38 ms·
Someone brought an interesting perspective in another thread and I can't shake it off. The other side keeps deplatforming them. Their legal cases are rejected.
by nicbou 6y ago
Someone brought an interesting perspective in another thread and I can't shake it off.
The other side keeps deplatforming them. Their legal cases are rejected. The mainstream media refuses to take them seriously. We're not even listening to them, because it's science and they're *ists if they disagree. We're not debating anymore. We just assume we're right.
We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate, and they are powerless to stop it. Is it surprising that they are furious about it, and explode in unpredictable ways? Wouldn't you do the same?
E: I accidentally hit submit halfway through my argument. You might be replying to a really different comment
- mmastrac 6y agoThey are spewing a constant stream of hatred and disinformation. Nothing of value was lost here.
- deelowe 6y agoHere's a direct quote from someone I'm close to: "I don't agree at all with those people storming the capital. This does not represent who we are, but what do you expect when the media claims not a single voter fraud case was won in court when in fact almost all of them never went to trial? They are lying." Nearly half the nation voted for Trump. I don't believe half the nation is full of hatred and disinformation. No more so do I feel people burning businesses and shooting cops represent the BLM movement. These people protesting. BLM, Occupy Wallstreet, Tea Party, Voter Fraud. At a certain level, they are all protesting the same thing. They are protesting the system. Cops, Bankers, Regulators, Politicians. The wealth gap is widening and people are getting frustrated. Unfortunately people are easily misled and are resorting to group think instead of recognizing the real problem. I'm not a republican, but does anyone not feel just a little uncomfortable that the less worse option this year was a career politician with his own sorted history and snake oil salesman smile? Come on man.
- detaro 6y agoIf your lawsuit doesn't even go to trial (for a variety of reasons), you clearly haven't won it. Unless you win a lawsuit, "haven't won any of their lawsuits" is 100% true. And the media did report on sme of the lawsuits being thrown out, but I'm sure they would have found something wrong with reporting that too. Or should the courts just suddenly start entertaining invalid lawsuits just so Trump lawyers don't look as incompetent? (And from reading up a bit, multiple courts have judged on merit and found that the claimants didn't provide compelling evidence for their claims)
- deelowe 6y agoMy point was that the lawsuits are irrelevant. People are looking for answers and misplacing their blame.
- seesaw 6y agoYeah, I was hoping that the HN crowd would be pondering over the root cause for how we got here. There is a reason a lot of people are angry on both the sides, and the reasons mostly overlap.
- nicbou 6y agoI couldn't tell, since what they have to say never reaches my feed. However I've been reading comments like yours across every platform for over a decade. At some point I'm not sure if they're really all that, or if I was just conditioned to believe that, and to leave them out of the conversation.
- mmastrac 6y agoI spent the last few days reading the donald site and it's just as bad as everyone says it is. Calls for refreshing the tree of liberty, calls for violence (in minecraft), etc.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoCheck out thedonald.win and voat if you want to see what you're missing. People saying things like this are sugar coating it.
- mlyle 6y agoYah. IMO-- only the most directly dangerous stuff -- incitements to violence-- should be removed. If you chase them out of Twitter, they'll make an even worse echo-chamber. > Their legal cases are rejected. The mainstream media refuses to take them seriously. > If you deny them the usual channels, is it surprising that they take the other route? On the other hand, if what they're asserting is crazy and unsupported by fact, what's the alternative? Report it uncritically as part of "both sides"? Listen to them in court and give them relief anyways?
- abernard1 6y ago> On the other hand, if what they're asserting is crazy and unsupported by fact, what's the alternative? How is this any different from the entirety of human history? America has gotten along quite fine without a central Ministry of Information directing what people should and should not believe is true. It is especially galling to think that some content moderators in the very narrow slice of society in Bay Area tech is qualified to do that job. We've reached the point where the American left is afraid of the idea of free speech.
- nelson_muntz69 6y ago> How is this any different from the entirety of human history? The difference is the echo chamber effect and the removal of opposing view points from an individual’s “feed”, while simultaneously facing no social pressure to conform to actual not-on-the-web society. Edit: spelling & clarity
- dpwm 6y ago> We've reached the point where the American left is afraid of the idea of free speech. Debating the merits and demerits of free speech surely has to fall within free speech. From what I've seen, free speech often gets raised as an unquestionable ideal and kills off sometimes uncomfortable discussion.
- mlyle 6y agoKarl Popper tells us about the paradox there...
- bjtitus 6y ago> Their legal cases are rejected. The mainstream media refuses to take them seriously. Well these last two seem pretty par for the course for illegitimate claims been promoted as legitimate. At a certain point the line of absurdity has been crossed at it is not the duty of society to constantly debunk illegitimate claims. > The other side keeps deplatforming them In this particular case, Parler has been host to a number of specific violent threats against the Vice President and members of Congress. Those threats are a crime under Title 18 Section 871 of the United States Code. Threats to others could constitute assault in many jurisdictions. I really see it as no surprise that platforms hosting Parler entry points are concerned about this. They could be potentially held liable since this type of speech is not protected by the first amendment.
- nicbou 6y agoYes, that is what reddit, twitter and Hacker News reinforce constantly. It's either because it's true, or because the other side has been repeatedly discouraged from adding their two cents in those communities. I've been seeing the world through this lens for so long that I can't tell. I find it somewhat implausible that half the population is dumb, racist and all those other labels. It seems much more likely that I don't fully understand their perspective.
- mmastrac 6y agoIt's not half the population but a significant portion of people are really that dumb and racist. We just need to figure out how to avoid them getting programmed like this.
- Stoic0 6y agoI know. Let’s ship em all to gulags for re-education and right think!
- botwriter 6y agoWhy does the left have to censor the right? Surely they should be able to beat the right with logical and reasoned arguments? Censorship has always struck me as a tool that a side which isn't confident in its arguments uses.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoI get what you're saying but the other side of the coin is maybe the society at large is rejecting them. And they need to understand that they're not guaranteed an audience, If the society at large doesn't want to listen then they'll have to sloowly try to win some support. They seem to forget that many on the left fought tooth and nail historically for things we now consider for granted but society wasn't on board for in the past. And maybe some ideas just aren't that appealing and they'd do better to pull other ones to advocate for.
- nicbou 6y agoIf they were a fringe movement I'd be inclined to agree, but they're half the voter base. They can't possibly all be violent bigots.
- giglamesh 6y agoHalf of the voter base has not even heard of Parler, let alone would be silenced if it was held to minimal standards of accountability.
- lanstin 6y agoThe power of the internet means sure they can. Like that poor Macedonian women who was so upset to be maxed when she was trying be a revolutionary. Our brains are surprisingly susceptible to weak thinking from the internet.
- e5india 6y ago> They can't possibly all be violent bigots. And yet Parlor is being de-platformed specifically because it refuses to police the portion of the conservative conversation that is so. It's not because they believe in smaller government or lower taxes. Conservatism plays this game where it uses this violent rhetoric casually and then acts all surprised when its own members act on that rhetoric. They tell each other that anyone who disagrees with them is an anti-american who want to make this a communist/socialist/fascist state. That voter fraud is rampant and that they will need to overthrow the government with violence. They do this is, in much more graphic detail than I'm using here. Then, when something violent occurs, we're all just supposed to sit here and pretend like it's just some happenstance and we shouldn't judge them by their own inaction in stamping out the rhetoric from their midst.
