35 ms·
Dyson air purifier outperformed by cheap DIY box fan filter in Marketplace test
- post_break 6y agoI bought an expensive Dyson air purifier for a couple of reasons. It has a remote so I can turn it on from bed. It looks attractive. The sound profile is much different than a box fan for sleeping at night. It can analyze the temperature, humidity, and air quality in real time and turn on if it notices air quality is getting bad. It also oscillates. That said yes it was expensive, but it replaced needing a fan for cooling and an air purifier, and if I needed a heater it could have done triple duty.
- rconti 6y agoIt's obviously popular to hate on silly-expensive tech, but these quotes were telling for me: > "I think what we're trying to do is pull back a little bit from the CADR metric," he said. "Not everyone needs an enormous CADR, has huge rooms or incredibly dirty air." > Several experts told Marketplace the CADR is the most important metric and an internationally recognized benchmark. > "CADR is what you want to know, period," said Francis (Bud) Offermann, an indoor air quality researcher who has helped develop test methods for the performance of portable air cleaners with the American Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM). CADR may well be "what you want to know, period" when it come to air filtration. However it might NOT be all you want to know when buying a consumer product. If the filter is quiet and effective and good looking and only ramps up when needed, is this not in some ways a better PRODUCT than a box fan running at full speed all the time with a filter taped to it?
- steve_adams_86 6y agoYeah, it felt a bit like me (a software developer) recommending to someone to use Google Cloud for their blog infrastructure rather than some basic one-size-fits-most solution that may or may not meet their needs forever. These people come from civil engineering backgrounds where air filtration requirements might often be thought of from an industrial or at least much larger than a domestic/micro loft scale. Having any air filtration at all at a smaller scale is generally just great if you replace filters often enough, don't aren't near industry or aren't in a city, don't cook at home often... Even then, a smaller air purifier's going to do an awesome job if you let it run regularly.
- cowmoo728 6y agoI'm also a little suspicious of relying entirely on the CADR metric. If you're running a filter in an environment that's constantly producing particulates and you need to filter large volumes of air, it seems useful. If you're about to walk into a smoke filled room and have 25 minutes to clean the air first, there's no question that CADR is king. I think it would be interesting to run a purifier in a normal house for 48 hours and see what the steady state particulate levels settle at around the house. I would guess that over a certain threshold CADR, there might not be that much difference. Room air circulation combined with a good enough CADR might even be more important, which is what Dyson claims. For all the people in the bay area worried about the next fire season, CADR is probably the most important since there's an extreme source of particulates. I'm just not sure that's the final say on air purifier effectiveness in less extreme conditions.
- bluGill 6y agoI'm more worried about the random friend who drops by. Sure we wear a mask, but when can we take it off when they are gone?
- Bakary 6y agoYou have to make sure the filter is HEPA, and calculate whether the device has had the time to do a full air change given the room size and its CADR rating. Viruses are generally too small for even the best filters, but the droplets that carry them are well within what a HEPA filter can manage.
- Maursault 6y ago> Viruses are generally too small for even the best filters... The average diameter of coronavirus particles is around 0.12 μm. The diameter of the envelope is 0.08 μm and the spikes are 0.02 μm long. A P100 HEPA filter will remove as much as 99.97% (for P95 it is 95%) of all airborne particulates with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 μm, and particles both larger and smaller are removed with an efficiency greater than 99.97%. Even if viruses are smaller than 0.3 μm, they are an easy target for HEPA filters.
- pfortuny 6y agoExactly. Like dB. Same as "processor speed is all that matters"... well, not. I honestly would gladly pay more for a QUIET computer (they are become more available).
- unreal37 6y agoI own this Dyson, and like it. It has a remote. Works from an app on my phone. It has a heater and a fan. It monitors the air quality which is usually fine. The "filter" is the least interesting part to me.
- kelvie 6y agoWe're also in the same boat. It's something that stays out all the time. It's just unsightly to keep a box fan filter out all the time (we used one when we first moved out, and man, the back of the filter gets disgusting). Looks do matter, and at least for our decor, there isn't really much choice. We pick our furniture based on how it mathes our interior decor, why would an air purifier be any different if it's out and on all the time?
- ska 6y agoI suspect the answer here isn't "replace your dyson with a box fan and bungie cords" but - if you care about air filtration, buy a cheaper more effective one that looks ok. It's not surprising a 3-in-1 product isn't very good at (at least) 1 of those functions.
- ListenLinda 6y agoCompare to your furnace (on fan mode) + air filter ... > It has a remote Check > It looks attractive Check. It's invisible. > sound profile Check. Furnace fans are in the garage. > analyze the temperature, humidity, and air quality Nope. But purpleair will sell it to your for $175. > oscillates Check. Covers entire flat.
- post_break 6y agoCheck your electric bill vs running a fan all night.
- casion 6y agoUh, mine doesn't have s remote, It's visible in living space, loud and doesn't effectively circulate all rooms. I suspect that you're fairly lucky.
- tallanvor 6y agoMany people who live in apartments don't have furnaces.
- efreak 6y agoWhite I agree with everything else, a furnace/ac does _not_ oscillate. It's fixed. You can adjust the vents to aim them, but you cannot make them push air to every part of the room on a rotating basis. Having said that, oscillating fans annoy me because the degree of rotation is almost never controllable. I have very rarely seen fans with a clip underneath that causes the rotation to reverse direction.
- ACow_Adonis 6y agoDisclaimer: Own the dyson cool-tower thingy, not the heat/cool one (as it didn't seem worth the money IMO). It was $200-$300 cheaper iirc. It does seem that they're comparing apples to oranges. Of course if you optimise for one metric ignoring the trade-offs and extra features: fixed air flow for a single given particulate removal measure, the cheapest solution that arrives at and maximises that metric is going to come out on top. But if you consider: - Hepa vs Merv - Additional carbon filter - Remote control - Multiple pivot options - Multiple power options - In built sensors and real-time reporting for small particles, large particles, no2, volatile organics, temperature and humidity - smaller horizontal footprint - Smartphone integration + remote operation - noise footprint then "shock", you have to pay more to have those features! (and they do provide value). Dyson certainly offers "I like to burn my money" options like many other companies, and they're not priced cheaply, but it's dishonest to review a sports car and a utility van on the metric of boot space and proclaim a "one little trick they don't want you to know about" type headline. Also, I haven't seen anyone else tackle it: what the hell is up with this "corona-virus protection" hints and claims in this article? Is that not enough to set off most people's internal alarms that the article is quackery?
