15 ms·
Everyone assuming a conspiracy theory needs to read this. Keep in mind that Robinhood also gives everyone a margin account by default. They also let people inv
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Everyone assuming a conspiracy theory needs to read this.
Keep in mind that Robinhood also gives everyone a margin account by default. They also let people invest on margin before their inbound bank transfers arrive (Robinhood Instant). The influx of new traders sending money to Robinhood or selling other stocks to buy GME quickly drained their credit lines, reducing the capital they had available for collateral.
Keep in mind that when someone sells a different stock to buy GME in the same day, they're buying GME on margin. Stock trades don't settle until T+2, so any new purchases using those proceeds are done on margin.
This was a capital crunch at Robinhood due to an unexpected herd of new traders all looking to do the same thing in unison. It violated the assumptions of their business model, and the only way to keep the platform from grinding to insolvency (or violating regulations) was to slow down the unexpected event by slowing meme stock purchases.
Is it really so hard to believe that such an unprecedented mass movement would break the underlying business assumptions of a pre-IPO startup that was heavily dependent on their credit lines?
The biggest problem is Robinhood's poor messaging. It's clear their highest priority was to avoid admission that they were running out of money. They didn't want to trigger a bank run or shake the confidence of their newly acquired users, so they tried to obscure the message as much as possible. As a result, the popular narrative assumed some sort of evil conspiracy theory.
- ac2u 6y ago>Everyone assuming a conspiracy theory needs to read this. I'm not sure of your point here. Anyone that assumed there's a conspiracy theory is pretty much right. Now, if you mean the 'Brokerage X is in cahoots with this particular hedge fund theory', then yes, it's fair to argue that's debunked. But the overall conspiracy theory of "there are forces conspiring against the natural supply/demand market forces", well, they've pretty much all had the nerve to come out in the open and admit it. It's not the stockholders fault that all these clearing intermediaries use shitty fragile risk models that haven't accounted for rare events and instead of facing the music they've artificially turned the marketplace for these stocks into sell-only in order to stop a further price rise and exposing themselves further. To be clear, the rest of your comment seems that we're in agreement, expect that I would go further to call a spade a spade, it's absolutely a conspiracy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pja 6y agoIt's not the stockholders fault that all these clearing intermediaries use shitty fragile risk models that haven't accounted for rare events and instead of facing the music they've artificially turned the marketplace for these stocks into sell-only in order to stop a further price rise and exposing themselves further. The availability of liquidity in the market at any price & at any time is an illusion. It’s an illusion that holds most of the time, but nevertheless it isn’t real. When the market is under stress, the illusion falters & the plumbing starts poking through the gaps. If you want to be able to buy and sell shares with very fast confirmation at the prices quoted in the market then you need intermediaries who can extend the credit that enables that transaction to happen. When the market is under stress, that credit becomes more expensive & liquidity falls away. This isn’t a conspiracy or the result of collusion, it’s a consequence of the structure of the market.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andylei 6y ago> it's absolutely a conspiracy I think a "conspiracy" requires some sort of actual coordination. A bunch of actors doing the same thing for the same underlying reason isn't a conspiracy. Lots of people going to sleep when it gets dark isn't a conspiracy.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWho, specifically, do you claim is conspiring? And to what end? These collateral requirements were implemented to reduce systemic risk of the system failing under extreme volatility. It was designed to prevent collapse, requiring government bailouts. It wasn’t designed to break a consumer-facing investment app that didn’t even exist yet.
- ac2u 6y ago>Who, specifically, do you claim is conspiring? And to what end? I'm happy to retract the conspiracy definition on the basis that there isn't explicit coordination. If you'll allow me to move the goalposts a bit I'll settle on the fact that my frustration is in the excuse-making that these actions are just regular checks and balances, instead of being the nefarious acts they are, unfair interference in the markets to the detriment of retail investors. When you have heads of brokerages coming on talk shows (my memory of who isn't great) recently claiming that they'll open things up "when things settle down", and actually claiming "this is a $17 stock" (nothing wrong with the opinion, it's just unfair for a marketplace to be wielding their influence like that), we're living in bizarro world when the media isn't calling them out on it. Then you have the CEO of nasdaq saying they'll consider halting trading if they can match social media chatter to movements (as if it's possible to prove causation anyway) so that large institutions get time to adjust?? When does the retail investor with their pension on the line ever get time to adjust? >extreme volatility. It might be extreme but it's not unpredictable. The helpless "how could we have seen this coming?" from institutions rings hollower each time throughout the decades that it's used. The answer here is to stop the interventionalism that tries to hide natural volatility. Do you think social media is causing volatility and leaving pump and dump bagholders? Fine, let it happen on the small scale more frequently and sooner or later people will learn through frequent exposure that you can lose your shirt. However, if you constantly intervene? You're hiding the volatility until a large event is allowed to hide in plain sight and deliver a liquidity crisis for many.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> Keep in mind that Robinhood also gives everyone a margin account by default. While this is technically true, it is not a typical margin account. People cannot invest more money than they put into their Robinhood account. In order to do that, they need to switch to RH Gold. RH Basic: I put $100 into the account, I can buy $100 worth of stock before my funds clear. (Robinhood Instant) RH Gold: I put $100 into the account, I can buy $200 worth of stock. (Actual effective margin) While both of these are technically margin accounts, most people associate the term "margin investing" with the latter model which requires $2000 in the account and a deliberate choice to upgrade.