- caconym_ 6y agoWhat is “the other route”? They are being deplatformed because their speech is violent and damaging—in many cases it’s literal incitement to violence. Their legal cases are being rejected because they have no legal merit. The mainstream media refuse to take them seriously because they have again and again shown themselves to be bad faith actors, peddlers of unsubstantiated conspiracy, outright liars, and so on. I don’t need anybody to tell me any of the above secondhand—they themselves, via Twitter accounts and so on, are primary sources. All things are not equal. Order and chaos are not equivalent. If a rabid cougar gets loose in a shopping mall, it does not earn the right to be there just by being there (de facto) and being really, really mad. It’s going to hurt people if we let it do its thing, and we take whatever measures we have to to get rid of it for the greater good of society.
- obiefernandez 6y agoThis is a great point that is not made often enough. The logical conclusion is that the de-platformed actors get mad enough that they start lashing out in criminal ways, doing stuff that gets them locked up or killed, or otherwise "de-platformed" in real life. There's some short term pain, but ultimately society has a net win. Convince me I'm wrong...
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoRemember your post when things don't end up going down the path you think you've expertly designed for your preferred outcome. When you ask "why is this happening?", know that you were part of the reason why things ended up the way they end up.
- yawaemworht 6y ago> The logical conclusion is that the de-platformed actors get mad enough that they start lashing out in criminal ways, doing stuff that gets them locked up or killed, or otherwise "de-platformed" in real life. There's some short term pain, but ultimately society has a net win. Convince me I'm wrong... Aren't you, in this comment, doing the same exact thing for which those people are getting deplatformed? I read that as a "if they get killed that's a win for society". Would you feel comfortable if somebody said the same thing about other categories of people?
- gmac 6y ago> Their legal cases are rejected. Not-an-American here. When their cases seek to disenfranchise large swathes of voters based on zero evidence, what’s the alternative?
- Nightshaxx 6y agoBut there are some suspicious looking numbers and events that happened. I personally don't believe that they are true, but why not just investigate them? People distrust dominion voting systems; Just allow a bipartisan audit. People think certain votes were counted without both parties present; just recount those votes. Where is the harm in just being absolutely sure of things? If you just shut down people because there is no absolutely solid, undisputed evidence, they just think you are hiding something.
- Tokkemon 6y agoEvery state already did that. There is no evidence of widespread fraud. Georgia, in particular, was crystal clear about this.
- jansanchez 6y agoThey have recounted the votes in Georgia like 2 or 3 times. Wisconsin was also recounted once. I didn't check the other states.
- Ancapistani 6y agoIt’s slightly more complicated than that. First, the position of the plaintiffs of those cases is that the actions of the “other half” have effectively disenfranchised them. If disenfranchisement is the issue at hand, it follows that one should investigate when someone claims to have been disenfranchised. Second, every case that I’ve followed up on has been denied on the grounds of standing. My understanding is that this means that either the court believes that there was no harm or that the court believes that there is no reasonable way the outcome of the case could provide relief for harm that may have taken place. Either way, to my knowledge, none of the court cases have actually been heard. No evidence has been presented and no arguments have been made.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoWe already know from history what happens when large groups are disenfranchised from the public sphere. Violence. Lots of it. And once it starts, it's not easily stopped. Some welcome this because they think it can be managed for their own purposes. But once civil order breaks down, things simply accelerate with no possibility of talk being able to stop it anymore. It takes on a life of its own. Those who dream of the power they can seize once the violence starts are completely delusional. The winners and losers cannot be predicted ahead of time. There's no good path through it but this does appear to be the path that some have decided to force society down. Doubt most of them are even aware that this is what they're doing.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoIronically this mildly marginalized group seems to be very unforgiving of other marginalized groups. When they have to put their most extreme words on alternative websites they blame that preemptively for extremist actions. When other groups have been marginalized systemically by public infrastructure, violence and a lopsided legal system, they advocate personal responsibility as a solution for systemic problems.
- sjg007 6y agoThe downvotes your post is experiencing is disheartening. Either there’s a big proTrump component of HNs or there are disinformation bots.
- dang 6y agoYou broke more than one of the site guidelines with this. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here. A corrective upvote would have sufficed. Notice that the comment you're talking about is no longer in a downvoted state.
- gamblor956 6y agoThese groups became violent while still enfranchised. And they're still enfranchised: they can still vote, and still post to the internet, and still talk to people outside. They simply no longer get a free internet loud speaker to envangelize to others.
- soupson 6y agoThe mainstream media refuses to take them seriously? Fox News’ ad revenues beg to differ.
- twiceaday 6y agoThis argument rests on swapping the meaning of 'them' from 'the loudest extremist Republicans' to 'the average Republican' half-way through.
- zests 6y agoIts the Motte and Bailey fallacy.
- henliher 6y agoTheir legal cases are not being silenced though. They've been free to submit their many lawsuits and they've been rejected for not having any legal merit. The mainstream media gave them a platform for 5 years. When Trump announced that he was running for president, every media platform was reporting on it. We've been seeing and listening about this administration and it's supporters more than any other administration in the past. They've had a very loud voice that this week culminated on the invasion of the US Capitol. The were not squeezed out of public debate, they've had a huge platform but their arguments as of late have become violent and dangerous.
- Ancapistani 6y agoCould you point me to an example of a case dealing with election fraud or mishandling that was decided on its merits? I’ve not seen one. Every one I’ve seen was dismissed procedurally before evidence was ever heard.
- gpm 6y agoI'm not sure if any complaint was dismissed solely on the basis of the evidence, and not also because the plaintiff also failed to do other things like show that the court actually had article 3 jurisdiction, but certainly many courts found the evidence and legal arguments lacking enough to dismiss the case, in addition to finding that it would independently need to be dismissed for other reasons. For example, see section F starting on page 22 of this ruling https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.azd.1255923/gov.uscourts.azd.1255923.84.0_2.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.azd.1255923... The legal arguments being so bad that they failed procedural is not a defense for the Trump side, it's a demonstration of how badly they are failing to make a case at all. The easiest part of an allegation of fraud is to not fail on procedural grounds. Edit: I mean - actually - easier than that is not being so aware that your evidence is lacking that you try and claim a case is and isn't about fraud in the same oral argument - but that's just a particularly special brand of incompetence and flailing that I've never heard of outside of the Trump campaign lawsuits... https://lawandcrime.com/2020-election/hear-it-for-yourself-rudy-giuliani-flubs-law-and-facts-in-federal-court-as-pa-counties-skewer-disgraceful-performance/ https://lawandcrime.com/2020-election/hear-it-for-yourself-r...
- mbesto 6y ago> We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate They didn't exist in the public debate to begin with. Social media opened that up. We're realizing just how negatively impactful a village idiot with a megaphone the size of a city block can be.
- andy_ppp 6y agoYes, the problem is this; I’m not interested in what someone who is dumb enough to storm the Capitol building has to say. And they aren’t interested in having a debate on the facts either, so what are we going to discuss? I don’t get how we can come together and make this better...
- lanstin 6y agoLook into targeted individuals - they are similar to QAnon but clearly exhibiting classic schizophrenia symptoms and now organized and helping each other come up with ways to keep the thought rays out of their heads etc. I have no answer but I remember how intoxicating it was when I first got access to an world wide communication network and could learn from neuroscientists all over the world (as a then 16 yo I got flamed a good bit.). We for sure haven’t figured out how to use global networks safely.
- dcolkitt 6y agoHonest question: Who do you consider the smartest Trump supporter? Do you think you have anything to learn from them by engaging in a good faith discussion? My point being maybe you think 95% of MAGA-hats are off their rocker, and Trumpism taken as a whole is grossly misguided. I don't really disagree. But is it possible that there's some core nugget of wisdom to take away. Something, perhaps that your current worldview is glossing over. Instead of just writing off the political beliefs of literally half the people in America, maybe we should really be super certain that we make a genuine attempt to understand where they're coming from. At worst, we've wasted some time talking to idiots. But my guess is if we make a good-faith and honest attempt to find the best and brightest Trumpists out there (instead of just smugly dunking on the dumbest trolls on the Internet), that maybe, just maybe there may be a kernel of truth underlying their ideology.
