15 ms·
Intel’s palpable desperation on display with Rocket Lake
- HelloNurse 6y agoAn unusually unfavourable article, even by the standards of semiaccurate.com. Can this new processor family be interpreted as something less terrible than "palpable desperation" and effectively giving up on the 10nm process? For example, prices might be aggressively low.
- pizza234 6y ago> For example, prices might be aggressively low. Although this is possible, it would be a huge hit to Intel's image. I think one can state that Zen 3 is higher performing than any Intel's architecture/model across the board. What happens when they'll release Rocket Lake? They'll introduce a new(er), slower architecture, to tackle... the budget segment? I think that, from an engineering point of view, Intel is going to be in deep for a few years, with the hope that they'll manage to pull a new architecture in 3/4 years. On the other hand, I've specifically written "engineering", because Intel still has copious amounts of "green persuasion", which shouldn't be underestimated.
- eropple 6y agoThis is one of the more oddly axe-grindy articles I've seen in a while. Poorly edited English and writing what feels like angrily about some pieces of silicon--is this just the house style for this site? Maybe somebody can provide some context.
- bnt 6y agoWhy does “poorly edited English” matter when the content seems to be on point? Not everyone on the Internet is a “native” English speaker. Content matters, not who and how they wrote it.
- phaedryx 6y agoI tend to associate "poorly edited" with "on a passionate rant" and "edited" with "slow and thoughtful". It might not be fair, but I do like to know the mindset the article is written from.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eropple 6y agoDoesn't matter how good somebody's points are when they metaphorically walk up to you half-dressed and screaming.
- Tepix 6y agoFor me the overly agressive tone was detrimental while reading the article. I kept thinking: "Is this really necessary?" It reminds me of the rethoric that we've seen in politics in the last four years.
- rasz 6y agoYour reaction reminds me of what Aamer Rahman describes at 2 minute mark in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKICKcMU3MU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKICKcMU3MU Just a reminder. Intel bribed, intimidated and blackmailed hardware manufacturers to alienate AMD while AMD was offering better product. Intel was fined record 1 Billion Euro. Intel hasnt paid a single cent of that fine to this day. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-intel-antitrust/intel-says-flawed-eu-antitrust-decision-underpins-1-2-billion-fine-idUSKBN20X1FV https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-intel-antitrust/intel-...
- Tepix 6y agoFunny video. However, the point stands: Just because some is insulting others it seems unwise to do the same.
- justin66 6y agoThis is typical of semiaccurate. It is awful.
- exmadscientist 6y agoYes, this is Charlie's house style and has been for ages. He's always hyperbolic and his tone always favors some companies over others. Everything's either the best or the worst (usually the worst), and so on. It's pretty much exactly like reading a tabloid. The counterbalance is that he's got one of the absolute best networks of moles in Silicon Valley and always seems to know things, often big things, before anyone else. Sometimes even before it's on anyone else's radar. So if you're familiar enough with him to back out his style to see the underlying (likely) facts, which isn't too hard, you can learn a lot about the big chip industry. And that's not just interesting to people like us, but very very valuable to a lot of people. (Disclaimer: I haven't read SemiAccurate much since he paywalled it ~10 years ago, a move that I don't like at all but completely understand from the perspective of his business.)
- dragontamer 6y agoI was curious and peaked behind the paywall years ago, when the PS4 / XBox One stuff was leaking. Charlie did good: he knew details of those systems a year in advance. He's ranty and very aggressive with his writing. His best stuff is kept behind the paywall. It wasn't really worth the money to me (and I only subscribed once as a curiosity). But those "moles" he talks about are clearly the real deal.
- rwmj 6y agoS|A is known for these ranty opinion articles - and dislike of Intel. On the other hand they do seem to have access to a lot of industry insiders and break important stories all the time.
- sounds 6y agoI believe S|A's dislike of Intel and access to industry insiders are correlated. Specifically I know a lot of industry insiders have a dislike of some of Intel's practices. When S|A talks about them, S|A knows to take the "ranty" tone, as a means of signalling up front to readers, "Hey, this isn't going to be a bland slide presentation..."
