28 ms·
California to Require All New Vehicles Be Zero-Emission by 2035
- tyoma 6y agoDoing this via executive order is going to prompt backlash in the form of a ballot initiative gutting emissions regulation in the state.
- war1025 6y agoWould be interesting to see California continue over-playing their hand and eventually swing back to being a Red state. California seems to have the curse of having enough going for it climate / business-wise that an incompetent and over-controlling government is tolerated by the population.
- freeone3000 6y agoThey keep getting re-elected so they must be doing something right. Maybe the policies aren't as unpopular as you think?
- rattray 6y agoMaybe the political system is broken enough that people who are doing things mostly wrong still get re-elected. (Not specific to California)
- freeone3000 6y agoCalifornia state assembly districts are geographically-contiguous, large, evenly populous, and generated by computer program vetted by both parties. If there's a failing, it doesn't happen in how representatives are chosen.
- rattray 6y agoI actually didn't know that – very cool! There's definitely a lot more to a political process than district sizing, though. For example: - open primaries - approval/score/ranked choice voting - banning political ads - ending two-party system (some of the above would help) - effective voter education (the state pamphlet is a start...) I know many of these sound pie-in-the-sky, but it's hard to imagine truly responsive government (ie; higher quality government than consumer services) without all or most of them.
- mbgerring 6y agoI can't reply to the below comment, but it's worth pointing out that we also have an open primary system in California, where all the candidates of every political party are on the primary ballot and the top two vote getters advance to a runoff in the general election. Also, several of our cities do have ranked choice voting, including in the Bay Area. California's government is the result of effective democracy reform.
- tstrimple 6y agoYeah, California should totally do what's working so well for Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi, etc. Bastions of freedom and enterprise am I right?
- nxc18 6y agoI think the bigger risk is that California fails to fix the most pressing issues (mainly housing). Lots of people are leaving the state and lots of people can't afford to live where they work, which causes all sorts of problems, like forcing people to drive long distances and pushing people to build in fire zones. In the context of the issues facing people, climate regulations just aren't top of mind, excepting the tea party folks. I fully support the governor in general, but this feels like a band-aid on poor fundamentals. In the case of housing, the state is incompetent and _under_ controlling. I also tend to think the state is _under_ controlling when it is hard to breathe because the air is dirty, something that's happened to me regularly since I've moved here.
- mlindner 6y agoThe housing problem is because of _over_ control. Anyone with a hint of economics teaching could tell you that. There are very strict zoning laws everywhere in the bay area that prevent the building of massive apartment complexes and restricts everything to 3-4 stories at best. This causes massive housing undersupply causing the prices to rocket upwards. San Francisco is especially bad with their government's constant effort to pour amber over all of their "historical" districts full of decrepit falling apart housing that need to be bulldozed and have sky scrapers installed in their place. If you add rent control to try to lower the prices all you will cause is a massive increase in the price of any non-rentcontrolled housing (such as houses). If you think 1.5M dollar houses is expensive, wait till you see 3-4M houses.
- nxc18 6y agoYou've written as if you disagree with me, but I don't think you do. It is very important when discussing political issues to make a distinction between state and local control over issues. I live in a community that is desperately fighting any attempt to build more, denser housing. They are working hard to find loopholes around state initiatives to build more housing. This is a case where the state should be more controlling, specifically by preventing cities from interfering with the creation of housing. Cities should not be allowed to pour amber over historical districts.
- subsubzero 6y agoWell between a huge exodus of people leaving for other states[1], a 11% unemployment rate[2], non-stop protests/riots over the summer, there won't be much of California left. I moved out of San Jose/south bay area as I couldn't deal with trash overflowing into the freeways from thousands of homeless encampments[3], illegal fireworks every night for 2-3 months straight[4](sending my dog into extreme panic), packages being stolen off of our doorstep, public schools that were outright terrible all while every 3bdrm+ house is almost $1.5M or more. Forgot to mention the wildfires making the areas air toxic[5] and PG&E turning off power due to the wind[6]. I stayed in state however and will not be voting for any CA incumbents for obvious reasons. [1] - https://www.theadvocates.org/2020/01/california-witnessed-a-mass-exodus-in-2019/ https://www.theadvocates.org/2020/01/california-witnessed-a-... [2] - https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm [3] - https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/09/14/san-jose-unveils-new-plan-to-clean-up-stratospheric-increase-in-illegal-dumping/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/09/14/san-jose-unveils-new-... [4] - https://sanjosespotlight.com/san-jose-illegal-fireworks-complaints-more-than-triple-amid-pandemic/ https://sanjosespotlight.com/san-jose-illegal-fireworks-comp... [5] - https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/A-miserable-month-of-bad-Bay-area-air-quality-15582682.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/A-m... [6] - https://www.actionnewsnow.com/content/news/Rolling-blackouts-or-a-PGE-planned-safety-outage-may-happen-this-holiday-weekend-572335651.html https://www.actionnewsnow.com/content/news/Rolling-blackouts...
- lklcxkkdk 6y agoWhy not require that all vehicles can fly? It feels like they missed a huge opportunity here.
- jamespullar 6y agoI don't trust licensed drivers on the ground as is.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoAssuming that future governors, legislature, and voters agree with Newsom.
- francisofascii 6y agoThe % of American's who want action on climate change seems to be going in an upward direction. So it is not a terrible assumption. Not to mention we already have zero emission vehicles. https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2020/06/23/two-thirds-of-americans-think-government-should-do-more-on-climate/ https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2020/06/23/two-thirds-of...
- username90 6y agoDid people vote for this? Doesn't look like he campaigned with this in mind, is it really democratic to just randomly put together things like this? https://www.politifact.com/california/promises/newsom-meter/ https://www.politifact.com/california/promises/newsom-meter/
- francisofascii 6y agoVoter polling on the importance of climate change may have shifted recently.
- jefurii 6y agoGiven that addressing climate change is increasingly popular with the electorate he's not out of step.
- lucasmullens 6y agoSince when were politicians not allowed to do things they didn't explicitly campaign for? California is on fire, seems only reasonable to react to that as Governor.
- bootlooped 6y agoPre-industrial CO2 levels were 300ppm. In my lifetime I saw us cross 400ppm of CO2; I may very well see it cross 500ppm before I die. This move feels radical, but I don't see how we avert catastrophe without moves that feel radical. If we keep plodding down the course we're on we'll just sleepwalk into oblivion.
