23 ms·
Should There Be Limits on Persuasive Technologies?
- Barrin92 6y ago>The New York Times once experimented by predicting the moods of readers based on article content to better target ads, enabling marketers to find audiences when they were sad or fearful Can we maybe go one step back in the discussion and not only discuss what we should do about it, but simply ask does it even work? There's Zuboff's book about surveillance capitalism that echoes much of what the blog post talks about, that recent netflix documentary that everyone was talking bout and so on, but how much evidence is there that this isn't all just mostly bullshit? When the Cambridge Analytica scandal broke they used the buzzword 'psychographic targeting'. turns out, psychographic targeting doesn't even really work[1]. A relative recently sent me an article about China allegedly using mind-control helmets to control their thoughts of children attached with a picture of children wearing helmets with blinking lights. I have yet to see a facial emotion detection system that labels Harold[2] of the "Hide The Pain" meme fame as anything other than 'happy'. I'm more afraid of how bogus all these systems are and the unquestioning power people attribute to tech, which itself enables these firms. It's no wonder they keep inviting Yuval Noah Harari for talks, they must feel flattered. [1]https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-03880-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-03880-4 [2]https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2017/07/11/11/harold-0.jpg https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/imag...
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoIt's a hypothetical. Waiting until the technology exists is probably a bad idea, since at that point there'd be someone with the means and motive to convince you that the technology is entirely benign.
- benjaminjosephw 6y agoI think the article does a good job of showing that current technology has the power to be a lot more persuasive than it ever has been. You could nit-pick on the effectiveness of individual methods but the broader point is clearly evident: technology, and our increasing use of it, has more potential to implement, test and refine new persuasive techniques at a scale never seen before in human history. The evidence for this is obvious. It stands to reason that we need to draw lines around what appropriate persuasion looks like not because these new techniques are definitely abusing our freedoms but because they might and in theory could. The potential in itself should be enough to treat the role of technology seriously and consider what the boundaries should be.
- Barrin92 6y agoMy point is that I think this kind of thinking is disempowering and counterproductive. By framing technology companies as all powerful, even if that's possibly inaccurate and overblown, tech supremacy becomes inevitable in the eyes of people who see it as lacking any alternatives. ("If they can predict me this well, they must know better, right?") I think this is why Silicon Valley loves to invite their critics who argue along these lines. This criticism doesn't deflect their own notion of supremacy, it just makes them look like bond villains, and they secretly love it. Showing that in many cases the emperor has no clothes, that complex human behaviour can't be reduced to some ML and that in many ways it's embarrassing self-aggrandizing marketing is I think, the much better way to reign in these firms.
- benjaminjosephw 6y agoTalking about the limits of how we use technology in society is hardly disempowering - quite the opposite. I would have thought that talking less about the potential supremacy of technology would be the real counterproductive measure in trying to curb that potential reality. Whether or not the influence of technology is overblown, the fact still stands that we need to draw boundaries around how technology can be used for persuasion. The question should be "where is the line?" not "should we even bother drawing one?".
- sideshowb 6y agoWhy can't both be true though For example, regression models aren't exactly ai magic, but unchecked, they compute discriminatory insurance premiums in a way we find morally unacceptable. The naked emperor still needs keeping in check.
- sideshowb 6y ago(addendum: actually, I can't help but feel that although it's been around since before I was born, I fully understand how it works and use it on a regular basis, regression still is ai magic ;-) )
- s1artibartfast 6y ago
- indigochill 6y ago> I'm more afraid of how bogus all these systems are and the unquestioning power people attribute to tech They say sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic, but in the day to day business world it manifests more like "Technology I haven't bothered to actually understand is indistinguishable from magic". And everybody loves magic!
- raxxorrax 6y agoIndeed. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25415052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25415052 Is an example of a self-fullfilling prophecy. Bad words aren't used because they are bad. They are not used to game the system and hence become bad words.... ...Sorry, English is not my native tongue. The industry described here is heavily degraded and removed from reality, it is a sorry mix of gambling, lying and posing. It was predictable they would swallow AI systems for their "work" like their lives depend on it. This is blind faith, you could use a prophet to do the same. There would be no net negative effect if it vanished overnight aside from slower price building. Regulation could do so much here compared to rules for advertisement or AI itself. This is actually a topic about bias, since people use tech for self-validation to a large degree.