- guardiangod 6y agoBack in early 2000s Charlie was a beat reporter for The Inquirer. The Inquirer was written like a British tabloid (in fact they were split from The Register.) As for his grudge, it probably stem from Intel's underhanded tactics. AMD had the Athlon XP that buried Intel's Pentium 4 in every measure. Intel made some very backhanded and immoral moves- * Bribed Dell to not use AMD * Threatened Taiwanese mobo manufacturers to not build Athlon mobo by withholding North bridge chips * Blackmailed the said manufacturers to not even show up for product conventions held by AMD * Forced RAMBUS down everyone's throat until Athlon forced them to release the i815 chipset (finally supports DDR1!) As a result AMD never managed to grow their revenue to a level that can sustain their R&D. When the Intel's Core arch arrived 4 years later it was over for AMD. The Inquirer had a lot of contacts that suffered greatly, and it must have left quite an impression on Charlie. I remember that one of his reports was that during a trade show, a Taiwanese mobo rep had to meet Charlie in secret in a hotel room to talk about AMD, in fear of Intel catching wind and retaliate. BTW Charlie also has a grudge against Nvidia for similar reasons, but Nvidia has been competent enough for the last decade that Charlie couldn't find anything to complain about.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nxc18 6y agoIs there good coverage of how Intel became so uncompetitive? My instinct is to say this is just the natural result of the presence of MBAs who are trained to focus _exclusively_ on this quarter's results so ignore R&D investment and also shit on employees by doing gimmicks like hotdesking to pinch pennies. I'm willing to bet my intuition is wrong, especially given my extremely deep bias against MBAs and 'this quarter' thinking. Any great sources on the full story?
- DylanBohlender 6y agoHere are a couple good articles explaining it. https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/227720-how-intel-lost-10-billion-and-the-mobile-market https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/227720-how-intel-lost-10... https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/intel/289196-murphys-law-vs-moores-law-how-intel-lost-its-dominance-in-the-computer-industry/ https://semiwiki.com/semiconductor-manufacturers/intel/28919... The TL;DR is that Intel has always been a vertically integrated shop (meaning that they usually fab and design their own chips), and that is starting to bite them because pure-play foundries are improving their tech at a faster rate. Intel has been unable to keep up with process advancements in their foundries, and that has led to pure-play foundries like TSMC taking massive market share. As chips get smaller and smaller, Intel has failed to keep up. They can only do 10nm for their mobile stuff and 14nm for their desktop stuff, whereas fabs like TSMC have been in 7nm territory for a while now and are moving into 5nm territory.
- avmich 6y ago> The TL;DR is that Intel has always been a vertically integrated shop (meaning that they usually fab and design their own chips), and that is starting to bite them because pure-play foundries are improving their tech at a faster rate. Are you saying that vertically integrated companies are inherently disadvantaged because pure-play companies have a bigger list of orders and can spend more on evolving technology? There is advantage to be vertically integrated, namely a better global optimization across domains, like between design and manufacturing. Would be interesting to know why it's not enough - if it's always not enough. If not always, then this particular case needs more reasons.
- henriquez 6y agoMy main question would be why Intel would even bother releasing Rocket Lake if, balancing between higher IPC and lower clocks, the performance would be _lower_ than the 10 series chips. So I disagree with the article that this will be an unqualified disaster. It's quite likely that they will be a little faster, at least core for core. But it also seems like these are notebook chips hacked into a desktop socket and limited to just 8 cores. That means the best case scenario for Intel would be (barely) scraping back their "single threaded gaming performance" crown while completely giving up against the multi-threaded performance of AMD's higher core count Zen 3 chips. The only way Rocket Lake would make any sense in the market would be if these are priced less than $400 (probably a lot less), and so Intel's margins will be much lower on what is likely to be a much larger die with more transistors. I don't think it's possible to call this anything other than a pure desperation move.
- drewg123 6y agoI think one reason is that they need to release a desktop CPU with PCIe Gen4. And if they can't do it in 10nm, they have to backport it to 14nm just to stay competitive. Amd has had Gen4 out in desktop CPUs for over a year now.
- muro 6y agoThey don't need to release one at all. They can skip PCIe 4 completely and go to 5. Their roadmap lists Sapphire Rapids in about a year (so in about 3 years on calendars everyone else uses).