- spoonjim 6y agoNo, it's not surprising that they explode in unpredictable ways. That's why you need the tanks and the guns for when they do, not just let them run roughshod over the basic concept of fact-based reality.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago>That's why you need the tanks and the guns for when they do, not just let them run roughshod over the basic concept of fact-based reality. I wonder if you spent the summer complaining about police militarization? Fact-based reality... IDK man. How would you ever know? The number of upvotes you get on your post?
- elliekelly 6y agoThey’re being de-platformed for the same reason the Marriott kicks a homeless person out of the lobby or Amtrak kicks a loud person out of the quiet car: most of the platform’s users don’t want them there.
- koolba 6y agoThis is more akin to Amtrak kicking out half the people on the train who already purchased tickets.
- varjag 6y agoWell you get your money back.
- bluthru 6y agoIf they're being a jerk and harassing other people I understand, but otherwise you would never encounter them.
- secondcoming 6y ago, or a black woman gets kicked off a bus
- chrischen 6y agoThey were never part of public debate. They were just talking amongst themselves, showing each other what they wanted to hear, and validating their own beliefs in a downwards spiral towards eventual extremism. This is enabled by the internet more than any specific social network. It's like sending someone to prison and expecting them to turn into a law abiding citizen: hard when all your peers are also criminals. Now the internet has essentially allowed such criminals to gather virtually and fester in their toxic ideas much in the same way a high school outcast may find they aren't alone when they get out of high school. One of the logical fallacies from pro-free-speech defenders of these people is the assumption that these ideas were organically developed. But I can assure you there is propaganda and foreign and domestic special interests that are intentionally shaping the thoughts and ideas from these people. I know in the Chinese community that interests like Falun Gong (an organization that believes extra-terrestrial Aliens are manipulating humans to intermix racially in order to subjugate us as well as other less-than-progressive beliefs like homophobia) have been heavily pro-Trump because of his anti-China policies, and they've been putting out a lot of toxic content aimed at Chinese-Americans [1] [2]. This is a disinformation war and taking actions like this is a part of war, otherwise services like Twitter are just complicit in aiding misinformation campaigns by one side. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/01/07/trump-qanon-stop-the-steal-japan/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/01/07/trump-qanon-... - Falun Gong organized "Stop the Steal" protests in Taiwan [2] http://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14013938 http://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14013938 - Same Falun Gong protests in Japan
- Anon1096 6y ago>They were never part of public debate. They were just talking amongst themselves, showing each other what they wanted to hear, and validating their own beliefs in a downwards spiral towards eventual extremism. Isn't the exact opposite true as well then? If one side is siloed, by definition the other side must be in an opposite silo. You've taken it upon yourself to define that your side is in the "public debate" and therefore somehow isn't just "talking amongst themselves". Don't you see the issue here? Left Twitter/Reddit/Facebook absolutely exists, and they are not meaningfully conversing with the other side. And, if anything, having a sitting president on your side should by definition mean that you are "part of the public debate", since everyone at least hears the president's words (and especially Trump's).
- chrononaut 6y agoDoes that imply that people in the year 2000, before most of these platforms existed, couldn't participate in any public debate?
- koolba 6y agoThey’ve been shifting the Overton window for years. Are against open borders? Then you’re a racist. Are against abortion? Then you’re a misogynist. Are for a pro worker visa policy and tariffs on imports? Then you’re a nationalist (which isn’t even a bad word but they make it sound like one) Are for the right to bear arms? Then you’re an uneducated hillbilly. Are for churches and other religious institutions to decide for themselves if they remain open? Then you’re a religious nut job who thinks the world is flat.
- SR2Z 6y ago> Are against open borders? Then you’re a racist. Find me one Democrat with actual power advocating for open borders. And it's not as if the speech used by xenophobes is free of racial overtones and dogwhistles, either. > Are against abortion? Then you’re a misogynist. If you are against a woman's right to do what they please to their own body, you have to give compelling evidence for why. There is no such evidence. > (which isn’t even a bad word but they make it sound like one) Because it is a word that historically was used by people who started a lot of wars and were fixated on who/what was _truly_ part of their nation. The "they" in "they've been shifting" is a strong majority of the people around you who now value racial inclusion and self-autonomy far more highly than ever before. This is a problem of values and pretending that all of them are created equal.
- jessaustin 6y ago... a word that historically was used by people who started a lot of wars... That's us. USA starts lots of wars. We've still got, what, seven going right now? Maybe it's down to six? (Ummm... Iraq Afghanistan Syria Yemen Korea Palestine Iran well that's at least seven but I'm probably missing multiple wars in Africa...)
- koolba 6y agoYep. And the one President in decades that hasn't started any is apparently the war monger.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIs it surprising that when fascists and racists are muzzled, they lash out to try to maintain the power to hurt others? No, it’s not surprising, and the lack of surprise is not part of any of the newsworthy stories of the last several days.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- e40 6y agoI saw a comment on twitter which went like this: What do you expect when Fox News and many other right-wing outlets are just lying all the time? When lawyers for DJT go into court and admit there is no fraud and then go out to the steps of the courthouse and give a press conference saying there is fraud and it must stop. Fox News, et al are talking about this non-stop since the election. Just think of all the people that have listened to this and believe it. What on earth do we expect them to do?
- Ancapistani 6y agoFor what it is worth, the vast majority of those who would be labeled as “far right” here on HN see Fox News as part of the problem, not a source of truth.
- lanstin 6y agoMuch more so since the election.
- Ancapistani 6y agoAs a rule, the further from centrist the person lies, the longer they have been disillusioned with Fox News.
- e40 6y agoI never said there are far right people on HN, and frankly, I don't really see them. There are a few trolls that get their comments killed, but I don't count them.
- Tokkemon 6y agoYeah, because both sides are equal in value and sanity. This is not about both sides. This is society taking control of itself again and deciding that this cancer on this society will not be allowed to grow further. Unfortunately it happened much later than it should have, so there will be collateral damage. But this hatred must be removed if society is to progress any further.
- bjustin 6y agoThe ones radicalizing these people are responsible for squeezing them out of public debate. What if these people were going around insisting the Earth is flat, trying to force other people to agree with you, then increasingly lashing out when others don't agree? Oh, and they are picking up new adherents by doing this as well. Consistent enforcement of the rules (which Apple is not good at, I will say) would have avoided this becoming such a problem. Parler has been a cesspit for its whole existence, as far as I know, and approximately nobody would have cared if Apple never let them on the App Store. And fewer people would blindly believe that the earth is flat.
- riwsky 6y ago“We just assume we’re right.” That’s just it, though: we assume we’re wrong. We audit ourselves. Watch any of the press conferences where the Georgia election officials detailed the extra work they did. It is that we assume we are wrong for the important things, and double check, triple check, that separates our viewpoints from those being deplatformed.
- jpttsn 6y agoIt can’t possibly work like that, logically. Those being deplatformed are as certain as you are that they are right. I’ve been disillusioned about this e.g. in trying to have conversations about religion with believers. No matter how much better I think my case is, they will think their case is just as much superior to mine. For every time I double check my books, they double check theirs. Philosophically, I don’t think that’s a “solution” to the puzzle.
