15 ms·
Platforms' current attempts to regulate misinformation amplify opinion power
- mc32 6y agoThere is no easy answer that I can see to this dilemma. Advertising driven platforms lead to people seeking meme type approval and are encouraged to share outlandish claims. On the other hand allowing government to set policy is obviously problematic (insert CCP, United Russia, or even the Dem or Repub parties in the US setting the rules). Other than perhaps dispersed federation (to cap growth) I don’t see a good way to manage this.
- uniqueid 6y agoAnother option is for a government to involve itself indirectly. It could regulate by requiring a social media company meet a vague "community standard." I'm not convinced that would work, but it's less authoritarian than a government dictating a list of acceptable content to private companies. Then you use some system (tally letters of complaint? votes? random sample of citizens, akin to "jury duty"?) to see if the community itself is satisfied.
- neuronic 6y agoAre you saying that governments should become admins in society-wide forums?
- uniqueid 6y agoI'm saying mc32 listed two possibilities, but there is a third: for government to delegate to the public. The people can decide what standards of moderation they want. That's an in-between approach, as it doesn't involve government officials drawing up a list of acceptable speech. The philosophy is similar to that of a referendum, jury duty, or an election. It's the community who decide if a company is behaving acceptably.
- jude- 6y agoI almost wonder if (1) capping the audience size a user can reach, and (2) limiting the rate of a user's audience churn would dissuade users from amplifying misinformation. Not only would it cap the dopamine hit they'd get from sharing outlandish bullshit, but also limit the damage they could do by doing so.
- yellow_postit 6y agoCapping access to reach is akin to current editorial media — politicians and celebrities get more reach than others. When those in a position of reach choose to share outlandish misinformation we still as a society don’t seem to have good ways to hold them to accounnt. Once those large reach accounts share out then smaller ones can disseminate to all the untracked nooks and crannies and amplify further.
- joshribakoff 6y agoI’m not buying into this article. Twitter for example isn’t reining this “opinion power”, the bad actors (certain “politicians”) are the ones reining the opinion power. Placing a warning label that a politician is saying something factually inaccurate isn’t reining opinion power Additionally the title is very click bait. There is no data or any kind of citations that can be used to conclude attempts to regulate misinformation amplify the bad actors efforts as the title would imply, in fact the paper attempts to point at other countries that have regulated things like child pornography and hate speech which is pretty unrelated to the matter of regulating misinformation
- mc32 6y agoThe thing is the warnings may not be applied equally. Or even if they are applied equally to all liars, some claims may in retrospect turn out right and then the warning turns out to have been wrong.
- joshribakoff 6y agoTo me this just sounds like an argument against fact checking in general, all this is also true of any third party fact checking service, either way someone can be politically slighted, but also anyone is free to start their own third party fact checking service (at least in a free society)
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt is true of any fact checking service. It's important, then, that there be more than one. Any single oracle of truth becomes a single point of attack for liars, propagandists, and suppressors of truth.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI do think the measures were counter productive, but it is hard to get any quantifiable data on this. I think the currency was trust, the product very expensive and the result a catastrophe. Sa sdorowje! And the invoice doesn't only include trust, it also includes freedom.
- IncRnd 6y ago> What if … Facebook was a government?1 It would govern a huge nation. With an expected rise in 2020 to 2.6 billion users,2 it would connect more people than are governed by any one nation on this planet. If Facebook were a government, there would be a civil war almost immediately, . There are no services provided. The only income or taxation for the hypothetical Facebook government would come from selling-out the citizens. Facebook is only alive, because it is protected by actual governments.
- giantg2 6y agoHow about the fix being proper education? If we educated everyone on logic and reasoning, then each person could do their own fact checking. I'm pretty sure that if the citizenry isn't capable of doing their own fact checking, they will also be susceptible of falling victim to false/compromised fact-checking systems. This lack of education is, in my view, the root of many problems in the US today and undermines the basis of a legitimate/well founded democracy.
- exolymph 6y agoIf this worked the problem would already be solved.
