64 ms·
Your Computer Isn't Yours
- zepto 6y ago“In other news, Apple has quietly backdoored the end-to-end cryptography of iMessage.” Is this substantiated somewhere? It seems like a big deal if there is any truth to it.
- sneak 6y agoIt's explained right there in the text: it's via iCloud Backup, which Apple makes no secrets about: - backing up your iMessages: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207428 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207428 - not being end to end encrypted: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 It's listed as being "encrypted in storage" and "encrypted in transit", which is a fancy way of saying "we use encrypted disks and TLS, all of which we have the keys for". Further down on the page, they have a list of things that are end-to-end encrypted. iCloud Backups are not in that list. It's not a secret.
- zepto 6y agoOk - so it’s complete bullshit. iMessage is end to end encrypted. There is no back door. The article is lying. On the other hand it’s true that iCloud backups are not encrypted. That’s a major problem. Worse in many ways since all your private documents, tax returns etc, are in there too. But let’s not lie about iMessage not being end to end encrypted. It certainly is. The problem is that the end is then backed up to an unencrypted disk. These two things are not equivalent. In one instance Apple can be compelled to provide access. In the other instance any man in the middle can intercept. Please - there are real problems to criticize Apple for. Let’s not muddy the water with lies.
- sneak 6y agoiCloud Backup, on by default, backs up the complete plaintext iMessage history to Apple via the network, automatically, using Apple keys. It also backs up the device's iMessage keys, to Apple via the network, automatically, using Apple keys. That's called key escrow. The plaintext message content backup bypasses the end-to-end encryption entirely, providing the service-in-the-middle with complete plaintext. Apple is the only "man in the middle" for iMessage - all encrypted iMessages transit their servers (using TLS, separate from the iMessage message encryption). Apple, via software changes, has gained possession of the user's iMessage key, and the message is no longer opaque to them when relaying it, and it is not end-to-end encrypted. The party in the middle (Apple) can read all of the messages, just as if it were two different TLS sessions to each user with no encrypted payload (the way most non-e2e messaging is implemented). Alternately, if Apple, via software changes, has caused the plaintext message content to be relayed back to Apple post-decryption, it is no longer end-to-end encrypted, as the service in the middle is no longer zero-knowledge, and has come into possession of the plaintext. If that's not a backdoor, I don't know what is. EDIT: (responding to comment below, throttled) From https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 > Messages in iCloud also uses end-to-end encryption. If you have iCloud Backup turned on, your backup includes a copy of the key protecting your Messages. This ensures you can recover your Messages if you lose access to iCloud Keychain and your trusted devices. When you turn off iCloud Backup, a new key is generated on your device to protect future messages and isn't stored by Apple. So if you have "Messages in iCloud" enabled, it backs up your iMessage encryption key (Apple already has the ciphertext from the iMessage service). If you have "Messages in iCloud" disabled, it backs up the plaintext of the messages themselves from your device. In both cases, Apple can read all of your iMessages, either because their software on your device gave them the key (iCloud Backup=on, Messages in iCloud=on), or because their software on your device gave them the plaintext (iCloud Backup=on, Messages in iCloud=off).
- zepto 6y agoCan you substantiate that the keys are backed up? Is messages in iCloud on by default? I remember being asked.
- jolux 6y agoJust turn off iCloud backup. It’s what I do.
- sneak 6y agoAnd everyone you iMessage with? Both parties to the conversation have the plaintext and a key that will decrypt the whole conversation. Unless you are 100% certain that everyone you iMessage with has also done this, your conversations are still not reliably private. Even then, Apple can silently inject additional escrowed wiretap keys into the keylist for one or both participants, although this is an active attack and can be detected by monitoring changes to the keylist for a given phone number or Apple ID provided by Apple's iMessage APIs.
- jolux 6y agoiMessage is not a security or privacy-first messaging app. It is a fun and usable messaging app with decent efforts towards privacy and no user tracking. The only messaging app that goes all the way with privacy is Signal, which I use for most of my communication. But Apple is focused on the user experience, and there are some fundamental trade offs with user experience that are not necessary for most users. Most users are never going to be subpoenaed by the police.
- dancemethis 6y agoWhy are you so quick to defend proprietary software against users? No way to show from proprietary crap that whatever potentially bogus encryption iMessage clients pretend to have isn't bypassed on the server side. And Apple has historically been hostile to user privacy. Users are the weakest link on the chain. They should be pre-emptively defended. Not the trillionaire companies. They should have the burden to prove - by providing the source and reproducible builds to their paying customers.
- zepto 6y agoWho should ‘defend’ these weak users? The government?
- lern_too_spel 6y agoApple has had a backdoor for iMessage since the very beginning. Apple controls the key servers, and the clients trust the keys provided by them. https://www.wired.com/2015/09/apple-fighting-privacy-imessage-still-problems/ https://www.wired.com/2015/09/apple-fighting-privacy-imessag...
- novok 6y agoThanks for summarizing a bunch of changes that make me depressed about modern computing. Now Android, 'privacy apple' macOS, iOS & Windows all act in similar way. The only thing left is bad user experience linux.
- sneak 6y agoI've opted to purchase the new MBAir, and will only use it in conjunction with a travel router, on which I have root, and can default-deny all network traffic from the laptop except for the stuff I explicitly permit. Dual-Wi-Fi, small travel routers will run for quite some time on a USB battery pack. I've been meaning to do this for some time anyway, due to the pervasive spyware that's embedded in most iOS apps, which Apple explicitly permits in the App Store. One travel router device should serve me for phone+tablet+laptop. I'll probably have it just do LTE+WireGuard back to a server I run, and then do all of the filtering/monitoring on the VPN server. It sucks that it's come to this. Hopefully Apple can find their way back. I have a machine running KDE Plasma, which is worlds better than it was in years past, but still has enough rough edges compared to macOS's mirror sheen that it's annoying to use. I'm keeping my intel rMBP 16" I just got as it's likely the last machine of this quality level that will be able to run such a system.
- dreamcompiler 6y ago> Hopefully Apple can find their way back. It's not going to happen. Apple talks up privacy and security but the truth is they don't care about those things. What they care about is having a locked-down platform because locked-down platforms make Apple $hitloads more money than open general-purpose computers. Let's take another example: Remember back before 9/11 and you didn't have to show an ID when you boarded a plane? The airlines hated that because it meant people could resell tickets when they changed their plans, and there was no way for the airlines to get a cut of that money. After 9/11, the Feds made the airlines ask for ID, which the airlines absolutely loved because it destroyed the secondary market for unused tickets. Of course they didn't frame it this way--the airlines said "they were happy to help enforce additional security measures"--even though you and I both know that asking for ID before boarding a plane is just another aspect of security theater. Apple is doing the same thing. Locked-down platforms they justify with security theater are making Apple a lot of money. They have absolutely no incentive to change anything.
- RandomWorker 6y ago1. Disconnect Internet (if possible) 2. Open Terminal 3. Run `sudo vi /etc/hosts` 4. Type `G$` (go to end of file) 5. Type `i`, left arrow, enter 6. Type `127.0.0.1 oscp.apple.com` 7. Press esc then type `:x` then press enter 8. Restart https://gist.github.com/nathanhleung/2ceeda4c743f2a1cf3d670c8b90445f6 https://gist.github.com/nathanhleung/2ceeda4c743f2a1cf3d670c... Some updated procedure.
- bikeshaving 6y agoCouldn’t they have used `tee -a` rather than providing an impromptu vim tutorial? Haha.
- deadbunny 6y agoNot even a very good one either.
- geocrasher 6y agoOpen Terminal run sudo echo 127.0.0.1 oscp.apple.com >> /etc/hosts restart
- jolmg 6y ago`sudo` can't affect `>>`. `>>` is the shell opening `/etc/hosts` before launching `sudo`. sudo tee -a /etc/hosts <<< '127.0.0.1 oscp.apple.com'
- b215826 6y agosudo sh -c 'echo 127.0.0.1 oscp.apple.com >> /etc/hosts'
- smichel17 6y agoecho "127.0.0.1 oscp.apple.com" | sudo tee -a /etc/hosts (-a is the short version of --append)
- geocrasher 6y ago
- deadbunny 6y agoYet despite all the wailing and gnashing of teeth - both in the article and in the comments here in the various threads - people are still making excuses for continuing to use Apple/Google/Microsoft/et al products because the alternatives are a bit rough round the edges. These companies have repeatedly shown that they don't respect people's privacy and people have resoundingly responded that neither do they. I would suggest that the users here are probably some of the best suited in the world to help smooth those rough edges and even surpass the features and usability in the privacy respecting alternatives I just hope we collectively notice this before it's too late.