- sandspar 6y agoInteresting question. Interesting too that we've become so self-confident in our machines and our studies that we think to ask it. Seeking to regulate something like the use of psychology, which we understand so little of, seems like an 18th century pirate asking his captain whether they should regulate the ocean. Like no, we only know a minuscule amount of information about it, about the bare surface of it at that - ask me again in 2,000 years.
- Bigpet 6y agoI don't understand what this argument is. I think the FDA was approving medicines long before the precise molecular mechanisms were known. Even with unknowns you can still study outcomes and legislate around them. Instead you seem to propose "oh we don't know enough, so we should just let it run wild". I do agree that sensible legislation around this is hard to impossible to do. I'd rather see some more research into the effects funded before jumping directly into legislation.
- sandspar 6y agoYou're right that we don't need to understand something completely before we regulate it. My point was to emphasize how little we know about psychology and how little good a law that addresses our current technology will do in the long run, since the psychology-focused technology we have 50 or 100 years from now will likely be vastly more dangerous. The image I have is of a caveman who, upon seeing one of his tribesmen kill another with a rock, proposes to regulate the use of rocks. Good idea maybe, but give it time and rocks will be the least of his troubles. However it's unfair of me to dismiss our real life solutions to real life problems by pointing to a problem that might come to exist in an imaginary long-term future. We can only make the best with what we have. Maybe I need to update my mental model of the law from an eternal-and-perfect view to an incremental-and-imperfect view, especially when it comes to the intersection of law and technology.
- JellyBeanThief 6y agoYeah, no. Ignorance is a reason to employ caution, not throw it to the winds. What do you imagine is going to be the horrifying fallout of telling businesses and politicians they're not allowed to build and act on detailed profiles of people?
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoI keep coming back to my default idea here - that PII needs to be seen as legally owned by me and only licensed to others for use. The default legal framework should include medical / epidemiology research as freely licensed and commercial use as ... well let's just say i think my license conditions will be expensive. If an advertising channel then shows ads that breach license they are liable. A fairly simple licensing process will come into play and we can find new ways to fund things Edit: Yes i do get a lot of the issues around regulation of tech - it's almost like saying regulation of every day life which is really broad. And the different bodies and approaches will also need to be broad. But i am a believer in markets and individual decision making and i also believe that personal information has in the past few years become a genuine new ... commodity? And we need to raise that commodity into visibility - to be able to put prices on it openly. Maybe it won't work, maybe privacy is like a human right and can only be dealt with at that level - but i don't think so - privacy to me seems ephemeral and usually poorly defined. Longer discussion to be had
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoIf you're a US citizen with a Facebook account, your value for Facebook is about $ 200 per year. That's the average, including children, seniors, etc. If you're a tech worker in your 30s, it's probably 3x as much. If you want to use Facebook without targeted advertising, you need to either convince them that they don't need all that money, or pay it yourself. And that's just Facebook. In other words: the internet economy without targeted ads will be a very different place. Facebook will survive. imgurl / snopes / fivethirtyeight? Unlikely...
- UweSchmidt 6y agoWorth noting that the $200 ultimately come from our pockets. We are paying those $200 anyway through markups on products ads made us buy.
- lordnacho 6y agoIsn't the 200 bucks more a way for FB sellers to get your money instead of other shops?
- throwitaway1235 6y agoI sometimes ask myself, in 20 years will we begin to see class action lawsuits directed at technology platforms that use notification triggered dopamine releases for growing engagement?
- xwdv 6y agoNo, because that case is too vague. Sending a notification isn’t a crime, especially when you request them by not turning off notifications.
- geofft 6y agoI mean, is giving someone nicotine a crime, especially when they request it by going to the store and buying more cigarettes?
- santraginean 6y agoIf that person is underage, yup. But also, are there social media apps where you have to opt in to notifications? At least with native apps, I've only ever seen opt-out behavior, which doesn't really work with that analogy.
- geofft 6y ago(My point is that it's also illegal when the person is of age - there was a fairly big lawsuit against the tobacco sellers for pushing an addictive, harmful product and pretending it was fine!)
