32 ms·
My experience with sexual harassment in the Scala community
- dheera 6y agoRelated: Open letter of support for community members targeted by Jon Pretty https://github.com/scala-open-letter/scala-open-letter.github.io https://github.com/scala-open-letter/scala-open-letter.githu...
- mirekrusin 6y agoI don't know anything about it, but this starts to look a bit like public lynching.
- ezluckyfree 6y agono, a lynching is a murder by a racist mob this is a community realizing that John Pretty is a predator and deciding that they don't want a predator in a position of power frankly, it's weird as hell for you to be confusing those two things
- mirekrusin 6y agonot me or you are to judge this, we don't know the details, it may as well be that he is completely shit partner and not much more than that, which is not unlawful. do you think after those posts his scala/programming/whatever he's doing career won't suffer? he's dead in many professional circles regardless if he's jail material or not.
- klyrs 6y agoHe wasn't her "partner", he was her mentor; he abused his position, tricked her into staying in an apartment alone with him, got her drunk and forced himself on her against her wishes.
- kingsuper20 6y ago>no, a lynching is a murder by a racist mob no, a lynching is an extra-legal murder by a mob.
- _qwfv 6y agoIn the US, lynching has extremely strong implications of racist violence. It's not strictly the definition of the word, but most folks in the states will understand a lynching to imply race related murders.
- cbmuser 6y ago> In the US, lynching has extremely strong implications of racist violence. Please don’t assume everyone is a US citizen.
- Pfhreak 6y agoI'm not. In fact, I'm the opposite. That's literally why I wrote that comment. It was for the benefit of people who were not US citizens who may not understand that a US reader will likely interpret the phrase that way.
- throwawayfrauds 6y agoThat’s not what lynching is. Lynching is mob justice without a trial. The name came from Charles Lynch, who punished Loyalists during the American Revolution.
- kbelder 6y agoThe similarity is that both are mob actions, done without legal charges or rules of evidence. I'm not defending the guy specifically; I have no idea whether he's a guilty scumbag or a persecuted innocent. But even jerks deserve a certain amount of due process before punishment. Maybe she's the scumbag? I don't know, and neither do you.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoA lynching is done by a literal mob. This is being done by a metaphorical mob.
- huachimingo 6y agoNot necessarily by a racist mob, just an angry mob[1]. [1]https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/lynch#English https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/lynch#English
- tester756 6y ago>this is a community realizing that John Pretty is a predator and deciding that they don't want a predator in a position of power Not really, it seems like cancel culture, did you even read this letter?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 6y agoNo, I don't think open letters are anything like public lynching.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Pfhreak 6y agoWhich part? The part where people are saying they've become aware of several independent, substantiated accusations against Pretty? The part where they state that sexual assault is unacceptable? The part where they demand that Pretty stop this behavior, and that communities put stronger code of conducts in place to specifically call out preying on/sexually assaulting members of that community as unacceptable? Refusing to associate with Pretty, who they believe is an sexual abuser? Which part of that is 'a bit like a public lynching'? I want you to be specific, because waving your hand loosely at a document and being like, "Well I dunno, but this seems like an execution designed to drive fear into a community" is not only wildly inappropriate but also rhetorically hollow.
- ipaddr 6y ago"We will not use or promote any software artifacts that are maintained by Mr. Pretty" This part seems over the top. You go down this road and you end up in some foss hell. Later you find out someone who abused someone checked in code in linux. You can't use windows or a mac because of jobs and gates and you are back on a c64 until you realize what a bad person Jack was and you end up on OS/2. I guess those who signed want to use an unmaintained version? I get that people want to do something. Maybe conferences are not the best avenue for the community to meet safely. Providing gender safe housing would go a long way to having a more successful conference if successful means less rapes.
- Pfhreak 6y agoEdit: Would you characterize that part as "a bit like a public lynching"? Because I definitely wouldn't, even if I disagreed with it or felt it was too much. --- I think you are very uncharitably reading that comment. There's a difference between, "This person checked some code into a repo" and "this person is the maintainer of a project". And I think that it's reasonable for people to hold the stance of, "I don't want to run this person's code because I believe they are a serial abuser" and to clearly state why. If other repos see that, maybe they decide to take on that stance, maybe they don't. They encourage others to consider doing the same, but the don't demand them.
- melenaboija 6y agoIt starts looking to me like a bit of explaining what happened repeatedly
- trynton 6y ago@mirekrusin: "I don't know anything about it, but this starts to look a bit like public lynching." Trial by Internet.
- dimgl 6y agoMake no mistake. This is a public lynching.
- calylex 6y agoYou have no evidence to be smearing someone's name and defaming them on HN in this way. Stop this behavior until there is legal grounds for doing so.
- rodgerd 6y agoIt's not defamation if it hasn't been judged so in a court of law.
- hdunrjdu 6y agoI have lurked here for a long time, but felt compelled to create an account to respond to comments in this thread because of how disappointed I was. This community is part of the problem. On a human level, how can you be so concerned that there's an outside chance that the accused is completely innocent, and at the same time, ignore the fact that in all likelihood, another human was exploited and raped? Yes, there is a criminal justice system, and yes "innocent until proven guilty" is an important part of it, but it's clearly unable to handle cases such as these. If that's not obvious, you must not be paying close enough attention.
- adultSwim 6y agoThis. Many of the comments are deeply disheartening.
- dd444fgdfg 6y agoyes but what happens now is "guilty with no chance of being proven innocent", which is much worse. This will have a massive impact on the accused persons life. Keep in mind, it might not be true and it's only one side of the story. we shouldn't be cancelling people on one sided stories when people reflect back on life and wish they made different choices.
- ramtatatam 6y ago> "There was another time that he insisted on having intercourse regardless of me saying I didn’t want to" This is rape is it not? Whoever this guy is, in my opinion this case should get in front of the judges. I can't imagine what the author of the story have gone through.