- kbar13 6y agosure thanks for the explanation. at the end of the day the user is trading with borrowed money, which is the problem.
- noodle 6y agoIMO the "problem" is that RH doesn't tell you that (or at least their marketing makes it confusing at minimum). The way they describe it as an "instant bank transfer", not "we give you margin until your transfer clears". The former gives you the impression that its your money that you're trading with, while the reality is it's a margin account. That's why a lot of people were angry. They were forced to sell GME because they were technically using margin and it got called, but they thought it was their own money from their own bank account. The optics are that RH forced them to sell GME when they didn't want to.
- Dma54rhs 6y agoWell someone took their own life because they showed him a real data for the moment and it was in red and it was all over news. Either way they target amateur market.
- matwood 6y agoIf you do any trading at all, you want a margin account so you don't have to wait for settling before making another purchase. While technically the money is borrowed for the 2 days to make your trade, I would never considered it borrowed in the typical use of the word margin.
- ratsmack 6y agoThis may be a perfectly good explanation, but if this is the case, why doesn't the Robinhood people release a statement explaining this instead of the puff piece the CEO did for PR.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWSB users are known to exploit Robinhood problems for fun. There was one case a few years back where they found a way to evade margin requirements and get arbitrarily high leverage, for example. If I were Vlad Tenev, I'd be seriously concerned that a detailed description of which kinds of trades cause problems for Robinhood would be used to collect WSB accolades by knocking the company over.
- thefounder 6y agoQuite a brush to put all wsb "accolades" in the same bucket. I could say some very nasty things about some ycombinator "accolades" as well.
- mancerayder 6y ago> WSB users are known That's a dubious way to refer to people. There are 7.5 million users in the sub at the moment.
- azinman2 6y agoThey did: https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2021/1/29/what-happened-this-week https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2021/1/29/what-happened-this...
- negrit 6y agoAfter the CEO got caught lying on TV, that's unacceptable.
- gruez 6y agoThe "lied" bit is debatable because there's multiple ways of interpreting his statement. It could be "there's no liquidity issue [and we could have let GME stock trade freely without running into liquidity issues]" but also "there's no liquidity issue [anymore, because we stopped GME from being traded]". The former clearly favors WSB's narrative, so that's what everyone there believed, even though it's reading too much into the CEO's statement.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ds206 6y agoI want to believe you but then I see how the short sellers think about these kinds of situations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VMuEis3byY4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VMuEis3byY4
- TuringNYC 6y agoWhat about funded accounts with no clearance in progress? This explanation only makes sense if RH allowed the above situations to buy, yet it seems they restricted globally.
- gruez 6y ago> What about funded accounts with no clearance in progress? Other comments have already mentioned that they can't use customer funds for the deposit, so they need to pay it out-of-pocket or borrow it.
- TuringNYC 6y agoI think this is only the case when the customer has sold something and immediately buys before clearance. I'm speaking about the standard case where you purchase stocks with funds in your account -- does that also require a deposit from the broker?
- wbl 6y agoYou're expecting a basic level of competence and maturity that RH doesn't have as evidenced by past problems.
- skybrian 6y agoThe stock trade still takes two days to settle. Apparently this is to allow for correcting errors before it becomes irreversible.
- dheera 6y ago> Stock trades don't settle until T+2 This too smells fishy and rigged to me. Modern databases don't need T+2 to achieve consistency. Ask PayPal or Visa or Alibaba. They can do it in a matter of seconds. But the people up at the top of the stock market choose to not implement it. Why? > on margin What about high frequency trading instiutions on Wall Street? Who gives them their margins, and why is it that they are subject to much less interference than RobinHood users?
- stu2b50 6y ago>Modern databases don't need T+2 to achieve consistency. Ask PayPal or Visa or Alibaba But that's actually not true though, it takes days to settle those transactions, the payment processors just provide the illusion of instaneousness by smoothing it over with their own fungible cash reserves.
- db579 6y agoIt may well be that it does take payment processors t+2 days but I think the point remains that it should not.
- MrMan 6y agoThe reasons are a combination of human factors. Technologically it is possible for atomic transactions to be completed far earlier, but commerce is a web of interactions between mostly real humans.
- beezle 6y agoEven if trades settled at T+0 (overnight) there are still rules against good faith and free riding violations in addition to liquidation issues.
- mschuster91 6y ago> it takes days to settle those transactions The question is: why? There's absolutely no technical (e.g. nightly batch processing) or process (e.g. physical cross-country mailiing of paper stocks) reason any more. It's 2021 not 1960, technology should have evolved over the last decades. To wait days for money and stock transfers is ridiculous
- tbrock 6y agoGiving people who don’t understand margin a margin account is the easiest way to have them blow themselves up financially. Most people think that this leverage is free, it’s not, and it multiplies your risk. If you are wrong you’ll be twice as wrong. If Robinhood should be criticized for anything it should be this. There’s a reason people have to usually apply for a margin account separately. Automatically handing them out is a recipe for disaster. I’m all for empowering folks to do what they want with their money but it should be pared with some sort of education.
