18 ms·
Oh, I find it fascinating how the audio gear industry has taught the consumers on how much money you are supposed to spend to have audio experience at certain l
by mrtksn 6y ago
Oh, I find it fascinating how the audio gear industry has taught the consumers on how much money you are supposed to spend to have audio experience at certain level. Pay attention on audiophile arguments, they will talk in terms of money(i.e. 150$ headphones vs 500$ headphones) when talking about audio quality.
I always find the audiophile market to be borderline fraud. They sell CD demagnetisers, ceramic cable lifters and all sorts of items that don't make any sense whatsoever.
Apple is my hero in that regard, where you actually pay for the product experience instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult. The most eloquent writer wins the debate and thy have lengthy take down articles with graphs clearly showing that the mor you pay the smoother the curves become. I would't usually have problem with such things but they often slide into extremism and quickly pushing you on the money-spend-for-audio-performance scale where you are simply supposed to check you bank account to see what sound quality you are about to get. So god help you if you are buying an audio equipment and you decided to do some research.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoWhy only borderline? It is a market that preys on delusion.
- si1entstill 6y agoDo you think it preys on delusion more than the "high end" spaces of other niche markets? I think the same kind of upsells occur in spaces like sporting gear, bags and luggage, computer peripherals, etc. Hell, I think even fine food and wine are similar in how they project an artificially high "taste ceiling," if you will.
- bun_at_work 6y agoThis is a strange comment. It starts like you're trying to argue something, but the argument isn't really present. You're saying "You think the audiophile market is bad? Why complain about that market when there are these other markets that do the same bad stuff?" What's the point? Does one bad industry ruin them all? Should we not have any?
- si1entstill 6y agoIt really wasn't intended to come across as an argument, thats why one isn't present. I don't think this is really a problem easily fixed (short of overhauling the ethos of consumerism). I was just curious if the commenter thought the "high end audio gear" market was distinct for some reason.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoYes, the audiophile market is uniquely stupid, in that they tend to make specific claims that are objectively wrong. The ethernet cables come to mind, or any (digital) cable that's supposed to be better at conducting a signal than any generic spec-compliant alternative. Wine, for example, just doesn't usually come with specific claims, except it's "good", or "fruity", or "created in the rich terroir of the L'Alpesian Valley". That region may not actually be better than any other, but it is different. Beyond that, everyone knows it's a matter of taste, with no objective measures of "good" or "bad", although there are obviously (imprecise) trends that many people tend to agree with (i. e. wine is better than vinegar).
- si1entstill 6y agoAh, yeah, I'm with you. I think the distinction between taste-driven preference vs technical superiority is important (maybe a more interesting discussion would surround the juxtaposition of audio gear and organic/non-gmo food marketing). But, I do think the same kind of "objectively irrelevant" upsell _does_ occur with the other non-taste-driven markets (electronic peripherals, sporting gear, etc). I'm not trying to come across as combative - I'm just trying to figure out why the consumer side of the "audiophile" market gets such a bad wrap. As I commented elsewhere, I think a majority of people who are "into" sound gear don't buy into the snake-oil of special ethernet cables... just as I don't think most consumers opt for gold-plated display cables. However, there are distinctions between different monitors and TVs; people seem to agree that they are perceptible, and they don't bat an eye at someone spending a bit of their time figuring out the optimal display for their situation and price point. I think I'm just trying to understand why, when someone compares headphones to other headphones based on pricepoint, they are assumed to be ceramic-cable-buying elitists.
- theincredulousk 6y agothe commonality between the phenomenons of audio and wine etc. is that they start on a foundation of objectivity and end in subjectivity and cognitive bias. Hearing and taste are two things that are literally unique (almost impossibly equivalent, probability wise) for every single person. As you go towards the top end of these things, the delusion creeps in, which is that the objectivity extends from the foundation to the roof, so to speak. The fact of the matter is that it was gone somewhere in the middle, e.g. why "trained listeners" cannot distinguish between a coat hanger and $1,000 cable, and while "wine experts" will often pick a $15 grocery store bottle over a $300 bottle in a blind taste test. And they will reverse their answers if told the price ahead of time. These same concepts exist in other product categories, but I don't know of any better examples than audio and wine.