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoespecially when you request them by not turning off notifications This is only funny because it's so close to the truth.
- deegles 6y ago"By using this service you consent to our EULA, forced arbitration agreement, and 24/7 notification policy."
- HabitCaptology 6y agoHighly interesting topic, I am currently planning to write my thesis about persuasive technology. If anyone has articles/ ideas/ stories/ books or papers to share I would highly appreciate it! I thought about researching how humans react to persuasive technology and start self regulating by installing adblocker/deleting apps... I am all ears if there are other interesting questions you might think of :)
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoI should think that actually having academics access to the internal effectiveness metrics would in and of itself be hugely beneficial. - what is the range of ads to be served like? I rmeber thebfounder of duck duck go saying lack of PII made little difference to him - someone is searching for "PC Monitor" then the range of ads seems pretty obvious. Is this true in "persuasive" mode? Are there bidders trying to serve political ads or lingerie when I search for a monitor? How can you tell? - is this a zero sum arms race ? A study I cannot find should that Political races are decided by who the public prefers not by total spend. Congressional races showed that if ad spend was matched the winner stayed consistent - it's only when one side out spent the other did ads have an effect. If I am outraged by ad X do ai also get served the anti-X advert? Would it work if I was? (this is the equalicalent of how many adverts saying fruit and vegetables are good for you outweighs adverts for sugary drinks? There is probably a lot of metrics out there on that - how comparable is it?) good luck
- HabitCaptology 6y agoThank you for the inspiration, I am currently reading the Subprime Attention Bias (https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374538651 https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374538651) that seems to pick up on the internal effectiveness metrics, and might have some answers regarding your first question. I am personally intrigued by the idea that people, who are aware of persuasive tech, PII, captology and marketing efforts skyrocketing in the attention economoy, start to mistrust products/ services or political agendas that spread their message with the help of such tech. Might only be my bubble though...
- 6y ago
- cblconfederate 6y agoThe article only talks about commercial manipulation technology, but what about political or religious ones?
- lordnacho 6y agoI wrote this for a related article yesterday: --- If we know that humans have all sorts of cognitive biases, how come it's ok to use that fact while at the same time we insist there's some kind of free market? Say you discover that putting good-looking women next to cars causes the sale of cars to increase. Why does nobody question whether it is legitimate to do so? It's as if there's a line between actively lying ("Studies show that men who buy this car will find many many women attracted to them") and just putting it there suggestively, for some as yet undescribed but working cognitive bias to do its magic. Some advertisers even make a joke out of it, eg the Lynx ads where the dude is thronged by a huge horde of women. It's a cliché, for a good reason. I suppose most people will just say you have free will and it's your own fault for thinking what was suggested, but I sense this is more of a grey zone than most people are willing to admit. How can the free market work if everyone is so easily affected by suggestion? --- Of course this also applies to the free market in ideas. In what sense are people free to make up their minds if it's decided for them what they should see, whether or not the government is doing it or FB? Isn't this the same as the authoritarian nightmares that we've been pointing fingers at?
- AntiImperialist 6y agoWith freedom, humans can control for this by learning from it. They can see that cars don't necessarily get you women despite of what the ads say. This can also be indirect learning by someone pointing it out. If you start making certain things illegal to say, you can use that against people. For example, given enough money for lawyers, you can sue people for saying that "these cars don't get you women" using the same anti-free speech regulations by finding holes and exceptions in them. History has shown that lawyers can pull this off.
- user-the-name 6y agoNonsense. There are plenty of things you are not allowed to say, and nobody is using them as "loopholes". False advertising is a crime already, for one.
- 6y ago
- gnicholas 6y ago> The technology exists to take your likeness and morph it with a face that is demographically similar to you. The result is a face that looks like you, but that you don’t recognize. If that turns out to be more persuasive than coarse demographic targeting, is that okay? I have wondered if in the future, movies/TV shows will be personalized with your name. I have found that when I watch a movie where the main character shares my name (and therefore other characters say the name a lot when talking to/about him), it makes the experience more immersive. It would seem fairly trivial to substitute in other names in a pretty smooth way (it would get tougher if you had to also adapt things like a business card that is visible on-screen, however). Of course, this could be taken to the next level if you changed the faces of the actor via deepfake-like technology. I don't know how actors would feel about this sort of thing, but hey maybe it would open up the door for a bunch of new actors, who would essentially be a blank slate for customized faces. Imagine a world where Hollywood actors don't have to be good-looking!