- pugworthy 6y agoWhat I don't see anywhere in there is whether it's effective at filtering air.
- AlexandrB 6y agoDyson : Air Products :: Beats : Audio Products Pretty much every Dyson product I've used, from the public bathroom air "blades" to the vacuums, seem like a gimmicky, inferior products with a premium price tag. None of them do their intended job better than older, cheaper products in their category. I know James Dyson is regarded as a genius engineer, but the consumer product company bearing his name seems to be 99% marketing.
- dominotw 6y agoI currently use dyson v11 cordless vaccum. I am in the market for a new one, what do you recommend instead ? Price is not too much of concern for me ATM.
- ttul 6y agoMiele makes the best vacuums IMHO.
- AlexandrB 6y agoI really like my Miele canister vacuum. It's light, quiet, and powerful. I find bagless vacuums, including Dyson's, to be a pain in the butt to clean by comparison. However Miele is certainly not a good value brand either. I've never used a cordless vacuum, but I find the concept suspect for basic physics reasons. You're either giving up weight, power, or both compared to something you can plug into a wall.
- ghaff 6y agoEven if you are giving something up for cordless--and I'm happy to stipulate you may be to some degree, there are a lot of situations where you want to do a quick touchup, clean up a spill, etc. and a cordless vacuum like a Dyson is so much quicker and easier. It's the same with a lot of battery-powered tools. They may not be quite as powerful as a corded or gasoline version but they're increasingly powerful enough, especially for relatively light duty use, and they're a lot more convenient.
- Siecje 6y ago
- ortusdux 6y agoI still cannot get over this product. They whole selling point of a dyson fan is the 'air multiplier' tech, which creates a low pressure zone that propels air through the ring. According to dyson, this tech can move 15x more air than the fan in the base of the unit. Why in the world would you build an air filter around a system that does not directly interact with 93% of the air it moves? https://www.jameco.com/Jameco/workshop/Howitworks/dysonairmultiplier.html https://www.jameco.com/Jameco/workshop/Howitworks/dysonairmu...
- timthorn 6y agoThe idea is that the fan is deployed in a closed room and over time, all the air in the room will be circulated through the filter.
- wincy 6y agoBut isn't using a fan too long in an enclosed room dangerous? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fan_death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fan_death
- mmastrac 6y agoNo. This is yet another urban myth. "Despite no concrete evidence to support the concept, belief in fan death persists to this day in Korea,[further explanation needed] and also to a lesser extent in Japan.[1][2][3]"
- ortusdux 6y agoIIRC, this myth stems from a successful govt propaganda campaign that aimed to reduce power usage at night and put an end to rolling blackouts.
- mminer237 6y agoThe Wikipedia article cites that as being yet another myth, although it is disproven by evidence of belief in fan death long before the blackouts.
- clarkevans 6y agoThis seems similar to https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/how-to-make-diy-air-purifier/ https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/how-to-make-diy-air-puri... (2013)
- dirktheman 6y agoTechnology Connections did an episode on air humidifiers a while ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHeehYYgl28 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHeehYYgl28 The fan and filter size matter the most. Most of these things are hugely overpriced for what they are.
- rblatz 6y agoAfter watching his dishwasher episode I lost all respect for him. He clearly forced that episode and his conclusions were predetermined so he could have a clickbait video title/theme.
- ljf 6y agoCan you elaborate? That episode really worked for me, and fit with my own experience of dishwashers and adding pre wash. My latest machine doesn't have a prewash holder, but does have a prewash cycle on the eco setting - which cleans fine for the majority of my needs - but if things are filthy I through some bicarb in to the machine before I turn it on and it is awesome.
- rblatz 6y agoI’m getting ready to hop into some meetings, so here is the short version, I can elaborate more later today. So he only measured cleaning results after the pre wash cycle and not after the full cycle. Obviously you would expect a short wash with soap to be better than a short wash without. And the results there were a lot closer than I would have expected. He completely ignored final results while opining that dishwasher tabs aren’t effective without actually testing them side by side.
- ljf 6y agoCheers, I get your drift ;) I can see what you mean but I feel his outcome has some validity and I find his video/tv stuff far far more interesting
- deleted 6y ago
- tomhoward 6y agoIn Australia, Kmart has a house-brand bladeless fan for AUD$89. The Dyson full-sized bladeless fans cost $600-$800. The reviews of the Kmart cheapo one are very positive, both from customers and review publications. We bought one for the baby's room and it's been great so far. It also doubles as a white noise generator.
- dylan604 6y agoThat's a name I haven't heard in a long while. K-Mart was always one of those stories of going to live on a farm upstate. Now, I know that it actually went to live in a land down under.
- julianlam 6y agoAfter watching this segment, I immediately bought a 20" box fan, a 20x20 MERV 11 filter, and put one together. It kicks the pants off of air purifiers twice the price and it moves a lot of air through. Best investment ever. CBC was testing CADR, which is one metric among others, but an important one if you're looking to clean a room's air, fast.
- kube-system 6y agoI've used a box fan with a 20x20 filter for years when I'm doing woodworking, but it's a little too clunky of a solution to use in my primary living space.
- dylan604 6y agoI love the fact that Lasko has decided to own this concept with box fan designed specifically for this setup. It looks much better than a filter taped to the outside of the fan. Maybe this would help with your decor vs cleaner air conundrum? https://www.amazon.com/Lasko-FF305-20-inch-Purifier-Purifying/dp/B089P1Z38J/ https://www.amazon.com/Lasko-FF305-20-inch-Purifier-Purifyin...
- dylan604 6y agoI've had one of these for years with MERV10-12 (depending on availability) filters. This is in addition to the 20x25 filter in the central unit. Judging by how dirty the filter on the box fan gets, it is amazing how the central unit is just unable to do an adequate job.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoDoes your central air also use a merv 10 filter? A lot of people use the cheap fiberglass ones which are not very effective
- turtlebits 6y agoThey are great for reacting to bad air quality (like wildfires), but are way too loud for normal use. I have an Awair and did that dance of turning on the box fan filter when levels were higher than normal, then turning it back off once in normal range. Now I much prefer keeping a quieter (less performant unit) on continuously to keep the levels low.