- mirekrusin 6y agoRape is doing it, not insisting, I think.
- eloff 6y agoInsisting could mean doing it in this context. English is weird.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Pfhreak 6y agoSex was had while she did not consent, she mentions in the fifth paragraph.
- the-dude 6y agoThat is not what she says there. She says she felt uncomfortable and taken advantage of.
- boblax 6y agoShe is definitely the kind of woman where a man shouldn't be making such advances. Let her be the acting party. She would have been telling another story if she were on top and had taken the initiative. One of the simplest ways for a man to avoid the problems of consent where he suspects there may be is to be the one from whom consent is needed. That is the absolute safest other than leaving. If you as a man attempt to get consent that may not be something you're able to obtain. She might be intoxicated and unable to consent. You might not know that. However what's safe is to let anyone initiate sex with you while you remain passive and let them have sex with you. If you leave then I would strongly advise to say it is because you are feeling sick and think it's something you ate. Go to the toilet first and say you have the runs. That will cushion her pride and make her just glad you left. No chance of something mean-spirited.
- jdmoreira 6y agoI have no clue on who this guy is nor do I have any sort of interest in Scala but this is terrible. If this is even remotely true I hope he suffers enormous consequences including being persecuted. How are people still getting away with this kind of abuse? How?
- QUFB 6y ago> How are people still getting away with this kind of abuse? How? Read the comments in this thread six hours from now and you'll understand.
- jdmoreira 6y agoI think I know what you are trying to say and I agree but I’m also on the camp that Richard Stallman didn’t say anything necessarily wrong, just awkward. On the one hand I want people to be able to to speak their minds but on the other hand this guy might be a sexual predator at best and a serial rapist at worst. and he is getting away with it!
- rodgerd 6y agoYou're apologising for a serial sexual harasser. You are the problem.
- sarakayakomzin 6y agobring in the stallmanites! I for one am glad there is someone to stand up for him - it makes it very easy to tell who wants to cherrypick and debate semantics due to their own biases.
- rodgerd 6y agoSix hours? It'll be flagged out of existence by then, most likely. On edit: it took mere minutes for the HN rape apologists to show up!
- goblox 6y ago
- gher-shyu3i 6y ago> I felt bad that I made him feel untrusted and stopped asking others to join. Mistake #1 > Remembering that he had suggested I get milk and wine in our previous conversation, I also bought them. I don’t remember how much I drank. Mistake #2. Obviously we're not excusing the behavior of the guy. However, when will we learn that we should not mix genders this way, and especially the many times people have been bitten with alcohol. It's bizarre really. People want to have their cake and eat it. They play with fire then cry when they get burnt.
- wrren 6y agoThis guy sounds like a practiced predator, he ought to be in jail.
- merb 6y agofirst, a small rant: tbf. I dislike the title. the real title is sexual harassment from Jon Pretty a leader of certain Scala Community standups. because the current title actually sounds like it's the whole commnity, but the blog is about a specific guy. --- second I really do not understand, how other people can be so horrible. he basically abused her in a moment where she was really really desperate and I think such a thing is really really bad.
- nerdponx 6y ago> In June, Heather noticed that I was upset at a dinner after ScalaDays. I shared with her about what happened. She warned me to stay away from Jon Pretty. And she wasn’t the only person who told me that. Even though my experience in Berlin was awful, it was difficult for me to accept that someone, who seemed like a good friend, mentor, and ally, could be so selfish, manipulative, and cruel. It sounds like people knew about him and didn't do anything. If the community is allowing it to happen, then the community is as much at fault as the sick individual doing the abuse.
- merb 6y ago> It sounds like people knew about him and didn't do anything. If the community is allowing it to happen, then the community is as much at fault as the sick individual doing the abuse. well around 2017-2019 I was active in scala aswell (more on the playframework side tough) and I dind't even knew about him until I read the blog. you know just because there are members from scalacenter and lightbend does not mean that the community as a whole wanted to have something to do with somebody like him. You know there are thousands of people going to ScalaDays every year, it's highly unlikely that the majority of the scala community would be happy about the guys behavior and it's also highly unlikely that the majority of people in the scala community knew about the guys behavior.
- atq2119 6y agoI've felt for a while now that the way the tech world talks about "the $foo community" is just fundamentally wrong. You can only have real communities as long as the number of people is small enough. Once you cross Dunbar's number, it's no longer really a community but rather a cluster of partially overlapping communities. Maybe the more accurate term would be "society" instead of "community".
- adflux 6y agoDoes this type of content really fit on this platform?
- dimgl 6y agoI actually don’t want to see stuff like this on Hacker News. But I don’t make the rules.
- melenaboija 6y agoI hope it does
- fisf 6y agoI hope it fits in a courtroom first and foremost.
- marcinzm 6y agoThe crimes were mostly committed in foreign countries of which neither party is a resident and which the parties were only visiting for a short duration of time. Countries whose language the victim may not speak fluently or at all. The chance of getting the local police to care is low and even if they did the cost of flights to testify at trials would be beyond the means of the victim.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yoavm 6y agoYes, hackers care about their communities.
- McGlockenshire 6y ago> Yes, hackers care about their communities. The number of creep defenders in this thread suggests otherwise. See also: any discussion about codes of conduct.
- fabian2k 6y agoThe "share an AirBnB to be able to afford the conference" part seems particularly damning to me. That seems entirely premeditated and predatory.
- hamburglar 6y agoIn particular, if true, the part where he first encouraged her to invite other people and then when she expressed interest in that, accused her of trying to bring a “chaperone” sounds very much like premeditation. The initial invitation was designed to make her think it wasn’t just the two of them, but then he shamed her into acquiescing to that exact situation.