- damnencryption 6y agoI was looking into various differences among demographics which use and prefer apple products. Nobody rated any of the problems often thrown in here as a priority. Majority of iPhone users are women and HN/reddit are primarily men dominated. It should be no surprise that apple caters to aesthetics over thermals and you see people complaining about that on these platforms. Apple customers put status and prestige when deciding to purchase something above cost. They are rich. They care about environment that's why apple "care" about environment. They care about privacy which is why apple "care" about privacy. So for them, it's reasonable to change the device than allow it to be repaired at some shady shop. It's consistent with their image. They can't compromise on privacy or safety because that's why they bought into apple ecosystem. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/feb/26/apple-does-not-let-bad-guys-use-iphones-on-screen https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/feb/26/apple-doe...
- JimTheMan 6y ago>Majority of iPhone users are women I sold iPhones for years and never noticed this trend. I highly doubt it is true in any significant way. I would also challenge the assumption that women want aesthetics over some other factor. In this day and age, that's an incredibly 'old fashioned' statement to make. From what I could tell. People bought iPhones because they were: a)Cool and of good quality. (Your everyman can just go buy an iPhone and KNOW it won't be junk. They don't know the other brands and researching stuff is a pain in the ass) b)They were used to using them and didn't want to use android/didn't like using android phones c)They had shit experiences with other platforms and just wanted something 'that would just work' d)The iPhone really was the first good smartphone on the scene. They have inertia associated with points a->c above.
- shmerl 6y ago> On modern versions of macOS, you simply can’t power on your computer, launch a text editor or eBook reader, and write or read, without a log of your activity being transmitted and stored. Oh, well. Apple is one of the worst lock-in minded companies with draconian policies. I'm surprised anyone expects anything else from them. If you worry about having a computer that's yours, macOS should be the last thing to consider running on it. Starting with Linux could help.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoThis is sad. But the solution is not to use Signal. Resistance if futile that way. I believe the only solution is top-down: voting governments that can change this once and for all.
- rsanheim 6y agoIt can be both things. Use signal if you are sending messages that are security sensitive, or if you want to prefer secure messaging by default. But of course vote and talk to elected officials and agitate for policy changes as well.
- grey_earthling 6y agoSignal uses centralised servers controlled by one organisation. It could interoperate with other servers, but the Signal organisation forbids it. I don't see how using Signal leads to freedom from control by an organisation.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoI have found it curious how this has gotten zero traction in the press. Earlier today, I was naïvely sure this would cast a pall over the product launches.
- damnencryption 6y agoThis can't be linked enough: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- arvinsim 6y agoApple PR....is very well funded I would assume.
- tpush 6y ago> I have found it curious how this has gotten zero traction in the press. ??? https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/12/21563092/apple-mac-apps-load-slow-big-sur-downloads-outage-down-issues https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/12/21563092/apple-mac-apps-...
- NKosmatos 6y agoWell said, we’ve come to the point where if you want the latest silicon, a very good build quality and the most hyped technology, you’ll have to give away some of your privacy. Extra points for mentioning Cory Doctorow, who is providing most of his (prophetic I dare say) books for free over at https://craphound.com https://craphound.com (you can also buy them and support him ;-) )
- danschumann 6y agoWhat I've been thinking about is doing the virtual machine route and being able to be on the same computer from dumb terminals around the house. In this case, you could many 3rd party OS vendors supplying the host machines. Dumb terminals could get competitive.
- bambax 6y ago> These machines are the first general purpose computers ever where you have to make an exclusive choice: you can have a fast and efficient machine, or you can have a private one. Most of the components inside my PC are over 10 years old. I do video editing. I do music production with many VSTs open and running. And of course web browsing with a million tabs opened at once. For any of those tasks I can't see what would be the point of having a faster machine. Everything happens at once. Also, having a modular machine lets you replace individual parts when they fail (which they almost never do anyway). What are people doing with their computers that need so much computing power? Is it gaming?
- sneak 6y agoIt's about battery life and size/weight. The faster a chip is, per watt, the fewer watts it needs to draw for the same amount of performance.
- tannhaeuser 6y ago> What are people doing with their computers that need so much computing power? Running and developing web apps and microservices in proprietary languages and using oh-so-great modern environments and IDEs only there to lock you into a vertical garden
- Arech 6y agoIt's a new software. Take the note editor inside Evernote for example. It just slightly more sophisticated than a common notepad.exe, but it lags and freezes like it computes the Moon flyby trajectory by numeric simulation once every few seconds. Or the new fancy autocompletion module for Spyder python IDE. some stupid autocompletion requires TensorFlow running and therefore I just can't use it, because my 6 core PhenomII ( which is enough for most of what I'm working with) doesn't have AVX-instruction set. MSVC had a decent autocompletion for ages, VisualAssist raised the bar even higher... But now I'm kinda forced to upgrade my PC to get a simply decent code autocompletion... What next? Quad-GPU rig to run notepad?
- XCSme 6y agoI tried Evernote on Windows, it was so much buggier and slower than the browser web app, it was really unusable.
- ncmncm 6y agoIn every case, the greatest return on investment for any surveillance system comes from extortion. Extortion takes many, many forms. Some forms are favored by the FBI and prosecutors. Others are favored by spooks. Criminals have many of their own. In every case, they involve coercion. A key fact about extortion is that the person being coerced is often not the person surveilled. It may be, instead, a judge, or a prosecutor, a purchasing agent, an admissions director, a night watchman. Each has parents, children, spouses, bosses, friends they would not want to suffer. The person surveilled need not even know they were used; the coercion is often more effective when they don't. For each time you have heard of a defendant who pled guilty to a false charge, a judge who ruled in obvious contradiction to settled law, a legislator who voted against contituents' interests or resigned for "personal reasons", a manager who embezzled, or a contract awarded to the weaker proposal, consider whether it really was just on a whim. This is the world of pervasive surveillance we are plunging into. This is the world that only consistent encryption and anonymity can have any chance of protecting against. But it is your family and friends who need the encryption and anonymity, not just you.
- damnencryption 6y agoYou make an interesting point about judges. I wonder how prevalent behind the door blackmailing is given we probably wouldn't heard about them if the person complied.
- anshumankmr 6y agoThis doesn't apply to Ubuntu,right? As in Canonical isn't doing something like this, right??
- Shared404 6y agoUbuntu hasn't done anything nearly this bad, although the amazon fiasco was pretty rough. I would still recommend getting comfortable enough with at least one or two other distro's that you can jump ship to if necessary.
- novok 6y agoWith how canonical is behaving with things like snap and such, I wouldn't be surprised if you find similar things. They just don't have the power of their own superior hardware platform to leverage it further.
- sneak 6y agoUbuntu doesn't run on the fastest/most efficient laptops that were announced this week.
- fabianhjr 6y agoThere is an Ubuntu ARMv8-A release (Commonly called AArch64) and there are many Linux-based distros running on AArch64 hardware. Probably wont use any extras on the Apple M1 SoC but it would run nonetheless.
- sneak 6y agoI guess we'll see when my M1 air arrives this month. It's my understanding that by default they won't boot anything not signed by Apple, but I'm hearing scattered reports that there may be some command line configuration tool options that can cause it to disable boot security and boot unsigned stuff. It's certainly the default configuration, and on all of their other arm64 platforms they've shipped so far (iPhone/iPad/ATV/Watch), disabling the boot security is not a configurable option. My fingers are crossed. We'll know soon. EDIT: https://keith.github.io/xcode-man-pages/bputil.1.html https://keith.github.io/xcode-man-pages/bputil.1.html
- istillwritecode 6y agoThe title should be "Your apple computer isn't yours".