- username90 6y agoWhy do it randomly in the middle of a term instead of campaign based of this so we can properly debate and discuss the details?
- tstrimple 6y agoBecause we don't live in a direct democracy?
- username90 6y agoHiding your true intentions and then showing your 15 year plan after you get elected is not in the spirit of representative democracies. Here in Sweden we discuss these things before elections and in general have more climate measures than California, so I don't see why a politician would need to be this heavy handed.
- natch 6y ago> I don't see why... The mistake here is assuming that just because you don’t see a reason, that must mean there is no reason. Maybe you should visit California next time we are in peak firestorm mode and then you might see.
- blackflame7000 6y agoSo this will stop the fires then? Better than say mandating forest management?
- kiliantics 6y agoToo little too late. How can a vehicle be "zero emission" anyway, unless the entire production and supply chain is also zero emission.
- blank_fan_pill 6y ago>How can a vehicle be "zero emission" anyway, unless the entire production and supply chain is also zero emission. Yeah, its almost like this is one step in a long, complicated process of getting the world off of fossil fuels, or something?
- bpodgursky 6y agoI guess we shouldn't do anything at all, as long as there's a pedantic way to dismiss the idea.
- kiliantics 6y agoAs has already been acknowledged in other comments, this is basically asking to be overturned before 2035. If you really mean it -- i.e. you're not just doing it for some kind of brownie points while never needing to show anything for it -- why not set a much sooner date and be the one that actually implements it?
- _greim_ 6y agoAgreed. We should definitely not try to make progress incrementally. It should all happen in one big chunk or not at all.
- gwbas1c 6y agoTesla's production is quite clean. Anyway, an electric car can run off of pretty much any energy source. It's much more expensive to make gasoline from sunlight or nuclear power than charging a battery. (And, if you're wondering, yes, making gasoline from sunlight (biofuels) is a thing, and no, it isn't practical, and yes, people DO try.)
- ivankirigin 6y agoThis phases out car sales, not the cars. Lifecycle is 15 years, so we're looking at 2050. For context, EVs are a few percent of sales in California, and almost zero for trucks.
- tyingq 6y agoSounds like only for "new car" sales also.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDon't trucks generally run on Diesel, so aren't effected by this? Could people start buying more Diesel cars, as well as trucks, because of this?
- svachalek 6y agoThe title says gasoline but the body says “zero-emission”. I suspect the actual legislation is about emissions not type of fuel.
- mlindner 6y agoIt says passenger vehicles, so I expect trucks to be included but not semi trucks and other cargo vehicles.
- chadash 6y agoThe subtitle says all vehicles sold must be zero-emissions, so that presumably includes diesel. But this seems to only target passenger vehicles, not freight carriers.
- babesh 6y ago“ Following the order, the California Air Resources Board will develop regulations to mandate that 100 percent of in-state sales of new passenger cars and trucks are zero-emission by 2035 – a target which would achieve more than a 35 percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions and an 80 percent improvement in oxides of nitrogen emissions from cars statewide. In addition, the Air Resources Board will develop regulations to mandate that all operations of medium- and heavy-duty vehicles shall be 100 percent zero emission by 2045 where feasible, with the mandate going into effect by 2035 for drayage trucks.” https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/09/23/governor-newsom-announces-california-will-phase-out-gasoline-powered-cars-drastically-reduce-demand-for-fossil-fuel-in-californias-fight-against-climate-change/ https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/09/23/governor-newsom-announces-...
- hbcondo714 6y agoOriginal source and announcement from CA governor discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24571019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24571019
- _greim_ 6y agoAn analogy I keep coming back to is a kid putting his hand in a stream to divert the flow, then being surprised when the water continues doing the same thing but in a more complicated way, due to the topography of the landscape.
- dfsegoat 6y agoI'm wondering how they will replace all the gas/diesel 4WD vehicles used by ranchers and vineyard managers here in Sonoma / Napa CA. The wine / grape industry is $1.5B+ for sonoma county alone - Napa is at least that or more. You need reliable 4x4 vehicles to access and work in the remote areas where many grapes are grown up here now.
- birken 6y agoThey'll probably make electric versions of those vehicles? Is there any reason those types of vehicles must be gas powered?
- bluGill 6y agoThat depends - The vast majority of 4x4s never go far enough off road that the advantages of gas matter. For the tiny number of people who do that, the ability to bring extra gas with is important. Note that batteries are so heavy that it isn't an option to bring batteries with - the weight is a negative in many 4x4 situations even if the truck could handle it.
- sulam 6y agoEV models of such vehicles are starting to be produced in "demo" models now, so it doesn't seem like a technical barrier to have them in mass production by the time this takes effect.
- ISL 6y agoOn the reliability front, electric vehicles have far fewer moving parts than IC vehicles. If the world switches entirely to electric, really great electric 4x4s will appear. I can't recall a time that I've used a cordless drill and thought to myself, "man, this thing would be so much better if it were powered by a two-stroke motor". This advantage is especially clear in the case of a 4x4: one need not include viscous couplings and fancy differentials.
- bluGill 6y ago>electric vehicles have far fewer moving parts than IC vehicles Not true. You still have the suspention system which has a lot of moving parts. there are also the moving parts of the brakes. Then the steering system. In theory you don't need a transmission, but in practice you do. There are a few less moving parts, but not substantially less. The moving parts you lose are mostly in a controlled environment with plenty of lubrication and no dirt (though there are other acid combustion byproducts). > I can't recall a time that I've used a cordless drill and thought to myself, "man, this thing would be so much better if it were powered by a two-stroke motor". I have a cordless chainsaw and weed whip. Both would be better with an IC engine. Batteries are much heavier than gas, and this is really noticeable when using them for a while. These are new Dewalt 60 volt systems, not some old technology. Of course there are advantages to battery - I won't got back to gas, like I would have 20 years ago when I first used a battery weed whip. I like the low noise and there is plenty of power. However the gas engine would be lighter. I've also seen gas powered drills and I'm sure that the same applies, batteries are good, but the extra weight to get the same power is a factor. Most drills are used indoors of course so gas was never a real option and that is why battery drills become popular as soon as they worked at all.