- mirekrusin 6y ago"seems" doesn't mean "is", we have law systems to deal with those kind of issues. Judges are for determining where the line between "shitty partner" vs "rapist" lies.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe author doesn't appear to want to make the claim that Mr. Pretty raped her. She suggests, strongly, that he's a shitty person. She wants other people to know this. Courts don't adjudicate such matters, unless they have further consequences.
- GavinMcG 6y ago"Insist[ing] on having intercourse regardless of me saying I didn’t want to" is rape.
- baobabKoodaa 6y ago"Insisting" on sex does not mean sex happened. If you're a shitty person and ask another person "come on have sex with me", and the other person says "no", and then you don't have sex, are you now a rapist?
- domano 6y agoThis is just downright disgusting, does somebody know if there have been consequences? I usually go to general or Go conferences and wonder if there is similiar stuff happening, but i have a good feeling since at least the go conferences alway emphasize inclusion. Lets hope this is true.
- ipaddr 6y agoEveryone is migrating Scala projects as we speak. This has very little to do with Scala and everything to do with the darkside of the conference scene. Getting involved with conferences at the level she did introduces travel - drugs - drinking - partying with somewhat like minded young people. The culture at the top can be about money, stars and groupies but it revolves around power. Those in charge decide who speak. Those who speak can get opportunity and money. Money buys speaker slots. Conferences are an anti pattern to programming.
- andrewzah 6y agoI must be going to the wrong conferences!
- domano 6y agoI have been going to conferences regularly for the past 9 years (eycept covid of course) and find them to be rather tame actually. Drinking is widely spread, but most other stuff i have not noticed. I also gave talks - maybe the community is different here in europe.
- jghn 6y agoI straddle a handful of domains in my professional life. Each of these domains has these stories come up from time to time. Further each domain talks about whisper networks where people alert newcomers who the bad actors are. I have come to view it as more likely that every community has these problems than to view it as a localized concern.
- swyx 6y agosimilar stories are emerging: - https://killnicole.github.io/statement/ https://killnicole.github.io/statement/ (edit i see she has added it to the article itself) - https://twitter.com/brianclapper/status/1387115214064193537?s=20 https://twitter.com/brianclapper/status/1387115214064193537?... - https://twitter.com/adelbertchang/status/1387090351626723329?s=20 https://twitter.com/adelbertchang/status/1387090351626723329... there seems to be some coordination here, as this came out pretty much at the same time. https://typelevel.org/blog/2021/04/27/community-safety.html https://typelevel.org/blog/2021/04/27/community-safety.html Yifan also linked to this piece on What You Can Do: https://hypatia.ca/2014/08/05/what-you-can-do/ https://hypatia.ca/2014/08/05/what-you-can-do/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- epicureanideal 6y agoSometimes character assassination is coordinated. I personally only slightly increase the probability of something being true when multiple accusers come forward. I still want to see proof. What if a bunch of your ex-girlfriends or ex-boyfriends got together and decided to ruin your life with accusations?
- joe5150 6y agowhy would they be motivated to do that?
- SamReidHughes 6y agoBecause he opposed Typelevel and defended Jon De Goes: https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1170098818286784512 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1170098818286784512
- lukasb 6y agoWhat proof would satisfy you? How is a victim of rape supposed to be able to supply that proof? Should women wear body cams at all times?
- tracer4201 6y agoNot to discount her story or what happened to her, but I’d be interested to hear his side of the story. I know nothing about this other than this one article, but I do know someone who committed suicide after a false rape accusation that stuck even after the accuser admitted to making it all up.
- dimgl 6y agoI’m not sure why you’re getting downvoted. Why shouldn’t we hear what he has to say? That being said, he’s already said he’s not going to be saying much on the matter.
- Vaslo 6y agohttps://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085?s=20 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085?s=...
- JPKab 6y agoJon Pretty sounds like a complete creep and yes, based on this account, a predator. That being said, there is a court and criminal justice system for a reason. While I empathize with the author, and utterly despise the archetype of high-status men who use their status within programming communities as a tool to target women, I find the nature of these kinds of posts to be counterproductive. Therapeutic to the author? Likely. A way to mobilize support? Certainly. But the method can be abused. Imagine a letter like this targeted at you one day, except unlike Mr. Pretty, you are innocent. Ask yourself if that's a possibility, and if you think that there is a zero probability of anyone maliciously weaponizing accusations of sexual misconduct. My brother was a victim of a vicious smear by a female colleague, who falsely accused him of stalking her as a result of him calling her out one day for stealing his project and presenting it while he was traveling to the funeral of his wife's grandfather. He was able to show video footage of him picking up his son and daughter at a daycare the very moment the woman claimed he was at her house, but by then, the HR department couldn't turn back, and he was fired. (He was later sent a large gift basket by several of his coworkers who had heard from someone in HR that the charges were false, but "optics" were the reason they had to move forward with his termination.)
- api 6y agoI don't like this court-of-public-opinion stuff much either and the abuse potential is real. At the same time: what else are people going to do? There seems to be no other recourse. Most people let bullies get away with it because even stepping in as a third party means standing up to a bully. It can be scary, but even if there's no real risk it's still a fucking pain in the ass. Who wants to get into a mud slinging competition with a predator? Or get a harassment lawsuit? If someone is willing to harass other people this way, they will certainly harass you this way.
- fishnchips 6y agoContact law enforcement.
- marcinzm 6y ago
- eloff 6y ago> I don’t remember how much I drank. I don’t remember him drinking. But I remember feeling uncomfortable when he made advances on me. I felt being taken advantage of that he had unprotected sex with me when I was intoxicated. Nothing felt right. I remember panicking and crying. I don't want to victim blame here because this guy sounds like a grade A creep and predator. But does a person not have some responsibility here to not get so intoxicated when alone with a member of the opposite sex in a private space? Because sometimes the person is consenting at the time and then regrets it later - and then proceeds to ruin the other person's life by accusing them of taking advantage of an intoxicated individual. I just find this whole area very slippery about when consent means consent and when it doesn't - especially the way sex, alcohol, and drugs are so intertwined in our society. I rightly or wrongly think you have to have some responsibility for putting yourself in such a vulnerable place where you are not in the right frame of mind to resist advances or make sensible decisions. Am I wrong about that? I don't know if she gave consent, and again, I'm inclined to give her the benefit of the doubt, based on her story, age, etc. I just want to discuss this whole business of consent while intoxicated on which I do not have a clear opinion.