- riwsky 6y agoWhat are you checking books for? Run experiments. Don’t go to your books about dropping weights off Pisa, just _drop weights off Pisa_. I don’t care what people are certain of: either those weights fall independently of their mass or don’t. If you are treating it like philosophy instead of science, you’ve already lost the thread.
- jpttsn 6y agoIn other words, actual enlightenment era style DIY science. But then how do I decide whether to recycle or not, vis-à-vis global warming?
- tanseydavid 6y agoGravity is NOT controversial and Political Science is all about philosophy.
- riwsky 6y agoGravity isn’t particularly controversial these days, no. Many things that aren’t now, though—like the curvature of earth, or heliocentricity—once were; that a topic is controversial doesn’t mean there’s no right answer. And I would agree that political science is largely concerned with philosophy, but let’s not mistake any old politicized belief as fitting under the umbrella of “political science”: that e.g. a manual recount renders any conspiracies about an automatic ballot-counting machine irrelevant to a final vote tally is a matter of common sense, not profound debate—and yet this has proved a controversial point these last few weeks.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI remember a time when this set of ideas was well known and understood, and routinely discussed for the benefit of civic enrichment and historical background. It was also well known that some holdouts were holding on to the ideas, but they were generally assumed to be cranks and their numbers were small enough to ignore. Then the internet. And their ideas were able to find purchase where they hadn’t, and to grow like a hateful tumor. Even then they were at least nominally a minority view. And then they found a path to power, and public vocal support became mainstream. Perhaps there was such widespread support for violence and hatred and malice before, but it was so shunned it couldn’t find its voice. That’s a pretty grim possibility but I accept it’s a real one. Or perhaps the attitude that all ideas are welcome combined with their amplification has expanded the base of people it could attract. In either case, I’m less concerned about whether a hateful viewpoint has easy access to eyes and ears, regardless of the size of the population holding those views, than the impact it has on those they hate. If (hypothetically) 35% of the population were literal nazis literally trying to get a genocide going, and the mainstream were trying their best with available measures to limit that possibility by excluding their views from most outlets commonly accessed by the remaining 65%, I’d say that’s a welcome relief for the most vulnerable among their targets. I don’t know how society benefits from the presence of hate in the public debate. Sure, the people who espouse hate are left out and pity for them. But what does their view contribute that we don’t already know? Are we actually better off with their views being a part of shaping our future?
- jrochkind1 6y agoyeah, i agree, this simply isn't going to work.
- intended 6y agoThis is not an interesting perspective, nor is it new. Americans have been politely deplatforming each other for a long while. It’s only become an issue now, and attracted a nice term for it. I’ll skip the issue that one side isn’t really there for a conversation in the first place. Instead I’ll demonstrate that the cable news era already built its own filter bubbles and significantly reduced the ability for one side (the left) to Influence the other (the right). I clearly remember that climate frauds were given air time on Fox. When that air time resulted in politicians pushing anti climate views, actual climate scientists came to FOX to make their case. Instead they were faced with ridicule, in the same way that throwing people to lions was a fun spectacle for the audience. This ability to divide reality kept evolving till America showed the world that its possible to undo science. Remember Creationism? An anti science argument, designed to confuse children and adults with the goal of disproving evolution! “Teach the debate”, that most fraudulent of arguments, implying that scientific debates on evolution meant that evolution itself was not a solid idea. And it worked! When the right filter bubble avoids reporting things in a manner that allow for a fair middle ground to be reached, then what? I’ll tell you now, you need to remove money from the news, which even to me sounds like an insane idea. I would heartily recommend that people stop worrying about deplatforming. It’s worked great for the American Right. While people here may decry Trump, he managed to snag 2 SC seats, unknown numbers of other judges, defunded everything, fought China, and even today has a 42% approval rating! MORE people came out to vote for Trump this election than they did when he ran against Hillary. Worry instead that deplatforming works. And then realize that while this will go on to be a massive comment thread, there are entire countries under the thumbs of despots or regions ruled by local leaders who never get heard about, and who will never get deplatformed, because it will never get the attention of the people running Twitter/FB.
- FuckButtons 6y agoThis is backwards - they’ve had a huge unchecked platform in the form of Facebook Twitter et al for the last decade or so and this is the result.
- Quinner 6y agoFive years ago civil society was in general agreement that racism was bad and that we should respect the democratic process instead of seeking to violently overthrow it. Of course there were people who disagreed but they were at the margins and their voices were isolated to a few forums most people never heard of. A demagogue came along and used mass media platforms to destabilize the norms of civil society and give a large platform to previously marginalized views. Being able to air those views on mainstream outlets perpetuates the problem and shifts norms. We need to at least try to put this genie back in the bottle. Most people will revert back to previous mainstream views. The significant segment needs to go back to an insignificant segment. That insignificant segment will be angry that they didn't win, and likely some of them will be violent. But they've always been that way anyway.
- nnspired 6y agoThere is no going back. It is because the “winning” side is actively doing their best to demonize everyone who doesn’t fit into their mold. So much for reconciling differences.
- jackson1442 6y agoI don't think I need to reconcile my differences with Nazis or racists, sorry.
- shepherdjerred 6y agoA republican sees this election as an attack on democracy -- an election that was stolen. A democrat sees the election as a grab for power. Both are right in their actions from their own point of view.
- chasd00 6y agoif it were trump who won by the same narrow margin i would not have been surprised if the exact same thing happened only with the sides reversed. I don't see any difference between the two sides, only that one is on top and one is not and from time to time it rolls over. This is why the "deplatforming" is eyeroll inducing, eventually the pendulum swings back the other way and it will be the other side getting deplatformed. and so on
- ketamine__ 6y agoThat's not how Mitch McConnell sees it. He says the election wasn't even close.
- bendmorris 6y agoFalse equivalence, because there is zero rational basis to believe the election was stolen. People who are motivated to convince others of this are lying to them. Some are literally inventing "evidence" like registered voter counts that have been shown to be inaccurate, or arguing that states violated their own laws, when the state supreme court, the final adjudicator, rules otherwise. Frankly, it doesn't matter "who is right in their own point of view." We have to be able to stipulate to a basic set of facts that are supported by objective evidence. You can't just make shit up and expect everyone else to cater to it.
- dkobran 6y agoWhat exactly do you expect to learn from debating anti-semites, self-proclaimed Nazis, or people that are shouting “hang Mike Pence”? https://youtu.be/Fag0aC_M0_U https://youtu.be/Fag0aC_M0_U Today’s news: Joe Biden condemned the rioters who stormed the Capitol as “a bunch of thugs,” “domestic terrorists” and “white supremacists.” The president-elect specifically called out the rioters who wore shirts saying “6MWE.” “6MWE” is an anti-Semitic phrase that stands for “Six million wasn’t enough,” referring to the six million Jewish people who were murdered during the Holocaust. If you feel like we are where we are because we’re not listening to these people than you can count me out. I have absolutely nothing to learn from a white supremacist or someone inciting violence. And likewise, they have absolutely nothing to contribute to political discourse.
- chrismarlow9 6y agoWe have places for discourse and for them to say what they think. But we expect human decency that has nothing to do with political views. The media reports on facts, with proof, because their reputation sort of hinges on it. Retractions don't make them look good. These people don't live in the realm of facts. So the best that can be done for them is to print their opinion with the actual evidence next to it. It's not the medias fault if that evidence totally disproves whatever they thought.