- sdfhbdf 6y agoI thought the Xiaomi Air Purifier line [1] was at least popular enough to be considered in such comparisons. Maybe it's my skewed European perspective where the Xiaomi phones and home products seem to really popular among people. [1]: https://www.mi.com/global/mi-air-purifier-3H/ https://www.mi.com/global/mi-air-purifier-3H/
- RL_Quine 6y agoThey're nice and hackable too.
- syntaxing 6y agoI always treated my Dyson purifier as a fan that happens to clean the air a little. I leave the real heavy lifting to my Blueair purifiers which my taped up box fan purifiers cannot beat (I measured the 2.5um output during the wildfires).
- clairity 6y agoto add on, it helps in some cases to have another fan or two to move air (and dust) to your air purifier. i have 2 blueairs (211+ & 411 auto) and they do a decent job cleaning by themselves, but the fans aren't powerful enough even on high to draw all the crap being constantly kicked up farther than a few feet away without extra help.
- dylan604 6y agoTo be fair, the wildfire situations are pretty much the extreme edege of "acceptable" living conditions.However, these consumer products aren't meant for those extreme conditions. The fact that any filter can handle that is a good testament.
- vanadium 6y agoI've got two Blueair 121s (the larger sibling to the 211+) that were recently on sale at Costco.com for the price of the 211+. My family could sense the difference in air quality within a couple hours. I can't say that about any of the prior purifiers we've tried.
- tareqak 6y agoThe recommended pick from the Wirecutter is the Coway AP-1512HH Mighty (as of this post, the recommendation was last updated January 15, 2021) [0]. The CADR is available on Coway's product page in what I assume to be imperial units given the units of the other specifications: "233 (Smoke), 246 (Dust), 240 (Pollen)" (under "Specification") [1]. This CADR score puts it just between the BlueAir Blue Pure 211 and GermGuardian AC530B in the graph from the post [2]. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-air-purifier/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-air-purifier... [1] https://cowaymega.com/products/coway-mighty-ap-1512hh https://cowaymega.com/products/coway-mighty-ap-1512hh [2] https://i.cbc.ca/1.5902727.1612545406!/fileImage/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/original_1180/air-purifiers-graph.png https://i.cbc.ca/1.5902727.1612545406!/fileImage/httpImage/i...
- liminalsunset 6y agoSome additional info about this device is available from Energy Star to confirm the CADR ratings are in cfm. [0] This is odd, as the standard for CADR is often in m3/h. That works out to about 420 ish m3/h in this case. I rememeber seeing a video on YouTube indicating this device takes 2.2W on low, 4.4 on medium, and about 40 on high. [1] The disparity is reasonable, as the fan laws state that power increases with the cube of shaft speed, and airflow is proportional. Given that the product runs with such low power, it uses a brushless dc motor. The only issue with this device is that it appears to lack serious amounts of carbon filtration - no hundreds of grams of carbon pellets for odor and chemical adsorption. Not sure if this could be added as a DIY addon. [0] https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-room-air-cleaners/details/2359491/export/pdf/download https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-r... [1] 5:25 of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBv2aPMWdmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBv2aPMWdmI
- ska 6y ago> [0] This is odd, I suspect by "odd" here you just mean "american". US consumers really don't like having to convert units.
- JohnBooty 6y ago
- pwinnski 6y agoMy Coway AP-1512HH has a CADR of 400 m3/hr, higher than all but the most expensive purifier they tested, and was $150 when I bought it. Looks like it's $200 now, though.
- Exuma 6y agoSaving for later when I need an air purifier
- JPKab 6y ago"Marketplace took its results and questions to Dyson engineer David Hill at the company's headquarters in Malmesbury, England. "We are, we think, delivering quite a good value proposition for the consumer," he said, stressing that Dyson purifiers can sense pollutants in the air as well as capture them, and also provide strong air projection." I just want to point out the above: Along with the picture, it gives the appearance that a reporter waited outside of a Dyson office and started interviewing an engineer. I've literally never seen a piece like this where the company's PR department ALLOWED an engineer to be interviewed. I certainly hope Mr. Hill didn't get in big trouble for this. At my company, if I speak to a reporter without explicit permission from legal, I'm a goner immediately.
- PieUser 6y agoIt's the same guy from this video [1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1k1-ui-hOOs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1k1-ui-hOOs
- indigomm 6y agoI've been to Dyson's HQ and I very much doubt they just grabbed an engineer. There is a security post and employees generally drive straight in and out. I can't see how you could interview anyone, assuming you work out who the engineers are.
- liminalsunset 6y agoWas personally hoping for a noise-normalized version of the test, as well since I'd imagine most people aren't going to keep an air purifier running on high, and the low setting may not deliver the requisite airflow.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoDyson is about design (art) not practicality. You want a boxy filter that works well, go right ahead. But some people don't want that in their living space. Ideally they could be beautiful, and clean properly. You can't win them all.
- hansvm 6y agoBox fan filters are great. The fans aren't really designed to operate with much load, so I had issues with the motors burning up eventually (3-12mo) when trying to force air through too fine of a filter (somewhere around merv 15 iirc, taped at the edges to prevent air from going around). In college I had a _really_ cheap flat, and all my neighbors were chain smokers. I didn't realize quite how bad it was in my apartment (large gaps under the door, etc) till a classmate pulled me aside and asked how long I'd been smoking -- apparently the residue on my clothes was easy for anyone with a functioning nose to recognize when I walked nearby. Long story short, box fan filters completely fixed that problem, and as an added benefit you could set one up next to any cooking disasters and watch the smoke get pulled from the air.
- cjlars 6y agoYou can reduce load on the fan by increasing the number of filters. Arrange 2 into a wedge or 4 into a cube around the box fan and direct the airflow with cardboard and tape. Worked great at our drafty place during the forest fires last summer.
- sgustard 6y agoWirecutter came to similar conclusions about the Molekule: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/worst-air-purifier-we-ever-tested/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/worst-air-purifier-w...
- dyno-might 6y agoI did a bunch of tests with a similar filter (albeit comparing to a cheaper commercial purifier) https://dynomight.net/2020/12/15/some-real-data-on-a-DIY-box-fan-air-purifier/ https://dynomight.net/2020/12/15/some-real-data-on-a-DIY-box... It's crazy that commercial manufacturers usually don't even attempt to provide data like this to show that their products actually, you know, work.
- laurent92 6y agoThis. Instead, they’ll come up with whatever irrelevant metric like measuring purification power in Watts. All we want to know is asthma per hour in the room, and cancers per years in that city ;)
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoThis could be a HN submission in it's own right. Really interesting 'home' science.