- ubercow13 6y agoCould you explain how it multiplies your risk in the case of RH?
- MrMan 6y agoWhy don't you figure out how borrowing to make a trade increases your risk, and explain it to the rest of the class? Teaching will deepen the lesson for you. Luckily it is all basic arithmetic.
- barbecue_sauce 6y agoWow, what a dick.
- barbecue_sauce 6y agoI stand by my comment.
- ubercow13 6y agoBut you're borrowing a fixed amount of money that has already been effectively taken from you. My understanding of RH (I am not a user) is that you are not allowed to spend above the amount that is already incoming to your account, via ACH transfer or via sold stock that hasn't yet settled. It wouldn't make sense for RH to margin call you because at any one time, whatever money they would ask for would already be incoming to your account. There would be no point in them liquidating your position because it would clear even later than the previous trades, which already cover any margin. And you can't sell options or anything. Therefore I don't understand what the risk to the customer is over and above a cash-only account. I guess there's a risk that your bank transfer won't go through, or your stock sale will be withdrawn or not settle? Is that likely?
- throwaway333444 6y agoThe problem with this theory is that it wasn’t just Robinhood. There were literally like a dozen or so firms that halted buying. Some of which were well known long established firms (Merrill, etrade). These firms should have had no problem continuing allowing purchasing.
- nverno 6y agoThe article discusses this- excess buys and market volatility lead to increased capital requirements by clearing houses, so it wasn't necessarily specific to robinhood.
- Hacker29382 6y agoWhen powerful people need to bend the rules, they don't do it outright. They find cover. And if there's any discretion in how much liquidity clearinghouses require, that's what they'll modify. You'll see similar things when influence is sold. Speakers are given huge fees for basic speeches and then they know what they should do. Nothing is spelled out, because that would be dumb.
- astrange 6y agoIf you gave me a lot of money, I wouldn’t need to do anything for you because I’ve already got your money ;)
- Hacker29382 6y agoAre you saying that influence either isn't sold or is spelled out in explicit terms when it is? Why do pharm reps take medical residents out to expensive dinners in nice parts of town (pre-covid), are they just nice people?
- astrange 6y agoGiving someone a nice dinner isn’t giving them a lot of money, though. You get influence by not paying people enough that they can leave, but making it seem like you might in the future. And yes, most marketing spending is pointless, and that’s just another kind of marketing.
- Triv888 6y agoI wanted to disable my margin account on RH but I didn't find how... luckily I no longer do business with them.
- nrmitchi 6y agoFor what it's worth, there seems to be a link in their docs to downgrade to a "Cash" account. But with that you lose pretty much all the functionality (instant transfers, instant settlements, etc) that makes Robinhood any better than any other non-margin alternative. Unless you're a huge fan of confetti. I hear Cash accounts still get the confetti.
- Triv888 6y agohahaha, I never noticed the confetti... maybe I blocked the javascript... but thanks.
- jdhn 6y ago1) All accounts were banned from buying these shares, even ones whose accounts had cleared funds. 2) If margin requirements were the problem, why not inform the user that due to the unusual circumstances, the increased margin cost would be passed onto the buyer?
- rozab 6y agoAnd most importantly, why was only buying of meme stocks disabled? This argument doesnt hold up to any scrutiny
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoIt does appeal to the "oh they're still a startup" mentality, perfect for the HN crowd
- Leparamour 6y agoAnd most importantly, why was only buying of meme stocks disabled? You gave yourself the answer. The collateral is connected to the volatility. The meme stocks saw their price volatility increase massively, therefore the DTCC collateral demand was raised from 3% (low-volatility) to a whooping 100% collateral.
- UncleMeat 6y agoBecause those are the ones that push up the required collateral with the settling firms. The meme stocks are buy-heavy and highly volatile. Stocks that are less volatile and have matched buy-sell rates don't. Halting buys of meme stocks meant that RH needs less collateral with settling firms. Halting other buys doesn't change a thing.