- nicbou 6y agoI might be mistaken, but wasn't Windows well ahead of Apple on this one? First it sneaked Windows 8 and 10 updates onto people's computers, then used every dark pattern imaginable to get them to consent to tracking, then slowly included ads in their operating system. For the last 2-3 years, I thought "at least Apple isn't doing that", but that is changing.
- corford 6y agoUnless I'm mistaken Windows 10 still allows you to disable everything and doesn't play games with what you can and cannot block at software/host firewall level.
- npteljes 6y agoIt does allow disabling settings, indeed, but it's a trove of dark patterns, including updates resetting your privacy settings.
- zepto 6y agoFor most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor. The general issue of other people (I.e. Apple et al) having a lot of control over your computer, is entirely valid even if some of the points in the piece are exaggerations. The problem is that people want it that way. They are in fact correct that computers are scary and too complex for them to manage, and they want someone they can trust to do it for them. Stallman may have predicted the issue, but he really didn’t do much to solve the real problems. The presence of open software isn’t enough without a way for people to know what is trustworthy without being experts. Until we provide that, this situation cannot change.
- sneak 6y ago> The presence of open software isn’t enough without a way for people to know what is trustworthy without being experts. As Apple has demonstrated, neither has the presence of closed software. Between Apple and Microsoft, they're nearly 100% likely to get software that is not trustworthy, and cannot be made so. This would be less worrisome if the state did not compel these organizations to provide their data to the military on demand without a warrant, but due to the vertical integration of big tech companies and US military spying, this becomes a major threat to our society and the basic exercise of civic participation. It's hard to do things like, for example, investigative reporting against corrupt government officials if the government officials know every time you open Premiere, and where you do it, because they forced your chip/OS manufacturer to tell them.
- zepto 6y agoFirstly - this is a false equivalence. Sure a government agency may be forcing Apple or MS to help them spy on you, just as they could have compromised whatever else you are using. But when you download software from at least the Apple App Store, you are in fact protected from many kinds of harmful software. Let’s not lie and pretend that isn’t a real benefit to many people, even though there are serious downsides to it. But even if you were right about the equivalence - what’s the point in the handwringing? There is no way out unless we build our way out. Shaking your fist at the man just isn’t going to do anything. The reason there is no alternative is that we haven’t solved the problems yet. People are in fact trying. Nothing you can say about Microsoft or Apple will make an alternative appear.
- FreekNortier 6y agoYet another reason not to use Apple products. I'm mainly on Linux currently but considering OpenBSD for one of my laptops.
- falseAss 6y agoif trustd really cannot be blocked by any vpn, i am wondering how's large corporates will react for this new macbook, e.g. whether to continue allowing employees to use this new macbook as working machine.
- rsanheim 6y agoThe tech corporate response may be one of the best avenues to actually apply any leverage against apple with this current situation. I've already heard of friends at big-tech companies where network admins are applying corporate wide VPN policies to block apple's ocsp.apple.com requests after the outage that happened yesterday and basically nuked productivity for hours. In some cases it meant engineers _could not_ deploy code due to an apple outage because `terraform whatever` wouldn't work, which is pretty outrageous.
- grey_earthling 6y agoWe're already used to being unable to deploy code due to a GitHub or NPM outage. I don't think this will persuade the corporate people with the money to invest in switching. By analogy, look at how many staff hours are wasted supporting IE.
- rsanheim 6y agoI think there is a huge difference in these two things: * I can’t work because a 3rd party we use for code hosting / dep management is down * I can’t work because my laptop literally can’t run any programs due to a poor security program installed and required by the laptop manufacturer
- arminiusreturns 6y agoI'm so glad I caught onto RMS and Eben Moglen when I did. I saw this coming a long way off, and have spent a lot of my time completely gpl'ing my daily use stack. There are a few rare exceptions (steam being the largest one)... but I'm happy I put in the effort. What we are headed for is a world where a certain subset of people with the technical knowledge have computing freedom, and that vast majority giving up all kinds of rights and data for convienience. A techno-caste system underneath the neo-feudal system that is incoming.
- comfyinnernet 6y ago"a world where a certain subset of people with the technical knowledge have computing freedom" Even that is optimistic.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoI should have said "have the ability to have...", but you are correct, unfortunately.
- unnouinceput 6y agoQuote: "These machines are the first general purpose computers ever where you have to make an exclusive choice: you can have a fast and efficient machine, or you can have a private one." I call BS on Apple having the fastest machine, even at current moment, not to mention in the future. I can make a gaming rig with latest Ryzen CPU that will run whatever I want and be both faster and cheaper than Apple's expensive crap.
- alphabettsy 6y agoHow about efficient? A Mac Mini is extremely efficient.
- lostmsu 6y agoThat whole thing is temporary until 2021 when other companies will get a chance to use 5nm fabs.
- samatman 6y agoDon't count on it. Apple's mobile chips have been consistently the best in the business. When the A14 was released, the second fastest mobile chip you can buy became... the A13. Is this unsurmountable? Obviously not, it's excellent engineering, not a pact with the Devil. But you can't just hand-wave it away either, Apple's silicon is the one to beat, and they have a head start.
- wayneftw 6y agoYou can only run Apple’s awful software platforms on Apple Silicon so they’re only competing with themselves and for the few people who actually run macOS in the case of the new Macbooks. Even if the rest of the PC industry never goes to ARM, Apple’s market share won’t change more than one measly percent IMO.
- lostmsu 6y agoYes, but here we are essentially talking laptop chips, not phone chips.
- Jayakumark 6y agoThis is really bad , apple touts itself as a privacy company but it seems like a fox in disguise and meddling with VPN is just completely immoral. Now google and Microsoft seem better to me as they at least tell you we are getting your telemetry data and don’t modify vpn traffic.
- drexlspivey 6y agoI am running wireguard on my router, let them try to bypass that
- rephlex2097 6y agoJust run Linux. Works for me.
- ur-whale 6y ago>Just run Linux. Works for me. Same here, but TBH, I am also starting to worry for large linux distros (eg ubuntu). And there's of course the black box hardware it runs on.
- djhworld 6y agoI'm running Linux on a 2015 MBP and it works great. However good luck getting decent Linux hardware support for any Mac >= 2016 and there is very little (probably zero...) chance of anything other than OSX running on an M1
- JAlexoid 6y agoI'm hoping we can get a RISC-V machine sometime in the near future.
- q3k 6y agoHow would that change anything?
- sliken 6y agoBy nature RISC-v machines will tend to be more open, have an open bootloader, and be friendly to running an open OS. Much less likely to block installing Linux, like Apple has done. Much less likely to block running linux, like on the Microsoft Surface. Sure some Apple like company could make a fork of RISC-v and then lock down the environment, spy on a user's network traffic, what binaries they run, etc.
- tpush 6y agoThere is exactly nothing about RISC-V that makes things built on it more open. RISC-V itself is an Open Source ISA, but that has nothing to do with having an open boot loader or whatever.