- TotempaaltJ 6y agoOr the method of teaching it is broken.
- adsjhdashkj 6y agoI think this is the _only_ solution, regardless of working or not. Assuming we can somehow defer peoples personal responsibility on logic and reasoning and _not_ have it be exploited / corrupted in the future is a hell of an assumption. It feels to me on par with the Government asking for backdoors to encryption. It definitely is not working now but that's not a supporting argument for the impossibility of an educated population. It's an argument against the current education infrastructure. Which, by most accounts, is flawed - some would say entirely broken.
- giantg2 6y agoI haven't seen logic classes or philosophy of argument classes in primary or secondary education - at least not on a large scale or being mandatory.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat would be a good start.
- 6y ago
- Threeve303 6y agoOnce real ID and contact tracing lead to a social credit system we could mass produce polygraph machines and attach the feed back to your new centralized login. Shrink it down enough and add a polygraph module to every phone. That way any time you post, people could see your polygraph results and know that there's an 80% (?) chance you're telling the truth.
- ceejayoz 6y agoPolygraph machines don't actually work.
- Threeve303 6y agoI have been reading about them lately. What's interesting is that some studies show about a coin flips chance of it being correct while others show upwards of 85%. Obviously what I said would never work but I've been trying to think about a technical solution to lies and misinformation. I'm not sure there is going to be one.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> What's interesting is that some studies show about a coin flips chance of it being correct while others show upwards of 85%. This may reflect their effectiveness as an interrogation technique - folks who believe they work may be more likely to confess, as they think it's all over.
- Threeve303 6y agoThat must be the difference. Reminds me of a scene from The Wire: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgrO_rAaiq0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgrO_rAaiq0
- bjt2n3904 6y agoPoe's law in action?
- 6y ago
- bjt2n3904 6y agoFlash back, four years. "But @bjt2n3904, misinformation is bring spread, that is causing 'real harm' (TM)!" Some justification. Real harm is being done now, and it isn't doesn't need social media to survive. You know, I spoke out against online platforms taking responsibility for what it's users wrote back then. But I wish I had the forethought to say this: How do you think conspiracy theorists, who believe their messages are being suppressed to hide the truth, will react when Facebook steps in and fulfills their prophecy? How do you think people who don't live in the tech bubble will react when they share an opinion on politics, and it gets marked as "Actually this is untrue" by Facebook, and buried? How do you think people, who already believe everything they read on the internet, will react when they see Facebook flag something as "untrue"? Certainly, it won't reinforce their biases about how <political opponent's supporters> are all misinformed people with the wool pulled over their eyes, and can be dismissed off hand. Surprising to no one, these attempts at correcting "misinformation" are having the opposite effect. Who would have thought that using technology to solve an obviously human problem wouldn't have worked? Edit: "Ackshually, @bjt2n3904, Facebook isn't under any obligation to follow the 1st Amendment, there's this great XKCD comic that explains this, hold on..." This is what we mean when we say "freedom of speech". It isn't just a good thing for the government, it's good for society, too.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoDo I take it from your post that you've never changed your position or accepted correction? Or is that only something you believe is true of everyone else? Or is this something you're leveling at Facebook, I'd certainly not swallow their opinion on the truth of something; but assuming they were measured and fact based then I'd take it as indicative.
- bjt2n3904 6y ago..."accepted correction"? What is this, some perverse elementary school? I've noticed that whenever my friends talk about certain matters, it sounds like they've turned their brains off. They read some book by a self proclaimed expert, and just accept it on face value. And then they talk about how excited they are to be "learning" and "receiving instruction". If that's what you mean by "accepting correction", it's far closer to "accepting indoctrination". We're all children at school again, we have no capability to reason, and must be taught with rote memorization.
- Heyso 6y ago"Attempts", when it is a success you won't hear about it.