- bun_at_work 6y agoI think this is an exaggeration, though, no offense. De-platforming extremists is not the same as limiting dialogue or public debate. I think of it like this - the crazy person on the street corner yelling at everyone that the world is going to end for years on end is not taken seriously be anyone. They could be right, sure, but that's not really a conversation worth engaging in. These sites are full of users who are shouting crazy conspiracy theories and promoting them like crazy. The worst of them are grifting, and lots of them are victims of human psychology and circumstance. I haven't seen any reasonable take from one of these communities be discarded or ignored. A lot of the issue comes down to how the reasonable ideas are mixed with the toxic ones. At some point it's just toxic, though. How many lawsuits are required to show the election was legitimate? There have been so many already. How many claims of voter fraud have to be investigated, when each new claim isn't real? How many times does congress need to investigate Hillary's emails? For the people in these communities it seems as though the only outcome they will except is the one they have predetermined. Along the way they will kill people, commit acts of sedition and treason, send bombs to democratically elected officials, and more. There is no reason to continue debating with them. The debates on those issues are over. When a petulant child argues with you about the color of the sky, how long do you entertain their claim that it's red, not blue? Furthermore, there are plenty of outlets for civil discourse all over the internet and other mediums. Why should we be upset when these private companies remove these toxic groups from their platforms? It's not like the platforms want less users. They want a stable country of laws, which the groups on these platforms are trying (intentionally or otherwise) to undermine. At some point the adults in the room need to say "enough." That's what is happening now.
- vb6sp6 6y ago"left" leaders aren't telling people to riot. They aren't mad because twitter is banning them. They are mad because someone is telling them to be mad
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- afavour 6y agoI reject the idea of an “other side” here. It’s very popular to bucket these things into black and white binaries but I don’t buy it. There are people who are on the fringes, both left and right, and then there are a lot of people who fit somewhere in the middle. Even “left” and “right” is a vast oversimplification at times. When you start to think about it that way the perspective you’ve outlined doesn’t make a lot of sense. Should these people have legally nonsensical court cases heard simply because they’re a minority group and we need to ensure diversity in plaintiffs or something? Overall, the argument only makes sense if there is some innate “right to be heard” that these people are being deprived of. There isn’t. There have been fringe movements that weren’t indulged by society at large for thousands of years, I’m not sure why any obligation would have changed.
- cmurf 6y agoParler, Apple, Google, Twitter are not public venues. In no possible way are they for public debate. If you go on Parler and call Donald Trump a malignant narcissist, you will get banned. If you say too many political things on Hacker News, you get warned and banned. None of these places are public venues. They are not the thing you seem to think they are. Maybe they aren't even what they have purported to be up until now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ketamine__ 6y agoDoes Parler actually ban people? I assumed anything goes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- secondcoming 6y agoI'm not an American or in the US, but it seems to me that the Supreme Court could likely have prevented all this, instead of dismissing the Texas suit with a two sentence response.
- throw0101a 6y ago> We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate, and they are powerless to stop it. Is it surprising that they are furious about it, and explode in unpredictable ways? Wouldn't you do the same? What did African-Americans do when they were marginalized for a century until the Civil Rights era of the 1960s? (And still are in many ways.) The folks you are referring to can say whatever they want: they have Fox, OANN, and Newsmax. They can set up phpBB to have online discussions. Mastodon and IRC are open source and distributed. They can rent a hall and have meetings and sign up as candidates for various political offices and put forward their platforms on Wordpress-powered sites. They can say whatever they want on myriad of platforms. But that doesn't mean anyone else has to listen.
- handedness 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Slave_rebellions_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Slave_rebellions_in_t...
- throw0101a 6y agoHow did each of those work out for the slaves?
- handedness 6y agoWell, for some of them, pretty darned well. A lot better than for their slaveowners, at least. Anyway, I'm not sure what your point is. Mine was that a lot happened before the 1960s, and much of it wasn't pretty.
- throw0101a 6y agoActually my statement (first sentence) was about the century before the 1960s, i.e., after the US Civil War when the slaves were already 'free'.
- 6y ago
- rootusrootus 6y agoI'll be honest -- I haven't really seen any cases where someone was deplatformed for a legitimate political view. By that I mean a viewpoint that is at least tolerant, if nothing else. If the argument against deplatforming is that people should be allowed to heap hatred on gay people or other minorities, then it's not a particularly strong argument. Maybe this is just inherent to a conservative viewpoint, I don't know. If progressives are pushing for more freedom, more tolerance, then to oppose it you have to, by definition, advocate for less of those. I like a spirited discussion, but I believe that intolerance is the one single thing we cannot tolerate. It destroys everything else.
- lr4444lr 6y agoWere you not here when the James Damore debacle happened? And he was hardly expressing a political PoV, just trying to marshall some data on good faith to respond to his company's solicitation for ideas people had to solve a tough problem.
- patmorgan23 6y agoAnd he advocated for policies that would tangibly make the workplace better and more equal like allowing for flex days and for employees to go part time during maturity/paternity leave.
- rootusrootus 6y agoThe Google engineer, right? I try not to read too much into company politics. Even at a relatively large company it can get very personal. AFAIK he wasn't really deplatformed anyway, he was fired. It seems that the NLRB decided the firing was proper. That's the sum total of my knowledge, and at first glance I don't think it's a good comparison with the larger discussion about deplatforming on public services.
- manfredo 6y agoI'd consider getting fired a much more serious form of ostracism than deplatforming. Getting banned from Twitter doesn't affect your ability to pay rent. I personally put the blame for his firing more on the blatantly distorted and sometimes even outright counterfactual coverage of his message. The number of mainstream and well respected outlets that falsely claimed he wrote that women are biologically less capable engineers, rather than that they lower predilection to enter the field , was disturbing. After his memo Google announced that they wouldn't set quotas for groups beyond the demographic's representation in the field. The people I know at Google felt that the reaction was overblown.
- renewiltord 6y agoI'm not surprised that they're furious. I'm just 50-50 on whether "explode in unpredictable ways" is worse than "spout and promote their blather in predictable ways". Right now, I'm thinking an occasional bomb planting here and there is better than normalizing the idea that "Famous Jew (((Bernie Sanders))) wants to eat your young" or whatever kooky shit they've come up with. Yeah, I think I'll take the unpredictable exploding for the moment. It's really not that bad.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Their legal cases are rejected. Because their claims are held up to the law and don't pass muster. > The mainstream media refuses to take them seriously. Some particular popular outlets are allied with them, the rest of the major media takes them quite seriously (it often investigated their claims and finds them unsupported, but that's not failing to take them seriously.) > We're not even listening to them, because it's science and they're ists if they disagree. No, we’re listening to them. The rest of us aren’t agreeing* with them. (On the other hand, this is more literally true in the opposite direction.) > We're not debating anymore. You can only debate from a certain degree of shared basis, which does not exist. > We just assume we're right. On the issues of objective, verifiable fact, this is a conclusion not an assumption. On the matters of fundamental moral values, beliefs on those issues have a fundamentally axiomatic nature: there is no debating them. On the other hand, this claim is, again, more true in reverse (especially on the issues of verifiable objective fact.) > We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate, Or they are excluding the rest of society from their debate. > and they are powerless to stop it. They are not powerless to stop disengaging or engaging only in bad faith. Well, I mean many of them individually probably psychologically are powerless to do so, especially while those they take their cues from are doing so, but as a collective group they are not. > Is it surprising that they are furious about it, and explode in unpredictable ways? What unpredictable ways? Most of their explosions are publicly telegraphed quite specifically, and have a direction that has been publicly requested by the public figures that they overtly venerate. It's not chaotic, unpredictable explosions of impotent rage of the factually disenfranchised, it's strategic, directed action at the behest of some of the most privileged segments of society, with the masses directed using mechanisms that are textbook features of cults. I mean, if you are talking about the Tes Party/Trump/Q/alt-right/etc. group. If you are talking about the people considered about the lack of accountability for murder of people of their race, actually, barring a partial shift that happened well into the paroxysm of protest over the last year, yeah, you are mostly exactly correct (though the nondisputable nature of fundamental moral principals is an issue there, too.)