- 0x00000000 6y agoRobinhood has also halted 50 other stocks including arbitrary ones like AMD. https://investorplace.com/2021/01/robinhood-bans-reddit-stocks-wallstreetbets-gme-cciv-sndl-jagx-amc-nok-bb/ https://investorplace.com/2021/01/robinhood-bans-reddit-stoc... There must be more to their internal situation they aren’t telling us because they probably just imploded their IPO
- SilasX 6y ago>Keep in mind that when someone sells a different stock to buy GME in the same day, they're buying GME on margin. Stock trades don't settle until T+2, so any new purchases using those proceeds are done on margin. TBH, that, for me, is the real scandal here. We have such an antiquated system that we can't actually be confident who owns the stock at any point until you do some super-slow settlement process that takes two days[2]. And so, enshrined in law, we have this bolted-on system where you have to put up extra collateral just to be confident of something that shouldn't need said collateral. There is no reason, with all the identities attached, and auditing procedures, and digital signing, and protocols we have today, that we shouldn't be able to know who owns the stock at any given point, and not have to rely on these super-slow resolutions. In this case, they had to add that collateral, even when buying with money that pretty obviously was there (had been deposited years ago). Plus, some articles are claiming[1] that even stock you do own, whose purchase long ago settled, is being lent out without your direct knowledge by the broker for a profit, which is like ... what? [1] https://yudkowsky.medium.com/r-wallstreetbets-is-trying-something-unprecedented-in-history-and-the-medias-not-reporting-it-7ab507e4a038 https://yudkowsky.medium.com/r-wallstreetbets-is-trying-some... [2] Incidentally, people like to ridicule Bitcoin for taking an hour to settle since you have to wait an hour to get six confirmations. But that's actually fast compared to this (centralized!) system, since you have to compare to the time after which you can "take the stock/cash and run".
- soared 6y ago> There is no reason, with all the identities attached, and auditing procedures, and digital signing, and protocols we have today, that we shouldn't be able to know who owns the stock at any given point, and not have to rely on these super-slow resolutions. Trillions of dollars are moved in these markets - you can't just hop in and do a quick rebuild with crypto, launch it, and call it good. Imagine rebuilding ythe core infrastructure at Microsoft - that takes years and years. But now you also have the entirety of the global economy dependent on your software. You also need to meet heavy government regulation and comply with oversight. There is a whole shit ton of reasons this process hasn't been updated to T+0. It was t+3, now t+2, and I've heard (from the CEO of Webull on bezinga power hour yesterday) wanting t+1 this year. Edit - to be clear I'm not saying dropping the current system for a new one is the only option. I'm saying improving the system at all (or rebuilding it) is arguably one of the most challenging software tasks one could undertake and there are serious reasons financial markets are not anywhere near what is "technically possible".
- SkyMarshal 6y ago> The biggest problem is Robinhood's poor messaging. It's clear their highest priority was to avoid admission that they were running out of money. They didn't want to trigger a bank run or shake the confidence of their newly acquired users, so they tried to obscure the message as much as possible. As a result, the popular narrative assumed some sort of evil conspiracy theory. This was my impression too, especially from RH CEO’s interview on Chris Cuomo. He tried to communicate that they were effectively getting margin called, but without explicitly saying it, vaguely referring to SEC and exchange rules and regulations, hoping the audience would read between the lines. But not giving a straight answer just fed the conspiracy theories. In hindsight, considering RH raised $1B additional capital a day or three later [1], it would have been better for him to have just been explicit about it. “Yeah Chris, here’s the problem. As you know RH enables no-fee trading and instant trading the moment you join. We maintain margin accounts with our exchange partners to risk manage this. However, the massive rapid influx of new users combined with the unplanned-for three-sigma increase in volatility in these stocks caused us to hit our margin limits with the exchanges. We’re getting margin called at unanticipated levels and just don’t have the capital buffer. We’re raising additional capital as quickly as we can to fund our margin accounts and re-enable trading, but until that’s accomplished we have no choice but to disable buys on these high-vol stocks. We disabled buys and not sells for two reasons: 1) only buys require margin in our system, and 2) if you think traders are angry when you disable buys, they get even angrier when you disable sells and lock them into a position that could suddenly go against them. To our customers, we’re terribly sorry about this and are working overtime to solve the problem. We’re raising additional capital to increase our margins with our exchanges, and are updating our risk models to better accommodate such black swan events going forward. We’re listening to complaints and suggestions and evaluating additional ideas we hear to improve our service.” Something like that I’m sure WSB would have bought, and eventually forgiven them for. [1]:https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25954539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25954539
- malandrew 6y agoBut even once they did they still lowered the limit to 5 shares, then 3, then 2 then just a single share.
- oysterberry 6y agoIt is not a conspiracy but the system is broken. Everyone seems to be missing the point of WHY collateral requirements have gone up. It is not because of volatility of the price movement, but volatility of whether the trade will clear. The reason the trade might not clear is because of hedge funds or market makers that might go bankrupt, and not have the capital to pay for the shorts that they need to buy back. The collateral is there so that if the hedge fund can't pay, the clearing house or broker must pay. What seems to have happened is somewhere along the line a broker did not margin call the hedge funds fast enough, and DTCC with their collateral requirements has spread the risk from that one broker or clearing house to all of the brokers. In essence, the hedge funds losses are in a way "too big to fail" now because of the way the risk was spread. In this system, everyone is working to protect themselves (thus not conspiracy), which in turn happens to be screwing over retail. The big issue is the broker somewhere or risk management team that did not force the short sellers to buy back their shares when it was still possible to do so without affecting the brokerages. They missed the time and now the losses might be too large to absorb. Meanwhile, they have no problem margin calling retail. Robinhood might be faced with an impossible situation they didn't cause, but they also aren't pointing the finger at the culprits and where the problem started, which is some entity allowing the hedge funds to be over leveraged and then not de-risking from that leverage fast enough when the trade went against them. A lot of this is explained by the webull ceo in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RS4JIEVyXM&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RS4JIEVyXM&feature=youtu.be
- gruez 6y ago>Meanwhile, they have no problem margin calling retail. Presumably because hedge funds have more lenient margin agreements than retail. After all, it's easier to collect from a hedge fund with billions AUM compared to a bunch of millennials living paycheck to paycheck with $50k of student loans.