- faitswulff 6y agoYes, you are victim blaming. Men aren’t wild bears, they’re human beings who should be held accountable for their actions. How drunk someone is around another human being has nothing to do with the perpetrator’s culpability.
- totony 6y agoI don't think that's what the parent meant. If someone is intoxicated, I agree that it seems weird to disregard their consent when drugs+alcohols are the social lubricant of society (and very interwined with sex). Also, of course you are responsible for your actions even when under the influence (drive and kill someone? no excuse because you were intoxicated - it's your fault). It's crazy to me that people call that "victim blaming". Although I understand how someone can take advantage of others, I don't think the distinction is intoxicated = taken advantage of.
- Kattywumpus 6y agoLet's just do away with the justice system entirely since social media seems to fulfill its functions perfectly.
- datavirtue 6y agoThis is actually a serious theory called anarcho-capitalism.
- calylex 6y agoYes. By Chomsky: "Anarcho-capitalism, in my opinion, is a doctrinal system which, if ever implemented, would lead to forms of tyranny and oppression that have few counterparts in human history. There isn't the slightest possibility that its (in my view, horrendous) ideas would be implemented, because they would quickly destroy any society that made this colossal error." Except we're seeing its horrendous ideas flourishing.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoRight. Just like the justice system would, social media will sentence him to the extremely harsh punishment of... not being invited to conferences anymore.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rayhu007 6y agoIt is terrible abuse and disgusting. Keep no silence, sue the predator and send him to where he deserve to be.
- typon 6y agoYou'd think this type of behaviour wouldn't happen anymore, given the whole MeToo movement and people constantly complaining about getting cancelled.
- throway98752343 6y agoThat's what makes me wonder if this kind of abuser can't help but do these things. But on the other hand, maybe anyone would, if conditions were right. These public callouts which occupy the area between keeping silent and taking legal action are like antibodies marking a potentially dangerous cell.
- DreamScatter 6y agoMaybe it didn't happen then?
- the-dude 6y agoI thought nothing in the post was particulary damning and all of it quite ambivalent.
- arkitaip 6y agoYou should come with a physical warning sign.
- willf 6y ago> I have reported all of my experience to the ScalaCenter in 2019. I was hoping to see concrete actions, such as building a reporting mechanism, to protect minorities in the community. Unfortunately, I am not aware of such actions taken. That sounds like a community failure, not just One Bad Guy.
- Tade0 6y agoMoreover, it appears that his behaviours were sort of an open secret - apparently this went on for years.
- alanlovestea 6y agoWhat can ScalaCenter do in this she said he said situation? If Yifan has any issue with Jon, she shall resolve the issue in court.
- jghn 6y agoI had the pleasure to get to know the author for a brief time in the period her article describes. Some of the surrounding events she describes were public knowledge via Twitter posts and such, for instance getting stranded in Berlin. From my outsider's vantage point I remember thinking something felt off about Jon's interactions/role in those stories. It was gut wrenching reading the article this AM realizing what was really going on.
- fishnchips 6y agoI have no interest in Scala and never heard of Jon Pretty nor his accuser but the accusations are of a criminal nature (either rape or slander) and it feels like as a society we've long developed more reliable tools and systems to deal with such matters.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoRight, a system where rape kits sit unprocessed for years
- oh_sigh 6y agoHow familiar are you with how Germany processes rape kits? I assume that you assume this was in America.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoGermany only moved to a consent-based legal definition of rape in 2016, so I’m not sure it has the best legal handling of rape either.
- js2 6y agoYes, of course she should have contacted law enforcement, but she was in a foreign country, intimated and young. And law enforcement still fails women: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/how-police-still-fail-rape-victims-97782/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/how-po... In an ideal world, the criminal justice system works. In the real world, it's a patchwork system that sometimes works and sometimes doesn't. https://www.washingtonpost.com/arts-entertainment/2019/09/17/unbelievable-true-story-behind-netflixs-gripping-new-drama-about-women-who-solved-serial-rape-case/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/arts-entertainment/2019/09/17... So this is why we see women continue to post these stories. Her story is backed up by other women. I believe her. Meta: I don't know how to make the justice system work better in a case like this. The presumption of innocence is critical and I don't want a system easily abused by false accusers, but it's also clear that predators can take advantage of the presumption of innocence. Even if she had gone to police at the time, ultimately she would have to convince them it wasn't consensual. https://slate.com/human-interest/2014/11/how-cops-respond-to-rape-a-new-study-of-officers-at-one-police-department.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2014/11/how-cops-respond-to... Edit 2: found this paper from 2012 written by a police organization that talks about the complexities of dealing with sexual assault in the criminal justice system: https://www.policeforum.org/assets/docs/Critical_Issues_Series/improving%20the%20police%20response%20to%20sexual%20assault%202012.pdf https://www.policeforum.org/assets/docs/Critical_Issues_Seri... A quote from the conclusion: Rape is the most underreported of crime, because rape victims find it so difficult under the best of circumstances to report it to the police. But it’s made worse when victims say they were interrogated by the police as though they were criminals. Or they are disbelieved and threatened with lie detector tests, or essentially are blamed for the conduct of perpetrators. Reading the paper, false accusations are barely discussed. The paper spends a lot more time talking about police not believing victims ("unfounding").