- gubby 6y agoIn my view the audiophile £500+ Ethernet cables are more than borderline fraud.
- wp381640 6y agoYou can’t shit on audiophiles without mentioning overpriced cables
- lethologica 6y agoFunnily enough I came across these the other day. https://www.transparentcable.com/collections/all/xl?catID=1&perfID=2&recID=26&sort_by= https://www.transparentcable.com/collections/all/xl?catID=1&... A fool and their money...
- dmitriid 6y agoThey will go very nicely with Sony's WM1Z Walkman® Signature Series https://www.sony.com/electronics/walkman/nw-wm1z https://www.sony.com/electronics/walkman/nw-wm1z
- vonmoltke 6y agoBoth of those links lead to insults to my EE education.
- maxerickson 6y agoBe sure to check out how much the Walkman costs.
- chinhodado 6y agoYou can't talk about expensive cables without mentioning Nordost Odin 2 - something like $30,000 per meter. https://www.analogueseduction.net/analogue-interconnects/nordost-odin-2-analogue-interconnects.html https://www.analogueseduction.net/analogue-interconnects/nor...
- blowfish721 6y agoProbably mentioned elsewhere in the threads but posting it here as well, be sure to check out their entire selection of snake oil. https://www.audioquest.com/cables/digital-cables/rj-e-ethernet/diamond https://www.audioquest.com/cables/digital-cables/rj-e-ethern...
- hajile 6y agoThere's an exponential curve of cost vs quality. Buying in the bend is best. The difference between a $50 and $200 pair of headphones is staggering. From $200 to $500 is still significant. From $500 to $1000 is extremely slight. From $1000 to $5000 is basically unnoticeable. Apple looks to be using plastic driver cones more at home in a $30 pair of headphones while selling something at the inflection point where headphones get really good. I'd bet heavily that these $500 headphones get outperformed by the $100 Sennheiser HD 280 pros. A $400 Sennheiser 650 will no doubt blow them away while still being $150 cheaper.
- gambiting 6y agoI mean, they do own Beats - they know exactly how to make headphones that are good enough quality and which sound nice for an average consumer. Now they can bundle that with some of their proprietary tech and that's how you can easily arrive at that price. No one will be comparing these with $500 Sennheisers because Sennheisers don't have all the features you'd buy these for.
- nemetroid 6y agoBeats are widely considered to be overpriced for their audio quality. I think it's reasonable to expect the AirPods Max to be as well, but I think the main draw of this product is seamless integration rather than pure audio quality, and the question is whether you're willing to pay a (substantial) premium for that. I expect that many will be.
- rob74 6y ago> Beats are widely considered to be overpriced for their audio quality That's why Beats was a perfect fit for Apple, Apple products are also overpriced for their performance...
- larrywright 6y agoThe new M1-powered Macbook Air would beg to differ.
- JansjoFromIkea 6y agoI dunno about fraud but it does occasionally have similarities to drug usage imo in that you can become aware of certain highs and then wind up endlessly chasing new levels of greatness. I remember the first few albums I listened to on what I then considered HIGH quality headphones (Koss PortaPros and ATH-M50s) and it was mindblowing how much better some albums sounded, how much better they felt. It creates an itch that people with disposable income will want to scratch, then once you move into bluetooth you're adding all kinds of connection issues to consider too.
- clolege 6y agoThe Porta Pros are still amazing headphones. Lifetime warranty, cheap, and great sound. They work perfect for exercising, if you're willing to put up with the cable
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI loved my Porta Pros. They sound fantastic and they’re so cheap. The problem was that they broke a lot (thank goodness for that lifetime warranty). After third or fourth time sending them back I decided I wanted something more reliable. You get what you pay for, I guess, but man. Best worst headphones I’ve ever had.