- ravenstine 6y agoI like the idea, but there's a lot of questions that need to be answered. The term "zero-emissions" is borderline BS when the energy is coming from a source that emits pollution way off in the distance. If I remember correctly, California has been closing more nuclear power plants than it has been opening, so it while it's nice that our cars won't be putting out smog someday, we aren't going to take climate change seriously unless we move to nuclear. To extend off that question, I've yet to hear an explanation as to how well the grid will tolerate millions of cars being plugged in all the time. During the summer California struggles to keep the lights on, so I'm wondering whether we will be investing in electrical infrastructure this time. Nuclear can help solve that. Same with natural gas to electricity conversion(like what Bloom Energy does).
- jonas21 6y agoCalifornia has a target of 100% carbon-free energy by 2045. https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/8/31/17799094/california-100-percent-clean-energy-target-brown-de-leon https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/8/31/1779909... EDIT: And on your second point, having a large number of electric vehicles may actually help smooth out load -- it's easier to temporarily throttle charging during peak load than it is to get everyone to turn off their air conditioning. Public charging stations, like Chargepoint, already do this. You can even imagine a future where you could tell your car to discharge its battery to power your home during peak demand and then charge back up overnight when power is cheap and plentiful.
- Svip 6y agoDoes that include imported energy?
- jonas21 6y agoYes. [1] [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB100 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
- StillBored 6y ago
- mumblerino 6y ago15 years away. Surely you could require new vehicles to be zero-emission sooner than that?
- ravenstine 6y agoLet me introduce you to some nice folks known as the automobile lobby...
- jefurii 6y agoThey're here already, commenting all over this page.
- dang 6y agoThis breaks the site guidelines. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful.
- acchow 6y agoThe largest automobile manufacturer in California produces exclusively zero emissions vehicles.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoMillions of curbs and apartment lots don't have electrical outlets, much less metered 50 kW supplies that would enable the public to move past hybrids.
- ape4 6y agodiesel-powered cars seems like an obvious loophole. Edit: I see it says "the California Air Resources Board will develop regulations to mandate that 100 percent of in-state sales of new passenger cars and trucks are zero-emission by 2035" So its phasing out non-zero-emission cars/trucks.
- ISL 6y agoDiesel engines produce plenty of emissions.
- blondie9x 6y agoFighting climate change takes courage and passion. Efforts such as these are the only way to win this battle. We need to further these efforts globally.
- throway1gjj 6y agoTakes a lot of courage to destroy other people's industries
- helaoban 6y agoLol no, how about: 'Newsom pats himself on the back with an executive order'.
- pwned1 6y agoWhat percentage of CO2 emissions are from cars?
- philipkglass 6y agoAs of 2017, California had statewide emissions of 424 million tons CO2-equivalent [1]. "CO2-equivalent" emissions include the global warming effects of CO2 plus methane, nitrous oxide, and other gases, normalized to the global warming potential of CO2. (For example, emitting a ton of nitrous oxide is roughly equal to 298 tons of carbon dioxide on a 100 year time horizon [2].) Using California's Greenhouse Gas Emission Inventory Query Tool [3], I searched for transportation, on road, light duty vehicles only, CO2 only. For 2017, the emissions were 58 million tons from light duty trucks and SUVs plus 58.4 million tons from passenger cars. The total of 116.4 million tons is about 27.5% of all California emissions. Since according to [1] the transportation sector accounts for 41% of all CA emissions, light duty road vehicles account for about 67% of California's transportation emissions. Heavy duty trucks account for another 32.3 million tons of CO2 emissions. [1] https://ww3.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/pubs/reports/2000_2017/ghg_inventory_trends_00-17.pdf https://ww3.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/pubs/reports/2000_2017/g... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential [3] https://www.arb.ca.gov/app/ghg/2000_2017/ghg_sector.php https://www.arb.ca.gov/app/ghg/2000_2017/ghg_sector.php
- pwned1 6y agoThank you, that's helpful.
- CameronNemo 6y agoWhat about trucks that transport goods across the state, including Amazon, UPS, and USPS trucks as well as traditional cargo trucks? Are those still going to be diesel powered and leaving a significant amount of brake dust in their wake? What about the ships that burn the dirtiest fuel imaginable right up until they near California ports? Are they still going to be greeted with open arms? What about all of the methane leaks from natural gas operations in the state? Will those actors face consequences? What about the oil drilling that happens all along California's coast? Will they still be able to extract fossil fuels without paying royalties to the state? Passenger vehicles are such a small portion of CO2 emissions, and implementing these restrictions pisses off a lot of people who do not want to change. High hanging fruit that is barely ripe.
- jefurii 6y agoThe announcement says heavy duty vehicles must be zero-emission by 2045. Saying there's lots of other work to do is not a good rationale for not doing this.
- CameronNemo 6y agoCan't companies just purchase and register a heavy duty truck in Nevada but operate it in California?
- athms 6y agoIf the vehicle is garaged or primarily used in California, it must be registered here. The state already has a problem with people keeping their vehicles registered in other states when they move here. For interstate trucking, companies will probably register in Nevada or Arizona, but intrastate transport companies are going to face large fines if caught.
- maerF0x0 6y ago> cars shouldn’t make wildfires worse Additional strain on the electrical grid could do so (else more rolling blackouts) >The Governor invested in forest health and fuel reduction Missing text "Your money" The Governor invested YOUR MONEY in forest health and fuel reduction > The executive order will not prevent Californians from owning gasoline-powered cars or selling them on the used car market. Ok, so a dealership can still bring cars in from AZ, OR, NV etc?
- echelon 6y agoHas the problem of having to recharge rapidly been solved? What if I need to drive somewhere in a hurry but my car isn't charged? What if there's a power outage or I forget to plug in my car overnight? I'm not saying these are blockers, but they're not convenient.
- mlindner 6y agoPlugging your car in overnight is a matter of course. You drive home and plug it in every day. It becomes muscle memory like anything else you do in life. You can rarely forget of course, but it's not like it's inconvenient. And for daily driving you can actually do many days of daily driving already without charging on standard electric vehicles today already, that'll have improved in 15 years as well. In Tesla's new announcement the other day one of the other things they mentioned is like a 10x increase in battery charge times with the new cell design which will be ready in 3 years or so. So give it time.