- q3k 6y agoHow does RISC-V imply an open bootloader or open hardware? It's just an ISA, and there is currently no RISC-V extension that I'm aware of that goes into details like platform boot or platform boot security. In fact, Si-Five have implemented their own from scratch [1], because there was no existing RISC-V blessed way of doing these things. And their implementation is open, but nothing prevents anyone else from implementing a closed, fused implementation. Or taking the Si-Five implementation and using it to prohibit any modifications by end-users, like vendors already do with U-Boot. [2] I already have in my hands a RISC-V microcontroller that can be locked down by the firmware developers to prohibit me from reading it out or modifying it [3]. And finally - even running your code on a RISC-V core is not enough to actually make a platform usable. You need documentation for every single peripheral around the core (and/or core complex). And even when you have that, implementation is still a lot of work. See: how much effort it was to do a decent Linux port onto the Tegra X1 on the Nintendo Switch, which is extremely thoroughly and publicly documented (in comparison to other platforms in this class, at least). And the only blocker there was secure/fused boot. Which again, RISC-V will not prevent. [1] - https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/12.10-14.20-SiFive-Shield-RISC-V-Summit-FINAL3.pdf https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/12.10-14.20-SiF... [2] - https://www.denx.de/wiki/pub/U-Boot/MiniSummitELCE2013/U-Boot_verified_RSA_boot_flow_on_arm_target.pdf https://www.denx.de/wiki/pub/U-Boot/MiniSummitELCE2013/U-Boo... [3] - http://www.gd32mcu.com/data/documents/shujushouce/GD32VF103_User_Manual_EN_V1.2.pdf http://www.gd32mcu.com/data/documents/shujushouce/GD32VF103_... ; C-f security
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoSo knowing this, how is it that HN remains so interested in the new "Apple silicon" or the latest "updates" to macOS. Why in God's name do people agree to participate in so-called "telemetry" and submit to whatever changes Apple wants to make in the OS, without question, in the form of "updates". Trying to control what programs users can run via "AppStores" and "developer certificates", and making them pay Apple for the "privilege" (what should be a "right"). If what the author says is true, I cannot see how anyone can take Apple's claims of "privacy as a human right" seriously. Purchasers have no right to privacy that can be asserted against Apple, who apparently needs to know how, when and where each customer is using the computer he/she bought. The company should be held to task for making such claims. I still have an old Mac G4 with OS9. It is not connected to the internet. Safe to say no one at Apple cares how, when or where I am using it, and that's how it should be. It is astonishing how overzealous this company has gotten. As Nancy Reagan once said, "Just say No."
- grey_earthling 6y ago> Why in God's name do people agree to participate in so-called "telemetry" and submit to whatever changes Apple wants to make in the OS, without question, in the form of "updates". I have automatic updates enabled because I trust the vendor who makes my distro to act broadly in my interests. If I discover they've done something I don't like, I can switch to a different vendor and get mostly the same software from them instead. The answer to your question is that these people trust Apple. I don't understand why.
- szc 6y agoI'm not going to comment on the linked article, other than say I think it contains serious mistakes in describing what OCSP is for and errors in other statements. In the background there is a war going on, but it isn't what you think. It is a war between malware creators and OS creators. From my perspective it goes like this: To "identify" malware you need signatures. Signatures need valid certificates. Signing keys get lost (or worse stolen), bad actors need to get identified and their identity revoked. If you don't have signatures you will end up with polymorphic malware. (Brew, pip, ruby gems, npm make me uneasy with how much external trust they require!) To stop persistence you need some system immutability and secure startup / boot. If you don't have secure startup / boot you will allow persistence in ways it may be impossible to remove. If you don't have an encrypted disk protected by a passphrase, a lost device means your personal data is now potentially now "public". If you don't also have the other above protections having a passphrase at this point may be meaningless. I use an iPhone because it boots from ROM and a DFU Restore wipes all mutable firmware. The flash, where my data is stored is encrypted. When I can, I will also use an Apple Silicon Mac because it works the same way. Hardware products and operating systems from other vendors and sources do not have these protections. Some attempt to, but the implementations are very flawed or poor - I choose not to use them with my personal information. For me, Apple products really are designed to protect my personal information.
- ur-whale 6y ago>For me, Apple products really are designed to protect my personal information. Which unfortunately isn't mutually exclusive with granting full access to your stuff to state-level actors. But I guess there's always a category of people who actually like the idea of big brother.
- szc 6y agoSorry, but please can you point to any real evidence that Apple allows state-level actors access? From what I can see it is exactly the opposite. I am not an advocate for big brother.
- 6y ago
- nathias 6y agoI use Arch btw.
- ExcavateGrandMa 6y agoWhat did you expect... sincerely...
- ilovefood 6y agoWell reading the terms and conditions (example: Catalina) it's not so far fetched that this is being done and it didn't happen suddenly but it was rather a long way coming. The outrage wouldn't have any legal ground. It seems that the issue is rather that the oscp service was down and thus was an annoyance (putting it mildly) instead of functionning as intended. Nothing is ever going to be yours if you don't put enough effort for it to be: in this case it would be an informed decision about what you want and need compared to what's available.
- ThePhysicist 6y agoWhat we poor souls didn't understand all these years is that we're effectively helping other companies to steal from Apple by running software that isn't distributed via their app store [1]. I think now that Apple has learned from iOS how profitable a walled garden business model is they are trying to bring that model to the PC world as well. Shipping hardware with their own processors is an important step in that direction because it gives them control over the IP of arguably the most important component of the computer, which in turn makes it easier to control software distribution for their architecture as well. The transition will be slower of course because people have to get used to seeing computers as closed-source devices with app stores, there are still too many of us who have the mindset that you can just install anything you want on a computer without asking Apple for permission and without paying tax to them. At this point I really wonder how any serious "hacker" can work on such a device, it's becoming the antithesis of everything that the original Hacker culture stood for. 1: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/11/judge-dismisses-apples-theft-claims-in-epic-games-lawsuit/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/11/judge-dismisses-apple...
- andy_threos_io 6y agoReal Hacker who has concern about her/his privacy wouldn't touch this kind of product with a 10 foot pole!
- 6510 6y agoAs a wise man once said: "haha, pwnd!"
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoAnd yet, Apple still has a reputation of being really privacy- and security- conscious. Windows' telemetry has had all the alarms raised for years now, and how does e.g. Canonical earn money? Same on mobile, Android phones - especially in the cheaper ranges - are dodgy as fuck when it comes to privacy and security.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago
- musicale 6y agoYeah, phoning home to Apple (or Microsoft, Google, Amazon, etc.) for everything you run sucks and needs to die a horrible death. Apple really doesn't need to do this, and it subverts their own privacy policies and features, including their commitment to on-device processing: https://www.apple.com/privacy/features/ https://www.apple.com/privacy/features/
- mclightning 6y agoWhy so much of the privacy-scare activism is coming from Berlin? It is starting to feel like a bubble syndrome, rather than organic.
- ggsp 6y agoMaybe because Germans have a history with state surveillance?
- mclightning 6y agoOh really? Nazis had surveillance system in place like todays? I suspect this has a lot to do with huge amount of EU funds going into Berlin-based initiatives to make it the new Silicon Valley. Creating a culture of antipathy, against SV. Well, obviously picking on the most obvious wrongdoing SV has as of late years; privacy.
- ggsp 6y agoThe Nazis had the Gestapo, the GDR had the Stasi. I’m not sure the Berlin startup scene is responsible for originating much of the German skepticism around privacy issues. Germany has a long history with data protection laws, starting in the '70s.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWe managed to get 2 autocracies in one century. One was totalitarian, the other was authoritarian. The authoritarian one is vastly more infamous, but the other wasn't that nice either.
- erk__ 6y agoI am pretty sure much of the genre from Berlin is from this specific person.
- andysch 6y agoSpeaking of Little Snitch, I suggest you look at 'iodé', an android phone with similar features built-in the OS.As far as I know this is the only true firewall on android
- aembleton 6y agoAnother option is to set the DNS of your Android phone to use one provided by https://nextdns.io/ https://nextdns.io/ Then you can allow or deny domains or apply blocklists.
- SubzeroCarnage 6y agoiodéOS [0] does not appear to be open source at all [1]. And only supports a handful of devices. Shamless plug, my ROM DivestOS [2] is available and takes source seriously with most scripts being GPLv3 [3]. Furthermore it appears that they are mixing incompatible license HOSTS sources for their blocker. And according to their FAQ the are shipping devices with the bootloader left unlocked, just like /e/. How awful. And to your last point, NetGuard is available [4]. [0] https://iode.tech/en/iode-solution/ https://iode.tech/en/iode-solution/ [1] https://gitlab.com/iode/ota https://gitlab.com/iode/ota [2] https://divestos.org/ https://divestos.org/ [3] https://gitlab.com/divested-mobile https://gitlab.com/divested-mobile [4] https://github.com/M66B/NetGuard https://github.com/M66B/NetGuard
- andysch 6y agoDoes DivestOS come with bootloader relocked? If it is the case what devices are supported?