- dbg31415 6y agoIt's not that I don't believe her. It's just such a slippery slope. This is vigilantism -- the same as if you went out and shot a guy who stole your wallet. We don't trust victims of crimes to dole out punishments. Justice is tempered by due process, checks and balances, proportional response, all that. So I believe her, but I don't think the world is a better place when people use this approach to conflict resolution. I'd much rather see her go to court and get a conviction. This is just revenge.
- Graffur 6y agoI don't know who he is, who she is and I don't care about the scala 'community' too much, especially the types that give talks at conferences. The writing is like a story that is missing pages. Surely the law needs to be involved here?
- jenkstom 6y agoAnother person with a narcissistic personality disorder. I look forward to the day (I'll be long dead, unfortunately) when our society can recognize these people as evil and deal with them in a constructive way while protecting people from them.
- vsareto 6y agoActions make people evil, not personality disorders.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joelbluminator 6y agoIt's not looking pretty for Jon Pretty...
- jliving207 6y agoJohn Pretty is a troublesome character and as he reads through this comment section to find out how his reputation will be hurt by this... I hope it becomes a barrier for him to participate in the Scala Community with influence over others and the Programming Communities all around. Punish John Pretty IMO
- willeh 6y agoThis may be a tone-deaf sidetrack but also perhaps an important piece of advice for some. There should be an impenetrable barrier between ones love life and ones professional life. While there are certainly people who have met their significant other in a professional setting, there are much better ways of doing that, especially nowadays. By striving to keep this separation water tight we can avoid both unwanted advances and false allegations. The above is not comment on the allegations in the post, any more than if everyone followed the above basic principle we would not have to deal with disturbing stories such as this one. It is important that stories such as this one are told but perhaps with the names left out.
- jnwatson 6y agoThat's simply unrealistic and unhelpful. That the author met this person in a professional setting is beside the point. It would be just as serious if it happened at a hobby event.
- willeh 6y agoPerhaps `professional` is too narrow then. I think the power differential is an enabling factor for behaviour like this. While there certainly are creeps in normal dating situations, they are often easier to avoid. This story is very much about how this power differential allows one person to abuse another like this. Being aware of how this affects human relationships is neither unrealistic nor unhelpful. It is something to take seriously and talk about in groups where it could arise.
- tucosan 6y agoI've seen careers of members of both sexes ruined because people let the pheromones cloud their judgment. The number one golden rule of professionalism: never f--- at the factory. Don't make advances. Don't even flirt.
- noobermin 6y agoThis is probably good advice but if people are spending more and more of their time at work and work starts becoming half of their life, with outings with coworkers, bosses being your friend and not just your boss, then where can you meet people exactly? You can't honestly demand both that people be disconnected from their coworkers and that they make work be 90% of their life. One part has to give (preferably the latter part).
- Shadonototro 6y agoWhat this story has to do with the whole "scala community"? Seems like she is naive and got seduced by someone, nothing crazy Why always portraying womens as weak people, c'mon
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rlmenu 6y agoLots of comments obviously focus on the issue whether this is truth or slander. There is another angle to this: A word of advice for new people in OSS. You do not need to go to conferences to be successful in the field. Many of the developers who actually write code do not attend conferences. On the other hand, people who want to associate themselves with the work of others, narcissists, activists of all kinds, parasites and a lot more are to be found in the conference circuits. There are some legit people as well but you'll also find them online where the work happens.
- noobermin 6y agoPainfully true but kind of unfortunate as young professionals are often pushed into going to conferences as a way to get ahead in their career.
- mrlonglong 6y agoIt's time these women came forward and reported the person to the police. As with #metoo, justice does indeed gets handed out, it just takes time. The only thing I'm sad about is the considerable amount of pain and suffering these women have to endure. Hugs all.
- mr_vox 6y agoThis case is one of thousands
- kweinber 6y agoFor those claiming this should be handled in courts: 1) you know it won’t be… especially internationally at the expense of the accuser that has to go through an extradition process. 2) it is still valuable to warn others that a predator is on the loose. 3) it’s already been publicly corroborated by someone else who had a similar experience and you can expect others to follow.
- mr_vox 6y agoThis case in one of thousands
- rayiner 6y ago> As an inexperienced young woman from a patriarchal culture, I was running away from the stereotype of being thought of as someone “traditional”. I should, like he implied, and wanted to be “cool about everything that happened”. “Just be cool” is such an abusive and manipulative behavior I’m flummoxed at how it’s lasted this long as socially acceptable.
- orwin 6y agoEveybody's talking about the "woke culture", "cancel culture" and all that and how it is bad for the society. The "cool culture" and associated social pressure is probably the single worst "culture" that happened in the last forty years, killed at least thousands and pushed even more to accept unacceptable things.
- Benlights 6y agoJon Pretty responds https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085/photo/1 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085/ph...
- hamburglar 6y agoI always try to remain approachable and supportive. Through this openness, I’ve nailed a lot of girls.
- Zelphyr 6y agoThere is a lot about the sexual events in this post that, to me, highlights something I feel is important which is: we parents need to get better had having conversations with our children around sex. This girl was feeling uncomfortable and crying but at the same time "didn't think those behaviors were problematic". I can't help but wonder if her parents never sat her down and discussed situations like this and, I get it. That's a really uncomfortable conversation to have with your child. It is, however, an important one. This doesn't just apply to girls by the way. We parents need to be telling our sons what kind of behavior is and isn't acceptable. It's not enough to expect them to figure it out. Who are they figuring it out from if not us? Probably other inexperienced boys. Please don't rush to put words in my mouth by thinking I am suggesting the guy in the article is innocent of the accusations. I'm making no commentary on either party from this article. That's for the courts to decide should one or both parties choose to take that course of action. I'm simply saying it is important that parents overcome their discomfort around discussions of sex with their children so that the children can make informed decisions.