- jcranmer 6y agoAnd if you don't have a garage?
- redisman 6y agoReplace parking meters with pay-to-use chargers I guess. If you're randomly street parking it'll be pretty difficult until they're ubiquitous.
- bradlys 6y agoUnless you don’t have parking meters where you park... It’s very rare that I park somewhere with parking meters near. For myself and many others, our cars will never see a driveway, a garage, or any place that could have a charging station. I think this will be a hugely limiting factor in adoption. As it stands, electric car owners are home owners more often than ICE purchasers and I don’t see that changing - maybe ever.
- 6y ago
- Someone1234 6y agoI like it conceptually, but isn't there missing technology still? Batteries have improved mildly, but energy to weight ratio (and energy to cost) remain problematic. If we witnessed a jump in battery technology, we may not even need to wait for 2035 for the market to do this for us. But in the meantime we're still seeing electric cars that cost at minimum 10K more than their gas counterparts (with the low cost of oil/gas right now only making that look worse). I'd love to own a Tesla Model 3 for example, but realistically it is a $37K car that competes with $25K gas vehicles or $27K Hybrids. When is THAT going to change? When is electric going to be affordable for the average person? The $7.5K federal tax incentives also disappeared (and we never had state incentives here).
- gnicholas 6y agoIIRC, the federal tax incentives phase out per manufacturer, based on the number of qualifying vehicles sold. So buyers of VW's newly-announced ID.4 will be able to claim the full credit, but buyers of Tesla's Model Y won't.
- Someone1234 6y agoThe ID.4 starts $40K base without destination charges or local taxes. Even with the $7.5K federal tax credit that's an incredibly expensive compact SUV (you can get full SUVs for $5K less, let alone compact SUVs).
- gnicholas 6y agoThey're reportedly targeting $35k minus the tax credit. Don't have the link but I read this in a publication this AM.
- Someone1234 6y agoMultiple publications are describing it as $40K base: https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/23/21444141/volkswagen-vw-id4-electric-suv-price-range-specs https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/23/21444141/volkswagen-vw-id... https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a34114103/2021-vw-id4-revealed/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a34114103/2021-vw-id4-reve... https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/09/volkswagens-new-id-4-electric-car-how-far-how-much-and-when/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2020/09/volkswagens-new-id-4-el...
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoElectric cars are all well and good, but even if everyone drives them, they still consume far more energy than public transport.
- cultus 6y agoThis is a good point and does not get that much attention. Electric cars are still large machines with a large environmental input. It is more environmentally friendly to just build out transit and encourage density. The vast majority of people would not need personal cars were they to live in a walkable area with good transit. Not only that, road building and maintenance is a far greater money sink than transit. People are just used to it and don't think about it. There will always be a need for some people to have personal cars. There's no silver bullet to climate change, and moving to electric is a good thing. However, we realistically need to reduce total consumption (in terms of environmental resource input) massively. Making it easier for people to live without cars is relatively low-hanging fruit, and increases quality of life, to boot.
- qppo 6y agoYou could argue it's a good thing they're more expensive while the alternatives are phased out, more people would need to use public transit or live within walking distance of places they use cars to reach today.
- bradlys 6y agoThe financial gains just shift to the landlord class and people get worse accommodations for their cost. Still a win-lose scenario.
- throway1gjj 6y agoCalifornia, legislates its way to homelessness then blames the lack of government
- downandout 6y agoThis was an executive order, not a law that was passed. Given that multiple new governors will likely have taken office in California between now and 2035, and any one of them can rescind or modify this based on the then-state of the electric car market and the economy, it doesn't really mean anything. If the electric car market is mature enough by 2035 for this to not cause major economic issues for car dealers and others throughout the state, then it will stand. But if that's the case, the majority of car sales will be electric with or without this order. If that's not the case, it will be quietly rescinded or modified by the then-governor. So this order, effectively, is just political posturing and changes nothing that won't naturally happen (or not happen) anyway.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoA bit stronger: Does the governor have the authority to do this by executive order? Or is he just shooting his mouth off?
- downandout 6y agoIt’s unlikely that the order will be legally tested until 2035, so that’s the beauty of a statement like this...he gets to play to his base on the eco side of things, and won’t ever have to deal with the fallout.
- Bhilai 6y agoPlease educate me, isn't climate change a lost cause now? We know its inevitable and despite wide awareness, no one basically does anything. Individual action is not going help and US government does not even believe that any such thing is happening and has relaxed EPA regulations on polluters and such, so is CA restricting sale of fossil fuel vehicles going to matter in the long run?
- loeg 6y ago> Please educate me, isn't climate change a lost cause now? We know its inevitable and despite wide awareness, no one basically does anything. Er, no. It is inevitable, but the degree of change absolutely continues to matter. > US government does not even believe that any such thing is happening and has relaxed EPA regulations on polluters and such, so is CA restricting sale of fossil fuel vehicles going to matter in the long run? Here's the context you might be missing: CA is a huge automobile market, and has historically set a number of requirements that automakers eventually incorporate into all cars sold into the US market. It's cheaper to build one SKU than two, as long as the CA SKU is only mildly more expensive than the non-CA would be. Additionally, auto manufacturers will have similar requirements for the EU market on a similar timeline.
- bsurmanski 6y agoEveryone is hesitant to make change because "it's going to cause too much economic impact". If someone demonstrates that it's possible to change without screwing over their economy, it's likely other states and countries will follow. Just because the USA has federal administration that doesn't want to act on climate change right now doesn't mean that it won't get a greener administration in the future. As for being a lost cause, isn't it preferable to minimize the effect, at least? would you rather the sea levels go up by 2.0 meters or 1.5 meters?
- tayo42 6y agoOur leaders need to be ballsy enough to make unpopular decisions to solve climate change. In the short term, things will be harder, more expensive, jobs will be lost. That's because the externalities of life have been free for our society. We need to be brought into a green world kicking and screaming.
- mlindner 6y agoThis is interesting timing. I wonder if this is because Tesla's battery day was yesterday and also the Volkswagen ID4 was announced today?
- jefurii 6y agoThe FUD and what-about-ism is pretty thick on this page.
- peferron 6y agoYeah, it's such a depressing read.