- SubzeroCarnage 6y agoDivestOS does not come with anything as DivestOS doesn't sell devices. Selling devices with outdated vendor firmware with known security issues would be immoral. However on select devices you can successfully relock the bootloader with DivestOS installed, as it is properly signed [0] and enables verity on supported devices. Other alternatives that support relocking are GrapheneOS [1], CalyxOS [2], #!OS [3], and RattlesnakeOS [4]. They too do not sell devices. [0] https://github.com/Divested-Mobile/DivestOS-Build/blob/master/Scripts/Common/Functions.sh#L143 https://github.com/Divested-Mobile/DivestOS-Build/blob/maste... [1] https://grapheneos.org/ https://grapheneos.org/ [2] https://calyxos.org/ https://calyxos.org/ [3] https://github.com/hashbang/os https://github.com/hashbang/os [4] https://github.com/dan-v/rattlesnakeos-stack https://github.com/dan-v/rattlesnakeos-stack
- ramtatatam 6y agoI'm so glad I sticked to Arch Linux since early days. It felt wild in the beginning but now, after 10 years, I'm glad I took the risk. Yes, I have had a few sleepless nights trying to solve problems (90% of time caused by myself, remaining 10% caused by not reading wiki/docs/forum before doing stuff). And yes, Arch is not as polished and pretty as MacOS is but... I don't care, I do backend so I can survive without frontend niceness. In the same time I feel sorry for people who rely on tools from apple... it won't be as easy for them to switch.
- amalantony06 6y agoOr you could ditch Arch and go with a workstation specific Linux distribution like Fedora or Pop_OS that works out of the box with a lot of hardware. Gnome is more polished than the MacOS UI imho. Been using Fedora for a few months now and I haven't had a sleepless night yet. Everything just works.
- hunterloftis 6y agoThe Linux desktop experience is sufficiently hardware-dependent to make single-sample distro comparisons useless. As a counter-example, I recently installed Manjaro (Arch-based) over Pop OS because Pop was slow and buggy on my relatively high-end system. Aggregate data can at least give a sense of how likely a given distro is to provide a smooth experience: https://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=popularity https://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=popularity
- ramtatatam 6y agoI always loved arch for its minimalistic approach. Well, maybe this is not entirely true since when we was pretty much forced to switch to systemd :) but it is still my favourite distro, even after those sleepless nights. I am maybe a weirdo but I don't regret a minute spent fixing my installation :)
- chenpengcheng 6y agoclickbait. lame.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dusted 6y agoMaybe your Mac isen't Yours is a more appropriate title? Though I'm cetain it's only a matter of time before we can no longer run Linux on new hardware :(
- long_warmup 6y agoWell, I do hope for this, because there is market for Linux so somebody will pick this up :)
- joana035 6y agoAnd those are true heroes. It is an immense effort to make proprietary hardware to work well, specially Apple hardware.
- long_warmup 6y agoI meant the original comment, that soon there will be no PC that runs Linux - I do hope for this because I feel this would be perfect business opportunity for somebody to come by and build PC's that run Linux and sell them for $ :)
- joana035 6y agoI definitively don't want to live in this kind of world :P But there is already companies selling computers with linux pre-installed like system76, dell and others.
- dusted 6y ago"If this bad thing happens = $$" That's actually, just douchebaggish and evil if you think about it, a perfect HN comment :D I'll upvote your comment for that :) That being said, I'll probably just find another platform if that happens, some SBC that can run linux, heck, we're almost at the point where it's realistic to build a good-enough computer out of whatever Atmel chips you can get free samples of :)
- trhway 6y ago>Your Computer Isn't Yours Thus saith DMCA. The battle was lost when it become possible for arbitrary things on your computer to be declared a "copyright protection" and thus to be made off-limit to you under the harsh penalty of the law. This is what created walled gardens, locked down devices, etc. and made Apple and Google probably the biggest beneficiaries of DMCA and really made them into those large monsters.
- cannam 6y agoOf curiosity, what is the GDPR position on this? IP addresses are personal information under the GDPR, I think?
- e_proxus 6y agoI’m surprised more has not been made of the claim that all this information is being sent unencrypted. If that’s really true, how can anyone take the claim being made by one of the largest and most privacy-touting companies seriously? If they send, in real-time, location and which program is being run unencrypted over the Internet for anyone to read, this should get a lot more traction. Especially because of it being Apple, making this a huge double standard.
- m4r35n357 6y agoMy Raspberry Pi belongs to me!
- everyone 6y agoMaybe retitle this "Your Mac Isnt Yours"?
- globular-toast 6y agoI thought this was going to be about the Intel Management Engine or something. Well, I don't use a Mac. I never have and never will. I run a general-purpose x86-64 computer with Gentoo GNU/Linux on it. It's mine. I know other people don't own their computers. I've known that for years. Other people don't own their cars or houses either.
- fs2 6y agoI always laugh when people claim their Apple computers are secure and privacy friendly compared to Windows 10. They are certainly not. The only viable OS at this point is Linux and even then you have to carefully select your distribution.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoOk Twitter says the PatrickWardle thing isn't available to me, so I don't understand this part: >@patrickwardle lets us know that trustd, the daemon responsible for these requests, is in the new ContentFilterExclusionList in macOS 11, which means it can’t be blocked by any user-controlled firewall or VPN. How does that work? I mean the not blocked by ANY user-controlled firewall or VPN? - is the phrase "ANY user-controlled" just modifying firewall or also VPN?
- jb1991 6y agoI don't really understand the tone here. Do people really believe there is "evil" motivations in Apple? How about Tesla and its control over your vehicle? Windows also phones home frequently and has advertising built-in. I get that many in the hacker crowd don't like this, so the obvious solution is, don't buy those products. But for everyone else, it's not this big downer of a problem. This is the only time this has happened to me personally, and probably to most, and the way it affected the machines has been pointed out by many to be a bug that will likely get patched. Will it still phone home to Apple? Probably. But if there is an outage, it will not likely cause problems like this in the future. And personally I don't care if my machine phones home to Apple. Life is too short and I get too many other benefits from using a mac to care about this. People are confusing their own individual preferences for the technology they wish to own with the larger motivations of the masses.
- nicbou 6y ago> Do people really believe there is "evil" motivations in Apple? I prefer them not to give them a chance to be evil, rather than trust them not to be. You're right, life is too short to be upset about it, but at the same time, it's not something you should feel comfortable with.
- sharedfrog 6y ago> I prefer them not to give them a chance to be evil, rather than trust them not to be. That's a good way of putting it. It's safe to say a sufficiently large company doesn't care about good and evil, or any other kind of moral question, pretty much by definition. They care about making money. They'll do anything legal they can for that goal, as well as continually test and push the boundaries of what is legal, and lobby for different laws at the same time. A very small company might care about other values, but I simply don't see that happening when you get to the stage of venture capital and shareholders. Edit: Likewise, a hungry bear isn't evil.
- sharedfrog 6y ago> People are confusing their own individual preferences [...] with the larger motivations of the masses. No, I don't think we are. We're lamenting the motivations of the masses. Most people want something that 1) looks pretty, and 2) "just works". The advantages of something objectively better (let's assume there's a metric we can agree on) would have to be exponentially greater than the effort to make it work in order to make most people bother with the switch. On top of that, it's a psychological defense mechanism to simply ignore bad things. Certainly if the effort to fix them is great. And that gets us to "I don't care if I'm spied on."
- hamilyon2 6y agoIs there secure boot mechanism that prevents installing ununtu on newest arm apple hardware?
- pi-victor 6y agoi wish i didn't read this
- Ensorceled 6y agoC'mon HN, the past few days have been pegged with stories about Apple where the comments just turn out to be dozens of rants about their closed garden. Can we move on? Install linux and let it go. “A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject.” ― Winston S. Churchill
- ForHackernews 6y agoHahaha: > I’ve one on order, and I will investigate and report on this blog. This computer is an outrage! I've rushed to give the manufacturer a lot of money!
- drexlspivey 6y agoI want to mention that such a feature CAN be implemented in a privacy preserving way using the K-anonymity model (it is currently being used by haveibeenpwned.com). In short you can sent the first 3 bytes of the hash to the server and the server would reply with all the full hashes that match at which point you just do a lookup in the response.