- faitswulff 6y ago+1 but especially our boys. Girls and women already learn so much about how to avoid being harmed by men. It’s time for our boys to learn how to become kind men - and for those of us who are men to model that for them.
- analognoise 6y agoDoesn't this remove agency from women? If two adults get together, fly together, get a room together, drink wine together, have relations... Then we're supposed to say that consent can't be given because the woman is drunk. But they're both drunk. Isn't it essentially the patriarchy to say that a woman can't make that choice? Like if they're equals and they're both drunk, why do we blame the men? Because they aren't really equals? Isn't that what we're fighting against? We blame the men for not ignoring the wishes of the woman while drunk. It's a little bit chauvinistic to think the men know better isn't it?
- 6y ago
- chovybizzass 6y agoI'm just going to stay away from Scala altogether now.
- umvi 6y agoJon Pretty's response: https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085/photo/1 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085/ph...
- tester756 6y agowas there a quarter without drama in Scala community? :o
- voces 6y agoSince the pattern is so similar, I now recognize this as a form of harmful #metoo activism. - Attack entire community, not individuals - Court of Public Social Justice - The charges amount to unwanted advances being made during a social interaction where that would be acceptable -- not sexual harassment, nor illegal behavior. Compare https://medium.com/@kristianlum/statistics-we-have-a-problem-304638dc5de5 https://medium.com/@kristianlum/statistics-we-have-a-problem... Make the problem about an entire industry: Holywood, Scala, MIT, Statistics. Garantuee public shaming and punishment for your target, by calling out criticism or disbelief as "victim shaming", people calling for you to lose your job, because they got angry reading a Medium post, not because you've been proven guilty by someone without a bias. Ending up in an apartment with someone in another country, drinking wine, but not remembering how much you drank, but you do remember that he did not drink anything (to play up him taking advantage over you), then crying and feeling upset, because someone makes an advance towards you, instead of feeling flattered and politely declining. Going skinny dipping at night in the sea with a bunch of clumsy rowdy tipsy researchers, then blaming an advance someone makes, on conference culture. Go to the police, get your day in court, and let justice prevail. Not going to join a mob, because someone made you cry once. Even giving the experience sympathy would needlessly rile me up. I'd like to think about other negative things when interacting with Scala and its community, preferably technical.
- GavinMcG 6y ago> because someone makes an advance towards you, instead of feeling flattered and politely declining Convenient to leave out the rape in the next sentence, and the other rape in the next paragraph: > I felt being taken advantage of that he had unprotected sex with me when I was intoxicated. Nothing felt right. I remember panicking and crying. > There was another time that he insisted on having intercourse regardless of me saying I didn’t want to. Sorry you don't like to think about that.
- voces 6y agoShe talks like a doll lacking any kind of autonomy. It is not "we had sex", but "he had sex with me". I don't know any woman who does not want to have unprotected sex, but just let it happen like that. Then come back for seconds, even though she is not in the mood. Are there naive young women who lack self-authority and self-esteem to say no, to an older man who needs those women to get their fix and wants to make up for their unpopular youth? Yes. And that awkward dance of nature takes two to tango. Panicking and crying during or after sex does not a "rape" make (but the definition depends on jurisdiction anyway, and we haven't even let a court in the right jurisdiction look if it qualifies, so I'd like to avoid that term). Unless you want to claim openly that a named person is now a serial rapist. I'd like to think it takes more than a Medium post for you to do that.
- tiew9Vii 6y ago> in the Scala community The allegations are serious. If the author believes she was drunk and did not consent to unprotected sex and taken advantage of that should be reported to the police and the courts due to the seriousness, it’s rape. The title is damaging “in the Scala community” it tarnishes a programming language and individuals who use the language due to the act of one person. The language is dieing with dramas among 1-2 specific people out of thousands. No one in the right mind would condone the allegations or the perpetrator and sounds like at least one incident a matter for the police. The allegations are against an individual and the ScalaCenter handling, not the community. The blog post lists individual people in the community who supported the author. I do wish the title wasn’t as click bait or more specific to the perpetrators as it is damaging, killing a really interesting industry and technology. I hope the author finds the peace and justice they deserve from sharing this. The public naming and shaming will have serious repercussions for the accused.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- o_p 6y agoWomen sleeps with infuential person and smears them after they are well positioned.
- throwaway800869 6y agoMany Hacker News users belabor the "innocent until proved guilty" angle when it comes to sexual assault. Could it be that users of a software focused site are overcorrecting for the threat of being labeled creeps?
- secondcoming 6y agoPresumption of innocence isn't 'an angle', it's a human right. Jesus christ
- rodgerd 6y agoInnocent victim of mob justice, Jimmy Saville. Innocent victim of mob justice, Jeff Epstein.
- rozab 6y agoThere has been a common theme in this thread that the justice system should just sort it all out. Leaving aside all the issues of jurisdiction and citizenship that make a prosecution vanishingly unlikely here, the criminal justice system is just not cut out for dealing with cases of rape. To prove it beyond reasonable doubt would require a level of evidence that is simply not present here. And in the UK, a suspect is only charged with a crime in 1.4% of reported cases[0]. This is why its so sickening when people gloat that some defendant in a sexual abuse case was found not guilty; it really doesn't mean they didn't commit the crime. But even though the criminal justice system is not cut out for this kind of thing, that doesn't mean we have no other recourse. The reason the standard for evidence is so high is because the system would otherwise be vulnerable to abuse, and the consequences of wrongful conviction (loss of liberty or even execution) are so grave. Whether or not you agree that this very high standard is justified (I don't), it is clear that the consequences of publicly calling out this behaviour are less serious. Social ostracisation within a very specific community isn't such a big deal, but the direct benefits (protecting women through awareness) may be almost as good. Whether or not you agree with the above, it's definitely an issue we need to think about. All it takes is someone close to you going through this to realise that the pre-MeToo system is inadequate. This new one isn't ideal, but it's a million times better. If you can think of a way to make things better then I want to hear it. [0]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-48095118 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-48095118
- nindalf 6y ago@dang I’m sad that this was flagged. It would be nice if you or some other mod could explain why this decision was taken.