- clolege 6y agoI've never had a pair break, just had to replace the pads as they wore out after a couple of years. I don't think I've been _particularly_ careful with them, but I definitely don't toss them into my backpack or anything like that? What did you upgrade to?
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI'm a somewhat clumsy person, so I'm willing to accept some of the blame here :) I had a pair of Grados that I didn't like quite as much, my next job gave me a pair of Beats for free, then I got a pair of AirPods and then upgraded to the AirPods Pro. I will not be purchasing the AirPods Max. So far the AirPods Pro have been the best combo of convenience, build quality and sound quality for me. But I still think about those Porta Pros.
- jankotek 6y agoI think it is rather naive view. Audio market is an industry with professionals. You can buy spare parts for 30-years old studio headphones. Apple with their "no repair allowed" business model and 500ms latency is a joke.
- mrtksn 6y agoThese are not the professionals, professionals and people who like to listen to music are completely different bunch apart from audiophiles. The audiophiles don't like music and don't make money from their equipment, they simply obsess with it. They are like those camera nerds talking about the sensors, color science and so on but are not actually into photography. The professional photographers simply use the equipment for the task and the people who love photography don't obsess with the camera. Same thing with the audio.
- Terrario 6y ago> people who love photography don't obsess with the camera That’s simply untrue.
- jankotek 6y agoWell, I would consider myself to be an audiophile. I got professional level equipment for about $400 many many years ago. Today it is probably even cheaper. I spend a lot of time on PSU, interference from power grid etc... Solved by $20 car battery... For an "audiophile" AirPods are ripoff similar to CD demagnetizer.
- ralfd 6y agoAirPod Pros are my first Bluetooth headphones which just work and I love the transparency mode. They may not be for you, but they are not a rip off.
- si1entstill 6y agoI bet I spend 20 or so hours a year researching headphones. My current daily drivers are $11 earbuds and a pair of $80 cans for focused listening. As with most things, there are a vocal few who do obsesses and come across as elitist, but I have a hunch that people like me are the (largely) silent majority.
- codegladiator 6y ago> Apple is my hero in that regard How does apple becomes your hero when they are selling the same thing ? > deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult That sounds like the apple cult. > quickly pushing you on the money-spend-for-audio-performance scale where you are simply supposed to check you bank account We are talking about $549 earphones from apple here.
- fortran77 6y ago> How does apple becomes your hero when they are selling the same thing ? Because he values image over substance, and his personal identity is tied to Apple. One thing about my Grado, Audeze, etc. I can repair them. I've had the same pairs for years, used day in and out, and when I wear them out I can buy new parts and easily fix them. I don't need to go to a "Genius" or have to spudge them apart and not have them ever fit right again.
- bun_at_work 6y agoYou're assuming a lot about the person you're talking about. Some people will probably buy these for the image, some because they work well with Apple products, some because ??. But you don't know what he values or who he is personally. Why be so toxic?
- fortran77 6y agoApple is his “hero.” As if they cured cancer.
- billo-ollib 6y agoOh c'mon. Apple products tend to be long lasting, are incredibly easy to use, don't malfunction, have a good design aesthetic and are a good addition to an already existing suite of Apple products. Suggesting that he values image over substance seems unnecessary.
- zemo 6y agofinding this a really weird comment. In both NYC and Chicago I've had no problem walking into a store where I can try many different sets of headphones and talk to someone on staff about my listening habits, taste in music, and environment where I'll be listening. Both times I got straightforward advice and wound up buying a headset that lasted at least five years that I loved.
- whynaut 6y agoit’s not a comment about in store experience, it’s about audiophile culture.
- zemo 6y agothis is like saying "programmers follow trends and there are many things in the tech industry that are frauds therefore you should not program the computer"
- taneq 6y agoIt's not remotely like that. They're talking about how people will spend dollars to defend their 'audiophile' badge with no regard for what if any actual impact it makes on sound fidelity.
- zemo 6y agoah yes programmers are so smart, they would never spend dollars attending conferences or buying training or buying service contracts to defend their 'scalability expert' or 'tech guru' badge with no regard for what if any actual impact their pet technology choice makes on their startup.