- jonemi 6y agoFor those who think the parent comment was conflating extreme right and average right, I just want to add some clarification as to why deplatforming still affects large swathes of the population and not just extreme segments. I’m a strong social and fiscal conservative who never voted for nor liked Trump. I’m religious and that informs my opinions on a lot of social issues. I would be in strange company on Parler, but this still bothers me. My family are all strong Trump supporters to the point that leaves me shaking my head. Working in technology, I also have a lot of progressive friends and coworkers. As a racial minority, I think I can say this. There’s a real analogue to the general sentiment that LGBT, POC, or female Americans experience and worry about social or professional consequences to voicing their experiences and opinions and the general sentiment conservatives experience from voicing theirs. Before you castigate me and say it’s false equivalence, take the good advice of the anti-racism movement and “just listen” to why I feel that way. This is my personal experience as a POC and as a religious conservative working in tech. Even as a more moderate conservative (e.g., I believe climate change is anthropogenic and the state needs to correct for market failures), I genuinely feel like my voice is being suppressed—that is, my opinions are becoming less tolerable by the mainstream. For example, I have very traditional views about LGBT issues and abortion, but those views are becoming labeled as violent (I don’t believe in any kind of violence, BTW, but just believing that doesn’t accord with mainstream beliefs is considered hurtful and violent), in spite of how I support legislation and personally demonstrate fairness and tolerance for my LGBT friends and am sympathetic to women’s health issues. There are a lot of people on the right who would do well to listen to BLM and those who feel like their voices are being suppressed. There are a lot of people on the left who would do well to listen to conservatives who feel like their voices are being suppressed. Let’s just have more humility about these things. If you feel like you’re in a morally/intellectually/factually superior position, quit treating people who aren’t as enlightened as the enemy. Treat them with some decency and compassion and listen so you might persuade them instead of berating them about their wrongness. I think it’s hubris to be so confident in our own positions as to preclude accepting people’s lived experiences (like mine) as meaningful anecdata. As I continue to feel the shift to fewer and fewer outlets for my voice, I genuinely worry. I blame the extremists on the right, absolutely, but I also blame extremists on the left. At the core I blame the tendency to not listen.
- 6y ago
- coolgod 6y agoWho is "We"? Why do you assume HN users aren't Trump supporters? Many people see this from a totally different perspective. In most countries, these recent events would be called a coup, performed by the blue faction of the establishment.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Wouldn't you do the same? No, if every educated person, scientist, lawyer, and generally decent person starts treating me like I'm radioactive at some point I'd probably start pondering if they're right rather than putting on a Viking outfit and storming the capitol in the name of Q. I actually lack the imagination to conceive of what goes on in the mind of someone who stands in a crowd of people who look like a mix of dollar-store militia and medieval role-playing convention and not ask themselves where they went wrong
- wisty 6y agoI can think of a number of historical examples where the decent people were wrong. I'm not saying this is comparable, but people will say it is.
- awb 6y ago> We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate Or maybe just a loud segment of the population. ~22% of the US population voted for Trump (75M out of 330M). How many voted because they love Trump and his dangerous brand of politics? How many voted for him as an FU to liberals? And how many voted for Trump because they want conservative judges, lower taxes, a ban on abortion, etc. and are willing to hold their nose and vote for him? Trump rallies were dwarfed by Obama’s crowds. Trump marches were dwarfed by BLM, climate and women’s marches. But the media loved every non-traditional thing he did and America was happy to watch the train wreck. It’s an emotional time right now, but my neighbors with Trump flags are still nice people and are a far cry from the few hundred (or thousand) lunatics that are drumming up trouble. If we can give folks direct representation or at least something other than winner take all voting, we might start getting the politicians we deserve. Don’t forget, Trump had the lowest % primary vote share of a presidential candidate. He simply won because so many other candidates were splitting the vote. Put him head to head against other politicians and he loses. Give republicans ranked voice voting and I doubt he ever gets nominated. This too shall pass, but I doubt it gets as big as the civil war some fear. A Republican will step up to fill the political void and reprint the party in their own image and voters will fall in line.
- hooande 6y agoPeople say that censorship is wrong because good ideas should beat out bad ideas in the public discourse. Truthful and science based thought has won this battle. That's it, there isn't a rematch. At the end of a sports contest, one side my be very unhappy with the result. Perhaps even violently so. But it doesn't change the outcome. This was contested and decided, even if there are people who still disagree
- mech422 6y ago>> Their legal cases are rejected. They had 60+ chances to make a case, and couldn't... >> We're not even listening to them >> We're not debating anymore. I'm not listening anymore because there IS no debate. 'Debate' is an exchange of ideas. This is basically a 'harangue' - and personally, I'm tired of it. No one has a 'right' to force people to listen to them. >> We just assume we're right. No, I assume they're wrong as the logic doesn't hold up. There is a difference. Personally, I think the election basically boiled down to 'rural' vs 'urban', but I'm sure there are other views. I can't force people to believe my views 'cuz I said so!' anymore then Trump can force me to believe him, 'cuz he said so!' >> Wouldn't you do the same? I don't recall doing the same when Bernie was written off by DNC, and there actually WAS evidence the DNC tilted things against him. edit: fix formatting
- nova22033 6y agoTheir legal cases are rejected. Their legal cases are being rejected because they are filing bogus claims without evidence...totally made up crap..not quite the victimization you make it out to be...
- SilasX 6y ago"No, because that doesn't violate the First Amendment, and you're not allowed to feel uneasy about suppression of speech that's 1A-compliant, like the Hollywood Red Scare." -- 80% of comments when this topic comes up
- wilsynet 6y agoLet me put it a different way. It’s not that they’re being deplatformed; it’s that Parler violated the App Store TOS. Specifically Review Guidelines Section 1.1 - Objectionable Content. And Donald Trump violated the Twitter TOS. No one is being deplatformed, and it isn’t a left vs right thing. It’s reasonable that these companies enforce their TOS as they would against you or me. There’s no Apple TOS for websites viewed in Safari. And Apple has not made it so you can’t access Parler through the web.
- design-material 6y ago> I find it somewhat implausible that half the population is dumb, racist and all those other labels. It seems much more likely that I don't fully understand their perspective. Imagine: a leader calls for a certain racial, ethnic, or religious group to be barred entry to their country. This is a textbook example of racist policies. Half the population either - voted him because of those policies (and so are racist), - or were unbothered by those policies and voted for him (and so are not non-racist) In earnest - is there any other conclusion than the above?
- logicchains 6y ago>Imagine: a leader calls for a certain racial, ethnic, or religious group to be barred entry to their country. A religious group is not a race. When China persecuted the Falun Gong, nobody called them racist. You could say it's islamaphobic, but that connotates an irrational fear. It's not completely irrational when the values of many adherents to that religion differ so significantly from secular American values: pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2011/01/18/stoning-adulterers/. Fundamentally the difference between a religion and a race is that race is not controllable; it's clearly wrong to discriminate against somebody for something entirely outside of their control. But people do have control over their ideology, so much as some people would advocate discriminating against racists for their racist beliefs, people can advocate for discriminating against people who believe the legal system should sentence to death adulterers, apostates (people who leave their religion) and homosexuals (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_for_homosexuality#In_current_state_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_for_homosex...).
