13 ms·
Less news, more opinion. Try to find out what's happening with the ship stuck in the Suez Canal. The amount of punditry and opinion far exceeds the actual info
by Animats 6y ago
Less news, more opinion.
Try to find out what's happening with the ship stuck in the Suez Canal. The amount of punditry and opinion far exceeds the actual info.
One of the few useful reports today is from Al-arabiya.[1] They probably have people on site.
[1] https://english.alarabiya.net/News/middle-east/2021/03/28/Tugs-dredgers-continuing-efforts-to-free-ship-stranded-in-Suez-Canal-Authority https://english.alarabiya.net/News/middle-east/2021/03/28/Tu...
[2] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/3/28/tugs-dredgers-still-work-to-refloat-ship-blocking-suez-canal https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/3/28/tugs-dredgers-still...
- inglor_cz 6y agoOpinion would be OK if it did not pose as news. People can see the attempt at cloaking subjective opinion as objective news and do not like it.
- fermienrico 6y agoIt needs to go in the reverse direction to correct. We need less opinions than ever.
- inglor_cz 6y agoOpinions are fine in places like Substack, where people actually pay to read them. Out in the ad-supported world of supposedly free content, yes, fewer opinions would be a boon.
- noxer 6y agoOpinions backed by facts would be fine. If someone explains why he has the opinion he has then I can agree/disagree/provide a better reasoning for another opinion etc. But most of the opinions voiced are either not backed by anything or backed by one of the most common logical fallacy.
- parineum 6y agoIt's not just that, opinions are intertwined with (often) cherry picked facts in such a way that it blurs the line between them. When writing in a style that I'd closely associate with how I'd like journalism written, I often find myself taking the beginning few sentences/paragraph to explain the facts of the situation as I understand it and the rest on what I think about it or why I think it occurred, etc. I write this way because I am very open to corrections on the facts and my opinions may change wildly if those facts are corrected or updated so stated the basis for my thoughts up front helps provide context. My opinions and explanations are a lot less malleable if the facts don't change. I'm open to expanding and discussing my opinions but they usually evolve rather than fully change. It's hard for me to really speculate on the driving force or the motive behind what we see in journalism today (or whether it's new) but it's very clear to me that the intent of the articles written don't seem to be clarity between fact and opinion.
- noxer 6y agoThe classic is "backed by statistics" so both sides pick the statistics that confirms their opinion. Last seen just these days in US media about guns/gun crime/shootings etc. etc. There are so many statistics which all define mass shootings however they want and its super easy to find the "facts" you need for whatever point you wanna bring across.
- SllX 6y agoI want fewer opinions in any publication I'm paying for news reports. I also pay for entertainment, and even to read someone's opinion, but these are separate products for separate purposes. The revenue model is really beside the point. Opinion-infested reports where the writer is casting aspersions, making judgements, serving vanguard for some cause or presenting the writer's own opinion as part of the narrative are worthless to me. It's fine to have opinions as long as 1. that is what you are intending to sell and 2. you acknowledge this and are upfront about it.
- koolba 6y agoOpinion is fine. The more opinions the better. But claiming some opinions are verboten or others must be accepted as fact rapidly destroys any historical reputation for a media organization. It’s gotten so bad that a the NYT apologized for letting a sitting US Senator (Tom Cotton)[1] publish an op-ed that diverged with the views of its subscribers. I might think that Senator Warren is an idiot, but I have no issue with her expressing her stupidity. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/04/business/new-york-times-op-ed-cotton.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/04/business/new-york-times-o...
- cozuya 6y agoYES, some opinions are verboten! Opinions that advocate for actively hurting people, that are illegal, should not be hosted by media companies! How is that possibly a bad thing?
- koolba 6y agoBanning opinions for “things that are illegal” would ban everything from discussion about drug legalization to same sex marriage. The current legal status of a topic has no bearing on whether someone can make a cogent argument for or against it. Things that are illegal likely deserve more public forum for thought and discussion.
- cozuya 6y agoThis is a glaringly bad faith interpretation of my post. You know what I meant - an op-ed featuring say a pro-pedophilia stance should not be published in a national media. This is not "discussion" or "public forum".
- patcon 6y agoRespectfully, and with kindness not provocation: This "you know what I meant" sensibility, when many people don't know what you mean or simply have very different bedrock views that must first be engaged with and laboured on (if not you, then by someone) -- I feel this is part of the chilling effect of the view you're espousing here, and which others are downvoting you for <3 To clarify, i am not talking about pedophilia here, but other "obvious" things
- marcusverus 6y agoThe real kicker is that the most respected publications are also guilty of this. The New York Times is currently being sued for defamation by Project Veritas. The NYT argued, on the public record, that they should be able to state opinions as fact outside of the Op-Ed section[0]. I read this as the NYT arguing that they have a license to lie with impunity on the front page. If we live in a post-truth era, it's not because of the internet or the shitty click-bait 'news' sources that proliferate. It's because these institutions, like the NYT and WaPo, in which we used to be able to expect an objective accounting of the facts, have devolved into the personal Pravdas of a few well-educated idiots who thought that they could steer the country in a better direction, but only managed to drive us into a ditch. [0](see p. 5/16)https://assets.ctfassets.net/syq3snmxclc9/maEy58HDFCR7qdtFObWXx/46c075c522acef6a169b7ce051f8955c/Order_denying_motion_to_dismiss.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/syq3snmxclc9/maEy58HDFCR7qdtFOb...