- blindm 6y agoAll OSes are chatty in some way or another. It's a small price to pay for having your system 'just work' without going down the Arch Linux road and having ultra control over every component of the OS. Even Ubuntu constantly phones home to `snapcraft.io` and `canonical.com` but needs to do that to check for updates and do things like sync the clock with NTP. Do I care that Canonical now knows when my box goes online? Hardly. It's a small price to pay for having a pretty solid OS that has good hardware compatibility and I have no issues with my printer, and it's plug-and-play. If I need to use Windows to open a .DOCX file (for work) I use Virtualbox where I have a Windows VM to do Windows things. I don't see the fuss really in using Linux as my daily driver. Others are so biased and fanboi-ish towards MacOS it's disturbing to witness.
- supernova87a 6y agoBefore declaring the end of the world, is there any official or even unofficial Apple information that can confirm all the explanations here correct and this was intended behavior? Or explain their position on it? Discussions here seem to have had several thousand comments without obtaining this basic info. It would be good to know, I would think?
- ecmascript 6y agoVery good writing, I started to use linux for all my computing because of these kinds of reasons. I will never go back and I won't take a job where I am forced to use a mac or windows computer unless I have to economically.
- nix23 6y agoBut macs are not Computers...they are platforms, and they belong to the platform owner.
- kristianpaul 6y agoI feel it never was mine anyway anyway: - The proprietary firmware blob to make gpu/video work - Whatever happen on wifi/modem module that i cant control/know - The Embedded Controller that i cant control or inspect either - That code that allows the cpu to boot and initialize That list could easily keep going. At the end for me its about having alternatives what matters so i can pick what to trust and what to control fully, probably thats part the Freedom that software can give to a material/physical world that isn't ours anyway.
- novaRom 6y agoWhy other countries tolerate this spying on their citizens? Why Apple, Google, and Microsoft products are still allowed say in Europe? Do European politicians understand that they and their descendants are owned by another country?
- mixcocam 6y agoIt's not just the hardware which is not yours. This also destroys the idea of the "stored program" introduced by Von Neumann. Which I would argue is a bigger loss. It's not that the piano is not really mine it's that the sheet music is no longer really mine which is a travesty.
- Soarez 6y agoCert revocation is critical to avoid malware. This shows why CRLs are still better than OCSP.
- angry_octet 6y agoHost based firewalls are fantastic for improving security, and allow rapid blocking of malware. Excluding an Apple service from firewall rules is just begging for disaster. It's rubbish decisions like this (and app telemetry like the OCSP borking), the similar (ad driven) madness on android and the extreme telemetry on Windows, that makes Linux so important. It's the only platform which doesn't actively seek to control how you use your own computer.
- amalantony06 6y agoI'd strongly advocate fellow hackers/technical users to move out of the Mac ecosystem and get yourself a Thinkpad. My Thinkpad X1 Carbon that I got a few months ago runs Fedora as seamless as the Macbook runs MacOS. I haven't had a single hardware compatibility issue to date. I don't even miss the Apple Trackpad since I've gotten used to the Thinkpad Trackpoint which is an order of magnitude better as an input device than any trackpad, with the only caveat that it'd take you a week or two to get a hang of it.
- dj_mc_merlin 6y ago> My Thinkpad X1 Carbon Are they easy to repair? And is 8/16GB enough? Looking to buy something similar too.
- m4rtink 6y agoMy t460p can go up to 64 GB. Some of the newer ones have part of the ram soldered on though, need to watch for that if you want to max it in the future.
- amalantony06 6y ago16GB is enough for the sort of work that I do. But if that's not sufficient for you, you could get the X1 Extreme which is the "Pro" version of the X1 Carbon, or you could get the Thinkpad P1 (ultra-portable workstation) or even a Thinkpad T series (corporate focused - cheaper than X1 & P series). X1 & P1 have a Carbon fibre chassis which is why they are more expensive than the T series, which has a magnesium alloy chassis. The newer Thinkpads are not as extensible/repairable as back in the day. However, anything is a significant improvement when compared to the horrible dictatorial ecosystem of Apple.
- aunty_helen 6y agoHey thanks for mentioning this. My current dread is having to switch to a linux laptop because I hate the yak shaving inherent with linux systems and driver issues. However, I won't be getting big sur or any other future osx systems until they fix their api and allow firewalls to actually work with their software. So starting to scope out what options I have and this helps.
- zxcb1 6y agoA solution to this walled garden paradox is to participate both in the Apple ecosystem and the open ones. Whenever you buy a new Apple device, invest the same amount in stock, and eventually you will have financed all of it.
- foxhop 6y agoMy phone isn't mine, even though I payed over $1k for it, I'm not able to screenshot certain apps with no way to bypass...
- optimalsolver 6y agoAll this debate in here about software platforms is moot as it all runs on closed-source hardware. I'm a Linux guy, but I certainly don't feel like I "own" my computer, what with my CPU and other hardware components being a black box. This is why debate over cryptographic software is likewise moot, seeing as those algorithms are run on opaque hardware manufactured by major corporations.
- xvector 6y agoBy this logic we should just throw up our hands and forget about security and privacy altogether.
- mattlutze 6y agoSolutions like "switch to ___ manufacturer and run Linux" are great and relatively accessible for folks in the tech/IT crowd. 1. What do we do for family members embedded in the Apple, Google, Microsoft ecosystems? 2. How do we help move our companies and non-tech colleagues off of Windows and the Microsoft cloud behemoth?
- m463 6y agoBuy the kids a raspberry pi.
- hans_castorp 6y agoIf I understand that correctly, this violates the GPDR. So it should be possible to sue them - at least in Europe.
- jmull 6y agoThere’s a rather strong counter to this is: I, and the vast majority of computer users, don’t want to manage every nitty-gritty detail of the security and privacy of my computer. I have better things to do. In fact, doing it fully competently is more than a full time job. So farming this out to a third-party is a necessity, for me and many, many others. Of course, it’s not perfect. How much can I trust the third party? How well can they prevent, fix, or remediate bugs, breaches, and other threats? How much do they even want to? It’s not perfect, that’s for sure. We see bugs. We see potential tracking opportunities. We see difficult to work-around limitation... But no one is offering a better solution. Not for me, that is, nor the vast majority of computer users. If your response to this is “Look at the sheeple defending Apple!” you aren’t getting it.
- hrktb 6y agoI remember that third-party being anti-virus softwares. Then given enough time they basically became malware themselves, and we got rid of them for the most part. Now that third-party is the computer vendor itself. Will we be able to get rid of them when they all start going down that path ?
- bsaul 6y agoA prison with golden walls is definitely safer and more convenient than freedom in the wilderness. The day the jail guards decide they don’t like you for some reason, you may start rethinking your lifestyle. I’m 100% apple hardware atm, my first mac was the macintosh plus with 128kb ram, and i’m an iOS professional developer. Let me tell you that moving away from apple is not going to be easy for me, but with the recent trend in government behaviors (always in the name of Good and Security) i feel that i have no choice.
- hashkb 6y agoWe get it. We want you to accept a "worse" experience and contribute to making it competitive. We don't "deserve" Apple, we chose it long ago (edit: many of us, because of problems with MS that Apple is now emulating) and it has changed to take advantage.
- nojito 6y ago
- cryptica 6y ago>> using a program called Little Snitch (really, the only thing keeping me using macOS at this point) I cannot believe the incredible the feats of mental gymnastics that some people will perform in order to ensure that evil corporations stay in control. How can someone who knows so much about illicit data collection still be using macOS instead of Linux for example? I wouldn't be surprised if the author also owns Apple (AAPL) shares by now. People these days will support evil while claiming that they're merely hedging against it... Be careful because you might tear a few neurons if you keep twisting your brain like that.