- oysterberry 6y agoYes this is true, and sometimes they don't even need to collect because they can write off the small loss (this is explained in the video from the webull ceo). But the lenient margin requirements let them hang themselves when they can't collect because the losses are too big and will bankrupt the hedge fund. So now they are too big to fail, it's not only the hedge funds problem that they made a bad trade, it is now DTCC and the brokers problem that the hedge fund made a bad trade.
- 13415 6y agoAbout a dozen brokers simultaneously halted buying, not just Robinhood.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoBecause the cost of collateral spiked in meme stocks in unison. They had to move money around to post the massively increased cost of collateral. Everyone seems to be forgetting how fast this all happened.
- dasudasu 6y agoThat's entirely possible and even likely, but that's still a huge market failure that should be corrected. You can't have a situation like this happening to some stocks exclusively. Where were those increases in required DTC collaterals when TSLA/NIO/your favorite SPAC was going through the roof? The conspiracy just moves to whoever unilaterally decided to raise collateral requirements from 2% to 100% -- a 4900% increase, and nice and whole numbers that seem fully arbitrary. A situation in which people have settled in their accounts should not depend on some backdoor credit wizardry that ultimately damages retail investors.
- tonfa 6y agoWere those stocks moving +100%/-50% daily?
- pfortuny 6y agoLying (and hiding this type of information behind dodgy reasons is tantamount to lying) is illegal also. Did they do a per-customer assessment? Why did they not just close shop for the day? At least that would have been honest.
- beezle 6y agoSo they should penalize all their other clients who are not involved in trading GME? Everyone else should pay the price because DTCC raised collateral requirements to settle GME trades?
- gruez 6y ago>Lying (and hiding this type of information behind dodgy reasons is tantamount to lying) is illegal also. Were they lying? They made carefully crafted statements that were true, which wsb proceeded to extrapolate to fit their narrative that something nefarious is going on. >Did they do a per-customer assessment? The deposit requirements are not dependent on the customer's credit abilities (see also: they can't use customer funds), it's directly dependent on what stock they're buying. >Why did they not just close shop for the day? At least that would have been honest. "I wanted to cash out last week but robinhood shut down! Robinhood caused me to lose 80% of my investment!"
- pfortuny 6y agoDid they release the true information? No. Like Bill Clinton, “they did never have sex with that woman”, which in a way of understanding is technically true. Either the market flows with honest information or it is being rigged.
- gruez 6y ago>Did they release the true information? I guess? * Did they shut down trading because of volatility? Yeah technically because the volatility was what caused their deposit requirements to go up. * Were they having liquidity issues? No, because they shut down trading before it became an issue. >Either the market flows with honest information or it is being rigged. I'm having trouble imaginging how him lying cause the game to be "rigged". Specifically, how him lying caused material harm to the robinhood users. People saw trading was restricted, so they jumped ship to other brokerages. They'd have done that regardless of whether it was caused by gremlins in the server room or liquidity issues.
- siruncledrew 6y ago>The biggest problem is Robinhood's poor messaging. It's clear their highest priority was to avoid admission that they were running out of money. IMO, this is why anyone wanting to "trade seriously" should NOT use Robinhood. Robinhood is like the fast food of investing. It's designed for convenience, but makes you worse off in the end. If you want a legit trading platform, then download Thinkorswim, Tastytrade, Schwab, Webull, Etrade, or Fidelity. Any of the above will tell you way more information than Robinhood, give you significantly better charts, and various extras like News and Level II data for free (at least Thinkorswim does). Honestly, just look around at the different offerings, maybe give them a test-drive, and choose whatever one suits you. Yes, you will probably have to learn the platforms, but that learning is valuable knowledge.
- Hacker29382 6y ago>Is it really so hard to believe that such an unprecedented mass movement would break the underlying business assumptions of a pre-IPO startup that was heavily dependent on their credit lines? Why didn't the recent-ish pot stocks bubble or the dry shipping bubble cause the same restrictions?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beezle 6y agoThis is a portion of a message sent to all users that IB sent out Friday afternoon: We are seeing unprecedented volatility in GME, AMC, BB, EXPR, KOSS and a small number of other U.S. securities that has forced us reduce the leverage previously offered to these securities and, in certain instances, limit trading to risk reducing transactions. IBKR currently has no restrictions on trading shares in those companies, and customers can open or close positions in those shares. Like many other brokers, IBKR placed options on certain of those stocks in closing only earlier this week. The plan is to lift those restrictions in an orderly manner while closely monitoring market conditions. To be clear, IBKR has not restricted clients’ ability to close existing positions in any of the U.S. securities subject to market volatility, and does not plan to do so. The limits IBKR has placed have applied to all customers and were not limited to “retail clients” or any other group.