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoPerhaps it is time to actually start paying for news, like Bloomberg and the finance industry.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seibelj 6y agoI do pay for news - The Economist, The WSJ, and various podcasts. But I pay because it’s valuable.
- fakedang 6y agoWSJ has declined to a significant level imo. Can't pass by some articles without hearing the phrase "radical left media" or "liberal media" or whatever. Financial news and if US business news coverage isn't super important to be granular for you, then go for the gold standard which is the Financial Times. The Economist approach doesn't appeal much to me, since most of the time they are like a free-market hammer to which everything looks like a nail. Tech news, Stratechery.
- jrockway 6y agoI think opinion devalues the brand of news. People will share opinion columns from a newspaper on social media, people will begin to associate that source with propaganda (especially if they disagree with the opinion), and then when that source publishes hard news they disagree with, they'll brand it fake news. While newspapers go on and on about how they separate the editorial desk from the news desk, it doesn't matter when they both have the same company's name up at the top. To some extent, this devalues the brand of all news. I'm sure that the Trump supporters who think The New York Times is fake news also don't read The Wall Street Journal. Even though the Journal has pretty conservative slate opinion columnists (and editorial board), people won't even consider it because they think all mainstream media is fake. (It never tells them what they want to hear; the real world without spin is VERY BORING.)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoAny reputable news org clearly labels opinion pieces as such.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoAll of news is opinion. That's how you get news! People decide what's noteworthy, or notable about it. You would literally not have news if people did this. You'd just be reading every single blade of grass or bug or bird or sneeze or sleepless night.
- throwaway2037 6y agoPaid content is awful. Even worse when the notice for paid content is very small. The whole thing feels dirty. Sometime in the last two years, The Financial Times wrote and featured (front page!) paid content for Saudi Arabia's Aramco as a company that is helping with the climate crisis. Truly, it felt like FT's reputation was for sale to the highest bidder. I also read some Singaporean print media. Various ministries in the single party gov't regularly pays local media to write "paid content". Without fail, the notice about paid content is not obvious or hard to find. What a shame.
- jostmey 6y agoThat is a symptom not the cause. News agencies have had to slash their budgets and can no longer afford to send journalist to cover stories
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIf only we had some kind of organization that would let news outfits pool their resources. Some kind of "associated press" or something.
- fakedang 6y agoAP is famous for underpayment of outsourced journalists and even then cheating them out of their earnings on some BS clause, apart from overcharging newspapers to use their content. They are also famous for trying to block an open press in the Meltwater vs AP case. My ex who was a freelance video producer for a while gave me numbers that showed AP paid for 10-20x less consistently than a regional outlet (like Al Arabiya or CBC).
- raarts 6y agoTrue. Newspapers, radio and TV used to be on the receiving end of most of the ad money. That has gone away almost completely over the last 25 years. And now they have to fight for clicks.
- BikiniPrince 6y agoI think you are close. The reality is they can sale sensationalism at dime store prices. There is no need to be a real news outlet when they can mimic “The Sun.” There is no cost and all profit to just printing garbage. In the short term. This is trading your credentials for cash. Eventually, people will wisen and realize this is not journalism. It will cost them dearly then, but that is the future. Who worries about the future?
- ergocoder 6y agoIf it is more news, it will be like "A former US president said covid wasn't real". The news reports accurately what happens. But we would still hate it. But tbh I actually prefer reporting the news, not opinion. If Donald Trump (a former president) causes lives with his lies, we should handle him through a legal mean, not through blackmailing a news channel to ban what he says.
- Black101 6y agoAll these millions lost daily and we can't even get a live video feed.... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oWPbXJ0AqIs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oWPbXJ0AqIs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyLeJUHuOGM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyLeJUHuOGM
- gruez 6y agoWhat's the point of getting live video feed of a static ship?
- Black101 6y agoto see the progress of their efforts? was that a serious question? Sometimes 2021 feels like the 1950s...
- gruez 6y ago>to see the progress of their efforts yeah but they're not making much progress, so what's the point? It's like watching paint dry.
- Black101 6y agoYou could watch it at 10x speed 10 years from now if someone was recording it (I'm pretty sure satellites are recording it but I'm not sure how much the footage cost)
- gruez 6y agoI'm not sure what your point is. Sure, it'll be interesting to watch, but the bar for a new organization to a crew to gather live footage is far higher than "some people would find it vaguely interesting".