- dang 6y agoMods don't flag submissions; users do. See https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#flag https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#flag. I turned off the flags on the post when I first saw it (before it made the front page) but it has gone through a couple of different phases since then.
- nindalf 6y agoThanks for the quick response.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agoI don’t give two damns about Scala and its community, and I neither believe nor disbelieve the linked post, but boy oh boy does it remind me of the academia in some (many?) countries, where educational/academic advancement per vaginam has been practically an unwritten norm for decades, to the joy of many a creepy professor!
- chmod600 6y agoIs the open source community harder to escape from, if you are a victim? If it's just one company, maybe you can switch. If it's open source, you probably need to switch jobs and discard a lot of your expertise.
- Vaslo 6y agoLooks like he made a response. https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085?s=20 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085?s=...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ie21 6y agowhat does this have to do with Scala community? she was harassed by many people who use Scala? Did they all wear Nike? What mobile phones were they using, iphone, huawei? Clickbait, trying to ruin a reputation? To what effect is this article written is the central question. Woman, use your head and learn from experience. Unbelievable, the times we are living in. I wouldn't speak to this woman ever, who knows what she might write about it years later. This is insane to go public like this about your private life, and again, to what effect? You don't have to be above average intelligence to understand the whys of this drama. Jesus...
- kazinator 6y ago> I maintained friendship with him for a few months after May, because I was convinced that it was all consensual and I didn’t want to “make a big scene” like he accused me of. So for months, the victim herself was convinced it was consensual, but I, the reader, in the space of a few paragraphs, am supposed be convinced that it wasn't? If I imagine this sentence prefixed with "Your Honor", I can see it not going very well for the plaintiff.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoGeneral PSA from someone who has studied such things: 1. Alcohol is the number one date rape drug and it's problematic in part because men tend to have a much higher tolerance than women. 2. Date rape frequently involves two people from different cultures with different social expectations. This often fosters terrible misunderstandings. 3. It's always problematic to "try a case" in the court of public opinion. Probably better to try to use a piece like this as a jumping off point for general discussion of the problem space and not an attempt to determine what "really" happened in this instance. 4. It's good to think about what women can do differently to try to protect themselves. Trying to talk about that is not, per se, blaming the victim anymore than it is blaming the victim to say "It's a bad neighborhood. Make sure you lock your car." 5. When someone is a habitual offender and genuinely a predator, their victim can do all the right things and still get assaulted. 6. Whether a woman did or did not do all the right things, a man choosing to assault her is still on him, just like you are still a thief even if someone failed to lock their car.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI continue to appreciate your appraisals and summaries, thank you. Your comments on tricky topics tend to lean more toward actionables, rather than the perpetual rehashing same arguments the rest of this comment section is filled with.
- tene 6y agoI'm curious if you or anyone else can share more detail or some examples regarding cross-cultural differences in societal expectations. I've got some guesses about what this might mean, but I haven't studied this, and don't have any personal experience here.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoA fairly obvious one: If you are from a culture where sex before marriage is permissible and you are a woman, men from cultures where women are expected to remain virgins until the wedding night may see you as "a loose woman." In such cases, they may even feel entitled to have you and get very mad if you try to tell them no. People from very conservative cultures tend to wildly misinterpret the actions of women from more liberated and empowered cultures. Her behavior may be viewed as promiscuous or as leading him on when she's doing no such thing. Some cultures expect a man to have to pursue a woman pretty hard before she says "yes." I read one article where a man from such a culture was sort of frustrated or disappointed when his lady from another culture gave it up too easily in his view. He wasn't happy at not having to "work for it."
- tucosan 6y agoI find these hit peaces extremely problematic. The public doesn't have the tools to properly investigate the accusations. It is impossible for anyone but the parties involved (and maybe not even them) to know what really happened. This woman could have gone to the police. She could have gone to one of the many support organisations for rape victims here in Berlin or in the US. She could have gone to the police even years later, which would have opened the possiblity of an official investigation. Instead she chooses to publicly write about it, without first even trying to take the legal route.
- nickysielicki 6y agoJon Pretty responded on twitter with the following: https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085 https://twitter.com/propensive/status/1387168037908910085 > I've been aware for some time that a short relationship I had with another Scala developer in 2018, which is the subject of a blog post published today, was being discussed increasingly widely within the Scala community. A second post relating to an earlier, two-year relationship has also been published today. > While I have no desire to discuss my private life in public, both posts contain several falsehoods, and I strongly reject their characterizations of me. > I have always believed in unbiased kindness towards others, and given the relatively few women using Scala, plus my role as a prominent figure within the Scala community, I have gone out of my way to be as welcoming as possible to newcomers. This kindness extends to everyone in the community. And at the conferences I frequently attend or organize, I always try to make myself approachable and supportive. > Through this openness, and over the last few years, during which time the Scala community has been the main focus of most of my activities, I have formed many friendships which have developed both at conferences and online. In the last decade, a tiny number of these proceeded, over a period of weeks or months, to become romantic relationships. They did so gradually, and with the full consent and cooperation of all parties. > I have no doubt that both women who have published posts today were hurt when our relationships ended. So was I. But the nature of relationships is that many of them do end, and that does not always happen amicably. However, I stand by how I behaved during both relationships, and after they ended. The suggestions that I acted improperly are false or, at best, misinterpretations of my intent. I am happy to be independently scrutinised on any of the points raised. > The nature of the claims that have been made is serious, and I do not discount that. But they are one-sided, retrospective revisions of the history of those relationships, which have evolved over the last three years. > Nevertheless, given the open letter against me, I feel that regardless of the baselessness of these claims, it would not be appropriate for me to continue to participate at Scala conferences, so I shall no longer do so. > I do not intend to discuss this matter further in public. > - Jon Pretty (OCR'd with tesseract)
- AzzieElbab 6y agoWhat does this have to do with the scala community? We all knew and covered for Jon Pretty because he is the Harvey Weinstein of scala?