- chpmrc 6y agoThis is true for any non E2E encrypted solution. Even using something like NextCloud, without E2E encryption enabled, on a small VPS provider would meet the same fate, except that Apple can afford resisting unreasonable requests and is far less likely to be cracked, the small VPS provider would likely have to shut down if they didn't comply and you would probably be completely unaware of them being cracked until the effects of the attack are evident. Plus the fact that these things happen with such popular products increases the problem's visibility (look at the score of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25073010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25073010 and this) and is the most likely way to drive some change in the long run. I find the idea of telling people, even technically capable ones, to "just start using Linux" laughable. First of all because to reach the same level of popularity, usability and availability of "good" 3rd party apps would require a company to start selling "good" prebuilt hardware with a "good", polished distribution preinstalled. Once such company becomes big enough it would still have to give in to requests from authorities such as the FBI. And if this company happened to be non American there would probably be a ban on importing these devices. So unless you want people to seriously purchase "libre" laptops and install a "libre" distro without ever coming into contact with any popular cloud service providers, you're out of luck. Second because I was an Ubuntu and Debian user and advocate for years during and a bit after college. Then I had the chance to work with a MacBook and there is absolutely no freaking way I'm going back to that mess. Just recently I had a colleague upgrade Debian and have an unusable paperweight because something broke with the bootloader or whatever. Had to flash a brand new image on a USB stick for him, on my Macbook...I buy my devices because I want to work with them, not on them. There might be some hope with companies such as Purism (https://puri.sm https://puri.sm) but there is really no reason to think they wouldn't end up just like Apple (or worse) should they ever start offering cloud storage services. Because the problem here is not technical, it's social and political. Even here in the EU we now have folks pushing for ending E2E encryption or placing backdoors. If that becomes reality any privacy friendly software will be outlawed. In short: this isn't a problem that individual for profit companies can or should solve. But it helps when a behemoth like Apple is involved. EDIT: looks like the EU is simply setting up a sort of "task force" to discuss options when it comes to lawful access of supposedly encrypted data. The outcome might very well be that they conclude there is no way to support both strong encryption (which is one of the pillars of the document btw) and backdoors. Probably just to show they are doing "something".
- flibble 6y agoIs this not flat out illegal under GDPR?
- vladmk 6y agoPlease increase the size of this article for mobile, looking forward to reading it
- kovacs_x 6y agobeing a devils advocate- isn't this a beta still for the very reason? I'm not sure Apple itself wants to be a developer unfriendly and everyone monitoring company + unencrypted traffic looks like something quick and dirty (analytics about beta users and issues?) Maybe let's get an Apple's response first on these issues? It's not these issues and implications are small, but shouting from very beginning is not a good way to start a reasonable discussion whether this is a beta feature or something apple now will include permanently and why.
- kovacs_x 6y agops. all OSX developers unite? :D
- rootsudo 6y agoEven worse once you consider the implications of TPM, and not just the code signing/hash sending of Apple telemetry. Just "how" hard is it to break into a computer, sure the hard disk may be encrypted. How strong is the encryption? When Truecrypt when dark, that was a a sad day in the community. But this just goes to show the sheer scale of Apple, and how much reach they have, that, even they, with all of their resources, talent, intelligence could not have foreseen their systems breaking up like this, over hash checking and providing a OSX update. It really makes the whole scale of iphones, ipads and other apple devices out there really, scary. It also highlights what you/I don't know about apple and the hardware I run. Scary times in the world of tech, each advance we make, it seems ten steps backwards. All this discussion about human rights, but no discussion about keeping, securing and ensuring privacy. Makes me wonder if it's all a distraction.
- api 6y agoWindows is just as bad if not worse. None of this behavior will change until consumers demand that it changes and start not buying things because of it. Linux is still yours of course, but the if I value my labor at $100/hour (which is low) then a Linux machine will cost me in excess of $500/month to operate since I will probably spend at least 5 hours dinking around with little edge cases, driver issues, etc. That's really expensive compared to a Mac or a good Windows laptop when you average it out.
- watertom 6y agoAsk the farmers that "own" John Deere tractors.
- userbinator 6y agoThings like this are why I continue to use old hardware and software, and my laptop runs Coreboot. People will try to spin that as "insecure" or worse, but how is a system with no open ports and zero unsolicited outbound network activity any more insecure than the invasively user-hostile spyware-ridden software today? It's because they are trying to "protect" users from themselves, which so conveniently means taking control away from them. Many will argue they don't need or want that control --- but that also has consequences for those who do, as the minority slowly gets squeezed out; and when users realise how much they can't do anymore because of these restrictions, it will already be too late. That classic Franklin quote has gained a new meaning in these times.
- gspr 6y agoI'll try my heavily downvoted comment from another thread again (I do regret the wording "wake up, people", it sounds too much like conspiracy nutjobs, but whatever): Wake up, people. Free software is the last line of defense we have left before technological tools are completely taken away from us, and we all have to live our digital lives at the behest of Giant Megacorps.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoWhat if you have two Mac-Chip PC’s each screening each other’s network requests per your definition? Is that a work around? Maybe there is a simple device that could route a mac’s own ethernet connection back to itself through USB and then you can set up a filter that exports through the ethernet. If someone could make such an easy to attach/setup device, it might a good business opportunity.
- NoSalt 6y agoI am SO glad I permanently moved from Apple to Linux several years ago. On top of that, I have a Pi-hole running on my network to block traffic for undesirables.
- cutler 6y agoThis is the last straw for me. Can anyone recommend a PC laptop which has screen quality somewhere near my 2013 15" Macbook Pro? My next computers will be running a desktop Linux distro.
- sudo_rm 6y agoThe title of this article really captures the feeling I had when I decided to ditch my iPhone. My mobile device was the last piece of tech that I owned that did not truly feel like I owned it. I've recently switched to an original Pixel running LineageOS. There are only a handful of pain points for me that make the switch difficult, most notably navigation. The feeling of actually having control of my device seems to be worth it so far.
- sailfast 6y agoOK who here wants to start the next consumer computer company to address this with a Linux distro and a focus on consumer privacy? I'm not your huckleberry, but I'll certainly buy from you. Any margin in the hardware these days?
- dannyw 6y agoPurism is what you are looking for.
- jjice 6y agoThis makes me very happy to have gone filled time Linux in the past year. I really want Linux to succeed on the desktop, and I think one very important step is to be able to get all the software (or clones) that people use running on Linux. So far, LibreOffice covers the majority of cases for MS Office and the average person can get by. Firefox and Chrome are covered, video players are covered, and honestly, I don't know what the average non-technical user uses besides those. Getting Adobe products to really work well would also be a huge win. I think the Linux desktop is mostly ready, there just needs to be a need for it at this point. Hopefully this is part of that need.
- cutler 6y agoIt won't be long before logging into the root account on your Mac is flagged as suspicious.
- dannyw 6y agoFlagged? It won't be long before `sudo` is removed from macOS. Why? For security, of course, and you'd get a million people defending it.
- lcall 6y agoI have personally seen many examples that make me agree with this. Really, if someone wants to get off the Microsoft/Apple financial/technology/control/they-own-your-technology-and-you-cant-always-make-your-own-decisions treadmill, I think you have to decide that slightly less inconvenience (if that) is worth having greatly increased trust and local control. And Debian (or maybe Devuan) Linux (then installing something like LXDE or XFCE) isn't perfect, but it is very easy to install and manage, IMO, and they have a great track record of stability (compared to others anyway), due to how to they manage security, freedom, and overall stability (for example, what you learn is likely to last a long time w/o having to relearn, relatively few bad surprises, excellent documentation, etc. I like OpenBSD, but if I couldn't, next would probably be Debian or Devuan for more reasons I have posted on HN at other times. Further opinions/links on these at my web site...) Edit: I installed Debian for my wife and a number of other locals. It was easy. I recommend adding the package that installs automatic updates (as root: aptitude install unattended-upgrades), and setting "umask 0007" in the default profile, and learning a little, can recommend some other things. BUT: my wife (a public school special ed teacher) doesn't know about those things and doesn't have to. People can use it without "learning linux" or having more than 5 min or general orientation, just like they used Windows XP, to do all their browsing, whatever, thousands of free apps available, and then one can grow from there, at one's own pace! :)
- lcall 6y agoBut, full disclosure: printing and some peripherals or specialized apps might require additional setup. Like, with OpenBSD I don't have (or need) bluetooth support. But a person can probably find someone, online or in person, to help if/when needed. I have done such, at times.