- rsweeney21 6y agoThomas Paine's "Common Sense" and "The American Crisis" would have been considered "misinformation", "propaganda" or "harmful content". These are considered "the two most influential pamphlets at the start of the American Revolution, and helped inspire the patriots in 1776 to declare independence from Great Britain" (Wikipedia) So many of the great discoveries in science were controversial in their time. "On the Origin of Species", expanding universe, microbiology. Do you really want the government deciding what is acceptable? No, we don't. We fought a revolution to have the ability to think for ourselves. I'm not that worried though. Even if platforms are subjectively regulated by companies or the government, life seems to find a way. There are plenty of other mechanisms to publish scientific breakthroughs.
- bjt2n3904 6y agoNeil Tyson, 2018: I’m okay with a US Space Force. But what we need most is a Truth Force — one that defends against all enemies of accurate information, both foreign & domestic. Has a government ever made the wrong choice when it decided which scientific theories are valid? I mean... I certainly can't think of any! Hooray, Truth Force! 1 - https://twitter.com/neiltyson/status/1031556958153666561 https://twitter.com/neiltyson/status/1031556958153666561
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- HPsquared 6y ago"We will get to the truth... By force!"
- john-shaffer 6y agoThe problem with Truth Forces of the past, such as the venerated Inquisition, is that they just couldn't be everywhere at once. They could never completely stop people from saying things in private, or from running to safe havens. If only the governments of the time had had platforms as pervasive and automated as Facebook and Google! They could have fact-checked and shadow-banned content about the earth being round or moving around the sun, the earth being older than 6,000 years, species adapting over time, etc. The damage has already been done, but at least we have proper censorship in place now to bury any such misinformation that may occur in the future.
- Barrin92 6y agoI don't buy the argumentation of the article. It centres around 'opinion power' the ability to set a political or cultural agenda and steer democratic discourse, and argues that holding platforms accountable makes them more legitimate wielders of opinion power, which the author claims is a mistake. I think there's some things wrong with this. First off I don't think Facebook or Google exercise a lot of opinion power, in particular given their dominance. Yes, the article is right to point out they support climate change action, or fight certain internet regulation, or gay rights but this is very, very mild, often non-partisan civic stuff and often just financial self-interest. I don't see Facebook or Google going around wielding the power of legacy media over politics, having a clear political slant in how they operate, or whatever. They mostly stay out of it, again probably for business reasons. More importantly though I think the article romanticises smallness, citing Barlow's cyberspace independence, advocating for less concentration, transparency and so on. It's the usual anglosphere-centric argument. Just give people transparency and get rid of all the big bad guys and the enlightened citizens of the cyberspace will find their way out of it, nothing new about that. I don't think this is realistic. People will use large social networks and platform giants because they provide the best service, they're not going to dig through transparency reports or statistics about algorithm influence, and this means corporate responsibility is necessary. The author may not like it, but large firms are the principal actors in our society, and they need to be held accountable, even if that gives them a seat at the table.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- est 6y agoIf two people have the same priors, and their posteriors for an event A are common knowledge, then these posteriors are equal. - Robert Aumann http://mason.gmu.edu/~rhanson/deceive.pdf http://mason.gmu.edu/~rhanson/deceive.pdf
- radisb 6y ago>Moreover, as the self-appointed facilitators of the new self-government of the online global population,32 currently there is little that would prevent the leading social media platforms from using and canalizing this civic power for the goals they see fit – much like a government with the difference that governments are subject to democratic oversight.. 2 things on the above: First point, self-appointed does not matter. It is just a declaration. What matters is that people/users themselves turned this declaration into a fact. So, second point, platforms are subject to democratic oversight: Like you control your vote, you control your keyboard or mouse that clicks the sign-up button or accepts the TOS, you control the mouth and the fingers that propagate the information, and the brain that consumes it. I really dislike it when people , by their own actions, become dependent on a service someone else offers in such a degree that they feel they are now entitled to the service and that it is now a public good. They strive to establish and cement this dependence on their own terms, assigning now the responsibility of maintaining it to the offerer (again on their own terms). That's the relationship between a spoiled child and its parents, not between a man and the society. Sorry for my bad English. Not my mother tongue.