42 ms·
Flu has disappeared worldwide during the Covid pandemic
- osipov 6y agohaha
- yosito 6y agoWhile I think this is most likely due to masking, distancing and staying home when sick, which were all far more effective against the flu than against SARS-CoV-2, I wonder how much this was affected by some of the deep cleans that cities were doing at the beginning of the pandemic where they basically sprayed entire cities with disinfectant trucks. Does anyone with more expertise have any thoughts about that?
- al3xandre 6y agoYou realize those « deep cleans » are mostly comms operations for governments to look like they are doing stuff, right? Virus live (mostly) in people, not on sidewalks. One of the most ridiculous example: the Thai government went to the extent of spraying disinfectant in the forest next to the Burmese border, and got pictures published in newspaper to show their great work. Comical! [1] [1] https://twitter.com/thainewsreports/status/1381918586348822531?s=21 https://twitter.com/thainewsreports/status/13819185863488225...
- yosito 6y ago> You realize those « deep cleans » are mostly comms operations for governments to look like they are doing stuff, right? Yes, but it must have had some effect on fomite transmission of some viruses, right?
- Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL 6y agoThe flu is global, yes? How many cities did your "deep cleaning" (I've heard it for the first time)? Out of a total of how many cities? I decline your notion on those grounds alone.
- nickysielicki 6y agoProbably not.
- PeterisP 6y agoAFAIK fomite transmission on public streets and other places sprayed by such "deep cleans" isn't a common spread vector for any widespread disease, so eliminating it can't make a meaningful difference.
- Retric 6y agoEven fairly small changes can be significant with exponential feedback loops. That’s not to say they actually had any impact, just that you can’t always tell what was important. For example it’s possible but unlikely that some other pandemic was accidentally prevented.
- cimi_ 6y agoAssuming what you're saying is correct (I don't know), what other effects does spraying disinfectants everywhere have? I would be very surprised if doing this is a good idea, even if it kills covid and/or flu.
- bitexploder 6y agoEhh... most viruses really don't live on surfaces very long. Unless they were continuously spraying the whole pandemic on a weekly basis I don't see how it could do much at all. And even if they were doing it every week... most of us get viruses from handled (by humans) surfaces.
- he0001 6y agoVirus exist everywhere and is the most common entity on earth. In a tablespoon of seawater there can be ten million of them. Most are not dangerous to man, about 600 is known. They are also very good to survive on their own without a host and can live in most hostile environments.
- soldehierro 6y agoViruses aren't alive, and they certainly can't reproduce without host cells, so saying that they survive on their own doesn't seem like a terribly accurate statement. Trying to extend the metaphors of life "alive or dead, surviving" to viruses only generates misconceptions, instead "viable or inactivated" is a better way of looking at it.
- BurningFrog 6y agoMy guess is it had an effect for a few hours that day.
- da_big_ghey 6y agosunlight already good at kill virus, this have been knowen for many year. study find corona is dead from twenty minute sunlight alone: https://academic.oup.com/jid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/infdis/jiaa274/5841129 https://academic.oup.com/jid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/inf... so maybe not so efective.
- al3xandre 6y agoSome more of these fun photo ops: https://twitter.com/thainewsreports/status/1388698457657905152?s=21 https://twitter.com/thainewsreports/status/13886984576579051...
- georgeplusplus 6y agoFlu - a coronavirus that has been wiped out because of social distance and masking and hygiene controls Covid - a coronavirus that is absolutely rampant because insufficient masking, distancing, and hygiene controls How you rationalize that hypocrisy so easily in your head is beyond me.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ancientworldnow 6y agoFlu is an influenza virus not a coronavirus - it's literally in the name. Additionally, varying levels of contagiousness and mechanisms of spread absolutely make actions more effective for some diseases and less effective or not effective at all for others. This is not a controversial statement despite your dramatic insistence on ignorance.
- collyw 6y agoSimilar sized virus, respiratory and seasonal. Plenty of similarities.
- smolder 6y agoInfluenza is not a coronavirus.
- PEJOE 6y agoInfluenza is not a coronavirus
- deelowe 6y ago...
- georgeplusplus 6y ago“Basic statistics” like occasionally wearing a mask and putting up signs to distance despite massive contrary evidence like mass protests and spring break? your numbers are a joke. Who knew defeating flu was this easy all along!
- cblconfederate 6y agoprobably the school closings were the largest contributor
- caturopath 6y agoSince this has varied so much by region, I wonder if there's any good evidence. This makes a lot of sense. Schools have been surprisingly rare causes of COVID outbreaks, but are constant epicenters for flu outbreaks.
- alpaca128 6y ago> Schools have been surprisingly rare causes of COVID outbreaks I can clearly remember that multiple countries closed schools within weeks of the first reopening because the virus was spreading there like wildfire, in the age group with the highest rate of asymptomatic(aka invisible until it's too late) cases.
- caturopath 6y agoThe CDC reports at https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/transmission_k_12_schools.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br... that "in-person learning in schools has not been associated with substantial community transmission" The low symptom rate corresponds to a low transmission rate. The worse your case of COVID, the more likely you will transmit it to others in the same situation. This is the obvious mechanism of the fact that kids, who very seldom have bad cases of COVID and so frequently do not show symptoms, are not usually major spreaders of the virus. This all is one of the really unusual things about COVID compared to other communicable diseases.
- anoncake 6y agoAka the group that has to suffer the most from lockdowns while benefitting the least.
- wozer 6y agoThey didn't do that in Germany, but the flu disappeared here, too.
- caturopath 6y agoOr -- I bet a lot more likely -- the handwashing etc. prescriptions that turned out to be pretty meaningless for COVID but that are important to the transmission of flu and many other diseases. Obviously personal action is harder to reproduce than government-sponsored trucks, so it's less useful if it was a main cause.