- ryandrake 6y agoSeems like this opens up a long-term opportunity for someone to build some car dealerships on the CA/NV and CA/OR borders, since it doesn't outlaw bringing existing cars into the state.
- mrfusion 6y agoHow can this be done by executive order? It really seems like the kind of thing you’d want your legislature involved in.
- claydavisss 6y agoRight. Without the legitimacy of legislative backing, there is no roadblock to a future Governor undoing this using the same Executive powers.
- sollewitt 6y agoMy take is it's actually a reactive move to counter his issuing more fracking permits in 2020 than 2019. This is CA, he's vulnerable on climate issues. I do believe he (like most CA residents) are acutely worried about climate change, but I think this particular action is more about optics than change.
- mlindner 6y agoBecause the state EPA sets the rules and the EPA is an executive branch function. State congress can overrule it by passing a law, but policy of an executive branch of government can be decided at whim by the governor.
- vogre 6y agoIs there already a way to recycle batteries efficiently? Without one this bill would lead to millions of cars with unrecyclable toxic batteries.
- philipkglass 6y ago"North America’s first lithium-ion battery recycling hub is coming to New York" Li-Cycle, a Canadian battery recycling firm has chosen the location for its first commercial lithium-ion battery recycling Hub: Eastman Business Park in Rochester, New York. Construction of the $175 million Hub facility is set to begin in 2021 and the facility is planned to be fully operational in 2022. https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2020/09/21/north-americas-first-lithium-ion-battery-recycling-hub-is-coming-to-new-york/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2020/09/21/north-americas-first-...
- gwbas1c 6y agoYesterday Tesla described their battery recycling plan in quite a bit of detail. Short answer: Tesla 100% recycles their batteries and will be able to 100% recycle them indefinitely.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 6y agoThere's like a 2% chance that ICE sales will be more than a single-digit percent of the market by 2035. Yawn
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoObjection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence.
- o_p 6y agoCould you use ICE cars by buying gas backed by carbon credits with this law?
- throwawaysea 6y agoWhy is California (and perhaps the political left in general) obsessed with banning or requiring things? Bit by bit the choice individuals could make privately or locally is being taken away from them. In a very real way, freedom is being replaced with decision-making by the state at broader and broader levels of jurisdiction. This is not a good way to manage society. If the value in adopting electric vehicles is there, let people recognize that value on their own and decide on their own to adopt it. Alter incentive structures in minor ways but don't override an open-ended libertarian choice architecture with top-down authoritarian decision-making. More about this in a book called Nudge, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_%28book%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_%28book%29
- rsynnott 6y agoIn 1952, due to a combination of weird weather and coal emissions, a smog in London lasting four days killed at least 4,000 people over its duration and possibly as many as 12,000 people over the next few months. This lead to the phasing out of domestic coal in cities, regulation on power plant flue gas, and so forth, over the following decade. People, and the energy industry, kicked and screamed, but the government (at the time controlled by noted lefties the Conservative party) did it anyway. There were two more incidents in 1957 and 1962 killing 750-1000 people each, but that was about the end of it. Maybe in a parallel universe the libertarian government of the UK did nothing, and people reduced their emissions on the same timeline anyway. But I think it's somewhat more likely that in that parallel universe people are still dying horribly in their thousands every time the dangerous weather conditions (cold, no wind) repeat. People are notoriously bad at externalities.
- PHGamer 6y agoits not the governments job to deal with this. europe made the same bullshit law. if electric can beat gas at the same price point people will naturally pick that. especially if elon is correct about his telsa stuff. if you could spend 25k and get a model 3 that did almost 400 miles and RWD i think it would kill a lot of car models.
- josho 6y agoThe free market solves for things that we price. It often fails when externalities are not accounted for. Ironically free market advocates often are against pricing in externalities through things like a carbon tax. If we priced carbon appropriately decades ago then the market would look drastically different today and this new zero-emissions requirement wouldn't be needed.
- staplor 6y agoIt is the governments job to deal with this. Polluting the atmosphere may be cheaper for an individual consumer, but is a negative externality for everyone else on earth. If the government didn’t involve itself in any green energy, Tesla would not be profitable.[1] [1] https://realmoney.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/tesla-s-main-product-isn-t-cars-it-s-subsidies-14769263 https://realmoney.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/tesla-s-mai...
- golemiprague 6y agoIn Europe the situation is even more complicated because many people don't have houses and garages like in the US so you need also to build infrastructure for charging overnight in the street. In Norway they seemed to deal with this issue but how is it going to work in places like London or Paris I am not sure
- mhh__ 6y ago> its not the governments job to deal with this. Right... Unless you have something like an aggressive carbon tax (at the consumer level), why would the free market work? Climate Change is clearly a tragedy of the commons (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons) The technology is clearly possible, but getting past a local equilibrium requires some energy.
- option 6y agoIt would be great to make sure: (1) our grid is safe and ready for that and (2) we don’t buy dirty electricity (like we do now more and more buy buying from Utah) and instead use renewables + nuclear mix
- mbgerring 6y agoWho's working on expanding electric vehicle infrastructure in rural California? This will become increasingly important late next year when electric trucks begin hitting the market.
- mrfusion 6y agoSomeone watched battery day ...
- millstone 6y ago> He said 34 electric vehicle companies, including Tesla Inc. already operate in California, which accounts for about half of the nation’s EV market. "California accounts for half the US EV market" is quite striking. What are the 34 companies? Is this counting non-vehicle companies like ChargePoint, tiny startups, existing automakers with EV offerings? It's striking how many more EV options are available in Europe. Here in CA, we mainly get electric SUVs. I hope this announcement expands the market.
- cbayram 6y agoIt’d be great if modern society could make smaller vehicles for personal use. Average number of occupants on the road has to below 2.0, seems terribly inefficient. The industries and costs associated w car ownership would have to adjust too for this too happen. Legislation is also necessary to deal with mutually destructive nature of not wanting to be on the same roads as larger fortified vehicles; i.e. lanes/roads dedicated to smaller personal vehicles. Above all, as a society, we have to start giving a damn about environmental destruction. Rethink the status quo, rethink urban planning, rethink overuse of plastics, rethink leaf blowing...
- peapicker 6y agoIn general, it seems like a good idea, but I worry... Because PG&E is such an aging, unreliable electricity network I seriously worry about what this will mean for how people expect to reliably charge those cars in northern CA during the summers of rolling blackouts etc without huge amounts of infrastructure rebuild.