- mekkkkkk 6y agoIt seems like you are arguing against yourself now. If the phenomenon you describe is real, and you think it's also present in audiophile circles, then you agree with the post you replied to in the first place. Your earlier allusion to "not program the computer" is a bit strange. Nobody is saying "stop listening to music". It's fine to spend a little extra on actual good quality headphones. Or to push for certain software design for good/pragmatic reasons. It's less fine if the headphones are completely overpriced because of unsubstantiated claims or unproven features. Same as it is less fine to push for some software design because of infatuation/obsession/narcissism despite significant downsides.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 6y ago> Apple is my hero in that regard, where you actually pay for the product experience What do you think the audiophiles are paying for? The only difference here is that you appreciate white boxes and thin devices rather than gold-plated connectors and oxygen-free cables. You like your thing but don't like theirs.
- buildbuildbuild 6y agoBe careful not to equate pro audio equipment with “overpaying audiophile” gear. Spending $500+ on headphones is common for engineers and musicians alike (typically custom fitted IEMs). Studios and professionals spend large sums on demonstrably better equipment. You won’t find many who identify as “audiophiles” in the “$1000 optical cable” definition of the word. AirPods Max are headphones lacking a headphone port. They will not be used by audio professionals. Latency is avoided at all costs in studio, on stage. Apple’s new headphones are a fashion statement. To some, wearing a new release conveys status. You know how much it costs and they own it. The price of a Porsche might appall you too.
- Reason077 6y ago> "AirPods Max are headphones lacking a headphone port." Not entirely. A 1.2m headphone-to-lightning cable is available for $35.
- buildbuildbuild 6y agoThank you I did not realize this. If the adaptive EQ can be disabled I suppose they could work in a pro setting, but likely in the mastering context of “I wonder what this mix will sound like on high end consumer headphones”
- diabeetusman 6y agoI'm not an audio engineer or a musician but I got custom IEMs and they were a great decision for me. My ears don't work with the majority of in-ear style audio devices out there for some reason-- my left ear is fine but everything falls out of my right. Back when I flew a lot, I could have my IEMs in but not listening to anything and I could barely hear the engines. There was a crying baby behind me and I didn't know until I took them out (while listening to music almost as quietly as my phone would go). It goes without saying, but they're also incredibly comfortable too.
- paultopia 6y agoI like this. Headphones as wine, basically.
- JohnBooty 6y agoI always find the audiophile market to be borderline fraud. They sell CD demagnetisers, ceramic cable lifters and all sorts of items that don't make any sense whatsoever. I, too, find that stuff abhorrent. The good news is that many, if not most audiophiles do as well. There are a lot of objectivity-minded audiophiles who reject that snake oil stuff with a passion. The fact is that basic audio reproduction -- which is essentially just signal reproduction -- is engineering, not art, and has been pretty much worked out for decades. We know what sounds good and we know how to make it happen. Long story short: reproducing the signal as accurately as possible, with a slight shift to emphasize bass frequencies (Google "Harman Curve") is what sounds good. Floyd Toole and Sean Olive are names to research if you want to know more. As an example of grass-roots efforts in support of objective audiophile-dom, one example would be this guy's site, full of detailed measurements of various gear: http://audiosciencereview.com http://audiosciencereview.com The perception of audiophiles has become a bit wacky over the years. Essentially, in the 70s/80s/90s, the stereo magazines became dependent on advertising from snake oil purveyors, and therefore weren't really free to decry that stuff. And then the media tends to focus on the really wacky fraud crap like CD demagnetizers and the like. That stuff exists, but that is the lunatic fringe and the rest of us laugh at it.
- warnick 6y agothank you and i totally agree
- Dumblydorr 6y agoYour last paragraph could easily apply to Apple fans and their unjustified love of Apple products. Any fandom or hobby has over the top individuals who spend 10X the effort for 0-10% gains. Just like there are people who install their own electrical pole and transformer for audio equipment, there are apple universe devotees who claim they need all the added features and then just browse the web.