- hctaw 6y agoIt sounds like the problem was sign-ups then, not trades.
- ar_lan 6y ago> The biggest problem is Robinhood's poor messaging. It's clear their highest priority was to avoid admission that they were running out of money. They didn't want to trigger a bank run or shake the confidence of their newly acquired users, so they tried to obscure the message as much as possible. As a result, the popular narrative assumed some sort of evil conspiracy theory. All of the previous bits of your message don't matter because this right here killed any chance of "good faith" people might have in Robinhood. Even if there really is no conspiracy, I personally am moving 100% to Fidelity after this fiasco (in fact, I moved everything but my remaining GME that exists in Robinhood already). I honestly, at this point, have about 20% faith that Robinhood will allow me to liquidate that GME - instead they will probably remove the "sell" button at some point too. I explicitly do not trust Robinhood anymore. It's one thing to say "we fucked up", or even "we can't handle this load anymore, we are going to need to remove the buy button". I'd be pissed but wouldn't want them scorched - at this point I hope the whole company goes bankrupt instead.
- gkoberger 6y agoI don't think there's a conspiracy, but I also don't think they get a free pass on this. They're going to lose much of their base, and they deserve to – if your whole thing is retail traders, and everything stops working when it matters most, then people are going to look elsewhere. The CEO lied on TV about the reason, there's rumors that their investors asked them to stop it (I mean, they got $1Bn relief... of course it was at least a topic of conversation), and they make a ton of money ($100M/Q I've seen) from one of the big players in this (Citadel). I'm not saying there's a conspiracy, exactly... but I am saying when it came down to making hard choices, it doesn't take a full-blown conspiracy for them to make some of the decisions they made that erred on the side of benefiting institutional investors. All their cash (via both raising capital and selling data to funds) comes from institutional investors rather than average retail investors, and that was recently made clear to a lot of people.
- sidibe 6y ago"I don't think there's a conspiracy" followed by hints of conspiracy. I think Robinhood didn't do anything wrong (or even incompetent), but they are screwed because the prospect of losing money (actually just the potential of more money, they haven't lost any yet if they close now since the mania isn't done) is emotional and triggers outrage and a need for someone to blame.
- gkoberger 6y agoThat's my point. I don't think there's a conspiracy, where the CEO of Wall Street called the Robinhood CEO and said "shut it down now" and they did. Rather, I think everyone acted in their own self-interest, and a lot of random retail investors found out that their best interests were the only ones that didn't align with everyone elses. A lack of a conspiracy doesn't mean the results were any different.
- np- 6y agoIMO, it's similar to something like institutional racism. There probably are very few people who are openly and unashamedly racist at the highest levels of power (although sadly not zero) - but all it takes is the current players acting in their own self interest to keep perpetuating an extremely unfair and totally rigged system. Basically what MLK described in his Birmingham jail letter. (and to be clear, I think both of us are on the same page) But I would say - their underlying intentions are absolutely and totally irrelevant to the discussion. The only thing that matters is that they acted in a way that boosted Wall Street at the expense of retail traders, and thus they are perpetuating a corrupt system, whether they feel like they are or not.
- thefounder 6y agoThere is no conspiracy theory. Simply put both the hedge funds and the brokers have a common interest to ripoff the retailer. It's not like they are hiding, at least the guy from Interactive Brokers https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7RH4XKP55fM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7RH4XKP55fM
- fortran77 6y agoWhy did this congresswoman, a champion of the marginalized and oppressed, call for a hearing? And why only for Robinhood, when several firms had the same policy? And why is the SEC not also the subject of her proposed "hearing?" https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1354830697459032066 https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1354830697459032066
- tedunangst 6y agoBecause the people who feel robinhood wronged them are most likely to donate to her campaign. Not as many IBKR users in her fan base.
- mgkimsal 6y agoLess cynically, she may have heard from more constituents who were affected by the RH policy than other firms. Doesn't have to tie specifically do 'donations' or 'fans'.
- fortran77 6y agoIt just seems odd to stand up for the rights of the oppressed to speculate on puts, shorts and covered calls.
- Nullabillity 6y agoThe sentence right after that, in her first reply to herself: > Inquiries into freezes should not be limited solely to Robinhood.
- whateveracct 6y agobecause it's mostly for show?
- gulikoza 6y agoIt's not just RH that has disabled buying, other brokers have as well. Most notably IB and Trading 212 (which uses IB) with the IB CEO going on TV telling how that benefited them. There's clearly more going on than just some collateral bullshit that RH is spewing...
- Avicebron 6y agoprag you have been a warpath, I hope robinhood is paying you well for this
- jzoch 6y agoIts in poor taste to call it a "meme stock purchase" when it legitimately has a chance to make (and for many has already made) investors a lot of money. While there are memes around the stock purchase (no different than with TSLA) it is a very legit investment strategy and market opportunity. This was not Robinhood denying a couple redditors some meme material - it was a company denying many regular americans a once-in-a-lifetime investment opportunity (and in itself the practice may have suppressed the power of that investment)
- jonnyone 6y agoIs there room for the argument that Robinhood should have seen this coming days, possibly weeks beforehand, and been raising capital preemptively? In addition, DTCC raised collateral for specifics stocks from 2-3% to 100%, is there not room for investigation why aside from "volatility"?