- sjg007 6y agoEveryone installs battery walls and solar panels. People will do this to avoid the blackouts anyway.
- legitster 6y agoI enjoy driving cars. With engines that go vroom-vroom. One of the benefits of a carbon tax is that I could continue to drive cars with engines that go vroom as long as I want so long as I can afford to pay the tax. And there is a very realistic situation that all of my carbon can be offset for just a few hundred dollars a year, if we have the resources to invest in next gen offset technology. But we are in a political situation where it is easier to outright ban this than simply ask people to pay for the cost.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y agoI say this as an EV fanatic and Tesla owner, but I'm with you that outright banning ICE cars is the wrong solution. It totally fucks anybody that can't charge at home. Do you know how many millions of people live in apartments? Do you think they're really going to shell out the cash to build EV chargers in all their parking spots? The problem is, increasing taxes on gas will disproportionately affect the poor who can't afford to buy an EV (and again, are unlikely to live somewhere with a charger), while also having side effects of increasing the cost of all physical goods that need to be shipped. Semitrucks become more expensive to run, and while Tesla is working on a semi, it's only going to be useful for intra-city distribution, since semis used for inter-city travel are almost constantly on the road and will be driven by multiple drivers to keep moving, so they don't have time to charge.
- jacb 6y ago> The problem is, increasing taxes on gas will disproportionately affect the poor who can't afford to buy an EV (and again, are unlikely to live somewhere with a charger) But banning ICE cars is clearly even worse for those unable to afford an EV, right? Unless policy-makers think that precommitting to ban ICE cars by 2035 will lead to a sudden flurry of new EV development _that wouldn't have happened if they had just precommitted to adding large carbon taxes by 2035.
- panopticon 6y agoThis only bans the sale of new ICE vehicles. Presumably, lower income households will continue to drive their ICE cars after this ban, and then move into an EV sometime down the road once the post-2035 used car market has enough EVs at the right price.
- m0zg 6y agoThat's pretty brilliant thinking on Newsom's part: shut down all remaining nuclear and fossil fuel power plants (which has led to rolling blackouts already) and require that all cars are electric. Bold strategy. Let's see how it plays out.
- devmunchies 6y ago> CA is phasing out the internal combustion engine. What about motorcycles and trains? Is this just cars? My motorcycle already gets like 80mpg.
- athms 6y ago>My motorcycle already gets like 80mpg. Motorcycles also pollutes more per mile than a light truck. They generate less carbon dioxide but produces four times more hydrocarbons, thirty times more nitrogen oxides, and eighty times more carbon monoxide.
- devmunchies 6y agowell, I guess electric motorcycles are the way to go :/ more energy efficient across the board than any car.
- julienb_sea 6y agoNot only will this not make a dent in the broader climate problem, this is a direct tax on the poor and forced transfer of money to green business like Musk's. I wonder if California is trying to convince Musk to keep Tesla in town. In any event, California also already cannot keep up with its electricity demands. Onboarding more renewables with batteries is not the solution, especially as California's car market will drastically increase demand for battery production. There are so many layers to why this is stupid. - Battery production is already a highly polluting operation. The mining needed to put the batteries together is not going to get easier or cleaner as the demand for batteries is artificially exponentially increased via California mandate. - How are you going to produce enough power for all these electric cars? Solar and wind aren't going to cut it, and they need to be supported by large battery or backup generation infrastructure. The batteries won't be available in large enough capacity. The backup generation is - wait for it - powered by gas, and less efficient for transportation than directly burning gas in the car's engine. - I'm predicting many individuals purchase gas generators as backups for their home, given how inconsistent power availability will be in California. - All these inconveniences will be absorbed by wealthy folks, like many of the commenters here, who pat themselves on the back for their virtuous actions. All the while callously creating ever greater burdens on the lower and middle class.
- tonyhb 6y ago> this is a direct tax on the poor and forced transfer of money to green business like Musk's Poor people aren't buying new cars. They're buying 10 year old cars that can still run on gas, be hybrids, or be electric. The same situation as now. > - Battery production is already a highly polluting operation. So is gas, "both ways". EG: exploration, drilling, refining, shipment, and actually burning it. Not to mention spills. This is a straw man. > - I'm predicting many individuals buy gas generators as backups for their home, given how inconsistent power availability will be in California. This is a PG&E problem. Don't hate progress, dude. New cars must not pollute in 15 years time. You could raise a kid to have a better understanding of the environment than a lot of people in that same time. This is a long time.
- zbrozek 6y ago
- d33lio 6y agoObviously this works when you purchase power from natural gas power plants out of state...
- ummonk 6y agoJust urban politicians who don't give a damn about rural people.
- adolph 6y agoMore accurate title would be "CA Gov Issues Order for Goal for Zero-Emission Vehicles by 2035" Text of order: https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/9.23.20-EO-N-79-20-text.pdf https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/9.23.20-EO...
- andyjih_ 6y agoWe need bold moves to address our climate crisis. No policy will be perfect though.
- eezurr 6y agoDirecting the population from one form of consumption to another huh? A real drastic measure would be to ban all non-service related advertising and social media. People are driven to consume by the infinite comparisons available all around them. The only people immune to this are those who practice asceticism. Another drastic measure would be to ban citizen ownership of cars. Local, regional, and national transportation services could fill in the gaps. When I was in Brazil, you could pay 2 Reals($) to hop in a van that ran on a circuit like a bus, but cheaper. People will fill the gaps if there's money in it for them. Another drastic measure would be to move all the money being dumped into self driving cars and electric cars to public transportation infrastructure/services. Another drastic measure would be to heavily tax processed food, so less energy is consumed to feed us. (And it will make people healthier, which will save a lot of energy in health care.). Another drastic measure would be to ban imports on most goods and force them to be produced locally. Now that we're forced to piss in our own pool, that will really motivate clean manufacturing. And we'll spend less energy getting the goods to the consumers. But no, the American way of solving problems involves adding more to the equation, not taking away. This is partly satire, maybe 30% serious.
- vaccinator 6y agoZero emission including power generation? Or do they just ignore it? that's the main problem with corporations' pollution...