- wdb 6y agoI can already imagine movies and tv shows starting, Please tell us your name out loud and then some deep fake voice magic will adapt the actors voice so it pronounce your name the way you pronounce your own name. That’s has to be so weird to hear your name in shows/movies.
- Hokusai 6y agoYou are describing video games.
- m4rtink 6y agoVisual novels often do that - you put in ypur name and it is seamlessly included into the text portion. It is a simple yet surprisingly immersive trick when the game starts talking about you or to you. :)
- agent008t 6y agoI wonder if countries where English is not a native language have a built-in advantage - media they consume in English runs in a virtual machine of sorts. I have noticed, for example, that anglosphere seems to adopt US Hollywood/cultural tropes much easier and faster than other countries. Down to, for example, people using the word 'like' every other word or speaking in a certain tone of voice being quite pervasive in England but to my understanding relatively rarely seen in, say, the Netherlands.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoAs usual for Schneier, a thoughtful, complete, balanced article. It will be hard to put guardrails on this stuff. It's pretty much 100% "gray area," easy to cast in many ways.
- sneak 6y agoI'm a little sad to see him falling into the "we are under attack and something must be done!" narrative around free and open discussion on the internet. By all accounts, the election system in the US is working, most people aren't antivaxxers, and belief in an undetectable wizard in the sky seems to be falling. We are winning the war against misinformation. Why are so many smart people claiming that we aren't, and that more censorship is required? > [TFA, Schneier] In this regard, the United States, already extremely polarized, sits on a precipice. Citation needed.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoHere's one. There are plenty of others. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-social-media-makes-us-more-polarized-and-how-to-fix-it/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-social-media-...
- sneak 6y agoIt doesn't offer any indication that social media is the root cause of the current state of political polarization in the US, or any indication that polarization is bad or harmful. I think people place far too much stock in US partisan screaming. It simply doesn't matter that much. I'm not arguing that the US isn't polarized, that much is clear. I just don't see any precipice.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoSocial media is not the cause of any of this. The techniques used, are probably hundreds of years old (maybe thousands). Social media is just a new medium; but an effective one that allows scale. I'm old enough to remember when television occupied the same slot.
- yurielt 6y agoThe article is not honest for the way that it presents some of its support arguments it tries to make it seems as if society is solely affected by this technologies in a vacuum or as if polarization in America just happened magically but this is far from the truth when we look at technology like that we can’t do a proper analysis we become parrots of simple platitudes
- atypicaluser 6y agoWhat's amusing is how Schneier himself falls prey to his own 'emotional thinking'-- > Emotional appeals have likewise long been a facet of political campaigns. In the 1860 US presidential election, Southern politicians and newspaper editors spread fears of what a "Black Republican" win would mean, painting horrific pictures of what the emancipation of slaves would do to the country. In the 2020 US presidential election, modern-day Republicans used Cuban Americans’ fears of socialism in ads on Spanish-language radio and messaging on social media. Because of the emotions involved, many voters believed the campaigns enough to let them influence their decisions. ... where he sets up (anchors) a reprehensible example of an emotional appeal (19th century racial bigotry) to reflect a 'reprehensible' example of modern-day emotional appeal (animosity towards a social/economic philosophy.) To reinforce his point he purposefully neglects to mention it was Southern Democrats who spread fear against 'Black Republicans' and instead uses 'Republican' twice (as a callback) to tweak the more modern-day version of that political party. The irony of Schneier using his long-standing and influential blog to insist we 'have a serious conversation about limiting the technologies of persuasion' is not lost on this reader. Edit--Feel free to downvote, but perhaps explain where my comment is wrong?