- jariel 6y ago"instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult." That sounds like Apple though ...'I pay for fewer ports!'
- caconym_ 6y agoAt or below around $1k, price is a decent proxy for sound quality in headphones if you stay away from the trashy consumer stuff e.g. Beats, Raycons. Audiophile snake oil crap (e.g. ionic crystal cable risers, brass pyramids, $10k USB cables) isn’t really part of the same market. High quality wireless headphones tend to come with a price premium and sound not quite as good, which seems fair since they are generally closed-back and have to drive a DAC and amp off a relatively small battery. At $549 these had better sound really good but I wouldn’t necessarily expect hur-dur-six-hundo level of audio quality. Generally I find the “Apple tax” worth paying for consumer gear if it’s something I can actually make use of. I’ll be very interested to see how these stack up, but unless they’re the second coming of headphone Jesus I already have enough headphones.
- dep_b 6y agoI don't get replies like this. I tried a bunch of high-end headphones through a switchable amp and I bought the one I thought had the best qualities I was looking for. There was a clear and huge difference in quality and character between each headphone but I didn't need the most expensive one (Sennheiser 650 I believe) because it sounded too nice for my purpose (studio). Went for the BD 990's instead. Distortion and frequency response graphs are pretty important but not the only important thing in terms of sounds quality. And sometimes you want speakers or cans that simply look cool or have a certain size.
- capnorange 6y agoyeah, seems similar to the shutterbugs. Blind camera tests have widely different opinion - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbeEkwlTeqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbeEkwlTeqQ.
- dheera 6y agoI don't think you need to be an audiophile to notice that my $160 Beyerdynamic DT880 would blow any AirPods out of the water in terms of sound quality. And also comfort honestly.
- zepto 6y agoPresumably you haven’t actually tried the AirPods Max yet.
- teleforce 6y agoI guess the expensive headphones price is not that bad if compared to the valve or vacuum tube amplifier :-)
- grecy 6y ago> I always find the audiophile market to be borderline fraud There's nothing borderline about it. That test proved nobody could hear the difference between super expensive monster cables or twisted coat hangers. https://gizmodo.com/audiophile-deathmatch-monster-cables-vs-a-coat-hanger-363154 https://gizmodo.com/audiophile-deathmatch-monster-cables-vs-...
- hindsightbias 6y agoI've never met an audiophile who would be surprised by that. They'd regard Monster the way IPA drinkers think of Michelob Ultra Pure Gold.
- jacquesm 6y agoYou can leave out the 'borderline'. Oh, and 'gold plated' is a synonym for 'you are being ripped off' as well as 'you are clueless'.
- rectang 6y agoFormer mastering engineer here. Discussing audio gear in any open online forum is pretty hopeless. Any conversation will eventually be dominated by people who misunderstand (often willfully) the human perceptual mechanism and its propensity for illusion. It's possible to talk about effects on the edge of perception: the protocols for the tests by which perceptual codecs are assessed and incrementally improved had to be designed somehow. But you basically cannot have such conversations unless every participant accepts their own fallibility and blind testing as the price of admission, which is only going to happen with a closed group.
- ksk 6y agoIt seems you you are a huge fan of Apple, but you haven't explained what Apple is doing here that is interesting or unique.You can have any opinion you want, but I don't think you understand what the audiophile market or community is. There is nothing "deeply troubling" about buying a Sennheiser HD600 or an AKG K702 or buying a DAC or an AMP to listen to audio if you enjoy doing that. > I would't usually have problem with such things but they often slide into extremism and quickly pushing you on the money-spend-for-audio-performance scale where you are simply supposed to check you bank account to see what sound quality you are about to get. You can say that about anything. CPUs, GPUs, Expensive low latency memory Memory, high performance cars, etc, etc, etc. If you chase high-end performance you end up paying a lot for diminishing returns.