- phkahler 6y ago>> My main question would be why Intel would even bother releasing Rocket Lake... Pure speculation, but maybe someone's bonus depended on delivering and this technically satisfies the requirement. It's not designs problem fab can't deliver the right node.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoYou ask: "Why Intel would even bother releasing Rocket Lake if, balancing between higher IPC and lower clocks, the performance would be _lower_ than the 10 series chips?" My understanding from the article is that the answer to that question is that Intel is unable to produce any quantity of chips at 10nm that makes (enough) money. The author surmises that rather than go a year with AMD essentially unchallenged in the market, Intel back ported a 10nm chip to a process that they have better margins on 14nm, so that they could tout "improvements" on an architectural basis while skipping over the question of improvements on a system basis. For me, what is most telling is the 500 series chip set which seems uncharacteristic. From a purely speculative point of view (that is code for pulling a wild ass guess out of my butt here) I could see this as having been the design they had done for Apple's next generation Macbooks before they lost to Apples' A14x chip. The factors that lead me to that guess are that it really looks like a 'point' product (specific changes, not a general set of family changes) to me that doesn't fit into thee PC ecosystem as well as other chip introductions (like IceLake) did with respect to their overall roadmap.
- jeffrallen 6y agoAfter Rocket Lake comes Desperation Lake and then Up Shit Creek. The latter comes only in a low cost version, without paddle.
- herodoturtle 6y agoAt which point Del Knox on Intel's door ;-)
- stagger87 6y agoOh hey, AVX-512 is finally coming to consumer desktop CPUs... like 6 years after Intel originally was planning?
- topspin 6y agoOne wonders whether the beating Intel is is taking will lead it forego license-based downclocking with Rocket Lake.
- wmf 6y agoThe AVX512 downclocking was to prevent the chip from overheating; one does not just turn that off.
- topspin 6y agoYou don't improve thermal performance by backporting to less efficient nodes either.
- stagger87 6y agoI hope so, but they might not have a choice. I think the next AMD chips are rumored to have AVX-512 and being on a smaller process node will help immensely with heat. At 14nm and being a backport that may not be optimized for 14nm, heat management may be a problem and downclocking still required. Despite that, it is still probably too late anyways. My industry has moved on to GPUs and FPGAs for real-time compute, but I remember when everyone was waiting for 512 after utilizing AVX-256 for some time. Although the thought of a 64-core threadripper with avx-512 at 5GHz on all cores is appealing.
- The_rationalist 6y agoSource for the rumor? Also, AVX512 can be on many workloads much faster than gpus.
- api 6y agoThe US needs to do whatever it takes to get TSMC to build not only top-tier fabs but centers of excellence here. As it stands TSMC on Taiwan, which is threatened by China, has damn near a monopoly on competitive fabrication. A single hit on Taiwan could terminally stall the entire global supply chain for top-tier chips.
- rasz 6y agoWhy would Taiwan let TSMC move its operations away and thus weaken Taiwans U.S. Defense Guarantees?
- hydroreadsstuff 6y agoWho would've thought that high-end chip manufacturing could be a (n enormous) bargaining chip.
- redisman 6y agoSomeone who can think long term I guess
- octoberfranklin 6y agoThe same people behind the Intel ME, AMD PSP, etc, etc. Silicon backdoors are the new nukes.
- corty 6y agoIt can be a mutually beneficial arrangement, perhaps letting TSMC US produce some defence-relevant silicon and providing a safe haven and nest-egg for Taiwans elites in case of invasion/unification.
- nolok 6y agoThat is not a beneficial arrangement for the Taiwanese population, compared to "if Taiwan fall this capability is lost, defending the island is absolutely necessary".
- ogre_codes 6y agoThis is just bad all around. Not just for intel, but for the entire industry. I always prefer companies doing well because their products are successful, not because their competitors fall down. More and more, Apple's timing on their switch to in-house ARM designs seems perfectly timed.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe industry is different. Cloud is a huge force and the mega tech companies literally have more money than they can spend. We’re going to move towards AWS, Microsoft, Apple chips. It’s really hard for a company like Intel or AMD to serve hyper scale customers.