- makomk 6y agoIt's more than just amusing - I think it gets to the heart of what arguments like this aim to achieve. They're not about how terrible tactics like this are in general, but about how awful it is that they're being used in the service of the wrong political ideology and goals (that is, not the author's political ideology) and how not only does the full force of the government need to be used to stop this but not doing so is actually undermining democracy and the legitimacy of of the system itself. They're also part of a broader idea that the legitimacy of democracy itself depends on whether the party supported by the pundits and journos wins.
- tgb 6y agoThe first example is clearly using Republicans as the victim. If anything that's the opposite of what you're claiming he's pushing. He could have chosen other framing (like "conservatives" as perpetrators) if he wanted to prey on emotions by connecting these two examples. His framing of those two examples, if anything, seems chosen to counter-balance each other.
- sokoloff 6y agoWould these limits apply to essays written by people who have for good reason cultivated a following of people generally interested in what they write and positively inclined towards agreement with them? Maybe this essay should be forced to be presented on essays.com without attribution and compete on the ideas within rather than the implied authority of the author. (I happen to agree with a lot of the content, but couldn’t completely compartmentalize that this was a persuasive essay against persuasion.)
- blackbrokkoli 6y agoI said it before I will say it again: The new thing, and the key point here is scale. You can discuss persuasion or cognitive bias away until everyone gets an aneurysm, sure. Some example: You can't not communicate. So even not persuading is persuading. What if the presidential candidate would just not give a scheduled speech? How do you communicate information objectively? Casual language creates bias, so does scientific language, simple language, passive language, active language. "Cognitive Bias" might as well be called "Cognition", since it is just how the brain works. You have to think "tree" immediately when you see one, even before you validated that all leaves are real and that the whole thing is not a projection on an transparent screen. Otherwise you can't function. But: Big tech throws us in a situation where a small group of people influences our perception on a massive scale. Facebook changes a sentence on their homepage and a billion people read it. Youtube raises some parameter (yeah I know that's not how AI works) by 0.01 and the political opinion about the Grenfell tower disaster changes ever so slightly - for 30 million people. Google's filter has a tiny hole and some troll broadcasts wrong medical information about gout to 200k people. Every time one of these things happen, the world shakes. Dozens die or survive. Demonstrations form and elections swing. Opportunities are wasted and ideas surface. I am not arrogant to actually propose an easy solution to this, and I don't think there is one. Just be aware that "I can always go and stab someone" is not a good argument when you are discussing a fully automated drone swarm with kill authority.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoTo your point about scale, once a tweak is made and X or Y "news story" is let loose in the wild, it gets amplified. The scale of the impact isn't linear, it's something more exponential.
- marmaduke 6y agoIsn’t this a bit like mode collapse in GANs?
- carabiner 6y agoTwitter CEO said we can give them the right to speak, but that doesn't mean the right to go viral. I think "viral" is an apt term - these are mind viruses that are 95% harmful.
- jl2718 6y agoWe are taught not to question authority, and punished when we do. Propaganda may be an exploit of early training, and this may be intent rather than side effect.
- beepboopbeep 6y agoI think there's a clear case for limiting the tactics currently employed by social media. They are using a clear strategy and deploying it to millions/billions through the use of algos. There are multiple ways to attack that and I encourage it before the world collectively loses its mind.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoimagine an advertisement so effective that anyone who saw it would immediately buy the product at whatever price asked as long as they could afford it. Imagining this we can see that there is obviously some limit beyond which advertising must be curbed, and admitting this the question just becomes at what point must advertising actually be curbed? Of course one could argue that such an advertisement must be for a product so wonderful and useful that everyone would want it - let us say immortality with youth and good looks - but if that were the case such a product should be recommended enough by word of mouth and the evidence of all the old people becoming young and good looking when taking it.
- suyash 6y agowhy limit to advertisement, it can also be used to manipulate you into voting for certain person or proposition that may not be in your best interest. Emerging technologies like AR, VR, Brain Computer Interface are ready for someone to abuse them.
- asciident 6y agoThe closest thing is probably a very charming, attractive/successful person soliciting you in person, at a place where you're open to buying that product (let's say a mall, or specialty store) or are a captive audience. Maybe we should ban the way luxury brands are sold, or military recruitment at high schools.