- Black101 6y agoI'm pretty sure some random Egyptian could monetize their live footage on YouTube... and also, I would like to see it. I don't understand why it needs to be a news organization streaming it... Is it how that country works? (IE: Do they block anyone else from publishing data about this event, a bit like what China would do?)
- axiolite 6y agoThe Al-arabiya article even references Reuters. They've been my go-to news source for many years: https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-egypt-suezcanal-ship/diggers-and-dredgers-struggle-to-free-ship-blocking-suez-canal-idUSKBN2BK09G https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-egypt-suezcanal-ship/digg...
- fakedang 6y agoYour go-to news source is Al Arabiya, a state-owned propaganda channel that is owned by an autocratic regime (Saudi Arabia), and is not even trusted by Arabs themselves? Or is it Reuters?
- beloch 6y agoIf you're a penny-pinching American news channel, a panel of pundits is a lot cheaper than having somebody in the field, whether that's a field correspondent or just a freelancer. Every time something happens in some far-flung corner of the globe you need new people and equipment on the spot, but your in-house pundits are always ready to show up to the studio and bloviate. Talking about other people's reporting is cheaper than doing your own reporting. The question is, can American news conglomerates not afford to do proper reporting, or have they just found that it's more profitable to leave that to others? To put it another way, if we found ways to bring more money back into journalism (e.g. By making companies like Google and facebook to pay for news content), how much of that money is likely to be spent on actual reporting? I have a sinking feeling that the pundits are here to stay.
- fma 6y agoThat's an interesting observation and in hindsight obvious. Back in the day we had news in the morning...news at noon and then some nightly news. The major networks (ABC, NBC) would play other random TV shows the rest of the time and make money. Now with 24/x7 news...they literally need to fill the time with some form of "news" and as you pointed out...pundits was their solution.
- Consultant32452 6y agoLet's not forget the FaceBook effect. Once news companies started getting instant feedback on their views via countable clicks/shares, it really showed them where the money is. A website starts up that just shows police brutality, gets millions of shares. Guess what's making the news? Now comes SEO style key-word packing. Lots of shares on police brutality? And racism? And lgbtq? Well, here's my cross-sectional news story that contains racist police brutality against lgbtq and even though the police officer was a minority this really just demonstrates internalized white supremacy.
- watwut 6y ago"if it bleeds it leads" predates facebook.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoLatest from nytimes: >A new tugboat has joined the ranks of those struggling to free the giant cargo ship blocking the crucial Suez Canal maritime route. Syria, citing the blockage, rations fuel, and Lebanon warns of a similar problem. What's the problem?
- dingoegret 6y agoThat outlet is a US psyop.
- scottlamb 6y ago> One of the few useful reports today is from Al-arabiya.[1] They probably have people on site. I'm guessing you meant to say the Al Jazeera article? In that Al Arabiya one I see clues they have no direct reporting: * Only a stock photo of the ship, not anything from the current event * Quotes and sources only by way of other media organizations ("Egypt’s Extra News", "Egyptian state TV", "Reuters"). * And facts I could get myself via vesselfinder.com or wikipedia ("321 ship stuck", "About 15 percent of world shipping traffic transits the Suez Canal.") I could have written this article from my home in the US despite having no meaningful knowledge of the Middle East or shipping. The Al Jazeera one has a photo of the ship actually in the canal and at least one direct quote. (Interestingly, they also have info from Rabie by way of Al Arabiya, which is not in the Al Arabiya article you linked. Looks like the Al Jazeera article was written later though given the count of waiting ships is higher.)
- throwaway2037 6y agoAgree. Even for The Financial Times, I have seen the same pattern over the last five years. Each year, it seems they push more and more commentary. Honestly, I have no idea if this strictly marketing (organisation of "front page") or actual budget changes. If anyone works in the news making business, can you comment about the cost of opinion vs non-opinion (fact-based) reporting? I assume opinion (pundits) are cheaper than non-opinion reporters. Why? Much less travel & location costs. Deeper: Can you imagine the cost of placing a highly educated reporter into a developing country with their family and children? I first thought about this after reading that Peter Hessler and and Leslie Chang were moving to Cairo to work for The New Yorker (TNY). Surely, their children will attend private international schools, where tuition would be paid for by TNY. And what about apartment / security / car-and-driver / yada-yada? I am not against any of it, but the total family package cost must be incredible! (Again: If anyone has first hand knowledge of overseas reporter living packages, please comment below!)
- jfengel 6y agoI think it's the same news, but more hours. So the rest is opinion. The news used to be something that came on at 11 PM and was over by 11:30. Then there was another half-hour of local news. That was it. And of those 30 minutes apiece, at most 12 would actually be news (aside from fluff, commercials, sports [which aren't really news], etc). Now news is a 24 hour thing, but there isn't 23 more hours of stuff going on. At least, not stuff that people would tune in to hear about. And since it's all the most engaging stuff, you basically get the same 12 minutes of news per day and the rest is yammering.