- no-dr-onboard 6y ago> "you actually pay for the product experience instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture" I appreciate your larger argument but this statement is ironic in light of your previous paragraph :/. IME (with time as an Apple software engineer) the Apple subculture _is_ a deeply troubling subculture. Take the iPhone for example: small, insignificant iterations that demand a premium. Consider the litany of software flaws that line BigSur and Catalina? What is the end consumer truly gaining with this new iteration? Would you respond "product experience"? Yet Apple appears to be doing well YoY with their returns on these products. I'm particularly fond of your phrasing though: "cargo cult". Again, ironically applicable to Apple.
- mrtksn 6y agoWhat I like about Apple fanboy subculture is that it's generally positive. Apple fans can get smirky when discussing Apple but would't chase down and brigate, turning every discussion about competitors into "We are smart Apple elites but good for you for trying". Competitor hateboys are not common among Apple fanboys. On the other hand they would be always targeted by people who are not in the Apple ecosystem, usually called sheep and explained how they are supposed to not be happy with the product they bought. For me, Apple is the company that cares about experience design as primary concern and that's why I care about what they are doing. It's intellectually stimulating, much more than chasing the random metric that somehow everyone decided that it's the number to look for. For example, lately everyone would talk about bezel to screen ratio. Previously it was Ghz, Megapxels, core numbers and what not.
- chungus_khan 6y agoThere might not be as many hateboys, but what I have found is that Apple fanboys are significantly more defensive, and often respond poorly to criticism, and are generally at best dismissive of it. This is probably a result of being so frequently accosted by said hateboys, but it makes nuanced discussion outside of the bounds of marketing copy difficult. Then again, rarely do fanboys make it easy...
- hatsunearu 6y ago> I always find the audiophile market to be borderline fraud. Not all of it is crap.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- criley2 6y ago>Apple is my hero in that regard, where you actually pay for the product experience instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult. The lack of self-perception here is astonishing. FYI, for those of us outside of the cult-of-Apple who watch how Apple sells phones with a bill of materials of $300 for $900+ to people who see them as a status symbol and a community of high-end influencers, we view Apple exactly as you describe here The way you describe Apple as "selling an EXPERIENCE" instead of selling headphones perfectly demonstrates how the Apple cult transcends a product market and speaks emotionally to the Apple cult. You aren't buying headphones, you're buying into the Apple Experience(TM). And finally I want to take a small laugh at the fact that you describe "THEM" as a creepy subculture and cargo cult, while in the same breath calling the Apple corporation "Your Hero"!! Cargo Cult is a great way to describe how we view you and your hero Apple.
- carabiner 6y ago> Apple is my hero in that regard, where you actually pay for the product experience instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult. I give you the $539 leather watch band: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MTQG2AM/A/apple-watch-herm%C3%A8s-44mm-%C3%A9b%C3%A8ne-bar%C3%A9nia-leather-single-tour-deployment-buckle https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MTQG2AM/A/apple-watch-her.... The $699 wheels: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-wheels-kit?afid=p238%7CslXU9HpqE-dc_mtid_1870765e38482_pcrid_435221946693_pgrid_101502584619_&cid=aos-us-kwgo-pla-btb--slid---product-MX572ZM/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-w... I think Apple is very complicit in the cargo cult and charging bullshit prices for fashionable items.
- whynaut 6y ago> I give you the $539 leather watch band: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MTQG2AM/A/apple-watch-her https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MTQG2AM/A/apple-watch-her.... The $699 wheels: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-w https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-w... The wheels are wild, but the watch band is Hermès. Their watches start at 3k. What would you have expected?
- chungus_khan 6y agoIf any industry is a cargo cult, the watch industry qualifies.