- snickms 6y agoTo be fair, the Dyson model claims to heat and cool the air as well as filter it - unlike the DIY purifier.
- bluGill 6y agoBut those are not functions that should be combined with an air filter.
- Tade0 6y agoLast year I bought an air purifier for ~800, but PLN ($1 = 3,7129 PLN at the time of writing) to deal with the Polish winter - already swapped out the HEPA and carbon filter(<$40 total cost) because the air coming out started to smell bad(four days of 120ug/m3+ smog with peak at 200ug/m3 tend to do that to filters). At a CADR of 300m3/h I think the price/value ratio is decent, as opposed to whatever Dyson is trying to con people into buying.
- unreal37 6y agoI don't think they "con" people. I bought the Dyson. I like it. I'm not looking to clean my air that much because I don't have problems with air quality. It's a misleading news program. CADR is not the biggest factor that matters to many people who can afford a Dyson.
- vldx 6y agoNot to be snarky, but what’s more important for an air purifier than it’s ability to clean the air? Signal your affluence?
- reaperducer 6y agoThe cobbled together box fan may work better than a Dyson, but my wife isn't going to let me put a cobbled together box fan in the library. People care about aesthetics. There are entire industries built around this, even in technical areas (industrial design, UX, etc...) So the Dyson wins simply because it will exist in the house and clean a portion of the air, while the Sanford and Son rig won't be in the house and will clean zero air.
- bluGill 6y agoSo hire a cabinet maker to build a nice box around it.
- h2odragon 6y agoGreat project for kids and cardboard, too.
- reaperducer 6y agoSo hire a cabinet maker to build a nice box around it. For that price of a good cabinet maker, I could buy a whole fleet of Dysons.
- clarkevans 6y ago> my wife isn't going to let me put a cobbled together box fan in the library Perhaps https://smartairfilters.com/en/product/sqair-air-purifier/ https://smartairfilters.com/en/product/sqair-air-purifier/ ? It's simply a fan + filter in an attractive box.
- hinkley 6y agoVornado has a similar model (qube50) and I would trust them to stick around longer.
- lxe 6y agoAttaching an air filter to a box fan doesn't look great and sounds loud. There's no remote and no pivot or heating functions.
- bluGill 6y agoWhy would you want a remote on an air filter? You want it on 24x7 because you never know when something will happen that means the air needs cleaning. If you need a heater, buy a heater, don't try to mix the heater with the air purifier as they have different needs. Pivot might be useful, but only for mixing the air - if you want to feel the air, then you want a fan not an air filter.
- snickms 6y agoMy neighbour used to have a Dyson leaf blower. I would wake up thinking I was in the men's room.
- f430 6y agoPeople are surprised that people are overpaying for a brand premium for a dismal product like Beats headphones. How else will Mr. Dyson be able to afford an 8~9 digit Singaporean penthouse? Certainly didn't become a billionaire by building an affordable, efficient working product and not using misleading marketing to obfuscate the short comings.
- turtlebits 6y agoI'm not a fan of Dyson products, but i really like their air purifier (with heat). I'm not that concerned with performance as I'm just trying to maintain clean air, not actively clean it. It's quiet, has an actual thermostat (instead of the 0-10 knob). No burning smell and hot air temperature isn't a fire hazard (great for clumsy kids). Best of all, it looks nice. That said, I don't think I'd be willing to pay upwards of $600 for one. (I got a refurb HP02 for <$200, and would buy another one at that price in an instant.)
- KingOfCoders 6y ago"Best of all, it looks nice." The Dyson USP.
- turtlebits 6y ago:). This is why we have terms like "Wife Acceptance Factor" and "Happy wife, happy life"
- KingOfCoders 6y agoI was a Dyson fan boy for years. Then bought a 1/3 price Miele vacuum cleaner which was less noisy and more effective. The Dyson looked nicer though with the designer colors.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Bakary 6y agoI've spent many hours navigating the air purifier market and it is one of the most opaque and customer-unfriendly ones I have ever seen. Beyond the advice given in the article, it's also important to check what the filter exactly is. Some filters are washable, but it often means that they are not as thorough as HEPA filters, which is a big deal if your goal is to avoid the dreaded PM2.5 that are as far as I can tell the main threat to health and the pursuit of happiness. A more general problem is that there is a conceptual contradiction between low noise and high filtering. It will be difficult for a silent filter to be quick at filtering your room. The good news is that even a relatively crappy, low CADR setup can still filter a bedroom over time so long as it remains closed. You will however be paying for replacements more often and it might not be worth it if you have to ventilate daily and the filter takes many hours to give you a clean environment. I like the work that Smart Air China is doing. I am not affiliated with them, but they have essentially done and made available the same sort of research as the one highlighted in the article and have long promoted the no bullshit use of a simple box fan with filter combo for lower income and highly polluted regions.
- ahaucnx 6y agoYes I agree. There are a lot of non or low performing units out there that are hyped up by marketing and dubious claims. My startup [1] does air quality measurements primarily for schools and we very often come across schools that wasted a lot of money purchasing non performing units. The best is really to get a PM2.5 meter and compare the performance of different units. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/schools/ https://www.airgradient.com/schools/
- float4 6y agoBetween a lot of nonsense I've read today, I suddenly read a comment from someone who devotes energy to making air in schools cleaner. Very refreshing. Good luck with your startup.
- technics256 6y agoWhat about something like VOCs? Important also or?
- diebeforei485 6y ago> Using incense smoke in 24.0 m³ chamber Yeah, that's not the sort of indoor air that people actually have.
- crististm 6y agoYeah... No! I don't have an axe to grind here but indeed there are more than one way to compare a product. Air debit is only one dimension. You can pick arbitrary dimensions to compare products depending on which one you want to (if you would) show preference to. Did they check also the noise level? The dimensions? How long you can run the thing before changing the filters? Do they have some form of regulator or are they always on? Do they fall apart when you bump on them? It's like comparing processors by their clock speed. Which one 'is outperformed' by the other?
- Dumblydorr 6y agoWe bought a larger Honeywell model for around 250 USD to help cut down on smokiness from woodstove, cat hair, and general dust. It works quite nicely, though it does have a high pitched whirr on higher settings. I don't have a PM monitor but anecdotally, it cuts through smokiness quite nicely.