- vbezhenar 6y agoApple should have switched to AMD instead. They would have almost perfect compatibility with Intel hardware and they would not need investing lots of money to develop chips. Now they either need to halt some Mac lines or develop all kinds of CPUs, from mobile (which they probably can do, because they should be similar enough to iPhones) to server-grade (which they have no experience at all). And there's no way Mac Pros would sell enough to offset development costs. I just don't understand how they are going to manage that situation.
- varispeed 6y agoI on the other hand hope that Apple will stay away from x86. If they started co-op with AMD it would be a matter of time AMD would have to produce special versions of processors that only Apple could purchase and end users wouldn't be able to do any repairs and a lot of manufacturing power would have been wasted on Macs making it more expensive for other people.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> it would be a matter of time AMD would have to produce special versions of processors that only Apple could purchase How is that supposed to affect anybody else who is still buying the regular stuff, or be better for Apple customers than the same thing but with an architecture transition and the inability to natively virtualize the x64 editions of Windows and Linux? > and a lot of manufacturing power would have been wasted on Macs making it more expensive for other people. Apple and AMD are both TSMC customers. They come out of the same fabs.
- varispeed 6y agoIt seems like Intel wasted at least 5 years. They thought they are invincible and competition will never catch up, plus they thought if they change the model name and repackage to a new socket, people will still buy it. They however didn't consider the fact that people bought these processors, because there was nothing else and also new people are becoming teens and adults and they need computers as well. Maybe they also counted on brand loyalty? I think brand loyalty ends when you need to waste your time waiting for a task to complete. I am so happy to pre-order 5950X. I will also buy new Threadripper when it gets released.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoCeding/ignoring the smartphone/ARM market had a double impact on Intel. Obviously they missed a titanically large market. But that huge market drove investment in fab technology outside of Intel, and allowed them to close the gap and provide competitive, now superior, fabs to AMD.
- sadness2 6y agoFor gamers, I expect these will be priced such that Intel will offer a better price-to-performance ratio than AMD. I've seen so many industry pundits talking about the defeat of Intel for the last 2 generations, but gamers just quietly look the frames-per-second to $ ratio and keep buying Intel and the cheaper Intel-based motherboards. I think Rocket Lake will allow this trend to continue while Intel prepares Alder Lake.
- FridgeSeal 6y agoNot sure how much that’ll hold, a lot of the gaming and pc subreddits and the communities there have been strongly favouring AMD chips in builds and advice. With Zen 3 chips I expect that to continue.
- sadness2 6y agoThere's always a loud contingent of AMD fanboys, but then there's the silent majority who don't care and just buy on raw gaming performance per $, which is reflected in market share. https://www.cpubenchmark.net/market_share.html https://www.cpubenchmark.net/market_share.html
- FridgeSeal 6y agoWell if they’re buying “raw performance per $” then they’ll be buying AMD chips anyway.
- yborg 6y agoIntel mentally isn't anywhere near the rock bottom they would need to be to admit inferiority to AMD by actually underpricing them even though they easily have the margin to do so. This might even be the right strategy if they think they can come back in a couple of years and beat AMD, why damage the brand now?
- sadness2 6y agoThis would not be a change in pricing strategy by Intel. Intel has consistently provided better price-to-performance ratio for gaming than AMD. Since AMD bumped their pricing with this launch, Intel arguably still holds this edge, especially if you account for overclocking and board prices. https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i9-10900K-vs-AMD-Ryzen-9-5950X/4071vs4086 https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i9-10900K-v... https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-10600K-vs-AMD-Ryzen-9-5950X/4072vs4086 https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-10600K-v... https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-10600K-vs-AMD-Ryzen-5-5600X/4072vs4084 https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-10600K-v...
- causality0 6y agoI'd be interested in an x86-64 processor that took the 1+3+4 approach of the Snapdragon 875. One big core with a super high clock rate and massive IPC, three smaller ones, and four that are smaller still. A desktop CPU with a single-core performance equal to half a normal 8-core chip would be an absolutely incredible tool for IPC-constrained applications like game console emulation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wmf 6y agoA desktop CPU with a single-core performance equal to half a normal 8-core chip This isn't possible. The cores are already as fast as they can be, so moving from 10 big to 1 big would only reduce performance.
