - it's 500 people working together in some fashion to produce a toaster. How you draw the lines around them and what company/division names you write on top is sort of secondary.
- lordnacho 6y agoI think it does matter how the 500 people are set up: - Information flows become adversarial. I don't want to tell my customer they're wasting money on the heating element, because what they waste ends up in my pocket. - Incentives are different. Customer wants the best heating element for their use case, but I want the one that I can sell to as many customers as possible, so I'll nudge them towards this one that seems to fit that description. - Marketing arm sees an opening and wants to innovate. Sadly they don't speak the same language as the techs, metaphorically and literally. You could say this is the same problem that the whole world has. Why aren't we all a global village, able to make decisions like saving the planet? Incentives are cut up and fall different ways because we don't see each other as one, and can't communicate that well.
- cutemonster 6y agoIn addition to that, a supplier might want to bill as many hours as possible, and dislike time saving innovations. And might happily proceed with building things they know won't be useful or after a broken spec. All this sounds like major big bad things to me.
- pas 6y agoBert's point is that those 500+ people should be in the EU. The EU should fund and maintain certain capabilities, like building, maintaining, and innovating communications networks, from fabs to finance.
- gitgud 6y ago> And at some point, the technical skills of the company become negative. And what does that mean? That your company knows so little about what it does that if you would ask a random person on the street for advice on the thing that your company makes, they are more likely to provide correct answers than the people that actually work for the company. This is a scary thought, but one that is regulated by capitalism and economics. Sometimes it's cheaper to hire smart people when needed, rather than keep people around just for their knowledge...
- eloisant 6y agoOn the topic of "reversing outsourcing", a few French shoe brands have decided to bring back production to France, and stop outsourcing. One of them was Le Coq Sportif. It was challenging because they realized that manufacturing sport shoes is actually difficult, requires expertise that was completely lost in France because it have been outsourced for 30 years. So they had to re-learn everything.
- throwaway_777 6y agoBesides Asimov's and Jonathan Blow's illustrations of the problem. What is the cure? Instead of focusing on abstractions of technology, why not focus on the fundamentals? With fundamentals, I mean mathematics and physics. This is perhaps all you need to understand tech in its fundamental nature. Everything is built out of mathematical and physical principles it seems. The problem then may be to determine how much you need of it for your field. Do you need quantum mechanics to know how bicycles work? Maybe classical physics (mechanics, electricity, optics) will suffice here and the rest is a combination of physical principles aka engineering or creativity if you will. (Creativity is a fundamental human skill it seems.) There's also abstract engineering as I would put it: computer science. What are the principles of CS? I am not so sure, but I have a rough idea that perhaps it is also field dependent. For computer graphics seemingly you don't need a lot of math. It's roughly at high school math level. You can do projections and other transformations without linear algebra (vector, matrix math). All you need to do here, is deriving relations/equations out of geometric rules (like you can for perspective projection for example). Then you have 2 fundamental ways of rendering things to the screen: rasterization (Pineda's method) and ray tracing. Rasterization: - after projection, you need to bring your vertices projected onto your virtual screen to an actual "screen" or should I say PPM image. Then you need a filling algorithm like Pineda's one. Ray tracing: - here, you don't need any projections. The projections are basically "a given". As you shoot rays from your virtual camera through your virtual screen, all you need to do here is to calculate intersections with geometrical objects and color them accordingly. That's it. So for all this basic rasterization and ray tracing you at least need: high school-level math (perspective projection, intersections, transformations, ...), basic rendering algorithms (Pineda's method, ray tracing, Phong shading, ...). I suppose the other field's fundamentals or basic principles can be "filtered out" from these many layers of abstractions. Matrix math or linear algebra is not needed for CG. (Although it is really comfortable to know it... It's like doing CG by Assembly instead of C or C++.) I also suppose that back propagation - the backbone of neural networks - can be also done with basic high school math. So my suggestion is: decide what are the basic principles of a given field and filter them out. Also, my question to all of you: learning Assembly is pretty much an educational endeavor nowadays as CPUs these days are doing lots of magic behind the scenes. So what are the fundamental principles here? Physics surely, but I see a problem with my argument above. Getting down to the common denominator (math and physics) is relatively easy, but it is hard to build a CPU out of it albeit theoretically possible. Charles Petzold's code seems to suggest that those principles are actually not that far from basic principles. Dunno, what do you think of my comment here?