- burlesona 6y agoMeanwhile I can vouch for the top performer in this test. I have multiple BlueAir filters in different sizes. They work very well, are reasonably quiet, look nice, and while they’re not cheap they aren’t the most expensive either. Most importantly I also measure particulate and the measurements back up what I can already tell just by smell: the BlueAir really do filter the air well.
- pyrophane 6y agoFrom what I can tell getting a good air purify is all about how much air the thing is actually able to move through the filter, which is primary a combination of filter size and the design of the fan itself. At its core, an air purifier is a remarkably simple product. The biggest mistake people make when buying these things is getting something that cannot exchange enough air to keep the room it is in clean. Manufactures contribute to this problem by overstating the square footage their units can cover. With respect to Dyson, I think that their cordless stick vacuums are pretty good, and you can sometimes find good deals on them that can make them not too expensive. They have decent suction that probably compares okay to many low-end corded vacuums, and the battery life is reasonable. If you have only a small area to vacuum, and it is mostly hard floors, the Dyson cordless vacs are a reasonable purchase. Just don't expect them to compare to a decent corded vac in the same price range in terms of power.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI guess I'll bring up the "let your kids play in dirt argument" and see if I get any comments. I've personally taken this path in life and I seem to have much fewer allergies and immune issues than lots of my friends who grew up with hospital-like childhood circumstances. It could just be observor bias but it seems like there is some underpinning to the theory of if you don't use it you lose it when it comes to immunity. I do wash my hands and keep my house tidy, but I don't dust every day or put in MERV32 level air filters. (just cheapest-that-i-can-find MERV 8 recommended by my HVAC manual)
- s5300 6y agoI think people tend to seek these types of things out after they're already suffering from adverse effects that they want to try to fix.
- nvarsj 6y agoIs there any point to air purifiers at all? I remember researching them a while ago as a way to alleviate my allergy symptoms without medicine. But the overall scientific consensus seems very dubious. To be frank, it seems like yet another one of those very expensive placebo products that rich people like to buy because of media scare mongering. I can see the obvious exception being a heavily polluted eastern city - but don't you need some heavy duty medical grade HEPA filters and fans to really make a large impact?
- pchristensen 6y agoIf you're in the Western US/Canada, they're very helpful during the (more frequent and increasingly severe) fire and smoke seasons. See this pic of a filter after 6 days: https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/9xroh4/air_filter_after_6_days_of_use_near_the_camp_fire/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/9xroh4/air_filter_aft... They're also good if you cook with oil indoors.
- akeck 6y agoIt's been easier for me to focus during WFH when my HEPA filter is running, so I think it depends on the person and the location.
- butterisgood 6y agoI've got one of these Dyson purifiers + humidifiers, and it does seem to make the air noticeably nicer in the room we us it in. But it's definitely NOT worth the price tag, as with all things Dyson lately. (Loved my vacuum 10 years ago, but the stick vacuums are kind of overpriced idiocy - get an Oreck)
- oblib 6y agoI've been taping filters to box fans for decades. Got them running in my home and office 24/7. I put a filter on each side. It's pretty impressive how much they catch.
- souprock 6y ago2-sided is a great idea. It would cut down the noise. Put a washable pre-filter on the intake, and a disposable HEPA filter on the output. What about fit though, with the homegrown solution? Is that a square foot of tape to fill the gaps? Changing filters looks to be a big taping job.
- akeck 6y agoI've been making cubes with 3x 2" MERV-13 filters, two cardboard panels, and a box fan. While large, they work really well for big rooms.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danans 6y agoSome of the best air filtering systems (and also among the most expensive) are systems like the IQAir [1], which are essentially boxes with a fan at one end and a series of filters arranged in an alternating diagonal pattern: Note: / and \ are each separate filters Filter box ___ | \ | Inflow --> / --> Outflow | \ | | / | ‾‾‾ This maximizes the filtration while reducing the static pressure, since the filtration is distributed over a large surface area. Of course a lot of the high cost of installing such a system is the whole-house ducting. They also make single room purifiers, but there are also not cheap [2]. 1. https://www.iqair.com/us/whole-house-air-purifiers/perfect16 https://www.iqair.com/us/whole-house-air-purifiers/perfect16 2. https://www.iqair.com/us/room-air-purifiers/healthpro-series https://www.iqair.com/us/room-air-purifiers/healthpro-series EDIT: Corrected orientation of diagram
- ahaucnx 6y agoBe aware that some of the whole house systems might not have a fresh air intake. This can lead to relatively high CO2 levels inside the building and affect wellbeing and cognitive performance.
- danans 6y agoIdeally yes, they should have a fresh air intake connected to something like an HRV, but there is still value in dust/smoke/pathogen filtration even if the fresh air source for removing CO2 is a different one (i.e an open window). They are definitely better than no air filtration at all.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI think the filter is rotated the wrong way in your diagram? It looks like they use a normal pleated filter.
- danans 6y agoYou're right about the orientation. I've fixed the diagram. But they don't just use 1 filter, they use a series of them, like you can see at this timestamp of this video: https://youtu.be/8f6Ih09uaDw?t=401 https://youtu.be/8f6Ih09uaDw?t=401
- ahaucnx 6y agoI am living in Northern Thailand that goes through the annual smoke season with often US AQI beyond 300 and in the Hazardous area. That experience lead to the foundation of my startup AirGradient [1]. More and more people here are moving beyond air purifiers and install positive pressure systems in their house, offices or schools. Positive pressure systems take the outside air, run it through a set of high performance filters and pushes it inside the rooms. This has mainly two significant benefits: a) The positive pressure prevents dirty air from entering the room in the first place. As a results you become totally independent from the outside pollution and you can achieve zero PM2.5 inside even on the worst polluted days. I made a performance comparison between a standard air purifier and a positive pressure system and the positive pressure system won by a huge margin [2]. b) Low CO2. If you use normal air purifiers you are in a catch-22 situation. In order to get good results you need to keep your doors and windows closed. This leads to a very fast build up of CO2 in a room. High CO2 levels significantly impair cognitive performance and can lead to drowsiness and headaches. We measured the CO2 in classrooms [3] and very quickly you will see CO2 levels beyond 3000ppm (most Standards recommend levels below 1200-1500ppm). Against Covid transmission prevention, the best setup would probably be a combination of positive pressure system (to ensure a constant ventilation rate) together with a recirculation unit (standard purifier) inside the room to trap aerosols with viruses. We have open-source open-hardware build instructions for a DIY air quality sensor measuring PM2.5 and CO2 [4]. I am more than happy to send you some free PCBs (you just paypal me the cost of the postage) and you can build your own sensor and log the data. Contact me if you are interested. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/schools/ https://www.airgradient.com/schools/ [2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/2020/03/30/air-purifier-vs-positive-pressure-fresh-air-system-an-unfair-battle/ https://www.airgradient.com/blog/2020/03/30/air-purifier-vs-... [3] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/2020/02/07/we-measured-the-co2-level-in-a-classrooms-this-is-what-we-found-out/ https://www.airgradient.com/blog/2020/02/07/we-measured-the-... [4] https://www.airgradient.com/diy/ https://www.airgradient.com/diy/
- carabiner 6y agoIf you're on the west coast, the time to buy these filters is now. They regularly sell out during the summer/fall fire season.