- MBCook 6y agoThe bigger problem is you need operating system support. Linux/android has it. iOS has it. If iOS has it there’s a very good chance that macOS has it (we’ll probably find out on Tuesday). What does Windows support heterogeneous cores at all? I don’t think it does. And until that happens, would you be able to sell a chip to the public?
- wmf 6y agoSurface ARM laptops have big.little so there must be some kind of support but I don't have any confidence that it's good. It will take MS a while to get it refined. People are probably better off disabling the little cores so threads don't slow down by getting accidentally scheduled on them.
- kasabali 6y agoWell said. A lot of people I see on hardware forums seem to have the deception that we'd suddenly have 10 GHz cores had big.LITTLE x86 processors appear. Reality is we'd have few of exact same cores we have today and a dozen more atom level cores put there solely for the purpose of marketing spec race.
- intelisdead 6y agoHere are benchmarks of the top processors from each competitor: Single Core: AMD 5900X - 3643 points (+15% faster) Intel 10900K - 3178 points Multicore AMD Ryzen Threadripper PRO 3995WX - 88673 points (+130% faster) Intel Xeon Gold 6248R @ 3.00GHz - 38521 points By the way, 5900X is not only faster than 10900K, but also consumes less power.
- kelnos 6y agoWhat's the comparison when it comes to mobile chipsets? I would love to have a laptop (12"-14", light and thin) with an AMD CPU and an actually decent GPU, but they seem to be incredibly uncommon.
- justinclift 6y agoMaybe this? https://www.anandtech.com/show/15762/the-acer-swift-3-sf314-review-swift-gets-swifter-with-ryzen-4000 https://www.anandtech.com/show/15762/the-acer-swift-3-sf314-... Or if going up to 15" is acceptable: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16153/the-acer-nitro-5-review-renoir-and-turing-on-a-budget https://www.anandtech.com/show/16153/the-acer-nitro-5-review...
- pengaru 6y agoDoes the lenovo X13 AMD model not qualify?
- nolok 6y agoAMD has the 5950X too
- knolax 6y agoThese names are getting more and more nonsensical. "Rocket Lake"?
- LockAndLol 6y agoWhat actually happened to memristors? I read about them nearly a decade ago and we still don't have any on the market if I'm not mistaken. How come Intel didn't invest heavily in those? And why is it only AMD that has a GPU baked into a CPU? Vega graphics are simply amazing and beat Intel's integrated graphics hands down. It's so nice to have only a single chip without buying an extra graphics card. Unfortunately, AMD isn't very present. I see Intel sponsoring every eSports event out there and handing out i9s as prizes. I'm not tunes into the gamers but I still have the impression they believe Intel reigns supreme... With RISC-V about to enter the market and AMD beating Intel on benchmarks, Intel better pull a rabbit out of their behind to stay competitive. But that's just a layman's view on the subject.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoIntel's glaring inability to make a competitive GPU despite several attempts over the years really highlights the structural problems of the company. It can only execute on its core business which the MBA infestation has been riding for a decade with their IP lead and now it finally has run out.
- Schiendelman 6y agoMicrosoft turned this around in 2009-2010 with one decision: Give everyone in engineering a 10-15% raise to keep up with competition. Intel’s fallen far behind on pay, so they have a brain drain problem and a morale problem. They won’t fix it until they pay people more. I think Intel’s more than 15% behind - they may need to bump by 25% or more.
- nolok 6y agoDepending on which branch of the company you're talking of (fab design, chip design, ...), and based on what info you can actually get on it which is less fact and more "large amount of anecdotical evidence", Intel's is between more and a lot of than 15% behind. And while I agree with your proposed first step of the solution, and the urgency to do it given the delay between that and any impact on results, their tendency to look only for short term gains and benefits will probably impede them. They've learned to love easy money, and they didn't need to really pay their people well because there was no serious competition, not in fab, not in chips. Now they're fallen behind on both, as easily predicted, but for a short while they extracted massive amount of money from their margin.
- reducesuffering 6y agoFrom keeping close tabs on general software engineering pay, Intel is only half what other companies pay for the similar years of experience. This means that anyone who is competitively looking in the job market is skipping over Intel. Anyone in the company who is very competent can easily jump ship and get a 2x pay increase, and what’s left inside Intel are the rest.
- person_of_color 6y agoI don’t get it. What’s so hard about getting 10nm to work??