- ReptileMan 6y agoHating on apple is a pet peeve of mine, but when the iPhone went out with it's locked down it just works appstore I knew we were in a watershed moment - around that time people just stopped being interested in how stuff works and everything was replaced by techo shamanism - with the few of us still knowing how to troubleshoot something being viewed as shamans. The idea that people could dig deep and get our knowlege (and the motivation to do so) just went out. We see this in cars - the check engine light is the most disgusting thing ever invented - you have so many displays, you could put directly the real error and let me know what it is. But no - we have to go the techo shamans to do their job. We move from not knowing things to unknowable - the idea that the knowlege is unobtainable. And that is bad.
- mellavora 6y agoRichard Stallman saw that same watershed moment a few years ahead of you...
- koonsolo 6y agoAnyone who tried to start a company knows that the hard part is not building the product, but getting the customers. As long as your company "owns" the customers, there is nothing you cannot outsource.
- riccardomc 6y agoI think about this often. A lot of people worry about the Singularity. I don't: the trivial, non-smart, underlying infrastructure running these amazing artificial intelligence will collapse much, much earlier than any spark of consciousness will be able to emerge. I help companies with cloud transformations and often I come across situations where businesses are in trouble because they completely lost their operational knowledge. They might know how their applications work internally, but they have no clue how the machinery around them keeps them ticking. Once I was at a company in Northern Europe that desperately needed to modernize their stack running on legacy mainframes in a colocation datacenter. Their core business was based on winning the five years government tender for a very crucial public service. They won for years and years, but now they were scared shitless because the new tender explicitly mentioned that the system was supposed to be hosted "in the cloud" and developed using a "microservices architecture". The main issue was two-fold. On one hand, for decades they offloaded the deployment of their core systems to the technicians of the datacenter itself with which they had an amicable and personal relationship. On the other, said datacenter was being bought by a US megacorp who didn't give a crap about the existing personal relationship with this very specific, crucial use case and told the company to simply pay them a crazy amount of money to perform the migration. They were also so blind to their lack of understanding of their own deployment process that they called us only two months away from the deadline. So, yeah... I advised my employer to stay away from this death march. And for the Singularity, it better have a good DevOps neural net.
- _aleph2c_ 6y agoThe people who have jobs in zombie firms are fragilizing their careers. If you are just managing a process, your job will be automated. Your leadership won't hesitate to lay you off. If your firm is protected by intellectual property which isn't respected by China, and your firm doesn't even have the skills to defend its own network, you can't keep your "property". If you train your Asian partners how to work within your regulatory framework, they will just hire a few members of your staff away, then open a competing firm in your own country and completely dominate you. The whole western system is being dismantled, thank you McKinsey & Company. Why don't people leave? Because they want their buy-out. They want the package that comes from grinding all of those years away at the zombie firm.
- HeyLaughingBoy 6y agoWell, that and "your job will be automated" very often means "your job will finally be automated 20 years after you retire."
- cryptonector 6y agoWhat a fantastic article. I can't help but think how SpaceX, for example, does everything they can. They don't outsource their engines. They don't outsource anything. Heck, they get involved in making new alloys even if they're not making the bulk alloy metal. Musk knows that to innovate, you must control your own destiny. We need more of this. Outsourcing is this management fad that all the business schools must have taught as de rigeur, and it's good for non-core competencies of a company sometimes, but never ever good for core competencies.
- cryptonector 6y agoThe abstract of the linked Boeing paper is very interesting. It feels like the author was afraid of being ignored.