- kyriakos 6y agoI don't understand how air purification systems work. I live in a relatively warm climate so windows are at least partly open most of the year. How would an air purifier help me if air keeps flowing in and out the windows?
- hedora 6y agoThey’re mostly useful when the outside air is heavily polluted. They’re also useful when you can’t open windows for some reason. Indoor air pollution is generally much higher than outdoor air pollution. Houses concentrate dust, etc.
- ph4te 6y agoNot sure I like this article. I would have liked to see the Levoit LV-PUR131 which is rated for 1000sqft/hr, 500sqft in 33 mins at $190, instead of the little one which we know will have a really low CFM/CADR. Blue Pure 211 rated 540sqft, GermGuardian rated 167sqft, Honeywell HPA160 rated 170sqft, Dyson Hot + Cool Air Purifier rated 290sqft. Levoit LV-H132 rated 68sqft, Also the Levoit is called out for being $150, as their cheapest, however they are on Amazon or at the local box store for $90.
- tw04 6y agoIf you're trying to move air, a vornado works far better than a dyson. On the flip side, if you have young kids, the heaters are great because there's no hot element to burn themselves on like a normal space heater, and no fan to stick their fingers in. The built in t-stat + timer are nice as well.
- gbourne 6y agoI've been using BlueAir (have the original one that looks like a tank) for 20 year and it has been fantastic. I live in NYC, so the air can get dirty and the BlueAir def makes a difference. And I've never even had to change the filter in 20 years! It is that good! Kidding - change it about every 6 months.
- hiven 6y agoThe quality of the products is really poor. Cheap materials, sloppy tolerances and no longevity. The best team in Dyson is the marketing function to make people spend so much on so little. I won’t even comment on the man himself.
- nateburt 6y agoI am surprised that so few people discuss the centralized, presumably less-wasteful, less-cluttered alternative that is a furnace-adjacent air bypass + filter (particularly relevant for those of us with access to our own fans/furnaces). The idea, as I understand it, is that a furnace can be modified by an HVAC specialist to send a portion of the air through a low-flow bypass duct containing a HEPA filter (or some other high-MERV-rating filter). This highly filtered air is, of course, combined with the less-clean air that passes through the low-MERV (standard) furnace filter before being delivered to ducts/rooms. This enables filtering of air for the entire living space without the need for an air purifier (a large plastic box containing future e-waste) in each room where clean air is desired. One obvious shortcoming of such a system is that in-duct/in-room sources of particulates (including concentrated bursts of particles from things like cooking) might be harder to combat. I don't know whether such a system can reduce particulates to levels commonly reached with in-room purifiers. Thoughts/adecdata on such setups?
- Der_Einzige 6y agoJust buy a high merv (e.g. merv 16) filter and you'll be good. No need to move the HEPA. Most modern hvac systems can support high MERV filters and doing this will significantly clean your air.
- inssein 6y agoNot really defending Dyson, but they have a public statement on CADR, and also just a note that CBC reviewed the older model. https://www.dyson.co.uk/air-treatment/purifiers/CADR https://www.dyson.co.uk/air-treatment/purifiers/CADR
- jjjeii3 6y agoDyson also created an awful robot cleaner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TH56kTJ-h4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TH56kTJ-h4 (video in German) It works worse than almost anything on the market and is ridiculously expensive.
- osrec 6y agoBack in the day, Dyson vacuums were supposed to be the best of the best. I think they lived up to that reputation to some extent. But now, everything they produce is a nice looking pile of barely functional junk, with a ridiculous price tag.
- joshe 6y agoIf you are in the SF bay area, LA, Australia, or another place with wildfire smoke problems, the 3M filtrete MPR 1900 filters with a fan is close to ideal. All the smoke uses up a lot of filter material, and this alternative has 10x cheaper filter replacement. It also moves a lot more air through a lot more filter, cleaning everything up more quickly. And the lack of aesthetics is fine for a few weeks. It's worth doing even if you rock a normal filter most of the year. For an upgrade use a few silent computer case fans instead and you can have a super quiet setup to run all day.
- ListenLinda 6y agoOne of the best air filters is your furnace + good air filter. No need for additional products. But if you go with a Merv 14 filter (which is amazing by the way), you will spend some serious money. Merv 12 is affordable. Merv 11 is an insult to air filters.
- chmod600 6y ago> "I think what we're trying to do is pull back a little bit from the CADR metric," he said. "Not everyone needs an enormous CADR, has huge rooms or incredibly dirty air." It seems plausible that CADR is becoming just a bigger number without improving effectiveness, like megapixels. It also seems plausible that Dyson is just struggling to avoid commoditization because it's a losing battle for them. And it's possible some of that has merit, because running a noisy fan when the air is already clean seems annoying.
- sdljfjafsd 6y agoCADR is an important metric for determining if a purifier is correct for your room. You can use it to calculate how many air changes it does per hour. If that number is too low, the air purifier is not going to work well in your room. Basically there's a minimum CADR for each room in your house, but of course, exceeding that gives you little benefit. Most people search for devices that are ~4 air changes per hour.
- nostrademons 6y agoMy wife rigged up a similar box fan + HEPA filter + duct tape solution during last summer's CA wildfires. They are remarkably effective. We also have the BlueAir purifier that was top-rated in this report, and arguably the box fan did better. (The BlueAir is better for kitchen smells, the box fan is better for particulates like wildfire smoke.) I think the filters are like $40 each from Costco and the box fan was $30-40, so it totaled about $70-80, about the same as the jury-rigged solution in the article. Highly recommend this solution if coolness is not a factor.