- failwhaleshark 6y agoSanitation theater is helpful in the sense that it calms certain people's anxieties, much like a placebo pill does.
- fidesomnes 6y ago> While I think this is most likely due to masking, distancing I give it 5 years from now when it is no longer politically intolerable that studies will come out and admit that masks and social distancing did absolutely nothing to slow or prevent infection.
- ben_w 6y agoConsidering that one year ago the general advice was not to bother with masks, this would be a surprising 360.
- Karunamon 6y agoThat advice was intentionally deceptive. It was based on not having a mass run on PPE needed by healthcare workers, not medical science or safety. It also likely led to more deaths due to the revelation that it was a lie, and people treating any further advice (which was actually medically sound) with the same kind of cynical skepticism used for liars. Rejection of masks wasn't much of a thing before this happened.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- opencl 6y agoIn this 2018 paper[1] transmission from surfaces accounted for ~4% of flu infections. So it probably made very little impact. [1]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6121424/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6121424/
- yosito 6y agoThanks! This is good information. I would imagine that ~4% less flu infections at the start of a flu season would be enough to slow down the season a bit, in theory, but not to the point flu has been slowed down now.
- andreygrehov 6y agoMost likely due to people staying at home. I don't believe a mask can in any way protect one from catching a virus [1]. Edit: if you downvote, please, comment why. I could be wrong, so would love to know your arguments. [1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7680614/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7680614/
- ceejayoz 6y agoFind a more credible source. https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-stanford-masks/fact-check-journal-article-questioning-effectiveness-of-masks-against-covid-19-is-not-a-stanford-university-study-idUSL1N2MJ1UD https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-stanford-masks/fac... The author lied about his affiliation with Stanford, and the paper was retracted. > Jonathan Davis, a spokesperson for Elsevier, told Reuters via email that Medical Hypotheses has since retracted the article after concluding it was misleading due to “a broader review of existing scientific evidence” showing that masks “are an effective prevention of COVID-19 transmission” and said that the article contained several misquotes and unverified data. Davis said that the author himself had submitted the affiliation with Stanford Medicine. > As reported here by Forbes, Medical Hypotheses has previously published articles such as “Is there an association between the use of heeled footwear and schizophrenia” (here) and “Ejaculation as a potential treatment of nasal congestion in mature males” (here). There's a reason it's titled "Medical Hypotheses".
- andreygrehov 6y agoI didn't know the article was retracted. Are there credible papers confirming that masks do help? Edit: also, quoting Reuters is fine. However, quoting Forbes is not. Forbes is a trash publication, getting published there costs a few hundred bucks.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe Forbes assertions are trivially confirmed. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15325026/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15325026/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18434036/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18434036/ Studies demonstrating mask efficacy are just as easily Googleable. You might not want to be throwing around "trash publication" slams here, given your cite.
- taeric 6y agoOdd that you don't mention closed schools. My model has those far higher in this than anything I personally do. That is, as a parent, I was far less prone to sickness before I had kids of school age. From all I have ever heard, I am far from unique in that.
- User23 6y agoWhy did the flu also disappear in the states that had effectively no covid restrictions? This is a serious question and not an attempt at rhetoric. I really am curious. Was flu never a problem in Florida? Was voluntary compliance so widespread that heavy handed government policy had no marginal anti-flu effect? Something else?
- brandon272 6y agoThe likely explanation is that, because the flu is significantly less transmissible than COVID, even states with "no restrictions" were able to knock it out because enough people took enough measures to protect themselves from airborne/surface communicable disease in general. In other words, you can probably beat back the flu significantly by having enough of the population mask up, wash/sanitize their hands, etc.
- ericcholis 6y agoAlso, I wonder if there is correlation of at-risk people getting more flu shots?
- brandon272 6y agoNot sure what the case is overall, but apparently in North Dakota, where flu cases were 1/65 of what they were the year prior, flu vaccinations are only up 5%: https://kfgo.com/2021/04/29/319613/ https://kfgo.com/2021/04/29/319613/
- petertodd 6y ago> The likely explanation is that, because the flu is significantly less transmissible than COVID But why is it less transmissible? One obvious explanation is because we've lived with it all our lives, and most people already have some level of pre-existing immunity to most flu strains they're exposed to. Both due to natural infections, and vaccines. > In other words, you can probably beat back the flu significantly by having enough of the population mask up, wash/sanitize their hands, etc. If pre-existing immunity is why it's less transmissible, those measures will result in fewer flu infections, and thus lower levels of pre-existing immunity. Which in turn, may make the flu more transmissible, leaving us where we started. Worse, if pre-existing immunity is decreasing the severity of the infections we do get, the net effect may actually be more deaths due to fewer, but more deadly, infections. Flu vaccines are notoriously ineffective, with a typical year being just 50% effective, and bad years being as little as 19%. They're probably the least effective widely used vaccines by a long shot (eg the MMR vaccine is about 97% effective). So we can't just assume we'd be able to make up the difference with increased vaccination. Flu vaccine coverage is already quite high anyway, 51.8% or so for the entire US population. edit: fixed % https://www.cdc.gov/flu/fluvaxview/coverage-1920estimates.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/fluvaxview/coverage-1920estimates.ht... https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/measles/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/measles/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/effectiveness-studies.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/effectiveness-studies....
- ibraheemdev 6y agoJust speculating here, but maybe because of false positives where flu cases get labeled as Covid? I've heard that PCR tests were not meant to be used for large scale virus detection. EDIT: The PCR test quote was fact checked and deemed to be misleading, but it still sounds like they are not very accurate [0]. [0]: https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-pcr-idUSKBN24420X https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-pcr-idUSKBN2442...