- soueuls 6y agoDefinitely someone I would consider a creep and I would advise introvert women to stay away from. Because his manners seem to be quite predatory, and he tried to keep in touch with her while she asked him to back off. But I can't really consider him a rapist, I read her statement, I read his. She repeatedly shows she was unsure about her feeling, she doubted herself, she even remained friends for several months. Having sex with a drunk stranger is pretty lame, but all of these things make me believe she did not explicitly refused, she probably went along, internally horrified but externally somewhat willing. I don't know what I would do if many years after, someone called me out publicly by claiming they did not consent, I would certainly feel sorry I hurt someone, but I would not consider myself a rapist and would treat myself like one.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoI think what's possibly needed is a return to a more traditional relationship and dating culture. In the past, if a man had a dalliance with with a woman and she got pregnant, he was expected to marry her. Now we expect women to have to be responsible for their own decisions the way men are, but women are generally more emotionally vulnerable than men, due to their more compassionate and less aggressive personalities, and are more easily manipulated as a result. Therefore it may be up to men to not abuse that. This was the assumption in place in the past, which is why young women often had chaperones present during close interactions with men, and why the 'marriage if pregnancy' responsibility was placed on men. We've tried the 'rawr girl power, women can do everything men can do' culture, and the result is scores of women being used and taken advantage of because they were not capable, emotionally/temperamentally, to be their own advocate in sex and dating interactions.
- cloudfifty 6y agoThat's a deeply misogynistic take. What do you base this on?
- CryptoPunk 6y agoHow is it misogynistic? I base it on the prevalence of stories like this, where a woman ostensibly consents to sexual advances and later regrets it and feels she had be abused. The issue is not consent. The issue is vulnerability. Women are generally more vulnerable to advances from men and more likely to consent to an interaction when it's not in their best interest, than men would be, due to well documented physiological and psychological differences between the sexes.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt essentially assumes incompetence on the part of women. That's not the only possible explanation. I don't even think it's the most plausible explanation. Social pressure and upbringing are large factors in human behavior and it takes time to make society-wide changes.
- dd444fgdfg 6y agoIt's so hard to talk about something like this objectively because momentum of the mob towards the popular discourse makes it almost impossible to detach. The woman does not say she was raped or anything happened to her without her consent (unless I missed that in which case I apologize and retract this comment, but I couldn't find it). The person currently being cancelled was a "community leader" (apparently) but was not her boss, teacher, or in official power over her. It sounds like he is a creep who manipulates women to be with him. What specifically did he do differently from any other guy who tries to "woo" a woman? These women consented to be with him at the time for the perceived benefits of being close to the community leader and what comes with it. They are adult women who made decisions. Now they want to retrospectively apply alternative morals to their actions at the time because they wish they didn't do that. You did this, it didn't happen to you.
- ookblah 6y agothings like this always make me shake my head and his "statement" on twitter doesn't do anything to help his case, twitter mob be damned. so generic (imo). he was in a high position of power and used that to set up situations that were dubious at best. if he even did like 25% of what was claimed he deserves whatever is coming. it's like the boss having questionable relationships w/ his employees then turning around and hiding behind the "it was consensual so that's that!" without understanding the fucking power dynamics.
- hiram112 6y agoI remember the first clue that Reddit was going downhill FAST was when I needed to "sort by controversial" on nearly every thread within every single mainstream sub because the hivemind had become both so ridiculously uniform and because the algorithms had become so blatantly biased against anyone with a differing point of view, that even if many others agreed, it would be almost impossible to see these comments organically using the defaults. We are now at that point on HN.
- scala__alacs 6y agoI'd like to give a Scala community "insider perspective" on Jon Pretty. Something always felt off about him. Being quite involved in the Scala community myself, I can tell you that the impact of his technical contributions is basically zero. None of the projects he developed along the years has had any momentum (save for one, called "magnolia", which has a modest userbase). He was giving more talks than anyone else in the community, solely based on vague ideas he couldn't even make happen. He was always bluffing somehow, presenting himself as some kind of grand architect pursuing grand ideas, while his effective impact was close to zero. He wanted to be perceived as someone influential, but simply didn't have the technical level for it, nor put the effort in. I think he was tolerated just because he's been around since basically the language was created, and thus was friend with many people, and could tell stories about the early days of Scala. With him (hopefully) going away, this will have no impact at all on the development of Scala or related projects, apart from saving slots at upcoming Scala conferences.
- adultSwim 6y agoParallels with Jacob Appelbaum
- ogintherapgame 6y agoThe girl had sex with a creepy manipulative dude and regrets it. I get it. She's obviously super naive. "Yup we can share an Airbnb, i'll bring the wine!". There's obvious sexual overtones there if you are in your 20's, no matter what any of you say. And having spoken at a conference does not put you in a position of power. He's just a creep, they are pretty common, confident outgoing girls will turn down a creep every weekend. Does not warrant public shaming. I'd be pissed if some girl i texted "Wanna get it ;-8" on tinder, in a blizzard of hormones, three years back, decides to public and destroy my career. I'd be pissed and it wouldn't be fair. That said i'm glad she did, because he sounds like a complete tool. The perpetual conference go'er crowd is full of weirdos.
- adultSwim 6y agoThis abuse is a huge issue in every single community and organization. When we aren't actively rooting it out, we are allowing it to flourish.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- james_smith_007 6y agoFirst world problems. There is no such thing as "harrasment". Someone f... with someone. It was not blackmail or physical coercion, so it's just your free will, period.