- zenexer 6y agoI would say there are two types of audiophile communities: 1. The sort that’s just looking to show off or is completely obsessed, without paying much regard to the enjoyment of the audio itself. 2. The sort that just wants to enjoy music. The communities that fall into category #2 are great. They’ll give advice such as: - Don’t waste money on X when you could buy Y for a fraction of the price. You’re unlikely to notice a difference. - No, humans can’t differentiate between properly-encoded MP3 320 and lossless. It’s physically impossible, and I’ll show you how to conduct a double-blind test to prove it. - Yes, X is better than Y, but it’s also a lot more expensive. Start with Y; if you’re really not satisfied, you can upgrade, but chances are Y is good enough. - Why on earth would you buy that cable? Just get some cheap crap from Amazon. It’s a digital signal anyway. - Balanced analog signals don’t benefit from expensive cables. - Unbalanced analog signals don’t benefit from snake oil, which includes pretty much any cable over 20 bucks. - If you’re enjoying your music, don’t mess with it. Stop trying to impress people. - Don’t buy $500 headphones from Apple. Amended: Don’t buy $500 headphones. - No, those $500 Apple headphones aren’t going to help you as an artistic professional—you need reference speakers, which those definitely are not. They’re designed to make even the crappiest audio sound like unicorn farts. - Are you regularly flying first class and need something to dampen the screams of children? Get whatever makes you happy, but $500 is probably excessive.
- nimih 6y ago>they will talk in terms of money(i.e. 150$ headphones vs 500$ headphones) when talking about audio quality. Isn't this the same as computer nerds talking about how much they're spending on their graphics card or their motherboard or whatever? I agree with your overall assessment of audiophile nonsense, but higher quality components and manufacturing processes cost money, so there's a limit to how good a $60 pair of headphones will sound (and hold up over time, for that matter) vs a $200 pair. In particular, it's not like folks who care about the quality of their audio equipment are _actually_ fixating on the price itself; brands like Bose are poorly regarded _precisely because_ their headphones have noticeably worse sound quality (and, in my own limited experience, fall apart faster) than the competition at any particular price point.
- mrtksn 6y agoI agree but my point is that it doesn't have to be like that and I have distaste towards fixating the overall product experience on the "sound quality per $" metric. Any product that emphasises on anything beyond that metric is talked down and its users are branded as "uneducated suckers". It's impossible to explain that you want a headphone that looks good, is light, can fold, can connect easily etc. They are extremists that prey on balanced products and people like those. That's why I like what Apple is doing: earphones/headphones designed with overall experience in mind.
- saltminer 6y ago> Isn't this the same as computer nerds talking about how much they're spending on their graphics card or their motherboard or whatever? GPUs have measurable performance benefits. Many people tend to buy more expensive parts than they need and there are diminishing returns (justified as "futureproofing"), but at the end of the day you can easily run reproducible benchmarks to determine exactly how much performance you bought. Audio quality is much more subjective and there's a whole lot of snake oil. You can certainly recognize a higher quality pair of cans to an extent, but price is not necessarily correlated with quality.
- tlrobinson 6y ago> Apple is my hero in that regard, where you actually pay for the product experience instead for being part of some deeply troubling subculture where passionately debating about very expensive cables and gadgets without ever being able to pass a blind test on the claims is the norm, almost like cargo cult. Out of the frying pan, into the fire: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_distortion_field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_distortion_field I’m joking, I’m a lifelong Apple fan, but this comment was amusing given the long history of people calling the Apple subculture a “cult”.
- dang 6y ago(This subthread was originally a child of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25345134 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25345134.)
- vinay_ys 6y agoI was an Apple Music subscriber listening music on AirPods until I bought a pair of studio reference monitors for 700 USD equivalent (Yamaha HS8). The joy of listening for hours without pain or fatigue from these while WFH is great. These ays my AirPods run out of battery and cut out in the middle of a meeting. The need for all kinds of portable battery powered devices have significantly gone down while working from home.
- tarsinge 6y agoModern music is usually heavily distorted on purpose at the mix step, I mean what's the point of buying equipment with high fidelity to listen to layered synth or auto-tuned voices? Recording engineers don't use audiophile gear, and it's no surprise when you have seen a typical guitar signal chain. Being able to discern instruments and layers with clarity and definition take years, yet I'm always amazed at what people failing to recognize the most basic things or issues, or do a basic EQ, will spend money on.
- sound1 6y agonow you are talking like an audiophile yourself - just kidding :-) there are people who appreciate high quality audio vs people who want 'seamless audio experience' vs snake oil addicts. They all are completely different things.