- design-material 6y agoThe Pew data seems to refute your point: it highlights opposing views across Muslim nations when it comes to redistributive justice - some nations are along the same lines as mainstream American thought, others aren't i.e. there isn't a universal, shared set of 'Muslim values' that can be said to clash with 'American values' And fair enough, it's not strictly racist. I believe the semantics here don't alter the spirit of what was said (that is, discriminating against a group of people) I'm not entirely convinced by the claim that one's religious choice being a choice means that it's not wrong to discriminate against them; what would your stance be on what the Chinese are doing to the Uighurs? (And - dare I ask - what does that then mean about your stance on the Nazi's policies?)
- 8note 6y agoIt's not like they aren't angry when they have a platform. The kkk folks were running people over in celebration of Trump's win. Appeasement is a failing strategy when it comes to fascists
- allarm 6y agoI mean - isn’t that obvious? Call it whatever you want - deplatforming instead of censorship- the result is the same - disbalance of opinions.
- bazooka_penguin 6y agoI honestly think just splitting the US off might be a better thing than marching blindly into worsening civil divide. We're at a point wherein either side winning the presidency is just riling up the other side. Biden literally represents only his 55% of voters and Trump his 45% and when one side ones the other strictly loses, there's no feeling of compromise anymore. This is going to end in one side subjugating the other, and the right is arguing right now that's exactly what the left is doing to them through the means that you mentioned in your post. I think, eventually they'll respond to their perceived subjugation and the recent riot was just the peak of an iceberg. They don't want to live a certain way but politics in general has been increasingly moving towards a national level, away from local politics. I can understand the right's belief that big city liberals are forcing left-wing values onto them because the left has expressed the same opinion about the right forcing values onto the left. The sentiment is mutual. And to some degree both sides are correct, there are definitely value systems that are forced from the top down (government), some may be good and some may be bad but that also depends on who you ask. And in the end neither side is happy. Now obviously, tech companies are in their right to ban whoever they want for whatever they want. That's how the US operates even though I don't like it, and the right was happy to give businesses that power. But at a societal level it's clear we have an America with more than one identity and it's acting like a dysfunctional mental illness because we're forcing people together that don't want to be together. If the middle east is any indication that's a recipe for inevitable conflict.
- voidhorse 6y ago> The other side keeps deplatforming them. Their legal cases are rejected. The mainstream media refuses to take them seriously. We're not even listening to them, because it's science and they're ists if they disagree. We're not debating anymore. We just assume we're right. Not really. More like, they voted in 2016 and won and "the other side" raised concerns about manipulation of voters and attempted to go through proper democratic channels to change things--which failed, so they accepted it and moved on until other debacles prompted similar action, and again, "they" accepted the results of those democratic processes, just like the game is supposed to work. The mainstream media has taken "them" seriously since 2016 and hasn't shut up about them since. Their legal cases are rejected because unlike what "the other side" did in 2016, they aren't following the process properly, have no legitimate evidence to present, they are totally incompetent, etc. > We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate, and they are powerless to stop it. The POTUS was their megaphone for 4 years. You are supposed to elect the person you feel best represents you and your interests. If "they" didn't do that, "they" shouldn't be trying to establish him as a monarch. "They" are traitors attempting to rob everyone that voted last year of their voice. Their turn with the microphone is up, but they refuse to yield it. Yes, the figurehead will no longer echo their ridiculous, conspiratorial, world view, so we are "squeezing them out" in a sense, but hey, it's called American democracy and it has worked that way for years. They've had 4 years to deliver on their promises and win a second term. Guess what. They didn't. You know why? Because instead of delivering they ignored a deadly pandemic and let 369K Americans *die* and the economy crumble. Now is not the time to sympathize and "let the other side be heard" we've been doing it for 4 years and there's nothing worth listening to unless your ears are comforted by the melodious sounds of the collapse of the United States. You're right, they're not scientists. And to regex away the things they actually believe (ists) instead of science shows that you don't really give the reality of what it actually means to be something like a, for example, racist the full weight it deserves. Being a racist means your beliefs actively lead to the disenfranchisement, or worse, direct violence on others, which also in turn eventually hurts you longer term (fyi). I think part of the problem with politics in this country is this very tendency toward abstractions, false equivalences, forgetfulness, and tepidness in language. Stop pussyfooting around. Call a spade a spade. If we all stayed grounded and spoke extremely concretely about things, it'd be a lot easier to prevent fringe voices intermixing with moderate voices under the banner of of a single ideology whose elements can differ wildly in their extremities. The fact of the matter is, most people only care about the one or two issues they feel affect them the most in a given moment and rather than compromise and side with the platform that maybe doesn't give them what they want on that one issue but is generally better overall they refuse to do so and will sleep with the devil just to have their one need met, damn everything else. The planet could literally become a flaming ball of molten lava and eliminate all life on earth and certain constituents in the US would not give a damn as long as it meant abortion was illegal. Here's roughly my theory of how American politics functioned over the past four years for several people in the "center right": Guy A believes something relatively reasonable, e.g. "I don't want to get taxed too much." Party L says, we want to help a bunch of people in the States out with free services. (Guy A thinks, hey that doesn't sound too bad), L continues, but to do it we need to tax you just a bit more than we do now. Guy A responds, well that sounded ok, but there's no way I'm letting you tax me more. Sorry. Guy B comes along and believes something heinous. Let's say he's a classical anti-semite and thinks all Jewish people are criminal and the root of all evil, he hasn't gotten to the point of wanting genocide yet, but he's on the path. Party R comes along. Party R says, we really care about guns. We want to make sure everybody can buy a gun, and here's why guns are great. Guy B likes this because he thinks he might need a gun in case he runs into a Jewish person. Guy A isn't a gun nut by any means but he wonders about taxes. Party R says they won't raise taxes at all, hell, maybe we'll lower them! Guy A is on board because even though Party L's initial proposition was more enticing, at least Party R won't increase his taxes. Next thing you know the anti-semite and guy that just wants low taxes are both called "republican" or "on the right". Both their interests become intermingled and caught up in a narrative that stands to represent the entire "party". A candidate comes along that appeals to the intersection of these interests, maybe he says some things that make Guy A a little uncomfortable, but hey at least his taxes are low right? Soon enough the fringe beliefs of Guy B become a more dominant element in the "party line" since the candidate wanted to appeal to all the interests of his party. And there you have it, Guy A becomes part of the anti-semitic party all because of his own stubbornness and refusal to compromise on a single point and then starts to feel attacked when "the other guys in Party L" start saying he and his guys in Party R are anti-semtic, because he isn't anti-semetic! But the attacks make him dig in more to Party R and gradually become more comfortable with supporting things that maybe would have bothered him before, like hating Jewish people, all because it's "his party" now and at least they still don't raise his taxes. So yeah, Guy A might wind up feeling "unheard" in all of this and like he's being conflated with neo-nazis when he's not really a neo-nazi himself, but he made his decision. Taxes were so important to him that he turned a blind eye to moral issues and decided to double-down when those issues escalated and "be loyal". Don't feel sorry for these people. That's how representation works. It doesn't matter if you went with the neo-nazis because you want low taxes, you chose them to represent you, so you don't get to say "well I'm not really a neo-nazi because I just wanted low taxes", especially when you doubled down and are only bailing out in the final hour since you finally realize it's repudiate or go down with the ship and your flight mode kicks in. You may not be personally murdering people, but you are an enabler at that point. You made a stupid, amoral decision and you are culpable for that. You need to take responsibility for such a choice. Now is not the time for sympathy toward "them". I did try to be sympathetic to the plight of this "unheard majority" in 2016. In 2021? Seriously? In order to even field such an argument after 4 years and a legitimate attempt to supplant the American flag for a flag with a single man's name on it seems to me completely delusional. Part of the reason things have gone this far is precisely because bad behavior has had zero consequences for this administration until maybe finally now. This president's incompetences has the death of 369k people and counting attached to it. Not to mention the jailed children, calls to foreign powers to help manipulate the 2020 elections, and deliberate lies to the citizenry about matters pertaining to their health (covid was supposed to "disappear" by Easter, remember?)