- jimbob45 6y agoYou don’t deserve the downvotes. There’s long been speculation that flu cases may be getting reported as COVID and vice-versa because of the symptom overlap.
- space_fountain 6y agoHum, I think I've only heard of this speculation coming from people who deny covid is a big deal and not that that position should be dismissed out of hand, but the overwhelming evidence is that the strong version of it at least is wrong. I'm also struggling to understand how symptom overlap would lead differences in the number of confirmed cases with PCR tests. These aren't cases confirmed by doctors talking to you and running through a checklist, these are tests that with a great degree of accuracy confirm if you have flu or covid in your system
- linuxftw 6y agoPerhaps the corona virus is asymptomatic for some people (as is known to be), and the effects they are feeling are from the flu. How many people get a false positive (or true positive that would otherwise be asymptomatic) while also being positive for the flu? Maybe corona virus is an enabler of some other disease, like a particularly virulent flu or some other respiratory infection. This questions are inconvenient, so they'll go unasked by the media, let alone answered.
- alpaca128 6y ago
- Flatcircle 6y agoI keep wondering how Lice will be able to hang around much after last year's social distancing, especially among children.
- Joker_vD 6y agoAre... are those still a thing in the first world?
- tpmx 6y agoYes. US: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=lice https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=l... Interesting to see the graph starting to drop dramatically in early 2020 after a decade of growth/high numbers.
- detaro 6y agoyes
- gibspaulding 6y agoI read somewhere (I think Bill Bryson's "At Home") that they were almost wiped out at one point in the 20th century, but have recently started making a comeback which seems to correlate with the rise of energy saving low temp wash cycles that aren't as effective at killing them.
- tpmx 6y agoLooking at the Google Trends graph I posted in the sibling comment - that would make so much sense.
- james_pm 6y agoPossible the higher instances are related to the fact that schools no longer do routine screening for lice. No more school nurse and no more chopsticks checks monthly means that they have a chance to spread amongst the kids before anyone notices.
- 6y ago
- jccooper 6y agoYou always fight the last war. Covid measures started as flu measures, and to a great extent still are even though we now know (and knew fairly early) that the transmission modes differ significantly.
- bla3 6y agoI thought we know by now that transmission mode is more similar than initially thought? That is, it's mostly airborne for both covid and flu.
- jccooper 6y agoFlu has significant fomite transmission, both direct and from emissions, where CoV-2 basically has none. Aerosol transmission is present in flu, but nowhere near as strong as CoV-2. There are definitely some overlaps, like direct large droplet transmission (which make measures like masks work for both.) Sanitation and "social distancing" work for flu, but coronavirus is mainly about ventilation.
- FearlessNebula 6y agoSo hand washing is much more important for the flu? That's great because it is much more in your control than ventilation
- paviva 6y agoAn alternative explanation is that of "viral interference"[1,2], i.e., the most transmissible virus boosting up viral immunity in the population, and precluding transmission of the less transmissible/fit virus [1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5489283/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5489283/ [2]: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanmic/article/PIIS2666-5247(20)30114-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanmic/article/PIIS2666-5...
- jMyles 6y agoIt's strange to call this an "alternative explanation", since it's the one that expert infectious disease researchers, nearly without exception, are pointing to. The (let's face it, silly) notion that masks and distancing suppressed all respiratory pathogens except one is a theory with very little traction, and which will almost certainly not stand up to serious scrutiny.
- addicted 6y agoThere’s nothing silly about a novel virus having greater abilities to overcome barriers when compared to other pathogens that humans have had years decades and centuries to develop defenses again. At the end of the day it’s likely gonna be the result of a combination of all these factors.
- jMyles 6y ago> There’s nothing silly about a novel virus having greater abilities to overcome barriers when compared to other pathogens that humans have had years decades and centuries to develop defenses again. Agreed! What you are describing is viral interference: population-level immune responses to one respiratory pathogen causing suppression of others. We've seen selective suppression of influenza and all of the other four endemic coronaviruses, while SARS-CoV-2 has thrived. This is true throughout the world, including places where stringent horizontal interdictive measures were taken, in places where no such measures were taken, and in all places in between. > At the end of the day it’s likely gonna be the result of a combination of all these factors. I think it's very unlikely - almost impossibly so - that interdiction has played a meaningful role in population-level suppression. I don't think it will be a combination; I think it will be explained by the same clearly observed phenomenon which has been responsible for similar outcomes in the past.
- fridif 6y agoWhile I am sure that masks and no working from the office played a part in this, I believe: 1) most flu cases are being mislabeled as covid 2) most people who have a mild flu are not going to the doctor 3) the easiest way to test this will be when covid goes away and the flu suddenly reappears.
- fecak 6y agoWhen Covid goes away, we can assume masking, distancing, and staying home will also go away. In that case, all communicable diseases are likely to increase, from the common cold to STDs.
- fridif 6y agoAnd thus the flu hasn't disappeared.
- pwinnski 6y agoAh, you're reading the word "forever" at the end of that sentence, which notably does not actually include the word. Influenza will likely never be eradicated from the earth completely, but in the most recent flu season worldwide, it was essentially missing.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThis is why a tiny fringe of epidemologists has been calling for social distancing to continue for the next several years at least, even after COVID, because they see this as a chance to wipe out other common illnesses. If a person hyperspecializes in a field like epidemology, there is the risk of the person expecting all government policy to revolve around their specific concerns. Sometimes in interviews those epidemologists simply seem oblivious to the effect this will have on live music, theatre, cafes and restaurants, etc., other times they say that we simply cannot allow ourselves those things any more, because saving lives is more important.