- pengaru 6y agoI'm waiting for California to start taxing the hell out of ICE-powered vehicles to discourage their purchase on the used market, or just hike gas prices so high it's an enthusiasts-only tolerated kind of thing. You can buy a rust-free used V8 SUV for like 2-3k in CA, and it'll be on the road for another decade if maintained.
- analognoise 6y agoThis only hurts poor people.
- jayd16 6y agoIt does but its not the only thing it does.
- reducesuffering 6y agoMore fitting is taxing new ICE purchases. Lower income folks could still afford cheap, used vehicles, but folks trying to purchase a 50k, 18mpg sports car will find they'll have to pay an additional ~20k based on the car's emissions. You can make it easier to vote for by being tax-neutral and any revenue is used to fund credits towards new EV purchases -5k. The emissions tax and EV discount will be adjusted yearly to maintain revenue neutral. We should be optimizing a maximal ICE tax and maximal EV discount that minimizes emissions across all new cars. People dropping ~35k+ on new ICE cars, while there is an equivalent 35k EV, must pay to account for their externalities in a true market.
- fomine3 6y agoNaturally taxing new ICE makes used ICEs expensive after a few years.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIt’s bizarre to me that we would consider legislating this before considering compulsory vegetarianism.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI like the sentiment but... This is going to be terrible for everyone who doesn't drive new cars because you can bet your ass that if they actually hit their goal and no new fossil fuel cars are sold in 2035 by 2040 they'll have massive "polluter" (or whatever they want to call it) surcharges (aka taxes in disguise) on what's already the highest registration prices in the nation. So the people who are driving a 2020 Camry in 2040 are gonna get screwed hard. If they truly believe electric will soon be economically viable without government subsidy (as all the headlines proclaim) then what's the point of the law?
- titzer 6y ago> then what's the point of the law? Ostensibly, to reduce CO2 emissions. > This is going to be terrible for everyone who doesn't drive new cars Unfortunately, cars have been pumping out negative externalities for more than a century. You can't avoid these negative externalities forever.
- clay_the_ripper 6y agoI think the point of the law is to paint a picture of where we want to go as a society (of Californians). It’s 15 years away, so these things are more a signal that “hey this is where we’re going”. This in turn makes you think “hmm maybe I should buy electric” which in turn makes manufacturers go “hmm I guess we should go electric if we want to sell in California.” Its a self fulfilling prophecy, a mission statement and a confirmation of what we already know: electric cars are here to stay, they are likely to improve massively over 15 years, and they are the future of transportation for CA.
- kumarm 6y agoIts funny the comment above you says CA Governor signed a law that he doesn't have to follow through since he would retire by then. You comment indicate why it discourages people buying non electric cars even now. So it's a good win for Earth?
- natch 6y agoAnyone buying a Camry in 2020 should have done an analysis of the TCO of a Camry versus a base config Tesla Model 3. Same goes for most SUVs versus Model Y. Many gas cars at this point are already a very bad economic decision especially when you consider tanking resale value. In a few years it will be the same for trucks versus electric trucks which will have up to 600 miles range. Legislation though... that is a longer topic. Basically the gas car companies have a lot of reasons to resist and come up with seeming deals so without a law they will perpetuate gas for much longer.
- biolurker1 6y agoFive years later than Amsterdam that is.
- frank2 6y agoAlthough his reputation would suffer by signing an order and then not taking steps to implement it, the current governor will almost certainly be retired or holding national office by the time it becomes possible (near 2035) to take practical implementation steps, and as far as I know there is no way for proponents of this measure to compel or pressure future California governments to implement this order. So unless I am missing something, unlike most executive orders, this order is merely symbolic and does not commit the government or anyone else to anything. Am I missing something?
- Justsignedup 6y agounpopular opinion: This law is not even remotely radical. By 2035 I don't think people will be living in California. My bad joke for the day. I'll see myself out.
- CodeWriter23 6y agoI completely reject the validity of this as it is being done through an Executive Order. Newsom doesn't get to decide this on his own, it needs to go through the Legislature to be valid.
- otterley 6y agoAre you sure that the CA Legislature didn't already grant the executive the power to regulate emissions?
- rm999 6y ago"Completely reject the validity" is an interesting way to word your thoughts in a comment about checks and balances :P The board that regulates emissions in California is basically run by the executive, with legislative oversight: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Air_Resources_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Air_Resources_Board
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoOw the irony
- mrDmrTmrJ 6y agoWhy not ban all ICE vehicle sales by 2025? (Except trucks to drivers with a CDL.) We need to move faster :)
- bjo590 6y agoDoes this apply to motorcycles/motortrikes? It seems to use the term "passenger vehicle" which is a bit ambiguous.
- exabrial 6y agoAnother tax on the poor. Sad.
- Animats 6y agoIt's probably time. All the major technical problems with electric cars have been solved. Now it's just deployment.
- fomine3 6y agoCurrent BEVs are relatively big and very heavy due to battery. Is it worth to replace very efficient sub compact car with ICE (Possibly HEV) to big BEV?
- millstone 6y agoBEVs in the US are mostly large, but that is because Americans prefer larger cars in general. There are small EVs like the Mini Cooper or the Fiat 500. It's true the Mini Electric is heavier than the non-electric version, but only ~15%, and it actually improves handling. I think the tech is more than there.
- eplanit 6y agoShouldn't radical decisions come from the people? I guess Authoritarianism is great if one agrees with the outcome? Newsom is the governor of a state that lauds itself as being the most insightful and aware of Climate Change -- yet for all these years the wise leaders have been doing nothing to prepare. We've been in drought and fire mode for about a decade now. How many new reservoirs have been proposed and built? What forestry practices have changed? Basically, none. His state is on fire, and he cannot keep the power on at peak times. This grand move is an attempt at deflection and distraction from his (and his predecessors') lack of true leadership.
- afrojack123 6y agoThis was going to happen anyways since government knows industry can make this happen. Hardly a California thing
- happyjack 6y agoWhat's funny is that California is probably going to be one of the last oil producing states. They have been endowed with six fields that are over a billion barrels, with the largest reserves in the nation behind Prudhoe bay.
- 0xDEEPFAC 6y agoAnother reason to move from CA... Anyone else sick of seeing careless Tesla drivers swerving around on autopilot?