- awillen 6y agoThe problem is the CEO specifically said they did not have a liquidity issue. That means one way or another, he's a straight up liar.
- fnimick 6y agoRead between the lines. They didn't have a liquidity issue after they disallowed the buying of stocks that had the 100% capital requirement from the clearing houses; hence, they no _longer_ had a liquidity issue.
- callalex 6y agoThat is still lying by omission. I’m really curious what motivates you to defend these liars?
- awillen 6y agoIf your business can't function normally (i.e. you have to disallow the buying of stocks that should otherwise be purchasable) because you don't have enough money, that is a liquidity issue. This is costing them a huge amount of bad publicity and losing them a lot of customers, so it's clearly an issue. If that issue is because they do not have enough cash on hand for normal business functions, then it's a liquidity issue.
- Waterluvian 6y agoAnd yet if I recall correctly, they were quite deceptive and cagey about simply telling everyone the truth upfront. Instead they said it was for everyone's own safety.
- qwertox 6y ago> Is it really so hard to believe that such an unprecedented mass movement would break the underlying business assumptions of a pre-IPO startup that was heavily dependent on their credit lines? This sounds more like an insurance issue which Robinhood didn't want to deal with.
- akiselev 6y ago> The biggest problem is Robinhood's poor messaging. It's clear their highest priority was to avoid admission that they were running out of money. They didn't want to trigger a bank run or shake the confidence of their newly acquired users, so they tried to obscure the message as much as possible. As a result, the popular narrative assumed some sort of evil conspiracy theory. What I don't get is, why is the fear of a bank run relevant? It's a startup and most people seems pretty YOLO about using it. I don't know anything about investor sentiment so I'm genuinely curious - I thought the SIPC covers the FDIC equivalent for RH accounts that show any semblance of trading. In this frothy market where a bunch of investors barely do due diligence, having collateral problems from too many customers joining too fast sounds like one of those rare "great problems to have," as evidenced by the line of credit they just got extended. Even with the added risk, investors are probably lining up. I was surprised that the CEO didn't go down that line of reasoning for the marketing effect.
- ameetgaitonde 6y agoIt might not be fear of a bank run, but of enforcement from the SEC or FINRA for not maintaining sufficient net capital. If they did run afoul of these regulations, it's probably advisable to not admit it on televised interviews. That would also explain why they accepted a $1 billion investment rather than expanding their credit lines, and continued to limit purchases of Gamestop stock. Monday at open, when last week's option contracts are settled, is going to be interesting.
- tempsy 6y agoI’m waiting for an explanation why Starbucks is on the restricted list. It’s not volatile.
- tedunangst 6y agoThe collateral requirements depend on net buys vs sells. I'm guessing RH was tapped to the limit, and the buy limits were applied to anything with unbalanced orders. That applied to a bunch of stocks then, some that were up, and some that were down and looked cheap. (SBUX and AMD were among those down after earnings last week.)
- tempsy 6y agowhatever the reason it’s clear they can’t handle whatever volume they are seeing right now. who would continue to use them at this point. most momentum trades are crowded - this implies any new crowded trade will have to be restricted.
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago> Is it really so hard to believe that such an unprecedented mass movement would break the underlying business assumptions of a pre-IPO startup that was heavily dependent on their credit lines? I don't think anyone is discounting this. The problem is that after going through so many of these problems with various pre-IPO startups, we appear to have not learnt our lesson. - Facebook made us think it was safe to publish our real names and pictures online, and attach them to a public profile. When cyber-stalking and cyber-bullying became a thing, they feigned shock & ignorance. - Twitter used to suggest anonymity and low-intensity were the main goals of their product. Then they doubled the character limit just as doxing and other forms of real-life intimidation began picking up steam on this platform. - YouTube used to portray itself as a free speech video platform, encouraging users to upload any and all videos that don't explicitly break the law. Now YouTube polices its content to such an extent, and with such murky and ever-changing policies, that speech which is perfectly legal and protected by federal law is banned without explanation. It now even inserts itself into the conversation with a degree of authority that pre-Google YouTube would never have dared attempt.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mancerayder 6y agoGreat. Now care to explain how the same thing happened with TDA, IB and Schwab? All under-capitalized as well?
- atlgator 6y agoThe logical fix would be don't allow people to buy on proceeds that haven't settled yet. Other brokerages do this regardless of the security. But instead they specifically limited buying only certain securities that their hedge fund affiliates happened to have shorts in, thereby eliminating buy volume entirely and causing the stock price to go down. It's too coincidental to ignore when there was clearly a more precedented alternative.