- winston_smith 6y agoIf your assumption is that people are helpless to resist persuasion, then who is this incorruptible entity who will protect us from having to make our own choices?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agothe assumption is that there is some point where people need to be protected, the scenario I envisage is a point where it is extremely obvious because if there was an advertisement that could cause you to automatically buy it people would need to be protected or the company with the advertised product would soon have all the money and all their customers would end up enslaved to it. The question of course is if there are any less extreme scenarios where people need to be protected. But I think the real question that needs asking here Winston, is when are you going to just give up and love Big Brother?
- j7ake 6y agoI definitely wouldn’t mind limits on these like there are limits to how much alcohol you can drink when you’re already clearly too drunk.
- stronglikedan 6y ago> there are limits to how much alcohol you can drink Pedantic, but there's only limits on how much you can buy while clearly drunk. Although, I suppose passing out is sort of a limit on how much you can drink.
- topkai22 6y agoOne of the comments has an amazing line “ Persuasion is at the heart of information security. Not “information technology security”, but the security a person has about their ability to make information-based decisions about which actions they can take in their best interest.” That being said, its seems the event that has brought the concern over persuasive technologies to the fore is the election of Donald Trump. New sorts of persuasive technologies may have Trump over the finish line, but I'm pretty convinced that he ran a competitive campaign without them. He identified policies and cultural grievances (immigration, anti-elite sentiment, trade, and white identity politics for example ) that no one else was talking about, ran with them. I dislike that these subjects resonated with enough of my fellow Americans to win an election, but they did. To retreat into a mindset of "those rubes must have been tricked" is to deny them agency and is problematic in and of itself.
- patcon 6y agoRe: can persuasive technology methods create tools/processes of radical neutrality. I'm actively contributing to a tool called Pol.is[3]. It's designed to be consensus-building tech. It's part of some pretty rad democratic processes in Taiwan[1]. It basically just puts a more approachable visualization over some overwise intimidating (but basic) statistical methods of "dimensional reduction", like PCA or UMAP. This visualization lets any participant explore all the statements that each statistical group agrees and disagrees on together. These "opinion groups" are just neutral statistical clusters. That feels important. It's just an integration of gut-feel statements that people perform a hot-take of: agree/disagree/pass. But it turns into this machine for everyone to independantly uncover the deep stories of each group. Once groups form, for complex but focussed issues, there are often 3-4 groups, even if you maybe thought it was just "us and them". Light-hearted example: https://pol.is/3ntrtcehas https://pol.is/3ntrtcehas This tool does lots of interesting things psychologically. One of my working theories of what makes it unique (I admit to having a few) is that it incentivizes the most passionate participants in a discussion to do the hard work of finding ever-more-nuanced "majority opinions" that everyone agree on under the differences. (These are elevated in the UI.) The nature of this incentive is up to the people who are designing the process in which the tool is embedded. For e.g., they might say that every "majority opinion" uncovered will shape an agenda item topic in a future livestreamed meeting of powerful people. So now you have the most passionate participants (who might otherwise shake apart concensus if their energy were directed otherwise), trying to craft clever statements to "manipulate" people in other groups to agree. But in essence, what this means is that those passionate people are exploring the consensus statements of opinion groups other than their own. They want to understand the group so that they can drop a statement into the opinion space between groups. But even if the intentions are not noble, and someone is just trying to "trick" others into agreeing, that participant is still doing deep work to delve into the theory of mind of the other groups, as evidenced through that groups consensus statements. Basically, the most active, passionate and potentially disruptive participants are encouraged to learn about their opponents in order to sway them, and in doing so, they accidentally indoctrinate themselves into empathic bridge positions. And these bridge positions are perhaps very important to stabilizing consensus and resolving conflict[2]. I'll admit that I wonder what a political or democratic system might look like if we used tools like this to elevate the voices of participants who straddle bridge positions between groups. Like what if we had democratic processes where instead of sending ambassadors from the center of opinion groups, we actually elevated those from the boundary spaces. (Maybe this was always the benefit of systems that use random sortition to elect leaders?) The selection of those people would be relatively politically neutral, as it's not a subjective choice, but a statistical one. Yes, one can probably "fake" being moderate, but to truly embody it, perhaps that changes you. And what effect would it have to send these bridge people (even transiently, for just one topic) into a position of power, to pass judgement? [1]: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/taiwan-democracy-social-media https://www.wired.co.uk/article/taiwan-democracy-social-medi... [2]: https://www.ted.com/talks/mariano_sigman_and_dan_ariely_how_can_groups_make_good_decisions/transcript?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/mariano_sigman_and_dan_ariely_how_... [3]: https://github.com/pol-is/polis https://github.com/pol-is/polis
- motohagiography 6y agoThe tech and the society around it are the problems, not the solutions. The solutions are cultural. If you want to re-establish a private sphere after its complete erosion in the last 25 years, you will have to take on the entire leviathan. IMO, the next wave of disruptive technologies are going to be about providing just that.