- chaostheory 6y agoI hope they do something about power infrastructure like aggressively promoting solar just as much because our current power infrastructure cannot support this. Decentralizing our power generation through solar would really mitigate our current situation much faster and support the future.
- meling 6y agoI’m not impressed. Norway requires the same by 2025. Come on California... move faster.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seany 6y agoI don't see how this doesn't end up with people buying property out of state so they can register vehicles to that address. I say this is a EV, plugin hybrid, gas, and diesel owner. The EV/PHEV were 100% purchased because of commute/climate reasons... but you can pull my diesel truck from my cold dead hands.
- namuol 6y agoIf EVs are that uncompetitive by 2035 then we've got bigger problems.
- seany 6y agoI want to be able to drive a _large_ vehicle with 4 people, 2 dogs, and "back woods" camping gear on open highway for 24hours with out stopping. When I do stop it needs to be less than 30 minutes, and cost similar price to a diesel truck that gets 20mpg. I'm not expecting much by 2035, but we'll see.
- throway1gjj 6y agoWhat % of unemployment in California would be worth it a 0.01% drop in carbon emissions world wide? Looking forward to [flagged] and downvotes.
- jp0d 6y agoI don't know what percentage of electricity generated in California comes from renewable energy. If it's not 100% renewable then the EVs won't be Zero-emission either! Let's not even talk about range anxiety, charging times and long queues at the charging stations during a long weekend. If Hydrogen can be manufactured/extracted efficiently, that's definitely going to be a lot better than EVs. At least there won't be millions of used batteries to be disposed.
- mjevans 6y agoPresumably they hope to use wind, or solar, or some other power generation technology. That is one of electric vehicle's actual points of benefit; the power generation source is modular.
- jp0d 6y agoYes, that's the hope. Less than 20% of the electricity is produced from renewable sources in my state (Victoria, AU). If the number of EVs increase that's just going to put more pressure on the grid and will require burning more coal. I don't know if the pollution from cars is worse than burning coals in a power plant. I'm guessing it's not. I'm hoping for hydrogen as the future. There is company working on Hydrogen here. Even Toyota and Honda have been working mostly on Hydrogen not battery based EVs. I've nothing against Tesla. In fact I admire Elon Musk as an engineer. But given the choice I'll probably go with Hydrogen fuel cell cars if it can be made readily available like Petrol.
- gibolt 6y agoThe entire new annual fleet will have to hit 100% electric before that, which is a massively steep curve. I recently started https://tryelectricnow.com https://tryelectricnow.com to connect EV owners with car buyers to try to have a larger, distributed impact. One ride will 'click' for most people, and they won't go back.
- asien 6y agoAFAIK EV have net C02 emission which are higher than Gas car. The extraction of Rare Earth ,and Electricity coming mostly from Coal in US don’t make them any cleaner than Gas Vehicle. Hence you can buy your non-ev outside of California and come back with it few minutes later ... This is pure communication , there is no real intention to actually address climate change. Hence , we are doing far worse than every GIEC model and most countries do not respect COP21 agreement....
- Keverw 6y agoYeah seems going electric just shifts things but maybe they are also hoping the tech and cheaper happens by then. Seems like right now they’d be pushing out the middle and lower class people even more, making California some elite state only for rich people. Like for example mandating solar on new homes seem noble on paper but makes things cost more when housing is already expensive.
- Tade0 6y agoAFAIK EV have net C02 emission which are higher than Gas car. Not true: https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-electric-vehicles-help-to-tackle-climate-change https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-electric-vehicles-...
- echopom 6y agoEven taking this model where Euro Car is 240 g/km and EV are 140 g/km , how this is supposed to stop climate change ?
- easytiger 6y agoAnd a prayer is said for rare earth elements. Folly into folly.
- codecamper 6y ago2035. Because we NEED 15 more years with our SUVs. What a joke. Politicians are useless.
- poilcn 6y agoIt's easy for politicians write laws that suppose to take effect in far future as it won't be them who will enforce them and be responsible for the failures in the process.
- adammunich 6y agoThis is the biggest news of the decade.
- cmutel 6y agoSorry for being late to the game, but we have an as-open-as-it-can-be tool to compare petrol, gas, battery, and fuel cell cars, both today and in the future, available here: http://carculator.psi.ch/ http://carculator.psi.ch/ The Python library which does the calculations is here: https://pypi.org/project/carculator/ https://pypi.org/project/carculator/ One nice thing about our tool is that it calculates life cycle emissions including projected changes in the electricity grid of the region you live in. Of course, these are uncertain, but most other academic analysis just use the current grid mix. It's important to realize that, even with the advances in electric vehicles, while they are better than combustion cars, they are far from zero-emission. Lifetime emissions for an electric car could still be 200 g CO2/km, split almost evenly between the electricity supply and everything else. Depending on usage, which of course has wide spatial variation, just road construction and maintenance itself could be 20 g CO2/km (this number is valid for Switzerland, which has very high utilization rates). I think most people who are have seriously investigated the current system and possible future developments in the next 10 to 20 years have come to the conclusion that a lot of the change has to be in consumer behaviour - clean tech is not clean enough, or can't be scaled up enough in the current economic and political climate, to reach any reasonable climate goal.
- tauntz 6y agohttp://carculator.psi.ch/start http://carculator.psi.ch/start "Simple" doesn't work and fails with an error "We have not been able to detect the country to run the analysis for. Please wait a few seconds and try again." "Intermediate" doesn't work and directs me to http://carculator.psi.ch/tool/ http://carculator.psi.ch/tool/ which gives a 404 Just thought you might want to know
- tcpekin 6y agoUnfortunately for me, I can't access simple analysis since the site can't figure out what country I'm in (no permissions were even asked for), and when I click on the intermediate analysis, the link doesn't seem to be valid. Only the advanced seems available to me. It would be great to not have to make an account as well.
- glaberficken 6y agoSo, this is for new vehicles only. What will stop people just hanging on to their existing ICE cars for longer years?
- travisporter 6y agoCar carbon capture to retrofit existing cars is this idea in my head that refuses to go away. Barriers: what to do with extra CO2, parasitic load, lost storage space. But if the result is zero emissions and I can pay, I dunno, $1000 and drop my fuel efficiency by 20%, I may go for it.
- vaccinator 6y agoLots of problems to be solved before this is a viable alternative for everyone.