- sdljfjafsd 6y agoWhy did you believe the box fan did better? Did you do any kind of testing to verify that? The Blue Air's CADR is 2.7x that of a box fan. I do agree that the box fan solution is a great low cost option for small to medium rooms, but if you need 1 device to purify a large area, it's not gonna cut it.
- nostrademons 6y agoNo objective data, because what I care about is usually "Am I choking on smoke? Will I stop choking if I run the air filter?" Subjectively we were still having problems with just the BlueAir (~1000 sq ft apartment), add the box fan and things got better, take away the BlueAir and things are still better. The filter on the box fan also got black faster, which is our indication that it pulled more particles out of the air. Makes a lot of sense, because the actual filter material is the same (they both use HEPA filters inside) but the box fan blows a greater volume of air through a larger filter area.
- codemac 6y ago> which is our indication that it pulled more particles out of the air This is not a good indication. The larger black particles are not nearly as harmful to you, and generally just fall to the ground. BlueAir and other vertical filters attempt to make sure they don't waste your filter on these large objects, and pull the smaller particles out of the air. Box fans pull a lot off the floor, which isn't super helpful. The CADR takes into account the differences you speak of, because it measures the amount of clean air. You may enjoy the fans more, but the filter material being the same doesn't mean a box fan cleans air any better.
- hedora 6y agoI wish they'd tested this DIY air filter instead. They made a 20" cube, where one face is a box fan, and four faces are filters. Brilliant: https://www.thisoldhouse.com/green-home/22231148/diy-air-filter https://www.thisoldhouse.com/green-home/22231148/diy-air-fil... It should have a much higher CADR than the single filter version at lower backpressure. That means less noise and more energy efficiency.
- vldx 6y agoThe Blueair 211/221 they’ve tested has essentially the same design and performed best. It’s CADR is also the highest (590 m3/h). It’ll be interesting to compare them in terms of efficiency and noise levels.
- ogre_codes 6y agoIf I was running a business and wanted maximum filtration for cheap, the box fan is rad. I want something which sits in my office and quietly sucks little bits of crud from the air. The Dyson absolutely does that job. Probably not as much as a loud ass box fan, but that’s not the point. There are other solutions which might do what the Dyson does in terms of noise/ air circulation, but the box fan rig isn’t it.
- the-pigeon 6y agoThis headline is intentionally misleading. They put a Merc 11 filter on a box fan. The Merc 11 filter outperformed Dyson. Not some homemade filter. And duh? Any air purifier where the air actually goes through a filter is going to perform better. Worth testing but not interesting.
- hytdstd 6y agoThe article completely ignores noise. I personally have a box fan filter, but I don't pretend that it's appropriate or better for most people-- it's loud and annoying to work in the same room, and almost impossible to sleep with. And it is important that they're constantly on [0] (air quality generally reverts to normal levels in less than 2 hours), because all homes breathe to mitigate moisture and mold growth. [0]: https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/can-you-turn-off-your-purifier-when-you-sleep/ https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/can-you-turn-off-your-pu...
- pugworthy 6y agoDifferent people have different priorities. For some, it's about health from the purified air - that's the top metric for success.
- zeroimpl 6y agoIf the only metrics you are comparing is price and purification level, then of course you won't want a Dyson. But there are other important objective metrics such as size and loudness which deserve to be a part of any scientific comparison. If the box fan is bigger and 4x as noisy, it's not a valid comparison for many situations. Instead should compare fans which are similar sizes and operating at similar noise levels. I have a Dyson fan and a box fan (not air purifiers), and the Dyson fan is significantly quieter, smaller (same height but about half as wide), while having a similar power (not exactly sure which one is stronger).
- okprod 6y agoI bought a Blueair and a Winix based on wirecutter and other reviews, they've been performing pretty well against cigarette smoke and cooking.
- Zardoz84 6y ago> Siegel and other indoor air experts said you should avoid ion generators and plasma air cleaners, which can emit ozone, a respiratory hazard that can cause serious health problems. Ozone (O³) are used to deodorize, fungicide, and disinfect air (and water, or products bathed with ozonized water). O³ is secure if the concentration isn't too high. And it's really effective doing this. Far better and secure that chlorine. Plus the O³ becomes natural O² given enough time (like 10 to 30 minutes for a room with a high O³ concentraion to be enought low to be safe.) I know very well that were it's used to disinfect air coiling tower, the risk of legionella bacterium infections, becomes 0. And I saw personally how effective it's to keeping at bay fungus on a problematic damp basement.
- kangaroozach 6y agoAustin is the best and it’s I hospitals. Why didn’t they test that?
- stevespang 6y agoEven better DIY filter is using TWO of the filters in a "V" shape - - - - taped to back of fan, cardboard traingles to seal off top and bottom.
- Havoc 6y agoAs a counter point: I've got the bottom ranked one in this and it definitely made a real impact on measurements. It's totally a budget bottom end, but article makes it sound useless which is not the case. That said I'd not recommend it. If I had to do it again I'd skip straight to my latest purchase though: Xiaomi Mi 3H Everything about it just screams OK this was designed by people that actually live with real air pollution. I bought it because interwebs said one can home assistant it, but thus far I haven't. Seems usable without wifi frankly Also I'd estimate effective filter surface area on the Xiaomi to be maybe 8x of the Levoit. Physically they're just different beasts
- neves 6y agoAny tips for a good and cheap Co2/PPM2.5 sensor to see if the purifier is working?
- NOGDP 6y agoDoes anybody know if there is a filter or something that increases oxygen concentration in the air? Maybe something that pumps air from the outside and only lets oxygen in?
- hedora 6y agoYou can get air exchangers with filters. They use the hot/cold air from inside to heat/cool the air from outside as they filter it. It reduces co2 by venting it outside. I’ve seen ads for medical “oxygen concentrators” which involves a face mask. No idea how they work, or what they do.
- zelon88 6y agoIf you like comparisons like these, I strongly suggest you look into the Project Farm Channel on YT. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2rzsm1Qi6N1X-wuOg_p0Ng https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2rzsm1Qi6N1X-wuOg_p0Ng
- unnouinceput 6y agoQuote: "Dyson has developed its own testing methodology, the POLAR test method, which, unlike the CADR, Hill said, "measures the intelligence of the purifier, the ability for it to know when that room is clean or dirty and automatically react, and its ability to mix that pure air around the room." Yup, corporate mambo-jumbo when they get caught with their pants down.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoI'm a function over form kinda guy, and a filter (cleanly) duct-taped to a $20 box fan has functional, eco- and prudential beauty. The money saved on the Dyson will buy MANY houseplants. And replacement filters. But then I'll never live in a $3M home or entertain guests wearing tuxes. No need for a whisper-quiet fan because in-house string quartets. Like Apple, Dyson's selling 'purdy'.