- csense 6y agoWhen we have new communication technology, it can rapidly change societies and cause conflicts. Think Nazi radio propaganda, or the role of the printing press c. 1500-1700, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religion#Definitions_and_discussions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_wars_of_religion#Defi... Over time things should stabilize as we get social antibodies against new forms of persuasion, and a new balance of power between groups that organize differently because of new communication patterns. For us on HN, Internet may be something that's existed for many decades, but social media and smartphones really changed things for the masses starting around 2008-2010 or so.
- weeboid 6y agoYes; the limits should be expressed as liabilities, both civil and criminal
- rhizome 6y agoA not-insignificant number of people don't even believe in psychology as a concept, so I'm thinking it's gonna be an uphill battle just to define the problem in a legislatively-useful fashion.
- specialist 6y agoThe problem is not truthiness, or lack thereof. We live in the attention economy. We have medias monopolizing that attention. It's the Supermarket of Ideas™, right? Maybe the Freedom Speeches™ and Freedom Markets™ camp followers could advocate for some competition. I dunno, maybe something crazy, like a doctrine of giving interventions their fair share of oxygen. For example: After Alex Jones spins up the peanut gallery, trained psychiatrists can talk them all off the ledge. Make sure they all get a cookie and some nap time. Call it the Milk & Cookies Fairness Doctrine.
- carapace 6y agoLet me be upfront about my bias: Since childhood I felt that TV commercials were a form of assault, assault on the mind. (So it wasn't too surprising to find out that it's literally the domestic use of war propaganda techniques. it's feels like assault because it is assault.) So, FWIW, I'm in favor of banning advertising more-or-less comprehensively. (And, yes, I realize that that sounds terrible to a lot of people for a lot of reasons. I'm not trying to persuade you that it's a good idea. That would be hypocritical, wouldn't it?) Anyhow, if you go look at the Wikipedia entry for "Neurolinguistic Programming" you'll see that it's coated in warnings that it's a pseudo-science. So that's where we stand today in re: state-of-the art persuasion technology. Most folks have never heard of NLP, many that have are openly skeptical (verging on hostile) and some people have entered into the Information Revolution proper. (Meaning they know and use this body of knowledge.) Given that we have allowed software to fall under patents, and that this knowledge constitutes the software of the mind, I'm reluctant to have it "go mainstream". I'd hate to imagine patent wars over IP that is essentially just structured thought... On the other hand, ignorance of the "operating system" of the mind causes unspeakable suffering. (I myself was cured of severe depression, just to add a personal, anecdotal, note.) And the differential between folks who know and folks who don't is also problematical. That would seem to argue in favor of rapid and widespread dissemination. Then there's the problem of the self-referential nature of persuasion and the limits thereof: can you limit persuasion if I can persuade you not to? Either persuasion tech doesn't work and so the laws are unnecessary, or it does work and can be used to affect its own regulation.
- Lammy 6y ago"Limiting" any technology only means limiting it for you and I, not for governments and others above the law. No thanks.
- Bakary 6y agoThere are two hilarious subtexts that always accompany these sorts of arguments: -It's okay to use persuasive technology to push political orientations I agree with -We want to defend democracy but we implicitly agree as commentators above the fray that people can't be trusted to make the right decisions and have to be manipulated towards our preferred orientation
- JoshTko 6y agoI'm ok banning emotional appeals in advertising. Would be great to include political ads. No music, no triggering words, just cold hard facts please.