- fridif 6y ago
- ipaddr 6y agoAir travel reduction, staying at home and distancing as playing big roles. Perhaps we should continue this way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BitwiseFool 6y agoIf I caught the flu, how would the government/scientists studying this stuff even know I got it? If you're anything like me you probably just take some time off and get over the illness without ever seeing a doctor or taking a flu-test. How do they measure such things? I suspect they use some elaborate statistical model to try and generalize the results to the whole population.
- gregmac 6y agoIf you had flu symptoms, are you not going to go get a covid test?
- willcipriano 6y agoI'm not OP but no, I work from home and only see the people I live with since this started. Knowing if its covid vs the flu wouldn't really matter much to me and either way my behavior would be the same. Frankly it would be worse for public health if I left the house while sick to satisfy my curiosity. I can imagine that many others in my situation would come to a similar conclusion.
- qudat 6y agoim in your situation: didnt need to leave my house and minimally interacted with people outside of my bubble. I felt sick recently and got the covid/flu test.
- drcross 6y agoWhy?
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoIf it was me it would be because I wanted to know if I need to be extra isolated from the people I live with.
- 6y ago
- johnchristopher 6y agoWill flu season be back at some point ?
- JohnWhigham 6y agoYes, except it will be called covid season.
- panarky 6y agoEvery community has a baseline mortality rate during "normal" times. During abnormal times like pandemic, famine and war, more people die than usual, but often the cause isn't known. If you subtract baseline mortality from actual mortality to get excess mortality, that's often a better estimate of the casualties from pandemic, famine and war than the death certificates for every person who died. Excess mortality in most countries shows that Covid deaths are significantly under-reported. And if there are fewer deaths from flu, and fewer from suicide [1], then excess mortality itself is under-reported and Covid killed even more than we thought. [1] https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/04/08/defying-expectations-us-suicides-were-down-during-pandemic/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/04/08/defying-expectations-...
- grumpyautist 6y agoThat article is drawing conclusions based on an incomplete data set. Suicide with covid is a covid death anyway.
- spinny 6y agonope, having covid when getting run over by a bus counts as a covid death in many places
- simion314 6y agoHow many places? And how many places are trying to hide the real numbers(India the most recent one)
- lame-robot-hoax 6y agoSource?
- asiachick 6y agoThere would be fewer traffic accidents as well right. No idea if the balance of consequences are a net plus or a net minus. In any case there were a couple peaks in the USA where deaths from all causes were 25% higher than average. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/excess-mortality-raw-death-count https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/excess-mortality-raw-deat...
- flarg 6y agoCovid probably killed off flu in nasal passages kind of like the common cold does to other viruses
- failwhaleshark 6y agoUnlikely/impossible to kill off all strains. Enough will survive that it will come back, just it will likely take longer to transmit due to greatly-reduced numbers of infected hosts.
- collyw 6y agoImagine actually believing this. The UK started counting flu and coronavirus as one in Autumn.
- postalrat 6y agohttps://syndromictrends.com/metric/panel/rp/percent_positivity/organism/main https://syndromictrends.com/metric/panel/rp/percent_positivi... Unless I'm reading that chart wrong it seems like flu went away but viruses that cause cold like symptoms stuck around. If masks/etc was super effective wouldn't you expect those to go down with influenza?
- jvm_ 6y agoIt seems there's a battle between virus's, they don't like sharing resources and the 'strongest' wins. https://www.bbc.com/news/health-56483445 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-56483445 Coronavirus: How the common cold can boot out Covid Think of the cells in your nose, throat and lungs as being like a row of houses. Once a virus gets inside, it can either hold the door open to let in other viruses, or it can nail the door shut and keep its new home to itself. Influenza is one of the most selfish viruses around, and nearly always infects alone. Others, such as adenoviruses, seem to be more up for a houseshare. If rhinovirus and Sars-CoV-2 were released at the same time, only rhinovirus is successful. If rhinovirus had a 24-hour head start then Sars-CoV-2 does not get a look in. And even when Sars-CoV-2 had 24-hours to get started, rhinovirus boots it out. "Sars-CoV-2 never takes off, it is heavily inhibited by rhinovirus," Dr Pablo Murcia told BBC News. He added: "This is absolutely exciting because if you have a high prevalence of rhinovirus, it could stop new Sars-CoV-2 infections."
- Pyramus 6y agoIt's very much disputed how much 'viral interference' was or is an influence in the current pandemic, and this effect (to my knowledge) has been only studied in animal models and human tissue [1], paper from the article [2]. Or to put it another way, the influenza season was already under way when SARS-Cov-2 hit in Feb 2020, but there is no indication the influenza virus slowed the SARS-Cov-2 pandemic. The exciting thing about viral interference is that no genetic similarity between the viruses is needed, however, the effect is only temporary (days to weeks) and limited. Unfortunately viral interference is also being misused as an 'alternative explanation' by folks that do not want to see the evidence that non-pharmacological interventions (hygiene, social distancing, quarantine, masks, large gatherings etc.) are effective against a whole host of respiratory diseases. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_interference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_interference [2] https://academic.oup.com/jid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/infdis/jiab147/6179975 https://academic.oup.com/jid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/inf...
- spinny 6y agohumm, i sense a bit of aftertaste of covid data in my fresh flu stats
- jgalt212 6y ago> The public health measures that slow the spread of the novel coronavirus work really well on influenza s/b The public health measures that slow the spread of the novel coronavirus work really well on FANG earnings.
- bluSCALE4 6y agoThis is stupid. Both my wife and I got sick and luckily it wasn't Covid. When we were tested, that's all everyone cared about so I'm sure they didn't mark us as having the flu even though we obviously had something.