- ogre_codes 6y ago> We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate, and they are powerless to stop it. Is it surprising that they are furious about it, and explode in unpredictable ways? Wouldn't you do the same? Everyone is being subjected to the same standards here. Fundamentally Parler was banned because they wouldn't enforce their own policies. From Apple's post: > Your app enables the display of user-generated content but does not have sufficient precautions in place to effectively manage objectionable content present in your app. All Parler needs to do is not allow people to plot violence on their platform. This is against Parler's policies, it's against Apple's App Store policies, the actual conversations are often against the law. It isn't as if Apple is banning Parler because people are debating the second amendment. They are literally being banned for allowing people to openly plots against multiple government entities and individuals.
- ookblah 6y agoyeah... i would agree if there was actually a "debate" happening. anecdotally i can say the majority of people who are 100% on board his stop the steal stuff are not discussing in good faith. at some point you stop paying attention and if, like in this case, it turns to violence you do what you can to stop it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thwoawayyowser 6y agoI'm not an American and I don't identify with the political sides that have formed up but it is terrifying to me to see about half of the population being silenced.
- 0goel0 6y ago> We are slowly squeezing a significant segment of the population out of public debate They are not debating. They are yelling and screaming mindlessly.
- mushbino 6y agoAre you saying that Qanon might be worth hearing out and given a fair shake on the national state?
- brnt 6y ago"They" elected a president 4 years ago. How mainstream can you get?
- hrbf 6y agoBeing able to voice your opinion without government interference or consequences is your right. However, there is no right to be heard, hosted, given air time, published or even listened to. In the example of conservatives, if you align yourself with the current batch of conservative representatives, most points you want to raise fall flat. Without other context, you’re generally judged by the company you keep. Conduct yourself like an empathic human being and it’s likely (but not guaranteed) that people will listen to you. Scream at them and only people who are already as angry as you are going to listen. That applies to humans in general.
- shripadk 6y agoThanks for saying this. I'm glad I am not the only one feeling this way after all! I literally said the same thing yesterday to another comment in another post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25672161 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25672161 This sort of censorship will backfire badly. I won't be surprised if a real Civil War breaks out in America because of suppression of right wing groups by the Big Tech. This division is very real and scary. I shudder to think what sort of ripple effects it will have on 100+ countries where Big Tech operates! If it can nuke the US President's account what chance do other Presidents/Prime Ministers or Governments have? Please remember that this is not just an action/reaction issue. It is not that simple. There are Second Order Effects at play. You can't even launch a rival platform without first gaining traction. How would you gain traction if the medium for gaining traction is controlled by Big Tech? How do you promote a Twitter alternative if Google, Facebook, Apple and Twitter ban you from their platforms. Can't advertise on Google, can't put your alternative app on Android Play Store or Apple Play Store, can't promote on Twitter. Literally have no choice but to follow the guidelines set by Big Tech and be at the mercy of Big Tech. We are looking at a Big Tech Cartel controlled by left wing ideology. That's precisely what it is today. So what should the right wing do? Create a right wing Google, Facebook, Twitter, Apple alternative? Are we staring at the balkanization of internet as we know it?
- globular-toast 6y agoThey were never part of the public debate. The internet made it seem like they were for a while. Now the powers that be are making it right again. Technocracy is the natural way of things. Democracy is just an illusion to keep people happy.
- cmsj 6y agoWhy is there always this call to treat the less moderate right wing, who are clearly not connected with reality anymore, as though they are simultaneously extremely powerful, and weak little babies who need our help? When those people hold the reigns of power, they don't stop to think about how we're feeling. Why should we walk ourselves to them, why shouldn't they reflect on their anger and its consequences, and walk themselves to us?
- cmsj 6y agoJoe Biden can't personally deradicalise 70+ million people. He's got maybe 2 years to get some stuff done before there is the risk of a mid-term power shift like Obama faced. I would suggest that his agenda should have three priorities: 1) Get the pandemic under control 2) Do the opposite of the Republican's long agenda of gerrymandering/disenfranchising, to tip the scales back towards a point where a Democrat victory doesn't require exceptionally high turnouts 3) Make big changes that actually, materially, visibly improve the lives of the parts of society that have been suffering the most. If Democrats can actually hold on to power for a decade, they have the opportunity to do the big, hard things that will improve life for everyone, and people have time to see the effects and appreciate them. As it stands right now, any Democrat victories seem to quickly revert to Republican control and anything they tried to do gets undone before it's finished.
- jmcqk6 6y agoIf they were willing to discuss and listen, this wouldn't be a problem. If people are just talking at you, it's not your fault there isn't a discussion happening. I have tried for years to talk with the type of person that is getting deplatformed here. I'm related to many of them. They don't want to have the discussion. They just want to dominate everyone else. They are responsible for the consequences of their actions.
- cannabis_sam 6y agoI think you might be making the mistake of thinking that all these people are actually arguing in good faith... They don’t have explainable concerns, they just want the result of the presidential election changed for no other reason than that they prefer Trump over Biden. Otherwise they would have accepted the outcome of all the legal challenges in court, where all the evidence they are relying on have been rejected. But they don’t... these people keep reiterating evidence that has already been dismissed by multiple courts. I absolutely agree that it’s deeply problematic to ignore the views of portions of the population. But how do you reconcile Trump’s and his supporters vivid fantasy world with reality?
- trianglem 6y agoRacism, sexism, belief in science are things that are not going to be negotiated on. The other side are literal intolerant fascists and should be silenced. Let’s the chips fall where they may, even if that’s some sort of civil conflict.
- manicdee 6y agoThere are only so many times you can “debate” someone who isn’t willing to learn before you start slamming doors in their faces. Along the way you spend a significant amount of effort trying to see things from their perspective, but their perspective is simply that they are right and you are wrong and the facts don’t matter. Poor education and a reliance on Murdoch/Sinclair or other similar media for their information is the main visible cause of this condition.
- DeonPenny 6y agoI'm angry for them. And these people own 70% of guns in the US. We will get what we deserve.
- seized 6y agoThe Paradox of Tolerance applies quite well here... The segment being squeezed out wasn't willing to debate. There's been a year of debate and tolerance about the merits of masks, science, conspiracy, etc. The segment being deplatformed didn't listen to or learn from it. They were far from powerless during that time. Not every side or segment has the rule about good faith like HN does. I say the above as a Canadian, watching that segment spread it's toxic behavior here.
- MarkMc 6y agoThat's a fair point, but I think it depends on whether someone is clearly inciting violence. In the case of Trump's Twitter ban I would agree with you - it will enrage Trump supporters and cause them to disengage from constructive debate. And Trump's tweets aren't really examples of 'inciting violence'. But in this case some Parler users are saying, "They should have burnt down Nanci Pelosi's house with her inside" and "That cop should have been shot and bleed out". This is clearly encouraging acts of violence, and the costs of giving such people a megaphone outweigh the benefits of engaged debate. So Apple is right to insist that Parler moderate such speech.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoI’m not sure I want the media I watch 24x7 talking about snake oil salespersons. If it’s newsworthy - like say one of the snake oil salesperson actually provided an irrefutable or at least a plausible proof of snake oil working.