- siraben 6y agoFellow Gen Z-er here. I recall reading Stallman's writings some time during high school (a few years ago), at first taking them seriously, using free software as a much as possible (even installed and used Trisquel at one point) but then gradually due to peer/environment, even school-related pressure I became more complicit in using non-free software. I began to dismiss Stallman's predictions as unrealistic or overreactive, but as the years passed, as many have noted, these predictions have been realized on a massive scale. Opting out of this stuff is hard, and in many causes would involve changes at educational institutions and companies. IMO it's the normalization and following-by-example of adults that lead children to sacrifice their freedom and privacy. Things such as - creating G-Suite accounts for users joining an institution - school-provided MacBook Pros/Chromebooks - making use of a proprietary program (when free alternative exist) mandatory in a course - strong one here, peer pressure from the network effect of services such as iMessage, social networks, or even AirDrop If anyone is in a position of influence for the next generation of society, please think about these points and at the very least make it possible to use FOSS alternatives and make users aware of the issues surrounding digital privacy and freedom.
- asdffdsa 6y agoWindows has been sending lots of data to and from my desktop as well, anecdotally.
- ho_schi 6y agoI frightens me, that people buy and use things when they look nice. I'm glad to use free and open software - not bug free, but at least free and trustworthy. Had a lot of trouble with Gatekeeper, signing, notarization and stapling it in the past. I'm so sick of it. I like my Linux. It has it glitches but it seems to like me also.
- known 6y ago"The significant problems we have cannot be solved at the same level of thinking with which we created them" --Einstein (b. 1879)
- jiveturkey 6y ago> we are finally here. we've been here for a very long time!!! the only computer that is "yours" is a raptor talos II.
- drummer 6y agoYou now pay a premium price for beautifully designed spyware.
- awinter-py 6y ago> These machines are the first general purpose computers ever where you have to make an exclusive choice: you can have a fast and efficient machine, or you can have a private one as a many-years linux laptop user I have had this choice for many years
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bywaterstreet 6y ago> It turns out that in the current version of the macOS, the OS sends to Apple a hash (unique identifier) of each and every program you run, when you run it. Hang on, this only happens on first run of the binary, right? It caches the hash afterwards? This statement is incorrect unless Apple are sending logs to the server (i.e. of every cache hit). Can somebody confirm?
- afro88 6y agoThat's what I've observed, but the cache does expire (I think daily). It doesn't send a request for a cache hit.
- ergwwrt 6y agoQuestion is.. can they get your bitcoin?
- LockAndLol 6y agoIf you're agreeing with the article, then get a computer/laptop that supports linux or even better, buy one that supports companies that support opensource. https://linuxpreloaded.com/ https://linuxpreloaded.com/ has a nice list of shops that sell devices with linux preloaded. Purism, System76 and others also contribute code to the OS ecosystem which means purchasing from them helps the community at large. You can also run Linux on your Mac and reduce e-waste. Check https://linux-hardware.org/index.php?view=search_computer&computer_model=macbook#list https://linux-hardware.org/index.php?view=search_computer&co... to see how well it is supported.
- voldacar 6y agoRegarding the state of computing - there are so many cheap critiques but so little construction. For years now, cutting edge OS research has just been reimplementing unix with $new_security_feature. So many lines of code are written but so little changes in terms of what we are supposed to expect out of our computers, and if it ever does, it's always in the direction of walled garden phone-ification of the personal computer. It feels like our CPUs and RAM have grown, but our ambition has atrophied. What we need is a new synthesis. A personal computing platform that picks up in 2020 from where the lisp machines left off in the 80's. Something built from scratch to be interactive, dynamic, and hackable. It will never actually happen, for "worse is better" reasons, of course. But it's nice to dream about. If anyone out there is working on something like this, even on a conceptual level, I would love to hear your thoughts :)
- diegs 6y agoGreat article. The remarkable thing to me is that Apple is working so hard to distinguish itself from other competitors about how much they value privacy. Tim Cook famously said, "privacy, to us, is a human right [1]." I wonder how (or even if) they'll acknowledge this one and walk it back. Hopefully more articles like this will ring even more loudly. Sending all this stuff via plaintext is just plain scary. I've never worked at Apple, but from my experience at other big tech companies, this would never pass a rudimentary security/privacy review (which surely this had, given the scale that this feature is operating at), which leads me to believe it's intentional. On the other hand, given how badly it crippled people's computers, perhaps it was just really poorly engineered. I think Apple's response (or lack thereof) could be really significant. I don't own any Apple hardware, but am still keen to follow this story. 1. https://medium.com/@profgalloway/no-mercy-no-malice-apples-conscious-uncoupling-7171bb185dcd https://medium.com/@profgalloway/no-mercy-no-malice-apples-c...
- greyhair 6y agoThis puts Apple's 1984 commercial completely in a different light. As they roll over to their own silicon, it is going to evolve from being a closed system to being a really really closed system. Twenty three years ago, Apple briefly flirted with a completely different future with the PowerPC/CHRP architecture. Briefly. At that time, I did not see them heading off in the direction that they have.
- pers0n 6y agoCan you block this stuff with a hardware firewall?
- illys 6y agoI read here a lot of nostalgia of the 80's and 90's computers that were open to users' curiosity and changes, helping teenagers and young adults to develop computer and programming skills... It is true but it is only a part of the story. For me, the real issue today is not much the disappearance of opportunities to practice and to learn: some of you noted the availability of open source, single board computers, cheap hardware, free software... and even the presence of a free JavaScript engine on all devices. No, the real issue when you have a computer flavor (PC, phone, tablet...) in hands is that there are too many distractions. In the past, you could get bored in front of your computer and look for new challenges: trying new stuff, trying some programmation, changing files... Now, you can switch from an unlimited stock of games, to an unlimited volume of press, to an unlimited volume of video, to an unlimited volume of discussions, to an unlimited volume of films and series... There is no place to get bored and look for new challenges. It even takes a strong will to refuse to engage with these stocks and keep programming and experimenting. I see it everyday with my teenager: I have a hard time stopping the brainwashing of day-long poor social discussions, shopping, video and series on a small phone screen. They are consumers instead of being actors. And when the phone is off, they are just lost, unable to engage in anything. To come back to the article, these machines are not only technical jails, they are also little mind-jails.
- bitwize 6y ago20-year-old, Slashdot-weaned me would have been outraged at this. 43-year-old me shrugs his shoulders and says "so?" You own the hardware -- a hunk of very expensive sand. But much of the stuff on the computer, whether software or content, you don't own. The OS belongs to Apple. The apps belong to ISVs and the books, games, movies, and music you download or stream belong to the publishers of those things. So you really have no right to any more functionality in the device than is advertised and provided; and not only that, but the various rightsholders are entitled to the protection of their rights. To the creative class, there are few evils greater than piracy, and to allow for devices that can perform arbitrary computation without restrictions that protect their interests is to give free rein to Satan himself. Such devices are to authors, as the saying goes, like the Boston Strangler is to the woman home alone. And most end users don't care how locked down or DRM'd their devices are. So this is the new reality. In fact, it is not preposterous to imagine a world in which general-purpose computers are flat out ruled illegal by a court. The only thing that saved the VCR in the Betamax case was the fact that it could be used for time-shifting which, under very limited circumstances, could be considered fair use. A court may decide that in an environment where most users' computing needs are met by locked-down devices, those who sell devices that are not locked down are committing contributory infringement.
- zaptheimpaler 6y agoSeems like Windows 10 already does this - here's a screenshot from Settings -> Privacy [0]. In text: "Let Windows track app launches to improve Start and search results". Defaults to on. Its not clear whether that tracking is happening locally or being sent to MS, but given the utter lack of detailed information on what exactly this setting entails, I have to assume the worst. [0] https://ibb.co/gR7GRQ0 https://ibb.co/gR7GRQ0
- vietvu 6y agoDamn, and I thought Apple might be the only one left.
- TenderBlender 6y agoAgreed
- cable2600 6y agoThis is why alternative operating systems like AROS, HaikuOS, ReactOS, OSFree and others need more support and third party apps like modern Internet apps. They don't track you and are open source and easier to use and configure than Linux.