- s0rce 6y agoSeems like they just need to show a % of positive influenza tests to control for a reduction in performing those tests.
- TrevorJ 6y agoFamily member had same experience. Classic flu symptoms. No breathing problems. Dr. Wrote down Covid symptoms in his notes which they did not have and had not complained of. They ordered a covid test, which was negative. I actually feel like they got WORSE care than they would have otherwise. The Dr. wasn't even interested in treating anything that wasn't covid, let alone diagnosing it.
- freyir 6y agoJust because you weren’t tested for the flu at your local doctor’s office, that doesn’t mean that the flu isn’t systematically monitored or that infection rates haven’t plummeted. The headline is hyperbolic (the article says it’s dropped to “minuscule levels”) but it’s entirely possible to determine that by sampling a small portion of the population.
- jjt-yn_t 6y agoon NPR recently, tuberculosis [ TB ] rates will likely increase for years and years VS had covid19 not made its appearance.
- Majromax 6y agoThis should not come as a surprise, and it was largely predictable from the outset. The flu has a base reproduction number (R0) less than 2 (https://www.vdh.virginia.gov/coronavirus/2020/12/07/covid-19-and-influenza-surveillance/ https://www.vdh.virginia.gov/coronavirus/2020/12/07/covid-19...). Covid has an R0 in the vicinity of 2.5 (https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scenarios.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...). In the meantime, public health measures like masking and distancing will work against both viruses. If people become reluctant to socialize because of covid (whether or not there be legal restrictions), they will also not spread the flu. As a broad conclusion, if public health measures reduce the effective reproduction number of Covid to about 1 (stabilizing exponential growth), they will also reduce the effective reproduction number of the flu to something substantially below 1. Since the flu would have also had a low baseline prevalence in the summer of 2020, it is no wonder that we failed to see a flu season. There's really no need for conspiracy theorizing.
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoNon virologist naive question, if we apply all these measures targeting SARS-COV2 and it also creates a massive negative pressure on flu viruses, is there a risk that this applies an adaptive pressure to select for a future uber infectious new flu strain?
- Majromax 6y agoI don't see any reason to expect it would. Summer months, for example, already apply a strong negative pressure on the flu virus (that is, we have a flu season), yet we have not seen a year-round flu. Diseases always face selection pressure to spread more easily and rapidly. When that selection pressure is caused by broad factors like "people aren't congregating together," it's hard to imagine how any simple evolution could overcome that barrier. Covid itself is instructive here. Some of the variants of concern are more transmissible than the originally-distributed variant as of March of last year, but those mutations don't uniquely overcome masks or social distancing. They would have always result in a more transmissible virus (because SARS-CoV-2 appears to be a zoonotic virus not originally perfectly-adapted to humans), and we are seeing them now because each infected person is a new roll of the mutation dice. Applying that lesson to the flu, the less prevalent the virus the less likely we are to see variations, not more. Alas, for influenza itself we always have the asterisk that we regularly see new variations cross to humans from animal reservoirs, so we're unlikely to eliminate it through only (nonpharmaceutical) human-health measures. (It'd be nice to get a universal flu vaccine, though.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shoto_io 6y agoIf I remember correctly, Prof. Drosten speculated about a heavy cold and flu season coming winter because we basically skipped one season. Remains to be seen I guess, but this prognosis resonated with me.
- teruakohatu 6y agoIf that is the case, expect to see it here in the antipodes first. In NZ we had a almost cold and flu free season last winter, just six confirmed cases in a country of 5 million [1], and are heading into winter now with looser border restrictions (relatively looser, Australians can now enter without being put into a managed isolation facility for two weeks). [1] https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/sunday/audio/2018767843/near-extinction-of-influenza-in-nz-as-numbers-drop-due-to-lockdown https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/sunday/audio/20187...
- newsbinator 6y agoWhat factors would cause skipping a season to result in more flu the following season?
- shoto_io 6y agoDecreasing levels of antibodies for example, which makes re-infections more likely for endemic diseases like colds/flus.
- cavejay 6y agoWith Australia being effectively Covid free we've already started to see much stronger cases of the flu. Local doctors in my City (Canberra) told multiple people I've talked with that the extra protective steps taken last year meant our bodies weren't as well positioned to handle the standard flu when we caught it.
- eecc 6y agoHopefully this won't cause selective pressure on flu viruses to become more aggressive.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoIf a more infectious variant surfaced, it might spread. But a lower absolute prevalence of flu (because of masks, social distancing, and lockdowns) means that low probability events - like a more virulent strain emerging - are less likely, and might not occur at all. Contrariwise this (beside basic humanity) is why the current out of control situation in India or Brazil is everyone's problem. High absolute prevalence means events that are one in a billion chance get to happen. And spread.
- chrisco255 6y agoDiseases have no trouble spreading through ordinary intimate social interactions with friends and family. In fact, you're far more likely to get sick from someone you are close to and spend hours with than someone you just pass by in a retail store. Lockdowns and mask policy are not neatly correlated with lower infection rates or death counts. Simple counterfactual example is Florida vs. California. Same results, vastly different policies. One has been open with no masking, no limits on indoor capacity, etc for over 9 months, and one has tightly restricted public congregation. Same results. Disproves the hypothesis.
- johncolanduoni 6y agoUnless of course you look at the city level, where different policies and different levels of compliance correlate quite clearly with cases: look at San Francisco or San Jose compared to Miami or Los Angeles.