- narogab 6y agoWhy not replace the main air circulation filter with a HEPA filter? E.g., I have two filters on my AC/heating system that I replace every month or so even though they're still pretty clean. I'm tempted to simply put HEPA filters in instead. Any problems? Or I could jury-rig it so that only half of the filter was HEPA and the other half MERV. That would still cut down tremendously on finer particles.
- brody_hamer 6y agoI was surprised to see no mention of energy efficiency. I would consider this an important factor. If I just wanted to clean the most air as fast as possible; I could set up 5 box fans. But that wouldn’t be energy efficient. Especially if I just leave them running constantly.
- omot 6y agoI always thought of Dyson similar to Apple products. Sure you’ll get a more powerful machine for fraction of the price if you get a windows computer, but you’re missing out on the brand and the experience. Most consumer don’t care about cpu speed or memory size, it’s probably similar for the vacuum market. Which company can tell their story more effective that’s where the profit is.
- Magi604 6y agoI have tried the box fan + air filter. It's way too noisy and ugly. I ended up just getting a generic tower hepa air filter for a few hundred bucks. I have not tested whether or not it's more effective than the box fan, but it's way quieter and it looks way nicer, and that matters to me.
- mizzao 6y agoYep, the Dyson might perform worse in some tests but the box fan is very noisy, and I hate noisy fans... especially for sleeping.
- dis-sys 6y agoWhy bother building your DIY one for $70 when you can get a decent air purifier with touch screen, PM2.5 sensor and wireless control for just $100? You'd be paying why more than what you should if your DIY one also have touch screen control, PM2.5 sensor and wireless control - the PM2.5 sensor itself costs $30. I have 4 Xiaomi air purifiers at home in Shanghai, during a highly polluted day (pm2.5 > 150), the in door measurement can be maintained <10 just a few minutes after turning on the Xiaomi air purifier. It has a nice LCD touch display and you can control it remotely using your phone. The price is just $100 each with a preinstalled filter, a replaceable filter that can last for 6 months costs you $40 only. link here - https://item.jd.com/5487565.html https://item.jd.com/5487565.html
- thitcanh 6y agoI have a related question: How do AC boxes and air purifiers interact? Do they work together or against each other? Would an AC unit keep reintroducing impure particles (like mold) nullifying the purifier’s work?
- mxfh 6y agoIf you have a NAS or Fan cooled Server near your living area, put a HEPA filter in front of the Airflow. Managed to find a fitting size one for my Synology one that can simply be affixed by making an impromptu collar out of half-folded wide duct tape around the front. PM 2.5 dropped down from 25 to 5. Temperature increase is neglegible and well within safe range. Plus you get no dust in the device itself, which was my motivation for this in the first place.
- the_pwner224 6y agoInteresting. Do you think it would still be effective to purity the room air when done on a desktop computer with a single 120mm intake fan (and a 140 exhaust though I assume there wouldn't be a filter on that)?
- mxfh 6y agoThat was my next step, look at the pressure ratings for mm H2O of your fans. Problem with most cases is, they are not a single tunnel like most NAS, but would have multiple openings that might change airflow direction if you add a filter in front of a single intake. For the NAS I trialed a range of Noctuas, but the stock fans (KM121225LL 2x120mm 2.3mmH2O) proved most reliable with the default Synology control settings. So anything in that 2mm Range should work.
- dorian-graph 6y agoHas anyone tried https://milacares.com https://milacares.com?
- ricardobayes 6y agoBox fans are such an American thing. They are almost impossible to get in Europe, which I find weird.
- dwd 6y agoI'm in Australia and have a few air filters around the house. They're good when you live in semi-rural and have neighbours who like open fires, not to mention occasional bushfire. A couple of different sized Philips which I like for the big colour led circle; two have PM2.5 count displays. But the air filters I have that really work are two Inovaair beasts. Solid all-metal construction and big drum filters that move a huge amount of air. Had an oven mishap recently which filled the house with burnt oil smoke. One of the older Philips (a 6000 series) was soon showing well over 250ppm but was struggling to bring the numbers down. The big Inovaair had the whole downstairs clear and the Philips happily reporting single digits in about 20min.
- skocznymroczny 6y agoAnyone know how Xiaomi air purifiers compare to these?
- whateveryoua381 6y agoThe best part from an engineer at Dyson (his last name is Hill): "Dyson has developed its own testing methodology, the POLAR test method, which, unlike the CADR, Hill said, "measures the intelligence of the purifier, the ability for it to know when that room is clean or dirty and automatically react, and its ability to mix that pure air around the room." While Hill agrees that CADR is an important part of purification, he notes that it is important that products also sense and capture pollutants, and project air. "I think what we're trying to do is pull back a little bit from the CADR metric," he said. "Not everyone needs an enormous CADR, has huge rooms or incredibly dirty air." Several experts told Marketplace the CADR is the most important metric and an internationally recognized benchmark. "CADR is what you want to know, period," said Francis (Bud) Offermann, an indoor air quality researcher who has helped develop test methods for the performance of portable air cleaners with the American Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM). "An air cleaner with a very high-efficient filter and very little air-flow rate will have a low CADR and little air-cleaning ability; same for an air cleaner with a very high air-flow rate and a very low filter efficiency." "
- whateveryoua381 6y agoAlso from Dysons site: "The POLAR test chamber is much bigger than a CADR chambler, and more representative of real-world environments than existing standards dictate with a 81m3 footprint and no external fan to support air circulation – the purifier itself must do this."[1] ie: dyson has written POLAR to exclude external fans into their new "standard". Honestly they also don't clarify what they mean by external fans. Since they compare to a box fan/filter in the CADR example above... one is left to either guess or assume that they are either talking about traditional fanned purifiers or are assuming that no hvac exists in "real-world" environments. [1]https://www.dyson.com/newsroom/overview/update/december-2020/what-is-cadr https://www.dyson.com/newsroom/overview/update/december-2020...
- gvd 6y agoWouldn't it just help to compare purifiers by setting them up in the same room in CA summer wildfire season and measuring the PM2.5 particles over time? How does that POLAR crap compare to that?
- executive 6y agoPricey but incredible: https://surgicallycleanair.com/ https://surgicallycleanair.com/