- hayst4ck 6y agoPeople create excuses all the time for everything. "You shouldn't hate Robinhood because they were new/incompetent/unprepared." Maybe. Maybe there's 10 different sources to they could have gotten the money from and they chose not to as well. Maybe there were actions they could have taken to solve the problem and chose not to because they were more aligned with the problem not being solved. This is why I don't like this explanation. At face value it is a good excuse, but when you do an analysis from an ethics and alignment point of view: Citadel is in bed with Melvin. Robinhood is in bed with citadel Robinhood sells data to citadel (this almost certainly is at the direct cost of its users) Robinhood does transactions through citadel (skimming some of the money off of users transactions) *Robinhood is more aligned with citadel than retail* The whole point of an excuse is to seem reasonable. Even if the excuse is true, the underlying relationships are very smelly. All of this from every side is speculation until discovery is done. Counterpoint, trading firms across the board were asked to alter behavior: If "You wouldn’t believe the shit going on behind the scenes right now. 10 hedge funds have fallen, and our clearing firm emailed to block ALL trading platforms from $GME, $AMC, and the like." is true, then that is quite literally a conspiracy. https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/l81l3g/dan_pipitone_cofounder_of_tradezero_fought_our/ https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/l81l3g/dan_pipitone_c...
- astrange 6y ago> Citadel is in bed with Melvin. > Robinhood is in bed with citadel The underlying relationships don’t exist because the two companies named “Citadel” here are different companies.
- hayst4ck 6y agoI definitely think I am under informed. Could you elaborate to help me understand?
- astrange 6y agoRobinhood uses a company named Citadel Securities for some order flow, which is a spinoff of the other Citadel, but is a separate LLC and doesn't care what the other one does. But it didn't matter even when they were the same company, because different departments of finance firms don't talk to each other by regulation ("Chinese walls").
- dalbasal 6y agoThere's a little more depth to this. It's not just an influx of users or the margin they provide to fund accounts before user money arrives to RH's bank account. Clearing houses, and clearing houses' clearing houses' have raised capital requirements for buying gme from 1%-2% to 100%. This has to be the brokers' capital. User capital doesn't count, so it doesn't matter that a user has fully paid for the share. This is unintuitive, but CEOs of several brokerages have confirmed. That may let RH off the hook (even they they could have borrowed easily, to cover fully paid, unleveraged purchases), but it does push the "conspiracy" question downstream. Why did clearing houses make this call? After all, it's not RH's that's liable to be unable to pay. They've already paid. At this point, there are enough credible reports confirming that clearing houses have been shutting down, or trying to, memestock buys at client brokerages. They probably do have market integrity reasons for doing so, but the specific mechanics are unclear. Also regardless, this is a decision that changes the game/rules, affecting winners, losers, outcomes. Who was the power to make these calls. I guess it isn't a regulator. Meanwhile, RH and other brokerages are responsible for whatever misunderstanding and conspiracies happened. "Because the stock is volatile and we're protecting our customers from volatility" is a naked lie. Start with a lie, and people will assume the worst. FWIW, I think it's telling that the CEO of Robin Hood was willing to imply liquidity issues to avoid talking about market makers or clearing houses. I don't know what it tells, but I guess we'll find out in the coming weeks. One thing that always comes out of these scandals is some insight into the wall street "infrastructure."
- sumedh 6y ago> Clearing houses, and clearing houses' clearing houses' have raised capital requirements for buying gme from 1%-2% to 100%. Was the requirement raised 100% in the past for other stocks.
- Paradigma11 6y agoIsn't there also the related/same problem that WSB users on RH explicitely and intentionally want to ruin the short sellers which unavoidable would leave the middleman/RH holding the bag? Suddenly your users, not customers those are the market makers, are your opponents.
- croutonwagon 6y agoIt’s also worth noting that’s a different model than a lot of the big companies. For example you don’t get margin on fidelity unless you apply for it and sign waivers and attest you can cover it. And any intraday trades will garner warnings if you don’t have the cash in account to cover. After a couple they will axe the ability. Robinhood intrinsically allows a lot more leverage and risk for their customers by default. And this isn’t their first snafu. They had people exploiting their margin defaults for basically infinite leverage a year ago, leverage these 20 somethings would never be able to cover.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fny 6y agoKeep in mind Robinhood could have just restricted said herd. If they did in fact have such huge liquidity issues, it's extremely irresponsible to allow tons more margin accounts to come online.
- chrismcb 6y agoBut... Wouldn't that mean they need to halt all buys? Why only the ones being targeted?
- ineedasername 6y agoThe biggest problem isn't poor messaging, it's biggest problem is that it's running too lean if it can't cover unanticipated calls for collateral. This is a game that requires some deep reserves. Hopefully when this settles down and they're able to reduce collateral requirements with the clearing house they'll keep the extra on hand.
- qazpot 6y agoThere is no temporary lapse in Integrity.
- dublidu 6y agoThey could have simply banned buying the stock using unsettled cash or margin. Instead they banned all buys and did a terrible job explaining their reasoning.
- jb775 6y agoI call BS. If margin were an issue, they could've easily paused that functionality. (just like how they magically paused trading on specific stocks) I'll stick with Occam's razor here. They were trying to appease the hedge funds who pay them hundreds of millions of dollars a year.