- chrisco255 6y agoNot at all, you can cherry pick cities and that proves nothing, they all have vastly different demographics, different density, different climates, etc. For example, New York City is one of the worst performing metros on the planet despite harsh restrictions (and high compliance) at the city and state level and in neighboring states. There's no discernible pattern in the data.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- roody15 6y agoNot sure about in other areas, but where i am from the hospital systems rarely checked for flu. During the pandemic anyone symptomatic was told to stay home. People who visited a health clinic were typically first given a covid test. My guess is quite a few people who had the flu over the last year likely did not get an official flu test since it was difficult to get into a hospital or health clinics during the pandemic.
- widget1321 6y agoI can't speak for everywhere, but I know that from what I'm told here (was actually talking about the lack of flu with some nurses who worked in local clinics and hospitals in the area), those who had covid-like symptoms were usually given the covid test no matter what. But, if flu would have normally been suspected and there wasn't a strong indication it was covid (loss of smell/taste, known exposure to a covid-positive person, etc.), they usually also got a flu test just in case.
- nitrogen 6y agoI look forward to the day when the standard practice is to test for every common respiratory pathogen at once when someone has cold/flu symptoms. The technology exists now for personalized, data-driven medicine to take off. I know someone who works for a company who produces such tests at the same cost as a single test today, but often insurance companies and providers don't know how to bill for them, so you see stories in the news about "irresponsible doctors who should never have ordered 20 tests" that were really a single test billed incorrectly.
- samiru 6y agoIn Finland Covid can be diagnosed just by flu like symptoms, even with a negative test result for Covid. Not sure how much this affects rhe stats. Practically no cases of influenza are recorded, though.
- drummer 6y agoEveryone with flu symptoms now gets diagnosed as having "COVID" based on an unreliable and questionable pcr test. It is all a scam.
- ceejayoz 6y ago"It's all a misdiagnosis and a scam" is trivially debunked. Anyone making this assertion is either incredibly misinformed or malicious. The simplest way to debunk the idea is to look at total deaths, from all causes, in somewhere like the US. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm Again, total deaths. From any cause. A large spike is immediately obvious in the charting. https://imgur.com/a/cEhR0Eh https://imgur.com/a/cEhR0Eh
- mehphp 6y agoWhat is the goal of this "scam"?
- drummer 6y agoMoney and power, as usual
- ehsankia 6y agoWow, I always knew Flu was seasonal, but never realized how extreme that was. Looking at the North America graph, basically after May, the flu almost entirely disappears until the end of summer. Roughly 3 orders of magnitude difference between the peak and summer time. I would've thought it was closer to maybe 10x.
- vanshg 6y agoI wonder if it's because folks who were feeling sick got tested for Covid first, and upon a negative Covid result, assumed (likely correctly) that it was just flu and didn't get a flu test
- trutannus 6y agoI think you're on the right track, likely our optics into the flu has disappeared. Not the flu itself.
- alliao 6y agoin new zealand at least the disappearance of flu is genuine, as hospitals routinely checks and it just never showed up
- ehsankia 6y agoDid you reply to the wrong person? Your reply has nothing to do with what I said. I was referring the pre-covid times, the first graph shown shows that Flu went to near 0 in the summer every year, even before covid.
- gorbachev 6y agoI was just commenting to a co-worker my entire family hasn't been sick since the pandemic started. That is very unusual for a family with young children. No flu, no stomach viruses, absolutely nothing for more than a year now. Thankfully no covid-19 either.
- bombcar 6y agoI suspect a significant reduction of flu vectors is simply closed schools.
- wombatpm 6y agoWhile I have two myself, I am the first to say it: Children are disease carrying vermin
- pchristensen 6y agoMy phrase is "The world is a filthy biological soup", so the less we're in the world, the less covered in soup we are.
- jcwayne 6y agoI prefer "walking petri dish".
- Igelau 6y agoI refer to mine as pint-sized biological weapons labs. I never thought catching a cold was such a big deal until I caught one that had been mutated first by preschoolers.
- Fomite 6y agoThere's a reason a lot of epidemiologists I know, myself included, are fond of the phrase "fecal patina"
- llampx 6y ago
- JulianMorrison 6y agoMaybe we were too callous just allowing the ordinary flu to run rampant, and we should consider in future doing things like masking up when a flu season is expected, so as to stop the disease from killing thousands of old people. And also possibly consider going for full eradication rather than harm reduction. Can flu jabs be made more effective, and multi-strain, using mRNA vaccine technology? That's a genuinely new tool in the toolbox.
- taeric 6y agoMy money is on schools being a more active vector than makes sense. And I don't see us closing them like we did on a regular basis.
- graeme 6y agoIt would be sensible to improve school air quality: increase ventilation, install air purifiers, etc That would reduce the spread of infectious diseases even with schools open as normal.
- taeric 6y agoI mean. Yes. But kids also touch things far more than adults. Combined with less developed immune systems, I suspect there is a floor to how well you can reduce transmission. More, it is almost certainly related to this densely populated the school is. Which, not surprisingly, will hit poor schools harder. Edit: furthering this idea, buses are not likely to keep the same protocols they have now.
- Waterluvian 6y agoDo viruses timeshare a host or is there a mechanism for one to dominate and therefore if you have X you're less likely to contract any others?
- Pyramus 6y agoI'd like to highlight this previous discussion on influenza: On the epidemiology of influenza (2008) [1] In this paper, in 2008, researchers observe and conjecture a number of things that we now know also apply to SARS-Cov-2: * The long-tailed distribution of R: Few infect many * A low secondary attack (household infection) rate of 20-30% * 'Asymptomatic' infection as opposed to sick-to-well infection [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26857283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26857283
- rodolphoarruda 6y agoThe second line chart showing 'Temperature South America' does not include Brazil. Why? The country represents ~1/2 of South America's population. I'm just curious.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- admeyer 6y agoWhen I get the flu I don't report it to flu trackers. Rarely have I ever told my doctor. Is this uncommon?
- bumbada 6y agoIt is the most common thing to do. What happens is a small percentage of flu cases get complications and need to go to the doctor, like for example you get it with other virus and your immune system overreacts. This is the reason doctors know flu is not present, because they are not getting those cases they got every year in Winter. Flu is the main medical issue in Autumn-Winter in most of the North hemisphere by quantity.
- splithalf 6y agoI hope reasonable people can see the potential for incentives to impact various public health measurements in ways that cannot yet be detected or well accounted for. Surely some aspect of flu disappearing is impacted by the priorities of thinly stretched medical personnel, what with a pandemic and all why would anybody test for flu? Who even tests patients for flu in the first place? It’s not recommended.
- cies 6y agoCovid-19 case counting is a mess. Usually it's based on "the PCR test" which is actually a group of many different tests (the chains they test on can be different and the number of cycles can be different as well). Cases may go undetected, so testing-after-symptoms is very different than testing-random-population-sample. Sometime cases are filed based on symptoms alone. Hence we know very little about the number of C19 cases. This was also a problem with the flu: they were always estimates. I prefer to look at excess all cause mortality (per 100 inhabitants) or z-index to get a grip on the size/movement of this pandemic. Most developed nations keep track of deaths very well.
- president 6y agoThere are critics saying that the PCR cycle thresholds they used for testing were too high (37-40). If you look at the values they use for determining covid post-vaccination, they used a cycle threshold of 28. Thoughts? https://twitter.com/MichaelPSenger/status/1387836517259694080?s=20 https://twitter.com/MichaelPSenger/status/138783651725969408...
- jakobnissen 6y agoIn my lab we don't really believe a result of it has a ct of 30. 37-40 sounds like asking for bad results.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoPages of PhD rationalizations! Hahahaha!
- 988747 6y agoMy take on that is: since pandemic started governments have been pretty paranoid, imposing a lot of burdensome restrictions on their citizens, like mandatory quarantine. This incentivized people to never go to doctor unless absolutely necessary, which means that most flu cases go undiagnosed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ggm 6y agoThe perverse outcome being issues for toddlers who don't develop strong immunity? The single year on year outcome 20,000+ to 1000- is amazing, but, what if this lays the seeds for a future influenza pandemic?
- intricatedetail 6y agoHow much money big pharma lost on that, is there a study?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- skeeter2020 6y ago1. stay in your home 2. wear a mask 3. extra emphasis on washing your hands and not touching your face I'm only prepared to continue with #3 and I hope Covid will encourage more people to get annual flu shots. Beyond that, I'm rolling the dice.
- mnouquet 6y ago1. not doing that, 2. never done that, 3. don't care about personal hygiene that much I'm surprised I'm still alive...
- audessuscest 6y agohttps://twitter.com/ianmSC/status/1387864442386325504 https://twitter.com/ianmSC/status/1387864442386325504
- williesleg 6y agoNo wonder we all have to take the vaccine, drug companies aren't selling any tamiflu or nyquil! You'd think the vaccine is free but the government pays for it. No one mentions the cost. Hmmm.....
- cheeri0 6y agoI'm just going to go ahead here and state the obvious. The flu did not magically disappear and people with the flu are without any question being counted as counted as covid-19 cases.
- pfundstein 6y agoFirstly no one said it's magical: It's a direct result of the covid-19 measures, and was predicted to happen. Secondly it hasn't disappeared, if you read the article it says there were 600 flu deaths (in the US) last year, where previously there were 20,000+. Finally, all it takes is a quick test to confirm whether it's influenza or coronavirus.
- cheeri0 6y agoWhoa calm down. No need to downvote because you don't like what I said. First and second: > 20,000+ down to 600 for no reason is magical. What would you call that? A mystery? Fine. The flu did not mysteriously disappear. Your last point: First off, those tests don't work. Everyone knows it. The inventor of the PCR test knows it. Elon Musk knows it about the antigen tests. They aren't accurate. Also, hospitals in the US are getting paid for each covid case. hmmmm. lol and you are so into this cult you can't admit that flu deaths are being counted as covid deaths. Wow.
- jakobnissen 6y agoNo. I work in my country's national influenza lab, and we still do tests specifically for influenza. We can distinguish between subtypes of influenza with those, the idea of the test being so broad it can pick up other phyla is outrageous.
- cheeri0 6y agoI never questioned the ability of a lab to detect the flu. I chose the null hypothesis that the flu did not disappear. You are the one claiming the flu disappeared lol.
- kaminar 6y agoIt's a lot easier to have few deaths for the flu, when nobody tests for the flu...and hospitals get paid $13k for every confirmed Sars patient. Duh...
- mvkel 6y agoDumb question: if the transmission rate of the flu got low enough for a full season, could it be eradicated too?
- anoncake 6y agoIn principle yes, but you'll need to convince birds to wear masks.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoIn my experience, lots of people treat the flu like it was 'no big deal', and will happily go to work (or be sent to school) to share with the other children. Covid sounded a lot scarier to them, so in the process of avoiding it, they accidentally did the right thing. Thus the drop in flu cases.
- FearlessNebula 6y agoThis is so frustrating. So many people think the flu = the cold when in reality if they had the flu they wouldn't even be able to make it to work because they'd be in bed. That is if they're not in a hospital bed which statistically they probably are.
- barbs 6y agoI live in Melbourne, where most restrictions have been relaxed due to low case numbers. I and a good number of friends have all caught a cold in the past couple of weeks. I'm curious to know why isolation measures haven't worked on the common cold as well as they have on influenza.
- dennis_jeeves 6y agoAnyone else skeptical about the whole flu has disappeared fiasco? If the same covid PCR test existed a few years back most flu/cold would have been classified as Covid.
- jakobnissen 6y agoWhat? No, at least the tests we use in my country is specific for one virus. People with influenza don't get tested positive for covid.
- sillystring 6y agoNah. They count every puliminary death as flu. They just called it covid last year.
- gregwebs 6y agoI saw this same information about flu disappearing in Hong Kong about a year ago. So this wasn't a matter of predicting an effect so much as translating it from one region of the world to another. And yet the medical establishment in the US has continued to push the flu vaccine on everyone. I can only assume that this over-zealousness helps the anti-vaccine movement. BTW, the flu death stats quoted in this article are mostly from pneumonia rather than influenza [1] [1] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2766121 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullar...
- dcolkitt 6y agoAnybody care to weigh in on something I can't figure out. Last October I had some sort of illness, with severe flu like symptoms. However my nasal swab PCR test, taken 48 hours after symptoms, came back negative. I assumed it was flu, but everything I'm read suggests that flu is virtually unheard of this season. For a standard cold, it seemed to severe (102 F fever, body aches and chills). I also had a strong reaction to the first Covid vaccine dose. What's the most likely explanation here?
- scomp 6y agoI had the worst cold of my life in July last year (could of been the flu, it was a struggle to walk from the lounge room to the bedroom), got tested thinking 100% I had COVID (partner was a COVID nurse, seemed likely I would get it). Got a negative result.
- dizzystar 6y agoI took the PCR test back in November. I looked up all the data I could and it wasn't really possible find any straight answers, but this is the closest I could come up with: If you test positive, you likely had it and can spread it. If you test negative, there is about a 40% of a false negative, but it also depends on when you were exposed, so you'll end up negative if you are outside the window... post symptom, you were probably outside the window. This also depends on the test itself. When I got mine, I went to a place that was using a new form of the test, and it was bad enough that the testing company lost their contract (whether they were fudging numbers or not is debatable, I can't find any good information on it either). At the end of the day, if you didn't go to a hospital and get diagnosed with covid, or had an antibody test after you recovered, you probably can't be certain. Sorry, it's the best I could come up with after days of looking it up from multiple sources.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> and it was bad enough that the testing company lost their contract (whether they were fudging numbers or not is debatable, I can't find any good information on it either) Ah yea. That happened in California and Florida for sure, probably other places too. In Florida there were two labs specially that were reporting 100% positive for weeks, I don’t care how badly they had it, that wasn’t actually possible. You probably had it, my personal experience was I got it early and aside from two days of flu symptoms it was gone. Didn’t know until I gave blood months later and had positive antibodies.
- throwitaway1235 6y agoThere seems to be a great deal of misunderstanding as to what a normal biome in a human nasal passage looks like. Thousands of different pathogens present at any given time. Having testable traces of Covid-19 in your septum is not the same thing as having Covid-19 the symptomatic disease. But it's statistically treated the same. Flu cases have dropped because people aren't being tested for it. If health authorities instructed populations to get flu tests as aggressively as covid-19 tests, flu cases would jump again. Not complicated guys.
- muttantt 6y agoOr... it was re-branded.
- grouphugs 6y agothis journal posts so much misinformation and xenophobic content i'd call it alt-right tbh, they're fucking nazis
- calltrak 6y agoThis is utter bollocks. They have re-branded the flu and now you will need a one world unfreedom passport to do anything.....
- thewileyone 6y agoWhat a difference wearing masks and social distancing makes ...
- piokoch 6y agoI am curious what are going to be consequences of this in coming year? Less flu overall? More dangerous flu overall as our immune system forgot it?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- phonebucket 6y agoOne way to see it is that the preventative measures against Covid got the flu numbers down. Another way to see it is that people who’d die from the flu died from Covid instead. How do we tease apart the two potential explanations?
- corona-research 6y agoYeah covid is a soft-power strategy though the majority of people are cowards that try to suppress the obvious.
- animal531 6y agoHere where I live we've had a pretty big gastro outbreak not too long ago, baffling doctors.
- lumberingjack 6y agoIn contrast because everybody's hold up and probably not in the best physical condition some of my friends who did get real flu we're amazed that it's strength had them laying on their asses not being able to do anything and they lost weight almost like covid but a lot worse
- daddylongstroke 6y agoActually, we've simply stopped testing for the flu. That's it. All of these comments from so many highly intelligent people, and I don't see a single person hypothesizing this. My wife is a triage nurse for the largest provider of such services in the US. She's literally spoken to 10s of thousands of patients over the last year, and thousands of nurses, MDs, pharmacy techs, and lab technicians. The main takeaway that she's gotten from the largest testing labs over the last year (think labs in the largest population centers of the US), is that they were not even accepting samples for anything non-COVID related for 95% of the year. They simply stopped testing for the flu. She would routinely have a chat with a lab technician, after an MD would put through an order, with the tech saying "stop sending this stuff to us, we're only testing for COVID for the foreseeable future." This has not stopped.
- tmaly 6y agoNot unlike the quote from Demolition Man: "In the future all restaurants are Taco Bell"
- nickalaso 6y agoThe top level comments are arguing that the cause for this is due to the effectiveness of various health measures. The problem with this argument is we would expect for flu cases to continue to be reported in countries and US states where lockdown measures were never properly enacted. This doesn't appear to be happening. Instead, "the drop-off in flu numbers was both swift and universal." (article quote) This universality suggests a data problem to me rather than an environmental change.
- ed_balls 6y agoIs there a downside of getting rid of flu? E.g. my immune system doesn't have right training?